November 8 – 14, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…Glen Schaller died, SC Chamber Players next concert. Greensite…on the last public hearing for the Wharf Master Plan. Steinbruner…Supes rubber stamp housing, insurance companies leaving Calif., Big Basin Park recovery, rail & trail @ 17th and State Park, Aptos Village & Swenson, governor and county fair board. Hayes…”we need more mountain bike trails”…a spurious statement (and how to solve it).Patton….thou shalt not kill. Matlock…Cuban peanut farms a-cross America. Eagan …Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes…”VETERANS”

...

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY HALL OF RECORDS AND FIRST COUNTY COURTHOUSE.

This was taken before 1894 when the courthouse burned down/up in the fire of that year. Abbott Square is there now, and the Hall of Records still stands on the corner of Cooper and Front Street. Cooper is a short little street. I have no idea which Cooper it was named after, probably Fred Cooper who had a bookstore.                          

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

                                                                                                             DATELINE November 6

GLEN SCHALLER DIED. Glen’s death last week had and has an impact not just on me but on so very many readers who sent notes of our loss. Glen was a very involved and important Santa Cruzan. His full impact on our political status will never be known. I know that I worked with Glen for decades and maintained a complete respect for his politics and his way of life. Nora Hochman wrote…

“Monday afternoon October 30, Glen Schaller was discovered dead in his apartment.  Many of you are aware of the significant health issues Glen faced – he was no longer working because of those issues.

Glen was a longtime significant activist in the progressive political community, labor and in Santa Cruz and Monterey Counties.  His work stewarding new candidates through the various election processes, arranging phone banks, attending and coordinating endorsement forums was important and impressive. Many of us worked on various campaigns with him and the news that he has died is indeed shocking.  His family is gathering here in Santa Cruz and will keep us all apprised of any activities to honor Glen and his deep roots in our community”.

Thomas Leavitt wrote, and enclosed a You Tube of Glen and me at Paul Lee’s Penny University…

“Glen Schaller‘s untimely passing is an immeasurable loss for progressive politics and union organizing in Santa Cruz. As both a member, and later co-chair with his sister, Merrie, I worked closely with him in the GLBT Alliance for many, many years… he was the epitome of ally, the only straight person in the room, but that never mattered. He was the campaign coordinator for the No on 8 campaign, and his work led Santa Cruz to have one of the highest votes against it. A brilliant and capable political organizer and strategist, and a warm, funny, thoughtful, considerate, and incredibly decent human being. I could go on and on about him, but the video on the right, of him speaking to the Penny Academy in 2012 (with you hosting, in fact), illustrates his skill, integrity, and thoughtfulness better than anything I could say. He handles tough questions with grace, peppers his comments with a remarkable knowledge of history, and then busts out about the Wobblies and anarcho-syndicalism in the middle of all that! He was just so damn smart and informed, someone I’ve rarely seen the like of in my many years of organizing. I’ll miss him, and his laughter and joie de vivre forever”.

What else is painfully sad is that The Santa Cruz Sentinel has not mentioned one word about Glen. That’s just another reminder of their lack of connection with our community.

SANTA CRUZ CHAMBER PLAYERS NEXT CONCERT. Their first two concerts of this season have been wonderful and almost jam packed for the Sunday afternoons. Their next concerts are tiled Sonatas for Friends and that means music by Ahn, Beethoven, Dorfan, and Prokofiev. Alison Lee and Isaac Pastor-Chermak, are the concert directors. The concerts will be SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 18, 7:30 PM and SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 3:00 PM at Christ Lutheran Church 10707 Soquel Drive, Aptos (Off Highway 1 at Freedom Blvd.)

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

NYAD. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). **** A must watch movie. No critique here, I loved it and became a total supporter of Diana Nyad (played by Annette Bening) the 64 year old who made four attempts at swimming from Cuba to Florida (110 miles!) She co-stars with Jodie Foster in this near documentary. The swim took her four tries over the decades before she succeeded and you’ll hang on to each attempt. Don’t miss this one. Try to get a copy of the New Yorker online from their piece in 2012 on Nyad herself.

FINGERNAILS. (APPLE TV MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). This bizarre and foolish movie is based on some research saying that if you rip off a fingernail from a couple who wonder about their love being true and strong and fry the nails on a machine, a percentage flashes up showing if the couple is good to go. It takes place in a large group of offices called The Love Training Institute   

ALL THE LIGHT WE CANNOT SEE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.9 IMDB). *** Mark Ruffalo is back onscreen this time with a French accent. It takes place in 1944 with Nazi Germany occupying a small French town full of resisters and a blind girl using a hidden radio to broadcast pro-France encouragements. The relationship between the girl and a German soldier holds our interest…to a point. Go warned.

THE AFTER. (NETFLIX SHORT) (6.4 IMDB). *** This short film seems to be a new idea on the movie internet…it’s only 18 minutes long. David Oyelow shows us the inside reactions to a tragic accident and how it affects his life. It’s touching, disturbing, and very deep into tragedy. It’s almost a silent film and we go so heartfelt into dealing with life’s surprises.

SISTER DEATH. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (5.8 IMDB). *** Almost entirely filmed and centered in a nunnery this movie from Spain covers it all. Ghosts, visions, dreams, memories, nightmares and even a rape by the nunnery gardener. It’s set during the Spanish Civil war and keeps us all guessing and hoping that the new nun comes to her senses. Watch it.

COLD PURSUIT. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). * 71 year old Liam Neeson drives a snow plow for a living and some drug dealers kill his son by planting drugs on him. It’s just one more Hollywood take and lacks any and all believability. Laura Dern is back onscreen too, and plays her usual mugging self. Not recommended.

KAALA PAANI. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.1 IMDB). *** This movie from India takes us right through the covid epidemic and what it did and does to the citizens who live on two islands. Many authorities look for a cure as death hits on several islanders. What’s unusual is that it takes place not now but in December 2027. Go for it.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non-hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

KILLERS OF THE FLOWER MOON. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (8.1 IMDB). ** You can find as many great and positive reviews for Martin Scorsese’s newest creation as there are negative ones. This is the biggie for Leonardo DiCaprio, Robert De Niro and even John Lithgow plus a very heavy Brendan Fraser. It’s the sad and tragic story of how the Osage Indians who lived and worked and settled on the oil rich lands of Oklahoma were murdered and cheated of their lands by the invading white so called settlers. It’s also three and a half hours long and has some very long scenes that drop/lose the important plot. See it just for the depressing history lesson.

PAIN HUSTLERS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB). * If you’ve ever wondered whether your Doctor gets hush money for prescribing your medicines this pseudo-documentary movie won’t solve your problem. Emily Blunt, Chris Evans and Andy Garcia do ok acting jobs in this not too subtle take-off on the Sackler family and OxyPharma/Fentanyl disaster. It’s all about hustling Doctors by any/all means to sell pharmaceuticals ie…Opioids. It’s centered in Florida in 2011 but it could still be happening. Not great, but involving.

ANATOMY OF A FALL. (DEL MAR THEATRE). (7.9 IMDB) * I dozed off once or twice during the 150 minutes this mysterious crime movie runs. A guy/husband/father falls accidentally, or maybe was pushed off a third floor of a vacation cabin and dies. There’s a blind son and a grieving wife to suspect were involved and complex plus numerous courtroom scenes to keep you involved. It’s complex, involving and an ending you can’t forget.

ABSOLUTE BEGINNERS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.6 IMDB). ** A Polish movie about some kids making a movie. Friends since childhood, these teenagers fall in love and go through hell including a drowning. There’s all sorts of relationship issues between these youngsters and it’ll keep your attention…at least through the first three episodes.

BURNING BETRAYAL. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (3.9 IMDB). * A Brazilian movie about marriage and sexual loyalty. The lead actress looks very much like Anya Taylor Joy but she’s a better actress. There’s courtroom scenes galore and even motorcycle club parties with women involved. The sex scenes are numerous and well done…if you like sex scenes, but mostly it’s boring.

FLASHBACK. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (4.9 IMDB). * This quickie is only 16 minutes long and that’s enough. A Yoga teacher goes through a series of flashbacks through her earlier ages. There’s time zones and unusual memories that we don’t know are real or not. There’s also a character named Doctor Bones who adds very little to this fragmented plot.

CREATURE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB). * This fantasy is based on the genuine Frankenstein plot…but you wouldn’t know it until 3 episodes into it. A father and son run a clinic and there’s demons and a dog named Darwin running around. The acting is hammy and the plot takes place in Istanbul. It says the plot centers on life and death and can life be created in a monster form. Confusing and not worth watching.

...

November 6

THE WHARF: FINAL WEEKS

The Wharf Master Plan is closing in for final review and vote by the city council on November 28th.  The Planning Commission concluded its hearing on November 2nd with a 4-1 vote (2 absent) to accept the staff recommendation. The commission proposed no changes to the Plan although one commissioner tried for a friendly amendment to remove the Landmark building, a request which was not accepted by the maker of the motion.

A reminder if you have forgotten: the Landmark building is one of three proposed large new forty-foot tall public buildings to be added to the Wharf along with a 33% increase in commercial space. This large structure at the far southern end, assuredly blocking views, is imagined as a replica for the original Fish Warehouse which was demolished in 1960. At that time, the end of the Wharf was reinforced with new pilings and preserved for fishing. For scale, the one- story Wharf buildings in the photo above are probably twelve feet high and the two- story buildings, probably twenty- four feet high (as per Engineering Report citations). The three new structures will be close to twice the current highest building heights if you include the usual roof add-ons plus where roof line heights are calculated. In addition to this new construction, the Plan proposes a lowered walkway, eight feet below deck, stretching for over 800 feet on the west side, bringing people, noise, and activity to just beneath the restaurants pictured above, from the far -left side to about halfway to the right. The Historic Preservation Commission at its hearing voted to remove this lowered walkway citing that “the highly visible walkway would degrade the visual character of the Wharf by introducing an appendage to the Wharf that is incompatible with its original historic design.” Alternative 2 in the EIR removes this walkway from the Plan. The Court ruled the city has not made an evidence-based case for not choosing Alternative 2, the environmentally superior alternative. Besides impacts from the Landmark building to the sea lion viewing holes, whose relocation sites have been deferred to the future, the Westside Walkway and the three tall new buildings receive the most negative reactions to the Wharf Master Plan.

In preparing for these hearings, with four down and one to go, I am struck by the contrast between the public process for the current redesign of San Lorenzo Park and the process for the Wharf Master Plan. The former, under city Parks planner Noah Downing has involved the public from the beginning and has kept that public involvement every step of the way. Not hand-selected focus groups for an a priori agenda but a wide range of the public and community groups to develop a plan. The consulting firm working on the redesign is presenting several options shaped by and responsive to the public with full transparency. Given this genuine respect for public process, it is highly likely that the resulting design will have full community support, even if not everybody gets exactly what they want.

By contrast, the Wharf Master Plan was created with no public input by a SF design firm for $1 million provided by the city via a grant from the Commerce Department, applied for by the city with the false claim that the Wharf was “severely damaged” by the 2011 tsunami. Besides creating the Wharf Master Plan, the design firm included an Engineering Report which detailed the condition of all 4,450 wooden pilings (in overall good condition with only 5% needing replacement) and the observation that “the Wharf was undamaged by the tsunami.”

So, the Wharf Master Plan was imposed on the community as a fait accompli in 2016. Since that time, despite massive public outcry against many of the changes proposed to the Wharf’s historical feel and character, the Plan remains virtually unchanged (except for 5 feet shaved off the tall building heights from 45 to 40 feet as per city council vote). Speakers against morphing the Wharf outnumber supporters by a very wide margin and still nothing has changed. Alarmed at the inadequate 2020 Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the Plan, a community group of which I am a member, raised money and filed suit in Superior Court. The Court ruled in the community group’s favor and against the city, requiring the Plan and its EIR be cancelled and recirculated, and still nothing has changed.

This ignoring of public sentiment is one thing. Distorting the facts, creating misleading narratives and marginalizing public input is another. Just a few examples: the city has created the fiction that the Wharf can only structurally survive if it is wrapped in a recreation cocoon of boat docks, lowered walkways, pontoons, viewing decks and widened promenades. Like encasing the statue of David in a plywood box to protect it. The Court ruled that there are many alternatives to strengthen the lateral stability of the Wharf other than those proposed in the Plan. Once the public points out a weakness in the city’s arguments, they switch to another. The most recent one is that the lowered Westside Walkway is needed for fire protection, providing firefighters access to the Wharf’s westside, currently lacking. When we point out that the city bought a Willard fire boat for just this purpose, the city omits that fact from its fifty- minute presentation, just repeating its original claim. Another “story” that gains commission sympathy is that the Wharf is barely breaking even in its revenues, so new economic generating facilities are needed. However, in their budget graphs they include expenses for the Lifeguards and Marine Rescue Units, both of which are under the Fire Department, so why are they even mentioned? Like claiming you can’t break even in your budget expenses due to paying your next- door neighbor’s mortgage. And if economics is a concern, why divert foot traffic away from the restaurants and retail stores to a lowered walkway at the back of such businesses, as a member of Don’t Morph the Wharf! pointed out at the Planning Commission hearing.

Then there’s small albeit noticeable manipulations such as listing letters submitted from the Sierra Club, the Santa Cruz Bird Club and Don’t Morph the Wharf! not under their group names but under the names of those who signed the letters. So, for the public and the commissioners it looks like there are three letters from five individuals rather than from three organizations representing hundreds of members. The Sierra Club Group represents three thousand members and supporters in this county but in the Agenda Report it appears as a letter from one person with no group affiliation.

Perhaps the city council will rein in this runaway Trojan horse, respect the recommendations of the Historic Preservation Commission, respect the Court Ruling and respect the voice of the public to preserve, not morph the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
November 6

COUNTY SUPERVISORS WILL RUBBERSTAMP HOUSING ELEMENT IN PUBLIC HEARING NOVEMBER 14

How can the public hope for any meaningful input on the County’s Housing Element that will drastically change density, building height and size with rezoning 74 parcels when the document is scheduled to be sent to the State for blessing the very next day?  That was one of my questions to the County Housing Advisory Commission and Planners last Wednesday.

Never the less, this is now our only chance to weigh in on what we feel is important…such as necessary environmental review to address traffic, water, removal of large heritage trees and existing housing to make way for what could be very dense, tall structures in Aptos, Seascape, Live Oak and Green Valley Road in Watsonville.

Planning Agenda

Housing Advisory Commission…who WERE all those people?!

EXCELLENT WILDFIRE INSURANCE VIRTUAL TOWNHALL MEETING

Assemblywoman Gail Pellerin held an excellent Virtual Town Hall meeting last week that featured a panel of four speakers that brought valuable information to the public.  State Fire Marshal Daniel Berlant talked about a new pilot program through State Office of Emergency Services (OES) to help seniors and disabled residents get assistance to do work reducing fire risk.  The Governor approved $100 million for wildfire protection grants.  Ms. Amy Boch gave a great presentation about the United Insurance Policy Holders Advocacy and described what help is available.   The two other presenters from the insurance industry and the State insurance Commission provided excellent information explaining the cause of the cancellation problems that have plagued property owners throughout the State.

Take a look at this, and thank Assemblywoman Gail Pellerin and her staff for putting it together

MORE INSURANCE COMPANIES LEAVING CALIFORNIA

Four more home insurance brands leave California

WE SHOULD EXAMINE FIRE RECOVERY IN BUTTE COUNTY AND APPLY GOOD PRACTICES HERE

Recently, a good article in the Mercury News reported the rebuilding process in Paradise is coming along quite well, with many upgrades to reduce fire risk in the future.  I was struck by the Butte County offering a choice of nine free pre-approved house plans.

‘We have come so far’: Five years after California’s historic Camp Fire killed 85, Paradise moves ahead with a goal to build a fireproof town [Mercury News article]

WHAT’S HAPPENING IN BIG BASIN?

Take a virtual look at Big Basin State Park recovery since the 2020 CZU Fire.  This should be interesting. Click for lots of photos: The Santa Cruz Mountains Bioregional Council (SCMBC)

WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE PROPOSED RAIL AND TRAIL IMPROVEMENTS BETWEEN 17TH AVENUE & STATE PARK DRIVE?

Make sure you weigh in with your thoughts about the rail trail corridor improvements schedule for areas between 17th Avenue and State Park Drive (Segments 10 & 11) on November 16, 5pm-7:30pm.  You’ll get two minutes.

The County is scheduled to receive comments on the Coastal Rail Trail Segments 10 & 11 Draft EIR at a public meeting on Thursday, November 16, 2023, 5:00pm – 7:30pm. The meeting will be held in-person at the County Board of Supervisors Chambers, 701 Ocean Street, Room 525, Santa Cruz, CA 95060. Remote participation is also available via Zoom.

Please note that to reduce the risk of ‘Zoom Bombing’, attendees will be required to register for the meeting. After registering, you will receive a confirmation email containing a link and information about joining the meeting. Registration takes approximately 1 minute, and you may register at any time up until the end of the meeting. Register here

This is a whopping 1474-page document, but I encourage you to read what you can and submit comment to:

Rob Tidmore, Park Planner IV
Email: RailTrail@santacruzcountyca.gov
Phone: 831-454-7947

Here is a link to the Draft EIR document

I have found the comparison of the environmental impacts of the Ultimate Trail (rail and trail) and the Interim Trail (trail only) on page 377 interesting.  The mitigations for both are on pages 752-758.  Take a look at the Appendix D Mitigation Monitoring Reporting Plan (MMRP) on pages 1223-1248.

The interesting thing about the Draft EIR is that it eliminates the 0.5 mile that includes the Capitola Trestle.

Attend the November 16 public meeting, and do your best to read and comment on the areas of the EIR that interest you most.

WILL APTOS VILLAGE PARK BE ABLE TO RECOVER FROM SWENSON’S DESTRUCTION?

The work to install a large drain pipe from the parking lots of Phase 2 Aptos Village Project to dump the dirty water into Aptos Creek continues.    Anyone who has ever attended a concert on the lawn there or watched their kids and dogs run about will wonder if this grand space will recover?

The view from the Park driveway, looking toward Aptos Creek.

The drain pipe will empty into a pit of rocks on the banks of the Aptos Creek, potentially undermining the rootball of a heritage Walnut tree and cluster of Redwood trees.

Write County Parks Director Jeff Gaffney with your thoughts. jeff.gaffney@santacruzcountyca.gov and maybe a letter to the editor.

GOVERNOR REVERSES BANNED STATES TRAVEL, AFFECTING SANTA CRUZ COUNTY FAIR INTERIM CEO

Governor Newsom is doing some interesting campaigning, isn’t he?  Not only did he travel to Israel and China, he recently quietly removed his Executive Order that declared a number of states to be “banned travel states” for California State employees.

Oddly, in July and August this year, he added more states to the list of many that were deemed unacceptable for California State employees to travel to for business and get reimbursed by the California taxpayers.  This was all based on what he considered regressive politics related to LGBTQ issues.

On September 12, he removed that ban with his approval of SB 447.  Instead, the California taxpayers will pay for advertising campaigns in those 25 states to encourage their governments to change their thoughts and policies.  Hmmm… Shouldn’t we just spend our money fixing roads and problems in California?

How does this affect the Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds? Well, Interim CEO Ken Alstott who managed the Fairgrounds (a state-owned facility) from April to May, and has remained on the payroll until just recently, lives in Tennessee, one of those Alstott banned states.  He commuted from that state to come work in Watsonville.  Now that the Governor has reversed the travel ban, Ken Alstott will be able to be reimbursed over $12,000 for his travel expenses (on top of his $17,000 salary) to help manage the Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds.

Isn’t that amazing?  Fair Board members were not concerned about this expense.

Luckily, the new CEO Zeke Fraser lives in Santa Cruz County.

BROKEN PARKING PERMIT DISPENSER AT COUNTY BUILDING DOES NOT PREVENT TICKETING IF YOU STAY TOO LONG

Does it make sense to you that the County employs a parking lot attendant part-time to issue tickets to vehicles that overstay their one or two hour limit, yet provide no way at all for people to purchase permits to stay longer?

Strange but true.  The County pays a very nice fellow named “Moon” to walk around the parking lot at the County Government Building on 701 Ocean Street to issue tickets.  He is not there every day, but is usually there on Tuesdays when the Board of Supervisors are meeting and unsuspecting members of the public may stay for an extensive meeting agenda…and get ticketed if they do not dash out of the meeting and move their vehicles.

Moon keeps assuring me that he is going to get the machines fixed pretty soon, but so far, that has not happened.

The County’s General Services Dept. oversees this matter, and although staff assured me that “they are working on it”, members of the public cannot purchase extra time for parking at their office in the meantime.  

For well over a year, there was no parking lot attendant.  The job was cut to save money.  However, Moon appeared with a ticket book last spring, and purportedly issued an entire book-worth of tickets to violators his first day on the job…including to County workers who chose not to pay for parking in the employee lot.  Ooops.

It was a bit of rub because many of the tickets were waived, yet the cost of the ticket booklet itself was hundreds of dollars.

Here is the notice posted on both parking permit dispensers at the 701 Ocean Street County Government lot.   They have been out of service for months, but the parking attendant continues to issue tickets for vehicles staying too long.

Is it in the best interest of the public to pay an employee to issue tickets to the public who are at the Government Building to do business or attend public meetings, and offer NO REMEDY to receiving a $30 parking violation, other than to leave a meeting every hour or two to move a vehicle?

Write to General Services Director Michael Beaton  michael.beaton@santacruzcountyca.gov  and ask that either the machines get fixed or Moon take a vacation until they are fixed.

THANK A VETERAN

This Saturday, November 11, marks observance of Armistice Day, aka Veterans Day.  It is not a celebration of war, but rather an opportunity to thank and honor those and their families who have fought for freedom, often with great sacrifice.  Veterans Day 2023: Founding, Fact & Meaning

The WWI Monument at the intersection of Freedom Blvd. and Soquel Drive in Aptos is 100 years old, first installed by the Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR) on Christmas, 1923 to honor the 60 residents of Santa Cruz County who perished in that war.  The Monument was originally placed alongside the Santa Cruz-Watsonville Road (now Soquel Drive), and was nearly buried by the construction of the new Highway One in the 1960’s.

In 2002, a young Scott Evans, member of Boy Scout Troop 599 of Watsonville, worried the Monument would be lost and the significance forgotten, so made it his Eagle Scout Project to relocate it to the present site.  Many local businesses, including Granite Construction Co., helped with the effort.  Scott won many accolades from DAR and local civic groups for his good work.

Now, the Cabrillo Host Lions Club partners with DAR to maintain the garden at the Monument, having won a recent environmental grant from California Lions Club.

The Veterans, DAR, Scouts and Lions will gather on Veterans Day, at 2pm, to commemorate the centennial of the DAR placing the Monument, and to honor those 60 soldiers who perished, and recognize all Veterans and their families.  Please join ceremony if you like.  Parking will be available at the CHP Office across from the Monument.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND THE DRAFT COUNTY HOUSING ELEMENT PUBLIC HEARING AT THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS NOVEMBER 14 MEETING.

LIGHT A CANDLE FOR PEACE IN THE WORLD.

JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK, AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,  Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
November 5

A SPURIOUS STATEMENT (and how to solve it):

“WE NEED MORE MOUNTAIN BIKE TRAILS! “

Let’s reflect a moment about the changing nature of the desires of outdoor enthusiasts’ over the past one hundred and fifty years. A hundred and fifty years ago, hunting (including market hunting) was a predominant desire of outdoor enthusiasts. Hunters had already hunted out tule elk and beaver across the Central Coast, and they were quickly driving to extinction California quail and band tailed pigeons. Wildlife laws and enforcement had to be put in place to change those behaviors and expectations. Then, a hundred years ago, Santa Cruz citizens flocked to the County’s North Coast to enjoy wildflowers, a national trend. Here and across the United States, city people went to the country on day-long sojourns to picnic, walk, and enjoy wildflowers which they picked, dug up, and brought home for bouquets and gardens. It took a concerted effort and rulemaking to conserve wildflowers, to change public behavior on open space.

Fast Forward: A New Desired Outdoor Experience in the 2000’s

A well-funded and organized political campaign can have a lot of impact. We’ve been surprised by marginal segments of the population gaining traction and power in so many aspects of our lives. The group Mountain Bikers of Santa Cruz (MBOSC) is an excellent example, and their statement ‘we need more mountain bike trails‘ is the rallying cry that has propelled them forward over a very short time. We can learn a lot about marketing, rallying cries, and how a functioning democracy can effectively counterbalance minorities by examining this parks management issue in Santa Cruz County. All politics is local.

Local Trail Statistics

There’s a lot behind the statement about ‘needing’ more mountain bike trails. In 2017, I first encountered this statement when MBOSC started circulating deceptive statistics about the limited number of mountain bike trails in Santa Cruz County. Shortly thereafter, a local land trust used those same statistics in a misguided effort at a partnership. MBOSC staff said: “We have 220 miles of legitimate trails here in the county. Of those, less than 40 miles are open to bikes.” On the contrary, my statistics (linked here) documented 136 miles of trails open to bikes.

What Need?

When pressed, MBOSC noted that the skewed data they presented was because their constituency wants more ‘narrow single-track’ trails dedicated only to those recreating on mountain bikes. So, first we must delete the word ‘need‘ and replace it with the word ‘want.’ With that, let’s also get more honest about the group and who wants what, where, and why. Here’s their marketing phrase, restated more honestly:

“According to an advocacy organization, a subset of those individuals who choose to recreate on mountain bikes want increased mileage in Santa Cruz County of narrow single-track trails that exclude all other types of recreational use, which they feel would otherwise interfere with their own recreational experience.”

Designing Trails for Desired User Experience

What processes do we have in place to weigh some parks users’ desired experiences with that of others? How do we balance the desire for “narrow single-track trails dedicated to mountain biking” versus other user desires on public and conservation lands? Here is a link to an overview of the modern method of planning for these issues in parks.

The Purpose of Parks Institutions

To plan for park visitor use correctly, one must delve into the institutional purpose of a given land management agency. To continue using my example of State Parks, this is what the State has to say about whether or not single-tracked trails only for use by mountain bikers are appropriate:

“Improvements that do not directly enhance the public’s enjoyment of the natural, scenic, cultural, or ecological values of the resource, which are attractions in themselves, or which are otherwise available to the public within a reasonable distance outside the park, shall not be undertaken within state parks.” (Cal. Pub. Resources Code § 5019.53)

I suggest that ‘narrow single-track trails used only for mountain bikers’ are ‘attractions in themselves‘ rather than enhancing ‘the public’s enjoyment of the natural, scenic, cultural, and ecological values‘ of a park. In the same manner, do we seriously want to argue that zip lines or drones would ‘enhance’ anyone’s enjoyment of the scenic values of a park?

A Specific Park Goal

Planning for desired visitor experiences proceeds with the definition of the purpose of a particular park. For Wilder Ranch, the purpose is:

“…to protect, preserve, and make available to visitors the cultural and natural resources, including historic features, natural biotic communities, geologic and edaphic resources, and related recreational values of this portion of the coastline and coastal mountain region of central California. Public use and enjoyment of the park is encouraged in the limits established by the State Park classification and resource sensitivities.”

So, Parks planners at Wilder Ranch State Park get to determine which types of desired visitor use experiences fit within those goals, which are clearly related to protecting and preserving lots of things at the park.

Visitor Experience Conflict

When parks managers created the management plan for Wilder Ranch State Park, in 1980, they worked with UCSC professors and students to study the park and there were lots of public meetings. Those studies and the public meetings suggested a potential for visitor experience conflict between the two user groups recognized at the time: hikers and equestrians. As was common with the outdated approach, since hikers outnumbered equestrians, they delineated 27 miles of trails for hiking use only and 9 miles of trail for use by both equestrians and hikers. Parks planners did not envision mountain biking at all, and the plan has not since been updated for that use. Without formal adoption of this new user group in the Wilder Ranch General Plan, mountain biking is not officially allowed at Wilder Ranch State Park. Obviously, there are conflicts between the desired experiences of bikers, equestrians, and hikers…and even more conflicts now recognized by subsets of bikers (thrill riders versus family riders) and hikers (exercise hikers and wildlife viewers).

Next Steps

To minimize conflict and plan to integrate the many modern visitor use experiences at Wilder Ranch State Park using standard modern protocol would require an update of the General Plan. This is important, anyway, at Wilder Ranch State Park as Gray Whale Ranch and Coast Dairies Beaches have since been added to the Park…without any review/planning (no thanks to #CaliforniaCoastalCommission and #CaliforniaNaturalResourcesAgency for being okay with that!).

User experiences are ‘balanced’ not in terms of majority rule, but rather in terms of minimizing conflict with other users and natural resources. In other words, just because your advocacy campaigns make a lot of noise about wanting more miles of ‘narrow-single-tracked trails only for mountain bikers’ doesn’t mean you’ll keep getting more and more of those ‘rad experiences.’ There are too many other conflicting types of users wanting experiences in nature for that to happen, especially when the primary purpose of so many of our parks isn’t active recreational sports, but rather conservation.

Let’s recall that visitor use and wildlife conservation are conflicting goals on open space. This requires careful planning to accommodate both in a given region, across park boundaries. To make this point more strongly, I urge everyone to use the statement “active recreation in open space is Nature Extraction” – we now understand that recreational use disturbs and even eliminates certain species of wildlife. We are extracting recreational areas of open space for human gain…same as mining, only perhaps less obvious. This is one of the top ten threats to biodiversity worldwide and we can find solutions right in our own county, if we take this seriously.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

November 5
#309 / Thou Shalt Not Kill

Since it’s a Sunday, let’s take a moment to remember the Ten Commandments, and specifically the Fifth Commandment, generally rendered, “Thou Shalt Not Kill.”

The Wall Street Journal is the beloved newspaper of those who want to think about money (and it is also aimed at those who want to be informed about those who think about money – which is my personal excuse for subscribing). Recently, the paper has given us a “good news” story about Bushmaster Firearms.

Here’s how The Journal reports the story, in an article published in its Saturday/Sunday edition, September 23-24, 2023:

In December 2005, five groups of Wall Street investors flew in private jets to Portland, Maine, where they took waiting limousines to a warren of metal buildings that resembled a midsize lumberyard. They had come to Bushmaster Firearms in pursuit of a highly profitable product whose market was growing faster than any other in America’s stagnant gun industry. The product was the AR-15, and red-hot Bushmaster, the nation’s leading manufacturer of the rifle, had decided to auction itself to the highest bidder.

Bushmaster’s owner Dick Dyke had once feared that he could never sell the company because so many people had a negative view of the gun. A few years earlier, Dyke had been forced to resign his post as President George W. Bush’s chief Maine fundraiser after the media found out he made AR-15s for a living. After that, his company was again pilloried when two snipers who terrorized the Washington, D.C. area used a Bushmaster in their attacks.

But by 2005, Dyke’s concerns had evaporated. Sales of the AR-15 were growing faster than any other rifle or shotgun. When Dyke let it be known that he might be interested in selling, potential private-equity buyers rushed up to Maine to see his operations and make a bid for the AR-15 maker. “All of the sudden, they became an amazing thing,” recalled John DeSantis, Bushmaster’s chief executive.

Bushmaster, which features a claim that the guns it sells are “made in America,” may well have been a business success story, but The Wall Street Journal article does note that the “massive increase in AR-15 production and civilian ownership” that came with this business success has had “profound consequences for the U.S., affecting how we vote, how we go to social events and how our children attend school.” As Jamelle Bouie puts it, in a column in today’s New York Times that refers specifically to the AR-15, “Our Gun Fetish Is Killing Us.”

I presume that anyone reading this blog posting knows what The Journal is talking about in its coverage of this subject. If you can penetrate the paywall that may be in place on The Wall Street Journal’s website, you can definitely get some details from the story. I am thinking, though, that most people know about Sandy Hook and about the subsequent episodes of mass murder carried out by persons using the AR-15 (and other weapons, too, of course).

Innovation is not always a great thing. Let it be said, however, that Bushmaster does continue to innovate. If you check its website, you will find that the company is offering “New Firearms. New Colors.” The M4 Patrolman, for instance, “delivers the perfect combination of style and substance,” the way Bushmaster tells it. I think we can see how this “style and substance” appeal might have attracted the Missouri woman pictured below, “at home with her [two] AR-15 rifles.”

I was struck by the lovely sign that this Missouri woman features in her home: “Think Deeply; Speak Gently; Love Much; Laugh a Lot; Work Hard; Give Freely; and Be Kind.” I was struck, also, by the pictures on her mantelpiece: her daughters (I am guessing) who are Sandy Hook-age young people.

We are both “individuals,” and we are also part of a greater whole. We are “in this life together.”

Since we are both individuals, and (more than that) part of the whole, we need to consider what we do from both perspectives. “Individually,” if we want to be sure that we don’t end up violating that Fifth Commandment, we should not be arming ourselves with automatic rifles and other weapons that make it easy to kill. Making this kind of individual choice against guns is documented in an article (also relatively recent) in The New Yorker. That article is titled, “The Last Gun I Shot.” It discusses Rachel Monroe’s relationship with the AR-15, and her decision to “put down the gun.”

“Collectively,” if we want to make it harder for individuals (including ourselves) to move into a violation of that Fifth Commandment, we should decide (and this would be a political choice) that corporations should not be able to establish their business success by selling armaments that are then conveniently used for mass murder. There are some efforts to arrive at such a result by way of lawsuits, which is all good and well, but I would like to continue to urge that we ought to make rules for ourselves that outlaw the widespread sale, to the public, of guns that are specifically designed to make it easy to kill multiple persons in short periods of time.

Since it’s a Sunday, I suggest that it would be good to reflect, just for a moment, on those Ten Commandments, and specifically on that Fifth Commandment, “Thou Shalt Not Kill.” If we do think about the Fifth Commandment, there are some implications. There are some possible actions we might take, both individually and collectively.

Let’s think about them.

And…. just to be clear, while today is a Sunday, I’d say that any day is a good day to think about that Fifth Commandment!

To Subscribe Just Click This Link

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
November 6

CUBAN PEANUT FARMS A-CROSS AMERICA

Steve Schmidt in his recent post on his Warnings blog after seeing the latest discouraging polls in the Trump/Biden face-off, begins, “This will be a short post because the words need no interpretation, explanation or augmentation. They are what they are. ‘What they are is a plan to destroy America and plunge into the abyss. Eight years after Donald Trump came down the escalator there are no secrets left. Everything is open. Fascism has come to America, and it is wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross’.” Those last sentences are from the Washington Post.

Schmidt goes on to enumerate the plans Trump and his associates are mapping for using the government to punish critics and opponents in his second term in office, giving Trump the ability to appoint those he wants to investigate or prosecute, with his allies drafting plans to invoke the Insurrection Act for deploying the military to defeat any civil demonstrations that arise…a certainty. Justice Department and FBI personnel will be targeted, as will Joe Biden and his family, as Trump loudly proclaims, though accusations of corruption aren’t backed by evidence.

The Donald’s lackeys will see to it that these plans are well-formulated, even if they have to carry the Toupee Orangerie bodily across the finish line and hide him in a broom closet a la Woodrow Wilson’s babysitters. Trump’s worsening senility, noted with alarm during his time out of office, seems to be of no concern to his hordes who have kept him under wraps as much as possible, though with the numerous court proceedings it has been increasingly difficult to do so. In his appearances he has warned us that President Biden is going to get us into World War Two, and he seems to have forgotten Hillary Clinton was his opponent in 2016, remembering Barack Obama as his nemesis. His word salads, ever-present in his ‘speeches,’ sound ever more confused, dumb-founded, disoriented, a childish imitation of his previous bellowings. Even the media is forced to take notice instead of covering for the former president in order to sell air time or printed advertising with their softball interviews, questioning if he is truly a viable candidate for 2024. If he can’t be propped up adequately, the public recognition of condition may finish him off more quickly than the traipsing of the courts as they attempt to bring him to justice.

Trump’s declining mental state seems to have rubbed off onto the attorneys as they represent him in Judge Engoron’s courtroom, by Attorney Kise mentioning Breitbart conspiracy theories, or Attorney Habba complaining to the press about the unfairness of the proceedings, both playing the complete wet-behind-the-ears fools as if they are experiencing their first trial in a courtroom. They are not helping their client with their antics, indeed, he is beyond help because the trial by summary judgement has been decided…he has lost already, with only the punishment phase to be decided. Therefore, all the legal team has to do is keep Trump happy, looking like serious defenders who get a paycheck at the end. Embarrassingly, Trump doesn’t get it. He has no idea what is going on around him, so we are witnessing a guy on his trip downward, represented by attorneys who get it as they look forward to defending the next doofus in the queue.

Trump believes his ‘children’ are being dragged unfairly into his mess, though they are waist high in the big muddy as officers in the Trump Crime Family…hardly children now, being in their forties, no longer in danger of losing the innocence of a nine year old, as attorney Habba whined for the cameras. Just another element in this fantasy world. Ah yes, reminds one of that other magic place besides Walt Disney World in Florida…Mar-a-Lago, where people enter as lawyers and emerge as witnesses and defendants! Someone needs to remind the team that their client isn’t being indicted in the middle of his presidential campaign, he chose to campaign in the middle of his indictments. Colin Jost of ‘Saturday Night Live’ and its ‘Weekend Update’ segment called out Trump for complaining that he “basically doesn’t have the right to speak” after being slapped with a gag order by a federal judge. Comparing Trump to a child being grounded, in a child-like voice, he dug at Trump by saying, “She’s like literally killing me,” adding, “you’re not even my real mom!” as he slammed his bedroom door. Jost later mocked the former prez for sharing a courtroom sketch on Truth Social showing Jesus seated next to him. “Because if there’s one guy whose trial famously ended well, it’s Jesus’,” Jost said.

The two Trump boys, ages 39 and 45…wait…isn’t that their IQs?… testified last week, making remarks afterward to the assembled press on the courthouse steps, identifiable by their egg-smeared faces. Papa was scheduled to appear last Monday…so how did he score? And, daughter Ivanka was to appear Wednesday after the judge had previously allowed her to delay her testimony by a few days to better prepare. However, at this juncture, Ivanka is asking for yet another delay because of the hardship she faces “with the school week” and the judge is a bit miffed. He thinks she can afford a babysitter to deal with her kids’ school attendance! But, the judge COULD have brought up her attendance two weeks ago at Kim Kardashian’s 43rd birthday party in Los Angeles during the school week, in a new outfit, new do and nice spray tan. No matter, this judge has had it with the Trump family’s delaying tactics so her fantasy got canned…no public outcry on this one, sweetie! Remember when Barack Obama said, “I’m inspired by my own children, how full they make my heart. They make me want to work to make the world a little bit better. And they make me want to be a better man.” Contrast that to Donald Trump’s “She does have a very nice figure. I’ve said if Ivanka weren’t my daughter, perhaps I’d be dating her.” Trump asked a woman at one of his rallies, “Do you have any children?” She answered, “Yes, I have one that’s just under two.” Defensively, Trump says, “I know how many one is!” One thing Trump will never defend is that awkward moment when a zombie looking for brains walks right on past him.

Trump’s choice for House Speaker, Mike Johnson, has decided to press on with the bribery investigation into the Biden family affairs. Former Speaker McCarthy had let the issue slide down on his priority list, but Johnson says, “There’s a lot of smoke here, and we’re going to find out very soon how big the fire is.” In the past, Johnson has accused the President of his alleged indiscretion, but says that the call for a rushed investigation toward impeachment should be approached with caution. House Republicans have failed in their attempts to link Biden to a Ukrainian oligarch, and the FBI has been unable to verify the tip they received. However, a Politico investigative report casts some doubt on Biden’s denial of involvement, contradicting White House claims on several points, particularly that he never discussed business dealings with family, and suggesting that incriminating emails were of Russian origin…fake news. Prominent in the denials is that Hunter Biden profited from China deals, or that his relatives benefitted from the Biden named. Politico feels strongly that the House investigation will bear fruit, with an AP-NORC poll showing that 70% of the public believes Biden acted either illegally or unethically. Will we see Mike Johnson move within one seat from the Presidency?

Speaker Johnson is a fervent supporter for trillions of dollars in cuts to our entitlements of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, and at the same time raising eligibility ages, surely in the spotlight as we advance into the election run-up to 2024. The GOP acknowledges the political risks involved in cutting back benefits, yet are opposed to tax increases to shore up the programs, with even Democrats recognizing the nonsustainability in their current form. The entitlements have an annual cost of $2.7 trillion, and to examine the dilemma Johnson says he will appoint a 16-member bipartisan commission as a priority, with an announcement to come soon. In order to protect office seekers from angry or disillusioned voters no final decisions will be made until after the 2024 election. Johnson doesn’t believe he should dictate objectives or set benchmarks, but the Dems know his record speaks for itself, calling his proposed commission political cover in cutting our earned benefits. “It is unfortunate and disappointing that one of the Speaker’s first priorities is creating a mechanism intended to slash programs that American workers pay for in every paycheck, fully expecting the benefits to be there when they need them,” says Max Richtman, president and CEO of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare. Alex Lawson of Social Security Works believes this is a GOP trap to lay blame on Democrats for the Republican’s policy of cutting and destroying Social Security.

Representative Matt Gaetz has given Johnson the moniker “MAGA Mike” as he crows about the power of the movement in putting Kevin McCarthy out to pasture. To be sure, he is one of the most extreme Republicans to be found. As the new Speaker said on Fox with Sean Hannity, “I am a Bible-believing Christian, and if you want to understand my politics, pick up a Bible off your shelf and read it. That’s my world view.” As MSNBCs Mehdi Hassan asked, “Could you imagine if a Muslim member of Congress said the same about the Koran?” ‘Fox & Friends’ picked up where Hannity left off, as Kayleigh McEnany and Ainsley Earhardt bubbled over Kayleigh’s interview with Johnson about his Christofascism, saying, “I really believe he thinks God is leading the way, this will all get figured out.” In his first remarks to the House as the new Speaker, Johnson suggested that God had placed him in power, saying he doesn’t believe in coincidences, citing a Bible verse about God putting people in positions of authority. Religious-right activist Rick Green declared Johnson as “one of our guys.” And right-winger Benny Johnson tweeted about Mike: he’s America First & MAGA, ally of the House Freedom Caucus, mentor of Jim Jordan, legal defense for Trump impeachment trials, objected to 2020 election fraud, and called for Pelosi to be arrested. Theocracy here we come! Somewhere in Louisiana, Jimmy Swaggart is waiting for is phone to ring.

One of the quotes that popped up with the advent of our new God-appointed Speaker was one from our old nemesis, Barry Goldwater. Barry said, “Mark my words, if and when these preachers get control of the (Republican) party, and they’re sure trying to do so, it’s going to be a terrible damn problem. Frankly, these people frighten me. Politics and governing demand compromise. But these Christians believe that they are acting in the name of God, so they can’t and won’t compromise. I know, I’ve tried to deal with them.” Wikimedia had a treasure trove of Barryisms! When the Moral Majority’s Jerry Falwell opposed the 1981 nomination of Sandra Day O’Connor to the high court, Barry declared that every good Christian ought to kick Falwell right in the ass…John Dean later changing the anatomical reference to “nuts” as the accurate quote. Barry doesn’t stop there as he says, “I’m frankly sick and tired of the political preachers across this country telling me as a citizen that if I want to be a moral person, I must believe in ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’ and ‘D’…just who do they think they are? And where do they presume to claim the right to dictate their moral beliefs to me? I am warning them today: I will fight them every step of the way if they try to dictate their moral convictions to all Americans in the name of ‘Conservatism’. The religious factions will go on imposing their will on others unless decent people connected to them recognize that religion has no place in public policy.” Ah, the conscience of a conservative…remember when?

And on the lighter side, Goldwater also said, “If you don’t mind smelling like a peanut for two or three days, peanut butter is a damn good shaving cream.”

And, who can forget Bob Dylan’s, “I’m a liberal to a degree, I think everybody should be free, but if you think I’ll let Barry Goldwater move in next door and marry my daughter, you must think I’m crazy. I wouldn’t do it for all the farms in Cuba.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com.
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Veterans”

“As we express our gratitude, we must never forget that the highest appreciation is not to utter words, but to live by them.”
~John F. Kennedy

“How important it is for us to recognize and celebrate our heroes and she-roes!”
~Maya Angelou

“Homeless and at-risk veterans need more than just shelter. We must give them the tools to empower themselves and reclaim the self-worth and dignity which comes from occupying a place in the American dream. It is a dream they fought so hard to defend for the rest of us.”          
~Maria Cuomo Cole

...

Matt Rife is one of my favorite current comedians, who, it seems, exploded on to the scene apparently out of nowhere. Here’s an interview where, among other things, he explains how.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

November 1 – November 7, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…Democratic Socialists of America and Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz Chamber Players second concert. Greensite…is preparing for Thursday’s Wharf hearing (11/02) at the Planning Commission and will be back next week. Steinbruner…Pellerin’s bills, Aptos radio tower property, Watsonville airport runway, Aptos village. Hayes…This is fall. Patton….The one state solution. Matlock…Interest – free manna from heaven with a martini. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes “Holidays”

...

NEW HIGHWAY 9 RIVER STREET INTERSECTION IN 1956. An amazing photo showing the new highway, The Tannery in lower right, CPDES hall center right, and the baseball field, the Sashmill far left, new San Lorenzo bridge in lower center. No Harvey West Park, and UCSC’s future site way up at the right.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE October 30

DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISTS OF AMERICA…and SANTA CRUZ ELECTIONS AND NEWS.
(this is from their latest mailer)

The local DSA internal elections for 2023/24 are here.  Elections have been moved to November to support the Executive Committee time for the transition. The Election Committee has developed the following as a self-nomination process. Please note the dates. Only members in good standing can run for office and vote in the election. You can check your membership status here.   If you are not currently a member and need to apply, or if your dues are lapsed, there are dues waivers available any who request it.

Donate to BrattonOnline

BrattonOnline is a work of passion, with varying contributors around the core of Bruce (obviously) and Gunilla, who have been doing this since 2003.

That’s 20 years!

We don’t get paid, but there are costs associated with running a website. If you want to pitch in, we are ever so grateful!!


The button below will take you to the secure donation form.

...

Nominations opened on Wednesday, October 25th:. Please use this Google form to submit your nomination/statement.

Saturday, November 4th: General Meeting – Last call for nominations. Google form closes and voting begins (for competitive committee seats). Voting will be held at the hybrid General Meeting in-person and online.  

If you are not sure about throwing your hat in the ring, you can ask to attend Executive Committee meetings to see if it is something you would like to be involved in, and you can find a description of the offices here. If you want to nominate someone else, the Elections Committee is asking that you please coordinate with them so they can submit their written statement through the Google form prior to voting at the general meeting.

SANTA CRUZ CHAMBER PLAYERS CONCERT. Their Concert #2 is titled Love and Thunder: A Road through Impressionism. It’s happening Saturday, November 4, 7:30 pm and Sunday, November 5, 3:00 pm. It’ll feature Chia-Lin Yang, Concert Director and piano; Elbert Tsai, violin; and Brady Anderson, cello. They’ll play Piano trios by Debussy and Brahms. Go here to get tickets and info

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

KILLERS OF THE FLOWER MOON. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (8.1 IMDB).**You can find as many great and positive reviews for Martin Scorsese’s newest creation as there are negative ones. This is the biggie for Leonardo DiCaprio, Robert De Niro and even John Lithgow plus a very heavy Brendan Fraser. It’s the sad and tragic story of how the Osage Indians who lived and worked and settled on the oil rich lands of Oklahoma were murdered and cheated of their lands by the invading white so called settlers. It’s also three and a half hours long and has some very long scenes that drop/lose the important plot. See it just for the depressing history lesson.

PAIN HUSTLERS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB). *If you’ve ever wondered whether your Doctor gets hush money for prescribing your medicines this pseudo-documentary movie won’t solve your problem. Emily Blunt, Chris Evans and Andy Garcia do ok acting jobs in this not too subtle take-off on the Sackler family and OxyPharma/Fentanyl disaster. It’s all about hustling Doctors by any/all means to sell pharmaceuticals ie…Opioids. It’s centered in Florida in 2011 but it could still be happening. Not great, but involving.

ANATOMY OF A FALL. (DEL MAR THEATRE). (7.9 IMDB) *I dozed off once or twice during the 150 minutes this mysterious crime movie runs. A guy/husband/father falls accidentally, or maybe was pushed off a third floor of a vacation cabin and dies. There’s a blind son and a grieving wife to suspect were involved and complex plus numerous courtroom scenes to keep you involved. It’s complex, involving and an ending you can’t forget.

ABSOLUTE BEGINNERS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.6 IMDB).**A Polish movie about some kids making a movie. Friends since childhood, these teenagers fall in love and go through hell including a drowning. There’s all sorts of relationship issues between these youngsters and it’ll keep your attention…at least through the first three episodes.

BURNING BETRAYAL. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (3.9 IMDB). *A Brazilian movie about marriage and sexual loyalty. The lead actress looks very much like Anya Taylor Joy but she’s a better actress. There’s courtroom scenes galore and even motorcycle club parties with women involved. The sex scenes are numerous and well done…if you like sex scenes, but mostly it’s boring.

FLASHBACK. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (4.9 IMDB). * This quickie is only 16 minutes long and that’s enough. A Yoga teacher goes through a series of flashbacks through her earlier ages. There’s time zones and unusual memories that we don’t know are real or not. There’s also a character named Doctor Bones who adds very little to this fragmented plot.

CREATURE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB).* This fantasy is based on the genuine Frankenstein plot…but you wouldn’t know it until 3 episodes into it. A father and son run a clinic and there’s demons and a dog named Darwin running around. The acting is hammy and the plot takes place in Istanbul. It says the plot centers on life and death and can life be created in a monster form. Confusing and not worth watching.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

BODIES. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.3 IMDB).**** Four bodies in four different eras or is it one body and four eras? This tight, tense, well-acted, big budget movie will keep you glued through all episodes. It’s from a graphic novel but you wouldn’t know it. 1943, 2053, 1891 etc. Is the body still alive? Are the four detectives related? Great questions and puzzling answers…don’t miss it.

OLD DADS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB).* It’s billed as a comedy but I didn’t laugh once. 3 long time old friends share racial slurs, share tempers, marriage failures and even get fired together. Bobby Carnavale never was and still isn’t a favorite actor for me…so skip this one.

30 COINS. (HBO SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). A mysterious voice over kept me from watching very much of this one. It’s in Geneva, Switzerland and a cow gives birth to a perfect human baby! The main character is a priest in a small town in Spain. He owns some rare coins which may be haunted. Watch it if the sound track works for you.

LESSONS IN CHEMISTRY. (APPLE TV SERIES) (7.9 IMDB). * Brie Larson the actress/actor is almost too pretty to have any serious problems…even in this drama. She gets fired and decide to host a tv cooking program to teach special menus to her audience. She gets involved with coupling issues, racial problems, and has bad sex with a doctor. After that a dog narrates episode 3! Your choice!!

THE CONFERENCE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (5.9 IMDB).*** A very scary Swedish horror movie about developers trying to create shopping center (with an IKEA store in it) in a community in Finland that doesn’t know how it will affect their community. It goes from deep dark murder to nearly slapstick laughs. It’s well made from any angle and worth watching.

BLANQUITA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.5 IMDB). *** A movie from Chile with a plot that centers on the sad life of a young girl who was raped, abused, and molested at a very early age. She decides to testify against the senator who was one of the guilty men. She gets guidance and help from a priest. It’s based on a real case and she gets vast media attention which causes both good and evil results.

PACTO DE SILENCIO/ “PACT OF SILENCE”. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.8 IMDB).* A successful media executive woman in Mexico goes on a deep and personal search to find the mother who abandoned her when she was born. She discovers four women who might be that possible mom.  Very dramatic, maybe too dramatic and it contains plenty of hidden issues.

...

Gillian is preparing for Thursday’s Wharf hearing (11/02) at the Planning Commission and will be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

October 30

COUNTING MANDATE

Remarkably, first-year Assemblywoman Gail Pellerin had 10 of her bills signed into law by the Governor.

AB 969 makes it illegal to hand count ballots, and interestingly, “This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.”

Should the State control how County Election Clerks and local governance decide to run their elections, restricting what they can do rather than enabling a variety of good options?

The law now reads:

15270.1.

(a) An elections official shall not conduct a manual vote count pursuant to this article or Article 6 (commencing with Section 15290) in any election unless that manual count is conducted pursuant to a plan approved by the Secretary of State. A manual count plan shall be consistent with the regulations adopted by the Secretary of State regarding manual vote counts. The Secretary of State shall prepare a template of a manual count plan that an elections official may use to assist in meeting this requirement.

SEC. 2.

Section 15270.2 is added to the Elections Code, to read:

15270.2.

The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations regarding manual vote counts.

SEC. 6.

 This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:

In order to ensure that county elections officials know what voting system they will be using, particularly with the upcoming 2024 March Presidential Primary, it is necessary for this act to take effect immediately.

AB-969 Elections: voting systems.

Write Assemblywoman Pellerin with your thoughts.

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MUZZLED APTOS LAND OWNER AND HIS CONCERNS

Last Wednesday, during a public hearing, the County Planning Commission discussed the possible parcels to be re-zoned for dense infill development in order to satisfy the State Housing and Community Development (HCD) zeal to force all municipalities to show evidence in updated Housing Element planning documents that massive numbers of housing units will be built or face losing all discretionary control of local land use decisions.

The HCD had just returned a few pages of comments on the County’s draft Housing Element update.  The bulk of the staff report focused on a 13-acre parcel in Aptos near State Park Drive and Highway One, formerly a small golf course, and until recently, featured three large metal towers that served as radio antennae. The County now plans to fit 403 housing units there, and also preserve about 2 acres of open space.  Commissioners wondered what the property owner intended to do?  I found it odd that County Planners said they had no contact with the property owner, and that there were no applications for permits related to the parcel.

During public testimony, many people from the nearby Seacliff Mobile Home Park on Mar Vista Drive testified that no one from the County had contacted them about this large project (403 units) going in on the narrow Mar Vista Drive that is already congested with overflow parking, and has no sidewalks.

A man who said he was the real estate agent for the parcel declared that the property had been for sale for a while, there were no offers, due in part to the County’s unknown actions in rezoning and some past problems.

The final speaker was the property owner himself.  He described how he and his brother bought the land long ago because it was all zoned multi-family housing.  However, in the 1990’s the County suddenly zoned it to be Open Space, with no notice to him and his brother.  He described that he had met with then-Supervisor Ellen Pirie and protested what he considered an illegal taking.  Purportedly, Ms. Pirie’s reply was: “Well, sue us.”

Now that the County is again talking about rezoning his property, he asked the Planning Commission to restore the multi-family zoning to the full parcel.

At that point, Planning Commissioner Chair Renee Shepherd cut off the man’s microphone and told him that his two minutes were up.  “What?!” the man replied.  “Your two minutes are up.  That’s all the time anyone gets here.” replied Chair Shepherd.  “Well.  That’s really too bad.” the owner said, shaking his head and walking away. No other Commissioners or Planning Staff asked for the owner to be able to return to the podium in order to answer questions that came up about the parcel later.

Isn’t that amazing?

You can listen to the recording of that meeting by clicking October 25 agenda and the recording button.

The documents are all there for you to read, too.  I hope you will do so, even though the main document is 866 pages, because the County’s actions will forever change the landscape and quality of life in Santa Cruz County as we know it.  The Planning staff is now hoping to add 6,000 units in the next eight years, even though the State mandate requirement is 4,634…”It is a conservative buffer” staff assured Commissioners.

You can read the comments that HCD sent in response to the County’s Draft Housing Element update here, in the third piece of Correspondence.

Commissioner Violante asked why there was no strikeout and underline editing shown in the document to indicate what changes staff had already made in response to the HCD comments.  Staff replied that the Excel document platform does not support doing that.  She also asked what parcels had been removed from the list of potential re-zone lots, as staff had stated in their presentations because it was not clear in the document?  Staff assured her they will provide a highlighted version to the Commissioners…but what about the public???

HOW DOES STARLINK INTERNET COMMUNICATIONS WORK?

A friend sent me this excellent tutorial that explains how Starlink Internet Communications works, but doesn’t hide behind the math.

Enjoy! 

She also asked about including a range of densities for various parcels, rather than a hard number, based on various unknown factors influencing how densely some lots could be developed.  Staff replied that they cannot change projections now because “HCD will not look upon it favorably.”

Commissioner Andy Schiffrin asked about impacts of density bonuses available to developers that would increase density even more.  He asked that the percentage of affordable units be increased from 15% to 20% because the actual percentage of very low income housing units ultimately gets diluted when developers are able to get such concessions.  He pointed out that the City of Santa Cruz has a 20% affordability requirement.  He stressed that the County should approve fees, not developers.

Planning Dept. Staff Stephanie Hansen stated that the Board of Supervisors “was happy with 15% affordable requirement, and instead voted to accept the Plan as recommended, but to do a Nexis study” to determine if it is necessary to increase the percentage in the future.  She made NO mention of the split vote of the Board on that issue, and that Supervisor Manu Koenig felt changing the percentage would not be wise because it could delay HCD approval.  Supervisors Justin Cummings and Felipe Hernandez did not vote in favor of approving the recommendation, and had wanted to increase the percentage of affordable units to 20%.

Planner Stephanie Hansen did not mention this at all, but Commissioner Schiffrin added “Well, I thought it was a 3-2 vote.”

Commissioner Schiffrin persisted: “Well, we are an advisory body to the Board, so we can make a recommendation that they increase the affordable housing percentage to 20%.  We make independent recommendations.  The Board can accept or reject them.”

The next opportunity for you and others to hear more about the County’s Housing Element update and impending actions will be the Board of Supervisors meeting November 14.  Attend if you can, and share the information with others.

Watch here for the agenda by the Friday before that meeting

IS CLOSING A RUNWAY AT THE WATSONVILLE AIRPORT A WISE THING TO DO?

The Watsonville City Council is debating whether or not to close down the alternate cross runway at the Watsonville Airport to allow for more housing to be built closer to the airport.  Given the strong safety need for pilots to use that cross runway for safe take-off and landing under certain weather conditions, and the fact that our County has historically relied on the Airport for emergency supplies in disasters, is the Watsonville City Council really thinking about the long-term public safety of the population at large, or their own fervor to satisfy the State building mandates?

A pilot friend of mine explained that had the family who crashed into the medical offices near the hospital in 2011 would have used the cross runway instead, that accident would likely not have happened.  What would pilots in the future have as an alternate for take-off and landing in the future if the Watsonville City Council erases that cross runway?

Please write the Watsonville City Council with your thoughts about any action to remove potential emergency uses of the Airport. Their next meeting is November 14 at 4:30pm in the Council Chambers on top of the parking garage at 275 Main Street. Check in with the Watsonville Airport Advisory Commission and urge them to make a strong recommendation to the Council to keep both important runways

SWENSON’S CONTRACTOR RIPS UP APTOS VILLAGE PARK LAWN AND TRENCHES TO APTOS CREEK FOR PARKING LOT RUNOFF DRAINAGE

Well, even though the County has declared it is now into the rain season (post October 15) and all earth disturbance must have a winter grading permit and install erosion control measures, none of that is happening at the Aptos Village Park lawn and Aptos Creek riparian corridor.  Please scroll to the end of this Blog and take a look at some photos from last week that include deep trenching vulnerable to wildlife, the public and their dogs.

I wrote to County Parks Director Jeff Gaffney, County Supervisor Zach Friend, and County Public Works Director Matt Machado to ask if there is a winter grading permit in place, whether Native American observers are on site (I saw none, but did speak with a “soils guy” from Archaeologic Resource Management (ARM) known as the “developer’s archaeologist”), and why there was no erosion control in the massive soil disturbance near Aptos Creek?

Not one of them answered. The quality of the lawn has been destroyed, along with the irrigation system.  Will Swenson repair all that damage to this popular County-owned park?

Has Fish and Wildlife approved dumping parking lot stormwater from the Phase 2 Aptos Village Project into Aptos Creek, known for having clean water for steelhead trout and maybe even Coho salmon?

Write Serena Stumpf serena.stumpf@wildlife.ca.gov with Dept. of Fish & Wildlife, and her Supervisor Wesley Stokeswesley.stokes@wildlife.ca.gov and ask.

Maybe you will have better luck with these local public servants than I did:

Jeff Gaffney jeff.gaffney@santacruzcountyca.gov
Matt Machado matt.machado@santacruzcountyca.gov
Zach Friend zach.friend@santacruzcountyca.gov
 (831-454-2200)

MAKE ONE CALL. WRITE ONE LETTER.  JUST DO SOMETHING AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
October 29

THIS IS FALL

The short days and chill nights have arrived, and there is much more about Nature’s Fall to take a moment to appreciate.

Mediterranean Fall

Mediterranean fall is the transition between the hot, dry season and the cool, wet season. We must thank the Rocky Mountains and the Sierra Nevada, and a variety of other factors for the lack of summer rainfall in much of California, including right here on the Central Coast. Mediterranean spots are very rare on Planet Earth, and their unique climates make for very interesting, species-diverse places. The “rainfall season” starts October 1st. If you manage property, your target date to be prepared for significant rain is October 15: if you are prepared by that date, you will almost always be in time for the first big storm.

Now is Dry

The rain-carrying wintertime storms are starting to sneak our way, but we aren’t quite there. Meanwhile, it is the driest time of year. The tiny rains we’ve seen so far have only wet the soil surface; the soil is bone dry as deep as it goes over most of our landscape. The last significant rains were from a storm that ended on May 3rd and, prior to that, a wetter storm on March 21st!

To Wet Things

The first significant rain is one inch of precipitation, which usually wets the soil enough that it won’t dry out again until Spring. Although there are many soil types across our region, one of the dominant ones is sandy loam. Each inch of rain saturates about 1 foot of soil. I count the inches and imagine the soil getting saturated deeper and deeper, eventually pouring through to the bedrock and recharging the water table, raising the level of groundwater, feeding the springs, streams, and rivers.

When it Keeps Raining

If we are fortunate enough to have a rainy winter, the rain brings so much life. First comes the petrichor, the smell of the newly soaked ground, a chemical that has been shown to be akin to cedar scent, but you know it when you smell it. Fungus gatherers delight in the seasonal parade of edible treats from boletes to oyster mushrooms to chanterelles (and many more). The mosses and lichens brighten, coating and dangling from every limb of every tree. The dust settles and the seeds produced last Spring start to germinate, the golden hills blushing with green.

Fall Bugs

The dry summer means few biting insects, but there are lots of other interesting insects around in Fall. Over the summer, dragonflies went through metamorphosis in streams and ponds and now the young adults are hunting in the uplands, far from their watery birthing places. Watch for them in meadows, over farms, and even in towns. They are gobbling up flying insects, including the rafts of flying ants that came out when it rained a bit a week or so ago.

Ants!

Each of the first rains triggers some insect or another to explode. This last rain produced millions of flying ants on the North Coast. The air was thick with them as they floated on the breeze, more like tiny butterflies than the bees that they are closely related to. One of these early rains will also trigger termites to fly. Both ants and termites nurture winged males and females that disperse to new territories. Different species seem to prefer to take wing with different cues.

Rain Beetles

Another insect flies with the first rains: rain beetles. These are extremely hard to see, but especially rewarding. Many of us celebrate the season’s first significant storm by going outside and getting soaking wet. Rain beetles are no exception. The male beetles make a loud humming-buzz as they seem to float around during the first big storm of the season, right at dusk, and always near chaparral with manzanitas and pines.

Pests

The first rain obliterates the very annoying canyon flies but also sets in motion the birthing of the season’s first mosquitoes. Canyon flies, aka ‘face flies,’ are the miniature flies that invade your eyes and ears and somehow make it into your throats, hack hack! They like the dry summer and even that last small rain made them disappear. However, whenever the soil gets wet, the soil-borne mosquitoes will hatch.

Newts and Salamanders Ahoy!

The first big storm also brings out amphibians. And here’s something you can do to help. I believe we are all pretty attuned to the first big rainfall, either by following the weather report or relying on a friend that does. As the forecast settles on the first storm of the season, stock up on your groceries and cancel your evening appointments. You’ll be safer and the critters that move around for the first deluge won’t die under your vehicle’s tires. Newts and salamanders await the first big rain and then they move around at night. They’ve been holed up in some burrow complex, pacing back and forth all summer eating beetles and grubs along a set of tunnels they have become quite familiar with. The night with the downpour means that they can move out of that familiar territory towards their breeding pools. And, move they do: in mass, across roads, in straight lines to their favorite pond.

First Flush

The first few rains also set loose a host of pollutants that have been concentrating during the dry season. Another reason to not drive on those first few nights of the Big Rain is that the roads are particularly slippery due to the concentration of oils that have leaked out of cars and plastered themselves to the roadways. After making the roadway treacherously slippery, those vehicle fluids then wash into the streams and rivers and flow out to the ocean. I have a habit of looking at the water flowing down the sides of roads in the City of Santa Cruz during the first rains and noting the continuous normally iridescent, oil sheen that is destined to the San Lorenzo and our precious Bay….so sad. If it is your job or you have any means of cleaning up the roads or other pollutant areas for that first flush of rain, I wish you luck in preparing for that, which is right around the corner. This also means you must pay attention if you have made any bare soil by gardening or farming- sediment loss is soil loss, and soils are a non-renewable resources, taking a long, long time to create.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

October 28

#301 / The One State Solution

Yesterday’s New York Times, as it was delivered to my doorstep in hard copy form, carried a column by David Brooks, entitled, “Searching for Humanity in the Middle East.” That’s Brooks, pictured above.

To me, at least, Brooks’ column made a plea for the kind of politics that I wrote about in this blog yesterday, in a blog posting I called, “Lead Like Lincoln.” Quoting Morning Edition co-host Steve Inskeep, I featured one of the rules that Inskeep contends was key to Abraham Lincoln’s political leadership: “Lincoln didn’t tell his supporters they were morally superior to the other side.”

Brooks’ column – which I advise you to read, if you can do it, understanding that The Times may well have fortified itself with a paywall that might make it difficult or impossible for non-subscribers to see what Brooks said – gives us Brooks’ thought that “the Israel-Gaza conflict has pushed us closer to nihilism.” It seems to me that Brooks’ commentary reflects the kind of vision that Lincoln brought to the Civil War, and that Inskeep highlighted in the quotation I have replayed above.

Brooks’ column is not, I guess, totally “despairing,” but his evaluation of where we are, as we “search for humanity in the Middle East,” is not exactly optimistic about where the world is headed. Here are Brooks’ final words, in his column from yesterday:

It feels as if we’re teetering between universalist worldviews that recognize our common humanity and tribal worldviews in which others are just animals to be annihilated. What Israel does next will influence what worldview prevails in the 21st century.

Brooks, in other words, seems to acknowledge that the situation in the Middle East (and around the world, as people “pick sides”) reflects the exact opposite of what Abraham Lincoln proclaims is needed.

Brook’s column (again, I advise you to read it in its entirety, if you can) discusses three “paradigms” that he says have collapsed, or have come close to collapsing, this past month, as events in Israel/Gaza have unfolded. Here is the “third conceptual paradigm” that Brooks says has become “shaky”:

The third conceptual paradigm under threat is the one I have generally used to organize how I see the Middle East conflict — the two-state paradigm. This paradigm is based on the notion that this conflict will end when there are two states with two peoples living side by side. People like me see events in the Middle East as tactical moves each side is taking to secure the best eventual outcome for themselves.

After this month’s events, several assumptions underlying this worldview seem shaky: that most people on each side will eventually come to accept the legitimacy of the other’s existence; that Palestinian leaders would rather devote their budgets to economic development than perpetual genocidal holy war; that the cause of peace is advanced when Israel withdraws from Palestinian territories; that Hamas can be contained until a negotiated settlement is achieved; that extremists on both sides will eventually be marginalized so that peacemakers can do their work.

Those of us who see the conflict through this two-state framing may be relying on lenses that distort our vision, so we see the sort of Middle East that existed two decades ago, not the one that exists today.

In fact, and this is what Lincoln’s admonition recognizes, we are living in “one world,” and we must find some way to do that. The idea that we can successfully live in different “states,” each state hating the other, is an illusion.

As Israel was created, after World War II, Hannah Arendt argued for a “One State” solution. Abraham Lincoln would have been on her side, I think. After all, that is what our Civil War was all about. It seems to me that Brooks, as a longtime observer of the politics of the Middle East, has arrived at the same destination as Hannah Arendt. Perhaps we should all get to that understanding (and quickly, too) and start figuring out how to make it work.

The alternatives to doing so, which include a worldwide nuclear conflagration, are not attractive. 

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
October 30

INTEREST-FREE MANNA FROM HEAVEN WITH A MARTINI

The Great GOP Presidential Candidate Shakedown has begun! Former Trump VP Mike Pence announced he has suspended his campaign, with Steve Schmidt on his The Warning blog declaring Pence “a hollow man with an appetite for the prerequisites of power and the perks that come along with it.” Mikey declared from the start in 2015 that he was “a Christian, a conservative and a Republican, in that order,” even as he followed his President through all the division and malice that were the earmarks of the administration. He was enamored of the perceived power, the mansion, helicopter, Air Force 2, the fanfare and motorcades, the perks that solidified his place in the American pantheon, as he stuck by Trump’s side throughout the embarrassments, and defiling of the Constitution. He was declared anathema by the MAGATs when he refused to do Trump’s bidding, showing his disloyalty by declining to delay the electoral college vote count on that momentous January 6; and, while he did his duty during that insane insurrection, Schmidt says, “The single issue that defined Mike Pence’s service was disloyalty – disloyalty towards decency, humanity, and patriotism. He served a cruel cause with a cold heart. He well and truly tried to ride the tiger in pursuit of power – only to wind up inside…I hope the photo albums were worth it. My generation will be cleaning up this disaster for the rest of our lives.”

So, who’s next? Tim Scott is making a big play for one dollar donations in order to qualify for a place in the next GOP candidate debate, but his name may be de-listed soon, along with those of Larry Elder, Will Hurd, Perry Johnson and Francis Suarez. Some lesser lights are hanging in there, but why and for how long? Nikki Haley, while far beneath front-runner Donald Trump in the polls, has a heated competition with Ron DeSantis as her poll numbers now exceed his. Vivek Ramaswamy seems to be spending most of his time with both feet in his mouth, so who knows where he ends up? They all seem to be waving their hands in the air at the Trump Train in hopes of validating their relevancy as worthy second bananas. There’s always somebody that doesn’t get the message…the reason you don’t believe you have been lied to and brainwashed, is because you have been lied to and brainwashed…simple as that!

A couple of weeks ago most of us in California got the Earthquake Early Warning signal on our cell phones, but some instead got the worthy message, ‘SUPREME COURT BACK IN SESSION!’ No doubt this was spurred by the ongoing grifting revelations regarding Justice Clarence Thomas and his consort, Ginni ‘Imelda‘ Thomas. Their never-ending ‘handful of gimme, and a mouthful of much-obliged’ addiction continues to obligate them to their sugar daddies instead of to the American public and the Constitution. What’s it this time? The Senate Democrats have discovered Thomas never paid back in full a quarter-million-dollar-plus loan from ‘a friend’ to buy a high-end recreational vehicle in 1999. The five year term saw the Thomas twins paying only the interest of about $20K annually before the term was extended to ten years. The Senate committee concluded that the loan was never paid in full and none of the principal was satisfied, though other documentation is being sought to conclude their findings.

Health care executive, Anthony Welters, who was the cash-cow for the loan has written a note, dated November 2008, indicated he was seeking no further payments because he believed Thomas’ annual payments exceeded the total purchase price of the Prevost Marathon Le Mirage XL RV. Talk about mirages! The nine years of interest payments would still leave about an $87K shortfall for the total loan amount which at this juncture should be considered taxable income for the Justice, a figure which seems to be suspiciously missing from his 2008 financial disclosure report. The ethics lapses in Thomas’ ‘gimme’ lifestyle continue to mount, further damaging the public’s opinions of government officials, and in this case, the Supreme Court’s which has been mum on the many disclosures. Our citizenry would be much obliged if the Thomases would just come clean instead of letting the situation fester…show us the documentation of your compliance, your innocence…where are the receipts? If Senator Robert Menendez and his wife are being taken to task over their indiscretions, why not Clarence and Ginni?

It is said that Vladimir Putin bought American…he purchased one Trump and got the whole Republican party for free! And now he has the added bonus of a House Speaker in Louisiana’s Mike Johnson, hand-picked enthusiastically by none other than Mr. Trump himself. The House had a close call when it came reasonably close to electing Gym Jordan to the position, but the GOP thought better and elected a guy who will wear a suit jacket instead. Johnson is known as an ‘election denier.’ But it goes much deeper, since he supported a Texas group’s bid to overturn the election while working in conjunction with others to overturn electoral college votes in four swing states. Prior to his four term stint in Congress, Johnson was a senior lawyer and national spokesperson for the Alliance Defending Freedom, the conservative group which opposes abortion, same-sex marriage and LGBTQ+ rights. In what has now become a familiar hardcore Christian nationalist formulation, Johnson touted during his 2016 Congressional race, “I am a Christian, a husband, a father, a lifelong conservative, constitutional law attorney and a small business owner in that order, and I think that order is important. I have been called to legal ministry and I’ve been out on the front lines of the ‘culture war’ defending religious freedom, the sanctity of human life, and biblical values, including the defense of traditional marriage, and other ideals like these when they’ve been under assault.”

Meidas Touch calls out the new Speaker, an opponent of gun control legislation, for blaming the recent mass shootings in Maine on both teaching evolution and abortion. Speaking at the Christian Center in Shreveport in 2016, he said that a “series of cultural shifts” in this country, led by ‘elites’ and ‘academics’ back in the 1930s who endorsed Charles Darwin’s theories erased the influence of Christian thinking and creationism from society. His religious fundamentalism marks his life and career, and he advocates for return of prayer in public schools, as he derides the “so-called separation of church and state” on the House floor, arguing that our nation’s founders did not establish the separation to prevent religion from influencing government, but rather to impede the government from restricting the influence and free exercise of religion.

Trump’s newly christened (CHRIST-ened?) lackey’s resemblance to Clark Kent may serve to conceal his full nut-job MAGAness, but we shouldn’t be fooled…he is a full-on, rabid election denier, a Bible-thumper who will bash your head in with his holy book if you don’t follow his brand of worship and his interpretation of the First Amendment. He fits in with the GOP brand very well with his denial of climate-change while getting big bucks from the oil and gas companies, is against raising the federal minimum wage, and is in the forefront of the drive to cut Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. So, did the House Circus get what they wanted out of their inept procedure of selecting a new leader? Mike who? Obviously, not by a long shot! Remember…93% of the House GOP voted against dumping Kevin McCarthy, who was an effective party fund raiser. Now they have a powerless, unproven nobody who has already started an irritating glut of an email campaign to introduce himself…and oh, can you send money?

What it all boils down to is that the Republican House will continue to be run by committees, each in their own tiny enclaves, doing what they wish with nobody to stop them. Speaker Johnson can take whatever position he wants on a whole range of issues, but he will be bulldozed by the committee chairs who know what they are doing, and who have the power and influence to do so, leaving Johnson’s crown perilously askew. Next up? Think the GOP might come up with someone who believes in democracy, rather than one who believes he is being ordained by his god? That would be manna from heaven! Kind of reminds one of the statement by Charles de Gaulle, “How can anyone govern a nation that has two hundred and forty-six different kinds of cheese?”

The New Yorker’s Andy Borowitz couldn’t let the ascendance of Mike Johnson pass by without some of his humor: In a stirring acceptance speech after being elected Speaker of the House, Representative Mike Johnson vowed to be “the greatest Speaker of the seventeenth century. For years, time travel was the stuff of science fiction,” he said. “Now as I take this majestic nation back four hundred years, I will make that dream a reality.” Noting that LGBTQ and women’s rights would be subject to his review, he said that he would also be taking a “hard look at some other so-called innovations, such as electricity and soap. My message to the American people is simple: I work for thee,” he said. When a reporter pointed out that there was no such thing as a Speaker of the House in the seventeenth century, Johnson replied, “I see you’ve been reading history books. Enjoy them while you can.”

And what we’ve all been waiting for, the promise of Artificial Intelligence: A guy goes into a bar that has a robot bartender and orders a martini. The robot brings him the best martini ever, and asks the man, “What’s your IQ?” A bit taken aback, nevertheless he answers, “168.” The robot then proceeds to discuss physics, space exploration, and medical technology. The guy leaves, but remaining curious, he goes back to the bar and orders another martini. With a great martini in hand, the robot asks him again, “What’s your IQ?” This time the guy answers, “100,” which prompts the robot to talk about NASCAR, Budweiser, and John Deere tractors. Exiting the bar, the guy’s curiosity is further aroused, so he goes back inside, orders a martini, and is met with the same question, “What’s your IQ?” This time he answers, “Oh, about 50,” and with that the robot moves in closer and says, “Isn’t it terrible the way Biden stole the election?”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Holidays”

“During the first 13 centuries after the birth of Jesus in Bethlehem, no one thought of setting up a crèche to celebrate Christmas. The pre-eminent Christian holiday was Easter, not Christmas”.     
~Nancy Pearcey

“The holidays make her feel as if she’s supposed to be in a cuddle, since everybody else suddenly seems paired off, like mittens, slippers or AA batteries.”       
~Gina Barreca

“Aren’t we forgetting the true meaning of Christmas? You know, the birth of Santa.”
~Bart Simpson.

“Once again, we come to the holiday season, a deeply religious time that each of us observes, in his own way, by going to the mall of his choice.”
~Dave Barry

...

DID YOU KNOW? is a “Social Studies Podcast” on YouTube. I’m not sure when podcasts went from being audio to being video, but I’ve seen a LOT of the lately…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

October 25 – 31, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…San Francisco and Santa Cruz’s similarities, Santa Cruz Chamber Players concert. Greensite…on time is short for saving our historic Municipal Wharf from a Pier 39 future. Steinbruner…CZU fire rebuilds, new Aptos Library, AMBAG’s growth forecast, Mosquito consultant, rail/trail comments. Hayes…Politician’s Community Surveys. Patton… a “Nation” defined. Matlock…a kraken, plea deals and tears on my pillows. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress… Goodnight! Quotes…”Halloween”

...

EASTSIDE SANTA CRUZ HALLOWEEN PARADE 1959. These little urchins were part of the Parent Education Nursery parade and they must all be in their 70s now! Let me know if you know any of them and we’ll celebrate!!

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE October 23

SAN FRANCISCO AND SANTA CRUZ’S SIMILARITIES. This week’s edition of The New Yorker (October 23, 2023) has a great article about San Francisco, its past present and future. I was actually surprised to learn as much as I got from reading it. As Gary Patton dutifully reports…if the paywall doesn’t stop you… go here to read all of it.

It tells how S.F. became the world headquarters of the AI (artificial intelligence) world. It goes deeper to report on the many business closures and I began to realize how similar Santa Cruz’s situation is. Politically it states, “We have two dominant shades of blue—progressives and moderates” In San Francisco they’re both Democrats. But they spar as if they were opposing political parties”. It goes on to state “But in the last forty years the number of malls in the United States has declined by nearly three quarters”. I could quote more but I’ll conclude with “If the struggle in San Francisco’s downtown is the struggle of the American dream-how to be a global city and a small, authentic town at the same time—the solution rests with those who can build bridges between structures of power and grassroots enterprise”.

SANTA CRUZ CHAMBER PLAYERS CONCERT. Their Concert #2 is titled Love and Thunder: A Road through Impressionism. It’s happening Saturday, November 4, 7:30 pm and Sunday, November 5, 3:00 pm. It’ll feature Chia-Lin Yang, Concert Director and piano; Elbert Tsai, violin; and Brady Anderson, cello. They’ll play Piano trios by Debussy and Brahms. Go here to get tickets and info

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

BODIES. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.3 IMDB).**** Four bodies in four different eras or is it one body and four eras? This tight, tense, well-acted, big budget movie will keep you glued through all episodes. It’s from a graphic novel but you wouldn’t know it. 1943, 2053, 1891 etc. Is the body still alive? Are the four detectives related? Great questions and puzzling answers…don’t miss it.

OLD DADS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB).*It’s billed as a comedy but I didn’t laugh once. 3 long time old friends share racial slurs, share tempers, marriage failures and even get fired together. Bobby Carnavale never was and still isn’t a favorite actor for me…so skip this one.

30 COINS. (HBO SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). A mysterious voice over kept me from watching very much of this one. It’s in Geneva, Switzerland and a cow gives birth to a perfect human baby! The main character is a priest in a small town in Spain. He owns some rare coins which may be haunted. Watch it if the sound track works for you.

LESSONS IN CHEMISTRY. (APPLE TV SERIES) (7.9 IMDB). *•Brie Larson the actress/actor is almost too pretty to have any serious problems…even in this drama. She gets fired and decide to host a tv cooking program to teach special menus to her audience. She gets involved with coupling issues, racial problems, and has bad sex with a doctor. After that a dog narrates episode 3! Your choice!!

THE CONFERENCE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (5.9 IMDB).***A very scary Swedish horror movie about developers trying to create shopping center (with an IKEA store in it) in a community in Finland that doesn’t know how it will affect their community. It goes from deep dark murder to nearly slapstick laughs. It’s well made from any angle and worth watching.

BLANQUITA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.5 IMDB). ***A movie from Chile with a plot that centers on the sad life of a young girl who was raped, abused, and molested at a very early age. She decides to testify against the senator who was one of the guilty men. She gets guidance and help from a priest. It’s based on a real case and she gets vast media attention which causes both good and evil results.

PACTO DE SILENCIO/ “PACT OF SILENCE”. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.8 IMDB).* A successful media executive woman in Mexico goes on a deep and personal search to find the mother who abandoned her when she was born. She discovers four women who might be that possible mom.  Very dramatic, maybe too dramatic and it contains plenty of hidden issues.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, Max or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.8 IMDB). ** It does give credit to Edgar Allen Poe for the title but not much else is from the book. It’s really a not too subtle riff on the very real Sackler Family and the opioid pharma OxyContin disaster. Usher’s Mom dies, her grave empties mysteriously, and six kids fight forever over the fortune. It’s really a horror film with a very confusing, crazed plot.

A DAY AND A HALF. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (5.8 IMDB). * This is a Swedish movie and is supposedly based on a true story. A crazed dad searches for his baby daughter, gets a gun and leads police on a long multi car chase all over Sweden. There is so much sadness and tragedy and combining of plots that it’s hard to follow and share the tension and mystery.

FAIR PLAY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). *** An absolutely engrossing and magnetic movie that grabs you at the start and you’ll watch every second. It’s about hedge fund business in New York City… no, it’s really about an affair that an up and coming woman exec has with an equally ambitious male executive. It’s the job versus love, its love versus money its strength versus weakness and you’ll watch every second trying to figure out who’ll win….don’t miss it.

BALLERINA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.3 IMDB). ***A Korean action movie and they just get better and better. Ballerina is full of violence and minimal ballet. Its how one woman seeks revenge after her soon to be best friend gets into a complex and dangerous situation. The scenes between the two friends are touching and real and the violence is just as real…be aware but enjoy it.

...
October 23

PRESERVING OUR MUNICIPAL WHARF FROM A PIER 39 FUTURE.

Time is short to still preserve our historic Municipal Wharf from being turned into a Pier 39.

The next two public meetings, Planning Commission on November 2nd followed by City Council on November 28th will determine the future of this iconic landmark.

If you’ve been following the issue, you know this is a second go-around after the Court ruled in 2022 that the initial EIR (Environmental Impact Report) on the Wharf Master Plan was deficient; that the city of Santa Cruz “violated CEQA’s substantive mandate” when it approved the project and ignored a feasible alternative with less environmental impacts. That Alternative #2 would remove the lowered Westside Walkway from the project and was determined to be the environmentally superior alternative meeting all project objectives in the EIR. The city failed to adopt it without providing feasible evidence for that decision. The Court ruled against the city.

Many other aspects of the Wharf Master Plan met strong community opposition; namely the addition of three new forty-foot-tall buildings, especially the one proposed for the Wharf’s southern end, impacting the views from the Wharf and the location of the sea lion viewing holes. That plus a thirty percent increase in new commercial structures at significantly higher elevations than the current buildings. However, it was the lowered westside walkway that was the focus of deliberations at the recent Historic Preservation Commission hearing.

Try to imagine in the above photo, an external walkway, eight feet below deck level, twelve feet wide, eight hundred feet in length, suspended on new shorter pilings not necessarily matching the other Wharf pilings, stretching below the Wharf restaurants with extended sloping ramps on both ends of its length. While the EIR claims it would not interfere with views from the restaurants, reality begs to differ. More significantly, it would bisect the current structure horizontally, changing the character and feel of the pilings which were determined to be the remaining historic feature of the 110- year-old Wharf. It would bring people, movement, noise, and intrusion into the nesting areas of migratory birds under the Wharf. It would make it more difficult for the birds to access their nests. And as more than one member of the public noted in a letter to the Sentinel, the current height of the Wharf pilings allows even the biggest waves to pass under the Wharf. Put a pedestrian walkway eight feet down, and “imagine how a tubular steel rail would fare once submerged in storm waves and swell and pounded by the surf and logs.” I would add to that scenario “and catapulted into the plate glass windows of the restaurants.”

However, it was the impact of the westside walkway on the historic character of the Wharf pilings that concerned most of the Historic Preservation commissioners. They voted 4-1 to recommend its elimination to council. They also voted unanimously against the staff recommendations to accept the EIR and the Wharf Master Plan.

At the earlier hearing before the Parks and Recreation Commission, the vote was 5-2 to accept the staff recommendations but some commissioners did pose challenging questions and concerns: two noted that there has been no economic analysis to assess whether the investment in proposed new facilities, buildings and commercial space will be financially viable, and whether the maintenance for the new facilities would require more work crew and at what cost. Another noted that the focus appears to be on economics at the expense of environmental impacts. More than one spoke to the impact on low income, subsistence fishermen and women since two thirds of the tailgate fishing areas will be removed. There is no doubt that the Wharf Master Plan is a gentrifying Plan, intended to shift the class make-up of Wharf visitors from working class to the more affluent. One indication of this shift came from the retired Wharf Supervisor, a strong supporter of everything in the Plan, who shared that some Wharf business owners object to people who spend all day fishing and don’t buy anything. That they pay parking fees wasn’t mentioned.

At both hearings, the city’s CEQA consulting attorney from the Sacramento law firm was personally in attendance. She had represented the city in Court, losing the case to the community group, Don’t Morph the Wharf! of which I am a member. She did not speak to legal matters but tried to help the commissioners craft their motions and clarify Roberts Rules of Order. That service was an expensive expenditure of public monies, one that staff, or chair should have been capable of handling. I thought of that expenditure when I noticed for Tuesday’s 10/24/23 city council agenda, a budget adjustment request from the city attorney’s office for an additional half million dollars over the millions already allocated.

If city management staff were responding to public sentiment, to the Court order, to preserving our history, the current recirculated EIR and Wharf Master Plan would have been modified from the first iteration. A modified Plan would protect nature and view sheds. The federal Commerce Department granted a million dollars last year to replace the pilings under the demolished Miramar restaurant, absent any Wharf Master Plan. Future grant monies for maintenance can be sought with a far more modest Plan.

That city management staff have dug their heels in to change nothing, means that those of us concerned about this Plan must be prepared to have our voices heard at city council on November 28th.

Email me at gilliangreensite@gmail.com if you want to be added to the growing list of community members who support preserving not morphing the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

October 23

COUNTY SUPERVISORS WANT RURAL PEOPLE TO RELOCATE RATHER THAN REBUILD

Why was this incredibly important issue hidden on the CONSENT AGENDA at last Tuesday’s Board of Supervisor meeting?

Only 38 of the 911 homes destroyed by the 2020 CZU Fire have been rebuilt.  Rather than improving the process to help those who lost their homes get back on their land, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors want to sweep those people out of the mountains, and into the dense urban area with a new deal that would allow a developer to get even more concessions for high-density subdivisions if they participate.  Affordable?  Not likely.   Isn’t this really playing on the desperation of those who have now run out of money and emotional fortitude, and have still not made permit progress with the County Planning Dept. and 4Leaf Consultants who are to streamline permitting and help these victims?

Take a look at Consent Agenda Item #26

Thank goodness for the Sentinel article that brought it to light for those who could not be at the 9am Tuesday meeting of the Board

The staff report has this to say about the sorry state of affairs for rebuilding those 911 homes that burned:

“That leaves roughly 45% of CZU fire victims who still own their property and who have not initiated any action to rebuild whatsoever.”

DOC-2023-842 Direct staff in the Community Development and Infrastructure Department and staff in the Office of Response, Recovery and Resilience to collaborate on additional outreach to disaster victims in Santa Cruz County to understand the obstacle

Rather than lead an investigation as to why this is so, Supervisors Koenig and McPherson want to launch a survey to see if the CZU Fire victims would like to move into the dense urban area and sell their rural property.

The transfer process would allow the sending site owner to sell their development rights to a developer or landowner with a property in the receiving area. In addition to specifications that incentivize including a residence for the disaster victim, the developer would then be permitted to increase the density or intensity of a receiving site development beyond what is typically allowed. A conservation easement would be put on the sending site to prevent future building at the disaster-prone area.

Koenig told the Sentinel that transfer of development rights have been used across the country, but this potential county program would mark it’s first-ever use in the context of helping disaster victims rebuild in safer areas.

“This program is not meant to force people out of their homes and it’s not meant to prevent people from rebuilding their homes wherever they want,” said Koenig. “It’s meant to create an alternative option in a way for people to either rebuild somewhere else or capture the value of their home even if it has been destroyed.”

What is the real reason behind this ludicrous plan that ignores the fact that some people need to live in quiet areas and are willing to take some responsibility for risks inherent?  Take a look at the Sempervirens GREAT PARK PLAN that very closely mirrors the boundaries of the 2020 CZU Fire:

Great Park Campaign Final Report Spring 2016

Great Park Campaign Report Spring 2014

This was proposed in 2016, with the big question mark about how to gain ownership of the private property within…like the McCrary family.  Well, guess what…their homes burned in 2020, and the County is letting precious few rebuild.  And now, here comes Supervisor Manu Koenig and Bruce McPherson dashing forth with a plan that would maybe be the only way available for those displaced by the ravages of the CZU Fire and getting nowhere with the County to rebuild, other than being financially drained.

Isn’t this amazing?

AMBAG ADJUSTS GROWTH FORECAST FOR OUR AREA

The Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments (AMBAG) is a powerful appointed staffed agency that meets with representatives from Santa Cruz, Monterey and San Benito Counties.  It is the local arm of the State’s stick that is mandating all jurisdictions to triple the number of new developments or run the risk of losing any semblance of local land use discretionary control.

 The AMBAG 2026 Regional Growth Forecast meeting last Monday with jurisdictional planners and managers was interesting.

The population in our area is projected to decrease, and be composed mainly of aging residents and college students.  Take a look at the slides attached at the end of this blog.  I think Slide 11 is especially interesting because it shows the numbers for 2026 are much lower than the 2022 Forecast that influenced the Regional Housing Number Allocation (RHNA) mandate driving the feverish updates on all jurisdictions to re-zone and plan for three  to ten times more building by 2030.

The first draft projections included constant population at the University of California, Santa Cruz and at California State University, Monterey Bay, which is unlikely given expansion plans at both universities of 10,000 – 15,000 students. Once university plans are included, the region will continue to grow slowly through 2050.

Agency members participating in the meeting wanted to have data to support the AMBAG claim that population could increase due to climate change bringing people here to the cooler coastal area, but it turned out there is none.  The data (one study by a former staffer) examined the trend to move away from wildfire-prone areas, leading to the idea related to climate change.

A person from Salinas wanted to know why the Growth Forecast has hard numbers, and could not be presented in a high and low range that would take into consideration uncertain factors.   The answer was that the computer model would not handle that level of information, so the EIR would be challenging, and it doesn’t matter because AMBAG re-evaluates the growth forecasts every four years anyway.

A person from Watsonville questioned the connection between an increase in agricultural jobs but a forecasted drop in population…that does not match with the City’s plan to focus more on providing affordable housing for farmworkers.  No comment from AMBAG staff.

The representative from the City of Santa Cruz pointed out that the development planning in the City is much higher than the 2026 AMBAG growth forecast of 2.4% but don’t ever see it going higher than 5%.  That was discussed awhile, but many wondered about the discrepancy between the AMBAG forecast and the State Dept. of Finance forecast that states population will be stagnant through 2060.

AMBAG staff seemed uncomfortable in explaining that a very recent “robust” discussion with the State Finance people has led them to believe that the next population forecast by the Dept. of Finance “will probably be a little higher.”  Hmmm….

The person from San Juan Bautista wanted to know how demand on infrastructure associated with the Growth Forecast is reflected in the analysis.  What about water and the expected increase in ag? The AMBAG staff talked a lot but gave a very illusive answer about  “we just have to show trends’.

Here is further summary from the staff report:

“Job projections are also lower than in the 2022 Regional Growth Forecast (RGF), reflecting updated data from the
California Employment Development Department. Data through 2022 show that the
region’s jobs have rebounded from the 2020 recession, but have not grown to levels
predicted in the 2022 RGF.

Population projections are substantially lower than the 2022 Regional Growth Forecast
(2022 RGF), reflecting updated information from the 2020 Census and new estimates from
the California Department of Finance (DOF) that show population loss in the region in recent
years, steadily falling fertility rates, stagnant mortality rates, and an aging population”

Agenda Packet 10-23-23

I was not able to get the meeting’s Zoom connection to work so joined by telephone.  I heard comments and questions from staff representing Santa Cruz City, Watsonville, Salinas, San Juan Bautista and I think, Marina, but none from Capitola, Scotts Valley or the County of Santa Cruz.

The AMBAG amended 2026 Regional Growth Forecast will return to the Board, the elected representatives, in November, and in-person public meetings are scheduled for January or February.

MOSQUITO VECTOR COMMISSIONER HIRES ASSESSMENT CONSULTANT TO SUCK YOUR WALLET DRY

Because an exotic mosquito was found in Watsonville last year, the Ag Commissioner wants to raise taxes to gear up for what may or may not be a problem.  However, never miss an opportunity to raise new taxes when people could be easily persuaded to vote for it in fear.

Take a look at the County Board of Supervisor CONSENT agenda Item #49 that approved $245,766 to hire SCI Consulting to develop a Benefit Assessment ballot measure in the near future.  This is the same consultant that developed expensive documents and weighted ballot measures for Santa Cruz County Fire in 2020 and Branciforte Fire District in 2023.  We are a lucrative County for this consultant, because their weighted ballot Special Benefit Assessments are much easier to get a 51% approval vote for than a regular 2/3 voter approval for a special tax.  Such would be the case for CSA 53 Mosquito and Vector Control revenue increases. [Agenda Item
DOC-2023-865
]

“Santa Cruz County Mosquito and Vector Control (MVC) is a special district and is currently funded by County Service Area (CSA) 53, CSA 53 South and CSA 53 North. The Division provides vector-borne disease monitoring, mosquito control, and other important public health services to all Santa Cruz County residents.”

Which is worse… blood-thirsty mosquitos or hungry consultants that glad-hand our local elected officials?

“The first step in this process is to administer a survey with the goal of testing public interest and potential rates. Survey results are expected by March 2024 and will provide direction on either moving forward or postponing the assessment measure.”

I wonder who will receive notice of the survey?????

NEW APTOS LIBRARY WON’T BE OPEN FOR AWHILE

Many who have been watching the Aptos Library new construction project thought it would be open by now.  However, according to library staff, the doors won’t open until December at the earliest.

The delay is rumored to be caused by PG&E scheduling issues, similar to what happened at the Capitola Library. Once up and running, the facility will be able to run 100% on power from the rooftop solar panels.

Library staff also mentioned the opening of the new Live Oak “Library” Annex (no books, no librarian but paid for with Measure S library tax funds) adjacent to the Simpkins Swim Center will also be delayed for reasons similar to the Aptos Library delay.

PUBLIC COMMENT ON RAIL TRAIL BETWEEN 17TH AVENUE AND STATE PARK DRIVE

Now is your chance to review the Draft EIR for the area segments to build a rail and trail on the corridor between 17th Avenue in Live Oak and State Park Drive in Aptos: Public Review Period on Coastal Rail Trail Segment 10 & 11 Project Draft Environmental Impact Report Now Open

There will be a Public Meeting on Thursday, November 16, 5pm-7:30pm with details to follow: IU Webmaster redirect

Public Comment closes December 16, 2023.

This 4.5 mile project evaluation claims to detail both the Ultimate Trail Plan (rail and trail built) and the Interim Plan (rail removed and trail-only built) with equal detail.  However, the study excludes the areas involving the Capitola trestle: “excluding a 0.5-mile section following surface streets through the incorporated City of Capitola from Opal Street/Cliff Drive Plaza to Monterey Avenue/Park Avenue”

Take some time to browse through this document and voice your thoughts.  Strangely, they are to be directed to Mr. Robert Tidmore at the Santa Cruz County Parks Dept.   The address provided on the website for comment is broken but here is what was sent to interested parties:

Rob Tidmore, Park Planner IV

Email:   RailTrail@santacruzcountyca.gov

Phone: 831-454-7947

I have already written Mr. Tidmore to ask that the Draft EIR be available at the Capitola, Live Oak and Downtown Libraries.  Currently, they are only available in the County Bldg. and Parks Office that are not open on weekends to allow public review.

For some reason, the County of Santa Cruz Parks Dept., not the RTC, seems to be the lead agency on this project, and will hold a public hearing on November 16.

The County Board of Supervisors approved accepting the unanticipated $45,000 payment from the RTC for this EIR work done by Remy Moose Manley LLP, a legal firm in Sacramento

This interesting item was Consent Item #52 on the October 17, 2023 County Board of Supervisors agenda

Remy Moose Manley LLP appears to be a large legal environmental firm.  I wonder why they got the job, rather than Dudek, another giant that opened up shop in downtown Santa Cruz as the current building boom was getting started

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT BOARD DISCUSSES ANOTHER SERIES OF BIG RATE INCREASES

Last week, the Finance Director, Leslie Strohm, interrupted the Raftelis Consultant to inform the Board that part of the reason the rate increase is necessary is due to the $11 Million revenue shortfall because customers have done such a good job in conserving.  Wow. Also, the nearly $120 million in cost overruns for PureWater Soquel plays a big role, but that was not really discussed.

“Well, I’m not in favor of the 25% increase the first year,” said Director Tom LaHue, tuning in from Anacortes, Washington.  Except for Director Bruce Jaffe’s questions about inflation, tuning in from his home, there was little discussion about anything of substance.

Four ratepayers were there in the audience, and one stood up and voiced opposition to yet another rate increase. “There are customers on fixed incomes who are struggling now to pay their water bill, and conserving all they can.  You don’t seem to care.”

The Board did not respond but directed staff to guide the Raftelis consultant in making a presentation to them November 21, when they will decide just how steeply the impending rates will climb.

Never mind that at the last rate increase public hearing (February 19, 2019), Director Bruce Daniels said “so as early as June, we could start reducing these rate increases we’re talking about, if we get the grant for PureWater Soquel Project”.  (see minute 2:12 – 2:13:40)  Hesitantly, Project Director Melanie Mow-Schumacher agreed.

Soquel Creek Water District 02/19/19

The District got that state grant, and others, but never reduced any rates.  And here they are, coming back for higher rates to pay the debt on PureWater Soquel large cost overruns and hefty monthly staff bonuses to mid-management associated with the Project work ($3600/month until the Project comes online).  Back in 2019, Finance Director Leslie Strohm assured the full cost of the PureWater Soquel Project had been built into the rate increases (see minute 15:40)

Now, in keeping with the District’s policy since 2020, no capital projects will be undertaken, such as the $2.5 million Quail Run Tank serving Aptos Village for which the District borrowed the full amount to build several years ago but has not done anything to actually build it.

Their game plan is to have a rate increase public hearing a few hours before Christmas Day (when lots of people are really too busy to notice) and send out ballots right away.  The problem for ratepayers is that the ballot will require a 51% protest to shoot the rate increases down…that’s pretty difficult, given there are nearly 15,000 customers.

Anyone in Soquel Creek Water District had better start speaking up now.  Write a letter to the editor of local papers and to the Board:

BOD@soquelcreekwater.org   The Board and staff all seem to be very out of touch with those they represent and work for.

Ratepayers have organized a meeting Sunday, October 29 at the Capitola Library conference room (near the newspaper reading area) for 4pm to strategize.  Please share this information.

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT SERVES BRIGHT BLUE KOMBUCHA MADE FROM TREATED SEWAGE WATER

The District chose to hold their Water Harvest Festival on October 14 in Chanticleer Park, a location not even in their service area?  Hmmm… well, never mind, because the PureWater Soquel Project treatment plant isn’t in their service area either.

I wondered why none of the District staff even gave a mention at last Tuesday’s Board meeting about how the event went.

Maybe the bright blue kombucha they served, made from treated sewage water the likes of what the PureWater Soquel Project is scheduled to inject into the pristine groundwater, then pump out to sell to customers, did not go over so well with informed members of the public?  Maybe not many people were interested in drinking something that resembles Tidy-Bowl blue toilet water…..

We are excited to unveil and host a Pure Water Kombucha tasting. Collaborating with Orange County Water District (OCWD) and Santa Cruz-based Living Swell Kombucha company, a special kombucha is being crafted exclusively for Soquel Creek Water District that utilizes OCWD’s purified water. OCWD currently operates the Groundwater Replenishment System (GWRS) which is the world’s largest water purification system for indirect potable reuse and produces 130 million gallons of water per day. At the Water Harvest Festival, we will be proudly serving ~300 tastings of vibrant blue-hued kombucha, made with purified water!

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER. TAKE A WALK IN THE WOODS AND THINK GOOD THOUGHTS FOR THE WORLD AND ALL LIVING THINGS AROUND YOU..

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

GREY HAYES.

October 22

POLITICIAN’S COMMUNITY SURVEYS

Two weeks in a row- my column is featuring community surveys, egads! Praises to the people and groups who reach out to invite community engagement through surveys. At the same time, I’m begging for the wealth of the Bay Area’s social scientists to help whoever is creating these surveys.

District 28, Gail Pellerin’s, Community Survey

Here is a link to a blank copy of the survey for reference after the live survey disappears. And, here is the link to the live survey. Fill it out only if you reside in California Assembly District 28, Gail Pellerin’s territory. The deadline is December 8th 2023.

Who is Gail Pellerin?

The following is Assemblymember Pellerin’s biography, from her website:

Assemblymember Gail Pellerin was elected to the California State Assembly in November of 2022 to represent the 28th Assembly District.

Assemblymember Pellerin served as the chief elections official in Santa Cruz County from 1993 until her retirement in December 2020. Gail served as President of the California Association of Clerks and Election Officials from 2010 to 2012 and as co-chair of the Secretary of State’s Voting Accessibility Advisory Committee.

Gail has a BS in Journalism from Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo. Before her experience in public service, Gail worked as a campaign assistant to political campaigns, a newspaper reporter and photographer, and a community college instructor.

Proper Survey Methodology

The first thing I instruct anyone who is creating a survey meant to inform their work is: assure that the answers are precise enough to inform your actions. Read the survey carefully with that in mind. Will Assemblymember Pellerin take the issues with the highest votes and focus effort there? Or will Pellerin use the responses to formulate a better election platform? Her next bid for election is November 2024. Maybe it’s a bit of both.

The next thing I tell anyone who is creating a survey is: tell the respondents what you will do with their data.

Neither the survey I posted last week, nor this current survey have anything definitive about how your answers might affect anything. This is a recipe for a low response rate and lowered community confidence in public process, in general. Ostensibly, public engagement surveys are created for just that: to engage the public. Surveys can not only gather information, but they can inform the public about what’s happening.

Another thing I tell survey design folks is to edit their surveys. The mix of words that are capitalized and not is distracting and further leaves intelligent respondents less than hopeful about the outcome of their time filling out the survey.

What to do with “Other?”

Most survey choices don’t reflect my proclivities, but sometimes there’s an ‘other’ choice- where I can fill in my non-conforming response. I get stuck there: if I have a non-conforming response, does that mean that it will be discarded, or will someone take the time to collate all such responses into trends? How to I pose my ‘other’ response such that it will blend with anyone else’s similar answer, so that together we make a bigger impact? Should I take the time to organize a lot of people in my District to fill in the ‘other’ category so that the Assemblymember pays attention?

I hope someone who designs these surveys lets me know, or, better, that future surveys guide respondents better.

First Question: What is Our Community’s Greatest Need?

The first question, “what is the greatest need facing your community,” is an interesting one. The question challenges the respondent to think of themselves as part of a greater community. This is laudable, encouraging civic thought along the lines of ‘what issue can an Assemblymember address that can cause the greatest good for the greatest number of my community?’ It follows that Pellerin chose the list from which the respondent can choose based on a feasibility analysis, but the survey does not clarify. The most important common human need is to reduce greed, as evidenced by income disparity in our community, and all the issues listed have root causes in that arena. Alas, addressing that need must be beyond feasibility.

With this question, I struggled with the previously mentioned “other” box. My base philosophy is that my community’s greatest need is environmental stewardship: we need all species, and we can do a lot locally to help that need. However, the survey offers the choice ‘Additional Park/Open Space,’ which doesn’t quite work. I almost wrote ‘species conservation’ in the ‘other’ box, but chose that ‘conforming’ answer just to be safe.

Question 3: Housing Nonsense

Check it out: the survey says to ‘check all that apply’ as ‘most needed.’ There’s a logical error inherent in that, right? There are undoubtedly statistics about this, and really this is a question for experts…very few civically engaged people would know how to answer this, but again it’s a laudable exercise to engage our community in the question. And, the informational aspect of the question again poses interesting contrasts. For instance, you can vote for “Middle income/moderate-density housing” versus “low income housing” or “senior housing,” suggesting low income housing or senior housing will be anything but moderate density. That is, suck it up low income people and seniors – you’re going to have to live in packed-in spaces. Interestingly, single family housing stands alone among the other choices that reflect income, age status, or density; so, medium or high density housing and housing for low income or seniors apparently also isn’t in the cards for stand-alone homes. Very informative!

Current Legislation

The final question, weighing in on expanding on someone’s list of current legislative priorities, is also enlightening. This question also says ‘check all that apply.’ I would assume any thinking person would check the box ‘combating climate change.’ Beyond that…isn’t it interesting what the Assembly member has chosen as the menu? This is where the ‘other’ box becomes especially enticing.

Quick! Fill in the survey if you are in District 28!! And, use the survey’s design and information as you cogitate on your vote next November.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

October 21

#294 / A “Nation,” Defined

Ayman Odeh, an Arab Palestinian citizen of Israel and a member of Parliament, is pictured above. Writing in the October 20, 2023, edition of The New York Times, Odeh addressed this topic: “What It Takes To Choose Life Over Revenge.”

Odeh’s commentary, of course, is pertinent to our current situation. Revenge is motivating both Hamas and Israel in the current, and horrific, conflict between them, a conflict that could expand to include the entire world, and bring death and destruction down upon all of us. What Odeh has to say is worth reading. It is worth thinking about. Because there is a just cause for “revenge,” so apparent on all sides, thinking about how we can avoid becoming a world that will destroy itself in the search for revenge is timely. If you can access what Odeh has to say, I encourage you to do so.

I am writing, though, on a slightly different topic, though I think a related one.

The following statement in Odeh’s opinion piece is what has stimulated me to publish this blog posting:

A nation is defined as a group of people with a common language, a common past and common dreams.

In fact, this is not true of the United States of America. The United States of America is not a nation that is defined by its commonalities. Sometimes called a “nation of immigrants,” the United States is not a group of people with a common language, common past, and common dreams. It is not what we have in common that makes us a nation.  Those who came here, both before – and particularly after the American Revolution – came from different pasts, and were people of different ethnicities, different religions, different languages, and different cultures. In fact – really think about this – we are defined as a nation more by our differences than by what we have in common.

What binds us together, as a nation, what makes us a nation, is our dedication to a particular idea about government. That idea is often expressed by this phrase: E Pluribus Unum. Out of many, one.

The force that binds us together in this nation is our joint commitment to a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” Self-government is what makes us a nation. We do not search for what we have in common. We search for ways that we – with all our differences – can live together. We search for how best to govern ourselves, and how to live together, and prosper, both individually and collectively, despite the fact of our obvious differences, and despite the fact that we may well disagree on what is best, and what we should do.

We are a nation dedicated to a government – to a “politics” if you will follow me that far – that allows us to debate and discuss what we should do, and then to mobilize our wealth, and resources, and energies to try to achieve it – reserving always, of course, our right to change our minds and choose to do something different.

If our nation is dedicated to that kind of government (and it is), if that is what “constitutes” us as a nation (and that is what our Constitution proclaims), then we should recognize and celebrate the fact that it is our commitment to self-government that makes us into a nation. We should not fool ourselves into thinking that we must “agree” to some single, “common” purpose. A proper understanding of our government, and of our nation, defined by our commitment to self-government, tells us that we can not only tolerate, but can take great joy in the fact of our differences. It is from within our differences that we work with each other to discover what we think it will be best for us to do. It is from within our differences that we seek to discover how we can live together.

In a nation so organized, revenge has no easy place to gain a purchase. Let us be sure that we are not swept up into the temptations of revenge, and that we are not carried away by those who believe that differences must eliminated, and that “wrong” must be expunged and “right” made triumphant.

That idea is an idea we see in many places.

We have a different message for the world.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

MATLOCKS MUSINGS

October 23

A KRAKEN, PLEA DEALS AND TEARS ON MYPILLOWS

In what they are hailing as a consensus choice, House Republicans have nominated a college intern named Zach to be the new Speaker of the House. The freshly minted GOP nominee acknowledged that he was “kind of surprised” to be chosen as Speaker but said that he was “totally stoked about wielding that hammer.” “I’m, like, whoa – all of a sudden, I’m Thor,” he said. “This is gonna be dope.” Zach, who is taking a year off from his studies at the Northern University of Southern Florida, is well-liked within the GOP conference, insiders said. “Zach never screws up our coffee orders,” one Republican congressman said. “You couldn’t say the same for Kevin McCarthy.” Nah, that didn’t happen – only in The New Yorker magazine, courtesy of humorist Borowitz.

But it COULD happen with the way the KidzRoom is playing now. Yet another couple of weeks without a House Speaker (unless one was elected after this writing from the nine who have dared a candidacy) with Scalise and Jordan being shot down! Scalise saw the handwriting on the wall after one ballot and bowed out, but former wrestling coach Gym Jordan was persistent, thankfully less so than Kevin Mac, and got his comeuppance quickly, being pinned three times, with the Big Lie Freak even admitting he had lost an election! His underbite must have mangled his tongue something awful in the process. Representative Matt Gaetz who was the mastermind of this whole fiasco by getting McCarthy tossed out, was irate as he whined on Xwitter, complaining that his fellow traveler and MAGA enthusiast was thrown off the mat by his GOP colleagues. What could be more satisfying than having two election denying insurrectionists, supposed sex abusers given the heave-ho by their party?

Jordan had launched a fierce arm-twisting campaign to convince his Republican colleagues to cast a vote for him, calling for a Tuesday roll call vote as a bullying tactic. The threats received online and by phone to House members and their families only drew anger, and by Wednesday he was losing ground. His method of attacks was reminiscent of his wrestling days as described by those who associated with him as a student and later as a coach. Wrestling is known as the art of forcing opponents to relinquish their posture and surrender, and Jordan says, “It’s as basic as it gets.” Writer John Irving who was a wrestler in prep school observes, “Wrestling offers folks in different weight classes the opportunity to bump into people your own size, and you can bump them very hard…” Former Speaker John Boehner compares Freedom Caucus member Jordan’s political style as “legislative terrorism,” as the two battled each other to the point where Boehner couldn’t take it anymore, resigning in 2015. As Boehner says, “He is wound tighter than a baseball. You just see him walk with an intensity that you don’t see in other members.” If they met in the halls of Congress, the former Speaker would try to defuse Jordan’s intensity by asking him, “What are you planning to f___ up today?” Jordan’s partisan influence that allows him to survive in his party is the very blockade to his success, which even the Former Guy was not able to overcome.

Republicans need a Speaker who can be more commonsensical, and many are pointing toward giving that power to temporary Speaker Patrick McHenry, but he has shown little interest in taking the gavel. Some are saying that his reluctance is what makes him a good candidate, but his name does not appear among the nine who are competing for the seat. House Majority Whip Tom Emmer of Minnesota seems to be ahead in the running, but Trump acolytes started hitting him with attacks and calling him “Nancy Pelosi in a Suit,” though the former prez has yet to publicly attack Emmer – at this writing. An olive branch was tossed in the form of a statement to Politico which said, “Whip Emmer worked hand-in-hand with President Trump to help House Republicans fire Nancy Pelosi and retake the majority. If he becomes Speaker, Whip Emmer looks forward to continuing that productive relationship.” Not very commonsensical! Steve Bannon has called Emmer a swamp creature who hates Trump, “the biggest never-Trumper in the House,” though he voted with Trump 90% of the time during that presidency. Islamaphobe right-winger, Laura Loomer, called Emmer “a closet liberal, essentially a Democrat, and one of the worst members of Congress.” So, how did he do after Monday evening’s candidate’s forum, and in Tuesday’s vote after all that fanfare?

Regardless of the outcome, CNN reported a few weeks ago that Kevin McCarthy and his allies (more than one? really?) are going on the attack against Matt Gaetz for leading the revolt against McCarthy’s speakership by ‘expelling’ him from Congress. The ‘allies’ plan to use an upcoming report from the House Ethics Committee that will show unprecedented corruption and ethics violations by Gaetz, including the much ballyhooed child sex-trafficking activity, charges for which have stayed sidelined for far too long. Gaetz has said if his House disruptions lead to an end of his political career, getting rid of Kevin McCarthy makes it all worth it. Perhaps he can get an adjoining cell to be near his fading bronze-skinned, crew cut shorn, balding hero, DJT.

Trump’s political fundraising scam is still rummaging through the pockets of those who believe this self-proclaimed billionaire needs their money to be elected, as he uses their donations to pay legal fees in his many criminal cases. Despite a federal ban on using donor contributions for personal use, the money is actually going to political PACs which are able to spend as they please. So, Trump’s multiple daily pleas for cash to send him back to the White House are a bit deceptive since the attorneys are raking it in for themselves. Federal Elections Commission records show that The Don’s Save America PAC has spent nearly $37M to over 60 law firms and individual attorneys since January 2022, and in the first half of the current year over $20M has gone out for not only Trump, but his businesses, his children, and former White House aides and employees of the Former Guy. Can paying attorney fees for co-defendants and possible witnesses be considered witness tampering or buying a person’s loyalty?

Which brings up the plea deals of Attorney Sidney Powell and Kenneth Chesebro in the Georgia election interference case, agreed to by DA Fani Willis for their cooperation with prosecutors. Would this have come about if Trump had agreed to send some defense monies their way? Or, was the evidence simply to damning for an easy way out? To most this wasn’t a surprise and it puts pressure on other co-defendants as they face legal jeopardy, a signal that if they want to deal the time to act is now, otherwise they go down with the ship. Scott Hall, a former bail bondsman pled guilty several weeks ago, and he along with Powell were accused of breaching an election office branch in Coffee County, Georgia. Powell played a broader role on Trump’s legal team in trying to overturn the 2020 election, though Trump, true to form, is asking, “Sidney who? She never was a part of my legal team!” The man needs to read his past emails for a refresher, as well as the plethora of emails between the attorneys on the ‘team,’ collected by the DA.

Both Powell and Chesebro faced seven felonies, but Powell pled guilty to six misdemeanors, while Chesebro pleaded guilty to one felony count. In so doing, they will avoid conviction under Georgia’s RICO Act, which accuses all defendants of entering an unlawful conspiracy to keep Trump in power, the basis of the indictment. Both individuals seem to be referenced as unindicted co-conspirators in Trump’s federal elections case in DC, and Powell still faces legal jeopardy from defamation lawsuits from Smartmatic and Dominion, the voting machine providers. Trial dates for Trump and the remaining fifteen co-defendants are not set, with Trump and Rudy Giuliani not expected to appear until late in 2024, so don’t expect them to plead guilty in the near future. Now, we wait for the shoes to start dropping since it appears Trump is not dropping any dollars in that direction with the three guilty pleas, and especially with the Kraken having devoured Sidney Powell.

And, we mustn’t forget poor Mike Lindell, crying tears on his MyPillows after losing his lawyers who unceremoniously dumped him for being in arrears on his legal fees…unable to pay them for the past two months. They claim he owes them millions and Mikey tells Politico, “I don’t know where I go from here.” The attorneys informed federal judges in Minnesota and Washington they wish to withdraw representation as Lindell faces billion-dollar lawsuits from Dominion Voting Systems and Smartmatic, saying he had made payments in a timely fashion through 2022, but 2023 has been another story with only small payments forthcoming. Both courts then approved the law firm’s request to withdraw as they were being placed in financial jeopardy. Even as Lindell’s legal and financial difficulties increase, he continues to stand behind Trump’s groundless election fraud claims. He claims he is facing five audits by the IRS, that American Express has slashed his credit line from a million dollars to $100K and that he lost more than $100M in retail sales by being dropped by Costco, Bed Bath & Beyond, QVC, JC Penney and Wayfair, though purchases may still be made online. In July he auctioned off equipment from his factory in Minnesota, yet he bragged to Steve Bannon on his ‘War Room’ podcast that he still spends a million dollars a month…donating to Save America PAC?
Go figure!

A narcissist, a pedophile sex-offender and a Russian spy walk into a bar. The bartender looks up and says, “What can I get you tonight, Mr. Trump?”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “Halloween”

“First of all, it was October, a rare month for boys.”  
~Ray Bradbury

“The farther we’ve gotten from the magic and mystery of our past, the more we’ve come to need Halloween”.    
~Paula Curan

“Most people will tell you growing up means you stop believing in Halloween things – I’m telling you the reverse. You start to grow up when you understand that the stuff that scares you is part of the air you breathe.”     
~Peter Straub

...

Just in case you didn’t know that YouTube has all kinds of stuff, not just cute animal videos… here’s 8 hours worth of singing bowl music for you to sleep to! Inspired by a sunset, the color of the video fades to dark, just like a real sunset.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

October 18 – 24, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…about Joy… Greensite…will definitely be back next week. Steinbruner Hayes…being present naturally. Patton…A Mark Twain Lesson. Matlock… Matlock will be back next week. Eagan … Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week: when opera makes you cry Quotes… “SEX” 

...

CONSTRUCTION OF CVS (LONG’S) DRUG STORE. This was taken July 22, 1965. You can see The Del Mar Theatre on the far left. Van’s Super Market in the photo is about where Oswald’s Restaurant and that ugly three story parking structure is located on Front Street.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE October 16

MORE CONCERNING JOY SCHENDLEDECKER. There’s been some confusion about my dropping Joy Schendledecker’s column from BrattonOnline. Let’s be very clear right from the start…I completely support Joy Schendledecker and her politics and I will definitely vote for her, no ifs ands or buts about it. Over the 48 (forty eight!!) years that I’ve been writing a weekly column (since Good Times Vol 1, April 1, 1975) I’ve dropped many co-writers, some of whom were my very best friends…simply because their “work just didn’t fit”. That’s what I told Joy and it’s impossible to explain further than “her writing just didn’t fit”. Not politics, nothing personal, her work just didn’t fit. Go here to read more about Joy and her campaign, and note my name among her endorsements …it’s been there quite a while. joyforsantacruz.com

MUNCHING WITH MOZART & FRIENDS. This free concert series happens every third Friday in the upstairs meeting room of the Downtown Santa Cruz Library. This will be Music for Violin and Piano with Brian Johnston, violin and Vlada Volkova-Moran, piano. That’s Friday October 20 at about 12 noon (better by 11:30 am).

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.8 IMDB). * It does give credit to Edgar Allen Poe for the title but not much else is from the book. It’s really a not too subtle riff on the very real Sackler Family and the opioid pharma OxyContin disaster. Usher’s Mom dies, her grave empties mysteriously, and six kids fight forever over the fortune. It’s really a horror film with a very confusing, crazed plot.

A DAY AND A HALF. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (5.8 IMDB). ** This is a Swedish movie and is supposedly based on a true story. A crazed dad searches for his baby daughter, gets a gun and leads police on a long multi car chase all over Sweden. There is so much sadness and tragedy and combining of plots that it’s hard to follow and share the tension and mystery.

FAIR PLAY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). *** An absolutely engrossing and magnetic movie that grabs you at the start and you’ll watch every second. It’s about hedge fund business in New York City… no, it’s really about an affair that an up and coming woman exec has with an equally ambitious male executive. It’s the job versus love, its love versus money its strength versus weakness and you’ll watch every second trying to figure out who’ll win….don’t miss it.

BALLERINA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.3 IMDB). ***A Korean action movie and they just get better and better. Ballerina is full of violence and minimal ballet. It’s how one woman seeks revenge after her soon to be best friend gets into a complex and dangerous situation. The scenes between the two friends are touching and real and the violence is just as real…be aware but enjoy it.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

BECKHAM. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). **    Not being a soccer or “football” fan as they call it in England, I had little idea of who David Beckham was…or is. He’s the greatest soccer star to ever make it bigtime. This excellent documentary takes us through his entire life from total 100% fame and love to absolute hell and disgust from every soccer fan in the world. He marries a Spice Girl, worries about kidnapping, and restores his fame and reputation after making a terrible mistake in one of his games. Go For it.

KHUFIYA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). This slow moving movie deals with the Pakistan vs. India war. It drifts from the spy driven plot and has many of the musical minutes that India movies keep inserting. There’s lung cancer, possible lesbian love the CIA, Osama Bin Laden and it still drags.

THE WONDERFUL STORY OF HENRY SUGAR. (NETFLIX MOVIES) (7.5 IMDB) (new addition) Wes Andersen took four stories by Roald Dahl and made simply fabulous and totally engrossing movies from them. First there’s “The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar” (39 minutes) which stars Benedict Cumberbatch, Ralph Fiennes, Ben Kingsley and Dev Patel. Immediately next on Netflix is “The Rat Catcher” (6.7 IMDB) featuring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes. Licorice lovers should heed advance warnings on that one! Then there’s “The Swan” (18 minutes) (6.9 IMDB). Again starring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes, The Swan deals and nearly faces some gruesome facets of human depravity…added as the fourth of the Dahl & Anderson group is POISON. (17 MINUTES). (6.9 IMDB). This short movie has all the casts of the previous films. Cumberbatch, Dev Patel, Ralph Fiennes and Ben Kingsley. It’s an impossible and intense story with Cumberbatch in a hospital bed with a poisonous snake lying in wait on his stomach. Go for the four of these by all means.

...
October 16

Gillian will definitely be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

October 16

APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT ROAD HAZARD TO NISENE MARKS STATE PARK VISITORS

The County Public Works Dept. still has done nothing about the public safety hazard caused by the Aptos Village Project’s construction fence encroaching into Aptos Creek Road and creating a real blind corner that should not be allowed.



And what will Swenson do with all this drain pipe, stored on a big gash made in the hillside that is supposed to be a new County Park?  Likely it will be used to take all the parking lot and roof drainage through the Aptos Village County Park and let the polluted stuff drain into the clean waters of Aptos Creek.  Do you think that California Dept. of Fish & Wildlife knows about this potential pollution of the southern-most coho salmon habitat?

Contact Ms. Serena Stumpf, biologist for CDFW, tasked with watching over our creeks:

Serena Stumpf serena.stumpf@wildlife.ca.gov

Her supervisor is Wesley Stokes wesley.stokes@wildlife.ca.gov, so copy him on your letter.

Ask County Parks Director Jeff Gaffney how this drain pipe will cross the County Park property:

Jeff Gaffney jeff.gaffney@santacruzcountyca.gov

A GLIMPSE OF JUST HOW HIGH SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT RATE INCREASES WILL BE

The big debt for the massively-expensive and over-budget Project of Soquel Creek Water District to inject treated sewage water into the MidCounty aquifer’s drinking water supply is coming due, and ratepayers will soon be screaming about yet another series of big rate increases.

Last Tuesday, the Soquel Creek Water District Board of Directors heard their Raftelis Consulting staff explain just how far in debt the District is, thanks to the massively-expensive PureWater Soquel Project, and just how steep the upcoming rate increases will have to be in order to pay the bills..

Here is the link to that October 17 Soquel Creek Water District Board agenda packet

Item 7.2 Rate Study on page 110 is of interest

The last rate increases were all based on an anticipated PureWater Soquel Project cost of $60 million.  The Project cost is now approaching $200 million. What’s more, the last round of rate increases, which were cumulative and added up to a 54% rate hike and also formulated by Raftelis Consultants with the goal of financing the Project, were calculated on an assumption that customers would use a lot more water than they actually did.  So, although the PureWater Soquel Project costs have skyrocketed, the revenues have been significantly less than anticipated, because people have cut way back on water use.  Hmmmm…

  • Grants (all for PureWater Soquel Project)

* The state and federal grant programs have contributed over $100 million dollars to the District through the State Water Resource Control Board’s Prop 1 Program, Department of Water Resource’s Sustainable Groundwater Program, and the Bureau of Reclamation’s Title XVI Program.

  • Debt Profile (This is debt encumbered with the PureWater Soquel Project)

* The District has three existing lines of debt. The 2020 Revenue Refunding Bonds are currently being repaid, the Seawater Intrusion Control Fund repayments begin in FY 2026, and WIFIA repayments start in FY 2030. The final payment for the CoBank Revolving Line of Credit will be in FY 2025.

SEE PAGES 110 AND 111 FOR PROPOSED RATE INCREASE SCENARIOS TO COVER THIS DEBT:

 Scenario 1

10% annual gross revenue adjustments are projected for the next ten years from fiscal year (FY) 2024 through FY 2033. Total fund balance reserves are drawn down to a relatively low level (Operating cash only) in FY 2026 and FY 2027 before rebuilding to the target reserve level by 2033. While these more modest, level rate adjustments do avoid rate spikes for customers, this example results in a high degree of financial risk for the District, relative to the other examples

Scenario 2

 25% gross rate revenue adjustment in FY 2024 (current year) followed by annual adjustments of 7.5% from FY 2025 through FY 2033.

This example provides the least financial risk for the District (relative to the other examples) as financial policy targets are achieved in nearly every year of the financial planning period. However, a significant initial rate revenue increase is required to achieve this degree of financial stability

or

Scenario 3

 12.5% annual gross revenue adjustments are projected from FY 2024 through FY 2028, followed by 5.5% adjustments from FY 2029 through FY 2033. This scenario moderates financial risk for the District by achieving, or nearly achieving, financial policy target levels throughout the financial planning period. 

Scenario 4

If customers use 300 AcreFeet/year more water than the Scenarios above use as a basis:

In this what-if scenario, 8.5% annual gross revenue adjustments are projected from FY 2024 through FY 2033.

At the time of this writing, it is unknown what action the Board directed Raftelis Consultants to take. 

CUSTOMERS NEED TO SPEAK UP NOW.   ONCE THE BOARD HAS DECIDED WHICH SCENARIO THEY WANT THE RATE CONSULTANT TO PRESENT LATER NEXT MONTH FOR THEM TO RUBBER STAMP, IT IS A DONE DEAL AND WILL DEPEND ON A PROP 218 PROTEST BALLOT VOTE THAT WILL BE NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO ACHIEVE.

But don’t worry…the Board approved a hefty pay increase all around for Mid-Management. Page 37 of the packet includes Consent Agenda Item 4.5 contract for mid-management:

7.1 Wages 

  1. Effective the first pay period in January 2024, a 5% increase to the salary schedule. 
  2. Effective the first pay period in January in the years 2022 and 2023 2025 and 2026 wages shall be increased by the amount of the “San Francisco/Oakland/San Jose All Urban Consumers” Consumer Price Index from October to October, with a minimum of 0.5% and maximum of 4.5%. 

Page 55 shows that mid-management will also get double the monthly stipend for certification ($100).

There is a reason why Soquel Creek Water District is known as “TH GOLD PLATED WATER COMPANY”.

WILL SELLING AN ADU SEPARATELY AFFECT WATER SERVICE REQUIREMENTS?

At the last Soquel Creek Water District Board meeting, a ratepayer let the Board know that he was trying to convert his garage into an ADU (“Granny Unit”) but had been shocked that the District insisted that the unit have a separate water service and meter.  “$33,000 for a water hookup to my garage seems a bit excessive” he said.

He pointed out that the District’s policy on this is old, dating back to 2002.    Staff put the matter on the October 17 Board agenda for review as Item 7.3 (see page 112)

The current separate metering policy applies to the following development types:
• Commercial units
• Single Family homes
• Multi-family dwelling units
• New construction ADUs (up to 1200 sq. ft)
• Tiny homes and tiny homes on wheels (less than 400 sq. ft)
Several laws that have taken effect in the last five years have prohibited water agencies like the District
from requiring separate metering for particular development types. Senate Bill (SB) 229 (Wieckowski)
excludes conversion ADUs, which are ADUs that are contained within the existing square footage of a legal
structure, from separate metering mandates. SB 7 (Wolk) prohibits water agencies from requiring

individual metering for multi-family projects defined as low-income housing.

Thus, the current separate metering policy does not apply to the following development types:

  • Conversion ADUs, including junior accessory dwelling units (JADUs)
    • Multi-family units designated as low-income (residential building financed with housing tax credits,
    revenue bonds, general obligation bond, or local/state/federal loans or grants, in which at least
    some of the rents are prescribed by deed restrictions or regulatory agreement, and in which at least
    90% of the dwelling units are designated for lower-income occupants

However, while it may have seemed logical that the Board might direct staff to remove the District’s requirement for separate water service and metering for an ADU, Governor Newsom’s action to sign into law the ability to sell an ADU separately from a main residence muddies the water, so to speak.

AB1033, introduced by Assembly Member Phil Ting, D-San Francisco, allows cities to decide whether property owners can sell ADUs as condos, separate from homes. The bill repeals an existing law that prohibits separate sales of ADUs and will allow homeowners to get loans to build them, as opposed to repaying loans through rental income. 

Ting also introduced AB976, which bans local ordinances that require property owners to live in their ADUs — removing barriers that would have otherwise prevented ADUs from being used as rental properties.

ADUs could be sold separately from homes under new California law [SF Chronicle article]

With 20% of California’s housing construction coming from ADU’s, this all merits consideration.

JUST TOO MUCH PRESSURE

Of interest on the Soquel Creek Water District Board agenda of October 17 is this Consent Item 4.6 to DENY a claim for damages due to a faulty pressure regulator (see page 95)

“On June 29, 2022, it became known to Palm Terrace’s Board of Directors that a Soquel Creek Water pressure regulator on or near Soquel Drive had been faulty and was the cause for substantial damage to Palm Terrace’s underground water lines. The water pressure reached close to 100 psi and caused several underground water lines to burst. Palm Terrace spent over $35k on plumber’s fees to stop the water leaks caused by the burst pipes and to repair the damaged pipes”

This is a familiar scenario for many of the District’s rate payers, especially in Seascape.  The Board always takes the action to deny the claim.

WHERE WILL THIS DENSE IN-FILL HOUSING BE LOCATED?

Mark your calendar now for the October 25 County Planning Commission 9am hybrid format meeting because it likely will be your last chance to weigh in with your solutions for where the County should re-zone for ultra-high-density housing developments.  Whatever the Commission decides about the Housing Element update will then go to the County Board of Supervisors for what is sure to be a rubberstamp of approval.

Read the documents presented on September 27, which the Commission will continue reviewing October 25: Planning Agenda

They will also review the 2024 County Growth Goal, which they did not have time to review at all on September 27.

The Housing Element is one of the most drastic changes to our neighborhoods as we know them.  Take a moment and read through the Plan.  You need to make your voice heard.

We should all be asking our elected officials:

WHY IS NO ONE CHALLENGING THE CRAZY STATE MANDATES WHEN THE STATE FINANCE DEPT. AUDIT PROVES ALL THE NUMBERS ARE UNSUPPORTED?

The elected officials are not asking, but many people are: Home – Catalysts for Local Control

California will have a relatively stable population over the next 40 years, and last week the state acknowledged it.  

The population will not grow by 7 million by the end of the RHNA cycle (2031). As suspected, the state has been working off of erroneous population projections and other data to create the overblown RHNA, and despite a 2022 audit that clearly said so, the HCD has so far refused to adjust housing mandates.

The AUDIT page links to many official state audit documents from last year describing “faulty methodology.” Independent researcher Gaetan Lion has been sharing his analysis with the state since January 2023, which confirms the new numbers. 

This should, in a reasonable world, force the recalculation the Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA). The figures are out of whack, and so are the proportions of housing they demand: 40% above moderate, 20% moderate, 40% combination of low and extra low. We are not short of above moderate (market rate) units, but we are short of everything else — because they are not as profitable. Current state housing policy encourages creation of NINE market rate units to every ONE “affordable” unit. 

Independent researcher Gaetan Lion sums up the changes here

Join the weekly Catalysts for Local Control online webinars every Monday, 5pm-6pm, and learn what you can do to meet with your elected decision-makers to bring this information they either are not aware of or simply don’t want to examine, and have to take action to insist the State Housing & Community Development (HCD) recalculate the Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) mandate numbers.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING OF YOUR CHOICE AND MAKE YOUR VOICE HEARD. 

LIGHT A CANDLE FOR PEACE IN THE WORLD.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
October 16

Being Present, Naturally

Family, friends – when you aren’t present, they feel it, you know it.

Nature can help you be present: clouds, wind, scents, the unexpected, the fascinating.

Help heal adults and children the same.

Our best moments are when we feel the most present. The stories we tell, the good ones and the bad ones, reflect on the times when we were most attentive. If you read that statement and let that realization sink in, you might be inspired to take a break from reading this.

The media we return to is that which absorbs us. When we see or read something that catches our attention, we focus on it and the world around us can fall away. Likewise, when we turn our attention outward, the world opens up. The more we pay attention, the more we see. We are incredibly good observers if we stop to do just that.

My favorite way to open myself to discovery, is to find a quiet place in nature and let all that is occurring there slowly reveal itself. There is so much complexity in any wild place that the discovery goes as deep as you are willing to observe.

Jon Young at least used to live near Santa Cruz and has written and taught a lot about how to become more present in the moment and how that presence of mind can help heal. This 17 minute TedX talk summarizes some of his most poignant lessons. Telling stories, listening to stories, being aware of your natural surroundings, and allowing yourself to become more a part of your surroundings are all central themes.

Mr. Young advocates for choosing a ‘sit spot’ to visit as a door-opening exercise to discovering yourself and nature, to finding a way to be present. Visiting one spot in nature and sitting there for an hour regularly with little movement allows us the time for discovery and the time for those beings that occupy that place to accept our presence and reveal themselves.

The Nature of Being in Nature

When we go into nature, how do we change? Some people go into nature for the most active forms of recreation: extreme or less extreme mountain biking, jogging slow or fast, the many forms of exercise for people or beast called ‘horseback riding,’ and then there is destination hiking or exercise hiking. Some people go into nature for more passive activities such as wildlife viewing, natural history study, art, poetry, contemplation, meditation, teaching children, learning from nature, becoming more at one with the wild and other beings, or just plain observation. The active forms of recreation (fast mountain biking, especially) are not compatible in the same time and place with the more passive types of natural area visitation. And yet, natural area managers mostly plan for ‘mixed use’ or ‘multi-use trails,’ mixing all of those uses together when they design and manage open space. This is despite a very well-honed natural areas planning science enshrined by the National Parks Service and other agencies who manage for visitor use expectations and experiences. There are University degree programs focusing on training natural areas managers in this science. Unfortunately, despite the huge investments in natural areas, I am unaware of any such science being applied in our region.

The Num-Num Cult

I recently came across an example of the kindergarten-level conversation we are subject to by the local open space managers who design the visitor use experiences we must tolerate. Check out this survey to “let us know if trails are meeting your needs” recently offered by the Santa Cruz Mountains Stewardship Network. The survey is meant to help inform the “State of the Trails Project,” which mostly otherwise appears on the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District’s website. Here is a link if you want to take it. When it disappears, you can view the blank survey as it appeared saved on my website, here.

I was disheartened by the survey in that none of the rich passive uses of parks were reflected in the choices respondents could choose from. Using their terminology, all my friends’ uses of parks would be forced to fit into one use – ‘hiking’ – which is very far off from our real and precious experiences in nature. Luckily for us, the survey has blank spots that allow you to add comments.

Majority Rules?

Such a survey makes me wonder where we are heading with managing natural areas for the quality of visitor use experiences. If businesses have any say, they will support visitor use experiences that raise the most capital, experiences with expensive equipment that breaks or wears out. More passive uses of natural areas will never compete. The most passive uses, the most healing uses, will create the least amount of spending. The frugality of healthy people is astonishing.

Will those of us who are turning away from techno-gadgets and buying things be so marginalized that we will have nowhere to go to have the natural areas experiences we cherish?

Nature Heals

Many of us already understand the importance of nature in helping us stay healthy. The most recent term highlighting this phenomenon is called ‘forest bathing.’ Health care professionals recommend forest bathing, which is about practicing mindfulness, being present in nature so that we see the wealth of colors, sounds, and smells that are around us. This requires peace and quiet, the most peaceful places are the places that heal the best.

Wilderness Changed

The term wilderness is fast disappearing, for better or for worse. The term was problematic, anyways as it ignored the wealth of indigenous presence across the whole earth and the importance of indigenous people’s stewardship. And yet, the idea of wilderness being a place where technology, bustle, and noise is left behind, where contemplation and connection with nature are paramount needs to be attended to in our natural areas. Besides the wonky science of natural areas management for the ‘quality of visitor experience,’ it seems we lack a phrase that well contains such places.

Your Turn

I hope that you take the opportunity to fill in that survey and that you let politicians and open space managers know about the many ways that you cherish nature in open spaces. Let’s inform them of the term ‘displacement’ when you no longer feel comfortable going to a natural area because of the type or number of other ‘users.’ Every one of us has a right to our kind of use in natural areas, and it is open space managers’ jobs to accommodate those uses. They should be asking us about the quality of our experiences and adjusting their management to maximize that quality over time.

I hope that you also take some time to do some forest bathing. It will do a world of good. The more of us that do it, the more peaceful the world will become.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

October 12
#285 / A Mark Twain Lesson

That is a picture of Lahaina, Maui, above. I got this picture from an article written by Tiffany Hsu, published in the August 31, 2023, edition of The New York Times. Hsu titled her article, “After Summer’s Natural Disasters, Cue the Climate Conspiracies.” That title comes from the “hard copy” version of the newspaper. Here is how Hsu begins her article:

As natural disasters and extreme environmental conditions became more commonplace around the world this summer, scientists pointed repeatedly to a shared driver: climate change.

Conspiracy theorists pointed to anything but.

I think Hsu’s article is fine – it’s worth reading if you can penetrate The Times’ paywall. However, I am not commenting, here, on Hsu’s description of how conspiracy theorists are diverting our attention from what we are actually doing wrong, and are thereby making things worse. That’s true, but I want to focus on something else.

I am taking this occasion (stimulated by Hsu’s reporting) to denounce the use of the phrase, “climate change,” as a description of the “cause,” or the “driver,” of the various events and occurrences that are ever more frequently putting local communities in danger, or (as in the case of Lahaina) virtually wiping them out. I am, by the way, not the only one who objects to the description of the global emergency we face as “climate change.” Kirpatrick Sale, writing in Counterpunch calls that language a “dangerous contrivance.”

PLEASE do not use the term “climate change” to refer to the cause of the events that we see occurring all around the world. The correct term is “global warming.” That is what is causing the problems that we see documented all too frequently on the news, or in our morning newspapers. Human actions are causing the world to get hotter. “Climate change” is the “result,” not the “cause,” of our problems.

Mark Twain is popularly associated with the expression, “Everybody talks about the weather, but nobody does anything about it.” “Weather” and “climate” are similar words; they refer to the same thing. Like talking about the “weather,” everybody is talking about “climate change.” And…. nobody is doing anything about it, pretty much.

That should (and must) change.

Maybe there is a chance that we will actually “do something about it” if we correctly understand what has gone wrong – what’s causing the problems. The problems aren’t “caused” by the fact that our climate is “changing.” The fact that our climate is changing is “caused” by the fact that human actions are now heating up the entire globe.

If we don’t want more burned down cities, more city-destroying floods and hurricanes, more species going extinct, then we need to do something. So, let’s be clear what we need to do.

We need to take actions that will stop our human activities from warming up the world. The cause of our problems is “global warming,” which has, of course, changed our climate.

But the change we can see in climatic conditions, and all the impacts that go along with those changes that we see, are the result of what we have been doing, and continue to be doing, to warm up our planet.

Mainly, we need to stop burning hydrocarbon fuels. Burning hydrocarbon fuels heats up the planet, and “global warming” is what happens when we do that, and “global warming” is causing the climate changes that are putting human communities in danger.

PLEASE do not use the term “climate change” to refer to the cause of the events that we see occurring all around the world. Human actions are causing the world to get hotter. “Climate change” is the result, not the “cause,” and what we need to combat is “global warming.”

How we use language is important, and we should not be allowing ourselves to use language that helps us dodge our responsibility. If we start thinking that the “problem” is the fact that our weather is changing, we’re not going to do anything about it.

Mark Twain was right about that!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

October 16

Matlock will be back next week.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Sex”

“Sex without love is as hollow and ridiculous as love without sex.”    
~Hunter S. Thompson

“Sex is the consolation you have when you can’t have love”
~Gabriel García Márquez

“Sex is an emotion in motion.” 
~Mae West

“Someone told me the delightful story of the crusader who put a chastity belt on his wife and gave the key to his best friend for safekeeping, in case of his death. He had ridden only a few miles away when his friend, riding hard, caught up with him, saying ‘You gave me the wrong key!'”     
~Anais Nin

...

OMG, this is amazeballs! Look at her face when she hears the person singing!! Backstory: she is on her 4th encore, and she sings a duet without having the male counterpart on stage with her. She was expecting the male part to just be played on the piano, but to her obvious delight an audience member steps in and sings with her. Turns out he’s an opera student, and after the show he went to apologize to her for his rudeness in interrupting(!)

This is so wholesome and sweet, and I cry every time I watch it 🙂 You’re welcome!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

October 11 – 17, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton… Peoples Democratic Club of Santa Cruz, Chamber Players. Greensite…will be back next week, really. Steinbruner LAFCO, Soquel Creek Water District, Aptos Village, and more… Hayes…slowing down or rushing? Patton…Yellow Knife…Matlock…imaginary lightning strikes and high standards. Eagan …Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week: Drunk History on Halloween… Quotes… “Spiderwebs” 

...

SANTA CRUZ BEACH & BOARDWALK 1940. This photo contains plenty of long ago history, By squinting you can see what used to be Opera Island over by the east parking lot in the San Lorenzo River. Note too The Casa Del Rey Hotel later turned into a senior center later razed rapidly (1989) by Charlie Canfield /Boardwalk to get FEMA earthquake money. Of course you notice the pier running out from the Boardwalk. Then there’s The La Bahia Hotel.  

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE October 9

PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC CLUB. With new energy the folks at the Peoples Democratic Club of Santa Cruz (PDC) reconvened last Saturday after the covid lull. I got there and was delighted to see Brian Murtha and others so eager to get their political wisdom back online and into the voting booths.  Check here, and even though it’s not quite up to date it’s the reconnection that works.

SANTA CRUZ CHAMBER PLAYERS. Present their concert #1 of this season titled Music of Hope. It features Rebecca Jackson, violin…Jessica Chang, viola… Samantha Cho, piano…  Katie Youn, cello & concert director. They will be performing music by Brahms, Enescu, Mahler, Nazaykinskaya, Shaw, Simon, and Wie on SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 7:30 PM and SUNDAY, OCTOBER 15, 3:00 PM. As usual the concert will be at Christ Lutheran Church 10707 Soquel Drive, in Aptos… uphill from the CHP Headquarters. The four women players are part of “SAGE, a musician’s collective appearing with the Santa Cruz Chamber Players for the first time, will perform music that paints a vivid portrait of the emotional consequences that the pandemic has had on us all. The concert begins with works about COVID-19 by SF composer, educator, and performer Jungyoon Wie and Composer-in-Residence at the JFK Center for the Performing Arts, Carlos Simon. Also featured is Caroline Shaw’s Limestone and Felt, which Shaw writes, “may represent two opposing ways we experience history and design our own present”, and Polina Nazakinskya’s Hope. The program, which includes Mahler’s Piano Quartet, Enescu’s Aubade for String Trio, and Brahms’ Piano Quartet in c minor, creates an astounding vision of our shared experience—one that transcends boundaries and inspires hope! Go here for tickets and data. Once again, that’s SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 7:30 PM and SUNDAY, OCTOBER 15, 3:00 PM.

MUNCHING WITH MOZART & FRIENDS. This free concert series happens every third Friday in the upstairs meeting room of the Downtown Library. This will be Music for Violin and Piano with Brian Johnston, violin and Vlada Volkova-Moran, piano. That’s Friday October 20 at about 12 noon.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

BECKHAM. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). Not being a soccer or “football” fan as they call it in England, I had little idea of who David Beckham was…or is. He’s the greatest soccer star to ever make it bigtime. This excellent documentary takes us through his entire life from total 100% fame and love to absolute hell and disgust from every soccer fan in the world. He marries a Spice Girl, worries about kidnapping, and restores his fame and reputation after making a terrible mistake in one of his games. Go For it.

KHUFIYA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). This slow moving movie deals with the Pakistan vs. India war. It drifts from the spy driven plot and has many of the musical minutes that India movies keep inserting. There’s lung cancer, possible lesbian love the CIA, Osama Bin Laden and it still drags.

THE WONDERFUL STORY OF HENRY SUGAR. (NETFLIX MOVIES) (7.5 IMDB) (new addition) **** Wes Andersen took four stories by Roald Dahl and made simply fabulous and totally engrossing movies from them. First there’s “The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar” (39 minutes) which stars Benedict Cumberbatch, Ralph Fiennes, Ben Kingsley and Dev Patel. Immediately next on Netflix is “The Rat Catcher” (6.7 IMDB) featuring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes. Licorice lovers should heed advance warnings on that one! Then there’s “The Swan” (18 minutes) (6.9 IMDB). Again starring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes, The Swan deals and nearly faces some gruesome facets of human depravity…added as the fourth of the Dahl & Anderson group is POISON. (17 MINUTES). (6.9 IMDB). This short movie has all the casts of the previous films. Cumberbatch, Dev Patel, Ralph Fiennes and Ben Kingsley. It’s an impossible and intense story with Cumberbatch in a hospital bed with the possibility of a poisonous snake lying in wait on his stomach. Go for the four of these by all means.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

FORGOTTEN LOVE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.6 IMDB). *** A well-meaning and nearly famous doctor / professor who lost his memory after an attack on the street by some thugs spends his days inundated by friends and neighbors who need his doctoring. It’s a sad unveiling of the difference between the rich and the poor. A bit corny and predictable but magnetic and you’ll stay with it.

SONG OF THE BANDITS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.2IMDB). **   An unusual slice of history when the Japanese attacked and murdered more than 5000 Koreans in 1915. This movie comes across almost like our westerns when the cowboys murdered our Indians. It’s fast moving, much blood and the violence is almost in the comedy department. Worth checking out.

THURSDAYS WIDOW. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.01 IMDB). ** This production has a point to make and it’s aimed at the differences or maybe the similarities between the rich and the poor. It all happens in Mexico and throws in plastic surgery, lots of politics and bold statements against the hired help. It will result in your thinking about the class differences you’ve seen in your lifetime.

...
October 9

Will be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
October 9

LAFCO APPROVES SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT SERVICE TO RENAISSANCE HIGH SCHOOL
Last Wednesday, the Santa Cruz County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) gave the green light for Renaissance High School on San Andreas Road to purchase water from Soquel Creek Water District under an Extra-Territorial Agreement. That means the Pajaro Valley Unified School District and the Water District can move forward quickly to install necessary pipes and equipment to supply the students and staff water that is not so high in Chromium 6, a carcinogen, and not have to formally annex the parcel to the District’s service boundaries. The process is much faster, and less expensive.

My question to the Commission was why the Agreement does not also include the adjacent KOA Campground, also on a private well and likely having issues with Chromium 6 levels. It is the nature of the groundwater in that area of the Aromas Red Sands Aquifer, and LAFCO’ s report last year had recommended Soquel Creek Water District provide service to Renaissance High School and the KOA Campground.

No one on the Commission addressed my question.

It was interesting that LAFCO approved one other such Extra-Territorial Agreement in the Scotts Valley area for sewer connection to a parcel in the Manana Woods area subdivision.

Previously, LAFCO has approved such agreements for expediency and the areas later were annexed.

BRANCIFORTE FIRE DISTRICT WILL DISSOLVE
Last Wednesday, the Santa Cruz County LAFCO also finalized the dissolution of the Branciforte Fire District, moving the annexation of that area with Scotts Valley Fire District. This means the residents of Happy Valley area will hand over all assets (their fire station, fire engines, equipment, land) as well as property tax assessments, the Measure T special tax they approved in 2016 to fund equipment for their fire station, and also a $500,000 gift by the Barnes Family Trust. It remains to be seen what level of control or reprentation the residents within the Branciforte Fire District boundaries will have once the merger (aka “reorganization”) is finalized.

Right now, CalPERS is reviewing the cost analysis. Despite assurances to the Commissioners from LAFCO’s Director, no request had been made by Scotts Valley Fire to obtain the analysis that is critical to the Branciforte Fire staff being hired on to Scotts Valley Fire responders.

For the second time, I have notified the Commissioners that critical documents, such as Resolutions, have erroneous dates and inaccurate information.

The LAFCO Director has made a habit of not including my correspondence on this matter available to the Commissioners or onn the website until the very morning of their meetings. This in fact happened at the October 4 meeting, when Commissioners only learned about the fact that the September 27, 2023 Protest Hearing for the Brancifortte Fire Reorganization was changed at the very last moment to be virtual only, and the LAFCO office at 701 Ocean Street location stated in mailed notices to residents was closed and not accessible. I know this…because I was locked out.

None of that seems to bother the Commissioners. With few exceptions by Commissioner Roger Anderson, the group is a Rubber Stamp, No Questions Asked Club.

Why does this matter? Keep your eye on many upcoming consolidations in the County regarding hospital, fire and water services.
Ask questions and verify the information.

SANTA CRUZ CITY WATER PROJECTS WILL ENCOURAGE REGIONAL WATER SHARING
Last week’s Santa Cruz City Water Commission meeting was really encouraging. Staff provided excellent presentations about the various cpital improvement projects the City is undertaking that will really support sharing water with neighboring water agencies when it is plentiful, and storing it in the groundwater reservoirs for use when needed. Along with conservation incentives, this is exactly what the Water Supply Advisory Committee (WSAC) and civic-minded folks such as Rick Longinotti, Scott McGilvray, Jerry Paul and many others have asked for since 2013 when the desalination project fell by the wayside due to high energy demand inherent.

It is encouraging to see this all in action now with the amazing projects the City of Santa Cruz is doing.

View the presentations here: View Meeting – OnBase Agenda Online

View Meeting – OnBase Agenda Online
The Santa Cruz Mid-County Regional Water Optimization Study, which will provide information about how water can be regionally-managed, is fully grant funded through a $7.6 milion gift to the MidCounty Groundwater Agency from the California DWR Sustainable Groundwater Management Grant Program.

The results are due to be public any day now, having been earlier promised for the City’s Water Commission meeting last week, but was not on the agenda. However, a recent comment by Soquel creek Water District Boardmember Bruce Jaffe last month makes it clear that the results will be of great interest: “PureWater Soquel will benefit things in other ways…” Hmmm…

What remains to be seen is whether other players, such as Soquel Creek Water District, will come onboard with the regional use of rainwater, or cling steadfastly to the expensive highly-energy demanding PureWater Soquel Project treated sewage water?

Sadly, last winter, when rainwater was so plentiful, Soquel Creek Water District did not even ask to purchase potable surface water from the City of Santa Cruz via the existing intertie, even though they could have, under the terms of the Agreement in place. When quizzed why not, District staff reported they “just did not have the resources to manage” the water transfer project. Hmmm…

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT BOARD APPROVES NEW ASSOCIATE MANAGER JOB AND A NICE PAY RAISE FOR ALL

The Board of Directors approved pay raises all around for everyone last week, and agreed with the General Manager Ron Duncan that, in addition to his Assistant Manager, Melanie Mow-Schmacher, he needs an Associate Manager to help out with “all things PureWater Soquel” treated sewage water injection into the aquifer. The Board also approved a 4.5% top-of-the-rate salary raise for Mr. Duncan, too! See items 7.2-7.5, beginning on page 33

It seems the District has unlimited funds, even in the face of the looming huge debt and skyrocketing operational costs when PureWater Soquel Project comes online next year. But wait! Another round of rate increases is scheduled to come to the Board next month on the November 21 agenda, right before Thanksgiving when many people likely won’t be paying close attention.

Stay tuned…

COUNTY COMMISSIONS IN FOR A BIG CHANGE?
Last week, staff from County Environmental Health let the County Water Advisory Commission know that big changes are in store for the County’s Commissions. The Board of Supervisors are due to review the County Administrative Officer’s plan to drastically change the Commissions on November 14. Two that are staffed by Environmental Health Dept. staff will be axed.

Will this be an improvement for the people, or a move by the CAO to further exclude us? Stay tuned.

APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT RUMBLES ALONG…WHAT ABOUT THE PARK?
Aptos Village Phase 2 under way [Santa Cruz Sentinel] County District Supervisor Zach Friend gave a glowing report of the work happening to build solid three-story buildings on both sides of Aptos Village Way in the Aptos Village. What he did not say is that the area is already so congested, traffic snarls are a common occurrence,Swenson reduced the number of affordable Measure J units from 12 to 10, and the parking promised is virtually nil.

Supervisor Friend is well aware of all this, as his office sits in the high-rent zone of the Project…the County financially bailed Swenson out with a 15-year lease for the MidCounty Safety Center, which is rarely open and whose meeting room can only accommodate 10 people…not exactly a Townhall Meeting venue for Zach.

And what about the County Park land? Ridiculous! Take a look in the photo below at the steep hillside above Swenson’s Phase 2 mess. County Parks staff are on record as admitting they have NO IDEA how this land could be used for a park, let alone the “active recreation” use it was supposed to provide the Community at the insistence of the Planning Commission in response to the world-famous Post Office Bike Jumps being bulldozed. Not to worry…the County gifted Swenson FREE drainage easement from teh Phase 2 parking lot and roof stormwater into the Aptos Village Park, and WAIVED PARK DEVELOPMENT FEES ($1000/bedroom for the 69 units anticipated).

Take a look at the”new county park land” behind these workers…the hillside behind the huge retaining wall. Do any of these workers look like they may be monitoring the excavation in this known Native American archaeological site? That is one of the project’s Conditions of Permit Approval. Hmmm….
Write Matt Machado and ask why Swenson is not including Native American observers for all earth disturbance, as they are required to do.

Last week, Swenson closed Aptos Village Way, the main access for the area through the Village, aside from Soquel Drive. Not only did it cause more traffic congestion within the area, it removed alot of the parking that Swenson has promised the people, including for Nisene Marks State Park.

Write Supervisor Zach Friend with your thoughts Zach Friend <zach.friend@santacruzcountyca.gov>. Maybe he will respond.

SIGN UP WITH COUNTY’S NEW “CRUZAWARE” NOTIFICATION PLATFORM
October 17, 1989 is a memorable day for those who were here and in the Bay Area, and experience the Loma Prieta Earthquake. On that note, and with respect to all other natural disasters that are possible, sign up with the County’s new CruzAware emergency notification platform to receive information in many modes:

After the floods last winter, many residents say they did not receive notice of impending floodwater risk and evacuation warnings. The old notification system, CodeRed, did not allow for digital text messaging on social media. Hopefully, the new CruzAware system will.

Wouldn’t it be a good idea to test the system’s effectiveness before it is actually needed? The Office of REsponse, Recovery and Resilience (OR3) is responsible for this operational alert system. Any FireWise Communities can arrange such a test. Mine did last Sunday and we discovered quite a few glitches that hopefully will be resolved soon.

However, I have to wonder if having a Countywide test , similar to what occurred on a national level October 4, might be a better solution? Contact David Reid, Director of OR3, and request this if you think it is important. David Reid <david.reid@santacruzcountyca.gov> Note the new e-mail template.

CHINESE PIONEERS
I really enjoyed the conversational interview last Saturday with George Ow and Sandy Lydon, sponsored by the Santa cruz Public Library and held at Project 418 on River Street in Santa Cruz. If you have not read “Chinese Gold”, you need to do so. The book has been reprinted in English and Chinese.

Go see the great exhibit “CHINESE PIONEERS: Power and Politics in Exclusion Era Photographs” that is happening now through November 12 at the San Lorenzo Valley Museum (6299 Gushee Street, Felton).

COMMUNITY MATTERS GUESTS THIS FRIDAY
This Friday (2pm-4pm) log onto Santa Cruz Voice.com online radio and listen to Ms. Veronica Elsea giving us all a better perspective on how to regard blind and sight-impaired people using white canes (National White Cane Safety Awareness Day is October 15). The second hour, Mr. Brian Peoples, Director of TRAIL NOW, will help us all understand what could be done on the railroad corridor.
santacruzvoice.com

Join the conversations!

MAKE ONE CALL. WRITE ONE LETTER. LEARN MORE ABOUT LOCAL HISTORY AND DO WHAT YOU CAN TO PRESERVE IMPORTANT CULTURAL RESOURCES. JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK…YOU WILL MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE!

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
October 9

SLOWING DOWN – OR- RUSHING?

So much environmental degradation seems to be due to our rushing around. How can we best slow down? Each of us can do our part in creating the Great Slowdown that we need to sustain the planet.

Save More, Buy Less

The first and easiest way to help the Great Slowdown is to stop buying so much Stuff. If you haven’t watched the Story of Stuff in a while, or not at all, DO IT NOW. This 21-minute video is compelling, fun, and has changed more lives than many a 20-some minute experience otherwise. I think it’s worth watching regularly, perhaps in October just before the stuff-a-thon holiday season besets our culture.

If you listen to the news, you will understand how important buying stuff is for our unsustainable economy. “Inflation is up, but ‘luckily’ consumer spending is cooking right along, otherwise our economy would be hosed.” A president once said in a national crisis, something like, “Just keep buying stuff!” Time is money, and by spending your money on useless crap, you are wasting your time, carelessly throwing away your life, and helping to wreck the planet. A few years ago, someone did a calculation and the transaction cost of each dollar spent was a liter of oil. I’m betting its worse now. Save a buck, keep a liter of oil from burning up.

Stop Rushing at Work

There is so much pressure to do more at work, but is that really helping anything? Chances are good that the more we rush, the worse off the planet is. How about we slow down? Carefully watch those who rush around with their work: why are they doing that? I’m betting that they mostly want to impress people, get others to work harder, or they are avoiding problems at home or something they might better be doing for Real Good.

The labor movement has something called ‘working by the book,’ which we might emulate to improve the planet. What is absolutely necessary to do with your work? What does the job description say? What are the metrics for success? Often, organizations keep the productivity targets elusive, to keep everyone guessing or trying to push for more. On the other hand, if productivity targets are defined, ask yourself if they are set too high. If so, it might be time to work with your colleagues to reduce them to something more manageable.

Slowing down at work is part of the solution, part of the Great Slowdown.

Working for the Planet

The capitalist system mostly asks each worker to create efficiencies that are bad for the planet. As we learn to care more for the planet, we will find ways to sneak improvements into the workplace that will help Earth. Is there a way to reduce driving, material transport, waste? Does your workplace purchase recycled paper, organic foods, and other eco-friendly products? Maybe there’s a sustainability policy on your business’ horizon.

Beware the Fakes

If you see potential greenwashing, ask about it! I recently asked a seemingly eco-conscious caterer what they meant by “gourmet sandwiches, made from the finest local ingredients” and it turned out that they used very mainstream factory-farmed meats and conventionally grown produce distributed from warehouses far away. They soon thereafter changed their menu language. That was the third time I was able to affect that kind of change. Do we choose places that are true to their word about their products? How do we know if we don’t ask? Why would they be true to their word if folks never asked?

Buy Green

The list of businesses that are truly green is getting smaller, not larger in Santa Cruz. There are fewer restaurants serving local, organic foods than there were a few years ago. Local grocery stores are sliding further from, not closer to, sustainability. I suspect all of this is because people are not pursuing green purchases.

Keep Your Keel

How easy it is to go with the flow, but is that truly the best thing for the planet? There is a concept called ‘slippage‘ where environmental policies are interpreted in ways that slip away from the intent of the policy, usually with negative environmental consequence. If your work entails intersection with environmental policies, it is time to ask how you can help interpret those to environmental benefit, not environmental degradation. It is time also to ask what is the greatest good you can do with your work, focusing on the issues of greatest impact for environmental improvement. As I’ve said in prior posts, the metric should be species conservation: how can our work best affect that outcome? The answers are usually easy to arrive at.

Beware of False Dichotomies

Those who are most invested in slippage often use false dichotomies. Parks managers often note that they have a difficult dual mandate: to provide for public recreational access while conserving wildlife. For a large portion of Santa Cruz County, managers are leaning heavily on this false dichotomy to ‘sell’ the concept that it’s just fine for our wildlife to disappear because of their mismanagement. Trails erode tons of sediment into streams and wetlands, trash litters our beautiful beaches, and graffiti proliferates on sea cliffs because of the slippage that is embraced by the poor logic presented by parks managers’ adoption of their false dichotomies.

Parks Management Slippage

Many of these parks’ managers use other forms of slippage. The California Public Resources Code says this about State Parks: “Following classification or reclassification of a unit by the State Park and Recreation Commission, and prior to the development of any new facilities in any previously classified unit, the department shall prepare a general plan or revise any existing plan for the unit.” Look at the North Coast beaches, and Gray Whale Ranch…and, enter slippage: none of those have general plans, and all have ‘new facilities.’ I’m sure that someone, somewhere can provide some beautiful logic about how that can be possible. Has someone said ‘if anyone asks just tell them we never “classified or reclassified” those “units” and they were never “previously classified” (hardy-har-har-har, that’ll get ’em).‘ Anyone in their right mind would know that the responsible thing to do would be to create a general plan before opening a park, and that’s what was meant by that part of the Resources Code. Meanwhile, we must all ask WHY are these precious places opened to visitation without a plan to conserve wildlife on those spectacularly biodiverse places?? If you work for State Parks, you must ask yourself what place you have played in allowing such things to happen and how you might reverse this slippage. If you work for other land conservation organizations, you might have similar things to ponder: do you hold a false dichotomy promulgated by those with anti-conservation agendas? Do you serve Earth or Greed? If you are torn and in doubt, maybe it’s time to slow down and ‘work by the book.’ It might be better if you embrace the Great Slowdown in your job while you increasingly help others become aware of slippage.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

October 6

#279 / Yellowknife

Today’s brief blog post can best be understood as a follow-up to yesterday’s brief blog post. The “generalization” advanced yesterday was that there is no longer any ability to engage in “away living,” if there ever was any such ability. The truth of that observation was reinforced for me by a message from Bill McKibben, which I received the day after actually writing my October 5th blog posting.

The picture above shows a line of people waiting for evacuation from Yellow Knife, Canada, which was mentioned by McKibben in his August 18, 2023, statement. That statement was titled, “An Ever-Smaller Board On Which To Play The Human Game.”

As McKibben wrote near the end of August, Yellow Knife was threatened with the kind of destruction visited on Lahaina, Maui earlier in the month. Things don’t look too dire in the photo above, but McKibben’s statement was accompanied by the following image, which does look a lot like the photos we saw as fire descended upon Lahaina:

Here is the specific statement by McKibben that captured my attention:

It’s important—in this year that has seen global warming come fully to life—to describe accurately what’s happening on our planet. And one key thing is: the number of places humans can safely live is now shrinking (emphasis in original).

In yesterday’s blog posting, I included an image of Earth from space. If you can’t visualize it, you can revisit that image by clicking right here. We’re in this together, now more than ever.

Just one more reminder, this one coming from Yellow Knife, Canada!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
October 9

IMAGINARY LIGHTNING STRIKES AND HIGH STANDARDS

Steven Lauter, columnist for the LA Times, said it: “The problem wasn’t McCarthy.” In his view, the former speaker let his bad habit of making promises he couldn’t, or wouldn’t, keep. With both political parties distrusting him he was removed from his position as Speaker of the House with the solidarity votes of Democrats and the eight rebels led by Representative Matt Gaetz. Recent Speakers Boehner and Ryan had their own unpleasant experiences, with Kevin McCarthy establishing a first, becoming the only Speaker removed by a vote of the House of Representatives. Lauter thinks that Victim #4 awaits a similar fate, and Andrew Glassman, congressional expert at Georgetown University says, “Someone will get 217 votes, but I’m not sure that the Republican conference is governable.” A Speaker is given significant authority, with real power emerging only with the individual’s ability to incorporate the the will of the House majority, presently not a coherent attribute, so symbolically  it’s just a guy holding a wooden gavel waiting for lightning to strike. Mary Trump observed: ” Kevin McCarthy served as speaker for approximately 27 Scaramuccis.”

Several weeks ago, McCarthy reported that the House GOP was “in a good place” on the spending bill, but their closed door sessions came up with nothing, listening to Trump instead of Speaker McCarthy. As Politico commented, “McCarthy is being chopped into pieces, and he doesn’t even know it.” Shirley Kennedy in The Palmer Report wrote, “Several Republicans refused to go along with McCarthy’s defense spending bill, being joined by Democrats. One can only wonder if he now regrets repeatedly giving in to the far-right members of his party, who now seem to be holding their power and Donald Trump over his head…these people are bending to an imaginary god who has no power. They believe, however, that their power is in supporting him, but what will they do when he is convicted of the myriad crimes with which he has been charged? They even attempt to cover for him.” She goes on to say that when asked about the former president’s demand to shut the government down, “McCarthy replied, ‘He only wants to “hold the line” and “pass appropriate bills.” Please. “Trump has no idea what bills are appropriate. He’s not in the same position as the many people who voted these clowns into office, and he could care less about any of them. Similarly, McCarthy doesn’t care either.” Kevin McCarthy now finds himself in the belly of the beast that he tried to ride.

The Speaker was able to muster enough support from Democrats and Republicans to pass a spending bill, avoiding a government shutdown, but Gaetz then mounted his campaign to remove McCarthy from the speakership, accusing him of collusion with the dreaded Dems. Kevin took the challenge, telling Matt to “bring it on,” to “get it behind us and start governing.” While assuming that he had strong party support, McCarthy accused the Florida representative of showboating to distract from his own problems, such as his accusations of ethics violations of misconduct, drug use, and other allegations. In leading the successful drive to oust McCarthy, Gaetz has stirred some Republicans toward even bolder steps to hold him accountable, even expelling him from Congress. Bring it on, huh, Matty!?

The New Yorker’s political satire columnist, Andy Borowitz, writes that, “House Republicans have convened an emergency meeting to determine who must sit next to Representative Matt Gaetz going forward. Members of the conference had hoped to take a week off after the grueling ordeal of ousting Kevin McCarthy, but the matter of who would be forced to sit next to Gaetz ‘had to be settled,’ one GOP congressperson said. ‘Colleagues have declared that, if they are required to sit next to Matt, they will retire from politics instead,’ the legislator, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said. ‘We could lose our majority over this.’ Republicans’ hopes that they had found a willing seat mate for Gaetz collapsed when Representative Lauren Boebert flatly refused the assignment. ‘Even I have standards,’ she reportedly said.”

Doing his part in spouting for the media, Matt Gaetz, is/was an advocate of the GOP’s impeachment of President Biden until he said too much. However, the foredoomed attempt was based on phony ‘evidence,’ or as it turns out no evidence at all. A generic House hearing was held, but votes to hold an actual impeachment inquiry disappeared along with the ‘evidence.’ As Bill Palmer writes, “Matt Gaetz is in way over his head. He doesn’t understand how to create allies within his own House Republican caucus. He doesn’t understand messaging. He thinks politicians get things done by running their mouths in front of cameras, and doesn’t understand that actual political muscle is flexed behind the scenes. So of course Gaetz got caught on camera admitting that his own party’s agenda is illegitimate. He’s that idiot.”

Steven Pastis in his Pearls Before Swine comic strip: Pig visits Wise Ass on the Hill and asks, “Oh, Wise Ass..for an immigrant to become a citizen and be able to vote, do they have to take a test?” Wise Ass answers, “Yes, a civics test.” Pig then asks, “Why do they have to do that?” Wise Ass answers, “Because if you’re gonna help us choose our elected officials you have to be knowledgeable,” whereupon Pig queries, ” Do the elected officials need to take a test?” And Wise Ass blows him away with, “No, they can be total morons.” Pig journeys down the hill and meets Rat, telling him, “The more I know the less I understand.” Amen to that!

McCarthy was only concerned about his precious speakership, with no idea on how to lead, and because of the agreements he made to get elected, he got tossed out on his ear. One is reminded of a description written by Roald Dahl of Henry Sugar, his character in the short story, ‘The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar’: “Men like Henry Sugar are to be found drifting like seaweed all over the world. They can be seen especially in London, New York, Paris, Nassau, Montego Bay, Cannes, and San Tropez. They are not particularly bad men, but they are not good men either. They are of no particular importance; they’re simply part of the decoration.”

Immediately following Kev’s dismissal, the maneuvering began to stick another victim in the seat, bringing up the names of Majority Leader Steve Scalise and Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim (Gym) Jordan. Endorsements are accumulating, not the least of which, is The Don’s praise for Jordan who has been a Trumper since day one. Scalise, who has called himself “David Duke without the baggage,” made a brief foray to secure backing in January, so a path to success may not arise on this go around, either. Jordan, not an ’empty suit’ but more of an ’empty shirt’ with the sleeves rolled up, may not have the support, not being able to rally the troops around his extreme conservatism, with Democrats readying themselves to pounce in light of the controversy surrounding Jordan’s years as an Ohio State wrestling coach. His baggage has become a target to be brought front and center, and Democrats will make it headline news again. Newcomer, Representative Kevin Hern of Oklahoma, and chairman of the Republican Study Committee has been discussed as a possibility because he may have new approaches to doing things instead of sticking to same slog that has bogged down the GOP for years. Jordan was the founding member of the confrontational House Freedom Caucus, and was a leader in pushing out former Speaker Boehner, who calls Gym a “legislative terrorist.”

The campaigning preceded last Tuesday’s candidate forum, followed by Wednesday’s planned vote in the GOP conference on a nominee for the position. The Dems nominated Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, in the event the House majority was unable to coalesce around a candidate. McCarthy ally, Garret Graves of Louisiana, recalled the four days it took to elect Kevin, saying it would require “some divine intervention” to wrap it up quickly. Some Republicans have floated the idea of making The Former Guy a nominee, after which he said he might consider it as a temporary position to be a “unifier” and “if necessary,” but his focus is winning the presidential nomination where he sees dismissal of all charges against him.

So, all of the above can only serve as background as this is being written, and everything may still be contentiously up in the air, disputable, open to doubt or perhaps settled, at least temporarily, by the time this is posted. With the urgency in the flare up between Israel and Hamas, the leaderless House GOP has brought up the possibility of reseating Kevin McCarthy, as this state of war may need their actions sooner rather than later. Initially, Kevin was “aware and grateful” of the suggestion but was not engaged in any discussion or negotiations. Lawmakers were also considering giving clearer powers to acting Speaker Pro Tempore, Patrick McHenry, for the short term or electing him outright, both unprecedented moves. Representative Mark Alford of Missouri posted on X, “We are paralyzed as a body. World events dictate urgency.”

Conservative radio host, Hugh Hewitt, asked McCarthy if he would serve as Speaker again should a deadlock result in the tumultuous body, to which he responded, “Look, the conference will make that decision. I’m still a member. I’m going to continue to fight and act. Whatever the conference wants, I will do. I think we need to be strong. I think we need to be united. The eight (conference members who voted against him), in my view, don’t look to be – it was a personal thing.” After losing his position he said he would not run again, as he reminded the press that the vast majority of the House GOP voted for him to remain in the post. Where does/did the GOP land in this continuing debacle? Poet and musician, Patti Smith says, “We go through life. We shed our skins. We become ourselves.” We can only hope the House has shed enough skin to benefit the rest of us.

This advertisement was posted on the Quora website: “NOW THAT THE PRESIDENT IS GONE, WHY NOT VISIT THE…Trump Presidential Library, Casino and Strip Club! A perfect way to remember the Bigliest President of all!

Contains all the key documents related to the Trump Presidency, a colored-in placemat from ‘Wendy’s’, a copy of Penthouse with Melania as the centerfold from 1989, and a signed copy of ‘The Art of the Deal.’

Roulette, Blackjack, and Poker are just three of the strippers performing two erotic shows nightly. PLUS…all you can eat free shrimp gumbo from the buffet Friday to Sunday!

Come for the historical documents of record, stay for the best girly show in Nevada.

The Trump Presidential Library, Casino and Strip Club. We’re three miles out of Vegas, turn left on the Interstate 9, follow the neon sign, we’re the first right by the Truckers Rest Diner. Free entry Monday through Thursday. No cover charge, first drink on the house.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com.
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down .

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Spiderwebs”

“The spider’s web: She finds an innocuous corner in which to spin her web. The longer the web takes, the more fabulous its construction. She has no need to chase. She sits quietly, her patience a consummate force; she waits for her prey to come to her on their own, and then she ensnares them, injects them with venom, rendering them unable to escape. Spiders – so needed and yet so misunderstood.”
~Donna Lynn Hope

“The greatest artist and web-designer ever is indeed a spider!”    
~Munia Khan

“What was building a web but a gustatory expression of hope?”  
~Adrian Tchaikovsky

“Spider webs are images of the nonlinear, of the many directions in which something might go, the many sources for it.”
~Rebecca Solnit

...

Drunk History on the birth of Halloween as we know it…

Check out the entire drunk history series, they are pretty hilarious and educational all at the same time.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

October 4 – 10, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…What’s up?  Santa Cruz Chamber Players. Greensite….will be back next week. Steinbruner…Our Downtown Our Future, injecting sewage water, Aptos Village, declining population, student housing, desal water, Lydon-Ow interview. Hayes…flowers for fall. Patton…a phenomenal culture of welcoming. Matlock…playing catch up with the hands of time. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes…”Towers”

...

SANTA CRUZ 1948. One of the first noticeable changes we can see here is the absence of trees. Thanks to so much good work and planning our tree population has increased substantially. But as Gillian Greensite notes so consistently and patiently the officials are still cutting them helter skelter.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE October 2

WHAT’S UP? I don’t remember a time since I arrived in Santa Cruz (in 1970) that the political scene was as bitter and divided as it is right now. Name calling and label slinging and out and out lying seem to have become the way of life each day. Is this a result or spinoff from our National Trump scene or is it the after effect of years of masks and covid? And on the same page UCSC’s ceasing of providing us with so many attractions of live stage, movies, and concerts has made them more of a factor to work AROUND instead of joining. Like so many others I’m going back to live concerts that are filling our music and churches again with happy and community connections.

SANTA CRUZ CHAMBER PLAYERS. Present their concert #1 of this season titled Music of Hope. It features Rebecca Jackson, violin…Jessica Chang, viola… Samantha Cho, piano…  Katie Youn, cello & concert director. They will be performing music by Brahms, Enescu, Mahler, Nazaykinskaya, Shaw, Simon, and Wie on SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 7:30 PM and SUNDAY, OCTOBER 15, 3:00 PM. As usual the concert will be at Christ Lutheran Church 10707 Soquel Drive, in Aptos uphill from the CHP Headquarters. The four women players are part of “SAGE, a musician’s collective appearing with the Santa Cruz Chamber Players for the first time, will perform music that paints a vivid portrait of the emotional consequences that the pandemic has had on us all. The concert begins with works about COVID-19 by SF composer, educator, and performer Jungyoon Wie and Composer-in-Residence at the JFK Center for the Performing Arts, Carlos Simon. Also featured is Caroline Shaw’s Limestone and Felt, which Shaw writes, “may represent two opposing ways we experience history and design our own present”, and Polina Nazakinskya’s Hope. The program, which includes Mahler’s Piano Quartet, Enescu’s Aubade for String Trio, and Brahms’ Piano Quartet in c minor, creates an astounding vision of our shared experience—one that transcends boundaries and inspires hope! Go here for tickets and data   Santa Cruz Chamber Players, Music of Hope  once again, that’s SATURDAY, OCTOBER 14, 7:30 PM and SUNDAY, OCTOBER 15, 3:00 PM.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange and usually co-hosted  by Kaos and Calamity Kyle.

FORGOTTEN LOVE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.6 IMDB).***   A well-meaning and nearly famous doctor / professor who lost his memory after an attack on the street by some thugs spends his days inundated by friends and neighbors who need his doctoring. It’s a sad unveiling of the difference between the rich and the poor. A bit corny and predictable but magnetic and you’ll stay with it.

THE WONDERFUL STORY OF HENRY SUGAR. (NETFLIX MOVIES) (7.5 IMDB) **** Wes Andersen took three stories by Roald Dahl and made simply fabulous and totally engrossing movies from them. First there’s “The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar” (39 minutes) which stars Benedict Cumberbatch, Ralph Fiennes, Ben Kingsley and Dev Patel. Immediately next on Netflix is “The Rat Catcher” (6.7 IMDB) featuring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes. Licorice lovers should heed advance warnings on that one! The Dahl & Anderson 3 movie set closes with “The Swan” (18 minutes) (6.9 IMDB). Again starring Rupert Friend and Ralph Fiennes, The Swan deals and nearly faces some gruesome facets of human depravity…go for the three of these by all means.

SONG OF THE BANDITS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.2IMDB).**   An unusual slice of history when the Japanese attacked and murdered more than 5000 Koreans in 1915. This movie comes across almost like our westerns when the cowboys murdered our Indians. It’s fast moving, much blood and the violence is almost in the comedy department. Worth checking out.

THURSDAYS WIDOW. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.01 IMDB). ** This production has a point to make and it’s aimed at the differences or maybe the similarities between the rich and the poor. It all happens in Mexico and throws in plastic surgery, lots of politics and bold statements against the hired help. It will result in your thinking about the class differences you’ve seen in your lifetime.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

INFAMY. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). A movie from Poland that hammers on us the terrible local prejudices against the area Gypsies. There’s a 17 year old girl who has to face the hatred and pain in being a minority. It’s a simple movie with lots of amateur mugging and posing, but it does get the point across.

HOW TO DEAL WITH A HEARTBREAK. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (4.0 IMDB). They list it as a comedy drama and it sure is both. This woman author tries hard to write her book. Then her dad dies and returns to help her write the book. So yes there are laughs/snickers but she’s 34 years old so we do lose patience with her.

SUSPECT X. (NETFLIX SERIES) (NO IMDB YET). Her husband disappears but he was an evil sort and this film from India makes quite a story out of it.  She has a math teacher as a neighbor, he’s loved by all and helps her hide the truths behind the husband’s disappearance from the police. It’s a bit overdone and heavy, but worthwhile.

BURNING BODY. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB). A policeman is found burned to death in his own police car. The acting is well done and it’s done mostly in Spanish and in Barcelona.

It’s based on a true and well known case that happened a few years ago. It’s mostly centered on the woman or women in his life and is worthwhile watching.

...
October 2

Gillian will be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
October 2

HOW DID THIS HAPPEN, AND WHAT CAN WE DO?

Affordable housing…what can we really do that will fix this problem in Santa Cruz?  Is that even possible? Please join the great discussions hosted by the Our Downtown, Our Future folks on Saturday, October 14 at the London Nelson Center to hear and participate in thoughtful discussions with three panels of local public leaders, with a range of opinions and perspectives. ourdowntownourfuture.org

Please sign up to inform the organizers about numbers so there is plenty of food for the lunch provided.

YOUR LAST CHANCE TO COMMENT ON INJECTION OF TREATED SEWAGE WATER INTO OUR AREA’S AQUIFER

Are you comfortable having Soquel Creek Water District inject treated sewage water that could contain nitrate and unregulated contaminants into the pristine groundwater the Midcounty area residents depend upon for clean drinking water?

You need to send written comment to the Central Coast Water Quality Board by October 11. This Permit Application is likely the final opportunity for public comment on the Project’s impacts to the groundwater quality and potential marine impacts.

I have reserved the meeting room at the Capitola Library (2005 Wharf Road) for Saturday, October 7, 3:30pm for a public study session and discussion.  I hope that any who are interested in this Project and potential impacts on the groundwater quality and marine habitat near the pipeline outfall will attend and submit informed comment to the Regional Water Quality Control Board by October 11.

The District has applied to the Regional Water Quality Control Board for a permit to inject treated wastewater into the MidCounty Groundwater Basin. Here is a link to the Permit application document for the Proposed Order No. R3-2023-0033

I have not been able to get a clear answer from the Water Board whether or not a legally-required Final Anti-Degradation Analysis has been approved to verify this injected water will not adversely affect the high-quality groundwater.  (Santa Cruz City’s injection of potable water into the aquifer in a pilot program caused arsenic spikes in water retrieved.)

However, according to recent correspondence from Mr. Harvey Packard at the Water Board, it won’t matter if this Permit to Inject Recycled Water is approved by the Board on December 14-15.  The Board staff seems willing to accept Soquel Creek Water District’s interpretation of draft analysis and sign off on any further study:

“If the board adopts the injection permit, there will be no further need for anti-deg analysis, and we will consider the district’s report final.”

What bothers me is that the District’s vague analysis would allow 3.5 mg/L of nitrate in the “product water” to be injected into the groundwater, and there would only have to be a “Best Practices Plan’ in place for how this could affect the MidCounty Groundwater Basin. There is no link provided at all to any actual Final Anti-Degradation Analysis report to verify any of the vague statements made in the Proposed Permit R3-2023-0033 (see page F-19 / page 137 of the document)

Public Comment on this application is due October 11.

Although the Proposed Permit Fact Sheet (page F16-19) gives a summary of Soquel Creek Water District’s findings regarding ANTI-DEGRADATION ANALYSIS, there is no link to the actual study to verify any of the vague claims that the Water Board seems willing to accept.  There is no evidence that the Water Board has reviewed and approved any such detailed Analysis that will ensure the protection of the high-quality waters of the aquifer.

Please note that on page 25, there is information about the permit conditions not filed under EPA Clean Water Act, and time-sensitive appeal:

11.3. These requirements have not been reviewed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) and are not issued pursuant to Clean Water Act section 402. 

11.4. Any person aggrieved by this action of the Central Coast Water Board may petition the State Water Board to review the action in accordance with California Water Code section 13320 and CCR title 23, section 2050. The State Water Board must receive the petition by 5:00 p.m., 30 days after the date of this Permit, except if this date falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or State holiday, then the petition must be received by the State Water Board by 5:00 p.m. on the next business day. Copies of the law and regulations applicable to filing petitions may be found on the internet or will be provided upon request. The provisions of this Permit are severable, and if any provision of this Permit, or the application of any provision of this Permit to any circumstance, is held invalid, the application of such provision to other circumstances, and the remainder of this Permit must not be affected.

Also, please note the conditions causing the Board to Reopen the Permit on page 26:

12.1. The Central Coast Water Board may reopen this Permit to include the most scientifically relevant and appropriate limitations for this discharge, including a revised Basin Plan limit based on monitoring results, anti-degradation studies, or other Central Coast Water Board or State Water Board policy.

The City of Santa Cruz is also applying for a separate permit to discharge the concentrated treatment brine from the PureWater Soquel Project into the Pacific Ocean via the City’s sewage treatment outfall pipe, also open to Public Comment, and due October 12.  Here is the link to that PROPOSED ORDER NO. R3-2023-0001 and NPDES NO. CA0048194

The Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board will consider both applications at their December 14-15, 2023 meeting.

Here is the link to the Water Board website for full information on both applications and comment procedure: Tentative Orders, Permits, Complaints and Resolutions | Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board

Please attend the Saturday, October 7 3:30pm study session at the Capitola Library if you have questions, but above all, submit your comments to the Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board by October 11 for the injection well permit, and October 12 for the ocean outfall brine effluent.

WHAT IS THIS?  STRANGE WATER CONNECTION IN THE APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT

Last weekend, I happened to travel through the Aptos Village Project Phase 2 construction zone, which is happening on both sides of Aptos Village Way. A strange water connection near the road caught my attention.  See the photo below:

Is this “service connection” legitimate?  Who, if anyone, is paying for the water?  Is this connection being assessed a hefty monthly service connection fee, like all the other ratepayers have to pay?  What about vandalism, and potential leaks and geysers (that happened in the Phase 1 construction) and contamination….

This is what happened last weekend in the Aptos Village Project mess.  Since Swenson removed all parking along Aptos Village Way between Parade Street and Aptos Creek Road, and the County Public Works staff is fine with allowing the contractor to fill up Aptos Creek Road with construction vehicles and mobile office space, things are not so rosey in the Aptos Village Project area.  This vandalism happened just a few yards away from that strange water service connection pictured above.

Write Soquel Creek Water District and ask about this strange water service connection: Board of Directors bod@soquelcreekwater.org.

Write Matt Machado at Public Works about the significant and adverse impacts on local traffic caused by Swenson’s construction and encroachment into Aptos Creek Road.  It is quite a hazard, and Swenson linked arms with then-County Supervisor Ellen Pirie to assure the public would have plenty of free parking, even for Nisene Marks State Park visitors (their limited parking fills up quickly).

Matt Machado (matt.machado@santacruzcountyca.gov)

Why is Swenson allowed to encroach into Aptos Creek Road with fencing, creating this real safety hazard?  Can you see the bicyclist that was quickly exiting Nisene Marks State Park on the right of this intersection at Aptos Village Way?   How do you think this encroachment would affect a fire evacuation out of the Park?  Yikes!

Please contact State Parks Chris Spohrer (chris.spohrer@parks.ca.gov),  Central Fire District Fire Marshal Mike DeMars (miked@centralfpd.com) and Sheriff Sgt. Zach West (zach.west@santacruzcounty.us)  (831) 454-7760  and ask that the construction fencing be  relocated out of the public roadway, and re-establish 200′ line of sight visibility at the Aptos Creek Road and Aptos Village Way intersection for public safety and fire evacuation needs.

DECLINING POPULATION TRENDS IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY AND CALIFORNIA AS A WHOLE

Last Wednesday, the County Planning Commission met to discuss not only the County Housing Element draft update and RHNA mandates, but also the County’s Annual Growth Goal.  The Commission ran out of time to discuss the latter, which will come back next month.

The Planning Dept. staff report included a very interesting analysis of the 430-unit subdivision planned for the Par 3 Golf Course next to Highway One, near State Park Drive.  That analysis had not been included in last week’s Housing Element presentation to the County’s Housing Advisory Commission.  Likely, it was quickly drafted to address a legal threat by The Aptos Council, sent to the Board of Supervisors in early September, pointing out many major CEQA violations.

Planning staff assured the Commissioners there will be an environmental Addendum made available soon, hopefully by the Planning Commission’s  October 25 Public Hearing on the Draft Housing Element Update.

The Commissioners also wanted to know why the Planning Dept. factored in an additional 10% buffer in the number of parcels to be rezoned for high-density development, four -six stories tall. The total unit goal jumped from 4,634 to 5,098 units to be built within the next eight years, with many parcels having to undergo re-zoning.

“We need to have HCD believe us.” said the planner.

“Can the Cabrillo College 640-bed project be included in the RHNA number response?” Commissioner Andy Shiffrin wanted to know?

“NO” said Planning Director Stephanie Hansen, because student housing is considered “temporary housing” and cannot be counted.  Commissioner Renee Shepherd pointed out that the UCSC and Cabrillo students occupy a lot of permanent housing, and certainly have an impact.

During public comment, Central Fire Protection District Chief Jason Nee spoke about how the District has been planning to purchase the parcel at 41st Avenue and Soquel Drive for a new fire station, replacing the flood-prone station in Soquel Village.  However, now that the County has identified the parcel as a re-zone location for very dense and tall housing, the owner raised the sales price such that the Fire District may not be able to afford to buy it.

Does any of this make sense?

Take a look: Population Trends

According to the Census and the State Department of Finance (DOF) population estimates, the unincorporated area had a growth rate of -1.3% in 2022 and is estimated to have an approximate -1.0% decrease by the end of 2023. In 2021 the unincorporated growth rate decreased by an estimated -3.4%. However, US Census data from 2020 indicates that population in the unincorporated area had steadily increased over the last decade. By comparison, the county as a whole decreased by -0.2% in 2021 and -1.1% in 2022. The state population also decreased by -0.5% in 2021 and -0.4% in 2022. These rates reflect the recent decline in state population estimates since the COVID-19 pandemic began and mark a major shift in the state’s historical trend of continued population growth.

Take a look at page 20, where Table 2 shows AMBAG’s approved population projections show a 1% increase in the County’s population between 2015 and 2045

So, why would AMBAG mandate a 300% increase in housing units in the 6th Cycle of RHNA?  Hmmm…

Some feel that the State Housing & Community Development Dept. (HCD), the agency tasked with forming these RHNA mandates and whipping municipalities into breakneck process to meet their approval deadlines, has been captured by special interests.  Learn more about this and start asking questions of local legislators.

DESAL WATER COSTING LESS AND LESS TO PRODUCE? 

Ten years ago, the local Desal Alternatives successful citizen initiative petition called for the ability of Santa Cruz City voters to decide whether or not to move forward on a desalination plant (in partnership with Soquel Creek Water District).  The group rightfully raised the red flag on  the exorbitant energy demand the process would require to produce potable water for the area, and demanded alternatives be examined.  The City Council immediately backed away from the Project, leaving Soquel Creek Water District to move in a feverish pace to adopt the PureWater Soquel Project (modified many times without EIR) that will instead use massive amounts of energy in an attempt to clean up sewage water and inject it into the pristine groundwater.

Now, new technology has drastically lowered the energy required for desalination.

“Bill Maher recently interviewed Elon Musk. When Maher claimed that we are running out of water, Elon replied that “Earth is 70 percent water.” Maher shot back that “you can’t drink that.”  Musk calmly replied that desalination is “absurdly cheap.”

Can desalination save a drying world?

Think about this.  Should the Soquel Creek Water District Board of Directors been so quick to jump on the best-available grant funding for what is known as Indirect Potable Re-Use of this sewage water when energy technology for desalination was making big strides in efficiency, and the State of California was quickly moving to allow Direct Potable Re-Use of the recycled water instead of injection into the aquifer?  The State Waterboard is due to approve Direct Potable Re-Use by the end of this year.  That means Soquel Creek Water District customers could be drinking the stuff directly….soon.

I would welcome your thoughts.

CHINESE GOLD BROUGHT TO LIFE WITH AUTHOR SANDY LYDON AND GEORGE OW INTERVIEW

Don’t miss this opportunity to learn more about the history of the Chinese in shaping Santa Cruz County, sponsored by the Santa Cruz County Public Library, this Saturday, October 7 at 10am-12:30pm. It’ll be at The 418 Project, 155 River St S, Santa Cruz, CA, 95060

“Experience the history of Chinese Americans in Santa Cruz with Author Sandy Lydon in conversation with George Ow. Lydon’s groundbreaking local history, “Chinese Gold” will be transformed into a multimedia book discussion by artist and educator Rui Li. Li presents additional interviews with Lydon and Ow in addition to a treasure-trove of images of old Chinatown. Copies of the book will be available for purchase in both English and Chinese.”

Write one letter.  Make one call.  Expect elected officials to answer your questions and make sure they do.  Make a big difference this week by just doing something.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

GREY HAYES.

October 1

FLOWERS FOR FALL

One native plant’s flowering is more enigmatic than any others for representing Fall on California’s central coast: coyote bush. This easy-to-identify and quite common shrub has so many stories to tell that it might serve as a gateway plant for those otherwise uninterested or unfamiliar with the native plants and plant communities that surround us.

Coyote Bush: the Trickster

For those of you who are following the series of columns where I’ve named native flowering plants each month in 2023, this is October’s flower. Unlike the others, this species is easy to find, so I’m letting you (and me) off the hook on that front. Instead, I present a different kind of challenge: sorting out the boy coyote bushes from the girl coyote bushes. This tricky shrub has separate female and male plants; I’ve never heard of a hermaphrodite, but there’s yet another challenge for the intrepid. The flowers of this shrub are tiny; there are no petals to be seen. But, there are so many flowers that the masses stand out. Male plants produce clusters of flowers bedecked with yellow pollen. Female plants apparently make nectar but more evidently make lots of white fluff, the ‘hair’ for which the plant is named.

Associated Wildlife – Mice!

My favorite mouse, the teeny tiny harvest mouse, loves coyote bush for many reasons. From film footage I’ve collected, it appears that harvest mice make use of meadow vole highways. And, meadow voles (aka meadow mice) love to use coyote bush as cover. Vole runs are at the soil surface and fan out like spokes in a wheel from a coyote bush into the surrounding prairie. Voles are voracious grazers and families of voles claim large areas of prairie as their grazing grounds, establishing what becomes a highway system, hidden just below a grassy roof. My Vole Cam footage barely catches the voles as they rocket so quickly back and forth on those highways. They jet down their transportation system in search of fresh hay, which they harvest until their mouths are fat with it, and it hangs out in all directions. Once full up, they rocket back home, dropping bits and pieces of their hay. They are very messy, and by the end of their foray, their trails are littered with criss-crossed grass pieces.

After the voles settle down in their holes for a rest, the harvest mice appear, sneaking in from hidden side roads and onto the messy vole highway. The harvest mice meticulously clear the litter from the vole highway and, by the time the voles wake up again, the harvest mice have left a clean trail for them to run up and down again. The voles put up big wads of hay in food chambers. I haven’t figured out if the harvest mice store food or just eat it on the spot. But, I have found very interesting harvest mouse nests, up in the boughs of coyote bush.

Coyote Down Nests

Harvest mice gather the ‘hair’ from female coyote bushes and weave the softest of tear-drop shaped nests where they raise their babies. Perhaps they weave in the longer down from thistles, as well. However they make their nests, they are small, intricately woven, and about 2′ up in coyote bushes…maybe even right above the coyote bushes that serve as home central for the vole family with which they associate. The harvest mice nests have a hidden or tiny doorway, which I haven’t figured out, yet. Perhaps they seal them shut coming and going, and I suspect I know why: alligator lizards.

Alligator Lizards in the Air…in the Air!

If the title of this section makes you mysteriously reminisce, perhaps you should listen to the America song, Ventura Highway one more time. The songwriter was sharing an ecological insight: aerial alligator lizards are a real thing. When seeking harvest mouse nests, I encounter alligator lizards perched in coyote bushes. They are often on the sunny side, perhaps basking while they seek their prey. No doubt that harvest mice are one of their meal items, and no doubt they seek out the nests within the canopies of coyote bushes. There’s so much going on in those coyote bushes!

Unwelcome Coyote Bush

Even with that wildlife story, and there are many others, humans don’t always welcome coyote bush: it’s an invasive species! For 2 million years, a diverse menagerie of large herbivores roamed California’s grasslands, grazing the grasses, uprooting trees and massively setting back shrubs. Much more recently, native peoples tended grasslands using fire and other tools that kept shrubs and trees at bay, stewarding the very species rich grasslands along California’s coast where coyote bush would have otherwise blanketed thousands of acres. Without tending coastal grasslands, coyote bush quickly invades. From seedlings to a continuous canopy of coyote bush takes only 20 years. The hundreds of grassland-dependent species don’t like that. Livestock managers don’t like that, either. And, parks and open space managers don’t like it: there goes the view and here comes a bad fire danger!

Flaming Bush

Coyote bush isn’t always easy to burn, but burn it sometimes does. When the fire weather calmed down after the worst of the Lockheed Fire in 2009, I watched hundreds of thousands of dollars get wasted as fire agencies tried igniting swaths of coyote bush to create a containment line and supposedly to make a study of this as yet unstudied fuel type. They dropped lots of different types of igniting devices on that stand from helicopters and from ground mounted guns. After hours of such play, the choking smoke that rose out of those areas blanketed Santa Cruz for days, but hardly anything had burned, there was no containment line, and, try as I might, I could never get any word about the results of their fuels modeling study.

Years later, in 2020, as I watched the CZU Lightning Complex Fire advance towards my home, I was able to witness how wildfire interacts with coyote bush. As the fire backed down a hill across from me, long swaths of coyote bush would smolder at first and then roar alight, followed by the next downhill swatch and so forth…the fire marching towards me. After the fire, the trunks and thick branches of the coyote bush remained, dead. 90 percent of those burned shrubs resprouted from their bases. The skeletons 3 years later are still pliable, not easily broken off…really difficult to negotiate on a walk. Soon, that and many other coyote bush stands will be green again…green with a continuous standing dead fuel load waiting for the next fire.

Coyote Bush Nursery

On the other hand, some people really welcome coyote bush. They say, ‘up with coyote bush! It’s a nurse plant!!’ They claim that coyote bush shade and shelter helps other species to establish. After the initial invasion of coyote bush in our native grasslands, up shoots poison oak, blackberry, oaks, monkeyflower, and California sagebrush. Whether or not those species really needed coyote bush to nurse them along remains a mystery, but the march of new, woody species into our endangered coastal prairies is fairly predictable after that initial wave of coyote bush. Tromp into a stand of coast live oak sometime – see if you spot old skeletons of coyote bush in the understory. They might be telling you a story of ecosystem change.

Your Turn

Whatever you do, please do try to get out and look carefully at coyote bush. Can you spot a female vs. a male? Also, crush some leaves in your hand and take a big sniff- you won’t soon forget the delightful piney scent of the foliage.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

October 2
#275 / A Phenomenal Culture Of Welcoming

Pictured above is our “Wall” at the United States’ border with Mexico, as seen from Nogales, Arizona.  Mexico is right on the other side. I took the picture in May, 2021, and I was appalled. I have never forgotten my visit to that border, and the statement that this border wall represents.

This picture documents how our fear and rejection has been made into a barrier of concrete and steel, with the razor wall making clear that the penalty for trying to come across that border will likely be death. Most recently, Texas has installed a floating barrier-wall in the Rio Grande River, also including razor wire. The news story from which I took the image below said this:

The Mexican government reported for the first time Wednesday that a body was spotted along the floating barrier that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott installed recently in the Rio Grande, across from Eagle Pass, Texas. Mexico’s Foreign Relations Department said authorities were trying to recover the body, and did not know the person’s nationality or the cause of death. Many had warned about the danger of the barrier, because it is designed to make it more difficult for migrants to climb over or swim under it.

You probably remember the statement that the United States has, historically, provided to those who would want to come here from another country:

The story from which I took the above image of the Statue of Liberty said this:

In the early 1900s, Georgina Shuyler was one of many to point out that the statue’s proximity to Ellis Island, and its visibility for ships and boats coming ashore, made it a powerful, welcoming symbol for immigrants entering the United States. In response to this new interpretation, the words from Emma Lazarus’s poem The New Colossus were famously etched into a plaque at the base of the statue in 1903, including the words: “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of your teeming shore.” It became recognized as a symbol of America’s rich multicultural history, founded by people from around the world.

I thought to write this blog posting about the topic of immigration because, as is so often true, a single phrase from a newspaper article caught my attention. The article was authored by David Oshinsky, who is director of the Division of Medical Humanities at NYU Grossman School of Medicine and a professor in the NYU Department of History. The article appeared in the Saturday-Sunday, September 30 – October 1 edition of The Wall Street Journal, and was titled: “The Nobel Prizes Need A Makeover.” In his article, Oshinsky noted the disproportionate number of Nobel Prizes that have been awarded to Americans:

If one were to make a composite of the typical Nobel Prize winner in science, it would be a middle-aged American man, nurtured in elite surroundings, whose eureka moment occurred about 15 years or so before winning the prize. The U.S. has dominated these competitions, winning close to half the science Nobels since 1901…

America’s dominance can be partly attributed, in fact, to its role as a haven for scientists seeking freedom and opportunity. What began as a trickle in the 1930s with the arrival of refugees from Nazism became a steady stream by the 1960s, as the U.S. liberalized its more restrictive immigration laws. Since then, the number of Nobels in science won by Americans born elsewhere has skyrocketed. Immigrants have accounted for close to 40% of the prizes awarded to Americans in the 21st century. “The U.S. has built a phenomenal culture of welcoming,” says Stefano Bertuzzi, an Italian émigré who heads the American Society for Microbiology (emphasis added).

Please let me say that I endorse the thought that a “culture of welcoming” is a positive for this nation. Wouldn’t you agree?

Let’s not forget that!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
October 2

PLAYING CATCH UP WITH THE HANDS OF TIME

The black and gold 16-foot clock seen in the photos of Trump Tower in New York City was erected on the sidewalk over twelve years ago without the required permits and city officials are now attempting to collect those fees. The ten-year permit for this type of clock installation is usually billed at $300 per year; and though the city’s oversight on the matter was not an issue until 2015, pursuit was dropped when Donald Trump became a presidential candidate and was then successful in his election to the office. NYC’s Department of Transportation wrote the organization recently to remind them that the clock and other “structures continue to be encroachments on the public right of way and are subject to enforcement.” It remains to be seen how this might be enforced with Manhattan Judge Arthur Engoron’s dissolution order for the Trump Organization last week…it may mean that removal of the ‘Trump‘ moniker from the tower as well as from the four faces of the intruding timepiece is in the offing. The attorneys for the former president were in court the day after the ruling asking for more clarity, but were denied, with the justice saying to check back later…stand back and stand by, if you will.

This is a monumental coup for New York Attorney General Letitia James in her lawsuit against Trump’s golf and real estate organization, which includes his two sons, TweedleDumb and TweedleDumber, and the executives who have been party to the perpetuation of years of fraud. Engoron made an early decision, after three years of pre-trial investigations and litigation, that Trump’s fraudulent inflation of his worth to banks and insurers added approximately $3.6B in fictional value to his annual net worth. Those knowledgeable about such matters have termed the ruling “the corporate death penalty” because it orders the cancellation of state ‘certificates’ allowing the Trump Organization and the hundreds of underlying trusts and LLCs to function as corporate entities. The order specifies that within ten days, Trump’s attorneys must submit names of three possible “independent receivers to manage the dissolution of the cancelled LLCs” to the court, which means selling corporate properties. However, the judge honored the request of the attorneys for thirty days to agree to a receiver, which then brought up the name of retired judge, Barbara Jones, an independent monitor currently, to assume that role.

This is a unique case for which there is little guidance to dissolve a multi-billion-dollar company, assets which range from not only Trump Tower, but home addresses held as LLCs, as well. Sticking points such as these led the judge say he was not prepared to make a ruling, leaving the two Tweedles with roofs over their heads for the time being. The state has alleged fraud involving two of Trump’s residences: Mar-a-Lago and the Trump Tower’s 10,000 square feet triplex penthouse where he lives on occasion…which was fraudulently tripled in size to 30,000 square feet in financial statements. Banks relied on the accuracy of this information to collateralize and maintain the hundreds of millions of dollars in Trump Organization loans. The court found that Trump valued Mar-a-Lago at $739M based falsely on the premise that it was free of any development restrictions, which gained him a generous tax benefit for which he was to give up residential development rights. Actual value of this property should have been around $75M, as estimated by the attorney general. Denying that the valuations were fraudulent, Trump’s attorneys claim that The Don was a “visionary” who saw value beyond what non-visionaries could see, as they prepare to fight fraud accusations and appeal the dissolution order. So, who gets the $25M clock?

Likely it won’t be Melania. Being the visionary that she is, she has recently renegotiated the marital pre-nuptial for the third time to protect the financial interests of Barron, her 17-year-old son, as his father’s legal troubles multiply and his financial future becomes questionable. “Melania is most concerned about maintaining and increasing a substantial trust for Barron,” a source said, as she hopes to secure “a specific amount at minimum,” and even as she seeks more money and property for her own security. Bill Palmer writes on his The Palmer Report, “Donald Trump is going to prison. His fate was sealed the minute the goons breached the Capitol.” The hype from both sides of the aisle about how he will escape prosecution and take over the country again, after four indictments and 91 criminal charges, is now looking grimmer by the day, and even Trump understands the predicament he faces. His posing questions to those around him concerning prison itself…state or federal, orange jumpsuit or not?…point to his behavior as the equivalent of a child who is realizing the enormity of his indiscretions. Yet the media is still playing his game that somehow he will remain politically viable, furthering their own game of selling cars, shampoo, miracle cures, and McDonald’s fast food – which, by the way, is not allowed in a prison populace!

Palmer goes on to say that Trump’s bragging in a civil trial deposition that his properties are worth much more than his current evaluations, resulting in a windfall should he be forced to sell, is showing that the influence of his ‘babysitters’ have prepped him for that very eventuality, by a liquidation at the end of Letitia James‘ civil trial. Being so far gone in his senile and delusional state, he’ll just accept that scenario as being real, always at the ready with another set of lies. Palmer concludes, “As always, the key part of the story is just how far gone Trump is cognitively. Based on how he now comes off in his public appearances, he seems to be at a point where his ‘babysitters’ could probably convince him of anything. That now apparently includes convincing him that his properties aren’t being forcibly sold off as part of liquidation, but are instead being sold off because he’s a financial genius. Anything to soften the blow on the way down.”

Trump’s defense in Georgia took a blow last week when Scott Hall, a bail bond business owner and one of the nineteen indicted in the Fani Willis conspiracy case, pleaded guilty to five misdemeanor counts, the first to do so. His plea agreement in Judge Scott McAfee’s hearing resulted being sentenced to five years’ probation, a $5000 fine and 200 hours of community service, and, being forbidden to participate in any “polling activities” while on probation. He is required to write a letter of apology to the citizens of Georgia and must testify honestly in any future proceedings in the case. Hall’s case centered on his breach of a Coffee County election office on January 7, 2021, along with a group who conspired to “intentionally interfere with and hinder and delay” the duties of another co-defendant, Misty Hampton, who was Coffee County’s election supervisor. The group’s goal was to “unlawfully access all election machines in said county in order to obtain proprietary data or property of Dominion Voting Systems used in the administration of elections in the state of Georgia.” Sidney Powell is likely in need of smelling salts, and Rudy Giuliani’s hair dye rivulets are out of control by now.

Perhaps in anticipation of being on the skids, Donald Trump, Jr. is branching out with his business acumen. He has been seen on Xwitter hyping a brand of coffee, called Blackout Coffee, a brand with conservative values! In a video from his podcast, Triggered, DonnyJ says, “You don’t have to choose between what you believe and what you buy. You’re gonna be drinking coffee anyway, and if you do, show support for a brand aligned with your conservative values. It’s American-made, it’s family-owned. And, they support what we believe in,” adding, “So, from sourcing beans, to roasting the coffee, and that processed customer support, and shipping, Blackout Coffee will never compromise on taste or quality, and they do it all while supporting freedom-loving values.” One Xwitter user wrote in response, “How does coffee become conservative…do they plant the beans in a MAGA hat?” Another user added, “Junior is gonna have to sell a lot of coffee to cover Big Daddy’s legal bills. I never thought I’d see the day when Presidential candidates have to sell coffee, t-shirts and gimme hats to get elected to the formerly greatest office in the world…” The brand’s website also offers mugs that read, “Give me coffee, or give me death,” and “Pro life-god-guns, and coffee,” among other catchy kitsch keepsakes.

Melania Trump, while keeping a low profile for the most part, managed to surface recently, making a sales pitch for – Christmas ornaments! We all remember her disdain in handling the White House Christmas decorations, as recorded by former friend and aide, Stephanie Winston Wolkoff, when she infamously said, “I’m working my ass off at Christmas stuff. You know, who gives a f*** about Christmas stuff and decoration, but I need to do it, right?” True, she did sell ornaments last year, but has added “a corresponding digital collectible” to the current $35 to $45 offerings. Some have suggested she engrave the ornaments with her past utterances about the holiday. Ah, anything to keep the home fires burning.

The Flaxen-Klaxon-Hair-On-Fire, Marjorie Taylor-Greene, is still managing to stir things up online with her antics. She recalled a recent air terminal experience with an airport worker, posting, “Friendly airline employee smiles and says, ‘tell President Trump that African American Muhammad says hello and is with him!” Xwitter users jumped her for fabricating her tale, one posting, “I’ll take things that didn’t happen for $200, Alex!” Another called her out by saying, “Racists always use adjectives to describe a person for the purpose of stating that they are not racist (i.e., “African American Muhammad”); however, it’s not necessary to do so, if you’re NOT racist, because actions speak louder than words.” “Jamal must have been on a break…they love that name for their imaginary black friends,” wrote one user. Then Ms. Jewish Space Lasers got her Jewish holidays mixed up by picturing a Chanukah menorah in a posted Yom Kippur message to the Jewish community. Why does she bother? She promptly deleted the post, but not after being called a meshuggener, along with other names for her ridiculous post. One person joked that she acted quickly in order to avoid Nancy Pelosi’s Gazpacho Police. Meidas Touch’s co-founder, Brett Meiselas, punched back with, “Frankly, Jews don’t need an antisemitic maniac who gives speeches at Nazi events sending out holiday messages in the first place.” Democratic Representative Jared Moskowitz of Florida adds, “Yom Kippur is where you atone for your sins. Lord knows you will be very busy.” TV comedy writer, Frank Lesser, says in Marge’s defense, “She thought it was an eight-pronged Jewish space laser.” And to help the befuddled Georgia-Marge-In-Charge in her future endeavors, SnarkTank99 designed her an Easter greeting for later posting, with a cartoonish Santa waving jovially with his bag of gifts.

Representative Andy Ogles of Tennessee gifted the former president with a new handle last week when he accidentally referred to him as “President Chump” as he spoke on the floor of the House. He quickly corrected this Freudian slip, but just as quickly it spread on the internet. “Sir, you had it correct the first time,” posted one responder. We may recall Ogles having to defend his Second Amendment-family Christmas card in 2021, as the group posed with their guns…shortly after The Covenant School in Nashville suffered a mass shooting in which six died. “No regrets,” he said at the time. And, Chris Christie during the GOP presidential debate last week gave Trump a new nametag…to the chagrin of the Disney Corporation, no doubt. Trump’s no-show status at the debates…dodging any controversial embarrassments with his competitors, earns him the honorific of “Donald Duck.”

A customer goes into a bookstore, asking the clerk if they stock Trump’s new book on how to deport aliens. The offended clerk tells him, “Get the hell out and don’t come back.” The customer replies, “Yes, that’s the one…do you have it in paperback?”

Dr. Dana Ménard informs us, “The cat who was completely obsessed with my bump when I was pregnant is quite uninterested in the baby now that she’s out. It’s a weird way to find out my cat is a Republican.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “TOWERS”

“The collapse of the Tower of Babel is perhaps the central urban myth. It is certainly the most disquieting. In Babylon, the great city that fascinated and horrified the Biblical writers, people of different races and languages, drawn together in pursuit of wealth, tried for the first time to live together – and failed”.
~Neil MacGregor

“Living in a community with very wounded people, I came to see that I had lived most of my life as a tightrope artist trying to walk on a high, thin cable from one tower to the other, always waiting for the applause when I had not fallen off and broken my leg”.
~Henri Nouwen

“The whole imposing edifice of modern medicine is like the celebrated tower of Pisa – slightly off balance”.
~Prince Charles

“A man’s mind is wont to tell him more than seven watchmen sitting in a tower”.
~Rudyard Kipling

...

Television in the 50s. The product promotion, the smoking, the everything – this is a fascinating glimpse from an episode of “I’ve got a secret”


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

September 27 – October 3, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton….housing for people, hidden valley concert. Greensite…on the Wharf and the Historic Preservation Commission. Steinbruner…Santa Cruz wastewater, Renaissance High school well, few CZU fire survivors, housing developments. Hayes…how change happens. Patton…streets without buses. Matlock…king kong house party and nerfs on meet the frass. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes…”October”

...

SANTA CRUZ TAXI FLEET…May 7, 1951. That’s Mayor George M. Penniman in the suit giving the Safety Award to the fleet representative. Looks like some ACME taxis in among the Yellow fleet.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE September 25

HOUSING FOR PEOPLE. There’s a deadline on getting enough signatures to get this on the ballot and what it will accomplish is more than necessary… it’s vital. Go to housingforpeople.org to get all the details but just remember it will increase the affordable housing ratio to 25% and it’ll give us a chance to stop the super tall buildings (12 + stories) that developers now cram through our easy to please city government. It’ll give our community a chance to vote on whether or not the buildings provide a human and reasonable percentage of affordable units. As the website says, “The citizens deserve a right to vote when builders want to break the current height limits”. It also states…” If you want to maintain our diversity by increasing low-income housing, so family members, low and moderate wage earners, youth and elders can continue to live here, sign our initiative!”

One reader sent the following summary/plea … Housing for People- NOT unaffordable towers! The ballot initiative will implement TWO important things:

  • Take back our right to vote on height and density when developers exceed the current zoning limits.
  • And it will increase the affordable housing ratio to at least 25% in all new developments of 30 units or more.
  1. The Santa Cruz City Council shall not adopt amendments to the City’s General Plan or Zoning Ordinance that increase the allowable height limits or Floor Area Ratios (F.A.R.) for development projects, which are greater than the height limits and F.A.R. in effect in the City’s General Plan as of June 1, 2023 (or the earliest date allowed by law), without a prior vote of the people approving the proposed increase.
  2. The inclusionary (affordable) housing requirements shall be increased from the existing 20% to at least 25% for developments with 30 or more housing units.

HIDDEN VALLEY STRING ORCHESTRA PRESENTS

“AQUARELLES”

HIDDEN VALLEY STRING ORCHESTRA Sixteen of Northern California’s finest string players. In the early tradition, the orchestra will perform without a conductor. Prepared under the direction of concertmaster, Roy Malan. Comprising sixteen of Northern California’s most talented and accomplished string players, the String Orchestra of Hidden Valley debuted to acclaim in November 2014. Lyn Bronson of Peninsula Reviews said of the String Orchestra’s debut, “A gorgeous performance. Every section . . . a perfect jewel.”

Repertoire:
Two Aquarelles by Frederick Delius
Intermezzo by Franz Schreker
The Peninsula Suite by Nancy Bloomer Deussen
Romance by Gerald Finzi
Serenade by Antonin Dvorak

TWO CONCERTS, TWO LOCATIONS:
The doors open 30 minutes before the performance. Reception with the musicians will immediately follow both performances.

Carmel Valley
Friday September 29 at 7:30 PM
Hidden Valley Theatre

104 W. Carmel Valley Rd, Carmel Valley CA 93924

Santa Cruz
Saturday September 30 at 4:00 PM
Peace United Church

900 High Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

TICKET INFORMATION:
$100 Patron, $25 General Admission, $10 Student

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

INFAMY. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). A movie from Poland that hammers on us the terrible local prejudices against the area Gypsies. There’s a 17 year old girl who has to face the hatred and pain in being a minority. It’s a simple movie with lots of amateur mugging and posing, but it does get the point across.

HOW TO DEAL WITH A HEARTBREAK. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (4.0 IMDB). They list it as a comedy drama and it sure is both. This woman author tries hard to write her book. Then her dad dies and returns to help her write the book. So yes there are laughs/snickers but she’s 34 years old so we do lose patience with her.

SUSPECT X. (NETFLIX SERIES) (NO IMDB YET). Her husband disappears but he was an evil sort and this film from India makes quite a story out of it.  She has a math teacher as a neighbor, he’s loved by all and helps her hide the truths behind the husband’s disappearance from the police. It’s a bit overdone and heavy, but worthwhile.

BURNING BODY. (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB). A policeman is found burned to death in his own police car. The acting is well done and it’s done mostly in Spanish and in Barcelona.

It’s based on a true and well known case that happened a few years ago. It’s mostly centered on the woman or women in his life and is worthwhile watching.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

JEANNE DIELMAN, 23, QUAI DU COMMERCE, 1080 BRUXELLES. (MAX MOVIE). (7.6 IMDB). **** This 1975 movie was just re-discovered and 480 movie critics from the Sight and Sound magazine (which is part of The British Film Institute) have stated that Jeanne Dielman is the greatest film of all time. Many, many critics around the world agree. Its three and a half hours long and was directed by a woman director Chantal Akerman. It covers three days in the life of a widowed mother and her son and takes place in Brussels. There’s almost no dialogue, the camera never moves from left to right, and it’s definitely worth watching.

EL CONDE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). **   A surprising re-take and reversion and political commentary on Augusto Pinochet’s public and private life. It was made in Chile and they call it a comedy. They have Pinochet being first born in 1776 and still being on earth as a 250 year old vampire. It parallels his actual political and personal history adding the vampire secret, and we get to watch blood drinking from a blender many times. It’s “filmed” in black and white which really adds to the desired mood. Note… Augusto Pinochet was leader of the military junta that overthrew the socialist government of President Salvador Allende of Chile in 1973.

A HAUNTING IN VENICE. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (6.8 IMDB). ** Kenneth Branagh is back with the third in his Hercule Poirot versions of Agatha Christie’s books. Michelle Yeoh and Tina Fey are deadly serious in it too. Branagh moved the plot to Venice in 1947 from Christie’s book “Halloween Party” she first published in 1969. It’s deadly serious, very confusing, and it’s hard to stay interested as Poirot makes his rounds. Not recommended.

LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.9 IMDB) *• An overly cute teen ager love story about two kids who fall in love at the airport as they depart to two different locations. Some critic called it a cheesy rom com and I agree. It’s silly, trite, and brings in a cancer drama to give it some validity. Not worth watching.

INSIDE. (PRIME MOVIE) (5.5 IMDB). *** It’s good fun to see Willem Dafoe back on screen. This time he’s a specialized art thief who flies in a helicopter and gets trapped in a penthouse in New York City that he was robbing. Because he’s a thief he can’t call or hope for help. He tries climbing, stacking furniture…nothing works. Dafoe is a fine actor and its good fun to watch his many attempts to escape.

...
September 25

PRESERVING OUR HISTORY

There are times when a picture is worth a thousand words as the adage says. Such was the case at the recent monthly meeting of the city’s Historic Preservation Commission. The meeting’s agenda included a public hearing on the recently released Final Environmental Impact Report (FEIR) for the Wharf Master Plan and the Plan itself. The recommendation in the Agenda Report from staff was that the commission recommend to the city council, approval for both. This hearing was the first of three commission hearings prior to the issue going to city council at the end of November.

If you had no idea the Wharf Master Plan, with its unpopular forty feet tall new buildings and much increased commercial was back, you can be forgiven. Throughout this long process from the first FEIR in 2020 the city has failed to give their widely unpopular make-over of the Wharf the publicity it deserves. The city’s public notice in the Sentinel of the release of the current FEIR in early September was buried in the Real Estate section, with no city seal, under a public notice from the county, with county seal. The required public hearing on the draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) was held one day before the end of the comment period, by zoom during working hours with few attendees since few knew it was happening.

You may recall that the city was taken to court by the community group, Don’t Morph the Wharf! over inadequacies in the city’s 2020 environmental review for the Wharf Master Plan. The Court ruled against the city and in the community group’s favor. The Court ruling was that the city must rescind both the EIR and the Wharf Master Plan. Thus began a new process. However, the city decided to recirculate for public review only a portion of the original Plan and EIR, allowing comments only on that new Recreation portion and not responding to comments outside of that portion.

EIR’s are required to include a study of Alternatives, including a No-Build Alternative. Alternative 2- The Modified Project, included in the 2020 EIR, got rid of the lowered Western Walkway (more on that in a moment) and reduced the height of the three new buildings from forty-five to forty feet. The city stated that Alternative 2 (a less environmentally impactful alternative) met all project objectives but they did not state the basis for not adopting it. The Court’s ruling included that the city had not provided evidence for non-adoption of Alternative 2 and required that the issue be addressed. At the Historic Preservation commission hearing, under the one slide referencing the Court Ruling, Alternative 2 was included as bullet point three in the slide show presented by the city’s Asset Manager in charge of the project. No commentary added.

The photo above, in my view, beautifully captures the essence of this historical structure. The city’s hired historical consultant for the 2020 EIR wrote that the historical portion of the 1914 Municipal Wharf lies in its 4500 wooden pilings. Its length (longest on the Pacific Coast and one of five longest in the world) and unique shape at the southern end are usually added to that list of unique features.

Take a moment to absorb the feeling and character of the Wharf captured in the photo. There is for me much beauty in the uninterrupted flow of dark pilings, curving at the southern end to lessen the impact of winter waves. It is said that Master Engineer Brunnier, who went on to design and build many iconic San Francisco structures, spent a year on Beach Hill observing the waves, wind and currents before designing the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf.

The proposed lowered Western Walkway would bisect the pilings eight feet below deck with an add-on made of different materials, for about half the length in the photo, starting roughly on the left. The Walkway would bring people, bustle, noise, and movement into this scene. For me, and others, this is transformative. In prepping for my comments at the Historic Preservation Commission I decided to print and hand out this photo.

The effect was electric. Hence the adage. All commissioners present “got” the impact. The chair waved the photo aloft stating that had they been given this photo they would have objected sooner, or words to that effect. Unfortunately, staff did not clarify that they could vote to recommend Alternative 2, which removes the Western Walkway, since this is a new approval process for both the FEIR and the Wharf Master Plan. Unaware of this option and unclear on what they were voting for, the commission voted to continue the meeting and form a sub-group to get more input from staff to get clearer on the issues.

With this opening at the Historic Preservation Commission level, the community has a chance to be better heard. Over two thousand people signed the 2020 Don’t Morph the Wharf! petition stating they did not want the Wharf to be so dramatically changed as per the Wharf Master Plan. We have only a few more months to make a difference. You can email me at gilliangreensite@gmail.com if you would like to be involved.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
September 25

COMMENT PERIOD OPEN FOR SANTA CRUZ WASTEWATER AND SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT PERMIT TO DUMP INTO THE OCEAN

If you are concerned about the pollutant levels the City’s sewage treatment plant dumps into the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary and Pacific Ocean, including the future concentrated contaminants and carcinogenic disinfection by-products of the PureWater Soquel Project treatment plant scheduled to start up next year, you have until October 11 to register your concerns with the Central Coast Water Quality Control Board, the permitting agency.

Staff of the Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board will present Draft Order No. R3-2023-0001 (Draft Order) for adoption at the Board’s December 14-15, 2023 meeting that will include all public comment received before October 12, 2023.

“The Draft Order includes requirements for the discharge of waste from the City of Santa Cruz Wastewater Treatment Facility (Facility) to the Pacific Ocean. The Draft Order also establishes requirements for production of disinfected tertiary recycled water. The Draft Order is intended to serve as a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit and will supersede existing Order No. R3-2017-0030, which remains effective until the Central Coast Water Board adopts a new order and the new order goes into effect. The Draft Order includes a Monitoring and Reporting Program and Fact Sheet as Attachments E and F.”

Take a moment to look through the Draft Order and associated attachments and send your comments

Here is the link to the Notice regarding the Soquel Creek Water District Permit Staff Report for their part of the wastewater effluent

Written comments are to be sent to the Waste Discharge Requirements Unit by email (must be no more than 15 megabytes)

RB3-WDR@Waterboards.ca.gov or by mail to:

Waste Discharge Requirements Unit Central Coast Water Board
895 Aerovista Place, Suite 101
San Luis Obispo, CA 93401

Please also indicate in the subject line “Comment Letter – Pure Water Soquel”

Contacts for further information:

James Bishop, (805) 542-4628, james.bishop@waterboards.ca.gov
Rachel Hohn, (805) 542-4789, rachel.hohn@waterboards.ca.gov
Jennifer Epp, (805) 594-6181, jennifer.epp@waterboards.ca.gov

No studies were ever conducted to evaluate the impact on the marine habitat that the PureWater Soquel Project’s concentrated brine effluent with carcinogenic disinfection by-products and temperature fluctuations. 

SOQUEL CREEK ANNEXATION OF RENAISSANCE HIGH SCHOOL WATER SERVICE
The private well at Renaissance High on San Andreas Road is polluted with high levels of hexavalent chromium, a known carcinogen. The Pajaro Valley Unified School District has attempted to treat the problem by installing reverse osmosis units at the well, but there is so much sand that gets pumped, likely the very fine pores of the membrane filtration clog easily and require a lot of maintenance.

Soquel Creek Water District did not want to annex the School into their service area, and also refused to annex a large parcel nearby whose owner requested service in order to subdivide and develop.  No one is even mentioning the KOA Campground adjacent to the School, whose well also very likely has trouble with hexavalent chromium levels.

I am very glad the Renaissance High School is being added for water service, and hope that the KOA Campground will also soon be added.

LAFCO Notice of Public Hearing

Here is one recent Letter to the Editor on the topic

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT COULD LEARN FROM PLEASANTON CITY COUNCIL…DELAY HIGH RATE JUMPS

It is refreshing to see that some elected officials do listen to their constituents and take responsive actions accordingly.  Soquel Creek Water District customers should read this article and speak out on impending water rate hikes coming your way:

Pleasanton Council Votes to Delay Proposed Water Rate Hikes

WHY HAVE SO FEW CZU FIRE SURVIVORS REBUILT?

Compare with Santa Cruz County … only 36 of 911 have rebuilt after three years.

The Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) received two responses in the survey of local jurisdictions that identified the number of units lost during declared states of emergency. The City of Santa Rosa indicated that 3,043 housing units were lost on October 8, 2017 and that, as of February 2020 when the survey was conducted, 2,323 units had been completed or were in the construction/permitting process. The County of Sonoma stated the unincorporated county lost 2,200 units in the 2017 Sonoma Complex Fires and 1,235 units had been rebuilt or were under construction as of February 2020.

FINAL REGIONAL HOUSING NEEDS ALLOCATION (RHNA) PLAN: San Francisco Bay Area, 2023-2031 (page 44)

SONOMA COUNTY IS CREATIVE WITH HOUSING ELEMENT STATE MANDATES…WHY NOT SANTA CRUZ COUNTY?

Santa Cruz County could learn a lot from Sonoma County and how Mr. Tennis Wick is fighting back creatively to protest the unreasonably high building requirement the State’s Housing & Community Development (HCD) is mandating through regional Councils of Government, which in our area is the Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments (AMBAG).

Sonoma RHNA appeal

Solano County is also taking an interesting approach by using sub-regions and keeping flexibility to move the number allocations around for future planning.

The Santa Cruz County Planning Commission will likely have met by the time you are reading this, with their Study Session scheduled for September 27, 9:30am

WHAT IS HOME RULE AND HOW COULD IT BE USED TO AFFECT LAND USE HERE?

Listen in this Friday at 2pm on “Community Matters” on Santa Cruz Voice to hear local activist Ms. Lira Filippini explaining Home Rule and how it could be used to keep local discretionary means to shape the quality of life in our County for future generations: Santa Cruz Voice – Listen and Be Heard

ARE THOSE HIGH STATE-MANDATED BUILDING NUMBERS LEGITIMATE?  LISTEN IN NEXT MONDAY EVENING!

Recently, the California State Auditor determined that the State Housing & Community Development (HCD) mandated numbers for counties and cities statewide to meet in updated housing element planning documents is unjustified because statistics and models show California population has in fact declined and will remain stagnant through 2060.

So, why is the HCD whipping municipalities to update planning documents at a feverish and impossible pace to include such big jumps in numbers of units?

Make sure you listen in next Monday, October 2 at 5pm to the Catalysts for Local Control webinar to find out the truth:

catalystsca.org

The Regional Housing Number Allocation (RHNA) mandates are not evidence-based and have no connection with reality, imposing unfunded mandates that have altered the planning process into a production process, and will burden all municipalities with funding infrastructure to support what appears to be favoring special interests.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  LISTEN TO THE CATALYSTS FOR LOCAL CONTROL WEBINAR NEXT MONDAY AT 5PM AND LEARN ABOUT HOW PHONEY THE RHNA NUMBERS REALLY ARE AND HOW YOU CAN GET INVOLVED IN EFFORTS TO HOLD THE STATE ACCOUNTABLE.

JUST DO ONE THING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Happy Autumn,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
September 25

HOW CHANGE HAPPENS

How we interact with our immediate community will determine the future of life on Earth.

A retired professor recently told me a story about a transition he’d seen over the last 25 years of teaching. Twenty-five years ago, when he entered the lecture hall, the room was noisy with conversation. That noise died away with hand-held computers: students were staring at their machines! It was eerily quiet.

Disastrous Blame

Do we blame a person or a political party for how polarized our society seems to be? Why? How often do we sincerely attempt to bridge interpersonal political divides? Occasions present themselves all the time for one-on-one bridging albeit briefly, but the opportunity to have longer, rich, safe dialogues are rare. But this must change if we are to steer away from the social, environmental, and economic catastrophes we are enmired in currently.

Not Dialogues

There are pressing local issues receiving no public discourse. Instead, we have public comment at City Council, County Supervisor, Coastal Commission, or other political body meetings. Citizens get three minutes to say something, during which more likely than not the political officials are chatting with each other, doodling, or otherwise checked out. There are no responses, no discussion or acknowledgement. On any particular subject, political officials occasionally explain their positions in the shortest, vaguest terms. More lengthy written opinions from one side or the other appear in various media, and you can occasionally follow the back-and-forth for a few volleys. All of this misses many important elements of a well moderated discussion and the crappy outcomes we experience clearly reflect that.

Thoughtful Discourse

Would you participate in a group dialogue with diverse perspectives if you knew that it would be well facilitated, and people would show each other respect? Imagine 100 people seated in a circle on comfortable chairs with a facilitator in the center. They are gathered to discuss a pressing local issue of interest to you. Experts on that issue are present, as are key decision makers. Everyone has pledged to be respectful and attentive. The facilitator is renowned for their skill. A group conversation unfolds where you feel heard, and you learn new substantive things about the issue. Others share perspectives that are different than yours, so afterwards you know more about why they hold those positions, just as they better understand why you hold yours. The group returns each month for a year to continue the conversation. Everyone’s understanding deepens. Perhaps the conservation results in improved decision making in our community. Perhaps it changes how things are implemented.

Small Hurdles

The kind of discourse I just described requires many things, many of which are attainable. There would need to be a skilled facilitator. It would be necessary that the participants be committed to the process, curious, respectful, and willing to share their perspectives. They would need to participate according to rules that allow everyone shared respect and time to speak. Experts and decision makers would need to be present. All parties would need to be willing to invest the time to allow the understanding to unfold. Probably, there would need to be a way of participants interacting with an easily accessed record of their discussion that they could reference to follow the progress. That list represents the superficial, easy necessities, but there are some deeper needs that would be more difficult to attain.

Bigger Hurdles

Financial costs and political power conspire to make such dialogues difficult if not impossible. Great facilitators, subject matter experts, and decision makers all would require payment for participation, including for preparation for, and follow up from, the in-person meetings. That funding would be more possible than the deeper problem: political opposition. It is in the interest of those in power to oppose any such dialogue, which is deeply dangerous to their power. They are effective in their opposition through challenging any public funding, decrying bias from the private funders, infiltrating the discourse with disrupters, publishing derogatory pieces about the discourse in the media, challenging participating members, reproaching participating members’ employers, etc., etc. These bigger hurdles represent the real challenges we must overcome to reclaim our democracy through the kind of participatory decision making I am presenting here. These larger challenges will need to be anticipated in through the organizing principles and personally through dedicated organizing committees.

Where to Start?

There are existing long-running, nascent, and still-to-be-born opportunities for my readers to get involved with the richly awarding discourses I have outlined. You might see them named ‘salons’ or ‘town halls.’ Some are called ‘collaborative natural resource management.’ People sometimes call them gatherings focusing on the ‘radical center.’  If you attend something with these names or tag lines, you must discern if you can see a way to having a voice with equal opportunity to contribute, if everyone is respectful, if the discourse is organized with rules and structure, and if the many divergent perspectives are well represented. Too often, the empowered or elite will falsely advertise so-called dialogues using these terms, so be on the lookout for those fakes.

Far too frequently, there are no organized discourses, and it is necessary to build the capacity to start them. You could have a place in that capacity in a variety of ways. If you have the means, you might consider funding the initiative. Without such means, you might consider other roles: facilitator, convener, note-taker, timekeeper, vibes monitoring, leader, or organizing committee member. Each of those roles is crucial and each requires different time commitments or skills.

A Priority Environmental Focus Area

Although the above can be applied to any subject, this column focuses on environmental issues. So, I want to focus the remaining space here on an issue that could use a well-facilitated collaborative dialogue across the Monterey Bay region.

If we are to accommodate all species, there needs to be facilitated landscape-scale collaborative conservation. We are currently dooming all species in our region because each conservation group is focusing only on its tiny piece of ground or issue. State Parks operate largely on a park-by-park planning basis. Different parks agencies do not collaborate with conservation planning. Land trusts do not work together with strategic planning for species conservation. The Bureau of Land Management does not cooperate actively with any other conservation group, and especially not with State conservation agencies to recover sensitive species. Private landowners are not invited into dialogue with ‘official’ conservation lands managers, even if they are adjacent. Conservation minded groups like the Santa Cruz Bird Club, The Wildlife Society, and the California Native Plant Society are neither leading nor participating in collaborative strategies for regional conservation. Municipal land planners aren’t working with any of the above to ponder how to collaborate on conservation.

This would be the first subject area I would suggest prioritizing. Such an effort would net great results and further widen the potential for recovering function to the Nation’s democracy. It would help societal healing. This work is necessary for the future of this region’s wildlife. We sorely need leadership. Please help.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

September 20

#263 / Streets Without Buses?

I am from Santa Cruz, California, and I really love our “picture buses,” one of which you can see above. The buses feature the outstanding and award-winning photography of Frans Lanting. “Whale Buses,” for instance, are now zooming around our local streets, urging us to protect whales “One Ride At A Time.” There are some other “picture buses,” too, celebrating other aspects of our natural world.

Frans and his partner, Christine Eckstrom, allied with The National Geographic Society, have been helping us to see the wonders of the natural world through their many years of superlative photography and video. Their recent book, Bay of Life, celebrates the environment of the Monterey Bay Area. There is now a “Bay of Life Project,” in fact, which accounts for those “picture buses.” The Community Foundation of Santa Cruz County will gladly accept your donations!

Much as I love the “picture buses,” the most common observation that I hear about buses in general is that there isn’t anyone, really, riding them! This observation, regretably, is pretty much on target; it’s accurate. A friend of mind, who has served on the Santa Cruz County Transportation Commission for many years, has always told me that our local transit agency is basically delivering “social services,” not “transportation services.” The system is really aimed at providing transportation to those lower income persons who can’t afford a car. Again, there is some truth to that!

Couldn’t we, I have long thought, get more for our money by trying out a different approach? One of my blog postings, back in November 2021, called for “Streets Without Cars.” I advanced a specific proposal for a new way of providing transportation services, to help reduce, or even eliminate, the traffic congestion that is so horrendous in my local community.

My proposal would remove from our streets and highways many of those greenhouse gas-spewing cars that clog them now. Traffic congestion is a big problem for almost everyone, and the Santa Cruz County Transportation Commission is trying to combat traffic congestion through highway widening projects. This is, in fact, a self-defeating strategy, because widened highways actually “induce demand” for more automobile trips, and so make the problem worse.

My proposed solution was to create a public, demand-responsive approach (like Uber or Lyft), so those who needed to get around our local community would end up “sharing” automobile trips. If you’d like to see what I said about that proposal, you should click this “Streets Without Cars” link.

I was surprised to read – in the Sunday, September 17, 2023, edition of my local newspaper, The Santa Cruz Sentinel – that this idea is actually being tried out in Wilson, North Carolina. The article was titled, “What if public transit was like Uber? A small city ended bus service to find out.”

Probably, unless you are a Sentinel subscriber (whose ever-increasing subscription prices are driving long-time subscribers, like me, to terminate their subscriptions), you’ll be blocked when you click the link. Thus, I am providing the following “screenshot” image of the story, which I think should expand if you click on it. You can also get essentially the same story, online, from another newspaper, by clicking right here.

In our case, here in Santa Cruz, we’d still need buses. LOTS of buses, in fact, because our “City On A Hill” (the UCSC campus) is a major destination for students who either don’t own a car or who couldn’t afford to park a car on campus. A transit hub, or hubs, could provide direct, express service to the campus. Other trips would utilize the “ride sharing” strategy now being tried out in North Carolina. Financing the system would be one major issue; the newspaper article doesn’t really outline that aspect of the system, but there are definitely solutions.

The big question? Are we willing to share?

I’d like to think so.

Let’s save the whales (and ourselves) “One [Shared] Ride At A Time.”

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

September 25

KING KONG HOUSE PARTY AND NERFS ON MEET THE FRASS

Charles P. Pierce, in Esquire magazine, asks of Kevin McCarthy: “Was it worth it, Kevin? The Speakership of the House of Representatives, I mean. The long, excruciating session of the House back in January? Fifteen long, excruciating ballots, between which, you had to negotiate with people who have pinwheels in their eyes? All of it on television, as the Democrats sat back and blithely watched the auto da fé like rubberneckers at a train wreck? All of that pain and embarrassment so you could call yourself the Speaker of the House even though everybody and his Uncle Fud knew you couldn’t actually be Speaker? Is it all worth it now, when there are too many chickens and not enough roosts?” So, here we stand…Kev has to be in his position to insure that the government is funded for the next year, but nobody is lifting a hand to help. Pierce says, “The Democrats are sitting over in the corner, making more popcorn. To the members of his own narrow majority, McCarthy is now poison among the extremists for going back on the deals he made to become Speaker, and among the more marginally sane, he is now poison for having made those deals in the first place. And Representative Lauren Boebert seems to be the only one capable of reaching across the aisle.” Snort, snort…good one!

Pierce believes our radical conservatives owe their current power to Newt Gingrich from his two years of radicalism in harassing the Clintons. “The logical end of being fed red meat constantly is cannibalism. And that’s the evolutionary stage of American conservatism at which McCarthy, that sap, finds himself now,” adds Pierce. He goes on to say that McCarthy’s fall parallels that of Gingrich after the GOP saw their House majority narrowed, particularly after Newt spent so much time on the Lewinsky scandal. He does credit him as being the architect of the first GOP House majority since 1954, giving him a couple of years of power and street cred…something Kevin lacks, and will never have.

Michelle Cottle of The New York Times contends that Mac has had it with the bullying of the zealot horde he has encouraged, but Gaetz and Greene are probably correct in that the Speaker is not following their rules, made in the smoke-filled rooms back in January, a problem with deals hatched in secrecy. Cottle says if the rabble-rousers wish to be taken seriously, they need to stop the King Kong act and at least file their threatened motion to dump McCarthy. She says, “The extremists are easy to denounce, especially with their tendency to act out like unruly teens – or Lauren Boebert at ‘Beetlejuice, but they are not to blame for the chaos consuming the House. It is Mr. McCarthy who led them to believe he would champion their policies and priorities. And it is Mr. McCarthy who elevated their influence in the conference, empowering them to wreak even greater havoc. Of course, they are going to make more and more outrageous demands. That’s what they do.”

Politico’s site reports the more than dozen Republicans, mostly Representative Byron Donalds‘ colleagues in the conservative Freedom Caucus, who are publicly torching the spending plan he brokered. With just a four-seat majority, Speaker Kevin McCarthy can only afford to lose a handful of them given that he can’t count on Democratic votes, leaving the GOP bill effectively D.O.A. The failure of the two negotiators he had empowered has brought on a full-House-party rebellion. Going beyond a simple centrist vs. right-wing clash, the Freedom Caucus itself is divided, with members backhanding the plan presented by their own leaders, along with the rising hue and cry to oust McCarthy should he rely on the Democrats to avoid a shutdown. Indiana’s Republican Representative Victoria Spartz vented, “The Republican House is failing the American people again and pursuing a path of gamesmanship and circus. Neither Republicans nor Democrats have the backbone to challenge the corrupt swamp that is bankrupting our children and grandchildren. It is a shame that our weak speaker cannot even commit to having a commission to discuss our looming fiscal catastrophe.” Charles Pierce describes Spartz as “one of the few truly eccentrics left in the Republican caucus in what passes for the GOP middle these days.”

Andy Borowitz in his The Borowitz Report in The New Yorker writes.“Calling a conflict raging in the U.S. Capitol “a clear and present danger to the world,” Volodymyr Zelensky offered to broker a peace deal between Representative Kevin McCarthy and his fellow House Republicans. The Ukrainian President warned that, if the fighting in Washington continued to escalate, it could spread to neighboring regions such as Maryland and Virginia. ‘My message to the warring parties is simple: it is time to stop the madness,’ he said. He said that he hoped to arrange a sit-down between McCarthy and House Freedom Caucus members such as Representative Lauren Boebert, ‘perhaps over a vape pipe.’ Though hopeful for a breakthrough, Zelensky acknowledged that negotiating with McCarthy and his Republican foes will be a challenge because ‘English does not appear to be their first language, either.'”

In the week following Kristen Welker’s first broadcast on Meet the Press, taking over after Chuck Todd’s retirement from the Sunday news show, she and NBC have endured a barrage of criticism for providing yet another venue for Trump to spout his drivel…with little pushback from Welker. Shades of Chuck Todd! Couldn’t we expect to be rid of this timidity in a new start which we’ve needed since losing Tim Russert? Jamess on Daily Kos says they have lost him as a viewer if NBC is simply going to act as a doormat for Donald Trump’s lies, feeling that he is not alone in that regard along with others who are grounded in reality. Kristen permitted Trump to blather on with statements untethered to reality on many critical issues without any forceful, dogged or worthwhile response. Trumpy the Clown did his usual shtick with his machine gun tongue…a stolen election, the J6 insurrection…anything that Welker brought up to have a decent exchange was dismissed. She was not prepared, and is not endowed, with the necessary intensity to take on Trump’s bombast, and is perhaps even unable to seize upon the issues of importance. Trump smelled fear and he went to work, with his torrent of outrageousness. One TV executive said, “It was a crazy way to set the tone of what Meet the Press will be under Kristen Welker.”

CNN’s senior media reporter, Oliver Darcy, makes the observation that newsrooms currently are treading into the unknown with the problem of “covering Trump.” This isn’t 1990, when decorum and honest debate, based on underlying policies were the rhetorical standard…the party of insurrection has a new leader, a new standard with bullying and shoveling the b.s. Darcy says, “When interviewing Trump, the goal cannot be to make ‘news’ like one might attempt with a typical politician. The purpose of the interview must be to hold power to account. It must be about asserting the facts in a meaningful way and forcing Trump to confront them. He will still, of course, lie – but at least the audience might be able to see through the showmanship if the interviewer displays a firm grip on the subject matter and exerts command. Unfortunately, few in the press who have taken on the assignment have proven capable of executing the difficult task in a compelling way. That doesn’t bode well for the news industry or, more importantly, democracy at large.”

So, wherein lies the need to interview Mr. Trump at all? What is there to gain since he lies like the rest of us breathe? Why go to the trouble, being unprepared to challenge the onslaught of lies in real time? He doesn’t need a national media platform if he refuses to play by the rules that are set down. Lending a modicum of respectability and credibility to the most ruinous and dishonest politician/showman/conman/grifter to further trash the goals and values of a once fact-based society is beyond comprehension. Definition of Meet the Press now making the rounds: the new home of Trump-speak – an ongoing train-wreck of compliance and deference to the perpetual Bully. Since everyone in the country is running for the US Presidency, primarily to keep themselves out of jail, they’re only here to help. The Constitutional mission of a newsroom, a free press, should be a dedication to holding government to account…not the greatest show on Earth, just the facts, Ma’am! Yeah, that’s the ticket, just the NEWS…assuming that skill-set is still an option in corporate news media.

Keith Olbermann in his Countdown podcast says he believes NBC News has launched internal investigations into Meet the Press staffers, including Kristen Welker and the executive producer, David Gelles, regarding violations of existing guidelines by airing the Trump/Welker ‘interview‘ without adequate fact-checking or warnings. The pre-taped program seems to fly in the face of “The NBC News Employee Handbook” which prohibits presenting provable falsehoods, which gave them three days between taping and broadcasting to edit any b.s. A second issue may be that a fact-check was not done in a simple dereliction of duty, but a pre-arranged agreement to convince Trump to submit to the presentation after his four-year snub of NBC. Olbermann has no proof of any of this and is on the trail. He speaks from his own experience with NBC, as he received a suspension without pay several years ago when he tangled with the network over involvement with campaigns of Raul Grijalva and Gabby Giffords. He was demoted from staff to a non-contract employee without benefits, after which he sued NBC for breach of contract, which garnered him $18M in damages. He thinks heads may roll, a la the Chris Licht/CNN dumpster fire when Kaitlan Collins had a similar ‘interview‘ with Trump on that network’s Town Hall, and that Meet the Press itself has a questionable viability. “They wouldn’t run this tripe on Dateline!” barks Olbermann.

Olbermann seems to know for certain that NBC veterans are calling for investigations based on the fact Welker and NBC News reporter, Dash Burns, wined and dined with Washington insiders including Jason Miller, Steven Cheung, and Chris LaCivita, Trump thugs all, in Milwaukee the night preceding the first GOP presidential debate. This would not necessarily be considered a breach of the NBC code, but the handbook would probably discourage such a meet-up; and, as Politico reports, the news employees paid their own expenses and not be guilty of accepting meals, gifts or other items of value from a political contact. At 10:00 am Eastern time, NBC website posted a fact check of the Welker fiasco. At 10:13 am its Meet the Press account tweeted: ‘Former President Trump made a spate of false and misleading comments about immigration, foreign policy, abortion, and more in a wide-ranging interview with Meet the Press moderator, Kristen Welker.’ So, why this post? The interview was in the can for three days before the broadcast…the content was well-known, so they knowingly aired lies, false or misleading commentary sans disclaimers or caveats. In violation of their own policy – an extinction-level event! With follow-up clips sent out on MSNBC, CNBC and NBC-owned affiliates! Then they had the nerve to interview Peter Baker of The New York Times who rationalized why the network wasn’t committing journalistic suicide by platforming a skilled, practiced, professional, psychotic liar. Insert a Shrug Emoji dressed in a suit, says Olbermann.

Summing it up, Olbermann believes NBC News, Meet the Press and Kristen Welker will never live down their premeditated decision to forfeit 75 years of journalistic credibility built up by their predecessors, and the best Welker can hope for is to be viewed as damaged goods, or a punchline, as is Kaitlan Collins after the CNN Town Hall snafu. The MAGA-Fascist lunatic right see NBC and CNN as the worst news entities, yet both organizations have engaged their networks in shocking and disgraceful episodes by prostituting their platforms to give Trump unfettered access to poison the viewing public with his lies and vows of political revenge, and the promised destruction our democratic institutions, while seeking to pardon his band of convicted insurrectionists. It seems that both networks are positioning themselves to survive in a world taken over by Trumpists in the future, or they are too greedy, blinded to the fact that they have been manipulated into pimping for the evil in our body politic. So, is it complicity or stupidity? Have they seen the actions of a Rupert Murdoch and his Fox News as successful? Olbermann casts a sidelong glance at the likes of Anderson Cooper, Wolf Blitzer, Lester Holt, and Savannah Guthrie, and even Rachel Maddow, wondering if they are completely adhering to their principles or merely standing up for the high dollars of their salaries. Will the dominoes start to fall, or will the softballs complacency turn into mere Nerf balls?

During a dull White House dinner several years ago, Melania Trump leaned over to chat with Secretary of State Tillerson.

“I bought Donald a parrot for his birthday. That bird is so smart, Donald has already taught him to say over two hundred words!”

“Very impressive,” said Tillerson, “but, you do realize he just speaks the words. He doesn’t really understand what they all mean”

“Oh, I know”, replied Melania, “but neither does the parrot.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    October

“The end of the summer is not the end of the world. Here’s to October…
~A.A. Milne

“There is no season when such pleasant and sunny spots may be lighted on, and produce so pleasant an effect on the feelings, as now in October.”
~Nathaniel Hawthorne

“October, tuck tiny candy bars in my pockets and carve my smile into a thousand pumpkins…. Merry October!”
~Rainbow Rowell

“I have been younger in October than in all the months of spring”.
~W. S. Merwin- Henry Ward Beecher

...

Nursery rhymes are never the innocent entertainment they appear to be…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

September 20 – 26, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…UCSC rankings and status, Munching with Mozart concerts.Greensite…on heritage tree loss and the appeal process. Steinbruner…Pajaro River problems, Cummings vs. Koenig and housing, Laird and zoom meetings, Bayview Hotel entrance. Hayes…a fine legacy. Patton…what do we need to do now? Matlock…snarking acquittals-r-us and loyalty oaths. Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week: why are funerals so expensive?! Quotes…”Earthquakes”

...

SANTA CRUZ’S TOWN CLOCK’S ORIGINAL LOCATION. This was July 27, 1964 when they took down our town clock. It then sat in one of our parks for years until a movement by activists got the new location where it sits today.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE September 18

UCSC’s PLACE IN THE WORLD. U.S. News & World Report did a study/survey of colleges last week and there are some surprises. In addition to the surprises there’s a lot to consider when we are so often forced to deal with our very important neighbor…and attraction. To cut to the chase…UCSC came in at #82. “UC Berkeley came in at #15 nationally, tying with UCLA. UC Davis was #28. They reported, “University of California, Santa Cruz is a public institution that was founded in 1965. It has a total undergraduate enrollment of 17,502 (fall 2022), and the campus size is 2,000 acres. It utilizes a quarter-based academic calendar. University of California, Santa Cruz’s ranking in the 2024 edition of Best Colleges is National Universities, #82. Its in-state tuition and fees are $15,288; out-of-state tuition and fees are $47,862. Go here to get the full impact of that report…

MUNCHING WITH MOZART RETURNS. Due to covid Munching With Mozart & Friends took a 3 year break and resumed its concerts last Friday. Carol Panofsky leads and emcees the concerts which are held every third Friday from 12:10 to about 1 p.m. Last Friday more than 80 people (mostly masked) jammed into the upstairs meeting room in the Downtown library. We heard Music For Piano Solo performed by Ziyue (Amy) Zeng a 17 year old piano master. She played Bach, Prokofiev, Beethoven and Franz Lizst and was absolutely wonderful. Check your calendars for October 20, November 17 and December 15 for the next concerts.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

EL CONDE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). ****   A surprising re-take and reversion and political commentary on Augusto Pinochet’s public and private life. It was made in Chile and they call it a comedy. They have Pinochet being first born in 1776 and still being on earth as a 250 year old vampire. It parallels his actual political and personal history adding the vampire secret, and we get to watch blood drinking from a blender many times. It’s “filmed” in black and white which really adds to the desired mood. Note… Augusto Pinochet was leader of the military junta that overthrew the socialist government of President Salvador Allende of Chile in 1973.

A HAUNTING IN VENICE. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (6.8 IMDB). **** Kenneth Branagh is back with the third in his Hercule Poirot versions of Agatha Christie’s books. Michelle Yeoh and Tina Fey are deadly serious in it too. Branagh moved the plot to Venice in 1947 from Christie’s book “Halloween Party” she first published in 1969. It’s deadly serious, very confusing, and it’s hard to stay interested as Poirot makes his rounds. Not recommended.

LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.9 IMDB) **** An overly cute teen ager love story about two kids who fall in love at the airport as they depart to two different locations. Some critic called it a cheesy rom com and I agree. It’s silly, trite, and brings in a cancer drama to give it some validity. Not worth watching.

INSIDE. (PRIME MOVIE) (5.5 IMDB).****It’s good fun to see Willem Dafoe back on screen. This time he’s a specialized art thief who flies in a helicopter and gets trapped in a penthouse in New York City that he was robbing. Because he’s a thief he can’t call or hope for help. He tries climbing, stacking furniture…nothing works. Dafoe is a fine actor and its good fun to watch his many attempts to escape.

JEANNE DIELMAN, 23, QUAI DU COMMERCE, 1080 BRUXELLES. (MAX MOVIE). (7.6 IMDB). **** This 1975 movie was just re-discovered and 480 movie critics from the Sight and Sound magazine (which is part of The British Film Institute) have stated that Jeanne Dielman is the greatest film of all time. Many, many critics around the world agree. Its three and a half hours long and was directed by a woman director Chantal Akerman. It covers three days in the life of a widowed mother and her son and takes place in Brussels. There’s almost no dialogue, the camera never moves from left to right, and it’s definitely worth watching.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE. (MAX SERIES) (7.2 IMDB) ****  It takes place in 1910 New Orleans and Storyville to be exact. The acting is stylized, the scenes are overly dramatic, and it’s not that kind of vampire. This is about a three way gay love affair and will it work? Much sex, booze, and posing. Roger Ebert called it cheesy, he’s right.

A TIME CALLED YOU (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB). ****  An involved Korean series that I really got caught up in. There’s a plane crash and a girl’s boyfriend dies…or did he? His girlfriend travels back in time to 1998 several times or does she? Maybe she’s actually in 1998?? It’s touching, well-acted and fleeting…don’t miss it.

WHO IS ERIN CARTER? (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.4 IMDB). There’s a hold up in a super market and a killing. But little tension, slow moving, little sympathy for anyone and everyone involved. Spain, Mexico and Britain all get involved but save your time and credit and forget Erin Carter.

SITTING IN BARS WITH CAKE. (PRIME MOVIE) (6.7 IMDB). ****It’s a lot of LA with plenty of bars with girlfriends getting the brilliant idea of making cakes and bringing them to bars to grab the guy’s attention. Bette Midler is legally in the film but there’s no good reason for her rare appearances. There’s a father with cancer, drinking, anger, a brain tumor, shouting and lots of making out. No reason to watch this one.

ONE PIECE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). **** Another attempt by a studio to combine live action fantasy with animation. It’s into the pirate world and back again. The actors and voices are as good as you can expect when you’re dealing with a two world set-up like this one. Maybe if you’re aged 5 to 12 you might be thrilled but otherwise it’s too cute and not intelligent enough. It’s only been season one so far…maybe they’ll tighten it up and add tension and better jokes….so go warned.

INVASION. (APPLE SERIES) (6.1 IMDB). **** Long time movie goers will recognize Sam Neill as the sheriff in this invasion of earth movie. All sorts of clues and warnings that aliens are coming but it’s not very exciting. Much of it is in the telling and re telling of individual’s personal history and their reaction to the invasion. It’s mostly nothing you/we haven’t seen before.

...
September 18

LOSING OUR HERITAGE

The Coast Redwood pictured above lives at the corner of Walnut and Lincoln streets, near the High School. Its life hangs in the balance as humans tussle over its fate. The property owner of the adjacent fifties-style apartment building, when advised by the city that the sidewalk was needing repairs, applied for, and was granted a permit for the tree’s removal by the director of Parks and Recreation, based on the findings of the city arborist. The section of the Resolution cited to allow this heritage tree to be cut down is Criteria and Standards 1: The heritage tree has or is likely to have, an adverse effect upon the structural integrity of a building, utility or public or private right of way.”

The public has the right to appeal a tree removal permit, so long as that action is taken within ten calendar days of the granting of the permit. The notice of a tree removal permit is posted onsite. One problem with this arrangement is that you have to live near or be passing by the site to know that a heritage tree is about to have its life ended. The city has no online list of pending heritage tree removal permits available for review.

Two days ago, I passed by the lovely tree pictured below. Whenever I see such a tree posting my heart sinks because I know what it means. Either the appeal period is over and it’s a done deal, as I found out later is the case for this tree, or I have to consider going through the arduous appeal process, pay the fee and invariably lose. The real loser is the tree. However, our lives and that of the birds are diminished with each heritage tree eradicated. Plus, that much less oxygen enters the atmosphere and eventually, more carbon dioxide, depending on the method of disposal of the tree. Grinding a downed tree into mulch is very popular these days. Short of fire, that is the fastest way to release carbon.

The typeface on the posting for the liquidambar was so small I couldn’t read it without stepping onto the property which I will not do. A long time ago, trying (unsuccessfully) to save a beautiful cypress tree via the appeal process, I and the then mayor walked up to the property door, knocked, and asked the tenant if we could look at the tree which was in the back yard. She said yes, we did and after a brief inspection, left. A few days later, a friend called me at work to say the property owner was on the radio accusing me and the mayor of trespassing. So, I avoid stepping onto private property.

The Coast Redwood was appealed to the Parks and Recreation Commission. I am no longer a commissioner, despite being eligible for a second term and unanimously elected as vice chair for the previous year by fellow commissioners. Council member Scott Newsome passed me over for the head of the non-profit Save the Waves Coalition, which has an MOU with the city, is interested in economic opportunities along West Cliff Drive and the city has donated money to the non-profit.

I attended the Redwood tree appeal hearing at the Parks & Recreation commission on August 14th. The usual format for an appeal is a staff report followed by fifteen minutes for the appellant, fifteen minutes for the applicant, public comment, five minutes rebuttal only for the appellant since that party has the burden of proof, then hearing body deliberation and vote. Not in this case.

The chair allowed five minutes for each side’s presentation and five minutes rebuttal for each side. Very unusual. The commission vote was three to two against the appeal. The appellants were young residents of Santa Cruz. They spoke compellingly, without hyperbole or unrealistic assertions. Despite their losing the appeal, my hopes for humanity were raised by their caring and involvement.

I just heard that this tree’s life sentence is not yet determined. The commission’s decision has been appealed to the city council. I assume but do not know that the appellants are the same.

The date for the new Redwood tree appeal is September 26th, at city council.

Your support would be welcome. It’s a tough issue since the tree is close to the house and there is impact to the sidewalk and the building’s low brick facade which appears superficial. Around the corner from the tree the foundation has a crack, which may or may not be tree root related and can be filled. If the growth of this ten-foot diameter tree is very slow, it is likely the apartment building will be torn down and rebuilt before any further impact is likely. The property owner’s civil engineer did not offer substantial evidence of structural integrity damage but did conclude there was some. The report appeared cursory, at least to me and apparently also to two commissioners.

Well-meaning but unrealistic clamors by members of the public to “save the tree, tear down the building!” will not get votes. Yes, the tree was here first but people’s property is not just expendable. I suggest an independent engineering inspection, paid for out of the city’s tree fund, with far more rigor and detail that has yet been made available. This tree, and all our fast-disappearing heritage trees (about thirty a month) deserve at least that much attention prior to being sentenced to death.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
September 18

GUT AND AMEND TO THE RESCUE

It never ceases to amaze me what elected representatives can do to help when there is a will and a need.  Known as “gut and amend”, a representative can completely change (“gut”) the entire content of a piece of legislation that has cleared many committee reviews and is close to completion, and the new  “amended” legislation that nowhere near represents what has been reviewed continues to quickly sail on to the Governor’s desk for approval.  Voila!  It is done.

Here is what has happened locally to completely sidestep environmental reviews that would have been needed to repair the Pajaro River levee:

“California Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas, whose district includes the Pajaro Valley, originally proposed Assembly Bill 876 in February focused on record-keeping related to certain child fatalities. On Aug. 29, with the end of the session less than three weeks away and the Feb. 17 deadline to submit new bills long passed, Rivas completely overhauled AB 876 to focus on expediting the Pajaro River levee repairs.”

A bill to speed up reconstruction of the Pajaro river levee heads to Newsom’s desk

The bill would allow the project to skip the California Environmental Quality Act requirements, a notoriously lengthy and expensive permitting process that can often add years to a project. When I spoke to Mark Strudley, executive director of the Pajaro Regional Flood Management Agency, a couple weeks ago, he said the ability to get a pass on the state’s environmental permitting requirements plays a central role in starting the project in 2024.

FOUR TO SIX STORY BUILDINGS IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD…THE FEVERISH PACE TO RUBBERSTAMP A NEW COUNTY HOUSING ELEMENT WITH SUPERVISOR KOENIG NIXING INCREASED AFFORDABTILITY REQUIREMENTS.

Last Tuesday, following staff reports on the proposed County Housing Element to ensure compliance with State mandates, Supervisor Justin Cummings wanted to increase the percentage of affordable housing required in new projects to be 25% in larger projects and to address affordability issues related to wage gaps of residents.

However, Supervisor Manu Koenig refused to allow that language to be added as a friendly amendment to his motion to rubberstamp staff recommendations.  Why?

Unfounded fears of scaring away developers with higher affordable housing percentages being required was addressed during public comment by Sandy Brown, who spoke on her own behalf and not as a representative of the Santa Cruz City Council on which she serves.  She said the number of applications for building increased after the City increased inclusionary affordability percentages in 2019 to 20% (from 15%).

“The timeline to get this approved is too quick to allow any slowdown this could add.” Supervisor Koenig said.  Planner Suzanne Ise agreed that it would “not reflect well on the county if we are late” in getting the State Housing & Community Development (HCD) approval.

Supervisors Bruce McPherson and Zach Friend went along with the move to stonewall increased affordable housing requirements.  Supervisor Friend was mostly upset that the 13-acre former Par 3 Golf Course on Mar Vista Drive in his district is targeted for inclusionary affordable housing, that may not include senior housing focus or open space. (Is he thinking about the postage stamp “Village Green” of AstroTurf he supports in the Aptos Village Project?)

It was refreshing that Supervisor Justin Cummings persisted: “I feel strongly about this, so I am going to make a substitute motion that this change be added,”  Again, the three Supervisors voted NO, leaving only Supervisors Cummings and Felipe Hernandez supporting increasing percentages of affordable housing required.

Supervisor Koenig said “We disagree on the cause (of the affordable housing shortage).  It’s due to restrictions on developers.  Adding an increase to required inclusionary percentages burdens developers.”

Having been stomped on, Supervisor Koenig’s motion to accept staff recommendations, with some nod to Supervisor Friend’s concerns, was then approved unanimously.  Hmmm…

You can watch what happened yourself on the County Board of Supervisor meeting recording

Click on item #9 on the agenda to listen to the presentations and discussions. Supervisor Friend’s questioning about the Par 3 golf course property begins about minute 1:50, but things are quite out of synch in terms of speaker and image. Sandy Brown’s presentation is at minute 2:04.

My question about why the County declared the 38 acres at 7th and Brommer as “excess property” to sell rather than retain it for affordable housing projects never got answered (minute 2:12) and no one answered my question about the defunct Kaiser Medical Center project that is zoned for 102 affordable units (minute 2:11)

Supervisor Justin Cummings begins advocating increasing affordable housing requirements at minute 2:17:10 with concerns that Nexis studies the County would require to identify locations of affordable units could take up to five years to complete.

What does all this mean for the quality of life in our County, and for private property rights?

I had attended the County Housing Advisory Commission meeting the week previous, and gathered some interesting information.

“Every parcel we have identified will be developed.”  said County Planner Ms. Ise.  What’s more, the County will require the applicant to build at least 75% of the minimum building requirement the planners have established.

Where are all these locations?

The parking lot at Seascape Golf Course, Par 3 Golf in Aptos, areas across from Rancho del Mar in Aptos, the farmland in Soquel, many places in Pleasure Point considered “under-utilized” and will be re-zoned to dense infill development..

Take a look at these maps, found in Appendix HE-F

Attend the County Planning Commission meeting Wednesday, September 27 at 9:30am review of the proposed Housing Element update and rezoning, and get your thoughts included:

Planning Agenda

Write the Commission c/o Nicholas Brown  Nicholas.Brown@santacruzcountyca.gov

NEW COUNTY E-MAIL TEMPLATE FOR YOUR CORRESPONDENCE

About two weeks ago, Santa Cruz County government e-mail templates changed, supposedly just so our County would be consistent with the templates other counties in the state area using.  I searched for a Press Release about this but found none.  County Public Information Officer Jason Hoppin said there had not been any press release, but it was posted on the County’s website.  He said the federal government is encouraging all government agencies to use the .gov domain name.  Although he wasn’t exactly sure why, he thought it might be more secure, and likely would encourage grant funding opportunities.

WHAT IS HE THINKING?

State Senator John Laird’s proposed SB 544 would restrict the public’s access to powerful State-level representatives when they meet by requiring the meetings to be in-person only half the time.  It would reduce the public’s accessibility because those who make policy at state commissions and boards would not actually have to be there in person to see and even know if they were listening.

California boards want to keep pandemic rules for public meetings. Critics call it bad for democracy.

This harkens back to the County Board of Supervisors meetings during COVID, when for over two years, we did not see the images of Supervisors Zach Friend or Ryan Coonerty on the meeting portal screens, and had no idea if they were even in the room of their remote locations during discussions on critical budget items affecting us all.

This SB 544 just landed on Governor Newsom’s desk.  Contact him and voice your opposition: 

Phone: (916) 445-2841
Email form

STUDYING THE ROCKY SHORELINES WITH LIDAR

ROXSI – Rocky shOrelines eXperiment and SImulation – Wilson Nearshore Research Group

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT SEEKING RUBBER-STAMP APPROVALS OF FUTURE RATE INCREASES

Soquel Creek Water District is planning to raise rates yet again, having hand-picked a group to show bobbleheads support of whatever the District staff feeds them, yet provide glowing support for rate jumps again.  This was described in the District’s newsletter,

“Quick Sips”  (because that’s all the water rate payers can afford?)

Raftelis Consultants did this five years ago to craftily raise rates to support the PureWater Soquel Project before the Board had even approved the Project’s Draft EIR.

The District formed a Water Rates Advisory Committee comprised of customers, board members and staff to work with Raftelis Financial Consultants to develop new water rates. The advisory committee has learned how water rates are created and have provided insight into the best ways to inform customers about any upcoming rate changes. Looking ahead, they will focus on a 10-year finance plan and rates necessary to support investment in critical infrastructure, operation of the water system and replenishment of the groundwater basin. A public rates hearing is anticipated for February 2024. Customers will be invited to attend and will receive notifications of any potential rate changes. Stay tuned for more updates.

COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ CLOSES BAYVIEW HOTEL ENTRANCE

The County of Santa Cruz closed the entrance to the historic Bayview Hotel last week with ugly orange plastic barricades.  The County has been the lead in getting the approvals required from the CPUC to get Swenson’s new Parade Street entrance to Soquel Drive.  The CPUC regulates new private railroad crossings and doesn’t like them.  The Commission approved the County’s request for Parade Street if they closed two other such private at=grade rail crossings.  The County arbitrarily chose the entrance to the historic Bayview Hotel, and a crossing in Davenport known as the Warrenella Road crossing.  Swenson was supposed to improve Cement Plant Road to cyclist and pedestrian traffic as a mitigation, but when that became too expensive, the improvements were cancelled, and the County successfully lobbied the CPUC to back off on closing the Warrenella Crossing.

Last week, Swenson removed the bright orange barricades that had been plopped there when Parade Street got opened.  The Bayview Hotel parking lot did get some much-needed paving, and now the former driveway entrance to the Hotel is gone.  How will the surface drainage directed from Soquel Drive onto the railroad track area get drained? It is often a pond in the big winter storms.  Write Public Works Director Matt Machado and ask.  matt.machado@santacruzcounty.us

Here is what the entrance to historic Bayview Hotel looks like now, with an asphalt curb along Soquel Drive’s bike lane.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK, AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
September 17

A FINE LEGACY.

How do we leave a good legacy that will benefit future generations in a world of uncertainty? Some suggest well – raised children are a sure bet, but with that this humble must demur. We must however try

A World of Uncertainty

We live in extraordinary, unprecedented times. Humans have built a remarkable global civilization with a burgeoning population. To survive, we are in a race to shed polluting fossil fuels. But, we have no idea if and how we can replace all that petroleum has provided to fuel population growth and the civilizing of landscapes. No matter what superficial form of government seems to be in place, the “oilogarchy” is deeply entrenched, exercising economic and political control. For evidence, just watch US politics: both parties’ have an inability to act in the expeditious way that the vast majority of citizens know to be necessary. And so, life, including human life, on Earth will likely become much more difficult for the next several hundred years. Of course, we should rise up and protest as if life itself depends on it, but there are other tangible things we can do to make the world more habitable for future generations.

Species and Ecosystem Restoration

There are a variety of activities you can partake in to help restore species and ecosystems, which humans will increasingly rely on for their wellbeing. As global warming creates climate chaos, and as humans increasingly falter without boosts from cheap petro-supplies, species diversity and resilient ecosystems will become more closely tied to better standards of living.

Oil and Water

For an example, let’s consider water. Some suggest oil and water don’t mix, but the two are closely intertwined over most of the world. We might suppose that the role petroleum plays in repairing, creating, and powering our water supply will be replaced by some renewable energy supply in the future. Plastic pipes will be made from hemp, renewable energy will power our pumps, electric vehicles will transport the legions of water district workers who maintain water systems, etc. However, when rain comes in torrential bursts or not at all, we will rely on very well-tended ecosystems to absorb and meter out rainfall so that we can benefit from more dependable surface or groundwater supplies.

Dust Storms

For another example, let’s consider erosion. The stability of our infrastructure- homes, utility lines, roads, dams, communication towers, airports, etc., depends on more than just good geological anchors: that stability is deeply dependent on functioning ecosystems. Species hold our stuff together. On the coast and along rivers and streams, species protect shorelines. On hillsides, in the mountains and on the plains, species hold the land in place. Without a wealth of species supported by resilient ecosystems, everything will come unzipped – gullies, floods, landslides…infrastructure collapse. At the same time, the bared soil will start to blow and dust storms will become more frequent, destroying engines, burying buildings and roads, and darkening the sky.

Restoration Means Now

The species that currently perform best at the “holding the soil in place” function are likely not the ones that will do best in a hundred years, given the rapidly changing climate. So, we must conserve every species, and plan to allow species migration through a healthy landscape of resilient ecosystems. Right now, this very year, we must quickly turn increasingly to restoration of the land because we have degraded too many places already. You can help by volunteering with the many habitat restoration projects in our area, taking better care of your land, voting for politicians that support ecological restoration and land care, spreading the word, and/or giving money to groups that are making a difference. Many people are joining this movement, we are making a difference, and we need more help.

Bye-Bye Soil, Hello Agricultural Substrate

Since World War 2, agricultural systems have become increasingly intertwined with petroleum at great expense to the soil that humans rely on for sustenance. Petroleum-fueled mechanical cultivation has destabilized billions of tons of soil which has already washed or blown away due to recklessness. You can watch it happening, still: in the Salinas and Pajaro valleys and along Santa Cruz’ North Coast watch the soil blow or wash away, depending on the season. At the same time, cheap fertilizers and expedient pesticides have been made possible by petroleum and the application of these have destroyed ecosystems that once sustained and built topsoil. Farmers for years have acted like soil is just a substrate, something to hold a plant in place long enough to harvest a crop. And so, most agricultural land is highly degraded and production is increasingly and deeply dependent on the supply of petroleum. While we can, there is a great opportunity to build the kind of soil health that will be necessary to feed humans when petroleum-subsidized fertilizers become too expensive, and the human population is still larger than it is now.

Soil Health

Healthy agricultural soils can retain more water, provide plants more dependable nutrition, and stabilize pest outbreaks. So, why would a farmer not create more healthy soils? There are two main reasons. First, investing in healthy soil reduces profits. For example, using cover crops to cover and build the soil during the rainy season means the loss of one or more potential harvests. That also drives up food costs, which then helps to create the second reason: mandates for soil health are politically difficult. The good news is that you can help with both of these conundrums.

You Can Help Create Healthy Soil

We all purchase groceries, and the choices we make can help support soil stewardship. Already, the organic agriculture movement has been growing and makes a difference for soil health. Certified organic agriculture requires farmers to find alternatives to pesticides and fertilizers that are synthesized from petroleum. In ‘conventional’ agriculture, novel petro-created compounds working alone or as a mixed concoction are released into agricultural systems without analysis on long-term soil health. Organic farmers more often rely on soil health as a means of production, and the higher cost of those products reflects that investment. Some tell me that they can’t afford organic foods, but discussions reveal that they are unwilling to make more basic food choices, preferring to rely on processed foods or meat that are especially more expensive when certified organic. Going organic may mean dietary changes that might be more healthy, anyway.

Besides using the power of your purse to support farmers who build soil health, you might more directly create healthy soils in community orchards or gardens. You can volunteer in a school garden which has the added benefit of helping children better understand soil health and healthy foods. You might also support, by volunteering or donations, organizations that are working to improve soil health on agricultural lands.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

September 16
#259 / What Do We Need To Do Now?

I don’t really know too much about Pauline P. Schneider. If you click the link to her name, and read about her, you will then know exactly as much as I know. Though I don’t really know her, I received a posting she made on her Substack blog about a month or so ago. I thought it was worth passing along. Schneider’s blog posting is also where I got the image I am using above. The blog posting that captured my attention was titled, “When Nations Drown/Burn.”

On the very same day I read Schneider’s blog posting, I got a bulletin from Tom Engelhardt, who was writing on the same topic, in “TomDispatch.” Both Schneider and Engelhardt were focusing on global warming. Engelhardt put it this way:

Hey, who knows? It could be the Gulf Stream collapsing or the planet eternally breaking heat records. But whatever the specifics, we’re living it right now, not in the next century, the next decade, or even next year. You couldn’t miss it — at least so you might think — if you were living in the sweltering Southwest; especially in broiling, record-setting Phoenix with 30 straight days of temperatures above 110 degrees Fahrenheit; or in flaming Greece or western China on the day the temperature hit 126 degrees Fahrenheit or sweltering, blazing Algeria when the temperature reached an almost unimaginable 135 (yes, 135!) degrees Fahrenheit; not to speak of broiling Canada with its more than 1,000 fires now burning (a figure that still seems to be rising by the week) and its 29 million acres already flamed out; and don’t forget Italy’s 1,400 fires; or Florida’s hot-tub-style seawater, which recently hit an unheard-of 101-plus degrees Fahrenheit. And though I’m still writing this as the month is ending, July is more or less guaranteed to set the record for the hottest month in history. And don’t assume that “record” will stand for long, either.

Who even remembers that this June was the hottest since records have been kept or that July 6th was the hottest day in recorded history (and July 3rd through 6th, the hottest four days ever)? And don’t be surprised if 2023 ends up setting a record for the hottest year or assume that such a record will last long on a planet where the previous eight years were the warmest ever. And if I’m already boring you, then one thing is guaranteed: you’re going to be bored out of your mind in the years to come.

Englehardt provides a link to a New York Times’ article, in making his claim that temperatures in Algeria reached 135 degrees Fahrenheit during July. Schneider doesn’t provide any link, but her blog posting claims that temperatures reached 154 degrees Fahrenheit in Iran.

What Schneider does propose (that Englehardt doesn’t) is a list of specific ideas of what we should do about the kind of catastrophic temperatures that are now being experienced, almost everywhere, on Planet Earth. Here is Schneider’s list, copied from her blog:

What to do?

  1. Birth control, sterilization, and abortion should be free and readily available globally. Yes, even in Texas.
  2. ALL Nations should decommission nuclear power plants immediately. They cannot be operated safely in a normal climate, even less so in a smouldering climate.
  3. All militaries and their weapons of mass destruction should be immediately repurposed and decommissioned as well. Same reason as for nuke plants above.
  4. The IPCC scientists should be publicly horsewhipped for minimizing the climate crisis since Reagan (Ronnie Raygun). Even though that was the purpose of their creation-to minimize the crisis, & defuse any positive climate activism. Thank you Heartland Institute for helping to murder the planet. Kevin Hester explains that in detail. https://kevinhester.live/2021/09/06/its-time-to-acknowledge-the-spectacular-success-of-the-ipcc/.
  5. Any and all pseudo “Green” and “sustainable” energies should be called out for their lies and misinformation. Electric cars, solar and wind, hydroelectric, nuclear, are all NOT green, nor sustainable. They all require MASSIVE amounts of fossil fuels, mining, transportation, and a secure grid-tied infrastructure. Few nations have that, and the US especially lacks a secure infrastructure of any kind. Thanks Heartland Institute for helping to ruin our infrastructure with your greed-based, inhumane policies.
  6. Finally, as we (most of us) recognize the existential crisis we are facing, billionaires should be banned from speaking, or having any public presence, or holding public office. There should be no billionaires to begin with, that is an obscenity of capitalism and has led to the destruction of our only home. They are welcome to leave and go to Mars. Today is good.
  7. Societal changes:

All humans must be treated with dignity and compassion as we begin to exit this existence. This is simple. Basic needs met for all: housing, food, medical care, safety. We MUST end the houseless/homeless crisis in the US. We MUST provide universal healthcare for all. We MUST ensure our poorest have a basic living income. We MUST have sane gun control in the US (like other nations do) to ensure safe neighborhoods, schools, parks, and shopping areas.

oooOOOooo

There are some problems with Schneider’s list of recommended actions (particularly if you believe that individuals should continue to enjoy the kind of constitutional rights about which Schneider seems little concerned).

That said….. I think this is what Schneider is trying to convey: (1) We need to take immediate and effective action to stop contributing to the processes that have driven and are still driving the catastrophic global warming that both Schneider and Engelhardt describe; (2) We need to take immediate and effective action to mitigate and reverse those processes, to the greatest degree we possibly can; and (3) We need to take immediate and effective action to make radical, real changes to how we conduct our lives and structure our economy and society.

Anyone disagree that we need to do those things? If not, if we are all in agreement that we need to take the kind of immediate and effective actions outlined in the preceding paragraph, I would like to suggest that we focus on those two words, “radical” and “real.”

Making radical and real changes in how we do everything. That is what we need to do now!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
September 18

SNARKING ACQUITTALS-R-US AND LOYALTY OATHS

The attempt by the Texas GOP to clean up its party fell short, as the Texas Senate acquitted their state attorney general of all charges following his corruption trial, not only echoing the thrust of the national organization, but showing its ability to be one of the most extreme bodies in the country. In defense of Ken Paxton during the impeachment proceedings, Texas representative, John Smithee said, “Today it could be General Paxton, and tomorrow it could be you.” In other words, Texas is fighting for all of us, just as Trump is standing strong between THEM and US! Paxton has been a vehement supporter of the former president, calling Biden’s 2020 presidential victory an “overthrow” by pulling off a coup to take away Trump’s ‘rightful place’ in the Oval Office. The Texas GOP is noted for a 2022 resolution designating Biden “an illegitimate and acting president,” implying that he won’t long be occupying his unearned seat and might be removed at will. As Ruth Ben-Giat on her Lucid/substack.com site says, “The logic of corruption also matters here. The GOP has embraced the methods and values of authoritarianism. It now depends on propaganda (the ‘Big Lie’), intimidation, and corruption – election denial being a form of corruption – for its identity and to maintain itself in power. In particular, it is a party that has remade itself in Trump’s image, with the goal of protecting the corrupt, and, the criminal dictating its actions.”

The New Yorker magazine’s snarky contributor, Andy Borowitz, writes “thousands of hardened criminals poured into Texas over the weekend after learning how easy it is to secure an acquittal there. Interstate freeways were reportedly backed up for miles as acquittal-seeking perpetrators sought to put down roots in soft-on-crime Texas. Harland Dorrinson, a self-styled recidivist who has been convicted in Ohio, Missouri, and Wisconsin, said that he was heading to the Lone Star State because, ‘in Texas, no one is below the law. An acquittal is yours for the asking if you’re white, male, and nefarious. I check all the boxes’. When told that one must also be elected as a Republican in order to qualify for Texas’ special “conviction exemption,” the career criminal was unfazed, noting that “even Greg Abbott” managed to do that.”

As Carl Gibson writes on Nation of Change, “Despite four criminal indictments totaling 91 felony charges, two impeachments, 26 women with sexual misconduct allegations, and arguably an act of sedition, and an attempt to incite a civil war, Donald Trump remains the front-runner for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination. What the indictment of Trump and 18 other Republican operatives, many being longtime acolytes of GOP causes, by a Fulton County grand jury truly shows that the Republican Party goes far beyond Trump.” He goes on to say that if an indictment within the Democratic Party occurred it would likely doom the individual’s career, with Trump it has only raised his polling position, despite charges in three separate jurisdictions. Should this not be regarded as a sign that the party is morally bankrupt and rotten to the core? Georgia’s RICO statute specifies that each co-conspirator in the case is equally liable, each facing up to 20 years in prison with a mandatory minimum of five years’ prison time. DA Fani Willis has said the guilty will not be able to serve less than five years, or be able to substitute time served with probation. Gibson feels that Trump is merely a byproduct of an increasingly criminal political party, with Eastman, Clark and Chesebro shouldering as much guilt in the plot to use fake electors to subvert the election; and while the GOP’s base has frowned upon dissent within its ranks, criminal accountability may finally be coming for operatives and elected officials.

Many in the GOP believe that Trump’s position at the top of the Republican ticket spells political disaster, with a loss of the US House, giving Democrats full control of Congress. Former Georgia Lieutenant Governor Geoff Duncan who testified before DA Willis‘ grand jury, expressed his belief that a Trump nomination would be a big mistake, comparing his candidacy to that of the failed Herschel Walker campaign. “We didn’t ask who was the best leader. We didn’t ask who had the best resume. Unfortunately, Republicans looked around to see who Trump supported, and he was a famous football player, and so he became our nominee and now we’re paying the price.” Former GOP Congressman Will Hurd of Texas admonishes Trump as being toxic to the Republican Party as a whole, and his nomination “gives the 2024 election to Joe Biden.” Other shoes may drop since Jack Smith’s grand jury is still active as it meets in the DC courthouse, continuing investigations of other individuals, pointing to unindicted co-conspirators who may face the music. And of course, we all are waiting with bated breath over Fani Willis‘ pointing to the 30 other unnamed co-conspirators in her Georgia case…the fun rolls onward. However, Carl Gibson says that it the GOP stays electorally competitive, democracy may remain in peril for years to come.

Jenna Ellis, a Trump lawyer who shares some of his criminal charges for attempted election subversion, now says she will not vote for this “malignant narcissist” who can’t admit his mistakes, and his tendency to simply say he’s never done anything wrong. Ellis also has a show on American Family Radio, a rightwing evangelical network run by American Family Association, a non-profit that describes itself as having been “on the frontlines of America’s culture war” since 1977. Her charges of violating Georgia’s anti-racketeering laws, while soliciting violation of an oath by a public officer, resulted in being granted $100,000 bail after her not-guilty plea. Her claims of being a constitutional lawyer have been widely doubted, though she served as a former counsel for the Thomas More Society, a conservative Catholic group, being sought out by Trump after he saw a television commentary by her. She rose in prominence to become part of what she termed an “elite strike force team” working to overturn Trump’s defeat by Biden, then being signed by Family Radio late last year. On a recent show, she spoke with rightwing host Steve Deace, who said, “Before that man needs to be president again…[to] escape the quote-unquote, ‘witch-hunts,’ that man needs Jesus again because…his ambitions would be fueled by showing some self-awareness. And he won’t do it because he can’t admit, ‘I’m not God’.” Ellis agreed with Deace, commenting, “I have great love for him personally. And the total idolatry that I’m seeing from some of his supporters that are unwilling to put the constitution and the country and the conservative principles above their love for a star is really troubling. As Christians we need to take this very seriously and understand where we are putting our vote.” Ellis was censured by a Colorado judge in March for her spouting falsehoods about the 2020 election, and she has been criticized for hateful comments about the mass shooting at the Club Q gay nightclub, in addition to showing a cruel video concerning a Mitch McConnell hospitalization. Curiously, Ellis tore into Trump in 2016, calling him an “idiot and a bully” unable to “handle criticism” before making a complete turnaround to back him. True to form, the former prez chose not to fund her defense or fund any of his co-defendants, which spurred suggestions that she could flip on him in her testimony.

An attempt to keep Trump off Colorado’s state ballot in 2024 in a suit initiated by a group of voters was filed several weeks ago, related to his role in the J6 riots, arguing that he should be barred under the 14th Amendment of the Constitution. A particular section prohibits anyone who has “previously taken an oath” to uphold the Constitution, who has “engaged in insurrection or rebellion” from holding office again. The suit was filed by six Republican, and other unaffiliated state voters, by Citizens for Ethics and Responsibility, which asked the court to rule it “improper and a breach or neglect of duty” for Secretary of State Jena Griswold to allow Trump’s name on future ballots. Griswold said she hoped “this case will provide guidance to election officials on Trump’s eligibility as a candidate for office.” Florida, on the other hand, just voted to abandon a rule adopted earlier this year which would require all 2024 GOP presidential candidates to pledge support to the eventual nominee should they want to be placed on the state’s March 19 primary ballots. The winner in that revision is none other than former President Donald Trump, who has loudly refused to sign any such commitment, and a slap in the face to early signer, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. Loyalty pledges have become an issue in the GOP as they attempt to unify the party behind one candidate in 2024. For instance, to appear on the first candidate debate stage in Milwaukee, individuals had to sign the pledge; but, although Trump refused to sign he also refused to appear to debate, keeping peace in the family for the present, anarchy averted.

Andy Borowitz strikes again with his revelation that “in order to qualify for the next nationally televised debate, Republican Presidential candidates must sign a pledge to go to prison in place of Donald J. Trump…confirmed by the Republican National Committee. Ronna McDaniel, the RNC chairperson, said that agreeing to serve hard time for Trump was ‘the only way’ that GOP candidates could prove their loyalty to the party. As for whether Trump had been asked to sign a pledge to go to prison for any of his Republican rivals who might become convicted of a crime, McDaniel said, ‘Absolutely not. He’s very busy these days, and we didn’t want to bother him.’ Nearly all of the GOP contenders immediately agreed to sign the pledge, with the exception of Chris Christie and Asa Hutchinson, the latter of whom said he preferred to be ‘hog-tied.’ ‘I’m sorry to hear that Asa feels that way,’ McDaniel said. ‘Being asked to go to prison in place of Donald Trump is an honor that only comes around only four or five times in a lifetime.’ In a related matter, the RNC chair confirmed that none of the candidates had agreed to go to prison in place of Senator Lindsey Graham.”

CNN’s conservative commentator, S.E. Cupp, on her ‘The Lead‘ broadcast, says don’t expect Trump’s rivals to start seriously attacking him anytime soon. She notes Chris Christie’s, Asa Hutchinson’s and Texas’ Will Hurd’s blasts at the former president, but others have been stingy with any criticism. “The problem is, for these people to implicate Trump, they also have to implicate his voters. None are willing to say, ‘Listen white nationalists, Proud Boys, Oath Keepers, we don’t want you. The Republican Party is not your safe space. You will not find comfort in a Nikki Haley administration’. They won’t say that because they all still want to win and they all still think they’re going to get Trump voters if they don’t swing at Trump more vigorously.” Her reality check is, “They are not going to win the cult of Trump over. It’s just not going to happen. There’s only one of him for a reason.” Right! We can only wish that were true…there’s a bunch more in the wings waiting to step into his tiny shoes!

It’s been reported that Melania Trump has rejected several requests from her husband to join him in his campaign appearances, though he claims he has been keeping her away and that she will accompany him soon, saying, “She’s a private person, a great person, and a very confident person and she loves our country very much.” He certainly has the “best words,” eh? To this assertion to Kristen Welker on NBC’s ‘Meet the Press,’ Trump added, “And, honestly, I like to keep her away from it. It’s so nasty and so mean.” The New York Times in July reported that she’s told friends she feels betrayed by staffers and friends during her time in the White House, but still supports and believes in the relevancy of her husband’s candidacy, while steering clear of any of his court appearances. As his legal woes accumulate, PR experts say she should “keep her distance, but plan an escape route,” before the legal complexities worsen. The easiest option for her is to claim she has to spend time with Barron, or doing charity work, being busy with anything for which she can’t be faulted, and The Donald isn’t going to make an issue of it. Amid the various rumors about their marriage is that it is merely a transactional union with an iron-clad prenup, making son, Barron, the big hang-up in their relationship, especially with any rumored breakup.

One of Trump’s fanatical backers last week was unceremoniously ejected from the Buell Theater in Denver after she was accused of vaping, singing, recording the show and being generally disruptive during the performance, along with her companion, Quinn Gallagher. Representative Lauren Boebert, who has been quietly dating Gallagher for a few months, denied they were causing a disturbance, just simply enjoying the musical, ‘Beetlejuice.’  Being warned about their behavior during an intermission after several complaints, they were finally escorted out following additional accusations of being too frisky…but not before Boebert tried to ‘pull rank’ and threaten the ushers and other theater personnel. Her campaign manager verified that the couple were shown the exit, but tried to sugar-coat the circumstances, before encouraging the public to see the zany and raucous show for themselves. Boebert is seen on video honoring the various theater workers with one-finger salutes on her way out, holding Quinn’s hand as she twirled around. Gallagher, a Democrat, is a co-owner of the Hooch Craft Cocktail Bar in Aspen, where they previously staged “a winter Wonderland Burlesque & Drag Show,” per an invitation for the event during Aspen Gay Ski Week – “an evening of cocktails, appetizers, and laughs.” Perhaps Boebert should apply for a position at Hooch because Adam Frisch is campaigning hard for her congressional seat in an attempt to remove the “unneeded distraction in her district.”

After Joe Biden moved into the White House, he questioned why he had always seen two Army soldiers standing near a Rose Garden bench as if they were guarding it. He approached them, asking why they were assigned to this duty. They weren’t knowledgeable, but thought it was some kind of tradition. Biden then called former President Trump, who told him it must have been a tradition that he simply had kept in place. A call to former President Obama garnered a similar answer; then a call to George W. Bush questioning the presence of the guards provided the answer. “What?! Is the paint still wet?!” he responded.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Earthquakes”

“You can no more win a war than you can win an earthquake”.
~Jeannette Rankin

“I will remember this day for the rest of my life. There is nothing you can say. It’s just like you won the match after the earthquake and it just feels great”.
~Elena Vesnina

“We want a story that starts out with an earthquake and works its way up to a climax”.
~Samuel Goldwyn

...

I have played you videos of hers before, but that’s not stopping me. Her name is Caitlin, and she’s great! Watch this video on the cost of funerals…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

September 13 – 19, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…about Hawaii diaspora, Mozart lunches. Greensite… on centering girls’ and women’s safety. Steinbruner…is getting ready for the County Fair and will be back next week. Hayes…BLM Overlooking Precious Wildlife Conservation. Patton…the “Law” of supply and demand. Matlock…disagreeing on that midnight train to Georgia. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes… “Santa Cruz”.

...

SANTA CRUZ FIRE DEPARTMENT circa 1941. Still the same building but the trucks have been updated.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE September 11

THINKING ABOUT HAWAII and HAWAIIANS.

I’ve subscribed to Ka Wai Ola for years. It’s the Office of Hawaiian Affairs monthly free newspaper. The September issue had a statement that surprised me…”more Native Hawaiians now live on the continent than in Hawaii”. It goes on to talk about the loss of statehood, the takeover by capitalists and government officials and concludes with the Maui wildfires. I looked up more “news” about the diaspora. Here’s some of what I found…”According to 2021 population estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau, the biggest growth of Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander populations was in Clark County, Nevada, which includes Las Vegas, and Sacramento County, California. The biggest decline of Native Hawaiian residents was in Honolulu”.

Then a quote from NPR…”Residents in Hawaii are spending on average 42.06% of their income on rent, which is the highest of any state, according to a Forbes Home analysis. California ranks second, but at a much smaller proportion of income going toward rent: 28.47%”. Lastly from NPR again…”Estimates from the American Community Survey showed that in 2011, there were about 296,400 Native Hawaiians in Hawai’i and about 221,600 on the continental U.S. Just a decade later, those numbers flipped. In 2021, there were about 309,800 Native Hawaiians in Hawai’i and about 370,000 in other states”.

MUNCHING WITH MOZART RETURNS. The heroic, brave, talented Carol Panofsky is bringing back and recreating the every third Friday noon free concerts to our downtown library’s second floor meeting room. The first return concert will be this Friday, September 15, 2023 from 12:10 – 12:50. It features solos by Ziyue (Amy) Zeng, at the piano. She’ll be playing Johann Sebastian Bach, Sergei Prokofiev, Ludwig van Beethoven and Franz Liszt.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

ABOUT ROTTEN TOMATOES AND IMDB. Some statistics somewhere showed that folks almost always go to critic’s reviews/critiques before attending a movie. I’ve always included IMDB (International Movie Data Base) ratings and since we found out last week that some Rotten Tomatoes critics were on the take and receiving monies from movie companies for good reviews I’m happy to stay with IMDB.

INTERVIEW WITH THE VAMPIRE. (MAX SERIES) (7.2 IMDB)   It takes place in 1910 New Orleans and Storyville to be exact. The acting is stylized, the scenes are overly dramatic, and it’s not that kind of vampire. This is about a three way gay love affair and will it work? Much sex, booze, and posing. Roger Ebert called it cheesy, he’s right.

A TIME CALLED YOU (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB). **  An involved Korean series that I really got caught up in. There’s a plane crash and a girl’s boyfriend dies…or did he? His girlfriend travels back in time to 1998 several times or does she? Maybe she’s actually in 1998?? It’s touching, well-acted and fleeting…don’t miss it.

WHO IS ERIN CARTER? (NETFLIX SERIES) (6.4 IMDB). There’s a hold up in a super market and a killing. But little tension, slow moving, little sympathy for anyone and everyone involved. Spain, Mexico and Britain all get involved but save your time and credit and forget Erin Carter.

SITTING IN BARS WITH CAKE.(PRIME MOVIE) (6.7 IMDB). **It’s a lot of LA with plenty of bars with girlfriends getting the brilliant idea of making cakes and bringing them to bars to grab the guy’s attention. Bette Midler is legally in the film but there’s no good reason for her rare appearances. There’s a father with cancer, drinking, anger, a brain tumor, shouting and lots of making out. No reason to watch this one.

ONE PIECE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). ** Another attempt by a studio to combine live action fantasy with animation. It’s into the pirate world and back again. The actors and voices are as good as you can expect when you’re dealing with a two world set-up like this one. Maybe if you’re aged 5 to 12 you might be thrilled but otherwise it’s too cute and not intelligent enough. It’s only been season one so far…maybe they’ll tighten it up and add tension and better jokes….so go warned.

INVASION. (APPLE SERIES) (6.1 IMDB). ** Long time movie goers will recognize Sam Neill as the sheriff in this invasion of earth movie. All sorts of clues and warnings that aliens are coming but it’s not very exciting. Much of it is in the telling and re telling of individual’s personal history and their reaction to the invasion. It’s mostly nothing you/we haven’t seen before.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

THE EQUALIZER 3 (Del Mar Theatre) (7.1IMDB). ** Denzel Washington (age 69) and Dakota Fanning (age 29) head the cast of this conclusion to the Equalizer series. I can’t find or remember what I wrote about the first two Equalizer series…and this part 3 just left me cold, bored and mystified. Somehow Denzel the Equalizer goes to Italy and gets all involved with the Mafia in order to protect his friends who live there. His background/history are mysterious and only hinted at. Go warned.

MASK GIRL. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB). ** Most definitely a Korean film that plays out as a semi comedy and some tragedy. A plain looking but shapely girl decides to wear a mask and performs strip dances online. Her followers work hard to expose her and it’s a foolish but curious use of animated cartoons and dance numbers to tell this foolish story.

THE CHOSEN ONE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (5.6 IMDB). ** A movie from Mexico (Baja California) about a 12 year old boy who discovers that he has powers like Jesus. It’s almost an amateur’s first attempt at making a movie. He makes wine from water, helps the handicapped folks and makes some momentous decisions about how to live his life. I’ve watched the first two episodes and will ignore the rest.

...
September 11

WE CAN DO BETTER

Continuing with the theme from last week on the stark difference I experienced between Tanzania and Santa Cruz on addressing violence against women, this photo is of a member of Monduli Teachers’ College exploring the topic of how a father might best react to hearing that his daughter has been raped. It applies also to granddaughters. This issue is rarely addressed, both in Tanzania and in Santa Cruz. As that country opens a dialogue on issues of violence against women, the city of Santa Cruz closes it down.

There is no lack of examples of the city’s marginalizing these issues. It was evident when I attended the recent meeting of the Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women last Wednesday. To say the meeting was frustrating would be an understatement. This indictment is not directed towards commissioners. Most are largely unaware of how neatly the city has stacked the deck to render them less than effective in their ordinance-mandated role.

In contrast to the first thirty- three years, the long-term dedicated staff position for the commission has been terminated. This was a position we worked very hard to secure. The person hired was trained in the issues and gave a minimum of twenty hours a week solely on commission work. That position has been replaced by a revolving door of city manager employees who are present for the meetings but have limited availability outside those few hours. The latest iteration is a senior member of the city manager’s office who had no clue how to handle a tied vote due to one commissioner abstaining from voting. Nor did the chair know what to do with a tied vote. The staff person left the chambers to look up the by-laws. Meanwhile I’m in the audience, prevented only by decorum from calling out, “you can’t abstain from voting unless it’s a conflict of interest!” After ten minutes or so, they figured it out.

Nor were they aware that a commission (or council) standing committee, in this case the Commission Police Committee must be publicly noticed, with time, place and agenda posted. When the public comment period for that item was recognized, I reminded them of this Brown Act requirement. I never expect a thank you, but a cold stare has a chilling effect.

This is small stuff but signifies a less than functional city body. It appears that valuable past commission records and documents have “disappeared.”  There is no institutional memory. The commission recently hired a consultant to tell them what they should be doing, all of which is in the records, if they are ever “found.”

Of more serious import is the issue of commission members’ access to redacted police records of reported sexual assaults, excluding those under investigation. Such access is not only supported by the Ordinance language, confirmed by state law but also has been the practice since 1981, until now.

By reviewing redacted reports of sexual assault and compiling the results, the commission can evaluate the quality of investigative techniques and provide the community with a comprehensive overview of important information about sexual assaults committed: when; what part of town; whether by a person unknown or known; whether an arrest was made; whether there were more or less sexual assaults reported last year or the last five years; whether the city has more sexual assaults reported compared to other similar cities; whether we have more or fewer arrests than other cities; whether we have a higher percentage of sexual assaults committed by strangers than other cities (we do). Such information is crucial for public awareness and safety.

When such information was available and developed by the commission in its required annual report to council, the city of Santa Cruz did not feature well. Our rate of reported rape was higher than average; our rate of arrest was lower than average; our rate of rapes committed by strangers was well outside the norm. The last commission comprehensive report was in 2012. A combined three -year report through 2016 was a one pager but still contained some data- based information. Since that time, reports have been a description of events with no data. When I wrote to council this year regarding the commission’s upcoming presentation of its report, pointing out the lack of data in the Agenda Report, a one slide pie graph of aggregate numbers from the SCPD website was added for the council meeting.

Put on notice (by me) that the commission was floundering, lacking dedicated staff; resources and access to police data, the council at that meeting gave the green light for the commission to send to council its wish-list for what the council could do to be of better support. Since then, the commission has drafted and approved a letter asking for more support, referencing the ordinance language that requires police cooperation to provide information not deemed confidential by state law. However, the city attorney has determined that providing such information will be problematic and has recommended against its provision. He has left it in the hands of the city council.

Message to council and the community: the commission cannot do its mandated work without that information and the public cannot be educated without that information. It’s a long road back to a functioning Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women and it starts with this one step. For girls and women’s safety…take it!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
September 11

Becky is at the County Fair and will be back next week.

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
September 11

BLM OVERLOOKING PRECIOUS WILDLIFE CONSERVATION.

Santa Cruz County’s newest conservation land managers are supposed to conserve the wildlife prioritized by the State of California, but are failing to acknowledge their obligations, which means some of our area’s iconic wildlife species will disappear faster due to lack of Federal cooperation at Cotoni Coast Dairies.

Background

The Bureau of Land Management oversees management of Cotoni Coast Dairies, but it is following much-outdated wildlife conservation guidance. Land management agencies like the BLM are guided by policies and procedures that guarantee that they do a good job of managing wildlife. For instance, BLM has its 6840 Manual “Sensitive Species Management,” which notes:

“The objectives of the BLM special status species policy are:

  1. To conserve and/or recover ESA-listed species and the ecosystems on which they depend so that ESA protections are no longer needed for these species.
  2. To initiate proactive conservation measures that reduce or eliminate threats to Bureau sensitive species to minimize the likelihood of and need for listing of these species under the ESA.”

In other words, BLM recognizes that the agency should not be contributing to wildlife species becoming rarer and so receiving more regulatory protection, which would impact private landowners by restricting the uses of their property.

Mouritsen’s Duty, Neglected

To avoid that, BLM California’s State Director Karen Mouritsen is required to, “at least once every 5 years,” review and update the BLM-maintained list of sensitive species in coordination with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW). It is unusual for such policy guidance to lay out a specific timeline, which adds clarity to expectations. The last time California BLM’s sensitive wildlife list was updated was in 2010, before Director Mouritsen’s tenure: 13 years ago! A lot has changed in those intervening years, and scientists have recognized that many more wildlife species are in need of protection by BLM.

Repercussions at Cotoni Coast Dairies

What happens when BLM’s sensitive wildlife species list isn’t updated? Let’s look at the Cotoni Coast Dairies example. BLM has already completed a Resource Management Plan that is meant to guide wildlife conservation on the property. Under the guidance and environmental review provided by the RMP, the agency is building miles of trails and parking lots, implementing a cattle grazing program, and allocating funding to other prioritized activities. BLM will soon embark on a Science Plan for the property. The RMP didn’t and the Science Plan will not consider conservation of wildlife species that do not appear on the BLM’s sensitive species list. And so, the following 10 rare wildlife species will receive no attention, pushing them further towards extinction: ferruginous hawk, grasshopper sparrow, Northern harrier, olive-sided flycatcher, American badger, San Francisco dusky-footed woodrat, Western pond turtle, California red-legged frog, American peregrine falcon, and short-eared owl.

A Deeper Dive – Grasshopper Sparrow

Let’s consider one of those species with a little more detail, the grasshopper sparrow. If this species is nesting in an area, under California law they are protected and our state wildlife agency, CDFW, has been charged with their conservation. According to BLM guidance, Director Mouritsen is 13 years overdue in updating the agency’s sensitive wildlife list for California to include this species. As their name suggests, grasshopper sparrows are grassland-dependent organisms. There is an abundance of nesting grasshopper sparrows at Cotoni Coast Dairies.

Without active management such as with carefully planned livestock grazing or fire, all of the grasslands at Cotoni Coast Dairies will disappear, being invaded first by brush and then by trees. This is already happening with extensive French broom and coyote brush invasion.

Already, BLM has planned its livestock grazing and recreational trail uses without consideration of preferred habitat for nesting grasshopper sparrows. Livestock grazing could be taking place to the detriment of the species, already. The construction of recreational trails and parking lots may have already destroyed important nesting habitat. When recreational visitors start using those facilities, it may occur before BLM has a baseline study of the density and location of nesting grasshopper sparrows. So, the agency will be unable to understand how land uses are impacting the species and so will be unable in an informed way to adjust its recreational or livestock management to better conserve the species.

It may well be that BLM’s management of Cotoni Coast Dairies will further reduce nesting populations of grasshopper sparrow, pushing the species closer to the point where they will need to be listed as threatened or endangered. When that occurs, private landowners whose land supports nesting grasshopper sparrows will see increased regulation and oversight by the State and/or Federal government. Their property values will be reduced and their ability to develop homes, farms, or other uses will be diminished.

An Alternative

On the other hand, if the California BLM State Director Mouritsen were to meet her regulatory obligation and update the BLM State Sensitive Wildlife Species List in the near future, a bunch of good would result. First, Cotoni Coast Dairies’ Science Plan could provide guidance for conserving those species. Second, because BLM funding is tied to the number of sensitive species on each property, Cotoni Coast Dairies would be better situated for increased conservation funding. If the Science Plan succeeded in moving forward the conservation of sensitive species like the grasshopper sparrow, BLM’s leadership on these issues could help many other land managers do the right thing for species, contributing to the potentiality of ‘delisting’ species, reducing the potential for increased regulatory burden and loss of private property values.

Do Your Part

I’ve said it before in this column, but I’ll say it again. NOW is the time to write Director Mouritsen to urge her to do her job. She hasn’t replied to any of the numerous letters she’s already received, so evidently she needs more pressure to take this seriously. Here’s some language to send to her via her email kmourits@blm.gov

Dear Director Mouritsen,

I care about wildlife and plant conservation on BLM’s Cotoni Coast Dairies property in Santa Cruz County. I write to urge you to help by adding sensitive species found on that property to the State BLM’s sensitive species lists. Only if those species are on the State’s lists will local administrators consider impacts of their management on those species in their analyses and planning for the property. So, I ask that you please:

  • Publish an updated State BLM sensitive wildlife list in collaboration with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, as mandated by the BLM’s 6840 Special Status Species Manual.
    • This list was last updated in 2010, but you are required to update it at least every 5 years.
  • Publish an updated State BLM sensitive plant list to include the State ranked 1B plant species documented at Cotoni Coast Dairies, as mandated by the 6840 Manual.

I would appreciate a reply to this email with details about how you intend to address these issues.

Signed,

xx

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

September 6

#249 / The “Law” Of Supply And Demand

Readers of my blog postings may or may not have heard about a plan, pushed by land speculators and development interests, to turn huge areas of open space and farmland in Solano County into a “new city.”

Click this link to read a recent AP news story about what has been a “stealth” effort by “billionaires” to buy up land for this proposed project. The whole idea – great for the billionaire land speculators – would be fundamentally inconsistent with Solano County’s current land use policies.

An attorney friend of mine – who lives in Southern California – recently wrote me a note in which she made the following observation, with reference to the proposed Solano County development:

I thought the whole point of these housing density bills was to stop sprawl. I wonder if the governor is supportive of this project too? I’m sure these billionaires assume they can just roll the land use laws. This will be a test to see whether the legislature and the governor will finally put their money where their mouth is, so to speak.

My friend’s comment references the fact that the Governor (and the State Legislature) have recently been undermining “local control” over land use. I mentioned that phenomenon in my blog posting last Monday, suggesting that an initiative petition being circulated in the City of Santa Cruz would be an important way to bolster local control over future high-rise developments in the city, besides helping to ensure that developers produce more “affordable” housing units than state law would otherwise make them produce.

The “housing density bills” my attorney friend mentions in her note to me are bills that mandate new density in existing cities, while depriving local elected officials (and local voters) of their ability to try to balance the demands for new development with other important objectives of good land use policy. For instance, preserving farmland and open space is important. So is dealing with issues like traffic, parking, neighborhood compatibility, water availability, etc., as new developments occur inside already existing urban areas. Recent state laws (those “housing density bills”) constrict or remove the ability of local officials to make key land use decisions, as they attempt to establish the right balance.

I wrote back a response to the question posed by my friend. I suggested that the newest efforts at the state level to reduce local discretion over local land use questions is mainly driven by our state’s very real, and very urgent, housing crisis. Unfortunately, the proposed “solution” for this crisis – eliminating local land use discretion and mandating new high-rise and high-density developments – isn’t actually effective in producing more “affordable housing.”

I have a theory why the state is going along with the developers, which I sent along to my attorney friend. She thought it was a pretty good explanation, so I decided I’d pass it along to those who read this blog.

If the so-called “Law of Supply And Demand” were actually a “law,” equivalent to the law of gravity or other such laws that describe the inevitable consequences of some action or condition, then maybe the state’s preemption of local authority would make some sense. But there is no such operational “law,” which is the point I made in the response I sent to my friend (I have also talked about this topic before):

It is my opinion that the political efforts now underway to overturn and undermine local land use controls (to promote “affordable” and “infill” housing) have very little to do with the “smart growth” philosophy that many of us have supported – and that I, certainly, still support. “Smart growth” does require infill, and infill projects, clearly, are more difficult politically (and often economically) than “greenfield” projects that represent the typical “sprawl” style of development that “smart growth” is intended to counter. In fact, genuine “infill” development (as contemplated in the “smart growth” philosophy of future land use development) requires great attentiveness to the “neighbors” who will, inevitably, be impacted by new infill development. Allowing local governments to figure out how to accomplish politically challenging infill projects requires the exercise of lots of local discretion, because the parking, traffic, and utility issues are very real.

In my opinion, the political basis upon which the YIMBY [“Yes” In My Backyard”] argument that the state should preempt local discretion is founded on the implicit claim that there is a reality to a posited “Law of Supply and Demand.” Proponents win the argument in favor of new, high-density development (both in the legislature and in the mind of the public) based on people’s belief that there really is a “Law” that insures that a reduction in housing prices will occur if the “supply” of housing is only increased. The argument that makes acceptable the erasure of rules intended to balance community concerns as development proceeds is based upon a genuine (though terribly mistaken) belief that if the “supply” of housing can be made to increase then the “price” of housing will fall.

The lack of affordable housing is a national, and state, and local crisis. So, to the degree that the supposed “Law of Supply and Demand” will provide a solution, as many believe it will, other important priorities can be disregarded. Of course, in the state legislature, the “pay to play” principle is also a major reason for our state legislators’ recent willingness to sell out the communities they represent for campaign dollars (and in some cases, probably, for personal dollars).

In fact, “demand” is not a constant, so increasing the “supply” doesn’t inevitably mean a decrease in price. The “demand” in my community, for instance, is functionally unlimited. If new housing units are made available in Santa Cruz County, there will be more than enough demand (coming from outside the community and generated by the possibility provided by the new supply) to “raise,” not lower, prices. That’s what is actually going on, but I have observed well-intentioned people say that while it’s “too bad” that local neighborhoods will be undermined by the developments being approved, on the basis of recently-enacted state laws, these outcomes are really alright, and necessary, since it is so important to produce affordable housing.

Regrettably, the state legislature has not mandated universal inclusionary housing requirements (requirements that we instituted in Santa Cruz County in 1978), which might actually help address the lack of affordable housing. Instead, the legislature is backing the “supply and demand” theory that if we just let the developers build more units the price will go down. Ironically, some of the legislature’s newest efforts have actually undermined our local inclusionary housing ordinance, by giving out “density bonus” units to developers that are substituted for what would otherwise be inclusionary affordable units required by our local ordinance.

Anyway, this short rant, stimulated by your inquiry to me, is intended to encourage all of us to try to get local and state officials, and the public at large, to realize that MORE housing does not, absent very specific, and increased, affordable housing mandates, mean more “affordable” housing. Certainly in places like Santa Cruz, California, these new state law mandates for more, more, more – and for higher, higher, higher – have just the opposite effect.

That’s the analysis that I sent to my Southern California friend. For residents in the City of Santa Cruz, let me reiterate my suggestion that we should be trying to get that “Housing For People” initiative measure qualified for the city ballot next March! It would increase the “inclusionary” percentage, locally, meaning more affordable housing, despite what the state has been doing to reduce our affordable housing requirements. It would also “secure our right to vote on height.”

If you care about affordable housing, and want to have more local control over new development, not less, this initiative measure is a step in the right direction!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

September 11

DISAGREEING ON THAT MIDNIGHT TRAIN TO GEORGIA

Last week the Fulton County, Georgia grand jury report containing the suggested charges in the election tampering case, with 39 names which had been under consideration for possible indictments by DA Fani Willis wasreleased. Of the names on the list Willis selected 19 for indictments. Former Georgia senators, David Perdue and Kelly Loeffler were included, as was South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham, but the DA decided to leave them as un-indicted co-conspirators…so far. Her reasoning was likely influenced by the vote tallies of the grand jury members, which were weighted heavily toward indictment but with enough variations which may have presaged problems with future trial jurors, not to mention the complex legal arguments involving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The complexity of indicting Trump national security advisor, Michael Flynn, though the jurors voted 20 to 1 for indictment, may have given him a temporary reprieve with his exclusion. The same explanation might be applied to Trump aide, Boris Epshteyn. One dissenter is noted on each of the votes for Trump’s recommended indictments, and Willis filed several of those charges against him; but, she also included her own charge for the fake elector scheme, not recommended by the grand jurors. Of course, Trump on Truth Social, dismissed the report as having “ZERO credibility.” “Essentially, they wanted to indict anybody who happened to be breathing at the time. It totally undermines the credibility of the findings, and badly hurts the Great State of Georgia, whose wonderful and patriotic people are not happy with this charge,” he whinged.

(Not-a-)Senator(-from-Georgia-) Graham, who appeared before the grand jury after the court ordered him to do so – taking it to the Supreme Court – said he was “totally surprised” to have been on the list and, “The next election, if I have questions, I’ll do the same thing.” Representative Adam Schiff pounced on Graham after he claimed his actions were “consistent” with being a Senator. “I think Lindsey Graham’s explanation doesn’t pass the laugh test,” Schiff said. “You don’t – as a Senator, a House member or another elected official – call a secretary of state in some other state and try to get them to toss out votes. That is not the least part of the job description, and he’s lucky not to be indicted.” Graham reportedly had called Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to toss ballots, “not to find votes,” in hopes of giving Trump the state’s electoral votes. The Former Guy’s attorneys filed three lawsuits asking the court to toss out the grand jury report and countermand Willis’s inquiry, along with an effort to sue the DA and Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney, who presided over the grand jury. A heavily redacted version of the report concluded no evidence of rampant chicanery resulting in a Trump loss, after which The Don’s legal team protested that some of the report’s content might influence a jury. Declining to take up the matter, the Georgia Supreme Court wrote that Trump was simply “circumventing the ordinary channels” for obtaining relief.

Cartoonist Clay Bennett of the Chattanooga Times Free Press portrays the old Proud Boys slogan – ‘Stand back and stand by,’ with the new one – ‘Stand trial and serve time.’ The Boys took a few hits last week with sentences handed down for their insurrectionist incursion on the D.C. Mall and environs on January 6, 2021. As the last of the seditious conspiracy cases wrapped up, which resulted in various charges for over 1,100 rioters, the groundwork is being prepared for the highest profile conspiracy case yet: the trial of un-President Trump, and the 18 others indicted along with him, with another 10 un-indicteds standing in the wings, awaiting their chances. Mary McCord, former federal prosecutor and Georgetown Law professor said, “The cases involving seditious conspiracy and the case in which Mr. Trump is charged federally do all involve an effort to prevent the peaceful transition of presidential power – to overrule or override the will of the voters. Mr. Trump is a different defendant than an ‘Enrique’ Tarrio or a Stewart Rhodes.” The conspiracies alleged are not the same, with prosecutors presenting different cases to a D.C. jury than that of the extremist group leaders.

Trump faces ‘only’ four counts in DOJ Special Counsel Jack Smith’s D.C. case, but the cases indicate a cause-and-effect tie with the extremist groups to engage in their various conspiracies according to Stan Twardy, a former federal prosecutor and practicing attorney. “Trump lit the match, and the Oath Keepers and Proud Boys were the gasoline that exploded here,” Twardy says of the indictments. Violence in both speech and behavior were basis of the DOJ’s cases against the Oath Keepers who predicted a civil war and had stashed weapons across the Potomac. The Proud Boys called for “war and revolution” as they dismantled barricades, breached the Capitol building and fought with law enforcement. Proud Boy ‘Enrique’ Tarrio crowed, “Make no mistake…we did this.” Trump’s case will be based on communications, revealing his words and those of his co-conspirators indicating the willingness, and agreement, to commit a crime. Mary McCord says, “Prosecutors will likely present a mix of Trump’s public statements and private ones to make their case. His legal team will likely argue that Trump had no intent to subvert the election results because he honestly believed he was the winner. Mr. Trump maintains to this day that there was fraud in the election. I think he’s tried to make the public believe that if he honestly and truly believed the election was stolen, that essentially, he couldn’t be guilty of anything because he had a right to attack the results of the election.” Trump’s delusional belief won’t necessarily clear him of misconduct as charged in Jack Smith’s indictment, with mention of the riot in which the former president sought to “impair, obstruct, and defeat the federal government function through dishonesty, fraud and deceit.”

Proud Boys, some of whom will be Old Boys by the time they see freedom outside of prison walls, were convicted in May, and last week got sentences ranging from 17 to 22 years. ‘Enrique’ Tarrio, who was seen as “the ultimate leader” by US District Judge Kelly, got 22 years, though he was not present at the J6 riot as he continued to spur his compatriots on. Four other PBs, Nordean, Biggs, Rehl, and Pezzola, got off with slightly lighter sentences, even after the prosecutors sought longer terms all the accused. The judge conceded that the conviction met the guidelines for enhanced terrorism penalties under federal law, saying further, “the terrorism adjustment overstates” their roles in the offense since they did not have the intent to kill or cause mass casualties. Though Tarrio apologized for the harm caused to the Capitol police on J6, the judge felt there was no remorse for those actions for which he was convicted. Judge Kelly said, “I think we’re talking past each other in many ways. There’s only so much that statement can go toward assuring me that deterrence is not warranted.”

Prison sentences will not deter the Proud Boys from infusing their destructive energy into the GOP, and their attempts to alter American’s lives by being in effect the Republican paramilitary force. After Oath Keepers leader, Stewart Rhodes, was sentenced to 18 years for seditious conspiracy, that organization has experienced a decline in numbers; but, Proud Boys draw their energy from the GOP, with Matt Gaetz, Marjorie Taylor Greene, Roger Stone, Lauren Boebert, and Michael Flynn carrying their banner. Arizona Representative Paul Gosar supposedly recruited Proud Boys to block certification of election results in his state after the 2020 election to no avail. And who can forget President Trump’s call to the Boys in a debate with candidate Biden saying, “Proud Boys, stand back and stand by?” Their membership rolls increased as they became his BFFs, and they showed us of what they are capable in their insurrection. Think Trump is starting to feel a bit edgy, now that the court system is showing its power?

A post on Quorum wonders if Florida Judge Aileen Cannon in her drive to absolve Trump of all charges, will continue to risk losing her cushy forever-job, or will she follow the law and precedent? An example of following the law: A jury is picked in Trump’s purloined documents case. Immediately the defense attorneys ask that the charges be dismissed because of blah, blah and blah… only a formality, which most presiding judges decline to honor, but they don’t HAVE to deny the request. So, should Trump’s team begin by saying, “Your honor, we ask that all charges be dismissed because the Moon is in the 7th House, and Jupiter is aligned with Mars.” Judge Cannon, hearing the power and logic of the appeal, might say, “Case dismissed.” Scary enough for you?

In Jack Smith’s D.C. case, he and the Justice Department will examine closely the cases against the insurrectionists, and in particular the verdicts returned against the leaders, which might inform them of the persuasive points, and what jurors will find to be compelling evidence. Former federal prosecutor, Barbara McQuade of the University of Michigan, feels attempts to portray the J6 actions as patriotic is one facet that has been, and will be, rejected by a jury. She said, “Jack Smith can be confident that a reasonable jury can be selected that sees the events of that day for what they were – a profound display of disloyalty to the United States.” Henry (Enrique) Tarrio’s seditious conspiracy conviction lets prosecutors see that a jury understands the guilt of a person who isn’t present at the scene of the crime, since Tarrio was in Baltimore on January 6 after being arrested on separate charges. McQuade warns that no two juries are alike, with just one outlier able to bring it crashing down. Again: the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that there is criminality.

Representative Jim ‘Gym’ Jordan got his sore butt handed back to him by Fulton County, Georgia DA Fani Willis last week after he attempted to interfere with her criminal investigation into Donald Trump and his minions. Jordan sent a letter demanding information and communications with the Department of Justice and Executive Branch officials, and information on federal funding the her office receives. The Ohio representative knows full well that Willis is within her rights to proceed with her case with the 19 indictments involving Trump’s four year crime spree of corruption and incompetence, but he and the MAGA crowd couldn’t care less. One writer compared Jordan’s letter to emails from ‘Nigerian princes’ which are intentionally loaded with grammatical mistakes and punctuation errors seeking to scam recipients of money or hard drive data. Smart people immediately know they are dealing with a scammer and hit ‘delete,’ leaving the ‘princes’ with the stupid recipients who won’t catch on until it’s too late…distilled brainlessness! The MAGA messages attempt to accomplish the same thing with their wacko conspiracy theories…smart people move on, or the conmen find a sucker.

Fani Willis is not one to put up with this meddling, and she forcefully responded to Jordan’s letter by telling him, “It is clear you lack a basic understanding of the law, and are overstepping your congressional authority.” The Palmer Report’s Bocha Blue feels it would make a good Saturday Night Live sketch, with Willis being a spirited and fiery woman against Jordan’s sludge-like character. Further, Willis told ‘Gym,’ “Your job as a legislator does not include criminal enforcement.” Blue describes Jordan as a ‘lurker,’ poking his nose into places it shouldn’t be, a person who has an unusually thick skull that doesn’t register phrases like ‘critical thinking skills.’ Willis essentially told the meddler where to stick his inquiry, and that his calling the prosecution a ‘political stunt‘ being related to ‘federal interests,’ does not relate to the interference in state-run elections. The charges against Trump in Fulton County rightfully belong to the state of Georgia, not the federal government! ‘Prince Gym’ tried to come across as knowledgeable, but it all fell flat in the face of Willis’ onslaught, as she pointed out several inaccuracies and misleading statements. She went on to state that his actions offend “each and every one of the settled principles of law,” as he attempted to obstruct the proceedings and advance his own partisan goals. The topper in her response used Jordan’s own words in his earlier letter to the House Select Committee: “This unprecedented action serves no legitimate legislative purpose and would set a dangerous precedent for future Congresses…the American people deserve better.” DA Willis is well-versed in the law and proper procedure, as she proved that Jim Jordan is a complete ass!

Former youth pastor and author, John Pavlovitz, who is known for his progressive social and political writings from a liberal Christian perspective posted an open letter on his website several years ago, which deserves a look-back. He says the phrase, ‘We’re just going to have to agree to disagree,’ is unacceptable, and he refuses the term. His response would be, “I believe you’re deeply, profoundly, and egregiously wrong…this is not a disagreement.” See his post here. Perfect for the after-Thanksgiving dinner-food fight!

Remember what Leonard Cohen said: “There is a crack in everything. That’s how the light gets in!”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Santa Cruz

“Growing up in northern California has had a big influence on my love and respect for the outdoors. When I lived in Oakland, we would think nothing of driving to Half Moon Bay and Santa Cruz one day and then driving to the foothills of the Sierras the next day”.
~Tom Hanks

“When I go home to Santa Cruz, I’m the same girl as when I grew up.”
~Marisa Miller

 “My own zigzag path through life led me back to Santa Cruz in the early Eighties, and I have revisited regularly since. The place hasn’t changed: head in the clouds, backside on the hills and feet in the ocean – one of the most decent and beautiful places on earth.
~Clive Sinclair

...

It’s a story of reincarnation, and it’s quite beautiful.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

September 6 – 12, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…about “brave and free”, letters to the editor concept, housing for people initiative. Greensite…on rendering rape invisible in Santa Cruz… Steinbruner…Big secret city land purcheses,make less garbage, B40 fire district, local opioid addiction, Aptos Village plot? Cabrillo name change.Hayes…a primer in conserving California’s coastal prairies. Patton…sign that petition!. Matlock…sanchismos, copyrights and rolling the dice. Eagan … Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week: Standup! Quotes “Hawaii”

...

BEACH BOARDWALK PLUNGE. April 25, 1963. One of almost yearly changes the Boardwalk does to bring in more business. This plunge became their miniature golf course.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE September 4

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR CONCEPT. I decided even before starting BrattonOnline  that Bratton Online wouldn’t deal with “letters to the editor” weekly and that’s been the idea for the almost 20 years we’ve been online. When I ran Keith McHenry’s 4000 word “letter” last week I wanted to give readers a chance to see what Keith was really like. WE read his accomplishments with Bread Not Bombs and his praise for Brave and Free and boasting and bragging… it was an almost auto-biography of one of our most noticeable citizens.

HOUSING FOR PEOPLE INITIATIVE. Steve Bare who is a local activist and much involved community member wrote a letter to Gary Patton. Gary, Steve and I decided that it would help Housing for People to reprint his letter in its entirety right here. Here’s his letter…

“Dear Gary,

This is Steve Bare. You know me when you see me; I’ve been around a long time and been active in peace and social justice efforts.

As you may know, I’m deeply involved with our Housing For People Initiative effort. (Loved the shot of you and our t-shirt!) You also probably realize that the Initiative is a relatively modest one that simply attempts to return some decision-making power to citizen voters and insists on a true 25% “affordable” housing inclusion in new development. It’s not a game-changer; it’s simply a step in the right direction. A step (one you have nobly taken many times in the past) toward retaining livability, community, sustainability, and uniqueness for us and our town.

Gary, this is no longer the unique, accepting, quirky, and eclectic town it was when I moved here over 40 years ago. But it’s still a wonderful place. But for how long? Well, not long at the rate things seem to be evolving. However, folks, and many non-political citizens as well, are shocked and saddened by the changes and the proposed development. The Housing For People Initiative can slow down what is, to my eye, the exploitation and commodification of our precious town. Frankly, what I see is simply an extension of a shameful system of exploitation that harms not helps, profits the few at the expense of the many.

I revere and respect all you’ve done to keep this town livable, civil, and unique. Will you consider giving more help and support to our humble Initiative? We need you, and what we’re doing is an extension of all the effort you’ve made heretofore.

Let’s take the next step. Go to … housingforpeople.org”

Peace, Steve Bare

...

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

THE EQUALIZER 3 (Del Mar Theatre) (7.1IMDB). ???? Denzel Washington (age 69) and Dakota Fanning (age 29) head the cast of this conclusion to the Equalizer series. I can’t find or remember what I wrote about the first two Equalizer series…and this part 3 just left me cold, bored and mystified. Somehow Denzel the Equalizer goes to Italy and gets all involved with the Mafia in order to protect his friends who live there. His background/history are mysterious and only hinted at. Go warned.

MASK GIRL. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB).  Most definitely a Korean film that plays out as a semi comedy and some tragedy. A plain looking but shapely girl decides to wear a mask and performs strip dances online. Her followers work hard to expose her and it’s a foolish but curious use of animated cartoons and dance numbers to tell this foolish story.

THE CHOSEN ONE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (5.6 IMDB). **** A movie from Mexico (Baja California) about a 12 year old boy who discovers that he has powers like Jesus. It’s almost an amateur’s first attempt at making a movie. He makes wine from water, helps the handicapped folks and makes some momentous decisions about how to live his life. I’ve watched the first two episodes and will ignore the rest.

Been there, seen that...

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

THE POPE’S EXORCIST. (NETFLIX) (6.1 IMDB). **** This scary, religious horror movie is taken from books by a Roman Catholic priest who actually did some exorcisms in and around the Vatican community. Russell Crowe is the priest and he’s as good as any actor could be in this touch-feely scary role.

TELEMARKETERS. (HBO) (7.7 IMDB). **** A fake documentary about those damned telemarketers who call all of us saying they are with the police and are trying to raise money for some phony police event or cause. It gives us a comedic view of their lives and how fake and almost illegal it is. Watch about half an hour…you’ll learn enough.

GOLDA. (DEL MAR THEATRE). **** Helen Mirren carries the role of Golda Meir and Moshe Dayan is in it and Liev Schreiber acts as Henry Kissinger. Golda is the first head (prime minister) of the new state of Israel and as you’ll be shown is/was a chain smoker (Chesterfields). It’s absorbing, well made, complex and basically covers the three week Yom Kippur war. Don’t miss it.

SHELTER. (PRIME) (6.6 IMDB) **** Tough to follow this mystery. A man dies in a terrible car crash…but does he die? His high school age son is nearly devastated but endures several other worldly experiences involving his dad. It’s even light and cute in parts and there’s even a Batlady and a character named Dylan Shakes. Watch at your own risk.

JURY DUTY. (PRIME SERIES) (8.3 IMDB) ****   Be very careful this is billed as a comedy but if you’ve ever been on a jury or been excused from serving on one…it’s no laughing matter. This jury selection takes place in Huntington Beach near LA. (or as we know it “Surf City”). It’s done in a pseudo-documentary style and goes through all the legal time and mind consuming legal steps in how a jury is selected. Not too bad a movie but torture if you’ve ever done time on a complex court case.

FIVE DAYS AT MEMORIAL. (PRIME SERIES) (7.7 IMDB). **** Not a new one, but a good one about the disaster during and after the Katrina hurricane that hit New Orleans in August of 2005. Vera Farmiga is one of the staff and all the acting and special effects are well worth watching.

JESUS REVOLUTION. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). ???? A very sweet, well intentioned Christian feel good and true movie about Los Angeles teenagers in the 1970’s. Kelsey Grammer plays a minister who eventually sees that the hippies around his part of LA mean well and they all join together to worship Jesus in a slightly different way.

...
September 4

LESSONS FROM TANZANIA

The statement above represents a commitment by the principal and teaching staff of Monduli Teachers’ College in Tanzania to take significant steps to address the serious issues of sexual harassment and rape. Prior to a three- day training for administrators and teachers, which I had been invited to co-facilitate, these issues were largely silenced, hidden by taboos from public discussion and accountability. By the end of the three days, there was a measurable decrease in victim-blaming and an eagerness to publicly tackle both issues that disproportionally affect women and girls.

When I was asked whether the situation is different in my hometown of Santa Cruz, I had to admit that it is. “In Tanzania”, I replied, “you have few resources yet a commitment to highlight these issues and make them public. In Santa Cruz, we have all the resources yet no commitment to highlight and make the issues public.” In Santa Cruz there appears to be a concerted effort to render them invisible. City management and various city councils over the past 18 years have effectively marginalized the city’s forty- year- old Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women, stripping it of resources, programs, and half-time trained staff. Despite an average of thirty reported sexual assaults annually, none is reported in the local media. You could be forgiven for concluding it is a non-issue. My hunch is that is the goal in this tourist town.

One issue of sexual harassment was recently reported in Lookout, Santa Cruz on August 13th, 2023. The story was written by a 16- year-old female high school student who described her experience while waiting for the bus, of being approached by a male who initiated conversation that quickly turned into verbal sexual harassment. She described her reactions, feelings, fears, and criticism of the Metro system for what she saw as a lack of resources to address such intimidation. Regrettably, the Lookout editors allowed a mistake in both the headline and the Quick Take summary of the article to be published. Both erroneously state that the incident took place “on the Santa Cruz Metro” for the headline and “on a Santa Cruz Metro bus” for the summary. This is not a minor mistake and should have been corrected. While the major issue is the sexual harassment, wrongly stating that it took place on a Metro bus not only casts doubt on the integrity of bus drivers to halt such behavior but also potentially discourages other females from taking the bus.

After forty- four years in rape prevention education, my instinct is to listen carefully to how people responded to sexual harassment, and sexual assault. My aim is to help the person lessen self-blame, a common response, while helping them expand their options for any future incident. The self-defense workshops I held at UCSC were titled Alternatives to Fear.  After a gargantuan effort and much student support, we were able to get Women’s Self Defense as a regular PE class at UCSC. One of my first actions as the first chair of the Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women in 1981 was to establish Women’s and Girl’s Self Defense Classes through the city’s Parks and Recreation Department and later, in city schools. As a balance, educational programs were aimed at males, as allies, as bystanders and as potential perpetrators. I’ll never forget the words of a young male, found guilty of rape and expressing remorse, who at his sentencing said, “I crossed a line I didn’t know existed.” With sex education non-existent in most states and most families, young males need more than slogans, peers, and popular media to navigate the sexual terrain. Most males don’t rape. And some who do are beyond education. However, look into the family dynamics of men convicted of rape and you will find another male figure who paved the way.

As recently as 2015, most universities and many communities across the country had some version of a Women and Girls’ Self-defense program. Such programs are not traditional martial arts, in fact they are distinctly different from a martial art. Women’s self-defense includes verbal assertiveness as well as simple physical techniques best described as “dirty fighting.” You aim for, not avoid, the vulnerable parts of the attacker. The verbal training helps the transition from a passive “why are you doing this? please don’t” to a loud “back off!!” That, and to trust one’s instincts. I’ve lost count of how many students shared their stories of avoiding an overly intrusive or threatening male by drawing on one or more of these options.

Thus, I was greatly frustrated when I first heard about Women’s Self-Defense no longer supported across the country because of the latest ideological posturing that self-defense was not “primary prevention.” Apparently “primary prevention” means you stop a male raping. How that is achieved gets a bit vague. When I pointed out that a female getting out of a situation by kicking a male in the groin is “stopping that male raping” I was told that,” no, he will go on to rape somebody else.” Such is the absurdity of ideology versus reality. One of the results of this misguided activism was the ending of self-defense classes at UCSC plus those funded and organized by the city of Santa Cruz.

I thought of all this history as I read the 16-year-old’s experience of sexual harassment at the bus stop. When she wrote “I hoped and prayed that maybe my instincts were wrong this time, that I misjudged him,” I could only bow my head in defeat. Trusting one’s instincts is the sine qua non of Women’s Self Defense.

If I return to do rape prevention work in Tanzania and am asked if things have improved in Santa Cruz, reluctantly I will have to say things have gotten worse: that the issues of rape, domestic violence and sexual harassment have been further marginalized and rendered invisible. The example I will use is the recent council approved Strategic Plan. Under the Public Safety section there are eight entries. Not one addresses these issues even though the 1981 Ordinance that created the Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women mandates” that the prevention of rape and domestic violence shall be one of the city’s highest priorities”. Noting the absence of these issues in the first reading of the Plan I spoke at city council, reminded council members of the Ordinance requirements, and asked that these issues be added to the Public Safety section of the Strategic Plan. At the next meeting, final reading, and unanimous council vote, they had not been added.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
September 4

COUNTY HOUSING ELEMENT UPDATED PLAN NOW AVAILABLE:

Project Documents

BIG LAND PURCHASES FOR BAY AREA UTOPIAN CITY KEPT SECRET…COULD IT HAPPEN HERE?

There has been much talk in the news recently about a group of ultra-wealthy investors, one of whom has a residence in Santa Cruz County, buying large tracts of farmland in Solano County and aggressively forcing farmers who do not want to sell their land to enter into legal settlements.  Solano County leaders say the deals have been secretive until recently, and worry about the security of such a new subdivision, Flannery Associates LLP’s “California Forever”, that would border Travis Air Force Base.

Do you think such a thing could happen in Santa Cruz County, say in some of the CZU Fire areas where few have been allowed to rebuild and costs to do so are climbing higher by the minute due to more studies the County wants and wide paved roads CalFIRE requires?  Or maybe on land owned by Lockheed Martin, also ravaged by the CZU Fire?  Hmmm…  Consider this below.

‘California Forever’: Company behind land purchases near Travis Air Force Base launches website, details plans

Below is a list of news sources from Wikipedia on the “Mystery Company” purchase:

  1. Peterson, Kristina; Gillum, Jack; O’Keeffe, Kate (7 July 2023). “Investors Bought Nearly $1 Billion in Land Near a California Air Force Base. Officials Want to Know Who Exactly They Are”. The Wall Street Journal. ISSN0099-9660. Retrieved 22 July 2023.
  2. ^Sierra, Stephanie (21 July 2023). “‘Mystery company’ buys $800M worth of land near Travis AFB, raising concerns about national security”. KGO-TV.
  3. ^Dougherty, Conor; Griffith, Erin (25 August 2023). “The Silicon Valley Elite Who Want to Build a City From Scratch”. The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 26 August 2023.

Many local landowners are getting sued for not caving in to Flannery Associates LLP’s aggressive land grab tactics: ORDER signed by District Judge Troy L for Flannery Assoc. LLC v. Barnes Family Ranch Assoc., LLC et al :: Justia Dockets & Filings

According to a Settlement document filed by all parties in the lawsuit (U.S. District Court, Eastern District, Sacramento Division Case 2:23-CV-00927-TLN-AC), the legal action is on hold while there is  discussion about a possible settlement, due to be complete by October 17, 2023.

Here is a map of current Flannery Associates holdings and areas pending takeover

It adjoins not only Travis Air Force Base, but also the Grizzly Island Wildlife Refuge

Learn more about that Wildlife Refuge here

Would nearby Jepson Prairie and Vernal Pools be affected? Jepson Prairie | Solano Land Trust : Suisun City, CA

The point that concerns me is that the artist’s rendering of this utopian California Forever project reminds me a lot of how the Aptos Village Project was sold to the public, and how easily (and secretively) deals are made behind closed doors to benefit the wealthy and the County coffers.

What would California Forever look like? Here are artist renderings from the developer

Now, think about what the north coast’s Cemex Land and CZU Fire areas look like now, and how the County is making it nearly impossible for anyone but the wealthy to rebuild.  Just think about it, and pay attention.

HOW CAN WE MAKE LESS GARBAGE?

Santa Cruz County’s Buena Vista Landfill has only a few years left before it will be full and will be closed.   Where will our garbage go then?  The plan is to truck it to Marina.

Last week while visiting the County Building, I happened to spot the agenda posted outside for the Santa Cruz County Local Solid Waste Task Force meeting on September 7.  I know some of those Committee members who work hard to help businesses and the general public to reduce, recycle and reuse, and am grateful for their good work.

What impressed me most about the agenda is the thorough review of all State legislation pending that manages to address how we can better handle the piles of garbage by just not creating so much in the first place,  recycling what we can and holding commercial enterprises accountable for reducing packaging.  Take a look at the Sept. 7 agenda, and participate if you can: Local Task Force

WHY IS LAFCO AVOIDING THIS?

Santa Cruz County LAFCO Executive Officer Joe Serrano responded to my Request for LAFCO to reconsider the August 2 approval of a Resolution that was wrought with errors and provided inaccurate voter numbers for the Branciforte Fire District area in the face of a move to dissolve their District.  Basically, he corrected the erroneous dates, arbitrarily shortened the Protest Period by a week, and claimed the updated voter registration numbers were irrelevant because County Elections had not notified him of any changes since he had last asked in May, 2022.

Claims of notices posted in the Sentinel have not been proven, and I could not find them in recent editions of the newspaper.

Initially, the Protest Hearing date of September 27 for the Branciforte Fire District Dissolution was shown on the LAFCO meeting website as “Protest Hearing for RO 22-07”.  How’s that for transparency?  Luckily, the project was described after I asked that this be done.

So, what’s the cause behind this feverish rush and clouded action?  Maybe transfer of tax monies to Scotts Valley Fire District in order to be collected by tax bills for 2024?  Maybe the Director’s application for an award to LAFCO for getting a consolidation accomplished in Santa Cruz County in two years?  Hmmm….Stay tuned. [Staff Report]

WHAT WOULD YOU DO WITH $20.3 TO $26 MILLION TO ADDRESS OPIOID ADDICTION IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY?

The County will receive about $26 million over the next 18 years as part of a class-action settlement against opioid manufacturers, distributors and retailers who settled for $51 billion.  What do you think would be the best use of that money to actually make a difference for people addicted to opioids?

“County Director of Substance Use Disorder Services Casey Swank explained that the Health Services Agency facilitated a community survey in August among Medi-Cal beneficiaries and substance use disorder treatment providers who were asked to rank core strategies within the eligible high impact areas defined in the settlement.”

Public shares priorities for Santa Cruz County opioid settlement spending

The County’s survey of 238 agencies and care providers yielded this:

“…the top three core strategies were treatment and recovery support for people involved in the justice system, reliance on substance use disorder wellness centers to divert people away from the justice system and treatment for individuals in the justice system.

Preferred uses among the 181 providers that responded to the survey are, in order of preference, crisis stabilization centers as an alternative to emergency rooms, peer support specialists or recovery coaches in emergency departments and substance use disorder wellness centers for youth and adults.”

What do you think?

I think the County would do well to launch a pilot project using Ibogaine to address and reduce addiction problems, as is being done in Brazil, New Zealand and South Africa under medical supervision: Ibogaine for addiction: Research, benefits, and more

Studies are showing it is effective and could remove addictive tendencies.

Then, I think we need to give these folks life skills to help manage money and learn new job skills that help them become independent, self-respecting people, and maybe have a farm modelled on the Homeless Garden Project in Santa Cruz to help them along the way.

Notice that I did NOT mention Safe Injection Centers or handing out free needles.

Please let me know your thoughts.

IS THE STATE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER MAKING DEALS?

A front-page article in the September 4  San Jose Mercury News caught my eye, reporting that State Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara may be making deals with insurance companies in hope that Californians will be able to get insurance coverage in the future.  But at what price?

Anxiety builds as coverage dissolves [article]

At issue is that insurance companies who claim they can no longer afford risky coverage in California are now leaving the state, not renewing existing policies and refusing to write new policies.  The claim is that this is brought on by Prop. 103, passed by the voters in 1988 (by 51%), that regulates what insurance providers can charge, subject to approval of the State Insurance Commissioner, which became an elected position rather than appointed.  Insurance companies were required to roll back their rates by 20%..

Information Sheet: Proposition 103 Intervenor Process

What can you do if you have a mortgage and are required to have insurance, but no companies will issue a policy?  The State’s FAIR Plan is the last resort, but is expensive and restrictive.  It is not a government or public tax-funded program but rather high-priced, narrow policies underwritten by a consortium of all insurance companies doing business in the State and that is administered by the FAIR Plan agency.  About FAIR Plan

FAIR Plan Insurance

What is of interest is that State Insurance Commissioner just approved an increase of 15.7% for FAIR Plan rates, yet rates for private insurance companies themselves is being held down.

The article in the Mercury News, California insurance companies have to base rates on historic losses rather than using predictive computer climate model numbers.  That prevents insurance companies from being able to recover their own insurance for large payouts in disasters, which they buy for their own economic survival.

What consumer watchdogs feel is happening is that Ricardo Lara is making deals with legislators to ease the restrictions on insurance companies.

The bottom line is that something has to be done to help those who are receiving non-renewal notices.

Participate in the online presentations on this topic as it relates to wildland fire risk

Listen in online to your local talk program “Community Matters” on Santa Cruz Voice.com this Friday (9/08) 2pm-4pm for a discussion with local insurance and real estate agents about this issue affecting Santa Cruz County. (santacruzvoice.com) State Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara and staff have been requested to participate.

FAIR INSURANCE PLAN RECOGNIZES FIREWISE COMMUNITIES FOR DISCOUNTS

When neighbors work together to reduce wildfire risk, it makes a big difference in favor of safety.  When those neighbors join together to become a nationally-recognized FireWise Community to expand that cooperative work and education, many insurance companies now recognize the effort and grant a discount on insurance policies within the FireWise neighborhoods.

Even the FAIR Plan now recognizes the value of FireWise Communities.  Below is just such information, sent by California Insurance Commissioner’s Office staff, Ms. Mary Beth Bykowsky, forwarded by Ms. Lynn Sestak, FireWise Coordinator  of the Santa Cruz County FireSafe Council:

—– Forwarded Message —–

From: Bykowsky, Mary Beth marybeth.bykowsky@insurance.ca.gov
Sent: Monday, August 28, 2023 at 06:43:30 PM PDT
Subject: New FAIR Plan Discounts

“I wanted to let all my Fire Safe Council, Firewise Communities and other concerned communities members know that the Department of Insurance has already approved the FAIR Plan to begin offering insurance discounts starting yesterday, August 23, and expects to have other companies approved by the end of the year. The FAIR Plan has offered a 10% discount on policies in a participating Firewise Community since May 2018. Now, the FAIR Plan is offering two more wildfire hardening discounts: one for Protecting the Structure, and another for Protecting the Immediate Surroundings of the dwelling. When applied, these discounts will reduce the wildfire portion of the policy’s premium by 10% and 5% respectively. Depending on your level of wildfire risk, this can be a large component of your overall premium. Contact your broker to find out what this means for your premium, how to qualify, and when you could receive a discount.”

Learn more here: Firewise USA Recognition Program

APTOS VILLAGE TRAFFIC CHANGES THIS WEEK

A friend sent me this note over the weekend:

“Parade Street in Aptos Village will be open to all traffic on Tuesday, Sept. 5 while the Bayview Railroad Crossing will be closed to all traffic from this date forward! ?? Please be prepared for potential traffic congestion as Parade Street reopens and Bayview Railroad Crossing closes. Make sure to plan your commute accordingly and explore alternative routes if possible.”

I wonder why this boondoggle had to happen on a school day, when traffic is already choking the area?

What will be done to close the historic Bayview Hotel private entrance?  At the time of this writing, neither Swenson nor the County has contacted the owner of the Bayview Hotel about what will be happening there.

Contact Santa Cruz County Dept. of Public Works Director Matt Machado<matt.machado@santacruzcounty.us> with your thoughts about Aptos Village traffic issues.

KEEP YOUR EYE ON CABRILLO COLLEGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES ABOUT THAT DELAY IN NAME CHANGE

The Board of Trustees voted last month to pause on taking further action on selection a new name for Cabrillo College.  There continues to be thoughtful Letters to the Editor in the Sentinel regarding the matter.  We all need to keep paying attention and offering written and public testimonies with solutions to the Board of Trustees because it is important to our Community.

The next Board meeting will be Monday, September 11 at 6pm in the Horticulture Bldg. at the Aptos Cabrillo College campus.

[Board meetings and dates]

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS.  JUST DO ONE THING THIS WEEK AND YOU’LL MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
September 4

A PRIMER IN CONSERVING CALIFORNIA’S COASTAL PRAIRIES

California’s coastal prairies are super-diverse habitats that (barely) still exist around the Monterey Bay and deserve careful attention by public and private landowners alike if we are to conserve these habitats for plants and wildlife for future generations.

What are Coastal Prairies?

Coastal prairies are dominated by herbaceous species (grasses, grass-like plants, and broadleaved plants aka ‘forbs’) where there is incursion of summer fog. Old growth coastal prairies are where human plows have not ‘turned over’ the soil, mixing the lower levels with upper levels and permanently altering the ecology. Old growth coastal prairies are extremely rare because people have historically farmed so much of what they primarily saw as productive prairie soils. Secondary coastal prairies have been intensively plowed and have a different ecology that requires different management approaches. Beyond the split between old growth and secondary coastal prairies, there are many, many types of coastal prairies.

Hydrogeomorphology Drives Diversity of Coastal Prairie Communities

Understanding soils and the corresponding differences in geology and hydrology will help with understanding of how beautifully complex coastal prairie classification can be. There are three geomorphic subdivisions that have been used to help to start classifying coastal prairies: flat, hillsides, and shallow-soiled ‘balds.’ Because water doesn’t drain quickly off of flat areas, coastal prairies found in such places often support extensive wetlands, some of which are only very wet in the most rainy of times. And, because soil doesn’t erode rapidly from those flat areas, deep soils typically develop under coastal prairies’ productive plants, which are so diverse as to have some species growing in every season. Hillside coastal prairies are better drained, and soil more readily erodes, so these drier, less productive prairies have a different ecology. And, at the top of those slopes there is frequently no soil at all…these areas are called ‘balds’ because only certain plants can grow there among the oft-exposed and bald-looking rock.

Let’s add two more levels of geomorphic complexity to this coastal prairie stew, both related to oceanic activity. Tides strongly influence the rarest types of coastal prairies, which thrive only where floods and King Tides inundate areas, with very salty and occasionally quite wet soils. These areas are also known as ‘saline wet meadows.’ Some line estuaries and lagoons and some are located even far inland where salts have accumulated over eons, like the flat areas where the Pajaro River wends its way across the valley north of Hollister. The ocean’s waves and tides carved stair-step flat areas, aka ‘marine terraces’ into the ocean-facing hills in the Big Sur and Santa Cruz mountains. You can see that terrace formation in action as you watch waves chiseling at the land across wide flat tide-pool-dotted rock: the soft-rock cliffs fall apart, Public Works drops massive piles of boulders, and someone inevitably proposes the ultimate boondoggle, a “sea wall.” Episodically, there’s an ice age, the ocean recedes, and tectonic uplift elevates the lowest marine terrace above the force of waves. There are at least 6 terraces, each with its own diversity of different-age soils and correspondingly diverse different coastal prairie types.

Managing Diverse Coastal Prairies

To conserve plants and wildlife, people looking to manage the bewilderingly diverse coastal prairies have a lot of work to do. The first rule in managing coastal prairies is: steward what you have, not what you want. We know diddly-squat about introducing new species to new places, but humans are apt to want to superimpose ideas from elsewhere on the spot they are looking at: that’s a common mistake. The second rule: manage for the thing you have that you want, not what you don’t want. Those two rules require you to start by cataloging everything. Get to know your place, make lists and maps…ask for help! People love cataloging and mapping species; iNaturalist, CalFlora, eBird, and other platforms offer increasingly easy platforms to help with this. Each species is in each place for its own reasons, and we are just getting to know coastal prairie species, so understanding why species are where is important to understanding how to conserve every species for future generations. For instance, we are beginning to understand that some species are only going to thrive in old growth coastal prairies. Other species require specific amounts of moisture. For decades, I have been working with a research team that has been documenting the importance of cattle grazing in conserving native annual wildflowers of California’s coastal prairies. Grazers can reduce vegetation height and the depth of dead plant material, both critical factors to allowing some species to thrive. Other species like taller, denser vegetation.

Indicator Species

Rightly or wrongly, and this is quite contested stuff, humans gravitate to looking at a small subset of species to indicate whether or not they are good land stewards. Because the citizens of the USA strongly support wildlife conservation and believe in conserving all species, we have national and state laws and policies that provide for the protection of rare, threatened, and endangered species. That focus makes these “listed” species the most commonly used species to inform land stewardship, and they have proven their value as such over and over again. Other government policies provide impetus for other biotic indicators. The California Coastal Commission at times designates suites of species as indicators of legally protected ESHA, Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Areas because of either their rarity or function. Wetland plant species serve as indicators of the most common ESHA and coastal prairie species have also served in that capacity in some places. Also, the Antiquities Act allows for US Presidents to provide for protection of species, ecosystems, or habitats. In the Monument Proclamation that provided protections for Cotoni Coast Dairies, there are several coastal prairie species listed that will also be used as indicator species for the BLM managers on that property.

Species Indicators of Coastal Prairie Management Success: a case study at Cotoni Coast Dairies

There might be enough policy-mandated indicator species in the coastal prairies at Cotoni Coast Dairies to adequately protect all the species that require those habitats. The Monument Proclamation lists the following species found predominantly in coastal prairies at the Cotoni Coast Dairies site: California buttercups, brown-headed rush, meadow vole, American kestrel, and white-tailed kite. The California Coastal Commission hasn’t yet weighed in on ESHA designation at Cotoni Coast Dairies, so we’ll have to wait and see how those designations change which species are used as indicators. Protections for rare, threatened and endangered species add a few more species to the list: Point Reyes Horkelia, Choris’ popcornflower, American badger, golden eagle, northern harrier, short-eared owl, grasshopper sparrow, and western pond turtle. It is fortunate that BLM is required to manage for, and monitor, so many coastal prairie indicator species: with this wealth and diversity of species, there is a good chance that many other species will be conserved. But, managing for this extensive suite will not be easy.

What’s the Management Recipe?

Each species has its own stewardship requirements. Managing for healthy buttercup populations requires managers to maintain wet meadows, most typically found on the terraces, but also in seeps on hillsides. Conservation of brown headed rush is similar, but this species likes less disturbance intensity. Meadow voles like dense grass in wet meadows, places that buttercup wouldn’t thrive. Choris’ popcornflower and Point Reyes Horkelia won’t thrive without higher disturbance intensity, which provides the extensive bare soil and lack of light competition that they need to proliferate. None of the coastal prairie indicator species will thrive without the right timing and intensity of grazing, mowing, or fire…which vary by species.

Applying the Principles

The guidance to manage for so many coastal prairie indicator species which are extant at Cotoni Coast Dairies provides a great foundation for rule 1: ‘steward what you have, not what you want’ but what about rule 2, ‘manage for the thing you have that you want, not what you don’t want?’ There is a great temptation for managers to focus on the negative in coastal prairie; too often coastal prairie managers say ‘I don’t want non-native grasses,’ with the ensuing endless stewardship battle as wave after wave of new non-native grasses invade following whatever stewardship attempt there was to control the preceding non-native grass management priority. I call this the exotic plant treadmill: one after the next weed keeps coming unless you focus on managing for what you want, the existing native species, to give them a chance to thrive in those same places.

It will be very interesting to see the BLM’s Science Plan for Cotoni Coast Dairies. I wonder how the science and procedures I outlined above might be applied to the property’s extensive coastal prairies.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

FROM GARY A. PATTON  From Gary’s “We Live In A Political World” website…

September 4
#247 / Sign That Petition!

Today’s blog posting is specifically addressed to residents of the City of Santa Cruz. Currently, volunteer signature gatherers are attempting to qualify an initiative measure for the City election to be held in March of next year. Supporters are calling the proposed initiative measure, “Housing For People.” Click that link to find out more about it. You can click the following link, too, to read coverage in the Santa Cruz Sentinel.

In essence, the proposed initiative measure would do two things, presuming that the measure qualifies for the ballot and is then enacted by the voters:

First, the initiative would increase the City’s so-called “inclusionary percentage” from 20% to 25%. When developers build new housing units, the City currently requires that 20% of these new units be reserved for persons with average or below average incomes. Given the housing prices that are set by the private market, this inclusionary requirement is one of the only ways that the City can insure that new development actually opens up new housing opportunities for ordinary, working people and their kids.

Unfortunately, the State Legislature is doing everything it can to reduce the ability of local inclusionary ordinances to make sure that at least some significant share of the new development occurring will benefit average and below average income people. Recent state laws essentially reduce the impact of the inclusionary percentages set by the local City Council, or the voters. That is one reason that the initiative measure now in circulation is so important. It is a way to make sure that we get the maximum amount of affordable housing possible, as new development occurs – even as recent state laws act to reduce, not increase, the mandated affordable housing percentage. Upping the local inclusionary percentage works against these state law efforts to reduce local requirements to benefit the developers.

Second – and I personally think that this is also important – the initiative measure, if ultimately enacted, will require the voters to approve any increase to the height limits currently set in the City’s General Plan and Zoning Ordinance.

The City’s Planning Director was proposing new developments in the “South of Laurel” area that would be on the order of twenty-one (21) stories high – more than twice the height of the Dream Inn. Right after his election last year, Mayor Fred Keeley suggested that the Council reduce this to twelve (12) stories, maximum, and the Council backed up that idea. However, no final decision on height limits in the so-called “South of Laurel” neighborhood has yet been established, and it is worth noting that twelve stories (while much less than twenty-one stories) is still about TWICE the height of the new development at the corner of Laurel and Pacific, as pictured in that Sentinel article.

The proposed initiative measure is being promoted on the following basis:

Secure Your Right To Vote On Height

When the Save Lighthouse Point Association took action to “Save Lighthouse Field,” back in the early 1970’s – an effort in which I was personally involved – one of the key ways that voters headed off planning policies that really didn’t take account of what City residents wanted was by passing an initiative measure that was placed on the June 1974 ballot.

Some have told me that our local community is no longer all that concerned about giving voters real power over the future development of the City. I hope that’s not true. In our system of self-government, City voters ARE the City.

So, let’s up that inclusionary percentage! Let’s “Secure Our Right To Vote on Height!”

Sign that petition!

Even better, get a copy of the petition measure, by clicking this link, and get your friends and neighbors involved, too.

Time is short and the stakes are very high!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
September 4

SANCHISMOS, COPYRIGHTS AND ROLLLING THE DICE

While the phrase ’tilting at windmills’ may not apply directly to our disgraced former president, most experts agree that he exhibits the classic paranoid personality disorder in his eccentric, odd behavior. That is borne out by his suspicions of those around him, along with his refusing to take blame for his past deeds. The Orange Don Quixote, who betrayed the country while catering to a long-time foreign enemy, had his Sancho Panza in the person of White House Chief of Staff, Mark Meadows, who proved to be incapable of being a voice of reason in dissuading his master’s delusional treachery, his ‘sanchismos’ not able to break through The Don’s fantasies. VP Pence lost his ‘sidekick’ designation in the game to throw out the election results, making Meadows a most intriguing persona within the coup team.

He knows all the secrets, where the skeletons are hidden, and where the bodies are buried, but was playing both sides as the investigation dragged on, even as his aide, Cassidy Hutchinson, spilled the jar of beans before the J6 Committee. After his indictment, Meadows sought in a hearing to have his case moved to federal court, where he will attempt to assert immunity as a federal officer during which he was simply doing his job under the Former Guy. At this writing the judge has not made a decision on the switch, but either way, Meadows is going to have to make a decision quickly about whether he will take the bullet for Trump. Meadows’ attorney wrote in his court filings, “These and the other acts that form the basis for the charges against Mr. Meadows all fall squarely within his conduct as Chief of Staff. This is precisely the kind of state interference in a federal official’s duties that the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution prohibits, and that the removal statute shields against.” Advantages for Meadows in moving to federal court would widen the jury pool to an area more GOP-heavy, plus a televised trial is not likely which would expose him to more embarrassment during the trial.

For the above hearing, DA Fani Willis subpoenaed Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger and two others who were present during the infamous “find 11,780 votes” phone call that precipitated two charges against Meadows. In court filings, it was noted that a government watchdog agency found Meadows and other Trump officials in their political activity prior to the election violated federal law. “Since the defendant was forbidden by law to use his authority or influence to interfere with or affect the result of an election or otherwise participate in activity directed toward the success of Mr. Trump as a candidate for the presidency, every single one of these activities fell outside the scope of his duties, both as a matter of fact and as a matter of law,” prosecutors wrote. Should these activities be adjudged to be in the scope of his duties, Meadows must then prove he has a tenable federal defense.

A brief written by eight prosecutors and federal officials backing the prosecutors in the Georgia case, all having served in GOP administrations. One of the individuals was J. Michael Luttig, a former federal appeals court judge with whom we are familiar from his appearance before the J6 Committee and numerous talk shows. The eight wrote, “The purpose of federal-officer removal statute – to protect federal operations by preventing retribution in state court for locally unpopular exercises of federal authority – would not be served by removal here. To the contrary, removal would be perverse, as this prosecution arises from interference with state-government operations and seeks to vindicate Georgia’s voice in a federal election, the very contest from which federal authority flows.” If the judge rules in favor of Meadows‘ move to the federal court, others indicted in the case will attempt to do the same and it is feared that all co-defendants will automatically be moved, as is being argued by indicted former Trump Justice Department official, Jeffrey Clark, whose hearing is scheduled for September 18. We can be certain that Trump is watching closely, though he unsuccessfully tried to move his New York hush money case to federal court, which is under appeal.

A commenter on the Quorum website says, “In a shocking roll of the legal dice, Mark Meadows preemptively put himself on the stand during pre-trial motions in a desperate attempt to convince a judge that participating in a wildly illegal and extremely clumsy conspiracy to overthrow our democracy with a crackpot team of America’s worst lawyers and ideological sociopaths was somehow “part of the job” of being Chief of Staff to the president…riiiiiiiiight!” Bill Palmer on his blog writes, “It’s one thing for Meadows to try the low percentage play of trying to get his Fulton Country criminal charges moved to federal court. Even though he’s unlikely to win, it can’t hurt to try, right? Actually, it can hurt to try, quite a bit, when you’re as much of an idiot as Meadows is. Meadows made the ground-breakingly stupid decision to take the stand under oath during the hearing about moving the trial. During that testimony he appears to have committed perjury, which can disqualify his request and get him hit with additional criminal charges. But it gets stupider. Meadows’ stated reason for going along with Donald Trump’s criminal plot to overthrow the election? He said that if he didn’t go along with it, ‘I know I would get yelled at’ by Trump. No really, he said this, on the witness stand. This admission wipes out a whole range of reasonable doubt defenses that Meadows might have tried to use. Meadows just made it a whole lot easier to convict him a trial. Meadows keeps proving himself to be astoundingly stupid. Fiction writers would have a hard time coming up with this character and making it believable.” As Sancho would say, “Hope is a good breakfast, but a bad supper.”

The aforementioned judge J. Michael Luttig in a recent appearance on Nicolle Wallace’s MSNBC show, claims that he has never been a “political person, or a political partisan” though he held the views, beliefs and principles, and the policy positions of the GOP during his lifetime. He is troubled by the current position and direction of today’s Republican party and is hopeful that it will come to its senses, both collectively and constitutionally. Together with Harvard’s Laurence Tribe, Luttig penned a column in the New York Times explaining their belief that Trump can be barred from holding office by using the 14th Amendment of the Constitution. Both the Attorney General and the Secretary of State of New Hampshire announced that they are seriously considering barring Trump’s name from the state ballot, based on Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, which states that those who have “engaged in insurrection or rebellion” may be disqualified from running for office again…for which Trump has been indicted.

Or how about, as Bocha Blue writes on the Palmer Report, that Trump be tried as an axe murderer? He quotes Georgia Republican and former Lieutenant Governor Geoff Duncan’s harsh words about Trump and Republicans in general as saying, “Trump has the moral compass of an axe murderer.” Sans axe, Trump managed to kill hundreds through his COVID-19 negligence, and his fomenting of the insurrection resulted in the death of one rioter and eventually several Capitol police officers. Blue says, “So yes, there is blood on Donald Trump’s hands. I thank Duncan for these remarks, not that they will have any weight with the Republican party, but in this case, it’s the thought that counts.”

The Lincoln Project website points to people trying to compare the Georgia case, with Trump and the 18 co-conspirators, to Watergate, but analyzes it as going much deeper because it indicts every member of the GOP…senators, congress members, staffers, the RNC, big money donors…corruption that goes to the very core of the GOP. And that’s why the Former Guy is being defended so vociferously…the whole bunch is tainted! President Nixon had to reckon with his own party, which had a moral conviction in evidence which has long since disappeared. Trump’s criminal enterprise is so feared that it’s easier to go along, in an attempt to legitimize the lies and false conspiracies. Sadly, these ignoramuses have the ear of a good portion of the American electorate who are scarfing up those “Never Surrender” mug-shot mugs, posters and t-shirts following Trump’s surrender.

SiriusXM radio host Dean Obeidallah thinks a legitimate legal case can be made against Trump, that he has violated U.S. copyright laws by hawking merchandise using the Fulton County mugshot. Indictment Don bragged that $7M flowed into his coffers from the $34 t-shirts and $25 mugs as soon as they were offered, but the rightful recipient of that money may be the Fulton County Sheriff’s department, an entity which could use a huge influx of funds for its ailing, poor conditions. According to a 2022 article in the University of Georgia School of Law’s Journal of Intellectual Property Law, “In the context of photographs taken by law enforcement during the booking process, the author of the mugshot photograph is the law enforcement agency.” So, does Fulton County want to see The Don in court…again…over copyright infringement?

Aldous J. Pennyfarthing writes, “After being mugshot (mugshouted? mugsharted?), Trump returned to X, which is what nobody calls the platform formerly known as Twitter, to send an X, which is what nobody calls a post formerly known as a ‘tweet,’ to his supporters in the death cult, which is what many of us call the party formerly known as the GOP. The sweet included Trump’s mugshot and a grift summons. Remarkably, QAnon folks saw something in it other than a surly, glowering weirdo who looks like he’s on Day Two of a three-day Strawberry Yoo-hoo cleanse. ‘It’s always darkest before the storm,’ one Trump supporter tweeted in response to the mugshot. ‘Tsunami Trump is coming for the swamp.'” Aldous J. questions the statement with, “Wouldn’t a tsunami make swamp immeasurably worse? Shouldn’t that be Wet Vac Trump? Or Intracranial Stent Trump?” It has been said that Donald Trump can be described as “a poor man’s idea of a rich man, a weak man’s idea of a strong man, and a dumb man’s idea of a smart man.” Touché! As Steve Schmidt said, “America has had its share of president’s who were crooks (Warren G. Harding, Richard Nixon), bigots (Andrew Jackson, James Buchanan), and incompetents (Andrew Johnson, George W. Bush). But never before Donald Trump have we had a president who combined all these qualities.”

Trump, in one of his Fox News & Agitprop interviews recalled the cognitive test he took during his presidency, under the supervision of White House doctor Ronny Jackson, and indicating that he had taken another test recently. “If you’re in the office of the presidency, we have to be sharp. The exam was 30 or 35 questions. The first questions are very easy, the last questions are much more difficult.” And we all remember the to-do he made earlier over the memory portion, of his being able to recall the words, “person, woman, man, camera, TV” Trump went on to say that his results impressed the medical staff, “They say, ‘Nobody gets it in order.’ It’s not that easy, but for me it was easy. And that’s not any easy question. They say, ‘That’s amazing, how did you do that?’ I do it because I have, like, a good memory. Because I’m cognitively there. Joe Biden should take the test.” Court, jury, verdict, prison…repeat those words several times, Donny.

After Trump’s mugshot was released, Georgia artist Chris Veal began painting a large mural on a building in Atlanta, using the photo in his creation, with right-wingers applauding what they thought was a protest against the arrest of the former prez. Veal finished his mural, to which a word bubble was added, which read, “M.A.G.A. My Ass Got Arrested.” The artist says feedback has been positive, with passersby smiling, laughing and giving him high-fives.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com. 
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Hawaii”

 “I thought my book was done, then we went to Hawaii and the whole last chapter happened.”
~Mariel Hemingway

“Hawaii is still the single most frequent fantasy destination, not because of political stability or conveniences, but because Hawaii seduces the imagination. It’s the perfect postcard – no props, no fillers.”
~Robert Wintner

“Hawaii is a paradise born of fire.”-
~Rand McNally

...

Have some fun! Here’s a bit of standup from Matteo Lane, one of my recent favorites 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment