July 5 – 11, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…protect our North Coast again, average penis length, movie critiques. Greensite…on how EIRs are manipulated: Downtown Plan Extension. Schendledecker… Skypark! toxic waste disposal! Public trust fund! Steinbruner…County planning dept., county fire dept. & grand Jury, Sheriff Dept. and surveillance composting toilet, Harbor Village, construction consultants $$$, skyscraper canyons. Hayes…Oaks, terrestrial coral analogues. Patton…community over Capital. Matlock…moms, courts and pit-bulls unleashed. Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes “Butterflies”

...

PACIFIC AND CATHCART STREETS, NOVEMBER 29, 1950.  This corner has gone through many changes since this photo. It was actually the Good Times building in the 80’s then Hoffman’s Bistro then Kianti’s Pizza.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE JULY 3

PROTECT OUR NORTH COAST…RIGHT NOW AND AGAIN. I arrived in Santa Cruz County (1970) just in time to help stop PG&E from building their Nuclear Power Plant in Davenport. Then again in the mid 70s we had the enormous battle against developers building 10,000 new houses in Wilder Ranch. Davenport and the North Coast now once again face just a large and threatening a danger…THE COAST COTONI NATIONAL MONUMENT.

The group Friends of the North Coast have valiantly been trying to arouse as many of us as possible to make any/all development as green and livable as possible. Go here to read and learn what FONC is all about… They just sent out a special wakeup call this week with this statement:

“Now that the property is a national monument, visitation and use can increase exponentially, as happened with Ft. Ord, where visitors jumped from 40,000 to 400,000 within a few years of its designation as a national monument”.

That’s 4000,000 in cars driving our Highway One and if you think Highway One is crowded now…wait and worry.

Next go here and see how so much more can be and should be done to preserve what we still have along that precious North Coast.

MY HOW YOU’VE GROAN!
According to the July 3rd issue of the New Yorker …research at King’s College (London) and at the University of Turin (Italy) the average size of the male penis “is 3.6 inches long when flaccid, and 5.2 inches erect. (The average girth is 3.5 inches flaccid, and 4.6 inches erect.)” And now we know!!!

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

TAKE CARE OF MAYA. (NETFLIX DOCUMENTARY MOVIE) (8.1 IMDB). A very devastating document for what has happened and continues to happen when hospitals and “Child Protective Services” cover up their mistakes and blame parents by calling them Child abusers and create prolonged cases in courts, with parents losing. This true case happened in Venice, Florida but exists in many locales. The hospital kept Maya a prisoner for three full months for only so called legal reasons.

INDIANA JONES AND THE DIAL OF DESTINY. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (6.9 IMDB). A very poor wrap-up and closer to the Indiana Jones series that started with such a literal bang. It’s stuffed full of CGI car chases, bloody roof jumping and the much ballyhooed restoration of Harrison Ford. It doesn’t help but Antonio Banderas and Mads Mikkelsen are almost hidden in it. It’s shallow, monotonous, pointless and painful…don’t go.

BLOODHOUNDS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.1 IMDB).   Another Korean film that accomplishes exactly what was intended …and it works. It’s about loan sharks, everybody wearing covid masks, and guts flying everywhere. Guts fly because the lead characters are not just close buddies but also are boxers…Korean style boxers of course.

ROCK HUDSON-ALL THAT HEAVEN ALLOWED. (MAX DOCUMENTARY MOVIE) 7.8 IMDB). Rock Hudson’s real names were Roy Scherer jr. and Roy Fitzgerald. He died from AIDS in 1984 and was a Republican. He was gay and only hid it from the public, not his friends and fellow actors. He mainly did musicals and comedies and the 70’s were his decade. Doris Day and Elizabeth Taylor both liked him as a person and co-star. He starred big in Giant and author Armistead Maupin tells a lot of the background.

ARMAGEDDON TIME. (AMAZON PRIME MOVIE) (6.5 IMDB). This is a slow tearjerker of a movie with stars like Anthony Hopkins and Anne Hathaway leading the cast. It’s about New York City, it’s about being Jewish, it deals with Nazis and there’s even a character named Fred Trump in it for no good reason. Fred Trump was Donald Trump’s Dad and he died in 1999. It touches on father abuses among other issues, and it’s set in the 1980’s.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

EXTRAORDINARY ATTORNEY WOO. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.7 IMDB). According to some recent article Korean films are leading the world in popularity nowadays. That proves true with this one. Attorney Woo is an autistic and brilliant young woman attorney (27 years old). The plot and drama and the laughs in the first episode makes this well worth hanging with. She defends a senior wife who hit her husband with a clothes iron. Serious, funny heartfelt and worth watching.

HUNGER. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). A Thai film that gets deeper by the minute as it deals with a high end restaurant named Hunger. The head chef is mean, cruel and very successful and he trains his staff of ex noodle joint kids in ways to make all foods into art pieces…but at what cost personally? Vegies might not like this one.

SLEEPING DOG. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.01 IMDB). This tricky German movie about a policeman who has amnesia and is then assigned a new rookie to investigate a murder case that was supposed to have been solved. It turns out that the police department has some issues that make this a pretty good movie.

BLACK MIRROR. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.8 IMDB). They call it an anthology series. That means 27 separate episodes, each with its own separate plot and stars. Well-directed and nicely paced and stars such as Jon Hamm, Salma Hayek, Rory Kinnear, Miley Cyrus, Annie Murphy, and Oona Chaplin all have good parts in one of the series. Odd, fascinating, perplexing and well worth watching.

LOUIS ARMSTRONG- BLACK & BLUES. (APPLE TV) (7.4 IMDB). This documentary should be required viewing, especially for Americans. His early New Orleans history, his world travels, his use of marijuana way back when, and especially his side of the scene involving race relations after being accused of Uncle Tomism for decades. Orson Welles, Dick Cavett, Ed Murrow, Leonard Bernstein are a few of the stars in this dynamite treasure.

...

July 3

(Double) Talking Traffic

It’s not a good sign when the public is vastly outnumbered by top level city staff at a city council meeting. The three back rows of senior staff include Planning director, Assistant Planning director, Public Works director and Transportation manager. I am the sole speaker from the public. The Consent Agenda item proposes a further allocation of monies ($295,000) to consultants Kimley-Horn for the traffic study on the Downtown Plan Extension Project. I am speaking to the item because I read the traffic study will be limited to weekdays only.

That’s right. Weekend traffic won’t be studied in the environmental review (EIR) for a major project in an area currently grid-locked on most summer weekends. That omission means mitigations cannot be proposed in the EIR or implemented.

This is the largest single project in the history of Santa Cruz. The proposed housing will bring an additional three to four thousand people into a relatively small area between Laurel Street and the first roundabout. An anticipated 1600 new housing units will be built in multiple 12 story (minimum) structures, plus a new enlarged Warriors stadium. The main road impacted is Front Street, the major route taken by summer tourist traffic and by residents on the lower westside.

Although I was the only member of the public expressing concerns (go figure), after I spoke the issue was taken up by councilmembers Sonja Brunner and Sandy Brown, who asked staff to explain the lack of inclusion of weekend traffic in the study. First the Transportation manager had a crack at it and then the Planning director weighed in.

Their reasons (my comments in italics) for excluding weekends from the traffic study are:

  • Adding weekends would be very expensive. (you don’t omit CEQA issues due to expense).
  • Doesn’t need to be studied if within half a mile of a high-quality transportation hub.
  • Conflicts with the General Plan which accepts more congestion downtown to make it more bike and pedestrian friendly. (this area is not yet “downtown”).
  • Studying weekends would show a need to widen the road which is not good for bikes and pedestrians. (there are several mitigations that don’t require road widening).
  • Would leave less land for development.
  • We don’t need to analyze to know traffic is heavy on the weekends. (doesn’t pass the CEQA test).
  • Study will be done on connecting Laurel St. Extension to Third Street; connecting to that neighborhood and the beach. (take note Beach Hill neighbors).
  • Need to reduce traffic demand (i.e., driving) for people driving in the area. (take note lower westside residents).
  • Level of Service (LOS) or a measure of delay is outside the scope of CEQA. (Not true if local conditions warrant a study of LOS.)

Councilmember Brunner persisted in her questioning and sent a strong message that she wants the issue of emergency vehicle access to have priority emphasis as the project and public meetings proceed. Councilmember Brown added her concerns that these significant impacts are not being fully addressed and supported Brunner’s emphasis on emergency vehicle access.

The Sentinel subsequently covered the issue in a prominent article by reporter Aric Sleeper. If a question had not been raised at the council meeting it is likely that this item, just one out of thirty-three other consent agenda items would have been approved without comment.

In October of 2022 the public was invited to contribute to a Scoping document for the project. This is a formal opportunity prior to the preparation of a draft EIR for the public to comment on what it wants included in the draft EIR. Below is an extract of what I submitted at that time. Other items I included in the original were about light pollution and habitat. You can judge if my requests on traffic and public services were considered or ignored.

Re: Scoping Comments for Downtown Plan Extension Project EIR

October 16, 2022

Dear Ms. Neuse,

The following are my comments submitted for the Downtown Plan Extension Project Subsequent Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR). Thank you for your careful consideration.

Public Services

  1. Assess the ability of emergency vehicles (police, fire, ambulance) to access the beach area, Wharf and Boardwalk during summer weekends when traffic currently is grid-locked at the roundabouts. Assess this impact, taking into account the additional traffic generated by 4000 new residents as well as increased commercial and visitor- serving establishments in the project area.

Transportation:

  1. Assess the increase in VMT from the thousands of residents of the lower westside who will divert away from this area due to gridlock and travel to and from their homes via Mission St.
  2. Factor in the delivery vehicles who currently use this route to make deliveries to the Wharf and Beach area, who will divert to Mission St. or California and then Bay St. to avoid gridlock.
  3. While VMT is required under CEQA, that law allows congestion to be studied if there are local conditions that warrant such study. Such conditions exist in the project area. Currently, the roundabout within the project area is grid-locked on summer weekends. Assess the congestion that will be aggravated by this project and fully mitigate. One mitigation is to re-divert beach-going traffic away from the project area so that the increase in traffic can be spread-out between Ocean St. and Front St. Consider a Boardwalk parking entrance and exit at the back as well as the existing front entrance to avoid the current situation of inbound Boardwalk traffic needing to navigate two congested round-abouts.

Fair to say that my comments were ignored if the statements from the Transportation manager and the Planning director at the council meeting are any indication. You should be concerned that the city of Santa Cruz Planning Department is not serving the public. The description from the council meeting is how the environmental review will likely be skewed. The significant impacts of this massive project will be manipulated into insignificance unless more people pay attention and demand better.

There will be more public meetings as well as the release of a draft EIR in probably late summer. There are new groups in town who love all development and could care less about the impacts on neighborhoods. They rely on residents being too busy or too distracted to follow the various meetings and agenda reports. They appear to have a Planning Department in their hip pocket. Time to get involved. There are supportive council members. They need to hear from us.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

July 3

SKYPARK! TOXIC WASTE DISPOSAL! PUBLIC TRUST FUND!

Guest columnist Tyler Maldonado, with Joy Schendledecker

City Council met in closed sessions on June 13th and again June 27th regarding real property negotiations over Skypark in Scotts Valley. Valued at $8.5 million, the 8.15 acre vacant lot is one of many abandoned airports in California, and is located on Mt. Hermon Road between Nob Hill and Target.

Closed session meetings are not open to the public, and parties to the meeting are disallowed from disclosing information gained from it following section 54963 of the Brown Act. Both lead negotiators, Director of Economic Development for Santa Cruz Bonnie Lipscomb and city manager Mali Lagoe of Scotts Valley did not comment for this reason.

According to Santa Cruz City law, proceeds from the sale of the Skypark Property are earmarked for the Public Trust Fund, a fund established in a Council Policy Manual update in 1998 to support capital improvement projects in Santa Cruz. Ongoing and future capital improvement projects are annually developed in the 3-year Capital Improvement Plan and can be found on the city’s website.

What does Public Trust Fund money actually fund? May 19, 2022, Planning Commission meeting, the 2023-2027 Capital Improvement Program Consistency with General Plan was presented. In 2022, Public Trust Fund monies went to projects like: new Harvey West Ballfield Lighting, the Cowell Beach Water Quality Project, City Residential and Collector Street Reconstruction and Overlay (aka repaving some streets), downtown bike locker replacements and signage, parking garage maintenance and upgrades, some wharf piling replacements, a “Space Utilization Plan” for City Hall, and to the Downtown Library Affordable Housing Project for early phase design and development of the downtown Library/ mixed use affordable housing project (and the list goes on).

In summary, more than $1 million was transferred from the Public Trust Fund to a variety of General Fund line items last year.

Additionally, on November 15, 2022, city council approved a $1.8 million Public Trust Fund-funded loan to For the Future Housing, Inc., affordable housing developer for a project on River Street (which seems like a good use, while some of the 2022 spending seems to stretch the approved uses).

“The City Council majority will have a say in what the money gets spent on, and those decisions would occur in a public meeting,” wrote Santa Cruz city councilmember Sandy Brown in an email response to an inquiry about how the anticipated proceeds of the Skypark sale would be spent.

Brown wrote that Scotts Valley is planning for a “town center,” in line with previous efforts to develop the property, according to the Scotts Valley Downtown Specific Plan established in 2008 to, “guide the development of a mixed-use node that will become the heart of the city.”

The city of Santa Cruz sold the property in 2018 to Scotts Valley Town Green Land LLC, a coalition of Bay Area developers for $8.5 million. Less than a year later, the developers walked away from the contract due in part to concerns over the cost of environmental cleanup of the site, which contained toxic materials such as arsenic and benzene.

Where will that contaminated soil end up? According to a January 2023 Calmatters investigation called, “Out of Site, Out of Mind,” it will likely go to one of two toxic waste landfills near indigenous land in Arizona or Utah. The full report is worth a deep read, but at least look at the summary news story. If and when the city is finally able to sell this toxic land, a stipulation of that sale should be that the soil is disposed of within California, preferably as close to Santa Cruz as possible. There is no possible environmental justice in sending it elsewhere.

The parcel was appraised at $8.3 million “as is” in 2017 by Zeller Appraisal Services for the City of Santa Cruz according to a Sentinel report, meaning the appraiser factored the cost of the cleanup into the valuation of the land.

That valuation was approved by the Santa Cruz city council in closed session and sent to Scotts Valley sometime in the spring of 2017, the Press Banner reported, which led the developer at the time Foothill Partners Inc. to pull out of the project. A year later, Scotts Valley Town Green Land LLC offered to purchase the site for $8.5 million to develop it into the “Scotts Valley Town Center,” a mixed-use development with 350 residential units above retail and entertainment-focused businesses.

Writing for the Good Times in May 2019, Alisha Green reported on the intersecting motivations at the time of the city of Scotts Valley and Town Green Land LLC that brought the project about in the first place. Seeking increased revenue from retail sales tax to offset a million-dollar-deficit, Scotts Valley pushed for increased retail space. Scotts Valley is projected to have a $5.2 million deficit for fiscal year 2023-2024, according to their budget report.

“One of the challenges with housing for me is that—I don’t have a nice number—but I know that housing, in my opinion, costs more in services than we receive in taxes,” Scotts Valley mayor at the time Jack Dilles was reported to have commented at the time.

“Our challenge will be to squeeze the developer so we can get what we want, at the same time there has to be profit in it for them to make it worthwhile,” Former Mayor Reed said in 2018, when the first phase of the development was being negotiated.

Developers on the other hand sought to build more housing, as residential rents would form the bulk of the profits. After a series of community meetings, those 350 units were reduced to 225 in February 2019; the developer pulled out of the project.

“The project that evolved for us, which reduced the housing component and maintained the original retail, did not have enough revenue to offset the costs,” Doug Ross, one of the leaders of the project, reportedly said.

Scotts Valley’s 6th housing element identifies 1,220 total and 392 “very low” affordable units as Scotts Valley’s share of necessary housing. If Scotts Valley doesn’t meet its RHNA goals, California’s Builder’s Remedy, a portion of the Housing Accountability Act of 2017 allows developers to bypass certain local restrictions if they meet some inclusionary affordable housing requirements.

Scotts Valley City law requires that 15% of all housing developments be deed-restricted as “below market rate”, affordable to someone making between 50 and 120% of the area’s median income.

“Because the state has ruled that local inclusionary ordinances can only apply to the base density of a project, we are not really getting any additional affordable units in projects that can seek up to 50% more units, by right,” Brown pointed out. Given this, Scotts Valley could allow developers to build a town center with as few as 10% “Below Market Rate” units.

If a sale finally goes through after multiple failed attempts, Scotts Valley could have its retail-focused town center and consequent tax revenues and meet some of its RHNA goal, and developers could make quite a buck with the state’s stick hanging over the city’s head, the question we are left with is this: what would Santa Cruz get? Given that the Public Trust Fund has been historically stretched to include all kinds of projects, general fund line items and even affordable housing financing, the direction of the funding seems likely to go wherever the city council points.

Perhaps with strong enough public opinion, it could even point in the right direction.

This column was initiated by, and largely researched and written by, Tyler Maldonado. I provided feedback, a little bit of writing, and a very small bit of research. Thanks Tyler!

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...

(Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022 schendledecker@icloud.com).

July 3

PUBLIC COMMENT ON COUNTY HOUSING ELEMENT ENDS

NEXT TUESDAY July 11

It is critical that the County Planning Dept. hear from  you  about where to place dense infill development in the unincorporated areas of the Community, and your last chance of substance to do so is next Tuesday, July 11.  This is the update to the County General Plan, and will shape the quality of life in our Community for future generations.

The Project documents are in the link below, but first take time to look at what the two Stakeholder Committees recommended in Appendix C

Will the Planning Dept. staff follow these recommendations?

In the meantime, it is important that you read through their Recommendations and make your own by next Tuesday.  E-mail them to:

2023HousingElement@santacruzcounty.us   or click on the yellow button in the Project document website below:

Project Documents

DISAPPOINTING THAT THE GRAND JURY CHOSE NOT TO REVIEW FIRE DEPT. IMPLEMENTATION OF PAST RECOMMENDATIONS

One of the Grand Jury Reports just issued is “Honoring Commitments to the Public”.  I was really hoping the Grand Jury would review the lack of an After Action Analysis by Santa Cruz County Fire Department and CalFire after the 2020 CZU Fire, to interview the Volunteers and determine what worked well and what did not.  This is a crucial aspect of planning for future emergency response.   However, I was disappointed to read this:

“The Grand Jury also reviewed Ready? Aim? Fire!; however, follow-up responses to this
2019-2020 investigation were not pursued, since over the past three years there has
been a major wildfire and three more fire-related Grand Jury investigations.
The value of the Grand Jury’s reports is realized when government agencies apply the recommendations to improve transparency and efficiency for county residents.”

Well, it would be great if the agencies actually did act in a manner improving transparency, wouldn’t it?

GRAND JURY REPORT ON SHERIFF DEPT. USE OF SURVEILLANCE

The Grand Jury did some good investigative work on other issues, namely the issue of Sheriff Dept. use of surveillance equipment, notably in the jails.

Here is the link to the Press Banner’s analysis of the report

Here is the report

Other Reports just released by the Grand Jury are here and are worth reading:

2022-2023 Grand Jury Reports and Responses

WOULD THIS SPEED PERMIT APPLICATION PROCESSING?

Last Tuesday, the County Board of Supervisors Consent Agenda was bursting, numbering —–items.  One Item, #29, proposed requiring the Planning Dept. to return within 90 days to report on the possibility of allowing building permit applicants to opt for having a Third Party Plan Check company review their plans, rather than the Planning Dept. staff.

The Planning Dept. has quite a few vacancies, leading to sluggish permit processing times:

Background

As of June 6th, 2023, the County’s Performance Measurement Dashboard for the Permit Center showed the following median processing times: Single Family Dwellings – 64 days; Remodel – 107 days; Multi-Family Housing – 154 days; ADU – 197 days. On average, 18% of this time is the result of the applicant responding to comments, and 82% is county staff’s review time.

Between March 7, 2023, and June 6, 2023, there was an increase in the median processing time for permits in all categories. Specifically, the processing time for a remodel permit increased 10.31% from a median of 97 days to 107 days.

Agenda Item DOC-2023-556

It will be interesting to see what the Planning Dept. staff reports to the Board on this.  When the Board hired 4Leaf consultants to handle the CZU Fire permitting work, Planning Dept. staff complained, seemingly worried about their job security.

COUNTY COMPOSTING TOILET PILOT PROJECT MOVES TO WATSONVILLE

Another Consent Agenda item last Tuesday included changing the location of the County’s Composting Toilet Pilot Project from Crest Ranch in Bonny Doon to the Watsonville City Wastewater Treatment Plant in order to expedite permitting and avoid CEQA analysis.  Now the bio-solids will be collected at the Ben Lomond Transfer Station, and transported to Watsonville for composting.

The idea was originally meant to help the CZU Fire Survivors rebuild their homes more quickly and to potentially avoid having to install the very expensive Alternative Systems that cost $75,000 or more as well as expensive geotechnical analysis for septic leach fields, now required by the County in many areas.  The Supervisors approved a pilot project to compost waste at Crest Ranch, but permitting has been a problem.

Background

The Santa Cruz County CBS Pilot was brought to the Board and approved in October 2022 to further support the rebuilding efforts of families impacted by the 2020 CZU Lightning Complex Fire. When the item was brought before the Board last year, only 14 of the 911 homes destroyed in the 2020 CZU Fire had been successfully rebuilt. Since then, 28 CZU-impacted households have successfully rebuilt their homes.

Agenda Item
DOC-2023-557

The Pilot Project is being enthusiastically shepherded by Watsonville City Sanitation Engineer, Mr. Ryan Smith. He testified before the County Board of Supervisors multiple times supporting the use of the alternative composting toilets when the County’s septic system ordinance was under State-mandated revision.

As the Chief Plant Operator at the City’s Wastewater Treatment Plant, Ryan Smith will provide on-site support and supervise the project with GiveLove. The City of Watsonville’s Public Works and Utilities Department has strongly supported this pilot and has agreed to host the Composting site at the treatment plant. Ryan Smith has led efforts on behalf of GiveLove to develop a license agreement between GiveLove & the City of Watsonville. On June 13th, the City of Watsonville’s city council adopted a resolution to execute the license agreement necessary to host the pilot project at the Watsonville Wastewater Treatment Plant.

So now, the six-month Pilot Project will allow 25 households in the CZU Fire area to get free composting toilet kits (usually costing $400 each).  The company providing the kits, GiveLove, will collect the data necessary to inform the Board next year about the success of the Pilot Project, allowing the Board to consider expanding the effort going forward.

This will be interesting to watch…stay tuned.

FORMER HOTEL SITE NEAR THE HARBOR IS NOW

EXCESS PROPERTY TO SELL

Back in 2017, the County Redevelopment Successor Agency wanted to give Barry Swenson exclusive development rights to a large County-owned parcel at 7th Avenue and Brommer, overlooking the harbor.  Maybe you went to those hearings, too, and heard the oily description of the massive project that would include an upscale hotel, condos and yurts for the “Visitor Accommodation” project. Proposed Development

Thank goodness, the County rescinded the deal with Swenson, however, last Tuesday, the Board officially declared the parcel “Surplus Property” and will offer it for sale. This was slipped through in Consent Agenda Item #35.

Here is what happens next:

Following adoption of a surplus resolution, the Surplus Lands Act (SLA) requires the Redevelopment Successor Agency (RSA) to issue a Notice of Availability for open space and for low-, moderate-income housing purposes to all required entities as provided in Government Code section 54221(f)(2) and 54222(a) and allow 60 days for response.  If a responsive notice of interest is received within the 60-day period, then the RSA is required to negotiate in good faith for at least 90 days to attempt to reach terms of sale. If mutually acceptable terms of sale are not reached within the 90-day negotiation period, then the Property may be sold outside of the requirements of the SLA (except that a limited affordability covenant must be recorded against the Property). 

The Property is surplus to RSA needs and not necessary for RSA’s use. It is therefore recommended to adopt a resolution declaring the Property surplus and stating the RSA’s intent to sell the Property.

Financial Impact

Upon successful negotiation for disposition, sale of the Property will result in proceeds that will be distributed to the various taxing entities consistent with the share of the property tax received following approval of one or more Development and Disposition Agreements (DDAs) or other form of document approved by the RSA Board and the Santa Cruz County Consolidated Redevelopment Oversight Board.

The Project will offer the opportunity for an increase and diversity of housing options on the Site.

The Project will stimulate the economy offering lodging, shopping, dining, and indoor/outdoor gathering places.

Agenda Item DOC-2023-562

What exactly will that mean???  Keep your eye on this and contact your County Supervisor when they all return from vacation on August 1.

831-454-2200

APPROVING A QUESTIONABLE CONTRACT WITH CALFIRE

Another large expensive, potentially controversial Consent Item the Board of Supervisors swept under the rug was #46, approving a one-year $7.3 million contract with CalFire to train the Santa Cruz County Fire Dept. Volunteers.

Agenda Item
DOC-2023-573

Here is why I felt the Board should have rejected the contract:

Dear Board, You need to consider this contract AS THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF SANTA CRUZ COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT, not at the Board of Supervisors. The augmented $899,514 to pay for six additional engineers/drivers was supposed to be paid for by the CSA 48 2020 Special Benefit Assessment action. Property owners were also told the new tax would allow a cost-saving three-year contract with CalFire…this is not the case now. Claiming a large cost saving due to arbitrarily reducing the Amador Agreement time is bogus and only saves money on paper. The Fire Dept. Advisory Commission was not happy with the way CalFire Chief Armstrong manipulated the information when it was presented, and the Commissioners voiced concern that CalFire is becoming more dependent on CSA 48 monies buying new equipment that CalFire then leases on demand. This proposed Contract also eliminates local in-house plan checks, and relies on a contracting agency that is far removed from Santa Cruz County and may know little about the needs of the public and building and fire matters, especially relating to topography. Please do not approve this contract. It does not serve the public safety needs of the people, and promotes the needs of CalFire at the expense of the Santa Cruz County Fire Dept. volunteers who are treated poorly. Do not approve any contract with CalFire until there is an After Action Review of the 2020 CZU Lightning Complex Fire with the Volunteers.

The Board paid no attention, and asked no questions of CalFire Chief Nate Armstrong who was loitering in the hall.

Write your County Supervisors and demand an After Action Review be conducted with the County Fire Dept. Volunteers for the CZU Fire.

NEW COUNTY PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICER REPLACES GAIL NEWEL

One would think, with COVID now in the rearview mirror, that the new County Supervisor action to appoint a new County Public Health Officer would be quite public.  Not so.  Last Tuesday, the Board approved the appointment of Dr. Lisa Hernandez via Consent Agenda Item #54:

Agenda Item DOC-2023-581

COUNTY RECEIVES $2.24 MILLION GRANT TO PROVIDE SEVEN UNITS OF HOUSING?

The County received $2.24 million in state Project Home Key grant monies to fund the 801 River Street transitional project that will provide seven housing units.  That works out to be $320,000/person. Isn’t there a more cost-effective way to help more people with these hard-earned public taxpayer dollars?

That was Consent Agenda Item #67 last Tuesday: DOC-2023-594 Adopt resolution accepting unanticipated revenue in the amount of $2,240,000 from the California Department of Housing and Community Development for Project Homekey; ratify the Standard Agreement and local Project Agreement for the 801 R

COUNTY HIRES CONSTRUCTION CONSULTANTS FOR $9 MILLION EACH

The County Public Works Director Matt Machado claimed in Consent Agenda Item #83 that the County just does not have the staff to oversee construction projects in the County, so the Board of Supervisors approved extending contracts hiring two consultants for $9 million each.

Analysis

Public Works is continuing to complete repairs to several damaged sites from the 2016-17 and 2022-23 storm events.  Due to these and other on-going projects, the current not-to-exceed amounts for each Independent Contractor Agreement are at their current capacity, yet much more construction management services are needed for the upcoming construction season.  This construction season includes several high value projects such as:

  • The Soquel Drive Buffered Bike Lane project awarded at $20,208,885,
  • 2023 Pavement Management awarded at $5,443,330,
  • Emergency Routes Resurfacing awarded at $2,246,700,
  • Highway 152/Holohan Road Intersection with Engineer’s estimate of $2,789,000, and
  • Valencia Creek Sewer Relocation with a low bid of $2,364,836. 

These upcoming projects are in addition to this winter’s emergency projects currently in construction and several others being added. 

Overall, there is approximately $54 million worth of Capital Improvement Projects to be constructed this season and currently estimated value of $32 million worth of Emergency Repairs.  Based on approximately $85 million in construction projects, management oversight is estimated at a cost 17% for roughly $14.5 this season. 

Since 2019, MNS Engineers Inc. has performed oversight services on multiple projects at a value to-date of $45 million while Consor has performed services on a value to-date of $33 million.  Rebidding on-call consultant contracts is not possible at this time as emergency repairs needed immediately on critical County infrastructure are necessary to respond to these emergencies.  Inspection and project management of these emergencies does not permit a delay resulting from a competitive solicitation of bids on new on-call consultant contracts.  These contracts will expire in April 2024; at which time, new contracts will be established. 

To continue managing oversight of 2022 construction season started projects in addition to 2023 construction season projects, it is necessary to increase the agreement with MNS Engineers Inc., and Consor North America, Inc.  Approving amendments of $5,000,000 for each consultant for a total increase of $10 million is less than the estimated needed value of $14.5 million in additional oversight services for this season alone.  This approval allows uninterrupted management services to projects currently in construction as well as multiple projects to start.

Financial Impact

The recommended actions would result in a new not-to-exceed amount of $9 million for each contract. 

DOC-2023-610 Approve amendment to agreements with construction management on-call consultants to increase compensation by $5,000,000 each for a total amount of $9,000,000 each, and take related actions, as recommended by the Deputy CAO/Director of Co

EVEN WITH $8 MILLION BUDGET DEFICIT, SUPERVISORS APPROVE LEASING NEW OFFICE FOR $27,552/MONTH FOR FIVE YEARS?

Consent Agenda Item #87 approved a new five-year lease at 150 Westridge Drive in Watsonville, near the huge new campus the County purchased this year for a South County Government Center.  This 13,776SF leased office space will house health care serviced while the buildings at 1430 Freedom Blvd. are demolished and rebuilt, and also include a new 1,350SF office for Fourth District Supervisor Felipe Hernandez.

DOC-2023-614 Approve lease agreement for real property located at 150 Westridge Drive, Watsonville; authorize the Deputy CAO / Director of Community Development and Infrastructure to execute the lease agreement on behalf of the Health Services Agency

Consent Item #93 approved spending $3.3 million for the architects to design the new building to replace the demolished structure at the Freedom Blvd. campus. DOC-2023-620 Approve agreement with Hawley Peterson Snyder (HPS) Architects for the South County Health Campus Project in the amount of $3,356,086; adopt resolutions accepting unanticipated revenue in the amount of $3,356,086 in Fiscal Year 2022-23;

NEW 10′ WIDE BIKE PATH ON GREEN VALLEY ROAD IN WATSONVILLE MUST BE BUILT IN ONE YEAR

Consent Agenda Item #94 approved funding a bike path on Green Valley Road between Airport Blvd(Holohan Rd.) and Mesa Verde Drive (where the Sheriff Substation is located).

The Engineer’s Estimate for this project, not including design, inspection, overhead, or contingencies, is $4,122,739.  The project is partially funded by multiple sources including $5,000,000 in Clean California Grant Funds, $400,000 in Measure D Funds, and $516,097 in County General Funds.

DOC-2023-621 Approve plans, specifications, and engineer’s estimate for the Green Valley Road Multi-Use Trail Improvements Project; set online bid opening for 2:15 p.m. on July 27, 2023; direct Community Development and Infrastructure to return on or

THERE WAS NOT A MEETING OF THE MINDS, SO THE COUNTY TOOK AWAY FLOOD CONTROL MONEY

It was amazing to see that the Board of Supervisors rejected the plea of Pajaro Flood Control Management Director Dr. Mark Strudley to leave the County funding support in place for Pajaro flood control projects for which the money was intended.  He asked the Consent Agenda Item #96 be pulled, in order to have better public discussion.  Chairman Zach Friend refused to do so.

Watsonville City Councilwoman Ari Parker also requested the Board not approve the proposed funding claw-back, but to no avail.  Wow.  Public Works Director Matt Machado dismissively explained to reporters in the hallway who asked why the County was taking back the funding, “It’s just crumbs.”

Agenda Item DOC-2023-623

GOOD LETTERS TO THE SUPS

Make sure you read through the Correspondence of last Tuesday’s County Board of Supervisor meeting.  Mr. Cove Britton wrote a good one regarding the Board’s farce involving the appeal of a Planning Dept. determination requiring expensive studies ad nauseum (Letter #i):

Written Correspondence WC-2023-11

FEDERAL MONEY TO SUPPORT DOWNTOWN SANTA CRUZ SKYSCRAPER CANYONS?

Russ Brutsche spotted this interesting article on Lookout Santa Cruz, sporting the federal official visit to Santa Cruz.  The City’s proposed new ordinance for all-electric housing seemed charming to Ms. Ariel Marshall from the Dept. of Energy.

As Santa Cruz plots an electric future, U.S. energy officials tour city with offer of federal funds

Why did she come here?  It seems Mayor Fred Keeley and City Economic Development Director Bonnie Lipscomb have grand plans to build a downtown canyon of skyscrapers and want to court federal dollars to help pay for it.

Will they also pay for the cleanup of liquefaction destruction as sea level rise discussions warn?

New Findings on Shallow Groundwater Rise Highlight a Climate Risk Not Addressed by Policy

NEW CHANTICLEER OVERCROSSING WILL OFFER SWEEPING VISTA OF TREATED SEWAGE WATER PLANT

The work on Highway One near the Soquel Drive/Soquel Avenue area is in full swing.  The pedestrian overcrossing that will be juxtaposed to the PureWater Soquel Project treatment plant will have sweeping views of the facility, and likely expose users to loud noise from the reverse osmosis pumps. When I toured a similar facility in Santa Clara, the agency issued ear protection.

Here is the strip of land the Chanticleer Overcrossing will occupy when built.  The County and RTC paid Soquel Creek Water District $740,000 for this strip of land.

Here is the PureWater Soquel Treatment Plant, but what you can’t see here are the multiple large hazardous chemical storage tanks that will be adjacent to the Chanticleer Pedestrian Overcrossing.

If you are interested in learning more about the Highway One and Overcrossing Projects, tune in this Friday at 1pm to “Community Matters” to hear Ms. Sarah Christensen, Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission Project Engineer, discuss the work happening now and what else is planned.  santacruzvoice.com

REST IN PEACE, ROB EDWARDS

I was saddened to read the obituary of Rob Edwards in Sunday’s Santa Cruz Sentinel.  Although I never had the pleasure of meeting this amazing fellow who worked hard to build a great training platform at Cabrillo College for archaeology students and was highly respected for his work, I have read and appreciated a number of his reports.  The most notable one was his survey of the barn at the Redman-Hirahara Farmstead, detailing the artifacts associated with the Japanese American families who lived there upon the end of the Internment Camps of WWII, having lost all they had while being imprisoned. Thanks to the Hirahara family and the Pajaro Valley neighbors, the apartments in the barn helped those unfortunate families get back on their feet.

Take a look at who Rob Edwards was, and the great legacy he leaves behind

Rob Edwards Obituary

Rest in peace, Rob, and thank you for your good work while you were here.

THE LEE RESOLUTION INITIATED THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE

I recently learned of the Lee Resolution, a document that preceded the Declaration of Independence and shaped the beginning of our Nation.  I had never heard of this piece of history and enjoyed learning more about how the process happened to launch the United States of America into being.   Happy Independence Day!

Lee Resolution (1776)

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A MEETING AND EXPECT ANSWERS TO YOUR QUESTIONS.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers and Happy Independence Day,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

July 3

OAKS, TERRESTRAIL CORAL ANALOGUES

This past weekend, I had occasion to gaze for hours on end up into oak trees, reminding me of an analogy I’ve thought about where oak trees are like terrestrial coral reefs. When snorkeling around an atoll with patches of coral, I glide over vast sea grass beds, which hide flounder, conch, rays, and serve as habitat for many more species. Ahead, I see a tall, dark shadow looming and slowly coming into view is a coral patch. As I draw near, many species of colorful fish dart in and out of crevices and caves formed by the coral. Far from those tropical waters, I hike through extensive grasslands startling grasshopper and savannah sparrows, snakes, and a resting fawn. As I draw closer to the oak forest that rings the grasslands, I see new species of colorful birds and many butterflies popping out and flying back into the protection of the oak canopies.

The long-lived evergreen oaks of the central coast serve super-important roles supporting wildlife, and their canopy structure lends for spellbinding entertainment.


Our California Sister

I want to tell you about an oak-related butterfly that often catches my attention. California sister, Adelpha californica. If you spend much time around one of our live oaks right now, chances are good that you’ll see one of these strikingly beautiful butterflies. They can be very, very energetic fliers with bursts of energy followed by short glides, and lots of sudden turns. They behave more like predacious dragonflies than nectar-loving butterflies. Flying in and out of each hole in an oak canopy, they sometimes dart down the top of each branch, methodically seeming to examine every bit of structure. Why?

I have many hypotheses about this high energy ‘patrolling’ of oaks by California sister butterflies. Are they guarding their eggs or larval babies? It takes more than 60 days for an egg to reach its adult stage, growing from tiny to larger caterpillars along the way. During the caterpillar stage, they are vulnerable to predation or harassment by many things, though apparently neither the young nor the adult butterflies are tasty due to concentration of toxic oak-leaf compounds. So, perhaps they are looking for just the right place, and just the right time, to glue one of their eggs to the oak. Back and forth the colorful butterflies go, flitting in and out of shade, deeper into the canopy or out from it in the full sun. Maybe they are thermoregulating through this behavior. I also wonder if they might not be clearing spider webs from their territory, to make it safer for their young to learn to fly after they emerge from chrysalis with their tender young wings and clumsy first flights.

Do the California sister butterflies fly around the trees where they grew up, or do they move around more? Are there generation after generation of the same families in the same trees? Do they guard the flower patches near their trees, to maximize their access to nectar? So many questions…

Other Oak Denizens

While watching the California sister antics, I saw a bright yellow swallowtail butterfly cruise rapidly by. Was it a coincidence that it didn’t slow down or was it wary of the danger of trespassing into California sister territory?

In the heat of the day, a high buzzing noise fills the air around the oak groves; during the morning and evening, there are clicks. Both of those sounds are cicadas. The buzzing noise are male adult cicadas. In the soil beneath the oak leaf duff, unwinged young cicadas are sucking on roots for a living. One day, they emerge as winged adults, shedding a hideous exoskeleton that you can sometimes find laying around. Female cicadas lay eggs in holes they cut into an oak tree’s pencil-thin twig bark.

Occasionally, some say especially at the onset of droughts, oak moths flitter around the canopies of oaks by the hundreds. They look like large, animated confetti. Their larvae drop so much poop in those episodic years that it sounds like its raining. They don’t kill the oaks, generally- perhaps they help defoliate the trees to keep them from using too much water…or perhaps they help cycle nutrients with all of their rich poop.

Still More Oak Friends

More than once, I saw dragonflies perching on the outermost tips of oak branches. So many bugs jet in and out of the oak canopy that there are plenty of chances for those dragonflies to grab one up and make a meal of it.

I recently encountered an oak tree that buzzed. Looking into the canopy, I noticed that yellow jacket wasps were animating the entire tree with buzzing movement. The wasps were eating an outbreak of oak pests, or just lapping up sweet insect exudates, from scale or aphids, I couldn’t tell – they were too high up.

Some of the oak associate insects make odd looking structures called “galls.” There are lots of different things that do that, and that previous link is a great place to explore the amazing variation of species. I add a photo of one I found this past weekend here, next to a canyon live oak acorn cup.

Birds in the Mix

Oak trees also provide for many birds. Acorns are important food to California scrub jays, which have been shown to store 7,000 acorns in the soil and subsequently forgetting about some that germinate and grow. Acorn woodpeckers store their acorns in holes in tree trunks. Lots of other birds eat acorns.

The most colorful oak bird is the Townsend’s warbler, which (unlike many other of its warbler relatives) overwinters along the coast in California. It is a real treat to see this yellow-streaked bird darting around an oak canopy in the otherwise drab winter.

As oaks get older, they drop limbs, leaving behind cavities that provide nesting locations for other colorful birds, such as the Western blue bird. Such nesting cavities are a limiting factor for the survival of many bird species.

Help the Oaks

Besides the many species of life that oaks support, oak trees make great shade, are drought tolerant, and grow nice firewood. The entertainment value of having an oak close to your home is well worth it. You can grow an oak tree almost no matter what kind of soil you have near your house. So, why not plant one? Or not…if you are lucky enough to live near oak trees, you can bet that a scrub jay will plant one for you and all you need do is help the sprouted young plant along.

If you pick a nursery oak tree, make sure that it is less than a year old and that the roots aren’t swirling around inside the pot: messed up roots are terribly detrimental. If one of those early roots goes around in a circle inside the pot, the mature root will follow its path, a disadvantage to long-term tree health.

You’ll want to water a new oak regularly through the first summer, but not thereafter. Try to avoid summer water if at all possible past the first year.

Oaks grow faster than you think! Get ready to plant one this fall by scoping out the right spot…

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

(Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild and whose occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

June 28

#179 / Community Over Capital

I wrote, recently, about The Catholic Worker Movement, and today I am following up.

Let me alert you to the May 15/22, 2023, edition of The Nation, which ran an excellent article by Renée Darline Roden. Her article was titled, “Works of Mercy.” At least, that’s the hard copy version of the headline. Online, the article bears this title: “The Anarchism of the Catholic Worker.”

I think what The Nation has to say about The Catholic Worker Movement is important. My own writing on this topic is not so bad, either. I encourage you to find out more. Just click those links.

The actual purpose of this follow-up blog posting, however, is not to brag about my own writing, or to celebrate The Nation’s important comment about an important topic. As is so often the case, one little phrase in Roden’s article sent me to my computer, to type out today’s blog posting. Here’s the comment, from The Nation, that lets you know why The Catholic Worker Movement is so important:

Resisting capitalism by creating a new economic life is not just a Gen Z innovation on the Worker movement. Choosing community over capital as the basis for an economy is the original Catholic Worker mandate (emphasis added).

Choosing “community” as the organizing principle of our economy is the antidote to much that has made our economy, and society, and our politics, so unwell. Here’s how I usually put it:

“We are all in this together!”

If that is, in fact, true (and that statement is, in my estimation, a profound truth about our human situation), then we need to structure our society, economy, and politics to reflect that reality.  Learning about The Catholic Worker Movement is a good place to start.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

July 3

MOMS, COURTS AND PIT-BULLS UNLEASHED

Before finishing up their summer term, the US Extreme Court showed us how it intends to continue reinventing America. Not content with their earlier decisions of ending the right to an abortion, limiting the EPA’s ability to fight climate change, and eliminating state gun control laws, the rampage continued with their history-making lurching toward the right. The initial rulings issued were deceptive, prompting hopes of moderation for the upcoming remainder, especially in the aftermath of criticisms heaped upon the judicial body over the past months. The heaviest decision dealt with overruling a conservative case which would have allowed state legislatures to have nearly unrestrained power on running elections, with complete control over gerrymandered district maps, a MAGA-supported case that would have altered use of electoral votes in the presidential election. Trump attorney, John Eastman, had maintained that state legislatures could simply ignore election results and appoint electors pledged to Trump, thereby keeping him in the White House after the contested 2020 election; so this decision against the crackpot ‘independent state legislature theory’ was a big relief for liberals who looked with trepidation toward 2024, as the GOP and its billionaire sugar-daddies looked forward to stacking the deck. Justices Roberts, Kavanaugh, and Coney Barrett, stood with liberals SotomayorKagan and Brown for the majority opinion.

Lower court rulings were upheld, determining that Alabama had drawn congressional districts in such a way that voting power in Black populated districts was diluted, which will require that districts be redrawn. Past court decisions which tended to weaken the Voting Rights Act, tended toward more restraint in this instance, some crediting Chief Justice Roberts with being able to rein in his conservative firebrands. Then, the Kraken was unleashed, as college admissions no longer had to consider race, eliminating affirmative action in cases brought forward by Harvard and the University of North Carolina, a decision toward which Justice Thomas has been anxiously waiting to cast a thumb’s down vote. Such a supple wrist, with Ginni aiding him in the lead-up to big day! Saving the final big decision until Friday on the Biden administration’s Student Loan debt-relief order, the court ruled it unlawful, capping its reframing of laws and doctrines that have served the country well for generations.

NAACP President, Derrick Johnson, called out Justice Clarence Thomas as “the worst thing” created by affirmative action in condemnation of the Supreme’s decision to overturn affirmative action in college admissions. Thomas benefitted from the program, gaining a spot in Yale’s law school, and upon graduating, he wrote that racial preference had “robbed my achievement of its true value.” Then turn in your robe, Clarence! Johnson declared, “Race plays an undeniable role in shaping the identities of and quality of like for Black Americans. In a society still scarred by the wounds of racial disparities, the Supreme Court has displayed a willful ignorance of our reality.” On the other hand, former VP Mike-the-whitest-person-in-politics-Pence argued that affirmative action is no longer need as it once was to correct racial bias. “But I can tell you, as the father of three college graduates, those days are long over,” he proclaims. Wow! Who knew that ‘Mother‘ isn’t White?!!

The non-case in the release of the court’s decisions allows a Colorado-based web designer who opposes same-sex marriage to deny her services to LGBTQ+ couples. Lorie Smith, who brought the case was allowed to post a notice that she would not design a site for gay couples due to her religious beliefs, which could have violated Colorado law. According to Smith, a man named Stewart approached her to design a site for his wedding, but Stewart denies contacting her, says he has been married to the same woman for fifteen years and had no idea this case was wending its way through the courts. Although the state could have figured this out early on and saved everyone a lot of trouble, being vacated as a fraudulent case, her lawyers allowed the hoax to proceed. While Smith believes her First Amendment rights would be violated, Justice Sotomayor wrote that the plaintiff was objecting to “conduct,” and ignores the importance of our right to public accommodation. One person suggests, “Every website request begins with, ‘We are gay, and we need a wedding website. If the business is accommodating, then say, ‘Actually, I need a graduation website for my son…I just wanted to make sure you weren’t a complete homophobe.”

Probably shouldn’t be considered out of the ordinary, but an Indiana chapter of Moms for Liberty quoted Adolph Hitler on the cover of their newsletter, ‘The Parent Brigade.’ Their apology rang a bit hollow in light of their dedication to banning books and targeting LGBTQ+ students and school staff, in addition to reaching out to the Proud Boys, Three Percenters, Christian Nationalists and other extremist groups. The Southern Poverty Law Center says the group’s primary goals are to fuel right-wing hysteria and make the world less comfortable for Blacks and LGBTQ+ individuals. On a recent weekend, five GOP presidential hopefuls auditioned before the group’s ‘Joyful Warriors’ conference in Philadelphia, as they trumpeted their parental rights credo against such things as COVID19 precautions, school libraries, school curricula that covers race, sexuality, and gender. The Former Guy told the group, “You’re the best thing that’s ever happened to America.” followed by Nikki Haley saying, “When they mentioned that this was a terrorist organization, i said, ‘Well, then count me as a Mom for Liberty.'” Ron DeSantis praised them with, “Scrutiny of this group is a sign that we are winning this fight.” Oklahoma Superintendent of Public Instruction, Ryan Walters, who has called teachers’ unions “terrorist organizations” capped the praise with, “You know who else was called a terrorist group, an extremist group? Those founding fathers. That’s who you are today. You are the most patriotic group in the country right now.” Other speakers continued the tirade, with James Lindsay describing the Pride flag as that “of a hostile enemy,” and Lt. Governor Mark Robinson (NC), declaring the transgender movement “demonic, and full of the Anti-Christ spirit.” All of this debasement, in Trump’s words is, “In service of fighting a cult of Marxists and perverts,” as these GOP candidates race to the bottom of the barrel.

As Bocha Blue of the Palmer Report writes, “These presidential contenders have no idea what’s about to come at them. They’re like innocent lambs heading to the slaughter…Right now, they’re doing the usual Republican dance, which is – run for President, but avoid attacking His Royal Traitor. Ah, but that’s OK because the ultimate test – the Big Kahuna – is getting ready to fasten its talons around ALL of them. See, it’s a question – one innocent question, but it has the potential to ruin all the candidates. It has the potential because there is no answer to this question. Anything they say makes things worse for them. Picture them being interviewed by reporters or perhaps in a debate. The Question: “Who is the rightful winner of the 2020 Presidential election?” Cue the bells of doom…it isn’t Trump they should be afraid of – it’s MAGA. Nobody in MAGA will EVER vote for a candidate who says Biden is the lawful and accurate President…MAGA wants their fantasy to continue. They will turn like pit-bulls on ANY candidate who doesn’t continue to delude them. And if they say Trump is the rightful winner? They lose all the independents. They lose America…They will try to answer with a non-answer. It won’t work. They will ALL have to say who they think is the President. And if they’re not worried about the answer, they’re in even more trouble that initially thought.”

After the Republican National Committee released its criteria last month with requirements for candidates to participate in the August debate, one of which is signing a pledge to support the Republican nominee, many of the hopefuls are taking umbrage over the mandate. Some are reluctant at signing, at least one refuses to do so, but the RNC is immoveable, chairwoman Ronna McDaniel saying, “It’s the Republican Party nomination, and the pledge is staying.” Time to uncage the pit-bulls, eh, Ronna?

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Butterflies”

“Well, I must endure the presence of a few caterpillars if I wish to become acquainted with the butterflies.”
~Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince

“The caterpillar does all the work, but the butterfly gets all the publicity.” 
~George Carlin

“Butterflies are self-propelled flowers.”     
~Robert A. Heinlein

...

Hope you had a great 4h of July! Here, have a couple of laughs!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

June 28 – July 4, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…lani faulkner for supe, Landmark theatre news. Greensite…will be back next week. Schendledecker…black lives matter in Santa Cruz. Steinbruner…Bruce Daniels resigns, groundwater agency issues, private well owner’s problems, Pure water Soquel, Cabrillo name. Hayes…Junes flower. Patton…my so-called friends. Matlock…gagging the mona lisa’s sugar-daddy. EaganSubconscious Comics and Deep Cover. WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week. Quotes…”July”

...

MORE ECONOMICALLY SUSTAINABLE LOCAL LOGGING… Back in the 1890’s these loggers probably used the same justifications for their clear-cutting as our local foresters do today. What would Santa Cruz County look like IF someone prevented this “selective forestry”?

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE June 26

NO WAY GREENWAY AND SUPPORTING LANI FAULKNER FOR COUNTY SUPERVISOR.

This is the campaign season. Announcements and campaigns are made or whispered every day. I ran this article June 6 and it bears repeating…and remembering,

This is from a notice Sally Arnold sent early this month…

“Together we built a landslide defeat of the Deceptive Measure D proposal to tear out the tracks, kill our transit future and delay trail construction.  After that historic victory, we thought that our elected officials would respect the will of their constituents and work toward trail construction and planning for rail service.

But that has not been the case.  Some politicians are still trying to stop construction of the trail!  This is a threat to the rail and trail that we must take seriously.

Recently, Supervisor Manu Koenig (District 1) wasted everyone’s time grandstanding and refusing to accept the Environmental Impact Report for Rail Trail segments 8 & 9, which were just funded for construction.  His failures to listen don’t stop with the Rail & Trail. First District residents are complaining about his focus on his wealthiest constituents rather than the majority of First District residents.  Whether it’s Coastal Commission policy, parking programs, bike lanes, housing or zoning – small businesses and constituents are upset with the incumbent.

One strategically placed government official can do a whole lot of damage if they have an agenda that’s not aligned with the will of our community. The Board of Supervisors is a small body (only 5 elected supervisors) so just one troublesome supervisor can make it difficult for the board to get things done for all of us.  This is why all of us, no matter which district we live in, should care about the District 1 supervisor’s race.

That’s why, as members of the No Way Greenway Campaign Committee, we are excited to support Lani Faulkner for First District Supervisor.  Lani brings a wealth of experience from her successful career in Biotechnology to her community involvement.  Lani serves on the Executive Committee of the Santa Cruz Chapter of the Sierra Club, the Community Traffic Safety Coalition, Equity Transit, Friends of the Rail & Trail and the NAACP.  Her work on the Democratic Central Committee and with local union leaders has given her the connections and relationships needed to get things done. Her experience working with government agencies is exactly what we need in a local leader.

First District residents asked Lani to run for First District Supervisor because she’s a true part of the community, who raised her family in Live Oak . She makes herself available, knows how to listen and is committed to finding common ground. Lani’s diplomatic approach to problem solving will help our whole community.

This race has direct consequences for not just the First District but the whole County.  In a time when we need to bring the community together to solve some of the tough challenges ahead of us, we need a Supervisor who works well with others.

Early endorsement and donations are important.   You can add your name and support Lani in other ways here: Endorse Lani for Supervisor

Feel free to call us if you would like to discuss this remarkable candidate.

Sally Arnold (831-419-4622)

Matt Farrell (831-331-7496)

No Way Greenway Campaign Committee go here for background on No Way Greenway.

LANDMARK THEATRES = COHEN MEDIA GROUP. From rumblings and rantings I wouldn’t bet on our Nickelodeon theatre ever opening again. I’ve been told that it has serious architectural issues like leaks, plumbing, rot and etcetera. Then too I can’t see Landmark/Cohen keeping the Del Mar in operation if audiences don’t increase. Cohen Media Group who bought out Landmark in 2018 has been both closing and opening movie theatres in places like Arizona, Annapolis, Closter, New Jersey and it closed its Pico Boulevard theatre (with 12 screens) last May. Cohen Media also has other financial interests and that’s why we see Savile row men’s clothing trailers at the Del Mar every time. It doesn’t seem like too many years ago that Mayor Chris Krohn re-opened the Del Mar restoring its historical value by screening “China Clipper” movie complete with a parade down Pacific Avenue.
In case you’re wondering, Landmark closes many, many of their theatres every Monday. Stay tuned and go to the Del Mar.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

EXTRAORDINARY ATTORNEY WOO. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.7 IMDB). According to some recent article Korean films are leading the world in popularity nowadays. That proves true with this one. Attorney Woo is an autistic and brilliant young woman attorney (27 years old) . The plot and drama and the laughs in the first episode makes this well worth hanging with. She defends a senior wife who hit her husband with a clothes iron. Serious, funny heartfelt and worth watching.

HUNGER. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). A Thai film that gets deeper by the minute as it deals with a high end restaurant named Hunger. The head chef is mean, cruel and very successful and he trains his staff of ex noodle joint kids in ways to make all foods into art pieces…but at what cost personally? Vegies might not like this one.

SLEEPING DOG. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.01 IMDB). This tricky German movie about a policeman who has amnesia and is then assigned a new rookie to investigate a murder case that was supposed to have been solved. It turns out that the police department has some issues that make this a pretty good movie.

BLACK MIRROR. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.8 IMDB). They call it an anthology series. That means 27 separate episodes, each with its own separate plot and stars. Well-directed and nicely paced and stars such as Jon Hamm, Salma Hayek, Rory Kinnear, Miley Cyrus, Annie Murphy, and Oona Chaplin all have good parts in one of the series. Odd, fascinating, perplexing and well worth watching.

LOUIS ARMSTRONG- BLACK & BLUES. (APPLE TV) (7.4 IMDB). This documentary should be required viewing, especially for Americans. His early New Orleans history, his world travels, his use of marijuana way back when, and especially his side of the scene involving race relations after being accused of Uncle Tomism for decades. Orson Welles, Dick Cavett, Ed Murrow, Leonard Bernstein are a few of the stars in this dynamite treasure.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

LIAISON. (APPLE SERIES). (6.4 IMDB).  Vincent Cassel is the lead in this carbon copied spy story. The only thing new in it is that everybody uses computers and I Phones. I’m serious when I tell you it takes place in Damascus, London, Turkey, and bad old Syria. But it turns out that London has water barriers that raise and lower when the bad tides come in. Santa Cruz’s West Cliffs need some of these barriers, but don’t watch Liaisons anyways.

MY POLICEMAN. (AMAZON MOVIE). (6.5 IMDB) A policeman and a teacher guy squabble back and forth throughout the entire movie deciding whether or not the policeman is gay. Lots of gay scenes in this one. It’s tender, and good old Rupert Everett is in it but can’t speak due to his ageing. Both tough and tender to watch and it’s handled beautifully.

EXTRACTION 2. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB). Chris Hemsworth is the big star of this war movie. It takes place in Georgia (right where Europe joins with Asia. It’s nearly 98% hand to hand battling…way too much and we don’t care who wins anyways with a name like Tyler Rake for Hemsworth.

A BEAUTIFUL LIFE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB). It’s supposed to be a romantic drama about life in the music recording business. It features a singer/ guitarist named “Christopher” who is very blah. It’s also about how one trains and performs under contract and it’s not worth seeing or reading about.

WHERE THE TRACKS END. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB).  A new film from Mexico centering on one school teacher and her favorite young student. It all happens along the Rio Bravo River among the very poorest of the students and citizens. It’s a genuine feel good saga it’s the field bosses fighting the helpless workers. It’s low key and near boring and undramatic.

THE DAYS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.3 IMDB).   Remembering what happened with the nuclear power plant disasters on Three Mile Island and Chernobyl and what could have happened in Bodega Bay and Santa Cruz this is a dramatic review of the seven days during the Fukushima Daiichi explosion in Japan in March 2011. A tsunami started the disaster in their nuclear reactor and it’s all carried out in three viewpoints… the government, the electric power company and of course the people/citizens including much of Tokyo that also lost power. Watch it by all means.

...
June 26

Gillian will be back next week…

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

June 26

BLACK LIVES MATTER IN SANTA CRUZ

Last Saturday, the SC Equity Collab‘s Black Lives Matter street mural in front of city hall was finally repainted, almost two years after its hate-fueled defacement.

My initial response to these street murals, as they cropped up around the country, was lukewarm. Like many of my BIPOC friends, I support the Movement for Black Lives’ “Vision for Black Lives Policy Platform,” which seems to put us politically to the Left of many other local BIPOC community members. I thought, hey, if that’s what people want to do, good for them, but it’s not really my thing. It seemed like a liberal, feel-good activity, and I didn’t really see how painting the slogan large-scale would change policies, save lives, and improve material conditions for millions of Black people in the US. As Black Lives Matters became more popular, it also seemed to become less radical, defanged (though it has still done much good).

But I’m rethinking my stance.

I was not part of the original painting process or the restorative justice process that followed, but about a year and a half ago I began to get to know some of the people involved through other community organizing efforts.

I attended two of the court dates for the mural defacement trial. One was about putting a price tag on the mural, since it was made with professional and non-professional volunteer labor and fundraisers. The professional artists who made it happen backed up their estimate of about $100,000 with detailed records of hours spent, typical professional muralist fees, and supplies. The artists also wanted community compensation for non-material damages, but in a criminal case that’s not allowed. Hearing the breakdown and justification, I gained a new appreciation for muralists and the specialized work they do.

The other court date focused on video and social media evidence against the defendants, Brandon Bochat and Hagan Warner. Not just the video they made when damaging the mural with their truck tires, but other racist incidents while driving, text messages, and social media trolling of local BIPOC people who spoke out about how the mural defacement intensified how marginalized and unsafe they often felt, and feel, in Santa Cruz. And BIPOC people do feel marginalized and unsafe in Santa Cruz, every day–if you don’t believe it, ask and just listen.

Both court dates were intense, emotional, deeply upsetting, and exhausting–and I was a white person on the periphery. Listening to, and believing, how the creation of the mural, its defacement, and this lengthy restorative justice process affected those at the center was essential to me beginning to understand it all. And even though I had heard a lot of it over the past year, the panel discussion at the mural repainting deepened my understandings.

Saturday I learned that, from the beginning, SCEC organizers Abi Mustapha, Sean McGowen, Taylor Reinhold and Shandara Gill wanted the mural to be more than a painted slogan, they wanted to seize the opportunity to create a platform for community dialogue and policy change.

I also heard, although the words were not explicitly used, that the post-defacement restorative justice process was abolitionist. No one called for jail time, no one thought that a punitive process would heal those harmed or prevent a future hate crime (if you don’t think this was a hate crime, please talk to Black people about how they feel about it). The call was not to reform carceral systems, but to work towards ending them even while engaging with them.

Organizers were intentional and insistent that Brandon and Hagan should not just be handed over to probation officers to perform some random community service. They remained engaged and advocated to co-create of new ways of healing on all sides of harm done by hate crimes. They showed up, they called the community to show up with them, they engaged the Conflict Resolution Center and Showing Up for Racial Justice to aid in the process, and they have been transparent and accountable to all of us in their communications.

Brandon and Hagan were both at the mural repainting Saturday, and they seemed to have really grown, so that they could truly engage with and understand our BIPOC community and the significance of Black Lives Matter. Through this process of restorative justice, they have been brought into the community, rather than shunned.

Thank you SCEC and collaborators for helping to make a world where breaking cycles of harm and finding universal liberation is a little more possible than it was three years ago. Black Lives Matter murals around the country may be fading away, but I’m glad ours has been repaired.

There were quite a few items of particular interest in last Tuesday’s city council agenda:

Closed Session:

1) Property: Approximately 8.15 acres located on Mount Hermon Road in Scotts Valley, CA (I’ve had some help researching this property, expect a column on it in the next week or 2.)

Consent Agenda:

  1. Update of Various Council Policies (CC) (including 2.1: Interim Use of Skypark Property)
  2. Dissolution of the City/County 2×2 Committee and Appointment to the Santa Cruz Housing for Health Partnership (H4HP) Policy Board (CM) (why appoint Deputy City Manager rather than Homelessness Response Director Larry Imwalle to this board?)
  3. City Overlook Emergency Shelter Operations and Management Contract Approval (CM)
  4. Tier 3 Safe Parking Operations and Management Contract Approval (CM) (11 and 12 are funded for the upcoming fiscal year from the remains of that $14 million, 1-time grant from the state)
  5. Contract Amendment for Kimley-Horn Associates for Professional Services Related to the Downtown Plan Expansion (PL) (it’s worth looking at this little document, which includes the below)

Extended Project Schedule and Next Steps

The Downtown Plan Expansion was initially scoped to be complete by the middle of 2023, and due to various factors this deadline has not been achieved. The amended scope also reflects additional management costs due to the extended timeline and incorporates sufficient funds to ensure completion of the project by March of 2024. At this time, the approximate project schedule will include another round of community engagement on a range of design and land use topics in late summer or early fall, a draft of the Amended Plan for public review by October or November, and release of the EIR in November or December. Public hearings for the policy amendments and certification of the EIR are targeted for early 2024.

  1. Overnight Parking Permit Fees Related to Oversized Vehicle Ordinance (No. 2021-20) Implementation (PW) (the stakeholder group has yet to be formed, and now it seems like Santa Cruz Cares and ACLU are not guaranteed spots on it.)
  2. West Cliff Drive Stabilization Project (c401501) – Ratification of Plans and Specifications, Authorization to Advertise for Bids and Award Contract, and Authorize Professional Service Agreement for Construction Support Services (PW) (and authorizing an exemption from local employment requirements, so much for Keeley, Golder, Brunner, Watkins, and Kalantari-Johnson supporting Good labor practices!)

General Hearing:

  1. Five-Year Strategic Plan (CN) (as I flagged in my April 21st column, among other things, we’re looking into establishing a Regional Public Safety Training Center.)

If you missed this year’s Day Worker Center fundraiser, you can donate now, while you listen to this playlist by Juan Antonio Cuellar, Collection Curator of the Arhoolie Foundation’s Frontera Collection.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
June 26

BRUCE DANIELS RESIGNED FROM SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Last week, longtime the Soquel Creek Water District Board member Bruce Daniels resigned, effective June 19.  His letter of resignation was not included in the meeting packet, but General Manager Ron Duncan stated that Director Daniels wanted to do other things, such as travel and work on writing computer models for students wanting to study climate change.

Somehow, I think it could be related to the Board’s action last January to dissolve funding for large conservation projects that the District has been collecting for a couple of decades in response to his failed attempt to convince the Board to declare a moratorium on new connections.  He always voted “NO” for any new service requests the Board reviewed, citing critical overdraft problems he felt needed to be addressed.   Staff convinced the Board in January that it was no longer necessary to continue collecting $55,000/acre foot new water demand, meant to fund large water conservation projects that would not otherwise get funded.

 Rubbish. 

The District collected a lot of money, doubled the number of water demand offsets they could sell, and used the money to buy new water meters that staff claimed would save a lot of water.  Shouldn’t that have been a standard operational expense?

Hmmmm……

Well, last Tuesday, the Directors discussed how to fill the Board vacancy. It was quite a dog and pony show. Even though Director Daniels had just submitted his resignation, Ms. Traci Hart, Director of HR, already had researched two plans of action the Board could take: 1) hold an election, or 2) appoint someone to their liking.  No surprise, Director Bruce Jaffe quickly responded that he had no interest at all in discussing an election.

“It’s a lot of work to run,” agreed Chairman Carla ChristensenHmmm….do they already know who they want on the Board?  Has Director Daniels made his selection behind the scenes and resigned mid-term to ensure his choice would be a shoe-in?

After some back-and-forth about who on the Board should serve on the Ad Hoc Committee of two to develop an application, they voted to schedule two Board meetings to interview the applicants on August 8 and 9.  Only then did Manager Duncan state that elections are expensive, the last one costing about $60,000.  Really?   Ms. Hart had earlier admitted she had not been able contact the County Elections Director to find out the cost, and whether or not there were an election for other matters on the November 2023 ballot.

Director Rachel Lather remained quite silent, only saying she was too busy to serve on the Ad Hoc, but offered “Well, I remember I worked hard on my application.”

She was appointed to the Board in 2016 when Director Rick Meyer passed away.  I remember how their selection process went, because I attended both of the Board meetings to interview replacement directors.  It was pretty clear to me that the Board had already decided Rachel Lather was their choice because she knew so much about sewage, having worked for the County of Santa Cruz in the sanitation dept.   The District was already gearing up to rubber stamp the PureWater Soquel Project to inject treated sewage water into the groundwater.  Let me tell you, there were some really excellent candidates who were not considered.

Also, I later learned that Rachel Lather was a close friend of Director Carla Christensen, which likely swayed the Board’s selection.

As we all know, an appointee becomes the “Incumbent” on the ballots for the next election….and has a significant advantage over others who may run for the Board.  That is what has helped keep Rachel Lather on the Board.   She refused to vote on the last repressive District rate increases that have raised the cost of water 9% every year for the past five years, admitted that she has lost sleep over the Board’s approval to double the number of new water demand offsets sold, and questioned why the District borrowed 100% of the money needed to fund the new Quail Run tank that benefits the Aptos Village Project but has never built the tank.

According to the District website, the applications are due July 31, but the applications are not yet available. 

2023 Board Vacancy

It will be interesting to see who the Board appoints.  Because of Manager Duncan’s repeated reference to “dedicated people on the Standing Committees” as possible Director appointees, I am guessing the choice will be a fellow who has CONSISTENTLY been their greatest cheerleader for big rate increases.   The District is currently working on a plan to raise their rates again… their project to inject treated sewage water into the groundwater is a lot more expensive than planned.  Stay tuned.

PUMPING LESS GROUNDWATER IS GOOD NEWS

The June 15 MidCounty Groundwater Agency Board meeting featured a presentation by Ms. Georgina King, hydrologist Montgomery & Associates.

“We have seen a steady decrease in groundwater pumping, and expect that to hold.” she said.

However, there are increasing chloride levels in the south area of the Basin, which could be an indicator of an advancing freshwater / saltwater interface.  Mind you, this is NOT where the PureWater Soquel Project is scheduled to pressure inject treated sewage water, ostensibly to push back seawater intrusion.

 2022 Groundwater Annual Report, filed April 1, 2023, using data from last year (even before the big winter rains) 

Look at page 25 of the Report: Overall, 401 acre-feet less groundwater was extracted in WY 2022 compared to WY 2021,

No surface water from the SCWD to SqCWD for in-lieu use was transferred in WY 2022. (That means no water transfers from Santa Cruz to Soquel Creek Water District.  There was plenty of water available, but Soquel Creek Water District just did not ask to activate the agreement that would then allow them to buy excess water from the City and thereby reduce pumping from the aquifer.  Their justification was that the District staff was too busy with the PureWater Soquel Project construction.)

Look at the groundwater extraction amounts in the table on pages 27-28 to see how water use has consistently decreased since 2008.

Look at the encouraging increased groundwater storage maps on pages 35-37, notably in the aquifer areas that Soquel Creek Water District intends to pressure-inject treated sewage water.

The MidCounty Groundwater Agency Board also approved their 2023 budget…how to use $7.6 Million grant money?  The budget includes spending $20,000 for public outreach. “What DOES the agency plan to do for public outreach in the coming year?” I asked.  No reply.

Spending $65,000 for metering on non-diminimus well owners, those pumping more than 2 acre-feet/year, will perhaps help those private well owners pay for the mandated meters that will soon assess them for groundwater extraction

It will be interesting to see the results of State-funded helicopter flights using magnetic resonance data to determine what the saltwater / freshwater interface status is.  The State is really dragging their feet on releasing this information.  However, based on the information, the MidCounty Groundwater Agency has budgeted $150,000 to do this analysis again, with a more refined level of surveying.

Take a look at what is planned that will affect the groundwater level and administration of such in the Midcounty areas.  Here is the link to the MGA website: Recent News | Santa Cruz Mid-County Groundwater Agency

LOOKING FOR PRIVATE WELL OWNERS TO REPRESENT OTHERS ON THE MIDCOUNTY GROUNDWATER AGENCY

In the next few years, there will be increasing pressure to tax private well owners in Santa Cruz County for their groundwater extraction.  The representation of those well owners on the MidCounty Groundwater Agency (MGA) is up for selection.

The application process is underway.  Unlike the Santa Margarita Groundwater Agency, which allows the private well owners to select their representative, the MidCounty GSA will have an executive committee from within to decide criteria.    Last week’s Board approved Sierra Ryan (from the County), Jon Kennedy and Curt Abramson (current private well reps) and one other executive member to develop an application process and criteria,

The Executive Committee (Soquel Creek Water District General Manager Ron Duncan, the City of Santa Cruz Water Dept. Manager Rosemary Menard, the Central Water District General Manager Ralph Bracamonte, and Sierra Ryan as County of Santa Cruz Water Resources Director) will decide who represents the private well owners, not the private well owners,

The application for the Private Well Owner representative is not available yet, but watch for it here and consider applying if you are a private well owner:

Private Well Owners | Santa Cruz Mid-County Groundwater Agency

CITY OF SANTA CRUZ LOOKS AT INDUSTRIAL USERS AND CONTAMINANT LOADS

The City of Santa Cruz Wastewater Treatment Dept. held a public hearing on June 14 (as reported last week by Bratton Online contributor Joy Schendledecker) to check off a mandatory box required to renew the City’s National Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit to discharge treated sewage water into the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary.  The Santa Cruz City Council will review and approve the report on discharge contamination in August.  The County of Santa Cruz is also working on what dumping limits are set, and the contaminant concentrations allows, and the matter will come before the Board of Supervisors for approval.

The City, with the help of Kennedy Jenks Consultants, conducted five sampling events at 19 sampling stations over a period of 16 months of industrial sources as well as at the Wastewater Treatment facility to generally monitor the household waste contaminant levels.  Because of the sampling results, five new pollutants will be monitored.

Ms. Melanie Mow-Schumacher of Soquel Creek Water District talked about the PureWater Soquel Project, stating roughly 25% of the wastewater effluent will be piped from Santa Cruz to the Treatment Plant under construction across from the County Sheriff Headquarters.  Because the District plans to inject that treated sewage water into the aquifer, it is important that the City have a good handle on the levels of contaminants and their sources, so hence, the NPDES permit update is crucial for them.

Will there be real time data sharing between the City and the District’s PureWater Soquel Project to be able to alert each other for unusual contaminant spikes or system failures and thereby ensure treatment system redundancy would effectively prevent irreversible and significant groundwater contamination?  The District’s treatment facility will have real-time monitoring of contaminant levels.

What bothered me is that the treatment “brine” from the PureWater Soquel Project will get dumped directly into the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary, and not treated again, as was stated in the 2018 Project EIR.  There are many carcinogenic contaminants that are a result of the disinfection process that will become one of the City’s industrial pollution sources…hence the inclusion of the District in the public hearing.

One member of the audience commented that it is difficult to find that level of information on the City’s website to see whether there are or have been spikes in wastewater contaminant levels.  She also mentioned the leak in the City’s sewage effluent outfall pipe going out into the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary.  Ms. Ann Hogan, Director of the City’s Wastewater Treatment Dept., mentioned that the website will be updated soon to connect with a STATE data tool called CRISPR that will soon be integrated with website information.  Ms. Hogan stated that there have been two dye-plume studies conducted recently of the damaged effluent outfall pipeline, and results will be made publicly available soon.

I left the meeting feeling that the City will do its best to monitor the industrial point-source contaminants, but the wild cards will be domestic sewage contamination levels and the PureWater Soquel Project effluent contamination concentrate and elevated temperature fluctuations.  Keep your eye on the City’s website improvements and ask the City Council to repair the damaged sewage effluent pipe that is allowing treated sewage (and PureWater Soquel contaminant “brine”) to be dumped closer to the beaches than is permitted.

Santa Cruz City Council citycouncil@cityofsantacruz.com

Here is a link to the EPA Clean Water Act website, detailing what the NPDES permit process involves.

Oddly, in a recent legal action I had regarding the California Coastal Commission’s rubberstamp approval of the PureWater Soquel Project, the First District Court of Appeal opined that “the Clean Water Act is only a suggestion and is not legally binding.”  Isn’t that interesting?

LISTEN AND BE HEARD THIS FRIDAY….CABRILLO COLLEGE NAME AND ON-SITE HOUSING PROJECT

This Friday at a bit after 1pm, Dr. Matt Wetstein, President of Cabrillo Community College, will be the guest on “Community Matters” online radio program.  Listen in:

https://santacruzvoice.com/

You can call in with your thoughts:  831-265-5050.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers and Happy Belated Summer Solstice,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
June 25

JUNE’S FLOWER

There are many native dandelion relatives on California’s Central Coast, and none of them are weeds. They all have that enigmatic seed head, so familiar to most of us. I’m naming a special wildflower “June’s flower:” the largest native dandelion of them all, Agoseris grandiflora, aka giant mountain dandelion.

We become familiar with dandelion seedheads at a young age. Children’s books and movies feature the beautiful plumose globes of seeds as they break apart by blowing people or from a breeze. Individual seeds are carried off, gliding on delicate parachutes to an uncertain but hopeful future. You might discuss the symbology with someone, and I’d be curious to learn what you ascertain.

As US citizens grow older, the capitalist marketing firms barrage our eyes and ears with quite contrary dandelion symbolism. Targeting adults, synthetic pesticide corporations portray dandelions as an Evil Weed that must be constantly battled. Dandelions’ menacing toothed leaves pop up and stretch skyward from otherwise perfectly manicured 2″ tall vibrant green, grassy lawns. Angry, menacing faces are transposed onto cartoon dandelion flower heads, taunting consumers. Standing on the aisle at the nursery or hardware store, we breathe peculiar, nasty chemical odors as we learn that ‘broadleaf’ herbicides miraculously kill dandelions, leaving the surrounding grass unharmed no matter how clutzy you might be with the spray bottle. And, you must spray! TV or internet advertisements portray constant waves of enemy dandelion parachutes blowing in from ne’er do well careless neighbors with unkempt yards. Hippies even cultivate dandelions and shun pesticides! Oddly, the dandelion and the whole lawn care racket has become another aspect of political division in the USA. This is serious, deep stuff.

In a related situation, I recently encountered similar division reading an internet ‘dialogue’ about a recently discovered new population of the extremely endangered Santa Cruz kangaroo rat. Some commentators suggested that anything called a ‘rat’ were welcome to go extinct as far as they were concerned. A rat is a rat is a rat, they claimed, and if a species were to go extinct, it was ‘Nature’s Way.’ Such is the state of manufactured political division and miseducation in the USA. Kangaroo rats are as related to the invasive house pest rats as humans are to lemurs. The same can be said of the invasive, non-native dandelion and our native giant mountain dandelion, though the two species look superficially similar. Nevertheless, I bet some folks suppose they have no use for even native dandelions; I hope that they are too few to threaten the web of life that provides us all the comforts we currently enjoy. Our native dandelions are important!

As with other of my featured “flowers-of-the-month” I have featured, you will not easily encounter giant mountain dandelion unless you go looking. To find it, go to dry, sunny locations where the soil is poor. Shallow rocky areas and road cuts are likely spots. The species likes hotter exposures – south- or west-facing slopes are perfect. It doesn’t like much shade, so the dominant surrounding vegetation should be short, sparse, and grassy. Examining iNaturalist and CalFlora databases, it doesn’t seem too easy to find the species unless you go the high ridge of the spine of the Santa Cruz mountains.

Try to arrive at a likely spot well before noon: giant mountain dandelion flowers close at midday. But, in June, you are more likely to spot the plant from its giant dandelion-like seed heads. Unlike many other similar species, this species’ heads are huge and pure white.

Trying to pick this one from the many other dandelion relatives will require a bit of guidance. European dandelions like moist ground, but giant mountain dandelions like dry ground; the two will never grow together. People commonly think that rough cat’s ear is a dandelion. I knew a Sicilian man who made dandelion wine out of a bucket full of those flowers, and he said it worked! Rough cat’s ear makes a flowerhead that is off-white, brownish…not the pure white we’re looking for. When it comes to more pure white seed heads, you might find many small ones on branches, but giant mountain dandelion has only one seed head per stem. The branched one is a new invasive species that is romping around the meadows in this region, and it’s called beaked hawksbeard.

Although the giant mountain dandelion has the biggest seedhead of them all, there are many other native dandelions with a grand range of different looking seedheads. The rarest of them, and one of the rarest plants in general, is the Santa Cruz dandelion – a plant that lives in only a handful of patches on Earth. If you find yourself in a particularly arid spot, especially inland on poor soils, you’ll find oodles of small native dandelion relatives with brownish shiny seedheads just an inch or so in diameter. These are in the Microseris genus and they all ‘nod in bud’ – flowerheads that bend down until right before they open.

What good are dandelions?

I have been asked time and again ‘what good are they?’ when I mention a given species. Giant mountain dandelions (photo to right) are certainly beautiful, and their seedheads are somehow very satisfying to blow, if you like to set dandelion seeds on their great journeys. Chalk up two values: visual aesthetics and fun. I’m not sure if they make good dandelion wine; one could try but it would be best to grow a stand of them to get enough flowers and not impact wild populations. I haven’t tried eating the greens, but I bet that they are very bitter: I haven’t seen bites taken out of them in nature. Some birds love dandelion seeds, and I suppose these are no exception, though the large amount of fluff might dissuade.

Wind dispersed seeds of plants that like hot, dry ground…doesn’t that sound like a good recipe for natural slope stabilization? We had plenty of landslides this past winter and need all the help we can get if the creeks aren’t to stay muddy.

Finally, it is the age of concern about pollinators. Honeybees are having troubles, and we have been turning to native pollinators with hope. The big juicy flowers of giant mountain dandelions are one more wildflower to support native pollinators. There may also be pollinators that depend on eating giant mountain dandelions during their larval stages – something that deserves exploring!

Your Turn

Okay- I hope you will take the challenge to go out now and find this giant native dandelion in its native habitat. You can click here for more information, though that CalFlora link suggests the species is in peak bloom in April- not so here on the coast! There are good photos at that site, so you can see the distinguishing features. The iNaturalist site for the species is here; by following this series of each month’s wildflowers, I’m hoping you’ve downloaded iNaturalist and will enter a photograph when you find this species.


Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

 June 19

#170 / My So-Called Friends

New York City Smoke, June 7, 2023

My so-called friends 
Have fallen under a spell.
They look me squarely in the eye 
And they say, well, “All is well.”
Can they imagine the darkness 
That will fall from on high 
When men will beg God to kill them 
And they won’t be able to die?

Bob Dylan, “Precious Angel

The lines above keep haunting me. And our global warming crisis proceeds. Pundits pick their sides.

An editorial in the June 9, 2023, edition of The Wall Street Journal comments on the forest fires in Canada that were raging on that date (with the smoke from those fires, as seen above, descending on New York City, and on Washington, D.C., and on much of the East Coast). The Wall Street Journal says that all that smoke should not make us worry that those fires and the smoke are a sign of an out-of-control global warming catastrophe.

Of course it is true, as The Journal tells us, that Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau does blame the fires on “climate change,” but the editorial in The Journal says that such fires have been occurring in Canada’s boreal forests of conifers, birch and poplar “for thousands of years.” Nothing to worry about, in other words! No reason to panic or get concerned! Our spell-bound “friends” at The Wall Street Journal are telling us that “all is well!”

Economist Paul Krugman’s June 9, 2023, column in The New York Times advances a different view:

I think it’s fair to say that even people who accept climate reality have tended to assume that really serious impacts still lie some years in the future; I sometimes find myself thinking that way, even though intellectually I know better. But it has long been clear that the damage from climate change will gradually build over time, as formerly freakish disasters become bigger and more frequent, as once-in-a-century floods, fires and droughts start happening every few years, affecting ever more people. The climate crisis will get much worse, but it is in fact already well underway.

And there are no safe places. Some people have tended to assume that a warming planet is only bad for faraway places that are already hot — India, say, or the Middle East — and might even be good for people living in colder climes. But right now Canada is on fire, and central New York State — heretofore famous for cold winters and lake-effect snow —has been hit as hard as or harder than New York City.

Things could be worse. Indeed, things are certain to get worse: Even effective climate action now won’t be enough to prevent disasters from becoming even bigger and more frequent for many more years.

While this is not really a happy admission, I am thinking that Bob Dylan is the one who has given us the most accurate “heads up” on what’s coming down the line.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
June 26

GAGGING THE MONA LISA’S SUGAR-DADDY

The GOP, or Repubititanic Party, continues its path of blindly meandering along toward the inevitable implosion behind its self-promoting Orange-tinted leader, who has faced little criticism from his base, and even among those running against him for the presidential nomination of the doomed party. As the Former Guy told Maxine Hughes of Welsh channel S4C in a documentary entitled ‘Trump: Extreme World,’ “You have people that follow rock bands and they listen to the same songs over and over and over. You have people that go to the Mona Lisa. They love the Mona Lisa and they’ll see it hundreds and hundreds of times, and it gets better every time, or to a Broadway play where they will see it 20 times.” Comparing it to his campaign events where he rants against his critics and dog-whistles the crowd, he admits he has few talking points, riffing on the same 20 subjects each time. “You’re talking about the border, you’re talking about the military, you’re talking about low taxes, you’re talking about certain things. I can’t just make new things up because I want to make a speech. I can tell them in different ways and I do sometimes do that, a lot of times. But they just want to hear it again and again.” Along with that Mona Lisa smile, assuredly! Leonardo da Vinci would have grown impatient trying to keep him hushed and immobile, resulting in a work portraying the subject wearing a smile-obscuring gag and handcuffs – not a bad idea over all.

The dozen or so GOP presidential hopefuls have pretty much declined any heady criticisms of Trump, aside from Chris Christie, as they consider the slavish posse still lined up behind the leading contender. Former VP, and invertebrate, Mike Pence, typified this behavior recently on ‘Meet the Press,’ when Chuck Todd soft-balled him about a pardon for Trump should Pence win the presidency. His response, as described by Aldous J. Pennyfarthing, as if it were “what Jesus would say if he were the corporate spokesperson for a Fort Wayne-based lunchmeat company trying to get out in front of a listeria outbreak – Pence pounced like a NyQuil-besotted banana slug.” A shocked and frightened Pence said, “Well (Reaganesque), I just think the question is premature. Honestly (Pencesque), Chuck, I’ve pardoned people who were found guilty of a crime.” Todd then asked him what was the bar for a pardon. “Well (ditto), let me say first and foremost, I don’t know why some of my competitors in the Republican primary presume the president (sic) will be found guilty. Look, all we know is what the president (sic) has been accused of in the indictment. We don’t know what his defense is. We don’t know if this will even go to trial. It could be subject to a motion to dismiss. We don’t even know what the verdict will be of the jury.” Spoken as a true vice-presidential wannabe!? Aldous J. writes a reminder to Pence that “he almost met Jesus on January 6 via the hanging squad, and that Jesus probably felt a migraine coming on and didn’t want to deal with a guy who wouldn’t stop asking if it was really safe for him to be alone with the Virgin Mary.” Chuck Todd then asks, “If you were President Biden, would you pardon him right now?” Pence answers, “I think this whole matter is incredibly divisive for the country. And, uh, look, uh, I just think at the end of the day, it is saddening to me that we are now in this moment.” Pen in hand, Pennyfarthing writes, “The correct answer is ‘No,’ I hope he rots in prison!” He visualizes both Pence and Christie on the debate stage with the other one- to two-dozen contenders, when the moderator asks, “Hands up if at any point Donald Trump tried to kill you,” which is bound to result in at least two raised hands, and maybe more. Who knows? Agent Orange keeps a lot of secrets, and recovery is still going on. For most of us who are tired of hearing this incessant burbling, we can echo musical artist Jimi Hendrix and cry, “‘Scuse me while I kiss the sky.” And Pence, using the mondegreen, “‘Scuse me while I kiss this guy.”

The ex-prez surely didn’t feel he was posing for a portrait when he faced off with Fox’s Bret Baier for an interview that was decidedly not in friendly territory, as historically has been the case. From the get-go, Baier pummeled him with curve balls, sliders and 98-mph fast balls that had him frowning and fidgeting red-faced, and on the edge of his seat awaiting the seventh inning stretch, or for a rain-delay to be called. Chuck Todd, and CNN’s Kaitlan Collins, who contributed to that network’s meltdown a couple of weeks ago, could learn a thing or two from Baier, an experienced reporter. Trump steamrolled Collins from his confused and jumbled memory, even with the softball questions she asked, as if he were being confronted with heavy accusations. The Don’s uneasiness showed his fear, being thrown off-balance by Baier’s insistence upon complete answers, not letting Trump’s attempts at dismissing questions derail his well-prepared interview. There was no hesitation as Baier interrupted, corrected, and challenged his interviewee, well-armed with quotes, sound clips, and charts with circles and arrows and a paragraph on the back, even having to defend Fox after Trump said, “I’m no great fan of Fox,” Baier pushing right back with, “You’re sitting here.” DOJ Special Prosecutor Jack Smith and associates gleaned a goldmine of prosecutorial evidence against Trump, thanks to Baier’s persistence. Poor Donny-boy…he really could have used his usual hooting and hollering crowd, cheering on his lies and bullying, not having to deal with this Fox-y individual who knows where all the bones are buried, where the skeletons are closeted. An amusing piece by Mia Mercado in The New Yorker about ‘bones,’ says, “A skeleton is a gathering of bones. Bones will typically get together for festive events such as Halloween, pirate-themed parties, and morbid Christmas. A gathering of skeletons is known as ‘catacombs’ in France. In the United States, it is known as C-SPAN.” Add Fox News to your list, Maria!

The US Extreme Court has just about wrapped up the summer session with the big decisions on student debt relief, affirmative action, same-sex wedding sites, ‘independent state legislature’ theory, and a few others to finish out the traditional June-ending docket. Doubtless, they are attempting to get it all wrapped up to allow Justices Alito and Thomas to pack their bags in time to take off on whatever trips their sponsors have arranged for them, with fingers crossed that they get the docket for the next session lined up before the recess.  It’s unlikely that Chief Justice John Roberts will require any of the justices to remain after those decisions are handed down, which would allow him to give them a refresher course on ethics and allowable summer activities to document on their return…maybe some handouts as they go whooping and hollering out the front door, eh J.R.? Clarence Thomas seems to be the record holder on scored gifts and trips, though billionaire Paul Singer’s big catch, Justice Alito, may be closing that gap with his well-publicized fishing trip, and a newly disclosed trip to Rome, where he spoke at a ‘summit,’ courtesy of Notre Dame University’s Religious Liberty Initiative. Ending a fifty-year standing of a woman’s right to bodily autonomy deserves more than a stay in a D.C. area Hilton, so why not a hotel overlooking the Roman Forum? Stephanie Barclay, director of R.L.I., has confirmed that the cost of sending Samuel and wife, Martha, was covered by the ‘religious liberty’ group. Alito says there isn’t a conflict of interest here because the group has a number of components and he was not invited to speak by the ‘clinic‘ that may have business before the Supreme Court. So, the ‘clinic‘ involvement might have been a problem for him, but not the organization of which it is a part…ka-ching! Nothing to see here, folks, no need for disclosure!

What a group! Thomas and his sugar-daddy, Harlan Crow, who has funded numerous luxury trips for Clarence and his wife, college tuition for a nephew, home-purchase and free rent for mom, and secret payments of tens of thousands of bucks to wife and insurrectionist, Ginni, through an arrangement with Leonard Leo. Brett Kavanaugh had a court debut with 83 ethics complaints and sexual assault allegations that keep cropping up. Neil Gorsuch conveniently sold property after his court confirmation, to a law firm with business before the court. Amy Coney Barrett, former Notre Dame (where have we heard that name before?) professor, after being seated on the high court, sold her home to a recently hired prof who was assuming leadership at the Religious Liberty Initiative (aha!), making her the third court member to make money from property sales with influential conservative people, or to those connected to legal advocacy groups writing for the court. Drip, drip, drip. And, chief honcho Roberts has that “what,…you lookin’ at me?” expression, as his wife rakes in millions by recruiting attorneys for firms with business before the court. None of the justices deemed it necessary to recuse themselves as notable cases were tried! The generosity of billionaires contributed greatly to assembling the super majority group, and the financial incentives put before them dissuades the justices from deviating from the doctrinaire ideologues and the conservative positions they push. Existing charts have demonstrated the trend followed by jurists as they get older toward a more liberal bias, leading these wealthy puppet masters to counter that anomaly with their largesse, codes of ethics be damned! What next? Overturning state and local gun regulations? Gutting voting rights protections? Attacking climate-change decisions? Striking down Roe v….oh yeah, too late for ALL that! Our citizens are now realizing that our Supreme Court isn’t a body that issues earnest and principled rulings, though we may at times disagree; the court is now seen as the American right-winger’s rigidly partisan and unprincipled political weapon, likely to remain significantly unchanged for another forty years. Conservatives are quick to rush into the fray, defending the court for being attacked and intimidated by left-wingers. Take Senator Tom Cotton’s standing up for Justice Alito’s Alaska trip funded by Paul SingerFederal Elections Commission records show Cotton’s election campaign received close to $20K from a Paul Singer and family. The man clearly knows where to put his money…Singerin’ a song, side by side!

On a recent Amicus podcast on Slate, with Dahlia Lithwick and Mark Stern, they discussed the Supremes‘ ethics breaches, identifying the pioneer of such behavior as Justice Antonin Scalia, who was a frequenter of fishing trips, or stays at hunting lodges and resorts on his wealthy acquaintances’ tabs. Ah yes, Paul Singer was one of his patrons. Exemplar Scalia set the tone for both Thomas and Alito, who have no use for following hard and fast ethics rules. Lithwick says, “I don’t care where Sam Alito goes on vacation. I don’t care that Harlan Crow builds a petting zoo for Clarence Thomas in the backyard. What I care about is that there is a machine that seats justices at the court, and keeps other justices off the court, and that billions of dollars flood into this machine.” She asks Stern if he thinks some of the justices are moderating some of their decisions because of the stench from the bad publicity. He answers, “I don’t want to say the court has moderated. This court remains extremely conservative on issues the justices care about, like doing away with affirmative action, attacking the administrative state, and enshrining the right to discriminate into the law of religious freedom. And the more that Thomas and Alito look like crooks, there’s going to be a reaction from the other conservatives. They’re going to have the chief justice standing there with his arms wide open saying, ‘Oh, you want an alternative? Well, that’s what I’m here for. I’m John Roberts, and I live for this. You want a narrowly crafted compromise that inches the law to the right? I’m on it. You want a surprise, centrist victory that simply preserves the status quo while making progressives feel good? I can cook that up for you.’ John Roberts knows how to do this. And in times of crisis and uncertainty, that can look a whole lot more appealing than the nihilism offered by Alito and Thomas.”

This just in! Satirist, Andy Borowitz of The New Yorker, reports that the “situation in Russia descended into further uncertainty after Arizona’s Kari Lake stunned geopolitical experts by declaring herself the new leader of the Wagner Group. Speaking from the mercenary force’s new headquarters in Phoenix, AZ, the former anchorwoman claimed that she won leadership of Wagner by a landslide. She warned Russian state media against questioning her claim to the Wagner helm. ‘I will be your worst frickin’ nightmare,’ she said. Wagner troops expressed surprise at Lake’s sudden elevation and reservations about whether she would be an improvement over their former leader, Yevgeny Prigozhin. ‘She seems really mean,’ one said.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “July”

“We can’t possibly have a summer love. So many people have tried that the name’s become proverbial. Summer is only the unfulfilled promise of spring, a charlatan in place of the warm balmy nights I dream of in April. It’s a sad season of life without growth…It has no day.”

~F. Scott Fitzgerald, This Side of Paradise

“July is a blind date with summer.”
~Hal Borland, Sundial of the Seasons

“But here I am in July, and why am I thinking about Christmas pudding? Probably because we always pine for what we do not have. The winter seems cozy and romantic in the hell of summer, but hot beaches and sunlight are what we yearn for all winter.”

~Joanna Franklin Bell

“Then came July like three o’clock in the afternoon, hot and listless and miserable.”

~Allie Ray, Holler

...

Language. It is so cool! I think most people have heard of mondegreens, but have you heard to eggcorns? Well, now you have. Thank me later 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

June 21 – 27, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…Pellerin party, join the DSA, Kauai bargain. Greensite…on city Public Relations. Schendledecker…water pollution, trees, and Juneteenth. Steinbruner…McPherson retiring, county budget burst, Aptos Beach road, park funds, keep Cabrillo name. Hayes…we love this land. Patton…a word from the godfather of AI. Matlockfavorite daughter, mata hari and mister Magoo, how do you do? Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week…woodworking tips Quotes…“Crows”

...

CAJASTACA COLLEGE in 1962. Once known as Cabrillo Community College and opened in 1959, it’s been called by many names, it usually has about 10,000 students. The Cajastaca were a smaller and separate group of the Aptos who lived more southerly…according to Martin Rizzo-Martinez.  Hard to imagine using that name instead of Cabrilho or Cabrillo. They were also named the Achistaca…try using that in a sentence. Read the end of Becky Steinbruner’s column below and see why they shouldn’t name it Aptos.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE June 19

INVITE FROM GAIL PELLERIN!

Happy Summer! The weather is getting warmer and you can feel the energy shifting all around us – with school out and families on vacation. Though summer is in the air, the election is around the corner and I am excited to announce that I am running for re-election as representative for Assembly District 28. I look forward to continuing our partnership to address the needs of the district.

The end of this month marks our second quarter fundraising deadline. This deadline is critical to the campaign, and I need your help. If you are able, please consider making a contribution to my campaign by midnight on Friday, June 30. You can click here or the button below to donate.

I also hope you can join me at my birthday celebration and re-election kick-off coming up on Saturday, June 24. You can click here for more information on how to RSVP.

DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISTS OF AMERICA…NOW!  dsasantacruz.org This organization of locals and from around the nation is about the closest in goals and dreams of any group I know. Check out what they’re fighting for. They sent this notice….

“Just prior to the next Monthly Membership Meetingon July 8th (hybrid Zoom and at London Nelson Center) we will be hosting a New Member Orientation. Whether you are a new member or looking for a refresher on the working groups in DSA Santa Cruz please join us and we can help you get plugged into the chapter and learn more about what we have. Register here if you’re interested in attending.

KAUAI BOUND???
My daughter Jennifer (former Santa Cruzan) has a timeshare week in lovely Kauai they can’t use and have it listed on Airbnb which means it’s secure. There’s only this one week available and at only $150 per night it’s a hell of a bargain. Especially this season. That’s Westin Princeville Kauai July 3rd-10th

It’s a Studio villa and sleeps 4 people. This link tells you all about it…

Get in touch with Jennifer, she’ll work it out.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

LIAISON. (APPLE SERIES). (6.4 IMDB).   Vincent Cassel is the lead in this carbon copied spy story. The only thing new in it is that everybody uses computers and I Phones. I’m serious when I tell you it takes place in Damascus, London, Turkey, and bad old Syria. But it turns out that London has water barriers that raise and lower when the bad tides come in. Santa Cruz’s West Cliffs need some of these barriers, but don’t watch Liaisons anyways.

MY POLICEMAN. (AMAZON MOVIE). (6.5 IMDB) . A policeman and a teacher guy squabble back and forth throughout the entire movie deciding whether or not the policeman is gay. Lots of gay scenes in this one. It’s tender, and good old Rupert Everett is in it but can’t speak due to his ageing. Both tough and tender to watch and it’s handled beautifully.

EXTRACTION 2. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB). Chris Hemsworth is the big star of this war movie. It takes place in Georgia (right where Europe joins with Asia. It’s nearly 98% hand to hand battling…way too much and we don’t care who wins anyways with a name like Tyler Rake for Hemsworth.

A BEAUTIFUL LIFE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.4 IMDB). It’s supposed to be a romantic drama about life in the music recording business. It features a singer/ guitarist named “Christopher” who is very blah. It’s also about how one trains and performs under contract and it’s not worth seeing or reading about.

 WHERE THE TRACKS END. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB).  A new film from Mexico centering on one school teacher and her favorite young student. It all happens along the Rio Bravo River among the very poorest of the students and citizens. It’s a genuine feel good saga it’s the field bosses fighting the helpless workers. It’s low key and near boring and undramatic.

THE DAYS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.3 IMDB).   Remembering what happened with the nuclear power plant disasters on Three Mile Island and Chernobyl and what could have happened in Bodega Bay and Santa Cruz this is a dramatic review of the seven days during the Fukushima Daiichi explosion in Japan in March 2011. A tsunami started the disaster in their nuclear reactor and it’s all carried out in three viewpoints… the government, the electric power company and of course the people/citizens including much of Tokyo that also lost power. Watch it by all means.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

SHE SAID. (AMAZON MOVIE) (7.2 IMDB). I wish I had more thumbs to give this detailed “near documentary” of the Harvey Weinstein sexual abuse cases. The film failed miserably at the box-office, but won awards all over the world. Two New York Times women reporters (one played by Carey Mulligan the other by Zoe Kazan) pursue Weinstein leads all over the world. Ashley Judd, one of Harvey’s victims appears in it and acts her part. 82 women have come out revealing their having been raped by Weinstein. He’s now serving a 23 year sentence in what used to be the Erie County jail in New York State, it’s now called the Wende Correctional Facility. Go for it.

LOVE & DEATH. (MAX SERIES) (7.2 IMDB).   Based on a true story out of Texas in 1980 this saga centers on a married couple and the male is played by Jesse Plemons, unfortunately. Being very truthful I’m admitting that I can’t watch Plemons in any role he’s been in. He’s slimy and reminds me all too much of Trump. He has an unhappy wife played by Elizabeth Olsen. There’s nothing believable between/within this couple and it’s just another murder plot like the million we’ve seen before.

THE CROWDED ROOM. (APPLE TV) (7.0 IMDB). Tom Holland does a deep and superior job of acting along with Amanda Seyfried. It takes place in Manhattan in 1979 and deals with D.I.D. (Dissociative Identity Disorders). Two murders happen and we get to watch Holland attempt to explain and examine his life before the killings. Only 3 episodes so far, and it’s all good.

HEARTLAND. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). It’s been running 15 seasons so I watched a few episodes. It’s corny, mostly poor acting, trite and all about a family’s inter relationships which were boring and we’ve seen it in hundreds of movies before. Avoid at all costs.

TO LESLIE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). Andrea Riseborough is the roughed up, downtrodden former winner of a $ 190,000 dollar lottery who has spent it all on booze, drugs and a very loose way of life. We watch her trying to retain some semblance of her former life and consistently failing. Allison Janney and Marc Maron are of no help to her. The twists, and shocks to her system are devastating, sad and very realistic and human. Watch it but not when you need laughs.

...

June 19

VONNEGUT WAS RIGHT

If you’ve not read Kurt Vonnegut’s Player Piano, or not in a while, it’s well worth the read. His prescience regarding machines and AI is real for our time. One paragraph caught my attention. The character is quoting the definition of the job of Public Relations: “that profession specializing in the cultivation, by applied psychology in mass communication media, of favorable opinion with regard to controversial issues and institutions, without being offensive to anyone of importance and with the continued stability of the economy and society its primary goal.” Kurt Vonnegut. Player Piano 1952

And look how they multiply! A decade ago, public relations people were scarce in the city of Santa Cruz. Gradually, department after department created that new position so now, most have them. Do they fit Vonnegut’s description? Well just today the City of Santa Cruz Community Relations Specialist posted a public release titled Cowell Beach Water Quality Success Continues Fourth Year on Heal the Bay Annual Beach Report Card. The city and its working group that addressed the problem can take a victory lap on this good news. Full disclosure, I’m a member of the working group, representing the Sierra Club since 2014. The release of the Heal the Bay Report is always a bit anxious making for the working group since for a decade Cowell Beach was #1 bummer on the Report Card. In response, the group took concrete steps to address the problem and the result is ongoing good news that deserves inclusion in a press release. But that is not all the news in the Heal the Bay Report that covers beaches and waterways in the city of Santa Cruz.

There is another entry in the Heal the Bay Report that pertains to Main Beach. That entry, with accompanying data reads:

“Seven separate spills sent a total of 553,150 gallons of sewage into waterways. Thirty-six thousand gallons of sewage flowed into the San Lorenzo River less than half a mile upstream from Main Beach in January. We are alarmed as we could not find a record of a beach closure due to that spill.”  Heal the Bay 2022-23 Beach Report Card.

This sure fits Vonnegut’s description of “specializing in favorable opinion with regard to controversial issues.” Only here, in our reality they bury the controversy. I guess it’s hard to put a favorable spin on spilled sewage. But to omit it entirely?

City council has just finished passing the budget going into the next year. I assume all the public relations positions were funded. They are well paid by frontline worker standards and far less useful in my opinion. Worse, their job is to manipulate public opinion, not share city news. Otherwise, we would have received a public release of the city’s good news on Cowell Beach and ways we need to do better on Main Beach. Except they strive to be favorable, as Vonnegut says, “without being offensive to anyone of importance.”

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

June 19

WATER POLLUTION, TREES, AND JUNETEENTH

Wednesday, June 14th, I attended the city’s “Industrial Users Local Discharge Limits Discussion” on the Enhanced Source Control 10-year Update (Becky Steinbruner was there too, check out her column below for her take).

This process is not to set what pollutants are allowed in our wastewater, but to identify what is already in there and place limits on it. Apparently, there is a bit of community freak-out each time this review comes up, because people misunderstand the testing and limits as new allowances for new discharge. That’s not the case.

This is the third review and update process since 2002, one of the ways in which we fulfill the Clean Water Act. The process is meant to allow for “apolitical continuity,” regardless of who is on our city council, according to Akin Babatola (City of Santa Cruz Environmental Compliance and Laboratory Manager). The mandate is to perform our wastewater treatment in environmentally responsible ways and defend against pollution, including now for water recycling (thus the “enhanced” of extra treatment and testing).

The city’s Wastewater Treatment Facility (WWTF) processes wastewater from homes and businesses beyond city limits, with about 80% coming from households. Our stormwater runs straight into our waterways without treatment (except some seasonal treatment of Neary Lagoon water).

Household wastewater is monitored in aggregate by the WWTF and our pollutants are taken into account in the WWTF’s National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit for our Monterey Bay outfall pipe. Industrial Users include non-householders like UCSC, restaurants, breweries, and manufacturers like Santa Cruz Nutritionals. Industrial users have their own NPDES permits, with additional site monitoring carried out by our own Environmental Compliance Officers, as well as by consultants for things like this current review.

Chatting with Mr. Babatola after the presentations, I asked what kinds of industrial dischargers are of concern in our community. I was surprised to learn that breweries can be a real problem, not because they use nasty chemicals, but because there is an incredible amount of organic matter left over from the brewing process that can create bacterial overgrowth and algal blooms. Smaller WWTFs may not be able to handle the intensity of that discharge. Ideally, breweries have the resources to install bio-digesters on site, to convert their waste into non-waste products like animal feed or compost. Of course, not many local breweries have the space or funding to do what Sierra Nevada does.

I also asked about the Compounds of Emerging Concern (CEC) on the short list that we may need to add to the long list before the next 10-year review. These compounds have been around for ages, but it’s only now that we have both the methods to test for them when they’re dispersed in water AND the EPA has set standards for their testing and limits. Carbon disulfide, listed above as coming from rayon and cellophane, is more likely coming from the wrappings on all our digital device batteries.

PFAS compounds are a good example of a class of chemicals that are very concerning, and that we can test for, but the EPA hasn’t set their standards yet (that may change in a year or so). So they’re, unfortunately, not on the list of currently limited compounds, or even the compounds of concern–but that doesn’t mean that they’re not already in our wastewater or, potentially, outflow to the bay.

A much shorter version of this workshop will be presented to city council in early August for (hopefully quick and painless) approval. Our WWTF workers, lab, compliance officers, operators, and maintenance people do amazing work (and win awards for it!). Look for this agenda item when the council is back from summer break and write or call in to support these expert recommendations.

The county is doing their own review and will present it just once to the Board of Supervisors, so keep an eye out for that one too.

At last week’s council meeting, the appeal of removal of two very large redwood trees in a yard on Union Street was denied (item 26, you can read the documents and watch it here). The trees were planted too close to the historic house somewhere between 40 and 90 years ago, and now they are getting a bit snug, even perhaps squishing it a little on one side, and sending roots under the foundation.

The valiant appeal effort by Elise Casby and Marvin Lewis was asking for more time, an independent inspection (which owners had refused), and consideration of options for preserving both the trees and the house. Options might include: modifying the house to accommodate tree growth, moving the house, maintaining or modifying drainage systems, or (I wonder) just removing one tree plus moving the house.

The house is currently owned and looking to be sold by out of town landlords who have rented it out for years. Their argument, upheld by a slim majority of Parks and Recreation Commission members and a large majority of council members (everyone but Councilmember Brown, natch), was that they needed to protect the return on their investment, and ensure an easy sale. It seems quite common around here for houses to be lifted for new foundations or to be moved. I wonder what the cost comparison of that to what will surely be a VERY expensive tree removal would be.

Councilmember Golder said (in a nutshell) that she felt the preservation of the house was ultimately more important than preservation of the trees, because the house was older, and historic. I’m all for historic preservation, but on the other hand, this is a settler colonial house that can only hold a handful of people at a time, being given priority over two giant trees that could live for thousands of years and be home to countless critters. Could we not have negotiated between the two interests more? Private property won over trees, again.

I hope you all found ways to honor and celebrate Juneteenth, and to connect with and support our Black community members. Please watch the documentary “13th” to learn about how slavery lives on in the US carceral system.

On June 8th I was lucky enough to attend a special “Music for Abolition” performance at the UCSC Institute of the Arts and Sciences. It was filmed and I hope it will be available to share freely at some point, because it was absolutely incredible. We owe everyone involved in co-creating and supporting the IAS a debt of gratitude for bringing great programming to Santa Cruz.

What Is Abolition, And Why Do We Need It?

Click on this …. and think about it!!

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
June 19

BRUCE MCPHERSON IS RETIRING AS COUNTY SUPERVISOR
Last week, County Supervisor Bruce McPherson formally announced he will not seek re-election as Fifth District County Supervisor.  It has been expected by many for a while, dating back to the contentious redistricting line discussions in 2021 submitted at the last minute by Scotts Valley Mayor Derek Timm, and that some felt were meant to redraw lines favorable to his running for Fifth District Supervisor.

One candidate, Monica Martinez, had already thrown her hat in the ring in April.  The public would be wise to scrutinize her actions as CEO of Community Services for Encompass …more to come on that.

It will be interesting to see if Bruce McPherson really retires, or if he will seek another State-level seat?  He did let me know his displeasure with “being termed-out in Sacramento” when I quizzed him about his opposition to the term limit proposal of County District Supervisors, last year by then-Supervisors Greg Caput.

No wonder Supervisor McPherson has been so outspoken recently on CZU Fire issues and Housing Element matters.  He no longer has to “go along to get along” with issues and the pressure to have the Board unanimously approve everything.

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY BUDGET BURSTS PAST $1.1 MILLION WITH LITTLE TRANSPARENCY OR PUBLIC DISCUSSION
Last Tuesday, the County Board of Supervisors and CAO staff fell all over each other thanking each other for passing the 2023-2024 Budget that has an even higher deficit than had been earlier reported, and made no mention at all of the looming CalPERS unfunded pension debt that is skyrocketing.

This all happened a full month earlier than is historically done, with public hearings reduced to half the time and eliminating both evening public hearings that have always been held in Watsonville and chambers in the Santa Cruz County Government building to give working people the opportunity to hear the proposed Budget overview presentations and ask questions / comment.

The information on the website is hard to find, and a link to the public hearings and inherent documents has been broken for weeks.

I have pointed these problems out to the Board more than once, and written the Director of IT for the county.  I wrote a letter asking that the Board Cure and Correct the Brown Act violations inherent.

NO response.

However, what has changed is that the Budget Hearings all have a posted transcript, beginning May 30.   That has never happened before.  Take a look at the abysmal transcript for June 13 Final Budget Hearing: 2023/06/13 01:30 PM Board of Supervisors Cont’d BUDGET HEARINGS – Last Day – Web Outline – Santa Cruz County, CA

When CAO Carlos Palacios initially was handed the reins of running the County by former CAO Susan Mauriello (she actually handed him what she called a “magic wand”), he said he would take a new approach with formulating two-year budgets that would improve long-term planning and cut costs.  Remember that?  Not so now.  In fact, in the instance of County Fire Dept. and CalFire, we have not yet seen a contract for service agreement, yet the County Fire Department vague and confusing budget shows a negative $3 million figure.   Hmmm..

Amazingly, a woman representing California State Association of Counties (CSAC) drove all the way from Sacramento to present two awards to the Board, one being for the Online Interactive Budget Website, and the other for Criminal Justice Council Policy Review.

She said the Online Budget website was really wonderful because it incorporates the County Strategic Plan.  What?  That’s the subjective list of feel-good words at the end of each agenda item that gets tallied up and converted into demonstrating how responsive each item is to problems at hand.  The words are the same ones as were on the list the CAO posted in public hearings and gave everyone a fixed number of colored dots to stick on what they thought most important.  Remember that little meaningless exercise?

Maybe the most amazing thing about that presentation was the photo op. when Chairman Zach Friend left the shelter of the dais and joined the CSAC lady on the public side of the Chambers, removing his mask so we could all see him suddenly smile for the camera.

You can watch it here, at minute 14:00: Video Outline – Santa Cruz County, CA

COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND PLANNING DEPT. REFUSED TO PROTECT LIFE AND PROPERTY ON APTOS BEACH ROAD
Last Tuesday, it was shocking to witness the County Planning Dept. twist information to thwart efforts of a property owner wanting to build an engineered retaining wall meant to prevent any further slide action threatening homes below, and the Board of Supervisors refusing to take action to protect lives and property, even though they could.

At issue is whether an engineered retaining wall at the top of a coastal bluff is properly called a shoreline protection element.  The property owners, their civil engineer, and their expert land use professional said “NO”, and argued that at first the County Planning Dept. had agreed when accepting their application.

The Planning Dept. changed their minds months later and said the project had to have an alternatives analysis because of the impacts on the shoreline sand.   The property owner initially rejected that, but finally had to cave in, spending the big dollars to provide such a report to the Planning Dept.  The Planner, Mr. Evan Ditmars, first said the appellant property owner had not provided the Alternatives Analysis, and would be grounds for dismissing the appeal, which brought a gasp of exasperation from the property owner in the audience.

Later, when questioned a bit further by Supervisor Manu Koenig, Mr. Ditmars and Deputy Planning Director Ms. Carolyn Burke (who is apparently leaving the County job for one with another municipality) then admitted that they had received the required Alternatives Analysis but did not have time to review it.

Chairman Zach Friend then opened the floor to the public, violating County procedure as to how an appeal is to held.  The Appellant paid likely over $2000 for the appeal hearing, but Chairman Zach Friend gave them TWO MINUTES for each who wanted to speak, even cutting off the appellant’s civil engineer mid-sentence because his time was up!

Chairman Friend then said the appellants could just start all over again, and re-apply with the now-completed Alternatives Analysis in hand.  Another gasp from the property owner.    Supervisor Bruce McPherson asked how much that would cost the property owner/appellant and could the Planning Dept. just review the Alternatives Analysis to see if the determination that there is no other alternative to building an engineered retaining wall to protect the homes below is valid?

Ms. Burke smiled and said they could do so for an hourly rate.

The topic then went to how much time that might take?  She wanted three to four months. Another gasp from the property owner, who then spoke up and said they really want to get this done before another round of winter storms.  Finally, the Board agreed to allow 30-60 days, and a report back.

It was shocking to hear the Planning Dept. twist things, and to hear the Board of Supervisors refuse to really jump in and try to protect life and property, which is their primary responsibility as elected public servants who have all signed an Oath to uphold such duty, under the California State Constitution Article XIII Section 35(a)(2).

Listening to what transpired at that appeal hearing last Tuesday is worth your time to do, and to write a letter to the Editor with your thoughts, and file a complaint with the Santa Cruz County Grand Jury.

Here is the link to the video.  Click on Item #13 on the agenda and listen carefully to what you hear.

Here are the documents for the June 13 Regular Meeting, item #13 Appeal Hearing

Here is the link to the Santa Cruz County Grand Jury website, where you can file a complaint, as well as read their investigative reports.

HOUSING ELEMENT NEEDS YOUR INVOLVEMENT
The County and all cities are feverishly working on putting together an updated Housing Element of their General Plans that will make the State Housing and Community Development (HCD) smile with approval by January 1, 2024, while incorporating the ridiculously-high mandated building rate without infrastructure to support it.  6th Cycle Housing Element Program

Here is your last chance to weigh in on this process with the County:

Community Open House

Watsonville Civic Plaza Community Room
275 Main Street, Watsonville

Food will be provided

Spanish interpretation available

Wednesday, June 28th

Get Involved

COUNTY PARK DEDICATION FUNDS SEEM CLOUDED
Here is what the County Budget Final Day documents said last week, leaving me to wonder where a seemingly errant $1.5 million in Capital Improvement Projects for Parks may have gone???

Due to the nature of capital projects, budget appropriations often carryover from one fiscal year to the next and remain programmed to a specific project until completion. Any remaining funds after a project is completed can be reprogrammed to support other existing projects or new projects. Park Dedication Funds are capital funds collected via park impact and in-lieu fees imposed on new development. Use of these funds is restricted to acquisition and certain improvements to parklands. Previous action by the Board consolidated 19 separate Park Dedication Funds into a central fund to increase their effectiveness in supporting park capital projects that have been prioritized in the Capital Improvement Plan, Parks Strategic Plan, and other emerging critical needs, all guided by making equitable parks investments throughout the county.

The County Administrative Office is engaged with project teams on year-to-year fund balance amounts in order to further supplement the proposed Capital Projects List using one-time project savings and balances. These proposed uses of additional funds will be presented on June 13, 2023 at the Last Day Budget Hearings to support the existing capital program priorities of the Board.

More details on projects and project changes, budget goals, fiscal sustainability and future considerations for FY 2023-24 will be included in the Capital Projects budget presentation.

Financial Impact

The Capital Projects Proposed Budget includes $20,598,354 in expenditures offset by $15,598,354 in revenues and $5,000,000 in General Fund contribution, reflecting an increase of $3,022,221 or 17.2% from the FY 2023-24 Base budget (the Adopted prior year budget adjusted for known active projects and projects completed in the current fiscal year).

Here is what the Last Day Budget Summary actually stated:

$1,961,996 increase of Capital Projects as detailed in Exhibit 2, that includes $250,000 for prior Board directed capital project initiatives, including neighborhood improvements in areas impacted by vacation rentals in Districts 1 and 2, and $1,711,996 to appropriate one-time Parks District unobligated fund balances per Board Direction on May 31, 2023, from the now consolidated Park Dedication accounts and in alignment with Board capital priorities and in conjunction with County Parks;

BUD-2023-39 Consider approval of the 2023-24 County of Santa Cruz Proposed Budget Concluding Actions; approve the Continuing Agreements List for 2023-24; authorize the Auditor-Controller, with the concurrence of the County Administrative Officer, to

Now I understand the significance of former CAO Susan Mauriello’s gift of a “magic wand” to CAO Carlos Palacios when she retired.

BRANCIFORTE FIRE DISTRICT RESIDENTS WILL HAVE NO REPRESENTATION AFTER ANNEXATION WITH SCOTTS VALLEY FIRE IS COMPLETE THIS FALL
Last week, the Board of Directors for both Scotts Valley fire and Branciforte Fire Districts met, both approving without any amendment, a Plan for Services for Branciforte Reorganization.  Neither Board honored what the people of Branciforte Fire District (“Happy Valley area”) have been told…that there will be redistricting action after the annexation that will ensure equal representation and control of funds, equipment and assets of Branciforte Fire area taxpayers.  Thus, all power will remain with the at-large elected Scotts Valley Fire Board.

Judging by how that Board treated me during my public comment time, I am worried they will pay no heed to any future recommendations the proposed Branciforte Advisory Commission might offer.

Right now, Branciforte Fire District residents are considering a Special Benefit Assessment ballot Prop. 218 action that will decide whether they will pay over $1million in addition to what they already pay in special fire assessments to support their local station.  LAFCO Director Joe Sereno has threatened that if they do not pay this staggering assessment, they will suffer closure of their station.  Scotts Valley Fire has said it would likely be used at critical fire and storm times, and maybe for other emergency uses, too.

Take a trip up Branciforte Drive and see what you think the people have to say.  Stay tuned.  Will the Branciforte Fire Board wake up and amend the Plan for Services to insist on district-based elections for the Scotts Valley Fire Board after annexation before it is too late?  Let’s hope they pay attention to what happened in the Central Fire District annexation of Aptos/La Selva Fire, wherein the agency converted to district-based elections for Board members, providing a more equitable level of representation.

SCOTTS VALLEY FIRE PLANS TO PUT A $21 MILLION BOND ISSUE ON NOVEMBER BALLOT
Chief Ron Whittle, at his final Board meeting before retirement, last Wednesday told the Board the plans for a new fire station are nearing completion, but at a higher cost than had been anticipated.   He said he felt the new administration building associated with the fire station was “kind of big”, and he would like to see whether reducing that would lower the cost, and the dollar level of the impending Bond that will be on the November ballot.

6.14.2023 Board Packet [pdf]

This begs the question….Will the property owners of Branciforte Fire District have to pay for that too once they are annexed, if the Bond passes?  Will they get to vote on that November ballot measure?  Hmmm….

CABRILLO COLLEGE NAME SHOULD STAY
Last Wednesday, the five chosen names for Cabrillo College were unveiled by College President Matt Wetstein and Trustee Cuevas.  I got stuck in traffic, and arrived late, just as people were scurrying about with post-its to “vote” for their favorite of the five names, but I met a lot of people who were leaving the room with frowns.

It turns out I was spared yet another self-congratulatory presentation bordering on condescension, and the blind insistence that Cabrillo College simply must change its name.  People wanted to know the results of the “Survey” asking for new name suggestions, and were told that a total of 383 of the more than 1000 suggestions stated the name should stay as Cabrillo College.

One brave citizen had stood up as the post-it frenzy was about to begin and said “If you think the name should not change, put your notes on that whiteboard over there.”  Several people did.

Well, the arrogant Name Trustees have just launched yet another “Survey” where you can digitally put your post-it and vote for your favorite of the five.

Take note…There is no choice provided for “NONE”.  Local Historian Sandy Lydon was in the audience, and pointed out that technically, Cabrillo College is not in Aptos.  “Folks, we are in Soquel.  Borregas Creek is the dividing line between Soquel and Aptos.  The post office messed up.”

Hmmm…That explains why Cabrillo College was not in the Aptos/La Selva Fire service boundary.

Name Exploration Sub Committee

Write a letter to the Editor of your favorite newspaper and share your thoughts on this matter.

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS AND EXPECT ANSWERS.
DO ONE THING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
June 19

WE LOVE THIS LAND

(I wrote this column after cogitating about a quote from Zachary Ormsby, a local BLM land manager, referenced here.)

Are there none among us who do not love this land?

It has been said that we all have in common the love of the land. I rather doubt it, but who am I to judge? Does everyone you know love the land?  How do you know? Do you talk about this love with others? Do the actions of those around you indicate their love of land?

Perhaps these concepts hinge on definition. What does “land” mean? What is “love?”

Land

The term ‘land’ is an odd one. In movies, sailors celebrate ‘land-ho!’ There once was a class distinction ‘landed gentry,’ also no longer used. There was once a ‘back to the land’ movement, but I haven’t heard that used in a while. At about that time, Aldo Leopold proposed a “land ethic,” which almost no one thinks about or has really formulated for themselves.

There are two more common ways the word ‘land’ is used. The most common seems to be in real estate: to buy or sell “land,” with or without “improvements,” such as a house, normally modified by a number of acres and usually in reference to more rural locations. For instance, you might hear something like: “Paulette purchased 5-acres of land out in Zayante with a 3-bedroom house.” Or “I’m looking to buy a few acres of land in the hills above Soquel.” Around here, only the relatively wealthy would be using this terminology.

A small subset of people would hear the other way the word ‘land’ is used nowadays. Open space agency personnel talk about the ‘land’ they manage. They create ‘land’ management plans and even sometimes engage the public in those planning processes. In this case, ‘land management’ is supposed to mean the entirety of what is good and necessary to steward a given place. When such agency personnel refer to the ‘land,’ they mean a given property, sort of in the same way the term is used in real estate.

Collectively Loving the Land

I haven’t heard anyone exclaim “I love this land,” but I have heard people proclaim their love of country. When was the last time you heard someone say, “I love my country!”? My mother used to say, “I love my state!” referring to Virginia, but I haven’t heard anyone else mention such strong feelings about a state. I have heard people say, “I love Santa Cruz!” normally when something odd happens that seems unique to the weirdness of the City.

In reference to love of ‘land,’ I have heard recreationalists say, “I love biking at Wilder Ranch,” or, “I love watching the waves from the bluffs at 4-mile,” or “I love taking wildlife photographs along the Enchanted Loop Trail.” Do those sentiments indicate a love of the land that is Wilder Ranch? Would you say that, collectively, those people love Wilder Ranch? This is starting to get confusing.

Sentimental Attachments

Nature is so nurturing that we develop attachments to place, but I wonder if those attachments are the same as love. Hearing or saying “I love my…partner, child, parent, friend” conjures up powerful emotions. We love to be loved and live to love. Love is all there is. Loving people has elements of caring, respect, nurturing, and a hundred other things. Some say that we cannot love what we do not understand, and I sense most people seeking to better understand those people that they love. This level of striving to understand is not the same with most people’s relationship with nature, or ‘land.’

When you say, “I love drinking tea with Lois,” you are not saying “I love Lois.” Likewise, saying “I love biking at Wilder Ranch,” is not the same as saying you love Wilder Ranch. We are clear on the first, but people seem confused about the second. In both cases, there is a sense of sentimentality about an action. If you truly loved Wilder Ranch, what would you in fact be doing with that strong emotion?

Love Actions

If you loved Lois and she was threatened by something, you would undoubtedly consider helping her. To do otherwise would suggest that maybe you didn’t really love Lois that much, really. Likewise, if you loved Wilder Ranch and it was threatened by something, would you consider helping? If you didn’t, would you feel good about saying that you loved Wilder Ranch – the actual ‘land’ that is Wilder Ranch?

Seeking Land Loving Relationships

Ideally, the best place to look for people who truly love open space “land” such as Wilder Ranch would be the responsible land managers. Those people can develop deeper relationships with the land because they interact with it often and must understand it to responsibly manage it. There are dangers in developing such a love for open space, though.

Even the land managers “in charge” of a given piece of ‘land,’ have told me that the choice to adequately manage the land is not theirs. Apparently, they answer to someone higher up in the bureaucracy, are pressured by politically powerful interest groups, or something…they never really say. What they do say is that they must ‘balance’ varied demands on the land; in such a way, I wonder if they experience trauma from seeing the land they love damaged. Do they harden their hearts, create boundaries so that they do not love the land too deeply, or do they find solace in religious beliefs about destiny, the nature of humans, or some such things? Perhaps these people can never let themselves love the land, or perhaps their love of the land is something mysterious and different from their love of people.

Besides the idiosyncratic, institutionally bounded loving bond that certain open space land managers might form with the land they oversee, who else might love the land? Most would recognize that indigenous people have an actual love of the land they call home. So, might other people get to know a given piece of land and grow to love it? In both cases, you would imagine that these people would spend a lot of time considering how best to nurture those places and would strive to protect them from harm.

Action

My challenge to you: learn to love some open space land, and act on that love as if the place were your own…as if that place were your lover, your child, or your parent. What if we actually collectively loved the land…all those different groups who land managers are torn to pieces trying to please…to ‘balance?’ We can nurture each other’s love of the land, especially by deepening understanding, rooted in a commonly embraced land ethic.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

June 10

#161 / A Word From The Godfather Of A.I.

That is Geoffrey Hinton, pictured. Some call him “the godfather of A.I.” I recommend that you read the Wikipedia entry linked to Hinton’s name, to get a sense of his credentials.

If you click this link, you will be able to read a short article that outlines Hinton’s growing trepidation about the rapid development of “artificial intelligence” and what that will mean for us. The “Now This News” website, from which I got the article, and the picture of Hinton I have placed above, informs us that Hinton has recently quit his extremely high-paying job at Google, because Hinton wants to “talk about AI safety issues without having to worry about how it interacts with Google’s business. As long as I’m paid by Google,” Hinton says, “I can’t do that.”

Hinton does not, I was happy to see, present A.I. as some kind of independently-existing entity that is now seeking to displace human beings from their position in the world, on the basis of a claim that we will all soon be “outmoded.” Some discussions of A.I. do seem to characterize A.I. in just this way, pretty much portraying A.I. as some kind of new “creature,” a Frankenstein intelligence that will soon wreak havoc upon, and then displace, all that is human.

It may well be true that the technology that makes artificial intelligence work, invented by human beings like Hinton, can now accomplish certain things much more rapidly and comprehensively than any human being ever could. Still, the way I read what Hinton is saying, artificial intelligence is (and will remain) a human-developed “tool.” It is not some separate and independent creature that will ultimately be able to dispose of human beings altogether.

Hinton, in fact, is not so much worried about what “A.I.” will do, but about what “bad human actors” will do, utilizing the new capacities available to them through A.I.:

“It is hard to see how you can prevent the bad actors from using it for bad things,” Hinton told The New York Times in a highly publicized interview published May 1.
“Hinton says one of his primary concerns with AI is its potential for spreading misinformation. He noted that, given how simple it is to use AI for text and image generation, it’s become easier for people to create fake content. Hinton worries that we’ll eventually reach a point where people might “not be able to know what is true anymore (emphasis added).”

“Personalizing” A.I., thinking of A.I. as some new “entity,” separate from ourselves, is a category error. “A.I.” is not, in fact, independent of its human creators – and never will be. Human beings always need to look to themselves to figure out what to do about everything – and now we have to decide what to do about this new “tool” that can, literally, make it impossible for anyone to know what is “true,” and what is “real,” and what is not.

We must know “the truth” if we want to be able to act in a way that can be successful in attaining the outcomes we want to achieve. If the result of using A.I. will be to make it impossible to know or discover the actual truth – and that is what “the godfather of A.I.” is telling us may happen – then it seems rather clear what we need to do with A.I.

Get rid of it!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
June 19

FAVORITE DAUGHTER, MATA HARI AND MISTER MAGOO, HOW DO YOU DO?

Fox Network hosts excitedly announced that Melania Trump had entered the federal courthouse in Miami for her husband’s arraignment, showing some support for him in his moment of need. Only problem being is that it was The Don’s political aide, Margo Martin, sometimes described as a look-alike for the former First Lady, but a bit of an embarrassment for the incompetents who have been masquerading as news-hounds, while hanging onto every word Melania uttered for too many years. Someone who wasn’t expected to show up, and didn’t, was daughter, Ivanka Trump, who wished ‘Daddy‘ well…from afar. She and husband, Jared Kushner got their two billion dollar reward by playing footsie with the Arab Prince Bone Saw, so they’ve no more need for the orange-complexioned doofus who showed them the ropes in their life of crime. About the 37 felony count indictment announcement, Ivanka said, “I love my father, and I love my country. Today, I am pained for both. I appreciate the voices across the political spectrum expressing support and concern.” So, that’s it…no defense, no comment, close the shades, dim the lights until this is over…and keep the choppers gassed up just in case you have to escape this chaos upon which you left your fingerprints.

Of course, who could blame them after seeing the incriminating photos provided by DOJ in its indictment. As Aldous J. Pennyfarthing says, “Trump is just a low-rent mashup of Mata Hari and Mr. Magoo, and now Republicans are scrambling to find their moral compasses. Unfortunately, they left them behind during their endless debauched evenings with Trump and they can’t go back to look for them now. Dude’s radioactive. Most Republicans are blaming the Biden Administration for a political prosecution, but President Joe Biden had zero to do with Trump’s indictment and is likely as confused as the rest of us as to why anyone would put a chandelier in the bathroom. I guess when you’re the biggest egomaniac in the history of the planet, it automatically seems like a cotillion.” Especially with the plastic shower curtain hanging on a spring-loaded shower rod to conceal the bath/shower. Aldous J. says Trump has big problems now, “But someday after he loses his long, courageous battle by being hit by a Central Park hansom cab while bending over to pick up a Ho-Ho, his family will likely rediscover their affections. But for now, the apple of his weird reverse-raccoon eye is keeping her distance.” Ivanka posted a tribute on Instagram last week, assumed to be for her father’s 77th birthday, saying, “I wish you a year filled with the happiness you deserve. Your love, energy and strength inspire me every day.” Many suspected it was praise for another birthday celebrant; however, she included photos of her posing with her perp dad, unable to make a clean getaway!

Trump was clearly looking for a bigger crowd to show up outside the Miami courthouse to protest his arraignment, especially after posting on his social media account, “See you in Miami on Tuesday.” Federal and local security feared that their local plague of Proud Boys might cause problems, so Mayor and newly-declared GOP presidential hopeful, Francis Suarez reassured citizens that security would be tight. Tess Owen commented on Vice News that the Proud Boys were too obsessed with Bud Light to care about Trump’s appearance. The weekend preceding the court date, the ‘Vice City’ Proud Boys chapter in Miami reposted a flier promoting the protest, but by Monday they were back to targeting Pride Month, according to Owen. Cape Fear Proud Boys in North Carolina were actively posting updates about their protesting of a drag show in Winston-Salem, ignoring the indictment, and Proud Boys’ Tulsa chapter interrupted their anti-Pride buzz to acknowledge the death of Unabomber Ted Kaczynski, writing, “Rest in peace king.” Bud Light’s sponsorship of a family-friendly Pride event in Flagstaff, AZ attracted more ire from the group, so it’s up to Trump to find a flash-point with Diet Coke to get the no-shows’ attention, it seems.

After his court appearance, Trump and his cronies stopped at Versailles restaurant in Miami, located in Little Havana. Taking advantage of the cameras, phones and reporters who followed along, his entourage awkwardly held an impromptu prayer circle before Trump yelled to the diners inside, “Are you ready? Food for everyone! Food for everyone!” Needless to say, as per his modus operandi, he quickly vacated the premises and everyone got their own bill, bamboozled by Cult 45 again!

One attention getter for many, was Diaper Don’s winning the judge lottery…luck of the draw in having Judge Aileen Cannon to oversee his indictment case. Haven’t we seen enough of her already? Previously, the 11th Circuit Court reversed her decision in the investigation when she tried to give special treatment to a “deserving former President of the US,” which would have held up the case, decidedly in Trump’s favor. Cannon’s premise that a former president is not subject to the law as would be any other defendant because “…the stigma associated with the subject seizure is in a league of its own,” which quickly fell flat with the Circuit Court’s panel who said she didn’t have jurisdiction and should have no say in the case. Judge Cannon completely overlooked existing law and appointed a ‘special master’ to prevent the Department of Justice from reviewing Trump’s purloined documents. “The law is clear. We cannot write a rule that allows any subject of a search warrant to block government investigations after the execution of the warrant. Nor can we write a rule that allows only former presidents to do so,” they wrote in dismissing her meddling.

Objections to her being assigned to this new position were swift, with petitions circulating to have her removed, or impeached, in light of her mangled, result-oriented diversion, and highly questionable favoritism toward the Former Guy. Now, with another chance to show her gratitude to Trump for appointing her to the judgeship, columnist and former US attorney, Harry Litman, writes, “There are nearly 700 federal district court judges in the country. Of all of them, Cannon is the first whose fairness might reasonably be questioned. And of all the cases in the federal court system, none calls for a judge and process that inspire public confidence more than this one. It’s of paramount importance that this case be assigned to another judge — any other judge.” There are 18 judges in the South Florida Federal District Court, so the chances of drawing AILeen’s name from the pool would be less than 6%! Why was her name even a part of the selection process?!! It appears that she will not recuse herself as she has already issued her first order to get the ball rolling, instructing attorneys in the case to get in touch with DOJ’s litigation security group to expedite the necessary security process for viewing classified materials. Notice of compliance to her instructions was to be filed by June 20.

It will now depend upon how efficiently Cannon manages her docket as to how long the case will take — trial before or after the 2024 election? Land mines lie in wait for our court system, with many opportunities for sabotage along the way. Should Cannon attempt to toss out the case, it can be appealed and overturned. She can use voir dire in seating the jury by asking questions to determine if prospective jurors are free of prejudice or whether they can be fair and impartial, thereby stacking the jury Chockful O’ MAGAnuts. She will have the ability to sustain any frivolous objection by the defense attorneys and overrule the prosecution’s meritorious ones. Maybe she will direct a verdict of acquittal to render the jury as nonessential, or declare a mistrial for any number of reasons…perhaps the jury is deliberating past time for her lunch date, or by stretching out the various deadlines to run out the clock. And, because many procedural moves cannot be appealed until proceedings have closed, Cannon will be in complete control. KABOOM!

Harry Litman details Trump’s plan to escape accountability: “Trump is engaged in an outlandish and, for the country, very dangerous plot to delay the case until he can end it by winning the presidency in 2024. At that point, he could just order the Department of Justice to stand down. Note that Trump wouldn’t have to run the legal risk of pardoning himself at that point. Even if he is speedily convicted — a prospect made considerably less likely by the assignment of Trump-appointed Judge Aileen Cannon to the case — his conviction would almost certainly still be on appeal by January 2025, allowing him to simply order the department to drop the case. How can Trump, abetted by Cannon, go about maximizing the delay? Through a series of pretrial motions, all lacking merit to various degrees but nevertheless likely to take up considerable time.” Those boxes now being unloaded at Mar-a-Lago contain champagne, confetti, and party streamers for the big celebration. Judge Cannon has to watch her step because if she dares to veer off-course, The Don will turn on her…Fair Game! A bad spot to be in…just ask Lindsey Graham, or any GOP presidential campaign wannabe, none of whom wish to anger the MAGA king! He’s comin’a getcha!

The GOP is entangled and lost in an M.C. Escher drawing of their own making as they attempt to defend Trump after his indictment over the classified materials he stored haphazardly throughout Mar-a-Lago…one incriminating photo shows boxes stacked in a room with a photocopier placed conveniently to accommodate his Secrets ‘R Us minimart. Trump’s apologists can’t get their story lines to meld properly as they ignore the contents of the indictment, slip-slidin’ on the thin, transparent veneer of denial as they accuse Biden and the DOJ of political conspiracy to destroy the former prez’s candidacy. Senator Chuck Grassley wins the Lamé Excuse Award explaining his avoidance of the formal charges document, by saying he’s “not a legal analyst,” though it’s a quick-read, a plainly-worded paper. You could finish it off easy enough, Senator, as you sip your Metamucil-laced Ovaltine at breakfast. So, while many of the MAGA crowd “haven’t read the indictment,” Speaker McCarthy cops to have read “portions of it,” and Senator Graham, teary-eyed, weaves all over the road, still unclear about what’s going on. ‘Little Marco’ Rubio whines, “there’s no evidence the secret docs were sold to a foreign power and that nobody else had access to it,” a theme which he might want to keep mum about for now. We can only count on it to get worse, with the investigators holding much information close to their chests for now, and the Trumpers exercising extortion, sedition and espionage to keep their voters in line, sprinting with a Josh Hawley-like elegance, fists raised high, through the halls of governance.

Ron DeSantis followers, who want to promote his candidacy and his love and respect of all mankind, chose to demonstrate outside Disney World in Orlando — not with flowers, balloons and sweet treats for the attendees, but with DeSantis campaign signs and Nazi flags. Sad that parents and their young ones had to be met with such a display of hate, some followers of the Florida governor carrying signs reading, “Destroy all Pedophiles,” “White Pride Worldwide,” and “DeSantis 2024 Make America Florida.” State representative, Anna Eskamani called it “absolutely disgusting,” but also “absolutely revealing because it shows DeSantis is doing what they want and they love him for it, and they’re not afraid to show it.” Gonna get worse before it gets better!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Crows”

A rooster crows only when it sees the light. Put him in the dark and he’ll never crow. I have seen the light and I’m crowing”.
~Muhammad Ali

“Even a cock crows over his own dunghill“.
~Navjot Singh Sidhu

“No matter how much the private sector crows that corporate tax breaks will lead to more jobs or robust economic activity, such benefits rarely materialize”.
~Rashida Tlaib

...

See Jane drill is a YouTube channel that does all kinds of cool carpentry and home improvement stuff. Check them out, starting with this ticking stick, which is obviously brilliant 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

June 14 – 20, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…community television, Lani Faulkner for supervisor, goodbye Michael Griggs, and movie critiques. Greensite…on West Cliff Drive consultants’ road show. Schendledecker…taxes and democracy. Steinbruner…Cabrillo names, Cabrillo housing, Aptos Village mess, Supes budget meetings, county fire budget? Hayes…city coyotes. Patton…mind reader. Matlock…boxes of innocence, sympathy for the jokers. Eagan Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week: dirty, dirty rugs… Quotes “Fathers”

...

LOVELY CAPITOLA BEFORE MANY, MANY STORMS, 1928. We can see the lovely and successful Capitola Hotel in the background. It opened in 1895. Carolyn Swift’s Images of America book “Capitola” (Arcadia Publishing) has dozens of photos of the many nature driven tragedy’s Capitola has faced and survived.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE June 12

OUR COMMUNITY TELEVISION??? It seems like it’s time we get an explanation explaining why our three channels 25, 26, 27 are so out of date, content and interest. Aside from the few hours we get from Classic Arts Showcase and yet read even that is available 24 hours per day we still get these ancient years old studio takes that are decades old…and of little interest. Are they out of volunteers? Did the county cut their money so severely? Television is a primary source of our news today and to have our three channels so dysfunctional is nearly dangerous. We deserve a huge change and a genuine explanation.

LANI FAULKNER FOR SUPERVISOR. I’ve been informed that Lani Faulkner candidate for First District supervisor has an excellent campaign going with bunches of followers. More than that over 120 folks came to her celebration at De Laveaga Park last week. This will be a supervisor race to watch and learn from, yes Manu Koenig will be re-running.

GOODBYE TO MICHAEL GRIGGS. Andy Griggs who was Michael Griggs brother, sent this. Both Michael and Andy Griggs were huge contributors to our theatre life here in Santa Cruz. Both of them were and are seriously missed when they moved.

“Many of you know that my brother, Michael Griggs, passed away in January. I have appreciated the messages of condolences and support, as well as requests about a memorial. Here is that information:

Michael Griggs was a visionary – a talented director, producer, administrator and actor. He made a mark wherever he worked, and built a far-ranging community of friends, colleagues and collaborators in Los Angeles and Santa Cruz, CA; Portland, OR; Omaha, NE; and internationally.

His passion for and dedication to theatre and performance was amazing. He readily shared that passion with all, even during difficult personal times. And he embraced life with humanity and care—always being there for friends, family, and the larger community. And so we celebrate his life!

If you were one of the many touched by Michael’s life, we would love for you to attend in-person in Portland or online for his Celebration of Life on June 19th at 7PM PST. You can register for either type of ticket using this link to eventbrite.

In lieu of flowers, and acknowledging Michael’s generosity and support of many national and international causes and organizations, we suggest three options for giving:

1)  The Actors Conservatory Michael Griggs Scholarship Fund

2) Buy a tree (or part of one) in Michael’s name at Dragonflyhill Desert Farm in the Coachella Valley of California

3) Make a donation in Michael’s name to the charity of your choice.”

You can check out the “official” obit here…

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. On the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

SHE SAID. (AMAZON MOVIE) (7.2 IMDB). I wish I had more thumbs to give this detailed “near documentary” of the Harvey Weinstein sexual abuse cases. The film failed miserably at the box-office, but won awards all over the world. Two New York Times women reporters (one played by Carey Mulligan the other by Zoe Kazan) pursue Weinstein leads all over the world. Ashley Judd, one of Harvey’s victims appears in it and acts her part. 82 women have come out revealing their having been raped by Weinstein. He’s now serving a 23 year sentence

In what used to be the Erie County jail in New York State, it’s now called the Wende Correctional Facility. Go for it.

LOVE & DEATH. (MAX SERIES) (7.2 IMDB).  Based on a true story out of Texas in 1980 this saga centers on a married couple and the male is played by Jesse Plemons, unfortunately. Being very truthful I’m admitting that I can’t watch Plemons in any role he’s been in. He’s slimy and reminds me all too much of Trump. He has an unhappy wife played by Elizabeth Olsen. There’s nothing believable between/within this couple and it’s just another murder plot like the million we’ve seen before.

THE CROWDED ROOM. (APPLE TV) (7.0 IMDB). Tom Holland does a deep and superior job of acting along with Amanda Seyfried. It takes place in Manhattan in 1979 and deals with D.I.D. (Dissociative Identity Disorders). Two murders happen and we get to watch Holland attempt to explain and examine his life before the killings. Only 3 episodes so far, and it’s all good.

HEARTLAND. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.5 IMDB). It’s been running 15 seasons so I watched a few episodes. It’s corny, mostly poor acting, trite and all about a family’s inter relationships which were boring and we’ve seen it in hundreds of movies before. Avoid at all costs.

TO LESLIE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). Andrea Riseborough is the roughed up, downtrodden former winner of a $ 190,000 dollar lottery who has spent it all on booze, drugs and a very loose way of life. We watch her trying to retain some semblance of her former life and consistently failing. Allison Janney and Marc Maron are of no help to her. The twists, and shocks to her system are devastating, sad and very realistic and human. Watch it but not when you need laughs.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

BLACKBERRY. (PRIME VIDEO) (7.6 IMDB). This is a half true story based on the very real history of the early history of the smartphone. It’s also half funny and cringe producing displaying the relationships of the people involved in the success and failure of that pre-iPhone device. Somehow because it all happens in Canada gives it an extra dimension, but it needed more than that.

REALITY. (MAX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). .Sydney Sweeney portrays Reality Winner which is the real name of the former FBI translator agent who released classified information relating to the 2016 election. That information connected Trump and Russia and caused all sorts of hell. It’s about how the FBI controlled and conducted her interrogation. An excellent and yet disturbing expose and it’s an adaptation of a play.  Go for it.

THE FAMILY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (  ? IMDB). A well done and rather long saga dealing with the Yakusa or Japanese version of the Mafia.  It centers on one young guy and his violent upbringing. He goes to prison for 14 years and returns to learn that the Yakusa and all of his community and day dreams have changed. Toughing, nicely photographed and worth watching.

FIREFLY LANE. (NETFLIX SEWRIES) (7.6 IMDB). Katherine Heigl and Sarah Chalke act as two best friends who support each other through their lives. They’ve got the usual set of issues and family scenes to re-act to but it’s too full of mugging and age old clichés to make a good series. The two actresses/actors aren’t professional enough to lift the series into the watchable category. Don’t go there.

QUEEN CHARLOTTE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). This totally fictitious take on history has unbelievably re-cast the court and especially the marriage of King George of England with a half black cast. It’s listed as a prequel to the Bridgerton series, and I’ve never watched a minute of Bridgerton. Being extra cute and quaint it centers on the wedding gown. It does credit to no one involved, and you needn’t be either.

...

June 12

Just Fix It!

A June 11th letter in the Sentinel titled City ignoring dangerous Eastside traffic issues details the ongoing problems faced by that side of town with trucks, commuters and tourists using Eastside neighborhood streets as cut throughs. Efforts over the years to have the city respond with even a stop sign have apparently been ignored. The letter writer draws attention to the swift city response to recent traffic calming on the Westside, viewed as favoritism. The reality is far more insidious.

The photo above is a part of the three sections of West Cliff Drive severely damaged by the January 2023 storms. One stretch is now closed to traffic with another stretch reduced to one-way as the city engineers seek federal grants to repair the damage. A major challenge to be sure but well within city Public Works engineering capabilities. The closures have necessitated the diversion of West Cliff car traffic onto neighborhood streets with Oxford Way being the most heavily impacted. In response to neighbors’ concerns, the city has closed Oxford Way to through traffic as a “traffic calming” measure. As soon as repairs are made, West Cliff Drive can be fully opened, car traffic will have no reason to divert through the neighborhoods and life can continue as before, inconvenient for the duration but not forever. One would think that’s the end of the story except it isn’t.

The city has been holding numerous public meetings on the topic of West Cliff Drive, attended by senior city staff and a team of consultants. I attended two of the three public meetings. The latest, a zoom meeting, repeated in-person the following evening, had three senior staff in attendance, including the Assistant City Manager and five consultants. That’s correct. Five consultants.

By whom and when was it decided that fixing the damage to West Cliff Drive, an engineering problem, needed a concentration of senior city management staff and a team of consultants? The consulting firm is Farallon Strategies, self-described as a “catalytic partner” whose byline is “Creating and accelerating transformative change.” They have been in existence since, wait for it, 2020.

Contrast these well-publicized meetings (not required) held outside of work hours with ample opportunity for discussion and comments, with the one poorly publicized meeting for the Wharf Master Plan draft, partial EIR (required) held during workhours, one day before the deadline for comments. Most of the time taken up by the project manager’s presentation with little time remaining for questions which were directed to the Q & A function. And the city wonders why the public lacks trust. Maybe they should hire consultants to help figure it out.

There are key words in the West Cliff consultants’ vocabulary that thinly veil the actual city agenda. The title, “Envision West Cliff” has nothing to do with fixing damage; the buzz words, “resiliency, inclusion and accessibility” make an appearance as does “climate change,” despite the meteorological community’s conclusion that the storms were not climate change-driven; West Cliff Drive is referred to as a “global attraction” and “economic driver”. When funding is mentioned, it is “recovery and further programmatic development.” The guided question for the breakout groups, “how do you think the community will use West Cliff 50 years from now? attracted what you might expect from such a question. I hope the consultants don’t think tracking our answers to their select questions has any validity. Note to city, for some of us, curiously, the functions did not work so our input was not tallied.

The most revealing of the city’s true intent is their labelling the one-way car traffic section as a “one way pilot.”  If the one-way section were simply an unfortunate, temporary situation until the damaged roadway and path are fixed, then the word ‘pilot’ would not be included. That it is included and has been from the beginning is a clear indication of their aim to turn West Cliff into a one-way, money-making, recreation destination or as the Farallon consultants would say, “accelerating transformative change.” Other new labels are simply incorrect. Staff and consultants now call West Cliff Drive an “arterial road”, which it certainly is not.

In this context “traffic calming” is like offering an aspirin after you hit someone on the head with a shovel. That it scored high on participants’ list of priorities shows how easily we are misled with jargon and hidden agendas. As George Orwell wrote in 1946, “Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful…and to give appearance of solidity to pure wind.”

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

TAXES AND DEMOCRACY

June 12

So here’s a thing with majoritarian decision-making: if there’s a win with 50+1, that means there could be 49 losers. And if a bunch of the electorate doesn’t show up, or abstains, then it could be a definitively minority decision. Having a ? threshold is better, for sure, when some kind of progressive ranked-choice voting isn’t possible or appropriate. At least then a larger proportion of voters can claim a win, with losers being a smaller marginalized group.

Whether it’s our families, workplaces, local organizing groups, or governance on any scale, when we marginalize close to half of voters, we aren’t even close to consensus, and we all but guarantee entrenchment of polarized positions and oppositional tactics. Consent and agency are key to decent relationships.

Inadequate or rushed public consultation sets us up for a disengaged electorate, and the relentless grind of surviving under capitalism makes it nearly impossible for many to participate.

I haven’t been able to attend any of the meetings about the proposed “Affordable Workforce Housing Revenue Measure.” They weren’t advertised with a lot of notice, and the first two were not available to join remotely. The third one was hybrid (and translated), but there’s not currently a recording on the project’s page.

Fortunately, I am getting notes from a number of attendees, so I’m not totally out of the loop. I’ve been told that two more meetings have been added, but they are not listed on the project page.

Here’s a copy of the draft measure, which also is not on the city’s page.

A couple of things in the draft measure stand out to me. The first is this “small print” that debt isn’t off the table:

  1. The People now wish to submit a revenue measure to the qualified electors of the City at a 2024 election for the purpose of generating revenues, including through bonded indebtedness secured by the revenue measure, to be spent on increasing the availability of affordable workforce housing and the prevention of homelessness within the City.

The second is the regressive (and mathematically complex) nature of the parcel tax calculations:

  1. For owners of all Single-Family Residential Parcels, the tax shall be at the annual rate of ninety-five dollars ($95) per Parcel.
  1. For owners of all Multiple Residential Unit Parcels, the tax shall be at the annual rate of sixty-five dollars ($65) per occupied Residential Unit.
  1. The tax for Non-Residential Parcels, other than Residential Hotels and Transient Hotels as specified in subsection (b)4., below, is calculated using both frontage and square footage measurements to determine total single family residential unit equivalents (SFE). A frontage of eighty (80) feet for a commercial institutional parcel, for example, is equal to one (1) single family residential unit equivalent. (See matrix.) An area of six thousand four hundred (6,400) square feet for the commercial institutional parcel is equal to one (1) single family residential unit equivalent. For tall buildings (more than five (5) stories), the single-family residential unit equivalent computation also includes one (1) single family residential unit equivalent for every five thousand (5,000) square feet of net rentable area. The tax is the annual rate of ninety-five dollars ($95) multiplied by the total number of single-family residential unit equivalents (determined by the frontage and square footage).

I understand that the rationale for exploring/initiating this revenue measure from the council and then handing it over to citizens for signature gathering is to help the process along, and so that it can pass more easily. I also understand that the rush to put it on the March ballot (now a summer special election with a close to $200,000 price tag) is to get it on the books before a November 2024 state ballot initiative potentially raises the citizen tax initiative threshold to ?. (Side note: as I reported in last week’s column, we may have to put this measure to the vote again if that state measure passes anyway.) So how about we slow it down a little more and put it on the November ballot with everything else, when we can expect decent voter turnout?

I have to say, while I agree that we need to find funds from all over the place to fortify our Affordable Housing Trust Fund, I’m not very enthusiastic about this measure, or the process as it’s happening.

For this initiative to use significant public funds to get to the petition-signing phase, while genuine citizen initiatives are self-funded and organized at often incredible personal and community cost, feels, well, disingenuous and manipulative. It’s unfair.

This is a regressive, not progressive, tax. If it were being written as a more progressive parcel tax, where larger, for-profit buildings pay a fair share, I’d be more supportive.

As I said every time Mayor Keeley brought up his housing bond in forums, I think increasing (well, instituting) our Property Transfer Tax would both raise substantially more money, and would at least charge a premium to these massive corporations and hedge funds that are hyper-financializing and manipulating our housing market. Check out how we compare to other California cities (clue: we’re really missing out!).

The bitter fight against the Empty Home Tax last year (and Rent Control in 2018), largely funded by the California Apartment Association via Santa Cruz Together, showed us who wants to maintain power over property in Santa Cruz, and who is willing to aid and abet them.

I’d like to see Santa Cruz Together pledge not to take any more funds from the California Apartment Association (or similar) and to work with the entire community, in truly grassroots ways, to find better solutions for renter protections, truly affordable housing, and a generally more stable local housing market. As long as they continue to take in these massive amounts of money to fund their pet candidates and oppose truly grassroots initiatives, they are skewing our community ecosystem away from democracy and towards plutocracy.

The reluctance of Mayor  Fred Keeley to stand up to those powers leads me to think that he’s either with them or is unwilling to rally the community to oppose them.

Junteenth is here, mark your calendars for this special event!

In last week’s column, I left out a major reason to engage with the Democratic Party: Labor. Grassroots, local labor organizing is truly essential. So is connecting with big labor orgs that are involved with and influencing local politics–to learn what their workers need, what policies they want, what abuses are happening in workplaces. Those big labor orgs are working with the Dems, so it’s a no-brainer to meet them there. Solidarity Forever!

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
June 12

PUBLIC MEETINGS TO DISCUSS CHANGING CABRILLO COLLEGE NAME…HOW ABOUT “NONE OF THE ABOVE”?

Just last week, I received notice from Cabrillo College President Mr. Matt Wetstein that there will be three public meetings to graciously allow the taxpaying public an opportunity to place colored dots and sticky notes next to their favorite of five new possible names for Cabrillo Community College, as selected by their Name Exploration Committee.  Wow.  After respondents to the earlier Community Survey overwhelming said “DON’T CHANGE THE NAME”.

Here is the update:

We are reaching a point where a set of 5 proposed names have been identified as finalists, and I wanted to make a personal invitation to you to attend one of our upcoming community meetings to learn about and discuss the proposed names. The dates, locations, and times of the meetings are listed below:

  • Wednesday, June 14, Aptos campus, Room 1001 Visual and Performing Arts, 6:00 pm
  • Wednesday, June 28, Watsonville Center, Room A-130, 6:00 pm
  • Wednesday, July 12, Felton, Felton Branch Library, 6:00 pm

I hope one of these dates works with your schedule. If not, I hope you will reach out with your thoughts on the proposed names. Look for media coverage on the names, especially around June 12th and 13th.  You may also visit our Name Exploration Webpage for information and updates.

LARGE HOUSING PROJECT FOR CABRILLO COLLEGE CAMPUS LIKELY WILL NOT HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD FOR CEQA

A Community member contacted me last week, wondering why I had not been at a recent public meeting about the proposed 624-bed student housing project proposed for Cabrillo College?  He said attendance was shockingly sparse.  Maybe no one knew it was happening? There was nothing about it on the College website, and nothing in local print media.

My friend told me the Project will not undergo an EIR analysis, but instead relies on one that was done in 1999.  The College is instead using an Addendum evaluation which does not require any public hearings or formal public comment procedures.   Usually, this is the avenue an agency takes when they want to make changes that are supposed to be minor and move quickly through the CEQA process to save time and money but is always at the expense of the public’s participation. (Soquel Creek Water District is a prime example with the major modifications to their PureWater Soquel Project going through two Addendums as major design modifications were required.)

Also, in order to help fund the Project, it will be shared with UCSC for student housing.

I wrote Cabrillo College to ask about the status of the CEQA process, and the timeline for approvals.  Below is President Matt Wetstein’s response:

Thanks for reaching out to us about the Cabrillo Housing Project.

The college has a website that has been created in conjunction with the June 5 community forum that contains information on the project. 

Invitations for the June 5 meeting were sent to households between Park Avenue and State Park Drive that are near the college’s campus. 

If you visit the new website, you can access the draft Environmental Impact Report Addendum that has been developed for the project. The College’s environmental consultant is QuadKnopf. The EIR supplement route is available to us because there are not substantial impacts envisioned from the project that go beyond what is in our master plan EIR that is filed with the state clearinghouse. One element still under study is the traffic and trip mile impact that might come from UCSC students residing on our campus. We hope to have that component completed by the end of the summer.

One note — the EIR Addendum is rather long (3,169 pages with appendices — 100 pages for the top level summaries). You can download it from the site listed above.

The Addendum to the EIR is an information item on the Board of Trustee Agenda June 12. The public portion of the meeting starts at 5:45 pm at the Horticulture Center.

We will take the completed EIR Supplement to the Board later this summer, after the traffic impact analysis is completed.

NO substantial impacts envisioned since this was examined in 1999?  What about water? What about sewer capacities? What about cumulative impacts on top of the new 6th Cycle Regional Housing Number Allocations (RHNA) that mandate the County build 4,634 new units in the unincorporated area in the next eight years?

Keep your eye on this and send your written comment to the Cabrillo College Board of Trustees c/o Ms. Ronnette Smithcamp rosmithc@cabrillo.edu

APTOS VILLAGE IS ABOUT TO BECOME AN EVEN BIGGER MESS

Last week, Barry Swenson Builder blocked all parking along Aptos Village Way between Aptos Creek Road and Parade Street in anticipation of beginning construction on the incredibly-dense and tall Phase 2 Aptos Village Project., and decorated the chain link fence with “NO PARKING” signs.  It created a mess last weekend for customers of businesses in the Phase 1 development, a charity fundraising event happening at Aptos Village Park, and visitors to Nisene Marks State Park…all of which have been promised “unlimited parking” by Barry Swenson VP Jessie Nichol during public hearings years ago on the Project benefits.

Last Tuesday, the County Board of Supervisors approved by consent (Item #73) to accept the Parade Street improvements in Aptos Village, allowing the gateway to the Aptos Village Project to formally open.  It also means Barry Swenson will close the historic crossing to the Bayview Hotel and Trout Gulch Crossing businesses.

I wonder if Swenson will pay for the damages resulting from accidents that are sure to occur at this ridiculous intersection, or if, like the cost of much of the work done to accommodate this development, the taxpayers will be left holding the bag?  Call Supervisor Zach Friend and ask that the County require parking on at least one side of the already-to-narrow Aptos Village Way be restored.  (831) 454-2200.

Here is the view of Aptos Village Way approaching the Phase 1 Aptos Village Project subdivision.  Swenson Builders has not allowed parking on the left side because Project Manager Mr. Jesse Bristow said there was no sidewalk.  The fencing on the right got installed last week, drastically reducing parking in the Aptos Village area.


Can you see the tall weeds on the hillside behind the “NO PARKING” sign?  It’s a fire hazard that Swenson ignores every year.

APTOS ONCE AGAIN HAS LOCALLY-OWNED NATURAL FOOD STORE

I am so glad Aptos Foods is open in the Aptos Center (7506 Soquel Drive, across from the new library construction site) because it is owned by local people, Julie Kellman and Dan Hunt, who also own Seascape Foods.  They have renovated the space and decorated it with colorful murals, have a well-stocked inventory with focus on locally-sourced items and organic produce.

(831) 612-6748

Please support this locally-owned store.  New Leaf Market in Aptos Village Project is owned by a large offshore Asian investment corporation.

COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS COMPLETE BUDGET HEARINGS

Last week, the Board of Supervisors approved budgets for many departments, but provided the public with no information about those numbers and how they got them.  I sent a Cure and Correct Letter to the Board, asking that this be remedied.  NO response.

Last Friday, I visited the lobby of the Clerk of the Board to see if the Budget is available there in print.  It is not.

If this worries you, please contact the Board of Supervisors! Email them at: boardofsupervisors@santacruzcounty.us  and call: 831-454-2200.  Whenever I call, I am always told that “None of the Supervisors are available”, but maybe you will have better luck getting through to your elected representative when you call.

CENTRAL FIRE DISTRICT UNFUNDED PENSION DEBT IS GROWING, ALONG WITH ALL OTHER PUBLIC AGENCIES

Last Thursday, the Central Fire Protection District Board of Directors heard a presentation by CalPERS advisor Mr. Ira Summer.  Even though Central Fire District financial staff have been very diligent about prepaying the Pension Debt accumulating because CalPERS investments are not doing as well as planned, the debt liability was $60 million as of June 30, 2022, much higher than anticipated.  In the next five years, the District’s contributions will increase by 50% and hold at that level for 10 years.

It was a gloomy report, coupled with the very real recession we face, but at least the District is publicly addressing the debt burden whereas the County of Santa Cruz CAO Carlos Palacios is not.

Here is the link to the Central Fire District Board agenda

You can listen to the meeting’s presentations and discussion here (Mr. Summer’s presentation is first on the agenda)

COUNTY FIRE BUDGET STILL UNKNOWN

The Board of Supervisors failed to recess during their Regular Meeting last Tuesday to take action as the Board of Directors for Santa Cruz County Fire Department, approving assessment increases for the properties within County Service Areas 4 (Pajaro Dunes) and 48 (all other areas of the unincorporated properties not included in other local fire district boundaries), This was Regular Item #12.

Consider adoption of resolutions confirming the previously established benefit assessment rates for County Service Areas (CSAs) 4, Pajaro Dunes, and CSA 48, County Fire; adopt resolutions setting a public hearing on June 27, 2023, on the proposed…

The Board approved a 5.6% increase for CSA 48, and a 4% capped increase for CSA 48 2020 Special Benefit Assessment Tax because it was capped at 4% in the Engineers Report associated with that illegal ballot action in 2020.

How can the Board approve rate increases without a contract with CalFire?  This document is yet to be seen.

IT IS AMAZING WHAT GETS HIDDEN ON COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISOR CONSENT AGENDAS

Although items on the Board of Supervisor Meeting Consent Agenda is, by definition, supposed to include non-controversial and small dollar actions, what gets hidden there is far from that definition.  In my opinion, it is done to not only hide important issues that likely are controversial and to relegate a maximum of two minutes to the public to ask questions about these issues that would, as a regular agenda item provide a staff presentation and single topic discussion (another 2-minute limit for the public).

Take a look at what was hidden in last Tuesday’s Consent Agenda:

#24 Allowing delayed re-payment to the County for the Pajaro Valley Health Care District and Watsonville Hospital acquisition:

In March 2023, the PVHCD staff engaged with the County and community partners in conversations to improve the PVHCD cash position during the ongoing transition of hospital operations. County staff determined that by revisiting the repayment term of the short-term loan agreement from a lump sum to six (6) payments, PVHCD could smooth the cash flow obligation, giving the new district relief. The attached amendment to the loan agreement extends the term to December 2025. Payments will be made in increments of $500,000, with a final payment of $100,000, with the first payment due in June 2023. Staff is also recommending an amendment of the agreement to reflect the actual amount of money borrowed ($2.6M rather than an amount not-to-exceed $3M).

#32 Create Guidelines for County Employee Use of Artificial Intelligence Platforms (how secure will that Digital Wallet information be that Supervisor Zach Friend is pushing to achieve, supposedly all donated by HUMBL Consultants???)

While it remains to be seen if Congress will develop meaningful regulations for AI products, it makes sense for the County of Santa Cruz to adopt a set of standards to ensure the responsible use of AI by county employees. AI tools can provide many benefits to county departments by assisting with research, improving written communications, developing templates for job postings, among many other potential uses. The County also has an obligation to protect the data of residents, promote transparency, and guard against discrimination. Creating a formal policy on usage would help ensure this important tool is available but guardrails and protections are in place.

Accordingly, the County should adopt an AI policy that addresses (but is not limited to) the following issues:

  • Data Privacy and security – AI systems must protect user privacy and county employees should refrain from sharing protected data until the systems are determined to be operating in compliance with HIPAA and other data protection laws.
  • Transparency – These systems should be explainable to users.
  • Accountability – AI products should be subject to regular audits and evaluations to ensure they are operating appropriately.
  • Fairness and bias – AI systems should be designed and used in a fair and unbiased manner. The technology should not discriminate on the basis of race, sex, or other protected classes.
  • Informed consent – Users should be provided with clear information about AI systems and their capabilities, with the ability to opt out of using the technology.
  • Responsible use – This technology should be used in an ethical manner.

The purpose is to allow the County Administrative Officer and/or designees the ability to create a policy that meets these general objectives but also provide flexibility to evolve as the capabilities continue to evolve.

#36 Directing County staff to write Director of California Dept. of Fish and Wildlife to Transfer Ownership of Greyhound Rock to the County of Santa Cruz.

Greyhound Rock is an important visitor destination on the north coast of the County owned by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) but managed and maintained by the County at its own expense for over 60 years.  Although the County historically had operating agreements with CDFW, there has been no operating agreement with CDFW for over ten years.

Recently, the Parks Department developed a proposal to use a portion of the property as a self-sustaining low cost/impact overnight accommodation site to provide outdoor educational programs that would serve low-income disadvantaged youth, and school groups throughout the region (attachment 1).  

A transfer of ownership of this site would greatly reduce complications associated with needing approvals by an additional agency when attempting to get permits and funding, which would help expedite our efforts to provide safe access to our coast.

Financial Impact…NONE????

#71 Update Guidelines for Engineering Geologic and Geotechnical Investigations and Publish Reports

The changes to the guidelines from the previous guidelines include updating references to the 2022 California Building Code; updating provisions regarding soils report waivers; adding guidance regarding Tiny Homes of Wheels; and updating guidance on when a soils report is required.

#73 Accepting Aptos Village Project Developers Parade Street at-grade Private Railroad Crossing and Annual $20,000 Payment to County for Maintenance (will the County taxpayers be held liable for any accidents at this new crossing?)

 This project involves the construction of a new railroad crossing with a crossing warning system, at the Soquel Drive and Parade Street intersection. 

Although Commercial Association and Mixed-Use Association are obligated, as successors in interest to Swenson Builders, to maintain the Parade Street Crossing, they lack the technical expertise and staffing to operate and maintain the Parade Street Crossing.  The County agrees to inspect, maintain, repair and operate the Parade Street Crossing pursuant to the CPUC Order and this Agreement.

Analysis

The Funding and Maintenance Agreement will allow for County maintenance, repair, and replacement of improvements and equipment necessary for operation of the Parade Street Crossing.

The parties estimate that the annual cost of maintenance for the Parade Street Crossing will be $20,000.  The Commercial Association and Mixed-Use Association shall annually deposit, or shall cause to be deposited annually, the total sum of $20,000 (Annual Deposit) for maintenance and repair of the Parade Street Crossing.

#86 Retroactive Approval of $350,655.91 for Additional Engineering Services for Soquel Drive Buffered Bike Lane Project (extra work done two years ago but never approved for cost overrun)

Additional items of work were required during the final design of the project.  Additional topographic surveys were required because of additional retaining wall areas for sidewalks and newly constructed water valves in the street.  Additional boundary surveys were required to establish the right of way lines because of the lack of existing monumentation.  Additional potholing for utilities were required because of maps provided by the utilities had potential conflicts with planned sidewalks, retaining walls and storm drains.  Additional right of way services were required because of an increase in the number of acquisitions.  After the 100% plans were completed, there were numerous changes because of requests from utility companies and public utilities that required significant changes to the design in several locations.

These additional items of work necessitate an amendment in contract services with Mark Thomas (approved on June 8, 2021)  CDI (that’s the Public Works and Planning Dept.) should have returned to the Board earlier for an amendment to the contract; however staff was focused on an expedited design process and delayed processing an amendment to the contract.  CDI has successfully met the design schedule and this board item seeks to retroactively amend the agreement with Mark Thomas.

Well….I think you get the idea…WATCH THOSE CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS!!!! And ask your elected Supervisors to make these important issues more public and transparent, or at least start holding Town Hall meetings in their Districts again.  Supervisor Manu Koenig is the only Supervisor holding regular Town Hall Meetings.

COLLEGE LAKE GROUNDWATER RECHARGE PROJECT IN THE WORKS FOR PAJARO VALLEY

Last Friday, the Pajaro Valley Water Management Agency officially kicked off the large groundwater recharge project at College Lake, near the Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds.  College Lake will no longer be drained to allow farming there, but instead will be a source of water to treat and sell to farmers in the areas near the Pajaro Dunes area where private ag wells extract groundwater for irrigation.  You can see the work happening now on Holohan Road near Green Valley Road in Watsonville.

Here is the view from Holohan Road in Watsonville.  The water from College Lake will be used for agriculture. irrigation closer to the beach areas, in lieu of pumping groundwater.

SAVING SEEDS OF NATIVE PLANTS FOR RESTORING FIRE AND FLOOD DAMAGES

Whenever I walk in the Santa Cruz Mountains, I see the remnants of past attempts to stabilize our local slopes, evidenced by the massive ropes of Algerian Ivy burdening the native forests.  Luckily, other means are available for helping the land to heal, and the Resource Conservation District (RCD) is available to help  https://www.rcdsantacruz.org/

Where can we find those seeds of hope for restoring the damaged areas with native plants? Take a look at this interesting source, recently featured in the San Jose Mercury News

Give them a call: 530-662-6847 https://www.hedgerowfarms.com/

Staff told me that Superior HydroSeeding in Watsonville is a big customer, but Hedgerow Farms staff can help private land owners to design restoration projects and supply appropriate native seeds.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND ONE PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
June 12

CITY COYOTES

Across the United States, wild dogs are adapting to human-transformed Nature in ways that some find unpleasant. I am consistently asked ‘are you a dog person, or a cat person?’ I like Nature, and that dog-cat dichotomy is an interesting one even with wild organisms.

Public Opinions about Wild Dogs

A recent local television news report about wild coyotes threatening outdoor pets is an interesting thing to watch. Viewing it, I wondered if the anti-Nature people interviewed represent any sizeable fraction of the local population. And, based on local elections, I suspect they do.

One interviewed person says, “we’re scared to leave our animals in our own yards.” With that statement, we see a widespread misunderstanding about property rights. People who “own” property in the USA are granted certain property rights, but those rights do not extend to the ability to impact wildlife however they desire. Wildlife are owned by society, not individuals.

Another anti-Nature person interviewed hopes: “if there would be a way that we could find a balance to live with the coyotes, so that they don’t go after our pets.” Beware the term ‘balance’ when applied to Nature! We see this term bandied about by businesses funding the outdoor recreation lobby and echoed by the public parks managers, who want us to accept their version of “balancing” recreational uses with Nature conservation. In each case the word ‘balance’ is code for killing wildlife. And, in each case, on purpose or by ignorance, this rhetoric is, in the short-term, anti-species, in the medium-term racist, and in the longer-term, anti-human. We need all species to live. As species slip towards extinction, it is the poor and underrepresented that suffer first. With the disappearance of each species, the human condition worsens. At some point, the services provided for ‘free’ by Nature will no longer support human society as we know it.

There is one other misconception in the interview: that all domestic cats are someone’s pets. Feral cats are very numerous and, along with the ‘subsidized predators’ of cat pets, present a tremendous and ongoing threat to wildlife. That threat is somewhat abated by coyotes.

Coyote Services

Coyotes keep natural areas freer of domestic cats, benefiting Nature thereby benefiting humans. Drs. Kevin Crooks and Michael Soulè (once a professor at our local University, UCSC) researched the effects of habitat connectivity in Southern California and found that natural areas that were interconnected and allowed coyotes access were more likely to have native bird species. This became known as ‘meso-predator release,’ – coyotes predate, and reduce populations of, smaller native carnivores (skunk, raccoon, grey fox) as well as invasive carnivores (opossum, cat), which would otherwise negatively affect native songbirds. In the United States alone, domestic cats which are not kept indoors kill up to 6 billion wild birds and 22.3 billion native mammals annually. Note the word ‘billion.’

With coyotes, songbirds and native mammals stand a greater chance of survival. Birds play crucial roles in stitching together Nature and thereby improving the plight of humans.

Carnivore Benefits

The studies about the beneficial ecological effects of larger carnivores go beyond the coyote. Dr. Chris Wilmers at UCSC has been a leader in researching and publishing about the effects of large carnivores on ecosystems. His and many other researchers’ findings echo the results of Drs. Kevin Crooks and Michael Soulè in showing that larger carnivore populations reduce unnaturally high mesopredator populations, to the benefit of many other wildlife species. Dr. Wilmers’ recent findings suggests that mountain lion conservation may even reduce human exposure to Lyme disease.

What to Do

Those of us who care about wildlife have a lot of work to do. Pro-wildlife people represent the vast majority of US citizens, but in this democracy we are contending with another growing majority: pet owners. It is interesting to note some statistics presented recently by Forbes: pet owners are a majority of the US population (66%); more people are “dog people’ rather than “cat people;” pet ownership is growing; it is expensive to own a pet, and; more wealthy people are more likely to own pets. Likely, many pet owners are also wildlife lovers, so we can work together for both goals.

At the most basic level, wildlife supporters must help other citizens to understand and appreciate that wild animals have the right to roam freely across ‘our’ private property. Wildlife are not owned, but the government has certain powers to manage them. As conservationists in a democracy, it is our imperative to work with government to guide that management.

Where coyotes roam, they reduce the population of domestic cats. Part of that is that coyote cat predation has led more people to increasingly keep their domestic pet cats indoors. We can urge people to keep their pets indoors or, if outdoors, to keep their pets on leash. These are inexpensive and effective solutions.

In an era where many people across the planet are actively destroying Nature and killing all wild animals, we should celebrate that we have wild dogs roaming into our urban areas. Please retell the stories in this article. Spread the word about the benefits of coyotes and other large predators. The negative press news story that I mentioned at the beginning of this article began with a citizen contacting KSBW: pro-Nature people need also to contact the media to cover their perspectives…try to figure out how those will be eye-catching and newsworthy, and reach out as much as you can!

Also…as always…vote for the environment! Now that we have some contenders for the next election cycle, it is a good time to reach out to ask them what their stances are for environmental conservation. Lots of folks asking early will help candidates pay attention to Nature and cogitate on their positions.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

June 9
#160 / Mind Reader

Artificial Intelligence (or A.I., to use the terminology that is ever more frequently employed) is definitely the “next big thing.” Some are prophesying doom. To get an informed take on why we should be worried, click that link, above – the one mentioning “doom” – for a video from the makers of “The Social Dilemma.”

Big businesses, let it be said, are apparently not that worried about our A.I. future. They are, increasingly, “all in.” If that brings you any comfort, just remember that the giant oil companies profess not to be worried, either, about the fact that our continued combustion of hydrocarbon fuels might put our human civilization in peril – or even end all life on the planet. If everyone starts getting worried, that could really undermine their business model!

In early May, The New York Times published an article that was titled, “A.I. to Read Your Mind Is Up Next.” That, of course, is the hard copy version. The online headline will differ. If you can skate past the paywall, the link I have provided should take you right there. Here are a couple of pertinent paragraphs:

In a study published in the journal Nature Neuroscience, the researchers described an A.I. that could translate the private thoughts of human subjects by analyzing fMRI scans, which measure the flow of blood to different regions in the brain.

Already, researchers have developed language-decoding methods to pick up the attempted speech of people who have lost the ability to speak, and to allow paralyzed people to write while just thinking of writing. But the new language decoder is one of the first to not rely on implants. In the study, it was able to turn a person’s imagined speech into actual speech and, when subjects were shown silent films, it could generate relatively accurate descriptions of what was happening onscreen (emphasis added).

Those reading this blog posting may, or may not, have heard about (or even read) what was once a rather famous book, Man A Machine, by Julien Offray de La Mettrie. I still have a copy of the book on my shelves – and my underlining proves that I definitely read it. In fact, I remember it rather well. As Wikipedia tells us (click the link to the title), “de La Mettrie extends Descartes’ argument that animals are mere automatons, or machines, to human beings.”

I did decline, when I read the book – and I still decline – de La Mettrie’s invitation to consider that human beings are actually just “machines.” Think about it, though; that is exactly what the concept of “Artificial Intelligence” invites us to do. The idea that “intelligence” (see definition below) is nothing more than mechanical manipulations of information, done super fast, is to suck out the marrow from the bones of our glory, leaving only structural sticks behind.

INTELLIGENCE:

The capacity for learning, reasoning, understanding, and similar forms of mental activity; aptitude in grasping truths, relationships, facts, meanings, etc.

I have no doubt that we can invent ways to make inanimate and unliving, mechanical processes duplicate the “intellectual products” that we, and our intelligence, have learned how to produce ourselves. ChatGPT may well be able to write a senior thesis, using the prodigious power of computers to pull examples and analogues from the entire written, oral, and visual products of human civilization.

But for whom are these artificially conjured products produced? For some human being, somewhere.

That is their only value, and I am suggesting that you shouldn’t believe it when someone invites you to equate your human existence with what a machine can accomplish (and particularly when you are told that the machine can do it better than you can).

Human beings are NOT “machines.” When we start thinking that we are, that is when we begin denying exactly what is most precious and unique in the fact of our existence. That is when we begin turning a divine mystery (and destiny) into a complex conjugation of computer code. That is when we start selling ourselves short!

If you think that that equating ourselves to a machine is ever going to work out alright – in the human world that we have created (and in the World of Nature, which we most emphatically did not create) – then I just say, “Good Luck!”

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
June 12

BOXES OF INNOCENCE, SYMPATHY FOR THE JOKERS

Busy news week, huh? Former presidential candidate and right-wing TV evangelist on his Christian Broadcasting Network, Pat Robertson, died at 93 years of age. His toxic cultural views were instrumental in empowering the religious right to its current influence within the Republican Party, as he blamed America’s woes on our sinful citizens. Abortion, divorce, gay sex, secular humanism – all led to the wrath of his almighty god who then visited us with hurricanes, earthquakes, drought, plagues from Africa…the list goes on. Robertson had a world vision for the spread of his evangelism and it is said there was hardly any right-wing despot or death squad he didn’t like, and he was quick to buy into their lies as long as they held a Bible in one hand, pressuring US hawks to intervene in Latin America. On his The 700 Club broadcast in 2010, he blamed the Haiti earthquake on a pact with the devil, when Haitians “got together and swore a pact,” promising to serve Satan if he freed them from French rule. The revolt against the French was actually against slavery, but Robertson’s support of the status quo fit right in with his concept of the Cosmic Patriarch demanding obedience of slaves to masters, women to men, and Americans to Bible-Thumpers. Jeet Heer writes in The Nation that Robertson’s lasting legacy is that he was able to make God seem terrible, the Smiter-In-Chief.

Author and investigative journalist, Greg Palast, called Robertson “just another Southern-fried Elmer Gantry with a slick line of Lordy-Jesus hoodoo, and who with his hot-line to God could hypnotize a couple of million American goobers into turning over their bank accounts for sulphur-scented investments from China to the Congo.” The evidence of having broken a number of commandments handed down by the Highest Authority, the IRS, constantly required his utmost penance. In 1990, Robertson’s cable network was sold to Rupert Murdoch for $1.82 billion, and since it had spun off as a for-profit corporation seven years earlier, Reverend Pat held the controlling interest. He donated hundreds of millions to both Christian Broadcast Network and what is now Regent University, which still burdened him with a heavy load of cash to carry through the eye of The Needle, on camelback or not. Palast says he was no hayseed huckster, but a worldly man of wealth and taste, and as The Rolling Stones sang in Sympathy for the Devil, “Pleased to meet you! Hope you guess my name! But, what’s puzzling you is the nature of my game, woo who, oh yeah!”

Another casualty we can mark off is the death of Unabomber Theodore ‘Ted’ J. Kaczynski at the age of 81, found dead in his federal prison medical center in Butner, NC. He was found guilty of attacking academics, businesspeople and random civilians with his homemade bombs from 1978 to 1995, during which time he killed three and injured 23 – none with which he was acquainted, in his war against the modern social order. As it was revealed, his targets were not randomly chosen but were specific individuals he associated with technology, the destroyers of nature. His violent spree, resulting in the longest and costliest manhunt in modern history, initially was diagnosed by psychologists who saw in his writing evidence of schizophrenia; and, after he insisted on defending himself in court, lawyers called this further evidence of his insanity as a demented serial killer with the fanaticism of a terrorist. He went from being a Harvard-trained genius in mathematics, to the University of Michigan, to being an associate professor at UC Berkeley, then dropping out from civilization, to a lonely boy recluse rural Montana, to being an infamous murderer. Living in his remote shack with no running water, reading by light of his homemade candles, he survived by living on wild rabbits and a small garden. His capture came with assistance of his brother, David, who saw the similarities in Ted’s manifesto and earlier writings, and he was able to assist the FBI in raiding the Montana cabin. After his capture by the FBI, the details of his ideology were revealed in the previously released 35,000 word manifesto, and were the subject of debate by commentators, some of whom took seriously his justification of his actions and the ideas that he claimed were his inspiration, as he tried to save humanity from itself. David’s $1M reward was given to families of the bombing victims to aid in their recovery from the tragedies.

In 2021, the upstart global golf tour funded by the Saudis Public Investment Fund disrupted the world of golf in signing players who defected from the PGA Tour, with Commissioner Jay Monahan refusing to associate with the organization called LIV Golf, and refusing to allow players who crossed the line from playing in the PGA. At the time, he made references to the 9/11 event with finger-pointing to Saudi involvement, and to the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi, along with known human rights abuses. His ego had obviously been thrown for a loop, so he framed the PGA to be seen as morally upright; but, hypocrisy has won out with the recent announcement of a merger of the two organizations. Howls of protest immediately arose, but money talks, and the Saudi Fund has infinite resources. Monahan has glossed over his previous comments, calling the merger a positive for the world of golf, with a willingness to “accept criticisms…but circumstances change.” Championship golfer, Phil Mickelson, who had earlier abandoned the PGA for LIV, had commented to a journalist at the time that his new bosses were “scary mo……..rs,…we know they killed Khashoggi.” And, also many prisoners with mass executions in 2010, Phil, accompanied by a crackdown on women’s rights.

Senate Finance Committee Chairman, Ron Wyden, called Monahan’s move, “hypocritical, and a shameless cash grab” that would meet challenges on Capitol Hill. Prominent in any discussions in Congress will be the PGA Tour’s federal tax exemption, with the introduction by Representative John Garamendi’sNo Corporate Tax Exemption for Professional Sports Act.’ He commented, “The notion that the Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund would pay zero dollars in taxes on their blood money and potentially make billions of dollars in profits while countless American families pay their fair share while struggling to make ends meet is ludicrous.” Wyden is concerned that US officials need to consider if the deal gives the Saudi regime improper control of US real estate. Senior fellow and intelligence analyst, Bruce Reidel, of the Brookings Institution raises concerns that a foreign power could influence our politics. Emily Kilcrease of the Center for New American Security says, “It’s not evident to me at this point what they can do with the PGA Tour that would raise the level of a national security risk. Obviously, they’re engaging in this because they’re trying to sport wash or kind of deflect attention from their human rights abuses.”

Needless to say, The Former Guy praised the merger on Truth Social, saying, “Great news from LIV golf. A big, beautiful, and glamorous deal for the wonderful world of golf. Congrats to all!!!” His personally owned golf courses are a major part to the LIV Tour, and his family has also been tied to lucrative deals with the Saudis. The Associated Press reported in November that a Saudi real estate company had signed an agreement with the Trump Organization for more than $1B for use of the Trump name on its hotel, golf course and villas. Notable is Trump’s son-in-law’s receipt of a $2B investment into his own investment firm, after Trump left the White House. Bruce Reidel comments on the Saudi royal family, “They make no secret that they prefer Trump and his family to Biden.”  President Biden had previously pledged to make the crown prince a ‘pariah’ over the Khashoggi killing, and gas prices soared last year showing the delicacy of this relationship. Biden then vowed consequence in response to the oil cuts, prompting the prince to say privately, “I will not deal with the US administration anymore,” promising major economic consequences for Washington.

Without a doubt, last week’s bombshell was the indictment we’ve all been waiting for as DOJ Special Counsel Jack Smith laid out the charges against former President Trump and one of his lackeys, Walt Nauta, for mishandling secret government documents and obstructing federal investigators…37 counts in 49 pages for which he had to answer in a Tuesday court appearance. Although he had known this was coming for days, our Tangerine Caligula had to had to have the limelight by announcing the pending indictment the day before it was dropped, all the while proclaiming his innocence and blaming his perceived enemies for the ‘witch hunt.’ He condemned his critics as “Communists, Marxists, and Radical Left Lunatics,” and denounced Special Counsel Jack Smith a “deranged psycho.” The action prompted a deluge of angry commentary online and in spoken remarks from his base. Kari Lake, still disputing her Arizona election loss, said to a GOP group, “If you want to get to President Trump, you’re going to have to go through me and you’re going to have to go through 75 million Americans just like me. Most of us are card-carrying members of the NRA. That’s not a threat. That’s a public service announcement.”

The support for Trump in light of his 37 counts astounds the rational mind! Kevin McCarthy, Lindsey Graham, Jim Jordan – all moved to tears (well, Lindsey anyway…he cries over anything except cruel abuse)! Even former Attorney General Barr, in an attempt to redeem himself in the eyes of the public, says that the case is clear cut and Trump is in trouble. Has anyone of these fascists read the charges? Do they have a clue about what’s going on? It’s clear that Trump doesn’t realize his jeopardy, as seen by his carousel turnover of D-level of attorneys. Satirist Andy Borowitz writes that, “Guest who dined at Mar-a-Lago after January, 2021, wondered why their menus featured missile sites of the United States and its allies…some assuming they were specials or themes. The hard to read menus irritated one dinner guest, who found it difficult to climb over boxes to get to her table.” And have you seen anything trashier than the bathroom chandelier? These next few (we hope) weeks will undoubtably be fraught with danger, fireworks and drama as we approach the trial date set by Trumper Judge Aileen Cannon – unless they were able to oust her from being involved after her previously dismal favoritism in the case. The GOP has degenerated into a seedy organization of debauchery, populated by Trump cultists, fascist-leaning Christians, gun nuts, flat-earthers and outright White racists, supported by corporate America, and unrestrained capitalists. Anti-unionists represented by the billionaires of Amazon, Trader Joe’s, and Starbuck’s have arisen to fight a newly awakened labor force, yet prominent facets of the party adhere to anti-science ignorance and willful know-nothingness led by the Boebert, Greene, Kennedy faction. Allegations of electoral fraud and rigged vote counting, in counties held hostage by Republican machinery, and mostly by Whining White males, sounds their pitiful refrain…sorry, Kari Lake!

Trump hasn’t, and isn’t, expected to drop out of the race for the GOP presidential nomination, but he actually said he might be willing to cut a plea deal with the Department of Justice if “they pay me some damages.” This is a big joke, but it appears Trump wasn’t attempting a joke. His impression that this is a civil case with monetary damages to be considered…a negotiable matter instead of a criminal trial, but instead of paying him to go away, the system is going to put him away. Maybe he thinks the GOP will pay him to exit the race instead of having to support a federal prisoner on the ticket. Jokers abound all around. Are you laughing yet?

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “Fathers”

“Someone once said that every man is trying to live up to his father’s expectations or make up for their father’s mistakes….”
~Barack Obama

“I think my mom put it best. She said, ‘Little girls soften their daddy’s hearts.'”
~Paul Walker

“The nature of impending fatherhood is that you are doing something that you’re unqualified to do, and then you become  qualified while doing it.”
~John Green

“What I’ve learned as a father is that the most important thing in the world is listening. It’s not about trying to be right.”
~Kevin Hart

“The biggest lesson for my kids is that they know they are the most important things I have. No matter what is going on in my life, your kids are forever.”
~Lin-Manuel Miranda

...

I swear, I wish I had this kind of equipment (and space to use it!). I wonder if it’s as rewarding of a job as the tik-tok videos make it out to be… 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

June 7 – 13, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton…first district supervisor, 2023 musical saw festival, movies. Greensite… on Wharf Master Plan Phase 2…Public Be Damned. Schendledecker…why work with the dems? Steinbruner…supes budget hearings, land use control, housing shortage real?, Cabrillo housing and name. Hayes…Never cry wolf? A situation of subservience. Patton…Heartfelt. Matlock…Animal magnetism, partying on, and Capone’s vault revisited. EaganSubconscious Comics and Deep Cover. WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week. Quotes…”FOG”

...

EARLY SANTA CRUZ PARADE. This happened October 16, 1900. Note that Pacific Avenue was wide enough to have the parade going in two directions. Note too the Sentinel Printers building on the left. Santa Cruz used to have many more parades every year before the police got nervous about crowds.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE June 5

NO WAY GREENWAY AND SUPPORTING LANI FAULKNER FOR COUNTY SUPERVISOR.

This is from a notice Sally Arnold sent this week…

“Together we built a landslide defeat of the Deceptive Measure D proposal to tear out the tracks, kill our transit future and delay trail construction.  After that historic victory, we thought that our elected officials would respect the will of their constituents and work toward trail construction and planning for rail service.

But that has not been the case.  Some politicians are still trying to stop construction of the trail!  This is a threat to the rail and trail that we must take seriously.

Recently, Supervisor Manu Koenig (District 1) wasted everyone’s time grandstanding and refusing to accept the Environmental Impact Report for Rail Trail segments 8 & 9, which were just funded for construction.  His failures to listen don’t stop with the Rail & Trail. First District residents are complaining about his focus on his wealthiest constituents rather than the majority of First District residents.  Whether it’s Coastal Commission policy, parking programs, bike lanes, housing or zoning – small businesses and constituents are upset with the incumbent.

One strategically placed government official can do a whole lot of damage if they have an agenda that’s not aligned with the will of our community. The Board of Supervisors is a small body (only 5 elected supervisors) so just one troublesome supervisor can make it difficult for the board to get things done for all of us.  This is why all of us, no matter which district we live in, should care about the District 1 supervisor’s race.

That’s why, as members of the No Way Greenway Campaign Committee, we are excited to support Lani Faulkner for First District Supervisor.  Lani brings a wealth of experience from her successful career in Biotechnology to her community involvement.  Lani serves on the Executive Committee of the Santa Cruz Chapter of the Sierra Club, the Community Traffic Safety Coalition, Equity Transit, Friends of the Rail & Trail and the NAACP.  Her work on the Democratic Central Committee and with local union leaders has given her the connections and relationships needed to get things done. Her experience working with government agencies is exactly what we need in a local leader.

First District residents asked Lani to run for First District Supervisor because she’s a true part of the community, who raised her family in Live Oak . She makes herself available, knows how to listen and is committed to finding common ground. Lani’s diplomatic approach to problem solving will help our whole community.

This race has direct consequences for not just the First District but the whole County.  In a time when we need to bring the community together to solve some of the tough challenges ahead of us, we need a Supervisor who works well with others.

Will you join us in supporting Lani for Supervisor?  Lani’s Launch Party will be held on June 11 at DeLaveaga Park, Forty Thieves Picnic area from 2 to 4pm.

Early endorsement and donations are important.   You can add your name and support Lani in other ways here: Endorse Lani for Supervisor

Feel free to call us if you would like to discuss this remarkable candidate.

Sally Arnold (831-419-4622)
Matt Farrell (831-331-7496)

No Way Greenway Campaign Committee; click here for background on No Way Greenway.

2023 SANTA CRUZ’S MUSICAL SAW FESTIVAL.  Kenny Blacklock sent this notice to fans and newcomers.

“Our annual street jam will take place on Saturday, July 29, from 1-3 pm at The Bookshop Santa Cruz 1520 Pacific Avenue in Santa Cruz around the Tom Scribner statue. However, if the gathering is too large, we may need to move the street jam to the corner of Pacific Avenue and Front Street. Please look for us there if we are not in front of Bookshop Santa Cruz. Our annual potluck and jam will take place on Saturday, July 29, from 6-9 pm in the outer parking lot of Roaring Camp Railroads in Felton. The main event will take place on Sunday, July 30th, 10 am – 5 pm at Roaring Camp in Felton, California. If you are interested in performing at the festival, please contact Art Peterson. The musical saw contest will take place at 11 am. Click here for more information on the contest. For more information about the festival, please visit our website or Facebook page. You can support the festival by joining the International Musical Saw Association. The membership fee is only $5 and can be paid online. Please also consider making a donation of any amount using our donation link. Thank you to everyone who has already made a donation to support the upcoming festival! We look forward to seeing you at the festival!…Kenny Blacklock International Musical Saw Association”.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

BLACKBERRY. (PRIME VIDEO) (7.6 IMDB). This is a half true story based on the very real history of the early history of the smartphone. It’s also half funny and cringe producing displaying the relationships of the people involved in the success and failure of that pre-iPhone device. Somehow because it all happens in Canada gives it an extra dimension, but it needed more than that.

REALITY. (MAX MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). Sydney Sweeney portrays Reality Winner which is the real name of the former FBI translator agent who released classified information relating to the 2016 election. That information connected Trump and Russia and caused all sorts of hell. It’s about how the FBI controlled and conducted her interrogation. An excellent and yet disturbing expose and it’s an adaptation of a play.  Go for it.

THE FAMILY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (  ? IMDB).   A well done and rather long saga dealing with the Yakusa or Japanese version of the Mafia.  It centers on one young guy and his violent upbringing. He goes to prison for 14 years and returns to learn that the Yakusa and all of his community and day dreams have changed. Toughing, nicely photographed and worth watching.

FIREFLY LANE. (NETFLIX SEWRIES) (7.6 IMDB). Katherine Heigl and Sarah Chalke act as two best friends who support each other through their lives. They’ve got the usual set of issues and family scenes to re-act to but it’s too full of mugging and age old clichés to make a good series. The two actresses/actors aren’t professional enough to lift the series into the watchable category. Don’t go there.

QUEEN CHARLOTTE. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB).   This totally fictitious take on history has unbelievably re-cast the court and especially the marriage of King George of England with a half black cast. It’s listed as a prequel to the Bridgerton series, and I’ve never watched a minute of Bridgerton. Being extra cute and quaint it centers on the wedding gown. It does credit to no one involved, and you needn’t be either.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

LOU. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.1 IMDB). Allison Janney goes into deep and very wet pursuit of her daughter who was kidnapped by the ex-husband/father. Through the Pacific Northwest territory and woods, rivers, storms she chases the two of them. He’s an ex-green beret and deals some surprise plot twists late in the film. Intriguing and mesmerizing, go for it.

YOU HURT MY FEELINGS. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (7.2 IMDB).   Absolutely wonderful and deep search into our own relationships and how we deal out and take in honesty. You’ll be reminded many times of similar scenes in your life and how you could have and should have dealt with those awkward and painful times.

MISSING. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). Watching this one is like never taking your eyes away from your cell phone or computer. It’s all a high tech search for a young girl’s mother who disappears. Too electronic, too Gmail, iPhone, and just plain high powered drivel.

BEING MARY TYLER MOORE. (HBO MAX) (8.3 IMDB). This documentary proves to us that Mary Tyler Moore not only changed television but changed the relationship between men and women. It reveals her rare and darker side and also places her among women who made giant strides in establishing a better relationship in the work place especially television.

THE SON. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.3 IMDB). Not exactly a sequel to The Father but it’s related. Hugh Jackman and Laura Dern deal with a son who has a psychological problem. He’s into acute depression and how do they help him? Anthony Hopkins appears briefly as the grandfather so we learn of the family history and it’s not pretty.  It’s about ex-partners and relationships and the acting is fine.

S.W.A.T. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB).   It’s all about South Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Police Departments problems. Centering on the racial Black issues and how tough it is to have Black cops chasing Black lawbreakers. It has lots of political and logical pressures that could have made this a very important movie, but it isn’t.

...
Wharf Master Plan Phase 2…Public Be Damned

If you had no idea the city was holding a community meeting for the public to comment on the revised, partial draft environmental impact report (EIR) for the Wharf Master Plan, it was not for lack of attention, nor are you alone. The “community meeting” itself was held by zoom on May 30th, the day before the May 31st deadline for comments on the draft partial EIR. There was no Sentinel published public announcement of the meeting, nor a prior public notice in the Sentinel of the circulation of the EIR and deadline for comments. Meanwhile, the CEQA process states unequivocally that “Public participation is a mandated and essential component of CEQA”. 

The meeting itself was zoom only. All other meetings held by the city are now in public with an additional zoom option. I don’t have to spell out the value of a public versus zoom-only meeting.

The meeting was set for an hour and a half. It was facilitated by the Director of Parks and Recreation and the Wharf Project Manager. The first hour was filled with a presentation from the project manager largely repeating what we already know, including information that can only be described as inaccurate and/or misleading. He incorrectly stated that the 2011 tsunami “partially damaged” the Wharf. The city’s 2014 application for funds from the federal Commerce Department stated, incorrectly, that the Wharf was “severely damaged” by the tsunami. Both claims are false. The Engineering Report that accompanied the Wharf Master Plan (on which the Commerce Department federal grant of close to $1 million was spent) states that “the Wharf was undamaged” by the tsunami “although the harbor sustained considerable damage.” This correction has been brought to staff and council attention many times, but the project manager chose to repeat the misinformation for the public.

Why is this important?

Because the narrative being circulated by the city is that all this new Wharf development, the three 40 feet tall buildings, the added commercial space, the new dock to accommodate 200- ton vessels etc. is needed to obtain grants to maintain the Wharf. Again, this is inaccurate and misleading. In 2021, the city was granted $1 million from the federal government’s Commerce Department for the small % of Wharf pilings that required replacement. That job has been completed. The Wharf is an iconic, historic structure. Funding to maintain its longevity does not require a Pier 39 make-over.

After an hour, when it was the public’s turn, we were told we could ask only clarifying questions via Q&A. They had not activated the “raised hand” function. I started to type my question but before a quarter way through the project manager said to the director, “looks like there are no questions so we can wrap this meeting up.” I scrapped my question and quickly wrote, “how can we speak?” The director said to the project manager, “there is one question” and thus began the public comment half hour. I repeated my question, and they unlocked the “raised hand” function. Four people spoke, three from Don’t Morph the Wharf! and one other community member. She had just learned that day about the meeting. She had submitted written comments on the 2020 EIR and was not pleased at the lack of public notification for this public meeting on the revised draft partial EIR, held one day before the comment deadline.

Not only is the city ignoring public input on the Municipal Wharf make-over that was opposed by thousands, but it also is ignoring the Superior Court ruling in the Writ of Mandate issued by Judge Paul Burdick. On the zoom, I asked why the city is not following that ruling? The project manager’s response was that their CEQA attorney said what they are doing “will suffice.”

Their contracted CEQA attorney lost the 2022 case, Don’t Morph the Wharf! v. City of Santa Cruz. The same CEQA attorney lost in the 2015 case, Save Our Big Trees v. City of Santa Cruz. Their CEQA attorney is incorrect in this interpretation of the Court’s ruling. The resolution (withdrawing the old project approval and decertifying the EIR) was required to be amended, removing all references to areas of the former EIR that would remain valid. The whole EIR must be amended in conformance with the Court’s Order and be recirculated for the public’s review prior to its certification. The city failed to do this, recirculating only a part of the EIR and limiting public comments to that part.

Maybe management staff and the city think there is nothing to lose when it is just public monies being squandered. That, and the public trust.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

June 5

WHY WORK WITH THE DEMS?

As many of you know, I am co-chair of our local Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) chapter this year. Until I registered as a Democrat for Bernie, I was a Green Party member for my entire voting life. I’m an unapologetic Leftist, an Ecosocialist Feminist.

So with decades of disappointment in elected (mostly neoliberal) Democrats, members of the Squad and the Congressional Progressive Caucus making some notable concessions that hurt working-class people and the environment, DSA again debating a complete break from the Dems, why would I choose to engage with the Democrats (and how)?

Even though our municipal elections are nonpartisan, in this town one really has to be a registered Democrat to run for office and be included in endorsement forums (which kind of makes the label meaningless as you end up with such a broad swath of actual political positions calling themselves Dems). As I prepared to run for mayor last year, I read the CADEM 2022 platform  (CADEM – California Democratic Party) and felt reassured that I could run as a Democrat and be consistent with the party’s stated values, my own values, and the national platform of DSA. I feel pretty comfortable joining the CADEM Progressive Caucus and the Left-wing of the Democratic Party.

In the thirty years since I started voting, I have not seen a rise in the effectiveness of third-party politics. And as much as I believe in DSA and other Leftist organizations, we simply do not have the membership (locally, regionally, nationally) to become our own effective party or to win elections for or with other third parties. I hope we get there someday, but until then I will try to work within the system that has a stranglehold on the electorate, to reduce harm and move towards universal liberation and justice for all.

As I age, I also feel more comfortable engaging with people from across the political spectrum. True democracy requires listening, negotiation, and consensus building. As much as I think I’m right and want to convince people of my positions, it would not be a democracy if I simply prevailed. Of course those of us on the Left experience what I consider undemocratic silencing, exclusion, and steamrolling by the moderate/neoliberal majority all the time–but I don’t want to do that to others.

And if DSA is a “big-tent” organization working to grow the movement for working-class power, we have to meet people where they are if we hope for them to join us or work coalitionally with us. I think this is true for all of us organizing on the larger left–if we want to change the system, we have to work both inside and outside of its power structures, together.

In the spirit of learning, engaging, and pushing from the Left, I recently attended CADEM 2023, the California Democratic Party Convention, in LA. I was in very good company, including 6 other Santa Cruz County DSA/YDSA members.

The best shirt at CADEM 2023: “The Resistance is not Futile; Welcome to The Rebellion; The Democratic Club of Moreno Valley Welcomes You to The Resistance,” designed by the person using the mobility device (I neglected to get her name, or maybe I just forgot to write it down!).

My favorite things about CADEM:

  • Meeting dozens of random people with shared interests. Amazingly, I did not feel like an alien (which is my default social/political mode).
  • Spending time with Assembly Members Gail Pellerin and Dawn Addis, Senator John Laird, and other regional delegates and colleagues.
  • Meeting the DSA member, anti-capitalist, proudly defund-the-police, and first openly-autistic mayor of Burbank, Konstantine Anthony.
  • Connecting with the (self-described) more moderate mayor of San Luis Obispo, Erica Stewart, over parenting teens, community mental health needs, and non-police emergency response.
  • Attending the Womens’ Caucus, Progressive Caucus, and Disability Caucus. I especially loved the Disability Caucus, where Mayor Anthony was stepping down as chair and we appointed vice-chair Sascha Bittner to interim chair until the elections are held next month. We were in the room next to the very raucous Labor Caucus, and as you can imagine there were people with speech and hearing issues in our room. Sascha spoke for a few minutes to thank everyone for supporting her as interim chair, and one of the best things she said was that she wanted to lead the Disability Caucus to grow as large and loud as the Labor Caucus. In spite of the small numbers in that room compared to Labor next door, I believe Disability Rights is where we find the most diverse community, working in the most intersectional ways.
  • Learning about the film, “Birthing Justice,” a feature-length documentary on racism and maternity, at the Women’s Caucus (watch the full film here). There were so many stump speeches that they ran out of time to show a clip, but the short panel of speakers on the film were fabulous and inspiring.
  • A certain number of stump speeches: especially by Barbara Lee, Katie Porter, and Lisa Middleton (first trans mayor of Palm Springs, now running for State Senate). Overall, it did get lengthy and repetitive at multiple caucuses!
  • Hearing Nancy Pelosi speak. I’m not a huge fan of her politics, but I respect her for all the hard work she’s put in throughout her career, and how she has talked back to Trumpism. We’re definitely better off for having her than not, given the rise of right-wing conservatism.

Least favorite things about CADEM:

  • It’s a bit much, with thousands of people cramming too many events into one weekend. It’s loud, and expensive. I do best with a balance of extrovert activity and recharge down-time.
  • Coming home with food poisoning (I’m recovered now, thank you).

Side note: The Progressive Caucus was especially interesting because there was an attempted takeover of the Executive Committee by a slate calling itself, “Progressives Moving California Forward,” that was made up of people who are apparently not Lefties, and even industry insiders. “The Troublemakers Slate,” all of whom are definitely on the Left, overwhelmingly prevailed. This was yet more evidence of the attempt of centrists and even neoliberals to capture the term “progressive” or mobilize identity politics for political gain rather than justice

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
June 6

COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISOR BUDGET HEARINGS HAD NO PUBLICLY-ACCESSIBLE INFORMATION

Did last week’s cursory Board of Supervisor 2023-2024 Budget Hearings violate the Brown Act by not providing the public with any access to the agendas or related documents, due to a website that was broken, and is still broken?  I think so.

On the Saturday before the Budget Hearings, I wanted to review the proposed County Fire Dept. budget, strangely scheduled to be reviewed as a Consent Agenda Item on Wednesday, May 31.  The website was broken, and I could access nothing for either the May 30 or May 31 Board Calendar.  I wrote to IT Director Ms. Tammie Weigl, who usually responds right away.  However, this time, neither she nor anyone else from IT Dept. responded until sometime during which I was seated in the Board Chambers, uninformed, and listening to staff presentations from Public Safety departments.

I testified to the Board that their website was broken, and no Budget information was available to the public.  Not one of them inquired with staff about the problem, however Chairman Zach Friend did get someone in right away when his microphone became unresponsive and he wanted to tell me to stop talking and couldn’t.  He muted my microphone, and Vice-Chair Justin Cummings took over until the IT staff could come rushing in to save the day.

Usually, the binder containing hard copies of the proposed Budget is on a table in the hallway, just outside the Board Chambers, but on May 30, it was not.   Other people in the audience also told me they had not been able to access Budget information.

After the day’s hearing adjourned, I visited the Clerk of the Board lobby to try the public computer there.  No luck finding the Budget information.  I asked for help.  Staff also could not access the documents supporting any budgetary agenda items, and suggested I file a Public Records Act request to obtain the 2023-2024 proposed County Fire Dept. Budget.  Wow.

Again, I wrote to IT and the Board of Supervisors to demand the problem be fixed, and copied the First Amendment Coalition.  On May 31, the binder on a table outside the Board chamber only contained copies of the agenda, but nothing of the actual Budget.

No one contacted me about the matter until after the May 31 Budget hearings had concluded.  Supervisor Manu Koenig responded that there did indeed seem to be problems with the website calendar, the usual method for accessing Board agendas and documents, but that there was another obscure method to find the information.

Don’t you think that would have been good to post on the website for the public?

At the time of this writing, the website Calendar is STILL BROKEN.

The Board does not seem to care. Maybe they don’t want the public to see why the Budget will be $8-$10 MILLION in the red???

However, here is the response sent from The First Amendment Coalition:

The Brown Act requires, in relevant part, “At least 72 hours before a regular meeting, the legislative body of the local agency, or its designee, shall post an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted or discussed at the meeting, including items to be discussed in closed session. A brief general description of an item generally need not exceed 20 words. The agenda shall specify the time and location of the regular meeting and shall be posted in a location that is freely accessible to members of the public and on the local agency’s Internet Web site, if the local agency has one.” Govt. Code § 54954.2(a)(1).

When agendas are posted on an agency’s website, they must comply with specified formatting requirements. See Govt. Code § 54954.2(a)(1).

According to the Brown Act, “No action or discussion shall be undertaken on any item not appearing on the posted agenda,” with some exceptions I assume are not relevant here. Govt. Code § 54954.2(a)(3).

I understand from your question that certain materials for the meeting in question were not available on the agency’s website within the required time. I’m not clear if the agenda itself was unavailable or only certain supporting materials.

I assume the agenda & supporting materials were physically posted in a location that is freely accessible to members of the public at least 72 hours before the meeting. If that is incorrect, please let me know.

I don’t know of a Brown Act case addressing the question whether a board’s action is invalid because the agenda or supporting materials were not digitally available on the agency’s website although they were physically available at a location accessible to the public. However, I can share some information about the statute & general case law.

Under the Brown Act, in certain circumstances, “The district attorney or any interested person may commence an action by mandamus or injunction for the purpose of obtaining a judicial determination that an action taken by a legislative body of a local agency in violation of Section 54953, 54954.2, 54954.5, 54954.6, 54956, or 54956.5 is null and void under this section.”  Govt. Code § 54960.1(a) (emphasis added).

“[A]ction taken” means “a collective decision made by a majority of the members of a legislative body, a collective commitment or promise by a majority of the members of a legislative body to make a positive or a negative decision, or an actual vote by a majority of the members of a legislative body when sitting as a body or entity, upon a motion, proposal, resolution, order or ordinance.” Govt. Code § 54952.6.

Therefore, if an agency took action at a meeting in violation of the agenda posting & notice requirements of section 54954.2, it is possible a court might declare such action null & void.

Section 54960.1 apparently refers to any “violation of Section … 54954.2,” without qualification. Therefore, if the agency took action in violation of any of the provisions of section 54954.2, including but not limited to the website posting requirements, it is possible a court might find such action null & void.

Before going to court, the plaintiff must make a written “demand of the legislative body to cure or correct” the allegedly unlawful action “within 90 days from the date the action was taken” if it was not taken in open session, or within 30 days if it was taken in open session, as appears to be the case here. Govt. Code § 54960.1(b), (c)(1). The legislative body must respond to the cure & correct letter within 30 days of receiving it. Govt. Code § 54960.1(c)(2); see also Page v. MiraCosta Community College Dist.,180 Cal. App. 4th 471, 500 (2009) (“To state a cause of action for violation of section 54960.1 of the Brown Act, a petitioner must allege (1) that a legislative body of a local agency violated one or more enumerated Brown Act statutes; (2) that there was ‘action taken’ by the local legislative body in connection with the violation; and (3) that before commencing the action, plaintiff made a timely demand of the legislative body to cure or correct the action alleged to have been taken in violation of the enumerated statutes, and the legislative body did not cure or correct the challenged action.”) (citation & quotation marks omitted).

If the agency does not cure & correct the alleged violation, the deadline to file suit is 15 days after receipt of the legislative body’s response, or 15 days after the 30-day response deadline expires if the body does not respond, whichever is earlier. Govt. Code § 54960.1(c)(4).

Please refer to the statutes to confirm the exact process & time limits, which are strictly construed & mandatory.

Although the text of the Brown Act does not expressly contain such a requirement, courts have held plaintiffs “must show prejudice” from a violation to justify setting aside agency action as null & void. Olson v. Hornbrook Community Services Dist., 33 Cal. App. 5th 502, 517 (2019).

I hope this is helpful.

Well, the one good bit of news came from Supervisor Justin Cummings, who actually responded to my plea for an After Action Review of the 2020 CZU Fire with County Fire Dept. Volunteers, who were instructed by CalFire to not respond to fires.  He said he is working to get this critical review done, and wanted to let me know my request was heard.  I am hopeful.

Please write Supervisor Justin Cummings to urge him to require an After Action Review and Analysis of the 2020 CZU Fire with Santa Cruz County Fire Dept. Volunteers…some of whom were dismissed by CalFire because they chose to stay and protect their Community during the fire.  Justin Cummings justin.cummings@santacruzcounty.us

And one last issue…why wasn’t County Fire Dept. given the same level of administrative importance at the Budget Hearings when all other Public Safety Departments gave staff reports as Regular Agenda items?

As District Attorney Jeff Rosell stated in his presentation, the California Constitution Article XIII Section 35 states:

  1.  Public safety services are critically important to the security and well-being of the State’s citizens and to the growth and revitalization of the State’s economic base.
  2.  The protection of the public safety is the first responsibility of local government and local officials have an obligation to give priority to the provision of adequate public safety services.
  3.  In order to assist local government in maintaining a sufficient level of public safety services, the proceeds of the tax enacted pursuant to this section shall be designated exclusively for public safety.

Don’t you think that fire and emergency medical response is included in “Public Safety”?  I do.

More next week on the dismal County Budget.

REMOVING LOCAL LAND USE CONTROL FOREVER?

Last week, the State Senate approved SB 423.  If the Assembly passes it, we are doomed to a tragic permanent loss of local land use discretionary control.  Here is what you need to know about this bill, and why it is important that you contact our State Assembly members to urge them to vote NO.

SB 423, introduced by Senator Scott Wiener, permanently streamlines multi-family housing approvals to have ministerial approval, removing the current sunset date of January 1, 2026 for such.  “This bill would authorize the Department of General Services to act in the place of a locality or local government, at the discretion of that department, for purposes of the ministerial, streamlined review for development on property owned by or leased to the state.

The bill would, among other modifications, delete the objective planning standards requiring development proponents to pay at least the general prevailing rate of per diem wages and utilize a skilled and trained workforce and would instead require a development proponent to certify to the local government that certain wage and labor standards will be met, including a requirement that all construction workers be paid at least the general prevailing rate of wages, as specified. The bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the obligation to pay prevailing wages. By expanding the crime of perjury, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would specify that the requirements to pay prevailing wages, use a workforce participating in an apprenticeship, or provide health care expenditures do not apply to a project that consists of 10 or fewer units and is not otherwise a public work.

This bill would define “objective planning standards” to exclude specified standards, including local building codes, fire codes, other codes requiring detailed technical specifications, and standards that are not reasonably ascertainable by the local government within specified time limits, as described.

Existing law authorizes the local government’s planning commission or any equivalent board or commission responsible for review and approval of development projects, or as otherwise specified, to conduct any design review or public oversight of the development.

This bill would remove the above-described authorization to conduct public oversight of the development and would only authorize design review to be conducted by the local government’s planning commission or any equivalent board or commission responsible for design review.

By imposing additional duties on local officials, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.

The bill would include findings that changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern rather than a municipal affair and, therefore, apply to all cities, including charter cities.

The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.

This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.”

California SB423 | 2023-2024 | Regular Session

Please contact your State Assembly member to urge a NO vote on this dangerous piece of legislation that would forever remove local discretionary control of developments in our local communities and throughout the State.

Assemblywoman Dawn Addis

ARE CALIFORNIA’S HOUSING SHORTAGES OVER-BLOWN?

Many are wondering how the new Regional Housing Number Allocation (RHNA) mandates by the State can be justified.  Who decides what the ultimate number of housing units must built in the State and what factors are used to determine those mandated numbers?

The analysis below claims the numbers are not built on well-researched reason:

Is the housing shortage overblown? This California analyst thinks so | Catalysts for Local Control

And, here is another analysis by CalMatters staff that would indicate the same conclusion.   Commentary: Five things I’ve learned covering California’s housing crisis that you should know

I have written AMBAG Planning Director Ms. Heather Adamson again to ask about the criteria for the models she has described as being used to determine the RHNA building mandates, and who in the world is controlling these puppeteer-like tactics?   Stay tuned for her answer.

WILL CABRILLO COLLEGE BUILD STUDENT AND STAFF HOUSING ON CAMPUS?

Cabrillo College may soon be deciding whether to build on-campus housing, but it remains to be seen how it would be financed and how it would be managed. The Board may be making this decision next Monday, June 12.  Here is the link to the presentation provided on January 9, 2023

This could be a real asset for boosting the declining enrollment, but in my opinion, would be especially valuable if coupled with expanding the nursing program.  Applicants for that program currently wait several years to be accepted for enrollment at a time when there is a shortage of qualified nurses.

Keep your eye on this proposed 640-bed housing complex at Cabrillo College.

WILL IT BE CALLED CABRILLO COLLEGE OR SOMETHING ELSE?

The saga continues as the hand-picked Name Exploration Task Force Committee, which has met four times to find a new name for Cabrillo College, will soon provide a list of 3-5 name suggestions to the Board of Trustees to review.  The Name Exploration Committee is also searching for the independent funding necessary to make such a change, using NO funding from the College bank accounts.  Will they hold true on that promise?

We had all better keep a close eye on that.

Here is the latest, as reported in Item I-2 of the May 1, 2023 Trustee meeting

The Task Force reviewed 351 suggested names on April 7 and were asked to return on April 21 with their top 10 choices.  The group met, and were scheduled to meet twice again in May to whittle down the 85 choices members wanted.

Shouldn’t this name change issue be decided by an official public vote at the ballot box?

Review the process to date of this unnecessary and expensive Name Exploration fiasco here

COUNTY CONTINUES TO ALLOW DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT OF CRITICAL HISTORIC RESOURCES

A few years ago, the Santa Cruz County Historic Resources Commission developed and recommended to the Board of Supervisors that the County adopt a Demolition by Neglect Ordinance that would enforce preservation on historic structures, such as the Redman-Hirahara House and Farmstead near Riverside Drive in Watsonville, to be protected from the elements causing degradation and prevent further collapse of historic structures.

Shockingly, the Board of Supervisors refused to adopt the Ordinance.

Thanks to their inaction and disrespect for historic preservation in general, many historic structures are in peril.  The worst example is the Redman-Hirahara House.  This is a cultural resource with an incredibly rich story that should make the Pajaro Valley swell with pride.

When the Japanese American citizens were imprisoned during WW2, many lost their homes and farms because they could not pay the property taxes while they were away in the prison camps.  However, the wonderful citizens of Watsonville prevented that travesty from happening to the Hirahara family by paying their property taxes for them.  As a result, the Hirahara family still had a home (designed by famous local architect William Weeks) and farm to come back to after they were released from the prison camps.  They converted their barn into apartments for their less-fortunate friends, and provided a place for them to re-establish.

How has Santa Cruz County celebrated this amazing story?

The Board of Supervisors cannot even be bothered to adopt a Demolition by Neglect Ordinance that would offer a shred of protection to the home, and stood idly by as the barn fell down and continues to deteriorate.

Please write the County Supervisors, and demand they adopt a Demolition by Neglect Ordinance.  It is the least they can do.

Board of Supervisors boardofsupervisors@santacruzcounty.us

This photo, taken last week, shows the continuing sad state of disrepair the owners are allowing to progress while the County Board of Supervisors continues to reject approving a Demolition by Neglect Ordinance that would prevent such travesties from occurring. This house is  on the National Historic Registry.

This recent photo shows the total collapse of the historic barn that once served as an apartment for Japanese-American families who returned to find their homes and farms had been taken.  The Hirahara family provided apartments for these families to live in while getting re-established.  Cabrillo College Archaeology Dept. surveyed the barn’s contents decades ago and determined it should be on the National Historic Registry.

Meanwhile directly across the street on Lee Road, the same property owners, the Tut family, enjoy the lucrative hotel, restaurant and fueling station businesses, and the County smiles on the Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT) and sales tax revenues associated.

Please write the County Board of Supervisors to insist they adopt a Demolition by Neglect Ordinance that would protect this and other valuable historic and cultural resources from rotting away before our very eyes.  The Redman-Hirahara House and Farm are in Second District Supervisor Zach Friend’s jurisdiction but he could care less.

Board of Supervisors boardofsupervisors@santacruzcounty.us

BIG CHANGES COMING IN THE WATSONVILLE SLOUGH AREA NEAR FEDEX

If you have passed by the southern area of Watsonville on Highway One, you likely saw extensive grading activity near the Slough.  This area is destined to become a large 155,847 Sq Ft new warehouse for what may be the largest beer distributor in California, and that is currently lodged on Riverside Drive nearby.  Supposedly, it will create up to 2,100 jobs, but the business currently has 137 employees.

Approved by the Watsonville City Council on April 11, 2023, work quickly got underway, evident in the photos below.

Excavators staged along Manabe Ow Road.

Rubble collected from the former farming area that will now become a large new warehouse for beer and Monster drinks, but that requires environmental mitigations for red-legged frog, western pond turtle, Burrowing Owls, and tar plant with all earth disturbances overseen by Native American Observers.

Here are the mitigations

Here is the link to all staff documents

BEAUTIFUL DETAILS ON INFRASTRUCTURE MAKE A DIFFERENCE

This detail in the Manabe Ow Road concrete bridge crossing the Slough is lovely, and appropriate for the habitat.

TOUR THE CITY’S RECYCLING CENTER

Visit the Santa Cruz City Recycling Center at the Resource Recovery Facility, 605 Dimeo Lane, any Friday from June 16 through August 25 at 10 am and 1 pm. This action-packed 90-minute tour gives insight on how the City recycles 36 tons of material every single weekday. Visitors will also experience the new food scraps processing operation that is reducing methane emissions from the landfill and learn about the Household Hazardous Waste Program.

Pre-registration is required. Tours are limited to 20 people. Children must be at least 8 years old. Youth ages 8 to 18 must be accompanied by an adult. Carpooling is encouraged as parking is limited. Reserve your spot here – it’s free!

Questions may be addressed to: csoon@santacruzca.gov

SCMU Review

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND ONE PUBLIC HEARING.  JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
June 5

NEVER CRY WOLF? A SITUATION OF SUBSERVIENCE

Whenever I wonder why more people aren’t protesting, I think of debt. We owe, we owe, so off to work we go. The income gap widens with constant reminders of homelessness and sick friends/relatives reminding us of the fragility of our lives and the expenses of medical care. Workplaces warn us that we represent The Corporation, even when we speak out as citizens. It is news and some laugh when a Jan 6th protester gets fired because of their illegal actions, but the same holds true for lesser, legal protests on the other side of the political spectrum. Most people find they can no longer afford to protest. The wolf is in the house…and no one is saying anything!

Submit, Move

Even if you aren’t protesting, if you are a federal employee, your work is subject to political whims.

I was working with some brilliant grants officers with the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) just before the last president was elected from the Republican side of the aisle. These employees had good experience navigating the complex Washington DC bureaucracy to help disperse and manage federal funding for the most competitive proposals. Republicans ordered that their USDA office move from DC to Kansas City, and all of those grants officers left, retiring early or finding other jobs. They couldn’t leave their communities, their homes, or their histories behind.

Similarly, but with Democrats at the helm, someone, for some reason, ordered our regional Bureau of Land Management office to move from Hollister to Marina. This put the main office many more miles distant from most of the land their staff managed and, if a BLM employee wanted to stay with the agency, now they had to move or commute a long distance to work.

You can speculate about why those administrations moved the agency offices. We are lucky to have a US Government Accountability Office report showing that the rationale for the USDA move was ludicrous, and so was clearly politically motivated. We don’t have any such study about the Central Coast BLM office, but I’m guessing that it was similarly politically motivated…but why?

Shut Up or Move!

Politically motivated office moving isn’t the only way a public employee might be ordered to pack their bags for a new location or leave. State and Federal public employees working for organizations like State and Federal Parks, the Bureau of Land Management, and State and Federal Wildlife agencies are very shy about saying anything substantive at all about their work. Saying the wrong thing to the wrong person can get you transferred to an unpleasant area doing unpleasant work.

You have to understand that in order to disentangle anything one of those employees says on record.

Puzzling Quotes

I want to present a couple of puzzling quotes from the media from some State and Federal employees working on issues crucial to conservation in California. Two things to keep in mind: 1) democracy depends on an informed citizenry, and a free press is key to that; 2) reporters sometimes get quotes wrong or use them out of context.

State Wildlife Agency Speaks

The first quote is verbatim from a recording from KCBS 740 a.m. from 6/2/2023; you can listen to it here. The story was on the remarkable documentation of one of the state’s most endangered wildlife species, a wolverine. The reporter, Holly Quan, asked how the State is monitoring the wolverine population, and this is the reply from California Department of Fish and Wildlife’s (CDFW’s) David Gammons:

“That’s the $10 million question right there. It’s a pretty difficult thing to do. Estimating the number of any wild animal is a difficult thing to do whether it’s a mule deer where there is a lot of them or something like a wolverine that’s a very rare species.”

The wolverine is protected under California’s Endangered Species Act. CDFW’s mission is to “manage California’s diverse fish, wildlife, and plant resources, and the habitats upon which they depend, for their ecological values and their use and enjoyment by the public.” CDFW has a long history of underfunded monitoring programs and too few well-trained wildlife biologists to adequately manage the State’s increasingly dwindling wildlife. Mr. Gammons not only did not answer the reporter’s question, but also failed to help the public to understand how woefully inadequate the funding is for his agency to do its job. Shame on Ms. Quan for not following up to get a better answer from him.

Federal BLM Talking

Here’s another puzzling paraphrase and quote. This is from a Lookout Santa Cruz article published on 5/30/2023 by Christopher Neely. Mr. Neely asked Zachary Ormsby, BLM’s Central Coast Field Manager, about how he plans to move forward with controversial management dilemmas, including poor access planning and, given expected high visitor numbers, a lack of a science-based approach for wildlife conservation at Cotoni Coast Dairies.

Neely paraphrases the beginning of Ormsby’s answer here:

“The federal government will consider public comment and sentiment on the plan and alternatives, but BLM has the power to unilaterally decide the path forward, Ormsby says. Ormsby says a parking lot is not guaranteed or required before BLM opens the land to the broader public.”

And this is a direct quote:

“My perspective is that we’ll come up with a plan and list of options that will allow this community to move forward with confidence and comfort without filing any more appeals,” Ormsby said. “The common element among all the groups is that we love this land. The only thing we’re trying to reconcile is that we all love it collectively.”

Huh? What Did BLM say??

The paraphrased part seems like a quote from BLM’s legal counsel, basically “We can do anything we want.” The second part is more puzzling. It says a lot that he starts with ‘my perspective,’ which gives him an out for potentially not representing BLM. That last bit about ‘love’ is impossible to disentangle- enjoy trying!

Cotoni Coast Dairies is protected as a part of a National Monument as well as being part of the National Conservation Lands network. Both designations come with a regulatory framework that provides strong protections for the primary purpose of these lands: conservation. The land in question lacks the requisite science plan, which should work in tandem with a management plan, allowing management to adapt approaches to protect wildlife from the impacts of public visitation. There are no (ZERO) staff assigned to the property. There is ample evidence that the current, overstretched staff cannot adequately manage the property, even without public use.

As with the prior CDFW example, BLM’s Mr. Ormsby lost an opportunity to stress the importance of more staffing and more funding to adequately protect the property. Instead, he intoned that it would be just fine to allow the public to access the property without those resources. His dodginess isn’t unique: it would seem that there are unwritten dodginess policies coming from at least as high as the BLM California’s state director, Trump-era appointee Karen Mouritsen. All planning documents for Cotoni Coast Dairies have been reviewed at her level and none reference key conservation policies providing National Monument or National Conservation Lands protections or other policy protections for sensitive wildlife and plants. That is considerable politics, amazing with its official subservience to even prior administrations. That’s how far this culture of fear reaches.

The Dilemma of Submission

History reflects poorly on those saying anything like “I was just doing my job.” State and Federal conservation personnel have access to great power, but they walk a tight rope with the political nature of their jobs. If either Mr. Gammons or Mr. Ormsby suggest that their agencies aren’t able to execute their mandates, there might be reprisal. On the other hand, I’m sure that both of these individuals have good intentions and want to be on the side of wildlife conservation. What can they do?

There are outside organizations that can help, but are they doing enough? I’m very impressed with the work of the nonprofit organization Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics. BLM has a similar organization, but one that seems a lot less functional, the Public Lands Foundation for American Heritage. CDFW’s Mr. Gammons unfortunately has nowhere similar to turn, but there are two nonprofits left that are pointed primarily to wildlife conservation in California.

Other Avenues

Defenders of Wildlife and The Wildlife Society are two organizations that might help speak out for the heartfelt concerns of public wildlife conservation employees like Mr. Gammons and Mr. Ormsby. I’m sure that many public employees who support conservation are members of these organizations. You might consider supporting them, too! If you have to choose, I suggest you support Defenders of Wildlife. At least the local chapter of the Wildlife Society has proven much more dysfunctional in my experience, refusing to advocate for what is a mandated, routine update of California BLM’s sensitive wildlife list, whereas Defenders of Wildlife has an excellent track record of tangible wildlife conservation outcomes in California

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

June 5
#156 / Heartfelt

My Sunday papers on June 4, 2023, included an article from the San Jose Mercury News. I am linking the article, as it appeared elsewhere. Here’s the headline on that article I am talking about: “Taylor Swift delivers heartfelt Pride speech to fans, slams ‘harmful’ anti-LGBTQ legislation.”

In other and related news, yesterday’s edition of the San Francisco Chronicle had an “Insight” column, by Ash Zemenick, that also spoke to issues of diversity. Zemenick backed up, with biology, what Rabbi Elliot Kukla said in an article featured in one of my recent blog postings. Zemenick’s column was headlined, “Biological sex, no matter definition, is not binary.”

LIFE (in all of its manifestations) is not “binary.” It’s not “we” versus “them.” It’s not “You” versus “Me.” We are all in this together, despite all the differences. It is “diversity,” not “division,” that best explains our human situation. That’s true in “politics,” as in every other case. Take it from Hannah Arendt, the great political theorist, who spent most of her life explaining that the origins of totalitarianism spring from an effort to suppress this truth, and from our inability to recognize (and tolerate) and celebrate “plurality.”

Plurality and diversity, let it be said, do call for a celebration – and a celebration of our diversity is exactly what happened yesterday, in my hometown of Santa Cruz, California. Celebration was the name of the day!

I am pretty sure that the first official “Pride” celebration in Santa Cruz County was held in 1975. I remember voting, as a brand-new County Supervisor, to have our Board issue a proclamation recognizing “Gay Pride.” My recollection is that the vote was 3-2, so there was not, really, unanimous agreement.

It’s great to see some progress on the diversity/plurality front – and that truly is a “heartfelt” observation. I’m with Taylor Swift on that.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
June 5

ANIMAL MAGNETISM, PARTYING ON, AND CAPONE’S VAULT REVISITED

Many ears perked up when Fox News host, Geraldo Rivera, claimed to have a plan to prevent the Former Guy from seeking the presidency once again. Simple…all President Biden has to do is pardon him to dissuade him from his Revenge Term campaign! Of course, Joe has already laughed off that idea with no comment, and critics immediately jumped on Geraldo for even suggesting such a ludicrous plan. Not to be discouraged, Rivera later commented any pardon would come with a price ­- a pledge not to run again. More responses showed few being in favor of that aspect, especially MAGATs who still insist Trump did nothing wrong, but with many saying he did the crime(s), so do the time! What…and miss out on a great birthday party?

According to Politico, Trump’s latest campaign gambit is a promise to celebrate America’s 250th anniversary with a lengthy, spectacular birthday party…if he wins. Wow, who could pass on that? In a new video, Donny says on “day one” he would convene a task force to plan “an entire year of festivities across the nation,” beginning with the “Great American State Fair” on Iowa’s State Fairgrounds. He also suggested a “Patriot Games” competition for high school athletes, but beyond that he hasn’t much to suggest that would fill a whole year. Nevertheless, he says, “It’ll be something…it will be a record year,” lasting from Memorial Day 2025 to July 4, 2026. In all likelihood the planners and personnel hired to handle this extravaganza will be those insurrectionists who will have received his pardons, and they will see to it…demand…that you have a good time as they expound their fascist rhetoric, outright lying, and racist blather. Sounds like a lot of trouble…so let’s have a simple celebration for the occasion where the party favors will be bobbleheads portraying Trump in his orange jumpsuit, along with the red, white, and blue-frosted cake and ice cream.

The Former Orange Cheeto-In-Chief (or is that Cheat-o?) has several new opponents in the surging crowd of GOP candidates, who will probably kill each other off as happened in 2016, The Don seeing himself standing alone at the end. He has chosen, along with the media, Ron DeSantis as his primary challenger, tagging him several new monikers as he lashes out at the nerviness of this guy who he graced with his support to become Florida’s governor. Chris Christie will be joining the scrum from New Hampshire, just across the bridge from New Jersey…simply follow the diversion created by his leftover orange traffic cones to reach the town hall. An adviser for the former governor’s super PAC, ‘Tell It Like It Is,’ says, “…he will run a ‘non-traditional’ campaign that is highly focused on earned media, mixing it up with the news cycle and engaging Trump.” He will need to use his ‘no-nonsense, in-your-face, Jersey tough-guy schtick’ says Steve Schmidt, “…the one where he yells at people to sit down and shut up, and quash the sycophantic streak that had him smooching Mr. Trump’s backside for years.” Schmidt feels that in 2016, no Republicans went hard at Trump because no one took him seriously…this time they are too afraid of him, so Christie could make it interesting. “You come at the king, you best not miss,” but if everyone is too chicken – too strategic, how does that work?

Former VP Mike Pence has thrown his helmet into the ring finally, after riding into town at the helm of a Harley-Davidson motorcycle last week, surely catching the attention of Senators Hawley and Graham, and Tucker Carlson, all from the MAGAT Hang Mike Pence Squad. As satirist Andy Borowitz writes in The New Yorker, “…political insiders are questioning whether he has more to offer the nation than unbridled sexual magnetism. He hopes to convince voters to elect him leader of the free world, but risks being perceived as little more than a smoldering piece of beefcake. Sex sells, but Mike Pence might just be too smokin’ for the White House.” Pence has managed to unite both the right and the left on one thing…nobody wants to see him as president, but CNN is taking another dive by having him on a town hall ala the Trump fiasco. That presentation brought decent ratings when it aired, leaving such a stench, that afterward ratings plunged and the broadcaster has been unable to recoup its former lackluster position. Pence has always pushed his extreme agenda in both Congress and the Indiana statehouse, and after beating the drum for Trump’s four-year tenure, he campaigned for election deniers in the mid-terms last year. Now he’ll attempt to out-Trump The Don, seeking a national abortion ban, cutting Medicare ending Social Security as it exists currently. Now Trump is having a hissy over Mikey’s being absolved of any wrongdoing by DOJ after the discovery of classified materials in his Indiana home. So, may as well go home, Mikey…nobody likes you…take that job as a car lot dancer!

GOP presidential contender, Nikki Haley, got her moment in the sun on a CNN Town Hall last Sunday and among her various claims needing clarification or outright refutation, she falsely claimed crime is at an all-time high (not so, indicators show a decrease), and that all medications on drugstore shelves come from China. In this vein, since most masks during the COVID-19 siege were made in China, she claims the vaccines used during the pandemic originated there, reaping huge profits for that country after introducing the plague to the world? She advised opponent DeSantis to just pick up the phone and call Disney in his silly vendetta which has proven to be no advantage to him so far. Haley also underscored the importance of supporting Ukraine in its defense against Russia, and she continues supporting gun rights for our citizens who need to have protection for their families – especially with the terrible crime rate! Her comment that the “women’s issue of our time” is a continuing theme in her speeches – transgender kids in the locker rooms! This anti-LGBTQ rhetoric falls in line with other GOP lawmakers who have made this a key focus of the 2024 race. CNN moderator, Jake Tapper, pressed her on the issue, her tepid response being “the country needs to take care of these kids and be ‘humane’ in discussions about trans issues. I want everybody to live the way they want to live, but stop pushing your views on everybody else.” No mention about taking away reproductive rights and institutionalizing forced births as a possible “women’s issue of our time.” Step away from the podium, Ms. Haley!

No word from the DeSantis campaign, or from CNN, about a CNN town hall appearance after his Twittering with Elon campaign debut flamed out, from which he is still trying to recover. Since Chuck Todd has announced his departure from NBC’s ‘Meet the Press,’ CNN could surely use another non-confrontational moderator to assist in handling the expanding horde of GOP hopefuls ready to spout their drivel while avoiding significant follow up questions. Elon has probably approached RonDe about a second chance to pull them both up from the flames, but nobody’s going there! The New York Times reports that since Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter, advertising from U.S. customers has dropped 59% lower than sales in the same period last year – the five-week stretch from April 1 to early May. Current and former employees say the ad sales staff worry that advertisers have curtailed spending out of concern over hate speech and pornography increases on the social media platform, with cannabis and online gambling causing some anxiety. Musk’s sporadic changes to the site, as well as “inconsistent support from Twitter and concerns about the persistent presence of misleading and toxic content,” are having a detrimental effect.

Twitter post – Workers in Europe: “I will be taking the summer off because I need a little suntan.” Workers in America: “I will be using one of my three paid vacation days to undergo open heart surgery.”

The US Extreme Court said it will consider whether a California attorney has a free-speech right to trademark the phrase, “Trump Too Small,” a phrase that arose during the 2016 presidential primary. It originated with taunts between Trump and Marco Rubio following The Don’s dismissive name for the Senator as “Little Marco.” Rejected by the US Patent and Trademark Office because federal law disallows trademarks that usurp a person’s name without their consent, the Biden Administration is asking that this be upheld. Solicitor General Elizabeth B. Prelogar says attorney Elster is free to use the phrase however he wishes but the government can afford no protection that would accompany trademark registrations. Be the first on your block to get the t-shirts that will surely appear, but this fight isn’t over by any means.

Another fight that flared up seems to be waning, with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s position being safe for the time being. GOP conservatives were outraged with the deal McCarthy made with President Biden in negotiating the budget brouhaha, with the Freedom Caucus preparing to burn him at the stake, though criticism came from both sides of the aisle at the saga’s outcome. North Carolina’s Representative Dan Bishop told reporters that expelling McCarthy “has got to be done. I’m fed up with the lack of courage, the cowardice, and I intend to see to it that there is somebody who’s prepared to say what needs to be done.” Questioned about who could have negotiated a better deal, Bishop only said, “Nobody in the Republican conference could have done a worse job.” It should be suggested that perhaps next time, if there is a next time, Henry Kissinger could come forward with his new assistant, George Anthony Devolder Santos, both of whom were instrumental in the Paris Peace Talks to end the Vietnam War. How quickly we forget the successes past!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Fog”

“Derive happiness in oneself from a good day’s work, from illuminating the fog that surrounds us”.
~Henri Matisse

“It is not the clear-sighted who rule the world. Great achievements are accomplished in a blessed, warm fog”.                   
~Joseph Conrad

“It’s impossible to know what happens in the fog of war”.
~Hillary Clinton

“Most of us live in a fog. It’s like life is a movie we arrived to 20 minutes late. You know something important seems to be going on. But we can’t figure out the story. We don’t know what part we’re supposed to play or what the plot is.
~John Eldredge

...

Kim Luke, (AKA Madame Luke when she emcees the Sin Sisters Burlesque Show) just put up this video, and I found it worth sharing 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

May 31 – June 6, 2023

Highlights this week:

Bratton… UCSC’s newspaper, housing for people, movies. Greensite…revisits housing costs. Schendledecker…will be back next week. Steinbruner… fires, insurance and rebuilding, Santa Cruz cyclists, human trafficking here, county fairgrounds drama. Hayes…bluff diversity. Patton…Doom loop. Matlock…life is hard and other disasters on the hill we climb. EAGAN…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week: Kristen Wiig as Ann-Margret Quotes….”Drones”

...

DOWNTOWN DAVENPORT FIRE. March 21, 1953. This was almost 20 years before Bruce and Marcia McDougal of Big Creek Pottery completely re built the Cash Store…and of course before the newer Post Office was established. This was also a block or two up Highway One from the present location.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE May 29

CITY ON A HILL PRESS & PRESSURES. According to UCSC reporter Kyle Keller City on a Hill Press (the former printed weekly UCSC newspaper) only publishes a print edition twice per year lately. This latest rare print issue is stacked with campus and Hollywood issues, news and opinions. Check out the online edition at cityonahillpress.com. Read about the antisemitic acts and how the Jewish students want action and about the Hitler birthday celebration.  Learn about the English to Spanish classes being decreased. Then there’s the problems with the quality of their on campus drinking water. There’s problems too with the staffing of the campus buses. More issues center on the location of the chancellor’s house being on or off campus and why it matters. The closing article gives a fine overview of the Hollywood writers’ strike. Going to college today just ain’t the same as it was in the ’50’s.

Housing For People! This is from a mailer delivered on May 29. It states in no uncertain terms…NOT for Luxury Hotels, not Luxury Condos. Not to benefit wealthy, out of town developers.

Santa Cruz’s existing zoning can build 8,364 units so the City can reach the state requirement of 3736 units by 2031 without building enormous, ugly, tall towers! (Towers that are DOUBLE the height of the old Taco Bell, Pacific-Laurel-Front current building and EIGHT times larger with 1600 units!)

Build local workforce housing, not second homes for the wealthy. We want to increase affordable housing to 25% in new development in Santa Cruz. We demand for the right to vote on the height and size of buildings that are beyond current, reasonable limits.

No to enormous, high-rise, towers of 145 feet, 12 stories that will have little to no affordable housing!

We want diversity in housing, socio-economic equity, housing for local workers and a livable, beautifully-built city!

Help us create a livable city for ALL people-not just a few.

Join us this weekend to hand out fliers

June 3, Clock Tower, 4:00pm to 5:30pm, LBGQT+ Parade

June 4, 12:00pm to 4:00pm- Pride Parade and Festival

Join us!    Sign our Petition! :

HousingForPeopleSantaCruz@gmail.com

Text or call:  831-471-7822

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

LOU. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.1 IMDB).    Allison Janney goes into deep and very wet pursuit of her daughter who was kidnapped by the ex-husband/father. Through the Pacific Northwest territory and woods, rivers, storms she chases the two of them. He’s an ex-green beret and deals some surprise plot twists late in the film. Intriguing and mesmerizing, go for it.

YOU HURT MY FEELINGS. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (7.2 IMDB).   Absolutely wonderful and deep search into our own relationships and how we deal out and take in honesty. You’ll be reminded many times of similar scenes in your life and how you could have and should have dealt with those awkward and painful times.

MISSING. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). Watching this one is like never taking your eyes away from your cell phone or computer. It’s all a high tech search for a young girl’s mother who disappears. Too electronic, too Gmail, iPhone, and just plain high powered drivel.

BEING MARY TYLER MOORE. (HBO MAX) (8.3 IMDB). This documentary proves to us that Mary Tyler Moore not only changed television but changed the relationship between men and women. It reveals her rare and darker side and also places her among women who made giant strides in establishing a better relationship in the work place especially television.

THE SON. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.3 IMDB). Not exactly a sequel to The Father but it’s related. Hugh Jackman and Laura Dern deal with a son who has a psychological problem. He’s into acute depression and how do they help him? Anthony Hopkins appears briefly as the grandfather so we learn of the family history and it’s not pretty.  It’s about ex-partners and relationships and the acting is fine.

S.W.A.T. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB).   It’s all about South Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Police Departments problems. Centering on the racial Black issues and how tough it is to have Black cops chasing Black lawbreakers. It has lots of political and logical pressures that could have made this a very important movie, but it isn’t.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

MASTER GARDENER. (DEL MAR THEATRE). (6.5 IMDB). A complex, involved, and very symbolic plot about a gardener (Joel Edgerton) with a history who works for a wealthy, temperamental rich land owner (Sigourney Weaver) and has visions and deep memories of his past life. The Proud Boys, Trump, Hitler, and more threats to peace are on, and in the gardener’s memories and conscience and he relates to the plants in his care as solutions.

THE MURDERS AT THE WHITE HOUSE FARM. (HBO MAX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB).     I binged watched all six episodes of this tangled British mystery, it’s that suspenseful. In 1985 five family members were shot and died and it’s a true story. Who did it and why and even how it was done are surprising. It lags a bit by episode 4 but it’s well done and thoughtful go for it.

MRS. CHATTERJEE VS. NORWAY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB).  This is an unbelievably true story centering on the cruelty and evil was the government of Norway treats a young mother from India. They took her two children for 3 years of fighting based on some cultural differences between the two countries such as eating and family beliefs. Finally India’s government steps in and helps her. Fine viewing.

A MAN CALLED OTTO. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.5 IMDB).   Tom Hanks and his real life son Truman play the leads in this sad saga of an old man facing old age. Hanks is really only 67 years old and that adds to the mystery of why he’s so grumpy and almost commits suicide four times in this thin view of aging. The plot is variable but Hanks is always worth watching.

THE MOTHER. (NETFLIX MOVIE)  (5.5 IMDB).   Quite a cast of names such as Jennifer Lopez, Joseph Fiennes, Gael Garcia Bernal, and even Edie Falco are in it! Full of car chases, violence and tripe from 1000’s of cheap action flicks. It’s the FBI vs Jennifer who is trying to protect her daughter and the plot gets worse and worser!!

THE TERMINAL LIST. (AMAZON SERIES) (7.9 IMDB). Chris Pratt takes the part of a Navy Seal officer whose troops were ambushed during a secret mission in Syria. He suffers from shell shock/concussion and the search for the unknown enemy is a good one. The movie is believable, well-acted, nicely photographed and even mysterious. Go for it. (re-print from July 6, 2022)

HIGH DESERT. (APPLE TV SERIES) (6.5 IMDB). It’s billed as a comedy but watching Patricia Arquette attempting to be as funny as Jennifer Coolidge was in White Lotus is more depressing than laughable. Matt Dillon and Bernadette Peters try hard for any possible laughs and fail miserably. The plot has Patricia’s mother dying and how Patricia deals with it and tries to make a living in Yucca Valley first as a stripper, then she becomes a private investigator. No laughs, no plot, no fun.

WHITE HOUSE PLUMBERS. (HBO MAX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB).   This is rare, it’s listed as a drama, as a history, and a biography because it’s actually based on the true story of the Watergate break-ins as intended by President Richard Milhous Nixon. Woody Harrelson is E. Howard Hunt and Justin Theroux is G. Gordon Liddy. Domhall Gleeson is John Dean and they all do credible jobs as the would be thieves who try at least four separate times to get the contents of a desk drawer that President Nixon believes will expose Daniel Elsberg. It’s full of laughs, impossible happenings and another history lesson for political followers.

...
May 29

A FEW THOUGHTS ON HOUSING

As more and more familiar Santa Cruz businesses are ripped down to accommodate the new high rises (Front St. above) and because it’s Memorial Day, I thought a reprint of a piece I wrote on housing in 2015 might be worth a second look.

The winter storms of 2023 have replaced the drought as the weather topic of the day but most from 2015 still applies. If anything, the situation is more dire. The median housing price has risen substantially, UCSC has announced plans to add 9 thousand more students plus 3 thousand more staff and faculty, people living in tents in open space lands has become a way of life and a thorn in the side for the city, long time local low income workers (or at least the ones I know) have been forced to move further away and the state has taken over local land use control, forcing cities over the next 8 years to build unsustainable, unrealistic numbers of housing units. Meanwhile California is losing people to other states.

In the face of this crisis in housing affordability and impending transformation of the town, I think we need data. Do the new affordable housing units go to current low-income workers or not? If not, then let’s drop the jargon and false hopes. The square footage of most of the new high-rise units under construction suggests they are not for families and therefore not designed for most long-time low-income workers. They look suspiciously like off-campus dorm units. That’s why we need evidence and data, which the city won’t provide. Which demographic is getting the below-market rate units? That information is needed so we can assess what is working and what isn’t. That plus a louder voice telling the Regents we are full and cannot take more students. No more tiptoeing around this obvious cause of the current local crisis.

May, 2015

The high cost of housing in Santa Cruz is a frequent topic of conversation like the drought. Unlike the drought it probably will not have an ending date. Those of us who came here in the 1970’s can recall that rent wasn’t an issue. For around $120 a month you could rent a house. Those who could, bought a house for around $50,000. How did the same house which cost $50,000 then, come to be valued around $800,000 now? The usual answer is supply and demand. The population in the city in the 1970’s was around 30,000 residents and today it is double that number. To avoid any hint of smugness, it’s well to remember that the real old-timers will tell you that those of us who came here in the 1970’s were also responsible for the growth of Santa Cruz, and they are right.  But it did seem at that time the town was largely affordable. Today it is largely unaffordable except for those who bought their house long ago, or those currently with high incomes or investment properties.

According to supply and demand, the solution to the high cost of housing is always a call for more housing to be built, never that demand might be tempered by local hiring, less sales promotion of Santa Cruz and a smaller UCSC. Most assume that more housing equals more affordable housing. But does it?  There has been a lot of housing built in Santa Cruz over the past 40 years and with greatly increased density, yet rents and housing prices have increased ten-fold or more. The developers and the politicians misuse the term “affordable” for market rate housing (ADU’s for example) or tie affordable definitions to the ever-increasing Area Median Income and pretend that projects such as 1010 Pacific Avenue will be affordable for teachers, police and firefighters as promised, when in fact such projects soon become student housing. With an ever-expanding UCSC and 54 percent of students living off campus, easily outbidding families and workers for rental housing, there seems no relief in sight.

Beyond supply and demand, housing is a commodity, like health care, where speculation, trading and profit are the driving forces beneath the surface cost. Housing activists in the Bay area, which faces similar issues, conclude that it is not possible to build your way into affordability. Affordable housing can be achieved only through subsidized housing and rent control. Building more housing without such policies in place will not result in an affordable Santa Cruz but rather an affluent, overcrowded city, straining available resources. J

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

May 30

Joy will be back next week.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
May 29

REBUILDING FROM THE CZU FIRE AND EXPERIENCING FUNDING GAPS?

That’s what is on the glossy postcards in a plexiglass rack outside the County’ Permit Recovery Center.  What this really means is “Have you run out of insurance money and still don’t have a permit from the County to rebuild?”  Sadly, many CZU Fire property owners are facing this problem.

I called the number on the postcard to find out what help someone could expect.

The call was answered by Jennifer, representing Catholic Charities.  She said the County has an Unmet Needs Committee, and the Santa Cruz County Community Foundation provides grant money to help those eligible.  This was put in place in 2021, with over 100 cases funded to help CZU Fire Survivors find temporary housing that includes purchasing a Tiny Home on Wheels or a mobile home, and get money to cover rebuilding project costs, such as the expensive geologic studies that the County has glibly required.

To apply, one must present identification, and proof of land ownership, such as a deed.  The home that burned need not have been permitted…which should be of help for those in the Last Chance/Swanton Community.

Processing takes a few weeks.  The Unmet Needs Committee meets twice monthly with the Community Foundation to discuss the applications on an individual bases.  The Applicant never meets with the funders directly.  Jennifer said some cases are pending, but no one has been denied funding of some sort.  The funding is via a grant, with no expectation of repayment.

Please share this information with any one you know who is still struggling to rebuild from the CZU Fire.

CZUFireHelp@gmail.com
831-920-4764

Take a look at the 2022 Community Foundation financial report.  Do the figures on page 8 makes sense if the number for the Total Assets is the exact same as the number for Total Liabilities and Net Assets?

It has always bothered me that Community Foundation Board meetings are not open to the public, yet the Foundation acts to administer grants of public monies the County of Santa Cruz has received for projects.

WHAT CAN WE LEARN FROM THE PERMIT SONOMA CENTER?

Santa Cruz County Planning Dept. staff sometimes references actions taken by Sonoma County Planning Dept. on issues such as rebuilding after major fires, and what to do to help property owners who lost what the County considers to be non-conforming structures. Indeed, the County copied a Sonoma County model of applying a Class K pilot program for the Last Chance Community in an effort to streamline the 2020 CZU Fire rebuilding effort.  The problem is that it was only effective for two years…and the permitting process has been much too slow.  Now the people are running out of time against insurance payouts for expenses.

The other idea I think Santa Cruz County needs to borrow from Sonoma County is the use of Pallet Shelter Villages for rapid and inexpensive housing for the homeless

It takes a village transitioning out of homelessness at Los Guilicos Village

What can we learn from Sonoma County? What can we do to help the CZU Fire Survivors get some relief in getting their homes rebuilt?

Please listen in this Friday at 1pm on Santa Cruz Voice to hear what Mr. Tennis Wick, Director of Permit Sonoma.

Rebuilding mission top priority for county’s head planner

Santa Cruz Voice is a free online radio platform featuring local interest programs. Santa Cruz Voice

SANTA CRUZ CYCLISTS FOR CULTURAL EXCHANGE

On May 21, the Pajaro Valley was filled with bicyclists touring the country backroads in an event known as “Strawberry Fields Forever”.  Hosted by the Santa Cruz Cyclists for Cultural Exchange (CCE), the ride brought cyclists from all over the world here.  Founded in Santa Cruz in collaboration with cyclists from Russia, the mission of the CCE is:

“Our intention in the time we have together is to discover our differences, find our common ground, experience some of the language, customs, and traditions of the host country, and share our visions, hopes and dreams for cooperation and world peace.”

Each stop on the ride featured delicious food and great music, much of which was donated.  The Wildcat Mountain Ramblers played for free, even though they normally charge a lot.  As a Ham Radio communications volunteer, it was my job to help relay information vital to the smooth operation of the event.  The most memorable communication I heard involved translating the words “Compost”, “Recycling”, and “Trash” into Mandarin for one of the rest stops.  It was a beautiful day.

CCE Cyclists for Cultural Exchange(left to right): Walt Brown, Sag vehicle coordinator, Serguei Goupalov, cyclist from Ukrania, and Vita Pritchard, co-founder of CCE.

TRAFFICKING HERE IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY?

Sadly, human trafficking is on the rise, and it is here in Santa Cruz County.  Ms. Heather Goode, Co-Founder of Arukah Project, a non-profit based in Scotts Valley, is working hard to help victims who escape their bondage to restore their lives and rebuild their souls.

She recently explained in an interview last Friday on “Community Matters” that it is increasingly difficult for law enforcement to capture the human predators because much of the trafficking is done on the internet, and lures people of all ages and sexes into the web of trafficking.  The predators are always on the move, and may show up in a town when a large event is happening, and rent a house via Air BnB, then move on.

What can you do to help Arukah Project help the survivors?

Sign up to help June 10 at Natasha’s Run for Justice in Nisene Marks State Park, or just come to the event associated in Aptos Village Park.   Buy some delicious food from the food trucks, sip a beer in the Beer Garden, and enjoy the Allison Sharino Band.  All proceeds will benefit Arukah Project.

Natasha’s Run for Justice, June 10, is named in honor of a trafficking survivor who finally was able to achieve legal justice against her predator after 15 years of working through the legal system.  “Arukah” is a Hebrew word meaning “Restore, Renew and Rebuild”.

CURIOUS DRAMA CONTINUES AT SANTA CRUZ COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS

Things seem to be getting worse rather than better at the Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds.  The new Interim CEO, Mr. Ken Alstott, informed the experienced Fairgrounds Office and Maintenance Staff on his first day on the job that he “would let them know if he planned to keep them on the schedule.”  On the second day, he hired back Office Staff who had quit last fall in loyalty to former CEO Dave Kegebein, whom the Board fired last October after a State Performance Audit showed many serious financial wrongdoings.  On his third day, Mr. Alstott offered the experienced Staff a letter of recommendation.  The following week, the staff was taken off the work schedule so that Mr. Alstott could “bring in his own team.”

Of interest is the immediate cozy relationship Mr. Alstott established with the Fairgrounds Foundation, which is directed by Ms. Jeannie Kegebein.  Mr. Alstott gave her the key to the Fairgrounds Office, which allows full access to all financial records.

The Fairgrounds Foundation has commandeered all alcohol sales on the Fairgrounds premises, making substantial profits, but not reporting such to the IRS on their Form 990, and no longer allows their meetings to be open to the public.  Public Records Act requests for the payments the Foundation has supposedly made to the 14th DAA related to these alcohol sales have not been forthcoming with documents proving anything at all has been paid.

This could be because some of the 14th DAA Fairgrounds financial documents were intentionally destroyed in 2019 by then-CEO Dave Kegebein, the loyal Office staff who just got re-hired by Mr. Alstott, and three Fair Board members: Loretta Estrada and Jody Belgard (who resigned after the Board fired CEO Kegebein last October), and Stephanie Fontana, who remains on the Board to this day.

All of this wrongdoing, and more, was personally witnessed by the Office and Maintenance Staff that Mr. Alstott essentially fired upon taking the reins as Interim CEO.  They had heard former Dave Kegebein say ‘We can’t hand over documents if we don’t have them.” as he dumped boxes of financial records onto a bonfire.

Whistleblower protection?  The State Dept. of Food & Agriculture (CDFA) Director of Legal Services angrily refused to discuss the matter with me by telephone recently.  The CDFA Civil Rights Staff agreed with me that this is likely retaliation and may be racial discrimination as well, but the Staff must file certain forms and provide certain precise information. That is daunting when one is in shock and has suffered verbal abuse and intimidation by former CEO Kegebein, former Interim CEO Kelley Ferreira, and now Interim CEO Alstott, in addition to vicious verbal attacks by Fairgrounds Foundation members at recent Fair Board meetings.

Mr. Alstott insists there is a limited amount of work he can do to pull together cogent financial reports for the Board because he only works part-time, commuting from the state of Tennessee.  Isn’t it odd that CDFA staff would enlist the help of someone who lives in one of the states California Governor Newsom deems as “unfriendly” and has banned any state employee from travel there to do state business?  Don’t forget that it was one of the reasons Dave Kegebein got fired…traveling to Texas, another “unfriendly state” to do Fair business. The 14th DAA is paying Mr. Alstott $70/hour for his travel time.  He is also collecting CalPERS benefits, being a former Fairgrounds CEO retiree and now an annuitant.

Last week, Mr.  Pruger, the President of the Fair Board, announced that three people had applied for the job of full-time CEO.  He was extremely irritable with some members of the public who spoke to question what is happening, but was all smiles and gave extra time for members of the Fairgrounds Foundation who spoke.  When I questioned why none of my letters to the Board were included in the past two months of Board agendas, Mr. Alstott stated that the public has to specifically ask in correspondence that we want it included in the Board packets for public access.    Hmmmm… The letter he chose to include in the May 23 packet did not have such a request included.  Hmmmm…..

The Fair Board has just scheduled a Special Meeting for June 7, held only virtually at 7pm, for another Closed Session discussion of selecting a fulltime CEO.  They will also discuss the lawsuit now filed against the Fairgrounds and the Foundation Director Jeannie Kegebein, and former CEO Dave Kegebein, largely relating to the murky financial problems of alcohol profits and lack of payments.

Who will it be?  My bet is that the new CEO will be a friend of the Kegebein’s, and a favorite of the Fairgrounds Foundation. Board of Directors Agenda Items

WHERE ARE THE DARK SKIES?

As a child growing up in the Eastern Oregon desert, one of the wonderful things I enjoyed was a completely dark sky at night that was filled with brilliant stars.  Our family now looks forward to that treat when we camp in the Sierra.  But the dark night skies filled with glittering stars and planets may be something we only remember, according to the article a friend sent me: Stars could be invisible within 20 years as light pollution brightens night skies

I have recently noticed that the LED parking lot lights at the Aptos Post Office are glaringly bright, meant to discourage illegal campers at night.  More and more, I see rural neighbors have strung bright lights over driveways and backyards, as if the dark night is something to stamp out.

Furthermore, when one can see the sky, it seems to be filled with more and more satellites, zooming around the Earth for a constant connection of internet and surveillance.

What do you think we can do to preserve the lovely dark nighttime skies for future generations to enjoy and the wildlife to use for navigation?  Please let me know your thoughts.

A NEW BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF OUT-OF-THE-BOX ART IN APTOS VILLAGE

Thanks to well-known local artist Ms. Ann Thiermann, Aptos Village will have a lovely mini-mural on what would otherwise be a drab metal telecomm box at the Trout Gulch Road and Soquel Drive intersection.  It is part of the Santa Cruz County Arts Commission’s “Out of the Box” murals on telecommunications and utility boxes in our Community.

Arts Commission

Ann has painted other such boxes nearby at the Rancho del Mar Shopping Center that really help beautify the area.  Many thanks to Ann Thiermann for her lovely work.

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  REVIEW A DRAFT EIR AND SEND IN YOUR COMMENTS.  JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
May 29

BLUFF DIVERSITY

A walk on the ocean bluff is invigorating, so close to many amazing natural phenomena, but these areas see too little ecological protection. Ecotones- the area between two habitats- are well known to host the most species. Birders understand the delight in exploring the edge of riparian or other forest habitats to encounter the most species. Likewise, humans are drawn to the edge of the ocean, and if they are aware of the life around them they have the opportunity to see layers upon layers of life.

Picture the many individuals and groups of people enjoying West cliff drive, strolling the bluffs at Wilder Ranch, gathering at the cliff edge across from Davenport, and driving Big Sur’s Coast Highway. Millions of people a year along the edge of the Pacific Ocean are standing, walking, or driving on a biologically precious part of our landscape.

Ocean, beaches, bluffs, and more

In the span of very few yards, many things come together. The ocean dynamically intersects with the beach, which in turn interdigitates with bluffs, creeks, rivers, and lagoons. At each of those intersection sites, biological life explodes with diversity. The ocean’s movement back and forth at the edge of the land is an engine of life, mixing air with water, stirring saltwater with fresh, mixing together and grinding up life, redistributing nutrients and lying bare new areas for colonization by new life. The saltwater spray soaks sand dunes and nearby soil, coating nearby leaves, and limiting what life can thrive to those species which can take the salt, a harsh drying mineral. As you back away from the bluff and beach, each yard gets less salty, less windy, and less harsh. The plants at the bluff edge have evolved to be nearly flat but just a bit back the same species is short, but upright. Way away from the coast, a species that was ½” tall at the bluffs is 5′ tall in the understory of an oak forest. Seeds grown from each population of those plants will produce plants that are similarly flat, short, or tall. The forces of the ocean drive individual species’ genetic diversity while forming more macro habitat diversity.

A windy north-facing dune face has short mostly perennial vegetation with an understory of moss and ferns to remind us of the cool, sunless moisture. A south-facing dune slope has taller, more drought resistant plants – more flowers, many annual plants. The slightest depressions in dunes and adjacent grass- and shrub-lands are moister and less windy; the slightest elevation gets more wind and is drier. A 6″ elevation difference profoundly influences what plants grow where on the flat terraces behind the windswept bluffs. Those differences have been levelled off in farm fields focused on agricultural production as well as in developed urban areas. Unfortunately, this precious ocean interface has been largely obliterated by humans.

Impacts

Trampling at the ocean-beach interface, trails through the dunes and bluffs, roads and trails as close as possible to the bluffs, housing with nearby ocean views, agriculture where houses have yet to be built. All those well-known human activities have obliterated this biotically rich interface.

Walking and Thinking

Whenever anyone visits me from far away, the ocean-beach-bluff interface is where we want to go. There are legions of humans that rarely get to experience the beauty of our beaches or the wonder of our bluffs. As we hike bluff trails, I see a wide swath of bare ground underfoot, right where I would otherwise look for the most interesting plant life. On the inland edge of the trail, where the trampling peters out, less frequent foot traffic maintains a level of disturbance that fosters interesting plant diversity. Here I find 5 species of showy red, purple, and yellow native clovers, unusual bright white popcorn flowers, fluffy lavender annual paintbrush, dainty native dandelions, and many more species. Further from the trail still, where few ever tread, the plant diversity plummets: a few tall shrubs or a sea of a handful of grass species. This is a good place to see the effects of varying disturbance regimes and to dream of what is best for species conservation.

On the oceanward side of the trail, too perilous for most people to step, there is a different array of native diversity. Yellow-orange fiddleneck flowers twine with seaside daisy, large-leaved strawberry plants, mat-forming perennial lupines, flat-growing meadow barley and brome grass, and the white-sappy-sticky buds of bright yellow flowering gumweed. In that narrow strip, I regularly count 25 showy native plant species in a hundred feet of walking. Soon, those plants will have nowhere to go, as the ocean chisels the soil from under them and the trampling prevents them from migrating inland.

The Wide, Flat First Terrace

Outside of the trail edge and out into the few ‘pristine’ native places near the coast, unmanaged prairies are a sea of weeds. On a tour with conservationists recently, I sensed surprise that such places needed management attention. A subsequent hike across the old growth (untilled) prairie north of Año Nuevo illustrated how some types of prescribed burns can help some native plant species proliferate- there were huge patches of tiny blue native iris, grand displays of white native hyacinth, and other wildflowers all integrated into a complex tapestry of native grasses, sedges, and rushes. Bumblebees, long-horned bees, and a wealth of native pollinators bounced between flowers. That’s what the west side Santa Cruz and the expansive brussels sprout fields used to look like.

Interface Restoration

As much as we ‘know’ about the terrible impacts to the ocean-beach-bluff interface, we are doing little to correct the situation. We know that sea level rise is accelerating with climate change. We understand that armoring (sea walls, tide gates, levees, and the like) are not viable solutions to the sea level rise crisis. Public parks managers are aware that recreational use of the ocean interface zone poses grave threats to increasingly endangered wildlife and plants. Conservationists all agree that the natural, intact habitats on California’s first ocean terrace are critically imperiled, having been almost entirely eradicated by development. This knowledge provides a rich opportunity for restoration solutions, if only there was any kind of leadership.

As our society retreats from sea level rise, “green infrastructure” IS the solution. Ecological restoration of the ocean-beach-bluff zone is the only sustainable way to address accelerating sea level rise. The beautiful salt and wind resistant native plant species found in the few remaining natural areas of the bluffs and beaches provide the template for the restoration we need. However, hikers and bikers are literally trampling those templates to death across the entire length of California’s coast. The seeds of plants adapted to this critical habitat are disappearing under foot and tire. Tragically, the California Coastal Commission, which would be the natural lead in protecting these few remaining areas, is increasingly providing pressure to increase visitor use and the consequent negative impacts that recreational access brings.

In a parallel situation, the brackish water species that inhabit the far reaches of our lagoons and estuaries are the same ones that we will rely on to keep the salty ocean water from flooding into every low-lying place along the coast. Those backwaters have largely been destroyed: Highway 1 on the North Coast obliterated the back portions of every lagoon – Laguna and Lidell Creeks, San Vicente Creek, and many others. Agriculture cuts deep into these low-lying brackish areas, destroying soils and habitats of the back of the Elkhorn, Tembladero, and Moro Cojo Sloughs. We need to learn how to restore the plants and plant communities in those systems, which are essential at moderating the combination of outgoing freshwater flooding and incoming tidal surge waters, which would otherwise erode massive new channels, carrying sea level rise further inland into built areas and across low-lying agricultural fields.

Stop the Stomp

You can mainly address much of what I mention above through voting for candidates that talk about facilitating “managed retreat” and “green infrastructure” solutions to sea level rise. But, you can also help by pressuring managers to better address recreational use of the beaches and bluffs. If you live in Santa Cruz, there are active discussions about the bluff erosion along West Cliff: are there any politicians talking about long term solutions, managed retreat, and green infrastructure…or, are they just passing the inevitable exorbitant costs to future generations? Your vote matters there or wherever you live- these issues are pervasive.

If you visit parks along the coast, notice how they are managed at the precious ocean-beach-bluff interface. In the last month, I have encountered two people that have reported problems to parks managers. In one case, parks maintenance personnel bulldozed and added gravel to an ocean-side trail, obliterating wetlands occupied by photo documented endangered California red-legged frogs. In another case, an individual reported parks maintenance personnel driving through saturated soils, degrading endangered coastal prairie habitat and associated wetlands. We need to pressure managers to move ocean-side bluff trails away from the bluffs to allow for the expansion and migration of coastal bluff vegetation. Agricultural fields on parkland need likewise to retreat. Oceanside trails should never be graveled, paved, or otherwise hardened. If you care about these things, let’s make some noise! It is high time that State, County, and City Parks create restoration plans for this critical life zone, and those plans should work out solutions to recreational impacts that prioritize conservation.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

May 20

#140 / Doom Loop

Lots of people seem to be thinking that we are caught inside a “doom loop,” or maybe several different kinds of doom loops! An explanation of what it means to be caught in a “doom loop” can be provided as follows: Things are bad, and are getting worse. Everything bad that happens makes some other bad things happen, so the doom gets darker, and the doom gets deeper, and catastrophe ultimately ensues.

A “doom loop” signifies that a possible catastrophe will become an inevitable catastrophe. Things are bad. We’re in a “doom loop,” and doom results. You get the picture! That “doom loop” thinking appears to be going around.

The diagram above shows how the Euro-zone is heading towards an economic disaster. The discussion that accompanies this “doom loop” diagram references an article in The Economist.

To provide another example, the San Francisco Chronicle has been speculating about the future of the City’s downtown. That future is being described in the following terms: “Can San Francisco dodge a ‘doom loop’?

The San Jose Mercury News has the same concern, with its article titled, “Bay Area exodus: Wealthy resident departures worsen ‘doom loop’ fears.”

New York Times columnist David Brooks is also worried by the “doom loop” phenomenon: “My greatest fear,” he says, “is that we’ve entered a distrust doom loop: People are so untrusting of their institutions and their neighbors that they are unwilling to reach out, to actively renew their communities and their country, and so the dysfunction will continue, and the distrust will increase, and so on and so on.”

Vox, an online magazine, has written about the future of public transportation, and Vox is at least trying to think positively, and to find some way out – some way to escape the “doom loop” they see coming. A recent article is titled, “How to save America’s public transit systems from a doom spiral.”

In the Silicon Valley, where you might expect to hear applause when a major new technology is created, people are not, apparently, all that happy about the deployment of the newest A.I. chatbots. “Catastrophic thinking” seems to be prevailing, with all the characteristics of a “doom loop.” At least, that is what David Wallace-Wells is reporting. Wallace-Wells is the author of The Uninhabitable Earth, and it’s pretty easy to discern a characteristic set of “doom loop” circumstances in his report on global warming.

oooOOOooo

I am quite familiar with the “doom loop” phenomenon – and also with its antidote. I still vividly remember my first exposure to a discussion that opened my eyes to the phenomenon known as “circular and cumulative causation.” I found out about it when I was an undergraduate student, at Stanford University. More or less by chance, I picked up a slim little book by a Swedish economist, Gunnar Myrdal – who was, by the way, a winner of the Nobel Prize in Economics. The title of the book I am talking about is Economic Theory And Under-Developed Regions. That book was published in 1957, and I believe it is now out of print. I value the copy I have! Myrdal makes clear that the phenomenon he describes can operate in both directions. His book was about how to stimulate economic development in underdeveloped regions. His prescription was just like a “doom loop,” but moving in the opposite, and positive, direction. Start doing good things! Everything good that happens means more good things can and will happen, and….. Voilà!

My understanding of reality postulates that we live, most immediately, in a “human world,” and that this human world is created by our own actions. Nothing is inevitable in the world we create. “Doom,” specifically, is not inevitable. It is quite possible that “doom” may eventuate, but “doom loops” are not self-generating or self-sustaining. We can observe what has happened in the past, and what is happening now (and we may well be able to take measurements within a real, and growing, “doom loop,” and see that such a “doom loop” is in progress). However, the continued progress of the “doom loops” we discern is not preordained. Description is not destiny. The reality we create – the reality that eventually precipitates itself from our past and current actions – will ultimately depend on what we do, and the actions we take. “Possibility” (including both good and bad possibilities) is the commanding category for the world in which we most immediately live. “Inevitability” is not!

Because that is true, and because the principle of circular and cumulative causation can operate in both directions, our future is never “predictable.” Something new and revolutionary may occur, and that can break any “doom loop” whose progress we may be observing.

When we start hearing about all sorts of “doom loops” (as we currently are), we need to begin charting new set of processes that can change the direction of the processes now underway – the ones taking us towards “doom.”

Because we tend to see ourselves, mostly, as “observers,” as opposed to seeing ourselves as “actors,” the “doom loops” that we construct in our minds, based on the accurate observations we make, seem to take on the quality of reality itself.

However, this mistakes our actual situation. The processes that result in the realities we inhabit are always “loops,” because the realities we inhabit are all the product of some type of circular and cumulative causation. So, let’s not be fooled. The “doom loops” we observe are not “inevitabilities.” They may seem like it, but that’s not an accurate perception of where we really are. “Observers,” when that is all they do, find themselves trapped in the “loops” they see around them, whether those “loops” are doom-tinged or benign. Forget the “doom loops,” at least insofar as you are tempted to think them as defining some sort of inevitable reality that is coming for us.

Action is the antidote.

Let’s do what we need to do to start those “loops” turning in a positive direction. “Possibility,” not “inevitability” is the nature of the reality we actually inhabit. Mesmerized by our “greatest fear,” to use the words of David Brooks, we may forget, as we watch those “doom loops” spiral, that we can take an action that will change the world.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
May 29

LIFE IS HARD AND OTHER DESASTERS ON THE HILL WE CLIMB

Life is hard as we all know, and it has been really hard for the extreme members of the US Extreme Court of late. Poor welfare queen Clarence Thomas has been pounded for weeks about his acceptance of largesse by his benefactor Harlan Crow, who incidentally, is terribly fond of mama Thomas’ home cooking…worth millions. Not to mention associate-justice-pro-tem and co-conspirator Ginni Thomas who simply smiles as her coffers are filled quietly, out of sight from the IRS and other prying eyes. But poor Chief Justice Roberts is in such torment over what he described in a speech to the American Law Institute as his most difficult career decision to date – in eighteen years of jurisprudence on the high court! The institute, established in 1923 to promote the simplification and clarification of US common law, is a research and advocacy group for judges, lawyers and legal scholars as it seeks to interpret our changing social needs. We can only imagine that the attendees were all ears, grasping the edges of their seats as they awaited Roberts’ revelation regarding his tough decision. We can also imagine the air hissing out of the cracks and crevices of the room as he voiced his pious, preachy, priggish pangs of anguish over…having to erect fences and barricades around the court building following the invalidation of Roe v Wade! And, how about the Greek Chorus of Alito, GorsuchKavanaugh, Barrett, and Thomas whining away behind the curtain giving him sustenance to carry on with his, and their, victimhood, lamenting the disregard for their entitlement of respect? The egotistical whining, the pompous, high and mighty conceit reminds us of what President Harry Truman called ‘Potomac Fever,’ which he defined as a “prevalent, ludicrous Washington disease characterized by a swelling of the head to abnormal proportions.”

As Lawrence O’Donnell on MSNBC’s The Last Word, and Bocha Blue writing in The Palmer Report were quick to point out, the court certainly has no concern over how many women have died or have fallen into the cracks of an uncaring medical system since their betrayal in reversing Roe. Both critics brought up the case of the ten year-old Ohio rape victim who had to cross state lines into Indiana for an abortion because medical professionals in her state were fearful of the government’s wrath had they accommodated her. Carrying to term a rapists baby is one thing, but for a pre-teen? This is so messed up! Indiana obstetrician-gynecologist Caitlin Bernard was eventually reprimanded and fined $3000 for publicly speaking about the case and violating the patient’s privacy, though she had not provided any identifying details and had complied with all laws. Volumes of women’s appalling horror stories could already be written in the short time since the court’s disastrous decision, and it can’t get any better with this whiny bunch of unsupervised, unfettered lifers who Truman would have hated. A Texas woman during a miscarriage developed sepsis, but was still unable to get medical attention; and, a miscarrying woman in Oklahoma was told to “go sit in the parking lot until you bleed out,” before help would be available. A good start for the Extremes lies in coming up with a code of conduct, written in conjunction with the two other branches of government…seems the justices can only hold a pen to endorse checks, or their lame decisions. With this hard-hearted bunch who don’t grasp the real world, they should heed the advice of one who said, “Don’t bother walking a mile in my shoes. That would be boring. Spend thirty-seconds inside my head. That should freak you right out!”

Florida’s Governor Ron DeSantis finally pulled the trigger in announcing his GOP presidential bid, detonating a flurry of laughter on both sides of the political aisle as his Twitter Spaces feed with Elon Musk fell apart with technical glitches…designated a ‘DeSaster‘ by the multitudes. In trying to out-Trump Trump, he is succeeding in that everything he touches turns to pyrite. Conspiracy theorist and goofball of note, Musk, was the designated conversationalist, with moderator David Sacks, a Sean Spicer wannabe, leading the charge to persuade the masses in this first-of-its-kind campaign intro to join this rambling culture warrior in his sinking crusade. Mickey, Minnie and Goofy are yipping it up on the new ‘It’s A Small-Minded World Ride,’ with certainty. And, Musk may be having second thoughts about rehiring all the competent Twitter personnel he fired…umm, not a chance…it was simply the chocolate pudding-coated control board, hardly a failed rocket launch! Steve Schmidt writes in his ‘The Warning’ blog, that in listening to this drivel, “I’ll be honest, my mind wandered during the event, particularly as DeSantis read his stump speech sitting next to Musk and Sacks in Twitter headquarters. I was overwhelmed by an intrusive thought that placed me in the middle of the ocean on a boat with these three, surrounded by hungry sharks. It was an easy choice. I jumped in.” Steve goes on to say, “What the debacle demonstrated is that Ron DeSantis isn’t a contender, but rather a clown. His $200 million in campaign cash isn’t enough to overcome his narrative of pugilistic incompetence, weirdness and disdain for people. Ron DeSantis has imploded. It’s already over. By the way, has anyone seen these new photos of the Titanic?”

Donald Trump, Jr. launched his attack on DeSantis, in defense of his father, calling the Florida governor “nasally and effeminate” during his Twitter blast with Musk. However, it took a bad turn for the Former Guy when Junior got the names mixed up and misread the script by saying, “Trump has the personality of a mortician, and the energy that makes Jeb Bush look like an Olympian.” Hee-hee!

Governor Ron DeSantis‘runnin’ up that road, runnin’ up that hill’ toward a presidential bid, gets uglier everyday as he attempts to “Make America Florida.” As a result of his book-bashing fascism, the poem written by Amanda Gorman for President Biden’s 2021 inauguration, “The Hill We Climb,” was removed from the elementary section of a Miami-Dade public school and placed in the middle school section after a one-person complaint and a subsequent school review. The complaint reads, “It is not educational and have [sic] indirectly hate messages, and the poem could cause confusion and indoctrinate students.” Complainer Daily Salinas, a Cuban whose first language is Spanish, later issued a bizarre apology for antisemitic Facebook posts, assuring us that she “loves the Jewish community” and watches an Israeli series on Netflix. She has also challenged books on Black and Cuban history, which the school relocated for older student access. She had to be removed from a school board meeting for protesting approved sex education books. Oh, and Salinas has been photographed at several Proud Boys rallies, in addition to having ties to an extremist Christian group…the list goes on for just a simple, ordinary citizen, nothing to see here. The first-ever Youth Poet Laureate, Gorman, 22 years old when she read her composition, was partly inspired by the J6 Insurrection, and said she was “gutted” to discover this censorship. “I wrote “The Hill We Climb” so that all young people could see themselves in a historical moment. Ever since, I’ve received countless letters and videos from children inspired to write their own poems,” she wrote. “Robbing children of the chance to find their voices in literature is a violation of their right to free thought and free speech.”

Following his campaign launch flame-out, DeSantis reported a “record $8.2 million fundraising windfall in the first 24 hours” after his announcement…the truth being that his people held a separate fundraising event after the Twitter debacle. That money is included within the $8.2M, so who knows how much was actually raised by each function…only DeRon knows! But, not record-setting…just more GOP/DeSantis fakery. Bill Palmer in his ‘Palmer Report’ says, “He spent all of 2021 and 2022 sitting on the sidelines and letting the mainstream media build him up as some super-savvy, super-disciplined, more charismatic and less prickly version of Donald Trump. Then he finally hit the national stage over the past couple of months, and he’s turned out to be an erratic dimwit whose personality ranges from nonexistent to just plain weird.” Palmer believes the media will continue to milk DeSantis for their own ratings, after all, it’s a cash cow for them. If they allow him to become a punchline now, it’s all over for him, so they will prop him up for now and get ratings later if it comes to punching him in the face. Ronno’s poll numbers have now cratered to half of the original numbers from two months ago, so Palmer thinks he is toast unless he can figure out how to discard the Ron DeSantis persona.

Donald Trump and RonDe, being populist politicians, are bullies by nature, but DeSantis is pretty much alone as a visibly relentless, gutless example. He is proud of his acts of far-right cruelty all for show to his followers…he really doesn’t care about any of it, and fears talking about his ‘accomplishments’ before audiences who might care. He won’t share his gutless use of the powers he holds such as attacking LGBTQ+ children, or their teachers, professors, parents who speak out against him, yet he panders to his base with his fake bravery. DeSantis could take some advice from Senators Rubio and Cruz who learned cowardice in their runs for the presidency after meeting up with a name-calling, blundering blowhard in 2016, but he’s simply a coward, evidently comfortable in running from his own shadow.

The NAACP has issued a travel advisory against traveling to Florida as a response to policies initiated by DeSantis that are discriminatory and anti-Black. Most of these policies have received much press coverage, but one of the most dastardly, underhanded plans is the enticement to relocate to Florida, directed toward cops who have histories of excessive violence, and have been cast aside by other jurisdictions. Since initiation of this program, several cops have been arrested for criminality –kidnapping and murder – not to mention their trademark use of excessive violence. DeSantis’ recently signed law, “License to Discriminate,” supposedly to allow healthcare providers and insurers to deny patient care on the basis of religious, moral or ethical beliefs. But who’s to say that it doesn’t also include injuries suffered in an accident if one is ‘driving while Black?’

Many are saying that Casey DeSantis is the driving force behind her husband’s campaign, an indomitable woman some have designated as ‘Lady Macbeth.’ She is said to be more ambitious than Ron, and has a taste for vengeance, never forgetting a slight. A former journalist, she is a breast cancer survivor, who it is said makes her husband more antisocial when she is present, being a standout when they are together on stage. But no matter what she does or how she comes across, Bocha Blue says, “She will never be able to change Ron from a charmless, miserable man into a charismatic candidate.”

In the midst of all this craziness, we can take some comfort as the Justice Department is wrapping up some significant prosecutions and handing out sentences to J6 insurrectionists, most notably, that of Oath Keeper Stewart Rhodes. He was found guilty in November and was handed an 18-year term, the longest prison sentence for a Capitol riot leader to date. Rhodes wasn’t actually in DC at that time, but was found to be instrumental in planning and assembling the mob responsible for that day’s destruction, and obstruction of Congress‘ duties. Two other Oath Keepers received sentences of eight years and six months, and four years as a jury acquitted them of the seditious conspiracy charges.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Drones”

“Drones can be useful tools, and I am all about useful tools. One of my mottos is ‘the right tool for the right job”.’      
~Martha Stewart

“Drones overall will be more impactful than I think people recognize, in positive ways to help society”.
~Bill Gates

“Drones are just another weapon, and they turn out to be a very effective weapon that puts no American troops at risk, and I don’t see why we shouldn’t use them against identified enemy targets”.
~Colin Powell

“Two days after the Boston marathon bombings, there was a drone strike in Yemen attacking a peaceful village, which killed a target who could very easily have been apprehended. But, of course, it is just easier to terrorise people. The drones are a terrorist weapon; they not only kill targets but also terrorise other people”.
~Noam Chomsky

...

I know we did some Ann-Margret a little while back. Well, I just read an interview with her where she said that Kristen Wiig did a perfect impersonation of her on SNL. Watch the video; I think you’ll agree…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

May 24 – 30, 2023

Highlights this week:

BRATTON…Kaiser Permanente’s decision, Ed Porter memory, movies. GREENSITE…on losing the sense of place that is Santa Cruz.  SCHENDLEDECKER…May updates, oversized vehicles. STEINBRUNER…Kaiser Permanente’s Taj Mahal doomed, housing elements, Soquel Creek water district issues, Memorial Day. HAYES…on a brief vacation. PATTON…Ron DeSantis and punishment. MATLOCK…avoid clichés like the plague. EAGAN…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week. QUOTES…”Memorial Day”

...

KING AND MISSION STREET June 7, 1957.  This was the Grand Opening of Carl’s Flying A Gas Station…complete with clown. It’s now the site of Five Gables Dentistry.                                                     

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE May 22

KAISER’S RETREAT. Kaiser announced its change of intentions about opening a new facility next to Highway One. Rick Longinotti co-chair of Campaign For Sensible Transportation released an announcement this am. that covers the entire news. I’m re-printing it here with a link to the Campaign campaignforsustainabletransportation.org so hopefully you’ll become involved with all the issues and forward moves they maintain.

“The Sentinel reports that Kaiser pulled out of its plan to build a large office building and 730 space parking garage on the frontage road on the ocean side of Hwy 1 near Chanticleer Ave. Kaiser’s explanation is that growth of other facilities in Watsonville, Scotts Valley and Santa Cruz make the project unnecessary. Maybe there’s another reason. That’s Henry Kaiser in the above photo driving a bus that Kaiser built. Maybe Henry’s ghost was perturbed that the Kaiser facility was proposed over a mile from the nearest bus stop. Evidently Kaiser expected all its patients and workers to arrive by car. (Hence the reason for building a parking garage that would be 50% larger than the next largest garage in the County.)

I’d like to think that the Campaign for Sustainable Transportation had something to do with Kaiser finding a different path forward. Along with the Sierra Club we wrote comments on the Draft EIR for this project, pointing out that Kaiser could locate on a large vacant lot at the corner of Soquel Dr. and Thurber Lane, in the General Plan’s Medical District, on a transit corridor. The final EIR was supposed to be published in summer of 2022. Maybe the EIR team couldn’t figure out how to spin the proposed Kaiser location as environmentally preferred. Maybe our organization’s successful lawsuit against Caltrans let Kaiser know we could hold them accountable. Or maybe Kaiser realized that promoting auto dependency doesn’t help people thrive.
Whatever the reason, let’s celebrate that our community has another chance to follow planned new development where transit is frequent (as called for in the General Plan).

CHRIS KROHN WRITES ABOUT ED PORTER.

May 8

Ed Porter: Teacher, Mentor, and Policy-maker

Remember Why You Live in Santa Cruz


Santa Cruz lost one of its most selfless, reliable, and outspoken public servants in the early morning hours of April 28th. Former City Councilmember, Santa Cruz High teacher, and Lockheed engineer, Ed Porter, died from a series of medical complications after suffering a fall in his home. He was 78 years old. Porter lived for more than 40 years in a stucco house at the end of Lighthouse Avenue adjacent to one of the open-space trophies of Santa Cruz’s epic progressive era, Lighthouse Field. He surrounded his home with lots of trees– pines and live oaks—because he believed in maintaining a vibrant urban forest. After taking early retirement from Lockheed Missile and Space Division as a senior engineer, he taught about computers at Santa Cruz High from 1979-2011. Ed was an environmentalist, humanitarian, mentor, and public policy wonk who was involved in some of the most ambitious and legendary Santa Cruz local political issues, the ones that would shape this community’s progressive agenda, and legacy, for years to come.

Ed Porter was elected to the Santa Cruz city council at the beginning of the millennium and became embroiled in some of this community’s most contentious issues like mobile home rent control, the fight for a living wage, and the struggle to save the Homeless Garden Project. While a councilmember, Porter delivered key votes in saving the Del Mar Theater on Pacific Ave. and to transform Salz Tannery into an arts and affordable housing complex. It was his council votes too that brought home a skate park, senior housing on Gualt Street, increased homeless services funding, and the Beach Street 2-way bike lane. Of course, his earlier neighborhood activist efforts were key in the development of Lighthouse Field Park.

During his second run for council in 2004 he edged out both former councilmembers Mark Primack and Scott Kennedy and won the fourth council seat in that election. Porter often credited his winning margin to his former S.C. High students who were able to survive the tight housing market. Ed was never one to shy away from a just political fight. In 2005, for example, Ed went head-to-head with then-Mayor, Mike Rotkin, in dueling opinion pieces in the fight over what the Dream Inn would become. Among Ed’s numerous reasons for opposing this former massive hotel project proposal was the impact on the next door residents of Clearview Court mobile home park, the “inadequate traffic plan,” and most significantly, “the project did not conform to our General Plan…” And guess what? Porter prevailed in helping protect our community’s beach front from a 6-level parking garage and convention hotel!

Edward Benson Porter, Jr., was born in Detroit, Michigan on September 4, 1944. He attended the University of Detroit High School and graduated from the Detroit Electronics Institute of Technology with a degree in electronics. Porter left Michigan when he was 21 and headed for Sunnyvale. He moved to Santa Cruz in 1974.  His father, Edward Benson Porter, Sr. (1910-1985) was born in Idaho and his mother, Winifred Mary Heinrich Porter (1917-2011) was a Detroiter. Ed was a Santa Cruz resident for almost 50 years, and he once wrote, “Living along the Pacific Ocean was my dream since I was six years old!” He often said that Country Joe McDonald’s song, “Paradise With an Ocean View,” was about him living in Surf City. Porter is survived by two loving sisters, Dona M. Porter of Chicago, Illinois and Patricia Porter of Portland, Oregon, ten cousins, and more than 30 local Santa Cruz friends who sat next to his bedside during his final days.

Right up until the time of death, Ed was a fierce critic of the market-rate high-rise housing that has often left behind middle-class locals and our community’s homeless. He was a consistent voice for affordable housing, alternative transportation, and environmental protection. Porter was a member of the People’s Democratic Club, an ardent advocate for Personal Rapid Transit, an avid photographer, and often could be seen on weekends at the Watsonville airport, either teaching flying or piloting his own Cessna 150 high above the community he loved. Involved until the end in local political campaigns, Ed supported and campaigned for winning candidates, Councilmember Sandy Brown and Supervisor Justin Cummings.

“Remember Why You Live in Santa Cruz” was Ed’s campaign slogan the second time he ran for city council and it should give us all pause to consider what it means amidst the current atmosphere of hyper-development. Porter will be remembered as someone who cared deeply about this community and who developed from neighborhood activist to elected official, and made a difference.

A memorial mass for Ed Porter is scheduled for Saturday, June 3rd at 1:00 p.m. at Shrine of St. Joseph, 544 West Cliff Dr., Santa Cruz.

Read Ed’s own words about Santa Cruz

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

MASTER GARDENER. (DEL MAR THEATRE). (6.5 IMDB). A complex, involved, and very symbolic plot about a gardener (Joel Edgerton) with a history who works for a wealthy, temperamental rich land owner (Sigourney Weaver) and has visions and deep memories of his past life. The Proud Boys, Trump, Hitler, and more threats to peace are on, and in the gardener’s memories and conscience and he relates to the plants in his care as solutions.

THE MURDERS AT THE WHITE HOUSE FARM. (HBO MAX SERIES) (7.4 IMDB).   I binged watched all six episodes of this tangled British mystery, it’s that suspenseful. In 1985 five family members were shot and died and it’s a true story. Who did it, why, and even how it was done is surprising. It lags a bit by episode 4 but it’s well done and thoughtful go for it.

MRS. CHATTERJEE VS. NORWAY. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB). This is an unbelievably true story centering on the cruelty and evil was the government of Norway treats a young mother from India. They took her two children for 3 years of fighting based on some cultural differences between the two countries such as eating and family beliefs. Finally India’s government steps in and helps her. Fine viewing.

A MAN CALLED OTTO. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.5 IMDB).  Tom Hanks and his real life son Truman play the leads in this sad saga of an old man facing old age. Hanks is really only 67 years old and that adds to the mystery of why he’s so grumpy and almost commits suicide four times in this thin view of aging. The plot is variable but Hanks is always worth watching.

THE MOTHER. (NETFLIX MOVIE)  (5.5 IMDB).  Quite a cast of names such as Jennifer Lopez, Joseph Fiennes, Gael Garcia Bernal, and even Edie Falco are in it! Full of car chases, violence and tripe from 1000’s of cheap action flicks. It’s the FBI vs Jennifer who is trying to protect her daughter and the plot gets worse and worser!!

THE TERMINAL LIST. (AMAZON SERIES) (7.9 IMDB). Chris Pratt takes the part of a Navy Seal officer whose troops were ambushed during a secret mission in Syria. He suffers from shell shock/concussion and the search for the unknown enemy is a good one. The movie is believable, well-acted, nicely photographed and even mysterious. Go for it. (re-print from July 6, 2022)

HIGH DESERT. (APPLE TV SERIES) (6.5 IMDB). It’s billed as a comedy but watching Patricia Arquette attempting to be as funny as Jennifer Coolidge was in White Lotus is more depressing than laughable. Matt Dillon and Bernadette Peters try hard for any possible laughs and fail miserably. The plot has Patricia’s mother dying and how Patricia deals with it and tries to make a living in Yucca Valley first as a stripper, then she becomes a private investigator. No laughs, no plot, no fun.

WHITE HOUSE PLUMBERS. (HBO MAX SERIES) (6.7 IMDB).   This is rare, it’s listed as a drama, as a history, and a biography because it’s actually based on the true story of the Watergate break-ins as intended by President Richard Milhous Nixon. Woody Harrelson is E. Howard Hunt and Justin Theroux is G. Gordon Liddy. Domhall Gleeson is John Dean and they all do credible jobs as the would be thieves who try at least four separate times to get the contents of a desk drawer that President Nixon believes will expose Daniel Elsberg. It’s full of laughs, impossible happenings and another history lesson for political followers.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

THE BOOK CLUB: THE NEXT CHAPTER. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (5.7 IMDB). ????

Diane Keaton, Jane Fonda, Candace Bergen and Mary Steenburgen are back again from their 2018 version of the Book Club and it and they all flop miserably. These gawking, hammy, gaping old women in their 70’s go to Italy and try desperately try to get laughs. Not a one of them compares with Lucille Ball‘s comic ability. There’s no plot, no logic, no interest in where they posing…or positioning. Don’t go.

CITY ON FIRE. (APPLE TV SERIES) (7.5 IMDB).   It’s the Fourth of July 2003 at Central Park in New York City and there’s been a murder. It’s well-paced and deals with many, many issues such as drugs, family structure, cocaine, mushrooms and the differences between the rich and poor classes…whether we like it or not.

MANIFEST. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB). A very curious plot that has a commercial airliner in 2013 vanish from the sky (and earth) for five years. What’s curious and nearly believable, is that it’s exciting and involving to watch. What happens to families and relationships and just everyday occurrences become quite possible and even probable! Watch it and wonder.

DEAD RINGERS. (AMAZON SERIES) (6.4 IMDB). Rachel Weisz plays both lead roles of twin sisters and the camera and makeup crews will leave you spell bound watching how they both appear together so often on camera. They are gynecologists who want to open a birthing center and as you could expect they have a very hidden and illegal motive and plan behind their plotting. Go for it.

...
May22

BULLDOZING A SENSE OF PLACE

Returning home along Front Street on Tuesday I witnessed the jaws of death delivering the final blow to the building that once housed one of my favorite local businesses, University Copy. A stranger paused as I took the photo, and we exchanged a few words of shared sadness. Tom, University Copy owner had vacated months ago when his lease was ended. Despite its being empty, whenever I passed by, the building still evoked pleasant memories of animated political conversations with Tom when I picked up my copying job. Such are the dynamics of a sense of place provided by time, familiar buildings, and small, local, long-time business owners and staff. Few such businesses will survive the big building frenzy that is devouring the heart and soul of Santa Cruz.

The pat response to such feelings for a sense of place usually goes along the lines of “change is inevitable;” “it’s going to happen anyway, get used to it;” “it’s just nostalgia, get over it” and some more derogatory. There’s no way to counter such dismissiveness; you either feel a sense of place or you don’t. I was a strong supporter of keeping the downtown library in its current location (and would never have voted for Measure S had I known of the hidden agenda to tear it down). There is a deep feeling of belonging when I go to the library with the handsome city hall building opposite and the Civic Auditorium kitty corner. Forty years of memories congealed in a building exert a strong tug of meaning, at least for me and others who feel the same way.

We are probably outnumbered. Newbies haven’t had time to develop a sense of place. Student activists want housing at whatever height without pause for thought for the cost or impact. YIMBY’s are developers in sheep’s clothing. Sacramento has its boot on our neck. City Planning caters to developers. City council never found the spine to challenge any mandate from the state.

Some of us have been sounding the alarm for several years, ever since the then Planning Commission and City Council abandoned the 3-story height limits for downtown as codified in the Downtown Recovery Plan. The decision-making bodies raised the height limits to 7 and 8 stories while keeping a straight face as they declared such changes were in keeping with the original Plan. Then the state density bonus kicked in. Again, with a straight face, this state law means that new developments must be granted extra height over the zoned limit if they offer a smaller percentage of affordable units of the total than would be required in the lower height under our existing laws!

As the large building at Laurel, Front and Pacific is nearing its full height and others such as the 90- foot tall, 276- unit development at Front and Soquel are coming into focus, the impacts of these and the scores of other new high- rise developments (Ocean St, Mission St. Water St. south of Laurel St.) are starting to hit the news. The recent discussion in online Lookout is whether Santa Cruz can retain its character, uniqueness and small- town charm as the new buildings rise above the former skyline. That’s an easy answer. No, it won’t.

Local architect Mark Primack is quoted in Lookout as saying, “When you focus only on aesthetics, you’re missing the point of what makes a city a great city, or town a great town. The point is that it’s people who make a town a great town. It’s the enterprising people who are there and the lives that they’re living. That’s what makes a town interesting.” I found this a very strange comment from an architect.

The small towns that most find appealing and even the big cities that attract, probably have a range of people not so different from Santa Cruz. What sets the gems aside is what has been savored over time and protected from over- development. In Sydney in the 1970’s, developers wanted to bulldoze the historic area known as The Rocks and replace with new high rises. Many were outraged but it was the Unions that stopped the destruction by refusing to work on the site. So, The Rocks was saved and today is a lively destination and tourist attraction.

As each familiar building and business is bulldozed, as stately trees are ripped out to make way for the mass of the new buildings, as the view of the mountains from the sea is lost to the high rises, so the sense of place in Santa Cruz diminishes until it is a mere speck in memory and the mind’s eye.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

May 22

MAY UPDATES

The problem with vacations is that you have to work twice as hard, for twice as long, to catch up after! So apologies in advance that the next few columns may be a little disjointed, between my lovely city break, family life, other work, and going to the CA Democratic Convention with notable Santa Cruzans next weekend (I am one of the Assembly District Delegates (ADDs) for Assembly District 28 this year.)

You may have seen that Reggie Meisler and I held an Affordable Housing Month event at the intersection of Delaware and Shaffer last Saturday. It was well attended by both housed and unhoused residents from the neighborhood, as well as students and community members from around the county. A group from the adjacent De Anza Mobile Home Park planned a protest, perhaps misunderstanding our event as a protest itself.

We weren’t able to make our full presentation because some participants wanted to engage differently. While there were a few upset comments, from multiple perspectives, I think we actually managed to have productive conversations as a larger group and in clusters at the end. There were also supportive De Anza residents there, who thanked us for coming out to speak about the issues and made a point to let me know that they were not part of the protest and supported the provision of services for people living in vehicles on the far west side in the absence of adequate housing and official safe parking programs.

I appreciate that there are some valid concerns about people living in vehicles, similar to people living in tents or completely unsheltered wherever they can find a spot (as well as illegal and nuisance behaviors of visitors to the area and housed residents). I feel strongly that we must care for all members of our community as they struggle to survive as best they can in this nationwide affordable housing emergency. While some of us disagree on the best approaches, the more we can work together on what we DO agree on, the better the outcomes will be for all of us. A couple of attendees documented the session (or at least parts of it), which I will share if they become publicly available.

Vice Mayor Renee Golder did attend (though I don’t think she stayed for the whole thing). At one point I was asked why we focus so much attention on the city, rather than on the county, to provide services. When I answered that we focus on the city, and opposing the Oversized Vehicle Ordinance in particular, because the city had introduced this ordinance and the county did not, I detected a scoff and derisive comments from our vice mayor. While it is true that Santa Cruz County does regulate overnight recreational vehicle parking and overnight parking on county roads and parking lots, and they require paid permits of residents via the sheriff’s office, they do not have an ordinance like this one, which targets people living in vehicles so obviously.

It also doesn’t make the county’s regulations just or unworthy of attention and alteration at some point.

City Council recently voted to pursue Mayor Keeley’s proposed housing bond with a series of public engagements:

Santa Cruz, CA [May 11, 2023] – Community members will have the opportunity to provide input and support in the creation of an affordable workforce housing bond or revenue measure through three community workshops called “Creating the Bond.” These workshops are aimed at allowing community members to be involved in the process and provide feedback and input on the details of the proposed revenue measure.

All three workshops will be facilitated by the Council Revenue and Budget Committee, and community members are encouraged to attend and provide their input. The workshops will provide a framework for gathering input and support from community members on the creation of an affordable workforce housing bond or revenue measure.

The workshops will take place on the following dates at the Santa Cruz Police Department Community Room located at 155 Center St. In Santa Cruz:

Workshop #1: Informational Session – May 18, 2023, 5:30-7:00pm

Workshop #2: Polling Briefing and Planning – May 25, 2023, 5:30-7:00pm

Workshop #3: Finalization and Next Steps – May 31, 2023, 5:30-7:00pm

This all feels very rushed to me, too rushed for busy community members to really get the info and engage meaningfully. There is not currently a recording of last week’s informational session on the city webpage, further limiting engagement. Thankfully, Max Chun did a write up in Lookout that is not behind the paywall at the time of this writing. I appreciate the reported comment by Rafa Sonnenfeld that, “We’ve mostly talked about property taxes, but there are other sorts of taxes that the city could consider, like property transfer taxes, for example,” he said. “What are the size of the potential housing subsidies we could potentially get from different tax options, basically.” During my mayoral campaign I argued that increasing our Real Estate Transfer Tax would be a better, more equitable way to raise revenue for affordable housing and related social services.

According to Lee Brokaw, there will likely be an initiative on the 2024 state ballot that increases the approval threshold for voter-initiated tax increases from 50+1 to ?. This may undermine Mayor Keeley’s effort to initiate this affordable housing bond within city governance but transfer the process to a citizen’s group for an easier pass at the polls, or it may mean that if the state initiative passes and so does ours (with less than ? for it) we may have to re-do the election. I don’t fully understand this potential, and complex, issue yet, but feel it’s important to pass on the information.

Tuesday’s regular city council meeting agenda includes completion of the Housing Matters Hygiene Bay, an update on West Cliff work and  “roadmap” community review kick-off. A “Library Incident Report” addendum summary sheet to the agenda shows that “incidents” at the downtown library have skyrocketed. There’s no information on the quality of the incidents, just numbers, but it seems cause for concern for patrons, workers, and those causing whatever these incidents may be. I’d like to hear from workers what support they need to be safe on the job.

There was a special council meeting for budget presentations, Wednesday, May 24th. I’ve just given the packet a cursory view, with my reading of the overall numbers below:

Fiscal Year 2024 Proposed Budget

City Attorney up

City Council up

City Manager up

Economic Development way up (housing)

Finance flat

Fire up

Human Resources flat

Information Technology flat

Library flat

Parks and Recreation up

Planning and Community Development up

Police up significantly

Public Works up

Water up

The May 9th regular city council meeting was jam-packed with important issues and discussions worth watching bits of: the Homelessness Response Quarterly Update, Pogonip post-sweeps /cleanup contract, Coral Street Revisioning tensions, the introduction of the “Affordable Workforce Housing Bond,” and the Police Independent Auditor Report (VERY troubling).

There was a Santa Cruz Police Military Equipment Virtual Community Meeting May 16th, which I hope will be available online soon.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
May 22

THE KAISER TAJ MAHAL PLAN IN LIVE OAK HAS VANISHED

Last week, Kaiser sent out a notice that the plan to build an enormous new Medical Facility and four-story parking garage at 5940 Soquel Avenue Frontage Road has been officially swept off the table.  The reason given is that Kaiser plans to instead continue to expand services with partnerships at other local medical facilities.    This would include the Watsonville Hospital, where the organization already has an agreement to provide Kaiser patients service under the Kaiser plan.

Somehow, I suspect there is more to the story than meets the eye here.  I think the County needs the land at 5940 Soquel Avenue to move forward with its original zoned use as dense affordable housing as a specially-designated Zone identified when the Redevelopment Agency handled it.  The County is in trouble with the State if the updated Housing Element cannot be approved by the end of this year, and prove that the Regional Housing Number Allocation (RHNA) mandating nearly 5,000 new units will be built within the next eight years can be accomplished, receiving the blessing of the State Dept. of Housing and Community Development (HCD).

I also think this is related to the agreement that the County Board of Supervisors approved recently to allow Kaiser a sweet deal to pay a lot less than the other hospital providers for the percentage of uninsured patient care costs.  Dominican Hospital representatives and other local health care representatives protested that deal, but the Board approved it anyway.

Hmmmm…

Keep your eye on this project.  The bottom line is what infrastructure will happen to support anything that is built at 5940 Soquel Avenue, which has no bus service, and no sidewalks to help people get there.

Below is the notice from Kaiser, sent last week via Mail Chimp to those who have requested updates on the project:

Update from Kaiser Permanente on the 5940 Soquel Avenue Project

Kaiser Permanente is committed to Santa Cruz County, and as part of that commitment, we continue to explore ways to expand our specialty care offerings throughout the region. As part of our assessment of how to best serve our members and deliver high-quality, affordable health care, we have re-evaluated the proposed project at 5940 Soquel Avenue and determined that we no longer intend to occupy this property.

Going forward, we plan to continue expanding services throughout the County while thoughtfully considering the dynamic, local health care industry and the access needs of our community.

WHO MAKES THE DECISIONS ON THESE STATE MANDATES THAT REQUIRES FEVERISH COMPLIANCE?

I continue to try to understand why the new RHNA mandates are more than triple the mandated build allocation of the Fifth Cycle.  It is not an easy dig.  I recently invited Ms. Heather Adamson, Planning Director of the Associated Monterey Bay Area Governments (AMBAG) as a guest on a weekly online radio program that I co-host to explain the mystery.  She let the listening audience know that there was a new methodology used that considered social economic justice in the forefront, and that cities and counties where there are more affluence were specifically targeted for higher numbers.  The thought is that everyone should be able to live where they want, regardless of the historic cost of doing so.

It was shocking that Ms. Adamson said the condition and availability of infrastructure levels serving the areas is not considered, and the RHNA Plan is exempt from California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review.  She said it also had to do with recent legislation, mandating higher levels of affordable housing to be built.

“What if we just say NO?” I asked.

She replied that the local jurisdictions would lose all chance of federal and state funding for transportation and planning projects, and developers would be allowed to invoke “Builder’s Remedy” and basically build whatever they want.

Wow.  That is a mighty big stick.

I continue to research this problem, and hope you will send me your thoughts.

What about the quality of life?  What about environmental impacts?

Here are some links to information I have found that you might also find useful.  This is a big deal, and I am really worried for the health, beauty and quality of life for our Communities.

Feel free to listen in every Friday on the “Community Matters” online radio program, 1pm-3pm, on Santa Cruz Voice

The Executive Order —-

The list of States who are participating

Webinars

AMBAG and the California Department of Housing & Community Development (HCD) will host periodic webinars for local jurisdiction elected officials and staff to assist in the preparation of its 6th Cycle Housing Elements.

6th Cycle Housing Element Technical Assistance: Governmental & Non-Governmental Constraints – April 24, 2023

AMBAG & HCD staff held a webinar for local jurisdiction planning/housing staff in the AMBAG region on the Governmental & Non-Governmental requirements for the 6th Cycle Housing Elements.  To view a recording of this webinar, please click here

6th Cycle Housing Element Technical Assistance: Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing – March 27, 2023

AMBAG & HCD staff held a webinar for local jurisdiction planning/housing staff in the AMBAG region on the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) requirements for the 6th Cycle Housing Elements.  To view a recording of this webinar, please click here

6th Cycle Housing Element Technical Assistance: Site Inventory – February 27, 2023

AMBAG & HCD staff held a webinar for local jurisdiction planning/housing staff in the AMBAG region on the sites inventory requirements for the 6th Cycle Housing Elements.  To view the recording of this webinar, please click here.

Introduction to 6th Cycle Housing Elements Webinar – March 29, 2022

AMBAG & the HCD staff held a webinar for local elected officials and local jurisdiction planning/housing staff in the AMBAG region on the 6th Cycle Housing Elements. This introductory webinar discussed the new state requirements for 6th Cycle Housing Elements and offer insight on how to prepare to start your 6th Cycle Housing Elements.  To view a recording of this webinar please click here.

For more information and additional housing element tools from HCD

Regional Housing Planning | Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments

WHY THE SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT BOARD ENDED CHARGING DEVELOPERS THEIR WATER DEMAND OFFSET FEES

On February 7, 2023, the Board of Directors for Soquel Creek Water District decided to end the policy to make developers pay $55,000/AcreFoot of water anticipated for new development because the aquifer was in critical overdraft. What made them change their mind on this expensive program enacted in 2003 and fees increased dramatically in 2016?

I could not attend that meeting then because storms knocked out our electricity and phone service, and I happened to have a suffered a concussion.  The District had not uploaded the video recording of this particular meeting until now. Link here. The owner of the video does not allow embedding on another site.

Item 7.2 begins at Minute 3:30.  Staff’s explanation and justification is fascinating, but Board members’ discussion is very illuminating.

The problem the Board faced was that the District has sold all but 3.9 Acre/Feet available according to their aquifer recharge studies, so would have to come up with a new conservation project to justify continued collection of the expensive fees.

It has little to do with the real status of the aquifer now.  Of course, they hold their intention to inject treated sewage water into the aquifer as a nebulous panacea, but that PureWater Soquel Project has been delayed for many reasons, and will not be on line until late 2024 or even longer.

So, how can the District justify continuing to sell new water service connections if the aquifer is still in critical overdraft?

Listen to this video to better understand the thought-processes of the District.  It never really was about trying to improve the aquifer but rather about getting more money.  Now, with some questioning the legality of the practice that portends to be an obstacle to the County’s rapid growth under State-mandated RHNA building, the District does not want to spend the money to develop any viable conservation programs that would not happen without collecting the $55,000/AcreFoot Water Demand Offset fees.

“At minute 53:50, Water Conservation Staff Specialist Ms. Flock admitted it would be difficult…”I don’t know what would generate enough water savings to justify it.”  That followed Director Tom LaHue’s statement that it would take lots of money to re-do the factors to legally justify continuing to collect the Offset fees at Minute 50:10.

Director Bruce Jaffe wondered at Minute 46:45 about how it would be fair to developers who have recently paid the hefty $55,000/acre-foot Water Demand Offset fee but suddenly, new developers won’t have to?

He worried at minute 43:00 if the recharge from PureWater Soquel will actually be enough?

I hope to listen to the complete recording and hope you do, too.  Please let me know your thoughts.

SOQUEL CREEK WATER BUSINESS IN LA SELVA BEACH

Last week’s Soquel Creek Water District Board meeting was a hybrid format, with in-person meeting resuming at the Capitola City Council chambers.  I arrived a few minutes after 6pm, thinking that the Closed Session would be first, as is customary in the remote meetings.  It turned out that the order of the meetings have changed, with Closed Session again at the end of the meeting.

I encourage Soquel Creek Water District customers to again attend these in-person meetings at 6pm on the first and third Tuesdays of the month.  These folks need to be held accountable.

Here are some interesting projects I learned the District is doing:

Utility Relocation in Conjunction with the County’s Buffered Bike Lane Improvement Project on Soquel Drive.  The District is guest in County Right of Way and needs to move utilities to accommodate a new storm drain various sidewalk improvements:

1.12″ Mainline relocation at Soquel Dr. and Mar Vista Dr.2.Hydrant Relocation on Soquel Dr near Mar Vista Dr. 3.6 air release valve relocations on Soquel Dr. and Soquel Ave.4.Raising ~25 Meter and valve boxes.

San Andreas Rd. Main Extension for Renaissance High School (Pajaro Valley Unified School District)

  1. LAFCO annexation required.
  2. The Rural Community Assistance Corporation (RCAC) and Weber, Hayes & Associates (WHA) are supporting PVUSD on funding application, LAFCO annexation, and engineering services for water main extension and service installation.

iii. Conditional Will Serve letter pending.

  1. Documentation showing District commitment to consolidation and authorization for applicant to act on behalf of the District will be presented to Board.
  2. District will be the lead agency for CEQA16.

Moosehead Dr. Main Replacement

  1. Pending confirmation of $1.416 Budget Bill
  2. CalTrans and County are coordinating to design a realignment of Moosehead Dr to be out of the CalTrans ROW. Coordination is scheduled for July 202317.City of Capitola Roundabout at Capitola Ave. & Bay Ave. intersection i. Staff is coordinating with the City for accommodating improvements which include a fire hydrant relocation and valve box adjustments.18.County of Santa Cruz Coastal Rail Trail at 41st Ave. RR crossing Staff is coordinating with the County for water line crossing conflicts

Water Distribution Model

  1. Staff is working with Akel Engineering to update the District’s hydraulic model. The most current model was last updated in 2014 and is missing key infrastructure upgrades from the last decade of CIP projects.
  2. $60k was budgeted for FY22/23

iii.  Additional funding is available through a state DWR grant through the MGA. This model will be used in the optimization study to evaluate how the Distribution system can accommodate redistribution of pumping in SqCWD’s system and evaluate the hydraulics of water transfers as they relate to the overall groundwater basin management scenarios.

REMEMBERING THOSE WHO HAVE FOUGHT TO PROTECT OUR FREEDOM

Memorial Day is a time to reflect and recognized those who died while protecting our freedoms.  Take a moment to do so.

In Flanders Fields

By John McCrae

In Flanders fields the poppies blow

Between the crosses, row on row,

That mark our place; and in the sky

The larks, still bravely singing, fly

Scarce heard amid the guns below.

We are the Dead. Short days ago

We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,

Loved and were loved, and now we lie,

In Flanders fields.

Take up our quarrel with the foe:

To you from failing hands we throw

The torch; be yours to hold it high.

If ye break faith with us who die

We shall not sleep, though poppies grow

In Flanders fields.

2023 UPCOMING COMMUNITY MEETINGS

The Housing Element identifies policies and programs to meet existing and projected housing needs for the urban unincorporated areas of the County. 


May 31:    Virtual Meeting Via Zoom 5:30-7:00 pm
Zoom Link

June 28:  Watsonville Civic Plaza ~ 275 Main St., 4th Floor,
Watsonville, 5:30-7:00 pm (Food will be provided)

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS…JUST DO SOMETHING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers, Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

May 22

Grey had a rough workweek and will be back next week.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

 May 15

#135 / Ron DeSantis Is Taking On The Eighth

The title of my blog posting today refers to the Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution. Click the link if you’d like to refresh your recollection of what the Eighth Amendment provides. Most importantly, the Eighth Amendment prohibits the United States Government (and now state governments, too) from imposing “cruel and unusual” punishments on any criminal offender.

If your son or daughter goes into Target and shoplifts, it is the Eighth Amendment that makes sure that the government doesn’t cut off your child’s hand, in order to punish this behavior. The United States Supreme Court has also held, definitively, in Kennedy v. Louisiana, that imposing the death penalty on a criminal offender, when the crime does not intentionally cause the victim’s death, violates the Eighth Amendment.

Ron DeSantis, the Governor of Florida (pictured above), doesn’t think that this is the way things ought to go. He is backing a piece of legislation that would directly challenge the decision in Kennedy v. Louisiana, and would, therefore, permit (and perhaps even encourage) the United States Supreme Court to broaden the scope of the death penalty.

Clicking this link will take you to a news story about this effort, which was published in the online magazine, Slate. As the article says:

When asked late last month if the bill is unconstitutional, Rep. Baker [a Florida legislator] responded that “fifteen years of wrongly decided case law is not persuasive” to her. She previously argued that Kennedy is ripe for reconsideration because the majority’s decision was not “based on any law” and did not point to any statute or constitutional provision for its basis but was, instead, based on the majority’s “independent judgment.” That statement is far from accurate. As testimony for the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers clarified at the committee hearing, the majority decision in Kennedy was grounded in the cruel and unusual punishment clause of the Eighth Amendment.

Of course, the legislators’ blatant disregard for precedent undermines the bedrock of our court system—the theory of stare decisis. Worse, legislation attacking precedent undermines our system of government, which is grounded on a separation of powers. When state Rep. Michael Gottlieb asked in a committee hearing late last month if this bill poses separation of powers issues, Rep. Baker said no, though offered no support for her position. Yet, these efforts deliberately undercut the long-standing work of the judiciary in an effort to achieve political gain

I believe that the concerns outlined in the article, and presented in the quotation, above, are absolutely valid. When unelected members of the Supreme Court start acting like a Legislature, this is an attack on the “bedrock” of our court system.

I do have another point I’d like readers to consider, as well. Is it actually ever appropriate to react to bad behavior by killing the offender?

I am suggesting, “No.”

If you are thinking, “Yes,” then think again about that shoplifting son or daughter of yours. There is one way to make sure, with absolute certainty, that your kids won’t ever violate the law again, once they have violated it once.

Kill ’em if they do!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
May 22

AVOID CLICHES LIKE THE PLAGUE – WILLIAM SAFIRE

Not sure where you might find the sign-up sheet, but according to msn.com, Russia is floating the idea of building a village for US and Canadian ex-pats who are tired of liberal ideology as Russia seeks to position itself as a bastion for “traditional” moral values. The project is supposedly approved…no further details at this time…but, around 200 families have expressed interest, wishing to run away from the North American cultural climate. These curiosity-seekers have no Russian roots – most are Catholics who “strongly believe in the prediction that Russia will remain the only Christian country in the world.” The cost of the new 2024 construction will be borne by the conservative settlers, located near Moscow in the suburbs according to immigration lawyer, Timur Beslangurov. Vladimir Putin signed a decree in September warning of a “battle for cultural supremacy” with global ramifications and cautioned of “the aggressive imposition of neoliberal views by a number of states,” as the country defends and spreads conservative views.

A contributor to Daily Kos cautions those families, saying they need to consider that Russian Orthodox traditionalists will have a dim view of their Catholic beliefs, which dates back to the Great Schism of 1054 AD. These American/Canadian right-wingers will be horrified at the Muslim population, having left countries with 1.1 percent (USA) and 4.9 percent (Canada) populations, taking up residence in a Russia that has a 12 percent Muslim citizenry. As if that’s not enough to dissuade them, they will find that Russia doesn’t have a Second Amendment, so no more stockpiling of their arsenals of military grade weapons to overthrow the secular government. Minor roadblocks might be the lack of indoor plumbing and flush toilets. The only candidate allowed on the city ballot for mayor will be Steven Segal…maybe Trump. But hey! Let’s give these folks some assistance by starting a GoFund Me drive to send them to a better place. Donald Trump already has a head start with his effort…calling it Truth Social, its octopus arms reaching into several entities, so don’t answer his appeals for funds. With any luck, perhaps DOJ can revoke his passport allowing more time for his orange jumpsuit fitting.

Of interest to the Former Guy is a US Eleventh Appeals Court ruling that overturns the death sentence of an inmate sentenced for a murder in 1997, unless the US Supreme Court overturns the appeal filed by Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall. Previously the murderer was determined to have “significant deficits in social/interpersonal skills, self-direction, independent home living, and functional academics,” therefore violating the Eighth Amendment against punishing a person with intellectual disabilities. Sounds vaguely familiar, eh? AG Marshall argues that the man’s IQ scores have consistently placed his IQ above that of an intellectually disadvantaged person, making his death sentence both just and constitutional. This is of relevance to The Don since the US Eleventh has jurisdiction over Alabama, Georgia and Florida… and who knows when one might glean some form of security provided by the Eighth Amendment?

A cautionary note for the above applicants: due to US sanctions against Russia, their Foreign Ministry announced that it was banning 500 Americans from entering the country, including Barack Obama, Stephen Colbert, and former ambassadors to Russia. No direct complaints were specified, but offenses included spreading Russophobia, arms supplies to Ukraine, and officials “who are directly involved in the persecution of dissidents in the wake of the so-called storming of the Capitol.” The ministry also denied a US request for consular access to Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, who was arrested in March, charged with espionage. That denial was a response to this country for denying visas to Russian journalists who wanted to cover Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s visit in April. To those ex-pat emigrants, be forewarned that luggage should not contain autographed photos, books, essays, posters, bumper stickers or mementos related to those named on the dreaded List of 500, or Gershkovich’s cell will be awfully crowded.

Russia’s list makes it explicit that Putin is shamelessly aligning himself with Trump and the MAGA-GOP and against those who dare to block the movement’s attempt to overthrow our democracy. Listed is Georgia’s secretary of state, Brad Raffensberger, who couldn’t seem to find “11,780 votes” for Trump’s Georgia victory, and Capitol Police officer, Michael Byrd, who shot Ashli Babbitt during her House of Representatives chamber assault. Adoption by MAGA trolls of the language and dictums that enabled Putin to overcome representative democracy, and by Hungary’s Viktor Orbán (hero of Tucker Carlson), endears this bunch of swamp dwellers to Mr. P., who in 2019 declared liberal democracy “obsolete.” Praise of Trump by both Putin and Orbán, especially in light of his pushback against the support of Ukraine by our government, further encourages the demonization of our values, with dismantling of social programs resulting in concentration of wealth and power to a small, dominant group which rejects equality.

Unclear at this time is whether MAGA maniac and Big Lie pusher Missouri Senator Josh Hawley is on the List of 500…the Russian Ministry is likely reading his new book, ‘Manhood: The Masculine Virtues America Needs,’ and gleaning information from the reviews before making a decision. Waxing poetic about manhood by one who was photographed raising his fist in support of the gathered rioters in DC on J6, later being videoed running for his life in the halls of Congress, seems a bit out of place. But, if you know a budding misogynist this might be just the ticket for his library! We can’t forget that DC police officer, Michael Fanone, in his anger after being attacked and injured while defending the Capitol that fateful day, called Hawley a “bitch” upon viewing the videos of his fist-raising and subsequent running like the wind through the building. Reviewers of ‘Manhood’ have not been kind: “I hear they’re making the book out of glass to make it as fragile as his ‘masculinity,” and, “I understand this is a terrific running program, but I also understand he’s a lumberjack and he’s OK.” One reviewer simply posted a photoshopped rework of the cover, making it read ‘Man In A Hood.’ It must be made clear that Josh has a long history of defending white supremacist values…when he was fifteen years old he wrote an early anti-woke piece defending the militias tied to the Oklahoma City bombing. The Guardian reviewer, Lloyd Green, calls him a “Neo-confederate at war with modernity, with a God-given right to be heard.” Add to that, ‘a puke-inducing creepy little punk,’ along with anything else that Officer Fanone wishes to toss into the mix.

Alabama’s rocks-for-brains/Publisher’s Clearing House Senator Tommy Tuberville is sure to favor Putin’s 500 list as he continues to withhold his approval of 200 promotions for military personnel, posing a clear risk for US military readiness. His beef is over a Pentagon policy, initiated in February, providing travel reimbursements and leave for service members to seek abortions out-of-state. Tommy has asked Defense Secretary Austin to rescind this policy, and until it happens he will stand in the doorway, preventing the unanimous consent process to award promotions. Senate Majority Leader Schumer could bring nominations to the floor individually…all 200 of them…requiring votes for each nominee which would eat valuable time to accomplish. Austin defends the policy, acknowledging female service personnel may live in areas lacking adequate care or limitations for reproductive health. However, Tuberville stands by his tweet, “No matter how much disinformation Democrats spread, I will continue to stand up to the most politicized Pentagon in American history.”

After the Trump verdict in the E. Jean Carroll case, Senator Tuberville was so disgusted he remarked that he was ready to vote for the Former Guy TWICE! On the same day, Tommy-boy? He charges President Biden with trying to destroy America by weeding from our military the Nazis, extremists, and white nationalists. Reporters asked him whether those white nationalists, bigots, idiots and misogynists should be in uniform, he shot back, “They call them that, I call them Americans! They just don’t fit Joe Biden’s agenda!” His office later tried to clarify that he was only expressing his skepticism that white nationalists exist in the ranks of the military.

Musician/iconoclast Frank Zappa, in an interview five years before his death in 1993, said, “…when the dogma becomes legislation, that’s when you have danger. I have this horrible fear that the United States could wind its way toward being a fascist theocracy.” Joan Baez, in a New Yorker interview by Amanda Petrusich, agrees that we seem to be tumbling backwards, everything related to propaganda, lying, business, money and power. She says liberals don’t know how to talk, as opposed to MAGA-talk…“Build a wall”, “lock her up”…three words that are simple to remember. Biden, on the other hand, is a “lovely person, who talks for an hour, but you don’t remember anything said.” She tells of meeting a young man in the 1980s who said of the ’60s, “Man, you had it all back then. You had the war, you had the glue, man.” His idealization of that time was centered basically on Beatles, Dylan, Woodstock, the music, the civil rights marches and war protests, not thinking of the danger had a young man been plunked onto a ship headed for Vietnam. She agrees that there was a ten-year period where “we had everything,” then John Lennon was killed and everyone wondered, “Who’s gonna write the next ‘Imagine?” “Well, nobody,” she answers. It might be music or something else, but what will recreate those feeling we had? She goes on to say, “We had that feeling when Obama ran for office. When he ran, not when he was in. You can’t do shit once you’re in office. But that was a moment where people felt an idea of what we had back then.” In a more ominous, cautionary note she observed, “Back then, we sat at lunch counters as an example of what nonviolent action could accomplish, because we were brave on the front lines. I think courage is contagious, but violence is really contagious…easier than nonviolent action. If someone shoots something up, well, the police shoot him, of course. It’s just a given. What kind of insanity is that?”

Speaking of insanity, Qasim Rashid, Esq. posts on Twitter: Every MAGA defense of Donald Trump boils down to these three options – 1) Trump didn’t say or do that, 2) If he did, it wasn’t illegal, 3) If it was illegal, then Biden did the same thing too. Facts don’t matter. Spike Milligan posts, “You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, which is just long enough to be president of the United States.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “MEMORIAL DAY”

“A hero is someone who has given his or her life to something bigger than oneself.”
~Joseph Campbell.

“Heroes never die. They live on forever in the hearts and minds of those who would follow in their footsteps”.       
~Emily Potter

 “He loves his country best who strives to make it best”.       
~Robert G. Ingersoll

...

It’s been a long week. Here’s some feel-good about a pet bird, who’s rather remarkable 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

May 17 – 23, 2023

Highlights this week:

BRATTON…latest rail & trail news, the Santa Cruz sign. GREENSITE…will be back next week. SCHENDLEDECKER…still on vacation. STEINBRUNER…county budget gloomy, soquel bike lane, military weapons, charging for research, housing element, Nisene marks, Aptos Village closures, live oak library. HAYES…May’s flowers. PATTON…a look out lesson MATLOCK…we’re having some fun now with a Foxified CNN. EAGAN…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week. QUOTES…”Snakes”

...

PACIFIC AVENUE 1960.  Years before the Pacific Garden Mall happened we had this view of the St. George Hotel. The whole building site once contained 15 buildings with 27 businesses.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

                                                                                                               DATELINE May 15

LATEST RAIL TRAIL NEWS. Keeping abreast of the breaking down and building up of changes in our rail trail development is an almost full time job. I asked Barry Scott leading activist with Friends of the Trail to bring us up to date. On May 15 he wrote…

“Three consistently anti-rail Commissioners on the RTC revealed their hand during a discussion related to a simple matter: acceptance as valid the Environmental Impact Report for Segments 8 and 9 of the Rail Trail.

When the City Council took up the matter, they approved the Environmentally Superior Alternative, aka the Ultimate Trail, and rejected the anti-transit “Optional First Phase: Interim Trail” alternative.

Led by former Greenway Executive Director RTC Chair Manu Koenig, Commission Alternate Rob Quinn (Greenway Board member until just weeks before his appointment by Supervisor Friend was made public), and Scotts Valley Commissioner Randy Johnson made the argument that the EIR is defective because it tells the truth about the impacts of the Interim Alternative: that it creates more harm and costs more money and takes longer than the Proposed Project- the Ultimate Trail (trail built next to the tracks).

What’s their plan?  They would like to see the Interim Trail treated as an Alternative that never needs to restore rail service.  They might just get away with it, or they might not and continue to just slow things down and make the trail and rail progress more painful for all of us.

This flies in the face of logic, several past studies, explicit guidance from Caltrans and past RTC and Council Resolutions, four Chambers of Commerce statements, and the 74% of voters who rejected Greenway last June in a clear and historic supermajority NO vote on Measure D.   We’re also getting record-setting grants specifically for the “Rail with Trail” multimodal approach to using the rail corridor.  Our RTC has great grant writers.

A simple action item on the May 5 agenda, to accept as valid the Segment 8-9 EIR, was approved 9-3 but the comments made reveal that Greenway won’t go away, and we should be concerned because with only two out of five Supervisors on the side of public transit on our rail line, we may be in trouble down the road.  Supervisor McPherson expressed doubts about rail transit and has voted against further work in the past.

Fortunately, nine of the Commissioners are looking after our interests and listening to voters.  Three Supervisors’ seats are expiring so be looking for qualified candidates for Districts 1, 2, and 5.

We can expect to see obstruction at every step of the way, with EIR reviews of Segments 10 through 12 and beyond.  Public comment for Segment 12 is open through June 2.  Supporters of rail and trail are encouraged to review the materials and submit public comments.  Here’s a link with the information needed for Segment 12 of the rail trail, just one part of the larger Watsonville to Santa Cruz Multimodal Corridors effort  “.

THE UNWELCOME TO SANTA CRUZ SIGN. Last week in this space I wrote about that ugly, garish, yellow and blue “neon” sign that once graced our entryway I said it was located at Ocean Street and Highway 17. Nuts…another mistake!! Jean Brocklebank corrected me and stated that it was on River Street not Ocean.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

THE BOOK CLUB:THE NEXT CHAPTER. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (5.7 IMDB). ????

Diane Keaton, Jane Fonda, Candace Bergen and Mary Steenburgen are back again from their 2018 version of the Book Club and it and they all flop miserably. These gawking, hammy, gaping old women in their 70’s go to Italy and try desperately try to get laughs. Not a one of them compares with Lucille Ball‘s comic ability. There’s no plot, no logic, no interest in where they posing…or positioning. Don’t go.

CITY ON FIRE. (APPLE TV SERIES) (7.5 IMDB).   It’s the Fourth of July 2003 at Central Park in New York City and there’s been a murder. It’s well-paced and deals with many, many issues such as drugs, family structure, cocaine, mushrooms and the differences between the rich and poor classes…whether we like it or not.

MANIFEST. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.1 IMDB).   A very curious plot that has a commercial airliner in 2013 vanish from the sky (and earth) for five years. What’s curious and nearly believable, is that it’s exciting and involving to watch. What happens to families and relationships and just everyday occurrences become quite possible and even probable! Watch it and wonder.

DEAD RINGERS. (AMAZON SERIES) (6.4 IMDB). Rachel Weisz plays both lead roles of twin sisters and the camera and makeup crews will leave you spell bound watching how they both appear together so often on camera. They are gynecologists who want to open a birthing center and as you could expect they have a very hidden and illegal motive and plan behind their plotting. Go for it.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

THE DIPLOMAT. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.2 IMDB)   Rufus Sewell is enough of a reason to watch this series. Oddly enough it’s all about diplomats and diplomacy. Rufus was a diplomat and now he’s married to a new ambassador. She’s leading the international discussions about how to deal with some countries killing attack on a warship that killed 41 troops. Keri Russell is Rufus’ wife and the focal point and the diplomacy wears thin after the first three episodes. Don’t expect much excitement or relevance.

SILO. (APPLE TV) (8.4 IMDB).   David Oyelowo is one lead in this neatly structured science fiction puzzle. More than 10, 000 people are living in a giant underground silo. The silo has been there for over 140 years. They can see out one specific window…or can they?  Tim Robbins has a mysterious governing role to play here. It’s well done, puzzling and many episodes yet to be released.

TICKET TO PARADISE. (AMAZON PRIME MOVIE). (6.1 IMDB). This gazillion dollar star flick has been out and around for over a year and even with George Clooney and Julia Roberts starring in it…it didn’t do well. The two of them were married once had a daughter and became bitter enemies. Now the daughter is living in Bali and wants to marry a handsome young local seaweed farmer. George and Julia try to stop the marriage and we get a fine view of Balinese culture and scenery. It’s diverting at best and gets more and more cheesy as the almost two hours drag on.

EXTRAPOLATIONS. (APPLE TV) (5.9 IMDB) This is eight separate stories, very separate movies, centering on the earth and how the universe will change our lives as a result of the nearly infinite changes to the earth. Actors including Meryl Streep, Tobey Maguire, Forest Whitaker, and Heather Graham all have small roles portraying humans whose lives are changed in the thirty three years that’s highlighted. Serious and well done, but few laughs.

...
May 15

Gillian will be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

May 15

Joy is taking a short break…will return soon.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
May 15

COUNTY BUDGET FORECAST IS GLOOMY

The updated County Budget report at last week’s Board of Supervisor meeting was not pretty, and it bothers me that even less time than usual will be publicly devoted to explaining and discussing the issue in the near term.

Budget Manager Marcus Pimental stated the County’s budget is now $1.1 billion.  However, expenditures exceed revenues by $12 million annually.  “It is unfortunate that the County will have to borrow $50 million this fall to cover operational expenses until property tax payments fill the gap.”  he said at Minute 50 in the video recording

The Budget will be $8 million to $10 million in the red every year between now and 2027.  Sales tax revenue is decreasing due to more people shopping online, causing the County to lose about $5 million annually.  The new disposable cup tax approved by voters last year is not bringing in the $700,000 projected but instead may only net $75,000- $100,000 annually.  Staff hopes to find out from the County Treasurer’s office why there is such a discrepancy.

Where DOES the County’s discretionary money go?  Listen in at about minute 54 of the meeting video recording to see that law enforcement and the Office of Response, Recovery & Resilience (OR3) gets the biggest piece of that pie.  The Sheriff’s Taj Mahal complex in Live Oak does not come cheaply, and now that the County owns the entire business complex at 5200 and 5400 Soquel Avenue Frontage Road, there is no property tax collected for any of it (that was all built by Barry Swenson Builder, and has had many structural problems requiring expensive repairs.)  Don’t forget that the OR3 was born immediately after CAO Carlos Palacios eliminated the one full time Office of Emergency Response Manager, Rosemary Anderson, as a cost-cutting measure in 2020.  Oh, well, it gave David Reid, the former analyst of Supervisor John Leopold, a nice job after he lost the election to Supervisor Manu Koenig.

The CAO emphasized the County has accomplished many significant projects, but pointed to large expenses such as new County radio systems that will cost roughly $30 million.  (Never mind the County sold the communications tower it owned to the City of Watsonville and now pays thousands of dollars for month rent to Etherics network on the mountain near Mt. Madonna.) He pointed to a report that Santa Clara County is expecting a $100 million budget deficit, and that Santa Cruz County will simply need to continue deferred capital improvement projects (roads, bridges, culverts, etc.) so we don’t end up like them.

Supervisor Bruce McPherson asked County staff to “Cool your jets” on establishing new programs that are state mandates but unfunded. The State Budget (released last Friday) is worse than we thought, with a $30 billion deficit.  He stressed that there are unrealistic challenges with State mandates before us.  “This is the most uncertain time I have ever seen in my years of State and local government.” and he urged all Departments to review projects that are “Nice to have but may not have money to pay for them.”

Supervisor Justin Cummings wanted to make sure the stipends for Commissioners that the Board recently requested is funded. (Budget manager Marcus Pimental assured him it is).

Zach Friend blamed it on Prop 13 for low property taxes and also slow reimbursements by FEMA for recent disasters and Covid.  He sees County worker furloughs likely.  Only 13cents/dollar in property tax money comes back to the County, he explained, and pretty soon the pressure will be too great for County funding.

He is glad the hearings are short, and feels having everything online will help the public better understand the Budget.  Hmmm……

Supervisor Felipe Hernandez emphasized that he wants the new park at 181 Whiting Road in Watsonville funded, and we need to let the State know Santa Cruz County needs help.

Supervisor Manu Koenig was nowhere to be seen during the entire meeting.

Watch the presentation and discussion of this by clicking on Item #7 on the County Board of Supervisor May 9 meeting agenda

The Budget hearings will be May 30 and 31, with a Supplementary hearing June 28, and Final approvals in September.  Pay attention, listen in and ask questions.

Where is that “Online Budget”?  Here you go!

SOQUEL BUFFERED BIKE LANE PROJECT FUNDING AND CONTRACT WILL BE APPROVED MAY 25

The much-talked-about Soquel Drive Bike Lane Project, stretching from La Fonda Avenue in Live Oak to State Park Drive in Aptos may soon get off the ground.  What will it mean for you?  If you are a student at Cabrillo College, your free on-street parking will completely vanish.  If you travel through Soquel Village, you will get squeezed by lane width reductions to 10’wide in the eastbound lanes, and 11′ wide in the westbound lanes.  Staff insists this will calm traffic speeds, but I wonder what fire engines and construction trucks going to the quarry nearby will do?

Take a look at these recorded public meetings from last year:

Soquel Drive Buffered Bike Lane and Congestion Mitigation Project – Community Workshop 2 – 1.20.22

The questions at this session were different and brought forth new and different information: Soquel Drive Buffered Bike Lane & Congestion Mitigation Workshop #1 on January 12th, 2022.

Public Works Dept. staff has let me know similar improvements are scheduled for Soquel Drive at State Park to Freedom Blvd. in Aptos in the near future.  How can Soquel Drive in the Aptos Village area possibly get squeezed any more than has already been done to accommodate the new Parade Street intersection for Swenson?

Parking for those businesses will already be taking a big hit with the new 14′-wide pedestrian / bike trail right-of-way that the Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) is planning to confiscate next year.

THE COUNTY HOUSING ELEMENT UPDATE NEEDS YOU

You need to be weighing in on this Housing Element update, because it will affect the quality of life for us all and for generations to come..

Santa Cruz County Planning Dept. staff are feverishly working to complete the updated Housing element of the County General Plan in order to submit it for approval to the State Housing & Community Development (HSD) Dept. for approval by the end of this year.  This is being brought about by the 6th Cycle Regional Housing Allocation Number (RHNA) produced behind the veil of Associated Monterey Bay Area Governments (AMBAG), mandating unreasonable levels of growth with required percentages of affordable units for the County and cities.

There are a number of virtual and in-person hearings on this, so attend as many as you can:

Get Involved

The online Public Survey provided here is quite worthless, in my opinion, so do your best to interact with staff and send written comments.

PUBLIC HEARING WITH SHERIFF HART TO REVIEW AUDIT OF MILITARY WEAPONS USE IN THE COUNTY

Mark your calendar for this opportunity to sit in on the Sheriff’s Annual Report of how and why local deputies used military weapons in responding to public incidents.

May 23, at 6:30pm in Community Room at Sheriff Center

The problem is that the County Board of Supervisors already signed off on this Annual Report last Tuesday, after much discussion about the merit of doing so.     Sheriff Hart asked the Board of Supervisors to approve the Annual Report required by AB 481 before the public hearing, claiming that it would be too confusing to have the public review a Draft, and bring that to the Board afterwards.

Members of the local ACLU raised objection, and also provided interesting information that questioned the credibility of “independent auditor” Michael Jenico, instead asking for an audit by local citizens.  People also disagreed with Sheriff Hart’s claim that M4 automatic rifles are “standard issue”, and thereby were not included in the Annual Report, and also that the Department has 24 drones, but claims there is no maintenance cost.

The Board ultimately voted unanimously (with Supervisor Koenig absent) to approve the Annual Report, but Supervisor Hernandez asked Sheriff Hart to consider doing things differently next year.  “I’ll consider it” said Sheriff Hart, “but I can’t make any promises.”

Click on Item #14 on May 9 Board of Supervisor meeting agenda

HOW MUCH SHOULD PUBLIC INFORMATION COST?

The First Amendment Coalition (FAC) sent out some shocking news and some great news last week.

Mendocino County tried to charge one local journalist $84,001.22 to respond to a Public Records Act request.  That County’s staff claimed it would take 2,139 hours, costing $67,145 to locate records revealing details of government workers use of the disappearing messaging app Signal and another estimated 534 hours, costing $16,900 to assemble the responsive records.  The County wanted the full amount paid up front.

Lawyers for the FAC and ACLU told the Mendocino County Board of Supervisors that No law authorizes counties to impose fees for locating, reviewing or redacting public records.” and informed them legal action was likely. Journalists and community members also pushed back, claiming the charges were illegal, effectively rendering the California Public Records Act ineffective.

“The Board of Supervisors in Mendocino County voted to repeal its local law, less than a year after adopting it as a purported cost-savings measure.” reported the FAC.

Whew!

But hang on! The FAC reported “While Mendocino County’s ordinance has fallen amid community outcry, fees like these remain a problem elsewhere.  Research by FAC and ACLU identified seven other counties—Los Angeles, Shasta, Siskiyou, Calaveras, Tuolumne, Santa Cruz, and Ventura—that passed local ordinances purporting to give them the authority to impose fees on the public for staff time spent on responding to requests.”

Here is the link to making such requests, and for seeing some responsive documents of other requests

I often have trouble opening the responsive files, but staff is helpful when I let them know of the problems.

A few years ago, the Board of Supervisors approved charging $27 for a USB stick when used for responsive Public Records Act request files.   Soquel Creek Water District charges a minimum of $120.00 for requests including correspondence, and further hourly charges at that $120 rate for anything over one hour.  They claim that is what their contractor requires.  Hmmmm….  I have notified the First Amendment Colition (FAC), and hope you will, too, if you have had problems with trying to obtain public information from local government and quasi-governmental agencies or told you have to pay large amounts of money to do so.

[FAC website]

Remember, it was via a Public Records Act request that Lookout Santa Cruz journalist Mr. Chris Neely brought to light the County’s decades-long violations of the Brown Act by holding secret City Selection Committee meetings at restaurants,  nominating various people for important positions on powerful commissions, such as the Coastal Commission.

NISENE MARKS STATE PARK ENTRANCE IS SINGLE-LANE 

Visitors to Nisene Marks State Park in Aptos can once again drive further into the Park on Aptos Creek Road, but the winter storm toll on the road is evident.  Let’s hope State Parks can repair the shoulders to accommodate fire engines and ambulances quickly and safely responding while other traffic (foot and bicycle, included) has room to get out of the way.  By the way, Aptos Creek Road is about the same width in many areas as the new Rail Trail the RTC is planning for the area.

This area of Aptos Creek Road should be barricaded to keep people from going over the edge, just as State Parks did nearby with the orange pylons and sandbags you see in the background, and below.

This area approaching the hairpin curve crossing Mangels Creek is where the road narrows to single lane traffic.  Below, you can see that the guard rail at the Mangels Creek crossing is damaged, and would do nothing to prevent a night-time bicyclist from crashing into the Creek at this hairpin turn.

Please contact State Parks if you feel this busy entrance into and out of Nisene Marks State Park needs more attention for public safety and emergency responders.

Public Safety Superintendent Mr. Gabe Mckenna gabriel.mckenna@parks.ca.gov

LEARN ABOUT HOW YOU AND YOUR HOME CAN SURVIVE WILDFIRE

Attend the free outdoor public educational event on June 4 at the Temple Beth El (3055 Porter Gulch Rd., Aptos) 1:30pm-4:30pm to learn from many fire and professional agencies about preparing for responders, home hardening concepts, fuel reduction resources, and fire insurance.  For more information, contact Nancy Yellin <nlyellin@comcast.net>, who has organized this great event with help from FireWise Neighborhoods of Viewpoint, Cathedral-Redwood, North Trout Gulch-Fern Flat, and Porter Gulch.

WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT?

The Aptos Village Project Phase I is what you see in Aptos now.  Many of the retail areas are empty, but Mentone’s restaurant seems to always have a good crowd.  While the New Leaf Market, owned by a large off-shore conglomerate, is busy, and the historic Apple Barn is safe for now, the paint is peeling and nearly all of the pervious asphalt areas have been cordoned off and dug up, for “Cleaning”, thereby reducing parking significantly.

In one case, a retail wine business and tasting room has been allowed to build outdoor seating over an area that removes two parking spaces that were ordered by Judge Paul Burdick to be provided when the We Are Aptos group sued Swenson and the County in 2016 for many losses of common area (aka, parking).

The County of Santa Cruz has thrown Barry Swenson Builder a financial life raft by leasing one of two prime retail areas for the MidCounty Safety Center and County Supervisor Zach Friend’s office.  Supposedly, it is now staffed again, but who would know it is even there, when there are no signs at the street level to publicly identify its existence?

So, Barry Swenson Builder may be building steam to begin the Phase 2 and Phase 3 in the area shown below.  The monstrous faded yellow earthmover equipment that has sat idle and rusting among the weeds and decrepit storage containers and mobile construction office is now gone, and most of the waist-high weeds have been cut.  What remains to be seen is whether the excavation necessary for foundations and drainage of the multiple three-story development will reek of diesel, remnant of the contamination that occurred there in 2016 when Swenson crews ripped out an Underground Storage Tank and flooded the area with some nasty petrochemical stuff, likely Bunker Oil from the Lam Mattison Apple Dryer facility there.

Wouldn’t it be ever-so-much better to cap this area with soil and bring back the world-famous Post Office Bike Jumps and Pump Track for the youth in our Community?  I do.  Please let me know if you have someone in mind that might be willing to finance a buy-out from Swenson and rebuild the Bike Jumps in Aptos Village.

LIVE OAK LIBRARY IS A PEACEFUL PLACE

I spend a lot of time at public libraries, and really appreciate them.  The Live Oak branch is my favorite for many reasons, one of which is the Corcoran Lagoon adjacent.  Last week, a pair of Canadian Geese brought their hatchlings up to wander about.  It was beautiful.

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND A PUBLIC HEARING, ASK QUESTIONS AND EXPECTANSWERS.

DO JUST ONE THING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers, Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

GREY HAYES.

May 15

MAY’S FLOWER

Each month of 2023, I’ve been describing a flower that does a good job of representing that month. I have purposefully been picking plants that are predictably in peak flower during the month I assign them. And, I’ve been choosing flowers that you’ll have to search for, a kind of treasure hunt. You’ll probably need to work to see Jonny-tuck, a kind of owl’s clover which has a lot of interesting things about it.

Odd Names, As Usual

Both of the common names of this species make little sense. I can find nothing about the shape of the flower that is reminiscent of a Jonny-tuck, friar tuck, or any such tuck at all. I guess it’s just my bad tuck. Also, this species isn’t a clover at all – it is not in the same plant family and doesn’t have anything resembling the lucky four, but mostly 3, leaflets. By the way, I think that there are far too many ‘inside jokes’ and confusing back stories in the realm of plant enthusiasts…I fear that these trends tend to more alienate than attract others to learning more about plants. Maybe one day I’ll create a common name registry for plants much as there is for birds…that might help.

Jonny-tuck (Triphysaria eriantha ssp. rosea) has a sister named ‘butter and eggs,’ (Triphysaria eriantha ssp. eriantha) which grows a bit inland. The butter and eggs name makes more sense: it has yellow and white flowers as opposed to the white fading to rose flowers of Jonny-tuck.

Paintbrushes

Many people are familiar with the showy perennial wildflower called Indian paintbrush. Jonny-tuck, along with other owl’s clovers, are relatives of Indian paintbrush. The ‘paintbrush’ name makes good sense: the narrow flower stalks look like they’ve been dipped in paint with colorful bristles sticking out. If I was in charge of plant names, I’d confer the name “paintbrush” on Jonny-tuck: perhaps it would best be called “white and rose annual paintbrush.”

Old Growth Prairie

We don’t know of a single plant species that is found only in old growth redwood forest in the Santa Cruz Mountains. It is easier for most people to recognize old growth redwood forest; recognizing old growth coastal prairie is another matter. There are probably dozens of plants found only in old growth coastal prairie, which is one of the top ten most endangered ecosystems in the United States. If we can recognize those species, then perhaps we can better protect the remaining old growth prairies.

Secondary Grasslands

After grassland has been converted to cropland and then abandoned to return to grassland, the original plant species composition never recovers. Something changes in those situations and some species can never return to their native homeland. Those types of previously tilled prairies are called ‘secondary grasslands’ in contrast to ‘primary grasslands’ better known as old growth prairie.

The French Connection

My grassland ecologist colleagues working in the super-plant-diverse prairies of Southern France have well documented the species impacts tilling for crops causes in old growth grasslands. Some of their study plots were last tilled hundreds of years ago. Those secondary grasslands have recovered many species, but still don’t support handfuls of other species. Those French ecologists classify the species that can live in previously tilled grasslands as ‘ex-arable’ species. They have a long list of old growth prairie dependent plants, as well.

An Indicator Species for Very Rare Prairie

As far as I know, this is the first proposal in print to classify Jonny-tuck, or any other California wildflower, as an old growth dependent grassland species. If I am correct, it will make it much easier to classify and then provide protection for the few remaining, very endangered old growth coastal prairies.

A high percentage of coastal prairies have been converted to cement: more than any other major ecosystem in the United States – 24%! The majority of the remaining coastal prairies are secondary grasslands, having been previously tilled. So, old growth coastal prairie may be the most critically endangered major (widespread) ecosystem in the United States.

Without indicator species like Jonny-tuck, we must rely on limited historical data, mostly difficult to interpret maps as well as aerial photos and topographical evidence of previous plowing. Maps and aerial photos can make places that were cut for hay look like crop land, but hayfields aren’t necessarily the same as the intensive tilling that turns old growth coastal prairie into secondary grassland.

Friend to Flowers

Besides being an indicator for old growth prairie, Jonny-tuck plays a very important role in protecting patches of prairie. This species, like all paintbrushes are parasites on their neighboring plants. A local scientist demonstrated a very closely related species parasitizing both the grasses and the wildflowers surrounding it, but only the grasses suffered a reduction in growth. So, Jonny-tuck probably helps to create the conditions that foster patches of wildflowers, protecting them from the non-native invasive grasses that threaten so many coastal prairie species.

What Next?

My normal monthly flower challenge for you: go out and find Jonny-tuck and document it on your iNaturalist account. This will help us start to map old growth coastal prairie, or at least provide the data to test my hypothesis.

If you find a patch, look carefully and note other co-occurring species that may also serve as old growth grassland indicators.

I was recently surveying for two very rare and endangered plant species. Both occurred in the vicinity of patches of Jonny-tuck: San Francisco popcornflower and Santa Cruz clover. You might find some really rare species near Jonny-tuck, too! If you do…let me know!

By the Way

Just because some coastal prairies are secondary grasslands does not mean that those areas should not be conserved. Those secondary grasslands are still coastal prairies and so still quite rare. Secondary coastal prairies support many prairie species, especially prairie-dependent wildlife including raptors, grasshopper sparrows, savannah sparrows, badgers, ground squirrels, and many more. We don’t yet know how many species we might be able to restore to secondary coastal prairie, but it is worth it to give many a try.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

May 13

#133 / A Look Out Lesson

The Mayor of Santa Cruz, Fred Keeley, is pictured above. The picture comes from a story in Lookout Santa Cruz, an online magazine that covers Santa Cruz County news. The Lookout article from which the picture was obtained is headlined, “Santa Cruz Mayor Fred Keeley will leave it to residents to figure out 2024 affordable housing bond.” Be aware that a ferocious paywall may well prevent non-subscribers from reading the article in full, though please give that link a click and see what you find!

For those who have been paying attention, it is no surprise that Mayor Keeley is deeply engaged in discussions about whether or not the city should place an affordable housing bond measure on the ballot next year. Keeley has long been a proponent of just such a bond measure, and in fact campaigned for Mayor on that basis.

A “bond measure,” as most of those reading this blog posting probably know, is a measure that, if passed by the voters, would authorize the city to borrow money (which means to incur debt) to be used for the purposes specified in the bond measure. The question for the voters would be whether or not the city should extend its fiscal borrowing power to raise money to be used for future affordable housing developments (and how, specifically, the borrowed money would be used).

What might seem surprising in the Lookout headline (for those who know Mayor Keeley and know about his commitment to an affordable housing bond), is the idea that the Mayor thinks it should be up to “residents” whether or not such a bond issue should be placed on the ballot next year – and what such a bond issue should contain. Mayor Keeley specifically campaigned for Mayor as someone who wanted to see such a bond measure placed on the ballot. Has Mayor Keeley become less committed? What’s going on?

If you can penetrate the Lookout paywall, and read the entire article, the mystery of the headline is solved. The Mayor has learned that if he and the City Council vote to put a bond measure on the ballot themselves, such a measure will only pass if there is a two-thirds affirmative vote by the voters. On the other hand, if “residents” place the measure on the ballot, by collecting enough signatures to qualify an initiative measure, then only fifty percent of the voters, plus one, will have to vote “yes” in order to put city taxpayers on the hook for whatever borrowing is specified.

Because borrowing money with a bond issue pledges that future city revenues will be spent to pay back those who loaned the city money for the activities specified in the bond measure, passing a bond issue potentially deprives the city of its ability to meet other needs in the future. In other words, there is a serious tradeoff involved. That is the reason that state law requires a greater than simple majority vote to make such a commitment – a 2/3 vote, in fact. State law is intended to make sure that city voters really want to make the commitment, since borrowing money for specific purposes, as defined in the bond measure, can lead to real fiscal problems down the road. If tax revenues fall, or if there are new and unanticipated challenges, the city may not have the fiscal flexibility that it otherwise would have had.

Using an initiative measure to place a bond issue on the ballot makes it much easier to pass. That is what leaving it to “residents” does, and I am betting that this, not a reduced commitment to the bond measure, is what has motivated the Mayor’s recent statement to Lookout. The Santa Cruz Sentinel, by the way, has also covered this story, in its Thursday, May 11th issue. The Sentinel also makes clear that having “residents” sponsor an initiative measure can eliminate the need for a two-thirds vote.

There are few issues that have a higher priority for city voters than producing more affordable housing. Still, it is important for voters to know what is really going on. If the Mayor and City Council don’t take official action, themselves, to place an affordable housing bond measure on the ballot, but seek to facilitate a ballot measure by “residents” (which will certainly include those developers and builders who will get a good share of the bond money if the bond measure is approved), the main motivation for handling the bond measure in that way will not be a desire to “let the residents decide.” The main reason will be to make it easier to get an authorization for city borrowing with a lesser affirmative vote than would otherwise be required under state law.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

May 15

WE’RE HAVING SOME FUN NOW WITH A FOXIFIED CNN

The residue from CNN’s Trump Town Hall is still raining down on us from his volcanic spewing of b.s. For those who were unfortunate enough to have watched this remake of a Jerry Springer Show it was simply a replay of the Orange Menace’s vulgar jokes, repetitive lies, and ego-spouting malevolent demagoguery…what did CNN expect to be informative or monumental about this irrelevant disservice to the journalism of political integrity? The Wednesday town hall featured our twice-impeached, once indicted, coup-promoting former president and a studio mob of 250 hand-picked hooting and hollering MAGATs who enjoyed every insult and disparaging remark against victim and “whack-job” E. Jean Carroll, and even calling host Kaitlan Collins “nasty” when she tried to control his now well-rehearsed runaway blathering. He has now repeated his complaint about the ‘stolen election of 2020’ so many times he believes the lie to be true, saying, “I think that, when you look at that result and when you look at what happened during that election, unless you’re a very stupid person, you see what happens.” Got that, all you stupids? A questioner in the audience asked, “Will you suspend polarizing talk of the election fraud during your run for president?” Trump answered with a “yes” as he continued with most of his time whining on the same tired subject of victimhood. The Lincoln Project reminds us that, “Trump is no victim. The justice system isn’t targeting a political opponent. They’re targeting a criminal.”

Tom Nichols, in the Atlantic, writes that Americans need to see more of Trump, believing he is an existential menace to American democracy, and that those independent voters who will decide the next election will develop “Trump exhaustion”…the more the better. The MAGA base can’t get enough of him and Tom feels that group has met its saturation point so what does it matter to keep throwing them more red meat. Unfortunately, their kind will outlast The Don and his immediate band of crooks. Calling Trump a “quivering bag of weird verbal and physical tics,” once he gets rolling it’s like standing near a box of cheap bottle rockets as he tosses a lighted match inside. After the salvo of noise, misfires, duds, and smoke passes, all that’s left is stinky air. And that is what interviewer Collins was left with as she tried to interact with the shouting, finger-pointing, out of control, irrational provocateur, even though she was chosen because she knew Trump and has a history of right-wing media history – hardly objective journalism. After the critical furor began, Trump commented that Collins “wasn’t exactly Barbara Walters.” It only took a bit over an hour for CNN’s reputation to take a major hit as it cheapened journalism, undermined our political process and bashed one of their rising stars into her next gig as the weather-girl on local tv in Boondocks, Mississippi.

Aldous J. Pennyfarthing writes on Daily Kos, “I’m not much of an interviewer, and I don’t really like being confrontational in face-to-face situations, but my first follow-up to Trump would have been, ‘Ah, so I see you wore your Pol Pot Underoos today, Donny.’ Because the only way to deal with a ridiculous, scornful person is with ridicule and scorn. Of course, CNN’s Licht has gone on record as saying that Trump’s odiousness needs to be put on full display, though it goes without saying we’d have gotten the gist if they’d just wheeled him around the studio for seventy minutes in a Hannibal Lecter mask.”

Intended or not, the town hall was catered to Trump and his campaign, seventy minutes of prime time – that we’ll never get back – devoted to lies, debunked conspiracy theories, a history re-write, accompanied by the standing ovations and cheering attendees egging him on to sling even more slime, with Kaitlin Collins unable to ward off his onslaught…no conversation, inadequate questioning as he steamrolled her. Indeed, Nichols calls it a “foreordained train wreck,” and CNN’s producers had to know what would result. So is CNN trying to corral the MAGA community now that Tucker Carlson has been fired by Fox News, now with a more relaxed approach toward Trump? The new weather-girl may have an assistant in the person of Anderson Cooper, who attempted to justify his employer’s fiasco by chastising critics about “staying in their silo” and not paying attention to Dorito Mussolini’s lies, insults, defamations, and incitements to violence. Cooper was immediately assailed from all fronts for asking voters to exit the silo and climb into Trump’s bunker. CNN is probably still cataloging all the tweets, texts and emails condemning Coop, and CBS is getting a heavy dose of the same asking ’60 Minutes’ to drop his occasional segments. We are adults, Anderson, and have no need to be scolded for not watching, or being critical, of such trash on CNN!

Other notables have made comments, such as a tweet by Speaker of the House Pro-tem and GOP-VP-candidate-hopeful, Marjorie Taylor Greene, who called Trump to praise him for his performance, calling it “outstanding,” while claiming that they “laughed and laughed” on the phone as they discussed his town hall outing. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweeted that CNN “should be ashamed of themselves” in part because they had facilitated “a public attack on a sexual abuse victim.” Trump’s misogyny was transparent and jaw-dropping, while the approval of the crowd was spine-chilling. Steve Bannon called the event “the humiliation of the mainstream media.” The Onion reported “With critics calling the former president’s highly anticipated town hall a ‘disgrace for all involved,’ Donald Trump was widely condemned Thursday for giving a platform to CNN.” Even conservative columnist, Marc Thiessen, says if this was a preview of the coming campaign, then get ready for four more years of Joe Biden. He terms it as a “three-alarm dumpster fire for the GOP which needs this wake-up call.” Jon Stewart concluded that he “learned nothing about Trump and his most ardent supporters I haven’t known since 2016” but learned “a lot” about CNN.

Learning a lot about CNN, originates with CNN’s corporate overseer Warner Brothers Discovery, Inc., whose CEO is David Zaslav, who wants to reposition the network to be preferred by “everybody…Republicans…Democrats.” Zaslav’s motivation is John Malone, a multibillionaire cable magnate who orchestrated the merger of Discovery and CNN, who identifies as a ‘libertarian,’ though he moves in rightwing Republican elements. Noteworthy is the fact that in 2005 he held 32% of the shares of Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, is a board member of the libertarian think-tank, Cato Institute, and in 2017 donated $250,000 to Trump’s inauguration. Chris Licht, CNN’s chairman and CEO began his tenure by cancelling Brian Stelter’s commercially successful Sunday show, ‘Reliable Sources,’ a fountainhead of intelligent criticism of Fox News and right-wing sources, and the rightward plunge of the GOP. Licht told the CNN staff to stop referring to Donald Trump’s “big lie” which he felt was a Democratic party argument, while favoring “straight news reporting” along with more conservative guests. Stelter, on his last show, said, “It’s not partisan to stand up for decency and democracy and dialogue. It’s not partisan to stand up to demagogues. It’s required. It’s patriotic. We must make sure we don’t give platforms to those who are lying to our faces.” Right on, Brian! After Wednesday’s Foxified town hall debacle featuring the basket of deplorables, we can dismiss CNN’s having the public’s trust as an unbiased news source after its attempt to normalize candidate Trump’s behavior and feeding this cancer on our democracy.

Chris Licht reportedly told Trump, “Have fun!” as he took the town hall stage, and Donny promised a boost in CNN’s ratings. Licht called it “making news,” believing America was “well served” because we got “answers” – toxic throughout. Bocha Blue on Palmer Report says, “The Washington Post has a masthead problem, proclaiming that ‘Democracy Dies in Darkness,’ but we should agree that it is being choked to death in the plain light of day. The stranglers are America’s political and media elites – one group lies for power, the other lies for money. Together, they are ‘having fun’.” Licht laid into media reporter Oliver Darcy for a critical assessment of the Trump disaster, writing, “It’s hard to see how America was served by the spectacle of lies that aired on CNN Wednesday evening.” Darcy was immediately summoned to a meeting with CNN’s suits, who told him he needed to be more “dispassionate in his coverage,” and that he was too emotional. But, he stood by his output and will likely see Licht escorted out the door for his involvement in this firestorm. Blue says Licht has to go or there is no CNN – just a cold, bloodless, robotic echo chamber for ratings. Aldous J. says Licht appears to be trying to woo MAGA conservatives away from Fox News, ‘Bonanza’ reruns, and the clammy stack of Reader’s Digests piled next to their basement toilets.

Karma may have entered the scene in Iowa over the weekend, where both Trump and Ron DeSantis had scheduled events for pressing the flesh of the electorate, and heralded as a clash of the titans. A Des Moines outdoor rally for Trump had to be cancelled as tornado threats were announced, likely not so much for crowd safety, but because the Grifter Bunch was afraid valuable cash and checks contributed would be lost to the winds. DeSantis on the other hand, having less support at this juncture had smaller venues to attend, so was able to sneak around weasel-like without encountering The Orange Menace. One Twitter critic posts that DeSantis always looks guilty, as if he had just stolen PeeWee Herman’s bike.

Der Orange Gropenfuhrer, being upset at the brouhaha over his town hall and unable to stir the base in Iowa, joylessly celebrated Mother’s Day on his Truth Social media site by posting, “Happy Mother’s Day to the mothers of the complete lunatics and maniacs who are part of the radical left…in particular the mothers, wives, and lovers of the radical left fascists who are doing everything within their power to destroy and obliterate our once great country.” No mention of his own mother, or Ivana, Ivanka, Marla or Melania – just his admonition to “please make these complete lunatics and maniacs kinder, gentler, softer, and most importantly smarter.” We have to admit he has given us a more complete education for the past eight years, no?

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “Snakes”

“If you see a snake, just kill it – don’t appoint a committee on snakes”.
~Ross Perot

“Always carry a flagon of whiskey in case of snakebite and furthermore always carry a small snake”.
~W. C. Fields

“I’m one of those people who snake through the crowd, keep my head low. I’m not looking for attention”.
~Julian Lennon

...

I saw that the quotes were on snakes, so I thought I’d follow suit this week…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

May 10 – 16, 2023

Highlights this week:

BRATTON…welcome to Santa Cruz sign, Ironsides and Raymond Burr, Chris Strachwitz, movies. GREENSITE… on the Wharf Master Plan is back, unchanged. SCHENDLEDECKER…taking a short vacation. STEINBRUNER…heritage redwoods, Aptos village parking, CalFire emergency reserves, dense housing, granny units. history fair 5/13. HAYES…the land we encounter. PATTON…Look at me. MATLOCK…return to brazile, blurry memories, blurry photos, radioactive mickey. EAGAN…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week, on bees. QUOTES…”BEES”

...

MARK ABBOTT MEMORIAL LIGHTHOUSE, May 5, 1967. Mark Abbott was killed in a surfing accident on February 28 1965. His parents Chuck and Esther Abbott who did a lot for our community hired Milt Macken contractor to build this lighthouse. It became a surfing Museum in May 1986.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

...
Donate to BrattonOnline

BrattonOnline is a work of passion, with varying contributors around the core of Bruce (obviously) and Gunilla, who have been doing this since 2003. That’s 20 years!

We don’t get paid, but there are costs associated with running a website. If you want to pitch in, we are ever so grateful!!

This button takes you to a secure donation form.

...

DATELINE May 8

APPROACHING SANTA CRUZ. Shenanigans were pulled and plots were thick when the entrance to the “main gateway” at Ocean Street and Highway 17 were designed and erected a few decades ago.  Pros and cons flew everywhere and somehow that blue and gold dime store artifact got erected. Go here to take the survey and vote..

There’s more info about this by calling 831 420-5156 or emailing mccormic@santacruzca.gov

We’re gonna have to live with this decision for years, so let’s pitch in.

CHRIS STRACHWITZ. Just a very fond and saddening farewell to my long time fellow UC Berkeley student and close friend Chris Strachwitz. Chris was the force and founder of Arhoolie Records. Chris would take me to all sorts of nightclubs in Oakland and San Francisco to hear the newest and best of emerging jazz and folk music. We shared great respect and love for the music of George Lewis and his Ragtime Jazz band. He is already missed.

IRONSIDES. Big thanks to Tom Noddy and Jeff Wagner and more for pointing out that I erred in my movie review of the Perry Mason TV program stating that Raymond Burr once played Mason the lawyer while in a wheelchair. He didn’t, Raymond Burr played detective Robert T. Ironsides while in a wheelchair in the Ironsides series. When he was Perry Mason he lasted 9 seasons…it was a big hit.

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

THE DIPLOMAT. (NETFLIX SERIES) (8.2 IMDB) Rufus Sewell is enough of a reason to watch this series. Oddly enough it’s all about diplomats and diplomacy. Rufus was a diplomat and now he’s married to a new ambassador. She’s leading the international discussions about how to deal with some countries killing attack on a warship that killed 41 troops. Keri Russell is Rufus’ wife and the focal point and the diplomacy wears thin after the first three episodes. Don’t expect much excitement or relevance.

SILO. (APPLE TV) (8.4 IMDB).    David Oyelowo is one lead in this neatly structured science fiction puzzle. More than 10, 000 people are living in a giant underground silo. The silo has been there for over 140 years. They can see out one specific window…or can they?  Tim Robbins has a mysterious governing role to play here. It’s well done, puzzling and many episodes yet to be released.

TICKET TO PARADISE. (AMAZON PRIME MOVIE). (6.1 IMDB).   This gazillion dollar star flick has been out and around for over a year and even with George Clooney and Julia Roberts starring in it…it didn’t do well. The two of them were married once had a daughter and became bitter enemies. Now the daughter is living in Bali and wants to marry a handsome young local seaweed farmer. George and Julia try to stop the marriage and we get a fine view of Balinese culture and scenery. It’s diverting at best and gets more and more cheesy as the almost two hours drag on.

EXTRAPOLATIONS. (APPLE TV) (5.9 IMDB) This is eight separate stories, very separate movies, centering on the earth and how the universe will change our lives as a result of the nearly infinite changes to the earth. Actors including Meryl Streep, Tobey Maguire, Forest Whitaker, and Heather Graham all have small roles portraying humans whose lives are changed in the thirty three years that’s highlighted. Serious and well done, but few laughs.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

SHOWING UP. (DEL MAR THEATRE MOVIE).(7.2 IMDB).     It’s odd to see Michelle Williams without her cutesy blond short cut and dimples but she plays a very plain young woman sculptor in this baffling look into a sculptor’s daily life. No real drama except what we imagine in seeing the relationship between the one foot tall sculptures and the artist herself. Mostly boring especially if you know any or many clay workers.

POLITE SOCIETY. (DEL MAR THEATRE MOVIE).   It’s a British film about two Pakistani sisters and their struggles to get through a marriage ceremony. Corny, trite, full of martial arts and way overused comic plots that haven’t been funny in decades. The almost perfect would be groom/doctor secretly plans on cloning and the movie goes on and on…don’t go.

GHOSTED. (APPLE TV MOVIE) (5.8 IMDB).   Chris Evans and Ana de Armas headline this way too cute comedy /romance. She’s a secret spy and Adrien Brody does manage to add some viable screen time. It’s all been seen and screened many times before and the would be plot escaped me just moments after it finished.

CITADEL. (AMAZON PRIME SERIES) (6.5 IMDB).   Stanley Tucci is who and what you’ll watch in this action drama. A huge train wreck starts it off and it’s all an unbelievable trek into supposedly competing spy groups and their past, present and future targets. It has every cliché we’ve seen in spy movies for nearly 100 years

PERRY MASON. (HBO SERIES) (7.6 IMDB).   If you’re old enough to remember chunky but brilliant Raymond Burr as Perry forget all that. This skinny Perry Mason is a defense attorney in Los Angeles 1932 and there’s a savage murder of a child on the Angel’s Flight railway. John Lithgow is Mason’s friend and foil and Erle Stanley Gardner is the author of course. Look a likes like Aimee Semple McPherson and Fatty Arbuckle add fun and even depth. Diverting and worth viewing.

ROUGH DIAMONDS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.5 IMDB).    A Belgian movie that centers and holds on the ultra-orthodox Jewish community in Antwerp. The opening is terrifying and the conflicts between religion and culture and life in this century are very involving. Then there’s the world famed Antwerp diamond business which keeps the tension high. Don’t miss it.

C.B. STRIKE. (HBO SERIES) (7.9 IMDB).    A war vet Cormoran Strike is the weird name that this now one legged detective has. He’s got a partner and together they work to solve the murder of a beautiful model. J.K. Rowling is the secret author behind the C.B. Strike series. One character looks and acts like Santa Cruz’s own Maia Foreman.

...
May 8

THE RETURN OF THE WHARF MORPH PLAN

As most of the community is aware, the 2021 final decision and ruling by Judge Paul Burdick on Don’t Morph The Wharf! v City of Santa Cruz and City Council was in the former’s favor. The city was ordered by the judge to set aside its EIR and Wharf Master Plan except for aspects the community group did not contest under CEQA: namely a relocated entrance gate and east promenade expansion, as well as structural improvements to the road, pilings, garbage collection and accessible bathrooms. The group reserved the right to address the shortcomings of the gate relocation to the CA Coastal Commission (CCC). Neither the Wharf Master Plan nor EIR require CCC approval but some items, such as the gate relocation require a CCC permit.

As ordered by Judge Burdick, the city was to set aside the 2020 EIR and Wharf Master Plan. If subsequently the city decided to embark on a revised EIR then it was required to address the Judge’s Statement of Decision which was substantive, despite the city and city attorney’s efforts to minimize its import.

Apparently, the city has opted for believing the required revisions are minor and released its self-described Recirculated Partial Draft EIR on April 17th, 2023. The community has until May 31st to respond, with a city-imposed caveat, reprinted below:

During this period, reviewers may submit written comments on the Recirculated Partial Draft EIR related only to the revised EIR sections included in this document. All other sections of the Draft EIR, dated March 2020 and Final EIR, dated September 2022, remain unchanged and are not subject to recirculation or additional public comment. (highlight added)

Such limiting of public comment is not in order. The city cannot limit what the public can comment on in a revised EIR.

You can read the revised document here.

In this new iteration, nothing has changed from the 2020 Wharf Master Plan and EIR, with its three 40- feet tall buildings, including the much-despised Landmark building at the southern end blocking the views of Monterey Bay. These, plus the ill-advised western walkway, attached with new pilings below deck to the old west side pilings so that tops of heads, chatter and activity will transform the aesthetics of the historic pilings as shown in the photo and intrude on the serene view from the Wharf restaurants, let alone the ability of the migratory birds to return to their nests under the Wharf.

The 2020 Wharf Master Plan generated vigorous, vocal opposition from not only the Santa Cruz community but also from out of state Wharf visitors. One measure of the opposition was the 2500 signatures on the Don’t Morph the Wharf! petition gathered over a two- and- a half- week period. Another was the scores of letters to council and speakers at the hearings, united in their opposition to what was being proposed in the Wharf Master Plan. Unfortunately, the city Economic Development Department did not correct its inadequate EIR so the only recourse for the community was to collect resources and sue, which it did…and won. Since the city outsources CEQA legal representation, the cost to the public purse was arguably three quarters of a million dollars or more.

The most important part of preserving our historic Wharf is its structural integrity. Don’t Morph the Wharf! gave its support for the city to move forward on that front. It is not surprising, although disappointing that in this new EIR the city states it has no plans to address the garbage collection issue, the single most impactful issue in terms of maintenance costs and wear and tear on the Wharf according to their Engineering Report. While economic vitality is important, that goal can be achieved without turning the Wharf into a Pier 39. Not to mention the unstated agenda of changing the class make-up of the folks who fish from and enjoy the current Wharf.

So here we go again. I’ve read the new, truncated revised EIR. I’m no lawyer but I can spot the weak spots that leave the city open to another legal challenge. If the city were listening to the public, it would come back with a significantly scaled down Wharf Master Plan. That it didn’t, is a measure of how it views the public. Let’s show the city again what this public wants for its historic Municipal Wharf!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

May 8.

Joy’s taking a short vacation.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
May 8

FUTURE RTC PROJECT IN APTOS MEANS HERITAGE REDWOODS WILL GO AND APTOS VILLAGE PARKING WILL DISAPPEAR FOR LOCAL BUSINESSES

Last Thursday (5/4), I attended the in-person Public Hearing held at the Rio Sands Motel in Aptos to learn more about the proposed Highway One widening and construction of the Monterey Bay Scenic Coastal Rail Trail in Aptos Village.   It was very well-attended, but unfortunately, there was no formal staff presentation of the project, instead providing only multiple stations for people to visit, in an “Open House” format.  People were given handouts, and display boards to use for their own attempts to understand the Project and how it might affect them.  The din was so great, people had to yell to be heard, which only added to the cacophony, and no one but the immediate people benefitted by any of this haphazard information exchange.

One staff member even told me there was no Draft EIR available in the room to look through, but I was later shown one at the Environmental Station.

The Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) is the lead agency on this Project, due to begin construction in 2025.

Most of the heritage trees you see in this photo of Highway One Southbound in the Aptos Creek area would be removed.  Staff was not clear about the ratio of replacement trees to be planted, or even where they would be planted.

The 14′ wide Rail Trail in Aptos Village would require removing all the parking you see in front of the Bayview Hotel and Trout Gulch Crossing (where Caroline’s Thrift Store is located) as well as relocating the electrical box you see in the foreground that controls the railroad crossing arms for Parade Street.  This will exacerbate the existing parking problems in Aptos Village.

Here is the link to the documents for this Project

Public Comment is due by June 2 at 5pm.

Why would the Rail Trail will be connected to new stairs at Spreckles Drive, and also Aptos Village County Park…with lots of mature trees getting cut down to do that, when the access is easy and already available from nearby Aptos Creek Road?  Will removing the front area of the Bayview Hotel parking area cause it to be removed from the National Historic Registry?  Will the increase in unpermeable surfaces incraedase contaminated stormwater funoff into Aptos Creek, a known to have coho salmon migrations?  Couldn’t that stormwater be filtered for trash removal and groundwater recharge in local biofiltered ponds?

CALFIRE ONLY WANTS A ONE-YEAR CONTRACT WITH THE COUNTY FOR EMERGENCY RESPONSE 

Last week, the County Fire Dept. Advisory Commission (FDAC) held a Special Meeting in order to discuss and, essentially rubber stamp a one-year contract with CALFIRE to provide training for the County Fire Volunteers and provide emergency response to the rural areas during non-fire season.  Once again, members of the public were only allowed a total of 3 minutes to comment at the very start of the meeting on all items on the agenda and not on the agenda, and were  prohibited from commenting on the proposed one-year contract and County Fire Dept. Budget after the presentation had been made.

It was smoke and mirrors, and I feel the County General Services Manager Mr. Michael Beaton was not familiar at all with the material, and is not working in the public’s best interest to secure the best deal for property owners. CALFIRE Chief Nate Armstrong insisted there can be no three-year contract issued, which the public was told in 2020 was a cost-saving measure made possible by the new large fire tax County Service Area 48 Fire Dept. voters had just approved.

Mr. Beaton attempted to convince the Commissioners that CALFIRE’s willingness to reduce the number of months considered non-fire season months (which are determined by environmental conditions, not politically) from seven to five would be a tremendous cost savings, and make the smoke and mirrors all look fine when this comes to the Board of Supervisors next week in the Budget Hearings (being held very early and significantly shortened).

Take a look at County Fire Dept. website…a work in progress, with little information regarding finances:

Santa Cruz County Fire Department

Who knows why this is even posted, supposedly as the Budget?

It is my understanding that there will be a Regular FDAC meeting again later this month, on May 17 at 4pm.  Attend if you are able and ask for not only financial accountability but also a County Fire Dept. 2020 CZU Fire After Action Review to help plan for future emergency responses.  CALFIRE refused to do one…but the County Fire Volunteers deserve to provide their assessments of that disaster and how to improve things for next time.  Maybe next time, CALFIRE should not instruct the Volunteers to “just go home”.

SHOW THE COUNTY WHERE YOU THINK DENSE HOUSING SHOULD GO

Last week, the County Housing Advisory Commission (HAC) met to hear updates on the County’s progress to address housing issues.  I could not attend the meeting, but happened to see the staff member in charge, Ms. Tracy Cunningham, in the hallway later.

When I asked about the progress of the new Citizen and Stakeholder Committees meeting to make recommendations to the Planning Dept. and Board of Supervisors about where to re-zone for high-density affordable housing mandated by the State, she told me about the just-released online tool Balancing Act Consultants developed for greater public input on the issue.

See what you think of this tool.  I find it obfuscates real and meaningful public input because it gives little information about which “aged shopping centers” would be repurposed, gives little choice as to density levels, and neglects to include many potential areas that could be developed in smaller cluster housing units.

There is also no information as to how the County has determined there are parcels existing that could provide 2,934 new units, or why the County requires an additional 464 new units as a buffer to the 4,634 new units the State is mandating be built in the unincorporated area within the next eight years.

It also leaves out the rural areas completely.

Ms. Cunningham told me the two select Committees would be meeting soon in parallel, and presenting their recommendations to the Planning Commission in the near future.

Here are some other interesting informational issues presented to the HAC last week:

CURRENT HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES: APPLY NOW

New Affordable Rental Housing in Live Oak:

Bienestar Flyer, English

Bienestar Flyer, Spanish

Santa Cruz County ADU Incentives Program:

How to apply, in English 
How to apply, en español 

Contact Ms. Tracy Cunningham to receive notification of future HAC meetings: Tracy Cunningham tracy.cunningham@santacruzcounty.us

How will the County keep track of what is maintained as “affordable” housing???  Is this creating just another level of government?

Here is the link to the Planning Commission website, where all of this will land before going to the County Board of Supervisors this fall.

Note that two of the Commissioners (Allyson Violante and Andy Schiffrin) also serve as analysts to County Supervisors…do you think that is right?

COUNTY LAUNCHES NEW INCENTIVE PROGRAM TO HELP BUILD MORE GRANNY UNITS

Maybe the County hopes more property owners will add Accessory Dwelling Units (ADU) to their parcels and help provide housing…and not Vacation Rentals. Here is some information about a new incentive program that is partnering with a non-profit Hello Housing consultant team, paid for by the County that is now offering a program administrator called “HelloADU”.

The application states property owners need only submit information about their parcel to the design team to receive a list of what is and is not possible to do.  Applications close July 31, 2023.  Likely, Ms. Tracy Cunningham, mentioned above, can provide answers to your questions about this opportunity.

Here is what the County Planning Dept. recently sent out: Program applications are available in English and Spanish here for qualified homeowners in unincorporated areas of the county.

Does your firm provide design and/or contracting services, or any other services involved in ADU development in Santa Cruz County?  If so, please join our ADU professional registry here:
Professionals | HelloADU

To stay informed, subscribe to a newsletter here.

BRANCIFORTE LIBRARY RE-OPENS THIS SATURDAY 5/13
At long last, the Branciforte Library remodel is complete and the popular Seabright neighborhood library will re-open this Saturday, May 13.  The celebration activities are set for 10am-2pm.  I hope the map of Branciforte County is still posted there…not many people would otherwise know Santa Cruz County began as Branciforte County otherwise.

Branciforte Branch Library set for grand reopening after two years

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY HISTORY FAIR THIS SATURDAY, MAY 13 IN FELTON

Don’t miss this great opportunity to learn more about local history and why it matters to preserve our cultural resources. [Eventbrite ticket link]

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND A PUBLIC HEARING AND ASK QUESTIONS.  MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers, Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
May 8

THE LAND WE ENCOUNTER

What if there never was any wilderness? What if the story of Adam and Eve is a myth about a legendary distant wilderness, before humans were human, before animals created homes?

What if the land we encounter has always been tended by humans?

And, what if wildlife, clean running streams, pollinators, badger and fish, all need us to do that tending?

How might that change your relationship with Nature? How might that change your notions of the importance of stewardship for Mother Earth?

In My Travels

In my travels to jungles to experience Earth’s biodiversity, I find the handiwork of humans, even deep in parks. In the Andean cloud forest, on the sides of Machu Pichu, the fog clears, and the bright sun reveals the corduroy of ancient agricultural terraces across impossibly steep slopes for miles around. A guide points to hidden complex irrigation systems that kept these farmed terraces watered. On one such hillside, I discover oca plants, Oxalis tuberosa, with their buttery sweet starchy roots; these were as important a food to the Inca as potatoes. Still they hang on.

In the mountains overlooking the Caribbean on Costa Rica’s coast, I followed red and yellow variegated leaves through dense thickets after passing through a tropical-tree shaded cacao plantation. We discover a mango tree and then a patch of bananas, and then more seemingly wild forest. Along this variegated leaf-marked trail, we find a couple rubber trees scarred from tapping 50 years ago. Finally after 6 hours of hiking, the crow of a rooster, the barking of a handful of dogs, and a clearing announces my arrival at an Indian outpost, the closest one to ‘town.’

A little North, on Belize’s low coastal plain, I am guided to ‘wild’ cacao plants deep in the rainforest. It takes hours of blazing hot, sweat drenched bug-bothered hiking through dense forest to get to the first few cacaos. Along the way, on the river floodplain in a fallen tree light gap, I find diverse hot pepper plants, some with blindingly hot spherical fruit, some elongated and a little sweeter. The hill in the distance is being explored as a jungle-covered pyramid and archeological site. A giant ceiba tree we pass is cherished by the local Mayans as a bridge between the spiritual and physical worlds.

Back In the Santa Cruz Mountains

What if the expansive coastal prairies, hazelnut and buckeye groves, old growth redwood stands, patches of endangered Santa Cruz tarplant, and diversely colored iris clusters are not ‘natural?’ What if they are legacies of Native American stewardship? My eyes were once more open to that kind of encounter when traveling out of the country. Now, I am starting to look at my home landscape with the same kind of curiosity.

Coastal Prairies and Endangered Tarplant

Salads of clover greens, nourishing seed cakes of red maids, sweet roasted bulbs…the prairies grew a valued diversity of foods. Digging sticks were used to remove the bigger tasty bulbs, aerating propagation beds for the following year’s bulbs. Small groups carried baskets of seeds for restoration following correctly timed prairie fires. On a few occasions, tarplant seed traded from the Central Valley is carefully sprinkled into wetter parts of the coastal meadows in hopes of providing a favorite tasty and nutritious snack.

The earliest logbooks of Old World peoples traveling along this coast described extensive coastal prairies, all burned. For generations, the dominant cultural belief of the invading people denied Indians the advanced intelligence that they clearly practiced in tending the land. Kat Anderson, who researches and writes about the complexity and expansiveness of Native Peoples’ land care, is slowly helping our culture to overcome such ignorance. She and I still encounter well educated people who have difficulty believing that the native peoples ever managed entire landscapes like these expansive coastal prairies. None of those grasslands would have been open, grassy ecosystems without regular burning, tree and shrub removal, and a wealth of other tending practices that we still must (re-)learn. Check out any patch of coastal prairie that isn’t burned, grazed, or mowed, and you’ll see it closing in from trees and shrubs: it takes just a few years.

Those coastal prairies have many rare native annual wildflowers; Santa Cruz tarplant is an especially endangered species that is barely hanging on in a few last places. Tarplants produce protein rich seeds, a staple food of the indigenous peoples of California who developed efficient techniques for harvesting large numbers of the seeds involving specialized harvesting and tote baskets. The Santa Cruz tarplant is a recently speciated taxon, a species that evolved over just the last 12,000 years – a time frame allowing for native peoples to have played an important role in its creation.

A crowd working with State Parks and the Central Coast Prescribed Burn Association, including members of local tribes, walk drip torches, starting a blaze through the grassland at Wilder Ranch. Needlegrass stands proliferate. 5th generation ranchers guide cattle through pasture gates, tinker with water troughs and maintain fences. The next spring there are immense stands of lupines, native clovers, sheets of white popcornflower, and patches of Santa Cruz tarplant.

How is it important to you that we have coastal prairies? Do you enjoy the soaring of hawks and eagles across the Monterey Bay? Are the stunning poppy displays this spring inspiring? Have you considered that prairies can help slow the spread of catastrophic wildfires, making them less intense and dangerous?

Hazelnut and Buckeye Groves and Iris Gardens

Cracking the hard shells from hazelnuts in midsummer revealed a smooth pale nut: roasted or raw, it was a valued delicacy. The second year after burning an individual hazelnut bush, the long flexuous stems are now ready for making baskets or fish traps. Hazelnut groves must have been replanted and tended, some bushes for nuts, some for baskets. Nearby were similarly tended buckeye groves, producing nuts that were leached of toxins and ground into flour on the same grinding stones used for acorns. But, acorns were less predictable with some years yielding poor crops.

In the understory of oaks, buckeye, and hazelnut were mats of native iris plants. Each spring, vast displays of iris flowers were picked to decorate costumes for spring ritual dances. The best colored iris plants were marked and propagated the following winter. Iris beds responded well to periodic low intensity ground fires, throwing up many more blossoms and longer leaves that were a favorite for making twine and rope.

Nuts! When I find hazelnut and buckeye, if I look around enough, I’ll find remnants of Indian camps or village sites. Dark soil pitched up from gophers reveals flakes of abalone and clam or trail/road clearing reveals some flakes of worked chert. I have planted both species: they aren’t difficult to grow. Once established, they don’t seem to die. Our hedgerow of hazelnuts was only 10 years old when the 2020 fire swept through and roasted them. The following year, those hazelnut bushes rebounded vigorously; 3 years later, they are bigger than ever. This is the first year that they will make nuts. Almost all of the buckeye trees in the CZU Lightning Complex Fire footprint now have 6′ tall new stems; they will flower and make nuts in a few more years.

That 2020 fire cleared the ground for a resurgence of native iris. People throughout Bonny Doon have been reporting a surprising array of flower colors, including unexpected blues, emanating from what is supposed to be a single species (Iris fernaldii).

A Western gray squirrel forages under the canopy of an ancient hazelnut grove for one of the very few nuts produced this year. The hazelnut bushes have few leaves and few stems, the shade from the dense, young Douglas firs too much for their liking. At the base of a nearby bank, piles of buckeye fruits lie among dry leaves. The forest floor is criss-cross strewn with dead branches from the windy winter, adding dangerously to the fuel load for future wildfires. Iris leaves poke up between this array of cast off branches, a single iris seed pod rattles in the afternoon breeze.

Old Growth Redwood

It took special attention to burn understory of the groves of giant redwoods. After the fires, prized morels sprung up in the spring to be followed by Prince mushrooms in the summer. The peaceful trees provided shade and peace in the hot summer. The towering trees sometimes lost easily gathered branches for firewood.

Redwoods appear in the pollen record of a local lake near Big Basin State Park around 12,000 years ago. This is the time that the native people were tending the land with fire. In the wake of their fires, the bare soil would have provided the right conditions for redwood seedlings to establish, but from where did those seeds blow? Redwood seeds do not travel far on their own. Over the last two thousand years, native peoples burned the redwood forests every 4-6 years. This was often enough to burn up the thick duff and branches while keeping the understory more open, without crowding shrubs and small trees that could add to the danger wildfires posed to the ancient trees.

Across the scar of the CZU Lightning Complex Fire, a few people struggle to clean up the fuels around the remaining redwoods. They hope to save the remaining big trees from the next wildfire, now more dangerous than ever from the immense fuel loading of hundreds of fire-killed trees. Meanwhile, prescribed fires are beginning to be lit in the understories of redwoods once again.

Reflections

If you believed in wilderness before reading this, did I change your thinking about how you see this landscape? Do you believe that humans are responsible for our diverse prairies, for Santa Cruz tarplant itself, for forming groves of hazelnuts and buckeye, for creating iris beds and a diversity of iris flower colors and for stands of old growth redwood? If you are not convinced, what evidence would you need to change your point of view? Who would you trust to provide or deliver that information? Please let me know.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

May 6

#126 / Look At Me!!!

The picture above is from the March 28, 2023, edition of The Wall Street Journal. Ann-Marie Alcántara, in her article on “Why People Are Getting More Disruptive At Concerts,” tells us that:

Concert season is in full swing, with Taylor Swift, Beyoncé and other artists dominating calendars in the coming months. But a new villain is hurting the experience for many: superfans seeking five minutes of social-media fame.

Homemade signs, screaming teenagers and bouncing beach balls aren’t new to concerts. What has changed is that, largely thanks to TikTok, any moment of a concert can go viral. More fans are trying to force that moment to happen with wild shenanigans, annoying noises or demands on artists to play unusual songs.

That desire to create a quick piece of content to share online has become a buzzkill for everybody else at the show.

I think that there is a human desire – in fact, a genuine human need – to “be seen,” to be recognized. We can validate the fact, and importance, of our own existence by the recognition we get from others. I have no claim to any great expertise in psychology; however, I think that this is a well-recognized psychological truth. Our individual ability to function, and to succeed, depends, to some significant degree, to the fact that our existence and actions are “recognized” by others (and hopefully recognized in some “positive” way).

Is, however, the “recognition” we might receive “online,” on “the internet,” actually the kind of validation that can sustain and ultimately support us, fragile individuals that we are? Is TikTok really the road to the kind of recognition that we seek? That’s the question that came to my mind as I read Ann-Marie Alcántara’s article in The Wall Street Journal. Another article, in the next day’s edition of The Wall Street Journal, raised the question again. That article, “There’s Money Behind The Camera on TikTok,” suggests that the road to the kind of recognition that can sustain a person’s sense of self-worth may best be found “behind” the camera, not in front of it.

I want to suggest – and, remember, I make no claim for any expertise in psychology – that the kind of personal “validation” and “recognition” we need to maintain our sense of personal worth, thus freeing us to be creative and successful in whatever we seek to do, is best obtained by interactions with “real people,” in “real life,” doing “real things” that we, and others, believe are important.

My views about this, I hope, cause no surprise. I don’t advise looking for validation by creating “viral videos.” I recommend “talking to strangers” and getting involved, with others, in movements for social, economic, and political change.

This is just a suggestion!

Instead of “Look at me,” How about, “look at US!” Look what we’re doing, together, to change the world.

That could be pretty impressive! Working with others, to change the political realities that define the world in which we actually live, can provide a genuine sense of validation and self-satisfaction.

Take it from me. I am speaking from personal experience!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
May 8

RETURN TO BRAZILE, BLURRY MEMORIES, BLURRY PHOTOS, RADIOACTIVE MICKEY

Donna Brazile, chair of the Democratic National Committee in 2016, the year of Donald Trump’s presidential election, is telling Democrats to “wake up” in light of a new national poll showing President Biden’s approval ratings in a downward slide. A Washington Post-ABC News showed a 6% difference at the beginning of May compared to early figures in 2023, his job approval taking the hit. With inflation continuing to plague the economy only 18% in the poll ‘strongly approve’ his efforts.
Brazile also points to the poll figures which show the former president beating Biden by 6%, with a favorable preference of 44% to 38%.

“It’s sobering in the sense that the coalition that elected Joe Biden, with the historic numbers that we saw in 2020, that coalition right now is fragmented. That should concern them,” she said. Brazile cautioned the White House in commenting on the slow, low profile mode of the campaign, saying she has serious concerns about his ability to reach voters. “They’re still unable to get a real good, strong message to the American people not just on their accomplishments but where they want to take the country. And so while the Republicans are operating on fumes, the Democrats are operating on policies. If they are unable to make this campaign from the bottom up and talk to the people where they are, its’ going to be a struggle,” she added.

One Democratic strategist described Biden’s plan to do a “really subtle launch” which is a “reflection of the type of candidate he is, but also the stage of his life he’s in.” The launch video was to be a focus, getting over 12 million views, with an outreach to over 5,000 key stakeholders in the Biden coalition; the first week Biden met with donors, had campaign engagements with the Biden-Harris 2020 volunteer community, followed by a handful of public and campaign-related events. Press Secretary Jean-Pierre told reporters he’s had “internal meetings in the Oval Office to discuss issues that matter to the American people.” The campaign has yet to release any significant fundraising figures, which is probably concerning to Donna Brazile. 


Republican
frontrunner Trump is calling “Crooked Joe Biden’s” launch a disaster and hearing “crickets” about fundraising, suggesting that Biden can’t compete with his outstanding grassroots donors. Others in the GOP suggest Biden isn’t strong enough to hit the trail and do a big reelection event. “He launched. He didn’t do a rally. So they’re going to hide him,” said RNC Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel.

Democrats argue that there is no need for Biden to usurp Trump’s spotlight this early in the game, letting the Former Guy’s legal troubles get the attention they deserve. Just let Trump be Trump, as THEY say! Campaigning against an opponent clad in an orange jumpsuit is probably the easiest solution. After all, it is a reelection, no need for drama eighteen months out from an election without a sure opponent, so let the president be the president to show his relevancy to the voters…WE say!

On ‘The Warning with Steve Schmidt,’ Steve launches into CNN and its New Hampshire town hall interview, “either featuring or starring Donald Trump,” and questioning the validity of David Zaslav’s declaring it “the new CNN.” Schmidt goes on to say, “The distinction between featuring Trump in a town hall, and one starring him is not semantic. It is elemental. Should the town hall simply feature Trump then it is possible the new CNN will trend towards journalism. That would be good. If it stars Donald Trump, it would harken the renewal of a dismal partnership, and place CNN in a business arrangement with Trump along his shady axis of partnerships, including Saudi Arabia, LIV Golf, NewsMax, Fox News and Tucker Carlson. The distinction matters in a world in which Fox News has been exposed as the most corrupt news organization in American history. Beyond the moment to moment malfeasance, dishonesty, racism, xenophobia and gaslighting, Bret Baier, Rupert Murdoch’s hard news bard, has been unmasked. He is a conman, not a news man. He lies for profit. He misleads to please the fragile sensibilities of his radical audience. This is the model that CNN has been encouraged to pursue by one of America’s richest and most powerful men.” 

Steve points out that a few years ago, John Malone, the largest shareholder in Warner Bros. Discovery, made critical comments about CNN, and cited Fox News as a model the network might wish to follow, saying, “Fox News, in my opinion, has followed an interesting trajectory of trying to have news news, I mean some actual journalism, embedded in a program schedule of all opinions. And I think they’ve been relatively successful with a service like Bret Baier, and Brit Hume before him, that try to distinguish news from opinion. I would like to see CNN evolve back to the kind of journalism that it started with, and actually have journalists, which would be unique and refreshing.”

Schmidt asks,“What exactly is a new CNN, and what will it become? A departure from the reality show ethic would be in the public interest and an unalloyed societal good. Perhaps it will become a news network again. There is certainly a great deal of open space to pursue and amplify ethical journalism. This is among the most corrupt eras of American history. Muckraking is the antidote to the corrupt access model. Partnering with the powerful to communicate to the masses isn’t journalism. It is propaganda. Accountability against the public interest is what this moment requires. Can CNN deliver?” That will certainly be something to watch for after the Trump appearance!

And speaking of Trump appearances, he declined to show up to testify in his defense on the final day of the E. Jean Carroll trial, formally confirming his intent after being given a last chance deadline by the trial judge. The former misogynist/president had teased that he would be in the courtroom, will find it difficult to appeal the verdict which is unlikely to be in his favor, and his trying to run out the clock on all his trials simply isn’t working in his favor as he continues to lose appeal after appeal. Although under the law he will be able to appeal, Carroll isn’t in it for the money, only vindication, to have Prima Donald branded as a rapist…exactly what she wants.

The Don has continually insisted E. Jean “isn’t my type,” so why would he be attracted to her for any reason? Plus, he never met the woman…didn’t know who she is, blah-blah, so why is she doing this to him? Telling was his video deposition shown at the trial, recording when he was shown a photo picturing him with Marla Maples, his wife at the time, and E. Jean Carroll…in happier times. Asked to identify those in the photo, he identified Carroll as his wife…“not my type,” eh? Informed of his mistake, he offered, “picture is kind of blurry”NOT blurry, dude!

Yet another case of mistaken identity this week involved Senator Ted Cruz in his response to the announced candidacy for his seat by Texas’ US Representative Colin Allred, a former NFL player with the Tennessee Titans. Cruz immediately in a fundraising text to his supporters revealed news of Allred’s launch for his Senate seat, along with a photo of his competitor. Only problem being…Teddy Boy uploaded a photo of New York DA Alvin Bragg instead of Colin Allred. Was his face all-red in this faux pas? It certainly had huevos rancheros dripping down his chin, so it might be time for a quick one to Cancun…see if your daughter and her friends are up for some face-saving assistance, Mr. C!

In Fulton County Georgia’s criminal probe, headed by DA Fani Willis, we’ve learned that eight fake electors/co-conspirators in the attempt to overturn the election results in that state have agreed to flip evidence in return for immunity deals. This would seem to seal the deal against Donnie Dotard, but defeatist hysteria within the media want you to believe he is invincible, and one news outlet thinks these eight fake electors may not know enough to be relevant. However, immunity deals aren’t handed out frivolously, and somewhere within the investigation is revealed the process, and results, where useful information has been found.

Special Prosecutor Jack Smith is continuing quietly in his multi-pronged investigation into Trump’s criminality, and when former VP Mike Pence showed up to testify, Smith was in the room when it happened, indicating the importance of the testimony of one who was in the room when it happened in the Trump years. Bocha Blue’s name for Smith, ‘Wolfman Jack,’ indicates his belief that the prosecutor is as “tough as nails and wouldn’t know a cowardly moment if he saw it,” as he pursues his quarry, rarely missing in the chase. In the stolen documents case Smith has a Mar-a-Lago insider, probably several if the truth be known, who has testified along with photos regarding the storage and movement of the purloined documents boxes…The Don has to be trembling in his Gucci boots. And the Justice Department continues to sentence many of the key players from the January Insurrection, so things are moving, even as we await the Really Big Show.

Last week’s conviction of leader Enrique Tarrio and three other ‘Proud Boys’ of seditious conspiracy for their involvement in the J6 Insurrection should be an ominous sign for that ilk. The 1861 law states that “if two or more persons conspire to overthrow, put down, or to destroy by force the Government of the United States, or to levy war against them, or to oppose by force the authority thereof, or by force to prevent, hinder, or delay the execution of any law of the United States, or by force to seize, take, or possess any property of the United States contrary to the authority thereof, they shall be fined or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.” It was concluded that Tarrio was guilty of those crimes, conceding that his physical absence from Washington, DC was not a factor. Are you paying attention, Donnie Johnny T.? It is pointed out that prosecuting attorney Vincent Bugliosi, convicted Charles Manson of murder…nothing to do with seditious conspiracy, of course…even though he wasn’t at the scene of the Tate-Labianca murders, but his plans were carried out by his followers as he commanded. So, even though Trump wasn’t physically present in the Capitol building, defacing paintings and scribbling on random computer screens with his black Sharpie, there is precedent…an inevitability that the Former Guy is liable in the extreme with all of the insurrectionists acting in his name, and probably didn’t even know Enrique Tarrio existed.

In absentia, Trump raises his ugliness again, this time in the personage of Governor Ron DeSantis, who is seeking final approval of the Trump-era EPA’s condoning the use of radioactive phosphogypsum in Florida’s roads. Conservation groups across the Southeastern states are urging RonDe to veto the bill allowing ‘demonstration road projects’ to use the toxic byproduct of the fertilizer industry, which has accumulated one billion tons stored in 25 ‘gypstacks’ in Florida. These stacks are hundreds of acres wide and hundreds of feet tall…far more material than could be stored in the closets of Mar-a-Lago and could probably fill several notorious Florida sinkholes. The current Environmental Protection Agency prohibits the use of phosphate waste as it poses an unacceptable risk to road construction workers, public health and the environment. Florida’s Department of Transportation would be instructed to complete a feasibility study on use of this material with a short timeline and a completion date of April 1, 2024. “No environmentally conscious governor worth his salt would ever sign a bill into law approving roadbuilding with radioactive materials,” says Rachael Curran, attorney with People for Protecting Peace River. “Even the fast-tracked ‘study’ contemplated by this industry-sponsored bill would create harm because that involves a full-scale project that would have very real, very detrimental impacts to the environment and health of Floridians, especially road-construction crews.” One can’t help but think this might be a part of DeSantis’ revenge-factor thrust at Disney. In the meantime, it might be wise to stay off the roads leading to Disney World and its environs.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“BEES”

“Everything takes time. Bees have to move very fast to stay still.”
~David Foster Wallace.

“Bees do have a smell, you know, and if they don’t they should, for their feet are dusted with spices from a million flowers.”
~Ray Bradbury.

“Handle a book as a bee does a flower, extract its sweetness but do not damage it.”
~John Muir

...

We just got two beehives! You would not catch me dead doing this kind of stuff though, I am way too afraid of them! 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

May 3 – 9, 2023

Highlights this week:

BRATTON…UC unfair to students and workers, another May Day. GREENSITE…on west cliff opportunism. SCHENDLEDECKER…there’s no escaping plastic smog. STEINBRUNER…Highway 1 bike lanes, businesses into housing, grant $ and homeless, budget hearings, history fair in Felton. HAYES…Our snakes. PATTON…Only the lonely. MATLOCK…slippin’ and a-slidin’ through the court systems. EAGAN…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover WEBMISTRESS’…pick of the week. QUOTES…”The Universe”

...

FISHING ON THE SAN LORENZO RIVER. This was opening of steelhead season December 8, 1940. It’s over by Murray Street on East Cliff Drive.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE MAY 1

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA UNFAIR TO STUDENTS. Long time tech genius Patrick Casey sent this startling link and news about,The school pumped billions into a Blackstone real estate fund eager to evict tenants and jack up student rents in the midst of a major housing crisis”. https://www.levernews.com/the-university-of-california-bails-out-eviction-happy-private-equity/ . Read about how two of UC’s Board of regent’s members have ties to this Blackstone fund. Read even more about “the company and its executives spent $5.6 million to kill California ballot initiatives that would have expanded rent control in the state”. Also from Lever News…”UC’s pension system is fairly unique in that workers have no power over how investment decisions are made. All decisions are made by the regents, which are appointed by the California governor for 12-year terms’. It continues…” Effectively, University of California (UC) is funneling cash into privatized student housing and corporate landlords — doubling down on a controversial investment strategy that comes with a massive layer of fees and Wall Street profits — instead of doing its part to address a growing housing crisis, one that affects its students and employees.  Now, in a nearly unprecedented coordinated intervention, the university’s labor unions — representing 110,000 workers — have called on UC to divest itself not just from the university’s holdings in the Blackstone real estate fund, but all of the university’s $6.5 billion invested in Blackstone holdings’.

“Essentially UC is investing in a corporation that further drives UC’s own workers’ housing insecurity,” said Kathryn Lybarger, the President of AFSCME Local 3299, which represents blue collar and health care workers at the University of California. “The bottom line is that people’s housing should not be a basis for making a profit, especially when it’s a public institution like UC. We’re demanding they divest and it’s on the scale of divesting from South Africa in the ‘80s. We’re talking about housing as a human right, not as an investing opportunity.” The entire article in Lever news is well worth reading and I hope the above excerpts encourage you to get the rest of their reporting.

AN INTRODUCTION…Lever News used to be the Daily Poster and is run by some former Bernie Sanders advisors, check out the rest of their staff and articles. Read Lever News too and learn how Nancy Pelosi has worked for years to help the business of hospitals stop Medicare for all coverage!!

MAY DAY AND….??? Now that 420 doesn’t seem like a hugely popular day to celebrate some of us got to wondering why May Day is such a huge and even international holiday.

Sure it started legally with the beginnings of summer with a May pole and dancing with flowers. That was in Russia in the Roman Days. Germany celebrated Walpurgisnacht the night before May 1st. In the USA it was (and almost forgotten now) International Workers Day (Tom Scribner made a big deal out of it with an extra margarita at Lulu Carpenters). Santa Cruz needs to create another celebratory day…maybe to recognize that the tourists are coming in 30 days?

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

SHOWING UP. (DEL MAR THEATRE MOVIE).(7.2 IMDB). It’s odd to see Michelle Williams without her cutesy blond short cut and dimples but she plays a very plain young woman sculptor in this baffling look into a sculptor’s daily life. No real drama except what we imagine in seeing the relationship between the one foot tall sculptures and the artist herself. Mostly boring especially if you know any or many clay workers.

POLITE SOCIETY. (DEL MAR THEATRE MOVIE). It’s a British film about two Pakistani sisters and their struggles to get through a marriage ceremony. Corny, trite, full of martial arts and way overused comic plots that haven’t been funny in decades. The would be groom/doctor secretly plans on cloning and the movie goes on and on…don’t go.

GHOSTED. (APPLE TV MOVIE) (5.8 IMDB). Chris Evans and Ana de Armas headline this way too cute comedy /romance. She’s a secret spy and Adrien Brody does manage to add some viable screen time. It’s all been seen and screened many times before and the would be plot escaped me just moments after it finished.

CITADEL. (AMAZON PRIME SERIES) (6.5 IMDB). Stanley Tucci is who and what you’ll watch in this action drama. A huge train wreck starts it off and it’s all an unbelievable trek into supposedly competing spy groups and their past, present and future targets. It has every cliché we’ve seen in spy movies for nearly 100 years

PERRY MASON. (HBO SERIES) (7.6 IMDB). If you’re old enough to remember Raymond Burr in a wheelchair as Perry….forget all that. This Perry Mason is a defense attorney in Los Angeles 1932 and there’s a savage murder of a child on the Angel’s Flight railway. John Lithgow is Mason’s friend and foil and Erle Stanley Gardner is the author of course. Look a likes like Aimee Semple McPherson and Fatty Arbuckle add fun and even depth. Diverting and worth viewing.

ROUGH DIAMONDS. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.5 IMDB).   A Belgian movie that centers and holds on the ultra-orthodox Jewish community in Antwerp. The opening is terrifying and the conflicts between religion and culture and life in this century are very involving. Then there’s the world famed Antwerp diamond business which keeps the tension high. Don’t miss it.

C.B. STRIKE. (HBO SERIES) (7.9 IMDB).   A war vet Cormoran Strike is the weird name that this now one legged detective has. He’s got a partner and together they work to solve the murder of a beautiful model. J.K. Rowling is the secret author behind the C.B. Strike series. One character looks and acts like Santa Cruz’s own Maia Foreman.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

CHEVALIER. (DEL MAR THEATRE) (MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). A genuine period piece complete with gorgeous costumes about the almost totally unknown true story of Joseph Bologne a black violinist/composer who was Mozart’s contemporary. He was given the title of Chevalier de Saint Georges and served and performed under Marie Antoinette. It’s a bit much of typical Hollywood spectacle but it does help the world acknowledge the genius of this unknown musician/composer. Go for it.

DROPS OF GOD. (APPLE TV SERIES) (8.3 IMDB). A rather far-fetched story adapted from a manga (graphic novel) is about a wealthy wine collector who dies and leaves his gazillion dollar wine collection to the winner of a wine tasting. It’s his estranged daughter and a wine expert who must compete. Lots of wine talk and much delving into the lives of Dad, daughter, and the Japanese wine expert. Maybe if you really like wines you’ll savor this one…but no hurry.

RAIN DOGS. (HBO MAX SERIES) (6.8 IMDB).   An odd but well done dramedy that centers on a poor momma trying her best to raise her daughter when the world just seems against them. All involved are in the destitute poor world and just their struggles are well worth watching. It is however gross and crude in certain scenes but overall it’s a fine way to spend your time.

THE LAST THING HE TOLD ME. (APPLE TV SERIES) (7.0 IMDB)    If you’ve ever OR never been to the Sausalito house boat “city” this is a must see. Jennifer Garner heads the cast as a mom whose nicely behaved husband suddenly disappears from his failing tech business. So Mother Garner and the stepdaughter work hard to not just survive but to find out where Dad disappeared to. Excellent series so far!!

ALL THE BEAUTY AND THE BLOODSHED. (HBO MAX) (7.6 IMDB). A very detailed and well done documentary about the Sackler family. That’s the family who made millions if not billions from their Purdue Pharma Company that produced and sold OxyContin. Aside from their obvious payoffs to the world of art, to date over 100,000 have died from overdosing on OxyContin and their earlier product Valium. It’s not exciting even dull at times when they get close to dull and unlikeable Sackler family members. It’ll probably make you wonder how our American system allows financial wars and victories like this.

THE LAST KINGDOM: THESEVEN KINGS MUST DIE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). Another attempt to copy the enormous success of Game Of Thrones (2011) this super violent costume epic dates back to the reuniting of England around 866 to 878. That’s when the Vikings and the Anglo-Saxons fought tooth and claw. Early Denmark fits in there too, but there’s no depth to any character and you really won’t care about what happens to anyone in the cross over plots.

QUEENMAKER. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.8 IMDB). This Korean film is a very serious critique on not just the political but the fashion, and the marketing, and the business of sex in Seoul, Korea. There’s blackmail, suicide, and double crossing and it’s a very well made movie. There’s a mayor involved and the exposing of what went on and continues to go on behind that particular office. Well worth watching.

...
May 1

West Cliff Opportunism

If you’ve been following the drama of West Cliff Drive, the January severe storm damage, the various city zooms and most recently the public meeting at London Nelson center, you can be forgiven if you have been taken in by the hype. It is well-coordinated, well-funded and slick.

Let’s sweep the deck of hype for a moment and lay out the actual scene. The big storms in January heavily impacted West Cliff Drive, undermining, and collapsing the path and roadway in three areas, according to Public Works senior engineering staff. The damaged areas were originally armored with rip rap but that barrier against the ocean waves had not been maintained since the 1990’s, hence its failure. Other areas with recent rip rap in good condition withstood the big waves and high tides, showing that such techniques to preserve the path and road do indeed work, according to the city engineers. Public Works has applied for grants from FEMA and from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) to fix the damage, including the damaged culvert at Bethany Curve. Rather than replacing the old rip rap they are proposing an alternative with pilings and an infill wall that they feel will be more favorably viewed by the CA Coastal Commission. In other words, they are moving ahead with fixing the damage and restoring the road and path to its pre-damaged condition. The job will take some months, some disruption, and a lot of work but it is all pretty straightforward. This could be the end of the tale except for…the hype.

At the London Nelson meeting, Public Works had a small area in the back of one room where you could talk with the engineers and learn about the progress to fix the damaged sections described above. Most of the room and the other two rooms were like a parallel universe where facts were ignored and jargon ruled.

The city manager led off the evening with a spirited endorsement of the need for “a long-term vision for this global asset” and that “the time to act is now!” Similar to other presenters he never actually explained why we need a long-term vision nor the rush to develop one. Nor did he mention the work of the engineers to fix the damaged areas so the road can be opened again. In fact, no presenters acknowledged Public Works. It seemed acknowledging that the road can and will be fixed got in the way of the new narrative.

This new narrative exists independently from fixing the road. After the city manager’s “the time to act is now!” rallying cry, which was not referring to fixing the damage, we heard from the consulting firm, Farallon Strategies. Yes, yet another consulting firm who we were told is a “benefit corporation” helping non-profits such as Save the Waves. Time to connect the dots. The CEO of Save the Waves non-profit, whom the city council chose to replace me on the Parks & Recreation Commission is also one of the leaders in the new group Save West Cliff, formed after the storm damage. This CEO, now a Parks Commissioner also has a 2021 MOU with the city of Santa Cruz which states, “to reap economic rewards and invest in surfing; to quantify the economic contribution associated with Santa Cruz’s quality surf environment”. Regarding West Cliff, the MOU states it will “undertake an economic evaluation study” with Huntington Beach used as a shining example of bringing in $55 million and 375,000 attendees as host of the US Open of Surfing. Got the picture? The hype is all about money. How to frame the damage to West Cliff Drive to serve a hidden agenda. That alone explains the disconnect between fixing the damage and the drama that is being orchestrated to exploit it: why Public Works was sent to the back of the room while the hypesters occupied the limelight.

The consultant from Farallon Strategies spoke of “re-narrating” past decisions on West Cliff Drive. That sounded ominous. He spoke of the need to create a “shared understanding” and “shared narrative”; “aligning vision” and “creating “staff consistency.”  Toe the line or else.

The next presentation was from the leader of Save West Cliff, the new group filled with big names and big purses including the aforementioned CEO of Save the Waves. We were treated to some cool historic maps of West Cliff, all designed to fit the new narrative. This was achieved by omitting some facts and fabricating others. The historic maps showed the retreat of West Cliff from the forces of nature over the past century. As old timers know, the retreat has been significant and has removed many of the rock formations that once better protected the shoreline. However, the presenter’s claim that “all protection we had is gone” is chicken little-esque and incorrect. Perhaps all natural protection is gone but (I can hear a faint engineering voice from the back room) the use of armoring has successfully secured the current path alignment since it was installed, except where such armoring has not been maintained.

No doubt we will be subjected to more meetings where “re-narrating” will be fine- tuned before this all goes to city council. There will be much handwringing over climate change despite the fact that such storms as we experienced in January are not a new normal according to climate experts. I expect equity and inclusion will make an appearance at some stage. Meanwhile the truth gets harder and harder to see, drowned out in a deluge of hype. The agenda of Save West Cliff so far is not clear and where articulated, is couched in feel good generalities. At some point, when a critical mass of people has adopted the aligned vision and shared narrative, the group will make its agenda evident. I’ll lay odds it involves turning West Cliff into a cash cow. Tastefully done of course.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

May 1

THERE’S NO ESCAPING PLASTIC SMOG

This is what I read with my morning coffee today: Plastic is already in blood, breast milk, and placentas. Now it may be in our brains. I try not to share too much news like this, because it is just so depressing, horrifying, and overwhelming.

It seems like Santa Cruzans overall think that we live in a very special place–if not a pristine ecological reserve, at least a very clean and environmentally aware community. The wellness industry sells us the idea that we can be “clean” and healthy in our homes and bodies if we just do all the right things, but…

Folks, I have news for you: most of us are complicit in our own environmental catastrophes, one way or another. Maybe we can’t see them as obviously as we can in other places, but that doesn’t mean we aren’t producing, and using, petro-plastics in amounts large enough to poison every living thing here.

Here are just three examples of our participation in a global toxic economy:

Chemical weapons in Santa Cruz Police Department’s arsenal. Thanks to AB 481 requiring disclosure of military equipment, we know what they keep in stock, including highly toxic tear gas. Now we need to know if the equipment is truly justified, not according to SCPD’s logic, but the community’s. We must stop investing in chemical weapons that are not even used, requiring disposal as hazardous waste when replaced every five years.

Wetsuits are toxic. I am thinking of developing a proposal for a new Sister City: Reserve, Louisiana. This historic Black town in Louisiana’s Cancer Alley is home to Pontchartrain Works, the only facility in the US that makes (incredibly toxic) chloroprene, the main component in neoprene. Neoprene is most dangerous at its production site, but also in its degradation through wear-and-tear. Santa Cruz is inextricably linked to Reserve through our surfing history and communities, commerce, culture, and our stated values of supporting Black Lives Matter and Environmental Justice.

The military-industrial complex. Since 1957, Lockheed Martin on Empire Grade has assembled and tested weapons like trident missiles. All munitions like this have petro-chemical ingredients that are highly toxic and persistent in the environment. I heard that they were planning to close in the next few years, but they’re recently and actively hiring for management and manual positions and I don’t find any announcement of closure online.

What’s got me thinking about this, making these connections, right now?

For five (or ten?) years I’ve been keeping tabs on what I call the vertically-integrated petro-plastics industry, as it relates to my long-standing interest in plastics, toxins, waste streams, infrastructures, and chronic illness. Virtually all of the plastic material ever made and still being made is petroleum based. Virtually all of that plastic is still in the environment. This includes a majority of the textiles we use. It is part of our invisible carbon emissions as well as a visible manifestation of them. We can see macroplastics larger than 5mm and we know they’re a problem in all sorts of ways. We generally cannot see the majority of microplastics and microfibers, let alone nanoplastics, and yet they’re ubiquitous, amounting to a kind of plastic smog that pervades land, air, water, and biological bodies.

Over the past six months I’ve been looking at the microcosm, and the micro-watershed, of Neary Lagoon. Neary Lagoon is interesting to me, and a lot of other people, as a site of colonization, agro-industrial use, waste infrastructure, and biodiversity. Hopefully what I’m doing with my research, art, and now a workshop, is synthesizing these disciplines and bringing them to the arts context for diverse audiences.

I’ve printed maps of the small waterways on the Westside that feed the Lagoon, and have begun to walk them, photographing and picking up plastics. I’ve been finding reasonably accessible, non-laboratory methods for seeing microplastics and microfibers—pieces under 5mm–with polarization, fluorescence, and digital microscopes. At the same time, I’m learning about the industrial history of this area, land use, current research and policy on plastic pollution in the bay.


Macro- and micro-plastics photographed in Jordan Gulch: degraded bottlecap filled with organic matter (L) and styrofoam debris (R) (photos by me)

City documents say Neary Lagoon is a remnant of the San Lorenzo River, which historically migrated back and forth across the flats between here and what is now Jessie Street Marsh. But clearly it is fed by all these freshwater springs and creeks, and before being filled for a railroad to reach the old pier next to the wharf, it was tidal and briny. There are now pumps to maintain one-way water flow.

What will happen to this lagoon and the wastewater treatment plant as sea level inevitably rises? How will the ecosystem change as it returns to brine? Should we restore it to brine now instead of continuing to cut it off? It must be a sink for petro-plastics and petro-pollution that runs off our roads into the untreated storm drains all over the neighborhoods. Car tire particles are amongst the worst microplastic pollutants found in Monterey Bay. Is there monitoring and research being done on those pollutants in the Lagoon?


Industry diagram on plastics in automotive components


Just a fraction of plastic debris from recent (frequent) car accidents at Bay and Escalona (photo by me)

I’ve also been assembling a dossier to share my research, which is available to all.

I’m already thinking about how to improve this workshop for Part 2, June 10th, 11am-1pm. That one will be part of Laurie Palmer’s Landing project https://landingevents.org/, also funded by the City of Santa Cruz Economic Development Department. I very much appreciate the support to continue this project. We’ll meet again at the Chestnut Street entrance to Neary Lagoon.

Thanks to everyone who came to Neary Lagoon Through a Different Lens, Part 1! Part of Martabel Wasserman’s Refocusing Ecology series, funded by City of Santa Cruz Economic Development Department

We looked at a big map of the micro-watershed of Neary Lagoon and one of its main feeders, Bay Avenue Creek. We talked history, municipal infrastructure, plastics, and greenwashing. We walked a little bit. We looked at very small pieces of plastic and microfibers with black light, polarization, macro lenses, and digital microscopes. (photo by Martabel Wasserman)

Many thanks to Martabel Wasserman for creating this Refocusing Ecology Workshop Series, the rest of the Ecosocialist Working Group, Blaize Wilkerson for her fabulous walking tours of Santa Cruz and Aulinta, Kathryn Mintz and the CityArts Commissioners for leading the funding of CARD projects, Researchers Anonymous members for graciously giving me advice and information, Clive Bagshaw for sharing his microplastics and microscope knowledge with me, and finally to Jorge, the head landscaper of The Villages at UCSC, for taking me on an impromptu and very informative hike up Jordan Gulch.

As individuals, we can Refuse, Reuse, Reduce, Recycle, and Repair, as much as we can given our capacities. And we must support the city and county as they continue to join other municipalities and the state in legal battles against petro-plastics corporations. Banning this or that single-use plastic thing might be better than doing nothing. But even if all of us do all of that, we’re not going to escape our toxic legacies or the global petro-plastic climate crisis. To be clear, the military-industrial complex is, and always has been, largely about plastics via the vertically-integrated petroleum industry. Until we find even more ways to de-power that huge machine, we’re screwed.

Joy Schendledecker is an artist, parent, and community organizer. She lives on the Westside of Santa Cruz with her husband, two teens, mother in law, and cats. She was a city of Santa Cruz mayoral candidate in 2022. You can email her at: schendledecker@icloud.com.

...
May 1

THE PLAN TO ADD BIKE LANES AND WIDEN THE HIGHWAY  IN THE APTOS VILLAGE AREA

The Draft EIR to widen Highway One between State Park Drive and Freedom Boulevard and create a 16′-wide pedestrian and bicycle trail adjacent to the railroad tracks is open for public comment until June 2.  This includes plans to add structures to the two trestles over Aptos Creek.  Please participate if you can.

Here is an interesting video of the model:

IS IT FEASIBLE TO CONVERT COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS INTO HOUSING?

Many are eyeing the Capitola Mall on 41st Avenue for a possible housing conversion project.  Will it be feasible?

When it comes to a similar question for the City of San Francisco, the answer is NO.  A recent summary of analysis by a group known as SPUR just released their findings on that question for San Francisco’s conversion of the empty Financial District area into residential units, following similar models in Calgary, New York, Chicago and Washington, D.C..

S.F.’s empty office space could hold 11,000 new homes — but only with City Hall’s help, report says

The report states that the City would have to remove the developer fees associated with requiring 75sf of open space/unit, waive the current requirement that 21.5% of the development be allocated to affordable inclusionary housing, and “loosening” the environmental analysis required by making approvals ministerial, and thereby exempt from CEQA. The analysis assumes all units are 650SF.

Here is a link to the SPUR summary

What are the issues that may be problematic for converting the Capitola Mall to residential space?  Likely, many of the same economic woes stated in the SPUR report, but add in infrastructure and water.

Take a look at the architects rendering last presented

That plan would include 637 residential units, a theater and commercial venues.

Are there legislators working to provide economic incentives for revitalization projects like this?  State Senator Anna Caballero’s SB 6 “Middle Class Housing Act”, which would fast-track the creation of walkable infill development and make it easier to turn land zoned for commercial uses into housing. was signed by the Governor on Sept. 28, 2022.  Other similar bills, AB 115 by Assembly member Richard Bloom, failed approval, as did AB 15 introduced by Senator Anthony Portantino that would have incentivized converting empty big box stores into workforce housing.

So, the problem of how to meet the staggering mandates issued by the State in the sixth cycle of Regional Housing Allocation Numbers (RHNA) is notable not only for Capitola, but all municipalities in California:

AMBAG as a whole was assigned 10,043 units in the last cycle by the California Department of Housing and Community Development, but has faced a tripling of the figure to 33,274 in the cycle beginning in 2023 and ending in 2031. As a result, over a nine-month period, AMBAG formulated its allocation methodologies to break the total and designate it across several cities.

Despite Capitola’s population only representing 1.4% of the total population for the region AMBAG represents, it received 4% of all housing units or 1,336 units. Capitola was saddled with an increased allocation because it is considered a high resource jurisdiction with a racially concentrated area of affluence; those two elements were weighted the highest within AMBAG’s formula selected Jan. 12. Because of the formula, Santa Cruz County and its cities will have to produce a total of 12,979 units — a discovery the Sentinel first reported

[Capitola to seek out consultant to help with next RHNA cycle allocation]

ANOTHER PILE OF MONEY…BUT WILL IT MAKE A DIFFERENCE?

The County just received $6.63 million dollars in federal grant money to help solve the homeless problem.  Remember the $10 million the County received about three years ago…did it make a difference?  Only to the non-profits who are happily enjoying what appears to be a  new industry in Santa Cruz County, and can belly-up to the grant fund trough indefinitely to serve their own interests.  When will we see something actually happen to change the situation?  Don’t hold your breath.

From Sup. Koenig’s office:

The County of Santa Cruz Housing for Health Division announced that homeless services projects across Santa Cruz County have been awarded $6.63 million in federal grant funding, representing the largest competitive federal Continuum of Care (CoC) allocation in County history.

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) funded all 21 projects that were submitted from Santa Cruz County. This includes three new projects: Housing Matters’ permanent supportive housing project at 801 River Street, as well as Walnut Avenue Family & Women’s Center and Monarch Services, programs that provide refuge to domestic violence survivors.

INTERESTING ITEMS FROM THE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISOR CONSENT AGENDA ON APRIL 25, 2023

The Consent Agenda on the County Board of Supervisor meeting agendas are often where significant actions are buried / hidden.  Take a look at these April 25 consent items

YOU SHOULDN’T HAVE SOLD MY PROPERTY

Consent Item #22

Analysis

Revenue and Taxation Code, Section 3731(b), provides that the sale of property by the tax collector may be rescinded by the Board of Supervisors if a hearing is scheduled and notification is provided to the purchaser of the property or a successor in interest. There is no codified process or current policy for how this hearing and consideration of the rescission should occur. In order for the Board to ascertain all the facts and consider whether the property should not have been sold, the Board may schedule a hearing to consider testimony and documentation related to this matter. The next available regular meeting agenda for such hearing is June 27, 2023.

CONSENT #47  COUNTY STORM DAMAGE ESTIMATES

Financial Impact

The total direct cost of the contracts associated with this board item is $14,996,700. Eligible costs will be reimbursed by FEMA at 75% and by FHWA at 88.53%, and Cal OES will reimburse 75% of the remaining eligible costs.  The total reimbursement from all agencies is estimated at $13,582,193. The estimated local match and ineligible cost  portion is estimated at $3,214,111 and will be paid with SB1 funds and General Fund contributions.

CONSENT #50  POSTPONE AWARD FOR SOQUEL DRIVE BUFFERED BIKE LANE

Financial Impact

The total project costs including design and construction is estimated to be $28,594,130.  The 2020 Solutions for Congested Corridors Program (SCCP) will provide $16,463,000. The County General Fund is estimated to provide $3,720,765.  SB1 funds, the Regional Surface Transportation Program Exchange (RSTPX), the City of Santa Cruz and the Soquel Creek Water District will provide the balance.

COUNTY BUDGET HEARINGS BEGIN EARLY THIS YEAR AND ARE SHORTER

I happened to see a Legal Notice in the Santa Cruz Sentinel, alerting the public to the dates for the County of Santa Cruz Budget Hearings. The Board has calendared May 30 and May 31 at 9am to consider the 2023-2024 Budget, and June 13 at 1:30pm for the last day revision approvals.

Usually, the Budget Hearings begin in mid to late June, and are held over the course of three or four days, allowing the Supervisors and the public the opportunity to thoughtfully read and digest the massive document and to allow for Department staff to make presentations about their budgetary needs and accountability.

No wonder Supervisor Justin Cummings asked for more time to publicly consider the financial situation of the County, for public benefit as well as his own.  You might recall that Supervisor Zach Friend shot that good idea down very quickly, “because some of us may have scheduled other activities for that time frame.”

The County’s economic future is clouded and uncertain, but CAO Carlos Palacios continues to push the Board to make more and larger real estate purchases to build his empire.

Major assumptions in balancing the FY 2023-24 proposed budget include a 1% decline in sales tax, a slow-down in growth in certain property tax transfer revenues, and collection of up to $14.5 million of the $67 million in outstanding FEMA obligations that would be used to restore and strengthen reserves. The budget assumes normalized cost increases for wages and benefits, increasing facility capital investments towards a recommended long-range target of approximately 1% of total General Fund expenditures, and budgetary reliance on available fund balance of $12.2 million.

Stay tuned…and get ready for an interesting Budget process.  Participate as much as you can.

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY HISTORY FAIR WILL BE IN FELTON

Don’t miss this great event and the opportunity to learn more about the history of our grand County.  This year, the event will be in the San Lorenzo Valley, at the Felton Community Center (6191 Highway 9) beginning at 1pm. In the past, this Fair has taken place in downtown Santa Cruz. It’s free, so bring your family and friends.

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND A MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS. 

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

 

Cheers, Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
May 1

SNAKES

As with most species, we have a wealth of snakes in the Monterey Bay region, and I want to help you to know them…and to encourage a young person to become a wildlife biologist.

April is Snake Month But May….

April is usually the month that you can see the most snakes. With the weather this year, it seems the snakes waited a little while so maybe May will also be rich with snake sightings. Most people I know see snakes crossing roads and trails. Too many people see snakes that were killed by vehicles on roads. Not many people get the opportunity to walk off trail to see snakes. If you can get out to off trail, you might walk with a few friends side-by-side in a line through a meadow- an efficient way to see snakes. Another place most folks aren’t afforded to look is along bodies of water. A foray along the edge of a marsh or pond will likely net a snake sighting. And yet another unusual activity is a good way to see snakes: turn over ‘cover’ – logs, boards, bark, tin roofing, or anything else that is big enough and has touched ground enough to provide a hiding place for snakes. The rule is to put that piece of cover back gently and exactly like you found it. Looking for snakes is a good way to get in touch with wild nature around here, and it is also a viable and fascinating career. There aren’t enough local wildlife biologists: can you name one? We need to encourage more children to seek careers in wildlife conservation. There are a variety of nice jobs for people who know their snake ecology.

Wildlife Careers

I’ll briefly outline the places one might work as a wildlife biologist, and then I’ll get to discussing what cool snakes there are around here. Parks and other conservation lands agencies employ ecologists to help conserve wildlife. There is also an abundance of ecologists working in research around the Monterey Bay. College and University wildlife careers come with teaching and research while jobs at other research institutions might not have the same teaching roles. There are also careers just doing outreach: think folks in museums, aquaria, on whale watching boats, and leading tours on land. Because of the environmental laws in our nation and in California in particular, there are a host of jobs as consultants, either in private business or as advisors working with Resource Conservation Districts or other such entities. While wildlife ecologists might not earn as much money as engineers, doctors, or lawyers, I know many who love their work and are leaving amazing legacies for future generations: peregrine falcons or condors that would otherwise have gone extinct, restored ponds hosting rare California red-legged frogs and tiger salamanders, wildlife corridors that support the movement of badgers and cougars, and many other such things. Next time a child or young adult mentions a love of birds, mammals, reptiles, or any wildlife, I hope that you will pause a moment and tell them how amazing it would be if they sought a career in wildlife biology. Perhaps they will be the ones to help conserve our rarest local snake, the San Francisco gartersnake.

Snake List

Here’s the list of the 12 local snakes:

  • San Francisco gartersnake
  • Santa Cruz gartersnake
  • California red-sided gartersnake
  • Coast gartersnake
  • Gopher snake
  • Northern Pacific rattlesnake
  • Ring-necked snake
  • California king snake
  • California mountain king snake
  • Forest sharp-tailed snake
  • Northern rubber boa
  • Wester yellow-bellied racer

Seeing Snakes

How many of these snakes have you seen? Traveling as I do through grasslands, I see gopher snakes every week. I once had a dog that for some reason wanted to gently pick up ring necked snakes in the forest. Now, I only see forest snakes (rubber boas, ring necked, and sharp-tailed snakes) when I go with a gaggle of folks doing surveys. There used to be more rubber boas on the north coast before the 2020 fire- a lot of them and other forest snakes must have died in that conflagration.

The Most Beautiful Snake

I don’t get around water much, but when I do, I have always seen gartersnakes and then I have to remember how to tell them apart. Your location matters if you are trying to see San Francisco gartersnake. That endangered species has never been documented south of Waddell Creek, but you supposedly can find them from Año Nuevo north and east to the urbanized areas. It ought to be called the San Mateo County gartersnake at this point, but maybe someone has seen one in the many wetlands of San Francisco. I include them here because they do occur on the northern boundary of the Monterey Bay, which is around Pigeon Point. The San Francisco gartersnake with its blue, yellow, and red stripes has been called the most beautiful snake in the world.

Santa Cruz’ Gartersnake

We have a namesake gartersnake which is much plainer, the Santa Cruz gartersnake. This one like most gartersnakes has a dark blackish background and a single yellow or orangish line down its back. This species overlaps a lot with the San Francisco gartersnake but its range extends south to Watsonville.

The coast gartersnake is midway in coloration between the colorful San Francisco gartersnake and the not so colorful Santa Cruz gartersnake. This one has the gold line down its back but also has a red checks down its side, mixed with browns and blacks.

Smelly Snake

I like garter snakes for their smell. When you pick them up, they emit a ‘foul musk odor’ – apparently a defense. The smell washes right off, it is water soluble.

Handling Snakes

I don’t recommend picking up snakes unless you know what you are doing. If you are older than 16, you shouldn’t handle them without a fishing permit from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. If you do handle a snake, even the non-venomous ones might bite you. If they bite, you have to let them stay attached to you until they let go: if you pull away, you could dislocate their jaws. It is no fun to have to watch a snake chew on you until it is done. Some snakes, like mountain king snakes, have razor sharp teeth that will then make you bleed a bunch after they chew awhile.

Snake Summary

Remember please to encourage young people to pursue careers in wildlife conservation. If you have a place for someone to live more affordably, you might pitch in for conservation by advertising it for a wildlife expert. Whatever you do, I hope you can appreciate our area more – our amazing snake diversity is just another example of how special our region is. Let’s conserve it!

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

FROM GARY A. PATTON  From Gary’s “We Live In A Political World” website…

April 28

#118 / Only The Lonely

If you click that video link, above, you will hear the incomparable Roy Orbison sing “Only The Lonely.” Click that link to the title if you’d like to read the lyrics.

Marta Zaraska, a Polish-Canadian science journalist whose work has appeared in the Washington Post, Scientific American, Spectrum, The Atlantic, Discover, and other publications, has written an article in the online magazine Quanta, in which she claims that “feelings of loneliness prompt changes in the brain that further isolate people from social contact.”

I am absolutely prepared to believe it, and I am not at all surprised to learn that there are genuine physical manifestations, deep inside our brains, associated with the sense of isolation and loneliness that can sometimes overwhelm us.

Speaking individually, we need to be aware when such feelings of loneliness start to creep up on us, or even when they presume to attack us “full frontal.” If and when that happens, we can (and need to) take steps to confront and deal with these feelings, because loneliness is dangerous, both to ourselves and to others.

Speaking from a social, or collective, perspective, let’s all remember that we are not, actually, just a bunch of isolated individuals. We are, as I repeatedly claim, “together in this.” This is more than a pious wish. I am convinced that it is, in fact, a profound truth about our human condition.

May I suggest that both “talking to strangers” and our active engagement in politics are helpful and effective ways to combat loneliness and all of its deleterious individual and social impacts?

That’s true – and I am convinced of it. I am speaking from personal experience, too. My engagement with “strangers,” with people whom I didn’t know, in the fight to “Save Lighthouse Field,” transformed my life. It certainly changed the future of the City of Santa Cruz, and Santa Cruz County. Click here for a reference to a publication of the Santa Cruz Museum of Art and History that includes my personal account of what we did!

Political engagement? Yes! If you want to fight loneliness, my advice is to get personally and politically involved!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
May 1

SLIPPIN’ AND A-SLIDIN’ THROUGH THE COURT SYSTEMS

The US Extreme Court continues to muddy the waters even more as they sink lower in the depths of public opinion. Last week all nine spoke as one as they responded to the heavy criticism of late, saying no fix is needed if it isn’t broken, on the subject of their lack of a code of ethics. Justice Clarence Thomas, along with Associate Justice Ginny Thomas, lit up the internet with their complicity in the Big Lie endeavors of the Trumpsters; which then slid into the charges of undeclared gifts and favors from benefactor Harlan Crow who also has a suspect property deal festering in the background. Charles Geyh, an Indiana University law professor and legal ethics expert says all the details given out this week were outlined by Chief Justice Roberts a decade ago: the justices will set their own rules and police themselves, just in case you missed it the first time, so pay attention!

Next up, the lingering story about the Chief Justice’s wife, Jane, being paid millions of dollars for placing attorneys at organizations – a legit enough vocation –  although some have had cases being decided by the high court, a slippery ethics matter? A former colleague of Jane Roberts has provided reports to both congress and the justice department as she seeks an inquiry, claiming that the Chief Justice has “potential ethics issues.” 

Justice Neil Gorsuch made his recent debut over a property deal that occurred nine days after his court confirmation, selling a Colorado property, along with two partners, to the head of law firm Greenberg Traurig which occasionally has cases before the court. Gorsuch’s 20% stake in the property netted him between $250,001 to $500,000 as noted in his financial report, but he declined to disclose the name of the purchaser. Under federal law, justices are required to file annual disclosures, but are not required to follow any binding ethics code. Should they have ethical questions, the justices simply discuss it among themselves…simple and quick, no? Legal ethics professor at Washington University in St. Louis, Kathleen Clark, views the problem “that the justices have not been subjected to basic accountability that just about everybody else in the federal government has to comply with.” Regarding Roberts‘ two-page letter issued this week, Clark says she sees “a failure to grapple with the fundamental problem of lack of accountability…the justices seem to be utterly clueless about the problem they have…they’re in a bubble apparently.”

The recent revelations has spurred calls for reform and last Wednesday Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski and Independent Senator Angus King announced legislation that would require the Supreme Court to create a code of conduct and appoint an official to oversee potential conflicts and public outcry. Additionally, the Senate Judiciary Committee will hold a hearing on Court ethics reform. And just to keep the heat on Justice Kavanaugh, it was just disclosed that Senator Charles Grassley had possibly omitted key evidence during that justice’s confirmation hearing in 2018 which led to a botched investigation by the FBI regarding sexual assault allegations, results of a further investigation to be released by the Justice Department by year’s end.

The Tucker Carlson/Fox News breakup continues to resonate as we await word of Carlson’s next landing place, and to see what a miraculous turnaround Fox exhibits after casting off their demon…get real, nothing changes with them! Bocha Blue in a Palmer Report piece writes that the lesson here for Tuck-Tuck is that power is not eternal, nobody is immune from the hubris effect. Once hubris claws its way into one’s soul, anything can happen…ask Roger Ailes, Bill O’Reilly or Donald Trump. Blue says, “Tucker Carlson thought he WAS Fox news – its mouth and its soul. But there are millions of mouths out there, and the fox has no soul. Tucker is finding out the hard way that he is already yesterday’s news.” Perhaps MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow summed it up best: “You don’t get to call football games on TV for the NFL. You don’t lead hundred-year-long Messianic religious revivals. You don’t persuade Americans to start tanning their testicles en masse,” referring to a Carlson segment pitching a potential solution to lowered testosterone levels in American men.

Dumping Tucker devalued Fox’s stock by more than half a billion dollars, which shows the ratings and revenue quotient his show held, yet Fox carried out the deed fully knowing what was in store for them. Bill Palmer feels that possible scandalous information over and above the Dominion settlement, Carlson’s emails, or pending lawsuits by former staff and investors have nothing to do with the firing of their biggest cash cow. Highly profitable cable news hosts don’t get fired unless they suddenly become unprofitable or are about to become unprofitable, so there’s more to the story. The Daily Beast’s senior editor, Andrew Kirell, feels that Carlson’s ‘bigger than Fox’ attitude has permeated other hosts and that other heads will roll after the recent firing has settled a bit.

The juggernaut of court actions against the Former Guy roll along, with E. Jean Carroll’s civil suit against Trump garnering attention last week. While civil trials don’t result in ‘guilty/not guilty’ verdicts the jury could find that The Donald raped Carroll 23 years ago in a Bergdorf Goodman dressing room, and is responsible for damages, shackling him with the term ‘rapist,’ a blow to his ego and perhaps devastating politically. Bill Palmer writes, “The thing is we keep hearing how such an outcome to this trial will have ‘no impact’ on Trump’s base, who will keep worshipping him forever. My response to that is a simple one: who cares? In terms of political process, the cretins in Trump’s base are simply not relevant.” He feels that since their votes are locked in anyway, they are 100% irrelevant, since they don’t influence those outside their own ranks, and unable to determine the outcome of any election alone. That base is a disturbing creep show, not a relevant political force now and never was…having no influence in his 2016 victory and unable to show up in enough force to sway the 2020 election, with a pitiful 55% in GOP polls currently. Both of Trump’s opponents in the elections received millions more votes than he, but all across the media spectrum attention is directed toward ‘Trump’s base,’ and not ‘Hillary’s base’ or ‘Biden’s base,’ while pretending those factions don’t exist. The path to winning elections is to see that the base is locked in and will turn out, and then focusing on persuadable voters outside the base. Let’s hope the electorate is paying attention, as well as the jury for E. Jean Carroll!

Georgia’s Fulton County DA Fani Willis released news that movement will be announced perhaps as early as July in the investigation into election interference by the ‘Big Lie’ advocates and maybe an indictment of Trump. She has advised law enforcement to make plans for disruptions and public protests, so it must be big! It appears her investigation is being delayed as cooperation seems to be improving as several ‘fake electors’ are taking advantage of immunity deals, having seen the handwriting on the wall. Trump is assuredly prepared to throw up as many roadblocks as he can muster, but that process is finite…no running out the clock to his heart’s content. Willis probably wanted to get this case behind her before election season, but even with the flippers coming forward, she must feel that those can be included in time to move toward a conviction.

Manhattan’s DA Alvin Bragg was up against a different clock, leading him to make his move to indict the former prez, and while that is true in special prosecutor Jack Smith’s case, criminal charges taking place in federal court will move much more quickly than most state courts. Bill Palmer feels that the “doomsday hype” about courts not having enough time to put The Trumpster on trial prior to the election are simply empty attempts to get retweets…thank you very much Elon Musk.

In the case of DA Bragg, he is still under a siege of sorts by Representative ‘Gym’ Jordan as he attempts to prove that this is all about a political witch-hunt to get Trump. Jordan sought to have materials turned over to his committee and was told to “go pound sand,” so he subpoenaed Mark Pomerantz to be subjected to questioning, following his resignation from the DA’s office, and the subsequent publishing of a book, entitled ‘People vs. Donald Trump…An Inside Account.’ Pomerantz came out of retirement to join DA Cyrus Vance’s team to look into Trump’s business practices and after investigating for a year and concluding that an indictment was in order, ala former mob boss, John J. Gotti, DA Vance left that office to be succeeded by Bragg, who was less enthusiastic about an indictment initially. Pomerantz left, wrote his book under a hailstorm of criticism for revealing aspects of the case, but insists he had not jeopardized pursuit of prosecution, whereupon Bragg initiated a civil case that does not include criminal penalties.

Bragg appealed to the courts to disallow a Pomerantz appearance on May 12 before Jordan’s committee, but later withdrew the appeal to open up the way in Jordan’s favor. The congressman’s charge that political motivation energizes the indictment is going to be a disappointment for him, since Pomerantz’s letter of resignation explains the root of his frustration and why he left the Manhattan team. He felt there was “evidence sufficient to establish Mr. Trump’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt,” and further stating that The Don was “guilty of numerous felony violations” making it doubtful that benefit will accrue to Jordan’s so-called investigation. As a former prosecutor, Pomerantz wanted charges to be filed, and Bragg was seemingly not motivated. According to Glenn Kirschner of ‘Justice Matters,’ Jordan is way out of his league in questioning someone of prosecutor Pomerantz’s status and that he will be chewed up and spat out directly back into the Trump Clown Car. Kirschner asks: “Who’s ready to see Pomerantz verbally tap dance all over Jim Jordan’s head?” as he raises his hand with a devilish smile.

We are reminded by Glenn that Jordan ‘blew off’ the very subpoenas to testify that he is now issuing, and makes a suggestion that his committee be renamed “the Congressional Committee to aid and abet Donald Trump.” ‘Do as I say and not as I do,’ eh ‘Gym-bo?’ Present at the testimony will be the DA’s General Counsel to shut down any improper questioning that might jeopardize the ongoing criminal investigation, so Jordan with no power to override refusals to answer questions is facing a brick wall.

The ‘Prove Mike Wrong Challenge’ has come to a semi-satisfying conclusion after a computer forensics expert submitted his report disproving that My Pillow B.S.-artist Mike Lindell failed to produce data showing evidence of foreign interference in the 2020 presidential election. Mikey’s embarrassing “Cyber Symposium” held in South Dakota in August 2021 attempted to show the existence of packet data, but the data scrolling on his big screen had no relation to election data; but, the contest judges, including one of Lindell’s attorneys, declined to pay the $5 million offered to prove the data as invalid. Robert Zeidman, who proved it was a scam, then filed for arbitration under the contest rules with both parties presenting their evidence in January. Finally, in April, the three arbitrators ruled against Mr. My Pillow, saying he had to pay the five mil as promised. Stupid, egotistical, and untrustworthy Mikey has no intention of forking it over, as he doubles down, and it will likely end up in court. With this much at stake we can expect to see Donald Trump try to worm his way into this fray for yet another handout.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“The Universe”

“We are an impossibility in an impossible universe.”    
~Ray Bradbury

“Two possibilities exist: either we are alone in the Universe or we are not. Both are equally terrifying.”        
~Arthur C. Clarke

 “Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe.”              
~Albert Einstein

...

Single dads don’t always have it easy. This guy is great though!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...
Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment