April 2 – 8, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on important community meeting Steinbruner… Pedestrian over crossing, Moss Landing, County planning commission … Hayes… Community and Self-Identification… Patton… Short-term pain, and no long-term gain… Matlock… Atlantic sinking…fire somebody…but her emails…one bad apple… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… a rare occurrence Quotes on… “Protesting”

...

THE “PALO ALTO” CONCRETE SHIP. This photo was taken in 1947. The “Palo Alto” was built of concrete by the U.S. Government in 1918, and it cost $2 million. It was towed to where it is today (Seacliff Beach) in 1930. It broke in half during a storm in 1932, and in recent years, the pier has been removed. The pieces of the ship are still there, “deteriorating gracefully”(?). Ever since I first heard of it, I’ve wondered why it wasn’t fixed up/maintained and showcased as a piece of history. Oh, youthful ideals and optimism!

If you are interested in her history in more detail, the East Bay Times published an article in 2023, with lots of pictures. It’s a slideshow, I almost missed it!

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: April 2, 2025

PROTESTS IN THE STREETS. So, apparently a lot of people are out there, making their voices heard. This is a Good Thing[TM]. Every day there is more and more distressing news about how much backsliding the US is doing, locally as well as globally. Canada, the nicest of all nations, are severing ties – do you realize how much you have to eff up for Canada to do this?!?

At any rate, I have to limit my intake of news for my own mental health. I will pass this on, however: Tomorrow, April 5 is the National Day of Action, put on all over the place by HANDS ØFF, handsoff2025.com. The Santa Cruz protest takes place as follows:

  • Where: 701 Ocean St. Santa Cruz, CA 95060 on the Water St. side of the building
  • When: 12pm–2pm on April 5, 2025

If Watsonville is closer to you, join their protest in the Watsonville Plaza at the same time.

...

THE RESIDENCE. Netflix. Series. (7.8 IMDb) ***-
I’m happy to see the return of the cozy mystery – Knives Out, Death and Other Details, and even Only Murders in the Building. Sure, Hallmark churns out an endless stream of formulaic/hygienic perky upper middle class “professional women” who solve mysteries while hygienically engaging in romance with some square jawed cop/firefighter/architect, but they lack any sort of charm or character. The Residence gives us Cordelia Cupp (Orange is the New Black’s Uzo Aduba): an acclaimed detective, and stout birder, who finds herself wader deep in drama and intrigue surrounding a murder in the White House. Giving absolutely zero f***s about titles and position, she pursues the truth through a cast of notables: Giancarlo Esposito, Jason Lee, Bronson Pinchot, Molly Griggs, and even Al Franken, reprising his role as a Senator. Might have been a few episodes too long, but worth the wait. Definite watch.
~Sarge

STAR TREK: SECTION 31. Paramount+. Movie. (3.8 IMDb) *-
I know I’m late to the table for this, but we decided to finally sit down and watch Star Trek: Section 31. Empress Georgiou (the mirror-universe evil counterpart of heroic Capt. Georgiou from Star Trek: Discovery) is pressed back into service with Section 31 – the black-ops division of Starfleet – for essentially a caper “mission”. Things go wrong, and she and a band of misfit specialists have to make it right. Michelle Yeoh is wonderful, as she always is. What she’s given to work with is tepid at best. I’m not a toxic fan – I’ve liked a lot of Trek related stuff that people kvetch about, but I do recognize when they miss the mark. Not just “doesn’t feel like Star Trek”, but feels like a fairly average caper film. No brilliant gotcha moments, no delicious red herrings. Just bland. Which is hard to do with Michelle Yeoh! It doesn’t quite make me feel like I was robbed of an hour and a half, but I was not really entertained. Highlight for the geek crowd: a Cheronian waiter. Watch only for a completionist compulsion.
~Sarge

NO OTHER LAND. In theaters. Movie (8.3 IMDb) ***-
Academy Award-winning documentary, No Other Land, highlights the impact of political conflicts on everyday people. Co-directed by Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra and Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham, the film follows them in the forced displacement of the small settlement of Masafer Yatta by Israeli forces. The view we get, from the “street” as it were, brings home the workaday world that is being unceremoniously wiped out by forces beyond shame or consequence. It makes it difficult to maintain an objective view of chess pieces being neatly moved around a board – it’s hard and personal, and as foreign as it should feel, hitting you right in the hometown. After winning the award, another co-director, Hamdan Ballal, was arrested and detained by Israeli authorities. The academy’s reaction: a tepid equivalent of “there are good people on both sides”. Definitely requires a watch.
~Sarge

THE ELECTRIC STATE. Netflix Movie (6 IMDb) ***- This has the energy of ’80s adventure films, like Batteries Not Included and War Games, with a touch of Fallout retro-futurism. Here’s the deal: In the ’50s, Walt Disney sparked a robot boom, leading to a robot rebellion in the ’90s. After the war, robots were confined to a walled-off Midwest wasteland. Michelle (Millie Bobby Brown) discovers her genius brother, supposedly dead, stuck in a robot shell and searching for a mysterious doctor. Keats (Chris Pratt) and his robot sidekick help her break into the wasteland. They’re pursued by a robot exterminator (Giancarlo Esposito) working for a tech billionaire, Skate (Stanley Tucci), who wants Michelle’s brother. Fun, nostalgic, and spot-on art direction. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

ADOLESCENCE. Netflix Series (8.4 IMDb) *** I was going to start off saying this was uninspired in its execution, till I saw a shot fly up from one character, fly several blocks away, drop down to where another character is getting out of a car, and hold a steady close up – all in one shot. A British crime drama about the impact of incel politics on pre-sexual children. Very saddening. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. AppleTV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- I don’t know how accurate this is as a depiction of young Bob Dylan (Timothee Chalamet), but it does make me yearn for those days as an adult (I wouldn’t be released till ’63). The film basically encapsulates Dylan from ’61 to ’65, following his relationships, and rise in the folk community, and his troubled transition to something more. Ed Norton as the supportive and eventally outgrown Pete Seeger, Elle Fanning as Dylan’s constantly trying-to-stay-in-his-focus lover Sylvie Russo/Suze Rotolo, and Monica Barbaro as the legendary sometime lover/sometime music partner Joan Baez. Worth a watch.~Sarge

THE BRUTALIST. PrimeTV. Movie (7.5 IMDb) *** I thought the title was JUST a reference to the Brutalist Movement in art and architecture. Oh how wrong I was. A brutal story about love, separation, and power. Adrien Brody is gut-wrenching in his performance as a holocaust survivor, drug addict, and brutalist architect. It’s like dragging yourself along the edge of a straight razor – the further forward you go, the deeper it cuts. Painful, but worth a watch. Interesting note – while Brody’s character is fictional, the name Lazlo Toth (and variants) is out there, most notable to me, it was the name of the guy who vandalized La Pieta, and it was the pen-name of Don Novello (Reverend Guido Sarducci on old SNL) when writing his “Lazlo Letters”. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

...
Stop the Skyscrapers

If you think the above graphic is just hyperbole, you haven’t been following the new state housing laws. What the graphic doesn’t capture may be even more alarming. The Downtown Extension Project, or the Downtown Plan Extension Project in SoLa (South of Laurel), is winding its way to city council like a snake on steroids.

The development site is twenty-nine-acres. It starts at Laurel St., extends along Front St. towards the Wharf, is bordered by Depot Park, Beach Hill and the river levee and encompasses the current Warriors Arena. It is easily the largest serious development proposal in the history of Santa Cruz. It is outside the view in the graphic but could easily end up having buildings at the size shown. That is, unless the city council utilizes one of its few remaining discretions over local development since the land use power grab by state politicians.

The current project area zoning is 35 feet with one area at 48 feet. If council rezones upwards, called upzoning, proposed as an option in the draft Environmental Impact Report (dEIR) for the project, then developers have the freedom to build skyscrapers as high as 25 or 30 stories. This unfortunate situation is a result of Assembly Bill 1287 which increased the density bonus to 100% so that cities are now required to approve projects at double the existing zoning density and waive city restrictions on building height, bulk, and setback, if the project includes a net 15% “affordable” units. The absurdity of this “bonus” is that city law already requires 20% “affordable” units in housing projects. So, we are getting exactly what for this give-away to developers? And, yes, the city’s state-required RHNA numbers (Regional Housing Needs Allocation) for the next seven years-and beyond- can be achieved without upzoning.

Unfortunately, the city’s dEIR for this project omits any study of possible environmental impacts resulting from AB 1287 which passed into law in October 2023. This new law should have generated a revision of the dEIR which was being prepared during that time, but it didn’t. Many have written to council asking for a revision of the dEIR to reflect this sea change in potential size and mass of new developments, but don’t hold your breath.

Within current zoning, any new building in this project site can be as high as seven or eight stories since AB 1287 doubles existing height limits. They can also go higher. But if council rezones the area to 85 feet as is proposed, the possibility of twenty to thirty stories or higher can be expected. Optimists who think this will never happen based on remarks from the Santa Cruz Warriors Team President, or the cost of steel construction in tall buildings, or commonsense, has forgotten that real estate is the number one investment in rich people’s portfolios. And don’t forget the equation; more well-off people moving to Santa Cruz, more low-income residents moving out. Affordable housing for local workers becomes unaffordable due to the ever-increasing Area Median Income. Plus, the city has no idea if its affordable housing is actually going to local workers and the city has no intention of finding out. Likewise, the initiatives currently gathering signatures for raising taxes for future affordable housing have no mechanism for ensuring such housing goes to local workers despite the deceptive names on the initiatives.

This massive development of high rises, bringing three to four thousand people into twenty-nine acres, plus creating an entertainment district with no parking, jammed into the main tourist access route to and from the Wharf, Beach and Boardwalk, plus a main access route to and from downtown or across town for the lower westside, suggests at least poor planning or a serious disregard for the community.

Residents and workers are not taking this lying down. A group of neighbors, largely from Beach Hill with activists from other neighborhoods, including yours truly, have formed a group under the banner Santa Cruzans for Responsible Development. We have met with individual council members to explain the importance of their one remaining power; to not change the zoning in this project area.

As always there is strength in numbers. You are encouraged to sign the petition which includes a wealth of helpful information and can be found here.

And attend the community meeting detailed below. Hope to see you there!

Come to a community meeting!
Saturday, April 5th, 10:30am
London Nelson Center
301 Center Street, Santa Cruz

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
Santa Cruz County supervisors will delay ordinance review

The Board of Supervisors agenda for next Tuesday includes delaying their consideration of the County’s Draft Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) Ordinance until September 9, instead of by April 25 as their vote last October mandated.  According to the staff report for Consent Item #57, the Director of Community Infrastructure & Development (aka Planning and Public Works) wants more time to learn what caused the January 16 Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire and how to use that information in crafting the Draft Ordinance. Meeting

MONTEREY COUNTY WEBSITE PROVIDES GOOD INFORMATION RE: MOSS LANDING DISASTER, BUT WHY IS SANTA CRUZ  COUNTY SILENT?
Sadly, the Santa Cruz County response to the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire has been woefully void of updated information.  With the exception of Consent Item #57 next Tuesday to delay consideration of a BESS Ordinance, the one and only report on January 28 has been the extent of the Board getting any public staff reports on the disaster….despite many residents asking for information and action during Public Comment (items NOT on the agenda) every single meeting…with no response from elected officials.

Take a look at Monterey County’s good information, and contact your local Supervisor to ask why they are so silent.
Moss Landing Battery Facility Recovery 2025 | County of Monterey, CA

LISTEN AND BE HEARD
I hope you will share this information and listen in today 2pm-4pm on “Community Matters”.  You can listen on your computer from anywhere in the world at 2pm Pacific Time. santacruzvoice.com/

Today’s program  will focus on the ongoing Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire issues, and the work the Green Party is doing to inform the public about energy storage technologies that are a safe alternative to hazardous lithium battery storage facilities.

In the first hour (2pm-3pm), my Guest will be Mr. Neil Pearlberg, pod cast host of “Off the Lip”.  We will discuss his recent program interview of Senator John Laird and the Moss Landing Battery Fire response.  We will not be accepting any calls from the audience during Mr. Pearlberg’s interview, but I urge you to listen to the story of what he experienced as public outcry subsequent to his podcast with Senator Laird and learn why it is important to have civil discussions on such important topics.

In the second hour (3pm-4pm), my Guest will be Mr. Sean Dougherty, Green Party candidate for Congress.  Meet the Green Party candidate challenging Panetta – The Pajaronian | Watsonville, CA

He has organized a  3pm educational rally this Saturday, Rally Against Lithium Fires, at London Nelson Center with others who oppose lithium battery energy storage systems (BESS), such the likes as what led to the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire in January, flaring again in February…and may be still smoldering.

Learn what  safe alternatives exist that Santa Cruz County leaders could be insisting be put in place as they move toward approving three BESS locations: 90 Minto Road in Watsonville (in permitting process), Freedom Blvd. near Aptos High School, and Paul Sweet Road, Santa Cruz (near Dominican Hospital).

There may also be an update on the “Never Again Moss Landing” group activities. Never Again Moss Landing, CA | Community Safety & Advocacy

We will invite callers to join the conversation only in the second hour: 831-265-5050

If you miss the live show, you can always listen to the recording.  It will be posted by 5pm on the Santa Cruz Voice website’s “Community Matters” page, whose link is under Current Shows. Santa Cruz Voice – Listen and Be Heard

WHAT IS SHE THINKING??
Also on the April 8 Board of Supervisor Consent agenda it Item #32, where 2nd District Supervisor Kim DeSerpa is appointing  Mr. Jesse Nickell of Barry Swenson Builder to serve on the County Planning Commission.  What?!  

Board Meeting Agenda, Tuesday, April 8, 2025 – 9:00 AM

Whose interests will he support in decision-making and why is he representing the 2nd District area when (I believe) he lives in the City of Santa Cruz?

Maybe he camps out in the Aptos Village Project, the ghetto built by Barry Swenson Builders with lots of money and “unwritten deals” from the County.

WILL THIS WORK?
Recently, I noticed new sidewalk pedestrian crossings installed on Chanticleer Avenue, near the Sheriff Center and the colossal pedestrian overpass on Highway One (scheduled to open next month).  It is located about half a block from the busy and hazardous intersection of Chanticleer Avenue and Soquel Frontage Road, where the pedestrian overpass dumps out to an unsignaled intersection with limited visibility.


I wrote County Public Works Dept. staff and asked what the plan is here.  They responded:

“This work is a part of the Chanticleer POC (HWY1 Phase 1), funded by multiple grants and Measure D.
There is not a plan to signalize Chanticleer and Soquel at this time.”

Do you think this will work to provide a safer intersection that will have multiple large delivery trucks of hazardous chemicals swinging into the PureWater Soquel Project sewage water treatment facility, also located on this busy corner?   Hmmm…

WAGE THEFT AT CONSTRUCTION SITE ON UCSC CAMPUS

More to come on this next week…

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE BY DOING JUST ONE THING THIS WEEK.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Community and Self-Identification
Beyond my family, I identify as a conservationist, but I have toyed with other identities: how about you? It strikes me as an important time to reinvest in community and to question with what kind of ‘movement’ or subculture do we identify. My idea is that we need more togetherness to move our society past the various forms of dis-ease that have seemed too common for too long. And, to get to that togetherness, we need to better, more consciously, place ourselves in a cultural context.

Communities of the US
Aside from racial identities or geographic affinities how many cultural movements or societal communities can you name? Communities of faith get a fair amount of recognition in the USA. About 67% of the USA identifies with Christianity and most of those are either Protestants (including members of the Southern Baptist Convention) or Catholics. I have met many people who strongly identify with their church community. Alternatively, some people identify as “belonging” to one political party or another: Democrats, Republicans, Green, Libertarian, etc. I have relatives and friends that have such affinities and identify themselves via their political party.

There are also quite a few people who seem to identify themselves as followers of some sport or sports team. I have been amazed at how jazzed such sports enthusiasts can become when encountering one another and sharing details of past player performances. There are similar cultural connections made with music, TV, movies, or books. I have been party to conversations of late where for an hour people throw out the titles of movies and books to see who likes what, getting to know one another, seeing how similar who is to who. Are Deadheads a community just about the music?

There is also the militia movement: guns, guns, and more guns…bonding people together with ammunition and love of…Liberty? Preppers, those that are preparing for the collapse of civilization, have a following. I’ve encountered a little-known subculture of anarchistic homeless earth lovers, quite numerous and hidden. They may or may not be related to Hippies, who are apparently still a thing: I know some self-identifying as such. I know no one who would call themselves a Yuppie, and I’m not sure if the Yippie culture is still around. I know of more than a few folks who identify as environmentalists. I also know people who identify with their approach to thinking, calling themselves first and foremost “scientists.” Perhaps that is more in alignment with the cultures related to professions, which are worlds into themselves. I’m not altogether sure that the artist, musician, or cook communities would altogether fit into the same category kinds of professional communities.

I’m sure we could go on and on.

Helping Your Community
After giving oneself the long, long name of all of one’s communities, the next thing might be to ask oneself how actively supportive is one to each of those communities. If you are a member of the Prunedale Militia, does that mean you have a plan, drill and practice that plan, so as to protect members of your community when necessity calls? If you are a Hippie, do you support your brethren with free food, do you work to reject mainstream culture? If you identify strongly as a member of a political party, how do you support that party…besides voting?

It seems to me that we could all use a little deeper dive into the communities with which we self-identify.

How Do We Do It?
In no particular order, again omitting the familial and geographic ties, I might give my long, long name as: Buddhist, farmer, restorationist, conservationist, deep ecologist, communalist, back-to-the-land, pro-labor, and far left. With each of these identities, I look for conversations with others regularly to keep growing and to identify who else is in those circles. Also, I write (this column and more) and do public speaking, I vote, and I am careful about to whom I give money (either through purchases or as donations). I have been asking myself lately if those things are enough to be more supportive of my communities. It is only through cohesiveness and scaling up do our communities become safe places where our ideals prosper. For instance, I despair that there is no regular, cohesive gathering of conservationists in the Monterey Bay, but who am I to criticize that inadequacy – aren’t many of us overwhelmed and unable to help organize or move forward that or any other group? How do we do this?

How Did We Get Here?
So much of what we take for granted now has been gifted us by our ancestors, who took the time and care to move our communities forward. The weekend and five-day work week are the result of folks organizing, taking their personal time to make a difference. Even the air we breathe and water we drink comes more healthily to us thanks to the Clean Air and Clean Water acts and lots of community organizing. Even more, our ability to choose our own leaders by organizing and voting came to us only through revolution, bloodshed, and keen negotiation.

Where Will We Go?
Like every conservation victory I’ve experienced, the successes I just mentioned must be re-won regularly, we must be ever vigilant and willing to act. We don’t do these things alone, we can only do those things together. And, we cannot get together until we see ourselves as more dedicated members of one of our communities and help others to feel they belong and are valuable to that community, as well.

If you have ideas especially about the dearth of a conservation movement around the Monterey Bay, please let me know.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, March 31, 2025

#90 / Short-Term Pain And No Long-Term Gain

It is well-established (and makes a good deal of sense) that some short term pain may well be worth it, if the “short term pain” leads to a “long term gain.” Presumably, this might the idea underlying our current president’s recent announcement that “a recession may be worth it.” Let’s examine that premise.

As it turns out, many economists don’t agree that the policy changes being made by our president are going to have any longer-term payoff. What they see is “short term pain” leading to “long term pain.” Click that link in the first paragraph and read what New York Times reporter Ben Casselman has to say on this topic (paywall policies permitting, of course).

I found the most revealing part of Casselman’s article to come right near the end:

Who bears the costs?
The 2017 tax cuts disproportionately benefited higher-income households, according to most independent analyses. Medicaid cuts would overwhelmingly hurt low- and moderate-income families, as would cuts to other government services. Tariffs likewise tend to be hardest on poorer households, which spend more of their income on food, clothes and other imported goods.

The short-term pain created by the administration’s policies, in other words, could fall hardest on low-income Americans — many of whom voted for Mr. Trump in hopes of improving their economic situation.

“It’s really hard to see how the Trump voters come out ahead,” Ms. Clausing, the former Treasury official, said. “Prices are going to be higher, disruptions are going to be higher and the safety net is going to get cut.”

Even some defenders of Mr. Trump’s policies, such as Mr. Cass, say cutting benefits to pay for tax cuts runs counter to the administration’s stated goal of restoring the middle class (emphasis added).

Just to highlight the obvious, the adminstration’s “stated” goal is not its “real” goal.

The “real” goal is to benefit the billionaires, and to hell with the rest of us.

That make it clear?

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
Zappaed, on to page two, whiskey leaks, run out the clock

Last week the Trump administration reminded us of the Frank Zappa quote: “Government is the Entertainment division of the military-industrial complex,” — not so entertaining as the reality was an ominous leak of “imminent war plans,” as described by journalist Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic who was an inadvertent recipient of the shocking security breach, being added by Michael Walz, who implied “conspiracy during one interview. Included in a group chat on Signal comprised of US Defense Secretary Pete HegsethVice President JD Vance and seventeen other top officials who discussed upcoming strikes against Yemen’s Houthi rebels, Goldberg disclosed that he had hours of advance notice of the action, not sure that it was authentic initially, only to see the Trump announcement about a “very effective” operation later on March 15. When questioned about the leak by the press, Trump claimed not to “know anything about it. I’m not a big fan of The Atlantic. To me, it’s a magazine that’s going out of business.” though National Security Council spokesman Hughes was already on the case reviewing how an inadvertent number was added to the Signal chain. If Goldberg had publicized the details in advance, it could have been deadly to our armed forces in the region, but he chose not to do so until the administration started defending its slip-up, and the Fox News talking heads began making excuses for their old colleague, Hegseth, with charges of “fake news,” a “hoax,” and other improbable spins about conspiracies. Democratic lawmakers were outraged by the security breach, with Senator Coons posting on X that “every single one of the government officials on this text chain have now committed a crime.”  Republican Mike Lawler, a New York representative, said: “Classified information should not be transmitted on unsecured channels — and certainly not to those without security clearances, including reporters. Period. Safeguards should be put in place to ensure this never happens again.”

In the chat, Trump’s cabinet complained about “bailing out Europe” by attempting to keep international shipping lanes safe from Houthi missiles for passage through the Red Sea, with JD Vance expressing his doubts that his boss is aware of the inconsistency in regard to his messaging to Europe that they have to go their own way, essentially “loathing of European free-loading.” Vance wrote that only 3% of US shipping runs through the Suez Canal, with 40% of European trade doing so, with Hegseth’s complete agreement. Interesting that he fled shortly to Greenland with his wife — things a bit too heated in the Oval OfficeJeffrey Goldberg’s surprise at being included in the chat message led him to believe that he could be “part of a disinformation campaign,” since he had met National Security Advisor Mike Walz only briefly in the past, and with the “administration’s contentious relationship with journalists,” and him personally, it was clear that this was out of whack. “I also could not believe that the National Security Advisor to the President would be so reckless as to include the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic in such discussions with senior US officials, up to and including the vice president,” said Goldberg. These revelations are surely going to trigger major questions about security within the Trump cabinet and the handling of highly sensitive government information, echoing the scandal brought upon Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign when she was accused of using insecure servers for emails, a major factor in dooming her run for office.

Another shocker is that his team allowed the president to take to the podium before the assembled press, without briefing him on the security breach, raising questions about the care and qualifications of his inner circle, dumbfounding former Defense Secretary Leon Panetta about the entire episode. Panetta said there was “no question” that the chat was legitimate, referring to the incident as a “serious blunder,” and that a proper conversation should have been held in-person in the White House“It has to be investigated, and somebody, frankly, needs to get fired. Somebody put that name on a list, and whoever that was deserves to be fired,” he told CNN. Regarding the leak, X users displayed a wide range of emotions and opinions, from disbelief to anger, with search terms encompassing ‘War Plans’ to ‘Hegseth.’ ABC’s late-nighter, Jimmy Kimmel commented on the ineptitude, saying, “Our national security is being guarded by a bunch of dudes he wouldn’t trust to throw your cousin a surprise party. The administration accidentally texted me its war plans. No one on the chain thought to ask, who is JG, what are these initials for? They could have been  leaking secrets to Jeff Goldblum for all they know. And not only did this happen, after it happened, no one thought to tell Trump.”

Typically, Fox News host Jesse Watters was indifferent to the accidental disclosure, likening it to an incident where a family member is inadvertently added to a group chat about “raunchy” bachelor party plans. “Well, that kind of happened today with the Trump administration. He (Goldberg) heard some things today he probably shouldn’t have. Could’ve been a wee bit of a security breach.” Goldberg disputes this, saying he removed himself from the group after realizing it was authentic and contained sensitive national security information, hitting back at the White House’s insistence that “no war plans were discussed” and “no classified material was sent to the thread.” Watters attempted to discredit Goldberg, calling him “not a good reporter” and “one of the biggest hoax artists around.” After Goldberg provided screenshots of the Signal group chat in a report to back up his story, Watters contended, “I’m sure it won’t happen again.” Fox’s Jessica Tarlov was absolutely taken aback by Watter’s nonchalance, standing her ground in calling the debacle a sign of “incompetence and recklessness on a scale unimaginable,” compounding Trump’s drop in ratings on his handling of the economy, inflation, and cost of living. “So they’re not doing this on a SCIF (a sensitive compartmented information facility), they’re doing it on an app that you and I, we all have on our phones, and it’s obviously incredibly reckless. National security risks — I don’t ever wanna hear ‘but her emails’ again,'” she added, referring to Hillary’s email server brouhaha. She called this incident a perfect example of what James Carville was asking of Democrats, to “run out the clock” and see what happens in Trump’s second term, where “folks have jobs that didn’t deserve them.”

Watters wasn’t done with Tarlov, trying to call it an accident, unlike “purposeful leaks from the Democrats” in the past. He began, “Yeah, they accidentally leaked something to the media instead of to the Democrats — ,” which brought Tarlov’s interruption to tell him, “They didn’t leak it; they invited him in.” “At least they didn’t home-brew a server and acid-wash it — ‘but her emails!’ I just did it,” Watters jabbed back. Hillary Clinton for her part, posted on X in response to the whole fiasco, “You have got to be kidding me,” alongside a side-eyed emoji. Secretary of Defense Hegseth, initially denying anything at all was amiss, jumped into the attack on Goldberg after he made his revelations, calling him a discredited journalist who makes a profession of peddling hoaxes, naming ‘Russia, Russia, Russia,’ or ‘fine people on both sides’ hoax, and the ‘sucker and losers’ hoax as examples of his “peddling garbage.” Donald Trump kept up his criticism by posting on Truth Social a link to the conservative satirical website, The Babylon Bee, and its article “4D Chess: Genius Trump Leaks War Plans to ‘The Atlantic’ Where No One Will Ever See Them.” Elon Musk stepped in to help by posting the link to the article, also writing, “Best place to hide a dead body is page 2 of The Atlantic magazine, because no one ever goes there.”

Pete Hegseth’s post claiming that “nobody was texting war plans, and that’s all I have to say about that,” brought a pushback from Fox’s Brit Hume who said, “Oh, for God’s sake, the administration has already confirmed the authenticity of the message.” Fox News anchor, John Roberts, praised Goldberg following his devastating exposé, saying, “I would think that there are worse people that you could text your secret plans to, but it appears Goldberg has acted responsibly here in writing this article.” Posts on X, call the operation “sloppy — the only thing worse would have been if they had used Facebook to communicate. We are the laughing stock of the world. Allies sharing intelligence is no more,” and “God, dude, this place is worse than China. They are not allowed to take responsibility for anything. Nothing they do is bad, ever. The media has to adore them, or it’s fake or illegal. This party belongs in prison before it’s too late.” The administration’s whitewashing started from the President on down to White House Press Secretary Leavitt, who said Trump “continues to have the utmost confidence in his national security team, including National Security Advisor Mike Walz,” followed by Speaker Mike Johnson rejecting the possibility that Walz or Hegseth might face disciplinary action. Both Leavitt and Johnson praised those involved saying, “top- level officials were doing their job, doing it well and executing on a plan with precision.” However, Politico is reporting that internal discussions among White House officials are considering ejecting Walz, supposedly with Trump to make a decision within a few days. Still holding your breath?

Satirist Andy Borowitz offered his take on the Signal breach in The Borowitz Report“Defending his decision to use an insecure messaging app to discuss classified war plans, National Security Advisor Mike Walz said on Wednesday that he chose Signal because it offered more emojis. ‘Those sleaze bags at The Atlantic are acting like using Signal is some kind of scandal,’ Walz said. ‘You want to know a real scandal? The government spent billions of dollars on a secure communications system that has zero emojis.’ Walz said that he refused to use the government’s system when it became clear to him that it lacked even rudimentary emojis like fist, fire, and smiley face. ‘I stand by my decision to use Signal,’ he said. ‘When you’re planning to bomb another country, an emoji is worth a thousand OMGs or LOLs.'”

Back during the nomination process for Trump’s cabinet members, red flags were raised about Hegseth’s ability to handle the job he was offered, with many stories about his alleged abusive behavior, public drunkenness, financial mishandling, and bigotry — all ignored as the Senate Republicans approved him with flying colors. “Soooo, we thinking old Pete was drunk on the job or what?” Texas Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett asked. “It would be funny, if it wasn’t so scary! Maybe we need some DEI (Definitely Earned It) hires to get this together because incompetence is OVERWHELMINGLY problematic.” Spotted: A demonstrator’s sign with a photo of Pete Hegseth sipping whiskey from a bottle, captioned “WHISKEY LEAKS…LIKE WATERGATE BUT WITH MORONS.” Journalist Aaron Rupar writes that history repeats itself, but at increasingly high levels of stupidity: “It’s like Watergate, only in this version Nixon directly mails the tapes to Woodward and Bernstein.” And The Onion headline: ‘Teen Warned Not To Accept Group Chat Invites From National Security Advisors She Doesn’t Know.’ Interestingly enough, real estate mogul Steve Witkoff, who was included in the Signal chat group was physically in a Moscow meeting with Vladimir Putin — US military strategy leaking in real time to someone in Russia. Just imagine that — a face-to-face so Putin doesn’t have to bother with reading a text, unless Witkoff handed the Russian leader his cellphone on which the Signal thread was stored.

US Department of Defense official explained to CNN’s Natasha Bertrand that “information providing indication or advance warning that the US or its allies are preparing an attack” — which Hegseth shared — is classified Top Secret“It is safe to say that anybody in uniform would be court martialed for this. We don’t provide that level of information on unclassified systems, in order to protect the lives and safety of the service members carrying out these strikes. If we did, it would be wholly irresponsible. My most junior analysts know not to do this,” he continued. Representative Maxwell Frost of Florida is sending letters to all the identifiable officials in the ‘Hegseth Disaster Signal Chat’ demanding they retain all messages for any pending litigation and Congressional investigations, saying, “Any deletion of the chat is a willful destruction of evidence.” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries called Hegseth “the most unqualified Secretary of Defense in American history” and demanded his immediate dismissal. Jeffries wrote, “The so-called Secretary of Defense recklessly and casually disclosed highly sensitive war plans — including the timing of a pending attack, possible strike targets, and the weapons to be used — during an unclassified national security group chat that inexplicably included a reporter. His behavior shocks the conscience, risked American lives, and likely violated the law.” Jen Rubin wrote on The Contrarian“Proud of your votes for Hegseth? This is on you as much as Hegseth. You knew he was not remotely qualified,” as she called out Senators Ernst and Tillis. Fun fact: Former US Air National Guardsman Jack Douglas Teixeira was sentenced to 15 years in prison four months ago for doing the same thing Pete Hegseth and his band of idiots did when they leaked war plans to a reporter.

So, discipline, dismissal or firing? Jimmy Kimmel says the excuses don’t stop, with Trump dragging out one of his old favorites — “witchhunt.” “First, he blamed the reporter, and when that didn’t work, he blamed the Signal app, saying, ‘it could be a defective platform, and we’re gonna have to find that out.’ Right, maybe one of the wires came loose and the gasket got cracked,” Kimmel quipped, adding, “Blaming Signal for this is like blaming Tinder for when you get caught cheating on your wife.” He wasn’t through as he tore into the talking heads at Fox and Newsmax as they continued with downplaying the scandal, calling it “the perfect storm of incompetence, inexperience, dishonesty, and hypocrisy from the same people who spent the last 12 years screaming about Hillary’s emails and Hunter’s laptop, while calling Signalgate a ‘non-story.'” Why cover it if it’s a non-story? Taking a final swing by mentioning Trump’s DEI initiatives, Kimmel said, “Thank God they got rid of DEI. Now you can rest assured that the idiots in charge are not chosen for their race or gender. They were chosen purely based on being idiots. I believe that Pete Hegseth wasn’t drunk. I believe he was perfectly sober when he made this idiotic mistake.” His belief that President Trump might not be very happy with his national security and defense picks may lead him to calling them Eric and Don Jr.

Satirist Andy Borowitz provides another followup view of Hegseth“Millions of Americans have been rattled this week by the bombshell that a former Fox News host might be a liar, reports on Thursday indicate. According to industry insiders, the revelation that a former employee might have knowingly disseminated falsehoods threatens to tarnish the image of the nation’s most trusted news organization. Harland Dorrinson, a crisis management specialist, said Fox News needs to ‘change the narrative’ by reminding Americans of its peerless and longstanding reputation for honesty. ‘Fox needs to remind people that they are the network of Bill O’Reilly, Glenn Beck, and Tucker Carlson,’ he said. ‘One bad apple doesn’t spoil the whole bunch.'”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Protesting

“When an individual is protesting society’s refusal to acknowledge his dignity as a human being, his very act of protest confers dignity on him.”
~Bayard Rustin

“He who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who helps to perpetrate it. He who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr.

“We won’t stop protesting. It’s the engine that moves society forward.”
~Jordi Cuixart

“There are good reasons for being in jail – for protesting.”
~Tracy Chapman

“Every day, I would show up, and there were no kids, just me and my teacher in my classroom. Every day, I would be escorted by marshals past a mob of people protesting and boycotting the school. This went on for a whole year.”
~Ruby Bridges

...

At the Philadelphia Zoo, Mommy, a Western Santa Cruz Galapagos Tortoise (a critically endangered species) that’s over 100 years old recently laid 16 eggs after mating with Abrazzo, a male tortoise of similar age. The staff whisked away (ouch, bad choice of words, sorry!) the eggs and placed them in incubators of 2 different temperatures. Temperature is what decides if the hatchling will be male or female. So far, 4 eggs have hatched, and they are monitoring the remaining eggs. This is a Big Deal[TM]


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

March 26 – April 1, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on 831 Almar Student Housing Project… Steinbruner… Builder’s Remedy, ballooning projects, and BESS… Hayes… Our Federal Bureaucracy… Patton… Let’s shake on it… Matlock… Biden resurfaces…party in the ditch…falling for the okiedoke… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… groovy low-fi for 3 hours… Quotes on… “Spring”

...

RAINY DAY AT SEABRIGHT AND SOQUEL STREETS. We don’t know what year this photo was taken, but if anyone is a serious car buff and would like to take a guess, feel free to let us know! We do know that second car is a Studebaker.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: March 26, 2025

NOT MUCH TO SAY THIS WEEK… (so watch me take up half a page in this space, lol!). I’m trying to settle in with this new reality of putting the column up without Bruce. You wouldn’t think that it would be so different – the other Brattonites, as I lovingly call us, send me their stuff and I do what I’ve been doing for 22 years at this point. Not surprisingly, I still think of it as, “I gotta do Bruce’s column”, and I miss him. I think he would be happy and proud that we are continuing. We haven’t changed much of anything, and I don’t think we will for a while. We appreciate all you readers more than you know, and with that, I turn you over to this week’s offering.

...

NO OTHER LAND. In theaters. Movie (8.3 IMDb) ***-
Academy Award-winning documentary, No Other Land, highlights the impact of political conflicts on everyday people. Co-directed by Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra and Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham, the film follows them in the forced displacement of the small settlement of Masafer Yatta by Israeli forces. The view we get, from the “street” as it were, brings home the workaday world that is being unceremoniously wiped out by forces beyond shame or consequence. It makes it difficult to maintain an objective view of chess pieces being neatly moved around a board – it’s hard and personal, and as foreign as it should feel, hitting you right in the hometown. After winning the award, another co-director, Hamdan Ballal, was arrested and detained by Israeli authorities. The academy’s reaction: a tepid equivalent of “there are good people on both sides”. Definitely requires a watch.
~Sarge

THE ELECTRIC STATE. Netflix Movie (6 IMDb) ***- This has the energy of ’80s adventure films, like Batteries Not Included and War Games, with a touch of Fallout retro-futurism. Here’s the deal: In the ’50s, Walt Disney sparked a robot boom, leading to a robot rebellion in the ’90s. After the war, robots were confined to a walled-off Midwest wasteland. Michelle (Millie Bobby Brown) discovers her genius brother, supposedly dead, stuck in a robot shell and searching for a mysterious doctor. Keats (Chris Pratt) and his robot sidekick help her break into the wasteland. They’re pursued by a robot exterminator (Giancarlo Esposito) working for a tech billionaire, Skate (Stanley Tucci), who wants Michelle’s brother. Fun, nostalgic, and spot-on art direction. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

ADOLESCENCE. Netflix Series (8.4 IMDb) *** I was going to start off saying this was uninspired in its execution, till I saw a shot fly up from one character, fly several blocks away, drop down to where another character is getting out of a car, and hold a steady close up – all in one shot. A British crime drama about the impact of incel politics on pre-sexual children. Very saddening. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. AppleTV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- I don’t know how accurate this is as a depiction of young Bob Dylan (Timothee Chalamet), but it does make me yearn for those days as an adult (I wouldn’t be released till ’63). The film basically encapsulates Dylan from ’61 to ’65, following his relationships, and rise in the folk community, and his troubled transition to something more. Ed Norton as the supportive and eventally outgrown Pete Seeger, Elle Fanning as Dylan’s constantly trying-to-stay-in-his-focus lover Sylvie Russo/Suze Rotolo, and Monica Barbaro as the legendary sometime lover/sometime music partner Joan Baez. Worth a watch.~Sarge

THE BRUTALIST. PrimeTV. Movie (7.5 IMDb) *** I thought the title was JUST a reference to the Brutalist Movement in art and architecture. Oh how wrong I was. A brutal story about love, separation, and power. Adrien Brody is gut-wrenching in his performance as a holocaust survivor, drug addict, and brutalist architect. It’s like dragging yourself along the edge of a straight razor – the further forward you go, the deeper it cuts. Painful, but worth a watch. Interesting note – while Brody’s character is fictional, the name Lazlo Toth (and variants) is out there, most notable to me, it was the name of the guy who vandalized La Pieta, and it was the pen-name of Don Novello (Reverend Guido Sarducci on old SNL) when writing his “Lazlo Letters”. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

...

March 24, 2025

How the City Gets Trapped into Providing Student Housing

First a correction to my last week’s piece on the Meder St. development. The 2030 General Plan allowance for the number of housing units per acre in this R1 single-family zone at the Low-Density level is between one and ten. The developer has chosen ten, gets to make it fifteen due to the state density bonus, resulting in ninety-seven, three story townhouses on six and a half acres. Thanks to senior planner, Rina Zhou for steering me to the General Plan entry for clarification.

Now onto another proposed project working its way to city council. Pictured above is a city webpage rendition of the project seeking council approval for 831 Almar Ave. It’s easy to lose track of which project and where since there are so many. This one is not the triangle-shaped piece of vacant land along Almar (that is also poised for development) but is close by. It is a 1.9-acre site, behind Safeway, bordered by the rail trail. The owners want to build a mixed-use development project of 120 housing units plus commercial. The problem is the land is zoned for Industrial. The 2030 General Plan entry for Industrial zoned lands in the city under LU 3.2.7 states…”restrict uses that are incompatible with industrial uses.”

The owners could start the lengthy, expensive process of applying for a change in the zoning or change tack and apply for a Planned Development permit. The latter gives some discretion to the decision-makers and there must be a clear public benefit associated with the project. So far there is none. The owners and their representative, architect Mark Primack have opted for the Planned Development route, which was approved at the last Planning Commission meeting with Commissioner Rachel Dann opposed and Commissioner Pete Kennedy absent. The public who spoke, mostly nearby neighbors, expressed strong negative reactions to the project, for its size, its impact, and its intended occupants, four to six hundred students.

I have written on past projects that have been presented as “workforce housing” – 1010 Pacific for example – but which have ended up largely as housing for the ever-increasing UCSC student population. It is all guesswork and observation. The city does not know what percentage of the city’s scarce inclusionary housing is occupied by students. Despite the 2023-24 Grand Jury recommendation that the city start to track such occupancy, the city declined to do so.

Until now, most developers and their representatives have kept quiet about the fact that much of the housing being built is tailored for students, although the size of most units is a give-away. They placate with feel-good jargon about “our essential workers.” Until now. The 831 Almar project is up-front that it is intended for student housing. How do they justify that fact to a community that needs affordable housing for its local workers, not student dorms? By misrepresenting the truth and with an untested assumption.

The untested assumption is that students looking for off-campus housing will choose to live in these new units, thereby vacating a single-family house. The developer’s representative, Mark Primack spoke to that, saying, “for every four or five students who choose to live at the new 831 Almar Ave., one home can remain available for families.”  Two problems with this assumption. One is, what will the rents be at 831 Almar? If they are higher than a single-family house equivalent for multiple students, the expected shift may not occur. The second problem is that UCSC continues to grow, to add more students. Given that reality, the result is more likely to be students occupying both single family homes and the new dense housing projects. Council has already approved a project to house six hundred students on Delaware Avenue.

The misrepresentation of the truth was from architect Mark Primack. He stated, “As we all know, the city has for decades maintained a policy in support of acceptance of the University’s efforts to house only half of their students on campus.” (Planning Commission 3/20/25).

At the earlier zoom meeting on the project, he stated, “As Renee Golder said, the city has an ongoing battle with the University for them to provide half the housing that students need on campus. That’s the limit the city set.” (Zoom 11/4/24 Emphasis added)

The city has no policy nor has set a limit for UCSC to house only half its students on campus. Quite the contrary. The city has engaged in lengthy negotiations to get UCSC to house a higher percentage of its ever-increasing enrollment on campus.

The effect of Mr. Primack’s misrepresentation is to create the impression that the city has made a commitment, in policy, to house half of UCSC students off-campus. Not only is that untrue, but it also mutes opposition to projects which are designed to be student dorms, such as 831 Almar and others sure to come.

I wrote to Mr. Primack and politely shared that I thought he was wrong; that there is no such city policy. I said I could be mistaken so would he share a link to the policy if I am incorrect.

Here is his reply:


From: Mark Primack <mark@markprimack.com>
Date: March 22, 2025 at 7:20:59 PM PDT
To: Gillian Greensite <gilliangreensite@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Re your statement about student off-campus housing

Gillian,

I'd ask you to stop being silly, but we both know that's not going to happen.

Regards,

Mark

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
Our Builder’s Remedy projects will evade usual public process

I received a call from a fellow who had just learned of plans for a five-story building with 63 units and 30 parking spaces in his neighborhood.  It’s at 841 Capitola Road, and is another project shoved forward by Workbench, an aggressive developer.  You may recognize that name as being the agent who proposed the 18-story Clock Tower development awhile back.

What got my attention when I looked into the 841 Capitola Road project is that it is one of four significant project applications that were filed during a short time when the County Planning Dept. had missed the December 31, 2023 State-imposed deadline to get the Housing Element part of the General Plan approved by the Housing & Community Development (HCD) folks in Sacramento.  HCD finally approved the document on April 9, 2024.

Because of that, developers were able to file applications for projects under Builder’s Remedy, and there by eliminate any ability of the County Planning Commission or other discretionary planning bodies to weigh in on the plans.

There were four such projects filed for permitting during the time when Builder’s Remedy applied, and 841 Capitola Road is one of them.

Builder’s Remedy

Initially, the pre-application stated 40 units, but then, the developer reduced the number to 28.

841 Capitola Road

Now, according to the permit application pending, it has ballooned to 63 units of unknown size and affordability, with 30 parking spaces.
Planning Status

The bewildered fellow who contacted me asked “What can we do?”  That is a very good question, particularly in this case of Builder’s Remedy.

Sadly, I do not know, other than to meet with your County Supervisor and impress that they step in as an advocate.  That  support will be difficult in Live Oak from a Supervisor who holds a real estate broker’s license and initially placed Workbench owner Tim Gordin on the County Planning Commission.

How did Builder’s Remedy ever come about?  Here is a pretty good history: ‘Godzilla next door’: How California developers gained new leverage to build more homes

New legislation, AB 1893, that strengthened Builder’s Remedy provisions became effective January 1 of this year.

Through its adoption of Assembly Bill (AB) 1893 (Assembly Member Buffy Wicks), which strongly confirms the applicability of the Builder’s Remedy, the California Legislature has acted to put these debates to bed. On Sept. 19, 2024, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed AB 1893 and AB 1886 into law.

  • The law replaces the “free-for-all” approach to Builder’s Remedy. Starting Jan. 1, 2025, new Builder’s Remedy projects must comply with site restrictions, density limits, certain objective local standards and other mandated requirements. In exchange for these new restrictions, AB 1893 eases certain affordability requirements and offers Builder’s Remedy applicants more explicit protection from common tactics used by opponents of Builder’s Remedy projects.
  • Existing Builder’s Remedy projects that meet certain requirements should be protected automatically, and existing projects that do not meet these requirements may “convert” to AB 1893 by redesigning the project without losing the project’s entitlement to the Builder’s Remedy. The law provides that existing vested projects may also choose to proceed under pre-existing law.
  • A companion law, AB 1886, clears the path for existing and future Builder’s Remedy projects by foreclosing a number of legal arguments that anti-Builder’s Remedy jurisdictions frequently employ to frustrate these projects.

California Legislature Passes Major Reforms for “Builder’s Remedy” Projects | Insights | Holland & Knight

All this certainly should not discourage people who care from learning all you can about the projects and speaking out about preserving what matters…such as quality of life, environmental protection and public safety matters.  It can still make a difference…especially by writing letters to the Supervisors, and Letters to the Editor in local papers…public image means alot to some, and if done in a respectful manner with suggested alternatives that are reasonable, can make a difference.  Show up and speak out, otherwise, all is lost.

ANOTHER DEVELOPER FEE ON THE HORIZON?
County Planning Dept. staff announced to the County Commission on the Environment this week that developers will likely see a new Vehicle Miles Traveled mitigation fee for future projects.  The money would be used to fund infrastructure for bicycle and alternative transportation to mitigate traffic impacts for their projects.

Stay tuned.

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY SUPERVISORS JUST DON’T SEEM TO WANT YOU TO KNOW
Even though 4th District County Supervisor Felipe Hernandez stated publicly stated on February 25  he was organizing a town hall meeting in response to many, many people who voiced concern about the County’s plan to allow battery energy storage systems (BESS) here, he now states he is NOT.

He replied to repeated correspondence by many that he does not intend to hold any town hall meetings on the BESS issue until AFTER the Board approves the impending Ordinance for three such project sites in the County (90 Minto Road in Watsonville, Freedom Blvd. near Aptos High School, and Paul Sweet Road near Dominican Hospital).

Why is he not willing to be transparent with the public until the Ordinance is approved to allow these facilities in neighborhoods and remove agricultural land from production?

Local residents are organizing their own town hall, under “Stop BESS in Santa Cruz County”. Stay tuned.

WHY ARE UC REGENTS HIRING NON-UNION CONSTRUCTION LABOR FOR MAJOR HOUSING PROJECT?
Listen in Friday, March 28 at 2pm on Santa Cruz Voice.com to hear why Carpenter’s Local workers are protesting at UCSC’s main entrance.  Mr. Bryan Shields, speaking out for the Nor Cal Carpenter’s Union, will explain why workers are protesting the fact that UC Regents have hired non-union workers for this massive construction project in the East Meadow.

https://www.santacruzsentinel.com/2024/06/20/photos-work-begins-on-uc-santa-cruz-housing-project/

Listen in on your computer or smart device from anywhere in the world at 2pm Pacific Time to learn more, and how the Nor Cal Carpenters Union is also working hard to support women in the construction trades.
https://santacruzvoice.com/

If you miss the show, you can listen to the recording that will be posted under “Community Matters” and Current Shows, after 5pm.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC HEARING AND SPEAK UP FOR WHAT MATTERS TO YOU.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Our Federal Bureaucracy

What is there to not like about the federal bureaucracy? What is your experience? I think it is worth discussing these things in hopes that our culture becomes wiser about the role of our type of democracy in shaping our future…for the better.

Backstop to Evil
As I was becoming an adult, I thought the federal government was a great idea – it was a backstop to evil. In my mind, if a state somehow succumbed to evil, then the federal government could step in and correct it. It seemed to me at the time that the federal government was less corruptible, more heroic. Having spent much of my childhood in the South, the federal government’s role in overcoming human enslavement and then making headway with civil rights was foremost on my mind. Then I came to understand that this oversight role was also important in averting environmental disasters- species extinction and toxic pollution, for example.

Maybe Not So Much
As an adult, I watched with amazement the federal response to Hurricane Katrina under the Bush/Cheney administration; the debate about the federal government’s role in that largely manmade disaster was fascinating. It was the first time that I cognizantly witnessed the federal administration purposefully shirking its responsibility to assist local governments during such a disaster. That was some powerful foreshadowing. Now I understand that things are not so black-and-white with federal oversight.

Species Extinction
The U.S. government’s role in averting species extinction has been critical, though not without flaws. I have been actively involved with federal efforts around the Monterey Bay for some time with a number of plant and wildlife species that are protected by federal statute. The list is huge, including: central coast populations of coho salmon and steelhead, California red-legged frog, California tiger salamander, Mount Hermon June beetle, Zayante band-winged grasshopper, many whale species, sea lions, harbor seals, Southern sea otter, California condor, peregrine falcon, marbled murrelet, all of the many neo-tropical migratory bird species (warblers!), Santa Cruz tarplant, Ohlone tiger beetle, and more.

The goal of the federal Endangered Species Act is to recover the ‘listed’ species to such a point that they are no longer in danger of extinction. The tool box federal officials use to that end include both ‘carrots’ and ‘sticks.’ As to the ‘sticks,’ I have not witnessed any federal legal proceedings despite ample opportunities for prosecution. However, I have seen smart, capable federal staff helping immensely to provide assistance to public land managers and private landowners, helping endangered species to recover. Under The Department of Interior, the US Fish and Wildlife Service offers its staff time and expertise as well as grant money with a prioritization and tracking system that is solid and survives staffing changes. Their every five-year review of the status of each endangered species is particularly invaluable. Without their work, it is difficult for me to envision a future for most of our local species currently on the federal list.

Travel
The federal role in assuring the resilience and safety of interstate commerce also has a critical link to the health of some local species and ecosystems. The federal Department of Commerce oversees the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), which is responsible for the National Estuarine Research Reserve System (NERRS). The latter was founded from a bit of legislative brilliance, which recognized that harbors at the mouths of rivers would best be managed in partnership with nature as guided by science. Otherwise, in gross terms, the dredging and pollution abatement costs to harbors (emphasize: important to the military and commerce) would be more onerous. NOAA and the NERRS were early adopters of Al Gore’s government accountability program. Vice President Gore put into place a system where each branch of the federal government would set goals for tangible outcomes, monitor, and report on progress and adjust systems to improve government efficiency. The NERRS adopted such a framework. Federal government efficiency is showcased in the NERRS through a “place-based” approach: the science, outreach, and education must be prioritized to address the needs of local populations and decision makers affecting the health of the estuary. Annual reports from each of the nation’s estuaries outline how their federal funding results in tangible outcomes.

Moss Landing Harbor
In back of the Moss Landing Harbor lies the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve (Elkhorn Slough NERR). We call it the “Elkorn Slough,” and it is our local example of a NERR applying this government efficiency program. I have personal experience with that system having worked there for 14 years (through 2017). The priority local needs for the education, outreach, and science for this beautiful estuary have always revolved mainly around agricultural impacts (sediment, nutrients) but also include managing water flow with tide control structures, recreational impacts on wildlife, and development pressure (erosion, endangered species). My experience was that much of the insufficient funding from the federal government was not channeled in ways that met the mandated purpose of the NERRS. There was only the slightest modicum of federal oversight enabling only the most minor adjustments to bring the NERR into compliance. During my tenure, I had to constantly leverage non-NERR resources to meet the funding obligations of my portion of the mandate. And, I had no sense that anyone at the federal level understood how I or anyone else at the Elkhorn Slough contributed to the outcomes mandated by Congress in any kind of way that demonstrated the efficiency of government. But, the reports and data are all there for anyone to examine, and there is a system in place should there be sufficient desire to steer that program in a different direction.

Your Government
As citizens, how do we support good federal programs and constructively improve others that need it? I am not aware of any system that allows citizen feedback on federal programs. And, I am not aware of any groups in the Monterey Bay area actively engaged with providing our representatives fair assessments of the efficiency of federal spending, at least not in the environmental arena. Currently, there is a fight to either cut or save everything: a polarity. I wish for more constructive conversation. I want to keep efficiently administered federal support for the environmental protection measures that even “progressive” California would not otherwise provide.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Tuesday, March 25, 2025

The picture shown above has made a big impression on me. It accompanied an article published by Bloomberg on January 9, 2025. On that date, memorial services were held in the National Cathedral, to honor former president Jimmy Carter.

Apparently, some consternation occurred, after the memorial ceremonies were over. Country stars Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood performed what has been reported to be Carter’s favorite song, John Lennon’s “Imagine.” Well, Lennon’s song does contain lyrics that encourage people to “imagine there’s no heaven.” What a song for the National Cathedral, right?

I choose not to enter into the recriminations that were apparently made by some. I just want to look at that picture, selected by Bloomberg to accompany its article on the memorial to Carter.

The picture shows President Carter shaking the hand of Deng Xiaoping, who served as the paramount leader of the People’s Republic of China from 1978 to 1989. Isn’t that a great picture?

While we are talking about imagining things, can we imagine a president who wouldn’t threaten other nations with military force or economic sanctions, but who would just talk to their leaders, instead? I am thinking about a president who would be working with one of those leaders to find ways for the United States to cooperate with that leader’s country, to address all the incredible challenges that face the world today. Wouldn’t that actually be amazing? I’d like to imagine that! A few steps short of heaven, to be sure, but that is the direction we need to go!

I bet a president like Jimmy Carter could work with those leaders of other nations (even China), and find some common ground and agreement on some positive things for the two nations to do cooperatively, things that would help both nations deal with the mutual problems and possibilities that are challenges for all of us. I can envision just what it would look like, too, when the president and one of those foreign leaders started working out some of the possibilities. Just like that picture of Jimmy Carter and Deng Xiaoping!

Here’s what I imagine our president might say: “Hey, that’s wonderful. That’s a great idea. Let’s shake on it.”

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
Legacy of catastrophe, tipping a whig cap, don’t worry…be happy

Steve Schmidt on his The Warning blog focuses on a story by Peter NicholasCarol E Lee and Megan Shannon concerning the reappearance of former president Joe Biden, offering to people close to him to raise funds, campaign and do anything else necessary for Democrats to recover lost ground from the rollbacks of Democratic Party-designed programs by President Trump. In a meeting with new Democratic National Committee chairman, Ken MartinBiden offered his help to raise the popularity of the party from the 27% favorability of voters to which it has fallen of late, a ranking that is likely to keep falling in its struggle to regain its viability. A report says Donald Trump responded to a possible Biden re-entry into politics by declaring, “I hope so.” Schmidt says Trump is happy. DNC Vice Chair Jan Kleeb responded with, “The Kool Aid tastes delicious. If you were to call any state party chair and ask if they wanted Joe to be a keynote speaker for their annual dinner, the answer would be ‘Yes.’ He is beloved by the party and beloved by voters.” It is said the Bidens are sequestered with their team of gaslighters, all plotting how to make money on the books that are coming as they consult with former administration officials, and a snarky question arises: Biden is signed with CAA in Hollywood, so it is fair to ask who will play him in the dramatic pardon scene at the end of his tenure? Schmidt says Biden’s selfishness is his legacy, and wife Jill’s lust for power, combined with the insatiability of his advisers for more of it, has led America into an abyss — which leads into another tragic legacy: Trump. This is a legacy of catastrophe, and the reality is that Joe Biden will serve the sentence that he imposed on all of us in solitary. Schmidt concludes that the lies and delusions should be put down at last, with a realization that more Biden and Schumer is not the right path — the party is already in the ditch.

Schmidt slams Senator Schumer by mocking his ‘strategy‘: By not going after every single issue, picking only the most important fights, then lying down on the train tracks. He describes Schumer as “the career politician from Brooklyn, a cloistered man from a cloistered club, presiding over our national suicide — sublime, indifferent and capitulant. The view is good from the tracks for Chuck Schumer and his team of fools, who can watch the Trump locomotive run over them again and again and again.” Illinois governor JB Pritzker rejected Schumer’s appeasement, saying, “Trump is not somebody that you can appease. We’ve got to stand up and fight. And by the way, at the state level, I think many of us are. But I think that we’ve got to make sure that in the Senate and the House, that the people who have a platform are standing up.” Schmidt charges the Democratic Senate members with failing the country in an urgent moment, being ill-led, and corrupted by the touches of a thousand lobbyists, who know the lure of self-interest as a primary enticement which is more important than fighting for constituents. “The Senate Democrats are a team that can’t fight because at their head they have a man who can’t stand up. Chuck Schumer is a lay-flat type of man. This moment calls for stand up people with guts, integrity and a plan. JB Pritzker should appreciate two things: Chuck Schumer isn’t changing, and neither is Donald Trump. Let me close by saying something as clearly and directly as I can. Is there anything more grotesque than what Donald Trump is doing? Is there anything more grotesque than Elon Musk stomping about the US government like it is SpaceX? What about the purges, the lawlessness? The answer is yes, there is. It is the surrender to it all. It is the laying down on the tracks when the train is coming. Why can’t Chuck see it? Why can’t Chuck hear it? He is a most preposterous figure. He is a hollow man from a fallen age — the archetype of the 21st century politician so perfectly suited for our fallen moment. The age of silliness has ended, and along with it, any pretenses that menace isn’t real and malice hasn’t seized power in America. It has. The question now is, can we get it back?”

The bugaboo for ‘Real Time’ host Bill Maher is ‘deregulation,’ a repudiation of which he believes is dragging the Democratic Party downwards, suggesting the party is facing the same fate as the Whig Party which collapsed in the 1850s, and a notion they should embrace. He cited the American Redistricting Project’s outlook that Democrats will lose congressional seats in CaliforniaNew YorkIllinoisMinnesotaRhode Island and Oregon by 2030, with Republicans gaining seats in TexasFloridaIdaho and Utah“I mean, it looks like ‘game over.’ And the reason why people are voting with their feet is a lot what your book is about: taxes and regulation,” he told New York Times columnist and ‘Abundance‘ co-author Ezra Klein“I’ve been screaming about it forever. We’re taxed (in California) more than any other state. People are leaving these kind of states for places where they don’t feel the heavy breath of government on them. It’s not that hard for Democrats to understand this, but they don’t. They seem to be incapable of doing anything about it,” he continued. Klein’s response cited polls revealing the reason people are ditching Blue States is ‘cost of living,’ stressing that if 2030 projections hold, the Red States will ultimately allow Republicans to win presidential elections without the Blue wall states of PennsylvaniaMichigan and Wisconsin“They are driving people out, working-class families, out of the states they govern because the cost of living is too high,” Klein says, linking it to regulations and taxes, adding, “But the big problem is they just don’t have enough energy, not a government capable of delivering, and they’ve been treating that as not a real problem.” He went on to praise Texas and cities like Houston and Austin which are booming because of their friendly environment for home and energy development, while noting the irony of the Texas GOP’s opposition to clean energy, yet able to thrive because of deregulation. “We need an Elon Musk who would do to California what he’s doing to the government — in a sane way. I mean, if you have 400,000 regulations and you cannot build a high-speed rail that started in 2008, you need somebody to come in here. Who is this person on the left?” Responding to his question, panelist and Substack writer, Andrew Sullivan said, “The left doesn’t want to deregulate. They just don’t have that instinct to deregulate. They’re gonna have to get over it, or they’re gonna be the Whigs.”

With the Democrats approval rating at 27%, Donald Trump’s star rose to a 44% rating, his highest-ever, prompting him to crow about it on Truth Social — still underwater, however, with 51% of those polled in disapproval. Americans who believe the country is on the right track also hit the 44% mark, with 54% saying we’re on the wrong track, but the Trump border security and immigration issues got a 55% approval. The economy polling has another topsy-turvy result with 54% disapproving of Trump policies, and a 44% approval rating in the NBC poll. Intra-party rifts and frustration consumed the Democrats in Congress as lawmakers approached a possible government shutdown a couple of weeks ago, as Senate Democrats had to decide between a House approved, GOP plan to keep the government afloat — a choice between backing Trump legislation giving him more power, or a shutdown forcing hundreds of thousands of workers to be idled. In the end, ten Senate Democrats sided with the MAGA side of the aisle avoiding a shutdown. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse is asking for less animosity, calling for Dems to end the “intramural quarreling” in this “fight for democracy,” as “we fight in the dugout, being absent on the field and the other team scoring runs.” Senator Chris Murphy, a ‘no’ voter, said he gets it why some of his colleagues voted to avoid a shutdown, but this risk aversion led to the party sinking to a historic low in polling. “I understand that had we gone into a shutdown, even for a handful of days, it would have been difficult, but it would have sent a message that the Democratic Party is not going to be bullied by Donald Trump.” In a CNN poll, 57% of Democrats and Democratic-aligned independents feel that party leaders should focus on stopping the GOP agenda, with 42% wanting cooperation with Republicans.

Last week, President Trump signed an executive order directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to “take all necessary steps to facilitate the closure of the Department of Education and return education authority to the States, while continuing to ensure the effective and uninterrupted delivery of services, programs, and benefits on which Americans rely,” though completely shuttering the 45 year-old agency will require an act of Congress. The workforce had already been cut in half, and dozens of grants and contracts canceled, all of which have drawn legal challenges. Former wrestling executive McMahon’s actions will effectively destroy a $100 billion-a-year department created by President Carter, as surely as Trump’s gutting of funding for the National Institutes of Health, the National Science Foundation and effective closure of USAID. Not to be overlooked are his and RFK Jr’s attacks on vaccine science, Trump’s attacks on freedom of speech of university students and professors, and state attacks on teaching truth in our schools about America’s history of slavery and Native American genocide. Then we have attacks on libraries with an executive order mandating cuts in funding, which will jeopardize literacy development and reading programs, reliable internet for those without it at home, and homework help and other resources for students and educators. The same executive order cut funding for museums, and on the arts, as Trump appointed himself as chair of the Kennedy Center in DCRobert Reich sees all this as an attack on the American mind, as “tyrants throughout history have understood that their major enemy is an educated citizenry. Slaveholders prohibited slaves from learning to read. Nazi’s burned books. Ignorance is the handmaiden of tyranny.” Reich sees Trump as “the frontman in this attack which is really coming from the anti-democracy movement: From JD Vance; and from Vance’s major financial backer, venture capitalist Peter Thiel, who staked Vance’s senatorial campaign and helped convince Trump to select Vance as VP; and from Thiel’s early business partner, Elon Musk.”

Thiel is a self-styled libertarian who once wrote: “I no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible.” Reich responded with, “Hello? Freedom is incompatible with democracy only if you view democracy as a potential constraint on your wealth and power. Curtis Yarvin comes as close as anyone to being their intellectual godfather. He has written that political power in the US is held by a liberal amalgam of universities and the mainstream media whose commitment equality and justice is eroding America’s social order. In Yarvin’s view, democratic governments are inefficient and wasteful. They should be replaced with sovereign joint-stock corporations whose major ‘shareholders’ select an executive with total power, who serves at their pleasure. Yarvin refers to the city-state of Singapore as an example of a successful authoritarian regime. Be warned,” advises Reich. Former Obama adviser, Steven Rattner, wrote on X“The Department of Education provides crucial funding for low-income public schools — eliminating it would result in the loss of 6% of teachers’ jobs nationwide.” He presented a chart based on data from the Center of American Progress on states’ K-12 education funding under Title I, the Ed Department’s main federal program to help low-income students, showing LouisianaMississippiFloridaAlabamaNevada, and Arizona — Trump states — as most reliant on that funding, and the most likely to lose hundreds of teachers, with many other Red States close behind. Rattner says this will likely lead to a devastating domino effect of educational instability in states that need it most.

Conservatives argue that other education department functions, such as administering loans, should be handled instead by the US Department of Treasury, and that civil rights infractions are the Department of Justice’s domain. Trump’s allies also want to expand school choice, which would allow students and families to use public money to select private or religious alternatives to public schools. But who can forget Trump’s primary victory speech in Nevada, when he said, “We won with the young. We won with the old. We won with the highly educated. We won with poorly educated. I love the poorly educated.” This post on Quora captures that moment: “A person who misspells three-letter words, talks in code, cannot finish a single thought in a sentence, acts like a toddler, and only thinks of himself with a strong desire to be worshipped and loved by his followers, will almost literally roll over and have his belly scratched for money by actual billionaires and corporate goons. Although graduating from Penn State, claiming he went to Wharton School of Business, his professors said he was the dumbest person they ever taught — and who could prove otherwise since he forbids his school records to be divulged. Military school instructors called him the dumbest person on the planet. I peg his IQ at about a 75, slightly above my dog’s IQ, which is borderline Special Needs. The scary part is how many MAGA supporters think he is a very smart man — revealing volumes about their own IQs.”

“Trump, his chief of ghouls Stephen Miller, and his czar of white ethnonationalism, Tom Homan, have been making the rounds of calling out ‘rogue’ federal judges who dare to try to apply the law to Trump and his administration,” wrote Elie Mystal in The Nation. The chief executive has called out for the impeachment of US District Judge James E Boasberg, who ordered Trump to halt the deportations of Venezuelans to El Salvador — which Trump ignored. “That SEEMED to trigger Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts, prompting him to pull out the weapon most preferred by institutionalists to fight the fascist takeover of the government: the sternly worded letter,” reports Mystal. Roberts issued a statement which read, in full: “For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose.” Mystal says people who don’t know any better are calling this a rare “rebuke” of the sitting president from the Chief Justice“I urge people to not fall for the ‘Okiedoke,’ and to understand Robert’s statement for what it is: meaningless drivel from a man trying to protect his own stature instead of trying to protect the country from a tyrant.” Robert’s letter telling Trump that impeachment is not an ‘appropriate response’ to a judicial disagreement is like me telling Trump that he can’t jump off his roof and fly. It’s not a ‘rebuke’ to tell somebody they shouldn’t do what they physically can’t do anyway. Impeachment of federal judges follows the same rules as the impeachment of a president, a process familiar to Trump, where the House brings impeachment charges, and the Senate presides over a trial which requires a two-thirds vote for conviction. Mystal gets a dig in, when he says, “Trump controls the House, but he doesn’t control two-thirds of the Senate. Judge Boasberg is not Palestinian, so I don’t think Chuck Schumer will give Trump the extra votes he needs.”

“Justice Roberts knows all that. His statement is meaningless because it tells Trump not to do something he already can’t do. Roberts is sprinting to the head of the parade already in motion, just to look like he’s leading it,” says Mystal. Looking at what Roberts didn’t say, Mystal points out that Trump is in direct violation of Boasberg’s order, but Roberts avoided that, and instead of an admonishment, Roberts only invoked the ‘normal appellate review process,’ NOT saying Trump should litigate disagreements with the judge, but saying Trump should feel free to ignore lower-court orders until the Supreme Court has a chance to weigh in — essentially telling Trump what he wants to hear. Roberts is trying to maintain the appearance of power in the face of a president who has shown no inclination to respect it, with the Chief Justice desperately trying sound as if he’s in control, to avoid a judicial confrontation with Trump. Mystal calls it a delicate game, looking back in history to Chief Justice John Marshall’s attempt to maintain an appearance of judicial supremacy against President Thomas Jefferson — the Marbury v. Madison case in 1803. The case dealt with the seating of commissioners appointed by President Adams, seats Jefferson didn’t wish to fill, so a lawsuit was initiated by William Marbury. Marshall knew Jefferson was never going to fill those positions, and all the court orders in the world wouldn’t have mattered a whit to Jefferson, so Marshall deferred to the president, saying it was wrong not to seat the commissioners, but it didn’t matter anyway because the entire congressional law itself was unconstitutional. Mystal concludes, “He was bending the knee.” Turn down the echo machine!

A phone call between President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin to discuss ending the war in Ukraine has comedian Jimmy Fallon casting a jaundiced eye, saying, “Both sides said the call went well, which makes sense because they’re both on the same side. Russia actually described the call as historic and epic, and nothing makes me feel safe like a happy Russia.” Despite the hype, the New York Times reported that the call accomplished nearly nothing, with Fallon joking, “The White House said Putin agreed to a partial ceasefire — at least they think he did. It was tough to hear on the phone with Elon’s kids playing tag in the background.”

Speaking of happy — the US has dropped to its lowest-ever ranking on the World Happiness Report conducted by Wellbeing Research Centre at the University of Oxford in partnership with Gallup and the UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network. Falling down one spot from last year, to 24th, and from the nation’s highest ranking of 11th place in 2012, rankings are determined from answers people give when asked to rate their own lives. Finland has held the top spot for eight years, followed by DenmarkIcelandSweden, and the Netherlands in the top five; Costa Rica and Mexico entered the top ten for the first time, ranking sixth and tenth place, respectively. Brent Hartinger and Michael Jensen-Brent in the Washington Post say that people don’t want to go to parties anymore — along with other signs the world is coming to an end. They say Americans‘ current obsession with social media and “therapy culture” isn’t going to end well, as people who do show up at social gatherings are sitting to one side staring at their phones assuring that things rarely take off. The Wall Street Journal adds that it’s now socially acceptable — even something brag about — to cancel your plans with other people at the last second. Both publications blame these new social mores on America’s political polarization — who wants to socialize with people on ‘the other side’ anyway? They say it’s the lingering after-effects of COVID — but please, that’s not it at all; why are both newspapers pretending not to see what’s really going on? Smartphones and social media! Why bother interacting with actual human beings when you can have all your social needs met by living online? Teachers will tell us that kids are literally addicted to their phones, accustomed to the dopamine hits from social media that bring on actual symptoms of withdrawal when separated from their phones. The greater problem is that social media isn’t really real; it’s the illusion of intimacy. It gives people what we want, to keep us forever engaged and looking at ads — but not what we need. It’s also important to sometimes be bored. And remember, as great as cat videos are, actual cats are always better.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Spring

“In the spring, at the end of the day, you should smell like dirt.”
~Margaret Atwood

“In the Spring, I have counted 136 different kinds of weather inside of 24 hours.”
~Mark Twain

“You can cut all the flowers but you cannot keep spring from coming.”
~Pablo Neruda

“In winter, I plot and plan. In spring, I move.”
~Henry Rollins

“Never cut a tree down in the wintertime. Never make a negative decision in the low time. Never make your most important decisions when you are in your worst moods. Wait. Be patient. The storm will pass. The spring will come.”
~Robert H. Schuller

...

This music is very different from last week’s offering. It is a playlist of 3 hours worth of mellow, groovy, instrumental music that you can play in the background when you’re doing something else. You’re welcome! 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

March 19 – 25, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on the Meder St. development… Steinbruner… Batteries, fire map, and private well owners… Hayes… We Are One… Patton… Direct Action On The “Climate Crisis”… Matlock… …tireless…nothing in return…cuz u trash… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… Salut Salon … Quotes on… “Timelines”

...

OFFICIAL OPENING OF OUR MUNICIPAL WHARF. This was in 1918; little did these folks know how we would beautify our wharf with our fabulous commercial enterprises. Do note the northern angle the wharf takes…that’s what saved it from the monstrous waves and storms over all these decades (over a century), until the recent debacle. Hmmm, I wonder what changed…

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email webmistress@brattononline.com

Dateline: March 19, 2025

Donate to BrattonOnline

It was suggested to me that I put up a donation pitch again, as it’s been quite a while. Here goes:

BrattonOnline is a work of passion, with varying contributors that started around the core of Bruce (obviously) and Gunilla, who began doing this in 2003. We miss Bruce tremendously, and are doing our best to continue this work in his honor.

We don’t get paid, but there are costs associated with running a website. If you want to pitch in, we are ever so grateful!!

This button takes you to a secure donation form.

...

WHAT’S YOUR FAVORITE THING HERE IN PARADISE? I often tell people, “Well, I do live in Paradise!” when they complain about, for example, their winter weather and mention how good I have it. I’ve been here since 1996, and I do love it. I googled “Santa Cruz” for some writing inspo, and the things that came up were mixed, to say the least! There were lots of articles about it being “the most expensive rental market in the US”, and lots of “5 things to do in Santa Cruz!”, which covered stuff like miles-long beaches and trails, the Boardwalk, and other “touristy” things.

My best friend from high school back home in Sweden, whom I hadn’t seen in 29 years(!!!) was recently here for a visit with my other friend from Sweden who lives in Portland. We had 3 glorious days of 3 BFFs hanging out being tourists, and I brought them to Roaring Camp, the Mystery Spot, a walk on West Cliff, a soak at Well Within, and a Sin Sisters Burlesque show at Kuumbwa Jazz Center. It felt like the right blend of relaxing, yet packed few days, and as often when you show someone new around your town, I got a better appreciation of it myself. I’m wondering what places you would bring someone to? What absolute must-sees did I miss? If you are so inclined, feel free to email me about it at webmistress@BrattonOnline.com 🙂

This has been part of my attempted self-care regimen that involves staying positive despite currently inhabiting the darkest possible timeline… do also feel free to share your tips and tricks! I now return you to your regularly scheduled programming…

...

THE ELECTRIC STATE. Netflix Movie (6 IMDb) ***- This has the energy of ’80s adventure films, like Batteries Not Included and War Games, with a touch of Fallout retro-futurism. Here’s the deal: In the ’50s, Walt Disney sparked a robot boom, leading to a robot rebellion in the ’90s. After the war, robots were confined to a walled-off Midwest wasteland. Michelle (Millie Bobby Brown) discovers her genius brother, supposedly dead, stuck in a robot shell and searching for a mysterious doctor. Keats (Chris Pratt) and his robot sidekick help her break into the wasteland. They’re pursued by a robot exterminator (Giancarlo Esposito) working for a tech billionaire, Skate (Stanley Tucci), who wants Michelle’s brother. Fun, nostalgic, and spot-on art direction. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

ADOLESCENCE. Netflix Series (8.4 IMDb) *** I was going to start off saying this was uninspired in its execution, till I saw a shot fly up from one character, fly several blocks away, drop down to where another character is getting out of a car, and hold a steady close up – all in one shot. A British crime drama about the impact of incel politics on pre-sexual children. Very saddening. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

[Mea culpa! I overwrote the review below with a different one last week, so sorry! Thanks to a reader for the email letting me know! Here’s the correct one: ~Webmistress]

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. AppleTV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- I don’t know how accurate this is as a depiction of young Bob Dylan (Timothee Chalamet), but it does make me yearn for those days as an adult (I wouldn’t be released till ’63). The film basically encapsulates Dylan from ’61 to ’65, following his relationships, and rise in the folk community, and his troubled transition to something more. Ed Norton as the supportive and eventally outgrown Pete Seeger, Elle Fanning as Dylan’s constantly trying-to-stay-in-his-focus lover Sylvie Russo/Suze Rotolo, and Monica Barbaro as the legendary sometime lover/sometime music partner Joan Baez. Worth a watch.~Sarge

THE BRUTALIST. PrimeTV. Movie (7.5 IMDb) *** I thought the title was JUST a reference to the Brutalist Movement in art and architecture. Oh how wrong I was. A brutal story about love, separation, and power. Adrien Brody is gut-wrenching in his performance as a holocaust survivor, drug addict, and brutalist architect. It’s like dragging yourself along the edge of a straight razor – the further forward you go, the deeper it cuts. Painful, but worth a watch. Interesting note – while Brody’s character is fictional, the name Lazlo Toth (and variants) is out there, most notable to me, it was the name of the guy who vandalized La Pieta, and it was the pen-name of Don Novello (Reverend Guido Sarducci on old SNL) when writing his “Lazlo Letters”. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

...

March 17, 2025

Turning a Silk Purse

This sweet piece of open space land is at 422 and 430 Meder St., opposite the Jewish Cemetery. It is the site of a proposed development project for ninety-seven townhouses. The builder is KB Home, a company that “builds homes primarily for first-time home buyers” according to Wikipedia. A meeting was held by the city on March 10, for the public to give opinions and ask questions on the design and pre-application review of the project. I, along with over ninety others, attended the virtual community meeting. The overwhelming sentiment from those who spoke or wrote comments was one of dismay; not for the fact that the land was finally being built on, but for the density of the development; ninety-seven three-story townhouses on a six and a half-acre site.

First some history. I’m acquainted with the long-time owner of this property. Sometime in the late 1980’s or early 1990’s I recall his frustration with the city over his trying to develop the property for first-time, single-family home buyers. The proposed houses, probably twenty-five in all – the allowed zoning in this R1-10 zoned district – were to be modest in scale and affordable to first-time homebuyers. The city pushed back hard, they wanted density, he didn’t. Finally, he gave up, withdrew the application and the land has remained a horse paddock ever since, until recently.

This newly proposed KB Home project comes in at fifteen units per acre, compared with approximately four units per acre according to R1-10 zoning. It includes the state’s density bonus, which raises the allowed number of units from ten to fifteen per acre. I have searched the city’s Municipal Code and General Plan but can find no entry for such a significant change to the stated zoning for R1-10, even with the addition of state-mandated density bonus and allowed ADU’s. This project is listed as a Medium-density project which I thought is disallowed in an R1 zone. I have emailed the project planner and hope to get more clarity by next issue and will correct or question, depending on the city’s response.

Leaving aside the zoning question for now, what else did we learn about this project? The representative from KB Home explained the townhouses are intended for families. Each is four bedrooms with three and a half baths. This aroused my skepticism. If KB Home is known for building for first-time home buyers, why would each townhouse have the same number of bedrooms? And why four bedrooms? Not suitable for most first-time homebuyers looking for affordable housing, but ideal for students.

After their first year on campus, students look for off-campus rental housing, usually a house where they share bedrooms and living space. Four bedrooms and almost as many bathrooms is an ideal layout for students. Given the proximity to UCSC with its lack of sufficient housing for its growing student body, a savvy investor would snap up these ninety-seven townhouses to rent to students. My hunch grew stronger with a look at the project plans, which show the ninety-seven townhouses arranged in barrack-like rows. If you were designing townhouses for young families, you would consider arranging them in clusters around a safe play space for children. There is no play space anywhere in the project plans. Granted this was an initial design and could change but it was presumably prepared to appeal to the public. Nothing in the project or the design appealed to the vast majority who expressed opinions.

When asked what the price range was to be for a townhouse, the representative said, “we don’t have a price range yet.” That is hard to believe. I can’t imagine securing funding without some specifics on rate of return. There were many concerns expressed; increased traffic at nearby, already dangerous intersections, impact on the wide range of wildlife that live on or traverse the property, impact on the water table, protection for the creek and a consensus that the scale was out of all proportion to the area. One commenter with a mastery of the English language called it an “aesthetic crime!”

With respect to the question of affordability, the 15% of units earmarked as “affordable” are for those earning the moderate rate or 120% of the Area Median Income (AMI). The KB Home representative mentioned teachers and public employees as examples. However, those two categories of workers are in the current Low-Income category given the escalating rate of AMI in the city due to the influx of high-income professional workers and the exodus of low-income service workers. It’s past time to have a public dialogue on the use and misuse of these income categories and assess who they are helping and who they are not helping.

To be continued.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

WHAT WILL PRIVATE WELL OWNERS PAY?
The MidCounty Groundwater Agency called a meeting for private well owners on St. Patrick’s Day to present a plan for a new tax on parcels and wells in order to fund the Agency’s $650,000 anticipated cost for compliance with the State mandates. I was very happy to see the large meeting room at Simpkins Swim Center full and overflowing and that it was a presentation with question and answer format, rather than a noisy open house social hour.

In general , people are against having to pay anything to the Agency because they are already paying to maintain their wells, pay the high cost of electricity to pump their water, and argued that septic recharge should be considered as a benefit to the groundwater recharge efforts of the region.

The matter will NOT be put to a vote of the property owners, who would be asked to pay a parcel tax plus a fee based on how much water they pump. The consultant estimated there are 1,900 parcels that could be assessed $20-$45 each, in addition to the water use tax. One fellow did the math and objected that the amount for the parcel tax alone would be well over the 10% the consultant’s pie chart showed in the presentation that would be needed from the private well owners to “pay their share”.

The MidCounty Groundwater Agency Board meets Thursday, March 19 at 6pm in the Capitola Library. People need to show up and speak up. Recent News | Santa Cruz Mid-County Groundwater Agency

ANOTHER IMPORTANT COUNTY CITIZEN’S ADVISORY COMMISSION TO BITE THE DUST?
I attended the County Housing Advisory Commission meeting on Wednesday, March 18. It was the first time the Planning Dept. staff had not cancelled the meeting in a year. How can that be when housing issues are so critical? The main topic on the Commission agenda was to provide comment on what the Board should regarding whether their advisory body stays intact or gets the ax, as several others have experienced.

Seasoned and knowledgeable Commissioners presented excellent comment to support their continued regular gathering to review housing policy and make recommendations to the Board that has appointed them. Appointing “stakeholders” without regard to countywide representation will not necessarily provide a balanced analysis of any policy the Planning Dept. or Board wants to have the Commission weigh in on for the record.

The thrust of all this has come from a study the County and City of Santa Cruz did to analyze composition of commissions based on ethnicity and socio-economic status. They also want more youth to serve on commissions, so now offer a $75/meeting stipend, despite claiming the reason the number of commission meetings would have to be dropped due to the staffing costs.

Hmmm….

The staff from the County Administrative Office, who is clearly pushing this agenda, said he appreciated the comments of the Housing Advisory Commissioners, but had his mind made up in what he plans to recommend to the Board of Supervisors in the near future. I’ll bet you can guess what that means….

PUBLIC MEETING ABOUT THE LARGE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROPOSED FOR 41ST & SOQUEL DRIVE
This location was at one time going to be another car sales lot, but the residents in Soquel launched a legal challenge because the Sustainable Santa Cruz County Plan had designated it for housing. That group won. Now, the lot where King’s Paint & Paper is proposed for a large affordable housing project. Come learn more about that on Thursday, March 27, 6pm-7:30pm in the Simpkins Swim Center’s Live Oak Community Room (979 17th Avenue). Light refreshments will be available, as well as Spanish translation. Children welcome.

DID YOU GET NOTIFICATION OF CPUC LANDLINE HEARINGS?
The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) will again be hearing pleadings from telephone service companies to eliminate them as Carrier of Last Resort (COLR), in yet another attempt to drop landline telephone service that is vital for rural areas when the electricity goes out, and there is no cell phone service.

The CPUC directed these telephone carriers to notify all their customers of the public hearings scheduled for April on the matter. Did you receive that notice? I have not, and neither have many people who depend on reliable landline phone service.

Here is what the CPUC ordered AT&T and others to do.

The carriers listed above are directed to:

  • Include notice of the PPHs as a written insert with a mailed bill to customers that currently receive bills via the United States Postal Service. The notice shall state the dates and times of the PPHs, and other information contained in Attachment A. The carriers listed above shall provide a draft notice to the Public Advisor’s Office within 10 days of the issuance of this ruling, and the Public Advisor’s Office may modify the draft notice;
  • Send an e-mail message to all customers that elect to receive their bills via e-mail. The subject line of the e-mail must clearly notify the recipient that the PPHs will be held in this proceeding and include other information contained in Attachment A. The carriers listed above shall provide a draft notice to the Public Advisor’s Office within 10 days of the issuance of this ruling, and the Public Advisor’s Office may modify the draft notice;
  • Send a text message to all customers that elect to receive their bills via text. The carriers listed above shall provide a draft notice to the Public Advisor’s Office within 10 days of the issuance of this ruling, and the Public Advisor’s Office may modify the draft notice;
  • Publicize the PPHs on all social media platforms used by the companies listed above; and
  • Post notice of the PPHs on the companies’ website in a prominent location so that customers can easily access the notice. By no later than March 27, 2025, each carrier or provider listed above shall file a letter with the Public Advisor’s Office verifying that it has complied with all directives set forth above and attaching a copy of the notice for each communication method. For each communication method described above, the letter shall state the dates the carrier sent the notice to customers, and the approximate number of customers notification.

I looked on AT&T’s website and found nothing, other than the notice of the hearings on this matter held last year!

CPUC APPROVES BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM ORDER
In case you have not yet heard, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) approved an update to Order 167 on March 13, relating to safety of battery energy storage system (BESS) safety policy and procedures. It became effective immediately.

The new regulation requires battery energy storage system (BESS) owners and operators to:

  1. implement the Senate Bill (SB) 1383 (Hueso, 2022) mandate to establish standards for the maintenance and operation of Energy Storage Systems;
  2. apply SB 38 (Laird, 2023) requirements for Emergency Response and Emergency Action Plans to Energy Storage System Owners;
  3. require Generating Asset Owners to coordinate with local authorities in developing their emergency plans;
  4. establish Logbook Standards for Energy Storage Systems and Renewable Generating Assets and revise Logbook Standards for each Generating Asset;
  5. modify Maintenance and Operation Standards for Generating Assets;
  6. add provisions to enhance safety and effectiveness of Generating Assets and Energy Storage Systems operation and maintenance;
  7. update procedures, references, and definitions;
  8. remove obsolete references and add relevant language; and
  9. update applicable industry codes, standards, and organizations.

SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS:

  • Will improve the safety and reliability of California electric generation facilities and energy storage facilities.

CPUC AUTHORIZES LARGE POWER COMPANIES TO PAY THE SIERRA CLUB FOR THEIR HELP
Also on the March 13 CPUC docket was approval to have ratepayers reimburse the Sierra Club for their help in some decision-making. Called “Intervenor Compensation”, the Sierra Club got paid $20,232.50 for their help. They had requested more. It was a consent agenda item…considered non-controversial. Should the ratepayers have to fund private groups who act as “Intervenors”? What do you think? Aren’t our power bills high enough?

R.20-05-003
Order Instituting Rulemaking to Continue Electric Integrated Resource Planning and Related Procurement Processes.

PROPOSED OUTCOME:

  • Awards Sierra Club $20,232.50 for substantial contribution to Decision (D.) 24-08- 064. D.24-08-064 makes an initial need determination under the provisions of Assembly Bill 1373, where the California Public Utilities Commission may request that the Department of Water Resources procure electricity from diverse long lead- time resources on behalf of customers of all load-serving entities under the Commission’s integrated resource planning purview. Sierra Club originally requested $21,322.50.

SAFETY CONSIDERATIONS:

  • Substantial contribution by intervenors, as found here, enhances the Commission’s ability to resolve safety and other issues under Public Utilities Code Section 451 for each public utility, by taking all actions “necessary to promote the safety, health, comfort, and convenience of its patrons, employees, and the public.”

ESTIMATED COST:

  • $20,232.50, plus interest, to be paid by the ratepayers of Pacific Gas and Electric Company, San Diego Gas & Electric Company, and Southern California Edison Company. (Comr Alice Reynolds – Judge Fitch) http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/SearchRes.aspx?docformat=ALL&docid=557444163 Pub. Util. Code §1701.1 — This proceeding is categorized as Ratesetting

NEW FIRE HAZARD MAPS WILL CAUSE BIG CHANGES IN OUR COUNTY
I attended the Scotts Valley Fire informational workshop recently and had an opportunity to speak with Fire District staff as well as representatives from the Building Dept. and Water Dept.

The State Fire Marshal released the maps last month, and identified many areas in local fire district jurisdiction as having high fire hazard classification. Take a look at the map

The change this generates is, according to the Building Dept staff, all structures built in 2010 and after will have to comply with one-hour fire rating materials and have zero combustible surfaces within the first five feet of any and all structures, including decks. No more composition roofing will be allowed. And, if one wants to upgrade a structure, the work will have to meet the new fire safety requirements.

On and after July 1, 2021 when you sell property that is located in a high or very high fire hazard severity zone, you’ll need documentation of a compliant Defensible Space Inspection. More information about requesting a Real Estate Defensible Space Inspection here.

I was glad to see the Water District’s presentation about the Graham Hill Blvd. work starting very soon to create an intertie connection with the City of Santa Cruz for regional water supply improvement. Traffic there will be a mess this summer, but the infrastructure and improved water supply for a large wildland fire will be worth the headaches….I think.

WRITE ONE LETTER. MAKE ONE CALL. ATTEND A PUBLIC HEARING ABOUT SOMETHING THAT REALLY MATTERS TO YOU AND ASK QUESTIONS.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
We Are One

Do humans all want the same things? Do we all know good from bad? When we look for explanations, for meaning, do we all find the same answers, and feel the same sense of wonder? It is my experience that we have much in common.

In Search of Unity

A critique of Our Time Now is that too many are finding too much fault and see too many divisions. Where is unity?

It is easy for me to find My Tribe and to describe The Others. My tribe consists of the ones who believe that all species deserve a chance and we learn to operate from that principle. Often, we feel apart, too few. We despair to see the Monterey Bay’s most special places disappear to poorly planned development, approved by bureaucrats who feel that their jobs are to strike a balance. We believe humans are capable of better, but that money and politics bend to special interests, eroding the quality of life for future generations. We know what is lost in the real world of biology, deep in the fertile healthy soil and along the ancient paths of wildlife, cannot be regained.

Then there are The Many Others, who have other principles. Many are just ‘getting by.’ A great many just want to have fun. Then there are the ones who worship money above all else, and the ones who believe that technology will somehow keep us alive and well after the loss of most of Earth’s natural biosystems. I have met these people, we have spoken about such things. These people are not strangers, they are not abstract. Can anything bring us together?

Falling Apart, Together

One unifying theme I see is a widespread belief that things are falling apart. My Tribe is unified in understanding that humans’ relationship with Earth is increasingly critically imperiled due to poor collaboration, greed, and despotism. Many others believe that humans are doomed to extinction, perhaps sooner than later. We see that a great many people believe that things have already reached a critical state, requiring absolute destruction. There is ample evidence to support all of those positions.

Somehow, through this varied cacophony of hopelessness, a stolid force has held up a belief that everything will be alright.

Coming Together, Naturally

Another unifying theme I experience is widespread trust that everything will turn out fine. We get in our cars and drive sometimes very high speeds among thousands of strangers expecting to arrive safely at our destinations. We go to the store and find almost everything we expect to buy. Our bank accounts are secure. The weather doesn’t go to wonky extremes very often. Most of us can get food and find a safe place to sleep, largely thanks to a society that works due to trust and routine. When things don’t turn out how we expect, most people believe that humans are working to make things better, that we will have solutions to the world’s great problems. There is ample evidence to support those beliefs.

Many people simultaneously hold positive beliefs alongside much more despairing ones. How do we reconcile such disparate world views?

Discrepancies

I have noticed many people struggling with holding opposite world views, unresolved. Most notably, I’ve seen people simultaneously decrying the inhumanity of the US ‘justice’ system and yet lauding it when it turns out favorably to their beliefs…all the while with an inability to detail even rudimentary synopses of legal arguments used in judgements. I’ve also witnessed people believing governments will find a workable solution to climate change despite local, national, and international decisions to the contrary. And, individuals celebrate trickle down economics when evidence strongly contradicts such approaches. In each case, it seems to me that there has not been enough smart talk, enough curiosity, to resolve these discrepancies. We need more smart talk.

Howdy!

After the hellos and beyond the weather, we must find things to talk about to bring us together. This will take getting personal, kindly. We might practice quickly arriving at the question of ‘what do you want to be remembered for?’ Or perhaps, ‘who has done the most good for you, personally (and why)?’ Asking people about how they are feeling is a good idea, too, but perhaps go more deeply than ‘how’s it going?’ Prolonging topics and conversations is a skill I’m seeing as important.

Carry It Forward

The most liked people remember things. Politicians remember names and faces and a few facts about many people. Every social network has someone or some few who recall many more personal things. Your circle is held together by shared memories, by long conversations lasting years. We build community by carrying conversations based on memory, respect, and kind curiosity.

What if we all make it a point to have more caring conversations, taking them as far as seems right each time we see each other? What if we take those conversations to people on our periphery, to build larger communities, to make a more peaceful society, to sustain Life on Earth? We must turn those conversations over and over in our minds, curiously seeking understanding, coming up with the next questions, and bringing those cherished questions back when we reconnect. This is what will bring healing.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

I do not, personally, like to talk about “Global Warming” under the rubric of “Climate,” or “Climate Change.” Human-caused “Global Warming,” or “Global Heating,” is what is actually going on, and what is causing all the climate-related issues we have come to consider as “normal.” Nonetheless, and despite my personal linguistic preferences, the illustration above does come from a website that references “Climate.” I am using it because I think that the image conveys an important message, which can be grasped even by those who do not, actually, read what I am writing about today. My title, therefore, reflects the source of the image which heads up this blog posting. It also references the statement I have included, below, which also uses “Climate” to describe the challenges now facing us.

Today’s blog posting is, essentially, to pass on the statement that I have included below. The statement is one that I received by way of an email from an instructor at Cabrillo Community College, addressed to those who are part of a “Sunrise Santa Cruz” listserve, which focuses on the Global Warming challenge to human civilization. The photo, taken in our Nation’s Capital, includes two members of Sunrise Santa Cruz, proudly present to argue for dramatic changes in national policy.

What do you think about the idea put forward by that Cabrillo College Instructor (see below)? Do you think that we would be willing to occupy our nation’s capital until our elected representatives actually start taking action on our Global Warming Crisis?

I would like to think that we could muster the kind of action described below. See what you think. Next step would be to do some planning for such a direct action – what would be an ongoing “occupation” of the nation’s capital until our elected officials start taking actions that they have avoided taking so far. Maybe the occupation could begin on the first day of Summer (June 20, 2025), as things start really heating up – as forests burn and heat deaths grow. How about that?

THE PROPOSAL:
A strong presence in DC is key to getting momentum in a good direction. For 14 years of teaching Climate Science now, I’ve had as my primary recommended action, to launch an occupation of DC ‘Occupy DC for Climate” with a rotating army of ~1/2 million people who will serve a ~1 week “tour of duty” with their backpack and total self-containment, before rotating home and another take their place. A large enough group they cannot be jailed, cannot be “disappeared”, cannot be hauled off without a half million iPhones capturing the actions of the police or National Guard against its own citizens. Citizens scrupulously obeying non-violence of course. Not a weekend march, but an occupation, with clear specific legislative demands to be enacted before the Occupation disbands. In contraast, One-on-one with your congressperson is NOT effective. Not when Party Unity is the insistence, and so no individual Republican or Democrat will dare break ranks, poke head above fox-hole, with their party, for fear of being “primaried” out next time, or worse. But if ALL are in the Capitol, looking out over a mob of insistent citizens – it has a very different effect, and the threat to their domination over the People is felt as real. They may begin to take more seriously that nagging guilt inside them, of being a coward towards defending the best of Democracy and honorable welfare (emphasis added).

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
NO EXIT RAMP, ADULTS IN THE ROOM, FREEDOM FRECKLES

Stephen Colbert who recently mocked Democrats and their hand-held protest signs displayed at Trump’s State-of-the-Trump speech at the joint session of Congress, has gained a bit traction with his own paddle-sign that read “Try Doing Something.” Protests against the administration’s policies are becoming more common, larger in number and in participants, with representatives holding town halls in their districts being forced to flee because of voter anger — advisers are saying, “just skip this tradition!” One person who has been persistent in punching at Trump with Tweets for years, but magnifying her activity since last October, is Natasha Rothwell, who starred as Belinda in the TV series, ‘The White Lotus.’ Every single day she posts a message reminding the president in some form saying, “Donald Trump, you are trash!” Natasha may include retweets, quotes, likes, and different views, one variant reading, “You have no value or use and you spend your days lying around doing nothing…cuz u trash.” Not content to pick on just Donny, her header on X has ‘TRASH‘ above headshots of the six conservative Supreme Court Justices, with arrows pointing appropriately to insure that they feel the burn.

Feeling the burn from last week’s vote on the continuing resolution to fund the government until September, is Senator Chuck Schumer who succumbed to the demands of blackmail as John Stoehr of Editorial Board posted on the blog. Schumer took to the floor and said that he would vote with MAGA to pass the resolution, with Stoehr asking, “What is Schumer getting in return?” He isn’t implying that corruption is an issue, only that this is politics and the Senator must be trading for something, right? The resolution allows Trump and Musk to continue dismantling the government, with Everett B Kelly of the American Federation of Government Employees saying, “A widespread government shutdown has been underway since January 20 and will continue to spread whether Senators vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on HR 1968.” Kelly, leader of the country’s largest public employee union, says HR 1968 sets in stone the administration’s crime spree, decimating agencies without due process, cutting off funding that has already been appropriated and signed into law, and with it the administration “will dramatically expand its termination of federal workers and double down on its campaign to make federal agencies fail, because there will be nothing left” to stop them. He believes it robs the constitutional authority of Congress, with the White House having said that even if the bill passes, it will ‘impound‘ that money — which is to say, ‘steal it’ — if it pays for things that Trump does not like. What it boils down to for Democrats who voted for it, is that Trump will become a criminal president, or if they voted against it, Trump will become a criminal president. Heads…I win, tails…you lose. Not a choice, blackmail, as Stoehr said.

Senator Schumer explained to Chris Hayes in an interview, that he made his choice to vote for the resolution, because the alternative was much worse by allowing a government shutdown. Trump would have favored a shutdown, allowing him to redefine what counts as ‘essential services,’ then cutting the government even closer to the bone. Stoehr saw Schumer’s premise, yet he didn’t explain why the House MAGAs voted to keep the money flowing if co-presidents Musk and Trump preferred a shutdown — and why did Schumer deceive us earlier into thinking he might lead a resistance demanding a one-month extension? Stoehr asks agains, “What are Democrats getting in return?” He answers his own question — “nothing.” Chris Hayes posted that “the institutional Democratic Party is guided by an almost pathological level of conflict-avoidance in almost every direction. ‘What can we do to make the least number of people mad?’ is just a bankrupt way to operate.” Stoehr concludes the Dems pathology is deeper than ‘conflict-avoidance’ — only the fear of being held accountable by someone somewhere “who requires the Democrats to take responsibility for the bad choices made by Republicans. Its’ a deep-seated sense of obligation that the Democrats are the only adults in the room, and if they don’t act like adults, things will get much worse than they are. Schumer believes in his bones that the Democrats must save the Republicans from themselves, and thus save the country from the Republicans, as reflected in his comments about a possible shutdown.”

Schumer is quoted as saying, “There’s no exit ramp. Anyone who wants the shutdown, I have asked: ‘Well, how do we get out of it?’ Guess who it’s up to — Trump, Musk, DOGE, all bad choices. I respect people who don’t want to vote for the CR. It’s awful. But with the alternative being a government shutdown, that’s even worse.” To this, Stoehr replies, “Well, yes! It is up to Trump! And if he does to the government after a shutdown what he’s already doing to it before a shutdown, then whatever happens is on him and him alone. Lots of good people are going to suffer, because the administration is evil. But the Senate Democrats cannot save them, nor should they try, because they cannot hold accountable the man responsible for their suffering if they themselves are complicit in it.” Stoehr feels that institutional Democrat Schumer is taking cues from the mainstream media, not “plucky indie newsletters,” and also the party’s donors who are concentrated in the northeast. “They want the Dems to bargain with the Republicans, not necessarily fight them, as serious combat would probably jeopardize their interests,” he discerns. “In times of crisis the mainstream media understands subconsciously that the Republicans are hopeless but that Democrats are not. They assume that Democrats will be the adults in the room, and because institutional Democrats interpret this assumption as something mainstream voters want, they deliver. Even if it means getting nothing in return.”

Representative Nancy Pelosi, in a statement regarding handling of the funding vote, took a shot at an unnamed Schumer, saying, “Democratic senators should listen to the women. Appropriations leaders Rosa DeLauro and Patty Murray have eloquently presented the case that we must have a better choice: a four-week funding extension to keep government open and negotiate a bipartisan agreement. America has experienced a Trump shutdown before — but this damaging legislation only makes matters worse. Democrats must not buy into this false choice. We must fight back for a better way. Listen to the women, For the People.” She goes on to praise House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries for his leadership in rejecting a false choice, and her colleagues in the House Democratic Caucus for their “overwhelming vote against this bill.” Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said, “There is a deep sense of outrage and betrayal. And not just about progressive Democrats — this is across the board — the entire party. I cannot underscore enough how incorrect that is. There are members of Congress who have won Trump-held districts in some of the most difficult territory in the United States, who walked the plank and took immeasurable risks in order to defend the American people, in order to defend Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare.” Representative Greg Casar, head of the Congressional Progressive Caucus chimed in, saying, “The GOP bill is specifically designed to allow Trump and Musk to continue plundering the taxpayers to enrich themselves.”

In the end, Senators and Representatives voted to “sell our country out to Donald Trump and Elon Musk for mass firings, cuts to vital services, and tax breaks for the rich,” according to the Common Cause website. Elected leaders are sticking to the same passive, by-the-book strategies that empowered people like Trump and Musk in the first place, while abandoning our public services and our values at the altar of political convenience. Stirring up a hornet’s nest of dissatisfied constituents, Senator Schumer was met with a barrage of demands for his resignation, calls which have only escalated. Food & Water Watch executive director Wenonah Hauter said, “Schumer has lost the confidence of a critical mass of well-meaning people around the country. He must step down from his leadership role in the Senate now, so a sufficiently determined resistance to the disastrous Trump-Musk agenda can be allowed to rise up and act before it’s too late.” Human rights lawyer Qasim Rashid said in a blog post, that Schumer must resign, and adding with perspicuity, “Let’s be clear: MAGAs control the House, the Senate, and the White House. The Democratic Party is not in its strongest position, and every single day Trump and Musk are working to gut democracy, attack working families, and consolidate power. And yet, when given the opportunity to use the one piece of leverage Democrats have — forcing Republicans to own the government shutdown — Schumer is folding like a cardboard box in a rainstorm. This isn’t just betrayal. It’s utter incompetence. We don’t need more politicians holding tiny signs and coordinating outfits while Trump consolidates power and enables fascism. We need leadership with the courage to fight injustice and hold the line when it matters.”

Aru Shiney-Ajay, executive director of Sunrise Movement, a youth-led, climate-focused organization, declared that, “Today was a spectacular display of cowardice from Senator Schumer. This morning, Schumer had arrested, 11 young protestors in his office rather than look them in the eye. This afternoon, he gave Elon Musk the keys to the government. Trump’s and Musk are hurtling our country toward disaster. They are gutting the educational system, enabling oil billionaires to burn the planet, and destroying vital government programs that millions rely on. Meanwhile, Chuck Schumer sits on the sidelines. The budget is one of the only pieces of leverage Democrats have, and Schumer just gave it away. That’s incredibly reckless. Chuck Schumer needs to step aside. Our democracy and our climate and our families can’t afford even another month of this b.s.” Democratic strategist, Waleed Shahid, commented, “This wasn’t about whether Democrats were willing to impose a cost on their opponents for governing through blackmail. Instead, Schumer made the kind of move that tells Republicans they can keep pushing.” Justice Democrats, a progressive group that helped Ocasio-Cortez upset a top House Democrat in a 2018 primary, said, “Corporate Democratic leadership is all talk and no fight. Gutless, spineless, and utterly unqualified to lead.” Schumer stepping down from his leadership isn’t enough for many, with many critics encouraging Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or Dan Goldman to challenge the Senator in the 2028 primary.

Domestic beer brewers should take a page from Canada’s oldest brewery, which has announced a ‘Presidential Pack’ of Moosehead beer — 1,461 cans of its Canadian lager, intended to last the course of President Trump’s entire second term, one beer for every day of that term. The pack retails for $3,490 CAD and is sold in Nova ScotiaNew Brunswick, and Ontario provinces. Leaning into the ongoing trade war with the USAKaren Grigg, director of marketing said in a press release, “If the start of 2025 has taught us anything, it’s that it will take determination to weather four years of political uncertainty — and what better way to make it through each day than with a truly Canadian beer.” Trevor Grant, VP of Sales and Marketing said the idea was talked about for a few weeks as the challenges with tariffs and the Trump administration dragged on, and, “Obviously, it’s a bit of a difficult situation, so we’re trying to maybe have a little bit of fun with it, as Canadian shoppers look for locally made products now more than ever.” Many of the big US companies that sell in Canada, like Anheuser-Busch, manufacture American brands within Canada, such as Bud Light, and thus aren’t affected by tariffs — or good taste.

Trump’s Health Secretary, Robert F Kennedy Jr, has remained relatively low-key as the measles outbreak worsens, with cases popping up in even more states across the country. Several weeks ago, Kennedy couldn’t get excited about the first death in Texas, saying, “It is not unusual, we have measles outbreaks every year,” ignoring the fact that outbreaks are considered rare, with measles considered eliminated in the US in 2020. Kennedy has been slammed for writing previously that measles are not deadly and that outbreaks had been “fabricated” to push people toward “unnecessary and risky” vaccines. His prominence in the anti-vax community has been credited with leading to an increase in the number of parents who won’t follow the science, now refusing to vaccinate their children. What our children have now learned from Kennedy and President Trump is that, ‘science is stupid.’ Fran Lebowitz, in her short essay entitled ‘Science,’ writes, “Legend has it that the atom was split when a bunch of scientists working late decided to order in a pizza. Indeed a terrifying story and one made all the more chilling when one learns that a number of their colleagues smarting from the snub of being excluded from this impromptu meal spitefully repaired to an all-night diner and invented polyester.” Be aware that Trump and Kennedy may designate measles as ‘Freedom Freckles.’

In defense of his bosom buddy and co-president, ElonDonald Trump came to the Tesla mogul’s aid after an announced boycott against the firm’s vehicles, in addition to protester’s vandalizing dealership showrooms or individually owned cars and trucks, not to mention plunging stock prices. The orange co-president posted, “To Republicans, Conservatives, and all great Americans, Elon Musk is ‘putting it on the line’ in order to help our Nation, and he is doing a FANTASTIC JOB! But the Radical Left Lunatics, as they often do, are to illegally and collusively boycott Tesla, one of the world’s great automakers, and Elon’s ‘baby,’ in order to attack and do harm to Elon, and everything he stands for. I’m going to buy a brand new Tesla tomorrow morning as a show of confidence and support for Elon Musk, a truly great American. Why should he be punished for putting his tremendous skills to work in order to help MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN???” Musk responded with, “Thank you, President @realDonaldTrump!” So be careful out there — those of us who decide against buying a Tesla because we dislike Musk are doing so illegally, and perhaps Donny should know, being a convicted felon himself as many pointed out. Let’s not forget that Trump once called for a boycott of Goodyear tires because of their dress code prohibiting political attire, i.e., MAGA baseball caps. Trump’s promotion of a specific brand and whining about ‘illegal‘ is silly and inappropriate for a president’s concern. Of course, while this is going on, the two co-perpetrators are ruining American’s lives, by tanking the economy, threatening long-time allies around the world, and compelling them to boycott all American products. No worries, though — Trump, a once fierce critic of electric vehicles (drill, drill, drill!) is buying a Tesla from the world’s wealthiest man. Oh! And, so is Sean Hannity! Lunatics all — to include those who voted for this.

Tesla sales boycotts are only part of the picture, as some Tesla owners are selling, or considering selling, their vehicles as the backlash against Musk and DOGE grows, even though they may take a serious financial hit as prices plummet according to dealership website CarGurus. Singer Cheryl Crow announced she is selling her Tesla, then donating the proceeds to NPR as a protest against Elon. Investor Joanne Wilson told Business Insider she was ditching her Model S, floating the idea of letting members of the public smash it with hammers. Real estate developer, Scott Oran decided to sell his Tesla out of “embarrassment,” and a concern over vandalism, and to beat the rush of other sellers to the marketplace with the brand which is most common for EVs. Oran feels that Musk has irrevocably damaged the Tesla brand, with the maker’s stock drop on a recent Monday of 15% — a $29 billion reduction to Musk’s worth in just one day. Not to fret over Musk’s loss — after Trump’s announced Tesla acquisition, reports emerged that Elon was considering a $100 million donation to a super PAC associated with, and controlled by, the president.

That donation probably went a long way into converting the White House south lawn into a Tesla showroom for Trump’s big auto purchase, with five vehicles displayed for his perusal before his decision to spring for a deep red Tesla Model S, valued at almost $80,000, for use by his staff since he doesn’t drive any more. It’s unclear whether or not Pennsylvania Avenue was lined with plastic tube men, or air dancers, to attract the locals to the big sale. Trump praised Tesla’s quality and Musk’s dedication during the White House auto sale, and a photographer got a shot of the script and Tesla price list given the president by Musk to make a sales pitch to the masses. It must have been a convincing sales pitch, because Trump also committed to gifting a Tesla Cybertruck to his granddaughter, Kai — what’s another $80 grand? According to the price list, “Teslas can be purchased as low as $299/month or $35K.” And who knows? Trump may qualify for tax incentives under the Inflation Reduction Act for purchasers of electric vehicles. That’s dependent upon whether or not the Internal Revenue Service is still operating by next year’s tax filing — no comment from Musk, as he told Fox Business’s Larry Kudlow that he’s been running his businesses “with great difficulty” since spending his time with DOGE. Time for that chainsaw to be shelved, Elon? If Trump is drawing his $400K standard presidential salary, he won’t qualify for the tax incentive, but if he’s only drawing his one-dollar annual salary as in his first assault on the presidency — he’s not saying…what do you think? — he might qualify for the EV credit.

So far, Trump has not commented on his 2023 post that electric car supporters should “ROT IN HELL.” The Atlantic’s Charlie Warzel wrote that the car promo was, “a stilted, corrupt attempt to juice a friend’s stock, and certainly below the office of the presidency,” and we might add, so is most of the other junky crapola Trump and his grifting Crime Family push constantly. If any other government official in the executive branch had done a similar promotion, they would have been in clear violation of the regulation prohibiting such endorsements; but Trump and his hillbilly VP are exempt, where norms are usually respected as the primary lever for holding the line. The Don has repeatedly demonstrated his appetite for overturning norms and pushing ethical bounds, so his Tesla push is not out of the ordinary for him, and in reality, it delights him that he has such impunity, says Lora Kelly in her The Atlantic Daily commentary.

On his show, Jimmy Kimmel expressed dismay at the changing reputation of Tesla recently, recounting how owners are attempting “to disguise their vehicles to avoid confrontations and vandalism.” He showed clips of Teslas minus the logos, which now sport MazdaAudi, or Subaru identification. “People are even trying to disguise their Cybertrucks. That’s like trying to pass off Chewbacca for a chihuahua. It doesn’t seem right,” he said. “Maybe this is all a ruse. Elon somehow tricked MAGA into driving electric cars. Maybe he really is a genius,” he speculated. The Late Show’s Stephen Colbert shared that recently someone stole the wheels off of every single Tesla in a Texas parking lot. “Whoever did it, I do not condone this. But I do appreciate your tireless efforts,” he said as he accepted a fake Nobel Prize for Puns“Thank you so much!” He continued, “I want to be clear. I do not condone violence or vandalism of any kind. That is a deeply held belief of mine that comes from the bottom of my CBS legal department.” He pointed to a trend where Cybertrucks are being covered in garbage, theorizing, “To be fair, that might not be vandalism. That might just be a simple mistake because they do look a lot like a dumpster.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Timelines

“The country should be more inclusive, not less inclusive, and over an infinite timeline, it becomes more inclusive. It doesn’t always happen at once.”
~W. Kamau Bell

“In the Chinese subconscious, the universe exists on a timeline that extends into the future without end, and also without change.”
~Liu Cixin

“My research process doesn’t vary much. I do a little reading to establish a timeline and decide how I’m going to approach the story.”
~Laurie Graham

“It’s funny because I think, as a general rule, that people seem to think that if you do lots of different things over the course of, like, a timeline, it means that you kind of disregard what you did before. But that’s not true of me. I still genuinely like everything I did as much as I liked it when I released it.”
~Dev Hynes

“The five stages – denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance – are a part of the framework that makes up our learning to live with the one we lost. They are tools to help us frame and identify what we may be feeling. But they are not stops on some linear timeline in grief.”
~Elisabeth Kubler-Ross

“Guys, I’ve been thinking about that night over and over, and one thing has become clear: this is the darkest, most terrible timeline.”
~Abed, Community

...

I have a feeling I have posted this video before, a long time ago. It is worth a re-watch, however… or two, or more! These ladies are hilarious, not to mention supremely talented. They are German, or at least based in Germany, started in the year 2000 and are still touring! I went down a rabbit hole doing research, but I’ll let you do your own. Here’s a link to (the English version of) their website. Enjoy!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

March 12 – 18, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on Rail Trail Segment 7 Phase 2… Steinbruner… Battery fires… Hayes… Out this week… Patton… To Whom Should We Send Invitations?… Matlock… easy pickings…whale’s head…parallel universe…Swasticar… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… Life in the Middle Ages… Quotes on… “Time Travel”

...

Lovely Downtown Santa Cruz 1894. Those mass transit trolley tracks were in stalled in 1891. Note the two direction buggy lanes. That tall white pole in front of where Jamba Juice is now was a “Victory Pole”. Way down the street you can just barely see the ODD Fellows tower, which is of course our Town Clock now.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: March 12, 2025

A WHOLE ‘NOTHER WEEK! How does this keep happening? I sometimes feel like I blink, and another week has passed. And then a month, and then a year… the passage of time is something I stew on now and again. At times, it makes me ponder time travel, and what that would mean if it was actually possible.

Someone asked me once, “If you had a time machine, would you want to go backwards in time, or forwards?” I was absolutely flabbergasted. It had never even occurred to me that anyone would want to go forward in time when there are so many historical periods to get into. Egyptians, Romans, Vikings, the Middle Ages… I wouldn’t know where to start!

It’s probably a good thing it’s just fantasy…

...

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. AppleTV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

THE BRUTALIST. PrimeTV. Movie (7.5 IMDb) *** I thought the title was JUST a reference to the Brutalist Movement in art and architecture. Oh how wrong I was. A brutal story about love, separation, and power. Adrien Brody is gut-wrenching in his performance as a holocaust survivor, drug addict, and brutalist architect. It’s like dragging yourself along the edge of a straight razor – the further forward you go, the deeper it cuts. Painful, but worth a watch. Interesting note – while Brody’s character is fictional, the name Lazlo Toth (and variants) is out there, most notable to me, it was the name of the guy who vandalized La Pieta, and it was the pen-name of Don Novello (Reverend Guido Sarducci on old SNL) when writing his “Lazlo Letters”. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE ÅRE MURDERS. Netflix. Series (6.7 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

...

March 10, 2025

A $ Sink

The photo shows progress as of January 2025 on the rail trail, Segment 7, Phase 2 which runs from Bay and California Streets, past Neary Lagoon and the Wastewater Treatment Plant to join up with Beach Street at the roundabout. It is eight tenths of a mile long.

In 2018, when the city circulated an environmental review of this site for one segment of the rail trail project, the Sierra Club expressed its concerns at the incompleteness of the city’s environmental work. Given the ecosystem sensitivity of the site, the Club requested an EIR be done. Initially there was no mention by the city of the Monarch butterfly overwintering site at the eucalyptus grove near the trestle bridge, despite the fact the city had earlier erected a display case describing the site as such. There was concern about the project’s required removal of forty-seven trees, with twenty-one listed as heritage. There was issue with the city’s downplaying a riparian wetland on the project site. Efforts to secure a full EIR were unsuccessful, however the city agreed to monitor the health of the eucalyptus grove for five years after project completion. The concrete slurry material recently deposited and hardened over the trees’ root zones is not a good sign.

Council approved the project in early 2021, with a price tag of $11 million. In late 2023, an additional $3 million was asked for and approved by council. A request for a further $900,000 is on this week’s City Council agenda.

Why less than a mile of trail should cost $15 million, even with a three thousand foot long retaining wall, is hard to fathom. My hunch is that the wetland created more of a problem than the city and consultants planned for. Staff’s explanation for needing an extra $900,000 is that “the site is situated adjacent to Neary Lagoon and is inundated with groundwater during and after heavy rain events.” Well, yes, it includes a wetland, as was documented by the Sierra Club in 2018. This should not come as a surprise. Citing it as an “unforeseen condition” the staff report explains that “a major unanticipated cost was the construction of a concrete cut-off wall… to limit groundwater so the soil could be adequately compacted to sustain the asphalt path”. Surely such conditions were carefully evaluated before deciding the site was suitable for rail trail construction. According to the staff report, the budget adjustment funds will come from “Measure D, a local source for transportation project funding.”

Measure D, a half-cent sales tax increase was approved by county voters in 2016. Its task is to “improve, operate and maintain Santa Cruz County’s transportation network”, according to the Measure D Fact Sheet published by the Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission (SCCRTC). The funding is split amongst various Transportation Projects. The Rail Corridor is one such project and is allocated 8% of the total funding over a 30-year period. According to the SCCRTC, this allocation would be for “Analysis (including environmental and economic analysis) of both rail transit and non-rail options for the rail corridor; rail line maintenance and repairs.” Studying the feasibility of rail transit prior to construction of a rail trail seemed wise to me and I voted for Measure D on that basis.

There was, however, a hidden agenda in Measure D. A further 17% of the total funding was listed under the heading of Active Transportation. The only entry under Active Transportation is the Monterey Bay Sanctuary Scenic Trail and the allocation is for” bike and pedestrian trail construction; maintenance, management and drainage of rail and trail corridor.” With careful use of language, there is no mention of rail trail construction but that is exactly what the funds are being used for. The rail trail therefore gets a combined 25% of the total funding.

Note to self and others, read ballot measures very carefully, including the fine print. Measure S for the library system was deceptive, as is the Initiative being circulated for signatures for the misleadingly titled “Workforce Housing Solutions Act.” Caveat lector!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
Fire, Fire at Moss Landing!

Why the batteries burned and what that means

Listen THIS SUNDAY (March 16) to KSQD and learn what happened…and why we need to continue to demand more information and local control.

Ric O’Connell – Ivan Aiello – Megan Thiele Strong

on Sustainability Now!  Sunday, March 16th, 5-6PM

On January 16th, 2025, a fire broke out at the Vistra plant in Moss Landing, California burning for two days and scattering heavy metals and other toxic materials across the plant’s surroundings, including Elkhorn Slough.  What happened there and why did the batteries burn?  What are the impacts of the fire and on the future of renewable energy?

Join host Ronnie Lipschutz for three conversations about the batteries and the fire, with Ric O’Connell, executive director of GridLab, who will explain what the batteries are doing there, Dr. Ivano Aiello, Professor of Geological Oceanography at San Jose State’s Moss Landing Marine Laboratories, who will discuss the results of his research into contamination of Elkhorn Slough, and Dr. Megan Thiele Strong, Professor of Environmental Sociology at San Jose State, who will talk about the health and social effects of the fire on people living around the site.

That’s on Sustainability Now! Sunday, March 16th, 2025, from 5-6 PM right here on community radio for the Monterey Bay Region, KSQD 90.7 FM, KSQT 87.9 FM, K207FE (FX) 89.5 and KSQD.org, streaming on the internet.

LISTEN IN NEXT FRIDAY TO HEAR ASSEMBLYMEMBER DAWN ADDIS ADVOCATE LOCAL CONTROL OF BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE
Please listen in Friday, March 21 at 3pm on Santa Cruz Voice “Community Matters” program to hear Assemblymember Dawn Addis discuss her proposed AB 303 legislation that would claw back local control of battery energy storage system (BESS) facilities.

She needs our support because she is up against big money.  Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors are dragging their feet on sending a letter of support…even given what has happened in Moss Landing Vistra Fires.

Listen from your computer or smart device from anywhere in the world at 3pm Pacific Time on Santa Cruz Voice.com and join the conversation.

Here is the proposed AB 303 legislation.

Contact the elected representatives below and urge their support of AB 303.

Assemblymember Dawn Addis
Robert Rivas, Speaker of the Assembly
Assemblymember Gail Pellerin
Senator John Laird

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL. LISTEN IN TO LOCAL FORUMS ON TOPICS THAT INTEREST YOU AND ASK QUESTIONS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING!

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Grey is out this week.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Tuesday, March 11, 2025

You probably know the sonnet by Emma Lazarus, “The New Colossus.” If you don’t know that poem in its entirety, you may, at least, recall the following and famous lines, which are inscribed on a bronze plaque, which was placed at the base of the Statue of Liberty in 1903:

Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!

It has been our experience, for more than one hundred years (and actually quite a bit more, I think), that the United States, as “a nation of immigrants,” has benefitted immensely from immigration. This is, really, what The Statue of Liberty, that enduring emblem of our nation, symbolizes.

Of course, this is not the view of our current president. Donald J. Trump appears to despise immigrants, as he made clear as he began his first campign for the presidency:

“When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. […] They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.” This quote from Donald Trump has become emblematic of the President’s attitude towards immigrants. Since the 2016 campaign trail, Trump has spread harmful narratives about Latinx immigrants, and his words have tangible impacts on local communities…. President Trump characterizes Latinx immigrants as a dangerous out-group to gain political power.

The president’s words – “They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists…” – have not, at least not yet, been inscribed anywhere, but the president’s denunciation of immigration is restated frequently, and it’s hard to escape the memory of the message about immigrants with which he began his 2016 campaign, and which are featured in the quotation that I have included above.

In the Emma Lazarus sonnet (meant to reflect the realities that the nation has actually experienced), America has invited immigrants to come. The nation has opened its “golden door” to them, welcoming them here, with the result being that our nation has become greater – and richer – because of those formerly homeless, and “tempest-tost,” and impoverished immigrants. Those “wretched” immigrants, welcomed here, have ended up contributing greatly to American wealth and success.

On February 28th, the president outlined a new approach to immigration. He has proposed a “Gold Card” visa, an invitation to those immigrants who are able and willing to pay $5,000,000 for the privilege of gaining entry to the United States.

Whom should we invite? To whom should we send an invitation to come to America? Should we continue to follow the advice of Emma Lazarus? Or, is Donald Trump, perhaps, the wiser head? Should only the already wealthy be welcomed here?

This question is now placed before us. Should we repudiate those who come here with nothing, hoping not only to enrich themselves, but to enrich this nation, too?

We have been asked to repudiate our historic welcome. Our current president says, “We Welcome The Rich! And only them!”

Are you with him? Or not?

I am not.

I am with Emma!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

PLAYING POSSUM, FULL OF IT, RUBY, COOKOUT POTATO SALAD

James Carville seems to have adopted the Napoleon Bonaparte quote: “Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake.” The influential Democratic Party strategist who came to prominence in the Bill Clinton years recently predicted that the Trump White House will “collapse” in less than a month as his approval ratings continue to decline with his multitude of unpopular executive orders, and slashing of governmental agencies by firing thousands — risking an economic nosedive. His advice to his party is to simply sit back and watch it all come down: “Democrats need to play possum. This whole thing is collapsing,” he predicted in an interview with Dan Abrams of Mediaite“We’re in the midst of a collapse. This is the lowest approval — not even close — that any president has ever had at a comparable time. It’s going to be easy pickings here in six weeks. Just lay back.” Later, he told Sean Hannity on Fox News that he sees Democrats up by 13 points in the congressional generic, with Trump at the lowest approval of any president, so early in the game, in American history. He challenged Hannity by his query, “So, your viewers are getting one view. And I’m reading another view. One of us is right and one of us is wrong. It’s that simple. Have they got fact checkers at Fox?” Trump came to his defense on Truth Social with the claim that he has “the best polling numbers” in his history. “The Democrats, run by broken down losers like James Carville, who’s weak of mind and body, are going crazy, and just don’t know what to do. They have lost their confidence and spirit — they have lost their minds!” he fired back. Carville maintains that the House Democrats know exactly what they are doing because they see what is going to happen, in spite of the concern in the party that its defenses are lacking. Trump’s first moves in office instigated from constituents, 1,600 phone calls a minute to the Senate, complaining that more needed to be done. Representative Jim McGovern of Massachusetts told Axios that the record number of calls were from “people disgusted with what’s going on, and they want us to fight back.”

Carville suggested to Democratic politicians that they should not get in the way of protesters around the country who are speaking out against co-presidents Trump and Musk, or as rural America says, “‘Don’t just stand there. Do nothing.’ Let this germinate. In the immortal words of Dalton in ‘Road House,’ ‘be nice until it’s time not to be nice.’ And that time is coming shortly.” Carville disagrees with moderates who say people are overreacting to Trump, warning, “No one is overreacting. We’re living in real time in a catastrophe.” One prominent date he sees is the November 5 election in Virginia, where Republican Governor Glenn Youngkin, a leading Trump supporter, will be dealing with a large and angry electorate made up of thousands of fired federal employees. Carvile asks, “Do you think they’re gonna vote? I think they’re gonna vote. I think I know which way they’re gonna vote, and they’re gonna vote heavily.”

Robert Reich says people are asking him, “Where’s the Democratic Party?” He says that at a time when America needs a strong, bold, courageous opposition, the party’s silence is deafening, but goes on to say, “But with due respect to my old friend James Carville who is telling Democrats to ‘roll over and play dead,’ he’s full of it. Trump is killing our country, reducing the US government to rubble, and destroying our relationships with our allies. Putin may love it, but it’s a catastrophe four us and much of the rest of the world. Democrats have been rolling over and playing dead too long. That’s one reason the nation is in the trouble we’re in. My simple advice to congressional Democrats: Wake the hell up!” He goes on to say that if the party had only “had the guts years ago to condemn big money in politics, fight corporate welfare, and unrig a market that’s been rigged in favor of big corporations and the rich, Trump’s absurd bogeymen (the deep state, immigrants, socialists, trans people, diversity-equity-inclusion) wouldn’t have stood a chance.” His comments preceded the joint congressional session State-of-Trump speech, where he correctly predicted the “Republican lawmakers who have turned over their brains and intestines” would applaud his stream of lies. His wish that the Democrats would boycott the whole event en masse did not come to pass and his suggestion that they would perhaps just sit on their hands and applaud a few insipid Trump utterances was close to what we saw. There were many empty seats, with some making an exit at various times during the ninety-nine minute ordeal. Representative Al Green had to be escorted from the gathering when he heckled Trump as he pointed his cane toward the president for spewing lies, and many of those remaining had brought signs which they held up in response to his insults and rambling lies.

The small, hand-held signs only brought derision and chuckles from the Republican faction, and a political cartoon printed in some newspapers emphasized the futility of the protest in showing a chainsaw wielding Elon Musk laying waste to government buildings as the Democratic donkey mascot sat nearby in a chair holding up a sign that read, “Tsk, tsk.” Andy Borowitz satirized the event with his own account: “Donald J Trump watched Elon Musk’s historic address to Congress Tuesday night from the last row of the House chamber. Striking a menacing tone, Musk threatened to mount lavishly funded primary campaigns against congressional Republicans unless they gave him a standing ovation after every line of his speech. Trump’s view of the speech was partially obstructed by Robert F Kennedy, Jr, who sat in the second-to-last row and brought a dismembered whale’s head as his plus-one guest.” With a bit more accuracy, Borowitz said, “In what is being called a historic performance, on Tuesday night Donald J Trump set a new world record for delivering the longest speech that did not include a single fact. Congressional Republicans were awestruck by their leader’s ability, at the age of 78, to give such a sustained fact-free oration. House Speaker Mike Johnson said, ‘He’s still got it.’ Republicans contrasted Trump’s address favorably with the Democratic response of Senator Elissa Slotkin, who spoke only briefly but whose remarks were riddled with facts.” It must be noted that Elon was actually present, all spruced up in a fitted suit and tie, after ditching the blazer/t-shirt/baseball cap/dark sunglasses attire which is his Oval Office outfit — much the same as Zelensky’sStephen Colbert offered his thoughts on the Oval Office’s strict dress code of decorum, saying, “You must either look like a businessman or a guy trying to hand you a flyer outside of a strip club.”

In his speech, Trump again spoke about trying to regain ownership of the Panama Canal, sure to cause diplomatic shockwaves, as he singled out Secretary of State Marco Rubio as the one “to blame if anything goes wrong,” — resulting in a wide-eyed and shocked reaction from Rubio, and a classic forever meme for denizens of social media sites. Poor ‘Little Marco’ was probably still in a state of shock from being present at the Trump-Vance-Zelensky brawl in the Oval Office a few days before. Rubio — who according to Saturday Night Live, will now be known as ‘Marc Ruby’ since Trump signed his English-only language executive order — posted on X that the president’s speech was “inspiring” and “momentous,” with Trump’s “clear mandate from the American people to renew the American Dream.” Ruby won his Senate confirmation 99 to 0, and many hoped that his maturity and government experience would serve him well in holding some sway over Bully Trump, but that is obviously not to be. Ominously, the American asset management company, BlackRock has volunteered to buy two ports at either end of the Panama Canal from their current Hong Kong-based ownership in order to lessen Chinese influence over the crucial international waterway. BlackRock and other investors will spend $22.8 billion to buy the ports of Balboa and Cristobal — a deal which is now only an ‘agreement in principal.’

Response by Senator Bernie Sanders to the joint session speech charges Trump with creating a parallel universe with “a set of ideas that either have no basis in reality, or are nowhere near the most important concerns of the American people” — a pivotal moment in our country’s history. He says Trump’s tactic is the BIG LIE, many of which were heard during the Tuesday night blathering, and these grossly false lies are repeated over and over again, with complicity of right-wing social media sites blasting them out until people accept it as truth. Sanders points to the purpose of these lies, not only to push a right-wing agenda, but to deflect attention away from those important issues facing the country — issues Trump and his billionaire friends don’t wish to address, otherwise there is no financial benefit to them. He emphasized the issues Trump ignored in his record-setting speech: About how will working people support families in these tough times, made tougher by the administration; the reality of the 60% of Americans living paycheck to paycheck; the broken, dysfunctional, expensive health care system, and the non-affordabilty of prescription drugs; the major housing crisis and homelessness;  the massive income and wealth inequality with three 3 Americans owning more wealth than the bottom half of our society; the corrupt campaign finance system that allows billionaires to buy elections; the life expectancy of the poor compared to the wealthy; and the planetary crisis of climate change. Trump urged Congress to pass his “big beautiful budget,” leaving out ugliness of the $880 billion that would come from Medicaid, leaving 36 million Americans in peril. But what the hey — spaceship ownership is such an important factor nowadays, as well! An occasional fireworks display over the Caribbean is a sight to behold!

On his nightly show, Stephen Colbert mocked Trump’s remarks, but he was most critical of the Democrats, saying, “But don’t you worry. The Democrats came ready to fight back with their little paddles. That is how you save democracy. By quietly dissenting…or bidding on an antique tea set, it was hard to tell what was going on. In fact, I made my own sign.” Impassively, he held up a sign reading: “Try doing something.” Before Trump’s address, Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries had demanded that Democrats sit meekly and do nothing during the MAGASpeech, a demand that was not respected by several individuals. Consequently, a dozen or so disruptors were called into a ‘come to Jesus meeting’ on Thursday following the address, to be helped to “understand why their strategy is a bad idea,” which brought forth the comment that “if Jeffries has any good ideas, we’d love to hear them,” accompanied by the snarky, “But he’s been busy on a tour to sell his children’s book, “The ABCs of Democracy.” It seems incredibly misguided to scold Congressional Democrats for taking a stand against an autocrat who the party has characterized as a fascist authoritarian — a puny stand though it may be. Elie Mystal wrote in The Nation“I asked Democrats to boycott Trump’s speech to Congress. They did not. Instead, they brought little placards emblazoned with political messages, as if they were in a silent auction for fascism. We live in hell.” Senator John Fetterman on X, characterized the protests as a “sad cavalcade of self-owns and unhinged petulance. It only makes Trump look more presidential and restrained.”

Elie Mystal, besides being disgusted with Democrats for showing up at the joint session, was further enraged that Representative Al Green was censured by Congress for disrupting Trump’s speech “to a joint session of sycophants and co-conspirators”; and, though many Democrats protested and voted against the procedure punishing Green, Mystal posted a list of the ten Democrats who voted with the MAGAts who he hopes will never be able to raise a dollar from other Democrats, ever again: Ami Bera (D-CA), Ed Case (D-HI), Jim Costa (D-CA), Laura Gillen (D-NY), Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D-WA), Jim Himes (D-CT), Chrissy Houlahan (D-PA), Marcy Kaptur (D-OH), Jared Moskowitz (D-FL), and Tom Suozzi (D-NY). He also decried Elissa Slotkin’s “tepid Democratic response to Trump’s multi-hour Netflix series address to Congress, during which she managed to praise notable Democratic hero, Ronald Reagan.” Mystal recounts her follow-up interview with Tim Alberta of The Atlantic“where she outlined her priorities. Her answers were the usual thin gruel that passes for Democratic Party talking points, but one line really stood out to me. She said, ‘It doesn’t win elections to speak to just the base of the party…if it did, Kamala Harris would be president.’ First of all, I’m really gonna need Becky with the 80% White Congressional district to keep Kamala Harris’s name out of her mouth. It’s easy to slag off the Democratic ‘base,’ which has been Black people for Slotkin’s entire life, when nobody is inviting you or your potato salad to the cookout anyway. It’s a little harder when you are running to represent all of America, not just the White folks who think they should own the place.”

Co-president Elon Musk is watching his Tesla vehicle empire skid downward, almost as fast as his pyrotechnics rocket company, though not quite as flashy. Sales are dropping dramatically worldwide, and dealerships are experiencing violent actions from an angry anti-Musk crowd, not to mention individual car and truck owners having their vehicles damaged and getting new paint treatments, or protest stickers applied surreptitiously. A post on Quora shares a definition of the portmanteau word, ‘DePlorean,’ combining ‘deplorable’ and ‘DeLorean,’ which has been applied to Tesla’s Cybertruck. The early 80s DeLorean sports car had a brushed aluminum exterior similar to the C-Truck, and carried similar social connotations of audacity, impracticality, and irritating behavior. While the DeLorean, which originally sold for $12,000 is now a prized collector’s item, the Cybertruck at $100,240 is an overpriced, poorly constructed symbol of excess, greed and stupidity, and much uglier when seen up close than online photos reveal. A UK-based group, ‘Everyone Hates Elon,’ recently unveiled an advertisement for a ‘Swasticar,’ which shows Musk standing in one of his cars while giving the Nazi salute, with printed copy proclaiming the vehicle “goes from zero to 1939 in three seconds.” The bus stop posted image has gone viral, and the group encourages supporters to spread it far and wide, saying, “Not happy with fueling the far-right in the USA, Elon Musk is now doing the same in Europe. We can’t let the richest man in the world poison our politics.” A GoFundMe page has been set up to raise cash to plaster the ‘Swasticar’ ad in more public places, as well as for production of small stickers reading “Don’t buy a Swasticar,” giving emphasis to their motto: “Pissing off Elon Musk, one small action at a time.”

In the UKMusk has supported the far-right, anti-immigrant Reform Party, and attacked the Labour government by spreading “lies and misinformation” about the criminality of immigrants according to Prime Minister Keir Starmer. A few weeks back, Musk expressed support for Germany’s Alternative for Germany party, which gained support in their losing election campaign, even though it has been classified as a suspected extremist group by Germany’s intelligence service. Two left-wing activist groups — UK’s Led by Donkeys, and Germany’s Center for Political Beauty, claimed responsibility after they beamed an image of Elon Musk making the Nazi salute onto Tesla’s factory in Berlin, accompanied by the words “Heil Tesla.” A jeering crowd who erupted at the mention of Musk’s name on the ‘Late Show‘ caused Stephen Colbert to comment, “That is the sound of Tesla sales plummeting.” He also joked, “Millions of young people can’t stand him — and those are just his kids.” Colin Jost on ‘Saturday Night Live’s Weekend Update‘ reported that “experts are saying that Trump’s tariffs will raise the cost of a new car by as much as $12,000, or you can get a free Tesla, since people are throwing them away.” Update co-host, Michael Che reported that European leaders have been coaching Volodymyr Zelensky on dealing with Trump —“kind of like how you need extra training to be a special ed teacher.” Che referred to a Trump claim that “no president has changed government more in 43 days,” to which Che replied, “Yeah, and nobody changed airport security more than bin Laden.” Addressing Trump’s constant back-tracking on his tariffs, amid concerns among consumers and investors, Che joked, “It’s a cunning political tactic experts call ‘bipolar disorder.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Time Travel

“If time travel is possible, where are the tourists from future?”
~Stephen Hawking

“Why do we need time travel, when we already travel through space so far and fast? For history. For mystery. For nostalgia. For hope. To examine our potential and explore our memories. To counter regret for the life we lived, the only life, one dimension, beginning to end.”
~James Gleick

“Songs really are like a form of time travel because they really have moved forward in a bubble. Everyone who’s connected with it, the studio’s gone, the musicians are gone, and the only thing that’s left is this recording which was only about a three-minute period maybe 70 years ago.”
~Tom Waits

“I distracted myself from the fear and terrorism by thinking about things like how the universe began and whether time travel is possible.”
~Malala Yousafzai

“We all have our time machines, don’t we? Those that take us back are memories… And those that carry us forward, are dreams.”
~H.G. Wells

...

The Terrifying Reality Of Medieval Life During The Norman Invasion. History Hit has lots of great documentaries, and some of them are available free on YouTube. Enjoy!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

March 5 – 11, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on the Ballot Measure… Steinbruner… Write your supervisors, lithium… Hayes… Cotoni Coast Dairies, 2064: A Dystopia… Patton… The Apprentice… Matlock… look, ma – it’s the new Tesla DePlorean…a food fight…thank-you #33+… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… Randy Rainbow… Quotes on… “Daylight Saving Time”

...

ST. CHARLES HOTEL. This was in Downtown Santa Cruz at the corner of Mission and North Pacific Avenue about 1890. That’s the Bavaria Brewery just to the left. Note the horse driven streetcar.

The Bavaria Brewery was the first brewery in the city of Santa Cruz. It was established in 1865. There’s an interesting article (behind a paywall) in the Sentinel about it.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: March 5, 2025

SET YOUR CLOCKS THIS WEEKEND. It’s that time again. To me, it seems that people either love or hate Daylight Saving Time. Personally, I kinda love it… I’ve even come up with a “lifehack” of my own that’s related to it: I replace the batteries on all the clocks in the house that day. DST does throw me off for a bit every time, but having the light for “longer” makes it worth it to me. Now, if only there was a way to make dawn and dusk last longer… and no “move north” is not an option.

Serious talk though, I grew up in Sweden and made my first visit to the US in 1981. I had cousins in Delaware, and besides “OMG it looks just like on TV!”, the biggest environmental shock I experienced when I visited was the absence of dawn/dusk. In Sweden around midsummer, the sun rises at 4:12am, sets at 10:15pm, and it’s still not dark until about 11:30pm. I still miss that.

ANNUAL POET & PATRIOT CELEBRATION If you miss the Poet & Patriot Irish Pub, you might want to go to Watsonville on March 15! Here’s the info (from the Facebook Event Page) on this yearly gathering:

Join us on March 15th as we raise our glasses in honor of the cherished Poet & Patriot Irish Pub, a beloved gathering place that held countless memories and connections for our community. This annual celebration, nestled around St. Patrick’s Day, invites you to reconnect with old friends and spark new friendships while reveling in the nostalgia of treasured photo collages that tell the stories of the past. You can expect a lively atmosphere filled with the best ciders and a variety of non-alcoholic options, along with delicious cuisine from High End Comida. Plus, don’t miss out on the live music and open mic opportunities where your voice can be heard.

Hosted by Santa Cruz Cider Company, 65 Hangar way, Watsonville, CA

With that, I turn you over to this week’s contributions from our intrepid columnists.

...

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE ÅRE MURDERS. Netflix. Series (6.7 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

...

March 3, 2025

Housing for Whom?

Today’s photo shows a small section of Pacific Station North, under construction. The site is across from Streetlight Records on Pacific Avenue. It already is starting to dwarf the adjacent six story 1010 Pacific, which when built in 2004 was the tallest downtown residential building except for the landmark Palomar built in 1930. To get council approval for exceeding the then three-story downtown height limit, the 1010 Pacific promoters emphasized that the housing would be for teachers, firefighters, and police…” workforce housing” they called it. The twenty percent Inclusionary rate (23 units out of 113) exceeded the Inclusionary rate at the time. The extra inclusionary units, plus the “workforce” promise were persuasive factors in securing council approval.

So how did that turn out? Did 1010 Pacific fill a critical need for workforce housing? The short answer is, we don’t know. The city does not track such metrics. The result is that slogans, feel-good labels and assumptions substitute for data and knowledge in city planning decisions. As for 1010 Pacific, folks who have rented there say it predominantly houses students and you can see that demographic heavily represented in the online comments from residents.

Pacific Station North is planned for one hundred and twenty-eight (128) units of affordable housing, plus commercial, retail and the new Metro Center. Thirty-two (32) units are set aside for the extremely low-income category, which realistically is the actual earning rate of low-income workers in the city. The formal HCD low-income cut-off rate is $93,000 for an individual. I recall the exit interview with the previous Sentinel Managing editor who expressed surprise that she had qualified for a low-income Inclusionary unit in the city. The income categories are locally unrealistic because they are tied to the Area Median Income which has significantly risen in the city of Santa Cruz due to the recent influx of high-earning professionals.

As our town is being transformed with massive high rises that loom over single story neighborhoods, blocking light and sun, with no required parking and no local ability to say no, it is reasonable that the city answers with data the question of who is getting the scarce affordable units? Is it students? Is it county residents?  Or is it, as the city Municipal Code 24.16.045 has required since 2007, city residents and workers in the city?

The Civil Grand Jury of 2003-04, of which I was a member, investigated this question and published a report titled, Housing for Whom? An investigation into Inclusionary Housing in the City of Santa Cruz. You can find it on the Civil Grand Jury website. The short answer again is, nobody knows. The city does no tracking for local worker or resident status. Especially interesting are the required responses from city staff and city council who largely dismissed the Findings and incorrectly claimed they had implemented three out of four Recommendations when the facts show otherwise.

Now we are faced with a possible Initiative for affordable housing on the November Ballot. Titled, Workforce Housing Solutions Act,” the backers are currently gathering signatures to qualify for the ballot. Signature gatherers include students at $20 an hour. Is this more of the same hype, pretending to be for local workers as the name suggests? Or is there a data-gathering tool in the ballot measure to ensure the housing benefits local workers and residents?

I’m afraid the answer is the former. The name “Workforce Housing Solutions Act” is…an act. Marketing jargon only. That fact is made clear under the definitions page where “affordable and workforce housing” is defined as “housing that is affordable to extremely low, very low, low and moderate-income levels.” No reference to workers to be found in the definitions. Section 3 of the text of the Act under Purposes and Intent has six numbered entries. The word “worker” never appears.

On page four of the text of the Act there is an entry that states:

Santa Cruz City residents, workers and veterans shall have priority for obtaining housing units, to the extent allowable by law.

Apart from the addition of veterans, this reference is no different from what is currently required by City Code for Inclusionary Housing, and which is never tracked, documented, or verified.

Without a mechanism included in the Ballot Measure to do such tracking and verification, any affordable housing funded by this added tax on city property owners can be occupied by a non-city resident and non-city worker so long as their income is at the required level.

At a forum on Saturday March 1 organized by Our Downtown Our Future (ODOF) whose leaders are supporting and promoting the ballot measure, Mayor Keeley spoke in support with words to the effect that no measure is perfect; that we should not dismiss one because it is only seventy percent of perfect. That one hundred percent of nothing you can have any day.

Carefully weighing the mayor’s words, I still did not come away convinced to support the ballot measure. It’s not just the hypocrisy of labelling your ballot as Workforce Housing Solutions Act with no intention that any resulting housing will necessarily go to local low-income workers, it’s not just that it will be the city’s Economic Development and Housing Department in charge of the accrued funds from the tax increase, it’s that I see the local rental housing affordability crisis disproportionally affecting our long-time local low-income workers. These workers are being pushed out of their local rental housing in disturbingly large numbers. They now commute to their jobs in Santa Cruz from Watsonville, Salinas and even San Jose. It is these essential workers, our own low-income workforce who should be benefitting from any tax levied on city property owners. Let UCSC and the county file their own ballot measures to help their low-income constituents.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
WHAT WILL BE DECIDED AND WHEN?

It seems unclear when exactly the proposed Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) project at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville will come publicly before the Planning Commission or the Board of Supervisors, and if there will be any separate public meeting for residents who live adjacent.

The April 25, 2025 date given as the Final Ordinance approval deadline by additional Board direction on October 29, 2024 is a Friday, which could coincide with the County Zoning Administrator hearing date.

How interesting that a project could be zooming through the permit process when the County has no language in place for how the project would be approved or regulated.

No one seems to have an actual timeline, but it is clear that residents Countywide need to demand County Supervisors approve an Urgency Ordinance and temporary moratorium on lithium BESS facilities in the County until an impartial technical advisory panel convenes and makes recommendations regarding the County’s BESS Ordinance.

We need to look to our neighbors in Morro Bay for guidance and inspiration.  Here is a great article about that: Coastal Commission Questions Battery Project | Estero Bay News The situation in Santa Cruz County is a bit different in that none of the three proposed BESS sites is within the Coastal Zone, so the Coastal Commission would not have any approval jurisdiction.  Because New Leaf Energy, the applicants for the 90 Minto Road project, could choose to apply with the California Energy Commission for an Opt-In Certificate to operate, thereby sidestepping local jurisdiction.  That is thanks to AB 205, passed by the legislature in 2022.   Assemblymember Gail Pellerin and State Senator John Laird both voted in favor of this work-around for the energy industry.

Interestingly, Assemblymember Dawn Addis also voted in favor of this bad piece of legislation, but now that Vistra attempted to use the work-around in Morro Bay, and the devastating Moss Landing Vistra Battery Storage Fire has happened, she has apparently reconsidered, and introduced AB 303. [Addis Introduces Legislation to Bolster Community Choice & Environmental Protections in Battery Projects]

We need to support this work to retrieve local authority on Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) projects in our Communities.  Please write your elected representatives and urge them to support AB 303.  Write the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors and urge the Board to send a letter in support of AB 303.
Board of Supervisors <boardofsupervisors@santacruzcountyca.gov>

North County Fire Dept. website has regular updates, including the Santa Cruz County press release of soil and water testing performed in the County at the direction of the Supervisor Manu Koenig and the Board: [2025 Moss Landing Vistra Power Plant Fire | County of Monterey, CA]

Here is some background information on this County’s crazy race to rush this through. (Pay attention to the conflict of interest of Supervisor Bruce McPherson and CAO Carlos Palacios…and now Supervisor Monica Martinez)
[Minutes of October 29, 2024 Board of Supervisor Meeting Agenda]

8. Consider proposed amendments and recommendation for establishing an Energy
Storage Combining District in Chapter 13.10 of the County Code and associated
General Plan amendments, and take related actions (Community Development
and Infrastructure)

Recommended Actions:

  1. Approved in concept draft amendments to the County’s General Plan and County Code to
    establish an Energy Storage Combining District in Chapter 13.10 of the Santa Cruz County
    Code; and

  2. Provided feedback for any changes to the draft amendments and the parcels to which the
    Combining District would be added; and

  3. Directed staff to proceed with finalizing the amendments, conducting environmental review
    under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), obtaining the Planning
    Commission’s recommendation on the General Plan, County Code, and zoning map
    amendments, and returning to the Board of Supervisors for adoption.

Public Comment:
1 person addressed the Board in chambers
2 people addressed the Board via Zoom

Additional Direction:

  1. Directed staff to work with energy industry experts to determine the feasibility of complying with
    updates to the County Code and General Plan that the Board has already adopted. Specifically,
    Code Section 13.10.314 and General Plan Policies ARC-1.3.1 and 1.3.2.

  2. Directed staff to revise the draft ordinance to include a minimum storage capacity of 50
    Megawatts and a minimum parcel size of 10 acres to ensure the ordinance will significantly focus
    on utility scale transmission storage projects consistent with the State’s definition of projects that
    will efficiently meet our decarbonization goals.

  3. Directed staff to return to the Board on or before April 25, 2025 with the final draft ordinances.

RESULT: APPROVED WITH ADDITIONAL DIRECTION [4 TO 1]
MOVER: Bruce McPherson, Fifth District Supervisor
SECONDER: Felipe Hernandez, Fourth District Supervisor
AYES: Koenig, Cummings, Hernandez, McPherson
NAYS: Friend

 

WHEN WILL THERE BE A TOWN HALL MEETING?
At the February 25 Board of Supervisor meeting, many people voiced opposition to the proposed Seahawk Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facility at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.  In response, 4th District Supervisor Felipe Hernandez stated “we are planning a public meeting but are working on who to invite and where to hold it.” It was unclear whether all Supervisors are involved, and how widely the notice for the meeting would be.

Write them and insist there be a countywide town hall meeting for the BESS Ordinance for Santa Cruz County, and that they immediately pass an Urgency Ordinance to halt all BESS projects and applications until an impartial Technical Advisory Panel convenes to advise Planning Staff and the Board.
Board of Supervisors <Boardofsupervisors@santacruzcountyca.gov>

Write your Supervisor individually to ask for regular Town Hall meetings.  The e-mail template is 

Firstname.Lastname@santacruzcountyca.gov

 

You can also write them via forms on their webpages

Currently, with the exception of 1st District Supervisor Manu Koenig, NONE hold regular public meetings with constituents.  Supervisor Koenig has open office hours only once a month, on the first Wednesday, 1pm-3pm, usually at the Sheriff Center in Live Oak. However, according to his webpage, March Office Hours will be held Wednesday, March 5th from 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM at the Government Center, 701 Ocean St. 5th Floor, Room. 500. Bring your questions and meet with me one-on-one. As always, first come first served.

CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION IS DETERMINED TO USE LITHIUM BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS
The California Energy Commission (CEC) held a workshop recently to promote lithium mining in Lithium Valley (aka Salton Sea) in California.  Held on February 19, the all-day “Workshop on Lithium Valley Vision” discussed promoting the geothermal lithium mining in the Salton Sea area to ensure that lithium supplies and prices would be competitive with world market supplies and to “facilitate expanded geothermal and lithium production in the region in a responsible and locally beneficial manner. ”  This was Informational Proceeding Docket No. 24-OIIP-02-Lithium Valley Vision.

Here is a summary:

Background
“Lithium Valley” is the term used to describe a world-class lithium industry centered on recovering lithium from geothermal brine in the Salton Sea region. This includes expanding geothermal energy production, conservation efforts, and economic development with substantive benefits for local residents.1 Located in the Eastern Coachella Valley and Imperial Valley, near the Mexican border, this region contains some of the largest lithium deposits in the world. Recent analysis from the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found that there’s enough lithium in the region to support over 375 million batteries for electric vehicles (EV)2.

Assembly Bill 1657 (AB 1657) (E. Garcia, Chapter 271, Statutes of 2020) authorized the CEC to establish and convene the Blue Ribbon Commission on Lithium Extraction in California, known more commonly as the “Lithium Valley Commission.” The Lithium Valley Commission explored opportunities and challenges surrounding lithium recovery and adopted a report with findings and recommendations that provide a pathway for the state’s Lithium Valley Vision, Report of the Blue Ribbon Commission on Lithium Extraction in California (see link below). The report, which was submitted to the state legislature in December 2022, recommends accelerating transmission planning, improving permitting, securing funding for infrastructure investments, incentivizing economic development to support industry growth, and increasing job training, among other actions.

The report found that interest in, and support for, the development of domestic lithium sources — specifically lithium recovery from geothermal brine in Imperial County — are occurring at the local, state, and national level.3 The report also found that members of communities and tribes near and culturally affiliated with the Salton Sea and Salton Sea Known Geothermal Resource Area are deeply interested in and concerned about possible impacts to the environment, cultural resources, and public health due to increased development of geothermal power plants and lithium recovery. There is also interest and support for the economic development, job creation, and business opportunities available to the community and tribes. On February 14, 2024, the CEC instituted an informational proceeding for the Lithium Valley Vision and designated Commissioner Noemí Gallardo as Lead Commissioner of this proceeding. Through this proceeding, the CEC seeks to collect additional information and perspectives to determine the most effective pathways to advance the Lithium Valley Vision. The proceeding will enable the CEC to establish a record of input from multiple perspectives, including those of local residents, government, California Native American tribes, industry, community groups, academia, the public, and other interested participants to help develop recommendations for a more strategic plan to advance the Lithium Valley Vision. The ultimate outcome of this proceeding will be a set of recommendations for state and local government to consider to ensure successful development of the Lithium Valley Vision.

This proceeding specifically seeks to:

  1. Identify the entities currently implementing Lithium Valley Commission recommendations and establish a coordinated approach between those entities to fulfill and track progress on the completion of those recommendations;
  2. Work closely with the County of Imperial and other local jurisdictions, as well as communities and tribes, to develop a shared Lithium Valley Vision;
  3. Determine how the Lithium Valley Vision ties into the state’s climate and clean energy goals;
  4. Develop recommendations to align resources and efforts towards the shared Lithium Valley Vision and the state’s lithium economy;
  5. Identify how to remove barriers to building out infrastructure required for the Lithium Valley Vision; and
  6. Explore whether new legislation is needed to fulfill the Lithium Valley Commission’s recommendations and the Lithium Valley Vision.

For more information about the Lithium Valley Vision, visit this webpage:
[Lithium Valley Vision]
For more information on Lithium Valley Commission and its report, visit this webpage:
[Lithium Valley Commission
]

The question we all must raise and demand to be answered is this: “Are lithium batteries the  absolute safest battery technology available?”   I think the answer is “NO”.  Please write the CEC and demand that non-lithium battery technologies that are far safer be used and incentivized.

3CE POWER CUSTOMERS WILL SEE A RATE INCREASE AS SOON AS APRIL
The Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) Audit and Finance Board met recently, approving a rate increase for all customers.  This is because power consumption has been lower than anticipated, thereby affecting overall revenue collected,  and the California Public Utility Commission (CPUC) is expected  to change regulatory policies at their March 19, 2025 meeting that will affect pricing and requirements.

The Board heard that revenues were down about 5% from anticipated levels of $5.7 million, causing a $12 million deficit if customers pricing does not increase.  The goal is to add $40 million to the Reserve, to allow continued electricfication incentives and purchasing operational facilities…. BESS facilities, for example.

The Board, Chaired by Watsonville City Councilmember Jimmy Dutra, approved the rate increase.  Boardmember Silva from Buellton worried that customers in the San Luis Obispo area that have just been brought into the 3CE service boundary were promised big savings on their energy rates…double digit-level savings.  Staff of 3CE assured him that it was clear in the information to these newly-signed up customers that the rates were temporary.

Next month, the 3CE Policy Board will review and likely approve these rate increases.  Monica Martinez, 5th District Santa Cruz County Supervisor, sits on that Board.  Contact her about the impending 3CE rate increase, projected to be 3%, and her conflict of interest on the Board regarding future votes on the County’s BESS Ordinance.  <Monica.Martinez@santacruzcountyca.gov>

WHAT IS IN YOUR WATER?
We all wonder now, and if Soquel Creek Water District does begin injecting treated sewage water into the midcounty’s aquifer drinking water supply, I think we should all worry more.  Take a look at this interesting site and compare your water with that of others. [Chemicals Found In CA Drinking Water Revealed In New Study]

Many thanks to my friend, Kris, for sending this information.

WILL SANTA CRUZ CITY BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE IF NEW AFFORDABLE HOUSING TAX IS PASSED?
The 2023-2024 Santa Cruz County Civil Grand Jury investigation found that the City of Santa Cruz has failed in many respects to honor promises of affordable housing funding accountability.  Please read “Housing for Whom?  An Investigation of Inclusionary Housing in the City of Santa Cruz” :
[Housing Report]

Here is the summary that must be addressed by the proponents of this new tax that would fund workforce affordable housing:

“Summary 
Inclusionary Housing refers to the percentage of units in a development project required by City Code to be set aside for below market rate rent or sale. This type of housing is a critical source of affordable housing in the City of Santa Cruz. The number is small while the demand is high. The City Municipal Code requires that local residents and workers in the City of Santa Cruz who meet income eligibility requirements are given preference (priority) for Inclusionary Housing.
 
But is this happening? 
 
The Grand Jury investigation determined that the City keeps no records, does no tracking, gathers no data, and has no evidence to determine if preference is being given to local residents and local workers when renting Inclusionary Housing units. 
 
The City has conflicting and contradictory policies on whether Inclusionary Housing applies to low, very low and extremely low income earners only, or whether moderate income earners are also eligible.
 
The City cannot state what percentage of the City’s affordable housing is occupied by income-verified UCSC students. The Grand Jury recommends that the disparity in the City’s legal documents regarding income eligibility levels for Inclusionary Housing be resolved; that the City develop publicly available metrics to ensure Inclusionary Housing preferences are being followed and to document the percentage of Inclusionary Housing units rented to UCSC students.”

How did the Santa Cruz City Council and Mayor Fred Keeley respond?   DENY, DENY, DENY.  Read the responses in the attached investigation report and ask yourself whether the City can be trusted now with a ballot measure to bring in more money for workforce inclusionary housing.

Listen in to a February 28 recorded interview on “Community Matters” program about the proposed  Workforce Affordable Housing Act Initiative (under “Current Shows” and Community Matters).  There is also a Public Workshop, sponsored by “Our Downtown, Our Future”,  on the topic on Saturday,  March 1, 3:30pm-5pm at the Downtown Library,   Hopefully it will be recorded.

SEEING RAINBOWS
The magic of  seeing refracted light is wonderful.  Plan to take the family to see the Light Refractor Scopes @STEAM Expo, held at the Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds on Saturday, March 8, in Crosetti Building, 10:30am-3pm.


WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  DEMAND PUBLIC TOWN HALL MEETINGS WITH YOUR COUNTY SUPERVISORS AND ATTEND THEM.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Cotoni Coast Dairies, 2064: A Dystopia

I invite you to immerse yourself for a few moments into my nightmare of the future of Santa Cruz’ North Coast. How will Cotoni Coast Dairies fare in the future, for instance in 2064? During the past year, many things have aligned to push my nightmare closer to reality. Note, this essay is the opposite view of my prior utopian sketch published here.

The Recipe
Extreme factions of the far right have expertly wrangled a successful populist movement, gaining control of all three branches of the US government. Swiftly, we see dismantling of conservation including parklands staff and environmental protections for wildlife, clean water, and clean air. We recall Brazil’s Bolsonaro regime and their treatment of the precious natural areas of the Amazon and its inhabitants: park boundaries ignored and rapacious resource development encouraged, including illegal settlements. This story has been repeated in many places around the world as populist national political interests are imposed. These trends repeat: abandoning local interests with the establishment of the parks at the outset and continuing alienation of local people post parks development. As ecologists and conservationist Dan Janzen has wisely noted, it is important that the most local people see their own interests reflected in conservation lands, so that they will play an active role in protecting those lands.

What’s Coming
It is 2064, the 50th anniversary of Cotoni Coast Dairies becoming public land, and none of the hundreds of shanty inhabitants living on the property are reminded of the significance of this milestone. Parking areas and trails, once developed for the recreational elite, are covered with trash and lean-to cardboard and tin shelters, which started during the Hard Times of the 2030’s. Presidential Administrations have opened most federal lands, especially Bureau of Land Management lands, to settlement, promising to alleviate housing shortages. Millions had been displaced by extreme heat and epic storms, driven by climate change in the quickly uninhabitable interior USA. The squalor of the hastily erected federal land climate refugee camps contrasts only slightly to those on the nearby State Parks lands, which were opened by the Governor a little later and had ad hoc administrators that attempted (at first) to organize them.

Missing Wildlife
By 2050, wildlife on the North Coast existed only as a fond memory of most settlers, who longed for the first decades of feasting on their tasty flesh. Even the smallest birds have succumbed to cooking fires, and the land is silent, without bird song. Tide pools have been scraped clean of limpets and mussels and people comb post-storm beaches for kelp and other marine vegetables, otherwise out of reach from harvest.

Wildfire
Fires have become tamer after the raging infernos of the 20’s and 30’s consumed the last of the mature trees and, eventually, even their memories…the blackened snags and stumps. Storms come almost every summer, and it is rare that lightning fails to ignite a hundred fires between Santa Cruz and Half Moon Bay. These run quickly across the mountains in the regularly howling winds, consuming whatever diminutive weeds survive. Hundreds of people succumb to wind-driven infernos, but more replace them. As bad as it seems, there is no better place remaining: the seasons are still relatively mild compared to anywhere else in the country.

The Water
The much-feared Water Guard and their families are the richest among the abject poor, for the cost of this scarce commodity cannot be avoided. They maintain and guard impoundments in the few streams that still provide water: Waddell, Scott, San Vicente, and Laguna Creeks. The other streams disappeared by 2050, now only scorched, mud-filled, lifeless canyons. The dams in the remaining creeks are maintained at high cost and much labor. Deluges are followed by flash floods carrying boulders, silt and debris that easily fill the tiny reservoirs. The stronger people earn water credit in trade for their labor rebuilding the dams, cleaning out storage pools, and replacing distribution pipes leading to water sales locations. Others earn their water by guarding this system day and night, sometimes with their lives. Water is life!

The Realization of This Nightmare
This dystopia is closer than most realize. It is a choice. It is everyone’s choice to avoid, but no one chooses the leadership necessary to do so. Instead, we keep electing representatives to take the place of the parents we wish we had had. Mother and daddy know best, we just want to be told to hush and to trust and that everything will be okay, but it never works out that way.

The pathway to this nightmare has been paved in so many ways. The back-room-deal-type Environmental Saviors responsible for the federal presence, for the Bureau of Land Management (of all agencies!) takeover of Cotoni Coast Dairies not that long ago fought local conservationists in court and won, then counter-sued the conservationists for their expenses. Those types are still working behind the scenes to make this deal seem palatable and good by succoring wealthy outdoor recreation types and funding their trail-building enablers. They have long abandoned partnerships with local community interests and even the more wide-ranging and very popular wildlife conservation movement. Alienation of those interests leaves the door wide open for the populists to overrun these lands which they portray as empty, pretty landscapes ready for settlement. It has always been so.

What You Can Do
The frustration we feel at the trends we have seen too late emerging can be put to good use. We can give money to the Center for Biological Diversity, a last bastion effectively using the legal system to protect wildlife, even around the Monterey Bay. We can vote for different representatives who primarily recognize the importance of the environment and the need to engage, enlighten, and empower those people who care about nature, which is everyone. We can speak up against the local lack of justice. We have more influence in local politics than national: this is the place we create the political movements that make a difference. This is the place we nurture the leaders of tomorrow’s State and Federal governments.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Tuesday, March 4, 2025
#63 / The Apprentice

On Friday, February 21, 2025, the “Review & Outlook” column in The Wall Street Journal included a statement about “Trump’s Executive-Power Restoration.” According to The Journal, our president’s “bold order putting ‘independent agencies’ under White House control echoes the Founders.” The column begins this way:

In case you haven’t noticed, President Trump is trying to assert control over the entire executive branch of government, for better or worse. His latest effort is an executive order published Tuesday that imposes new White House supervision over so-called independent agencies like the Securities and Exchange Commission. This could be a constitutional watershed (emphasis added).

There is no doubt that the very essence of our Constitutional government is at stake, but The Journal is wrong about what “the Founders” contemplated. What they contemplated was a government in which the “Legislative” branch decided all major issues, and wrote the laws, with the “Executive” branch given the subsidiary responsibility of seeing that “the laws were faithfully executed.” After all, the American Revolution was fought to extract the United States, and its government, from the grip of a “King.”

Our current president, recently, proclaimed himself a “King,” and even if Mr. Trump meant this only metaphorically, and to indicate simply that he considers himself to be a powerful and effective manager and leader, there is still a pretty significant problem.

Here’s the problem: Mr. Trump, in truth, is not doing a very good job managing the federal government, after having announced that it was time, as The Wall Street Journal put it, for “new White House supervision” over important governmental agencies. Maybe it would actually be a good idea to undertake a substantive review of various governmental bureaucracies. I, personally, can’t really say that if this were done correctly it would be a mistake. However, any such review should be undertaken only in a very well-thought-out way, with lots of opportunities for those affected, and the public, to understand what’s going on, and to comment and participate. This would be the opposite of what is actually happening.

I am sorry to have to say it out loud, and to question Mr. Trump’s sense of his own greatness, but Mr. Trump just isn’t a very effective, or competent, top manager. He thinks he is one, certainly, and he says he is one, but he is not.

Mr. Trump, for instance, somehow managed to drive two different Atlantic City casinos into bankruptcy, which is hard to understand, since where gambling casinos are concerned, the “House” always wins.

It is worth paying attention to what a column in The New York Times said, on the very same day that The Journal published its editorial comment, which I have quoted above. Here is The Times’ headline: “We Are Blundering Our Way Into a Financial Crisis.” If that financial crisis does come, it is Mr. Trump who will have gotten us there. On a different topic, as I have recently noted, the president’s failure to conduct himself properly (and wisely) in a meeting with President Zelensky of Ukraine is having a negative impact on our ability remain in a leadership position in the world.

In terms of both competence and experience, as a manager – and as our chief executive – Donald J. Trump is just not very good.

He is an “Apprentice,” and he has gotten himself (and the nation) all mixed up.

Our president does think he is a competent executive, course. However, that is only because he used to play one on TV!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

AN AMBUSH, KICKING THE DOG, KICKING THE CAN, NO-NO-NOBEL

The world is still reeling from the embarrassing Oval Office clash between Presidents Trump and Zelensky, and Vice-Intruder Vance last week. A much-anticipated agreement with the USA to move toward a settlement between Ukraine and Russia to resolve Putin’s ongoing three-year attempt to rejoin Zelensky’s country into the Russian fold was simply a shameful ambush by the White House. As Sabrina Haake writes in her column, “The flip side to shame is revulsion. Watching Trump and Vance kick Zelensky for the cameras was like watching a neighbor starve his dog, then kick it for looking at his food bowl.” Haake says watching Trump’s and Vance’s attempts to pressure the Ukraine president into surrendering to Putin made her sick with shame, since they wanted him “to agree to a ceasefire with no security guarantees and to ‘trust’ Putin to honor his word.” The 2014 invasion of Crimea and the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, coupled with Putin’s murdered critics (watch out for that open window!) and disappeared rivals emphasizes to Zelensky that Putin is unrelenting in his quest. Our two ‘leaders’ accused Zelensky of “being disrespectful” and “trying to re-litigate” the morals of the war for the press and the cameras — all arranged by Trump for his anticipated glory and that now-trampled Nobel Peace Prize.

Norwegian parliamentarian Christian Tybring-Gjedde is quoted as saying that Trump’s dictatorial bullying doesn’t qualify as a diplomatic outreach that warrants a third nomination to follow the two that we saw in his first term. “He is dictating terms that the Europeans are very scared of and are really worried about what’s going to come of this. Right now, I don’t think there’s a prospect of a Nobel Peace Prize. But you never know,” said Tybring-Gjedde. The dark and foreboding browbeating heaped upon Zelensky for not saying ‘thank-you’ enough times for US firepower used against Putin’s invasion, has spoiled Trump’s pledge to “end the war on day one.” It’s obvious that Trump’s whining over the lack of the Nobel on his résumé remains a sore point, as he responded to a reporter’s question during a press conference recently: “They will never give me a Nobel Peace Prize. It’s too bad. I deserve it, but they will never give it to me.” National security advisor Mike Waltz, and Representative Elise Stefanik, both told conservatives that Trump is a “president of peace” who deserves the award. Yet, fears have now risen that the president will use his dominance to end the war on Russian terms, with his rhetoric having grown more hostile to Ukraine over the past few weeks — calling Zelensky a “dictator” and accusing Ukraine of being the aggressor.

Sitting next to Trump, with arms folded, Zelensky was scolded like a disobedient schoolboy, bombarded by Vance’s accusation, “Have you said ‘thank-you’ once in the entire meeting?” Following the cancelled meeting, after Zelensky was unceremoniously escorted to his limo, and without having to delve into suppressed files, CNN posted thirty-three occasions in which Zelensky expressed his gratitude, one before a joint session of the US Congress in 2022 — a more comprehensive search would certainly have doubled, tripled that number. Attempting to one-up Vance, a testy Trump then said, “You’re either going to make a deal or we’re out. And if we’re out, you’ll fight it out. I don’t think that’s going to be pretty, but you’ll fight it out. But you don’t have the cards.” Mafioso Trump seemed to forget that he was in the Oval Office as he went into presidential campaign mode, talking about the “phony witch hunt” he endured regarding Russia’s 2016 election meddling. “Let me tell you, Putin went through a hell of a lot with me,” Trump whined. MSNBC’s Nicole Wallace responded to this diatribe with a twisted-face “Awww….” as if to say, “Isn’t that sweet?” After the Ukraine president had left the building, Trump announced he was not welcome back, until he is “ready for peace.” Or until Trump is seriously ready to compete for that Nobel. Should he forge an agreement favorable to Russia and leave Europe vulnerable to an aggressive Putin, Trump doesn’t ‘have the cards’ in his quest, since the Nobel selection committee is appointed by the Norwegian parliament, leaders of a country nestled next to an expansionist Russia. Trump is still obsessed over Barack Obama’s Nobel Prize which he was awarded nine months into his presidency, and in 2018 expressed dismay that plant scientist Norman Borlaug won for helping to combat global famine: “Can you believe it? He won the Nobel Peace Prize!” Yeah! So take that, USAID!

The Oval Office conflagration with the demand that Zelensky bend the knee and kiss the ring was off to a bad start even before the televised blowup, after Zelensky was presented with a minerals-for-security agreement by the White House — with no security deal guaranteeing protection from Russian aggression. Ukraine’s president, prior to his trip to DC, had repeatedly specified that security assurances would need to be included, and with his rejection during final discussions, the anger of Trump and Vance spewed out in the subsequent pathetic meeting with the media. Columnist Phil Boas of The Arizona Republic likened the spectacle to “a food fight with petty insults, imbecilic logic, the barking immaturity that is the vernacular of loudmouths and incels, and cosplaying freaks who occupy so much of the social web. Gone were diplomacy and decorum as the world watched with mouths agape, trying to process the consequences. And how long can the Trump administration walk this tightrope, this knife’s blade to restore what it calls American greatness? When you blow past old rules of conduct, through longstanding guardrails, you may think you’re making progress, but you are surely wreaking your own destruction. If you don’t respect boundaries, your political foes won’t either. They’ll come at you, and with fury.” Boas calls Trump an agent of destruction, who currently finds it rough-sledding in his attempt to follow through on campaign promises; Americans sought change in the November election, but the roller coaster is out of control and if the president and his mob don’t slow it, the American people will — and sooner than the next election.

Bill Maher on HBO’s ‘Real Time’ was visibly outraged about the treatment of Zelensky by the Trump White House, dejectedly joking, “Great day to be an American. My first thought is that he’s browbeating a guy who speaks English as a second language. So we’re all agreed this is deplorable. I’ve tried not to use the word deplorable as much as I can, but when it’s deplorable, it’s deplorable.” World leaders, politicos and average Americans on social media posts agreed that the Zelensky takedown was lacking in the decorum expected of a sensible and reliable USA. Maher’s guest, Fareed Zakaria, called it “tragic” to see an American president “bully, berate” and “demean” a nation’s leader “who depends on the US for its survival” — before giving a cheeky suggestion to Zelensky. Zakaria joked, “The way to have gone in there, is first, you begin by saying, ‘President Trump, you are a genius. You have completely transformed the landscape. I have with me the highest order of merit — Ukraine has never created a civilian honor this big — for you.’ You have a big medal, put it on him, then say to him, ‘I look forward to working with you.'” John Stoehr, of The Editorial Board, an online newspaper, writes, “I think it’s emblematic of the fact that Donald Trump surrounds himself with grown men who are willing to act like little boys if that’s what it takes to make Big Daddy happy.”

The Trump/Vance performance took place just in time for NBC’s ‘Saturday Night Live’ to take full advantage for a cold open to the show last week. James Austin Johnson as Trump opened the sketch with, “I’d like to welcome President Zelensky to this incredible trap.” Referring to Zelensky’s casual attire, which Trump called attention to as soon as Ukraine’s president stepped out of the limousine, Johnson’s Trump complimented Mikey Day as Zelensky: “I’d like to thank President Zelensky for dressing like casual Star Trek. We love Star Trek because there’s no DEI. The white guy was the leader and he bossed around Spock who was, I believe, Guatemalan.” Mikey Day portraying Zelensky, was unable to speak any lines within the shouting match, being interrupted by Bowen Yang’s JD Vance as soon as he opened his mouth to enter the ‘conversation.’ “I have to jump in here because that’s how we planned this. You didn’t say ‘thank-you.’ You didn’t say anything about us being handsome,” and interrupting Day’s Zelensky again, says, “You have been talking this entire time. I’m sorry, does the sign outside say ‘Ukraine House’? No, it says ‘America House.'” The SNL couch potato portraying a wide-eyed Secretary of State, ‘Little’ Marco Rubio, only sunk deeper into the cushions, muttering, “No Inglés!”  Johnson’s Trump threw out the “I have the cards” line from the embarrassing Oval Office display: “You say you want to end this war, but frankly you don’t have the cards. I have the cards. I have ‘Skip’. I have ‘Draw Four’. I have ‘Get Out of Jail Free’ — the Supreme Court gave me that one.” Comedian Mike Myers crashed the meeting as Elon Musk, chain saw, black t-shirt and mannerisms that were accurate in depicting the real DOGE terrorist. Myers/Musk asks Johnson/Trump, “Uh, Donald, what are you doing in my office? You know I’m president now. I’m kidding! I’m kidding. Maybe not!” He joked about the scores of firings accomplished through DOGE actions: “They’re saying I’m firing people with no cause. But I do have cause. It’s ’cause I feel like it.” Reality bites!

Satirist Andy Borowitz reports that Zelensky is bowing to Trump’s demand to call for an immediate election with the condition that it be held in the USA and he be allowed to run for president. “For almost 250 years, the USA has been a beacon of democracy and freedom,” he said. “It should have a president who respects those ideas, and I will gladly relocate from Ukraine to do the job.” He was optimistic about his chances of defeating Trump, adding, “I have heard his approval rating is 4 percent, and most of that comes from Elon Musk’s children.”

Elon Musk’s DOGE army of college dropout hackers, termed the Nerd Reich by federal workers, are using threats and intimidation to gain access to governmental departments and the sensitive data trove in order to gut essential government services, eliminate regulators, a dismantling meant to reshape the federal workforce to serve Trump’s interests and those of his wealthy contributors. One official laments, “I can’t believe this is how they’re blowing up the Constitution — this little nerd army — God help us.” ‘Tonight Show‘ host Jimmy Fallon mocked Musk’s directive to have US federal workers list and submit five things they’ve done in the past week to justify holding their jobs or face termination — for which Musk has no official authority. Workers were dismayed and angry, mostly for getting a work email on a Saturday, joked Fallon, but he had a response for those who dared: “1) I received this email, 2) I opened this email, 3) I read this email, 4) I laughed at this email, 5) I deleted this email. There’s five,” said Fallon, “It’s hard to take seriously when rules from ‘Cinderella’ are being stolen,” as he referred to the 11:59 PM deadline for a response. Social media also gathered a few contributors: 1) Woke up, 2) Got out of bed, 3) Dragged a comb across my head, 4) Found my way downstairs and drank a cup, 5) Looking up, I noticed I was late. Another had a suggestion that would suffice for several weeks of reporting: 1) Put your right arm in, 2) Take your right arm out, 3) Put your right arm in and you shake it all about, 4) Do the Hokey Pokey and you turn yourself around, 5) That’s what it’s all about. Trump is known for attempting to insult Obama by insisting he was born in Africa simply to diminish his standing in the eyes of his base-in-waiting — now he has Elon, who was actually born in Africa, ruining the country for him.

The White House said that Cabinet secretaries could have the final word on whether employees must respond with their week’s accomplishments, as stated by press secretary Karoline Leavitt. Leavitt said, “The president defers to his Cabinet secretaries who he’s obviously entrusted to pursue the guidance relative to their specific workforce. And for some of the agencies that you’ve seen that have said ‘please don’t send these emails,’ it’s in their best interest for that specific agency, and the president supports that.” She added that over one million responses had been received, “to insure that federal workers are not ripping off American taxpayers, that they are showing up to the office and that they are doing their jobs.” The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) informed Cabinet heads that response to Musk’s edict is voluntary and failure to do so will not be considered a resignation — that threat not appearing in the email, but given voice by President Musk. New FBI Director Kash Patel said, “When and if further information is required, we will coordinate the responses. For now, pause any responses.” Predictable mass chaos reigned as Johnny-Come-Lately Trump arrived on the scene to praise Musk’s email — in order to gather details on employee accomplishments, and to find if employees even exist who are issued paychecks! This led to the OPM issuing yet another statement, quietly stripping the ‘voluntary action’ sentence, with Musk sending a second email demand. Needless to say, it remains a chaotic and unclear situation across all departments with the State Department still advising employees not to respond. Philosopher and essayist George Santayana is quoted as saying, “Perhaps the universe is nothing but an equilibrium of idiocies.” But we could narrow it down to a confederacy of dunces, huh?

Twenty-one staff members of the US DOGE Service (formerly the US Digital Service) submitted a letter of resignation, citing the destruction of the federal government, which follows on the heels of department employees who were laid off earlier. The letter addressed to White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles and posted publicly, reads, “We will not use our skills as technologists to compromise core government systems, jeopardize Americans’ sensitive data, or dismantle critical public services. We will not lend our expertise to carry out or legitimize DOGE’s actions. As civil servants, we remained committed throughout the Presidential Transition to delivering better government services through technology and stood ready to partner with incoming officials. Each of us left senior private sector technology positions to pursue nonpartisan public service. We swore to serve the Constitution across presidential administrations. However, it has become clear that we can no longer honor those commitments at the United State DOGE Service.”

Press Secretary Leavitt revealed last week that a dramatic change is being initiated in the press access for journalists covering President Trump, with the White House press team overseeing the press pool instead of the White House Correspondent’s Association“Legacy outlets who have participated in the pool for decades will still be allowed to join,” she announced, but the change will bring in ‘new voices.’ “We will continue the rotation of the five major television networks to ensure (‘endure’ might be more apt) the president’s remarks are heard far and wide around this world. We will add additional streaming services which reach different audiences than traditional cable and broadcast,” she clarified. The WHCA’s president, Eugene Daniels responded to this abrupt change, saying, “This move tears at the independence of a free press in the United States. It suggests the government will select the journalists who cover the president. In a free country, leaders must not be able to choose their own press corps.” Daniels revealed that Leavitt and her team didn’t include him and the WHCA in any discussions for the change, claiming that the organization is already expanding into a wide range of outlets as part of the overall pool. Trump, in his pettiness, is still barring the Associated Press over their refusal to acknowledge his executive order by changing their stylebook to read ‘the Gulf of America’ instead of ‘the Gulf of Mexico.’ Weird that Trump shared an AP article on social media in criticizing Zelensky for saying the end to the Russian/Ukraine war is “far away.” Fox News and Newsmax have urged Trump to lift his ban, and a federal judge has declined to order the White House to do so. The WHCA’s annual gala dinner in DC is on schedule, and Trump is surely to skip the event, with the expected stinging barbs being thrown in his direction.

‘Tonight Show’ host Jimmy Fallon mocked the administration’s expropriation of the press pool by saying, “Yep, Trump will now only take questions from Fox News, Foxier News and Foxiest News.” Leavitt explains, “So by deciding which outlets make up the limited press pool on a day-to-day basis, the White House will be restoring power back to the American people who President Trump was elected to serve,” — justifying the reason to allow independent journalists on TikTok to apply for press credentials?

Attorney General Pam Bondi made a big deal of her announcement that the Epstein files would be released, which contain lists of clients and flight logs of passengers flown on his private plane to his private island. After release of the documents, word quickly got around that it was information previously made public — no bombshells! To counter the uproar, Bondi pointed a finger at the FBI, who she blamed for withholding “thousands of pages of documents.” Conspiracy theorists were accusing the Deep State agents for lack of transparency, providing Jimmy Kimmel with fodder for his show’s monologue. “That’s right, the deep state agents are trying to hide it. Well, first the deep state agents need to go through the documents to make sure they dot every ‘i’ and cross out every ‘DJ-T,’ and then they can release the documents,” he offered. Continuing, he said, “You know, the fact that these Looney Tunes keep conveniently forgetting that Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein were good friends is unbelievable.” Reading from a 2002 issue of New York magazine’s profile of Epstein, he said to the audience, “This is a quote from Donald Trump: ‘I’ve known Jeff for 15 years, terrific guy. He’s a lot of fun to be with. It’s even said that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of them are on the younger side. No doubt about it — Jeffrey enjoys his social life.'” “And they’re running around with binders,” Kimmel chuckled, as he cited a New York Times report: ‘Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein had a party at Mar-a-Lago, calling it a ‘calendar girl’ competition.'” Kimmel concluded, “It was only two men and 28 disappointed calendar girls — I hope that’s in the binder when it comes out.” We can rest assured that Kash Patel will get to the bottom of this deep state mixup!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Daylight Saving Time

“I don’t mind going back to daylight saving time. With inflation, the hour will be the only thing I’ve saved all year.”
~Victor Borge

“The sun got confused about daylight savings time. It rose twice. Everything had two shadows.”
~Steven Wright

“You will never find anybody who can give you a clear and compelling reason why we observe daylight savings time.”
~Dave Barry

“Daylight time, a monstrosity in timekeeping.”
~Harry S. Truman

“An extra yawn one morning in the springtime, an extra snooze one night in the autumn is all that we ask in return for dazzling gifts. We borrow an hour one night in April; we pay it back with golden interest five months later.”
~Winston Churchill

...

Here is the most recent Randy Rainbow. I saw him in San Francisco a few years ago at the Masonic, I believe. Fabulous show, of course!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

February 26 – March 4, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… Notes from Australia… Steinbruner… aftermath of the battery fires, and more… Hayes… Autocracy Continues to Build… Patton… Don’t be a scaredy-cat… Matlock… the new pledge…a Faustian deal…somewhere in New Jersey… Eagan… Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… Art! Do some art!! Quotes on… “March”

...

THERE GOES THE NEIGHBORHOOD. You want to bet that back in the 1890’s, when this was taken in our Aptos hills and mountains, that the lumber company (Loma Prieta Lumber Company) had some answer to the tree-huggers who thought that, just maybe, clear cutting wasn’t the best idea in the world?

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: February 26, 2025

SPRING? I can’t believe we are going into March already. I assume it will not be recognized as Women’s Month in any meaningful way, but we can all recognize women around us, every day. If you have Amazon Prime, there’s a documentary series called Extraordinary Women. There are 13 episodes available on Prime, and the subjects range from Hedy Lamarr to Indira Gandhi to Dr Ruth! I intend to watch the series in March. Join me, and we can talk about it!

...

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE ÅRE MURDERS. Netflix. Series (6.7 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

...

February 24, 2025

Notes from Australia

The photo is a clue to where I’ve been, missing for the past three weeks. Down Under, where it is hot and humid at this time of year, my favorite weather. The view is from one of the commuter ferries that connect the many Sydney Harbor waterfront locations, in this case Manly and Circular Quay. We were headed to the Opera House for a Brahms and Beethoven concert with the Australian Chamber Orchestra.

Today, the Opera House is an immediately recognizable, iconic structure that is world-renowned. However, I remember the controversy, when its design by the Danish architect Jorn Utzon won first place in the open competition and his inspirational concept then faced the formidable challenge of implementation. The state government eventually took over the project, changed architects and funded its ever-increasing cost with an Opera House Lottery. When skeptics suggested that most Aussies prefer horse-racing and rugby to opera, the Dairy Farmers Collective of New South Wales generously offered to hold their annual conference in the new structure. Today, the Opera House seems to be doing fine without the dairy farmers’ support.

After the concert we walked to the Rocks area and found an old pub, the Glenmore Hotel, for dinner. The Rocks area is now a popular food destination that in the early 1970’s faced demolition to make way for new residential high rises. A familiar story for Santa Cruz, a small group of neighbors organized to preserve the old historic buildings that housed mainly low-income residents. Unfamiliar for Santa Cruz, they were joined by the Builders Labourers’ Federation with their green bans, which became a powerful force against development projects harmful to the built and natural environment. They saved the Rocks area and fifty years later, despite gentrification, locals and visitors alike would heartily agree it was well worth saving.

In the spirit of it’s a small world, I was chatting with the two bartenders in the pub bar as they prepared our drinks. I’m never asked where I’m from since I pass as local, however sometimes I feel the need to explain that I live in Santa Cruz, CA as I stare too long at the money or try to figure out how to pay on the bus and train. So, the bartenders were told I live in Santa Cruz. To my surprise, they knew about the damage to the end of the Wharf, which they correctly called a pier but incorrectly believed, from the media, that the whole structure had collapsed. I set them straight on that and added that they were talking with the prime agitator to save the Wharf from gentrification. They liked that.

There’s a lot to like about Sydney and the coast north and south of it. Trees dominate, even close to the city. Great swathes of canopy stretching for miles with the houses tucked beneath them. Very cooling. Very nice visually. Birds are raucous, from an earlier evolutionary time. I grew up on the coast twenty miles north of Sydney, in a small beach town that like Santa Cruz has shifted from working class with cheap housing to management/investor class with expensive housing. Yet that headland looks the same as it did decades ago, except the Norfolk Island pines are much taller. The houses look the same and have not been bulldozed for infill and high rise….at least not yet. Only their value, an artificial concept has been manipulated to rise.

In the photo below you can see that beach and headland which was home until I moved into the city to go to Sydney University and lived with others in an old run-down townhouse. That old townhouse is now gentrified in a gentrified neighborhood and worth a high price, although not demolished. Speculation in housing causing prices to rise is a global phenomenon.

A few nice things about the Sydney area and probably Australia in general. Tipping is not expected nor given, except in very expensive restaurants. Sales tax is included in the price, so you pay what the dish cost and nothing more. It sure makes splitting the cost of a group dinner much easier! I was told that a barista, working full-time could earn $70 grand a year. Not enough to pay rent without sharing but not too bad either. Minimum wage is around $25 an hour. Most earn well above the minimum wage, especially tradies who are among the well-off.

There are many things each country could learn from the other. I saw new single-family houses under construction with steel framing. That seemed a good idea in any fire-prone area, especially if the rest of the house is brick veneer, not wood. To make that construction choice financially feasible, it helps that Australia produces all its own steel. On the other hand, Sydney could follow-our lead and institute smog checks. Despite most cars being new models, I could smell the exhaust even if there was no noticeable smog in the air.

I flew back yesterday and now it’s time to buckle down and tackle the issues here at home. My jaw dropped at first sight today of the slab of high-rise construction which I guess is Pacific Station North. And that is minor compared to the radical transformation contained in the Downtown Extension Project, should it be approved. Get ready, get involved, get organized! It’s time for a new green ban effort in the spirit of the Builders Labourers Federation. It’s discouraging here that the unions have narrowed their sights to a paycheck rather than broadening their sights to see what else is worth preserving. If shown what will be lost, maybe some will care.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
EXCELLENT PRESENTATION ABOUT CONTAMINATED SLOUGH SOILS FOLLOWING MOSS LANDING BATTERY FIRE

Last Friday, I attended an excellent presentation at UCSC by Dr. ivano Aiello, a scientist at Moss Landing Marine Lab, explaining his work to sample Slough soils for heavy metals following the Vistra Battery Fire that began on January 16 and burned for days…only to recently be rekindled.  Here are the main points to note:

  1. His team has been sampling soils in that area for about 10 years, establishing  a good baseline of pre-fire metal levels.
  2. His team visited the sampling sites immediately upon being allowed back into the area, finding large chunks of burnt materials on the ground (which they treated as hazardous material).
  3. His team only scraped off the top 1-2mm thickness of soil surface and used in-field x-ray technology to get readings, but also took samples back to the lab to dry and test via spectrophotometry (“the gold standard” of analyzing materials).
  4. The levels of nickel, manganese and cobalt were very high and showed a linear correlation with respect to the fire location.  Highest levels were found 2-3 miles away from the fire.
  5. The EPA sampled at least 1″ cores of soil, thereby likely diluting the levels of metals that were on the soil surface.
  6. The EPA sample sites were all on the upwind side of the fire, except one site in the Hester Slough sampling area that Dr. Aiello’s staff recommended the EPA sample.
  7. The single EPA site recommended by Dr. Aiello’s staff did show high levels of Nickel, Cobalt, Manganese and Lithium, but the EPA did no further sampling in that area.
  8. The other EPA sample sites all showed low levels of the metals, so the evacuation order was lifted.
  9. Dr. Aiello’s team found clear evidence of nickel, manganese, and cobalt attached to nanoparticles in the soils and on plant surfaces examined under an electron microscope,. and the proportion of the metals matched the composition of Vistra’s lithium ion batteries that burned.
  10. The “Never Again Moss Landing” citizen science work that collected 124 surface swipe samples from the broad area correlated with Dr. Aiello’s “bulls-eye” test areas showing very high levels of nickel, manganese and cobalt.

One student asked if Vistra will have to clean up the contamination?  This is not being discussed, said Dr. Aiello.  He drew an picture of an oil tank and a leak of a known amount.  “What is the difference between an oil spill and this battery fire?  Why isn’t anyone talking about remediation?” he asked.  Based on his testing results and the area of  the slough his team sampled, he calculates 6,369 pounds of nickel, cobalt and manganese were deposited over 154km2 (almost 60 square miles).   Further extrapolating, estimating the metals released from the 70% burned Moss 300 facility, over 2.1 million pounds of heavy metal went up in the smoke, with heaviest deposits 3-5 miles west of the fire.

His team has continued to samples every two days.  Dr. Peter Weiss is working on sampling water areas. About 20 scientists are working on studying the impacts to micro-invertebrates and plants…how will this disaster affect the food web?  There is very little in the literature about such an issue….just one battery fire in Illinois, but that only evaluated HF gas, not heavy metals.  Interestingly, he has seen that core soil samples show an increase in the metals at depths that correlate with the 2021 Moss Landing Battery Fire.

So, one must ask….why are Monterey and Santa Cruz County officials so quiet…and Vistra and the CPUC even more so???

Please contact your County Supervisor and demand a town hall meeting.  Call 831-454-2200, and/or locate and email your supervisor

COULD PHYTO-MINING FIELDS CONTAMINATED BY MOSS LANDING VISTRA FIRE HELP REGAIN GOOD FARMLAND?
With the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire flaring up AGAIN this week, one has to wonder about the impacts to local farm land, and waterways.  No information has yet to become public from Monterey County or Santa Cruz County testing.  No Supervisors in Santa Cruz County have held any town hall meetings to discuss the problems with the people, and the February  25 Board of Supervisor agenda has NOTHING about the County’s response to the disaster.

Have you asked the produce manager where you do your shopping if the items for sale were grown in the areas where the Moss Landing Battery Fire smoke plume travelled? I have…they don’t know.
Extreme nickel hyperaccumulation in the vascular tracts of the tree Phyllanthus balgooyi from Borneo

SUPPORT AB 303 FOR LOCAL CONTROL OVER BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM PROJECTS
In response to the horrible Vistra Battery Fire, District 30 Assemblymember Dawn Addis introduced AB 303 to reverse the power grab of AB 205 that currently allows developers to petition the California Energy Commission for an Opt-In certificate and begin operations, thereby by-passing the local jurisdictions and the people affected.

Please write the County Board of Supervisors to request they write a letter of support for this important legislation

HAS THE CEC APPROVED ANY OPT-IN PROJECTS FOR BESS?
Here is something to think about, but not relax…

A cautionary note is that the CEC has yet to approve any opt-in projects. Developers in the CEC’s permitting queue under the opt-in program have also described the process as slow and overly conservative. State law prohibits the CEC from approving projects through the opt-in process unless they are determined to be consistent with local regulations, codes, and ordinances unless certain (and potentially difficult) findings are made. To date, the CEC has demonstrated little appetite to override inconsistent local prohibitions or restrictions on battery energy storage development. Projects that cannot demonstrate consistency with all otherwise applicable local or state regulations may face an uphill battle, making it all the more important that jurisdictions considering new regulations do not prohibit future battery energy storage projects.
Given the importance of battery storage to grid resiliency and integration of renewable energy, the California Legislature may be open to changes in state law to make permitting energy storage projects easier. Legislative amendments under consideration include:

  • Amendment of the Warren Alquist Act to mandate less stringent findings for CEC override of inconsistency with otherwise applicable laws.
  • Streamlined approval for qualifying battery energy storage projects along the lines of AB 1236 (Chiu, 2015) and AB 970 (McCarty, 2021) addressing electric vehicle (EV) charging stations. These existing streamlining provisions mandate that local jurisdictions adopt expedited, streamlined permitting processes for EV charging stations via a ministerial, administrative review process that is exempt from CEQA and is limited to health and safety review. A similar mandate could be approved for qualifying battery energy storage projects.
  • Mandated streamlined permitting of storage projects through only limited CEQA review such as through some kind of tiered checklist approach from an already certified EIR.

Los Angeles County, after approving what it described as the last battery energy storage project under its current regulations, announced it received grant funding and has hired a consultant to begin environmental review to adopt new zoning regulations specific for battery energy storage. Like Alameda County, San Diego County declined to adopt a moratorium on battery storage projects and recently  declined to adopt inflexible new policies to guide best practices for regulating battery energy storage, instead allowing the Fire Chief to implement flexible requirements on a case-by-case basis until the state fire code is updated next year.
Finally, as fire safety concerns associated with lithium-ion technology batteries continue to be addressed, permitting hurdles for battery storage projects should ease. An update to the California Fire Code to address electrical energy storage systems is anticipated in July 2025 (with a draft to fire departments in May 2025). When final, the updated Fire Code will be effective on January 1, 2026.

As noted above, several jurisdictions are willing to approve this key new technology on a case-by-case basis and defer adoption of jurisdiction-specific zoning restrictions until the statewide Fire Code is updated. 

DEMAND SANTA CRUZ COUNTY ADOPT AN URGENCY ORDINANCE AND MORATORIUM ON LITHIUM BATTERY STORAGE
As a result of the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire disaster, several Counties in California have enacted an Urgency Ordinance to implement a temporary moratorium on BESS projects.  They have also acted to convene a Technical Advisory Group to assist with crafting a BESS Ordinance that is protective of their residents and the environment.

Santa Cruz County also needs to take this action.  Please speak up about this matter on the February 25, 2025 Board meeting and demand for action.

City to write emergency BESS ordinance

Moss Landing fire leads to emergency regulations

Solano County also implemented a moratorium on front of the meter battery energy storage systems and convened a Technical Advisory Group:

On January 23, 2024, Solano County enacted a two-year moratorium on the approval of front-of-the-meter battery energy storage systems to allow planning staff time to develop land use standards that ensure public safety, health, and welfare. The Planning Services Division is engaging stakeholders and the general public for input and guidance in this process. Please attend an upcoming Public Workshop or submit comments or questions to energystorage@solanocounty.com
About the Technical Working Group
The Technical Working Group consisting of stakeholders from various sectors, meets monthly to advise on the ordinance development.

Solano County – Energy Storage

LOW IMPACT CAMPING IS BACK AGAIN!
The crazy idea to let camping (and campfires!) spring up in the high-fire risk unincorporated areas is back again.  Due to public outcry, this disappeared last year…but thanks to Assemblyman Ward, it is bubbling again.

AB 518, as introduced, Ward. Low-impact camping areas. Existing law, the Special Occupancy Parks Act, establishes requirements for the construction, maintenance, occupancy, use, and design of special occupancy parks. Existing law defines “special occupancy park” to mean a recreational vehicle park, temporary recreational vehicle park, incidental camping area, or tent camp. This bill would specify that, for purposes of that act, a special occupancy park does not include a low-impact camping area, as specified, that is located in a county that has enacted an ordinance, as specified, authorizing low-impact camping. The bill would define a “low-impact camping area” to mean any area of private property that provides for the transient occupancy rental of a temporary sleeping accommodation, as defined, for recreational purposes that is not a commercial lodging facility and meets specified requirements. The bill would require the county in which the low-impact camping area is located to enforce some of those requirements, relating to waste disposal and quiet hours, as specified. The bill would require that a county that has authorized low-impact camping to take specified actions, including, among others, to establish a registry of low-impact camping areas, as specified.

Consent agenda item 26 on the Feb. 25 Board of Supervisor meeting consent agenda states:

26. Direct the Chair to send a letter to the legislative sponsor opposing the passage of Assembly Bill 518, Low-Impact Camping, and direct the Chair to share the letter with our state legislators and relevant legislative committees (Board of Supervisors – Third District)

Thank you, Supervisor Cummings!  Call and write to support the Board’s action.

DOWNTOWN EXPANSION OR EXPLOSION?
The Santa Cruz City Council approved amendments to the Downtown Plan (formerly Downtown Recovery Plan [DRP]) in November 2017. The DRP was originally adopted in 1991 to guide reconstruction of the downtown after the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake that destroyed significant portions of the downtown area. The intent of the DRP was to establish policies, development standards and guidelines to direct the recovery process toward the rebuilding after the earthquake. The DRP was adopted as a specific plan (pursuant to California Government Code requirements) to implement policies in the downtown area (PAGE 12)

Implementation of the project would facilitate additional development as a result of various circulation, land use, and infrastructure revisions. For purposes of environmental review, the project area is conservatively anticipated to accommodate: ? Future Development: Up to 1,800 housing units and 60,000 square feet (sf) of gross commercial area. Redevelopment would replace approximately 66 dwelling units and 76,770 gross sf. of commercial uses. ? New Arena: Construction of a new approximately 180,000 sf permanent sports and entertainment arena for the Santa Cruz Warriors basketball team. The arena would contain a main event court with spectator seating for approximately 3,200 seats for basketball, and approximately 4,000 seats for concerts, performances, etc. Additional facilities would include a practice facility consisting of an additional court and training spaces, and supporting concession, retail and administrative uses. This would replace the existing 35,000 sf. temporary arena with 2,475 fixed seats for basketball and 3,100 fixed and temporary seating for other entertainment events. ? Building Height: No new development shall exceed the base heights of 85 feet, 70 feet, or 50 feet except as the result of compliance with any density bonus program or provision of state or local law (as discussed below). Building heights adjacent to Beach Hill hillside shall be limited to no more than 70 feet to provide a transition in height adjacent to the Beach Hill neighborhood. Additional height is permitted through application of a State Density Bonus, the City’s proposed Downtown Density Bonus, or other local density bonus provision. (page 13)

For reference, the Santa Cruz Civic Auditorium has a 2,000 seat capacity.
Civic Auditorium Specifications

Community Spaces: Existing and planned public streets and the Santa Cruz Riverwalk are envisioned to be designed to accommodate public gatherings and events such as pre- and post-arena events, holidays events and festivals, and informal gatherings.

  • Mobility: Pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicular circulation improvements envisioned as part of the creation of the community spaces:
  • Create a circulation network that integrates the built environment and civic spaces, both within and adjacent to the SOLA neighborhood.
  • Create a new Spruce Street Plaza along Spruce Street by permanently closing Spruce Street to vehicular traffic east of Front Street to the Santa Cruz Riverwalk. Emergency, maintenance, and delivery vehicle access shall be maintained through the use of removable barriers or bollards.
  • To create better opportunities for the public to engage with the San Lorenzo River, realign the connection to Laurel Street Extension to the base of Beach Hill, just north of the Cliff Street stairs. This improvement can only be initiated after existing residents and support facilities have been relocated, consistent with City policies and State law.
  • Consider removing the surface parking and public roadway north of the realigned Laurel Street Extension, and thereby creating a more developable Block B.
  • Construct a new roundabout and associated pedestrian and bicycle improvements at the southern convergence of Pacific Avenue and Front Street.
  • As redevelopment proceeds, the City will further evaluate and discuss with the community the possibility of closing Spruce between Pacific and Front Street to auto traffic during special events.

    (page 14)

    SIGNIFICANT AND UNAVOIDABLE IMPACTS:

    CUL-1 (DPA EIR Impact 4.4-2): Historical Resources. Future development accommodated by the proposed plan amendments could result in impacts to historical resources (CUL-a) due to alteration or modification of historical buildings.

    Essentially….the buildings will be documented before the bulldozers arrive.

    Significant impacts that can be mitigated:

    AQ/GHG-3: Exposure of Sensitive Receptors. Future development and growth accommodated by the project would potentially expose sensitive receptors to substantial pollutant concentrations during short-term construction but not during long- term operations (AIR-c)

    BIO-3 (DPA EIR Impact 4.3-3): Indirect Impacts to Nesting Birds. Future development as a result of the project could result in disturbance to nesting birds if any are present in the vicinity of construction sites along the San Lorenzo River (BIO-d)

    MM CUL-3.1 Cultural Sensitivity Training and Tribal Monitoring Require Native American construction monitoring of future development projects within the project area to include cultural sensitivity training for construction workers and tribal monitoring during ground disturbing construction.

    2.3.3 Less-Than-Significant Impacts (page 25-26)
    The following impacts were found to be less-than-significant. Mitigation measures are not required.
    Page 2-6 | Summary
    Draft Subsequent EIR
    January 2025

    1. AES-1: Scenic Views
    2. AES-3: Visual Character of the Surrounding Area
    3. AES-4: Introduction of Light and Glare
    4. AQ/GHG-2: Criteria Pollutant Emissions
    5. AQ/GHG-3: Exposure of Sensitive Receptors
    6. AQ/GHG-4: Objectionable Odors
    7. BIO-1a (DPA EIR Impact 4.3-2): Impacts to Sensitive Riparian Habitat
    8. BIO-1b (DPA EIR Impact 4.3-1): Indirect Impacts to Special Status Species and Riparian and Aquatic Habitat
    9. BIO-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.3-2): Indirect Impacts to Birds
    10. BIO-3 (DPA EIR Impact 4.3-3): Indirect Impacts to Nesting Birds
    11. CUL-1 (DPA EIR Impact 4.4-2): Historical Resources
    12. CUL-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.4-1): Archaeological Resources
    13. CUL-3 (DPA Impact 4.4.-1): Tribal Cultural Resources
    14. HYDRO-1: Stormwater Drainage
    15. HYDRO-2: Water Quality
    16. HYDRO-3: Flood Hazards
    17. NOI-1: Permanent and Temporary Noise Increases
    18. NOI-2: Excessive Groundborne Vibration
    19. POP-1: Inducement of Substantial Population Growth
    20. POP-2: Displacement of People or Housing
    21. Pub-1a (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-1a): Fire Protection
    22. PUB-1b (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-1b): Police Protection
    23. PUB-1c (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-1c): Schools
    24. PUB-1d (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-1d): Parks
    25. PUB-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-2): Parks and Recreation
    26. T-1: Conflict with Circulation Plan, Policy, or Ordinance
    27. T-2: Conflict with VMT Thresholds
    28. T-3: Design-Safety and Emergency Access
    29. UTIL-1 (DPA EIR Impact 4.8-1): Water Supply
    30. UTIL-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.8-2): Wastewater Treatment
    31. UTL-3 (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-3): Solid Waste Generation
    32. UTL-4: Solid Waste Generation
    33. UTL-5 (DPA EIR Impact 4.6-4): Energy Use

    2.3.4 Impacts Not Found to be Significant
    The EIR found no impacts for the following:

    1. AES-1 (DPA EIR Impact 4.1-1): Scenic Views
    2. AES-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.1-2): Scenic Resources
    3. AQ/GHG-1 (DPA EIR No Impact): Conflict with the AQMP
    4. BIO-5: Conflicts with Local Ordinances
    5. LU-1: Physically Divide and Established Community
    6. LU-2 (DPA EIR Impact 4.9-1): Conflicts with Policies and Regulations

    (page 49)

    Development Bonus Options
    As described in Chapter 4 of the Downtown Plan (as amended), the Downtown Density Bonus
    consists of two options for taking a development bonus:

    Option A: A qualifying proposal would be allowed up to 75% additional FAR on top of the base
    FAR of 3.5, and up to an additional 75% in height not to exceed 145 feet if the project agrees to
    go through a discretionary process that includes review by an Architectural Review Committee
    for recommendations to support high quality design and materials as well as a Planning
    Commission Subcommittee to review materials at the Building Permit stage.

    Option B: A qualifying project would be allowed a waiver of the maximum FAR if the project
    conforms to the height limits set by the Downtown Plan (50, 70, 85 feet), and agrees to go
    through a discretionary process that includes review by an Architectural Review Committee for
    recommendations to support high quality design and materials as well as a Planning
    Commission Subcommittee to review materials at the Building Permit stage.

    (page 50):

    Qualification Options
    Development projects will be able to qualify for a Downtown Density Bonus in any of the following three ways:
    Downtown Plan Expansion City of Santa Cruz
    Page 3-16 | Project Description
    Draft Subsequent EIR
    January 2025

    1) On-Site: Provide BMR units in an integrated market rate and BMR development project that meet both of the following criteria:
    a) A minimum of 13.4% of the total units in the final project (density bonus plan) would be available to low-income households and
    b) An additional 8% of the total units in the final project (density bonus plan) would be available to moderate-income households making up to 110% of AMI. The number of BMR units would represent 21.4% of the total units in the project.
    2) Off-Site: Provide BMR units at an off-site project with a minimum number of bedrooms in BMR units equivalent to 26.7% of the total bedrooms in the Downtown Density Bonus proposal and targeting households with incomes up to 80% of AMI.
    a) The site with the BMR units must be located either:
    i) within a half mile of the South of Laurel project area, or
    ii) within the boundaries of the expanded Downtown Plan, or
    iii) within the Coastal Zone. (see Maps, attached).
    b) The off-site project must demonstrate the following:
    i) Land control and an ability to achieve the required number of bedrooms in BMR units, and submission of building permit applications prior to building permit issuance for the market rate project, and
    ii) That the project with the requisite BMR units begins construction before a certificate of occupancy is issued to the market-rate project. If that is not feasible, the applicant shall either identify units on site with the market rate project that can be used for BMR housing or post a bond in the amount of the in-lieu fee that would otherwise have been required to qualify for the Downtown Density Bonus.
    3) In-Lieu: Pay a fee toward the City’s affordable housing trust fund at a rate of $60 per square foot of housing units in the Downtown Density Bonus proposal.
    a) The City is required to spend all of these funds on development and preservation projects serving lower-income households and a minimum of 50% of these funds must be spent inside the Coastal Zone.

    Is it all about the ARENA? (page 51)
    Construction of a new approximately 180,000 sf. sports and entertainment arena with a capacity of approximately 3,200 fixed seats for basketball, and approximately 4,000 fixed and temporary seating for other entertainment events such as musical concerts. Ancillary uses include a secondary practice court, locker/team support facilities, food service/merchandising, and administrative support services. This would replace the existing 35,000 sf. temporary arena with 2,475 fixed seats and 3,100 fixed and temporary seating for other entertainment events. The number of annual events is estimated (by the Santa Cruz Warriors) to be:
    Number of Attendees Annual Events
    2,500+ 60 (30 Warriors, 30 concerts/entertainment)
    1,000-2,499 40 (20 Symphony, 20 concerts/entertainment)
    150-1,000 50 (35 UC Santa Cruz sporting events, 15 other)
    <150 Attendees 25

    Please make sure you send in your comments by Feb. 21, 5pm:
    Comments on the DEIR must be submitted in writing or via email to Sarah Neuse by 5pm Friday, February 21, 2025.Public Review Period: January 8, 2025 through February 21, 2025.

    Submit Comments to: Sarah Neuse, Senior Planner, via email: sneuse@santacruzca.gov 

    OR via US Mail:

    City of Santa Cruz

    Planning and Community Development Department
    Advance Planning Division
    809 Center Street, Rm 101
    Santa Cruz, CA  95060

    Santa Cruz Downtown Plan Expansion
    Draft Subsequent EIR

    APPLY NOW FOR ADVISORY OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE THAT WILL DECIDE HOW TO SPEND $7.5 MILLION MEASURE Q MONEY ANNUALLY
    On January 28, the County Board of Supervisors discussed at length how they might select the five appointees for the Measure Q Water, Wildfire and Wlldlife parcel tax money Advisory Committee.  After receiving a report by Deputy CAO Nicole Coburn, OR3 Director Dave Reid, and County Parks Director Jeff Gaffney, the Board decided to call for applications from the public to be submitted by March 11, with final selection by March 25.

    You can listen here (Item #10)

    I encourage you to apply!  Here is the application

    I think the best question anyone asked was by Jean Brocklebank, “Will these Advisory Committee meetings be open to the public?”  No one answered her excellent question. Ask your Supervisor and let me know if they answer.

    MAKE ONE CALL.   WRITE ONE LETTER.  SEND A LETTER IN SUPPORT OF AB 303 TO STATE LEGISLATORS.  ASK FOR A COUNTY URGENCY ORDINANCE AND MORATORIUM ON LITHIUM BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS (BESS).

    MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

    Cheers,
    Becky

    Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

    Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

  • ...
    Autocracy Continues to Build

    I have long labored in this column to outline the frustrating situation all biologists feel in this world as our interests are destroyed by increasingly autocratic tendencies of the government. And no, I have never been partisan about this situation. Both parties are to blame in creating the country we find ourselves in right now, facing a perilous future where generations will not only not be able to enjoy the standards of living we do today but will suffer to keep a standard of living with any comfort at all.

    I am not surprised, however, to find many people freaking out about a government bent on destroying social programs. After all, many voters have long been fed a thin gruel diet of small social program ‘wins,’ so that they will overlook that their future is being stolen by the 1% who are paying for both political parties, allowing them to extract wealth and power by destroying Life on Earth.

    Tinkering Around the Edges
    I was recently listening to the Bay Area’s own brilliant journalist Kara Swisher interviewing Rahm Emanuel, a person who seems like a reliable voice of mainstream Democratic politics. Ms. Swisher pressed Mr. Emanuel on what the Dems should do at this juncture, and his responses were along the lines of ‘messaging the voters’…’adopting a new platform or two’…etc. There was zero reflection about the way politics is using people to enrich the 1% while destroying the environment and no reflection on how to engage and involve citizens in their own governance.

    All Politics Is Local
    National government tactics are repeated here in California and all around the Monterey Bay. If you think that the current use of Executive Orders is unusual, check out the far-reaching litany of executive orders from California’s governor, who is proud to reduce environmental protections as part of these moves, none of which is primarily directed at environmental conservation.

    In Santa Cruz, I see politicians and government staff baselessly blaming and attacking people who are trying to protect the environment, including other columnists who write for Bratton Online. These local politicians and staff have long supported the roughshod environmental analysis of many projects before them as long as the project serves some social good and/or is economically attractive. For instance, many pointed out the inadequacy of the Regional Transportation Commission’s analysis on the estimated numbers of tourists attracted by the new North Coast Rail Trail, but politicians didn’t care enough to direct better work. I have witnessed this same political hunger for other projects that badly impact the environment at Arana Gulch (recreational development), Pogonip (recreation and agricultural developments), Glenwood (housing and school development), Santa’s Village (housing development), Seascape (housing development), Wilder Ranch (recreational development), UCSC (housing development), Terrace Point (educational buildings), Nisene Marks (recreational development), Cotoni Coast Dairies (tourism development), and Neary Lagoon (transportation development).

    Up Close and Personal
    I have had occasion to be privy to the autocratic decision making that creates the results where the environment, and conservationists, end up losing and here’s how it goes. First, someone who wants to develop and negatively impact nature works with an expert at navigating the review process so that they get just what they want. Second, once they have a plan for meeting regulatory demands (aka “jumping through the hoops”), they meet with one or two of the politicians whose vote they’ll need. Then, they make a deal of some sort to guarantee the votes. Then, the person proposing negatively impacting the environment meets with the bureaucrats who also get calls from the politician, and then they, too, make a deal. Finally, after everyone’s approval to the plans and approach, the project proponent goes through the motions of a public process, taking and ignoring input and moving forward with what they wanted to do in the first place. When pressed about why not do a more authentic public process, anyone that was part of those deals will tell you, “why bother?”…”it just makes more trouble”…”we know best and came up with the best solution.”

    Do those trends sound familiar at a national level right now? We have far more potential to affect political change closer to home than further away.

    Why Aren’t the Dems Fighting?
    Some people who are concerned about the Administration’s actions nowadays ask ‘why aren’t the Democrats fighting?’ The answer is that everyone in power is in awe of what they, too, might get away with one day. Plus, some of what is being highlighted as shocking power grabbing is the same stuff that all politicians have been doing for some time now, but perhaps less bombastically.

    During the first round of this administration, there was a surprising assertion that we were suddenly going to war with Iran, a country with about the same number of military as the USA. NPR picked one of their preferred retired generals to interview about the wisdom of this decision and that general said that he could not condone the action because ‘Americans have not been prepared for this war.’ That is, the military demands that politicians prepare citizens for war, presumably so that the funding will keep flowing to support the war effort once it is started.

    I believe it has become equally normalized that it is the politicians’ job, in working for their biggest donors, to keep citizens constantly prepared for environmental degradation. And, it is my experience that the staff people of governmental agencies look at legally mandated disclosure and environmental review interactions with citizens as a burden and a waste with no chance of improving the agency’s work and better protecting the environment.

    Is It Any Surprise?
    Given what I’ve just outlined, I am not surprised by what I’m witnessing at a national level. As a nation, we have prepared ourselves well for this situation to work out excellently for the 1%. I am not happy that many more people get to experience the exasperation that conservationists have been feeling for decades, but so it goes. Perhaps this is the best chance we have had to start working together.

    How can we organize an alternative in local politics where the people are prepared for a Monterey Bay that is protected by its citizens for the next 1,000 years? The answer lies with more permanence of residency, sustainable and vibrant economies, and removal of any environmental impacts of growth, but those things are at odds with our current societal structure. And yet, these things (and more) are sorely needed. If we can make it work here, the goodness will spread. It starts with developing leadership and engaging many more people. You’re right there with us, right now.

    Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

    Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

    ...

    Monday, February 24, 2025

    In my blog posting last Saturday, I warned us all not to stipulate to having “lost” our system of democratic self-government, just because we have a president who is clearly trying to convince us all that our system of self-government is already “gone.”

    Citing to Joni Mitchell’s great song, “Big Yellow Taxi,”I pointed out that if we want to avoid the loss of our system of self-government, it is vital that we don’t stipulate to claims that we have already lost it. It is vital that we continue to act upon the premise that “we, the people,” are actually in charge of what the government does, and what the government is entitled to do. If we lose our faith that this is true, we are stipulating to claims that we should not accept – and that we don’t have to accept.

    That this kind of “Scaredy Cat” compliance is a real danger can be found in an article printed in The New York Times on Monday, February 17th, “Venting at Democrats and Fearing Trump, Liberal Donors Pull Back Cash,” The Times reported as follows (emphasis added):

    While Mr. Trump has not taken action against any liberal groups or lawmakers, Democrats worry his frequent threats of retribution during the campaign have led to a chilling effect on the charitable foundations and nonprofit advocacy groups that have long been pillars of the country’s civil society.

    Jeff Skoll, a Silicon Valley billionaire and a longtime friend of Elon Musk’s, said there was “an awful lot of pressure” to side with Mr. Trump.

    This month, Mr. Skoll, who has donated tens of millions to Democratic candidates and causes in recent years but said he did not vote in the 2024 presidential election, posted a photo on social media of himself standing with Mr. Trump backstage at the inauguration. On Friday, he had breakfast in Palm Beach, Fla., with Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, the minority leader, where they discussed the prospect of Mr. Schumer’s using Mr. Skoll to back-channel ideas to the president….

    In an interview, Mr. Skoll acknowledged his unique position, saying he had heard from many others who were frightened to fund opposition to the administration.

    “There are people who were absolutely against Trump, never Trumpers, who fear that they’ll be retaliated against and they’ll have to leave the country,” Mr. Skoll said. “Folks who wish to oppose him — it may take some time before they gather up the courage.

    When the billionaires start being afraid, that’s a sign of real trouble. Let’s not get infected ourselves!

    Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

    Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

    ...

    A BRIONI TUTU, GOLDEN AGED EGGS, 400 YEARS, ANOTHER DIRTY WORD

    It appears that Donald and Elon, along with the Project 2025 mob, have resurrected ‘The New Pledge’ which ran in Matt Groening’s Life in Hell comic strip back on December 16, 1994. The pledge reads: “I pledge allegiance to and wrap myself in the flag of the United States Against Anything Un-American, and to the Republicans for which it stands, two nations, under Jesus, rich against poor with curtailed liberty and justice for all, except for Blacks, homosexuals, women who want abortions, Communists, welfare queens, tree huggers, feminazis, illegal immigrants, children of illegal immigrants, and you if you don’t watch your step.” Our current government makeup didn’t miss a beat in the intervening thirty years, and we can bet with assurance that they have a New Constitution waiting in the wings.

    Gregory E. Sterling, dean of the Yale Divinity School, in an article on the MSNBC website says that the US Agency for International Development being cast into the “wood chipper” by Musk is a sign that a core Christian value of caring for others “is under threat.” Distressing to Sterling is the alarming and tacit support of many, including Trump’s evangelical horde, who proclaim the Gospels as their guide, and by doing so “have sold their souls in a Faustian deal for political power.” Cited is an NBC News exit poll in the presidential election with the upshot that 63% of voters in the “Protestant or other Christians” demographic supported the new administration — and if restricted to Whites, the number climbs to 72%. In the Catholic fold, 59% supported Trump, with 63% of White Catholics voting for the convicted felon. But — yikes! — 82% of White evangelicals went for King Donald. The Dean is concerned that many will associate Christianity with the worrisome programs of the MAGA administration, and that the “younger generation will either come to dismiss Christianity as amoral or identify with it for its relationship to political power rather than its moral and spiritual principles” — neither of which he finds acceptable.

    A colleague of Sterling’sPhil Gorski, author of ‘The Flag and the Cross,’ an exploration of the rise of Christian nationalism, seconds the concern about Christianity becoming a “dirty word,” and, an acquaintance who is senior pastor of a large Manhattan church now describes himself as a “follower of Jesus Christ,” abandoning his descriptor as ‘Christian.’ Sterling closes his piece by saying that the “closure of USAID and the pulling of funds from other agencies and groups that care for the ‘hungry…thirsty…stranger…naked…ill…imprisoned’ is anti-Christian at its core. It reflects a rejection of a basic value that Jews and Christians hold sacred. Christians may disagree about a number of important issues, but the imperative to care for the downtrodden is not one of them.” A recent caller from Georgia on C-SPAN with right-wing pundit Armstrong Williams recalled his family’s vacations in the Great Smoky Mountains, when they would feed bears at the side of the road — until it was declared illegal. He claims that once this largesse was terminated the bears starved to death because they didn’t know how to fend for themselves, referring to the old proverb about teaching a man how to fish. Host Williams called his story well taken, saying, “The best Department of Health, Education and Welfare I had growing up was my mother and my father.” Right! Empathy is for losers! Ignore those roadside cadgers!

    During Trump’s 2016 campaign he sought the backing of the religious right, granting them unprecedented access to empower their agenda during his first term; therefore, they poured millions in contributions toward his 2024 campaign to reseat themselves in the White House to continue their oppressive agenda to strip away rights and freedoms, and to make it safe to “once again” to say, “Merry CHRISTmas!” The level of influence held by the religious right turned the Executive branch into a virtual policy-making arm of their movement in Trump’s first term, and with their continuing domination we see the appointment of lifetime federal judges from religious-right legal groups who will further dismantle church-state separation and undermine our freedoms. With Trump’s favoritism toward these groups, their appetites for even more power and control has brought an uptick in overt and aggressive Christian nationalism, a threat not only to freedom and core democratic values, but non-acceptance of religious pluralism. This movement is also more likely to support authoritarianism and political violence, while nurturing racial resentment and hostility toward immigrants in their so-called “biblical worldview.” Their belief that Trump has been anointed by God to lead the country once again was recently mirrored by Speaker of the House Mike Johnson — genuflect, genuflect, genuflect!

    Raymond De Vries who calls himself “a sad observer of political decline” posts on Quora in response to a questioner who asked, “How can you call yourself Christian and not support our most Christian president yet, Donald J. Trump?” His answer: “You seem to think a Christian is someone who says the homeless ‘will be arrested, but they will be given the option to accept treatment and services if they’re willing to be rehabilitated.’ And, it’s just fine for Christians to praise war-waging invaders as ‘genius’ and ‘savvy’ and refer to the displaced and dead in the invaded country as ‘independent.’ Or skipping community services to play golf, and call military service members who gave their lives for their country, ‘suckers’ and ‘losers.’ And since when is it Christian for someone claiming to be a multi-billionaire to beg for the charity of wool-pulled-over-their-eyes sheeple who donate millions of dollars (or buy overpriced Bibles and other tchotchkes) to cover his legal defense costs against charges of rape, financial fraud and insurrection? And asking, ‘Why do I have to repent, to ask forgiveness if I’m not making mistakes?’ But methinks anyone who thinks Donald Trump is a Christian has been possessed by the devil….”

    But we know that Trump likes the title, employing the tactics of a mob boss, as demonstrated in many of his proclamations and threats, one of the latest being against Ukraine president Zelensky after he criticized The Don for siding with Russia in the ongoing war. Ukraine has been particularly critical of the supposed ‘peace talks’ between only Russia and the US — no Ukrainians allowed, please. Trump calls Zelensky a “modestly successful comedian” who conned the US out of $350 billion to fight a “war that couldn’t be won, that never had to start, but a war that he, without the US and TRUMP, will never be able to settle.” He also whined that the US spent $200 billion more than European nations contributed as a guaranteed loan, while the US will get nothing back. In a peacetime scenario, Zelensky would have termed-out of office, and despite Trump’s calls for wartime elections due to a “4% approval rating,” the Ukrainians show support at around 60% with no calls for an election, though Zelensky has offered to step down “in the interest of peace if necessary.” Trump called the Ukrainian president a dictator who is responsible for starting the war — words straight from the Putin playbook. British satirical magazine, Private Eye, ran its latest cover with a poke at the Trump/Zelensky standoff. A photo of Trump and Zelensky walking side by side has word balloons added with Trump asking, “Guess what the deal is?” Zelensky replies, “I give in.” “Correct,” Trump agrees. Even the Rupert Murdoch Wall Street Journal’s editorial board called Trump’s criticism of Zelensky an “assault,” warning that his “seeming desperation for a peace deal could come at the expense of his own presidency.” The board wrote: “The only dictator in the war is Mr. Putin, who poisons exiled Russians on foreign soil and banishes opponents to Arctic prison camps.” And a punch to Trump’s gut: “Call us when he holds a free election.” Further, Trump’s attempt to turn the Ukrainians against Zelensky is likely to have the opposite effect, and they agreed with Zelenksy’s “retort to Trump which suggests he’s living in a ‘disinformation bubble.'” WSJ board sums it up with: “Ultimately, any deal that results in Ukraine’s surrender will be a blow to American power — the opposite of Mr. Trump’s promise to restore a golden age of US prestige and world calm.”

    A couple of weeks back The Don was facing criticism and mockery on social platforms for calling the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts a “woke” venue, though he admitted he has never attended any events — only that he “got reports” and that “people said the shows were terrible, a disgrace.” Consequently, he announced some new board appointees after “reports” of drag performances, and expressing his desire to become board chair “to make sure it runs properly. We don’t need ‘woke’ at the center.” Social media sprung into action, calling his comments “MAGA movement in a nutshell.” GenXGuy posted, “He heard it from many people the shows were terrible…big strong men…with tears in their eyes…’sir, these shows are terrible. Only you can save the Kennedy Center.'” True to form, satirist Andy Borowitz of The Borowitz Report posted: “Donald J. Trump tightened his grip on the American arts scene on Monday by naming himself principal ballerina of the Kennedy Center Ballet. Announcing a purge of the company’s ballerinas, Trump declared on Truth Social, ‘I will soon be announcing a new roster of ballerinas, with an amazing ballerina, DONALD J. TRUMP.’ He said he was ‘disgusted’ to discover that all of the company’s current ballerinas were women, a state of affairs that he blamed on DEI. Trump’s takeover of the Kennedy Center has surprised millions of Americans, who previously thought that the worst thing that could happen to the Kennedy brand was JFK’s nephew strapping a dismembered whale’s head to his minivan.”

    Of Trump’s intrusion into the arts, The Daily Beast website said, “Revenge, as the saying goes, is a dish best served cold and in Washington time always a moveable feast…When Donald Trump seized control of the performing arts venue, unseating David Rubinstein as chairman, it quickly became clear among the Democrat board members (and some Republicans) there was little they could do to prevent it. And so they will do what the true establishment does; they will bide their time…DC’s permanent elite believe Trump’s sudden, random interest in the center had little to do with content, and more to do with his own, more obvious, payback. The insiders didn’t accept him last time around and they won’t this, and it prickles under his skin like a rash that won’t go away. His own redress is to try to take away their toys. ‘He has kicked over a beehive,’ said one knowing person, ‘but he won’t know until it stings him in the ass.’ They will forgive the intrusion for now…but they won’t forget…even if the Kennedy Center morphs into the Trump Center overnight. ‘This isn’t the Deep State,’ said one insider. ‘This is Deep Society.’ However, if Trump thinks his coup is bloodless, at least for now, then he’d better look closer to home. Melania had apparently told friends she wanted to become more involved in the Kennedy Center and was already on the board as an honorary trustee along with other former first ladies Jill Biden, Michelle Obama, Laura Bush, and Hillary Clinton. Now her husband has stolen her thunder once again. She’d probably get a warmer welcome at the Women’s National Democratic Club.” Strike up the US Marine Corps band! Or how about Trump’s J6 Prison Choir? Never grow tired of those guys, do we?

    Steve Schmidt couldn’t refrain from heralding the new Chairman Trump“Donald Trump, chairman of the Kennedy Center, is a man with no taste and less integrity, who buried his first wife on a New Jersey golf course. Easily distracted and perpetually bored, Donald Trump has given away the powers of his presidency to Elon Musk, while using the prerogatives of his high office to launch meme coins and install himself as chairman of the Kennedy Center. Donald Trump may soon demand that his slow shuffle and jerky spasms to the songs of ‘The Village People’ tunes be called ballet. When this happens 49% of the country will wear leotards on their heads, and cheer for the most beautiful ballerina in the land — the one dressed like a schlub in an oversized Brioni suit, with a too-long tie made in China. It is in this moment that Trump will do for the arts what Tulsi Gabbard is going to do to the intelligence agencies, RFK is going to do to the public health agencies, Kash Patel is going to do to the FBI, and Pete Hegseth is going to do to the military.”

    We all remember how Elon Musk flew to Germany to campaign for the ultra-right wing AfD party in the lead up to their national elections, and how he then flew back to DC to stand beside the Resolute desk and lord it over a seated Trump, with Elon’s son, X, wiping his boogers on the desk and telling Trump his time in the chair was about to end? Well, it happened again — this time in an interview with Fox News’ Sean Hannity. According to Leigh Kimmins on The Daily Beast, Trump looked like he was hung out to dry by Musk and Hannity, as they ignored the president, or interrupted him in this high-profile sit-down take-down. Hannity’s softball questions in the Roosevelt Room in the White House briefly became a love-in, but further in it became apparent that the president was being shunted aside, with Musk portraying himself as a hero to save America in his indiscriminate machete-wielding attack on government departments. Trump attempted to chime in about Europe “taking advantage of us,” but bosom-buddy Musk shot him a look in order to keep up his own diatribe. Trump again tried to compliment Musk on his achievements, but was interrupted by Hannity who looked at Musk to ask if he was “trying to be president, as the media suggests.” Another Trump attempt to join in was interrupted by Hannity who wanted to talk to Musk about sending ships to Mars. Their chat rambled on, with Trump blasting left-leaning outlets, and feeding tired, classic lines to his voter base…gotta keep ’em happy, you know! After viewing the interview, Tom Nichols of The Atlantic wrote: “Like many Americans lately, I am seized with curiosity about who is actually running the government of the United States. But I am still not sure who’s in charge.” The official answer from the White House says Trump’s in charge, and that Musk isn’t even in charge of DOGE, or involved in the agency at all — only a “senior adviser to the president with no actual or formal authority to make government decisions himself.” Time to disarm Musk of his machete? Let’s ask Hannity!

    Text for a much-needed bumper sticker: MUSK — THE MAN WHO SAVED CANCER! A bill that was up for a 2024 renewal of funding for the Gabriella Miller Kids First Pediatric Research Program was trimmed of this $190 million amount last year because Elon didn’t like the bipartisan effort under President Obama that established the program. The original bill, as presented by Republicans, included the renewal but Musk and former Republican Leader Eric Cantor drove forces that led to its being cut. Musk showed his cruelty by posting on X, photos of the two versions side by side, captioned “Yesterday’s bill vs today’s bill,” accompanied by a laughing emoji. Ultimately, the House rejected the new bill 174-235, with nearly 30 Republicans joining Democrats in voting against it. House Republican Leader Steve Scalise said the same bill will not be brought forward for a vote. Not discouraged by this failure, Musk and his DOGEs have hobbled a federal government facility that does critical research into Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s. According to Greg Sargent of The New Republic, the “Trump-Musk cuts” have resulted in the firing of numerous top researchers at the National Institute of Health“a prediction of big setbacks to fighting dementias.” “The Trump-Musk rationales for deep cuts to spending on medical research are an insultingly ridiculous farce,” Sargent alleges. “Republicans once lavished praise on this research. Trump and Musk are hobbling it. What will those Republicans say now?” Any suggestions, Hannity? How about we start a GoFundMe to buy Musk a seat on his first rocket to Mars — the first Earthling to set foot on the Red Planet — irresistible!

    Stephen MillerTrump’s White House Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy, got some acerbic replies to his post on X directed at his one million followers, when he asked, “Are you enjoying America’s new Golden Age?” The critics seem to think Trump’s term number two is, so far, a case of all glitter and no real gold. Hunter Petro suggests, “Call it the ‘Golden Age’ because it takes a bag of gold bars to afford a dozen eggs,” and Ron Smith offers, “NO, President Musk is a terrible president.” Gojo18 posts a question, “Are we living in the same country?” Eleazar’s Virgins claims, “Yeah, now that USAID has been shuttered, pronouns banned, racists applauded, and water has been poured out of California’s reservoirs, my life is so much better.” Nicadispatch feels as many of us do by requesting, “Let me know when it starts.” Miller, whose title conceals the massive influence he actually commands with Trump and throughout the administration, is helping to drive a maximalist immigration enforcement agenda from which he obviously derives immense sadistic satisfaction. He spearheaded efforts to enact sweeping changes in presidential authority for the dismantling of the federal bureaucracy and to reduce or eliminate entire departments. Miller has worked on his plan for years — prior to his first gig with Trump’s first term — and has now had four years between terms to perfect his plan. He unapologetically pushes traditional boundaries to test the waters, and he avoids the limelight to avoid outshining the boss. In the effort to overwhelm the administration’s opponents, Miller worked to have in place for signatures, on Day One, the dozens of executive orders of which Trump made a spectacle as he signed. “Hello to the Golden Age of America and welcome back Donald J. Trump,” Miller said as he addressed the crowd at Capitol One Arena in DC on inauguration day. “It’s been four long years. It’s felt like 400 years.”  On the other hand, it’s been four long weeks and it seems like 400!

    Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
     

    ...

    EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

    EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    March

    “As I lay so sick on my bed, from Christmas till March, I was always praying for poor ole master. ‘Pears like I didn’t do nothing but pray for ole master. ‘Oh, Lord, convert ole master;’ ‘Oh, dear Lord, change dat man’s heart, and make him a Christian.'”
    ~Harriet Tubman

    “It was one of those March days when the sun shines hot and the wind blows cold: when it is summer in the light, and winter in the shade.”
    ~Charles Dickens

    “March is a month without mercy for rabid basketball fans. There is no such thing as a ‘gentleman gambler’ when the Big Dance rolls around. All sheep will be fleeced, all fools will be punished severely… There are no Rules when the deal goes down in the final weeks of March. Even your good friends will turn into monsters.”
    ~Hunter S. Thompson

    “I am never at my best in the early morning, especially a cold morning in the Yorkshire spring with a piercing March wind sweeping down from the fells, finding its way inside my clothing, nipping at my nose and ears.”
    ~James Herriot

    “The last time when I handed over information was in February or March 1949.”
    ~Klaus Fuchs

    ...

    These kinds of things are why I love YouTube. I’m going all in on this lady’s quest to make 100 tiny paintings from February 23, 2025 to February 23, 2026. I’m so excited to make more art – for way too long I have been proving the theory that buying art supplies is a hobby in and of itself… Let me know if you will be joining the quest! Happy arting!


    COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

    Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
    (Gunilla Leavitt)

    ...

    Deep Cover

    Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

    February 19 – 25, 2025

    Highlights this week:

    Greensite… back soon … Steinbruner… out this week … Hayes… Trails through the woods …Patton… Arrogance and ineptitude … Matlock… L’etat c’est moi…brick-by-brick…stupidity and crankery… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… birdsong for sanity … Quotes on… “Camping”

    ...

    MORE ECONOMICALLY SUSTAINABLE LOCAL LOGGING. Again back in the 1890’s these loggers probably used the same justifications for their clear-cutting as our local foresters do today. What would Santa Cruz County look like IF someone prevented this “selective forestry”?

    photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

    Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

    Dateline: February 19, 2025

    BACK FROM THE DESERT. I sure do love a roadtrip! We have a travel trailer, and a couple of times a year we take it on the road. We got it for the Non-Burning Man during the pandemic, and have taken it to Western Winter Blast in Lake Havasu, AZ, I think 3 times now. Sometimes I think about how cool it would be to live a nomadic lifestyle, just taking off when the mood strikes, but then I remember how much I love where I live and think better of it. A couple of times a year though! 🙂

    ...

    HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

    THE ÅRE MURDERS. Netflix. Series (6.7 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

    THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

    NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

    ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

    FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

    STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

    NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

    SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

    EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

    A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

    ...

    Gillian is taking a break, but she’ll be back!

    Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

    ...

    No piece from Becky this week, but she maintains:

    WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  REVIEW ONE SECTION OF THE DOWNTOWN EXPANSION PLAN AND MAKE A COMMENT.
    MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

    Cheers,
    Becky

    Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

    Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

    ...
    Trails Through the Woods

    What could possibly be wrong with trails through the woods? Ad hoc, unsanctioned, illegal, illicit, unapproved…choose your adjective to precede the ‘trails through the woods’ phrase and then ask ‘what could possibly be wrong with unsanctioned trails through the woods?’ While we’re at it, let’s ask the question, ‘what type of person would build and maintain unsanctioned trails through the woods?’ Let’s hypothesize for a moment.

    Law Abiding Citizen
    There’s a lot going on in our nation with people’s attitudes about abiding by laws. Some people are as apt to decry a convicted felon in the White House as they are to cite the horrors of the justice system, saying it is utterly failing most of the poor souls who face the courts. How does that work, logically? I’m not sure it does. But, are we saying at the same time that we should question the laws, as well? Has ‘law abiding citizen’ become an anachronism or just plain laughable? Or, maybe our culture has become accepting of individual interpretation of laws, but not in all cases. For instance, who in their right minds would support widespread law breaking with hit and run drivers, armed robbery, or homicide? But, say how about the lesser offences of shoplifting, forgery, assault, or libel? Are we getting to your more acceptable level of crimes, yet? How about….driving 20 mph over the speed limit, selling alcohol to minors, extortion, or petty theft? And then, somewhere down the line you encounter the laws against damaging public property, trespass, entering closed areas of public land, visiting public parks when they are closed, and violating federal and state clean water laws or endangered species regulations. How are we feeling about the types of citizens who break those laws? Are we giving them a pass? Someone is. A lot of people are. Hundreds and hundreds of people in our community have decided that the criminals committing that last litany of crimes are ‘okay people’ undeserving of one iota of investigation that might result in at most a warning, and almost never prosecution.

    Anarchists I know would scoff at the legal argument here. Many who know how broken the justice system is would also shrug off the legal arguments, as well, understanding that without justice there can be no reasonable pursuit of legal matters. So, perhaps we must turn to ethics to examine the truer nature of those who would participate in unsanctioned trail building and maintenance.

    A Matter of Ethics
    Should we consider the consequences of illegal trail building? Or, is it enough to ask if rogue trail building is good? Is building an unsanctioned trail in and of itself causing harm to other people? Is maintaining a rogue trail respectful of all people? These are the types of questions one must ask in seeking answers outside of legal context. As I have posed these questions over the years, the most common answer is “I don’t know.” So, we must ask another question of morality: is it unethical for an illicit trail builder to create new trails if they are ignorant of the consequences or context of their actions?

    Consequences, Respect
    The consequences of constructing and/or maintaining rogue trails are well known, or at least readily available. The most glaring impact of rogue trails is on wildlife. Conservation lands managers have a difficult time providing for some trail access while also conserving wildlife: the two goals are mutually exclusive. Park users disturb wildlife, so one must plan around that to have healthy wildlife populations. Trails constructed outside of that planning process scuttle attempts at nature conservation.

    And so, rogue trail builders either have contempt for parks managers’ planning processes or do not care about wildlife or both.

    The same sets of arguments also apply to conservation of flora, fungi, soil, and clean water.

    And again, it would stand to reason that those who construct illegal trails have contempt for park oversight personnel’s work/expertise and also do not care about conserving native plants or mushrooms and don’t care if soil erodes, that we have clean running streams, or that natural areas provide for drinking water.

    Let’s extend these logical frameworks to the element of respect. Morals often refer to respecting others: their lives, their pursuits, safety, happiness, etc. All groups with which I have interacted in the past few decades readily recognize that humans need all species to continue existing for our own survival. And so, those who create and maintain unsanctioned trails score quite low on the ‘respect others’ morality scale with that first test. The majority of USA citizens support wildlife conservation; second test strikes against those who would build trails without the careful planning that parks managers use to weigh the pros and cons of new trails. We could go on…

    In Sum
    In kind words, how would you summarize the findings above to describe those people who make it a habit to create, or maintain, unsanctioned trails? Excluding nihilism, one would need to start with the term ‘criminal,’ but that would not be enough. The word ‘selfish’ sounds unkind, eh? And, even so, just ‘criminal, selfish…’ lacks something.

    Most of the social circles with which I have discourse include short hand lines of reference to describe types of people who love fun just a little too much. You know, when fun overrides respect for others? The term ‘fun-loving’ falls short of describing the types of people referenced in these conversations; the people being referenced generally have problems, which is why they are being discussed. Such conversations generally end in head shaking…no great solutions…sighs and ‘I hope they figure it out….’ or ‘maybe so-and-so (someone possibly close to them) can have a chat with them.’ I think we are getting closer to understanding the types of people we are dealing with.

    Next time you take a walk in nature, watch for the many trails veering from the signed, sanctioned one you are hiking. Ask yourself how much traffic that trail must get to be so well rutted and then think about how far that trail must travel, how much work it takes to chainsaw (at night) those trails open after trees fall. What a massive effort by _______ types of people (fill in the blank)! Think about the conversations they must have with one another and their networks… and how that is influencing the goodness of our community.

    Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

    Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

    ...

    Wednesday, February 19, 2025

    #50 / Arrogance And Ineptitude

    An article in The New Yorker analogizes the Musk “takeover” of various agencies of the federal government to the “shambolic American takeover of the Iraqi government,” in 2003.

    I don’t know much about those events in Iraq, to tell you the truth, and The New Yorker article, “Elon Musk’s Revolutionary Terror,” was revealing. Hopefully, the magazine won’t have deployed a paywall that will prevent interested persons from reading the full story. In case there is a paywall, though, here is the first paragraph. This will certainly give you the basic idea:

    Nearly twenty years ago, the Washington Post’s Rajiv Chandrasekaran wrote a classic account of the shambolic American takeover of the Iraqi government, “Imperial Life in the Emerald City.” Most memorably, he described what a Times reviewer called “the lethal combination of official arrogance and ineptitude” that plagued the foreign occupiers from Washington who, after the 2003 U.S. invasion, moved into the Green Zone—the walled-off compound that had once belonged to Saddam Hussein. Young conservatives were favored, heedless of experience. Some job seekers were asked their views of Roe v. Wade. Others were hired after sending their résumés to the right-wing Heritage Foundation back in D.C. While Baghdad spiralled into out-of-control violence, the G.O.P. ideologues who reported for duty in the desert worked to privatize Iraqi government agencies, revamp the tax code, and launch an anti-smoking campaign. A clueless twenty-four-year-old found himself in charge of opening an Iraqi stock exchange. It didn’t work out well.

    In the United States, WE – ordinary people – have been legally placed in charge of the government. This is not only “theoretically” true. That is absolutely what both our Constitution and the laws provide. This means that if we exercise our democratic powers of self-government we can dislodge the arrogant and inept Elon Musk, and strip him away from his pretentious idea that he is, somehow, entitled to run the world, just because he seems to be, at the moment, the world’s richest person.

    “Arrogant and inept” is a pretty good way to sum Musk up. Let’s not be afraid to comment on “Emperor” Musk’s clothing choices, either, as depicted below, in a cartoon that was published in the Daily KOS.

    Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

    Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

    ...
    LUNCH MENU, A HAPPY KREMLIN, SHUSHING X, SAY SOMETHING!

    In an essay in the Ohio Capital JournalDavid DeWitt writes that in January 2020, he wrote about how politics of stupidity and crankery in America was degrading us as a society and as human beings. He concludes his latest piece with, “America’s love affair with swaggering ignorance and confident stupidity continues to reach awful new heights. The bill will come due. The piper will need to be paid. The damage will be extensive.” As if to second DeWitt’s statement, Donald Trump on Saturday made his own statement that stunned observers, in posting on social media, “He who saves his Country does not violate any law.” MSNBC’s Chris Hayes attributes this loosely to both France’s King Louis XIV, and Navarre, saying, “L’etat c’est moi,” translation being “I myself am the nation.” Columnist Jamelle Bouie of The New York Times called it “the single most un-American and anti-Constitutional statement ever uttered by an American president.” Conservative anti-Trumper Bill Kristol said, “We’re getting into real Führerprinzip territory here.” Tech reporter Matt Novak offered, “Dude is quoting Napoleon now. When do we get to the exile portion of the Napoleon timeline?” In a darker vein, writer and actor Bill Corbett adds, “Trump making an excellent argument for his own assassination — good one, dummy!”

    In a podcast interview prior to the election, Trump’s FBI deputy director, Andrew McCabe who was fired in 2018, was asked if he thought Trump is a Russian asset, to which he answered, “I do, I do. I don’t know if I would characterize it as an active, recruited, knowing asset in the way people in the intelligence community think of that term…he has given us many reasons to question his approach to the Russia problem, and I think his approach to interacting with Putin, be it phone calls, face-to-face meetings, the things he has said in public about Putin, all raise significant questions.” McCabe also questioned Trump’s approach to his supporting Ukraine and NATO in the face of Russia’s aggression, and certainly in light of his claim that Russia would have avoided aggressive action into its neighboring country had he been president. Trump still maintains that all he wants is “peace — and Ukraine’s rare metals deposits — negotiate, and get this over with!” We have to remember Kamala Harris ridiculing Trump during their presidential debate that his so-called friendship with a known dictator would only result with his being eaten for lunch. McCabe ended his interview, declaring that Russia’s “interest is just simply sowing chaos and division and polarization. If they can do that, it’s a win. If they can actually hurt a candidate they don’t like, or help one that they do like, that’s an even bigger win.” Score one for the dictator(s)!

    The Daily Beast columnist, Julia Davis, who monitors Russian media, has reported that there is glee in the Kremlin regarding Trump’s cabinet choices, an ominous sign for the USAVladimir Solovyov, on his show ‘Sunday,’ said, “What an excellent team is coming along with Trump! Not with respect to Ukraine, but as far as everything else goes. If they are allowed to get in, they will quickly dismantle America, brick by brick. They are so great.” TV host Olga Skabeeva enthusiastically pronounced the cabinet picks, “…totally wonderful!” And her husband, Evgeny Popov who is host of Russia’s ‘60 Minutes,’ agreed, calling Trump’s selections his “…radical dream team. All of them personally despise Zelensky,” and on a cautionary note adds, “They aren’t friends of Russia, except for Tulsi Gabbard.” How does that phrase go — ‘Forewarned is fore…‘ — never mind! Russia’s predictions are already being borne out by the actions of those put in place by the GOP-dominated Senate, hellbent on undermining the very agencies they ‘lead,’ brick-by-brick, stone-by-stone. Ja’han Jones of MSNBC says, “Trump is constructing a kakistocracy — a government filled with incompetent or otherwise unsuitable characters. And based on Russian state TV, the Kremlin couldn’t be happier.”

    Julia writes that Moscow was initially unsettled by Trump’s stern proclamations regarding the Russia/Ukraine impasse, but his latest actions have transformed into pure joy as he self-destructs America’s standing as a global superpower. The new-old president is also well into his plan to undermine international relationships with our long-standing allies, exceeding Russian expectations. Propagandist Vladimir Solovyov gloated over these developments, saying, “It’s awesome, right? The Canadians and the Mexicans thought all was well, but Trump told them ‘By the way, I don’t like you either.'” This statement provoked jolly laughter from the other pundits in the studio. Putin called President Zelensky’s tenure “illegitimate,” prompting US envoy Keith Kellogg to suggest Ukraine hold a presidential election since “…most democratic nations have elections in their time of war. I think it is important to do so.” Solovyov takes this as a US adoption of the Russian view, and Dean Henry Sardaryan of the Moscow State Institute of International Relations agrees that serious efforts behind the scenes have led to a seismic shift in the American approach. Sardaryan has interpreted words of Secretary of State Rubio to mean the US is abdicating its global leadership position in favor of multipolarity, with Tucker Carlson being “unleashed” to publicly “demolish Zelensky” in order to sway citizens to accept Trump’s future decisions toward Ukraine. Moscow is looking forward to stepping into the void left by the demise of USAID, by creating a tool to exercise influence over other countries, much like China has been doing for years.

    By Trump’s outright rejection of bipartisanship in his first term, political scientist Dmitry Evstafiev had predicted the disintegration of existing political institutions in the USA, to be replaced by an authoritarian system — now, to the delight of Russian experts, Trump isn’t letting them down. Andrey Sidorov notes that the US is rapidly moving into a dictatorship, with Americans unable to reverse this trajectory by the usual democratic means. Current Russian prediction for the US: “everything is excellent.” Co-president Elon Musk has co-president Trump’s blessing to dismantle the government and to gut popular programs — a decision that will likely come back to haunt him says the Washington Post’s Philip Bump. Bump suggests Musk is taking his cues from X, where he has cast himself as the main character in a rightwing bubble, and he is being disingenuous or ignorant if he believes his unscientific polls on the platform represent the desires of Americans — not just his echo chamber. According to Bump, Musk seems to believe Americans want less out of government, rather than better — a fatal misreading. “While a significant portion of those who did vote approved of the idea that Trump would overhaul the government, many were voting for other reasons. There’s a reason the bureaucracy exists at the scale it does, which is that constituencies and advocates have convinced representatives that those programs are worth funding. As Musk himself pointed out, when funding stops, complaints start. We can expect a staggering number of complaints over the coming months.” And it has already started — several Red States have dared to criticize the gutting of programs. Musk is following the same stratagems as when he took over Twitter, by slashing budgets, engaging in massive layoffs, while ignoring the long term effects to create his own world, rather than the one the end users want. Bump cautions, “…this is governance, not a right-wing social club. If X crashes, users shrug. If the government crashes, people die. The former is not good for business. The latter is not good for politicians.”

    On ‘The Last Word,’ MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell had much to say about the joint Trump/Musk Oval Office press conference last week, pointing out the power displayed by Musk over the sitting president. Elon stood beside the Resolute desk expounding to the press (with 3,666 words), and a seated Trump (who spoke only 2,487 words), that the non-official DOGE is saving American taxpayers trillions of dollars — no breakdown, just take his word for it and ignore the suffering and chaos. O’Donnell described the scene as “a picture of presidential subservience the likes of which we have never seen, the most powerless image of a President of the United States ever created by a camera.” The t-shirted, MAGA-hatted Musk conveyed, with his son X in tow, without saying a word, that “Donald Trump is not the boss of me.” Trump’s first-term Vice President Mike Pence “never had a day like that in the Oval Office with Donald Trump,” and current VP JD Vance “will never have a day like that in the Oval Office with Donald Trump because Donald Trump is the boss of JD Vance,” O’Donnell added. To top it off, Musk’s son was rumored to have admonished Trump with, “Shush your mouth,” when he started to speak. Roy Wood, Jr. appeared on the ‘Daily Show’ giving his take on how much control President Trump has over the DOGE leader as he runs roughshod over the federal government, saying, “I look at this Trump-Elon relationship — you ever had a homeboy who had a girlfriend nobody liked? And the friend has to act as if ‘Oh, we’re fine. We’re happy.’ It is going to take a consecutive series of brave people to keep this administration from going off the rails. You’re going to need a bunch of brave judges because he’s going to come for their heads, too.”

    In the aftermath of the joint Oval Office press conference, where Trump also made a big show of signing various death sentences for government agencies, satirist Andy Borowitz wrote a dateline Washington coverage in his The Borowitz Report“Boasting that it was ‘like taking candy from a baby,’ on Wednesday Elon Musk tricked Donald J Trump into signing a reverse mortgage on the White House. ‘All these years, you’ve fixed it, you’ve taken care of it. Maybe it’s time for your home to start taking care of you. There you go,’ he whispered into Trump’s ear, putting the pen in his tiny hand. Assuming ownership of the White House was just the latest real estate coup for Musk, who earlier in the week tricked Trump into signing over the deed to Mar-a-Lago.”

    Former RNC chairman and current MSNBC host, Michael Steele, took a Saturday morning discussion into a blistering tirade against both Democrats and Republicans for groveling beneath Donald Trump’s relentless destruction of democracy. ‘Weekend‘ co-host Alicia Menendez read from The Nation’s recent report which said “the courts cannot save us,” spurring Steele to hit the ceiling. Co-host Symone Sanders Townsend asked him, “What would you have us do?” Steele blasted back, “I would like you to show that you give a damn! That you got a little emotion about the fact that people are losing their jobs indiscriminately. That this individual sitting down at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue has given absolute power to one man who brings his son into the Oval Office, whose son says to him, ‘You’re not the president, you shouldn’t be in that chair.’ Now, where did he get that from? He got it from his daddy, because that’s what his daddy thinks of the man who brought him into the Oval Office. So, I’d just like to see somebody wake the hell up and get excited about the fact that your country is under assault! They’re not at the gate anymore, they’re in your bedrooms, they’re in your living rooms, they’re in your businesses, they got your data, they got all your stuff. Elon Musk has his tentacles in everything you’re doing, not just off of X, but now he’s in the Treasury Department, he’s in the Labor Department, he’s in the Department of Homeland Security and nobody seems to give a damn, so that’s all I want. Somebody to show that they care enough to get off their fat ass and say something about it.” When co-host Menendez attempted to interject and point the finger at complicit Republicans, Steele went off again, “The hell with Republicans! They’re not going to do anything, they’re the problem!”

    Along with DemocratsAlaska’s conservative Senator Lisa Murkowski is lamenting and criticizing the Trump administrations’s terminating the employment of about 200,000 civil service workers who were in their probationary periods. Murkowski warned of negative repercussions in Alaska with potentially 100 or so in her state being fired. She posted on X, “Any of these abrupt terminations will do more harm than good, stunting opportunities in Alaska and leaving holes in our communities,” continuing that she shares “the administration’s goal of reducing the size of federal government, but this approach is bringing confusion, anxiety, and now trauma to our civil servants.” Some X users were not having her “whining,” and arguing that she and her party are the ones inflicting damage. One post reads, “Your party & you propping Trump up has allowed this to happen. Stop whining about something you enabled.” Another reads, “I didn’t think the leopard would eat MY face,” while another reads, “You failed Alaskans and all Americans by voting for his Russian assets, Fox pundits, election deniers, conspiracy theorists, useful idiots, DOGE and other frauds. What could possibly go wrong?”

    Steve Schmidt wrote in his The Warning blog that it was clear in watching Trump’s meeting with King Abdullah of Jordan, the king was “struggling to maintain his composure and dignity as the American president blustered like a fool about a vision for the future of the world that is both utterly insane, and would be a disaster for the USA, Israel, Egypt, Europe, Jordan and the Palestinian people, who would live in ignominy as a crime against humanity,” getting resettled from their homeland. “It is also a repudiation of the UN Declaration of Human Rights, architected by the US. Think about the arrogance at hand. We are witnessing a historic moment. Before it is over, we will all have a role to play. Trust me on this. The king knows what is coming. He just doesn’t know what to say. What can be said? Whatever must be said, it must be said by an American first. The world is waiting to hear a sound, even if it is a whisper. It is the sound of an opposition stirring that makes clear that liberty is not a hollow faith. Or is it?”

    On The Tonight ShowJimmy Fallon joked that on Valentine’s Day Melania asked Donald if he forgot again. He was quick to say, “Oh no — I got Elon something.” And Andy Borowitz strikes again, posting, “Melania Trump has determined that the Valentine’s Day card she received on Friday could not possibly be from her husband because her name was spelled correctly, the First Lady has confirmed. ‘If it spelled ‘Melanie,’ ‘Melanin,’ or ‘Malala,’ then I’d know it from him,’ she said. ‘It was signed ‘the President,’ she continued. ‘So guess it from Elon. I wish Justin Trudeau send me card one day,’ she added wistfully. ‘That be best.'”

    Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
     

    ...

    EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

    EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    Camping

    “Camping is not a date activity. If you absolutely must bring your girlfriend camping, try to leave her home next time.”
    ~Unknown Author

    “The camping trip will provide welcome relief from civilization.”
    ~Garrison Keillor

    “Camping is not a date; it’s an endurance sport.”
    ~Gretta Wing Miller

    “You can never be too old to camp or too young to camp, camping is for everybody.”
    ~Elizabeth Gilbert

    “Heaven is under our feet as well as over our heads”
    ~Henry David Thoreau

    ...

    How does an hour of soothing nature and bird sounds sound? Like this, that’s how!


    COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

    Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
    (Gunilla Leavitt)

    ...

    Deep Cover

    Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

    February 12 – 18, 2025

    Highlights this week:

    Greensite… is out for a bit, but she will be back… Steinbruner… Downtown explosion plan, comment NOW … Hayes… the unfolding of spring… Patton… Get engaged locally… Matlock… cause for panic…mealy-mouthed wobblies…old-time religion… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover…Webmistress serves you… Valentine’s Day origins… Quotes on… “Valentine’s Day”

    ...

    HISTORIC “CLEAR CUTTING” PLUS. Dating around 1900, these hard working guys felled everything that vintage “selective harvesting” would allow. We are living in the heritage of those timber practices. I have no clue where in our mountains this epic photo was taken…and it sure is impressive.

    photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

    Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

    Dateline: February 12, 2025

    GREETINGS FROM THE DESERT. It’s almost Valentine’s Day, and as most every year, I am spending this week celebrating pyrotechnics at the Western Winterblast, a gathering of professional and amateur pyros, held by the Western Pyrotechnics Association. This year is the 36th annual event, and it’s days and days of fireworks! Not to mention nights! The displays are fantastic… It’s held at the racetrack in Lake Havasu, AZ, and the locals come watch the fireworks displays in the evenings. The manufacturers and distributors show off their new stuff at this type of event, so the variety and quality is unmatched.

    Btw, Lake Havasu is the town whose founder bought the London Bridge and had it shipped over, brick by brick. And no, the story you’ve heard about “some dumb guy who thought he was buying the Tower Bridge” is not true. They knew what bridge they were buying, and in hindsight, it was a very clever move indeed. Lake Havasu is a pretty neat place. Check it out, if you ever get the opportunity.

    ...

    THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

    NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

    ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

    FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

    STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

    NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

    SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

    EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

    A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

    ...

    Gillian is taking a break, but she’ll be back!

    Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

    ...
    CLEARING UP CONFUSION

    My apologies about the incompleteness of that section of last week’s Bratton Online report about the Eastside BID.  I forgot to edit it and include that the information came from Ms. Katie Ferraro, Santa Cruz City Economic Development Director.

    The reference to the “engineer’s report” regards an analysis by a licensed engineer that separates general benefit vs. special benefit of the fee and is used to calculate how much the fee would be, based on that analysis.  It is a requirement for all Prop. 218 votes, which give weighted voting to those who would pay the most.

    YOUR CHANCE TO COMMENT ON THE DOWNTOWN EXPANSION (aka EXPLOSION) PLAN DRAFT EIR IS FEBRUARY 21
    The Downtown Expansion Plan more closely resembles an Explosion Plan, and is by far the largest project in the City’s history.  Please take a look and submit whatever comment you can.

    • Ask for a study of the risk of liquefaction, especially in the face of Climate Change anticipated.
    • Ask for a study of the noise that would result from pounding beams to the bedrock to support the structures..
    • Ask for an analysis and modeling of flooding risk related to the San Lorenzo River and anticipated climate change sea level rise.
    • Ask for an analysis of the connection to the beach and Boardwalk, ie, where would shuttles be located and associated parking for out-of-town tourists be located.
    • Ask for an analysis how this massive project is consistent with the character of Santa Cruz and adjacent communities???

    Will this really improve the economy by destroying what is left of the beach town atmosphere the tourists (and residents) seek by visiting and living here?  Won’t it just be a repeat of dense urban centers in the Bay Area that people want to escape when they come to Santa Cruz????

    Send your comments by 5pm February 21

    Submit Comments to: Sarah Neuse, Senior Planner, via email: sneuse@santacruzca.gov 

    OR via US Mail:

    City of Santa Cruz
    Planning and Community Development Department
    Advance Planning Division
    809 Center Street, Rm 101
    Santa Cruz, CA  95060

    Downtown Plan Expansion

    SANTA CRUZ AGRICULTURAL POLICY COMMISSION WILL NOT MEET UNTIL APRIL 17…BESS ON THE AGENDA?
    Considering the recent Moss Landing Battery Fire and unknown impacts on agricultural land in both Monterey and Santa Cruz Counites, it is curious that the group that would seemingly be most interested in advising the Board of Supervisors on the matter would cancel abruptly.  Nothing to consider???   Hmmm…

    Here is the reply from County Planner Sheila McDaniel, staff member in charge of the County Agricultural Policy Advisory Commission (APAC), when I sent an inquiry about where the group would be meeting:

    The APAC meeting,  regularly scheduled for the date of 2/20/2025, has been cancelled due to a lack of items to be heard. The next regularly scheduled APAC meeting is booked for 4/17/2025.

    It is even more curious that the APAC will not meet until a few days before the Board of Supervisors is scheduled to consider a new County Ordinance regulating Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) in the County, and potentially approving the permit for the first of it’s kind in the County at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.  This facility would remove many acres of prime agricultural land from production and must be approved by the APAC.

    Hmmm….

    Please contact your County Supervisor and ask about this…and demand a few town hall meetings.
    454-2200  Board of Supervisors

    CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION MEETING
    I tried to participate in the California Energy Commission business meeting this week, but they could not hear me, due to technological problems.  I wanted to implore the Commission to investigate the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire, and to reject all applications for  lithium-ion Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) projects.

    California Energy Commission : Docket Log

    Here is some interesting information that was on their docket:

    11. Charge Bliss, Inc. Proposed resolution approving agreement LDS-24-005 with Charge Bliss, Inc. for the first phase of an up to $28,091,162 grant, and adopting staff’s recommendation that this action is exempt from CEQA.

    The agreement will fund deployment of a 33 MWh non-lithium-ion Long Duration Energy Storage (LDES) system, with a discharge duration of at least 10 hours, at the Valley Children’s Hospital (VCH) in Madera County. The agreement will initially provide $4,328,572 for the first phase consisting of preliminary engineering, detailed project planning, and commercial scale designs, and up to an additional $23,762,590 may be added, with approval from the CEC’s Executive Director, through an amendment. The LDES system will be operated as part of a microgrid being funded by VCH featuring 2.2MW of fuel cell capacity, 1.2MW of solar photovoltaics, and a 2.8 MWh LDES system. (LDES Funding) Contact: Javier Flores (Staff Presentation 5 minutes)

    CENTRAL COAST COMMUNITY ENERGY INVESTING IN BESS IN THE STATE…AND ANOTHER RATE INCREASE COMING
    I attended the Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) Operations Board meeting this week.  Santa Cruz County CAO Carlos Palacios sits on that Board.  Santa Cruz City Manager Matt Huffaker was elected as Chair..

    I spoke about the need to place a moratorium on lithium-based BESS facilities, and explore safer and more environmentally-friendly alternatives, such as sodium-ion BESS options.

    The Board did not respond to my comments, but I noted that the representatives from Monterey County were asking many questions later about the agenda item regarding the BESS project in Tracy.
     
    [Just a heads-up…Director Shaw explained that a rate increase for 3CE customers is coming.  He also said that on March 13, 2025, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) is expected to have completed an investigation of the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire, and is expected to review new safety requirements for such technology.]

    This 3CE Operations Board met February 12 and approved spending nearly $800 Million for the hybrid power and battery storage plant in Tracy that will construct a Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facility next to an existing natural gas-powered electricity plant.  The plant will run on energy from the BESS part-time.

    CEO Shaw gave a presentation that included a slide directly addressing the impacts of the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire.  I asked that the slides be uploaded onto the meeting agenda website…they still are not there.
    .
    SEE #13

    with a power delivery term of 15.5 years with an expected Start Date of January 1, 2027, in an amount not to exceed $783,000,000

    BACKGROUND:
     At its September 14, 2023 meeting, the Policy Board, relying in part on its earlier policy position to promote low or zero emission conventional generation resources that “serve as a bridge to California’s zero-carbon grid,” voted unanimously to support the innovative hybrid-battery energy storage system approach that can both: 1) reduce existing natural gas facility emissions; while also, 2) secure valuable Resource Adequacy product for 3CE customers. The Policy Board’s direction permitted staff to implement a component of 3CE’s strategic approach to cost-effectively meeting our Resource Adequacy compliance obligations under a slide of day compliance structure. Specifically, to “control […] existing traditional dispatchable resources that can perform in each hour of the 24-hour slice of day paradigm.”

    In January 2024, the Operations Board approved, consistent with Policy Board direction, two such hybrid-battery storage Projects (the Panoche and Midway hybrid projects). While these earlier projects added a 1-hour discharge duration battery energy storage system, the Tracy Hybrid project proposed here would add an 8-hour long duration BESS. 

     

    In May 2024, 3CE launched a request for offers (“RFO”) targeting procurement of renewable energy and/or storage resources to help meet our internal goals, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and meet reliability requirements.

    Approval of the Tracy Hybrid Project accomplishes the earlier board direction to control dispatchable resources to stabilize 3CE’s Resource Adequacy needs on a longer-term basis while reducing existing Low Med High emissions by constructing a battery at an existing natural gas facility. 3CE will be a joint offtaker of this project, with 3CE taking one third of the total capacity meaning 98MW of RA from the CCGT and 13.3 MW of the 8-hour BESS facility. Two other CCAs are finalizing agreements for offtake of the other two thirds. This hybrid resource will provide valuable fixed-price RA benefits to ensure RA compliance for 3CE under the Slice-of-Day (SOD) RA paradigm, which began in 2025. If approved the proposed project would meet approximately 18% of 3CE’s RA obligation at a savings over 3CE’s forecasted RA price. Once the BESS obtains operational status, 40MW of the interconnection capacity currently allocated to the CCGT facility will be redistributed to the BESS.
     
    While not located within the 3CE jurisdictional footprint, the facility is in Tracy, San Joaquin County and grid-tied to the CAISO balancing authority. 


     

    The proposed Tracy Hybrid Project would be the third hybrid-BESS project with developer MRP. The earlier projects are scheduled to be operational in 2026 but to date, no development issues have arisen with either project. MRP owns and manages about 2,000 MW of generating capacity in California and 4,000 MW outside of California. Approval of the Tracy Hybrid Project accomplishes the earlier board direction to control dispatchable resources to stabilize 3CE’s Resource Adequacy needs on a longer-term basis while reducing existing Low Med High emissions by constructing a battery at an existing natural gas facility. 3CE will be a joint offtaker of this project, with 3CE taking one third of the total capacity meaning 98MW of RA from the CCGT and 13.3 MW of the 8-hour BESS facility

    Environmental Stewardship The project is in an area zoned for industrial uses with other operating power plants nearby. Land, biological and cultural surveys are complete and were included in technical reports to San Joaquin County and no significant impacts were identified. As both the existing CCGT and new BESS facility are on a developed parcel, no significant impacts are anticipated as part of the local planning and entitlement process. The project is anticipated to reduce the CCGT output and thereby lower emissions in the local area.

    Here is some background information about the existing natural gas power plant in Tracy:
    Tracy Combined-Cycle Power Plant

    What about PG&E???  Well, that entity is also charging ahead with nine BESS projects, all of which are lithium-ion technology.

    Project Details
    The nine projects announced today and listed below all feature lithium-ion battery energy storage technology, each with a four-hour discharge duration. PG&E has executed 15-year Resource Adequacy agreements for each of the following projects:

    • Beaumont ESS I, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Terra-Gen, LLC) – The Beaumont Energy Storage project is comprised of a 100 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Beaumont, Calif. (Riverside County) and scheduled to be online by August 2023.
    • Sanborn ESS I, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Terra-Gen, LLC) – The Edwards Sanborn Energy Storage project is comprised of a 169 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Mojave, Calif. (Kern County) and scheduled to be online by August 2023.
    • Canyon Country ESS I, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Terra-Gen, LLC) – The Canyon Country Energy Storage project is comprised of an 80 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Santa Clarita, Calif. (Los Angeles County) and scheduled to be online by October 2023.
    • Moss Landing Energy Storage 3, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Vistra Corp) – The MOSS350 Energy Storage project is comprised of a 350 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Moss Landing, Calif. (Monterey County) and scheduled to be online by August 2023.
    • Poblano Energy Storage, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Strata Clean Energy, LLC) – The Inland Empire Energy Storage project is comprised of a 100 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Rialto, Calif. (San Bernardino County) and scheduled to be online by April 2024.
    • NextEra Energy Resources Development, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of NextEra Energy Inc.) – The Corby Energy Storage project is comprised of a 125 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Vacaville, Calif. (Solano County) and scheduled to be online by June 2024.
    • NextEra Energy Resources Development, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of NextEra Energy Inc.) – The Kola Energy Storage project is comprised of a 275 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Tracy, Calif. (Alameda County) and scheduled to be online by June 2024.
    • Nighthawk Energy Storage, LLC (an affiliate of Arevon Energy) – The Nighthawk Storage project is comprised of a 300 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Poway, Calif. (San Diego County) and, pending required local approvals, is scheduled to be online by June 2024.
    • Caballero CA Storage, LLC (a wholly owned subsidiary of Origis USA, LLC) – The Caballero Energy Storage project is comprised of a 99.7 MW stand-alone, transmission-connected battery energy storage resource located in Nipomo, Calif. (San Luis Obispo County) and scheduled to be online by June 2024.

    PG&E Proposes Nearly 1600 MW of New Battery Energy Storage Capacity

    This includes Tracy…

    SANTA CRUZ CITY DOING GOOD WORK TO MAKE USE OF WATER WHEN IT IS ABUNDANT
    I attended the Santa Cruz City Water Commission meeting on February 3 and was pleased to see such commitment to projects that will make good use of stormwater when it is abundant.

    I was also impressed by the great amount of work the City does in-house on these projects…unlike Soquel Creek Water District, who hires multiple consultants for just about everything.

    City staff did discuss a reclassification of Water Year determinations.  What would have been a “normal year” will now be classified as a “wet year” under the new five-tier evaluation system (that I still do not understand)

    AT LAST! THE WHALE BRIDGE WILL OPEN!
    According to Supervisor Manu Koenig’s recent newsletter, the Chanticleer Pedestrian Overcrossing, aka ‘Whale Bridge’, will open
    MAY 14 at 5:30pm.  I wonder if there will be sidewalks on the inland side to accommodate all the foot traffic to the bridge?  Last known, there will be no such improvements for pedestrian safety in that busy Grey Bears corridor.

    WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  REVIEW ONE SECTION OF THE DOWNTOWN EXPANSION PLAN AND MAKE A COMMENT.
    MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING.

    Cheers,
    Becky

    Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

    Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

    ...
    The Unfolding of Spring

    The rain started again, restarting the lushing verdancy across meadow and field, spurring the growth and creep of understory carpets. Fortunate are those who can wet their shoes in the droplet covered grass, who can wander into forest to witness the sorrel, ferns, and moss sparkling with moisture. For those who have done so but cannot now, let memories suffice: living those memories is the next best thing. For those who cannot access these places, may my words bring you some sense of the reality of this moment of the progression of the season.

    Meadowlands

    The open fields, the prairies, the grassy hillslopes are the quickest with rainfed spring. In 2020 and again in 2021, the meadows greened in December and browned again in February for lack of rain…I worried that we might experience that kind of fire-dangerous drought this year, but the rain returned. Mostly cool nights and short days preserved rain’s wetness through the month-long dry spell through January. February brought the rain. In the week since the rain returned, plant height in the prairie nudged higher…4 more inches. Grass leaves proliferate, whorls of wildflower leaves unfold. The leaves sparkle with water drops.

    How can the meadows be so wet, even when it isn’t raining? Dewdrops condense from the moisture in the air settling on the cooler ground and the plants growing there. First thing in the morning grasslands are wet from dew just like it just rained. This is compounded when the soil is moist because some plants, especially grasses, soak up water and exude droplets from their leaves. Plant drool.

    Telltale circular stunted areas of grasses betray fairy rings of mushrooms forming. Soon a circle of softball sized spherical white puffball mushrooms will emerge at the periphery. Parasols of other mushrooms, brown, gray, red, yellow, and white are the prairie flowers for now, popping up here and there, little surprises for those who wander fields.

    The first true wildflowers in the meadows – “footsteps of spring” – can be found in shallow-soiled, short stature grasslands. In preparation for its flowers, the flat, frilly rosettes of leaves have started turning audacious chartreuse, soon to be pure bright yellow to frame buttons of tightly held flower clusters. These plants are often nestled in beds of mosses and liverworts which also proliferate when grasses can’t overtop them on shallow soil or closely grazed pasture. Those bryophytes, though tiny, are underappreciated for their luscious texture and pleasing array of green hues.

    Late Winter Forest Show

    The moss and lichen gardens are more pronounced in coast live oak forests, which ring meadows in the transition to the deeper, darker redwood or fir stands. Hanging from coast live oak limbs are long, moistened drapes of pale green lichen, swooshing back and forth in breezes. Living mats of a hundred colors and textures cling to the mostly hidden gnarly bark of oaks. Some moss patches seem ancient, inches deep and crawling with tiny critters. Other types of moss are shorter with starfish arms reaching out to claim new territory from the even smaller lichens, stuck like paper art right onto bark. Wait- where’s the bark? Everything that looked like bark is actually lichen – round patches curl at their edges, some types like tufts of feathers, other types with masses of closely ranked, coral-like knobby protuberances. Different lichens can be mustard yellow, sea green, dark almost black green, white, and even red, but you have to get close to appreciate the array of color.

    Coast live oaks are evergreen trees, keeping some leaves all year, but this time of year they have shed many of last year’s leaves, so the lichens and mosses inhabiting their branches and trunks get more sunshine. This makes the sunny days between rainstorms the best time to take in the lush moss beds and lichen mats.

    Under the Deep Shade

    Creeks chatter and sing, spattering high on their banks in the wake of rain. Canyonsides, under redwood, fir and tanoak, sword ferns and redwood sorrel are entering their heyday. Sword ferns unfurl fresh fronds through the center of previous years’ darker, battered leaves. Sometimes stands of these ferns blanket the understory with little else, each plant 3′ across and nearly as tall. These old growth ferns are increasingly rare as they are not tolerant of hot wildfire, which destroys them. Not so with redwood sorrel, which springs back from more protected nooks after fire. In the footprint of the 2020 CZU fire, redwood sorrel has already claimed the extent of its pre-fire understory territory. This sorrel has shamrock clover-like 3-leaflets, from one to the next they touch each other, completely covering the deep, moist redwood duff, forming vast carpets of medium green, uniformly 3” tall. Pinkish white flowers are opening and will soon be quite the display. On trail or roadside, milk maid flowers are ahead of them, already in peak, if subtle, bloom. Milk maids are radish relatives with four petaled nearly white flowers.

    With the new wave of rain, mushrooms have begun once again to proliferate in the forest understory. Even if you can’t name them, you might like to take a closer look at their artistry. As with all Life, we are at an epicenter of species diversity like few other places in North America, and the mushroom diversity reflects that. My favorite are the skinny deep purple-red wine-colored ones, the big ones with bright red caps, and the slimy yellow and green ones.

    Fresh Air!

    The rain has washed the pollen out and breezes carry oxygen rich, moist air that is just right for breathing. Long gone is the wildfire smoke and roadway dust. On a warm day, the sweet smell of bay tree flowers might waft your way. Taking deep breaths of Nature’s air is worth making the trek out of doors and into the wild: it is good for you.

    Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

    Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

    ...

    Tuesday, February 11, 2025

    “Get Engaged Locally”? To be clear, I am not talking about the wisdom of focusing your romantic endeavors, leading to marriage, to people who live in the same Zip Code. I am talking about “politics.”

    Pictured is Joyce Vance. As Wikipedia tells us, Vance “is an American lawyer who served as the United States Attorney for the Northern District of Alabama from 2009 to 2017. She was one of the first five U.S. Attorneys, and the first female U.S. Attorney, nominated by President Barack Obama.”

    Most important, I think, is the fact that Vance now writes a daily blog on Substack, called Civil Discourse. I subscribe to her blog, and I encourage you to do so, too. There is a “no charge” option.

    Vance’s daily postings in Civil Discourse are invaluable in helping people to understand the “legal side of politics and government.” This is increasingly important with Donald J. Trump now serving as President of the United States. The president works for us, of course, not the opposite, but given Mr. Trump’s impression that we are all supposed to take orders from him, it’s important for us to know our rights and powers, and the president’s obligations, and the limitations on what the president is authorized to do, or command.

    Vance’s posting on November 29, 2024, was titled, “Wild Accusations,” and commented on a claim made by the president’s friend Elon Musk. Musk claimed that Alexander Vindman, former Director for European Affairs for the United States National Security Council, was guilty of “treason,” and not only “should” but “would” be punished – presumably by imposition of the death penalty. Musk, like Trump, has an elevated sense of his own greatness, and of his own importance, and of his own power. The following statement is an excellent example of claims that are totally unjustified, legally and otherwise.

    In her Substack blog posting, Vance quoted from an earlier interview she did with Vindman, and reported on that interview as follows (emphasis added):

    In November of 2023, Alex was our guest for Five Questions. His answer to my final question for him is just as important today as it was then:

    Joyce: So many people are engaged and want to do whatever they can to ensure democracy survives the 2024 election and Trump. What do you see as some of the opportunities for each of us to get involved and do our part?

    Alex: The most important thing we can all do is read your Substack to stay smart on threats to our democracy! But seriously, one thing we can do is get engaged locally. Once people connect with their communities and stay engaged, they will notice that their communities are good; no one is living in a Trumpian hellscape of American decline, and it’s important to push back against this narrative.

    Complacency is not an option. Understand the power of your vote. If your vote wasn’t important, foreign adversaries wouldn’t be working so hard to influence your vote. Republicans wouldn’t be removing large swaths of voters from the rolls. Normalize talking to your friends and acquaintances about voting and educate them on candidates and issues. We have just under a year until the election and it’s going to be a marathon, not a sprint….

    I endorse Vindman’s recommendation (even though – and perhaps especially because – the 2024 election has now come and gone and our former president, Trump, has been returned to the White House). At the “local” level, people can and will learn that they really are in charge of the government (and not the opposite). I was elected to the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors five times, and served on the Board for twenty years. A County Supervisor is one of only five persons who are in charge of County Government, which has the ability to set policy on land use, social and health services, and on virtually every other important area of our community’s life.

    My personal experience in local government in Santa Cruz County has absolutely demonstrated to me the truth of what Vindman says.

    Get engaged locally! 

    That’s the important message that comes from a couple of people who are mainly involved with politics and government at the national level. It’s very good advice!

    Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

    Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

    ...

    SPECIAL PROJECTS, SQUIRRELS, MISSING MEL, SELF-LOATHING

    On a recent edition of the ‘Late Show,’ Stephen Colbert said in his opening monologue that he didn’t want to “cause panic” as he began to relate all the panic-inducing illegal and unconstitutional actions of the Trump administration. As for the firing of all the Justice Department personnel who investigated the J6 Insurrection case, Colbert said there will be nobody left, necessitating a name change to “the Department-Of-Just-This-Guy,” adding, “The firings are probably illegal, and it’s clearly retribution — unless you ask a Republican like Congressman Dan Crenshaw.” A video clip of Crenshaw, asked about the retribution aspect, said, “Who knows if it’s revenge. I think it’s open to interpretation,” to which Colbert added, “Sure. Who knows? It’s just like that movie ‘V for Vambiguous.’” He decried the administration’s ‘Special Project’ of launching investigations of specific prosecutors who were just doing their job. “Going after honest civil servants doing their job is not a special project. It is a disgrace. A special project is when, to protect you from bullies on the playground, instead of going to recess, you get to help Miss Brogdon clean the erasers,” he explained.

    The Bully-On-The-Playground Trump ignores the laws, adhering to the ugly habits that he can’t abandon, even a law that Congress passed as a reform simply because of his behavior during his first term in office. So he charges ahead with his corruption,  not caring, joined by an uncaring electorate who isn’t paying attention anyway. His recent firing of fifteen inspectors general, those independent watchdogs heading agencies of the executive branch to monitor waste and corruption, purging some who were appointees from his first term, is only a continuation of his ripping out the guardrails — no walls here, please! The inspectors came into being in 1978 as a deterrent to scofflaw presidencies, such as Richard Nixon’s, against the abuse of executive power. Originally, there were only twelve inspectors, but over the years that  number grew to 73 — inspectors general for the inspectors generals? The current issue is that under the law, a president had to give Congress 30 days’ notice regarding an intent to fire an I.G., providing some vague reason why it is necessary. Bob Bauer and Jack Goldsmith wrote at Lawfare in 2022, “More frequently than prior presidents, Trump manipulated vacancies and related laws to fire or dismiss disliked inspectors general and replace them, pursuant to the Federal Vacancies Reform Act of 1998, with a more like-minded or pliant official.” This prompted Congress to amend the law by replacing the word ‘reasons‘ with the phrase ‘substantive rationale, including detailed and case-specific reasons.’ In spite of the law’s change, strengthened because of Trump’s actions, he has mocked it by flouting the original law. No 30 days’ notice, no rationale — he just did it, telling the press that it was all fine and, “It’s a very common thing to do,” which became the catchword for RepublicansFox NewsSinclair, and the remainder of the propaganda chorus. As you might expect, Senator Lindsey Graham admitted that Trump broke the law, “technically,” but chuckled that he wasn’t losing any sleep as a result.

    We can expect the president’s new I.G. appointees to turn a blind eye to petty corruption, but these dark-of-night actions foretell that more serious and aggressive acts are in the offing a la Project 2025, such as attacking executive agencies, as Michael Tomasky wrote in The New Republic. Tomasky says that’s only a guess, “Not being an evil genius myself, I have trouble keeping up with these people.” He accuses the Democrats of “being their usual wobbly selves, with mealy-mouthed vows to work with the administration, not understanding the situation we’re in.” Sounds very much like most of the media prior to the election, treating the presidential race as a business-as-usual quadrennial event — ho-hum, let’s move along, nothing to see here, it’ll all work out, la-la-la-la-la. Tomasky says, “The situation is this. Trump takes up about 80 percent of the oxygen. His craven party and the right-wing media will applaud everything he does, legal or not, and invent some justification for it. The half of the country who voted for him will agree and approve. They assume, for example in the case of the inspectors general, that these people are corrupt deep-staters who are standing in Trump’s way, so good riddance, law schmaw. They don’t need to be galvanized, in other words. As long as Trump’s getting his way, they’re in the game, and they’re content.” He goes on to say that those who voted against Trump need to be galvanized, but some are still hurting from the election results, others don’t want to engage, while many feel there’s no hope. But somebody needs to step up and lead, choosing issues that will galvanize the anti-Trumpers, instead of ignoring Trump’s missteps as part of the game. Tomasky characterizes this as “such a passive, Democratic way to look at this. There’s always an excuse not to act, if not acting is what you want to do.” He closes by adding, “The president broke the law. Clearly and unambiguously. On his fifth day in office. In what democracy is that NOT an issue? I fear we know the answer.”

    To smooth over some of the rough edges of his new tenancy, Trump continues to reach out with his being “saved by God” mantra, which he emphasized in his inauguration “weave.” So now we have, by executive order no less, a new ‘Faith Office’ in the White House to be led by televangelist Paula White-Cain, who has been Trump’s so-called spiritual advisor, with Attorney General Pam Bondi running interference with a task force to root out “persecution” of America’s Christians. These actions will sit well with Christian nationalist cabinet members, and Trumpster Dumpster/Vice President JD Vance, and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, despite Trump’s sketchy relationship with religion. His flirting with religion during his first term, is noted by his tear-gassing demonstrators to clear the path to allow him to clutch an upside down Bible in front of a church for a photo-op. Other photo-ops show him praying with evangelicals in the oval office, after which he derided the event, in essence, asking aides, “How do these people believe this stuff?” He recently told a crowd at a prayer breakfast in DC, that he has had a religious awakening, especially since the assassination attempt in Butler, PA during a campaign rally. Evidently, he wasn’t awakened enough to heed Bishop Mariann Budde’s sermon when she called for him to show “mercy” toward immigrants and LGBTQ citizens. Many of his appointees and hangers-on have ties to the New Apostolic Reformation Church, which as a Christian Nationalist movement is calling for government and society come under their control. Notably, House Speaker Mike Johnson is linked to this group, as is ‘Faith Office’ leader Paula White-Cain. Secretary of Defense Hegseth belongs to a church affiliated with the right-wing Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches — you guessed it — a Christian nationalist front, calling for reestablishment of Biblical law, and possible repeal of women’s right to vote. For the moment, Trump is not espousing these views, but he continues to please the religious right with his accommodations — he’s easy! In his prayer breakfast speech, he explicitly called for an increased role in religion, saying, “We have to bring religion back. Let’s bring God back into our lives.” Also hinting that we need to bring him back to a third term in the Oval Office — identity confusion?

    Florida’s megachurch preacher, Paula White-Cain, as a proponent of ‘prosperity theology’ fits right into Trump’s credo that God rewards the faithful with material wealth and personal success. Many of Trump’s MAGA supporters are disappointed that White-Cain is now embedded in the Oval Office, considering her theology as heretical by blaming financial woes as a lack of faith, which will only be used to exploit vulnerable churchgoers. Christian podcast host, John Mason, wrote on X“Paula is a known heretic and known false teacher who has no regard for the Gospel of Jesus Christ.” Self-described ‘Orthodox Christian’ and leadership coach Scott Ross, agrees that White-Cain is a heretic, calling Trump’s appointment “an abomination, utterly opposed to authentic Christianity, she has had multiple husbands, twisting the Gospel for profit.” Curiously, Paula is currently married to guitarist Jonathan Cain, of the San Francisco-based band, JourneyRuth Ben-Ghiat whose blog is ‘Lucid‘ via Substack posted on Reddit about an email from a reader recently. The reader states, “I have prayed about writing you. I know you are a liberal but you are also a historian. I want you to know that God himself spared Trump twice from death at the hands of another. This means he has blessing and approval from the Almighty just like George Washington. I think you should recognize that, and admit God wants him as our salvation.” Ruth replied, “Well, Hitler survived six serious attempts and at least 42 plots. God also allowed him to live. Do you think God approved of what he was doing? Do you think he was Germany’s salvation?” Crickets.

    The biggest bit of news has been the establishment of a new branch of government to join the ExecutiveLegislative, and Judicial — the MuskRat, headed by slasher Dork Lord, and now co-president Elon Musk (or Leon, as Trump calls him), and his fake departmental DOGE team of unvetted, non-security-cleared teens and twenty-somethings who are rummaging through the files of governmental departments with their computers and portable hard drives. Hold ’em high guys, for the highest bidder — what say you Mr. Putin? The Blitzkrieg Team has had a field day with access to sensitive Treasury Department data, paramount in that treasury trove being Social Security and Medicare information. Musk and his DOGiEs demanded access to the files, resulting in a refusal from 30-year veteran Deputy Secretary David Lebryk, and upon his refusal to do so, he was put on administrative leave before being forced to resign. Following the DOGE raid, Senator Ron Wyden sent a letter of outrage to Trump’s new Treasury SecretaryScott Bessent, indignant that “officials associated with Musk may have intended to access these payment systems to illegally withhold payments to any number of programs. To put it bluntly, these payment systems cannot fail, and any politically motivated meddling in them risks severe damage to our country  and the economy. I can think of no good reason why political operators who have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the law would need access. Sources tell my office that DOGE was granted full access to this system — Social Security, Medicare benefits, grants, payments to government contractors, including those that compete directly with Musk’s own companies.” Wyden goes on to point out that Medicaid portals in all 50 states were shut down when Trump unsuccessfully attempted to freeze all grant and loan payments, and has concerns that Musk is seeking to gain access to and potentially control the Fiscal Service’s payment systems in order to carry out a political agenda in violation of the law. The senator says it appears that Musk is forcing out qualified and experienced public servants in order to get his way and fulfill Trump’s goal of eviscerating the federal budget, including potentially by cutting Social Security and Medicare benefits for millions of Americans. Perhaps instead of four branches of government we are really looking at only one — headed by two individuals? Just remember, Trump’s first lie of his second term was the oath of office.

    Elon Musk revealed that he and Trump were in agreement to shut down the foreign aid agency known as USAID, telling employees not to report to work, with Secretary of State Marco Rubio then declaring that he had taken over as acting administrator of the agency, ending its largely independent status. Without warning, senior officials and hundreds of civil servants have been suspended and eliminated, though Rubio said many of the programs would continue, even as he blamed the radical change on “worker insubordination.” Many USAID employees and Democratic lawmakers gathered in front of the agency’s headquarters in DC, denouncing the shutdown as illegal because Congress created, and funds, the agency as a distinct entity. Over the past several months the omnipresent Musk has gained a growing list of critics, but a voice from his past has been brutal in an analysis of his former confidant’s character. CEO Philip Low, of NeuroVigil, a Bay Area startup, posted on Facebook that Musk tried to undermine the business even after investing in it, because of his own rival business, NeuraLink. Low’s post has less to do with the two enterprises, which only have similar products with different marketing bases, than about personality, as he terms Musk to be “a total miserable self-loathing poser.” Low claims that the 14-year relationship of the two allowed them to share personal problems, with both men having violent fathers who lost their fortunes, both being bullied in high school, then ending up in similar environments in Silicon Valley. He portrays Musk as self-centered, believing he is above everyone else, as a power hungry and cynical individual who persuades people toward far-right political leanings world-wide. Low attributes Musk’s two Nazi salutes at Trump’s inauguration festivities, to his being a thrill-seeker who knew exactly what he was doing, as he tried to ingratiate himself to the Nazis in the MAGA movement. He says Musk was likely disappointed when the audience didn’t return his gestures to show his complete control and domination over them — and raising his leverage over Trump in the process. The post ends with Low’s warning that Musk readers should stop working for him, not supporting Tesla and X, saying, “He only wants to control, dominate, and use you — don’t let him. Cut him and his businesses out of your, and your loved ones, lives entirely. Unless you happen to be a self-loathing loser, too, he will be much more afraid of you than you should be of him.” But as Rex Huppke posted on Bluesky“These are not good people. And the time to panic is right freakin’ now!” 

    The Little-Day-One-Dictator (you think he meant to say One-A-Day-Dictator?) still has his greedy territorial expansionist gears turning in his head from Canada to Panama to Greenland to Gaza, which can become the Riviera of the Middle East after ethnic cleansing, bomb and land mine clearance, and bulldozing for removal of megatons of debris from demolished buildings. No mention of a wall to prevent residents from returning, or to keep spies, saboteurs and bomb squads at bay. Senator Amy Klobuchar, speaking at the Washington Press Club Foundation Annual Congressional Dinner, mentioned that the organization dates back to a time when the US was comprised of only 46 states, sarcastically joking that the US would be adding more states thanks to Trump’s roving eye to other lands. “Speaking of Greenland, there’s a question for you that I want to pose. What’s the difference between Greenland and Donald Trump? Greenland is not for sale!” she gloatingly cracked. This was met with a chorus of boos from the GOPers in the audience, to whom she said, “OK, to any Republican and Trump administrators out there, who might want to throw eggs at me for that joke — you can’t, because they’re too expensive.” ‘Late Show‘ host Stephen Colbert suggested that Trump probably wants to change Canada’s name should it become our 51st state, and since it’s just above Minnesota, it could be called Maxisota. Then again, Trump might want to investigate leftover names suggested by Thomas Jefferson in 1784, for some of the western territories, a grid divided into sixteen regions. Jefferson submitted ten names, two of which, Michigania and Illinoia survived with editing, but other baroque offerings as PelisipiaAssensipia, and Cherronesus only made it into the circular file. The Donald will probably grace any new states with names based on his DEI hires: Don, Eric and Ivanka.

    President Trump has chosen his next battle to be with paper straws, saying an executive order would “end the push for Paper Straws. BACK TO PLASTIC!” People posting on media could hardly believe it: “This takes an executive order?”, “Clutching at straws, literally,” “Focusing on what really matters!”, “Politics aside, this genuinely reads like a toddler upset at school lunch,” “This is what you voted for?”, and “Congrats, America!” With the flood of executive orders so massive that Trump can’t remember them all, a Congressman said, “They’re running low on squirrels they hope we chase.”

    Satirist Andy Borowitz, in his Report a few weeks ago wrote: “In a bid to reassure the nation, Pete Hegseth said if confirmed as Secretary of Defense, he will connect a breathalyzer device to the nation’s nuclear arsenal…instead of being on a car it would be on nuclear weapons. Hegseth added that he would submit to a daily phone conversation with his mother, and ‘if Mom says I don’t sound right, I won’t go near any nukes. Besides, if I’m hung over, I won’t set off anything loud.’ In a final pledge, Hegseth said, ‘I promise the American people: if I’m drunk in the morning, I’ll have someone else drive me to the Pentagon.’” In a subsequent satire, Borowitz indicates things went awry, writing: “Pete Hegseth’s tenure as Secretary of Defense got off to a wobbly start on Monday after he was arrested on suspicion of DUI for crashing an M1A2 Abrams Main Battle Tank into the Pentagon. The arresting officer, Harland Dorrinson, arrived at the Pentagon shortly after receiving reports of a large battle tank making figure 8s in the parking lot. Finding the smoldering Abrams protruding from the side of  the building, Dorrinson said Hegseth was ‘extremely combative when I asked him to step out of the tank.’ Hegseth was later booked, released, and driven home by Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh.”

    Mr. Trump became the first sitting US president to attend football’s Super Bowl on February 9, and amazingly he managed to make it all about him! He erroneously chose the Kansas City Chiefs to win the game in a pre-game interview with Fox News’ Bret Baier, giving high praise to quarterback Patrick Mahomes. He revived his grudge against pop singer, Taylor Swift, when she was shown on the Jumbotron and was soundly booed by Eagles fans in the stands because of her relationship with the Chiefs. Trump turned this negative reaction toward himself when he claimed she was being booed for supporting Kamala Harris in the presidential sweepstakes, saying, “MAGA is very unforgiving! Only the Chiefs had a rougher night.” Raise this man’s golden high chair before he throws another ketchup-laden plate of french fries onto the field! And where was Melania? In the cheap seats?!

    Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
     

    ...

    EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

    EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    Valentine’s Day

    “Valentine’s Day is a love-note to the rest of the year. Graciously, it comes at a perfect time to be savored — that period of calm between winter holiday commotion and spring enticements.”
    ~Jo Lightfoot

    “Oh, here’s an idea: Let’s make pictures of our internal organs and give them to other people we love on Valentine’s Day. That’s not weird at all.”
    ~Jimmy Fallon

    “Today is Valentine’s Day – or, as men like to call it, Extortion Day!”
    ~Jay Leno

    “Any guy hates Valentine’s Day. Even if you’re in love, you can’t win on Valentine’s Day. If you’re married, you can’t win on Valentine’s Day. Valentine’s Day is like the thing you want to avoid at all costs.”
    ~Vince Vaughn

    “When I got old enough to date, I realized that Valentine’s Day is just a commercial marketing scam to make men feel bad. So I let my boyfriends off the hook.”
    ~Evangeline Lilly

    ...

    Encyclopedia Britannica’s 2 minute exposé on the origins of Valentine’s Day.


    COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

    Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
    (Gunilla Leavitt)

    ...

    Deep Cover

    Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

    February 5 – 11, 2025

    Highlights this week:

    Greensite… is out for a bit, but she will be back… Steinbruner… Downtown Expansion Plan Intel, Battery Storage Updates, Good Job on Water Projects… Hayes… The importance of cows… Patton… Have we lost faith? Failed?… Matlock… will to live…hold your breath…free cake… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… English words left behind by the Vikings… Quotes on… “Football”

    ...

    CHUCK ABBOTT & FRIENDS PLANTING A TREE, June 3, 1965. I have no idea who the other folks in this photo are. But it’s Chuck Abbott caring how “his downtown” looks by planting a tree in the front yard of his Lincoln street home. The tree is still there. Chuck and his wife did more for beautifying our community than anyone I can think of.

    photo credit: Bruce Bratton‘s photo collection.

    Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

    Dateline: February 5, 2025

    FOOTBALL. Being Swedish, to me, football is a game played with your feet, kicking a ball across a giant field and into a goal, trying your best to not be stopped by opposing team members. I’ve never understood American Football. It has always seemed like a lot of “hurry up and wait”. People here sure love it though! Happy Superbowl, to all of you who observe… See you on the other side!

    ...

    THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

    NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

    ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

    FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

    STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

    NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

    SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

    EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

    A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

    ...

    Gillian is taking a break, but she’ll be back!

    Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

    ...
    SPEAK UP ABOUT WHAT SANTA CRUZ CITY DOWNTOWN EXPANSION PLAN COULD MEAN TO YOU

    Listen in Friday, February 7 at 3pm when longtime local activists Frank Barron and Rick Longinotti discuss as Guests on “Community Matters” what they have found tucked away (or absent from) in the Santa Cruz City Downtown Expansion Plan Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR).

    If you haven’t yet heard of this massive development in the Laurel Street area, here is the summary from CEQANet:

    Present Land Use
    Regional Visitor Serving/ Downtown Subdistrict E, Residential High Density/ Residential-Tourist Commercial

    Document Description
    The proposed project consists of a series of amendments to the City’s Downtown Plan by extending the boundary of the existing Downtown Plan to incorporate the approximate 29-acre project study area and incorporate policies, development standards and design guidelines for the study area in the City’s Downtown Plan (amended January 28, 2020) that will facilitate future redevelopment of the project area. The project also includes amendments to the City’s General Plan 2030. the Local Coastal Program (LCP). the Beach and South of Laurel Comprehensive Area Plan, and the Municipal Code to provide updates consistent with the proposed Downtown Plan amendments, including General Plan/LCP land use designation and zone district changes for parcels within the project area. The proposed Downtown Plan amendments could facilitate additional development as a result of various circulation. land use and infrastructure revisions. For purposes of environmental review, the project area could potentially accommodate a minimum of 1,800 housing units, 60,000 square feet (sf) of gross commercial area, and construction of a new approximately 180,000 sf permanent sports and entertainment arena for the Santa Cruz Warriors basketball team to replace the existing temporary arena. The arena would contain a main event court with spectator seating for approximately 3,200 seats for basketball, and approximately 4,000 seats for concerts and other performances or uses.

    Santa Cruz Downtown Plan Expansion 2022090276 – 2025-01-07 – EIR

    Comments on the DEIR must be submitted in writing or via email to Sarah Neuse by 5pm Friday, February 21, 2025.Public Review Period: January 8, 2025 through February 21, 2025.

    Submit Comments to: Sarah Neuse, Senior Planner, via email: sneuse@santacruzca.gov 

    Public Comment is open now until February 21….take a look at the map here and just read one section of the DEIR that most interests you…and write one letter.

    Downtown Plan Expansion | City of Santa Cruz
    Project page for the expansion of Santa Cruz’s Downtown Plan into the neighborhoods south of Laurel Street.

    What will this massive development  affect  traffic, water, and the quality of downtown Santa Cruz?  Listen in from your computer or smart device from anywhere in the world at 3pm Pacific Time Santa Cruz Voice – Listen and Be Heard

    Join the conversation by phoning 831-265-5050.  Listen to the recorded program from the Santa Cruz Voice.com website under “Current Shows” at the bottom of the page, under “Community Matters”.

    NEVER AGAIN MOSS LANDING.
    Please link arms with this fast-growing grassroots group to learn more about what has happened following the disaster at Moss Landing Vistra Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facility.  Never Again Moss Landing

    When no government agency was stepping up to sample for metal contamination from the fire, this group dug into their own pockets to fund $7,000 in expert testing of more than 140 samples taken from a wide area to  gather information.

    Please support them in whatever way you can and consider joining their informational outdoor rally this Saturday:

    COMMUNITY MEMBERS WILL ASSEMBLE AND ADDRESS THE VISTRA MOSS LANDING BESS FACILITY FAILURE AND FIRE.

    On Saturday, February 8th at 12:30pm PST, community members will assemble and speak in the parking area to the rear of the Whole Enchilada Restaurant in Moss Landing, CA. 7904 CA-1, Moss Landing, CA 95039. Space is reserved for members of the media.

    This is a citizen-organized event that will highlight impacts upon the surrounding community and actions being taken to address citizen concerns. Several speakers will present their observations and findings.

    Briefing:

    1. “Never Again Moss Landing” is a Fast-response grass-roots all-volunteer resident group which advocates for our community’s voice and interests in response to the Moss Landing BESS Fire. We believe that a disaster like this must never again occur. We coordinate local citizen efforts to organize and deploy facts that can restore our community’s environment, health, and welfare. We are not affiliated with any other governmental, business, or advocacy groups. Our website is NeverAgainMossLanding.org. Queries: info@neveragainmosslanding.org.
    2. Our two Facebooks Groups were created in the immediate aftermath of the January 16th fire: 
      a. Moss Landing Power Plant/Vistra Fire Symptoms 
      b.  Moss Landing Battery Plant Environmental Disaster Community Group

    3. With over 4700 members there are thousands of individual entries at these two sites detailing personal medical impacts, anger at Vistra Corporation and its response, anger at the EPA and its lack of response, fires at other battery plants, impacts upon pets and livestock, fears of general contamination and environmental degradation, uncertainty about what has happened and continues to happen, and distrust of local, state and federal responses. Members of the media are kindly advised to monitor these sites which reflect widespread citizen responses to the fire and its aftermath.
    4. Founded in 2016 out of the bankrupt reorganization of Texas Competitive Electric Holdings (TCEH), Vistra Corporation (VST) is a retail electricity and power generation company headquartered in Texas with a current market capitalization of over $57B. It has traded between $137 and $191 in the past month and closed at $168 a share on January 31st. The company is the largest competitive power generator in the U.S. with a capacity of approximately 39,000 megawatts powered by a diverse portfolio that includes natural gas, nuclear, solar, and battery energy storage facilities. It was ranked the No. 1 polluter in the United States for the 2024 Greenhouse 100 Polluters Index Report, producing 1.5% of all greenhouse gas emissions generated in the United States of America. Vistra opened the Moss Landing BESS facility in June 2021. There were two emergency mishaps reported at their facility prior to the 1.17.24 fire. The CPUC has granted Vistra a 20-year permit to operate at this location.
    5. The outcomes sought from this event include:

      a. The Moss Landing/Vistra BESS plant fire must be recognized as an unprecedented and extraordinary disaster for the Monterey Bay region and its residents. This fundamental reality must be shared and clarified locally, nationally, and internationally so that communities understand the scope and seriousness of this environmental and health crisis and its causes.

      b. Legal, administrative, and oversight requirements must be identified and enacted so that a fire will never again occur at the Moss Landing BESS. The required facility standards for regulation and operation must be greatly strengthened. This facility must not be allowed to reopen until the community is satisfied that these requirements have been met.

      c. Local elected officials and our community’s health, educational, and environmental departments need to provide transparency and immediate guidance to residents, businesses, medical and animal welfare facilities, and academic and educational organizations regarding testing protocols and treatment for the ongoing widespread and documented health issues related to this emergency. We are looking for guidance and information from the CA Dept. of Health, the CPUC, and our state elected officials. It is our view that such transparency and guidance have been woefully absent to date.

      d. The EPA, FEMA, Dept. or the Interior, and NOAA need to immediately send personnel to measure and monitor air, soil, and water quality in the greater Monterey Bay Area.

      e. In addition to immediate assessment and testing of impacts upon human, animal, and environmental health, long-term testing of our region must be developed and instituted. The effects of exposure to heavy metals and other toxic chemicals emanated from the burning of lithium batteries is unknown. Vistra must pay for these expenses which would be implemented and administered by government agencies, our educational institutions, and/or independent third parties.

      f. Vistra must immediately be required to release its testing, monitoring, and remediation data including that of third party providers engaged by Vistra. The plant cannot reopen without such full and ongoing disclosures.

      g. Dozens of large environmental, medical, corporate, agricultural, and community-action organizations are present in our community. These groups need to coordinate and collaborate their efforts in response to this disaster. Local government can play an important role in coordinating such efforts.

      h. Finally, the media as representatives of the public, need to demand answers from Vistra to the many unanswered questions about how this disaster happened. Accountability cannot be replaced by complacency or uncritical acceptance of information being provided by Vistra and the Public Relations company FTI consulting (SC) Inc.

      Never Again Moss Landing is a locally created, citizen-led, all-volunteer group facilitating community awareness and response to the Moss Landing/Vistra BESS plant fire.

    STATUS OF WATSONVILLE BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM (BESS) IS FURTHER ALONG THAN LEAD TO BELIEVE
    On October 29, 2024, Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors approve in concept three sites in the County to locate Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facilities.  Little did we know that New Leaf Energy and Swift Consulting was circling the Planning Dept., and soon after filed an application for a BESS at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.

    This week, I spent quite alot of time researching the proposed Seahawk BESS project and other types of battery technology that would be much safer than lithium.
    Here is what I have learned:

    Sodium battery technology is much safer, cleaner and environmentally and socially-responsible.

    The project at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville is much further down the road to approval than has been made public:

    1. New Leaf Energy did not purchase the land (37-acres).  It remains in a Heritage Trust under Steven K. Dobler, following the death of farmer John Lukrich.
    2. County Assessor data base information shows five residences on the property, one dating to 1929, yet these are not listed in the Hazardous Assessment Report filed with the Plan.
    3. Plans submitted December 17, 2024 by Swift Consulting on behalf of New Leaf Energy do not include any information about the required public meeting that was required to be held before filing the application.  This meeting was indeed held on December 12, 2024 but it is unknown who received the mailed notice postcard that failed to provide any time of day the meeting was being held at Amesti School.
    4. Plans submitted show at least 136 battery storage units, each with only 10′ separation from the next.
    5. In April, 2024, DK Engineering developed the Boundary & Topographic Survey for the site for New Leaf Energy.
    6. In July, 2024, Dudek Consultants completed a Wetland Stream and Delineation Report for the project.
    7. On November 6, 2024, County Planner Matt Johnston approved a stand alone biotic report for the project.
    8. On November 6, 2024, County Planner Sydney Niiyama approved a stand alone archeological Report Review for the project.
    9. On November 6, 2024, County Geologist Craig Stewart approved a stand alone Geological Hazard Assessment for the project.
    10. On December 10,, 2024, C2G Civil Consultants in Scotts Valley, CA developed a Stormwater Control Plan for the proposed project.
    11. On December 12, 2024, Swift Consulting filed the project application that included: Health Risk Analysis (which only addresses diesel particulate air quality during construction), Fire Emergency Response Plan, Hazardous Consequences Analysis, Noise Study, and Decommissioning Estimate.  There is NO Neighborhood Meeting Results report.
    12. Nearby residences on the adjacent downwind parcel will be vacated until the BESS facility is decommissioned in 2050. These two residences (Gomez” and a barn are shown as nearby receptors (285′ and 300′ away), as is the Pajaro Valley Unified School District bus sheds and offices at the end of Grimmer Lane (1,220′ away from the proposed project.
    13. NONE of the adjacent dense residential subdivisions or Shapiro Knolls affordable housing complex is even mentioned, but are actually closer to the proposed BESS than the Grimmer address.
    14. The proposed project Plan shows a 12′-14′ high noise wall on the side of the project facing College Lake, but does not include any noise wall for the north side of the project that faces dense residential subdivisions.  That area of the proposed project would have a 7′ tall chainlink fence with vegetative landscaping that includes Incense Cedar trees on one page, and Douglas Fir trees on another version of the plan.  The landscape plan was developed by Dudek’s office in Portland, OR.
    15. New Leaf Energy has a local office in Oakland, CA.
    16. Sequoia Energy Storage LLC is also listed as parties to the project, with the address in Oakland CA  946112, however the principle Mr. Max Christian has the address in Lowell, MA.
    17. All of the proposed BESS project area is within an existing production orchard, and encompasses two parcels: 05110177 and 05110178, and are zoned for agriculture.  The Plan requires significant cut and fill grading. The County must re-zone the land and the County Agricultural Policy Advisory Commission (APAC) must approve taking the land out of agricultural production as well as the required 1:1 conservation agreement inherent.
      [NOTE: The APAC was schedule to meet on February 20 but Planner Sheila McDaniel just informed me that “The meeting was canceled this morning due to a lack of items for consideration.  The support staff should post a meeting cancellation online shortly.”]

    18. The proposed project Plan indicates the Zayante-Vergeles Fault is nearby;
    19. The proposed project Plan inaccurately lists Central Fire District jurisdiction when in fact, the project is within Pajaro Valley Fire District (Maybe that explains why Pajaro Valley Fire did not receive notice of the December 12, 2024 public meeting.)
    20. The proposed project Plan includes only a 10,000 gallon water storage tank on site.
    21. The project would be unmanned, with a note that cancer is likely over the course of the project for any personnel visiting the site long-term, and would rely on SCADA radio information to relay indications of storage cell venting (the initial stage of battery failure) and smoke detection. Therefore, pg. 322 states the “Health Risk is less than significant, and the chronic hazard index is less than significant.”  It is unknown where the information would be received, and how quickly staff could respond, and how nearby populations in adjacent subdivisions downwind would be affected.
    22. Chemicals listed in the Plan do not include HF gas, which is typical in lithium fires and is extremely hazardous to health and the environment.  The analysis only lists hydrogen gas as a byproduct of refrigerant that would be used, and includes a warning that all fire fighter personnel should stay 100′ from the trouble battery container doors.

    I spoke with the Project’s Planner, Mr. Evan Ditmars.  He is aware that New Leaf Energy did not specify any time on the post cards mailed to what seems to be a very small list to notice the one required meeting before filing the application,  and did not seem bothered.  He assured me there will be many opportunities for public input because the project very likely will require a full Environmental Impact Report (EIR).

    Somehow, I just don’t trust that.

    Please contact your County Supervisor, and demand a moratorium on lithium battery energy storage systems until there is a more restrictive Ordinance for our County on this issue, and demand a technical advisory committee be formed that will develop this Ordinance…not the New Leaf Energy CEO or Carlos Palacios, the County Administrative Officer who sits on the Operations Board of Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) and depends on BESS facilities to fulfill the company mission. (Former County Supervisor Bruce McPherson sits on the Policy Board) Governing Boards – Central Coast Community Energy

    EXECUTIVE ORDER FOR GROUNDWATER RECHARGE APPLIES ONLY TO 39 COUNTIES
    Last week, Governor Newsom relaxed flood measures that allow groundwater recharge without less regulation in place.  This does not include Santa Cruz County.

    The Executive Order suspends the need for a local or regional agency to determine the imminent risk of flooding based off of local planning documents. While few regional or local agencies have established the specified types of planning documents, local or regional agencies are able to determine the presence of flood conditions by other means. The Executive Order allows local and regional agencies to use readily available information and expertise to determine imminent risk. Local and regional agencies continue to be required to issue a public notification that flows are at imminent risk of flooding and inundation of lands, roads or structures.

    Technical Guidance Water Code 1242.1 – Flood Diversions for Groundwater Recharge

    Wouldn’t it make sense to allow fallow agricultural land to flood with stormwater when it is plentiful and thereby recharge the local aquifers?  Dr. Helen Dahlke at UC Davis has been working on this, upon farmers doing it themselves to raise ag well levels.
    Can California’s floods help recharge depleted groundwater supplies?

    Take a look…why can’t we do that here in appropriate areas, instead of pumping intreated sewage water that relies on expensive chemical and energy dependent treatment (aka PureWater Soquel Project) with risk of aquifer pollution?
    How to Recharge our Aquifers : Helen Dahlke

    IS ANYBODY LISTENING?
    On May 21, 2024 at the request of the Santa Cruz County Water Advisory Commission, Chair Justin Cummings, on behalf of the Board of Supervisors,  sent a letter to multiple state water regulatory agencies and elected officials and asked for a forensic analysis as to why the Big Basin Water Company (BBWC) management problems were not addressed until the point of a Court-ordered receivership resulted.

    “As a critical partner in helping to stabilize BBWC and plan for the water and wastewater resilience of thousands of residents, Santa Cruz County sees an opportunity to draw attention to both the successes and shortcomings that have shaped the current situation.  The County requests that relevant state agencies and representatives involved in private utility oversight capture lessons-learned so they can be built upon to ensure that the hardships and uncertainties felt by BBWC customers are not repeated around the state, especially following a natural disaster.”

    The letter was sent to the following, in an effort to learn how to better serve the public.  However, a Public Records Act request with the County reveals that NONE of the recipients has responded to date.

    Jennifer Epp
    Waste Discharge Requirements Program Manager
    Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board
    895 Aerovista Place, Suite 101
    San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-7906

    Jonathan Weininger
    District Engineer, Monterey District  Division of Drinking Water
    State Water Resources Control Board
    1 Lower Ragsdale Drive, Building 1, Suite 120
    Monterey, CA 93940

    The Honorable Alice Busching Reynolds
    President, California Public Utilities Commission
    505 Van Ness Avenue
    San Francisco, CA 94102

    Why does this matter?  Because the Big Basin Water Company, a small privately-owned water company is just the tip of the iceberg.  Forced receivership and consolidation is on the horizon for others.

    Please contact your County Supervisor and ask that they follow up with the officials who received the Board’s May 21, 2024 letter.  Better yet, contact the recipients yourself and discuss the issue.

    MEANWHILE…LEGISLATION TO FORCE CONSOLIDATION IS MOVING ALONG
    The February 5, 2025  Santa Cruz County LAFCO meeting included Item 7c, reviewing a water report from UC Berkeley and UCLA, along with this discussion and recommendation: (pages 15-39)

    In order to address the ongoing challenges in advancing the State’s interest in making public water systems more resilient through consolidations, with a specific focus on disadvantaged and otherwise underserved communities, a stakeholder group was formed with representatives from the two universities, CWC, LCJA, and various LAFCOs. Attachment 2 provides a copy of a joint letter signed by the stakeholders to advance the water report’s recommendations. Specifically, the letter identifies three legislative proposals:

    • Amplify MSRs Role in Communicating Community Needs
    Amend California Government Code 56430 and its provisions on preparing municipal service reviews to require LAFCOs to take up these studies at noticed hearings as well as require the affected agencies to formally receive the studies at their own noticed hearing and providing confirmation of doing so back to LAFCOs.

    • Expand LAFCOs ability to initiate organizations and reorganizations under certain circumstances Amend California Government Code 56375(a) and its enumeration of LAFCO initiating powers to support timely water or wastewater services consistent with community needs.

    • Address Service Barriers for Mutual Water Companies and Mobile Home Parks Amend California Government Code 56036 and its definition of “special district” for LAFCO purposes to include mutual water companies. Similarly, amend California Corporations Code Section 14300 to address known gaps.

    Next Steps
    The stakeholder group is currently developing support documents such as a fact sheet for additional context and a first draft of the proposed bill language. Additionally, the group is searching for possible bill authors. Santa Cruz LAFCO is currently scheduling meetings with our local representatives, including but not limited to Senator John Laird, to discuss the recent water report and potential bill.”

    Stay tuned and ask LAFCO to hold a long-promised and required Public Event relating to water issues.

    CENTER FOR FARMWORKER FAMILIES AND PFAS IN BUENA VISTA MIGRANT CAMP
    The Buena Vista Migrant Camp and adjacent Tierra Alta wells have the highest PFAS levels in the County. Farmworker reality tour

    Santa Cruz County Public Library Presentations
    All library talks are free and open to the public. We recommend arriving at least 10 minutes early to secure your seat.

    Saturday, February 15, 3-4:15pm: Boulder Creek Branch Library
    13390 W Park Ave, Boulder Creek, CA 95006

    Thursday, March 13, 6:30-7:45pm: Capitola Branch Library
    2005 Wharf Rd, Capitola, CA 95010

    Thursday, April 24, 6:30-7:45pm: Garfield Park Branch Library
    705 Woodrow Ave, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

    *Date TBD*: Live Oak Annex @ Simpkins Swim Center
    979 17th Ave, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

    CAPITOLA WILL SPEND $4.7 MILLION TO RENOVATE JADE STREET COMMUNITY CENTER
    Community Center Renovation Project Recommended Action: Staff recommends the City Council:

    1. approve the construction contract for the Capitola Community Center Renovation Project with SSB Contracting, Inc. in the amount of $4,726,000, including selected additive alternates.;
    2. authorize the Public Works Department to issue a notice to proceed upon final contract execution;
    3. approve Amendment 3 to the Professional Services Agreement with Boone Low Ratliff Architects for design consultant services for the Project in the amount of $18,320, for a total contract amount of $579,033; and
    4. adopt a resolution adopting the NEPA and CEQA determination and amending the FY 2024-25 Budget.

    Exterior improvements will include replacing the building’s roof and siding, repairing or replacing rafters and concrete piers, and addressing damaged stucco walls. New windows will be added, and all existing exterior doors and windows will be replaced. A shed roof will be installed at the main entry to provide a welcoming and sheltered entrance. Inside the building, the upgrades will include the addition of a single-user accessible restroom, a new office, and a permanent divider between two meeting spaces. Existing offices, the reception area, restrooms, and the kitchen will be enhanced with new finishes throughout. Modern mechanical systems, including a new HVAC system, water heater, and electrical upgrades, will ensure the building operates efficiently.

    To improve accessibility, upgrades will be made to the parking area and the paths of travel to ensure compliance with current accessibility standards. In addition to the core project, three additive alternates were included in the bid to provide flexibility based on available funding. These alternates focus on landscaping and irrigation, kitchen and acoustic upgrades, generator enhancements, audio/visual (AV) equipment, and exterior site improvements (such as electric vehicle (EV) charging stations). Although budget constraints prevent the full realization of the outdoor improvements in this phase, the project has been designed to allow for future-phased work as additional funding becomes available.

    Regular Meeting of the Capitola City Council – 6 PM, January 30

    PROPOSED SANTA CRUZ SEABRIGHT AND MIDTOWN BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT FEES…MAKE SURE YOU SPEAK UP!

    A “No” Vote is Not Enough, California Appellate Court Holds

    When it comes to assessments for business improvement districts, voting “no” is not enough to exhaust one’s administrative remedies. For a property owner to preserve the right to challenge a BID assessment, the property owner must provide the reasons for its objection to the assessment during the public hearing on the BID formation, in addition to submitting a ballot opposing the assessment, a California Appellate Court has held.

    In Hill RHF Housing Partners, L.P. et al. v. City of Los Angeles, et al., businesses and property owners challenged the City’s recently formed BIDs. The BIDs were formed under the Property and Business Improvement District Law of 1994, and are authorized to fund public improvements benefiting assessed property within the BIDs through the levy of an assessment. Because the assessments would be levied on property, the City was required to comply with the requirements of Proposition 218 in addition to those in the PBID Law.

    Consequently, prior to forming the BIDs, the City mailed a notice of public hearing and assessment ballot to property owners within the proposed BIDs’ boundaries. At the public hearing, affected property owners had the opportunity to state objections to the proposed BIDs, and the City was required to consider all objections or protests prior to forming the BIDs and levying the assessments. However, the petitioners did not present written or oral testimony at or prior to the hearing stating the reasons for their objections. PBID Law and Proposition 218 prohibit approval of such assessments if a majority of the ballots returned opposed formation of the BIDs and the assessments. There was no majority protest, and the BIDs were established.

    The petitioners then filed a petition for writ of mandate, alleging (among other things) that the assessments’ special benefit allocation was flawed. While the trial court denied the petitions on the merits, the Second District Court of Appeal on June 29 affirmed the judgment on the threshold issue of whether the petitioners had exhausted their administrative remedies.

    Parties in California must exhaust administrative remedies before resorting to the courts so that agencies have an opportunity to reach a reasoned and final conclusion on issues being contested. Exhausting administrative remedies narrows the scope of claims on judicial review, facilitates the development of a factual record, gives the agency a meaningful opportunity to apply its expertise and may even render litigation unnecessary.

    Accordingly, submitting a “no” vote in the BID assessment did not exhaust administrative remedies, where the BID formation process required the City to consider all objections prior to acting on the BID formation. A “no” vote does not allow the agency to address a property owner’s grievance. Rather, objections must be “sufficiently specific so as to allow the agency the opportunity to evaluate and respond.” At minimum, property owners must submit a ballot and state the reasons for their objections at the public hearing, either verbally or in writing.

    Property Owners Must Participate in Public Hearing to Challenge BID Assessments

    The Eastsife/Midtown Business Improvement Development Plan came before the City Council on January 23 and the petition process to evaluate the costs is now on the move.   It is critical that you speak up about this at every opportunity, or you will not be able to challenge it in the future.

    She kindly sent the information below about what residents and businesses can expect going forward. The City Council will review it January 23, along with a review of the Downtown Economic Plan. City Council AGENDA REPORT, Agenda of 01/23/2024

    It appears to be scheduled as a benefit assessment and Prop. 218 vote, likely weighted so that those whose assessments would be highest will have more power at the ballot box:

    IMPLEMENTATION PHASE
    January 2025:
    • Final MDP and Engineer’s Report upon City review
    • Prepare petitions and petition packets to include Management District Plan
    • Summary, PBID newsletter, official petition, and petition instructions
    • City Council Study Session – Status Update

    February 2025:
    • Petition kick-off (allow 3 months)

    April 2025:
    • City Council approves Resolution of Intention and calls for public hearing;
    • Assessment ballots mailed to all assessed property owners

    June 2025:
    • City Council public hearing, tabulate ballots (45 days later)

    This sums up alot….

    “Development in the pipeline and currently in construction is rapidly changing our physical environment downtown. As more than 1200 housing units are absorbed into the downtown community over the course of the next five years, we will need to regularly revisit circulation, parking use, and consumer and transportation behavior as needs in our downtown core change.”

    (page 6 of the City Council agenda report)

    Here is information about a Downtown PBID

    Do you think this will help businesses or add just one more financial burden?

    A NEW GROUP TO ADVISE ON COUNTY FIRE ISSUES
    Next Tuesday , County Board of Supervisors will consider approving the process to form a new Fire Department Advisory Group that will  advise the General Services Dept. Director, Mr. Michael Beaton, for the next couple years during what is likely to be major consolidation and reorganization.

    “In fulfilling these duties, the FDAG will explore alternatives to the governance structure of County Fire, with a focus on making it more effective. The FDAG will collaborate with other fire agencies and groups concerned about fire and emergency services to examine options for improving services for all who live and work in Santa Cruz County. The FDAG will operate without formal bylaws and will not be governed by the Brown Act. In accordance with Santa Cruz County Code Section 2.38.071(A)(5), alternate procedures concerning public participation, noticing of meetings, quorum requirements, minutes, and any other appropriate matters will be provided.”

    See item #10:
    Chapter 2.38 BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, COMMITTEES AND DEPARTMENT ADVISORY GROUPS

    According to the Operating Procedures in Tuesday’s agenda packet, the new FDAG  will meet only on an as-needed basis.  FDAG meetings will not require a quorum of its membership, or any minimum attendance of members.

    While some FDAG meetings will not be held publicly, the public will be able to access the FDAG meeting notice, standing agenda, and minutes for those meetings by either independently viewing them on the County Fire Department website or by requesting the materials to be sent electronically, as available.

    Does this seem like open and transparent government to you?? I just don’t think this is an improvement over the former Fire Department Advisory Commission that the Board and CAO Carlos Palacios dissolved last year.  Please write your Supervisor with your thoughts, and participate in the Tuesday, February 11 meeting if you are able.

    WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  CONTACT YOUR COUNTY SUPERVISOR ABOUT PROPOSED LITHIUM BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM PROJECT IN WATSONVILLE…AND DEMAND A MORATORIUM.

    MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

    Cheers,
    Becky

    Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

    Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

    ...
    The Importance of Cows

    Without large ungulate grazing both wildlife and plant species disappear in grasslands, including California’s coastal prairies. Domesticated cattle (Bos taurus) can be managed in such a way as to provide for those disturbances if wild ungulates have been locally extirpated, which unfortunately they have in many places. People hope that one day native ungulates can take the place of cattle, but those species are nowhere close to being successfully restored in most places. These stories are not told often enough, so many people have opinions about cattle that are unfounded and destructive. Let’s change that.

    What Do Cattle Do?

    I challenge the reader to compare fence lines or to walk in places with varied cattle grazing regimes. It goes best to slow down and take notes on what you see. Noticing things in nature can be exhilarating; it takes you out of your normal thoughts. Guided and focused investigations are helpful to some people in pursuing this observational state. The following are my observations, which I challenge you to confirm or question.

    One Dr. Weiss has wisely proclaimed, ‘Cattle graze globally and deposit locally.’ That “global” grazing removes biomass, reducing thatch aka litter. With too little ungulate grazing, plant litter accumulates for many years, blocking sunlight from hitting the ground. This biomass accumulation can also intercept rainfall, which subsequently evaporates before it reaches the ground.  Managed correctly, cattle grazing reduces the growth of taller species, allowing short-statured plants access to sunlight. Very short grasslands are not good for often invasive slugs and snails, which devour wildflowers. Cattle prefer to eat grasses over wildflowers. In the absence of well-managed cattle grazing, a few very competitive, tall stature plants dominate to the detriment of the many shorter and lesser competitive species, especially wildflowers.

    What Do Tule Elk Do?

    Once upon a time, there were herds of tule elk roaming the Monterey Bay area. I visited an old cabin in Soquel once where there was a hunting trophy tule elk head from the early 1800’s, collected somewhere nearby. Studies comparing tule elk and cattle grazing at Point Reyes suggest that the two species are very comparable in their diet. One can visit tule elk easiest at Point Reyes National Seashore and at Coyote Ridge Trail in Santa Clara. At Coyote Ridge, tule elk are found alongside cattle, which are being managed to restore endangered wildlife and plants.

    Touring Elkdom

    In order to see how the species is affecting the landscape, I visited a population of tule elk near Limantour Beach at Point Reyes, where the species has long been allowed to roam freely. There is no cattle grazing in the coastal prairies there- tule elk are the only large ungulate at that location. Evidence of the grassland stewardship role of elk was scant: only a few patches were grazed to an appreciable level, so species requiring more grazing disturbance were absent. There aren’t enough elk, or the elk that are there are not concentrated in grasslands enough, to create short stature habitat supporting annual wildflowers. Unlike in cattle-grazed areas of the park, there were no patches of the rare San Francisco owl’s clover or Point Reyes Horkelia and no stands of native violets to support the endangered Point Reyes silverspot butterfly. It seemed to me that coastal prairies at that location were fast disappearing – shrubs like coyote bush were well established and proliferating, and the patches of grassy areas were few and small.

    I next explored areas of marsh and dense coastal scrub to see how tule elk were impacting these other habitats. The large marsh that backs up behind the dunes at Limantour beach, at the outlet of a few creeks including Glenbrook Creek, is rife with elk trails. Environmentalists have long proclaimed concern about cattle interactions with wetlands and riparian areas, so much so that miles and miles of fencing has been established to protect those habitats in California. However, I noticed that the trails elk were using through the marsh created habitat complexity, creating patches of deeper, open water that might be conducive to certain sun-loving aquatic species like the rare California red-legged frog.

    In the dense scrubby patches, tule elk had roughly bulldozed into shrubs, breaking branches and creating trails in areas that had been otherwise unpassable to larger mammals. I saw grasses and wildflowers establishing along those trails and wondered if coyotes, bobcats, mountain lions and more were using those pathways as well to hunt.

    Cattle Management

    Aren’t cattle unnatural? That’s a question posed by those doubting the role of cattle on conservation lands. The few that recognize the role of grazing at maintaining coastal prairies are mainly comfortable only if this is done my native species…tule elk. Very, very few people appreciate the need to manage cattle grazing to mimic the natural disturbances requisite for ecological restoration and conservation. Those that do have that appreciation know too little about what ‘management’ means.

    Managing cattle requires articulating goals, prescribing a grazing regime, monitoring, and adapting management in response to monitoring data. I have heard such unrealistic goals as ‘increase all native grasses’ or ‘decrease all exotic species’ or ‘restore to 80% cover of native species’ or ‘create dense native grasses with healthy populations of native annual wildflowers.’ There are 300 species of native grasses in California; at any site in our region there might be 10. Each native grass species, each exotic species, has a particular life history that responds differently to cattle grazing: we need more specific goals to inform management. Every footprint you make in coastal prairie, even the best examples remaining of that habitat, comes to rest on 80% cover of non native species. We may never return to 80% cover of native species, but if we do it will undoubtedly be of a handful of tall, very competitive grasses rather than a diverse assemblage. To paraphrase the esteemed R. Morgan, grasses aren’t the answer, they are the problem. Even native grasses outcompete native wildflowers.

    Cattle grazing regimes are complex to proscribe, but let’s see how that works. Another quote is in order, from Deb Hillyard: “Saying ‘grazing’ is like saying ‘weather.’ You wouldn’t say ‘weather is good.'” These things need some qualification. Grazing regimes alter the number of animals, the breed of cattle (weight, behavior), the ‘class’ of animal (bulls, newborns, heifers, stockers, etc), how long a herd is in what size of pasture, how often they return to that pasture, how long of an interval of ‘rest’ between grazing incidents, how much they move around the pasture, and where water and supplemental food is placed in the pasture (etc). All of those things can drastically affect how the coastal prairie responds. Next time you encounter cattle, see how many of those qualifications you can remember and see if there are clues to help define them.

    If we learn to be literate in tule elk…in cattle…in coastal prairie stewardship…we will be a step closer to restoring ourselves alongside this beautiful and diverse landscape.

    Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

    Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

    ...

    The above picture accompanied an opinion column that appeared in the San Jose Mercury News on Sunday, February 2, 2025. The column was authored by Jeff Smith, who is described as “a lawyer and medical doctor.” We are also informed that Smith retired in 2023, after serving for fourteen years as County Executive of Santa Clara County.

    The title on Smith’s column was this: “Empire In Decline: Americans Have Lost Faith In United System Of Governance.” That is a serious assertion. I have reproduced the entirety of the column at the bottom of this blog post, so those reading this blog posting can truly appreciate the implications of what Smith is claiming.

    Do let me say that Smith makes no assertion that the picture above should be seen as a group portrait of people who are gathered together in some governmental building to assert their loss of faith in our government. In fact, while the photo is not identified, it appears to me to be a picture of the United States House of Representatives – and maybe Senators are present, too.

    I was, I must say, stunned by Smith’s column in The Mercury News. It was Smith’s use of the “past tense” that got me! While Smith holds out a “riduculously small” amount of “hope” for our nation, that smidgen of hope that Smith says we have is absolutely inconsistent with his use of the past tense.

    If we have “lost” faith (past tense) and if our system of government has truly “failed” (past tense), then our opportunity to have the kind of government that Smith wants us to have (and that we all want to have) is no longer an option.

    Smith either (1) doesn’t really believe that the past tense is being correctly applied in his column (and is using the past tense, presumably, for rhetorical purposes); or (2) Smith is simply unable or unwilling to face the implications of his own analysis. If our system of government has truly “failed,” as he asserts, then the efforts that began in 1776 are now complete. The final report is in, and we have definitively “failed” to establish and sustain a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people,” which is how President Abraham Lincoln described what our government was all about. Indeed, Smith claims that our nation “failed” a long time ago.

    Looking at the news reported in the same edition of the newspaper in which Smith’s column ran, it is pretty clear to me that those who have taken control of the Executive Branch of our government, thanks to the election of Donald Trump to the presidency, are acting like the “we failed” analysis is the correct one. As I say, this is really a serious issue – and stipulating to the “we failed” analysis means it’s “Game Over” for self-government in the United States of America.

    Before saying more about our alleged “failure,” let me move on to the “lost faith” assertion. Smith asserts that it is a “fact” that the American people, collectively, no longer have any faith that we have a government that is, to repeat Lincoln’s wonderful phrasing, “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” In fact, Smith claims that no one believes that such a government is even possible.

    You can check back to my recent blog posting featuring the music of Leonard Cohen, in which his lyrics proclaim that “everybody knows that the fight is fixed; the poor stay poor and the rich get rich.” Smith absolutely agrees with these lyrics, and he doesn’t suggest that we could ever sing a different song. “Everybody knows. That just how it goes.”

    Smith uses a strange phrase in making his argument that our government experiment has “failed,” and that we have “lost faith” in the idea that democratic self-government is even possible. Smith claims that this “failure” and “loss of faith” diagnosis is correct because we do not have a “united system of governance.” That’s the strange phrase I am talking about. What does Smith mean by a “united system of governance”? As I read his column, he seems to mean that we don’t have a situation in which everyone agrees that rich White males and other wealthy people should  relinquish some of their wealth, power and privilege to benefit society as a whole. “That is not going to happen,” Smith states.

    Well, to use a technical term: DUH!

    Since when have we ever thought that our system of government was based on consensus, on the idea that everyone will be “united” in agreement? In fact, our politics and government is based on the opposite idea, and on the recognition that people profoundly disagree on just about everything. Our system is supposed to get those who disagree to make decisions that a majority can “accept.” That happens only when those who are dissatisfied with the current situation build their political power. (Hint: you have to get personally engaged if you want that to happen). Given that Smith appears to think that we must have a “united” government, in which people would agree on what he says they will never agree on, it is hard to understand where Smith thinks that “ridiculously small” window of opportunity might come from. If Smith is right about needing a “united” system of governance, you can board over that window of opportunity right now.

    Let’s think about how radical Smith’s claims actually are. Smith is basically saying that what most people call “democracy” has “failed” in the United States (not that it is “imperiled,” or “in danger,” but that it has “failed,” and that we have, moreover, “lost faith” that it can ever be restored (although Smith does note that “revolution” may be an available option, which doesn’t sound too attractive to me, if he means that I should find a gun and start killing those rich people with whom I am in disagreement).

    When impossibilty is the premise – which is exactly the case with Smith – nothing can be done. If Smith is speaking as a “spectator,” then his predictions of failure may be correct, but when he opines that all of our possibilities are in “the past,” and when he talks like “it’s all over,” then we know that he has missed the truth of our real situation.

    In reality, we are facing real, and dangerous, and daunting obstacles to creating the kind of society and government we’d like to make work for “we, the people.” That’s true. That’s the “present tense.” As for the future, our actions now will determine how the future turns out.

    Would you like to sit around and feel defeated? Read Jeff Smith!

    Would you like to do something about what you don’t like, and what needs to be changed? That requires action – and there isn’t going to be any action, or any “resistance,” if we have truly “lost faith” and stipulate to the fact that we have “failed” in the never-ending challenge of self-government!

    Find a small group of friends to support you, people whom you can support, too, and then get to work!

    PS: You will have to reallocate how you use your time!

    oooOOOooo

    Jeff Smith: We have lost faith in our united system of governance
    Bay Area leader says the ‘great American experiment in government’ has failed, and we have been in denial for years
    We Americans have a huge problem that we do not want to face directly.

    We have lost faith in our united system of governance. Only 64% of eligible adults voted in the 2024 presidential election and far fewer vote in gubernatorial elections. A large group of Americans do not believe it matters who is in office or what happens in government.

    Even those who vote often make decisions based upon scant or misleading information. In the modern era, “alternative facts” are a shield against reality. Denial is an enormously powerful tool that allows us to avoid any individual responsibility for our situation. The kernel of truth that we do not want to face is that the failure of our nation is our fault.

    The “great American experiment in government” failed long ago, and we have been in denial about that for many years.

    Why did we fail? Can it be fixed? Should we just start over? I believe the answers to these questions are simple and everyone knows the truth deep down.The answer to the “why” question starts with our founding documents. What the Founding Fathers meant by “all men are created equal” and “endowed … with certain unalienable Rights,” is not what it sounds like today. To them “all men” meant rich, White male property owners — not women, not people of color, not those without property, and certainly not poor people, slaves or Indigenous people.

    From the start, our country has struggled to make sense of the inherent conflict between language, practice and intent. Racism, xenophobia, misogyny and unchecked avarice are built into our society and our laws. Indeed, the history of the United States is understood best as a series of conflicts about these very issues. We failed because we have never honestly resolved these conflicts.

    Should we burn it down and start a new plutocracy? The answer is also obvious.

    We are doing that right now! Many powerful empires/countries have come and gone. Very few lasted more than 350 years. Essentially all failed when the disparity of wealth and opportunity among the citizens became so massive that most felt that revolution was their only practical choice.

    The United States is remarkably close to that point now. In fact, we may have already passed it. The nation’s 800 billionaires hold more wealth than half the nation. Those at the bottom have been starved of the opportunity to succeed, and many of them are women, people of color, and stuck in generational poverty created by the wealthy who control government. Remembering Lincoln’s famous quote, “a house divided cannot stand.”? We are there.

    Can it be “fixed”? No! Not with the current structure. Fixing the current system would require that rich, White males and others relinquish some of their wealth, power and privilege. That is not going to happen since the system protects themThe only peaceful way to change the entire system requires the participation of all citizens. The privileged class must accept the fact that their behavior is bad for everyone, including themselves.

    Is there hope? Yes, but the window of opportunity for change is ridiculously small. The entire world knows that the U in USA is a fantasy. Will we admit it to ourselves and take the action necessary to honestly call ourselves united? I do not know [emphasis added].

    Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

    Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

    ...

    UNELECTED BARNACLE, IT’S A COUP, IMPEACHMENT?

    Couple of valid entries on social media last week: “They should invent a January that doesn’t drain your will to live!” Sort of fits in with some of the other mopey posts in evidence. And a perfect companion would be this: “Anyone know which wine pairs with societal collapse?” That one may be more valid when we examine what is coming to pass in DC with King Donald and the unelected co-president Elon MuskSteve Schmidt on his The Warning blog writes that the two, along with Musk’s goons, are locking government officials out of their computers, offices and buildings as they demand access to the governments payment systems, asserting powers they have no right to assert. To which Schmidt declares, “Heil Trump! King Donald has stomped and huffed and shaken things up.” One outstanding question: Has Musk taken an oath, like the federal workers he has plans to fire, to uphold the Constitution? Musk, an unelected barnacle (as Rolling Stone’s Nikki Ramirez calls him) to King Donald is now ensconced as head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) despite lacking Congressional approval, being tasked by Trump to find ways to slash government spending, reduce bureaucracy, and do away with regulations. As Ramirez notes, DOGE has little legal authority to execute cuts, and no mandate to meddle with the Treasury, but his entanglement with the administration has him influencing every aspect of policy. According to The Washington Post, after Trump’s November victory, Musk and his thug team have been requesting access to payment systems under the Bureau of the Fiscal Service which controls distribution of more than $6 trillion in annual funds, such as Social SecurityMedicare benefits, tax refunds, and federal salaries. Now he has crashed through the doorway with complete control.

    Treasury official, Mark Mazur, told The Post“This is a mechanical job, paying benefits, vendors, whatever. It’s not one where there’s a role for non-mechanical things, at least from a career standpoint — your whole job is to pay the bills as they are due. It’s never been used in a way to execute a partisan agenda. You have to really put bad intentions in place for that to be the case.” Which calls into question why Musk/DOGE are seeking access in Trump’s hard-right takeover of the government. According to Wired magazine, Musk has been able to place three close allies at the head of the Office of Personnel Management, who has sent emails to employees encouraging them to resign, offering them several months of paid leave, but as Rolling Stone reports, “While the administration is pitching the resignation offers as ‘a nice vacation,’ they could still be forced to work.” This resignation letter is quite similar to the one Musk sent to Twitter employees after he bought the social media platform — we saw how that all went down — or came down!  Musk is getting off on his newfound power, but word is circulating that Trump’s inner circle is getting frustrated with Musk’s abuses of his proximity to the president. One Trump ally said to Politico that abuse is clear, however the president has no leverage over the situation and Elon couldn’t care less. So, here we are with the world’s richest man whose companies have grown fat on US government contracts, and now he has a greater financial interest in how the government operates than your average naturalized immigrant. Rolling Stone’s Ramirez asks, “Is it a blatant conflict of interest to have the world’s richest man continue to profit off his investments while serving in a uniquely powerful and virtually unchecked role over US policy, regulation, government spending, and investment? Yes! Will Republicans do anything to stop it? Don’t hold your breath.”

    Back in NovemberMusk and his then-partner in DOGEVivek Ramaswamy, laid out some of their ideas to the Wall Street Journal about their plans. First, mass firings were threatened to reduce employment by resignations to the minimum to accomplish the constitutionally permissible and statutorily mandated functions, after which Trump could suspend worker protections to enforce a “mass head-count reduction across the federal bureaucracy.” In light of recent events, how many air traffic controllers does he think might be the absolute minimum? With help from the Supreme Court they hoped to usurp new power with would allow Trump to ignore Congress and not spend money, something called impoundment. A $500B cut in spending would target items like foreign aid and public broadcasting, already evidenced by Trump’s attempt to throttle federal grants. Some targets might have merit, such as examination of federal contracting and procurement, but when Medicare becomes a subject of discussion it gets scary, despite Trump’s pledge to protect safety net spending. As Senator Ron Wyden said, “I can think of no good reason why political operators who have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the law would need access to these sensitive, mission-critical systems. Americans don’t want an unelected and unaccountable billionaire dictating what working families can and cannot afford.” Fears are heightened that Musk and Trump’s cronies are attempting to gain authoritarian control over the government by ousting or sidelining career civil servants and undermining Congress, which has the constitutional authority to decided how the government should spend its money. Representative Pramila Jayapal wrote, “Musk is rooting around in Social Security and Medicare payment systems. He’s reaching his hands into our pockets and firing anyone who tries to stop him. This reeks of corruption — it must stop.” Senator Elizabeth Warren called for this “alarming” news to be investigated by Congress.

    The New York Times was told that no payments had yet been blocked and that the stated mission of DOGE is to review payments, not stop them. Musk suggested on X that he was only looking for inappropriate expenditures, but also that blocking funds might be appropriate. He went on to say that it was discovered that payment approval officers at Treasury were instructed always to approve payments — they literally never denied a payment in their entire career. Former Treasury officials told the Times that funds are dispersed by a comparatively small staff who rely on the agencies that earmark the funds to vet them, and while there are certain automatic safeguards in place, it was not the role of Treasury to approve or reject specific payments. Lindsay Owens of Groundwork Collaborative wrote: “The Treasury system cuts the checks — Musk has infiltrated the system to stop payments. It’s a COUP!” Owens in an op-ed seen on MSNBC outlined three reasons why Musk might want to access the Treasury payment system: 1) Stop payments to certain programs in order to work around the courts’ block on the administration’s spending freeze. 2) Access list of blacklisted federal contractors in order to boost his own or friend’s companies and harm his competitors. 3) Reduce Social Security or Medicare payments as part of DOGE’s goal of cutting $2 trillion from federal spending. Owens notes that Musk isn’t “chasing these cuts for their own sake. He’s helping congressional Republicans attempt to pay for a new round of tax breaks for corporations and the ultra-wealthy — including himself.” A recent poll finding reveals that only around one-third of Americans approve of DOGE and that 52% disapprove of Musk. Olivia Rosane of Common Dreams offers, “If Musk is going to continue running the government like one of his failed businesses, perhaps someone should force his ‘resignation’ too,” and as Michael Phelan of Social Security Works says, “We need to raise holy hell to STOP this.” Asha Rangrappa of The Freedom Academy offers, “In the end, ending this insanity will likely be up to us, the people. Perhaps when people see that their own bottom line is under the control of an unelected, unconfirmed, foreign national billionaire who has no allegiance to the US government, it will spur action in the streets.”

    The non-profit Free Speech for People is heading up a new nonpartisan campaign to solicit support for President Trump’s removal from office — ‘Impeach Trump Again’ — with a report that over 100,000 signatures have been obtained on their petition. The group is encouraging Congress to launch an impeachment investigation, claiming that their petition shows “widespread support,” and that the public is unwilling to accept a King Trump“We need bold leaders in Congress willing to stand up and hold Trump accountable for his abuses of power and initiate an inquiry,” said director Alexandra Flores-Quilty. Sadly, we are in short supply of bold leaders. A post on Quora asks if Trump can be buried at Arlington National Cemetery, drawing this reply: “Last time I checked, it is explicitly illegal to bury someone anywhere who is still alive. However, former presidents CAN be buried there, though it could contaminate the ground, insulting every other human being interred in that sacred ground. Arlington is primarily for military veterans who served honorably, veterans who were decorated during their service; so since Trump is a cowardly, lying draft dodger who has insulted, demeaned, and degraded veterans, having his body anywhere around that hallowed ground would be a slap in the face to every veteran and their family who had ever served this country.”

    At this writing, the country and the world, are reeling from Trump’s calamitous misadventure of implementing tariffs upon our three biggest trading partners: CanadaMexico, and China, all of whom have promised retaliatory measures. Canada and Mexico said their responses would be implementation of their own tariffs against the US, with China saying it would file a lawsuit with the World Trade Organization and enact “necessary countermeasures.” Like taking over the Pana-MAGA Canal? Trump gave a start date of last Tuesday, pronouncing the levies would remain in place “until the crisis is alleviated,” meaning the flow of drugs and undocumented immigrants into this country. Tit-for-tat tariffs from this trio of trading partners could send prices soaring for consumers in the US and world-wide. A press conference by Prime Minister Trudeau indicated Canada would levy tariffs on Tuesday on $30B worth of US goods, with additional tariffs in the coming weeks “to allow Canadian companies and supply chains to seek alternatives.” Trudeau said the long history of the US-Canada alliance should lead to a better path without Trump’s punishment, while warning US citizens that this move “will have real consequences for you, the American people.” He also encouraged Canadians to opt for Canadian-made goods over American products, or changing summer vacation plans to stay in Canada. No comments were forthcoming from the White House.

    Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum posted on X that she has instructed the implementation of Plan B, which has been standing by in anticipation of Trump’s tariffs. The plan includes “tariffs and non-tariffs in defense of Mexico’s interests,” but no details were announced. Sheinbaum slammed the tariffs, saying in her X post, “We categorically reject the White House’s slander of the Government of Mexico alleging alliances with criminal organizations, as well as any intention to interfere in our territory,” adding, “Mexico not only does not want fentanyl to reach the US, it does not want it reach anywhere. Therefore, if the US wants to combat the criminal groups that traffic drugs and generate violence, we must work together in a comprehensive manner, but always under the principles of shared responsibility, mutual trust, collaboration and above all, respect for sovereignty, which is non-negotiable. Coordination, yes; subordination, no.” Trump is probably still wrestling with his Webster’s to understand what she posted, or perhaps texting Elon for answers, but then again, he probably doesn’t care.

    China’s filing a lawsuit with the WTO may have little effect since the US has blocked the appointment of appellate judges to the organization for years, which leaves it unable to mediate international trade disputes. Therefore, China’s action may only serve to gather international support against Trump’s tariffs. The Chinese Ministry of Commerce said in a statement, “China calls on the US to correct its mistakes, work toward mutual understanding, engage in candid dialogue, strengthen cooperation, and manage differences on the basis of equality, mutual benefit, and mutual respect. Additional tariffs are not constructive and bound to affect and harm the counternarcotics cooperation between the two sides in the future.” Of course, none of those words and phrases are in Trump’s vocabulary and it’s way too late for him to implement any of them personally, or in his business practices, or in his destruction of the federal government. Both China and Mexico say they have taken steps to address the flow of fentanyl and to stem international flow of the precursor ingredients, so it’s up to the US to address its own domestic demand for the drug. The Chinese government may try to side-step a trade war, since it is still struggling to recover from the COVID pandemic, but pressure will likely mount, giving the Chinese government the impetus to respond, using a new December 1 law which gives it explicit authority to do so.

    As for the tariffs, Trump says, “We will make America great again, and it will all be worth the price that must be paid, we are a country that is now being run with common sense — and the results will be spectacular!!!” No one knows exactly what the impact will be on American consumers, nor how long the tariffs will be in play, but if they should remain if effect for a long period, Trump’s “pain” will become a solid reality. Your next cup of coffee may be more expensive, with prices increasing after Trump and Colombia had a spat over deportation flights — the president reversed a 25% tariff on the country when an agreement was reached. So even though the tariff never happened, coffee markets were rattled by the aspect of tariffs, resulting in price increases in coffee futures. Coffee prices have been increasing over the past several months due to bad weather which has reduced growers’ yield, so Trump’s threat threw unexpected uncertainty into the global trade system which is racing to keep up with increasing demand. Producers will probably continue to gradually increase prices simply as a hedge against the possibility of tariffs, though companies such as KeurigStarbucks and Nestle lock in prices years in advance which will make them immune, for awhile, to the dynamics of the Trump administration.

    About Trump’s tariffs (“the most beautiful word in the dictionary,” he says) announcement, journalist SV Dáte wrote that Trump announced he has increased taxes on Americans by $297B a year. Conservative Bill Kristol said, “If only we had a body, with democratic legitimacy and powers conferred by a Constitution, that could overrule a president who seeks to impose arbitrary tariffs and to deport people who fled here to escape oppression. It could be called the Congress of the United States.” Economist Marc Lévesque chimed in, “So, it’s official. Trump just violated the Canada-US-Mexico Free Trade agreement that he himself signed.” Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers called Trump’s tariffs “a self-inflicted wound to the American economy.” Trump posted, “We pay billions of dollars to subsidize Canada. Why? There is no reason. We don’t need anything they have. Therefore, Canada should become our Cherished 51st State. Much lower taxes, and far better military protection for the people of Canada…and NO TARIFFS!” To this post, Steve Schmidt says, “My friends, this is vile. In fact, it is evil. They are the words of a Putin or Xi. They are the words of international gangsterism and thuggery. These are the words of a Hitler. They are the words of the president of the United States, and they are repugnant. These are the words of expansionism and tyranny. These are the words of derangement.” Schmidt’s essay is lengthy, but poignantly he declares, “Why is this happening?…it is happening because the American Republic is collapsing. It is being destroyed from within, as Lincoln predicted in 1838: ‘…if destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher…'”

    We might reflect on the words of Ronald Reagan who said, “Our peaceful trading partners aren’t our enemies; they are our allies. We should beware of he demagogues who are ready to declare a trade war against our friends — weakening our economy, our national security, and the entire free world — all while cynically waving the American flag.” Or perhaps as Steve Schmidt says, “Fascism has come to America and it is wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.” And as Trump says, “Let them eat cake!”

    With markets and businesses awakening on Monday morning to the advent of the tariffs, stocks fell, energy costs surged, but word of an agreement from Trump and Mexico’s Sheinbaum to delay tariffs with Mexico agreeing to place 10,000 troops at the border, securing it from migrants, seemed to calm nerves — for now. Same goes for Canada: a 30 day reprieve with promised border security. But don’t relax just yet! That sound of hammering and objects hitting the floor and doors being slammed? That’s Elon Musk and his goons chipping away at our government. Gosh, if only we had a body we might call the Congress of the United States!

    Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
     

    ...

    EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

    EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    Football

    “You can’t be a real country unless you have a beer and an airline. It helps if you have some kind of a football team, or some nuclear weapons, but at the very least you need a beer.”
    ~Frank Zappa

    “Gentlemen, it is better to have died as a small boy than to fumble this football.”
    ~John Heisman

    “Football is a simple game. Twenty-two men chase a ball for 90 minutes and at the end, the Germans always win.”
    ~Gary Lineker

    “Without football, my life is worth nothing.”
    ~Cristiano Ronaldo

    “I was missing out on public school and going to the football games, prom or homecomings. But I’ve been to three World Championships… so I think it’s like a win-win.”
    ~Simone Biles

    ...

    Some of the most unexpected words in the English language actually came from the Vikings. Bet you didn’t know, huh?


    COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

    Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
    (Gunilla Leavitt)

    ...

    Deep Cover

    Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

    January 29 – February 4, 2025

    Highlights this week:

    Greensite… on Traffic Study for the Downtown Extension Project… Steinbruner… Never Again Moss Landing, Supervisors loath to take action on Battery Energy Storage problems; bacteria eats PFAS… Hayes… Living by Principles… Patton… Executive Disorder… Matlock… time’s up?..a minor incident…an apology… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… FireAid… Quotes on… “Rebuilding”

    ...

    RONALD REAGAN AT THE CIVIC AUDITORIUM. This was taken October 8, 1966 when he was running for Governor of California against Pat Brown. Brown was trying for a third term after having to deal with the Watts riots and UC Berkeley anti-Vietnam demonstrations.

    photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

    Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

    Dateline: January 29, 2025

    REBUILDING. I made the quotes this week about rebuilding after watching the very inspiring FireAid concert on YouTube. I believe there’s a second concert tonight (Friday), and I would be very surprised if these shows can’t be found on YouTube after the fact. It brought me back to the old days of LiveAid, and I don’t only say that because some of the artists were the same… Seriously though, go check them out, they’re worth watching. You can listen/watch on every streaming service possible, and of course, you can donate. Go to FireAidLA.org.

    Enough blather from me. With my apologies for being late, let’s launch into this week’s column:

    ...

    NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

    ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

    FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

    STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

    NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

    SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

    EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

    A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

    THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

    ...

    January 27, 2025

    Traffic Tall Tales

    In a recent piece for BrattonOnline I critiqued the Transportation section of the draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the city’s Downtown Extension Project. My main criticism was that the EIR studied only Vehicle Miles Travelled (VMT) and neglected inclusion of congestion, referred to in the trade as Level of Service or LOS. Anyone who lives in the city knows that congestion is the main traffic issue in this area south of Laurel, with tourist beach traffic often gridlocked on summer weekends as in the photo from a Saturday in July. However, a recent legislative change to CEQA means that only VMT, not congestion is required to be studied for environmental review. While congestion can be studied, it cannot be used to demonstrate a significant impact, the measure by which mitigations can be required-or projects rejected.

    I was correct that the draft EIR did not study congestion, however a traffic study of LOS was done by the city, just not included in the draft EIR. Until a colleague pointed it out, I was unaware of the study which is hard to find on the city’s website. Having read it, I would like to share a few highlights so you can judge whether you agree that we are being taken as fools by the city and their consultants, at considerable taxpayers’ expense.

    The study was done because the City’s General Plan under its Transportation section requires review of congestion at intersections for new projects. Increased congestion can be addressed in minor ways such as fiddling with traffic lights or requiring developers to pay Traffic Impact Fees (TIF’s). Such “improvements” are not as robust as Mitigations under CEQA and have no standing when EIR’s are being evaluated.

    The 564-page study, titled “Santa Cruz Downtown Expansion Plan, Local Transportation Analysis” was prepared for the City of Santa Cruz by Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. The document is dense with tables and charts. The flaw is not hard to spot. It is in the quote of the study analysis below.

    Typical weekday peak hours were chosen because they represent the majority (70%) of peak travel conditions on the city roadways. The peak hour of summer Saturday traffic was not analyzed because those dates are not representative of typical travel patterns consistent with the proposed project. Kimley-Horn Inc.

    So, even if the 3,500 new residents have guests, deliveries, and outings on the weekends, it is not worthy of study because it is not “typical travel patterns” of the new residents. That seems a big assumption. The proposed project, including prior General Plan anticipated growth in the same area, is estimated to generate 6,307 new daily automobile trips. It doesn’t mention that residents will be staying home or only walking and biking on weekends.

    The consultants seem unfamiliar with this part of town. They studied AM 8-9 and PM 5-6 peak hours, “typical of weekday commutes.” The roads in the project area are largely not commute routes, unlike Mission or Bay.  The study’s other automated traffic counts were done in February, March, and October: anything it seems, to avoid peak summer weekend traffic analysis.

    According to the study, for some intersections, even without including peak summer weekends, “the project exceeds the City’s level of service standards of deficiency, causing the level of service to go from acceptable to substandard with the addition of the project trips.” But none of this will be on the table for council when the draft EIR is considered and voted on.

    Thanks Sacramento. Besides your required density bonus mandating overbuilding in Santa Cruz, making even affordable housing less affordable, you have removed an important area of environmental review. Both VMT and LOS should be studied under CEQA, not just the one.

    The consultants’ summary suggests the study bias. They write:

    The project can support the Santa Cruz vision for a vibrant and sustainable downtown area while remaining consistent with the City’s Transportation Study Guidelines. 

    Don’t forget the deadline for comments on the draft EIR is February 21.

    Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

    ...
    Never Again Moss Landing

    IS SANTA CRUZ COUNTY MONITORING METALS WHILE  FAILING TO ISSUE SAFETY CLEANUP ADVISORIES?
    Last Tuesday, the County Board of Supervisors heard an oral report from Monterey County staff as an update on the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) fire.  Mr. David Reid, Director of the Santa Cruz County Office of Response, Recovery and Resilience (OR3), who in effect is the office of emergency services, stated that since the fire occurred in Monterey County ,it is their jurisdiction to make such reports and respond.

    There has been no survey or sampling of surfaces in Santa Cruz County for heavy metals associated with the Moss Landing Battery Facility fire.

    As of this writing, the Santa Cruz County staff may possibly be providing soil and water sampling, but the extent and results are unknown.  Meanwhile, no public safety advisories or other precautionary information is being provided.  With the exception of Supervisor Manu Koenig, the Supervisors were mostly worried about who would pay for the testing.

    I wonder if they would be so reticent if they were the farmworkers who are working with bare hands in the fields with unknown levels of contamination??????

    Monterey County issued the precautionary safety cleaning information: Protecting Public Health During Fire Residual Clean-up

    Why are our County officials lagging on this potentially critical public health and safety issue?

    Here is a link to the Special Meeting of the Monterey County Board of Supervisors on January 21 to provide information to the people: Board of Supervisors on 2025-01-21 10:00 AM – Special Meeting

    Meanwhile, the Santa Cruz County Supervisors are largely sitting on their hands.  Please contact your Supervisor and the new Chair of the Board, Supervisor Felipe Hernandez. 

    Phone: 831-454-2200 
    Felipe Hernandez <felipe.hernandez@santacruzcountyca.gov>
    Pro-tip: All Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors and staff have the e-mail template of <Firstname.Lastname@santacruzcountyca.gov>

    MARSH SOILS WITHIN TWO-MILE RADIUS OF VISTRA BATTERY FIRE CONTAIN STAGGERING INCREASE IN METALS
    Thanks to the baseline information collected over the past decade by the Moss Landing Marine Lab scientists, we now know that recent samples of the Elkhorn Slough Estuary show extremely elevated levels of metals.  Furthermore, the metals found in marsh soil samples taken since the Vistra Battery Facility fire that began on January 16 and burned for days are associated with nanoparticles, and are indicative of association with the smoke plumes issued during the fire.

    Scientists Detect Heavy Metals in Environmentally Sensitive Elkhorn Slough After Battery Storage Plant Fire | SJSU NewsCenter

    Having the baseline levels is critical.  Thank goodness for this crucial work.  Will it mirror the Vistra and EPA statements to area residents that everything was fine, and Monterey and Santa Cruz County officials recommending people just shelter in place with doors and windows closed?

    Hmmm….  stay tuned, but keep asking those critical questions of the officials.

    Meanwhile, here is where you can take action….

    LOCAL RESIDENTS NEED TO UNITE AND PRESS FOR ACTION AND ANSWERS
    Please join your neighbors in taking action as a grassroots effort to press officials for action and demand answers.  This group quickly mobilized for a community meeting and soon after issued.a call to action that helped residents in Santa Cruz and Monterey Counties properly collect surface residue samples from over 125 locations to determine a survey of lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese levels potentially indicative of the Moss Landing Battery fire plume.

    Can you help in any way?  Taking action is a great way to counter the feeling that you are powerless in this terrible event.  Sign up and do what you can…

    Never Again Moss Landing

    SANTA CRUZ COUNTY’S BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS (BESS) PROJECT APPLICATION IN WATSONVILLE MOVES AHEAD
    Last Tuesday, the Board of Supervisor chambers at 701 Ocean Street was full and overflowing…so was the parking lot outside, with people demanding answers and information about the Moss Landing Battery facility fire and also protesting the proposed Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.

    Supervisor Koenig attempted to get a moratorium on lithium battery energy storage projects in Santa Cruz County until Vistra and the Governor’s office release final investigation reports and after-action analysis of the Moss Landing incident, to send  letters to the California Public Utilities Commission and California Energy Commission to request formal evaluation of other BESS facilities that are similar to the Vistra plant that burned, and finally, to direct staff to evaluate soil and produce in Santa Cruz County for possible metal contamination levels for public safety.  He also motioned that the April 25 date currently scheduled for the Board to hear the rezoning of the three BESS sites and likely the Seahawk BESS project application.  He and Superviosr Hernandez both favored stronger regulations for BESS projects to ward off the end=run of local jurisdiction control available when an applicant could instead run to the California Energy Commission to get immediate approval.

    All of those good proactive and responsive suggestions were shot down by other Supervisors who worried about who would pay the cost of soil and produce sampling,   Even though County Counsel advised that the Board could take these actions as associated response to the Moss Landing Battery fire report information, the other Supervisors were not willing to do so.  While Supervisor Cummings was in favor of bringing the matter to the next Board agenda,  Supervisor DeSerpa was not in favor of moving the presentation to be associated with the Watsonville BESS report any sooner than April 25 because she was sure there would be plenty of information available on the recent disaster by then.

    Please listen to all this discussion on the Board of Supervisor meeting recording for January 28. for Item #8, especially the Board discussion at around minute 3:00 to completion.

    I visited the proposed Watsonville BESS project at 90 Minto Road.  The area is beautiful, with apple orchards and is known as Interlaken, with College Lake and Pinto Lake adjacent.  Residents in the dense neighborhood adjacent said there is a wide variety of lovely migratory birds that visit.

    Residents knew nothing of the proposed BESS project application currently on the fast track for approval to help Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) to meet their business plan.  Don’t forget that County Administrative Officer Carlos Palacios and former County Supervisor Bruce McPherson shoved this all through and sit on the Board of 3CE.

    That means that the December 12 public meeting that New Leaf Energy held (they are required to hold only one) was not sent to the dense neighborhoods around the proposed BESS site.  I wonder if the administrators of nearby Salsipuedes Elementary School received notification, and why the meeting was held at Amesti School instead…with NO time included for when the meeting would begin.

    I wonder if the nearby residents on Minto Road, which includes the Shapiro Knolls dense affordable housing complex, received any notification?????

    I wonder how there could ever be a rapid evacuation for the Minto Road neighborhood, with such a narrow road that is seemingly blocked by high storm water levels in the creek nearby.  Would there be secondary access for fire engines if there were to be a fire at the BESS facility?

    I wonder why Supervisor Hernandez seems fine with all this?

    Take a look at the photos below and contact him with your thoughts:  Felipe Hernandez <felipe.hernandez@santacruzcountyca.gov>

    Also, consider sending a thank you letter to Supervisor Manu Koenig, for being well-prepared and ready to take action to protect the health and safety of the people and environment in Santa Cruz County.  Manu Koenig <manu.koenig@santacruzcountyca.gov>

    Here is a tour of the area where a BESS facility is proposed at 90 Minto Road.  Below is Minto Road near where it intersects Green Valley Road.  What would a large-scale emergency response look like on this road at the same time residents there would be evacuating?

    Below is the orchard adjacent to the existing PG&E transmission yard.  A significant portion of the orchard would be taken out of production, violating the County’s Measure J approved by voters to preserve agricultural land.

    Below is the view from Agate Drive, a neighborhood immediately adjacent to the proposed BESS facility and that would be downwind of any smoke plume in the event of a fire.  This neighborhood did not receive notification of the December 12, 2024 “public meeting” that New Leaf Energy held at Amesti School. The post card New Leaf Energy mailed had NO time included for the meeting.

    Do you think any of the people living in the Shapiro Knolls dense affordable housing complex shown below on Miinto Road and immediately adjacent to the proposed Seahawk BESS at 90 Minto Road received any notification of the December 12 “public meeting” or are even aware of the project?

    Do you think any of the residents in the small cabin-like housing that likely is farmworker housing even know about the proposed BESS?  Will their homes be demolished?

    What about an evacuation plan for the Salsipuedes School nearby and downwind of the proposed  BESS project?  Do you think those families know about this proposed project and the problems associated with a lithium battery energy storage system fire???

    Do you think the apple orchards below should be preserved, as is required by Measure J?

    The Interlaken area of Watsonville where the proposed Seahawk BESS is a riparian area, and resembles the same aquatic habitat of the Elkhorn Slough Estuary.  How would a toxic smoke plume affect the College Lake and Pinto Lake environments?

    If you are concerned by any of this, please write or call your Supervisor.  Demand a noticed public hearing during an evening and invite residents Countywide.

    Board of Supervisors: 831-454-2200.

    CPUC WILL INTRODUCE NEW SAFETY STANDARDS FOR BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS (BESS) IN MARCH

    The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) will consider new safety regulations for Energy Storage Systems (ESS) at it’s March 13, 2025 meeting because:

    There is currently no provision in General Order167 that requires ESS Operators to report safety incidents
    such as injuries, fatalities, thermal runaways, fires, or other system failures to the
    CPUC. Regulatory oversight of ESS facilities is necessary because of the safety and reliability risks that can occur if ESS facilities are not properly operated and maintained.”

    Incidents at lithium-ion ESS facilities have caused fires, evacuation orders, and shelter-
    in-place orders for nearby residents; therefore, warranting an investigation by Electric Safety and Reliability Branch

    (ESRB.)

    There have been a number of safety incidents at ESS facilities since 2021, including:

    1. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, September 4, 2021
    2. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, February 13, 2022
    3. Terra-Gen; Valley Center Energy Storage Center, April 5, 2022
    4. PG&E; Elkhorn Battery Energy Storage Facility, September 20, 2022
    5. Terra-Gen; Valley Center Energy Storage Center, September 18, 2023
    6. SDG&E; Kearny South Energy Storage, April 29, 2024
    7. Convergent; Orange County Energy Storage 2, July 17, 2024
    8. REV Renewables; Gateway Energy Storage Facility, May 15, 2024
    9. SDG&E; Northeast Operations Center, Escondido, September 5, 2024
    10. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, January 16, 2025.

    Proposal to Enhance Safety of Battery Energy Storage Facilities

    COULD BACTERIA RID FOREVER CHEMICAL CARCINOGENS?
    Here is some good news!!  A study has shown that bacteria could effectively clean up PFAS in the soil and water.  This could help with areas such as the Rountree Detention Facility and Migrant Worker Complex wells, both of which have shown elevated levels of PFAS, a persistent chemical that is pervasive and very carcinogenic.

    Rare Aerobic Bacterium Found to Break Down ‘Forever Chemicals’ | Sci.News

    AB 205 CERTIFICATION BY CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION IS BAD NEWS!
    At Tuesday’s Board of Supervisor meeting, Supervisor Manu Koenig attempted to convince the Board to be proactive and consider more restrictive regulation than the State;s for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) facilities.  Here is what is so worrisome and that merits rapid action by the Board.

    AB 205 gives CEC exclusive siting authority over these eligible projects if a developer submits an application to CEC under this certification process instead of an application for entitlements from the jurisdiction in which the project is located. CEC’s siting certification is in lieu of any permit, certificate, or similar document required by any state, local, or regional agency, or federal agency to the extent permitted by federal law. It also supersedes any applicable statute, ordinance, or regulation of any state, local, or regional agency, or federal agency to the extent permitted by federal law, with limited exceptions. AB 205 specifically provides that the certification does not supersede the authority of an exclusive list of agencies: the California State Lands Commission, the California Coastal Commission (CCC), the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC), the California State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) or the applicable regional water quality control boards, local air quality management districts, or the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC).

    Expedited Environmental Review of Eligible Projects

    AB 205 requires CEC to serve as the lead agency for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) when developers file an application for certification with the CEC before July 1, 2029. Within 30 days of the submission of the application, CEC must review the application and make a determination of completeness. Environmental review must be completed within 270 days after the application is deemed complete, subject to certain limited extensions. CEC must also develop plans for timely consultations with relevant state and local agencies. A certificate issued pursuant to this streamlined process shall be valid for a period not to exceed five years from the date of issuance.

    CEC cannot approve a qualifying project without first finding that the facility will have an overall net positive economic benefit to the local government that would have had permitting authority for the site and related facility. Such economic benefits include but are not limited to employment growth, housing development, infrastructure and environmental improvements, and property taxes and sales and use tax revenues.

    Other Application Requirements

    To qualify, developers must meet certain prevailing wage and skilled and trained workforce requirements in construction contracts. Developers must also secure contracts with community-based organizations—such as workforce development and training organizations, labor unions, social justice advocates, local government entities, and California Native American tribes—where there is mutual benefit to the parties to the agreement.

    An application for certification must be accompanied by a fee of $250,000 plus $500 per MW of gross generating capacity or per MW of gross energy storage capacity, as applicable, or $0.70 per square foot for a thermal generation plant not powered by fossil fuels, subject to a total cap of $750,000.
    Projects that receive certification are subject to an annual fee of $25,000, with payments due by July 1 of each year in which the facility retains its certification. Petitions to amend an existing project that previously received certification shall be accompanied by a fee of $5,000.

    Don’t you think the California Energy Commission would be more than happy to issue this type of certificate for new BESS facilities and have their wallets fattened annually?  How objective would their environmental analysis actually be?????

    Please write your County Supervisors and insist on very restrictive requirements for any BESS facility.
    How about a technical advisory committee to assist development of the requirements, and not allow it to be in the hands of County Planning staff or New Leaf Energy or Vistra???

    AB 303 WOULD HELP FIX THIS
    In response to Vistra attempting to use the AB 205 tactic to do an end-run for a BESS in Morro Bay,  Assemblymember Dawn Addis has proposed AB 303 to claw back the power for the jurisdictions that would be affected by such a project.

    Please support this legislation by writing Assemblymember Addis, and other legislators.
    Addis Introduces Legislation to Bolster Community Choice & Environmental Protections in Battery Projects | Official Website – Assemblymember Dawn Addis Representing the 30th California Assembly District

    MORE ABOUT THAT BIG WHITE BALL ON TOP OF THE SHERIFF BUILDING
    The County OR3 has some interesting information on the sidebar, including the radar readings from the x-band radar equipment on top of the Sheriff Building in Live Oak.  Take a look at this when the rain returns:
    Experience

    The OR3 website also includes the “PurpleAir” monitoring data system that many people referred to during the recent Moss Landing Battery Energy Storage Site (BESS) Fire.

    BOARD OF SUPERVISORS APPROVE SPENDING BIG BUCKS TO REMODEL CHAMBERS?
    The Board approved Consent Agenda Item #26, spending $2,310,500 to remodel the Board Chambers with new layout and furnishings.  Does this make fiscal sense when the County had to borrow $96million to stay financially afloat?

    I just don’t think so!
    Government Broadcasting Revitalization Project Design Concept

    Why does CAO Carlos Palacios and General Services Director Michael Beaton want to push this wasteful spending?  To improve visual experience for meeting recordings..
    Really?  This all comes after the huge remodel project of the General Services Dept.

    The County has changed its website.  In order to view the map of the proposed new layout of the Board Chambers, one must sign in.  The system kept rejecting my attempts to log in.  The other new item is that one has to “just know” to click in the empty space between agenda items to see the links for documents appear.  Some require registering to access them.

    What a setback for transparency.  Don’t worry though, there is now an “AI Statement” at the end of the documents that I was able to access, letting me know that the report was partially generated with AI.

    Please write your Supervisor with your thoughts on the $2.3 MILLION remodel of the Board Chambers and the problematic access to Board documents.

    WILL MT. MADONNA INN EVER COME TO LIFE AGAIN?
    Maybe you remember the lovely views of the Pajaro Valley and Monterey Bay while having dinner decades ago when the Mt. Madonna Inn was open for business.  According to a sign posted there now that give hope to a reopening of this magnificent location at the summit of Hecker Pass Road (Highway 152)
    According to County staff:

    The application is nearing completeness. Once complete, we will prepare a staff report and schedule a public hearing before the Zoning A.dministrator.

    Planning Status

    Stay tuned….

    WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  SIGN UP TO HELP THE MOSS LANDING GRASSROOTS EFFORT. MAKE ANOTHER ONE TO YOUR SUPERVISOR ABOUT FACILITIES IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY. DEMAND TOWN HALL MEETINGS.

    MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING…MAYBE TWO!

    Cheers,
    Becky

    Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

    Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

    ...
    Living by Principles

    What comes to mind when you hear someone say something like, “She is a principled person?” If you trust the source of the statement, perhaps you will think more highly of the person being referenced, which is curious because you don’t have any idea of the nature of her principles. Perhaps merely having principles and acting upon them makes you more predictable, and that predictability is an asset. It seems that this might be a good time to reflect on principle-based living.

    Social Principles

    I posit that most religions are based on social principles of great value. Kindness, fairness, gratitude, generosity, and attentiveness are some such principles, stated positively. Some principles are stated in the negative such as “evil” including murder, greed, vengeance, gluttony, etc. It is a mystery to me that discussion of such principles is not the primary driver of political discourse. Perhaps we get confused when juxtaposing wealth redistribution as both generous (to the poor) and greedy (against the rich)? Or, maybe we wonder if it might or might not be kind to murder someone for heinous crimes? These are heady questions.

    On a national level, we might feel ready to label presidents, members of the house and senate, or even Supreme Court officials as ‘principled’ or ‘unprincipled,’ but how would we take such labels to more definition? What precise principles would you suggest your favorite national politician has had or has lacked? So much media hype focuses on either fallabilities or exhilarating roaring successes of our so-called ‘leaders,’ and yet that question may be difficult to answer. I challenge you to try.

    I suggest that everyone has some familiarity with social principles and that most people, if asked, would be able to speak to their personal framework. However, beyond that, I wonder how much people are guided by principles for their work, their homes, or their relationship with the environment.

    While I challenge everyone to think about what principles they operate on at the workplace or in their homes, I am more interested here in elaborating on some environmental principles that you might consider.

    Ecological Principles

    There are principles that could guide humans in better forming their relationship with the environment, creating increased benefit for future generations. The root of all evil is said to be greed, and what better test of an environmental principle than just that – greed?

    One of the key attributes of greed is to seek only to take, without giving. For thousands of years, indigenous peoples understood that humans should be very mindful about what they took from nature, and also they should give back. Frugality is a central principle for humans’ relationship with the environment. The less stuff we buy, the more pro-environmental we are. Last I checked, it cost a liter of crude oil every time a dollar was exchanged.

    Giving Back to Nature

    What is ‘giving back’ to nature? An indigenous person asked our community once why we were burning our prairies without seeding after the fire. Perhaps that is one way of giving back. We still aren’t doing that. Another way to give back would be to control the invasive plants and animals that are so terribly affecting nature. Please write to me if you can think of any other ways that Monterey Bay residents might give back to nature.

    Energy Expenditure Principle

    The way we create energy makes a difference and serves as a ripe area for environmental principle formation. Is the principle to create the most energy from the least impactful source? If so, how are we getting reports on how we might help?

    The havoc being wrought by climate change has convinced many to be more mindful about what we take from nature, but most people have a very shallow understanding about that. Burning fewer fossil fuels is a Big Problem for life on Earth, but I hear very little about the impacts of alternate energy solutions on nature. Nuclear energy has a great environmental impact not normally described, same with solar panel production and concrete/steel installations for the bases of wind turbines. We might all benefit from getting more information about trade offs for various types of energy production. That way, we can shape our political or consumer voices to help create the best solutions. Plus, what are we hearing about using less energy, altogether? Long gone are the energy saving public service announcements of the now-lauded Jimmy Carter years.

    Species Conservation Principle

    Fossil-fuel burning-caused climate change is the number one threat to the environment, but there are other threats, and the core concern I believe we should have is about species conservation. I suggest that we should weigh human decisions on how well we can guarantee that all species continue to thrive. I have yet to speak with anyone that discounts this principle’s importance, but I have also seen many decisions made with too little information to adequately assess this principle. How is a regular person to evaluate whether or not a decision favorably affects species conservation? Luckily, we have public disclosure laws and people considering impacting the environment are required to analyze and disclose impacts on species. So, one would expect things like disclosure of species that might be impacted and how the impacts would affect their future chances of survival under the varied alternatives project proponents are required to analyze. If you don’t see such analysis, you should be careful about supporting such proposals.

    For further thought on this, consider author Gregory David Roberts’ assertion in the novel Shantaram of the principle of complexity conservation. He would say that we should weigh the good of an action on whether it creates more or less complexity in the future…more complexity is the goal.

    Go ahead- try using these pro-environmental principles or come up with your own! Let me know how it goes.

    Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

    Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

    ...

    Thursday, January 23, 2025


    Most of us have been reading about those “Executive Orders” issued by our newly-inaugurated president on “Day One.” In an article dated January 21, 2025Time Magazine has complained about them, outlining a number of problems, and though I think Time is correct in its observations about the drawbacks of trying to govern by “Executive Order,” it has missed what I think is the most important point.

    Here’s the issue I want to raise: When the president issues an “Executive Order,” what gives the president the right to do so? Where does the president get the power to tell people what to do? After all, if we quickly check out our Constitution, Article II tells us that the president’s basic duty is to “take care that the laws are faithfully executed.” In other words, the president’s power to tell other people what to do with respect to one thing or another does not come from holding the office of the presidency. It comes from a law, enacted by Congress, specifically granting such a power to the president.

    So, and let’s think about it, have all the president’s recent “Executive Orders” been based on a law enacted by Congress, specifically granting the president the power to issue the various orders he has been issuing?

    The answer, clearly, is “No.” Issuing an “Executive Order” that claims to take away the citizenship of people whom the Constitution specifically says are citizens is the most egregious example of the overreach that our president is demonstrating. I am betting, though, that an extremely large percentage of the other “Executive Orders” recently issued by our president, on his very first day in office, are not actually valid “Executive Orders,” at all, in the sense that anyone is legally required to do what the president says.

    In an editorial in the Wednesday, January 22, 2025, edition of The Wall Street Journal, that newspaper decried Trump’s action in purporting to give TikTok what the paper called an “Illegal Amnesty.” Whatever your position on TikTok, Congress passed a law; the president has now asserted the right to countermand that law, simply by executing a so-called “Executive Order.” This was NOT legal. The Wall Street Journal is right about that!

    And how about the president’s “Executive Order” unilaterally withdrawing the United States from the World Health Organization? I am betting that Congress has not told the president that he gets to make that choice. WE get to make that choice, and “we” act by laws passed by Congress, if those laws are then signed by the president. Is there some law that says that the president is granted the power to declare national health policy, based on the president’s personal preferences?

    Day One of this new presidency has now come and gone, and the president is acting like his election, in and of itself, gives him the right to order everyone else around. This is emphatically not what our system of self-government contemplates, and so emergency sirens ought to be wailing! But…. now is not the time to seek shelter underground. Now is the time to fill up the streets, and to object, in no uncertain terms, to the improper claims by the president that he has some kind of right to “rule,” based on having been elected president. We need to demand that our Members of Congress, each one of them, insist that THEY decide, as our elected “representatives, what the laws and policies will be that guide our national actions, and our national life.

    As for the so-called “Executive Orders” that have been issued by the president, let’s recognize them for what they are, the diseased evidences of “Executive Disorder.”

    What we’re seeing is a sickness, and our current president has a very bad case! Let’s not allow him to infect the rest of us, and the entirety of our government.

    Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

    Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

    ...

    ZORRO IMPERSONATOR, WHOPPER OVERLOAD, BEYONCÉ VICTORY

    Has it been four years yet? That’s a question raised by a poster on X at the end of an exhausting week of Trump and his antics following his inauguration. It’s certainly a worthy query as many of us will agree. The Crazy Eight website evaluated it with, “In his inaugural speech Donald Trump called for a ‘Revolution of Common Sense,’ where apparently truth is stranger than fiction, and reality is more alarming than satire…His first priorities? Helping everyday Americans struggling to pay their bills by renaming the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America AND profiting billions from his new cryptocurrency! Ain’t that swell?”

    Buzzfeed selected a few of its favorite Tweets of the Week“I don’t care who’s trans, bro — I want doctor’s appointments for $5”“There’s not going to be lower grocery prices, you stupid slut”“Being a person with a brain and someone who can read during this period of history is really, really difficult”“Nobody is telling men they’re losers, and that’s the problem”; “I’d rather get a pap smear from Edward Scissorhands than watch any second of the inauguration”; “Melania’s looking like a smooth criminal”; Referring to the announcement that Trump’s inauguration would be moved indoors, one poster asks, “And, ya’ll want to invade Canada?”; “My BF keeps muttering to himself, ‘We had to get through Hoover to get to FDR,’ like it’s a prayer.” Saturday Night Live’s Weekend Update anchor, Michael Che, showing a Tesla Cybertruck picture, said, “Musk can’t be a Nazi, because the Nazis made nice cars.”

    The TV ratings are available for the inauguration, and Trump has to be disappointed that no Sean Spicer has stepped up to convince the world that records were broken. According to The Wrap, combined cable and network news totals amount to 24.59M, with Fox News unsurprisingly accounting for 10.3M, nearly half of the viewership, between 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time. Morgan Stephens of Daily Kos observes “that more people watched Beyoncé’s Christmas halftime show than the 47th president’s inauguration.” Trump’s viewer ratings are well below his own 2017 inauguration (and Joe Biden’s in 2021), garnering only 7.2% of the US population to see that he didn’t place his hand on the Bible and air-kissing Melania in her Zorro hat. Stephens attributes the dip in viewership to general apathy, despondency, Trump fatigue or his polarizing presence, combined with loss of appetite for his theatrics.

    Trump made it clear that his second term will be more of the same, as he added to his collection of false and misleading claims, estimated by the Washington Post that during his first Oval Office occupancy he spewed 30,573 whoppers. One critic dubbed him “America’s Liar-In-Chief,” as he launched into his inaugural address about immigration, the economy, electric vehicles, the Panama Canal, his 2020 stolen election, and the January 6 insurrection. His brazen mendacity is not only habitual, but strategic as we see within the MAGA mob’s tactics. A former Republican communications director on Capitol Hill, says, “It’s a continuation of Donald Trump’s brand. He knows that sunlight is the best disinfectant, so he’s going to continue to lie to mask what he’s doing. If you can undermine institutions and credible sources of information, you can get away with lying and deceiving people. We’re watching that mass delusion happen right before our eyes in the Trump administration 2.0.” During the following week with reporters, Trump continued to spew misleading assertions, wild exaggerations and blatant lies, culminating on Fox News with his explanation for the blanket pardon of the January 6 rioters and their attacks on police as “very minor incidents.”

    CNN reports that Trump, in his attempt to rewrite history detailing the attack on the US Capitol, had a database detailing the array of criminal charges and successful convictions of the January 6 rioters removed from the Department of Justice’s website. That searchable database served as an easily accessible repository of all cases prosecuted by the US Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia — which declined to comment! Removal of the site coincides with Trump’s decision to pardon all convicted defendants, plus early release of 14 members of far-right extremist groups, including 10 convicted of seditious conspiracy, and a request to dismiss more than 300 unresolved cases. This ‘whitewashing’ of the mob attack wipes out cases against some of the most violent rioters who injured police, and was celebrated in particular by the pardoned Brandon Straka for his role on J6. Straka proclaimed it a “huge victory,” saying that the site was a “weapon of harassment” used by the government to make life impossible for its “targets from J6.”

    Acting US attorney, Ed Martin, known for his organizing the ‘Stop the Steal’ movement and being involved in financing the 2021 Trump rally on the Ellipse, is given credit for removing the DOJ website. Straka had campaigned for the site’s removal because the information was available to potential employers, landlords, and social or business contacts, complicating the lives of the J6 participants. Details of the J6 cases are still accessible on the DOJ’s website in the form of press releases about charges and convictions, and are available through court records and services such as Pacer.

    David Smith in the Guardian reports that even the White House website has been compromised, with a Trump biography claim that a 2024 “landslide victory defines the American success story.” Omitting the ‘big lie’ regarding the 2020 election, his victory came “a second time despite several assassination attempts and the unprecedented weaponization of law fare against him.” While fact-checkers attempt to hold Trump to account, Republicans are less willing than ever to correct his falsehoods in this now fragmented media environment, with MAGA influencers only too eager to amplify them. Kurt BardellaDemocratic strategist and media relations consultant, says, “If there’s any lasting impact from Donald Trump’s time on the political stage, it’s that we live in a world now where you can just make up your own facts, and truth is however you decide to bend it. There are content creators and content machines that exist solely for the purpose of laundering anything that Donald Trump says and making it true to a certain degree. It’s a play off the Richard Nixon quote: ‘If the president does it, it is legal; well, if the president says it, it’s true. That’s the world that we live in now.'”

    Sara Boboltz of B writes, “as President Donald Trump settles into his second term and world leaders ponder what the next four years have in store, some British officials who have dealt with him in the past are sharing words of advice: ‘Expect chaos, but also laughs.’ Workers in the British prime minister’s office during Trump’s first term told Politico EU that small crowds of civil servants and advisers would gather to listen in on phone calls with Trump. ‘The calls were extraordinary — brilliant. Everyone was in there with tears of laughter because they were hilarious.’ Two listeners said that whatever agenda had been planned ‘would quite quickly fall by the wayside’ and the calls ‘were never what you wanted them to be about, broadly.’ Americans are already well-versed in Trump’s meandering style of speech, surprising gaffes and penchant for jumping between topics at whim, which he calls ‘the weave’ with his claims that he always ends up hitting his intended points in the end. One person contributed, ‘Yes, he will say some mad or unpredictable things, but there’s almost always an underlying argument or basis for a negotiation, and if the conversation goes south, Trump is always happy to discuss his UK golf courses.'”

    British satirical magazine, ‘Private Eye,’ printed its latest cover with an apology to Donald Trump, headlined ‘Donald Trump: An Apology.’ The document reads: “In common with all other media organisations, we may in the past have given the impression that we thought Mr. Trump was a sleazy, deranged, orange-faced man-baby who was a threat to democracy and who should be in jail rather than the White House. We now realise, in the light of his return to supreme power, that he is in fact a political colossus, the voice of sanity, a champion of liberty, a model of probity and the saviour of the Western world. He is also slim, handsome and young. We would like to apologize unreservedly for any confusion caused by our previous statements and thank President Trump for his kind invitation to give him 94 million pounds to attend his inauguration event.” In smaller print at the bottom of the page, it reads: “This statement has not been fact-checked.”

    James Austin Johnson, portraying Trump on Saturday Night Live said, “Just like my founding fathers, I am creating a new country as well. And just like them, we’re doing it very white-ly. Workplaces must go back to looking like the TV show ‘The Office.’ Mostly white people but with one funny Black guy who’s having a really bad time.” Johnson/Trump called his inauguration “a tremendous success,” being held inside “due to cold and fear. We got a lot of surprise guests, like Melania!” He pointed out the presence of his billionaire buddies, “Zuck, Bezos, and of course, Elon. We love Elon, but to quote some of his own children, ‘I do not want him in my life.” Johnson/Trump shared his views about only two genders, “one to work, and one to cook. We’re going back to common sense in regard to gender. No more makeup on men, unless you need it to be president.” On his cabinet appointees, he boasted, “We’re filling my cabinet with some of the best people. They’re all very good except for most of them. How great is Pete Hegseth? He said he’s going to stop drinking if he gets the job, and that’s all I needed to hear.” And, “Who would’ve thought it easier to get a cease-fire in Gaza than lower the price of eggs?” Satirist Andy Borowitz writes that Joaquin ‘El Chapo’ Guzman is asking Trump for a pardon out of ‘professional courtesy,’ claiming that he was a DC riot participant. Ready to turn over a new leaf, Borowitz says Guzman promises to stop selling drugs and focus on crypto, while acknowledging he is a controversial figure but, “I’m not some total maniac like Hegseth.”

    Stephen Colbert of the ‘Late Show’ ripped into Republicans who showed absolutely no outrage with Trump’s pardoning of 1,500 January 6 rioters who attacked the US Capitol, some of whom assaulted several police officers. Colbert quoted House Speaker Mike Johnson with saying it was not his “place” to question Trump’s decision. “Not your place? They attacked the House of Representatives! That is literally YOUR place!” The Tonight Show host, Jimmy Fallon, says Trump’s granting of clemency took his allies by surprise, with one adviser revealing the president simply said, “Release them all.” Must have been too much trouble to read all those pages of names which would keep him away from his grifting. Fallon noted, “At this point the only prisoner Trump hasn’t released is Melania.”

    Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
     

    ...

    EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

    EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    Rebuilding

    “When we rebuild a house, we are rebuilding a home. When we recover from disaster, we are rebuilding lives and livelihoods.”
    ~Sri Mulyani Indrawati

    “If we wish to rebuild our cities, we must first rebuild our neighborhoods. And to do that, we must understand that the quality of life is more important than the standard of living.”
    ~Harvey Milk

    “Governments must give to all those who have hit life’s hurdles the chance to rebuild and have a future.”
    ~Pauline Hanson

    “It cannot take decades to resurrect, we must act immediately with purpose and enthusiasm to rebuild.”
    ~Alan Autry

    “The city of New Orleans showed America what it takes to rebuild a great place. We’re all going together, and we’re not leaving anybody behind.”
    ~Mitch Landrieu

    ...

    You didn’t think I’d miss this opportunity, did you? 🙂 Here’s FireAid 🙂


    COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

    Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
    (Gunilla Leavitt)

    ...

    Deep Cover

    Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment