Blog Archives

April 2 – 8, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on important community meeting Steinbruner… Pedestrian over crossing, Moss Landing, County planning commission … Hayes… Community and Self-Identification… Patton… Short-term pain, and no long-term gain… Matlock… Atlantic sinking…fire somebody…but her emails…one bad apple… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover … Webmistress serves you… a rare occurrence Quotes on… “Protesting”

...

THE “PALO ALTO” CONCRETE SHIP. This photo was taken in 1947. The “Palo Alto” was built of concrete by the U.S. Government in 1918, and it cost $2 million. It was towed to where it is today (Seacliff Beach) in 1930. It broke in half during a storm in 1932, and in recent years, the pier has been removed. The pieces of the ship are still there, “deteriorating gracefully”(?). Ever since I first heard of it, I’ve wondered why it wasn’t fixed up/maintained and showcased as a piece of history. Oh, youthful ideals and optimism!

If you are interested in her history in more detail, the East Bay Times published an article in 2023, with lots of pictures. It’s a slideshow, I almost missed it!

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: April 2, 2025

PROTESTS IN THE STREETS. So, apparently a lot of people are out there, making their voices heard. This is a Good Thing[TM]. Every day there is more and more distressing news about how much backsliding the US is doing, locally as well as globally. Canada, the nicest of all nations, are severing ties – do you realize how much you have to eff up for Canada to do this?!?

At any rate, I have to limit my intake of news for my own mental health. I will pass this on, however: Tomorrow, April 5 is the National Day of Action, put on all over the place by HANDS ØFF, handsoff2025.com. The Santa Cruz protest takes place as follows:

  • Where: 701 Ocean St. Santa Cruz, CA 95060 on the Water St. side of the building
  • When: 12pm–2pm on April 5, 2025

If Watsonville is closer to you, join their protest in the Watsonville Plaza at the same time.

...

THE RESIDENCE. Netflix. Series. (7.8 IMDb) ***-
I’m happy to see the return of the cozy mystery – Knives Out, Death and Other Details, and even Only Murders in the Building. Sure, Hallmark churns out an endless stream of formulaic/hygienic perky upper middle class “professional women” who solve mysteries while hygienically engaging in romance with some square jawed cop/firefighter/architect, but they lack any sort of charm or character. The Residence gives us Cordelia Cupp (Orange is the New Black’s Uzo Aduba): an acclaimed detective, and stout birder, who finds herself wader deep in drama and intrigue surrounding a murder in the White House. Giving absolutely zero f***s about titles and position, she pursues the truth through a cast of notables: Giancarlo Esposito, Jason Lee, Bronson Pinchot, Molly Griggs, and even Al Franken, reprising his role as a Senator. Might have been a few episodes too long, but worth the wait. Definite watch.
~Sarge

STAR TREK: SECTION 31. Paramount+. Movie. (3.8 IMDb) *-
I know I’m late to the table for this, but we decided to finally sit down and watch Star Trek: Section 31. Empress Georgiou (the mirror-universe evil counterpart of heroic Capt. Georgiou from Star Trek: Discovery) is pressed back into service with Section 31 – the black-ops division of Starfleet – for essentially a caper “mission”. Things go wrong, and she and a band of misfit specialists have to make it right. Michelle Yeoh is wonderful, as she always is. What she’s given to work with is tepid at best. I’m not a toxic fan – I’ve liked a lot of Trek related stuff that people kvetch about, but I do recognize when they miss the mark. Not just “doesn’t feel like Star Trek”, but feels like a fairly average caper film. No brilliant gotcha moments, no delicious red herrings. Just bland. Which is hard to do with Michelle Yeoh! It doesn’t quite make me feel like I was robbed of an hour and a half, but I was not really entertained. Highlight for the geek crowd: a Cheronian waiter. Watch only for a completionist compulsion.
~Sarge

NO OTHER LAND. In theaters. Movie (8.3 IMDb) ***-
Academy Award-winning documentary, No Other Land, highlights the impact of political conflicts on everyday people. Co-directed by Palestinian filmmaker Basel Adra and Israeli journalist Yuval Abraham, the film follows them in the forced displacement of the small settlement of Masafer Yatta by Israeli forces. The view we get, from the “street” as it were, brings home the workaday world that is being unceremoniously wiped out by forces beyond shame or consequence. It makes it difficult to maintain an objective view of chess pieces being neatly moved around a board – it’s hard and personal, and as foreign as it should feel, hitting you right in the hometown. After winning the award, another co-director, Hamdan Ballal, was arrested and detained by Israeli authorities. The academy’s reaction: a tepid equivalent of “there are good people on both sides”. Definitely requires a watch.
~Sarge

THE ELECTRIC STATE. Netflix Movie (6 IMDb) ***- This has the energy of ’80s adventure films, like Batteries Not Included and War Games, with a touch of Fallout retro-futurism. Here’s the deal: In the ’50s, Walt Disney sparked a robot boom, leading to a robot rebellion in the ’90s. After the war, robots were confined to a walled-off Midwest wasteland. Michelle (Millie Bobby Brown) discovers her genius brother, supposedly dead, stuck in a robot shell and searching for a mysterious doctor. Keats (Chris Pratt) and his robot sidekick help her break into the wasteland. They’re pursued by a robot exterminator (Giancarlo Esposito) working for a tech billionaire, Skate (Stanley Tucci), who wants Michelle’s brother. Fun, nostalgic, and spot-on art direction. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

ADOLESCENCE. Netflix Series (8.4 IMDb) *** I was going to start off saying this was uninspired in its execution, till I saw a shot fly up from one character, fly several blocks away, drop down to where another character is getting out of a car, and hold a steady close up – all in one shot. A British crime drama about the impact of incel politics on pre-sexual children. Very saddening. Worth a watch. ~Sarge

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. AppleTV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- I don’t know how accurate this is as a depiction of young Bob Dylan (Timothee Chalamet), but it does make me yearn for those days as an adult (I wouldn’t be released till ’63). The film basically encapsulates Dylan from ’61 to ’65, following his relationships, and rise in the folk community, and his troubled transition to something more. Ed Norton as the supportive and eventally outgrown Pete Seeger, Elle Fanning as Dylan’s constantly trying-to-stay-in-his-focus lover Sylvie Russo/Suze Rotolo, and Monica Barbaro as the legendary sometime lover/sometime music partner Joan Baez. Worth a watch.~Sarge

THE BRUTALIST. PrimeTV. Movie (7.5 IMDb) *** I thought the title was JUST a reference to the Brutalist Movement in art and architecture. Oh how wrong I was. A brutal story about love, separation, and power. Adrien Brody is gut-wrenching in his performance as a holocaust survivor, drug addict, and brutalist architect. It’s like dragging yourself along the edge of a straight razor – the further forward you go, the deeper it cuts. Painful, but worth a watch. Interesting note – while Brody’s character is fictional, the name Lazlo Toth (and variants) is out there, most notable to me, it was the name of the guy who vandalized La Pieta, and it was the pen-name of Don Novello (Reverend Guido Sarducci on old SNL) when writing his “Lazlo Letters”. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL. Disney+. Series (8.6 IMDb) *** The one that started the Netflix/Marvel cavalcade. Charlie Cox and Vincent D’Onofrio bring depth and humor/tragedy to the David and Goliath of New York. Matt Murdoch/Daredevil (Cox), an attorney who was struck blind as a youth, develops the ability to “see” through the use of organic sonar, and uses that ability (along with rigorous martial arts training) to take on the criminal denizens of the shadowy streets. Wilson Fisk/Kingpin (D’Onofrio), a man of outsized power (figuratively and literally) with rage issues, but also a nuanced romantic side, finds his criminal enterprises falling into the “sights” of the blind kid from Hell’s Kitchen. Subsequent stories dealt with other comic characters, Elektra and The Punisher. Amazing fight choreography (not just martial arts, but the fluidity of the staging) if you’re into that – not for the faint of heart. Now on Disney. ~Sarge

DAREDEVIL – BORN AGAIN. Disney+. Series (9 IMDb) *** For anyone thinking that Daredevil would lose its edge being on Disney, think again. The original cast of Netflix’s Daredevil are back for this sequel from Disney. After a journey through various other shows (the Defenders, Hawkeye, Echo, and She Hulk) Cox and D’Onofrio are back. In the first two episodes we see Matt, in the wake of a tragedy, hang up the horns, and Fisk coming out of rehabilitation after getting shot in the face by Echo (see: “Hawkeye” and “Echo”). Matt returns to lawyering, and Fisk … has a vision for a better New York, as Mayor. Just a wee tad chilling, given the current climate. First two episodes on Disney right now – new episodes every Tuesday. ~Sarge

COMPANION. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV. Movie (7.1 IMDb) *** Iris (Sophie Thatcher) and Josh (Jack Quaid) traveling to a friend’s country home for a party where the fact that one of the guests is an android “companion” is the LEAST surprising thing that will be discovered. Some distressingly recognizable relationship dynamics are revealed and explored. Also some violence, and a sexual assault, for those who might be triggered. Well made for a light budget, with some nuanced performances. For those troubled by AI – you might want to start saying “please and thank you” to Alexa and Siri. ~Sarge

MOANA 2. Apple TV, Fandango, PrimeTV, YouTube, Disney+. Series (6.8 IMDb) ** Moana, after reconnecting her people with their seafaring heritage, discovers the ocean is empty. She’s called back by the Gods to face a greedy deity who sunk a cornerstone island, once the link between all Oceania’s seafaring people. Unfortunately, it’s a step down from the original. “Get Lost,” sung by the mid-film villain Matangi, lacks the charm of “Shiny,” and Maui feels like a shadow of his former self. Moana’s crew is a completely superfluous random mix—grumpy farmer, Maui fanboy, manic tech girl, and another comic relief animal (who’s outshone by HeiHei, the chicken). Only the mute rabid coconut warrior, Kotu, adds any value. Much like the first film, the Big Bad is just an angry, personality-less force, this time throwing lightning instead of fireballs. While it’ll entertain kids, there’s little for the parents this time around. Comes to Disney+ March 12th. ~Sarge

HEART EYES. In theaters. Movie (6.6 IMDb) **- A meet-cute rom-com – with a slasher! Odd mix, but it seems to be director Josh Ruben’s forte. Ad designer Ally (Olivia Holt) accidently presents a “historic tracic lovers” motif JUST as notorious serial killer, Heart Eyes, who murders romantic couples on Valentine’s Day, resurfaces. She teams up with “ad fixer” freelancer Jay (Mason Gooding) in a “Desk Set” will-they won’t-they team-up, until an unexpected kiss puts them in the sights of Heart Eyes. The slashing is moderately creative, the chemistry fairly good, but it just lacks a real personality for Heart Eyes (which you need for a franchise killer). Not for the timid, but not epic gorefest either. On par with Christopher Landon’s 2020 body-swap horror/comedy “Freaky” (ala Freaky Friday – only instead of mother/daughter, it’s slasher/cheerleader). ~Sarge

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

...
Stop the Skyscrapers

If you think the above graphic is just hyperbole, you haven’t been following the new state housing laws. What the graphic doesn’t capture may be even more alarming. The Downtown Extension Project, or the Downtown Plan Extension Project in SoLa (South of Laurel), is winding its way to city council like a snake on steroids.

The development site is twenty-nine-acres. It starts at Laurel St., extends along Front St. towards the Wharf, is bordered by Depot Park, Beach Hill and the river levee and encompasses the current Warriors Arena. It is easily the largest serious development proposal in the history of Santa Cruz. It is outside the view in the graphic but could easily end up having buildings at the size shown. That is, unless the city council utilizes one of its few remaining discretions over local development since the land use power grab by state politicians.

The current project area zoning is 35 feet with one area at 48 feet. If council rezones upwards, called upzoning, proposed as an option in the draft Environmental Impact Report (dEIR) for the project, then developers have the freedom to build skyscrapers as high as 25 or 30 stories. This unfortunate situation is a result of Assembly Bill 1287 which increased the density bonus to 100% so that cities are now required to approve projects at double the existing zoning density and waive city restrictions on building height, bulk, and setback, if the project includes a net 15% “affordable” units. The absurdity of this “bonus” is that city law already requires 20% “affordable” units in housing projects. So, we are getting exactly what for this give-away to developers? And, yes, the city’s state-required RHNA numbers (Regional Housing Needs Allocation) for the next seven years-and beyond- can be achieved without upzoning.

Unfortunately, the city’s dEIR for this project omits any study of possible environmental impacts resulting from AB 1287 which passed into law in October 2023. This new law should have generated a revision of the dEIR which was being prepared during that time, but it didn’t. Many have written to council asking for a revision of the dEIR to reflect this sea change in potential size and mass of new developments, but don’t hold your breath.

Within current zoning, any new building in this project site can be as high as seven or eight stories since AB 1287 doubles existing height limits. They can also go higher. But if council rezones the area to 85 feet as is proposed, the possibility of twenty to thirty stories or higher can be expected. Optimists who think this will never happen based on remarks from the Santa Cruz Warriors Team President, or the cost of steel construction in tall buildings, or commonsense, has forgotten that real estate is the number one investment in rich people’s portfolios. And don’t forget the equation; more well-off people moving to Santa Cruz, more low-income residents moving out. Affordable housing for local workers becomes unaffordable due to the ever-increasing Area Median Income. Plus, the city has no idea if its affordable housing is actually going to local workers and the city has no intention of finding out. Likewise, the initiatives currently gathering signatures for raising taxes for future affordable housing have no mechanism for ensuring such housing goes to local workers despite the deceptive names on the initiatives.

This massive development of high rises, bringing three to four thousand people into twenty-nine acres, plus creating an entertainment district with no parking, jammed into the main tourist access route to and from the Wharf, Beach and Boardwalk, plus a main access route to and from downtown or across town for the lower westside, suggests at least poor planning or a serious disregard for the community.

Residents and workers are not taking this lying down. A group of neighbors, largely from Beach Hill with activists from other neighborhoods, including yours truly, have formed a group under the banner Santa Cruzans for Responsible Development. We have met with individual council members to explain the importance of their one remaining power; to not change the zoning in this project area.

As always there is strength in numbers. You are encouraged to sign the petition which includes a wealth of helpful information and can be found here.

And attend the community meeting detailed below. Hope to see you there!

Come to a community meeting!
Saturday, April 5th, 10:30am
London Nelson Center
301 Center Street, Santa Cruz

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
Santa Cruz County supervisors will delay ordinance review

The Board of Supervisors agenda for next Tuesday includes delaying their consideration of the County’s Draft Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) Ordinance until September 9, instead of by April 25 as their vote last October mandated.  According to the staff report for Consent Item #57, the Director of Community Infrastructure & Development (aka Planning and Public Works) wants more time to learn what caused the January 16 Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire and how to use that information in crafting the Draft Ordinance. Meeting

MONTEREY COUNTY WEBSITE PROVIDES GOOD INFORMATION RE: MOSS LANDING DISASTER, BUT WHY IS SANTA CRUZ  COUNTY SILENT?
Sadly, the Santa Cruz County response to the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire has been woefully void of updated information.  With the exception of Consent Item #57 next Tuesday to delay consideration of a BESS Ordinance, the one and only report on January 28 has been the extent of the Board getting any public staff reports on the disaster….despite many residents asking for information and action during Public Comment (items NOT on the agenda) every single meeting…with no response from elected officials.

Take a look at Monterey County’s good information, and contact your local Supervisor to ask why they are so silent.
Moss Landing Battery Facility Recovery 2025 | County of Monterey, CA

LISTEN AND BE HEARD
I hope you will share this information and listen in today 2pm-4pm on “Community Matters”.  You can listen on your computer from anywhere in the world at 2pm Pacific Time. santacruzvoice.com/

Today’s program  will focus on the ongoing Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire issues, and the work the Green Party is doing to inform the public about energy storage technologies that are a safe alternative to hazardous lithium battery storage facilities.

In the first hour (2pm-3pm), my Guest will be Mr. Neil Pearlberg, pod cast host of “Off the Lip”.  We will discuss his recent program interview of Senator John Laird and the Moss Landing Battery Fire response.  We will not be accepting any calls from the audience during Mr. Pearlberg’s interview, but I urge you to listen to the story of what he experienced as public outcry subsequent to his podcast with Senator Laird and learn why it is important to have civil discussions on such important topics.

In the second hour (3pm-4pm), my Guest will be Mr. Sean Dougherty, Green Party candidate for Congress.  Meet the Green Party candidate challenging Panetta – The Pajaronian | Watsonville, CA

He has organized a  3pm educational rally this Saturday, Rally Against Lithium Fires, at London Nelson Center with others who oppose lithium battery energy storage systems (BESS), such the likes as what led to the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Fire in January, flaring again in February…and may be still smoldering.

Learn what  safe alternatives exist that Santa Cruz County leaders could be insisting be put in place as they move toward approving three BESS locations: 90 Minto Road in Watsonville (in permitting process), Freedom Blvd. near Aptos High School, and Paul Sweet Road, Santa Cruz (near Dominican Hospital).

There may also be an update on the “Never Again Moss Landing” group activities. Never Again Moss Landing, CA | Community Safety & Advocacy

We will invite callers to join the conversation only in the second hour: 831-265-5050

If you miss the live show, you can always listen to the recording.  It will be posted by 5pm on the Santa Cruz Voice website’s “Community Matters” page, whose link is under Current Shows. Santa Cruz Voice – Listen and Be Heard

WHAT IS SHE THINKING??
Also on the April 8 Board of Supervisor Consent agenda it Item #32, where 2nd District Supervisor Kim DeSerpa is appointing  Mr. Jesse Nickell of Barry Swenson Builder to serve on the County Planning Commission.  What?!  

Board Meeting Agenda, Tuesday, April 8, 2025 – 9:00 AM

Whose interests will he support in decision-making and why is he representing the 2nd District area when (I believe) he lives in the City of Santa Cruz?

Maybe he camps out in the Aptos Village Project, the ghetto built by Barry Swenson Builders with lots of money and “unwritten deals” from the County.

WILL THIS WORK?
Recently, I noticed new sidewalk pedestrian crossings installed on Chanticleer Avenue, near the Sheriff Center and the colossal pedestrian overpass on Highway One (scheduled to open next month).  It is located about half a block from the busy and hazardous intersection of Chanticleer Avenue and Soquel Frontage Road, where the pedestrian overpass dumps out to an unsignaled intersection with limited visibility.


I wrote County Public Works Dept. staff and asked what the plan is here.  They responded:

“This work is a part of the Chanticleer POC (HWY1 Phase 1), funded by multiple grants and Measure D.
There is not a plan to signalize Chanticleer and Soquel at this time.”

Do you think this will work to provide a safer intersection that will have multiple large delivery trucks of hazardous chemicals swinging into the PureWater Soquel Project sewage water treatment facility, also located on this busy corner?   Hmmm…

WAGE THEFT AT CONSTRUCTION SITE ON UCSC CAMPUS

More to come on this next week…

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE BY DOING JUST ONE THING THIS WEEK.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Community and Self-Identification
Beyond my family, I identify as a conservationist, but I have toyed with other identities: how about you? It strikes me as an important time to reinvest in community and to question with what kind of ‘movement’ or subculture do we identify. My idea is that we need more togetherness to move our society past the various forms of dis-ease that have seemed too common for too long. And, to get to that togetherness, we need to better, more consciously, place ourselves in a cultural context.

Communities of the US
Aside from racial identities or geographic affinities how many cultural movements or societal communities can you name? Communities of faith get a fair amount of recognition in the USA. About 67% of the USA identifies with Christianity and most of those are either Protestants (including members of the Southern Baptist Convention) or Catholics. I have met many people who strongly identify with their church community. Alternatively, some people identify as “belonging” to one political party or another: Democrats, Republicans, Green, Libertarian, etc. I have relatives and friends that have such affinities and identify themselves via their political party.

There are also quite a few people who seem to identify themselves as followers of some sport or sports team. I have been amazed at how jazzed such sports enthusiasts can become when encountering one another and sharing details of past player performances. There are similar cultural connections made with music, TV, movies, or books. I have been party to conversations of late where for an hour people throw out the titles of movies and books to see who likes what, getting to know one another, seeing how similar who is to who. Are Deadheads a community just about the music?

There is also the militia movement: guns, guns, and more guns…bonding people together with ammunition and love of…Liberty? Preppers, those that are preparing for the collapse of civilization, have a following. I’ve encountered a little-known subculture of anarchistic homeless earth lovers, quite numerous and hidden. They may or may not be related to Hippies, who are apparently still a thing: I know some self-identifying as such. I know no one who would call themselves a Yuppie, and I’m not sure if the Yippie culture is still around. I know of more than a few folks who identify as environmentalists. I also know people who identify with their approach to thinking, calling themselves first and foremost “scientists.” Perhaps that is more in alignment with the cultures related to professions, which are worlds into themselves. I’m not altogether sure that the artist, musician, or cook communities would altogether fit into the same category kinds of professional communities.

I’m sure we could go on and on.

Helping Your Community
After giving oneself the long, long name of all of one’s communities, the next thing might be to ask oneself how actively supportive is one to each of those communities. If you are a member of the Prunedale Militia, does that mean you have a plan, drill and practice that plan, so as to protect members of your community when necessity calls? If you are a Hippie, do you support your brethren with free food, do you work to reject mainstream culture? If you identify strongly as a member of a political party, how do you support that party…besides voting?

It seems to me that we could all use a little deeper dive into the communities with which we self-identify.

How Do We Do It?
In no particular order, again omitting the familial and geographic ties, I might give my long, long name as: Buddhist, farmer, restorationist, conservationist, deep ecologist, communalist, back-to-the-land, pro-labor, and far left. With each of these identities, I look for conversations with others regularly to keep growing and to identify who else is in those circles. Also, I write (this column and more) and do public speaking, I vote, and I am careful about to whom I give money (either through purchases or as donations). I have been asking myself lately if those things are enough to be more supportive of my communities. It is only through cohesiveness and scaling up do our communities become safe places where our ideals prosper. For instance, I despair that there is no regular, cohesive gathering of conservationists in the Monterey Bay, but who am I to criticize that inadequacy – aren’t many of us overwhelmed and unable to help organize or move forward that or any other group? How do we do this?

How Did We Get Here?
So much of what we take for granted now has been gifted us by our ancestors, who took the time and care to move our communities forward. The weekend and five-day work week are the result of folks organizing, taking their personal time to make a difference. Even the air we breathe and water we drink comes more healthily to us thanks to the Clean Air and Clean Water acts and lots of community organizing. Even more, our ability to choose our own leaders by organizing and voting came to us only through revolution, bloodshed, and keen negotiation.

Where Will We Go?
Like every conservation victory I’ve experienced, the successes I just mentioned must be re-won regularly, we must be ever vigilant and willing to act. We don’t do these things alone, we can only do those things together. And, we cannot get together until we see ourselves as more dedicated members of one of our communities and help others to feel they belong and are valuable to that community, as well.

If you have ideas especially about the dearth of a conservation movement around the Monterey Bay, please let me know.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, March 31, 2025

#90 / Short-Term Pain And No Long-Term Gain

It is well-established (and makes a good deal of sense) that some short term pain may well be worth it, if the “short term pain” leads to a “long term gain.” Presumably, this might the idea underlying our current president’s recent announcement that “a recession may be worth it.” Let’s examine that premise.

As it turns out, many economists don’t agree that the policy changes being made by our president are going to have any longer-term payoff. What they see is “short term pain” leading to “long term pain.” Click that link in the first paragraph and read what New York Times reporter Ben Casselman has to say on this topic (paywall policies permitting, of course).

I found the most revealing part of Casselman’s article to come right near the end:

Who bears the costs?
The 2017 tax cuts disproportionately benefited higher-income households, according to most independent analyses. Medicaid cuts would overwhelmingly hurt low- and moderate-income families, as would cuts to other government services. Tariffs likewise tend to be hardest on poorer households, which spend more of their income on food, clothes and other imported goods.

The short-term pain created by the administration’s policies, in other words, could fall hardest on low-income Americans — many of whom voted for Mr. Trump in hopes of improving their economic situation.

“It’s really hard to see how the Trump voters come out ahead,” Ms. Clausing, the former Treasury official, said. “Prices are going to be higher, disruptions are going to be higher and the safety net is going to get cut.”

Even some defenders of Mr. Trump’s policies, such as Mr. Cass, say cutting benefits to pay for tax cuts runs counter to the administration’s stated goal of restoring the middle class (emphasis added).

Just to highlight the obvious, the adminstration’s “stated” goal is not its “real” goal.

The “real” goal is to benefit the billionaires, and to hell with the rest of us.

That make it clear?

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
Zappaed, on to page two, whiskey leaks, run out the clock

Last week the Trump administration reminded us of the Frank Zappa quote: “Government is the Entertainment division of the military-industrial complex,” — not so entertaining as the reality was an ominous leak of “imminent war plans,” as described by journalist Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic who was an inadvertent recipient of the shocking security breach, being added by Michael Walz, who implied “conspiracy during one interview. Included in a group chat on Signal comprised of US Defense Secretary Pete HegsethVice President JD Vance and seventeen other top officials who discussed upcoming strikes against Yemen’s Houthi rebels, Goldberg disclosed that he had hours of advance notice of the action, not sure that it was authentic initially, only to see the Trump announcement about a “very effective” operation later on March 15. When questioned about the leak by the press, Trump claimed not to “know anything about it. I’m not a big fan of The Atlantic. To me, it’s a magazine that’s going out of business.” though National Security Council spokesman Hughes was already on the case reviewing how an inadvertent number was added to the Signal chain. If Goldberg had publicized the details in advance, it could have been deadly to our armed forces in the region, but he chose not to do so until the administration started defending its slip-up, and the Fox News talking heads began making excuses for their old colleague, Hegseth, with charges of “fake news,” a “hoax,” and other improbable spins about conspiracies. Democratic lawmakers were outraged by the security breach, with Senator Coons posting on X that “every single one of the government officials on this text chain have now committed a crime.”  Republican Mike Lawler, a New York representative, said: “Classified information should not be transmitted on unsecured channels — and certainly not to those without security clearances, including reporters. Period. Safeguards should be put in place to ensure this never happens again.”

In the chat, Trump’s cabinet complained about “bailing out Europe” by attempting to keep international shipping lanes safe from Houthi missiles for passage through the Red Sea, with JD Vance expressing his doubts that his boss is aware of the inconsistency in regard to his messaging to Europe that they have to go their own way, essentially “loathing of European free-loading.” Vance wrote that only 3% of US shipping runs through the Suez Canal, with 40% of European trade doing so, with Hegseth’s complete agreement. Interesting that he fled shortly to Greenland with his wife — things a bit too heated in the Oval OfficeJeffrey Goldberg’s surprise at being included in the chat message led him to believe that he could be “part of a disinformation campaign,” since he had met National Security Advisor Mike Walz only briefly in the past, and with the “administration’s contentious relationship with journalists,” and him personally, it was clear that this was out of whack. “I also could not believe that the National Security Advisor to the President would be so reckless as to include the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic in such discussions with senior US officials, up to and including the vice president,” said Goldberg. These revelations are surely going to trigger major questions about security within the Trump cabinet and the handling of highly sensitive government information, echoing the scandal brought upon Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign when she was accused of using insecure servers for emails, a major factor in dooming her run for office.

Another shocker is that his team allowed the president to take to the podium before the assembled press, without briefing him on the security breach, raising questions about the care and qualifications of his inner circle, dumbfounding former Defense Secretary Leon Panetta about the entire episode. Panetta said there was “no question” that the chat was legitimate, referring to the incident as a “serious blunder,” and that a proper conversation should have been held in-person in the White House“It has to be investigated, and somebody, frankly, needs to get fired. Somebody put that name on a list, and whoever that was deserves to be fired,” he told CNN. Regarding the leak, X users displayed a wide range of emotions and opinions, from disbelief to anger, with search terms encompassing ‘War Plans’ to ‘Hegseth.’ ABC’s late-nighter, Jimmy Kimmel commented on the ineptitude, saying, “Our national security is being guarded by a bunch of dudes he wouldn’t trust to throw your cousin a surprise party. The administration accidentally texted me its war plans. No one on the chain thought to ask, who is JG, what are these initials for? They could have been  leaking secrets to Jeff Goldblum for all they know. And not only did this happen, after it happened, no one thought to tell Trump.”

Typically, Fox News host Jesse Watters was indifferent to the accidental disclosure, likening it to an incident where a family member is inadvertently added to a group chat about “raunchy” bachelor party plans. “Well, that kind of happened today with the Trump administration. He (Goldberg) heard some things today he probably shouldn’t have. Could’ve been a wee bit of a security breach.” Goldberg disputes this, saying he removed himself from the group after realizing it was authentic and contained sensitive national security information, hitting back at the White House’s insistence that “no war plans were discussed” and “no classified material was sent to the thread.” Watters attempted to discredit Goldberg, calling him “not a good reporter” and “one of the biggest hoax artists around.” After Goldberg provided screenshots of the Signal group chat in a report to back up his story, Watters contended, “I’m sure it won’t happen again.” Fox’s Jessica Tarlov was absolutely taken aback by Watter’s nonchalance, standing her ground in calling the debacle a sign of “incompetence and recklessness on a scale unimaginable,” compounding Trump’s drop in ratings on his handling of the economy, inflation, and cost of living. “So they’re not doing this on a SCIF (a sensitive compartmented information facility), they’re doing it on an app that you and I, we all have on our phones, and it’s obviously incredibly reckless. National security risks — I don’t ever wanna hear ‘but her emails’ again,'” she added, referring to Hillary’s email server brouhaha. She called this incident a perfect example of what James Carville was asking of Democrats, to “run out the clock” and see what happens in Trump’s second term, where “folks have jobs that didn’t deserve them.”

Watters wasn’t done with Tarlov, trying to call it an accident, unlike “purposeful leaks from the Democrats” in the past. He began, “Yeah, they accidentally leaked something to the media instead of to the Democrats — ,” which brought Tarlov’s interruption to tell him, “They didn’t leak it; they invited him in.” “At least they didn’t home-brew a server and acid-wash it — ‘but her emails!’ I just did it,” Watters jabbed back. Hillary Clinton for her part, posted on X in response to the whole fiasco, “You have got to be kidding me,” alongside a side-eyed emoji. Secretary of Defense Hegseth, initially denying anything at all was amiss, jumped into the attack on Goldberg after he made his revelations, calling him a discredited journalist who makes a profession of peddling hoaxes, naming ‘Russia, Russia, Russia,’ or ‘fine people on both sides’ hoax, and the ‘sucker and losers’ hoax as examples of his “peddling garbage.” Donald Trump kept up his criticism by posting on Truth Social a link to the conservative satirical website, The Babylon Bee, and its article “4D Chess: Genius Trump Leaks War Plans to ‘The Atlantic’ Where No One Will Ever See Them.” Elon Musk stepped in to help by posting the link to the article, also writing, “Best place to hide a dead body is page 2 of The Atlantic magazine, because no one ever goes there.”

Pete Hegseth’s post claiming that “nobody was texting war plans, and that’s all I have to say about that,” brought a pushback from Fox’s Brit Hume who said, “Oh, for God’s sake, the administration has already confirmed the authenticity of the message.” Fox News anchor, John Roberts, praised Goldberg following his devastating exposé, saying, “I would think that there are worse people that you could text your secret plans to, but it appears Goldberg has acted responsibly here in writing this article.” Posts on X, call the operation “sloppy — the only thing worse would have been if they had used Facebook to communicate. We are the laughing stock of the world. Allies sharing intelligence is no more,” and “God, dude, this place is worse than China. They are not allowed to take responsibility for anything. Nothing they do is bad, ever. The media has to adore them, or it’s fake or illegal. This party belongs in prison before it’s too late.” The administration’s whitewashing started from the President on down to White House Press Secretary Leavitt, who said Trump “continues to have the utmost confidence in his national security team, including National Security Advisor Mike Walz,” followed by Speaker Mike Johnson rejecting the possibility that Walz or Hegseth might face disciplinary action. Both Leavitt and Johnson praised those involved saying, “top- level officials were doing their job, doing it well and executing on a plan with precision.” However, Politico is reporting that internal discussions among White House officials are considering ejecting Walz, supposedly with Trump to make a decision within a few days. Still holding your breath?

Satirist Andy Borowitz offered his take on the Signal breach in The Borowitz Report“Defending his decision to use an insecure messaging app to discuss classified war plans, National Security Advisor Mike Walz said on Wednesday that he chose Signal because it offered more emojis. ‘Those sleaze bags at The Atlantic are acting like using Signal is some kind of scandal,’ Walz said. ‘You want to know a real scandal? The government spent billions of dollars on a secure communications system that has zero emojis.’ Walz said that he refused to use the government’s system when it became clear to him that it lacked even rudimentary emojis like fist, fire, and smiley face. ‘I stand by my decision to use Signal,’ he said. ‘When you’re planning to bomb another country, an emoji is worth a thousand OMGs or LOLs.'”

Back during the nomination process for Trump’s cabinet members, red flags were raised about Hegseth’s ability to handle the job he was offered, with many stories about his alleged abusive behavior, public drunkenness, financial mishandling, and bigotry — all ignored as the Senate Republicans approved him with flying colors. “Soooo, we thinking old Pete was drunk on the job or what?” Texas Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett asked. “It would be funny, if it wasn’t so scary! Maybe we need some DEI (Definitely Earned It) hires to get this together because incompetence is OVERWHELMINGLY problematic.” Spotted: A demonstrator’s sign with a photo of Pete Hegseth sipping whiskey from a bottle, captioned “WHISKEY LEAKS…LIKE WATERGATE BUT WITH MORONS.” Journalist Aaron Rupar writes that history repeats itself, but at increasingly high levels of stupidity: “It’s like Watergate, only in this version Nixon directly mails the tapes to Woodward and Bernstein.” And The Onion headline: ‘Teen Warned Not To Accept Group Chat Invites From National Security Advisors She Doesn’t Know.’ Interestingly enough, real estate mogul Steve Witkoff, who was included in the Signal chat group was physically in a Moscow meeting with Vladimir Putin — US military strategy leaking in real time to someone in Russia. Just imagine that — a face-to-face so Putin doesn’t have to bother with reading a text, unless Witkoff handed the Russian leader his cellphone on which the Signal thread was stored.

US Department of Defense official explained to CNN’s Natasha Bertrand that “information providing indication or advance warning that the US or its allies are preparing an attack” — which Hegseth shared — is classified Top Secret“It is safe to say that anybody in uniform would be court martialed for this. We don’t provide that level of information on unclassified systems, in order to protect the lives and safety of the service members carrying out these strikes. If we did, it would be wholly irresponsible. My most junior analysts know not to do this,” he continued. Representative Maxwell Frost of Florida is sending letters to all the identifiable officials in the ‘Hegseth Disaster Signal Chat’ demanding they retain all messages for any pending litigation and Congressional investigations, saying, “Any deletion of the chat is a willful destruction of evidence.” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries called Hegseth “the most unqualified Secretary of Defense in American history” and demanded his immediate dismissal. Jeffries wrote, “The so-called Secretary of Defense recklessly and casually disclosed highly sensitive war plans — including the timing of a pending attack, possible strike targets, and the weapons to be used — during an unclassified national security group chat that inexplicably included a reporter. His behavior shocks the conscience, risked American lives, and likely violated the law.” Jen Rubin wrote on The Contrarian“Proud of your votes for Hegseth? This is on you as much as Hegseth. You knew he was not remotely qualified,” as she called out Senators Ernst and Tillis. Fun fact: Former US Air National Guardsman Jack Douglas Teixeira was sentenced to 15 years in prison four months ago for doing the same thing Pete Hegseth and his band of idiots did when they leaked war plans to a reporter.

So, discipline, dismissal or firing? Jimmy Kimmel says the excuses don’t stop, with Trump dragging out one of his old favorites — “witchhunt.” “First, he blamed the reporter, and when that didn’t work, he blamed the Signal app, saying, ‘it could be a defective platform, and we’re gonna have to find that out.’ Right, maybe one of the wires came loose and the gasket got cracked,” Kimmel quipped, adding, “Blaming Signal for this is like blaming Tinder for when you get caught cheating on your wife.” He wasn’t through as he tore into the talking heads at Fox and Newsmax as they continued with downplaying the scandal, calling it “the perfect storm of incompetence, inexperience, dishonesty, and hypocrisy from the same people who spent the last 12 years screaming about Hillary’s emails and Hunter’s laptop, while calling Signalgate a ‘non-story.'” Why cover it if it’s a non-story? Taking a final swing by mentioning Trump’s DEI initiatives, Kimmel said, “Thank God they got rid of DEI. Now you can rest assured that the idiots in charge are not chosen for their race or gender. They were chosen purely based on being idiots. I believe that Pete Hegseth wasn’t drunk. I believe he was perfectly sober when he made this idiotic mistake.” His belief that President Trump might not be very happy with his national security and defense picks may lead him to calling them Eric and Don Jr.

Satirist Andy Borowitz provides another followup view of Hegseth“Millions of Americans have been rattled this week by the bombshell that a former Fox News host might be a liar, reports on Thursday indicate. According to industry insiders, the revelation that a former employee might have knowingly disseminated falsehoods threatens to tarnish the image of the nation’s most trusted news organization. Harland Dorrinson, a crisis management specialist, said Fox News needs to ‘change the narrative’ by reminding Americans of its peerless and longstanding reputation for honesty. ‘Fox needs to remind people that they are the network of Bill O’Reilly, Glenn Beck, and Tucker Carlson,’ he said. ‘One bad apple doesn’t spoil the whole bunch.'”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Protesting

“When an individual is protesting society’s refusal to acknowledge his dignity as a human being, his very act of protest confers dignity on him.”
~Bayard Rustin

“He who passively accepts evil is as much involved in it as he who helps to perpetrate it. He who accepts evil without protesting against it is really cooperating with it.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr.

“We won’t stop protesting. It’s the engine that moves society forward.”
~Jordi Cuixart

“There are good reasons for being in jail – for protesting.”
~Tracy Chapman

“Every day, I would show up, and there were no kids, just me and my teacher in my classroom. Every day, I would be escorted by marshals past a mob of people protesting and boycotting the school. This went on for a whole year.”
~Ruby Bridges

...

At the Philadelphia Zoo, Mommy, a Western Santa Cruz Galapagos Tortoise (a critically endangered species) that’s over 100 years old recently laid 16 eggs after mating with Abrazzo, a male tortoise of similar age. The staff whisked away (ouch, bad choice of words, sorry!) the eggs and placed them in incubators of 2 different temperatures. Temperature is what decides if the hatchling will be male or female. So far, 4 eggs have hatched, and they are monitoring the remaining eggs. This is a Big Deal[TM]


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *