February 7 – 13, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton…more throwback Greensite on a wild adventure!.. Steinbruner…Measure M, Pdestrian/cyclist bridge in Aptos?. Hayes…on senate candidates… Patton…Crypto is a scam!… Matlock…Garbage in, garbage out… Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes….”Delay”

...

BEACH BOARDWALK AND TRAIN MEETS BUS. This happened back on August 16, 1954. I never noticed before but permanently painted on the side of both buses it says “Oakland – Santa Cruz Beach”.                                                         

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection. Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

DATELINE February 7, 2024

MEA CULPA! This week’s quotes are on “Delay”, because I got so very delayed getting this column up and posted. I vastly over-estimated my access to electricity on my yearly trip to Lake Havasu in Arizona, where this year the 35th annual Western Winter Blast was held at the race track. 4 days of fireworks, with pyrotechnics enthusiasts and pros from all over! I thought I’d be able to do the column from the road, but I was sadly mistaken. I’m catching up with the next column in a couple of days.

More archive diving, but I hear Bruce is doing better!

//Gunilla//


DATELINE FEBRUARY 2016

CRUSADING FOR CORRIDORS. Just like using the term “auxiliary lanes” as a coverup for Widening Highway 1 developers and pro-growth politicians are claiming that building clumps of 3 and 4 story high rises along our most heavily used streets is environmentally OK. By claiming that we’ll use fewer gas miles by walking (or biking) from these ugly dwellings to shop. These money-minded developers know damned well that in our spread out county (and cities) few if any, would or could walk from COSTCO to their Doctors, or from TARGET to their Dentists, or from the movies to their car repair place. Think about how “thin” our County is because of the mountains and the coast line. Think about how ugly the new PAMF (Palo Alto Medical Facility) on Mission (Highway 1) is and how it’s built right up to the sidewalk. The approaches and major streets in our county are ugly enough…stop the corridor push.

AUXILIARY LANES…A WIDER VIEW. It took me awhile but after hearing about the concept of “auxiliary lanes” as somehow being different or environmentally better than “Widening Highway One” the dawn came!! Look at the stretches on Hwy 1 that have had “Auxiliary  Lanes” added…it’s just a sneakier way of widening a stretch at a time. Don’t fall for it…keep attached to The Campaign For Sensible Transportationwebsite…they’re on top of this battle to stop the drive to have that $$$ 450 Million Dollar $$$ Transportation Tax happen in November. sensibletransportation.org [wayback machine version of the website, URL has since been hijacked]

[BACK TO THE CURRENT TIMELINE They’re still messing with that dang freeway… -Webmistress]

Bruce will be back with movie reviews as soon as he’s had a chance to write more!

...
February 5th 2024

A Wild Adventure

Waking up on Sunday morning, February 4th. you didn’t need a weather forecast to know it was blowing a gale. Trees strained the limits of flexibility, their branches thrashing wildly in the wind.

The city issued a severe storm warning, urging people to avoid all travel and stay indoors. Good advice except I had a ticket for an elephant seal fundraising event at Ano Nuevo State Reserve.

It seemed most people followed the city’s advice. There were few cars on Highway 1 as I headed out of town. Small signs warning of flooding seemed a bit overstated until I hit a body of water that proved their point. The cliffs at Rancho del Oso were spectacular with waterfalls cascading from the bluff tops, the water carried away in the high winds like smoke from a fire. I had left plenty of time for the short trip. About a mile from Ano Nuevo, I was just congratulating myself on good planning when I saw a line of cars ahead stopped. A police vehicle blocked cars travelling south while a ranger’s vehicle blocked cars travelling north. With my car’s engine turned off and no forward momentum the severity of the storm became more apparent. The wind buffeted the car, the power lines swayed, and I had stopped in the direct line of a big pine tree thrashing about on the ocean side of the road. More than a few folks would get a laugh if I met my demise from a falling tree, even more so if it were a eucalyptus. I can see the humor in that except when it looks like a distinct possibility.

Of course, no official walked up the line of cars to let us know what was happening. That helpful task seems to be missing from the job description. Were we in for an hour’s wait? Four hours? Was it wise to turn back? Only the howling wind answered that line of thinking. A few intrepid souls ventured from their cars and approached the scene of the problem, so I called out, asking what was the story? Apparently, it was two downed lines, one a PG&E line and the other, an unknown. Now, PG&E isn’t popular these days, however when their truck finally appeared on the scene they were greeted with a small round of applause. A while later we all crept past the source of the incident and were on our way. I picked up a couple who had left their car to walk the mile into Ano Nuevo and although we were quite late, the docents knew what had happened and gave us a warm welcome. Those power lines had apparently been down for five hours.

Ano Nuevo is lovely enough on a calm day. With wind gusts of 50 miles an hour and foam from the waves whipping across the sand dunes it was fiercely dramatic. The ocean was a cauldron of white-topped waves. Small clusters of docents were in specific locations to answer our every question. Some had drawn the short straw and were on the unprotected shoreline, others secured the more sheltered spot behind a sand dune. One who had a long history as a docent at Ano Nuevo said he had never experienced weather this extreme. I believed him.

The star attractions of course ignored the howling wind and lay around as if it were a balmy day. Since we had about three hours to observe their behavior, we did see far more action than their lounging around. The fundraiser is a special annual event, so it allows for closer viewing and more personal interactions with the docents than does a regular group tour.

I’ll share only one piece of information about these unique mammals, and it has more to do with human behavior than with theirs.  As you may know, in the early 1800’s there were hundreds of thousands of elephant seals in existence. By the late 1800’s they had become almost extinct, hunted for their blubber that produced valuable oil. There were tiny groups of them left on Guadalupe Island off the coast of Baja Mexico. By 1892, only nine were still found on Guadalupe Island of which seven were killed for the collection at the Smithsonian Institute. In 1922 the Mexican government finally outlawed all hunting, making Guadalupe Island a biological reserve, protecting the elephant seals with armed guards. The 160,000 elephant seals that exist today are a direct result of the Mexican government’s protections.

Next time you visit Ano Nuevo, voice a well-deserved “muchas gracias” to the Mexican government.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

MEASURE M DEBATE IS STRONG
Many are debating the citizen initiative Measure M…isn’t it a good idea to allow the people affected in a Community to have a voice in what happens there?  YES! Can we trust our local elected representatives will listen to us when we speak up?  NO.  Therein lies the problem that brought about the amazing effort of many people who really care about the City of Santa Cruz to gather over 6,000 qualified voter signatures to get Measure M on the March 5 ballot.

There are many public debate forums…

For everyone who missed the excellent recent Measure M virtual debate sponsored by Our Downtown, Our Future, it was just posted on YouTube.  Here is the link:
Santa Cruz Measure M Forum — Hosted by Our Downtown, Our Future

Santa Cruz Lookout scheduled one for February 5 that may also soon be available as a recording:
Meet the candidates: Lookout’s primary election forums are here

Here is a link to a recent Santa Cruz Lookout article: Measure M — Santa Cruz’s height limitation and affordability measure — is the Measure of Much Debate, Many Questions and Murky Answers

This affects everyone…and could really shape the look and feel of the Santa Cruz we love.  Will the new City Council pay attention?

NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT???
The County of Santa Cruz, the Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) and CalTrans are partnering for the Project that will vastly reduce parking for Aptos Village businesses while adding bike and pedestrian bridges adjacent to the railroad bridges, some of which will be demolished.   The Project’s Highway One areas between State Park Drive and Freedom Boulevard will require the towering redwood trees alongside the road be axed.

However,  the Final Environment Impact Report that just became available from Caltrans claims the Project will have no significant impact, but does acknowledge (and ignores) the significant and unavoidable impact of tree loss.
EIR Hwy 1 from State Park Dr to Freedom Blvrd, and Coastal Rail Trail Segment 12

In a nutshell, here is what the Project involves:

 “Construct a new trail bridge crossings of State Route 1 at two locations and adjacent to the existing railroad bridges at Soquel Drive/Aptos Creek, and Valencia Creek would be constructed. New at-grade trail crossings would be constructed at Aptos Creek Drive, Parade Street, and Trout Gulch Road. An at-grade trail connection from the new trail to the Aptos Village County Park between Aptos Creek and Aptos Creek Road would be constructed. Under the optional first phase being considered, the two existing railroad bridges over State Route 1 would be removed and two new trail overcrossings over State Route 1 would be constructed in their place. The existing railroad bridges at Aptos Creek and Valencia Creek/Soquel Drive (south) would be repurposed for the new trail by removing the railroad decking and replacing with a new trail deck and railing system. The existing single span railroad bridge superstructure over Soquel Drive (north) would be removed and replaced with a new trail deck and railing system.
 
…the trail along the existing railroad track alignment would need to be removed, a trail would be constructed adjacent to the tracks as described by the proposed ultimate trail project, and the railroad tracks re-installed in their approximate existing location. At-grade railroad crossings of Aptos Creek Drive, Parade Street, and Trout Gulch Road would need to be reconstructed.” (Summary pages S-3 and S-4)

It seems a done-deal, but write to Lara Bertaina, Senior Environmental Planner, at (805) 779-0792 or
lara.bertaina@dot.ca.gov and voice your concerns if you have them.

I would also be interested in your thoughts on this Final EIR.

SURVEY FOR NEW PEDESTRIAN/ CYCLIST BRIDGE DESIGN IN APTOS VILLAGE
The Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) has big plans for Aptos Village that are couched in the Segment 12 Rail Trail Project.
RTC Seeking Input on Bridge Design Options for Coastal Rail Trail Bridge in Aptos

RTC OPEN HOUSES FOR ZERO EMISSION RAIL AND TRAIL IMPROVEMENT PRELIMINARY PURPOSE AND NEED STUDY
Will there ever be electric passenger rail service in Santa Cruz County, or will the possibility suffer death by permanent study?

Last Thursday’s RTC meeting featured a discussion of this Study of Zero Emission Rail and Trail Improvements that lasted for nearly two hours.

What I want to know is why the proposed electric passenger rail service study would stop the service at Santa Cruz, and does not include Davenport or  North Coast areas.

The Commission received a presentation on the Zero Emission Passenger Rail and Trail Project’s Preliminary Purpose and Need Statement, and received public comments and provided input on the item. The project proposes new high-capacity passenger rail service and stations on approximately 22 miles of the Santa Cruz Branch Rail Line from the City of Santa Cruz to Pajaro, as well as 12 miles of Coastal Rail Trail from Rio Del Mar Boulevard through the community of La Selva Beach and the City of Watsonville, as well as the Capitola Trestle section. 

The Project’s Purpose and Need Statement identifies and documents the needs and constraints that drive the development of transportation improvements in the Project study area and further outlines the opportunities to address these needs through the project’s fundamental purpose.

There will be two Open Houses for you to see what THIS study involves:
February 12  6-7:30pm  Ramsey Park Family Center, Watsonville
February 13, 6-7:30pm Live Oak Grange (1900 17th Avenue)

LEARN MORE ABOUT THE REDWOOD FORESTS
If you appreciate the wonderful Redwood forests, consider learning more about them here: Under The Redwoods – Sempervirens Fund

REST IN PEACE BARBARA CHAMBERLAIN
Barbara Chamberlain lived in Aptos for decades, and was a driving force behind the Cabrillo Host Lions Club work to improve the local Community with projects such as building the permanent restrooms, perimeter walking path  and benches in Polo Grounds County Park, Veterans Memorial benches in Aptos Village Park, and the WWI Monument Garden on Freedom Boulevard in Aptos.  She was also instrumental in organizing the library at Bradley Elementary School in Corralitos, and was an award-winning author and Life Member of the American Pen Women.
Barbara Chamberlain Obituary

She and her late husband, Dr. Dave Chamberlain (second dentist to come to the Aptos Village) cared deeply about the Aptos Community, and always tried to help those in need.  Dave was a Charter Member of the Cabrillo Host Lions Club, and Barbara served as District Governor for the service club.

We will miss her energy, story telling, and kind smile.  Rest in peace, Barbara.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC DEBATE OR HEARING.
DO ONE THING THIS WEEK, AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

February 5

Which Senate Candidate will be Best for the Earth?
Will you vote in March for Nature? How? It is a good time to do some research, ask some questions of candidates, and prepare to be an informed citizen when you cast your vote.

Situation Description – The Upcoming Election
There is a wide field of candidates running to be our Federal Senate representative. Senators are a Big Deal. Once elected, they can stay a long time in the office and there are many fewer of them than House representatives, so they are more powerful as individuals. As I often say in this column: I hope you cast your vote with careful consideration of the environmental platform of the candidates.

Three candidates stand out as particularly interesting in the lineup: Barbara Lee, Katie Porter, and Adam Schiff. Things are a little odd this election because we are voting twice for this same Senate seat.  The first vote is the PRIMARY for the full, 6-year term for senator. The top two vote getters will be the ones we get to choose between in November. The second vote we cast for senator is for someone to serve just until January 3, 2025, when Diane Feinstein’s term would have ended. They say that these types of things cause voter confusion and errors. Seems simple enough…

A Brief History
The seat up for election is the seat that Diane Feinstein had held for 31 years until her death while in office, 1992-2023. After Senator Feinstein died, Governor Newsom appointed Laphonza Butler to the position; Senator Butler is not running this election for that seat. This is the first time that the seat has been opened for an election since 1982, when Pete Wilson won it from Mill Valley’s Samuel Hayakawa. Pete, you’ll recall, went on to become the State’s Governor, setting up a situation that made it possible for Diane Feinstein to win the special election to finish his term. Once ensconced, it is difficult to unseat a Senator. (Some argue for term limits, but I can’t agree, preferring folks who get good at their work to stay put and do that well-practiced job even better for those they represent.)

Vote for the Environment!
Ask yourself if you know one single thing about the environmental voting record of…Diane Feinstein….Adam Schiff….Barbara Lee….or Katie Butler. I highly recommend the VoteSmart website to examine environmental voting records, endorsement ratings (many years back), and records of top funders. In short, Diane Feinstein scores higher than any other candidate trying to take her place on environmental issues, and she had a long record to chart.

When you examine ratings by the various environmental groups, think about who they are. I look to two organizations in particular: the Center for Biological Diversity Fund and the Defenders of Wildlife Action Fund. These two organizations have not been corrupted by the Outdoor Industry Association and their ilk, as have so many other so-called environmental organizations. Too many ‘environmental’ groups are professing tha all of nature’s problems are best solved by e-bikes and unbridled public access to every square inch of conservation land; the passionate people in these movements frequently overlook the central importance of species conservation to life on Earth.

A Common Voter Conundrum
We often look to polls to determine who is the ‘most electable’ before casting our vote. We want to be on the winning side. The problem is that even those who are being polled are influenced by the media portrayal of who is most electable, but where does the media get that information? Inch by inch, voters gravitate towards who they feel others would vote for, not who they prefer. The result is that people get elected who weren’t the heartfelt choice of the majority of voters. How sad!

Environmental Records, Compared
Of the three candidates I’m discussing, Adam Schiff’s environmental voting record is the worst, Barbara Lee’s the best, and Katie Porter in between. Adam Schiff’s environmental voting record is different from the other two candidates with one recent vote in particular: he voted ‘no’ on legislation (Save Oak Flat from Foreign Mining Act) that would have blocked a Trump-era midnight deal that transferred sacred Native American land from the US Forest Service to a foreign-owned mining corporation. Why Representative Schiff thought it was a good idea to vote in favor of one of Trump’s corporate, anti-nature blunders is dumbfounding. Barbara Lee and Katie Porter both knew better.

However, all three candidates refused to co-sponsor the Keep it in the Ground Act of 2021. That legislation would prohibit further oil exploration of the outer continental shelf and would stop our friends at BLM from issuing, renewing, reinstating, or extending any onshore fossil fuel leases that are not now productive. So, you can see that all three candidates are somehow firmly in the court of the Oilogarchy, as are so many politicians….all of whom are driving species to extinction by heating the planet.

The Endorsements That Matter
The Center for Biological Diversity and its associated Action Fund align fairly well with my values, and their website has easy-to-navigate comparisons of the candidates, so that you can see why the Center endorses Barbara Lee and not the other two.

Other endorsements are interesting. For instance, it is very interesting, given the contrasts that I outlined above, that the Sierra Club has failed to endorse one of the candidates for this Senate seat. Another group I follow is the League of Conservation Voters; again, given the contrasting votes outlined above, it is interesting to see that the three candidates are given pretty much identical scorecards.

Ask! Look!
What they say is as important as what they don’t say. Check out Adam Schiff’s website and you’ll see in BIG BOLD LETTERS the heading “PROTECTING WILDERNESS LANDS AND PRESERVING ENDANGERED WILDLIFE” – and then a big fat nothing about endangered species in the words below. You must dig a lot to find something, anywhere with anything he has done to protect endangered wildlife. Good luck finding any legislation that he originated that addresses the many shortfalls of species protection. Barbara Lee’s website contains this statement in favor of keeping the Endangered Species Act (ESA) as it is, which harkens back to the first answer I ever got from a candidate on this subject. When I asked their campaigns about their endangered species platforms, Obama’s staff wrote back to me that he wanted to keep the ESA as it was whereas Hillary Clinton’s staff wrote me and said merely that she opposed drilling for oil in the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge. Barbara Lee’s website mentions the problematic theme that she “is committed to protecting endangered animals and preserving and increasing public access to our national parks and public lands.” Increasing access??!! That’s a coded nod to the Outdoor Industry Association and their lackies who are trying to turn our parks into playgrounds to the detriment of wildlife.

You can view a moving video of Katie Porter speaking eloquently about the need to pass the Recovering America’s Wildlife Act of 2023; Ms. Porter is on the House Natural Resources Committee, which suggests her passion for, and knowledge about, environmental matters.

I hope you’ll spend a little bit of time following this course of questioning and even drop a line to the Senatorial candidates asking them about their positions on the environment, and species conservation specifically. Those things make a difference. And, hopefully, you’ll be casting your vote for the environment in this coming election!

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

I have already said this! More than once! Click right here for a link that will provide you with access to my many statements to the following effect:

“Crypto Is A Scam*”

Why should I send out a warning, one more time? I guess I am easily triggered by the thought that various people (even my own children, and their friends) might take real money, money belonging to them, and lose it all by “investing” it in cryptocurrencies.

My father’s admonitions come back to me. He bought me a book on the topic of how humans continue to be taken in by scams, and he gave it to me with the warning that I should pay attention. I think this was when I was in high school. That book is still in print. Check it out: Extraordinary Popular Delusions And The Madness of Crowds, by Charles Mackay. It’s a fun read, besides being true.

If you don’t think I know what I am talking about (and if you never met my father, so you have no real reason to believe that he knew what he was talking about, either), you might want to read a fairly recent article in The New York Times. The article was titled, “The Crypto Power Vacuum,” and quoted Hilary Allen, a law professor at American University’s Washington College of Law, and an “expert on financial regulation.”

Here is what Allen said about cryptocurrencies, in that New York Times‘ article:

There is no intrinsic value to any of this…. The only hope is to have more money sloshing around, and more people willing to buy into it to create demand….. Crypto isn’t disrupting Wall Street; it’s merging with it….. It’s fairly obvious — they think they can make some money here (emphasis added).

So (one more time): Don’t let the crypto-hucksters make their money at your expense! Don’t bite!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
February 5

GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT ON A FOOL’S ERRAND

Recent polls released by Bloomberg and Morning Consult indicate that Donald Trump is not immune to public disfavor should he be convicted in any of the remaining criminal trials he faces, with 53% of voters in seven key states stating a refusal to vote for him in that eventuality. And, should a prison sentence be a result, that percentage would rise by two percentage points…WHAT? Only two points…what’s wrong with a 47% spike, people? We know he’s a crook…he’s either purposely or inadvertently confessed to every wrongful action of which he’s been accused! “The preponderance of polling out there shows that there is a chunk of Republican voters who say a felony conviction would be a bridge too far,” says GOP strategist Dan Judy“Does that mean that Trump still gets 80 to 85 percent of Republican voters, rather than 90 or 95 percent? Probably. But that could easily be the election right there.”

With the Bloomberg poll showing Trump up by six points with registered voters in the battleground states, the question is: would those figures be borne out in the general election? Some aggrieved voters typically look past any misgivings and vote for that candidate who echoes their own views. Case in point being the Access Hollywood tape where Trump disparages women, yet went on to being victorious. The four indictments with a total of 91 criminal charges only served to strengthen his hold onto the MAGAt base, rallying them with each new announcement targeting their Golden Jesus. An Economist/YouGov poll indicates a favorability of 79% within the GOP, but only 40% in the general public. While Trump asserts his innocence of all charges, the trials lie ahead, as does the onslaught of the Biden campaign and his supporters, both within the Democratic Party and its fringes.

At this juncture, it appears the lesser of the charges – the Stormy Daniels bribery case – will see the light of day before the other, more serious cases are brought to the fore, simply because the Supreme Court is wrestling with whether or not a president has immunity from prosecution…which brings up the question of whether Trump would see a boost resulting from any acquittal. Dan Judy tosses in, “As people always say, the most valuable resource you have as a candidate is time. The more time he is spending, and his people are spending, trying to keep him out of court and out of prison, the less he is spending out on the campaign trail trying to fire up his base, or persuade the few persuadable voters in this country.” Judy, known as a Trump cynic, realizes that any prediction regarding the former prez’s fate has often proven to be a fool’s errand. “As with so many things with him over the years, there is no history to fall back on here. There is nowhere to go to say, ‘This is what happened in the past in a similar situation.’ There is no way to know for sure,” he cautions.

Leaks from within Trump’s circle indicate that he believes he will be convicted of attempting to overturn the 2020 presidential election results in his upcoming trial, as Axios reports. He fully expects a DC jury will find him guilty of conspiring to defraud the American people on four charges that carry a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison, a verdict which would send his attempt to retake the White House into complete shambles, even as he plans to attend every proceeding of the trial to prove that a corrupt system is seeking his destruction. In the Georgia elections interference case, Trump is pointing at DA Fani Willis’s relationship with the chief lawyer in the case, Nathan Wade, as evidence of corruption, undermining the charges against him as Wade is being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in “this scam for her lover.” Willis admits to the relationship and says there are no grounds to dismiss the case or remove her from the prosecution.

Bocha Blue in a Palmer Report post says, “Trump wants to be seen as a Viking god, bold and proud in the spirit of an Achilles, never feeling fear. But that’s wrong. No Achilles’ heel for him. Donald Trump is lying. He’s lying to you, he’s lying to me. He’s lying to himself. Donald Trump is one of the most fearful little humans on the planet. He fears the unknown; he fears the known. He fears anything that will take away his pride, money or ability to win elections. And he is very scared of being found guilty in one of his criminal cases. To that, I say, of course he will be found guilty, but apparently, this is just making its way into Donald Trump’s consciousness, and it’s causing him a great deal of fear.”

It happened at the Colorado Republican primary debate, a long night under the hot lights with nine candidates, appearing before a large, attentive crowd eager to hear their spiels. All evening they had been asked to answer questions individually, but out of the crowd came a question addressed to the lot of them…“How many of you have been arrested? Let’s see a show of hands.” Six hands shot into the air…Lauren Low-Rent Boebert being one of those…six out of nine in the Wild New West! So, how did the crowd react? “Yeahhhhh!!!!,” accompanied by wild applause…their kind of folks, politicians proud of their arrests! Bocha Blue says, “Stupidity lives everywhere, even in the beauty of the sweeping mountains. These people are the party who says they ‘back the blue.’ This is the supposed party of law and order. Take a good look at ’em…you may not be able to for long, as they head for Whig territory. Six in nine! Boebert humiliated herself by not even making it into the top three in the straw poll. We should be grateful, perhaps, that it was not ALL of them with raised hands.” Reminds one of folkie Arlo Guthrie’s recording of ‘Alice’s Restaruant,’ where he tells of reporting for the military draft after being arrested earlier for dumping garbage for the restaurant. One of the sergeants asks him if he had ever been arrested and if he had gone to court, both answers being in the positive, which required him to go sit on The Group W bench, along with others who may not be moral enough to be in the Army. When the ‘meanest guy of all’ asks him, “Kid, whad’ya get?” And upon answering, “I didn’t get nothing. I had to pay $50 and pick up the garbage.” When the Group W bunch found he had been arrested for littering, they all moved away from him until he added, “And creating a nuisance,” bringing them all back to shake his hand while having a great time sitting on their bench.

Bad news for Trump in the action he filed in the UK over the ‘Steele dossier,’ which contained allegations that he took part in “perverted” sex acts and gave bribes to Russian officials – the High Court judge dismissed the case he brought against Orbis Business Intelligence, founded by MI6 officer, Christopher Steele. Steele was the author of the dossier which contained the allegations that Trump had been “compromised” by FSB, the Russian security service, at which time The Don reportedly participated in “sex parties” in St. Petersburg, and consorted with prostitutes in Moscow. In her judgement, Mrs. Justice Karen Steyn said, “In my view, there are no compelling reasons to allow the claim to proceed to trial in circumstances where, whatever the merits of the allegation that the personal data are inaccurate may be, the claim for compensation and/or damage…is bound to fail. In reality, the claimant is seeking court findings to vindicate his reputation in circumstances where he has not been able to formulate any viable remedy which he would have a real prospect of obtaining, or which would itself be of any utility; and having chosen  to allow so many years to elapse – without any attempt to vindicate his reputation in this jurisdiction – since he was first made aware of the dossier, including the memorandum, on 6 January 2017.”

Orbis produced the dozen memos in the dossier in 2016, but Trump was sworn in as president in 2017 when material was then published by BuzzFeed. During the court hearing, Antony White KC, for the consultancy, said the case had been brought to pursue a “vendetta” against Orbis and the former MI6 officer, saying,“The claimant has a deep and intense animus against Mr. Steele and Orbis, which is reflected in numerous vituperative public statements which he has made since it was made public by BuzzFeed. Mr. Trump has a long history of repeatedly bringing frivolous, meritless and vexatious claims for the purpose of vexing and harassing perceived enemies and others against whom he bears a grudge.” The charges of Trump/Russia collusion in the dossier were accorded some plausibility based on Steele’s reputation, but have been discredited over the years, with Steele himself saying the claims were unverified tips that warranted further investigation, and not for release to the public, but he stands by the work, the sources, and the professionalism applied. Back to you, Donny!

Narcissism or dementia…you decide! Trump posted a question on his Truth Social site, along with a photo of half his face spliced with a photo of Elvis Presley, with the query, “For so many years, people have been saying that Elvis and I look alike. Now that this pic has been going all over the place, what do you think?” Maybe the new Taylor Swift competition brought this on; obviously, she needs to start paying attention! His previous attempts to liken himself to Nelson MandelaAbraham Lincoln and the Mona Lisa got him nowhere, so why not try Elvis? Or as one responder suggested, “Fat Elvis!” Close enough for you, DonnyboyBen Meiselas of Meidas Touch said that Trump’s recent behavior “has people finally seeing just how delusional, cognitively impaired, and utterly weird Trump’s campaign is.” President Biden remarks, “This is the weirdest campaign I’ve ever been engaged in,” and rival Nikki Haley has used the former prez’s prominent public blunders to ramp up her attacks on his cognitive abilities.

Curmudgeon, political writer and painter, Robert Harrington, who lives in England, posts on the Palmer Report that a scene in the 1987 Charles Bukowski movie, ‘Barfly,’ has the male lead hooting with laughter, as the female lead from the next room asks him, “What is it?” His answer, as he listens to a drunken couple’s brawling in the next room, “It’s hatred, the only thing that lasts.” Harrington is not so sure about that, but says it has staying power and motivating power, which drew him into political writing. He calls Eisenhower the last decent Republican president, and only had pity for Nixon, never noticing Ford. He vaguely disliked the Reagan/Bush duo, with George W’s martial rhetoric mildly repellant. But, hate for Trump is real, visceral, with abhorrent loathing as for a worst enemy, with his having transformed the mother country into a place of strife and division. As a Never-Trumper he has a core hatred. He quotes Brian Beutler of Substack’s ‘Off Message’ who says, “Never-Trumpers comprise a majority of the country. It suggests that anti-Trumpism is the most powerful force in American politics, and it husbanded well [it will make] an insurmountable obstacle to his hold on power.” Harrington believes this hate guarantees our win against Trump, a huge motivator to get voters to the polls, resulting in a crushing, unprecedented defeat. He always ends his posts with, “And, as ever, ladies and gentlemen, brothers and sisters, comrades and friends, stay safe.”

Trump continues to claim that the Constitution gives him the right to do as he chooses as president, and even as not-president, it seems. But he probably is confusing Article 2 with Article 8, which says once a man is elected president he is immune from prosecution for anything he did before, during and after the term is up, as long as his name is Trump. Plus, Article 9 says that this former president, if he so chooses, has the ability to return, re-write the Constitution and make himself King of the USA. Dream on, Donnyboy! Those articles don’t exist…yet!

Musician, song-writer and poet, Patti Smith says, “In art and dream you may proceed with abandon. In life may you proceed with balance and stealth.” So, let’s don our combat sneakers and join Robert Harrington to rid our country of this divisive enemy of democracy to restore our balance and safety! And as author Kurt Vonnegut advised, “And how should we behave during this Apocalypse? We should be unusually kind to one another, certainly. But we should stop being so serious. Jokes help a lot. And get a dog, if you don’t already have one.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Delay”

“Delay is preferable to error.”
~Thomas Jefferson

“In Washington, ‘delay’ is too often code for ‘derail.’ Wink, wink.”
~Peter Welch

“Delay is the enemy of progress.”
~Eliot Spitzer

“Delay in justice is injustice.”
~Walter Savage Landor

“At times it is folly to hasten at other times, to delay. The wise do everything in its proper time.”
~Ovid

...

[this is a throwback of mine, because it was so good!]

“Sweden has distributed author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s feminist manifesto, “We Should All Be Feminists,” to every 16-year-old student in the country.” The essay is an adaptation of the TEDx talk below. When you have a half hour, watching this video is an awesome way to spend it.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 31 – February 6, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton…more throwback Greensite…on new development: losing our way… Steinbruner…reminder: protest the Soquel Creek Water District rate hike, and County Fair . Hayes…on stuff… Patton…book recommendation… Matlock…bad to the bone… Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes….”Rain”

...

UCSC STUDENT VIGIL AGAINST TUITION May 18, 1967. Sure, that’s then California Governor Ronald Reagan visiting the UCSC campus. I’m betting that is Vernon Berlin who started KSCO radio holding the microphone on the left. History knows what Reagan thought of students.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.
Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com

DATELINE January 31, 2024

UPDATE ON BRUCE Bruce is still on the mend. For more details, or to just say hi and get better, you can email him at bratton@cruzio.com. I think he has a tablet so he can read email.
[Note: broken email link should be fixed, copy and paste if it still doesn’t work -Webmistress]

The archives are rich with material, so I went in and grabbed some more.

//Gunilla//


[Dateline MARCH 2015]

HIGHWAY 17 SIX, part 2. One thing we can agree on is that Governor Jerry Brown, the UC Regents and UC president Janet Napolitano won’t change tuition by one cent for months. Even then, it may increase.The HIGHWAY 17 SIX are receiving tremendous support for their blocking of Highway 17 protest. They have a Civil Rights attorney Dan Siegel who used to be legal advisor to Oakland Mayor Jean Quan. He resigned from that office because of her use of police against the Occupy Oakland Movement. We should all agree that our California education system is terrible and ranks near the bottom of most lists. We should also agree that more than ever we need to provide our kids with better and better education….just to compete on the career/ job market. We need to agree that a $5000 top is a sufficient tuition for any California resident. Those Highway 17 Six fought hard, gave up a lot and are being incredibly brave for their cause of fighting the UC tuition increase and police violence. Back in the day (1957-65) when I was a UC Berkeley student and card carrying member of SLATE at the UC Berkeley Campus and later sat inside UC Berkeley’s Sproul Hall with Joan Baez and Tom Luddy who showed his collection of silent films on the hallway walls, we heard Mario Savio say, “There’s a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious—makes you so sick at heart—that you can’t take part. You can’t even passively take part. And you’ve got to put your bodies upon the gears and upon the wheels, upon the levers, upon all the apparatus, and you’ve got to make it stop. And you’ve got to indicate to the people who run it, to the people who own it that unless you’re free, the machine will be prevented from working at all.” It was 1965 when Martin Luther King Jr. said, “One has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws.” I think those brave Highway 17 Six and thousands of University of California students need to think bigger.

[BACK TO THE CURRENT TIMELINE What happened with this? As far as I know, the Hwy 17 Six got 6-month jail sentences. -Webmistress ]

KEEPING THIS HERE TO REMIND YOU TO VOTE YES ON MEASURE M…PLEASE DONATE NOW!!
There is still time to donate, funds are needed by Febrary 10, 2024 In short, if enacted by the voters, Measure M will accomplish TWO simple things:

#1.) Require the city to get voter approval before height limits can be raised to allow oversized, high-rise developments anywhere in the city, downtown or in our neighborhoods.

#2.) Increase the number of affordable housing units that big developers must provide, from 20% to 25% for projects of over 30 units, as the City Planning Commission researched and recommended.

Measure M is facing enormous and well-funded opposition from out-of-town developers and their allies.  We NEED your financial assistance now to run a successful campaign. With only 60 days left before we vote on March 5, 2024, the sooner you donate the better. Another incentive to donate soon is we have matching funds.

Our fundraising goal is $50,000. This money will be used for our online presence, campaign materials, advertising, professional assistance and to rally residents to vote.

Make as generous a contribution as you possibly can to help pass Measure M and be part of the future design of Santa Cruz!  
TWO ways to donate:

  1. Online with the DONATE button on:  Yes-on-M.org
  1. Or Write a check to: “Yes on M”, and call us to pick it up 831-471-7822 or send the check before Feb. 10 to:  
    Yes on M, PO Box 2191, Santa Cruz, Ca. 95063

Partial List of Supporters:

Gary Patton, Former County Supervisor, Environmental Attorney
Katherine Beiers, Former Mayor
Jane Weed-Pomerantz, Former Mayor
Nell Newman, Founder, Newman’s Own Organics, Environmentalist & Biologist
Rick Longinotti, Author, Right to Vote on Desal Initiative
Joseph S. Quigg, Affordable and Market-rate Housing Developer
Frank Barron, Retired Urban Planner
Keresha Durham-Tamba, Bilingual Educator, Environmental-Climate Activist
Hector Marin-Castro, Santa Cruz City Teacher’s Aid and Service Worker
Susan Monheit, Retired State Water Regulator, Environmental Scientist
Steve Bare, Retired High School Teacher, Military Veteran
Laura Lee, Retired Teacher, Corporate Trainer & Facilitator

Bruce will be back with movie reviews as soon as he’s had a chance to write more!

...

January 29th 2024

Losing Our Way

Photo by Katie C.

Driving to meet a friend for dinner at a downtown restaurant on a recent Saturday evening, I followed a familiar route. It was raining heavily; visibility was poor, and I missed the Cedar Street left turn off Laurel. “Never mind I’ll turn at Pacific” I thought. What happened next was a strange, disorienting experience. With that new tall, block-length building looming ahead through the rain and glare of headlights, I did not recognize where I was. My brain tried to make sense of the unfamiliar surroundings with one part knowing it should be Pacific Avenue and another part rejecting that fact. The familiar Liquor store sign and low-rise Pacific Avenue landmarks were lost in the mass of the new high-rise. I turned left, still unsure where I was. Such is the loss of a sense of place, what writer Rebecca Solnit calls a sixth sense.

Urban planner Edward T. McMahon writes: “A sense of place is a unique collection of qualities and characteristics – visual, cultural, social, and environmental – that provide meaning to a location. Sense of place is what makes one city or town different from another, but sense of place is also what makes our physical surroundings worth caring about.”

He adds, “If I have learned anything from my career in urban planning, it is this: a community’s appeal drives economic prosperity. I have also learned that, while change is inevitable, the destruction of a community’s unique character and identity is not. Progress does not demand degraded surroundings. Communities can grow without destroying the things that people love.” Edward T. McMahon, UrbanLand April 4, 2012.

Granted, few would defend the former Taco Bell and Bonesio’s Liquor Store as “charming”. Nonetheless they are/were a familiar part of the fabric of our town. For those who have lived here for a while, they embodied the same character as the Broken Egg and the Fun Spot, both razed for a parking garage and a parking lot respectively, hardly pluses on the “charming” scale.  While a Taco Bell is not unique, it was at least on the working-class end of the gentrification scale. Not only are we losing a sense of place, we are losing the working class character of Santa Cruz along with the working class itself. This class shift is readily seen on the far west side of town. It will soon become evident along Water Street and Soquel on the Eastside as older low-rise long-time businesses are bulldozed, replaced with new, mixed-use high-rise generics, eradicating the last remnants of character and familiarity, let alone the businesses themselves. I can hear the scoffing from some newbies who either profit from this transformation or have no internalized sense of place. That, or they have swallowed the party line of “we need more housing” without examining the class impacts of just adding a bigger supply of mostly market-rate housing.

Thus, it was a pleasant surprise to read the Mayor’s Message in last Sunday’s Sentinel. Randy Johnson is the Mayor of Scotts Valley. His words are the first I’ve heard from a local politician that are overtly critical of the heavy hand of the state dictating to local communities just what they shall build with no leeway for local control. Sure, we have heard other local politicians tell us that we have no more local land-use control due to state mandates, but it is spoken in the tone of resignation, never as push-back. In contrast, Mayor Johnson is outspoken and sticks up for his town. In response to an out-of-state developer who informed Johnson that he, the developer intended to use the “builder’s remedy” to build a multi-level 200-plus unit project on a small city lot, Mayor Johnson writes, “So the outcome of the State’s housing directive is that a Midwest Company, a thousand miles away has more control over our city’s future than its citizens do. That’s wrong.” The mayor continues, “I would propose a ‘city’s remedy’ where the state rethinks its ‘one-size-fits-all’ position on how to meet the state’s housing needs. Every community is unique. The integrity of local control must be trusted. We should work in a spirit of cooperation and find balanced and workable solutions that set up cities and counties for success. To do otherwise condemns us to a path of confusion, skepticism, and distrust that serves no-one and compromises our future.” There is more but you get the picture. A political leader fighting for the character and identity of his city. How inspiring!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

PROTEST SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT DRASTIC RATE CHANGES
Last Thursday, the District held a Rate Study webinar that was a repeat of what the Raftelis consultants had presented to the Board in December to convince them to approve the drastic changes to fixed service fees and rates over the next four years.

 Customers can  send written protest to be received by February 20 but not once did any of the District staff say that people could protest and how to do that.  The District rate increase mailer gave very little fine-print space to that either.
Here is where to learn more about protesting these drastic rate changes that are really going to hit the low water users the hardest.

The consultant had been running the meeting, but General Manager Ron Duncan took over to try to answer the good questions that people were posting in the chat box.  He took alot of time saying very  little before turning the questions over to Ms. Strohm or Ms. Schumacher, the new Assistant Manager.

The shocking thing that he did say is that “everybody’s water rates go up because people conserve.”

He must have been referencing the claim at the October 17, 2023 Board meeting by Finance Director Leslie Strohm that “we’re in this situation due to a  $11,000,000 shortfall in water sales revenues.”

The truth is  the cost of the PureWater Soquel Project has ballooned and even the $95million received in grants is not enough to pay the actual $200,000,000 construction cost or the projected annual operating cost of the treatment facility that has doubled to $5,500,000 annually.

The extravagant $1000/month bonus for Ms. Strohm that the Board approved at behest of General Manager Ron Duncan, made retroactive to when the Project began and that will continue until it is completed, certainly has not helped the financial health of the District.  Melanie Schmacher, the Project’s outreach coordinator (recently made Assistant Manager) gets a $1,600/month bonus, and Taj DuFour, Engineering Director, gets $1,000/month bonus.

Now, with the impending rate changes, most low-water users will see their bills increase by about $30/month while those who use alot of water may see decreases.  Does that make sense?

Ms. Schumacher answered one such question last Thursday.

When the PureWater Soquel Project was getting started in 2019, the District was not sure it would get grants to fund construction, so the Tier 2 rate were made five times higher than Tier 2 to pay for it.  Now that the Project is close to becoming operational (maybe this fall), everybody will benefit by the protection to the groundwater basin by injecting 1500 AcreFeet of treated sewage water annually into the groundwater, so everybody must pay their fair share.

At that point, the Raftelis rate consultant jumped in and assured the audience that the current rate changes and tier restructuring “will have a smoothing effect” over what the last rate changes caused.

Hmmm……

The District has removed the video links to the rate increase discussions the Board had with Raftelis rate consultants on November 6, 2018 (the same meeting where they approved the Twin Lakes Church injection well project before the EIR for the PureWater Soquel Project was even certified).

The last time the Board raised rates, Ms. Strohm recommended that the Board review District revenues and expenses annually to determine if the rate increases were still necessary.  That has never happened.

Former Director Bruce Daniels even publicly stated that if the District were awarded the anticipated $50 million grant for the PureWater Soquel Project, the Board would lower the rates.  Well, the District staff purports to have gotten about $95 million, but the rates never were adjusted, and are now drastically going up 10% this year, and 12% annually thereafter for three years.

If you or anyone you know is a customer of Soquel Creek Water District,  and do not agree with the proposed dramatic rate changes, please send written protest.  It must be received by the February 20 public hearing.

You can find the protest template here

FREE RENT FOR THE FAIRGROUNDS FOUNDATION AT SANTA CRUZ COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS?
Last Tuesday, the Fairgrounds Board met to approve a number of things the new CEO has put before them.  That included a Contract with the Fairgrounds Foundation that will provide FREE RENT for that less-than transparent fundraising group’s office and storage.

Hmmm…can the State gift that to a non-profit?

Take a look at the murky deal the new CEO made with the Fairgrounds Foundation, and that somehow did not even raise an eyebrow by the Fair Board members (some were missing) before approval.

There is NO list of “Assets” that the State-owned Fairgrounds will be paying $12 to rent, and in exchange, allow the Fairgrounds Foundation a gift of free office and storage space on the grounds:

3. Rent. 
In consideration of the lease of the Assets as provided herein, Fairgrounds agrees to pay the Foundation an annual rental amount of Twelve Dollars($12.00) due and payable on the first day of each calendar year during the Lease term, commencing on January 1st, 2024.

4. Use of Grounds. 
In consideration of the lease of the Assets outlined herein, Fairgrounds commits to furnishing the Foundation with office and storage space. The extent and placement of the provided space will be determined solely by Fairgrounds.
(page 209)

This is not transparent.  No list of “Assets” the State is renting from the Foundation, no explanation of the $12 rent amount the State is paying to the Foundation, and no value provided for the office and storage space the State is providing the Foundation for free.

All this, after a State audit in 2022 that uncovered many significant and troubling financial and policy matters that led to then-CEO Dave Kegebein getting fired.

But wait….it gets worse…..

EX-FAIRGROUNDS CEO NOW IN CHARGE OF THE AG HISTORY PROJECT AT THE FAIRGROUNDS
It was shocking to me last Tuesday to hear Ms. Kitiyama report to the Fair Board on behalf of the Ag History Project that Dave Kegebein is the organization’s new Executive Director.

This is the same Dave Kegebein who the Fair Board fired in October, 2022 for embezzling alot of money and many other concerning actions.   This is the same person who now continues to arrogantly command other tenants at the Fairgrounds to do his bidding.

Take a look at the Compliance Audit and ask yourself if you would trust to allow such a person around and be actively involved in major financial and policy issues:

The new CEO is seemingly a puppet for all of this….so nothing has changed.  In fact, in my opinion, transparency is worse.  And the Fair Board asks virtually no questions.

2024 SANTA CRUZ COUNTY FAIR THEME
Also reported at last Tuesday’s Fair Board meeting was that an unknown group decided this year’s September 11-15 Fair theme will be “Pioneer Days and Modern Ways”.

There will be a 200-drone light show each night, with tickets sold to those who want seats in the grandstand to watch it and listen to the musical accompaniment.

Parking fees are going up $5/vehicle, but you might get a deal if you carpool with others.  Those details are still being worked out.

Stay tuned.

SWENSON’S APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT STORMWATER NOW DRAINING INTO APTOS CREEK
Last week, Swenson crews connected the large stormwater drain pipe up in the Aptos Village Park so that all the parking lot, street and rooftop stormwater will now flow into Aptos Creek.

I wonder how this will affect the water quality for those steelhead and coho salmon trying to make their way back upstream to spawn?  Do you think California Dept. of Fish & Wildlife have approved this?

Write and ask: Wesley Stokes <wesley.stokes@wildlife.ca.gov> and Serena Stumpf <serena.stumpf@wildlife.ca.gov>

Take a look at the hillside disturbance and pipe that is above ground in Aptos Village Park below.

Digging up the road in Aptos Village Park for the stormwater drain pipe.

PHASE 2 OF SWENSON’S APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT IS TOWERING
It is amazing to see the construction moving along on towering mixed use subdivision of Aptos Village Project Phase 2.  The buildings will be three-stories tall, and seemingly with minimal setbacks from the hazardously-narrow Aptos Village Way.

The last amended design I saw was to minimize or eliminate landscaping and space between the structures, and parking was seemingly inadequate.  All parking on Aptos Village Way for businesses in the Phase 1 area is now prohibited, due to construction traffic…or something.

This towering construction is happening on both sides of Aptos Village Way and all parking is prohibited.  Swenson promised the public there would be parking for Nisene Marks Park users…but where?

The parking study for the Project was inaccurate, to say the least.  But it doesn’t matter now…most of the office and retail spaces are vacant.

GOOD NEWS!  APTOS LIBRARY TO OPEN FEBRUARY 5
According to librarians at the Capitola Library, the newly-constructed Aptos Library is due to open February 5.

It is good to see the construction chainlink fencing gone, and the lights on inside.

WRITE ON LETTER TO THE EDITOR.  MAKE ONE CALL TO AN ELECTED OFFICIAL ABOUT SOMETHING THAT CONCERNS YOU.  ATTEND A CANDIDATE FORUM IF YOU CAN FIND ONE.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,

Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Appreciate Your Stuff, and Get Less of It

After reading this sentence, look around and ask yourself: where did all this stuff come from? We surround ourselves with stuff. A significant part of some people’s mental focus is about acquiring more stuff, comparing prices of stuff, comparing their stuff to other people’s stuff, and figuring out how to get rid of their old, broken, or worn-out stuff.  Stuff is both underappreciated and overconsumed.

The Story of Stuff

If you haven’t watched it yet, or if it’s been a while, I urge you to take 7 minutes out of your day, right now, and watch Annie Leonard’s The Story of Stuff. It is brilliant and hopefully will inspire you to change your relationship with stuff. Here’s a funny question to ask your friends or family members: “Do you like stuff?” It is a worthy question. Some people unabashedly exclaim “YES!” Others not so much. Some people deny liking stuff altogether.

House Stuff

There is a lot of important stuff around you. Housing is critical for everyone. A house is where people put their stuff and it is where they gain shelter from the elements, safety from other people, wild animals, unleashed dogs, etc. Most people around here who live in homes live in a ‘stick built’ house that is sheathed inside with drywall and outside with plywood then something else over that. I once had visitors from France who watched a renovation next door and awkwardly asked, “Is that a historic home that they are renovating?” I said, “No, that’s how we build things.” They laughed a bunch saying that in France they never build with wood, only metal framing, which lasts so much longer and doesn’t burn. They were incredulous. Wood is grown. Metal is mined. Construction wood is sequestered carbon. Metal is high energy carbon release. Metal lasts longer and is recyclable. The trade-offs between those two types of stuff are interesting when considering building. Where did the wood in your home come from? If it is an old home, perhaps it is old growth redwood from these very mountains. If it is newer, the lumber probably came from clear cut forests in the pacific northwest or Canada. Where did your drywall come from? It was mined. Check out this big hole in the California desert where gypsum is mined and then turned into drywall. This giant mine is appropriately named ‘Plaster City, California‘ and makes more than half the drywall in the country. Most people who build houses don’t ask many questions about the ecological footprint of their house ingredients. Do you want an affordable home, or not? Asking for more sustainable products is going to cost you more! By building affordable homes that are built with traditional products, we are passing on some enormous costs to future generations. Poor forest management is filling streams with sediment, destroying fisheries, causing life threatening landslides, destabilizing economies and communities built around more sustainable forest management. Gypsum mining has caused surface- and groundwater contamination, erosion, and permanently removes wildlife habitat.

Other Stuff

Outside of the bones and skin of your home, there’s lots of stuff inside the house: where did it come from, how long will it last, what happens to it when it gets old and breaks? So much around us is made of fiber. Carpets, towels, furniture coverings, sheets, curtains, clothes…woven and stitched together fibers. How many of us consider the source of those fibers? Personally, I like my fibers to be biodegradable and organically grown, but I have paid a lot for that choice, and it has not always possible to find. Cotton that is not organically grown is a synthetic fertilizer and pesticide-intensive crop…not something I want to support or surround my body with either with clothes or in sheets and towels. When such things wear out, it used to be that Goodwill would take the worn-out stuff and sell it as rag cloth, which was recycled. I’m not sure that occurs anymore. One could compost pure cotton cloth after it has outlived its value as rags. Rag cotton has at times been recycled as insulation for homes, a replacement for (mined) fiberglass insulation. Wool is another natural fiber. Watch carefully when selecting natural fibers because too often they are augmented with various plastic fibers, which degrade into microplastics and are barely if at all recyclable. What does one do with those plastic fibers and the myriad of plastics found in other stuff which is similarly not recyclable?

Away

A friend suggests visiting “away.” One “away” is at the end of Dimeo Lane on the North Coast of Santa Cruz County. When you throw things ‘away’ the place it goes is actually a landfill. Interesting word, ‘landfill.’ Like it was empty before? Sacrifice zone is one way to put it. “Drainage basin destroying, methane belching, seemingly contained long-term pollutant blob requiring intergenerational expense allocation” is the more honest thing to call it. That’s where your old stuff goes. As Annie Leonard points out in the film I linked you to above, most ‘stuff’ has been carefully planned for obsolescence. In other words, it breaks according to plan. And, when most stuff breaks, there is nothing to be done with it except throwing it ‘away.’ Most stuff is such an amalgamation of materials that it is impossible under the current regulatory environment to recycle. That’s our fault: we don’t care enough to vote for people who prioritize solutions to this problem.

Solutions

Until policies require that all ‘stuff’ lasts longer and is completely recyclable, the solution to the problem of stuff is to buy less of it, focusing on buying only the stuff that we need, and making sure that what we buy isn’t bad stuff…it lasts, its creation hasn’t poisoned the environment, its obsolescence is appropriately long, and its disposal creates life instead of death. In the 1980’s someone figured that the transaction cost of exchanging a dollar bill in purchase burned a liter of crude oil, so just plain spending less is a good thing for the planet. Saving money is good: few people appreciate that their money is their time and that we don’t really have that much time…for our loved ones…for our own enjoyment. When considering buying something, ask yourself: do I really need this? Like 3 times. If we really need something, then we must ask ourselves ‘is this bad stuff?’ Like 3 times. The specific questions to determine if something is Bad Stuff are: How was it made, what’s it made of, how long will it last, where will it end up when it’s no longer useful? Maybe we should carry a card with these questions to take out and read before our purchases. Oh, that’s no fun! (can you imagine yourself or your shopping partner saying that?). Is shopping fun? It will be a deeper kind of fun with this line of questioning. We are changing the world when we avoid buying stuff and when we only buy Good Stuff. Be that change.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 2024
#33 / Is Our Land A Beast To Be Bought And Sold?

Trudy Wischemann, who sometimes goes by “woodworker,” writes columns for a couple of newspapers published in California’s Central Valley, The Foothills Sun-Gazette and The Mid-Valley Times. Her thoughts come to the public under the title, “Notes From Home,” and I recommend them to you.

Thanks to Wischemann, I have become acquainted with Gerald Haslam, who is pictured above. Haslam was a  writer, and he was also an emeritus professor of literature at Sonoma State University. He died in 2021. Clicking the next link will take you to Wikipedia page devoted to Haslam.

And let me give you another link to click, as well. Clicking on the following link will take you to a website maintained by the University of Nevada Press, and give you an opportunity to buy this book by Haslam:

I am recommending you do that – or that you hunt the book down in your local library and read about the Central Valley, and about the people who have lived there in the past, and who live there now.

When I worked for the Planning and Conservation League, based in Sacramento, I traveled through the Central Valley on a weekly basis, commuting to and from “home,” in Santa Cruz, California, on the coast. I learned very little about the Central Valley as I passed through it. Haslam’s book has helped increase my understanding.

This specific blog posting, coming to you in early February 2024, was stimulated by a particular line in one of the essays contained in The Other California, a book I finished reading right before the end of last year.

The familiar vista of the Sacramento Valley from an airplane reveals more than a physical contrast. Obvious are roads, canals and fence lines slashing below, straight and measured geometry assignments. Equally obvious is the lurching course of a great river, feeder streams squiggling into it like a mad artist’s doodling.

Less obvious when viewing those features from above is that they represent opposing visions of the place. The canals, the roads, the fence lines are proprietary, profane reflections of contemporary American beliefs; the streams are familiar and sacred reflections of Native American assumptions.

In what sense profane? The Valley was not the ancestral home of Europeans; they had no enduring link to it, so it was in no way sacrosanct. Moreover, they assumed theologically that nature was somehow the enemy of people – a beast to be domesticated, bought and sold (emphasis added).

Those of us who have been concerned by what is sometimes called “land use,” will understand what Haslam is talking about, suggesting that the lands we inhabit can be seen as “a beast to be bought and sold.” Haslam’s writings celebrate both of the realities he urges us to consider – the “sacrosanct” reality of the natural world and the “profane” reality of the “human world” we have carved out from the “world of nature.” Haslam’s writings, which are poetically expressed, teach us about the right relationship of these “two worlds” that we call home.

The words you are reading here – for anyone who is reading them – are posted to a blog that I maintain, “We Live In A Political World.” Each daily entry in that blog is preceded by this introduction:

We live, simultaneously, in two different worlds. Ultimately, we live in the World of Nature, a world that we did not create and the world upon which all life depends. Most immediately, we inhabit a “human world” that we create ourselves. Because our human world is the result of our own choices and actions, we can say, quite properly, that we live, most immediately, in a “political world.” In this blog, I hope to explore the interaction of these two worlds that we call home.

For those, like me, who were born in California, who call California “home,” Haslam’s writings are essential. They speak to all of us who want thoughtfully to consider what it means to live here, and to take seriously our obligations to this place, and to those who live here with us.

While Haslam does call us to our obligations, he reminds us, also, how right it is joyously to celebrate the good fortune that has called us to be alive, right here, in California, right now.

Gerald Haslam: recommended!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

TAKING BAD TO THE BONE TO THE BONEPILE

Money, money, money problems seem to be raising ugliness within the GOP ranks of late. It’s reported that the Biden campaign has been out-raising the Trump campaign, and the DNC has raised massive amounts of cash compared to the RNC, much of which is rumored to be going into Trump’s coffers toward his legal woes. As the RNC heads toward the bottom, a vote is to be held to authorize a line of credit, thanks to Citizen Trump, who is tanking this major political party’s funds. Totally apropos, since he has tanked almost everything in his own business history before running the nation aground during his term in office. The Grand Old Party won’t see the light of day again with his involvement, and to paraphrase Hillary Clinton“Trump has written several books, but they all seem to end with Chapter Eleven!” Last one out the door, please turn out the lights!

The nonchalance over funds seems to have the GOP approaching the nation’s budgetary impasse with the same stubborn laxity, with House Speaker Johnson relinquishing control of the House Clown Car to the Talibangelicals. They cancelled votes on two party-line funding bills, a transportation bill was pulled due to resistance to cuts to he Amtrak budget, and a financials services bill was wrenched thanks to the MAGAts attempts to pack it with anti-abortion legislation. “I don’t think the Lord Jesus himself could manage this group,” groused Texas Representative Troy Nehls“We’re ungovernable.” The Republicans spent days in finally selecting Speaker Johnson, but it brings them no closer to a cohesive majority, and the DNC is having a field day gleaning ammo for the upcoming campaign ads. This looks like a job for fund-raiser extraordinaire/high-wire artist George Santos…or, Kevin McCarthy, who at least proved his worth in that capacity before being run out of town.

GOPers need not look to our former prez, Donald Trump, for any assistance at refilling the coffers with his online grifting expected to edge into constant begging for his base to buoy up this poor, Constitiution-battered billionaire(?)/millionaire(?)/average joe(?) victim of Biden’s DOJ. It should take only a century or two to save his butt at the rate the meter is adding with each court appearance. Trump’s bragging during his deposition in the bank fraud trial came back to haunt him in the E. Jean Carroll defamation suit, as Carroll’s attorney made good use of the information he blurted at that time to inflate his net worth, his words used to convince the 9-member jury that he could afford to be penalized heavily to put a stop to his slandering of Carroll. Trump, in comparing his brand’s worth to that of Coca-Cola, said with puffed chest and Mussolini chin jut, “In my case, I know it’s billions and billions and billions of dollars, with the brand name alone valued at $2.9B or even $3B. I wrote a book recently and it sold through the roof! It’s all brand value. We have a lot of cash, we have great assets.”  At one point he gloated about the secondary market for his ‘collectible’ digital trading cards, “some selling for $82K apiece.” He also claimed that the Mar-a-Lago estate could be worth as much as $1.5B, but Palm Beach property appraisers give it a range of $1.8- to $28-million. It likely will be worth more upon change of the name to Carroll-a-Lago. Circulating on the internet currently is a Photo-shopped image of Trump Tower with new shiny gold letters reading E. Jean Carroll Tower…let’s run that one by Mr. T!

Journalist David Cay Johnston, author of the 2016 biography entitled ‘The Making of Donald Trump,’ feels that Trump’s mouth could never back off attacking E. Jean in hopes of a gigantic jury award in order to complain to his base that, “It’s a New York jury”, code for un-Christian and non-White, which his base will eat right up but will not serve to reach the supporters he really needs. Last year’s sexual abuse and defaming verdict against Trump resulted in a $5M award, which Johnston says he never expects to pay, but he also doesn’t believe he will ever see the inside of prison cell. The Don’s Truth Social network had postings critical of Carroll all during the second trial, and along with his Bad Boy immaturity during his presence in court, he was assured of a massive penalty by the observant jurors. Now, he’s faced with another quandary…$83.3M worth. Beyond criticizing the outcome of the trial, Truth Social has gone silent about E. Jean, likely because his caretakers have wrested his cell phone away from him. Bill Palmer on his The Palmer Report, asks, “Did his handlers take his account away from him? Is he passed out face down in a bowl of Cheeto dust? If Trump decides to keep attacking Carroll, it’s just going to cost him even more money…she can circle back for additional damages and sanctions if Trump can’t stop himself.”

Palmer accuses the media of trying to decipher whatever new move Trump makes, analyzing what, and why, it’s being done, when it has no coherency…only sheer stupidity. Then, as they peer into the dark hole which this stable genius has dug himself into, they ooh! and aah! that Trump finally has us right where he wants us. Flaunting his invincibility throughout the Carroll trial proved to be his downfall with the nine jurors, and perhaps it will stifle complaints that ‘Trump gets away with everything.’ Had he been gagged and tied to his chair, perhaps the new award simply would have been another $5M forfeiture. No doubt, Trump’s keepers told him to cease running his mouth following his first loss, but he’s either too far gone cognitively to understand how much harm he was doing to himself by continuing to attack, or he’s too far gone psychologically to care how much harm he was inviting to himself. In either case, he continues hiring the worst attorneys while insisting on defense schemes that are guaranteed to fail, all the while attacking judges, their staffs, and the court system in its entirety.

Posting a bond of $5M to file an appeal on the first trial occurred with minimum whining, but how does he post $83.3M to appeal the second verdict? It’s debatable whether or not he has that much cash on hand, and his PAC is stretched from paying his legal fees, at least the bills that even get paid. Absent an appeal, he must pay Carroll, a lengthy process involving having assets taken from him – a procedure that he is unable to prevent. Carroll was only interested in vindication, not money, and she has proven her patience in the years-long process to see justice. Trump stands to lose another $370M resulting from the New York civil fraud trial…ka-ching, ka-ching, ka-ching! Trump’s assets have wings! And, before we forget, a New York state judge recently ordered Trump to pay nearly $400K in legal fees to The New York Times and three Times reporters after dismissal of a suit he brought in 2021, an “insidious plot” to obtain his tax records he charged. Revelations that he wasn’t the self-made billionaire he claimed to be, that most of his wealth was derived from his parents or from tax-dodging, even as his businesses bled money. State Supreme Court Justice Robert Reed ruled that Trump’s claims “fail as a matter of constitutional law.” Hey, don’t that judge know the Orangeman don’t need no stinkin’ constitution?

Judge Arthur Engoron, in the New York civil fraud case against Trump, has new information to consider in his decision about financial penalties to be levied, regarding a $50M mystery debt related to the Trump Organization’s Chicago tower and an intercompany loan. Former federal judge Barbara Jones, the court-appointed monitor in the Trump fraud case, provided information that indicates the former president lied knowingly and repeatedly on his federal financial disclosures about a major loan that never existed, evading a possible $48M in income. Her information in a letter to Engoron says the filings contain inconsistencies and errors, but the company has been cooperative in the investigation. “When I inquired about this loan, I was informed that there are no loan agreements that memorialize the loan, but that it was a loan that was believed to be between Donald J. Trump , individually, and Chicago Unit Acquisition for $48M,” Jones wrote in reference to the name of Trump’s LLC holding the debt. She added, “In recent discussions with the Trump Organization, it indicated that it has determined that this loan never existed and would be removed from any upcoming forms submitted to the Office of Government Ethics, and would be removed from subsequent versions of the firm’s financial statements.”

Alan Garten, chief legal counsel for the Trump Organization, told The Daily Beast that her claim is inaccurate and the loan did in fact exist, which will be addressed in court. Garten insists that not only does the loan exist, but that it is money owed to Trump after a loan to the LLC. However, in an October filing, it was stated that Trump owes the LLC upwards of $50M, in the form of a ‘springing loan,’ a loan with unfavorable terms to the borrower. In 2016, Trump confirmed this arrangement to The New York Times, having bought back the loan form a “group of banks several years ago,” and that he had preferred to keep the debt on the books, while paying interest to himself from a practically worthless LLC. In the interview, Trump said, “We don’t assess any value to it because we don’t care. I have the mortgage. That is all there is…very simple…I am the bank.” It seems that a ‘practically worthless’ LLC with a $50M credit on its books would be worth at least that much! Jordan Libowitz, communications director for Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in D.C. remarked, “Assuming the court filing is correct, Trump would appear to have intentionally and repeatedly broken the law. Personal financial disclosures attest under penalty of law that information submitted is true…Trump had to know that the Chicago business never loaned him the money.” The Trumpmeister will surely be blaming the accountants and attorneys and others for any blunders. Watch out, EricJunior and Ivanka!

In a January 26 bankruptcy filing, former Trump attorney, Rudy Giuliani, listed a claim against his former boss over unpaid legal fees, stating the amount as “undetermined.” The initial December ’23 bankruptcy filing came after a federal judge ordered him to “immediately” pay more than $148M to defamed election workers, Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss. In a series of unsuccessful lawsuits, Giuliani attempted to contest, and overturn, the 2020 election results in favor of Trump. The New York Times reported in August 2023 that, “Mr. Trump has never explicitly told Mr. Giuliani why he is effectively stiffing him, but the former president has pointed out that he lost the cases related to the election.” Also reported is that the Trumpster told his aides that he didn’t wish to see Giuliani get “a dime” unless he succeeded, and noted that $340K had previously been paid by the Save America PAC to assist with some of Rudy’s debt. Giuliani’s new filing also lists an “undetermined” amount owed him under “Joseph Biden Defamation Action,” a suit filed in October when Biden used the term “Russian pawn” in reference to the former NYC mayor…supposedly costing him “millions and millions of dollars” in lost clientele. In the category ‘tax refunds owed to you’ is listed “Overpayment of taxes from The Mask Singer” in 2022 amounting to over $10K, when he appeared on the TV show, The Masked Singer while singing ‘Bad to the Bone.’ The Donald probably smirked dramatically over that telecast.

While Giuliani managed to raise over $700K from just 13 donors , per an FEC filing, to help with legal fees after the court ruling, he was left with about $180K cash on hand after settling a half-million dollars of his legal fees. Rudy has always insinuated that he has “insurance” against Trump when the need arises, so does he have the courage to actually pull that trigger, now that he is in such dire straits? He once referenced that he and Trump would go down together, spurring Trump to host a too-little-too-late fundraiser, but with this new bankruptcy filing, he is hoping those who have claims against him will now go after Trump. This is an unlikely scenario, since The Don is begging for Divine Intervention to bail him out. This can only become more complex! Poor Rudy laments that he failed to save for retirement, failing to apply for any benefits and foregoing the pension, and “giving back to the city I love…although I would like to take it now. I don’t know how to go about it.” Hire a competent attorney, Rudy!

On his show recently, Seth Meyers showed a snapshot of a stunned-looking Giuliani, comparing it to “the state of American politics right now.” But, “If we really wanted to accurately represent America in 2024, we’d replace the stars on the flag with Rudy’s eyes.” Adding, “Good luck sleeping tonight!”

But, take heart from cartoonist, Charles M. Schulz“Don’t worry about the world coming to an end today. It is already tomorrow in Australia.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Rain”

The way I see it, if you want the rainbow, you gotta put up with the rain.
~Dolly Parton

“Det finns inget dåligt väder, bara dåliga kläder.” Swedish saying that means “There is no bad weather, only bad clothes.”
~ Gunilla

“Save a boyfriend for a rainy day – and another, in case it doesn’t rain”
~Mae West

“Criticism, like rain, should be gentle enough to nourish a man’s growth without destroying his roots.”
~Frank A. Clark

...

Last week was West Coast Swing, this week it’s slam poetry! This young man, Demetri Manabat, is fantastic. This piece goes places you do not expect at first. Take a listen (for optimal clarity, turn on the subtitles!) and then go give him a follow.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 24 – 30, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton…more throwback Greensite…will be back next week… Steinbruner…reminder: protest the Soquel Creek Water District rate hike . Hayes…the forest after the fires… Patton…Instant Stratification… Matlock…voting and cold weather… Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes….”Decluttering”

...

VERY EARLY SANTA CRUZ (Late 1800s) You can probably guess that this is the corner of Pacific/Front/Mission streets. Note the easy parking and the horsecar tracks going down Pacific.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

DATELINE January 24, 2024

UPDATE ON BRUCE Bruce is still on the mend. For more details, or to just say hi and get better, you can email him. I think he has a tablet so he can read email.

I did another deep-dive in the archives, and pulled up some content from 10 years ago. Check it out below!

//Gunilla//


[ABOUT A DECADE AGO]

LICENSE PLATE SCANNERS/ READERS. Brad Cava of Santa Cruz Patch brought this issue to the public when he printed, “With little or no discussion the Santa Cruz City Council Tuesday (9/12/13) approved the purchase of $38,000 of cameras that can photograph and keep indefinitely the license plates of every car entering or leaving the city. Called Automated License Plate Readers, the technology has been controversial in other cities, with freedom advocates claiming it is a step toward a 1984 surveillance system. The ones proposed by local police are mobile and can be kept in an officer’s car and set up when needed. They can read thousands of license plates per minute. The money comes from a federal grant to help local agencies buy equipment. Police across the country have used them for cameras and other paramilitary equipment. The sheriff’s department will share in the funds.

Then this….from Santa Cruz News.org September 2013

“The American Civil Liberties Union has called for restrictions on the devices’ use, asking lawmakers and law enforcement to adhere to certain principles, including:

  • License plate readers may be used by law enforcement agencies only to investigate hits and in other circumstances in which law enforcement agents reasonably believe that the plate data are relevant to an ongoing criminal investigation.
  • The government must not store data about innocent people for any lengthy period. Unless plate data has been flagged, retention periods should be measured in days or weeks, not months and certainly not years.
  • People should be able to find out if plate data of vehicles registered to them are contained in a law enforcement agency’s database.
  • Law enforcement agencies should not share license plate reader data with third parties that do not follow proper retention and access principles. They should also be transparent regarding with whom they share license plate reader data.
  • Any entity that uses license plate readers should be required to report its usage publicly on at least an annual basis.

Earlier this year, the ACLU released an extensive report on the use of the technology in municipalities throughout the U.S. The report was compiled after ACLU employees reviewed more than 26,000 pages of material gathered through public records requests from nearly 600 police departments in 38 states and Washington, D.C.”

John Malkin of Free Radio 101.3 fm talked about the scanners/readers on my Universal Grapevine program Tuesday 1/21. One topic we discussed was the very common reaction to scanners being…

“I don’t do anything illegal, and if it can track down criminals why worry about it?” The real concern is about invading our privacy. Think about all the places you go that are your own private concern. Places, choices, visits you don’t want made public. Doctor visits for a private concern, visits to a relationship that folks don’t need to know about, weekly stops for a little bottle of alcohol or a few drinks to get you through the week, seeing an ex-partner, an analyst or psychiatrist who’s helping you with affairs, seeing a healer, a Scientologist group, stopping at Frenchy’s Bookstore, learning where our politicians hang out when they aren’t supposed to. You can fill in your own private visits…all legal, and all worth keeping private. With these scanners there are few if any laws or regulations ruling who can use the results. When 1000’s of cars are scanned involving a specific crime there are only sketchy regulations regarding how long those scans can be kept. Many agencies around the US keep them for years.

There are issues here folks and as we keep learning our Santa Cruz City Council could care less and they approved these scanners, with no consideration whatsoever. Now we can do something about it. The ACLU Santa Cruz Chapter is having a meeting Wednesday, February 12 at 7 p.m. at London Nelson Community Center to talk about and hear background on License Plate Scanners.The public is invited and if you want to get involved with this scarey issue this would be the time to do it.

[BACK TO THE CURRENT TIMELINE What happened with this? Do we now have license plate readers everywhere we go? -Webmistress ]

KEEPING THIS HERE TO REMIND YOU TO VOTE YES ON MEASURE M…PLEASE DONATE NOW!!
There is still time to donate, funds are needed by Febrary 10, 2024 In short, if enacted by the voters, Measure M will accomplish TWO simple things:

#1.) Require the city to get voter approval before height limits can be raised to allow oversized, high-rise developments anywhere in the city, downtown or in our neighborhoods.

#2.) Increase the number of affordable housing units that big developers must provide, from 20% to 25% for projects of over 30 units, as the City Planning Commission researched and recommended.

Measure M is facing enormous and well-funded opposition from out-of-town developers and their allies.  We NEED your financial assistance now to run a successful campaign. With only 60 days left before we vote on March 5, 2024, the sooner you donate the better. Another incentive to donate soon is we have matching funds.

Our fundraising goal is $50,000. This money will be used for our online presence, campaign materials, advertising, professional assistance and to rally residents to vote.

Make as generous a contribution as you possibly can to help pass Measure M and be part of the future design of Santa Cruz!  
TWO ways to donate:

  1. Online with the DONATE button on:  Yes-on-M.org
  1. Or Write a check to: “Yes on M”, and call us to pick it up 831-471-7822 or send the check before Feb. 10 to:  
    Yes on M, PO Box 2191, Santa Cruz, Ca. 95063

Partial List of Supporters:

Gary Patton, Former County Supervisor, Environmental Attorney
Katherine Beiers, Former Mayor
Jane Weed-Pomerantz, Former Mayor
Nell Newman, Founder, Newman’s Own Organics, Environmentalist & Biologist
Rick Longinotti, Author, Right to Vote on Desal Initiative
Joseph S. Quigg, Affordable and Market-rate Housing Developer
Frank Barron, Retired Urban Planner
Keresha Durham-Tamba, Bilingual Educator, Environmental-Climate Activist
Hector Marin-Castro, Santa Cruz City Teacher’s Aid and Service Worker
Susan Monheit, Retired State Water Regulator, Environmental Scientist
Steve Bare, Retired High School Teacher, Military Veteran
Laura Lee, Retired Teacher, Corporate Trainer & Facilitator

Bruce will be back with movie reviews as soon as he’s had a chance to write more!

...

Gillian will be back next week!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

WHY WILL SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT CUSTOMERS PAY TO LEGALLY DEFEND DIRECTOR BRUCE JAFFE?
The Inspector General is taking legal action against Bruce Jaffe, and the Soquel Creek Water District customers will pay to defend him.  The issue is unknown, but the situation is curious.  Is it to protect Bruce Jaffe’s image for his Second District County Supervisor campaign or the District’s self-important image?

What could he have possible done to cause the Inspector General, a new County-level investigator of complaints against the Sheriff Department, to take legal action against him?
Hmmm….

I had to file a Public Records Act request with the Water district to get the Draft Minutes of the December 5 Soquel Creek Water District Board meeting, hoping to see the report from Closed Session about Bruce Jaffe getting sued.  I was outside the meeting chambers December 5 when the District’s legal Counsel quickly reported the results of the Closed Session.  His report was hard to hear, so I asked him to repeat it. He was quickly whisked away by General Manager Ron Duncan, but called out “it will be in the Minutes”.

But the Minutes were not included in the next Board agenda packet, so I had to file a Public Records Act request to see them.

Ms. Western, Administrative Clerk for the District, sent a reply some days later that the Draft Minutes were included in the January 16 Board agenda packet.

Here is what it says about the District defending Bruce Jaffe (pages 14-15)

CLOSED SESSION 

8.2 Conference With Legal Counsel—Anticipated Litigation Significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 54956.9: 1 case

 At 8:13 pm, President Christensen announced that the Board will return to closed session to discuss Items 8.1 and 8.2. General Counsel Nelson stated that the Board would meet in closed session for Item 8.2 related to potential litigation arising from an investigation by the Office of Inspector General related to meetings attended by Director Jaffe on behalf of the District.

 For Item 8.2, by a vote of 4 to 0 (Jaffe recused), the Board voted to defend Vice President Jaffe under government code section 995.6, based on a finding that (1) the administrative  proceeding is brought on account of acts within the scope of being a director, and (2) the defense is in the best interest of the District and that based on available information Director Jaffe acted in good faith, without actual malice, and in the apparent interests of the District. This defense is being provided with a reservation of rights. Vice-President Jaffe did not participate in Item 8.2 as he has a conflict of interest as the item relates to his financial interests.

Hmmm….

Who is the “Office of the Inspector General”?

The OIG shall focus on matters relevant to Sheriff’s Office policies and procedures and shall not interfere with criminal, personnel, and other investigations by the Sheriff.

(B)    The OIG shall provide independent monitoring of, and reporting about, the Sheriff’s Office related to law enforcement, jail operations, jail facilities, and the employees and contractors involved with law enforcement and jail operations, including the provision of health services in the jails, as set forth in this chapter

Chapter 2.17 OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL

The State Inspector General is also with the purpose of law enforcement and correctional department oversight:
Agency Details | www.ca.gov

How does Director Bruce Jaffe fit in with the Sheriff Dept?  Why is this related to Soquel Creek Water District?

What is Govt. Code 995.6, the grounds upon which the Board voted unanimously to have Water District customers pay for Bruce Jaffe’s legal defense?

Section 995.6 – Administrative proceeding brought against employee

A public entity is not required to provide for the defense of an administrative proceeding brought against an employee or former employee, but a public entity may provide for the defense of an administrative proceeding brought against an employee or former employee if:

(a) The administrative proceeding is brought on account of an act or omission in the scope of his employment as an employee of the public entity; and(b) The public entity determines that such defense would be in the best interests of the public entity and that the employee or former employee acted, or failed to act, in good faith, without actual malice and in the apparent interests of the public entity.Ca. Gov. Code § 995.6

Added by Stats. 1963, Ch. 1683, Sec. 16.

Section 995.6 – Administrative proceeding brought against employee, Cal. Gov. Code § 995.6 | Casetext Search + Citator

I think the rate payers deserve to understand what they are paying to defend.  I publicly asked the District Board for this explanation at last week’s Board meeting, but got no response.  Is the District helping Bruce Jaffe’s campaign for Second District County Supervisor?
Hmmm……

FINANCIAL WOES AT SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT?
The financial picture at Soquel Creek Water District appears of concern.

Why would there be unexplained credit card fees of $14,183.50 for the month of November? (see page 45 of the January 16 agenda)

Retiree health benefits for November, 2023 alone were $82,335.58 (page 60)  For a company with staff of about 25, doesn’t this seem high?

SCWD BOD Agenda Tuesday Jan 16, 2024

Has the PureWater Soquel Project construction cost, which has ballooned from $60 million initially anticipated but now climbing to $200 million, caused unmanageable debt?

It seems the District’s full focus on this Project has also adversely affected other Capital Improvement projects that have been planned and are needed:

Quail Run Tank has been postponed….this was to provide water for the Aptos Village Project.  The District borrowed 100% of the money needed to design and build it.  page 65 of the January 16, 2024 engineering staff report explains…

2. Quail Run Tank (Design 100%) i. Due to staff workload and funding, no tank construction will occur in the near future

Many other Capital Improvements are described as “on hold due to PureWater Soquel Project”

(page 65):
12. Fairway Tank Recoat
i. Budgeted in FY 23/24, but on hold to prioritize Pure Water Soquel.

8. Maplethorpe/Victory Ln Main Crossing i. Staff contracted with consultant to perform topographic survey of the erosion before determining remediation measures. Received Map June 2022. ii. Topographic survey is complete. Design and construction on hold to prioritize Pure Water Soquel.

How will customers pay for the high cost of operating the Project, once it becomes operational?  Initially, the District stated the annual operational cost was $2.5 million.  Now, without explanation, the District rate study recently reported the annual operational cost will be $5.5 million.

Maybe the vague energy calculations in the Project 2018 EIR were not accurate?   (Note: That EIR is hard to find on the District website, and the District refuses to place hard copies in the public library.  I had to make an appointment to go read it recently at the District Office, and was restricted to one hour. )

 The estimate  in the EIR (page 3-43) was “Project’s expected electricity demand would be 3,600 megawatt hours/year.  1,800 MWh/Y for Advanced Water Purification Facitily (AWPF) operations, and 1,800MWh/Y for conveyance operations.”  It really does seem they were making it up, doesn’t it?  But the Board approved it anyway, and has never looked back except in 2020 and 2021 when there were Project Addendums that were so major, there really should have been public hearings and CEQA comment periods.

But this did not happen, and the Board approved it all.  And now the bills are beginning to come due….

JUST MAKE THEM PAY MORE
Already, it seems that many customers of Soquel Creek Water District are struggling pay their high water bills.  According to the Financial Director report (page 72 of the January 16, 2024 Board agenda packet):

• Staff applied for $77,000 in customer assistance through the Extended Water Arrearages Program offered by the State Water Resources Control Board. If awarded, these funds will apply directly to assist customers who have struggled to keep their accounts current post-pandemic. 
• Customers continue to benefit from the Low-Income Household Water Assistance Program. A bilingual bill insert was included with January bills instructing customers on how to apply for assistance.

The District’s answer is to raise fixed service charges, water rates and reconfigure tiers.  The Board did NOT ask staff to cut costs (such as their own $200/meeting stipend, or the $1,600 and $1,000 monthly bonuses the top three management staff have been receiving since PureWater Soquel Project construction began and will receive until the Project is completed) or selling any of the surplus land the District owns (such as the large buildable lot adjacent to the District office or the unused mobile trailer next to the Office that was supposed to be the PureWater Soquel Project construction office).

However, the rate changes the Board approved last month are likely not even legal.  Please read the Correspondence by Mr. Jon Cole, a District customer who sued the District and WON over this same issue.

  Last time the District tried to make customers pay for a treatment plant that did not even exist.  This time, the District wants customers to pay for a treatment plant that is not operational and not providing any service at all.

You can hear his public testimony at the January 16, 2024 regarding this illegal problem
here at minute 4:50

He pointed out that the District still had not posted the Raftelis Consultant Rate Study on their website, only the Executive Summary.
His testimony made a difference….the 2023 Raftelis Rate Study is now available, but one must scroll to the bottom of the page to see it.

PROTEST NOW
If you or someone you know is a customer of Soquel Creek Water District, please protest the impending drastic rate hikes now.  Find good information and a protest template here:  protestscwd.com

People who live in mobile home parks with 100 or more units and a 4″ service connection would see their fixed service fees more than double by 2027.  Ditto for commercial accounts.

ADU BUILDERS STILL MUST PAY HIGH SERVICE CONNECTION FEES TO SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT
Even though customers hoping to build an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) have testified recently to the Soquel Creek Water Board that their policies and costs associated are prohibitive to construction, the Board voted to keep things in place, with the exception of requiring applicants with a Tiny Home on Wheels (THOW).

According to the Staff Report, ADU’s are the most popular water service application.  There have been 32 built in the District, and currently, there are 37 will-serve agreements for new service to ADU’s in the District.  There is one applicant for service to a THOW.

“District’s Current Metering Requirements for New Residential Development The District’s current rules for metering are found in Ordinances 16-02 (Attachment 1) and 22-03 (Attachment 2, see Section 4(E)(1)). 

For residential development projects, the District currently requires all new units to be individually metered from all other dwellings unless prohibited by law. Due to the California laws mentioned above, the District can no longer require separate metering for JADUs and Conversion ADUs. Submetering, where a dwelling unit is metered using a non-District meter and is read and billed by the property owner, is not currently allowed in lieu of separate metering unless approved by a variance.” 

The Board was hesitant to make changes.

 “Getting rid of the separate metering requirement for THOWs and ADUs would mean that they are not contributing towards the water system while increasing potential capacity. They also would not pay a separate monthly service charge from the primary residence(s). While this may result in lost revenue for the District, the current rate study did not include any new services in the revenue calculations so the absence of separate metering would not impact the revenue anticipated from new rates.”

Director Jennifer Balboni, brand new in her position, cheerily declared that she is happy with the District’s policies and felt there should be no changes.  Ultimately, the Board voted to remove the requirement for THOW to have a separate meter.  Director Balboni voted against it.

You can watch the Board’s discussion of this important matter, thanks to Community TV posting it right away on their website’s “Government on Demand” link to Soquel Creek Water District:
Item 7.3 discussion begins at minute 27:15.

REGIONAL WATER OPTIMIZATION REPORT UPDATE
A State Water grant funded a study for Soquel Creek Water District to collaborate with the City of Santa Cruz to model how water can be regionally managed.

The report has been promised, but is long-overdue.  Finally, Montgomery & Associates consultants will be presenting an update to the Soquel Creek Water District Board on February 6.

• Sustainable Groundwater Management Act Implementation Grant Optimization Study (Study) 
o Groundwater and hydraulic modeling of “optimized” project alternatives continues with results to be presented to the Project and Executive Teams during a Workshop the week of 1/8. A key objective of the Workshop is for the Executive Team to select the four final optimized projects to be further analyzed for cost/economics and funding opportunities, environmental needs, and water quality, based on the modeling results. 
o Staff plans to coordinate with Montgomery & Associates on an Optimization Study update to the Board in February.

(page 62)

4. Optimization Study i. Engineering staff has been attending optimization study meetings to coordinate hydraulic modeling consultant work. This work will take groundwater pumping distributions provided by groundwater modelers and evaluate how pumped water can be moved throughout the distribution pipe network.

This grant-funded modeling and study has been promised for a long time…tune in to the Soquel Creek Water District Board meeting on February 6 to learn more.

WHERE IS THE TRANSPARENCY FOR THE SHERIFF PATROL TAXES OF CSA 38?
This month, Santa Cruz County LAFCO Director Mr. Joe Serrano reported to the Commission the difficulties he found in tracing the use of $3 million collected annually since 1983 from County property owners to support the Sheriff Dept. patrols.

He is giving the County one year to develop a website link to show how the money is spent.  If that does not happen, he is recommending that CSA 38 be dissolved for lack of transparency.

He explained to the Commission that usually he does extensive Sphere and Service Reviews, but he was not able to perform this level of investigation and reporting because
there just isn’t much information available to even show a connection between CSA 38 and the Sheriff Department.

In response to public comment questioning “Where IS the money going?   What County Dept. has taken a flat $500 annually since 1983 for administration?  Why was there a $9,400 surplus last year for the first time?”  Assistant County Administrative Officer Ms. Melodye Serino, stepped up to the podium.  “I said I wasn’t going to speak, but I just want to let you know that the money is being spent on Sheriff patrols.”   Ms. Serino was also and Assistant to former CAO Susan Mauriello.  Now that should make you worried.

Here is what the LAFCO report said, in part:

The CSA was created in 1983 as a funding mechanism to provide “extended police protection” in areas outside the four cities. However, there is no clear correlation between CSA 38 and the County Sheriff Department. LAFCO could not determine how CSA 38 provides services, how many employees operate the district, whether it has a standalone board and regular meetings, and could not locate an official webpage providing additional information, including but not limited to policies/bylaws. For these reasons, the County should clearly define CSA 38’s purpose and role in the county by providing more transparency and easier access to supporting documents (ex. agendas, minutes, policies, maps, finances, etc.) 
CSA 38 MSR Staff Report

Here is the link to the 2018 LAFCO Sphere and Service Review for CSA 38

HOW SAFE WILL THE ACCESS TO THE CHANTICLEER OVERCROSSING  BE?
Last week, I reported the disappointing  news that the County Public Works has no plans to make improvements on Chanticleer Avenue or Mar Vista for the two new pedestrian / bicycle overpasses that are or will soon be built over Highway One.

Take a look at the photos of the Chanticleer area near Grey Bears, where blind and low-vision pedestrians will have to navigate in order to use the Chanticleer Overcrossing when it is completed.

The “Road Work Ahead” is the Chanticleer Overcrossing work at Highway One.

Another view of Chanticleer at the very busy Grey Bears area, looking down to the Overcrossing access.  Again, no safety improvements are planned here for the near future.

FIGHT TO KEEP DEPENDABLE LANDLINE SERVICE FOR RURAL AREAS
Last week, many throughout Santa Cruz County and beyond received a vague letter from AT&T about hearings before the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).  What that letter does not make clear is that AT&T is asking permission from the CPUC to stop maintaining landline telephone service.

Landlines work in disasters when electricity fails, causing many with “bundled” internet and telephone service to lose their phone ability to call 911.   If you or someone you know received this letter, and want to fight to keep your dependable landline phone service, make sure to submit written comment:
 regarding AT&T withdrawing its requirement to be an Eligible Carrier for landline service 

and

regarding AT&T to be allowed to stop being a Carrier of Last Resort 

Here is the Public Advisor’s Office contact: 
Email: Public.Advisor@cpuc.ca.gov
Phone: 1-415-703-2074

CANDIDATE FORUMS NEAR YOU?
There are not many opportunities to hear local Candidates  or Supporters/Opponents of local measures speak.  The League of Women Voters used to be a good source, but no more. Here is a link to some sponsored by LookOut Santa Cruz

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A CANDIDATE FORUM AND ASK QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT MATTERS TO YOU IN THE COMMUNITY.  WRITE A LETTER TO THE EDITOR.

JUST DO ONE THING  THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

3.5 Year Post Fire Forest

Halfway through this rainy winter and the post fire forest is vibrantly green with occasional crashing trees. In six months, it will be impossible to walk off trail in the footprint of the CZU Lightning Complex Fire. You never know if what you view trailside is anything like most of the landscape…it normally isn’t.

What the Rain Brings

Trickling brooks, meandering newts, buds nearly bursting, lush mosses and fluffy lichens. With the frequent sprinkles and sometimes downpours the forest sings with the tinkling and bubbling of ephemeral streams. Every declivity carries water from the rains…some run for hours, some days and others weeks after a storm. The wetness has awakened amphibians. Chorus frogs croak, newts march. Otherwise bare tree trunks and rocks are glowing brightly with a hundred colors and textures of greens and whites – this is show time for mosses and lichens.

Whoops!

The wet winter belies human’s hydrological mistakes as water that used to go one way is diverted another – by trails, roads, houses, or other such developments. New, larger amounts of water than Nature designed are chanelled into drainages unfit for such flows – gullies open, slopes fail; this is not natural, this is ignorance, expediency, or greed. Silt and mud run into streams and rivers, turning them brown. The receiving ocean changes color, too. These mistakes are especially frequent post fire as plastic culverts burned, trail builders work mid-winter, between the storms (!) clearing and destabilizing fire-damaged slopes, and humans generally scuttle around, under-resourced, trying to rebuild and repair infrastructure in the mud. It is a better time to observe hydrology, make notes about drainages and seeps…rest and wait for the land to dry before mucking it up. And, it is a great time to monitor culverts and drains so they are working as engineered.

Crash!

Fire damaged trees are falling fast. Perhaps thousands of fire-damaged trees reached a critical threshold for the wood destroying fungal hyphae. We had such hope that so many trees were resprouting after the fire – shade! Habitat! Now, many hopeful trees are toppling, especially big, majestic oaks. Fire-killed trees are also toppling. Five years after the Lockheed Fire, burned areas were criss-crossed four feet deep with tree carcasses. If you were nimble, you could walk across this cribbing, but woe to those who slipped! In between the fallen trees sprouts up a sea of shrubs, making it impossible to see the fallen trees, or how to walk across them. The ocean’s distant roar, soft pattering mist…and the crashing sound of another tree coming down. That’s what the fire’s footprint sounds like these days on Santa Cruz’s North Coast.

A Sea of Ceanothus

Mile after mile, one post-fire species is winning big time. Blue blossom, California lilac, aka Ceanothus (thyrsiflorus) germinated right after the 2020 fire and is everywhere. How did this shrub show up where there used to be redwood forest and no shrubs? Two things explain it: birds and seedbank. Many species of birds (especially quail) gobble up blue blossom seeds, but don’t digest all of them completely, pooping out seeds wherever they travel. Those undigested seeds last 40-100 years in the soil, forming a “seedbank.” Fire clears the duff, floods the understory with new sunlight and that seedbank germinates.

In just 3.5 years, the tiny seeds from that blue blossom seedbank have created thickets of 8′ tall shrubs, lush and green.

The problem is…there are too many shrubs! Not all those blue blossom shrubs will live. Already, rodents are girdling them or they are dying from other things – 1 in 100 of the shrubs are brown-dead right now. As they grow, they will compete for light and water. A drought will come and thousands and thousands of blue blossom will succumb, but they won’t be able to fall over: they are held aloft by their close neighbors. Millions of tons of bone dry, standing dead blue blossom will fuel the fire tornadoes of the next wildfire to cross this landscape.

The Old Ways

I ask anyone thinking that the CZU Lightning Complex Fire and the resulting vegetation is a ‘natural’ phenomenon to reconsider, please! First, consider what the word ‘natural’ means on our landscape. For millions of years, fires and the resulting vegetation would have been strongly affected by huge herds of browsing and grazing animals. Mastodons and mammoths toppled trees. Bison, horse and camel relatives, elk, pronghorn, ground sloth, and many more grazed and browsed. There would have been very little fuel (patchy) to burn: resulting fires would never have reached the proportions of the CZU fire, even in the worst droughts. There was a quick exchange of that Pleistocene megafauna for the stewardship of indigenous peoples – and their use of fire similarly resulted in fire-resilient forests. The post-clearcut forests we know have never seen such abuse and subsequent disuse.

Critters Now

Ray Dasmond, a globally renowned wildlife expert and ex-UCSC professor taught us that deer love brush. For a long time before the 2020 fire, there were very few deer. The exception was in the vicinity of town, where deer had always proliferated: irrigation creates summer green forage triggering females to have another batch of young, even if there’s not that much food. In more rural areas, sightings of deer were worthy of conversation. Some blamed the mountain lions: a mature lion eats one deer each week. The 2009 Lockheed Fire had scorched 7000 acres, leaving more than a bit of brush across its footprint, but apparently that wasn’t enough deer food, or there was a different deer-limiting factor.

Walking around the CZU fire area, I am seeing more deer and notice that the blue blossom is being lightly browsed. Right now, there are many big, healthy bucks and they are following females along with one or two of last year’s young. There are widespread deer trails in the wildland forest! Might it be that the local deer population will rebound?

I doubt that there could ever be enough deer to make up for the blue blossom growth. Is it time to re-introduce tule elk? How fast can we learn to use fire the way the Native Peoples did? What do we do with the miles of blue blossom? I fear the future fire. I fear we might lose our forests.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

MONDAY, JANUARY 22, 2024

#22 / Instant Stratification

The smiling face of Elon Musk, above, seems an appropriate accompaniment to this blog posting, which comments on an article that appeared in the January 18, 2024, edition of The Wall Street Journal. The article was titled, “Musk Gives Tesla’s Board a Big Headache.”

Musk is credited with being the “richest person in the world.” According to a January 2024 article in Investopedia, Musk has a net worth of $229 billion. Anyone who might have a hard time grasping just how big a number $229 billion is is might begin with this explanation from Paul Franz:

People don’t have a strong intuitive sense of how much bigger one billion is than one million. One million seconds is about 11 days. One billion seconds is about 31.5 years.

Take in what an immense number $1 billion is, and then multiply that number by 229. You get the picture. $229 billion is an “ungodly” amount of money. It’s what many might call an “obscene” amount of money. However, let’s save our outrage for the news conveyed by that article in The Wall Street Journal.

In the article, readers are informed that Musk has told the Tesla Board of Directors that he needs a raise in his salary. A considerable raise! Musk is currently the owner of about 13% of Tesla’s shares outstanding. He has demanded that he be given a 25% ownership interest. According to the online version of the article in The Journal, that amounts to a “$60-billion plus pay package.”

I like my title for today’s blog posting. It will make us all think, I hope, of the phrase “instant gratification,” which psychologists tell us has a “dark side.” A salary raise that so vastly increases economic and social stratification is definitely a “dark side” phenomenon.

There is a solution. It’s called “politics.” Musk is the number one example of a group of individual persons who have been permitted to sequester vast wealth, and the power that goes with that wealth. There is, as Bernie Sanders is fond of reminding us, a “billionaire class.” There are, apparently, something like 750 billionaires in the United States.

The political and legal arrangements that have allowed the growth of this “billionaire class” can be changed. However, not by writing blog postings (though those don’t hurt, I am hoping). Organized political efforts – what amounts to a “revolution” – is what must occur. That doesn’t mean killing a bunch of people, either.

It does mean that hundreds, thousands, and tens of thousands of ordinary people will have to decide that their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor will be pledged to what The Declaration of Independence called for in the first place – a society, an economy, and a political order in which all persons are created equal, and in which their individual ability to enjoy life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, will be supported by their collective efforts, and not be allowed to perish from the Earth.

Our revolution renewed. This is what we need!

To Subscribe Just Click This Link

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

HAARPING AWAY TO WEATHER THE STORM

Over the past several days we have seen dramatic changes in the GOP presidential sweepstakes, with ChristieScottRamaswamy, and DeSantis joining the Bootlickers VP Queue, leaving Nikki Haley to fight it out with Donald Trump. Three of the dropouts have not hesitated to jump onto the Trump bandwagon, with Tim Scott predicting that Trump will unite us as a nation. Where has he been for the last seven or eight years? In the ongoing Pundit ParadeJonathan V. Last on The Bulwark says, “The future is Trump,” though he contrasts the ex-president with Biden, saying our current president despite having neither a cult of personality, nor media domination, nor engendering strong feelings in a party that does not fear him. The economy is in good shape and as long as this streak continues, the voters will begin to appreciate it fully. With Biden’s long list of popular legislative accomplishments, and his willingness to cooperate with Republicans to pass laws that create jobs, to invest in infrastructure, and reform laws, a rationale is created for his re-election. Trump has no actual policies for his whining candidacy beyond personal retribution, stopping immigration, and drill, drill, drilling for oil, an action on which Biden exceeds all presidents including Trump himself. Trump’s 91 criminal counts, a boon for his primary campaign, will burden his general election campaign, benefitting Biden. No word from DeSantis (now identified as Ron DeSuperfantastic now in Trump circles) on the disposition of his white go-go boots, which he should relinquish in exchange for a participation trophy.

Bill Scher in Washington Monthly says, “Forget New Hampshire. After Trump’s Iowa landslide, it’s over.” He feels that while the Hawkeye State rarely predicts a GOP nominee, Trump is different. The New Hampshire conservative vote is usually diluted by independent voters, which in the last three competitive NH primaries ranged from 37 to 47 percent; primary elections in those states through Super Tuesday have exit polls indicating independents are less than ? of the vote totals. New Hampshire was a springboard for Trump in 2016’s primary because he won 35% of the vote, with 49% of the remainder of votes cast going to five center-right challengers, due to the failure of the party establishment to back one candidate, and due to disunity within the grassroots conservatives. Hard-right candidate, Ted Cruz, who won Iowa garnered only 12%, but moving to more conservative state primaries brought coalescence around Trump. Scher gave Nikki Haley a chance of a reasonable showing in a three- or four-person race, but with the dropouts not in contention, it’s basically a two-person duel with heavy ramifications in future primaries. With NH behind us now, how did Haley’s candidacy fare in this test?

Sarah Longwell writes in The Bulwark that “It’s time for former Trump officials to come out against him if we want to stop a Trump restoration and his promised MAGA dictatorship. It’s going to require building a coalition of people who understand the stakes. And there are no better messengers better equipped to convey the peril of a Trump presidency than those who lived it firsthand, on the inside.” Then, she backtracks, asking, “But wait, haven’t they done that already? Mark Milley posed for a front-page spread in The Atlantic. John Kelly gave a statement to CNN. Others have back-channeled their grave misgivings, off the record to Puck and Politico. Hard truth: That’s not enough. I talk to Republican primary voters every week in focus groups, and you know what they don’t read? The Atlantic, Puck and Politico. Fundamentally, the reason they seem unbothered by Trump’s autocratic tendencies is that a lot of them don’t know about them.” Right, Sarah! The bulk of them DON’T READ…just like their messianic idol/idiot!

Charlie Sykes, also in The Bulwark, says, “Trump is dominant, but vulnerable. Biden has a problem with voters who are in denial. Iowa could help him with that. Via The Messenger: ‘Biden’s internal polling shows the vast majority of the campaign’s targeted voters don’t believe Trump will be the GOP nominee, a major issue for a campaign desperate to make 2024 a binary choice.’ Even Biden’s internal polling, according to top campaign officials, has highlighted this trend, with recent surveys finding around 75% of the campaign’s undecided voters do not believe Trump will be Biden’s opponent in November. Trump’s dominating win in Iowa last week could change that dynamic with undecideds.” The above pundit roundup quotes are garnered from Greg Dworkins’s Daily Kos post.

Mother Jones posted a memorable headline following Trump’s Iowa caucus triumph: “FLORIDA MAN FACING 91 CRIMINAL COUNTS WINS IOWA CAUCUSES. Donald Trump just accomplished something he wasn’t able to do in 2016 – he won the Iowa caucuses.” Not long after precinct sites opened Monday night, the networks called the first-in-the-nation GOP race for the former president, who appeared to be cruising to a dominant victory over rivals Ron DeSantis and Nikki Haley. None of his four indictments, criminal counts, civil suits and a Supreme Court battle over whether he can even appear on the ballot in some states turned off Iowa Republicans. Instead, they rewarded him for it. Niece Mary Trump notes that Monday didn’t bring all good news for Uncle Donald in her Substack newsletter, The Good In Us…the former president’s attorney, Joe Tacopina withdrew his law firm from representation in the two New York cases, leaving Trump with Alina Habba to stumble along for him. Tacopina told ABC News that he had withdrawn “on all matters,” offering no immediate reason(s). Mary says, “On what everyone knew was supposed to be a day of victory for Donald in Iowa, this loss will still be burning in his mind. It’s not unusual for Donald to go through lawyers at an alarming rate, but Tacopina’s high profile status shows just how dysfunctional Donald’s ‘defense’ really is.”

Tacopina withdrew ahead of a Tuesday jury selection in a second defamation trial related to E. Jean Carroll’s allegations that Trump raped her in the 1990s, for which Trump was found guilty. Trump was dissuaded from testifying in the first trial but wished to speak in the second, which may have played a role in the attorney’s departure, according to Mary Trump, especially in light her uncle’s penchant for self-destruction behavior. In a statement to Reuters re Tacoima’s firm’s departure, a spokesperson for Trump said, “He has the most experienced, qualified, disciplined, and overall strongest legal team ever assembled.” In the history of the world, doubtless, and into the future for time immemorial, gosh darn it!

According to The Palmer Report, “Trump was represented in 2017 by the best, most powerful lawyers money could buy – before he was inaugurated, such as the Kassowitz Firm. Now he’s got this numbskull – Alina Habba. She has no idea what she’s doing, not a clue about how to get something into evidence, while being belittled by the trial judge and E. Jean Carroll’s lawyers. She’s completely destroying herself with her lack of knowledge about the rules in a Federal Court of all places!” Not up to the job, but, boy, is she a knockout…just ask her! However, this is the best representation the grifting money can buy, unless Trump can poor-me a bit more pitifully on Truth Social to get those rubes to increase their contributions. So, he goes from the Kassowitz Firm to threatening the Supreme Court to rule in his favor, since Kassowitz probably expected him to pay their bill, leaving Habba to work for nothing while basking in the glow of an orangey fake-tanned jerk with a bad combover. Joe Tacopina disclosed to Al Sharpton that he quit because he had to “consult his compass” which also involved personal reasons, and while he was vague in his explanation, it was clear he was tired of being a part of the Trump Dumpster Fire. The defense’s tactic to enrage the judge into making a mistake doesn’t seem to be working. No attorney will be able to save Trump from the finality of his fate, so Habba is as good as any in her blundering since Trump has no idea what is going on anyway…good karma for both of them.

“Person. Woman. Man. Camera. TV.” Oh, the profundity! Bocha Blue on The Palmer Report says we should change those words to: “Traitor. Insurrection. Indictment. Trial. Prison.” Trump in his mental decline keeps bringing up the legendary quote regarding his quack exam by then-White House Doctor Ronny Jackson, who everyone knows is himself a complete basket-case. Trump, in his senility has revealed that Nikki Haley was once the Speaker of the House who refused to provide troops to control the J6 Insurrection…wow, who knew? Or how about his claim that George Conway is a city in New Hampshire? How did George accomplish this feat? And did Kellyanne know about this? And who can forget that the former prez remembers that Barack Obama is the current president who will be facing him in the general election in November? Plus, “Melania’s son, Barron, is tall.” Anything else, Donny?…Eric?…Don, Jr.?…Ivanka? OK, we won’t go there! He evidently is under the impression that he isn’t running campaign ads, but someone on the staff didn’t get the word, evidently, as we’ve all noticed a bunch of them. MSNBC host Johnathan Lemire says his decline is deeply alarming. “I think it’s going to be harder and harder for the campaign to manage this guy, and in just my opinion, he looks like he’s in a serious state of decline. And seriously, so confused.” Bill Palmer sees this as a now familiar pattern of The Don’s“trying to say something that’s idiotic to begin with, and then getting so confused that he ends up saying something even more incoherently idiotic. This man is not well. How long before he’s so far gone, he ends up in an assisted living facility?”

The Iowa caucuses were affected by below-zero temperatures and with the thermometer predicted to see a high of -4 degrees, accompanied by 20mph winds, voters who were determined to turn out did so in diminished numbers which did not affect the overall resulting percentages. Enter Laura Loomer (formerly of Project Veritas, and best known for her rabid anti-Muslim positions, who also happens to be a lunatic heavily supported by Trump and the right), posting her conspiracy theory that the adverse weather was caused by HAARP to discourage caucusers from venturing out. HAARP is research project sponsored by the University of Alaska which studies the ionosphere, their location being advantageous for studying the Northern Lights, and according to Loomer, for brewing up horrible weather conditions to visit upon hapless voters. Conspiracy theorists have also blamed the organization for earthquakes, mind control, power outages, TWA flight 800, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and anything else their red-hat-covered-brains can bring from the rat hole.

Luckily for Trump, the weather provided him with a whole new campaign slogan going forward. He told supporters on the Sunday preceding the caucus date that even if they were “sick as a dog,” it was worth braving the chilly conditions to vote. Even if they then passed away, “It’s worth it,” he said. So, there you have it: “Vote and Die,” on the prospective t-shirts and bumper stickers. This is a perfect summation of Trump’s attitude toward his base…“Do this thing for me, and if you should die, that’s okay…I’m worth it.” Ah, Mother Nature! What would Trump be without it?

Colin Nissan had a recent humorous essay in The New Yorker magazine, entitled ‘Nature, Wow!’ where he says that, “People are curious about nature. That’s why there are so many Google searches about it, such as ‘Which snakes are venomous?’ And ‘Quick remedies for throat closing.’ Or ‘Can I write my will on a leaf?’…And ‘Places to move where there are less snakes.’ There’s something for everyone in nature, even deserts, for people who love the beach but hate enjoying themselves…Researchers have spent years trying to unlock the mysteries of nature, like why the plural of deer is also deer, and why sunsets are free but paying a taxidermist for one ferret cost me almost a grand. Twelve hundred with the sailor outfit. Nature is famous for its calm and tranquility. A good example is the beautiful silence right after a school of piranhas goes to town on a carp. The big takeaway here is that we need to do everything we can to live in harmony with nature or we can kiss those watermelons goodbye. That means listening when nature is trying to tell us something, and also cutting ourselves some slack if we can’t decipher nature’s cryptic messages amid all the intense weather and natural disasters.” So, there you have it…Laura Loomer and Donald Trump unravelled the cryptic messages for their purposes, but as for the voters in Iowa and New Hampshire, not so much! For the rest of us, we don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows…the answers are in plain sight!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Decluttering”

“Decluttering is infinitely easier when you think of it as deciding what to keep, rather than deciding what to throw away.”
~Francine Jay

“Have nothing in your house that you do not know to be useful or believe to be beautiful.”
William Morris

“Bottom line is, if you do not use it or need it, it’s clutter, and it needs to go.”
~Charisse Ward

“Don’t own so much clutter that you will be relieved to see your house catch fire.”
~Wendell Berry

...

I don’t know how familiar you are with improv West Coast Swing dancing. Contestants get a random partner and a random song, and come up with things on the fly, like this AH-MAZING number below. Do enjoy! Note: You can find clips on YouTube that have the same dance, but with the cheers from the audience audible as well.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 17 – 23, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton…update and a throwback… Greensite…on The Wharf: Thanking the Mayor and City Council… Steinbruner…protest the Soquel Creek Water District rate hike before it’s too late. Hayes…Contrasting Biodiversity Hot Spots. Patton…No colossus… Matlock…on galloping mediocrity… Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes….”Martin Luther King, Jr”

...

THE GOODTIME WASHBOARD 3 WITH BING CROSBY. That’s my old trio with Wayne Pope, Bing Crosby, me and Pete Arnott during our appearance on Bing’s Hollywood Palace nationwide TV show from April 1, 1964. Also appearing on that show was Louis Armstrong, Nanette Fabray and Red Buttons.

photo credit: Bratton’s private photo collection

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

DATELINE January 17, 2024

UPDATE ON BRUCE You may have noticed things being a little different in the last column, with no new content from Bruce. That’s because he’s recuperating from a fall. I’m not sure if he was showing off jitterbug moves, walking on stilts, or what he was doing, but he is being well taken care of, and he’s on the mend. For more details, or to just say hi and get better, you can email him. I think he has a tablet so he can read email.

I dug deep in the archives, and pulled up something Bruce wrote in 2011. Check it out below!

//Gunilla//


The early years from a German Documentary on American “folk” music

MY SHOW BIZ HISTORY. Long before moving to Santa Cruz in 1970 I was nearly immersed in show business, almost, but never quite, full time.

Starting with our Palomar Jug Band in Pasadena circa 1957, we played a lot in LA’s Pershing Square and even the fabled Shrine Auditorium. Moving to Berkeley and trying to achieve an education and maturity at UC Berkeley, myself and two fellow students and friends, Pete Arnott and Wayne Pope, started a trio called The Goodtime Washboard 3.

We formed the trio because another friend and co-student Chris Strachwitz told us a local beer hall The Monkey In on Shattuck Ave needed a band. Chris Strachwitz is the brain and brawn behind Arhoolie Records.

As you can see from the historical photograph above The Goodtime Washboard 3 went on to considerable fame (no fortune) and I was with them until moving to Santa Cruz. We played San Francisco’s Purple Onion, The Hungry I (opening for comedian Shelley Berman) and did hundreds of gigs with stars like Milton Berle, Mel Torme, Herb Shriner, and Ray Bolger. We recorded some 45s and three albums, one for Fantasy and two for Capitol Records (in Frank Sinatra’s studio!).

BING CROSBY JOINS OUR GOODTIME WASHBOARD 3.

BIGGER SHOWS. We joined The Bohemian Club in San Francisco where I was the token Democrat and played with even bigger stars. It led to meeting and having Bing Crosby invite us to play on his Hollywood Palace with Louis Armstrong, Nanette Fabray, Red Buttons and heavies like that. This is a clip from that show back in 1964 – watch how Bing puts on thimbles and joins our group!

2024 ADDENDUM The aforementioned Chris Strachwitz founded Arhoolie Records in 1960. He passed away last year at the age of 91. For the last 18 months of his life, he and his long-time friend and disciple, music critic and author Joel Selvin, worked on a book from Chris’ huge collection of photographs he had taken over the years. Many of them had never been seen before they were published in Down Home Music: The Stories and Photographs of Chris Strachwitz, which Joel Selvin finished on his own after Chris died. You can click that link to order the book, if you’d like. While you are there, read about the Arhoolie Foundation, which Chris founded in 1999, dedicated to the documentation, preservation, and celebration of regional roots music and its makers. On the advisory board, you’ll find people like Bob Dylan, Bonnie Raitt, Steve Miller, and many more.

KEEPING THIS HERE TO REMIND YOU TO VOTE YES ON MEASURE M…PLEASE DONATE NOW!!

There is still time to donate, funds are needed by Febrary 10, 2024

In short, if enacted by the voters, Measure M will accomplish TWO simple things:

#1.) Require the city to get voter approval before height limits can be raised to allow oversized, high-rise developments anywhere in the city, downtown or in our neighborhoods.

#2.) Increase the number of affordable housing units that big developers must provide, from 20% to 25% for projects of over 30 units, as the City Planning Commission researched and recommended.

Measure M is facing enormous and well-funded opposition from out-of-town developers and their allies.  We NEED your financial assistance now to run a successful campaign. With only 60 days left before we vote on March 5, 2024, the sooner you donate the better. Another incentive to donate soon is we have matching funds.

Our fundraising goal is $50,000. This money will be used for our online presence, campaign materials, advertising, professional assistance and to rally residents to vote.

Make as generous a contribution as you possibly can to help pass Measure M and be part of the future design of Santa Cruz!   TWO ways to donate:

  1. Online with the DONATE button on:  Yes-on-M.org
  1. Or Write a check to: “Yes on M”, and call us to pick it up 831-471-7822 or send the check before Feb. 10 to:  
    Yes on M, PO Box 2191, Santa Cruz, Ca. 95063

Partial List of Supporters:

Gary Patton, Former County Supervisor, Environmental Attorney
Katherine Beiers, Former Mayor
Jane Weed-Pomerantz, Former Mayor
Nell Newman, Founder, Newman’s Own Organics, Environmentalist & Biologist
Rick Longinotti, Author, Right to Vote on Desal Initiative
Joseph S. Quigg, Affordable and Market-rate Housing Developer
Frank Barron, Retired Urban Planner
Keresha Durham-Tamba, Bilingual Educator, Environmental-Climate Activist
Hector Marin-Castro, Santa Cruz City Teacher’s Aid and Service Worker
Susan Monheit, Retired State Water Regulator, Environmental Scientist
Steve Bare, Retired High School Teacher, Military Veteran
Laura Lee, Retired Teacher, Corporate Trainer & Facilitator

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

A HAUNTING IN VENICE. **
(it was at the DEL MAR THEATRE in Sept. 2023, and is on HULU now). (6.8 IMDB). Kenneth Branagh
is back with the third in his Hercule Poirot versions of Agatha Christie’s books. Michelle Yeoh and Tina Fey are deadly serious in it too. Branagh moved the plot to Venice in 1947 from Christie’s book “Halloween Party” she first published in 1969. It’s deadly serious, very confusing, and it’s hard to stay interested as Poirot makes his rounds. Not recommended. More than that, three generations of my family watched it last Saturday (12/30) and no one liked it!!

THE HOLDOVERS. (PEACOCK MOVIE) (8.01 IMDB). ***
Paul Giamatti is at his very best in this sensitive touching drama of a teacher/guardian at a high class prep school in the 1970’s. His relationship with the boys, one especially is testy, kindly, and nearly unforgettable. He also has out of alignment eyes which he points out. The eyes were false by the wa

HOLIDAY IN THE VINEYARDS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). ** Probably an age gap, but I didn’t get one laugh from this self-titled comedy. A mother tries to raise her two sons and fend off a salesman from a competing winery. Too much mugging, bad acting, and barely amusing.

BANK OF DAVE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). ***
A regular working class Brit (it’s a British movie) decides to fight the banking establishment and start a small neighborhood bank. He goes against all Brit tradition and actually succeeds! It’s a true story well-acted by Rory Kinnear

THE FAMILY PLAN. (APPLE TV) (6.3 IMDB). ** A big cast with Mark Wahlberg and Michelle Monaghan trying for laughs because it’s listed as a comedy. It all takes place in Buffalo, New York and there’s a lot of former Buffalonians in Santa Cruz. Wahlberg is a former legal and official government assassin trying to raise a family. Nothing great, not the plot which is a century old or the acting.

GWYNETH VS. TERRY (MAX) (5.8 IMDB). *** Just knowing that Gwyneth had amassed a fortune from her Goop makeup world made me curious about what she would be like testifying in court. She and Terry Sanderson, a retired 76 year old Optometrist, collided on the downhill ski slopes in Utah in 2016. The jury declared Sanderson at fault. They both sued each other and it’s at least distracting. Gwyneth is 50 years old and she won one dollar in the settlement.

NORMA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). ***
This semi comedy was filmed between Uruguay and Argentina. A hired housekeeper quits her job and now the head of the household (Norma) has to deal with her two daughters, marijuana, therapy and the rest of her life. Riveting and watchable.

CURRY & CYANIDE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB). ** A documentary from India based on the 2019 “Jolly Joseph” case when a mother was arrested for committing six murders over a 10 year span including her own child! Puzzling, complex and well done. Depressing but watch it.

...

January 15th 2024

Rest In Peace, Henry J. Brunnier

The press release below captures a historic moment for the city of Santa Cruz. Had decisions gone the other way, it is fair to say that the 110-year-old Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf would be on track for a Pier 39-style transformation, chipping away the character of Santa Cruz one iconic structure after another.

There were many factors that contributed to this happy outcome. Every letter written, every voice raised, counted. Letters to the council ran fifty to three in our favor.  Without the California Environmental Quality Act there would have been no avenue to hold the city accountable for ignoring the Wharf Master Plan’s environmental impacts. CEQA gets a bad rap these days, usually from those eying profit and growth over environmental protection. However, this Act, signed into law in 1970 by Governor Ronald Reagan is a crucial tool to inform government decision-makers and the public about the environmental impacts of proposed projects. If environmental impacts are ignored or unmitigated, then the public has the right to ask the Court to decide if CEQA has been violated. In this case, the Court ruled against the City and mandated the 2020 Wharf Master Plan and its EIR (Environmental Impact Report) be cancelled and revised. That Court decision was two years ago this February.

At that pivotal point in 2022, the city could have decided to simply scale back the Wharf Master Plan, remove the most environmentally impactful and most publicly disliked aspects of the Plan, namely the forty-foot-tall new warehouse-style addition dubbed the Landmark building and the below-deck westside walkway, running horizontally for a third of the Wharf’s length under the restaurants and shops. That still left a lot of additions and changes to the Wharf to extract more tourist dollars. Instead, what the city did was double down. All sorts of new reasons were dreamed up to justify the westside walkway. Additional consultants were hired to counter concerns about migratory birds. The Historic Preservation Commission’s vote to remove the westside walkway was pooh-poohed by staff and dismissed as arbitrary. Propaganda swirled at every commission hearing over the past three months.

In the week leading up to the council hearing on January 9th. two of us from Don’t Morph the Wharf! met individually with the mayor and as many council members as were available during that holiday week for city staff. We found every one of them to be good listeners. We had a chance to rebut misinformation and present our case. Without receiving any promises, we felt heard.

The rest, as they say, is history. The mayor and the city council deserve much praise and appreciation for their unanimous vote to retain the historic character of the Municipal Wharf. There will be some upcoming changes that the public needs to pay attention to and be involved with, but none involving a CEQA challenge. Meanwhile, the mayor and city council have restored faith in the democratic process at City Hall, an invaluable outcome.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

PROTEST SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT RATE CHANGES BEFORE FEBRUARY 20
If you or someone you know is a customer of Soquel Creek Water District, you really need to  send in a protest vote right away to stop the impending 60% increase to fixed service fees and a 10% and 12% annual increase in water rates, lowering the Tier One-Tier Two rate threshold from 5.99 units to 3.99 units.

The PureWater Soquel Project costs ballooned from $60 million to nearly $200 million, and operational costs for the boondoggle have escalated (without any explanation) from the initial $2.5 million/year to now $5.5 Million/year!

Protest now by sending in your written vote to oppose it. Go to the Santa Cruz County Assessor’s Office and type in your address to find your APN (Assessor’s Parcel Number). Once you have that, go to
protestscwd.com for more info, and to download the form to print and fill out. Here’s a direct link to the pdf. Don’t forget, they must RECEIVE this by February 20, so do it now.

IS CONSOLIDATION IN THE FUTURE?
Maybe the best way out of this expensive PureWater Soquel Project debt burden is to consolidate with other adjacent water municipalities. Listen in this Friday, 2pm on “Community Matters” online Santa Cruz Voice radio with Guest Mr. Joe Serrano, Director of Santa Cruz County LAFCO to learn more about that possibility and other impending consolidations in fire districts throughout the County.
santacruzvoice.com

DRINKING RECYCLED SEWAGE WATER DIRECTLY FROM YOUR TAP NOW LEGAL IN CALIFORNIA?
California approves rules that turn sewage into drinking water
The State Water Board approved the ability for water agencies in California to soon sell treated sewage water directly to your tap. The final approval is yet to be handed down by the State Office of Administrative Law, but will likely happen by this summer or fall.

What are your thoughts about this?

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT WANTS TO INJECT TREATED SEWAGE WATER INTO THE MIDCOUNTY AQUIFER FOR EVERYONE TO DRINK
Even though the PureWater Soquel Project will be injecting an anticipated 1.67mg/L nitrate (existing nitrate level in the groundwater is 0.06mg/L) and 33mg/L chloride  (and who knows what else?!) into the pristine groundwater for the MidCounty’s drinking water source, the Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board approved the permit on December 15, 2023 to okay it.

The permit pointedly omits any ability to use the recycled water for irrigating the new sod lawn athletic fields at Twin Lakes Baptist Church School, which Soquel Creek Water District has gifted 3AcreFeet/year of water (potable or recycled) for the next 50 years as part of the deal for leasing the land for one of the injection wells on their property.

Hmmm…

 “This is the wave of the future!” Water Board Director Stephanie Harlan, former Capitola City Council member, shouted with jubilation..

Never mind that the staff of Soquel Creek Water District either could not or would not answer several questions asked by other Board members, such as “How much will the Project cost?”  and “How large are the injection well pipes?”

Staff from the Water Board vaguely and incorrectly answered the Board’s question as to where exactly is the salt water intrusion happening?  “Um, I think it’s in the Aptos and Capitola area where the injection wells are located” said Staff member James Bishop, just after imploring the Board to approve the permit “because the District needs this permit to move forward with the Project.”

Hmmmm…..

The night previous, Ms. Georgina King of Montgomery Associates hydrogeologist consultant for the MidCounty Groundwater Agency, which includes Soquel Creek Water District as the major pumper for the area, told the group that “Overall, the Basin is doing pretty well.”  There is some slight increase in chloride showing up in a cluster of three monitoring wells in the Seascape area, but those wells were drilled in the 1980’s for the purpose of locating and monitoring the saltwater/freshwater wedge known to exist (Luddorff Scalmanini analysis, paid for in part by Soquel Creek Water District).

Stay tuned, because a Request for Reconsideration and Stay has been filed with the State Water Board regarding the PureWater Soquel Permits.

You may be interested to know that when Director Harlan requested that the Soquel Creek Water District website include a link to a State tracking site where potential PureWater Soquel system problems or testing failures be posted, she quickly backed down from this request that had been made by a member of the public submitting comment on the proposed permit when Water Board staffmember Bishop did not support it.

WHY NITRATE IN YOUR DRINKING WATER IS NOT A GOOD THING
In case you were not able to hear a good discussion on KSQD about the problems with nitrate in local drinking water, please take time to listen to this January 7, 2024 interview with Ms. Chelsea Tu of California Waterkeepers

IS THAT A SCHOOL, A PARK OR A GULAG?  WHY IS SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT GIVING TWIN LAKES CHURCH AESTHETIC FAVORITISM?
If you visit Damon Gutzwiller Memorial County Park (aka Willowbrook Park) in Aptos, you may be shocked to see the appearance of a gulag project next to the tennis courts and the Santa Cruz Montessori School adjacent.

The fence protects one of the three PureWater Soquel Project injection wells.

This razor wire is a drastic change from what Soquel Creek Water District showed in the Project EIR Aesthetic documents.  The District did the same razor wire gulag-like change in fencing treatment at the injection well on Monterey Avenue adjacent to the ShoreLife  Mennonite Church and pre-school in Capitola.

However, the District seems to have given aesthetic favoritism to the Twin Lakes Church and School on Cabrillo College Drive, and followed through with a more attractive protective fence …no barbed wire at all!

Take a look at the photos below and write Soquel Creek Water District Board about this aesthetic favoritism at the expense of those whose youngsters attend ShoreLife Church and Sgt. Damon Gutzwiller Memorial Park.
Soquel Creek Water District Board of Directors <bod@soquelcreekwater.org>  and copy Emma Western <emmaw@soquelcreekwater.org>, and also write a letter to the editor of your favorite newspaper.

The Board of Supervisors voted to rename Willowbrook Park in honor of the fallen Sheriff  Sgt. Damon Gutzwiller, who frequented the park with his young son.
Willowbrook Park renamed in honor of the fallen Sheriff Sgt. Damon Gutzwiller

Soquel Creek Water District did not show a razor wire gulag like this in the EIR documents for PureWater Soquel Project Willowbrook Injection Well, but here it is, adjacent to the tennis courts at Sgt. Damon Gutzwiller Memorial Park.

Here is the view adjacent to the Santa Cruz Montessori School and the gulag of the PureWater Soquel Project Willowbrook Injection Well site.  The view is similar at the Monterey Injection Well adjacent to  the ShoreLife Mennonite Church and pre-school.

However, here is the view of the PureWater Soquel Project Twin Lakes Church Injection Well.  This is the type of fencing and landscape treatment that the other two injection wells were promised, but instead have 10′ chainlink fence with razor wire at the top.

Why is Soquel Creek Water District favoring Twin Lakes Church aesthetics?

JUST VOTE NO ON MEASURE K
TheCounty Board of Supervisors ignored the 2021 Grand Jury Investigation Report on the 2018 Measure G Countywide 1/2cent sales tax deception and on December 5, 2023, slapped on the March 5, 2024 Measure K initiative for yet another 1/2cent countywide sales tax.

WHY YOU SHOULD VOTE “NO” ON MEASURE K NEW 1/2 CENT SALES TAX

In 2018, the County Board of Supervisors placed Measure G on our ballots, asking for a 1/2 cent sales tax increase for 12 years for “unfunded critical needs”.

To continue funding 9-1-1 emergency response, paramedic, sheriff, fire, emergency preparedness, local street repairs, mental health services, homelessness programs, parks, economic development and other general county services, shall the County of Santa Cruz be authorized to increase by ordinance the sales tax on retail transactions in the unincorporated area of the County by one-half cent for twelve years, providing approximately $5,750,000 annually, subject to annual audits and independent citizens oversight?[2]

It passed by 65.85%, but the County Grand Jury investigation in 2021 concluded it was a deceptive action because there really was no Citizen Oversight, and promised projects, such as “fire”, have to date received ZERO DOLLARS from this tax increase.

Now, compare the language of Measure K…a forever sales tax:

To fund essential Santa Cruz County services, including wildfire response/prevention/recovery; affordable housing to support working families and frontline workers including nurses, emergency responders, and educators; mental health crisis programs for children/vulnerable populations; substance abuse programs; improved public safety, road maintenance/pothole repair, parks/recreation; and programs to reduce homelessness, shall Santa Cruz County’s transaction and use tax (sales tax) be increased in unincorporated areas by one-half cent, providing approximately $10,000,000 annually, until ended by voters?

EXACTLY WHAT DOES THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER (CAO) MEAN BY “SAFER, STRONGER SANTA CRUZ”? 

What exactly does the Board of Supervisors and CAO plan to do to accomplish any of those vague promises?
Why is Ms. Nicole Coburn, Deputy CAO, leading all the public presentations to support Measure K?  Is that a conflict of interest?  At a recent North Santa Cruz Democratic Committee presentation, she admitted that the CAO decided to call Measure K  a general tax and allow ALL VOTERS in the cities and uncorporated areas to vote on it in order to have the benefit of a 51% approval threshold, rather than restrict ti to the Unincorporated Area as a special tax that would have required a 2/3 majority approval.

SHOULD THE COUNTY HAVE PURCHASED A NEW SOUTH COUNTY GOV’T CENTER FOR $16.5 MILLION AND A NEW 38-ACRE PARK FOR $38 MILLION?

Here is an excerpt from the December 5, 2023 Board of Supervisor agenda item #9 for the initiative:.
Santa Cruz County CA, Agenda Item DOC-2023-974  Where is the money to help wildfire victims or fund County Fire Department response in the unincorporated areas?

Priorities for Community Investments

Concurrent with the ballot measure, staff also recommends that the Board adopt the attached resolution establishing budget priorities related to addressing key challenges in FY 2024-25. These priorities are aimed at addressing critical community needs, aligning with the County’s commitment to ensuring public safety, emergency response, mental health services, and vital infrastructure improvements. Details of the proposed budget priorities for FY 2024-25 are listed in Table 4.

Table 4 – FY 2024-25 Budget Priorities for Half-Cent Sales Tax

Budget Priority Area Amount
Housing and Essential Workforce Retention – Address the acute housing crisis, ensuring frontline workers can afford to live in the community, with funds to support housing plans and predevelopment costs on County campuses and other potential housing sites. $1.0 million
Countywide Homeless Services – Tackle homelessness with a focus on year-round, 24-hour navigation centers and other services distributed across Santa Cruz, Watsonville, and unincorporated areas. $1.0 million
Climate Resiliency and County Parks – Enhance the County’s response to climate change with funds for wildfire, flood and emergency response, prevention programs, and disaster recovery services. Additionally, support maintaining and improving neighborhood parks. $1.0 million
Road Repair and Infrastructure Projects – Address pressing infrastructure needs, including street repairs, potholes, and failing public facilities, to ensure safe and efficient transportation networks and government service centers. $1.0 million
Other Essential County Services – Address current challenges and emerging community needs, including mental health services for children and vulnerable populations, and invest in improved public safety. Based on actual revenues

The amounts above are based on the FY 2024-25 sales tax estimate of $7.5 million assuming the rate is effective July 1, 2024 and revenue from the sales tax increase is received from the State by October 2024. It is possible that due to the timing of the March primary election that the State may need additional processing time that could delay the effective date and subsequent cash flow by one calendar quarter, effectively reducing the expected amount to $5.0 million for FY 2024-25. If that occurs, the amounts in Table 4 would be proportionally reduced to equal $5.0 million.

WHY ISN’T THE CAO TALKING ABOUT THE $43 MILLION UNFUNDED CALPERS PENSION LIABILITY COMING DUE?

IS IT FAIR FOR THE RESIDENTS IN THE CITIES TO VOTE ON THIS WHEN THEY WILL NOT HAVE TO PAY THE TAX WITHIN THEIR CITIES?

Taxation Code 7285 refers to how the money gets spent:

The revenues derived from the imposition of a tax pursuant to this section shall only be used for general purposes within the area for which the tax was approved by the qualified voters.

SINGLE-USE MANUFACTURERS SOON WILL PAY COUNTIES FOR DISPOSAL/COMPOSTING COSTS

CalRecycle Releases Draft SB 54 Single Use Packaging Regulations and Packaging Forms Deemed to Be Recyclable or Compostable

On December 28, CalRecycle released long-anticipated SB 54 draft regulations for public review.  SB 54 (Allen) of 2022 requires manufacturers of single use packaging and food service ware to take responsibility for the management and recycling of the products they introduce into the stream of commerce.

The draft regulatory text can be found here.  CalRecycle has not yet initiated the formal rulemaking process, but is expected to do so in the near future.  That action will trigger a 45-day comment period during which RCRC and other stakeholders will be able to provide formal comments, express concerns, and suggest modifications to the proposed regulations.

As RCRC previously noted:

“SB 54 marks a tremendous paradigm shift for solid waste management in California, where local governments have traditionally borne the full responsibility for achieving the state’s solid waste management and recycling directives.    

“In particular, SB 54 requires single use packaging manufacturers to ensure that covered material is recyclable or compostable, create and fund end markets, and bear responsibility for costs incurred by local agencies and recycling service providers associated with the collection, storage, handling, and marketing of those products.  The measure is clear that the Legislature intends to ensure that local jurisdictions will be made financially whole for any new costs incurred associated with the measure.”  

Pursuant to SB 54, CalRecycle was required to determine what categories of covered materials are recyclable and compostable.  Under Public Resources Code Section 42060.5, all local jurisdictions must include those covered materials determined to be recyclable and compostable in their collection and recycling/composting programs, unless they receive an exemption or extension from CalRecycle.  Locals are not precluded from collecting additional materials not included on that list.  Importantly, those 19 counties with fewer than 70,000 residents (and cities within those counties) may exempt themselves from this requirement.

RCRC is currently reviewing the draft regulations and will be actively soliciting feedback from counties to guide its advocacy efforts on the proposal.  While CalRecycle did integrate some changes RCRC suggested in pre-regulatory workshops, RCRC is concerned that the scope of the proposed enforcement provisions in the draft regulations are inconsistent with and likely exceed the authority provided by SB 54.

For more information, contact RCRC Senior Policy Advocate, John Kennedy.

FINAL NOTE ON CHANTICLEER OVERCROSSING PROJECT IMPROVEMENTS….NOT
A few weeks ago, I received some great feedback from readers about the Chanticleer Overcrossing project.  These good folks helped me understand thte project better, and caused me to schedule a meeting with Ms. Sarah Christensen, RTC Project Manager.  What I learned is that the safety improvements in the Overcrossing’s access from Grey Bears industrial zone are all up to the County of Santa Cruz to actually do, and are not part of the Overcrossing project itself.  Ms. Christensen had no information as to a timeline, so I wrote Mr. Matt Machado, Director of County Public Works.

Here is his disappointing answer:

Hi Becky,

Our initial planning was to be in coordination with the new Kaiser Hospital.  Kaiser was to contribute some funds so we could conduct preliminary design and pursue grants.  With the Kaiser project off of the books we have no seed money to get this project going.  Considering all of the storm damage I do not see any realistic budget going toward this need in the foreseeable future.

Matt

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ATTEND A PUBLIC HEARING AND ASK QUESTIONS WITH THE INTENT THAT OFFICIALS WILL RESPECTFULLY PROVIDE YOU ANSWERS.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK AND JUST DO ONE THING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Contrasting Two Biodiversity Hot Spots

When I can muster it, I travel to the American tropics to experience an even greater degree of species diversity than California. I’d like to share some of what I noticed in the contrasts between the people and places I experienced this December in Ecuador, perhaps the most species rich place on Planet Earth.

Oh, the Riches

One of the most interesting conversations I had while traveling in Ecuador was during the taxi ride back to the airport as I was departing for California. I mentioned to the taxi driver some of the things I’d noticed in Ecuador that contrasted with California. For instance, the roadways were clean – no litter! Also, I hadn’t seen any homelessness during my travels, though I frequented areas where entire people had no obvious means of employment. Everyone I encountered during my 3-week stay had been more than polite – outgoingly kind more like it. And, those with whom I interacted seemed to appreciate and even understand a lot about the biological richness of their country. I told the taxi driver that these things were surprising to me as Ecuador was supposed to be such a poor country. He shook his head and corrected me – Ecuador is a rich country, quoting Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich Alexander von Humboldt, “Ecuadorians are rare and unique beings: they sleep peacefully in the midst of crisp volcanoes, live poor in the midst of incomparable riches and rejoice with sad music.” He then asked me if the United States was also a rich country, and how well did the people of the USA sleep? I didn’t know quite how to answer. (It turns out that one-in-five US citizens take sleep medication regularly).

Tourism Economy

It is interesting that both Santa Cruz County and the country of Ecuador generate approximately the same amount of cash due to tourism: $1.1 billion annually. It is there that the similarities end. The Beach Boardwalk is the driving force for Santa Cruz County tourism. Experiences in nature are what drives tourists to Ecuador; they go to experience Darwin’s discoveries in the Galapagos Islands or to see the rich jungles, volcanos, mountains, and the plethora of wildlife. Everywhere you go in Ecuador there are lodges hosting people whose destination is Nature. Lodges are gateways to the Parks, and each lodge has a cadre of nature guides trained to help tourists see the richness around them. Nature guides study for years to become certified to lead tours in the parks. The guides I met could identify hundreds of birds by their songs, knew a bit about most of the plants we encountered, could identify tracks in the mud, and could talk about the distribution of species across the country and beyond. There are hundreds and hundreds of such guides in that country, which is the size of Colorado.

What a Contrast!

As I returned home, I wracked my brain to think of a single lodge in the Monterey Bay that caters to nature tourists and has any nature guides at all. The San Francisco Airport toilets were much nastier than the toilets in the Quito airport. Trash litters Highway 1. The homeless population was not sleeping peacefully, though others might have been, back in my hometown of Santa Cruz. I’m not sure how many of my culture were rejoicing, with sad music or otherwise: joyfulness is not a phenomenon I equate with this culture. Certainly, most of us living around the Monterey Bay aren’t living poor, but we, like Ecuador, dwell ‘in the midst of incomparable riches.’

When is a Tourist Just a Tourist?

What does it matter that tourists go to the Boardwalk versus taking a walk with a nature guide? They come, they spend, they go home…it’s all good for the economy, right?

Between guided hikes at an Ecuadorian lodge at 9,000′ I sat by a fireplace looking through the reading material on the coffee table. There, among giant, full-color books published by the Ecuadorian government about the nation’s biological richness, I saw a magazine published by the American Bird Conservancy. That group, and the Audubon Society are two fairly mainstream conservation groups working to save birds from extinction. Many of the tourists supporting Ecuador’s lodges are birders. There is a natural connection between tourism and conservation. The same cannot be argued about Beach Boardwalk visitors.

So, why isn’t there an economy of immersive nature tourism around the Monterey Bay?

The Thrill Isn’t There and We Just Don’t Care

Thrilling, isn’t it? Roller coasters…rides…the children won’t be bored. Once the children grow up, the adults head overseas to see birds and nature: why not sooner? What is it about Nature that makes experiencing it so family unfriendly?

Even a drive along Highway 1 is so unenthralling as to invite so much littering.

Do we care so little about impressing the tourists, do we have such little pride, that we don’t bother keeping our airport toilets and roadsides clean? Aren’t we richer than that? Or, are we really quite poor?

What would Humboldt say of those currently living around the Monterey Bay? “They are just normal beings: they sleep fitfully in the midst of isolation and crime, living poorly in the midst of incomparable riches and rejoice in violent movies.”

Awake! The Unfolding is Nigh

Now the rain has wetted the green hills, flowers are bursting, birds are singing spring songs, and streams are noisily dancing. The solution is at hand. Toss aside the social media, decline the invitation to the movies, take the trail and saunter. Invite someone to join you, someone with whom you can adventure and discover the amazing life unfolding around the Monterey Bay. First on the list: the manzanitas! A dozen species within a short drive – discover them all, their beautiful bark, their honey-scented flowers with hummingbirds and bumble bees aplenty. Jackrabbits and brush bunnies, roadrunners and quail, coyote and mountain lion tracks around every corner. Need a guide? Sign up for a walk if you can find one: ask me if you can’t. The Monterey Bay’s ecotourist economy and resulting conservation start with you, now and tomorrow. Let’s make Ecuador a sister country to the Monterey Bay – biodiversity hotspots with plenty of inspiration to share.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

#18 / Colossus Not

The Colossus of Rhodes

Donald Trump’s recent victory in the Iowa caucuses has led to lots of statements in the press (and elsewhere) that take it for granted that our former president is now clearly going to be the 2024 Republican Party nominee for president, and that he has an excellent chance of beating the presumptive Democratic Party nominee, Joe Biden.

Well…. Maybe not!

Charlie Sykes, who writes blog postings that appear online in The Bulwark+, has a different perspective. Here is an except from Sykes’ posting on January 17, 2024, which was titled, “Dominant but Vulnerable.”

He doth bestride the narrow world
Like a colossus, and we petty men
Walk under his huge legs

— Julius Caesar, William Shakespeare

Lest there was any lingering doubt, the Iowa caucuses confirmed Trump’s dominance in the GOP. He crushed his opposition and is now described as basking in the momentum of his landslide. He bestrides a supine Republican Party like a colossus and petty men beg his favor.

But that’s only part of the story, and perhaps not the most important one. Iowa also revealed just how weak Trump may be in the general election. The Bulwark’s Joe Perticone takes a closer look at the numbers:

[Monday’s] caucuses saw just over 110,000 Republicans turn out to vote. In 2016, that number was nearly 187,000, around 70 percent higher. Some voters stayed home because of the cold snap, of course—it was 30 degrees below freezing in Iowa last night—notwithstanding Trump’s invitation to them to take their lives into their own hands.

But registering only around three votes for every five votes cast the last time there was an “open” primary suggests there could be a real enthusiasm problem among GOP voters. And in addition to this year’s low turnout, consider the fact that Trump, a quasi-incumbent with greater name recognition than anyone alive, earned the votes of just over half of the state’s caucusgoers—the most committed members of Iowa’s GOP.

Let’s break it down even further:

Only about 14-15% of GOP voters showed up; which means that Trump’s landslide total comprised about 8 percent of Iowa Republicans.

A substantial number of Republican voters are signaling that they are Never Trump. NBC reports that nearly half of Haley’s Iowa backers say they’d vote for Biden over Trump. As Mona Charen noted yesterday the pre-caucus poll by the Des Moine Register found that fully 25 percent of Iowa Republican caucus-goers say they won’t vote for Trump in November.

That’s reflected in some of the on-the-ground reporting from the Dispatch:

[It] was remarkable how many Iowa voters backing Ron DeSantis and Nikki Haley told The Dispatch some version of the same thing Monday evening after Donald Trump’s commanding caucus victory: If he’s the nominee, count them out….

“I can’t believe that out of 340 million Americans, those are the two best options that we can come up with,” a Haley supporter named Greg told us from an elementary school caucus site in suburban Waukee. “But yes, I cannot see myself voting for Trump under any circumstances. He’s an insurrectionist and a criminal, and I will not support him.”

I am inclined to agree with what Sykes and Perticone are saying.

Donald Trump? Not a colossus!

To Subscribe Just Click This Link

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

GALLOPING MEDIOCRITY IN THE NO-SPIN ZONE

His head spinning out of control, former Fox News host Bill (The O’Reilly Factor/No Spin Zone) O’Reilly is not having it that his books are being removed from Florida’s Escambia County libraries, being included in a list of 1,000 titles pending investigation under the state’s new book ban laws. Bill-O was quoted saying, “Preposterous! We are investigating and are seeking comment from @GovRonDeSantis. This will not stand.” Conservatives in the Sunshine State have been carrying out their campaign to remove any printed matter containing ideas, philosophies, and language with which they disagree, particularly those teaching critical race theory, or containing LGBTQ+ topics and those by LGBTQ+ authors. As a previous stalwart in favor of this legislation, O’Reilly claims, “When DeSantis signed the book law, I supported the theme because there was abuse going on in Florida. There were far-left progressive people trying to impose an agenda on children, there’s no doubt about it.” Of course, he now thinks the wording in the laws is “far too nebulous” and that Governor Ron should declare it “insane” that his books have been removed.

Further, “There are materials that are inappropriate and those materials have to be specifically included in the law with language that is very specific. You can’t be throwing John Grisham under the bus, it’s absurd,” he notes. Seeking retribution, he wants to find out who in the school district removed the books and “put their pictures up on television and on my website.” Perhaps we should have more respect for those reviewers at being more discriminating than they are given credit for since O’Reilly’s book entitled ‘Killing Lincoln,’ was initially banned from sale at Washington’s Ford Theatre bookstore when it was released. He and his coauthor, Martin Dugard, were accused of including factual errors, and a lack of documentation, according to Rae Emerson, deputy superintendent of Ford’s Theatre National Historic Site, a unit of the National Park Service. Emerson’s review recommended that the book not be sold at Ford Theatre’s NPS store. So, while the NPS chose not to carry the Lincoln title, Ford’s Theatre Society sells it in their gift shop, allowing visitors to judge the merits of the book themselves.

Spinner’ O’Reilly was not the only victim of the Escambia County School District. Also targeted were dictionaries and encyclopedias sitting on their shelves, which drew widespread discussions and criticisms of the extremes to which they took the new book banning laws. HB 1069, which governs the new rules, targets books that depict or describe sexual conduct, launching Florida into the forefront of national bans, with 1,972 instances in 37 school districts in the ’22-’23 school year as documented by PEN AmericaPenguin Random House, along with PEN America and other organizations have filed a federal lawsuit against Escambia’s school board, arguing that their actions infringe on free speech rights and equal protection under the law. We can’t have kids with tender sensitivities reading about the likes of BeyoncéOprah or Thurgood Marshall, and if they wanted to know what MLK Day was all about, they might ask somebody…in a whisper! And, Anne Frank? Don’t ask! In essence, the government can remove any content of ‘disapproved speech’ which raises the question of the purpose of educational resources in restricting access to diverse literature. A federal court will hear the school board’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit, crucial in determining the validity of both sides’ arguments re the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The outcome will likely have implications not only for Florida, but educational content across the US. Taken straight from the banned dictionary: Ignorant – lacking knowledge or awareness, in general, uneducated or unsophisticated. So, there ya go, Bill-O…just find that group and you can post photos and info to your heart’s content!

GOP presidential candidate Chris Christie showed some awareness in abandoning his bid for that spot, leaving the field for the MAGAs and the wannabe-MAGAs to fight it out. Bridgegate and all his failings aside, national affairs correspondent John Nichols wrote, “He was the last high-profile GOP contender who was fighting for whatever remains of the soul of the Republican Party.” Christie’s announcement was a concession/confessional as he stepped aside, admitting that ego was his downfall in becoming involved with Trump’s Spray-Tanic political quagmire that he now battles against. Some of his words were admirable in the melancholy atmosphere of the gathered supporters who came understanding what they would hear regarding his nowhere-role in today’s GOP. He vowed to keep up the pressure against Trump’s candidacy, telling his crowd and all voters that the former guy is unfit and should never be near the oval office again. Bocha Blue, in his essay in The Palmer Report, drops a few lines from ‘Vincent‘ by singer/songwriter Don McLean“Now I think I know, What you tried to say to me. How you suffered for your sanity, And how you tried to set them free. They would not listen, they’re not listening still. Perhaps they never will.”

Christie also offered a few unsolicited words, picked up on an open microphone, about Nikki Haley who has seen her poll numbers pick up in recent days. He said, “She’s going to get smoked, and you and I both know it. She’s not up to this.” At this writing, Iowa caucuses are hours away, so in retrospect was she up to it? How did she fare against DeSantis? And how badly, in a cloud of dust, did The Donald leave her, stranded and smoking? A NBC News/Des Moines Register/Mediacom poll had shown that 43% of Iowa’s Haley supporters would cross to the Democrats and Biden’s candidacy in the general election rather than give their vote to Trump, with 23% supporting Trump if he is the GOP candidate. Independent Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. could see 19% of Haley’s supporters swing into his column. “Haley is consolidating the anti-Trump vote. She does well with people who define themselves as anti-Trump,” said pollster J. Ann Selzer, who has spent three decades conducting surveys in Iowa. Still afraid to attack Trump too directly, in the final GOP debate with rival DeSantis, Haley was asked, “Does Donald Trump have the character to be President?” A momentary deer-in-the-headlights look brought her answer, “Well, I think the next President needs to have moral clarity,” and after a pause, “His way is not my way.” Still running for numero dos, Nikki? During the debate, if DeSantis mentioned Nikki’s record, she would tell viewers, “Go to DeSantisLies.com,” ignoring an equally valid site, TrumpLlies.com! A Mike Luckovich political cartoon has contestant Nikki Haley on TV’s ‘Wheel of Fortune,’ with the posted question, “What was the US Civil War fought over?” The board shows _ _ A _ E R Y, so Nikki takes a stab at guessing the missing letters with “D R A P E R Y.” A perfectly good MAGA answer…after all, Scarlett O’Hara in the Civil War epic, ‘Gone With the Wind,’ makes perfectly good use of drapes, and who can forget the Carol Burnett Show’s sketch of that particular movie scene, curtain rod and all?

Johnny One-note Trump never participated in any of the candidate debates leading up to the Iowa caucuses, his reasoning being the polls showing him to be the runaway choice of the MAGAGOP, and it’s just as well since everyone knew what was going to come out of his mouth, with nothing pertaining to the topic at hand. His so-called debating style actually has a name with historical roots: the Gish Gallop. It is defined as a well-established method of outmaneuvering rhetorical opponents with an overwhelming onslaught of dubious arguments, also known as ‘spreading‘ in the debate community. The style’s name is attributed to Duane Gish, a biochemist and creationist who in the 1980s and 1990s used it to his advantage in evolution dialogues. The Gish Gallop leverages two basic human reasoning tendencies, on the concept that it’s easier and faster to make false claims than it is for an opponent to disprove even one. If the opposition fails to disprove every one of the questionable claims, triumph goes toward the ‘spreader.’ In setting up organized, formal debates, the Gallop (not to be confused with the Gallup) has met disapproval with rules limiting the points made by a presenter within a certain time frame; however, in today’s political atmosphere, televised debates, radio show panels, and talking-head presentations make Gish’s showbiz style right at home – an entertainment network’s dream come true.

Coping with a Gallop opponent can be done, but it’s time-consuming, and the open-mindedness and ability to recognize what is happening is paramount. By reframing the argument, a skillful debater can simply ignore the list presented and focus on a single coherent counter-argument not easily debunked, making the presenter look like a flake. Trump has perfected the Gallop, probably unconsciously, with his spewing of rapid-fire lies, insults and accusations, burying most opponents who are likely unprepared and limited in time to respond to his overwhelming blast. We have seen weak-willed interviewers who fail to interject, correct or take a pause to respond to his gibberish, being totally unprepared to counter his tricky onslaught with facts, documentation or relevant information. Eugenie Scott, a biologist and retired anthropology professor, founded the National Center for Science Education in 1981 to ensure that evolution, not creationism, is taught in our schools, says, ” Debate is a sport. It is not a way of informing the audience or the public of the accuracy of an opinion. It is played by rules that are different from those of logic and empirical evidence.” She also describes debates as “drive-by shootings when it comes to critical thinking.” And, speaking of drive-bys, we must remember that Hillary Clinton was deemed the winner in all the Trump/Clinton debates in 2016 and we see how that ended. Raise your hand if you believe RFK, Jr.‘s claim that the COVID-19 virus may have been “targeted” to spare Ashkenazi Jews and the ChineseNew York Times columnist, Farhad Manjoo, writes, “You can come with all the facts in the world, but when you’re dealing with a conspiracist, there’s no real way to ‘win’ an argument. For people whose views aren’t anchored to facts, ‘winning’ is simply getting attention. And when you publicly argue with someone like Kennedy, you’ve already lost.”

Speaking of losing, our former prez has been convicted of fraudulently and massively inflating the worth of his properties, enabling him to borrow excessive amounts of cash on properties worth billions of dollars less. Then he backtracks to the original evaluations when it comes time to tax time, with no taxes being paid as a consequence of the claimed write-offs. He faces a fine of $250M and possibly seeing his businesses shut down in New York. Those properties with his name on them are owned by the banks, so the $80M and properties he garnered from his late father are dust in the wind since he has overextended himself. Speculation is that his cash-poor situation as he faces several penalties from his numerous court disasters will take down his empire…those unsuspecting MAGAs who send him their hard-earned monies from his beggarly entreaties on Truth Social can barely pay his legal fees. Plus, he is about to lose what was once a real ego-booster…his 2007 Hollywood Walk of Fame star! Hugo Soto-Martinez who represents the district where the star is located is looking into having the star removed. He says, “Donald Trump is a racist, fascist, and a threat to our democracy. We’re looking into where the authority lies, what the legal issues may be, and what a process for it might look like.” This will be a first, and most believe the ultimate authority for removal of this embarrassing honor is the City Council. Removal would also save a fortune for the city, which has had to pay for many cleanups, as the star has been defaced, smashed and otherwise damaged to the tune of $20,000 or so. Bocha Blue writes on The Palmer Report that complete removal is best…Hollywood stars are for the talented, and Trump’s only talent is starting insurrections and name-calling. As Joseph Heller says in his novel, ‘Catch 22,’ 

“Some men are born mediocre,
some men achieve mediocrity,
and some men have mediocrity thrust upon them.”
 

Which box does Trump fit into?

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

“Martin Luther King, Jr”

“Science investigates; religion interprets. Science gives man knowledge, which is power; religion gives man wisdom, which is control. Science deals mainly with facts; religion deals mainly with values. The two are not rivals.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr in 1959

“For when people get caught up with that which is right and they are willing to sacrifice for it, there is no stopping point short of victory.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr in 1968

“We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr in 1963

“Let no man pull you so low as to hate him.”
~Martin Luther King, Jr in 1956

...

Jimmy Stewart, War Hero? Sure, just check out this video… there’s a lot I didn’t know.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...


Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 10 – 16, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton…re-run this week Greensite…back next week… Steinbruner…also back next week. Hayes…still in Ecuador. Patton…“Self-Government” And Measure M. Matlock…has said it before… Eagan…Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover. Webmistress…pick of the week. Quotes….”January”

...

THE ORIGINAL SANTA CRUZ PUBLIC LIBRARY’S DEATH. This was taken September 12, 1966. Even back then our City Council made stupid decisions. They destroyed this classic library and built the one that all the hooplah is about now. It’s the same location…you can see the once upon a time funeral home complete with incinerator just across Church street.  Now it’s the Prophet Elias Greek Orthodox Church.

Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com
photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

DATELINE January 10, 2024

KEEPING THIS HERE TO REMIND YOU TO VOTE YES ON MEASURE M…PLEASE DONATE NOW!!

In short, if enacted by the voters, Measure M will accomplish TWO simple things:

#1.) Require the city to get voter approval before height limits can be raised to allow oversized, high-rise developments anywhere in the city, downtown or in our neighborhoods.

#2.) Increase the number of affordable housing units that big developers must provide, from 20% to 25% for projects of over 30 units, as the City Planning Commission researched and recommended.

Measure M is facing enormous and well-funded opposition from out-of-town developers and their allies.  We NEED your financial assistance now to run a successful campaign. With only 60 days left before we vote on March 5, 2024, the sooner you donate the better. Another incentive to donate soon is we have matching funds.

Our fundraising goal is $50,000. This money will be used for our online presence, campaign materials, advertising, professional assistance and to rally residents to vote.

Make as generous a contribution as you possibly can to help pass Measure M and be part of the future design of Santa Cruz!   TWO ways to donate:

  1. Online with the DONATE button on:  Yes-on-M.org
  1. Or Write a check to: “Yes on M”, and call us to pick it up 831-471-7822 or send the check before Feb. 10 to:  
    Yes on M, PO Box 2191, Santa Cruz, Ca. 95063

Partial List of Supporters:

Gary Patton, Former County Supervisor, Environmental Attorney
Katherine Beiers, Former Mayor
Jane Weed-Pomerantz, Former Mayor
Nell Newman, Founder, Newman’s Own Organics, Environmentalist & Biologist
Rick Longinotti, Author, Right to Vote on Desal Initiative
Joseph S. Quigg, Affordable and Market-rate Housing Developer
Frank Barron, Retired Urban Planner
Keresha Durham-Tamba, Bilingual Educator, Environmental-Climate Activist
Hector Marin-Castro, Santa Cruz City Teacher’s Aid and Service Worker
Susan Monheit, Retired State Water Regulator, Environmental Scientist
Steve Bare, Retired High School Teacher, Military Veteran
Laura Lee, Retired Teacher, Corporate Trainer & Facilitator

I search and critique a variety of movies only from those that are newly released. Choosing from the thousands of classics and older releases would take way too long. And be sure to tune in to those very newest movie reviews live on KZSC 88.1 fm every Friday from about 8:10 – 8:30 am. on the Bushwhackers Breakfast Club program hosted by Dangerous Dan Orange.

THIS IS A REPEAT FROM LAST WEEK

A HAUNTING IN VENICE. **
(it was at the DEL MAR THEATRE in Sept. 2023, and brand new to HULU now). (6.8 IMDB). Kenneth Branagh
is back with the third in his Hercule Poirot versions of Agatha Christie’s books. Michelle Yeoh and Tina Fey are deadly serious in it too. Branagh moved the plot to Venice in 1947 from Christie’s book “Halloween Party” she first published in 1969. It’s deadly serious, very confusing, and it’s hard to stay interested as Poirot makes his rounds. Not recommended. More than that, three generations of my family watched it last Saturday (12/30) and no one liked it!!

THE HOLDOVERS. (PEACOCK MOVIE) (8.01 IMDB). ***
Paul Giamatti is at his very best in this sensitive touching drama of a teacher/guardian at a high class prep school in the 1970’s. His relationship with the boys, one especially is testy, kindly, and nearly unforgettable. He also has out of alignment eyes which he points out. The eyes were false by the way

HOLIDAY IN THE VINEYARDS. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). ** Probably an age gap, but I didn’t get one laugh from this self-titled comedy. A mother tries to raise her two sons and fend off a salesman from a competing winery. Too much mugging, bad acting, and barely amusing.

BANK OF DAVE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.1 IMDB). ***
A regular working class Brit (it’s a British movie) decides to fight the banking establishment and start a small neighborhood bank. He goes against all Brit tradition and actually succeeds! It’s a true story well-acted by Rory Kinnear

THE FAMILY PLAN. (APPLE TV) (6.3 IMDB). ** A big cast with Mark Wahlberg and Michelle Monaghan trying for laughs because it’s listed as a comedy. It all takes place in Buffalo, New York and there’s a lot of former Buffalonians in Santa Cruz. Wahlberg is a former legal and official government assassin trying to raise a family. Nothing great, not the plot which is a century old or the acting.

GWYNETH VS. TERRY (MAX) (5.8 IMDB). *** Just knowing that Gwyneth had amassed a fortune from her Goop makeup world made me curious about what she would be like testifying in court. She and Terry Sanderson, a retired 76 year old Optometrist, collided on the downhill ski slopes in Utah in 2016. The jury declared Sanderson at fault. They both sued each other and it’s at least distracting. Gwyneth is 50 years old and she won one dollar in the settlement.

NORMA. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.2 IMDB). ***
This semi comedy was filmed between Uruguay and Argentina. A hired housekeeper quits her job and now the head of the household (Norma) has to deal with her two daughters, marijuana, therapy and the rest of her life. Riveting and watchable.

CURRY & CYANIDE. (NETFLIX MOVIE) (7.4 IMDB). ** A documentary from India based on the 2019 “Jolly Joseph” case when a mother was arrested for committing six murders over a 10 year span including her own child! Puzzling, complex and well done. Depressing but watch it.

SPECIAL NOTE….Don’t forget that when you’re not too sure of a plot or need any info on a movie to go to Wikipedia. It lays out the straight/non hype story plus all the details you’ll need including which server (Netflix, Hulu, or PBS) you can find it on. You can also go to Brattononline.com and punch in the movie title and read my take on the much more than 100 movies.

WILDERNESS. (PRIME SERIES) (6.3 IMDB). ** There’s this couple in New York City who appear to love each other but she finds out he’s been cheating on her for years and continues to do so even after she confronts him. So it goes on and on with her trying different means of getting revenge. It’s stretched to a series but could have made a neat but troubling movie

ASTEROID CITY. (PRIME MOVIE) (6.6 IMDB). ??? It’s directed by Wes Andersen and has an all-star cast with Tom Hanks, Scarlett Johansson, Bryan Cranston, Edward Norton, and more. Like Andersen’s other films its puzzling, mystical, funny, quixotic, and symbolic of something that you won’t quite be sure of. See it just for fun and forget trying to decode it. And no thumbs rating because it’s in a class by itself.

HIGH TIDES. (NETFLIX SERIES) (7.5 IMDB). ***
A more or less lighthearted Belgian series filmed in the city of KNOKKE in Belgium which will remind anybody of Santa Cruz except that KNOKKE is centuries older. It’s about the wealthy class and their relationship with the poorer working class. Not too subtle or even educating. Lots of cocaine, racial digs and downtime.

REACHER. (PRIME SERIES) (8.1 IMDB).  *** The new Reacher star isn’t puny little Tom Cruise anymore it’s a guy named Alan Ritchson and he’s a hulk of a human and they always aim the camera looking up at him to make him even taller and bigger. There’s an aerial murder and Reacher blends into the local police forces special team to find out who’s doing the other killings.

LEAVE THE WORLD BEHIND (NETFLIX MOVIE) (6.5 IMDB). ** An all-star cast with Julie Roberts, Ethan Hawke, Kevin Bacon and especially Mahershala Ali as the well-meaning but silent neighbor. The movie loses tension, there’s too much mugging, and the racial theme isn’t carried out to any new degree. It’s about the class system and how we view our neighbors. Don’t hurry.

THE COVENANT. (PRIME MOVIE) (7.5 IMDB). ** Jake Gyllenhaal and Dar Salim play two Army survivors during the war in 2018 Afghanistan. Jake is an interpreter and Dar is wounded so Jake carries him for miles risking both their lives. It’s slow, predictable and mostly USA propaganda. Don’t bother.

...

Gillian will be back next week.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

Becky will also be back next week.

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Jan 8

Contrasting Two Biodiversity Hot Spots

When I can muster it, I travel to the American tropics to experience an even greater degree of species diversity than California. I’d like to share some of what I noticed in the contrasts between the people and places I experienced this December in Ecuador, perhaps the most species rich place on Planet Earth.

Oh, the Riches

One of the most interesting conversations I had while traveling in Ecuador was during the taxi ride back to the airport as I was departing for California. I mentioned to the taxi driver some of the things I’d noticed in Ecuador that contrasted with California. For instance, the roadways were clean – no litter! Also, I hadn’t seen any homelessness during my travels, though I frequented areas where entire people had no obvious means of employment. Everyone I encountered during my 3-week stay had been more than polite – outgoingly kind more like it. And, those with whom I interacted seemed to appreciate and even understand a lot about the biological richness of their country. I told the taxi driver that these things were surprising to me as Ecuador was supposed to be such a poor country. He shook his head and corrected me – Ecuador is a rich country, quoting Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich Alexander von Humboldt, “Ecuadorians are rare and unique beings: they sleep peacefully in the midst of crisp volcanoes, live poor in the midst of incomparable riches and rejoice with sad music.” He then asked me if the United States was also a rich country, and how well did the people of the USA sleep? I didn’t know quite how to answer. (It turns out that one-in-five US citizens take sleep medication regularly).

Tourism Economy

It is interesting that both Santa Cruz County and the country of Ecuador generate approximately the same amount of cash due to tourism: $1.1 billion annually. It is there that the similarities end. The Beach Boardwalk is the driving force for Santa Cruz County tourism. Experiences in nature are what drives tourists to Ecuador; they go to experience Darwin’s discoveries in the Galapagos Islands or to see the rich jungles, volcanos, mountains, and the plethora of wildlife. Everywhere you go in Ecuador there are lodges hosting people whose destination is Nature. Lodges are gateways to the Parks, and each lodge has a cadre of nature guides trained to help tourists see the richness around them. Nature guides study for years to become certified to lead tours in the parks. The guides I met could identify hundreds of birds by their songs, knew a bit about most of the plants we encountered, could identify tracks in the mud, and could talk about the distribution of species across the country and beyond. There are hundreds and hundreds of such guides in that country, which is the size of Colorado.

What a Contrast!

As I returned home, I wracked my brain to think of a single lodge in the Monterey Bay that caters to nature tourists and has any nature guides at all. The San Francisco Airport toilets were much nastier than the toilets in the Quito airport. Trash litters Highway 1. The homeless population was not sleeping peacefully, though others might have been, back in my hometown of Santa Cruz. I’m not sure how many of my culture were rejoicing, with sad music or otherwise: joyfulness is not a phenomenon I equate with this culture. Certainly, most of us living around the Monterey Bay aren’t living poor, but we, like Ecuador, dwell ‘in the midst of incomparable riches.’

When is a Tourist Just a Tourist?

What does it matter that tourists go to the Boardwalk versus taking a walk with a nature guide? They come, they spend, they go home…its all good for the economy, right?

Between guided hikes at an Ecuadorian lodge at 9,000′ I sat by a fireplace looking through the reading material on the coffee table. There, among giant, full-color books published by the Ecuadorian government about the nation’s biological richness, I saw a magazine published by the American Bird Conservancy. That group, and the Audubon Society are two fairly mainstream conservation groups working to save birds from extinction. Many of the tourists supporting Ecuador’s lodges are birders. There is a natural connection between tourism and conservation. The same cannot be argued about Beach Boardwalk visitors.

So, why isn’t there an economy of immersive nature tourism around the Monterey Bay?

The Thrill Isn’t There and We Just Don’t Care
Thrilling, isn’t it? Roller coasters…rides…the children won’t be bored. Once the children grow up, the adults head overseas to see birds and nature: why not sooner? What is it about Nature that makes experiencing it so family unfriendly?

Even a drive along Highway 1 is so unenthralling as to invite so much littering.

Do we care so little about impressing the tourists, do we have such little pride, that we don’t bother keeping our airport toilets and roadsides clean? Aren’t we richer than that? Or, are we really quite poor?

What would Humboldt say of those currently living around the Monterey Bay? “They are just normal beings: they sleep fitfully in the midst of isolation and crime, living poorly in the midst of incomparable riches and rejoice in violent movies.”

Awake! The Unfolding is Nigh
Now the rain has wetted the green hills, flowers are bursting, birds are singing spring songs, and streams are noisily dancing. The solution is at hand. Toss aside the social media, decline the invitation to the movies, take the trail and saunter. Invite someone to join you, someone with whom you can adventure and discover the amazing life unfolding around the Monterey Bay. First on the list: the manzanitas! A dozen species within a short drive – discover them all, their beautiful bark, their honey-scented flowers with hummingbirds and bumble bees aplenty. Jackrabbits and brush bunnies, roadrunners and quail, coyote and mountain lion tracks around every corner. Need a guide? Sign up for a walk if you can find one: ask me if you can’t. The Monterey Bay’s ecotourist economy and resulting conservation start with you, now and tomorrow. Let’s make Ecuador a sister country to the Monterey Bay – biodiversity hotspots with plenty of inspiration to share.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

MONDAY, JANUARY 8, 2024
#8 / “Self-Government” And Measure M

Last Saturday, I briefly contrasted “opinion” and “the truth,” noting that we need to understand the difference between them when we start talking about “politics.” According to Hannah Arendt, politics is about “opinion,” and not about “truth.”

Today, before commenting on Measure M, which will be on the ballot this March in the City of Santa Cruz, it strikes me that I might say a word about the difference between “democracy” and “self-government.”

Many people conflate the two. The slide shown above, for instance, taken (and slightely modified) from a slideshow published by the Munk School of Global Affairs & Public Policy, seems to imply that “self-government” and “democracy” are equivalent. I would like to suggest to you that they’re not.

“Democracy,” at least the way I believe most people understand the term, is focused on “voting.” Our political choices (about candidates for office, and about various policy matters that may be put before eligible voters for a decision) are made, in a “democratic” system, by the process of allowing people to vote. Usually, a majority of the voters will determine who is elected, or what will be done about the question put to a vote. This is “democracy,” and make no mistake, we definitely need “democracy,” and more of it. Democracy, however, when democracy is equated to “voting,” is not “self-government.” Voting is “necessary” to self-government, but it is not “sufficient.”

When I was a Santa Cruz County Supervisor – quite a few years ago, now – I was a big proponent of “self-government,” and I warned my constituents that we needed to be careful not to set up our government on the basis that we “elect the people, who hire the people, who then run our lives for us.”

In fact, when “democracy” is equated to “voting,” that is exactly what can (and often does) happen. People concerned about the so-called “Deep State” are indicating that a government so configured – a government in which we elect the people, who hire the people, who then run our lives for us – is not a satisfactory way for a self-governing people to make governmental decisions.

Once “the government” becomes those people “hired to run our lives for us” – the planners, the bureaucrats, the City Mangers and the department heads in charge of governmental budgets – those people may not pay any attention at all to those voters who are supposedly in charge of their government. This is definitely what those who are concerned about the “Deep State” assert has happened at the national level, but the same thing happens at every level of our government, including the local level.

When Lincoln said, in the Gettysburg Address, that the Civil War was fought to make certain that a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people” will not perish from the earth, Lincoln was not, I’d argue, thinking about a government in which voters “elect the people, who then hire the people, who then run their lives for them.”

That would be a government “for” the people (or at least theoretically so). “Self-government” is something else. It’s something more than voting.

“Self-government” means a government “BY THE PEOPLE,” a government (and politics) in which ordinary people are personally involved.

Lincoln’s statement in the Gettysburg Address implies – in fact, that phrase “says” – that governmental and political activities must be directly carried out by ordinary people. “BY THE PEOPLE.” That means you. That means me. That means us.

WE need to be directly involved in what the government does; we need to know what it’s doing, and we need to allocate our own time in such a way that we can have a direct impact on the governmental actions that are being taken in our name.

“Politics,” in fact, needs to be one of our major commitments. It needs to be a “personal” commitment. Politics demands our time. It demands our money. Politics demands that we take action to ensure that our political institutions reflect and carry forward our most deeply-held concerns.

The patriots who carried out the American Revolution pledged “their lives, their fortunes, and their sacred honor.” Those are the last words in the Declaration of Independence. All of these need to be mobilized, by us, in the task of self-government.

MEASURE M (CITY OF SANTA CRUZ)

Measure M is an example of genuine self-government. In the City of Santa Cruz, voters will be asked in March to vote on an initative measure (Measure M) that will allow city voters to decide, themselves, whether height limits will be raised, to permit new taller buildings (12-story buildings, in fact) that are basically twice as high as what current General Plan and Zoning designations will permit.

Those who drafted and circulated the petition have succeeded in putting Measure M on the ballot for a “vote.” A “YES” vote will put the citizens of the City in control over proposed General Plan and Zoning Code provisions that could allow developers to double the height of new development in the South of Laurel area – or perhaps, later on, in the city’s residential neighborhoods. If Measure M passes, it will be because of a democratic vote of the people.

But Measure M involves more than a democratic vote. Thousands of Santa Cruz City residents got personally involved in government and politics, and put Measure M on the ballot. Skeptics, by the way, said “it couldn’t be done.” But Measure M is on the ballot because self-government is still alive and well in the City of Santa Cruz.

Real self-government in the City of Santa Cruz: that is what Measure M represents. Click that link to visit the campaign website. Isn’t genuine self-government what we local residents should be working for? I signed the ballot argument urging a “YES” vote on Measure M. You can get engaged, right now, in the campaign. Click this link to visit the campaign website. Tell your friends and neighbors what you think. Put up a “YES on M” sign. Contact the Measure M campaign. Make a campaign contribution.

Put ordinary people back in charge!

To Subscribe Just Click This Link

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

GOBSMACKED BY QUID PRO QUO AND THE HAIRDRESSER

Ginny Hogan, author of ‘I’m More Dateable than a Plate of Refried Beans,’ writes in her The New Yorker essay, “We don’t even let the person with the most votes win the actual presidential election, so why would a poll matter?” She doesn’t trust polls because Trump is up and then Biden is up, with poll numbers shifting constantly, and if ABC knows something CNN doesn’t, then shouldn’t they share? She says she once conducted her own poll, asking three close friends if she should have her hairdresser give her bangs…even though she has a square face. Even the stylist thought it a bad idea but she trusted polling results of her friends. Of political polls she feels that if the results of an election are predicted in the poll, why should she vote? It’s a waste of her time, and if Taylor Swift isn’t included, why is it a ‘representative poll?’ Why are ‘only‘ five thousand people sampled when more than five thousand vote in the election? So, she doesn’t trust polls, and since her hair was already thin, why did she waste having some hang over her face? Plus, her husband left her…after two years, but it had to be related to the bangs. And, if pollsters are smart enough to predict the future, why are they working in politics…shouldn’t they be retired? It’s creepy enough that samples are taken from people who answer calls from unknown phone numbers. With a margin of error of five percent, polls are usually wrong…why not call it the ‘margin of correctness?’ And, why does ‘poll’ have two ‘L’s, being redundant? Ginny concludes that she is lonely, and getting bangs again may be the solution.

The Nation.weekly says, “The biggest mistake that politicians and pundits make when they try to discern the direction of a presidential race is that they read a single poll and think it’s definitional. But ‘of the 10 most recent polls listed on Real Clear Politics, as of December 29, Biden was leading in three of them and tied in two others,” as reported by national affairs correspondent John Nichols. He maintains there is no reason to celebrate yet, “but if the incumbent continues to focus on the economy and other issues people care about right now, there’s a compelling case Biden’s polling position will improve as the 2024 race unfolds.” Cross your fingers and don’t see your hairdresser just yet!

The former prez continues to post ridiculous videos provided him via his Truth Social media platform and a recent one is certainly cringeworthy, with voiceover proclaiming: “And on June 14th, 1946, God looked down on his plan Paradise, and said, ‘I need a caretaker.’ So, God gave us Trump.” Did your knees simply give out, or did you fall into place of your own accord? Trump is claiming in his emailed fundraisers that Barack Obama admits Biden will be defeated in ’24, and is therefore stepping up to sabotage the GOP by urging Democrats to register as Republicans so they can cast votes for a RINO who will “get eaten alive by the Democrat Deep State.” However, it seems that any heads-up RINOs have long ago registered as Democrats or Independents.

Trump’s attorney, Alina Habba, on Fox’s Sean Hannity show, discussing the banning of the former prez’s name from ballots in Maine and Colorado, actually said it out loud: “I think it should be a slam dunk in the Supreme Court. I have faith in them. You know people like Kavanaugh – who the president fought for, who the president went through hell to get into place – he’ll step up. Those people will step up. Not because they’re pro-Trump, but because they’re pro-law. Because they’re pro-fairness, and the law on this is very clear.” So, there you have it – the quid pro quo. Alina wants everyone to also be aware that her attractiveness is of utmost importance…she can “fake being smart.” On the PBD Podcast hosted by Bryan Cullen, she said, “I don’t think I’d be on TV or sitting here if I didn’t look the way I look. It doesn’t hurt to be good looking.” Cullen commented on why an ‘alpha male’ like Trump would pick her for his $250M fraud case, saying, “He picks a smart, feminine, capable woman.” Habba readily agreed with, “Right.” Xwitter responses were quick to jump into the discussion. “Legally Bland,” said Anthony LoPresti“Sound legal strategy from Trump,” replied @PatriotTakesClay Moser advised Habba to “…start at least faking she’s smart.” And, Chris Herbst paraphrased an old chestnut, “Basically, I’m not a good lawyer, but I play one on TV.” Unknown is whether she likes beer…leave that to Kavanaugh to determine. Clay Bennett’s cartoon depicting a Decision 2024 voting ballot with check boxes for ‘Trump‘ and ‘Or Else‘ seems appropriate here.

Another cartoon worth a mention is one in The Economist portraying the GOP/MAGA elephant presenting Trump with a congratulatory third anniversary Insurrection cake, and asking if he cares to share any thoughts. His reply: “Practice makes perfect.” A Marjorie Taylor Greene book-signing/meet-and-greet planned to take place at The Westgate Resorts in Kissimmee, Florida was cancelled by the resort management when it was found that the event was in reality a commemoration of the third anniversary of the J6 Insurrection. The local Republicans had scheduled it as a book-signing, but the ownership got wind of the intent and simply pulled the plug on it, saying, “Please be advised that Westgate was not made aware of the purpose of this event…[it is] being cancelled and is no longer taking place at our resort.” The Greene camp had no comment, after NBC obtained an invitation billing the happening as an ‘exclusive’ commemoration of the J6 riot, with tickets costing attendees between $45 and $1,000. Democratic state Representative Anna Eskamani deadpanned, “Just another day in Florida. Was really hoping this was a joke when I first saw it.”

Activist and film maker, Michael Moore as well as others, propose that we get involved in promoting commemoration of January 6 as a national holiday, calling it ‘Democracy Day.’ Otherwise, that date is going to be taken over by the MAGA crowd as ‘Saint Donald Trump Day,’ when we will hear nothing but lies, slander, name calling, and whining about a stolen election…and who knows if the Confederate flag will make also make another appearance in the halls of the Capitol building? Plus the resurrection of the Mike Pence Commemorative Gallows? Michael feels this is a day in infamy when we almost lost our democracy, that it should never be forgotten, passing it down to future generations to renew our commitment to liberty, freedom, equality and solidarity. He says, “The Vote is precious, a necessity to create and fulfill the promise of a democracy – and why we must always defend it against any and all enemies, foreign and domestic. Especially domestic!” We should all agree with him, that we are worth it.

Ron DeSantis and Nikki Haley are increasing their attacks on Trump in the countdown to the GOP caucuses in Iowa, vying for a distant second place behind Toupee Orange and paying less attention to each other. Their hesitancy to go after Trump in their campaigns, beyond criticism for being a no-show at debates, seems faint-hearted at this late date. DeSantis has jumped on Trump for being a flip-flopper, and not following through with promises, and that he carries too much baggage to be a winner. Haley has repeated that Trump was the “right president at the right time, but chaos follows him. And we can’t have a country in disarray and a world on fire and go through four more years of chaos. We won’t survive it.” She feels she is the strongest candidate to face Biden, that the country doesn’t need “another nail-biter of an election” as polls now indicate for a Trump/Biden matchup. Neither candidate has been critical of Trump’s conduct relating to his four indictments, only noting that the charges could bite him in the general election…weeks too late?

Observers believe DeSantis sees Iowa as his last stand, as he has shifted staff to Iowa and increased spending, going all-in for the state. Republican strategist, Ron Bonjean, asks, “Where was this focus months ago? In order to get noticed you’ve got to take on the front-runner, and you’ve got to do it progressively.”  He claims former New Jersey Governor Christie’s approach turned off many GOP primary voters, a backfire from focusing too much at once. Republican strategist, Brian Seitchik says the attacks by Haley and DeSantis are “too little, too late. Trump-lite won’t work…if you want to be king, you’ve got to beat the king.” Seitchik says if Haley can claim second in Iowa and win New Hampshire“We have a legitimate race.”  Waiting for Trump to implode hasn’t happened, therefore the strategy of avoiding confrontation of Trump was impractical. “If the strategy is playing for 2028, or playing for VP, or playing for a Cabinet position, that’s understandable, but if you got into this race 12 months ago with the intention of winning, you had to go after Trump,” Seitchik maintains.

Bocha Blue, in his The Palmer Report post says, “The Clueless Haley, from the beginning had no chance. The only reason for the attention is because the media love a good horse-race, and let’s face it, there ARE NOT good quality Republican candidates to prop up. They tried Ron DeSantis and we saw how that turned out, so let’s try Haley. That move precipitated the deer-in-the-headlights moment when asked about the Civil War.” So what does she do, trying to do damage control over several days? She went T-H-E-R-E! She says to Erin Burnett“I had Black friends growing up.” Xwitter exploded with: “Is she trying to lose?”“Girlfriend, you have truly hit rock bottom.”“Hot damn, she’s a fool.” Blue asks, “Is she subconsciously sabotaging herself, or is she really that clueless?”

Aldous J. Pennyfarthing says, “Vultures have been circling the Florida governor’s purpling presidential corpse for some time now, and for good reason. He’s had trouble connecting with voters, looking like he learned to smile by watching circus chimpanzees getting their backs waxed. He has the charisma of a falafel and none of the spice. His laugh sounds like a 99¢ ringtone with a corrupted file. His top opponent is Donald Trump, an alleged criminal, and that’s a tough hill for any challenger.” The DeSantis campaign and super PAC have spent more than $160M, and spent the better part of 2023 on the road. But, he now says, it may not have been enough to overcome the advantage he believes Trump received from getting indicted four times. “If I could have one thing changed, I wish Trump hadn’t been indicted on any of this stuff. It sucked out a lot of oxygen,” DeSantis told the Christian Broadcasting Network. One DeSantis supporter and donor felt the race was over after the first Trump indictment. Because Republican voters aren’t the most discerning, the perception that he is being unfairly persecuted is a badge of honor for him, rather than a vulnerability which is where DeSantis should have gone, rather than attack Hunter Biden with his fake outrage…duh! So DeSantis was carrying Trump’s water when he should have been waterboarding him the whole time.

Former Florida congressman, David Jolly, says of DeSantis“He started the primary on third base, then stole second. We’ve now witnessed one of the most expensive and embarrassing collapses in Republican history.” Trying to out-Trump Trump was a fatal strategic choice, since he was polling better before he began his campaign…then the voters saw him as he really is. “The idea of a DeSantis was appealing, but the reality of the DeSantis was repellant, “ says Mac Stipanovich, a Florida politics veteran, to HuffPost. “It is telling that his favorite president is Calvin Coolidge, the avatar of anti-charisma in politics.” The Heritage Foundation said of the Republican National Convention of 1924, “It’s generally remembered as the most uninteresting convention in Republican history. Delegates didn’t bother showing up at many of the sessions. The most popular drink was a Keep-Cool-With-Coolidge highball, composed of raw eggs and fruit juice. Will Rogers suggested that the city of Cleveland ‘open up the churches to liven things up a bit.'” But this is a reminder that politics, in the end, is not about drama but about principle, not about charisma but about character. All this was said BEFORE Coolidge was described as ‘the most articulate conservative who ever served as president.’

As for DeSantisSteve Duprey, a former Republican National Committee member told HuffPost“When you come across as a mean person who shows little empathy for the real concerns for citizens, and who always wants to make sure everyone in the room knows you think you are the smartest person there, it doesn’t go over all that well. Focusing on Disney, wokeness, a little hippie college in Sarasota, and an abortion ban out of sync with most of America, instead of the economy, the debt, the border, isn’t a winning formula…other than that, he’s nailing it.” Another anonymous Florida Republican offered, “Who was he? Was he for Trump? Was he against Trump? Was he courting Trump voters? Is he more practical, sensible? Or is he a right-wing nut? I don’t know. But he’s just not likable.” DeSantis’ ‘Make America Florida’ project as a model of right-wing governance was only destined to flame out, never translating to the campaign trail, where he was forced to interact with real people with real concerns. “To me he never looked happy,” an Iowa political operative said. So the biggest obstacle for DeSantis was himself. Pennyfarthing concludes, “Sadly, for Floridians, once he ends his campaign for the White House, he will go back to Florida.”

Perhaps poor Ron can take some solace from this Ariel Elias haiku:

I’ve said it before.
And I will say it again.
I’ve said it before.

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down. 

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

    “January”

“Feeling a little blue in January is normal.”
~Marilu Henner

“Nothing burns like the cold.”
~George R.R. Martin

“Through the chill of December the early winter moans…but it’s that January wind that rattles old bones.”
~John Facenda

...

I’ve seen a couple of documentaries about the FLDS and Warren Jeffs. This is more intimate, we are being guided around the town by a former FLDS member. He is articulate and pleasant, and very good at explaining all the goings on. It’s definitely worth a watch. Also, check out the channel – this guy interviews a lot of fascinating people.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
82 Blackburn Street, Suite 216
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Direct email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Direct phone: 831 423-2468
Cell phone: 831 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...