February 5 – 11, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… is out for a bit, but she will be back… Steinbruner… Downtown Expansion Plan Intel, Battery Storage Updates, Good Job on Water Projects… Hayes… The importance of cows… Patton… Have we lost faith? Failed?… Matlock… will to live…hold your breath…free cake… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… English words left behind by the Vikings… Quotes on… “Football”

...

CHUCK ABBOTT & FRIENDS PLANTING A TREE, June 3, 1965. I have no idea who the other folks in this photo are. But it’s Chuck Abbott caring how “his downtown” looks by planting a tree in the front yard of his Lincoln street home. The tree is still there. Chuck and his wife did more for beautifying our community than anyone I can think of.

photo credit: Bruce Bratton‘s photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: February 5, 2025

FOOTBALL. Being Swedish, to me, football is a game played with your feet, kicking a ball across a giant field and into a goal, trying your best to not be stopped by opposing team members. I’ve never understood American Football. It has always seemed like a lot of “hurry up and wait”. People here sure love it though! Happy Superbowl, to all of you who observe… See you on the other side!

...

THE BREAKTHROUGH. Netflix. Series (7.1 IMDb) **- Thanks to Netflix’s voracious appetite for new material, we’ve had a lot of opportunity to watch movies and tv from all over the place. I’ve been noticing an alarming number of bleak crime dramas from Sweden – one of them was “The Breakthrough”, a police procedural based on a real-life 16 year murder investigation. Though the first 3 episodes were a trifle slow, the final episode finally brings it all together. Peter Eggers stars as a police detective who does a LOT of speedwalking while beating his heart out against an impossible case. ~Sarge

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

...

Gillian is taking a break, but she’ll be back!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
SPEAK UP ABOUT WHAT SANTA CRUZ CITY DOWNTOWN EXPANSION PLAN COULD MEAN TO YOU

Listen in Friday, February 7 at 3pm when longtime local activists Frank Barron and Rick Longinotti discuss as Guests on “Community Matters” what they have found tucked away (or absent from) in the Santa Cruz City Downtown Expansion Plan Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR).

If you haven’t yet heard of this massive development in the Laurel Street area, here is the summary from CEQANet:

Present Land Use
Regional Visitor Serving/ Downtown Subdistrict E, Residential High Density/ Residential-Tourist Commercial

Document Description
The proposed project consists of a series of amendments to the City’s Downtown Plan by extending the boundary of the existing Downtown Plan to incorporate the approximate 29-acre project study area and incorporate policies, development standards and design guidelines for the study area in the City’s Downtown Plan (amended January 28, 2020) that will facilitate future redevelopment of the project area. The project also includes amendments to the City’s General Plan 2030. the Local Coastal Program (LCP). the Beach and South of Laurel Comprehensive Area Plan, and the Municipal Code to provide updates consistent with the proposed Downtown Plan amendments, including General Plan/LCP land use designation and zone district changes for parcels within the project area. The proposed Downtown Plan amendments could facilitate additional development as a result of various circulation. land use and infrastructure revisions. For purposes of environmental review, the project area could potentially accommodate a minimum of 1,800 housing units, 60,000 square feet (sf) of gross commercial area, and construction of a new approximately 180,000 sf permanent sports and entertainment arena for the Santa Cruz Warriors basketball team to replace the existing temporary arena. The arena would contain a main event court with spectator seating for approximately 3,200 seats for basketball, and approximately 4,000 seats for concerts and other performances or uses.

Santa Cruz Downtown Plan Expansion 2022090276 – 2025-01-07 – EIR

Comments on the DEIR must be submitted in writing or via email to Sarah Neuse by 5pm Friday, February 21, 2025.Public Review Period: January 8, 2025 through February 21, 2025.

Submit Comments to: Sarah Neuse, Senior Planner, via email: sneuse@santacruzca.gov 

Public Comment is open now until February 21….take a look at the map here and just read one section of the DEIR that most interests you…and write one letter.

Downtown Plan Expansion | City of Santa Cruz
Project page for the expansion of Santa Cruz’s Downtown Plan into the neighborhoods south of Laurel Street.

What will this massive development  affect  traffic, water, and the quality of downtown Santa Cruz?  Listen in from your computer or smart device from anywhere in the world at 3pm Pacific Time Santa Cruz Voice – Listen and Be Heard

Join the conversation by phoning 831-265-5050.  Listen to the recorded program from the Santa Cruz Voice.com website under “Current Shows” at the bottom of the page, under “Community Matters”.

NEVER AGAIN MOSS LANDING.
Please link arms with this fast-growing grassroots group to learn more about what has happened following the disaster at Moss Landing Vistra Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facility.  Never Again Moss Landing

When no government agency was stepping up to sample for metal contamination from the fire, this group dug into their own pockets to fund $7,000 in expert testing of more than 140 samples taken from a wide area to  gather information.

Please support them in whatever way you can and consider joining their informational outdoor rally this Saturday:

COMMUNITY MEMBERS WILL ASSEMBLE AND ADDRESS THE VISTRA MOSS LANDING BESS FACILITY FAILURE AND FIRE.

On Saturday, February 8th at 12:30pm PST, community members will assemble and speak in the parking area to the rear of the Whole Enchilada Restaurant in Moss Landing, CA. 7904 CA-1, Moss Landing, CA 95039. Space is reserved for members of the media.

This is a citizen-organized event that will highlight impacts upon the surrounding community and actions being taken to address citizen concerns. Several speakers will present their observations and findings.

Briefing:

  1. “Never Again Moss Landing” is a Fast-response grass-roots all-volunteer resident group which advocates for our community’s voice and interests in response to the Moss Landing BESS Fire. We believe that a disaster like this must never again occur. We coordinate local citizen efforts to organize and deploy facts that can restore our community’s environment, health, and welfare. We are not affiliated with any other governmental, business, or advocacy groups. Our website is NeverAgainMossLanding.org. Queries: info@neveragainmosslanding.org.
  2. Our two Facebooks Groups were created in the immediate aftermath of the January 16th fire: 
    a. Moss Landing Power Plant/Vistra Fire Symptoms 
    b.  Moss Landing Battery Plant Environmental Disaster Community Group

  3. With over 4700 members there are thousands of individual entries at these two sites detailing personal medical impacts, anger at Vistra Corporation and its response, anger at the EPA and its lack of response, fires at other battery plants, impacts upon pets and livestock, fears of general contamination and environmental degradation, uncertainty about what has happened and continues to happen, and distrust of local, state and federal responses. Members of the media are kindly advised to monitor these sites which reflect widespread citizen responses to the fire and its aftermath.
  4. Founded in 2016 out of the bankrupt reorganization of Texas Competitive Electric Holdings (TCEH), Vistra Corporation (VST) is a retail electricity and power generation company headquartered in Texas with a current market capitalization of over $57B. It has traded between $137 and $191 in the past month and closed at $168 a share on January 31st. The company is the largest competitive power generator in the U.S. with a capacity of approximately 39,000 megawatts powered by a diverse portfolio that includes natural gas, nuclear, solar, and battery energy storage facilities. It was ranked the No. 1 polluter in the United States for the 2024 Greenhouse 100 Polluters Index Report, producing 1.5% of all greenhouse gas emissions generated in the United States of America. Vistra opened the Moss Landing BESS facility in June 2021. There were two emergency mishaps reported at their facility prior to the 1.17.24 fire. The CPUC has granted Vistra a 20-year permit to operate at this location.
  5. The outcomes sought from this event include:

    a. The Moss Landing/Vistra BESS plant fire must be recognized as an unprecedented and extraordinary disaster for the Monterey Bay region and its residents. This fundamental reality must be shared and clarified locally, nationally, and internationally so that communities understand the scope and seriousness of this environmental and health crisis and its causes.

    b. Legal, administrative, and oversight requirements must be identified and enacted so that a fire will never again occur at the Moss Landing BESS. The required facility standards for regulation and operation must be greatly strengthened. This facility must not be allowed to reopen until the community is satisfied that these requirements have been met.

    c. Local elected officials and our community’s health, educational, and environmental departments need to provide transparency and immediate guidance to residents, businesses, medical and animal welfare facilities, and academic and educational organizations regarding testing protocols and treatment for the ongoing widespread and documented health issues related to this emergency. We are looking for guidance and information from the CA Dept. of Health, the CPUC, and our state elected officials. It is our view that such transparency and guidance have been woefully absent to date.

    d. The EPA, FEMA, Dept. or the Interior, and NOAA need to immediately send personnel to measure and monitor air, soil, and water quality in the greater Monterey Bay Area.

    e. In addition to immediate assessment and testing of impacts upon human, animal, and environmental health, long-term testing of our region must be developed and instituted. The effects of exposure to heavy metals and other toxic chemicals emanated from the burning of lithium batteries is unknown. Vistra must pay for these expenses which would be implemented and administered by government agencies, our educational institutions, and/or independent third parties.

    f. Vistra must immediately be required to release its testing, monitoring, and remediation data including that of third party providers engaged by Vistra. The plant cannot reopen without such full and ongoing disclosures.

    g. Dozens of large environmental, medical, corporate, agricultural, and community-action organizations are present in our community. These groups need to coordinate and collaborate their efforts in response to this disaster. Local government can play an important role in coordinating such efforts.

    h. Finally, the media as representatives of the public, need to demand answers from Vistra to the many unanswered questions about how this disaster happened. Accountability cannot be replaced by complacency or uncritical acceptance of information being provided by Vistra and the Public Relations company FTI consulting (SC) Inc.

    Never Again Moss Landing is a locally created, citizen-led, all-volunteer group facilitating community awareness and response to the Moss Landing/Vistra BESS plant fire.

STATUS OF WATSONVILLE BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM (BESS) IS FURTHER ALONG THAN LEAD TO BELIEVE
On October 29, 2024, Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors approve in concept three sites in the County to locate Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) facilities.  Little did we know that New Leaf Energy and Swift Consulting was circling the Planning Dept., and soon after filed an application for a BESS at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.

This week, I spent quite alot of time researching the proposed Seahawk BESS project and other types of battery technology that would be much safer than lithium.
Here is what I have learned:

Sodium battery technology is much safer, cleaner and environmentally and socially-responsible.

The project at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville is much further down the road to approval than has been made public:

  1. New Leaf Energy did not purchase the land (37-acres).  It remains in a Heritage Trust under Steven K. Dobler, following the death of farmer John Lukrich.
  2. County Assessor data base information shows five residences on the property, one dating to 1929, yet these are not listed in the Hazardous Assessment Report filed with the Plan.
  3. Plans submitted December 17, 2024 by Swift Consulting on behalf of New Leaf Energy do not include any information about the required public meeting that was required to be held before filing the application.  This meeting was indeed held on December 12, 2024 but it is unknown who received the mailed notice postcard that failed to provide any time of day the meeting was being held at Amesti School.
  4. Plans submitted show at least 136 battery storage units, each with only 10′ separation from the next.
  5. In April, 2024, DK Engineering developed the Boundary & Topographic Survey for the site for New Leaf Energy.
  6. In July, 2024, Dudek Consultants completed a Wetland Stream and Delineation Report for the project.
  7. On November 6, 2024, County Planner Matt Johnston approved a stand alone biotic report for the project.
  8. On November 6, 2024, County Planner Sydney Niiyama approved a stand alone archeological Report Review for the project.
  9. On November 6, 2024, County Geologist Craig Stewart approved a stand alone Geological Hazard Assessment for the project.
  10. On December 10,, 2024, C2G Civil Consultants in Scotts Valley, CA developed a Stormwater Control Plan for the proposed project.
  11. On December 12, 2024, Swift Consulting filed the project application that included: Health Risk Analysis (which only addresses diesel particulate air quality during construction), Fire Emergency Response Plan, Hazardous Consequences Analysis, Noise Study, and Decommissioning Estimate.  There is NO Neighborhood Meeting Results report.
  12. Nearby residences on the adjacent downwind parcel will be vacated until the BESS facility is decommissioned in 2050. These two residences (Gomez” and a barn are shown as nearby receptors (285′ and 300′ away), as is the Pajaro Valley Unified School District bus sheds and offices at the end of Grimmer Lane (1,220′ away from the proposed project.
  13. NONE of the adjacent dense residential subdivisions or Shapiro Knolls affordable housing complex is even mentioned, but are actually closer to the proposed BESS than the Grimmer address.
  14. The proposed project Plan shows a 12′-14′ high noise wall on the side of the project facing College Lake, but does not include any noise wall for the north side of the project that faces dense residential subdivisions.  That area of the proposed project would have a 7′ tall chainlink fence with vegetative landscaping that includes Incense Cedar trees on one page, and Douglas Fir trees on another version of the plan.  The landscape plan was developed by Dudek’s office in Portland, OR.
  15. New Leaf Energy has a local office in Oakland, CA.
  16. Sequoia Energy Storage LLC is also listed as parties to the project, with the address in Oakland CA  946112, however the principle Mr. Max Christian has the address in Lowell, MA.
  17. All of the proposed BESS project area is within an existing production orchard, and encompasses two parcels: 05110177 and 05110178, and are zoned for agriculture.  The Plan requires significant cut and fill grading. The County must re-zone the land and the County Agricultural Policy Advisory Commission (APAC) must approve taking the land out of agricultural production as well as the required 1:1 conservation agreement inherent.
    [NOTE: The APAC was schedule to meet on February 20 but Planner Sheila McDaniel just informed me that “The meeting was canceled this morning due to a lack of items for consideration.  The support staff should post a meeting cancellation online shortly.”]

  18. The proposed project Plan indicates the Zayante-Vergeles Fault is nearby;
  19. The proposed project Plan inaccurately lists Central Fire District jurisdiction when in fact, the project is within Pajaro Valley Fire District (Maybe that explains why Pajaro Valley Fire did not receive notice of the December 12, 2024 public meeting.)
  20. The proposed project Plan includes only a 10,000 gallon water storage tank on site.
  21. The project would be unmanned, with a note that cancer is likely over the course of the project for any personnel visiting the site long-term, and would rely on SCADA radio information to relay indications of storage cell venting (the initial stage of battery failure) and smoke detection. Therefore, pg. 322 states the “Health Risk is less than significant, and the chronic hazard index is less than significant.”  It is unknown where the information would be received, and how quickly staff could respond, and how nearby populations in adjacent subdivisions downwind would be affected.
  22. Chemicals listed in the Plan do not include HF gas, which is typical in lithium fires and is extremely hazardous to health and the environment.  The analysis only lists hydrogen gas as a byproduct of refrigerant that would be used, and includes a warning that all fire fighter personnel should stay 100′ from the trouble battery container doors.

I spoke with the Project’s Planner, Mr. Evan Ditmars.  He is aware that New Leaf Energy did not specify any time on the post cards mailed to what seems to be a very small list to notice the one required meeting before filing the application,  and did not seem bothered.  He assured me there will be many opportunities for public input because the project very likely will require a full Environmental Impact Report (EIR).

Somehow, I just don’t trust that.

Please contact your County Supervisor, and demand a moratorium on lithium battery energy storage systems until there is a more restrictive Ordinance for our County on this issue, and demand a technical advisory committee be formed that will develop this Ordinance…not the New Leaf Energy CEO or Carlos Palacios, the County Administrative Officer who sits on the Operations Board of Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) and depends on BESS facilities to fulfill the company mission. (Former County Supervisor Bruce McPherson sits on the Policy Board) Governing Boards – Central Coast Community Energy

EXECUTIVE ORDER FOR GROUNDWATER RECHARGE APPLIES ONLY TO 39 COUNTIES
Last week, Governor Newsom relaxed flood measures that allow groundwater recharge without less regulation in place.  This does not include Santa Cruz County.

The Executive Order suspends the need for a local or regional agency to determine the imminent risk of flooding based off of local planning documents. While few regional or local agencies have established the specified types of planning documents, local or regional agencies are able to determine the presence of flood conditions by other means. The Executive Order allows local and regional agencies to use readily available information and expertise to determine imminent risk. Local and regional agencies continue to be required to issue a public notification that flows are at imminent risk of flooding and inundation of lands, roads or structures.

Technical Guidance Water Code 1242.1 – Flood Diversions for Groundwater Recharge

Wouldn’t it make sense to allow fallow agricultural land to flood with stormwater when it is plentiful and thereby recharge the local aquifers?  Dr. Helen Dahlke at UC Davis has been working on this, upon farmers doing it themselves to raise ag well levels.
Can California’s floods help recharge depleted groundwater supplies?

Take a look…why can’t we do that here in appropriate areas, instead of pumping intreated sewage water that relies on expensive chemical and energy dependent treatment (aka PureWater Soquel Project) with risk of aquifer pollution?
How to Recharge our Aquifers : Helen Dahlke

IS ANYBODY LISTENING?
On May 21, 2024 at the request of the Santa Cruz County Water Advisory Commission, Chair Justin Cummings, on behalf of the Board of Supervisors,  sent a letter to multiple state water regulatory agencies and elected officials and asked for a forensic analysis as to why the Big Basin Water Company (BBWC) management problems were not addressed until the point of a Court-ordered receivership resulted.

“As a critical partner in helping to stabilize BBWC and plan for the water and wastewater resilience of thousands of residents, Santa Cruz County sees an opportunity to draw attention to both the successes and shortcomings that have shaped the current situation.  The County requests that relevant state agencies and representatives involved in private utility oversight capture lessons-learned so they can be built upon to ensure that the hardships and uncertainties felt by BBWC customers are not repeated around the state, especially following a natural disaster.”

The letter was sent to the following, in an effort to learn how to better serve the public.  However, a Public Records Act request with the County reveals that NONE of the recipients has responded to date.

Jennifer Epp
Waste Discharge Requirements Program Manager
Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board
895 Aerovista Place, Suite 101
San Luis Obispo, CA 93401-7906

Jonathan Weininger
District Engineer, Monterey District  Division of Drinking Water
State Water Resources Control Board
1 Lower Ragsdale Drive, Building 1, Suite 120
Monterey, CA 93940

The Honorable Alice Busching Reynolds
President, California Public Utilities Commission
505 Van Ness Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94102

Why does this matter?  Because the Big Basin Water Company, a small privately-owned water company is just the tip of the iceberg.  Forced receivership and consolidation is on the horizon for others.

Please contact your County Supervisor and ask that they follow up with the officials who received the Board’s May 21, 2024 letter.  Better yet, contact the recipients yourself and discuss the issue.

MEANWHILE…LEGISLATION TO FORCE CONSOLIDATION IS MOVING ALONG
The February 5, 2025  Santa Cruz County LAFCO meeting included Item 7c, reviewing a water report from UC Berkeley and UCLA, along with this discussion and recommendation: (pages 15-39)

In order to address the ongoing challenges in advancing the State’s interest in making public water systems more resilient through consolidations, with a specific focus on disadvantaged and otherwise underserved communities, a stakeholder group was formed with representatives from the two universities, CWC, LCJA, and various LAFCOs. Attachment 2 provides a copy of a joint letter signed by the stakeholders to advance the water report’s recommendations. Specifically, the letter identifies three legislative proposals:

• Amplify MSRs Role in Communicating Community Needs
Amend California Government Code 56430 and its provisions on preparing municipal service reviews to require LAFCOs to take up these studies at noticed hearings as well as require the affected agencies to formally receive the studies at their own noticed hearing and providing confirmation of doing so back to LAFCOs.

• Expand LAFCOs ability to initiate organizations and reorganizations under certain circumstances Amend California Government Code 56375(a) and its enumeration of LAFCO initiating powers to support timely water or wastewater services consistent with community needs.

• Address Service Barriers for Mutual Water Companies and Mobile Home Parks Amend California Government Code 56036 and its definition of “special district” for LAFCO purposes to include mutual water companies. Similarly, amend California Corporations Code Section 14300 to address known gaps.

Next Steps
The stakeholder group is currently developing support documents such as a fact sheet for additional context and a first draft of the proposed bill language. Additionally, the group is searching for possible bill authors. Santa Cruz LAFCO is currently scheduling meetings with our local representatives, including but not limited to Senator John Laird, to discuss the recent water report and potential bill.”

Stay tuned and ask LAFCO to hold a long-promised and required Public Event relating to water issues.

CENTER FOR FARMWORKER FAMILIES AND PFAS IN BUENA VISTA MIGRANT CAMP
The Buena Vista Migrant Camp and adjacent Tierra Alta wells have the highest PFAS levels in the County. Farmworker reality tour

Santa Cruz County Public Library Presentations
All library talks are free and open to the public. We recommend arriving at least 10 minutes early to secure your seat.

Saturday, February 15, 3-4:15pm: Boulder Creek Branch Library
13390 W Park Ave, Boulder Creek, CA 95006

Thursday, March 13, 6:30-7:45pm: Capitola Branch Library
2005 Wharf Rd, Capitola, CA 95010

Thursday, April 24, 6:30-7:45pm: Garfield Park Branch Library
705 Woodrow Ave, Santa Cruz, CA 95060

*Date TBD*: Live Oak Annex @ Simpkins Swim Center
979 17th Ave, Santa Cruz, CA 95062

CAPITOLA WILL SPEND $4.7 MILLION TO RENOVATE JADE STREET COMMUNITY CENTER
Community Center Renovation Project Recommended Action: Staff recommends the City Council:

  1. approve the construction contract for the Capitola Community Center Renovation Project with SSB Contracting, Inc. in the amount of $4,726,000, including selected additive alternates.;
  2. authorize the Public Works Department to issue a notice to proceed upon final contract execution;
  3. approve Amendment 3 to the Professional Services Agreement with Boone Low Ratliff Architects for design consultant services for the Project in the amount of $18,320, for a total contract amount of $579,033; and
  4. adopt a resolution adopting the NEPA and CEQA determination and amending the FY 2024-25 Budget.

Exterior improvements will include replacing the building’s roof and siding, repairing or replacing rafters and concrete piers, and addressing damaged stucco walls. New windows will be added, and all existing exterior doors and windows will be replaced. A shed roof will be installed at the main entry to provide a welcoming and sheltered entrance. Inside the building, the upgrades will include the addition of a single-user accessible restroom, a new office, and a permanent divider between two meeting spaces. Existing offices, the reception area, restrooms, and the kitchen will be enhanced with new finishes throughout. Modern mechanical systems, including a new HVAC system, water heater, and electrical upgrades, will ensure the building operates efficiently.

To improve accessibility, upgrades will be made to the parking area and the paths of travel to ensure compliance with current accessibility standards. In addition to the core project, three additive alternates were included in the bid to provide flexibility based on available funding. These alternates focus on landscaping and irrigation, kitchen and acoustic upgrades, generator enhancements, audio/visual (AV) equipment, and exterior site improvements (such as electric vehicle (EV) charging stations). Although budget constraints prevent the full realization of the outdoor improvements in this phase, the project has been designed to allow for future-phased work as additional funding becomes available.

Regular Meeting of the Capitola City Council – 6 PM, January 30

PROPOSED SANTA CRUZ SEABRIGHT AND MIDTOWN BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT FEES…MAKE SURE YOU SPEAK UP!

A “No” Vote is Not Enough, California Appellate Court Holds

When it comes to assessments for business improvement districts, voting “no” is not enough to exhaust one’s administrative remedies. For a property owner to preserve the right to challenge a BID assessment, the property owner must provide the reasons for its objection to the assessment during the public hearing on the BID formation, in addition to submitting a ballot opposing the assessment, a California Appellate Court has held.

In Hill RHF Housing Partners, L.P. et al. v. City of Los Angeles, et al., businesses and property owners challenged the City’s recently formed BIDs. The BIDs were formed under the Property and Business Improvement District Law of 1994, and are authorized to fund public improvements benefiting assessed property within the BIDs through the levy of an assessment. Because the assessments would be levied on property, the City was required to comply with the requirements of Proposition 218 in addition to those in the PBID Law.

Consequently, prior to forming the BIDs, the City mailed a notice of public hearing and assessment ballot to property owners within the proposed BIDs’ boundaries. At the public hearing, affected property owners had the opportunity to state objections to the proposed BIDs, and the City was required to consider all objections or protests prior to forming the BIDs and levying the assessments. However, the petitioners did not present written or oral testimony at or prior to the hearing stating the reasons for their objections. PBID Law and Proposition 218 prohibit approval of such assessments if a majority of the ballots returned opposed formation of the BIDs and the assessments. There was no majority protest, and the BIDs were established.

The petitioners then filed a petition for writ of mandate, alleging (among other things) that the assessments’ special benefit allocation was flawed. While the trial court denied the petitions on the merits, the Second District Court of Appeal on June 29 affirmed the judgment on the threshold issue of whether the petitioners had exhausted their administrative remedies.

Parties in California must exhaust administrative remedies before resorting to the courts so that agencies have an opportunity to reach a reasoned and final conclusion on issues being contested. Exhausting administrative remedies narrows the scope of claims on judicial review, facilitates the development of a factual record, gives the agency a meaningful opportunity to apply its expertise and may even render litigation unnecessary.

Accordingly, submitting a “no” vote in the BID assessment did not exhaust administrative remedies, where the BID formation process required the City to consider all objections prior to acting on the BID formation. A “no” vote does not allow the agency to address a property owner’s grievance. Rather, objections must be “sufficiently specific so as to allow the agency the opportunity to evaluate and respond.” At minimum, property owners must submit a ballot and state the reasons for their objections at the public hearing, either verbally or in writing.

Property Owners Must Participate in Public Hearing to Challenge BID Assessments

The Eastsife/Midtown Business Improvement Development Plan came before the City Council on January 23 and the petition process to evaluate the costs is now on the move.   It is critical that you speak up about this at every opportunity, or you will not be able to challenge it in the future.

She kindly sent the information below about what residents and businesses can expect going forward. The City Council will review it January 23, along with a review of the Downtown Economic Plan. City Council AGENDA REPORT, Agenda of 01/23/2024

It appears to be scheduled as a benefit assessment and Prop. 218 vote, likely weighted so that those whose assessments would be highest will have more power at the ballot box:

IMPLEMENTATION PHASE
January 2025:
• Final MDP and Engineer’s Report upon City review
• Prepare petitions and petition packets to include Management District Plan
• Summary, PBID newsletter, official petition, and petition instructions
• City Council Study Session – Status Update

February 2025:
• Petition kick-off (allow 3 months)

April 2025:
• City Council approves Resolution of Intention and calls for public hearing;
• Assessment ballots mailed to all assessed property owners

June 2025:
• City Council public hearing, tabulate ballots (45 days later)

This sums up alot….

“Development in the pipeline and currently in construction is rapidly changing our physical environment downtown. As more than 1200 housing units are absorbed into the downtown community over the course of the next five years, we will need to regularly revisit circulation, parking use, and consumer and transportation behavior as needs in our downtown core change.”

(page 6 of the City Council agenda report)

Here is information about a Downtown PBID

Do you think this will help businesses or add just one more financial burden?

A NEW GROUP TO ADVISE ON COUNTY FIRE ISSUES
Next Tuesday , County Board of Supervisors will consider approving the process to form a new Fire Department Advisory Group that will  advise the General Services Dept. Director, Mr. Michael Beaton, for the next couple years during what is likely to be major consolidation and reorganization.

“In fulfilling these duties, the FDAG will explore alternatives to the governance structure of County Fire, with a focus on making it more effective. The FDAG will collaborate with other fire agencies and groups concerned about fire and emergency services to examine options for improving services for all who live and work in Santa Cruz County. The FDAG will operate without formal bylaws and will not be governed by the Brown Act. In accordance with Santa Cruz County Code Section 2.38.071(A)(5), alternate procedures concerning public participation, noticing of meetings, quorum requirements, minutes, and any other appropriate matters will be provided.”

See item #10:
Chapter 2.38 BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, COMMITTEES AND DEPARTMENT ADVISORY GROUPS

According to the Operating Procedures in Tuesday’s agenda packet, the new FDAG  will meet only on an as-needed basis.  FDAG meetings will not require a quorum of its membership, or any minimum attendance of members.

While some FDAG meetings will not be held publicly, the public will be able to access the FDAG meeting notice, standing agenda, and minutes for those meetings by either independently viewing them on the County Fire Department website or by requesting the materials to be sent electronically, as available.

Does this seem like open and transparent government to you?? I just don’t think this is an improvement over the former Fire Department Advisory Commission that the Board and CAO Carlos Palacios dissolved last year.  Please write your Supervisor with your thoughts, and participate in the Tuesday, February 11 meeting if you are able.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  CONTACT YOUR COUNTY SUPERVISOR ABOUT PROPOSED LITHIUM BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEM PROJECT IN WATSONVILLE…AND DEMAND A MORATORIUM.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
The Importance of Cows

Without large ungulate grazing both wildlife and plant species disappear in grasslands, including California’s coastal prairies. Domesticated cattle (Bos taurus) can be managed in such a way as to provide for those disturbances if wild ungulates have been locally extirpated, which unfortunately they have in many places. People hope that one day native ungulates can take the place of cattle, but those species are nowhere close to being successfully restored in most places. These stories are not told often enough, so many people have opinions about cattle that are unfounded and destructive. Let’s change that.

What Do Cattle Do?

I challenge the reader to compare fence lines or to walk in places with varied cattle grazing regimes. It goes best to slow down and take notes on what you see. Noticing things in nature can be exhilarating; it takes you out of your normal thoughts. Guided and focused investigations are helpful to some people in pursuing this observational state. The following are my observations, which I challenge you to confirm or question.

One Dr. Weiss has wisely proclaimed, ‘Cattle graze globally and deposit locally.’ That “global” grazing removes biomass, reducing thatch aka litter. With too little ungulate grazing, plant litter accumulates for many years, blocking sunlight from hitting the ground. This biomass accumulation can also intercept rainfall, which subsequently evaporates before it reaches the ground.  Managed correctly, cattle grazing reduces the growth of taller species, allowing short-statured plants access to sunlight. Very short grasslands are not good for often invasive slugs and snails, which devour wildflowers. Cattle prefer to eat grasses over wildflowers. In the absence of well-managed cattle grazing, a few very competitive, tall stature plants dominate to the detriment of the many shorter and lesser competitive species, especially wildflowers.

What Do Tule Elk Do?

Once upon a time, there were herds of tule elk roaming the Monterey Bay area. I visited an old cabin in Soquel once where there was a hunting trophy tule elk head from the early 1800’s, collected somewhere nearby. Studies comparing tule elk and cattle grazing at Point Reyes suggest that the two species are very comparable in their diet. One can visit tule elk easiest at Point Reyes National Seashore and at Coyote Ridge Trail in Santa Clara. At Coyote Ridge, tule elk are found alongside cattle, which are being managed to restore endangered wildlife and plants.

Touring Elkdom

In order to see how the species is affecting the landscape, I visited a population of tule elk near Limantour Beach at Point Reyes, where the species has long been allowed to roam freely. There is no cattle grazing in the coastal prairies there- tule elk are the only large ungulate at that location. Evidence of the grassland stewardship role of elk was scant: only a few patches were grazed to an appreciable level, so species requiring more grazing disturbance were absent. There aren’t enough elk, or the elk that are there are not concentrated in grasslands enough, to create short stature habitat supporting annual wildflowers. Unlike in cattle-grazed areas of the park, there were no patches of the rare San Francisco owl’s clover or Point Reyes Horkelia and no stands of native violets to support the endangered Point Reyes silverspot butterfly. It seemed to me that coastal prairies at that location were fast disappearing – shrubs like coyote bush were well established and proliferating, and the patches of grassy areas were few and small.

I next explored areas of marsh and dense coastal scrub to see how tule elk were impacting these other habitats. The large marsh that backs up behind the dunes at Limantour beach, at the outlet of a few creeks including Glenbrook Creek, is rife with elk trails. Environmentalists have long proclaimed concern about cattle interactions with wetlands and riparian areas, so much so that miles and miles of fencing has been established to protect those habitats in California. However, I noticed that the trails elk were using through the marsh created habitat complexity, creating patches of deeper, open water that might be conducive to certain sun-loving aquatic species like the rare California red-legged frog.

In the dense scrubby patches, tule elk had roughly bulldozed into shrubs, breaking branches and creating trails in areas that had been otherwise unpassable to larger mammals. I saw grasses and wildflowers establishing along those trails and wondered if coyotes, bobcats, mountain lions and more were using those pathways as well to hunt.

Cattle Management

Aren’t cattle unnatural? That’s a question posed by those doubting the role of cattle on conservation lands. The few that recognize the role of grazing at maintaining coastal prairies are mainly comfortable only if this is done my native species…tule elk. Very, very few people appreciate the need to manage cattle grazing to mimic the natural disturbances requisite for ecological restoration and conservation. Those that do have that appreciation know too little about what ‘management’ means.

Managing cattle requires articulating goals, prescribing a grazing regime, monitoring, and adapting management in response to monitoring data. I have heard such unrealistic goals as ‘increase all native grasses’ or ‘decrease all exotic species’ or ‘restore to 80% cover of native species’ or ‘create dense native grasses with healthy populations of native annual wildflowers.’ There are 300 species of native grasses in California; at any site in our region there might be 10. Each native grass species, each exotic species, has a particular life history that responds differently to cattle grazing: we need more specific goals to inform management. Every footprint you make in coastal prairie, even the best examples remaining of that habitat, comes to rest on 80% cover of non native species. We may never return to 80% cover of native species, but if we do it will undoubtedly be of a handful of tall, very competitive grasses rather than a diverse assemblage. To paraphrase the esteemed R. Morgan, grasses aren’t the answer, they are the problem. Even native grasses outcompete native wildflowers.

Cattle grazing regimes are complex to proscribe, but let’s see how that works. Another quote is in order, from Deb Hillyard: “Saying ‘grazing’ is like saying ‘weather.’ You wouldn’t say ‘weather is good.'” These things need some qualification. Grazing regimes alter the number of animals, the breed of cattle (weight, behavior), the ‘class’ of animal (bulls, newborns, heifers, stockers, etc), how long a herd is in what size of pasture, how often they return to that pasture, how long of an interval of ‘rest’ between grazing incidents, how much they move around the pasture, and where water and supplemental food is placed in the pasture (etc). All of those things can drastically affect how the coastal prairie responds. Next time you encounter cattle, see how many of those qualifications you can remember and see if there are clues to help define them.

If we learn to be literate in tule elk…in cattle…in coastal prairie stewardship…we will be a step closer to restoring ourselves alongside this beautiful and diverse landscape.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

The above picture accompanied an opinion column that appeared in the San Jose Mercury News on Sunday, February 2, 2025. The column was authored by Jeff Smith, who is described as “a lawyer and medical doctor.” We are also informed that Smith retired in 2023, after serving for fourteen years as County Executive of Santa Clara County.

The title on Smith’s column was this: “Empire In Decline: Americans Have Lost Faith In United System Of Governance.” That is a serious assertion. I have reproduced the entirety of the column at the bottom of this blog post, so those reading this blog posting can truly appreciate the implications of what Smith is claiming.

Do let me say that Smith makes no assertion that the picture above should be seen as a group portrait of people who are gathered together in some governmental building to assert their loss of faith in our government. In fact, while the photo is not identified, it appears to me to be a picture of the United States House of Representatives – and maybe Senators are present, too.

I was, I must say, stunned by Smith’s column in The Mercury News. It was Smith’s use of the “past tense” that got me! While Smith holds out a “riduculously small” amount of “hope” for our nation, that smidgen of hope that Smith says we have is absolutely inconsistent with his use of the past tense.

If we have “lost” faith (past tense) and if our system of government has truly “failed” (past tense), then our opportunity to have the kind of government that Smith wants us to have (and that we all want to have) is no longer an option.

Smith either (1) doesn’t really believe that the past tense is being correctly applied in his column (and is using the past tense, presumably, for rhetorical purposes); or (2) Smith is simply unable or unwilling to face the implications of his own analysis. If our system of government has truly “failed,” as he asserts, then the efforts that began in 1776 are now complete. The final report is in, and we have definitively “failed” to establish and sustain a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people,” which is how President Abraham Lincoln described what our government was all about. Indeed, Smith claims that our nation “failed” a long time ago.

Looking at the news reported in the same edition of the newspaper in which Smith’s column ran, it is pretty clear to me that those who have taken control of the Executive Branch of our government, thanks to the election of Donald Trump to the presidency, are acting like the “we failed” analysis is the correct one. As I say, this is really a serious issue – and stipulating to the “we failed” analysis means it’s “Game Over” for self-government in the United States of America.

Before saying more about our alleged “failure,” let me move on to the “lost faith” assertion. Smith asserts that it is a “fact” that the American people, collectively, no longer have any faith that we have a government that is, to repeat Lincoln’s wonderful phrasing, “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” In fact, Smith claims that no one believes that such a government is even possible.

You can check back to my recent blog posting featuring the music of Leonard Cohen, in which his lyrics proclaim that “everybody knows that the fight is fixed; the poor stay poor and the rich get rich.” Smith absolutely agrees with these lyrics, and he doesn’t suggest that we could ever sing a different song. “Everybody knows. That just how it goes.”

Smith uses a strange phrase in making his argument that our government experiment has “failed,” and that we have “lost faith” in the idea that democratic self-government is even possible. Smith claims that this “failure” and “loss of faith” diagnosis is correct because we do not have a “united system of governance.” That’s the strange phrase I am talking about. What does Smith mean by a “united system of governance”? As I read his column, he seems to mean that we don’t have a situation in which everyone agrees that rich White males and other wealthy people should  relinquish some of their wealth, power and privilege to benefit society as a whole. “That is not going to happen,” Smith states.

Well, to use a technical term: DUH!

Since when have we ever thought that our system of government was based on consensus, on the idea that everyone will be “united” in agreement? In fact, our politics and government is based on the opposite idea, and on the recognition that people profoundly disagree on just about everything. Our system is supposed to get those who disagree to make decisions that a majority can “accept.” That happens only when those who are dissatisfied with the current situation build their political power. (Hint: you have to get personally engaged if you want that to happen). Given that Smith appears to think that we must have a “united” government, in which people would agree on what he says they will never agree on, it is hard to understand where Smith thinks that “ridiculously small” window of opportunity might come from. If Smith is right about needing a “united” system of governance, you can board over that window of opportunity right now.

Let’s think about how radical Smith’s claims actually are. Smith is basically saying that what most people call “democracy” has “failed” in the United States (not that it is “imperiled,” or “in danger,” but that it has “failed,” and that we have, moreover, “lost faith” that it can ever be restored (although Smith does note that “revolution” may be an available option, which doesn’t sound too attractive to me, if he means that I should find a gun and start killing those rich people with whom I am in disagreement).

When impossibilty is the premise – which is exactly the case with Smith – nothing can be done. If Smith is speaking as a “spectator,” then his predictions of failure may be correct, but when he opines that all of our possibilities are in “the past,” and when he talks like “it’s all over,” then we know that he has missed the truth of our real situation.

In reality, we are facing real, and dangerous, and daunting obstacles to creating the kind of society and government we’d like to make work for “we, the people.” That’s true. That’s the “present tense.” As for the future, our actions now will determine how the future turns out.

Would you like to sit around and feel defeated? Read Jeff Smith!

Would you like to do something about what you don’t like, and what needs to be changed? That requires action – and there isn’t going to be any action, or any “resistance,” if we have truly “lost faith” and stipulate to the fact that we have “failed” in the never-ending challenge of self-government!

Find a small group of friends to support you, people whom you can support, too, and then get to work!

PS: You will have to reallocate how you use your time!

oooOOOooo

Jeff Smith: We have lost faith in our united system of governance
Bay Area leader says the ‘great American experiment in government’ has failed, and we have been in denial for years
We Americans have a huge problem that we do not want to face directly.

We have lost faith in our united system of governance. Only 64% of eligible adults voted in the 2024 presidential election and far fewer vote in gubernatorial elections. A large group of Americans do not believe it matters who is in office or what happens in government.

Even those who vote often make decisions based upon scant or misleading information. In the modern era, “alternative facts” are a shield against reality. Denial is an enormously powerful tool that allows us to avoid any individual responsibility for our situation. The kernel of truth that we do not want to face is that the failure of our nation is our fault.

The “great American experiment in government” failed long ago, and we have been in denial about that for many years.

Why did we fail? Can it be fixed? Should we just start over? I believe the answers to these questions are simple and everyone knows the truth deep down.The answer to the “why” question starts with our founding documents. What the Founding Fathers meant by “all men are created equal” and “endowed … with certain unalienable Rights,” is not what it sounds like today. To them “all men” meant rich, White male property owners — not women, not people of color, not those without property, and certainly not poor people, slaves or Indigenous people.

From the start, our country has struggled to make sense of the inherent conflict between language, practice and intent. Racism, xenophobia, misogyny and unchecked avarice are built into our society and our laws. Indeed, the history of the United States is understood best as a series of conflicts about these very issues. We failed because we have never honestly resolved these conflicts.

Should we burn it down and start a new plutocracy? The answer is also obvious.

We are doing that right now! Many powerful empires/countries have come and gone. Very few lasted more than 350 years. Essentially all failed when the disparity of wealth and opportunity among the citizens became so massive that most felt that revolution was their only practical choice.

The United States is remarkably close to that point now. In fact, we may have already passed it. The nation’s 800 billionaires hold more wealth than half the nation. Those at the bottom have been starved of the opportunity to succeed, and many of them are women, people of color, and stuck in generational poverty created by the wealthy who control government. Remembering Lincoln’s famous quote, “a house divided cannot stand.”? We are there.

Can it be “fixed”? No! Not with the current structure. Fixing the current system would require that rich, White males and others relinquish some of their wealth, power and privilege. That is not going to happen since the system protects themThe only peaceful way to change the entire system requires the participation of all citizens. The privileged class must accept the fact that their behavior is bad for everyone, including themselves.

Is there hope? Yes, but the window of opportunity for change is ridiculously small. The entire world knows that the U in USA is a fantasy. Will we admit it to ourselves and take the action necessary to honestly call ourselves united? I do not know [emphasis added].

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

UNELECTED BARNACLE, IT’S A COUP, IMPEACHMENT?

Couple of valid entries on social media last week: “They should invent a January that doesn’t drain your will to live!” Sort of fits in with some of the other mopey posts in evidence. And a perfect companion would be this: “Anyone know which wine pairs with societal collapse?” That one may be more valid when we examine what is coming to pass in DC with King Donald and the unelected co-president Elon MuskSteve Schmidt on his The Warning blog writes that the two, along with Musk’s goons, are locking government officials out of their computers, offices and buildings as they demand access to the governments payment systems, asserting powers they have no right to assert. To which Schmidt declares, “Heil Trump! King Donald has stomped and huffed and shaken things up.” One outstanding question: Has Musk taken an oath, like the federal workers he has plans to fire, to uphold the Constitution? Musk, an unelected barnacle (as Rolling Stone’s Nikki Ramirez calls him) to King Donald is now ensconced as head of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) despite lacking Congressional approval, being tasked by Trump to find ways to slash government spending, reduce bureaucracy, and do away with regulations. As Ramirez notes, DOGE has little legal authority to execute cuts, and no mandate to meddle with the Treasury, but his entanglement with the administration has him influencing every aspect of policy. According to The Washington Post, after Trump’s November victory, Musk and his thug team have been requesting access to payment systems under the Bureau of the Fiscal Service which controls distribution of more than $6 trillion in annual funds, such as Social SecurityMedicare benefits, tax refunds, and federal salaries. Now he has crashed through the doorway with complete control.

Treasury official, Mark Mazur, told The Post“This is a mechanical job, paying benefits, vendors, whatever. It’s not one where there’s a role for non-mechanical things, at least from a career standpoint — your whole job is to pay the bills as they are due. It’s never been used in a way to execute a partisan agenda. You have to really put bad intentions in place for that to be the case.” Which calls into question why Musk/DOGE are seeking access in Trump’s hard-right takeover of the government. According to Wired magazine, Musk has been able to place three close allies at the head of the Office of Personnel Management, who has sent emails to employees encouraging them to resign, offering them several months of paid leave, but as Rolling Stone reports, “While the administration is pitching the resignation offers as ‘a nice vacation,’ they could still be forced to work.” This resignation letter is quite similar to the one Musk sent to Twitter employees after he bought the social media platform — we saw how that all went down — or came down!  Musk is getting off on his newfound power, but word is circulating that Trump’s inner circle is getting frustrated with Musk’s abuses of his proximity to the president. One Trump ally said to Politico that abuse is clear, however the president has no leverage over the situation and Elon couldn’t care less. So, here we are with the world’s richest man whose companies have grown fat on US government contracts, and now he has a greater financial interest in how the government operates than your average naturalized immigrant. Rolling Stone’s Ramirez asks, “Is it a blatant conflict of interest to have the world’s richest man continue to profit off his investments while serving in a uniquely powerful and virtually unchecked role over US policy, regulation, government spending, and investment? Yes! Will Republicans do anything to stop it? Don’t hold your breath.”

Back in NovemberMusk and his then-partner in DOGEVivek Ramaswamy, laid out some of their ideas to the Wall Street Journal about their plans. First, mass firings were threatened to reduce employment by resignations to the minimum to accomplish the constitutionally permissible and statutorily mandated functions, after which Trump could suspend worker protections to enforce a “mass head-count reduction across the federal bureaucracy.” In light of recent events, how many air traffic controllers does he think might be the absolute minimum? With help from the Supreme Court they hoped to usurp new power with would allow Trump to ignore Congress and not spend money, something called impoundment. A $500B cut in spending would target items like foreign aid and public broadcasting, already evidenced by Trump’s attempt to throttle federal grants. Some targets might have merit, such as examination of federal contracting and procurement, but when Medicare becomes a subject of discussion it gets scary, despite Trump’s pledge to protect safety net spending. As Senator Ron Wyden said, “I can think of no good reason why political operators who have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the law would need access to these sensitive, mission-critical systems. Americans don’t want an unelected and unaccountable billionaire dictating what working families can and cannot afford.” Fears are heightened that Musk and Trump’s cronies are attempting to gain authoritarian control over the government by ousting or sidelining career civil servants and undermining Congress, which has the constitutional authority to decided how the government should spend its money. Representative Pramila Jayapal wrote, “Musk is rooting around in Social Security and Medicare payment systems. He’s reaching his hands into our pockets and firing anyone who tries to stop him. This reeks of corruption — it must stop.” Senator Elizabeth Warren called for this “alarming” news to be investigated by Congress.

The New York Times was told that no payments had yet been blocked and that the stated mission of DOGE is to review payments, not stop them. Musk suggested on X that he was only looking for inappropriate expenditures, but also that blocking funds might be appropriate. He went on to say that it was discovered that payment approval officers at Treasury were instructed always to approve payments — they literally never denied a payment in their entire career. Former Treasury officials told the Times that funds are dispersed by a comparatively small staff who rely on the agencies that earmark the funds to vet them, and while there are certain automatic safeguards in place, it was not the role of Treasury to approve or reject specific payments. Lindsay Owens of Groundwork Collaborative wrote: “The Treasury system cuts the checks — Musk has infiltrated the system to stop payments. It’s a COUP!” Owens in an op-ed seen on MSNBC outlined three reasons why Musk might want to access the Treasury payment system: 1) Stop payments to certain programs in order to work around the courts’ block on the administration’s spending freeze. 2) Access list of blacklisted federal contractors in order to boost his own or friend’s companies and harm his competitors. 3) Reduce Social Security or Medicare payments as part of DOGE’s goal of cutting $2 trillion from federal spending. Owens notes that Musk isn’t “chasing these cuts for their own sake. He’s helping congressional Republicans attempt to pay for a new round of tax breaks for corporations and the ultra-wealthy — including himself.” A recent poll finding reveals that only around one-third of Americans approve of DOGE and that 52% disapprove of Musk. Olivia Rosane of Common Dreams offers, “If Musk is going to continue running the government like one of his failed businesses, perhaps someone should force his ‘resignation’ too,” and as Michael Phelan of Social Security Works says, “We need to raise holy hell to STOP this.” Asha Rangrappa of The Freedom Academy offers, “In the end, ending this insanity will likely be up to us, the people. Perhaps when people see that their own bottom line is under the control of an unelected, unconfirmed, foreign national billionaire who has no allegiance to the US government, it will spur action in the streets.”

The non-profit Free Speech for People is heading up a new nonpartisan campaign to solicit support for President Trump’s removal from office — ‘Impeach Trump Again’ — with a report that over 100,000 signatures have been obtained on their petition. The group is encouraging Congress to launch an impeachment investigation, claiming that their petition shows “widespread support,” and that the public is unwilling to accept a King Trump“We need bold leaders in Congress willing to stand up and hold Trump accountable for his abuses of power and initiate an inquiry,” said director Alexandra Flores-Quilty. Sadly, we are in short supply of bold leaders. A post on Quora asks if Trump can be buried at Arlington National Cemetery, drawing this reply: “Last time I checked, it is explicitly illegal to bury someone anywhere who is still alive. However, former presidents CAN be buried there, though it could contaminate the ground, insulting every other human being interred in that sacred ground. Arlington is primarily for military veterans who served honorably, veterans who were decorated during their service; so since Trump is a cowardly, lying draft dodger who has insulted, demeaned, and degraded veterans, having his body anywhere around that hallowed ground would be a slap in the face to every veteran and their family who had ever served this country.”

At this writing, the country and the world, are reeling from Trump’s calamitous misadventure of implementing tariffs upon our three biggest trading partners: CanadaMexico, and China, all of whom have promised retaliatory measures. Canada and Mexico said their responses would be implementation of their own tariffs against the US, with China saying it would file a lawsuit with the World Trade Organization and enact “necessary countermeasures.” Like taking over the Pana-MAGA Canal? Trump gave a start date of last Tuesday, pronouncing the levies would remain in place “until the crisis is alleviated,” meaning the flow of drugs and undocumented immigrants into this country. Tit-for-tat tariffs from this trio of trading partners could send prices soaring for consumers in the US and world-wide. A press conference by Prime Minister Trudeau indicated Canada would levy tariffs on Tuesday on $30B worth of US goods, with additional tariffs in the coming weeks “to allow Canadian companies and supply chains to seek alternatives.” Trudeau said the long history of the US-Canada alliance should lead to a better path without Trump’s punishment, while warning US citizens that this move “will have real consequences for you, the American people.” He also encouraged Canadians to opt for Canadian-made goods over American products, or changing summer vacation plans to stay in Canada. No comments were forthcoming from the White House.

Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum posted on X that she has instructed the implementation of Plan B, which has been standing by in anticipation of Trump’s tariffs. The plan includes “tariffs and non-tariffs in defense of Mexico’s interests,” but no details were announced. Sheinbaum slammed the tariffs, saying in her X post, “We categorically reject the White House’s slander of the Government of Mexico alleging alliances with criminal organizations, as well as any intention to interfere in our territory,” adding, “Mexico not only does not want fentanyl to reach the US, it does not want it reach anywhere. Therefore, if the US wants to combat the criminal groups that traffic drugs and generate violence, we must work together in a comprehensive manner, but always under the principles of shared responsibility, mutual trust, collaboration and above all, respect for sovereignty, which is non-negotiable. Coordination, yes; subordination, no.” Trump is probably still wrestling with his Webster’s to understand what she posted, or perhaps texting Elon for answers, but then again, he probably doesn’t care.

China’s filing a lawsuit with the WTO may have little effect since the US has blocked the appointment of appellate judges to the organization for years, which leaves it unable to mediate international trade disputes. Therefore, China’s action may only serve to gather international support against Trump’s tariffs. The Chinese Ministry of Commerce said in a statement, “China calls on the US to correct its mistakes, work toward mutual understanding, engage in candid dialogue, strengthen cooperation, and manage differences on the basis of equality, mutual benefit, and mutual respect. Additional tariffs are not constructive and bound to affect and harm the counternarcotics cooperation between the two sides in the future.” Of course, none of those words and phrases are in Trump’s vocabulary and it’s way too late for him to implement any of them personally, or in his business practices, or in his destruction of the federal government. Both China and Mexico say they have taken steps to address the flow of fentanyl and to stem international flow of the precursor ingredients, so it’s up to the US to address its own domestic demand for the drug. The Chinese government may try to side-step a trade war, since it is still struggling to recover from the COVID pandemic, but pressure will likely mount, giving the Chinese government the impetus to respond, using a new December 1 law which gives it explicit authority to do so.

As for the tariffs, Trump says, “We will make America great again, and it will all be worth the price that must be paid, we are a country that is now being run with common sense — and the results will be spectacular!!!” No one knows exactly what the impact will be on American consumers, nor how long the tariffs will be in play, but if they should remain if effect for a long period, Trump’s “pain” will become a solid reality. Your next cup of coffee may be more expensive, with prices increasing after Trump and Colombia had a spat over deportation flights — the president reversed a 25% tariff on the country when an agreement was reached. So even though the tariff never happened, coffee markets were rattled by the aspect of tariffs, resulting in price increases in coffee futures. Coffee prices have been increasing over the past several months due to bad weather which has reduced growers’ yield, so Trump’s threat threw unexpected uncertainty into the global trade system which is racing to keep up with increasing demand. Producers will probably continue to gradually increase prices simply as a hedge against the possibility of tariffs, though companies such as KeurigStarbucks and Nestle lock in prices years in advance which will make them immune, for awhile, to the dynamics of the Trump administration.

About Trump’s tariffs (“the most beautiful word in the dictionary,” he says) announcement, journalist SV Dáte wrote that Trump announced he has increased taxes on Americans by $297B a year. Conservative Bill Kristol said, “If only we had a body, with democratic legitimacy and powers conferred by a Constitution, that could overrule a president who seeks to impose arbitrary tariffs and to deport people who fled here to escape oppression. It could be called the Congress of the United States.” Economist Marc Lévesque chimed in, “So, it’s official. Trump just violated the Canada-US-Mexico Free Trade agreement that he himself signed.” Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers called Trump’s tariffs “a self-inflicted wound to the American economy.” Trump posted, “We pay billions of dollars to subsidize Canada. Why? There is no reason. We don’t need anything they have. Therefore, Canada should become our Cherished 51st State. Much lower taxes, and far better military protection for the people of Canada…and NO TARIFFS!” To this post, Steve Schmidt says, “My friends, this is vile. In fact, it is evil. They are the words of a Putin or Xi. They are the words of international gangsterism and thuggery. These are the words of a Hitler. They are the words of the president of the United States, and they are repugnant. These are the words of expansionism and tyranny. These are the words of derangement.” Schmidt’s essay is lengthy, but poignantly he declares, “Why is this happening?…it is happening because the American Republic is collapsing. It is being destroyed from within, as Lincoln predicted in 1838: ‘…if destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher…'”

We might reflect on the words of Ronald Reagan who said, “Our peaceful trading partners aren’t our enemies; they are our allies. We should beware of he demagogues who are ready to declare a trade war against our friends — weakening our economy, our national security, and the entire free world — all while cynically waving the American flag.” Or perhaps as Steve Schmidt says, “Fascism has come to America and it is wrapped in the flag and carrying a cross.” And as Trump says, “Let them eat cake!”

With markets and businesses awakening on Monday morning to the advent of the tariffs, stocks fell, energy costs surged, but word of an agreement from Trump and Mexico’s Sheinbaum to delay tariffs with Mexico agreeing to place 10,000 troops at the border, securing it from migrants, seemed to calm nerves — for now. Same goes for Canada: a 30 day reprieve with promised border security. But don’t relax just yet! That sound of hammering and objects hitting the floor and doors being slammed? That’s Elon Musk and his goons chipping away at our government. Gosh, if only we had a body we might call the Congress of the United States!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Football

“You can’t be a real country unless you have a beer and an airline. It helps if you have some kind of a football team, or some nuclear weapons, but at the very least you need a beer.”
~Frank Zappa

“Gentlemen, it is better to have died as a small boy than to fumble this football.”
~John Heisman

“Football is a simple game. Twenty-two men chase a ball for 90 minutes and at the end, the Germans always win.”
~Gary Lineker

“Without football, my life is worth nothing.”
~Cristiano Ronaldo

“I was missing out on public school and going to the football games, prom or homecomings. But I’ve been to three World Championships… so I think it’s like a win-win.”
~Simone Biles

...

Some of the most unexpected words in the English language actually came from the Vikings. Bet you didn’t know, huh?


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 29 – February 4, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on Traffic Study for the Downtown Extension Project… Steinbruner… Never Again Moss Landing, Supervisors loath to take action on Battery Energy Storage problems; bacteria eats PFAS… Hayes… Living by Principles… Patton… Executive Disorder… Matlock… time’s up?..a minor incident…an apology… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… FireAid… Quotes on… “Rebuilding”

...

RONALD REAGAN AT THE CIVIC AUDITORIUM. This was taken October 8, 1966 when he was running for Governor of California against Pat Brown. Brown was trying for a third term after having to deal with the Watts riots and UC Berkeley anti-Vietnam demonstrations.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: January 29, 2025

REBUILDING. I made the quotes this week about rebuilding after watching the very inspiring FireAid concert on YouTube. I believe there’s a second concert tonight (Friday), and I would be very surprised if these shows can’t be found on YouTube after the fact. It brought me back to the old days of LiveAid, and I don’t only say that because some of the artists were the same… Seriously though, go check them out, they’re worth watching. You can listen/watch on every streaming service possible, and of course, you can donate. Go to FireAidLA.org.

Enough blather from me. With my apologies for being late, let’s launch into this week’s column:

...

NOSFERATU (2024). Prime. Movie (7.4 IMDb) ***- A darkly delightful remake of F.W. Murnau’s 1922 original “Nosferatu” (itself, an unauthorized adaptation of Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”). The story points match, down to the use of shadows as characters. The performances by Depp, Hoult, and Skarsgård breathe new life into the story, as do the visual textures of the cinematography and costume design (even the choice of using Dacian – a long dead language from central Europe – for Orlok’s dialogue). Slowly menacing in its pacing, this film builds its mood in a way that most modern horror films fail to. ~Sarge

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

...

January 27, 2025

Traffic Tall Tales

In a recent piece for BrattonOnline I critiqued the Transportation section of the draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the city’s Downtown Extension Project. My main criticism was that the EIR studied only Vehicle Miles Travelled (VMT) and neglected inclusion of congestion, referred to in the trade as Level of Service or LOS. Anyone who lives in the city knows that congestion is the main traffic issue in this area south of Laurel, with tourist beach traffic often gridlocked on summer weekends as in the photo from a Saturday in July. However, a recent legislative change to CEQA means that only VMT, not congestion is required to be studied for environmental review. While congestion can be studied, it cannot be used to demonstrate a significant impact, the measure by which mitigations can be required-or projects rejected.

I was correct that the draft EIR did not study congestion, however a traffic study of LOS was done by the city, just not included in the draft EIR. Until a colleague pointed it out, I was unaware of the study which is hard to find on the city’s website. Having read it, I would like to share a few highlights so you can judge whether you agree that we are being taken as fools by the city and their consultants, at considerable taxpayers’ expense.

The study was done because the City’s General Plan under its Transportation section requires review of congestion at intersections for new projects. Increased congestion can be addressed in minor ways such as fiddling with traffic lights or requiring developers to pay Traffic Impact Fees (TIF’s). Such “improvements” are not as robust as Mitigations under CEQA and have no standing when EIR’s are being evaluated.

The 564-page study, titled “Santa Cruz Downtown Expansion Plan, Local Transportation Analysis” was prepared for the City of Santa Cruz by Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. The document is dense with tables and charts. The flaw is not hard to spot. It is in the quote of the study analysis below.

Typical weekday peak hours were chosen because they represent the majority (70%) of peak travel conditions on the city roadways. The peak hour of summer Saturday traffic was not analyzed because those dates are not representative of typical travel patterns consistent with the proposed project. Kimley-Horn Inc.

So, even if the 3,500 new residents have guests, deliveries, and outings on the weekends, it is not worthy of study because it is not “typical travel patterns” of the new residents. That seems a big assumption. The proposed project, including prior General Plan anticipated growth in the same area, is estimated to generate 6,307 new daily automobile trips. It doesn’t mention that residents will be staying home or only walking and biking on weekends.

The consultants seem unfamiliar with this part of town. They studied AM 8-9 and PM 5-6 peak hours, “typical of weekday commutes.” The roads in the project area are largely not commute routes, unlike Mission or Bay.  The study’s other automated traffic counts were done in February, March, and October: anything it seems, to avoid peak summer weekend traffic analysis.

According to the study, for some intersections, even without including peak summer weekends, “the project exceeds the City’s level of service standards of deficiency, causing the level of service to go from acceptable to substandard with the addition of the project trips.” But none of this will be on the table for council when the draft EIR is considered and voted on.

Thanks Sacramento. Besides your required density bonus mandating overbuilding in Santa Cruz, making even affordable housing less affordable, you have removed an important area of environmental review. Both VMT and LOS should be studied under CEQA, not just the one.

The consultants’ summary suggests the study bias. They write:

The project can support the Santa Cruz vision for a vibrant and sustainable downtown area while remaining consistent with the City’s Transportation Study Guidelines. 

Don’t forget the deadline for comments on the draft EIR is February 21.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
Never Again Moss Landing

IS SANTA CRUZ COUNTY MONITORING METALS WHILE  FAILING TO ISSUE SAFETY CLEANUP ADVISORIES?
Last Tuesday, the County Board of Supervisors heard an oral report from Monterey County staff as an update on the Moss Landing Vistra Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) fire.  Mr. David Reid, Director of the Santa Cruz County Office of Response, Recovery and Resilience (OR3), who in effect is the office of emergency services, stated that since the fire occurred in Monterey County ,it is their jurisdiction to make such reports and respond.

There has been no survey or sampling of surfaces in Santa Cruz County for heavy metals associated with the Moss Landing Battery Facility fire.

As of this writing, the Santa Cruz County staff may possibly be providing soil and water sampling, but the extent and results are unknown.  Meanwhile, no public safety advisories or other precautionary information is being provided.  With the exception of Supervisor Manu Koenig, the Supervisors were mostly worried about who would pay for the testing.

I wonder if they would be so reticent if they were the farmworkers who are working with bare hands in the fields with unknown levels of contamination??????

Monterey County issued the precautionary safety cleaning information: Protecting Public Health During Fire Residual Clean-up

Why are our County officials lagging on this potentially critical public health and safety issue?

Here is a link to the Special Meeting of the Monterey County Board of Supervisors on January 21 to provide information to the people: Board of Supervisors on 2025-01-21 10:00 AM – Special Meeting

Meanwhile, the Santa Cruz County Supervisors are largely sitting on their hands.  Please contact your Supervisor and the new Chair of the Board, Supervisor Felipe Hernandez. 

Phone: 831-454-2200 
Felipe Hernandez <felipe.hernandez@santacruzcountyca.gov>
Pro-tip: All Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors and staff have the e-mail template of <Firstname.Lastname@santacruzcountyca.gov>

MARSH SOILS WITHIN TWO-MILE RADIUS OF VISTRA BATTERY FIRE CONTAIN STAGGERING INCREASE IN METALS
Thanks to the baseline information collected over the past decade by the Moss Landing Marine Lab scientists, we now know that recent samples of the Elkhorn Slough Estuary show extremely elevated levels of metals.  Furthermore, the metals found in marsh soil samples taken since the Vistra Battery Facility fire that began on January 16 and burned for days are associated with nanoparticles, and are indicative of association with the smoke plumes issued during the fire.

Scientists Detect Heavy Metals in Environmentally Sensitive Elkhorn Slough After Battery Storage Plant Fire | SJSU NewsCenter

Having the baseline levels is critical.  Thank goodness for this crucial work.  Will it mirror the Vistra and EPA statements to area residents that everything was fine, and Monterey and Santa Cruz County officials recommending people just shelter in place with doors and windows closed?

Hmmm….  stay tuned, but keep asking those critical questions of the officials.

Meanwhile, here is where you can take action….

LOCAL RESIDENTS NEED TO UNITE AND PRESS FOR ACTION AND ANSWERS
Please join your neighbors in taking action as a grassroots effort to press officials for action and demand answers.  This group quickly mobilized for a community meeting and soon after issued.a call to action that helped residents in Santa Cruz and Monterey Counties properly collect surface residue samples from over 125 locations to determine a survey of lithium, nickel, cobalt and manganese levels potentially indicative of the Moss Landing Battery fire plume.

Can you help in any way?  Taking action is a great way to counter the feeling that you are powerless in this terrible event.  Sign up and do what you can…

Never Again Moss Landing

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY’S BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS (BESS) PROJECT APPLICATION IN WATSONVILLE MOVES AHEAD
Last Tuesday, the Board of Supervisor chambers at 701 Ocean Street was full and overflowing…so was the parking lot outside, with people demanding answers and information about the Moss Landing Battery facility fire and also protesting the proposed Battery Energy Storage System (BESS) at 90 Minto Road in Watsonville.

Supervisor Koenig attempted to get a moratorium on lithium battery energy storage projects in Santa Cruz County until Vistra and the Governor’s office release final investigation reports and after-action analysis of the Moss Landing incident, to send  letters to the California Public Utilities Commission and California Energy Commission to request formal evaluation of other BESS facilities that are similar to the Vistra plant that burned, and finally, to direct staff to evaluate soil and produce in Santa Cruz County for possible metal contamination levels for public safety.  He also motioned that the April 25 date currently scheduled for the Board to hear the rezoning of the three BESS sites and likely the Seahawk BESS project application.  He and Superviosr Hernandez both favored stronger regulations for BESS projects to ward off the end=run of local jurisdiction control available when an applicant could instead run to the California Energy Commission to get immediate approval.

All of those good proactive and responsive suggestions were shot down by other Supervisors who worried about who would pay the cost of soil and produce sampling,   Even though County Counsel advised that the Board could take these actions as associated response to the Moss Landing Battery fire report information, the other Supervisors were not willing to do so.  While Supervisor Cummings was in favor of bringing the matter to the next Board agenda,  Supervisor DeSerpa was not in favor of moving the presentation to be associated with the Watsonville BESS report any sooner than April 25 because she was sure there would be plenty of information available on the recent disaster by then.

Please listen to all this discussion on the Board of Supervisor meeting recording for January 28. for Item #8, especially the Board discussion at around minute 3:00 to completion.

I visited the proposed Watsonville BESS project at 90 Minto Road.  The area is beautiful, with apple orchards and is known as Interlaken, with College Lake and Pinto Lake adjacent.  Residents in the dense neighborhood adjacent said there is a wide variety of lovely migratory birds that visit.

Residents knew nothing of the proposed BESS project application currently on the fast track for approval to help Central Coast Community Energy (3CE) to meet their business plan.  Don’t forget that County Administrative Officer Carlos Palacios and former County Supervisor Bruce McPherson shoved this all through and sit on the Board of 3CE.

That means that the December 12 public meeting that New Leaf Energy held (they are required to hold only one) was not sent to the dense neighborhoods around the proposed BESS site.  I wonder if the administrators of nearby Salsipuedes Elementary School received notification, and why the meeting was held at Amesti School instead…with NO time included for when the meeting would begin.

I wonder if the nearby residents on Minto Road, which includes the Shapiro Knolls dense affordable housing complex, received any notification?????

I wonder how there could ever be a rapid evacuation for the Minto Road neighborhood, with such a narrow road that is seemingly blocked by high storm water levels in the creek nearby.  Would there be secondary access for fire engines if there were to be a fire at the BESS facility?

I wonder why Supervisor Hernandez seems fine with all this?

Take a look at the photos below and contact him with your thoughts:  Felipe Hernandez <felipe.hernandez@santacruzcountyca.gov>

Also, consider sending a thank you letter to Supervisor Manu Koenig, for being well-prepared and ready to take action to protect the health and safety of the people and environment in Santa Cruz County.  Manu Koenig <manu.koenig@santacruzcountyca.gov>

Here is a tour of the area where a BESS facility is proposed at 90 Minto Road.  Below is Minto Road near where it intersects Green Valley Road.  What would a large-scale emergency response look like on this road at the same time residents there would be evacuating?

Below is the orchard adjacent to the existing PG&E transmission yard.  A significant portion of the orchard would be taken out of production, violating the County’s Measure J approved by voters to preserve agricultural land.

Below is the view from Agate Drive, a neighborhood immediately adjacent to the proposed BESS facility and that would be downwind of any smoke plume in the event of a fire.  This neighborhood did not receive notification of the December 12, 2024 “public meeting” that New Leaf Energy held at Amesti School. The post card New Leaf Energy mailed had NO time included for the meeting.

Do you think any of the people living in the Shapiro Knolls dense affordable housing complex shown below on Miinto Road and immediately adjacent to the proposed Seahawk BESS at 90 Minto Road received any notification of the December 12 “public meeting” or are even aware of the project?

Do you think any of the residents in the small cabin-like housing that likely is farmworker housing even know about the proposed BESS?  Will their homes be demolished?

What about an evacuation plan for the Salsipuedes School nearby and downwind of the proposed  BESS project?  Do you think those families know about this proposed project and the problems associated with a lithium battery energy storage system fire???

Do you think the apple orchards below should be preserved, as is required by Measure J?

The Interlaken area of Watsonville where the proposed Seahawk BESS is a riparian area, and resembles the same aquatic habitat of the Elkhorn Slough Estuary.  How would a toxic smoke plume affect the College Lake and Pinto Lake environments?

If you are concerned by any of this, please write or call your Supervisor.  Demand a noticed public hearing during an evening and invite residents Countywide.

Board of Supervisors: 831-454-2200.

CPUC WILL INTRODUCE NEW SAFETY STANDARDS FOR BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS (BESS) IN MARCH

The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) will consider new safety regulations for Energy Storage Systems (ESS) at it’s March 13, 2025 meeting because:

There is currently no provision in General Order167 that requires ESS Operators to report safety incidents
such as injuries, fatalities, thermal runaways, fires, or other system failures to the
CPUC. Regulatory oversight of ESS facilities is necessary because of the safety and reliability risks that can occur if ESS facilities are not properly operated and maintained.”

Incidents at lithium-ion ESS facilities have caused fires, evacuation orders, and shelter-
in-place orders for nearby residents; therefore, warranting an investigation by Electric Safety and Reliability Branch

(ESRB.)

There have been a number of safety incidents at ESS facilities since 2021, including:

  1. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, September 4, 2021
  2. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, February 13, 2022
  3. Terra-Gen; Valley Center Energy Storage Center, April 5, 2022
  4. PG&E; Elkhorn Battery Energy Storage Facility, September 20, 2022
  5. Terra-Gen; Valley Center Energy Storage Center, September 18, 2023
  6. SDG&E; Kearny South Energy Storage, April 29, 2024
  7. Convergent; Orange County Energy Storage 2, July 17, 2024
  8. REV Renewables; Gateway Energy Storage Facility, May 15, 2024
  9. SDG&E; Northeast Operations Center, Escondido, September 5, 2024
  10. Vistra; Battery Energy Storage Facility, January 16, 2025.

Proposal to Enhance Safety of Battery Energy Storage Facilities

COULD BACTERIA RID FOREVER CHEMICAL CARCINOGENS?
Here is some good news!!  A study has shown that bacteria could effectively clean up PFAS in the soil and water.  This could help with areas such as the Rountree Detention Facility and Migrant Worker Complex wells, both of which have shown elevated levels of PFAS, a persistent chemical that is pervasive and very carcinogenic.

Rare Aerobic Bacterium Found to Break Down ‘Forever Chemicals’ | Sci.News

AB 205 CERTIFICATION BY CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION IS BAD NEWS!
At Tuesday’s Board of Supervisor meeting, Supervisor Manu Koenig attempted to convince the Board to be proactive and consider more restrictive regulation than the State;s for Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) facilities.  Here is what is so worrisome and that merits rapid action by the Board.

AB 205 gives CEC exclusive siting authority over these eligible projects if a developer submits an application to CEC under this certification process instead of an application for entitlements from the jurisdiction in which the project is located. CEC’s siting certification is in lieu of any permit, certificate, or similar document required by any state, local, or regional agency, or federal agency to the extent permitted by federal law. It also supersedes any applicable statute, ordinance, or regulation of any state, local, or regional agency, or federal agency to the extent permitted by federal law, with limited exceptions. AB 205 specifically provides that the certification does not supersede the authority of an exclusive list of agencies: the California State Lands Commission, the California Coastal Commission (CCC), the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC), the California State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) or the applicable regional water quality control boards, local air quality management districts, or the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC).

Expedited Environmental Review of Eligible Projects

AB 205 requires CEC to serve as the lead agency for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) when developers file an application for certification with the CEC before July 1, 2029. Within 30 days of the submission of the application, CEC must review the application and make a determination of completeness. Environmental review must be completed within 270 days after the application is deemed complete, subject to certain limited extensions. CEC must also develop plans for timely consultations with relevant state and local agencies. A certificate issued pursuant to this streamlined process shall be valid for a period not to exceed five years from the date of issuance.

CEC cannot approve a qualifying project without first finding that the facility will have an overall net positive economic benefit to the local government that would have had permitting authority for the site and related facility. Such economic benefits include but are not limited to employment growth, housing development, infrastructure and environmental improvements, and property taxes and sales and use tax revenues.

Other Application Requirements

To qualify, developers must meet certain prevailing wage and skilled and trained workforce requirements in construction contracts. Developers must also secure contracts with community-based organizations—such as workforce development and training organizations, labor unions, social justice advocates, local government entities, and California Native American tribes—where there is mutual benefit to the parties to the agreement.

An application for certification must be accompanied by a fee of $250,000 plus $500 per MW of gross generating capacity or per MW of gross energy storage capacity, as applicable, or $0.70 per square foot for a thermal generation plant not powered by fossil fuels, subject to a total cap of $750,000.
Projects that receive certification are subject to an annual fee of $25,000, with payments due by July 1 of each year in which the facility retains its certification. Petitions to amend an existing project that previously received certification shall be accompanied by a fee of $5,000.

Don’t you think the California Energy Commission would be more than happy to issue this type of certificate for new BESS facilities and have their wallets fattened annually?  How objective would their environmental analysis actually be?????

Please write your County Supervisors and insist on very restrictive requirements for any BESS facility.
How about a technical advisory committee to assist development of the requirements, and not allow it to be in the hands of County Planning staff or New Leaf Energy or Vistra???

AB 303 WOULD HELP FIX THIS
In response to Vistra attempting to use the AB 205 tactic to do an end-run for a BESS in Morro Bay,  Assemblymember Dawn Addis has proposed AB 303 to claw back the power for the jurisdictions that would be affected by such a project.

Please support this legislation by writing Assemblymember Addis, and other legislators.
Addis Introduces Legislation to Bolster Community Choice & Environmental Protections in Battery Projects | Official Website – Assemblymember Dawn Addis Representing the 30th California Assembly District

MORE ABOUT THAT BIG WHITE BALL ON TOP OF THE SHERIFF BUILDING
The County OR3 has some interesting information on the sidebar, including the radar readings from the x-band radar equipment on top of the Sheriff Building in Live Oak.  Take a look at this when the rain returns:
Experience

The OR3 website also includes the “PurpleAir” monitoring data system that many people referred to during the recent Moss Landing Battery Energy Storage Site (BESS) Fire.

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS APPROVE SPENDING BIG BUCKS TO REMODEL CHAMBERS?
The Board approved Consent Agenda Item #26, spending $2,310,500 to remodel the Board Chambers with new layout and furnishings.  Does this make fiscal sense when the County had to borrow $96million to stay financially afloat?

I just don’t think so!
Government Broadcasting Revitalization Project Design Concept

Why does CAO Carlos Palacios and General Services Director Michael Beaton want to push this wasteful spending?  To improve visual experience for meeting recordings..
Really?  This all comes after the huge remodel project of the General Services Dept.

The County has changed its website.  In order to view the map of the proposed new layout of the Board Chambers, one must sign in.  The system kept rejecting my attempts to log in.  The other new item is that one has to “just know” to click in the empty space between agenda items to see the links for documents appear.  Some require registering to access them.

What a setback for transparency.  Don’t worry though, there is now an “AI Statement” at the end of the documents that I was able to access, letting me know that the report was partially generated with AI.

Please write your Supervisor with your thoughts on the $2.3 MILLION remodel of the Board Chambers and the problematic access to Board documents.

WILL MT. MADONNA INN EVER COME TO LIFE AGAIN?
Maybe you remember the lovely views of the Pajaro Valley and Monterey Bay while having dinner decades ago when the Mt. Madonna Inn was open for business.  According to a sign posted there now that give hope to a reopening of this magnificent location at the summit of Hecker Pass Road (Highway 152)
According to County staff:

The application is nearing completeness. Once complete, we will prepare a staff report and schedule a public hearing before the Zoning A.dministrator.

Planning Status

Stay tuned….

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  SIGN UP TO HELP THE MOSS LANDING GRASSROOTS EFFORT. MAKE ANOTHER ONE TO YOUR SUPERVISOR ABOUT FACILITIES IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY. DEMAND TOWN HALL MEETINGS.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING ONE THING…MAYBE TWO!

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Living by Principles

What comes to mind when you hear someone say something like, “She is a principled person?” If you trust the source of the statement, perhaps you will think more highly of the person being referenced, which is curious because you don’t have any idea of the nature of her principles. Perhaps merely having principles and acting upon them makes you more predictable, and that predictability is an asset. It seems that this might be a good time to reflect on principle-based living.

Social Principles

I posit that most religions are based on social principles of great value. Kindness, fairness, gratitude, generosity, and attentiveness are some such principles, stated positively. Some principles are stated in the negative such as “evil” including murder, greed, vengeance, gluttony, etc. It is a mystery to me that discussion of such principles is not the primary driver of political discourse. Perhaps we get confused when juxtaposing wealth redistribution as both generous (to the poor) and greedy (against the rich)? Or, maybe we wonder if it might or might not be kind to murder someone for heinous crimes? These are heady questions.

On a national level, we might feel ready to label presidents, members of the house and senate, or even Supreme Court officials as ‘principled’ or ‘unprincipled,’ but how would we take such labels to more definition? What precise principles would you suggest your favorite national politician has had or has lacked? So much media hype focuses on either fallabilities or exhilarating roaring successes of our so-called ‘leaders,’ and yet that question may be difficult to answer. I challenge you to try.

I suggest that everyone has some familiarity with social principles and that most people, if asked, would be able to speak to their personal framework. However, beyond that, I wonder how much people are guided by principles for their work, their homes, or their relationship with the environment.

While I challenge everyone to think about what principles they operate on at the workplace or in their homes, I am more interested here in elaborating on some environmental principles that you might consider.

Ecological Principles

There are principles that could guide humans in better forming their relationship with the environment, creating increased benefit for future generations. The root of all evil is said to be greed, and what better test of an environmental principle than just that – greed?

One of the key attributes of greed is to seek only to take, without giving. For thousands of years, indigenous peoples understood that humans should be very mindful about what they took from nature, and also they should give back. Frugality is a central principle for humans’ relationship with the environment. The less stuff we buy, the more pro-environmental we are. Last I checked, it cost a liter of crude oil every time a dollar was exchanged.

Giving Back to Nature

What is ‘giving back’ to nature? An indigenous person asked our community once why we were burning our prairies without seeding after the fire. Perhaps that is one way of giving back. We still aren’t doing that. Another way to give back would be to control the invasive plants and animals that are so terribly affecting nature. Please write to me if you can think of any other ways that Monterey Bay residents might give back to nature.

Energy Expenditure Principle

The way we create energy makes a difference and serves as a ripe area for environmental principle formation. Is the principle to create the most energy from the least impactful source? If so, how are we getting reports on how we might help?

The havoc being wrought by climate change has convinced many to be more mindful about what we take from nature, but most people have a very shallow understanding about that. Burning fewer fossil fuels is a Big Problem for life on Earth, but I hear very little about the impacts of alternate energy solutions on nature. Nuclear energy has a great environmental impact not normally described, same with solar panel production and concrete/steel installations for the bases of wind turbines. We might all benefit from getting more information about trade offs for various types of energy production. That way, we can shape our political or consumer voices to help create the best solutions. Plus, what are we hearing about using less energy, altogether? Long gone are the energy saving public service announcements of the now-lauded Jimmy Carter years.

Species Conservation Principle

Fossil-fuel burning-caused climate change is the number one threat to the environment, but there are other threats, and the core concern I believe we should have is about species conservation. I suggest that we should weigh human decisions on how well we can guarantee that all species continue to thrive. I have yet to speak with anyone that discounts this principle’s importance, but I have also seen many decisions made with too little information to adequately assess this principle. How is a regular person to evaluate whether or not a decision favorably affects species conservation? Luckily, we have public disclosure laws and people considering impacting the environment are required to analyze and disclose impacts on species. So, one would expect things like disclosure of species that might be impacted and how the impacts would affect their future chances of survival under the varied alternatives project proponents are required to analyze. If you don’t see such analysis, you should be careful about supporting such proposals.

For further thought on this, consider author Gregory David Roberts’ assertion in the novel Shantaram of the principle of complexity conservation. He would say that we should weigh the good of an action on whether it creates more or less complexity in the future…more complexity is the goal.

Go ahead- try using these pro-environmental principles or come up with your own! Let me know how it goes.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Thursday, January 23, 2025


Most of us have been reading about those “Executive Orders” issued by our newly-inaugurated president on “Day One.” In an article dated January 21, 2025Time Magazine has complained about them, outlining a number of problems, and though I think Time is correct in its observations about the drawbacks of trying to govern by “Executive Order,” it has missed what I think is the most important point.

Here’s the issue I want to raise: When the president issues an “Executive Order,” what gives the president the right to do so? Where does the president get the power to tell people what to do? After all, if we quickly check out our Constitution, Article II tells us that the president’s basic duty is to “take care that the laws are faithfully executed.” In other words, the president’s power to tell other people what to do with respect to one thing or another does not come from holding the office of the presidency. It comes from a law, enacted by Congress, specifically granting such a power to the president.

So, and let’s think about it, have all the president’s recent “Executive Orders” been based on a law enacted by Congress, specifically granting the president the power to issue the various orders he has been issuing?

The answer, clearly, is “No.” Issuing an “Executive Order” that claims to take away the citizenship of people whom the Constitution specifically says are citizens is the most egregious example of the overreach that our president is demonstrating. I am betting, though, that an extremely large percentage of the other “Executive Orders” recently issued by our president, on his very first day in office, are not actually valid “Executive Orders,” at all, in the sense that anyone is legally required to do what the president says.

In an editorial in the Wednesday, January 22, 2025, edition of The Wall Street Journal, that newspaper decried Trump’s action in purporting to give TikTok what the paper called an “Illegal Amnesty.” Whatever your position on TikTok, Congress passed a law; the president has now asserted the right to countermand that law, simply by executing a so-called “Executive Order.” This was NOT legal. The Wall Street Journal is right about that!

And how about the president’s “Executive Order” unilaterally withdrawing the United States from the World Health Organization? I am betting that Congress has not told the president that he gets to make that choice. WE get to make that choice, and “we” act by laws passed by Congress, if those laws are then signed by the president. Is there some law that says that the president is granted the power to declare national health policy, based on the president’s personal preferences?

Day One of this new presidency has now come and gone, and the president is acting like his election, in and of itself, gives him the right to order everyone else around. This is emphatically not what our system of self-government contemplates, and so emergency sirens ought to be wailing! But…. now is not the time to seek shelter underground. Now is the time to fill up the streets, and to object, in no uncertain terms, to the improper claims by the president that he has some kind of right to “rule,” based on having been elected president. We need to demand that our Members of Congress, each one of them, insist that THEY decide, as our elected “representatives, what the laws and policies will be that guide our national actions, and our national life.

As for the so-called “Executive Orders” that have been issued by the president, let’s recognize them for what they are, the diseased evidences of “Executive Disorder.”

What we’re seeing is a sickness, and our current president has a very bad case! Let’s not allow him to infect the rest of us, and the entirety of our government.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

ZORRO IMPERSONATOR, WHOPPER OVERLOAD, BEYONCÉ VICTORY

Has it been four years yet? That’s a question raised by a poster on X at the end of an exhausting week of Trump and his antics following his inauguration. It’s certainly a worthy query as many of us will agree. The Crazy Eight website evaluated it with, “In his inaugural speech Donald Trump called for a ‘Revolution of Common Sense,’ where apparently truth is stranger than fiction, and reality is more alarming than satire…His first priorities? Helping everyday Americans struggling to pay their bills by renaming the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America AND profiting billions from his new cryptocurrency! Ain’t that swell?”

Buzzfeed selected a few of its favorite Tweets of the Week“I don’t care who’s trans, bro — I want doctor’s appointments for $5”“There’s not going to be lower grocery prices, you stupid slut”“Being a person with a brain and someone who can read during this period of history is really, really difficult”“Nobody is telling men they’re losers, and that’s the problem”; “I’d rather get a pap smear from Edward Scissorhands than watch any second of the inauguration”; “Melania’s looking like a smooth criminal”; Referring to the announcement that Trump’s inauguration would be moved indoors, one poster asks, “And, ya’ll want to invade Canada?”; “My BF keeps muttering to himself, ‘We had to get through Hoover to get to FDR,’ like it’s a prayer.” Saturday Night Live’s Weekend Update anchor, Michael Che, showing a Tesla Cybertruck picture, said, “Musk can’t be a Nazi, because the Nazis made nice cars.”

The TV ratings are available for the inauguration, and Trump has to be disappointed that no Sean Spicer has stepped up to convince the world that records were broken. According to The Wrap, combined cable and network news totals amount to 24.59M, with Fox News unsurprisingly accounting for 10.3M, nearly half of the viewership, between 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. Eastern Time. Morgan Stephens of Daily Kos observes “that more people watched Beyoncé’s Christmas halftime show than the 47th president’s inauguration.” Trump’s viewer ratings are well below his own 2017 inauguration (and Joe Biden’s in 2021), garnering only 7.2% of the US population to see that he didn’t place his hand on the Bible and air-kissing Melania in her Zorro hat. Stephens attributes the dip in viewership to general apathy, despondency, Trump fatigue or his polarizing presence, combined with loss of appetite for his theatrics.

Trump made it clear that his second term will be more of the same, as he added to his collection of false and misleading claims, estimated by the Washington Post that during his first Oval Office occupancy he spewed 30,573 whoppers. One critic dubbed him “America’s Liar-In-Chief,” as he launched into his inaugural address about immigration, the economy, electric vehicles, the Panama Canal, his 2020 stolen election, and the January 6 insurrection. His brazen mendacity is not only habitual, but strategic as we see within the MAGA mob’s tactics. A former Republican communications director on Capitol Hill, says, “It’s a continuation of Donald Trump’s brand. He knows that sunlight is the best disinfectant, so he’s going to continue to lie to mask what he’s doing. If you can undermine institutions and credible sources of information, you can get away with lying and deceiving people. We’re watching that mass delusion happen right before our eyes in the Trump administration 2.0.” During the following week with reporters, Trump continued to spew misleading assertions, wild exaggerations and blatant lies, culminating on Fox News with his explanation for the blanket pardon of the January 6 rioters and their attacks on police as “very minor incidents.”

CNN reports that Trump, in his attempt to rewrite history detailing the attack on the US Capitol, had a database detailing the array of criminal charges and successful convictions of the January 6 rioters removed from the Department of Justice’s website. That searchable database served as an easily accessible repository of all cases prosecuted by the US Attorney’s Office for the District of Columbia — which declined to comment! Removal of the site coincides with Trump’s decision to pardon all convicted defendants, plus early release of 14 members of far-right extremist groups, including 10 convicted of seditious conspiracy, and a request to dismiss more than 300 unresolved cases. This ‘whitewashing’ of the mob attack wipes out cases against some of the most violent rioters who injured police, and was celebrated in particular by the pardoned Brandon Straka for his role on J6. Straka proclaimed it a “huge victory,” saying that the site was a “weapon of harassment” used by the government to make life impossible for its “targets from J6.”

Acting US attorney, Ed Martin, known for his organizing the ‘Stop the Steal’ movement and being involved in financing the 2021 Trump rally on the Ellipse, is given credit for removing the DOJ website. Straka had campaigned for the site’s removal because the information was available to potential employers, landlords, and social or business contacts, complicating the lives of the J6 participants. Details of the J6 cases are still accessible on the DOJ’s website in the form of press releases about charges and convictions, and are available through court records and services such as Pacer.

David Smith in the Guardian reports that even the White House website has been compromised, with a Trump biography claim that a 2024 “landslide victory defines the American success story.” Omitting the ‘big lie’ regarding the 2020 election, his victory came “a second time despite several assassination attempts and the unprecedented weaponization of law fare against him.” While fact-checkers attempt to hold Trump to account, Republicans are less willing than ever to correct his falsehoods in this now fragmented media environment, with MAGA influencers only too eager to amplify them. Kurt BardellaDemocratic strategist and media relations consultant, says, “If there’s any lasting impact from Donald Trump’s time on the political stage, it’s that we live in a world now where you can just make up your own facts, and truth is however you decide to bend it. There are content creators and content machines that exist solely for the purpose of laundering anything that Donald Trump says and making it true to a certain degree. It’s a play off the Richard Nixon quote: ‘If the president does it, it is legal; well, if the president says it, it’s true. That’s the world that we live in now.'”

Sara Boboltz of B writes, “as President Donald Trump settles into his second term and world leaders ponder what the next four years have in store, some British officials who have dealt with him in the past are sharing words of advice: ‘Expect chaos, but also laughs.’ Workers in the British prime minister’s office during Trump’s first term told Politico EU that small crowds of civil servants and advisers would gather to listen in on phone calls with Trump. ‘The calls were extraordinary — brilliant. Everyone was in there with tears of laughter because they were hilarious.’ Two listeners said that whatever agenda had been planned ‘would quite quickly fall by the wayside’ and the calls ‘were never what you wanted them to be about, broadly.’ Americans are already well-versed in Trump’s meandering style of speech, surprising gaffes and penchant for jumping between topics at whim, which he calls ‘the weave’ with his claims that he always ends up hitting his intended points in the end. One person contributed, ‘Yes, he will say some mad or unpredictable things, but there’s almost always an underlying argument or basis for a negotiation, and if the conversation goes south, Trump is always happy to discuss his UK golf courses.'”

British satirical magazine, ‘Private Eye,’ printed its latest cover with an apology to Donald Trump, headlined ‘Donald Trump: An Apology.’ The document reads: “In common with all other media organisations, we may in the past have given the impression that we thought Mr. Trump was a sleazy, deranged, orange-faced man-baby who was a threat to democracy and who should be in jail rather than the White House. We now realise, in the light of his return to supreme power, that he is in fact a political colossus, the voice of sanity, a champion of liberty, a model of probity and the saviour of the Western world. He is also slim, handsome and young. We would like to apologize unreservedly for any confusion caused by our previous statements and thank President Trump for his kind invitation to give him 94 million pounds to attend his inauguration event.” In smaller print at the bottom of the page, it reads: “This statement has not been fact-checked.”

James Austin Johnson, portraying Trump on Saturday Night Live said, “Just like my founding fathers, I am creating a new country as well. And just like them, we’re doing it very white-ly. Workplaces must go back to looking like the TV show ‘The Office.’ Mostly white people but with one funny Black guy who’s having a really bad time.” Johnson/Trump called his inauguration “a tremendous success,” being held inside “due to cold and fear. We got a lot of surprise guests, like Melania!” He pointed out the presence of his billionaire buddies, “Zuck, Bezos, and of course, Elon. We love Elon, but to quote some of his own children, ‘I do not want him in my life.” Johnson/Trump shared his views about only two genders, “one to work, and one to cook. We’re going back to common sense in regard to gender. No more makeup on men, unless you need it to be president.” On his cabinet appointees, he boasted, “We’re filling my cabinet with some of the best people. They’re all very good except for most of them. How great is Pete Hegseth? He said he’s going to stop drinking if he gets the job, and that’s all I needed to hear.” And, “Who would’ve thought it easier to get a cease-fire in Gaza than lower the price of eggs?” Satirist Andy Borowitz writes that Joaquin ‘El Chapo’ Guzman is asking Trump for a pardon out of ‘professional courtesy,’ claiming that he was a DC riot participant. Ready to turn over a new leaf, Borowitz says Guzman promises to stop selling drugs and focus on crypto, while acknowledging he is a controversial figure but, “I’m not some total maniac like Hegseth.”

Stephen Colbert of the ‘Late Show’ ripped into Republicans who showed absolutely no outrage with Trump’s pardoning of 1,500 January 6 rioters who attacked the US Capitol, some of whom assaulted several police officers. Colbert quoted House Speaker Mike Johnson with saying it was not his “place” to question Trump’s decision. “Not your place? They attacked the House of Representatives! That is literally YOUR place!” The Tonight Show host, Jimmy Fallon, says Trump’s granting of clemency took his allies by surprise, with one adviser revealing the president simply said, “Release them all.” Must have been too much trouble to read all those pages of names which would keep him away from his grifting. Fallon noted, “At this point the only prisoner Trump hasn’t released is Melania.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Rebuilding

“When we rebuild a house, we are rebuilding a home. When we recover from disaster, we are rebuilding lives and livelihoods.”
~Sri Mulyani Indrawati

“If we wish to rebuild our cities, we must first rebuild our neighborhoods. And to do that, we must understand that the quality of life is more important than the standard of living.”
~Harvey Milk

“Governments must give to all those who have hit life’s hurdles the chance to rebuild and have a future.”
~Pauline Hanson

“It cannot take decades to resurrect, we must act immediately with purpose and enthusiasm to rebuild.”
~Alan Autry

“The city of New Orleans showed America what it takes to rebuild a great place. We’re all going together, and we’re not leaving anybody behind.”
~Mitch Landrieu

...

You didn’t think I’d miss this opportunity, did you? 🙂 Here’s FireAid 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.

Direct questions and comments to webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)

...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 22 – 28, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… Greensite on the Affordable Housing Ballot Measure … Steinbruner… Battery Storage Fire Risks in Santa Cruz County?  Taxing MidTown, Ugly Soquel Creek Water District Project … Hayes… First Bloom, Maritime Chaparral… Patton… Cindy Sends A Message … Matlock… …parental advisory…whataboutism…truly pathetic…indulgent nitwittery… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… peaceful jellyfish to calm your soul … Quotes on… “Resistance”

...

RORY CALHOUN AND WIFE LITA BARON IN SANTA CRUZ. This was probably taken upstairs in the Palomar Hotel or maybe the Del Mar mezzanine sometime in the 1950’s. That’s Eunice and Leonard Sanchez and Mary and “Hi” W. Eisile with Rory and Lita. Rory lived here between 1927 and 1936, then went to Santa Cruz High but got in some near serious trouble and left for Hollywood. He was the only actor to star in 3 films with Marilyn Monroe. We brought him back for a special home town welcome warming in 1991.

photo credit: from Bruce’s private collection

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: January 23, 2025

RABBIT HOLE. I did not expect to spend 45 minutes looking up things about Rory Calhoun today, but that’s ADHD and the internet for you… This week’s photo made me curious. I confess I don’t know a lot about him. Turns out he was born in LA, and spent his early years in Santa Cruz. He turned to a life of crime as a juvenile, went to prison, and still ended up a 1950s heart-throb actor with quite some success. I wonder if that would even be possible today. Here’s a link to his Wikipedia page. Spend a minute if you have it, his life was quite interesting.

LA STILL NEEDS HELP. (I’m leaving this here for another week, since it’s still an urgent matter.) While they are in need of donations of all sorts (people have lost ev-e-ry-thing after all), following the impulse to load up the car and drive down there is not that great of an idea. In fact, when there are disasters, well meaning “civilians” are often a hindrance as opposed to the help they want to be. If you feel moved to give to SoCal (and you should, if you can), please coordinate with some form of already ongoing relief effort. Here’s an article on KQED on How to Help People Affected by the LA Fires, containing links and useful information. Here’s something I learned that I did not know – if you have a GoFundMe that specifies that the money will be used for relief (like house repairs, funeral expenses, etc) from a natural disaster, then you can not receive funds from FEMA for that same disaster. That’s a good thing to know! Also, be leery of fundraising scammers. Sadly, these “digital looters” pop up around natural disasters.

...

ERASERHEAD. Max. Movie (7.3 IMDb) **** In honor of the passing of one of the most individual visions in the film industry, David Lynch, I went back and revisited “Eraserhead” for the first time in 40 years. It would become a cult hit during the late 70’s-80’s. There was nothing like it at the time, with a Buñuel level of slow-paced uncomfortable surrealism, and a story that can’t easily be described. As such, it tends to be shoehorned into the genre of horror, which, on a certain level, is fair, but it is so much more. It will be a slog for the short attention-span set, but worth every unsettling moment. Starring Jack Nance, one of Lynch’s personal ensemble favorites. ~Sarge

FLOW. Apple TV, PrimeTV. Movie (7.9 IMDb) *** “Flow” is a an amazing journey – animated with a small crew on open-source software, it is a personal exploration by animals in the wake of a global flood. A cat is joined by a capybara, a bird, a lemur, and a dog, as they explore the flooded world together on a boat. No dialogue, but actual animal voices in the soundtrack. A refreshing new animaed film, without the glossy signature stylings of Pixar or Dreamworks. We need more of this. Latvian, but it translates well. ~Sarge

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

BABYGIRL. In theaters. (6.6 IMDb) ** “Babygirl” aka “Nicole’s mid-to-late life crisis” feels false in so many ways, including, if not especially, the sound of her orgasms. A lot of reviews have focused on the exchange of power, particularly female empowerment because the traditional male-female age gap is turned on its head. I found the deeper message to be that no matter how successful a woman becomes, what she truly craves is to be objectified and bossed around by a man. Have 50 years of feminism and a powerful #metoo movement taken us nowhere? Kink part aside, her young buck gets abusive in other ways and she’s just there ready to forgive and forget and go another round. In real life she would have ended up alone with nothing in a studio apartment going to Sex Addicts Anonymous meetings. Besides being distracted by facial tweaks and procedures, I couldn’t help wondering what compelled Nicole to do this movie in the first place other than to show off her toned 57 year-old body while she can. Which begs the old adage, just because you can, doesn’t mean you should. ~Hillary

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

...

January 20, 2025

Housing Ballot Measure: Housing For Whom?

Signature gathering has begun for the City of Santa Cruz Workforce Housing Affordability Act. Supporters expect the ballot measure to be ready for the November 2025 election.

Under this Act, funds would be raised from each property in the City of Santa Cruz being taxed an extra $96 annually, with some exemptions, plus a transfer tax that would kick in on the sale of properties above $1.8 million. If passed by a simple majority, the money collected, expected to be around $5 million a year, would go into the City’s Affordable Housing Trust Fund.

At first glance, this ballot measure appears easy to support. Other than those who oppose any new taxes, who could be against affordable workforce housing? Except that “workforce” as used in the ballot measure is merely feel-good jargon, without substance.

Evidence for this is found in the Definitions section 3.34.010 (b) which states: “Affordable and Workforce Housing” shall mean housing that is affordable for extremely low, very low, low and moderate-income households.” Note the absence of reference to the word “workforce”. According to the ballot measure’s definition, this housing will be available for those qualifying at the stated income categories, whether in the city or not, whether workers or not. Despite its name, the ballot measure is not earmarked for workers. The term “workforce” appears added as a marketing ploy.

Wait, I hear the promoters’ objection; look under the section (c) Eligible uses. 9, which states: “Santa Cruz residents and workers, and veterans shall have priority for obtaining housing units, to the extent allowed by law.” Well, we have some evidence about this “priority” business with respect to inclusionary housing and the evidence is not encouraging.

The Civil Grand Jury of 2023-24 released nine investigative reports, one of which is titled, Housing For Whom? An Investigation of Inclusionary Housing in the City of Santa Cruz. Full transparency, I was one of the nineteen jurors for that year.

For Inclusionary Housing, that percentage of housing a developer is required to offer at below market rate, the City’s Municipal Code has similar required priorities for residents and local workers. The Grand Jury investigated to determine whether such priorities are being applied, if and how the city tracks the data and what percentage, if any, of such housing is occupied by UCSC students.

The Grand Jury Investigation determined that the city has no data on whether the required priorities are being followed. As a result of this investigation, the Grand Jury made four Recommendations to the city to remedy this lack of data. The city declined to adopt any of the Grand Jury’s Recommendations. They either disagreed with the Findings-all exhaustively documented- or misleadingly stated the issue was already resolved when it clearly was not. In their rationale for not gathering data on resident or worker qualifications for inclusionary housing the city claimed such data gathering would be an invasion of privacy, an asinine excuse given the copious personal information required to prove income eligibility and the fact that such information is not publicly available.

Because this housing ballot measure includes no data gathering tool to determine whether the new tax will benefit locals, and the “workforce” as the promoters claim, one can conclude it’s a crap shoot. Because the tax will be levied only on city property owners, but the housing may be occupied by non-city residents, your vote is worth thoughtful consideration.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
More battery storage in Watsonville?

With Moss Landing fire still smoldering, a large battery bank storage facility in Watsonville…thanks to former Supervisor McPherson.

Well, here is the first of the three projects that Planning Dept. staff vaguely referred to as “projects we have heard about” in their presentation. Many thanks to my friend, Al, who sent me this information.

Battery Storage Near Watsonville [Lookout article]

“The 14-acre scale project is being developed by New Leaf Energy, a renewable energy developer based in Lowell, Massachusetts. It’s planned for a site in an unincorporated area of Santa Cruz County on Minto Road, near Green Valley Road, next to a Pacific Gas & Electric transmission substation.”

Last August, then-Fifth District County Supervisor Bruce McPherson tried to rush through approvals of four large parcels in the County for rezoning to accommodate hypothetical battery storage facilities.  Planning Dept. staff stated that the projects were news to them, and would need at least six months to determine necessary environmental evaluations and make staff reports.  “How about by mid October?” was McPherson’s response.  Sure enough, by mid October, the item was back on the agenda and staff had recommendations to approve three sites.  It seems that one of the four original sites proposed was within Scotts Valley City limits where the County has no jurisdiction.

Then-Second District Supervisor Zach Friend opposed converting farmland into industrial use, reminding the Board that Measure J prohibited them from doing such.

That did not stop McPherson, nor the others from voting 4:1 in favor of establishing these large battery facilities on ag land, near residences and near Aptos High School.

The battery energy storage system is expected to help reduce the chance of power outages in Santa Cruz County and provide renewable energy to the existing power grid and increase its reliability, said Max Christian, project lead for New Leaf Energy. The project’s estimated cost is $200 million.

The system is planned to have a capacity of 200 megawatts — enough power to support up to 200,000 homes for up to four hours, in its current design. Changes can be made to the battery’s design before construction even begins, as technology is always changing, said Christian.”

The battery storage system has an estimated 20-year lifespan and will collect its electricity via solar power during the day, to be stored and fed back into the grid during peak hours.

The battery energy storage system will be located on a locally owned apple orchard on Minto Road, he said; the project will be built on part of the orchard where the soil is not viable for planting apple trees. Christian said the rest of the property will still be used by the family who owns it. 

The project could bring the county up to $50 million in economic benefits during its 20-year lifespan, largely from property and sales tax revenue, said Christian. The development of the project will increase the amount of property tax paid for the land, and the county will also receive revenue from development fees and the transfer tax from the land sale.

The project first started development in 2019, said Christian, and projects like this one have a long process. A permit application was submitted to the county’s planning department in December, and Christian anticipates the project will go in front of county supervisors later this year. 

The anticipated construction date is set for 2027, he said, and the battery energy storage system will not begin to operate until 2029.

At the time of this writing, yet another massive fire has happened at the Moss Landing battery storage facility and large areas were evacuated… Will this be the picture of what is to come at the Green Valley site in Watsonville…and Aptos…and Santa Cruz?  Stay tuned.

Seahawk Energy Storage

What the fire industry is saying….Hundreds evacuate as Calif. Li-ion battery plant, one of the world’s largest, burns

Please watch this expert video, describing the need for changes in warehouse-style battery energy storage sites and demand Santa Cruz County adopt new codes to ensure updated technology that prioritizes public and environmental safety.

Disaster at Moss Landing: The Risk of Battery Storage

On January 21, the Monterey County Board of Supervisors held an emergency Special Meeting.  Vistra claimed there was no problem with air quality following the fire, and yet has no idea when cleanup will begin.  The emergency response plans required by the State to be submitted to the local emergency response agencies seem to be missing, showing non-compliance of SB 38 (Laird).

Did you get a notice from CruzAware to stay inside with doors and windows closed during this fire?  I did…in the Aptos Hills.  Imagine what would happen if such a fire were to occur at any of the three Battery Energy Storage Sites Supervisors McPherson and Hernandez shoved through on October 29, 2024.

Please contact your County Board of Supervisors, 831-454-2200

YET ANOTHER UGLY HIGH-RISE IN SANTA CRUZ
Recently, Novin developers got approval to build the 831 Water Street project that will be five stories tall and one massive building.  Now the City Planning Commission approved a Workbench developer project that will be a block away, and six stories tall.  This is an historic neighborhood, known as Villa de Branciforte, but the massive unimaginative giant boxes keep getting approved, with no nod whatsoever for blending in with the character of the neighborhood.

Water St. housing proposal advances

A six-story, 83-unit housing complex is proposed on the 900 block of Water Street in Santa Cruz. (Natalya Dreszer — Santa Cruz Local file)

The Santa Cruz Planning Commission on Jan. 9 unanimously advanced plans for a six-story, 83-unit housing complex on the 900 block of Water Street in Santa Cruz.

All the homes are expected to be rented below market rate. Representatives from Santa Cruz-based developer Workbench said the units will be one-, two- and three-bedrooms from 532 to 953 square feet. The ground floor is anticipated to have commercial space and an outdoor patio for a potential restaurant.

The project initially was proposed with four stories and more than 100 units, but it was made taller with fewer units.
—Stephen Baxter

An October plan revision called for six stories rather than four on the 900 block of Water Street. (Workbench)

PARK PLACE HOMEKEY PROJECT SEEMS STALLED
The controversial Homekey Project at 2838 Park Avenue is stalled.  According to Supervisor Manu Koenig, the project is over-budget, and needs additional funding.


This project was built in modules somewhere else and transported here, claiming the cost was very low.  I wonder how many local jobs got bypassed in doing so?
Stay tuned.

MIDTOWN BUSINESS TAX?
Santa Cruz City Economic Development staff and consultant team recently held two workshops for businesses and property owners in the Midtown/Eastside neighborhood to provide an update determining the feasibility of a Property-Based Improvement District (PBID) and gather additional feedback.  Ms. Katie Ferraro lead the workshops on behalf of the City.

She kindly sent the information below about what residents and businesses can expect going forward. The City Council will review it January 23, along with a review of the Downtown Economic Plan.

It appears to be scheduled as a benefit assessment and Prop. 218 vote, likely weighted so that those whose assessments would be highest will have more power at the ballot box:

IMPLEMENTATION PHASE

January 2025:

  • Final MDP and Engineer’s Report upon City review
  • Prepare petitions and petition packets to include Management District Plan
  • Summary, PBID newsletter, official petition, and petition instructions
  • City Council Study Session – Status Update

February 2025:

  • Petition kick-off (allow 3 months)

April 2025:

  • City Council approves Resolution of Intention and calls for public hearing;
  • Assessment ballots mailed to all assessed property owners

June 2025:

  • City Council public hearing, tabulate ballots (45 days later)

This sums up alot….

“Development in the pipeline and currently in construction is
rapidly changing our physical environment downtown. As more than 1200 housing units are
absorbed into the downtown community over the course of the next five years, we will need to
regularly revisit circulation, parking use, and consumer and transportation behavior as needs in
our downtown core change.”

(page 6 of the City Council agenda report)

Here is information about a Downtown PBID

Do you think this will help businesses or add just one more financial burden?

ISN’T THIS UGLY???
The PureWater Soquel Project Advanced Water Treatment Facility is built but not operational.  Located next to the new Chanticleer Pedestrian Overcrossing in Live Oak, the plant will store many hazardous chemicals necessary for treating the sewage water before sending it a couple more miles away to be pressure injected into the aquifer supplying drinking water for the Aptos and Capitola area residents.

When the Project was approved in 2018, Soquel Creek Water District promised the tanks and structures would be shielded from view by lovely trees and vines.  Take a look at what the reality is of this ugly blight in the Live Oak Community and view shed of Highway One…and the Chanticleer Overcrossing users.


The Board of Directors still has not addressed the ugly site, even though they formed an ad hoc committee months ago to evaluate the mess and make recommendations to improve the aesthetic quality of the facility.  See what the Soquel Creek Water District promised the public on pages 26, 44, 52, 56 and 67

What would you suggest the Ad Hoc Committee recommend to address this visual blight they have caused in the disadvantaged Live Oak Community???

NO CHICKENS OR COWS AT THE COUNTY FAIR THIS YEAR?
Recently, the California State Veterinarian and Governor Newsom issued an edict banning all exhibits of poultry and beef in the State indefinitely.  This comes as a result of some cases of Avian Influenza in the state.

This caused a large and very popular Gold Coast Poultry Show in Hollister at Bolado Park to be scratched at the last minute.

What would have hosted over 1,000 different breeds of chickens, ducks, turkeys and geese from throughout the west coast was instead barren.

The question remains….how will this affect the 2025 Santa Cruz County Fair?

State Veterinarian Bans All California Poultry and Dairy Cattle Exhibitions at Fairs and Shows [pdf]

HONORING ALVERDA ORLANDO
Last month, Ms. Alverda Orlando passed away.  She loved local history, especially Davenport’s, and worked hard to help preserve it.

I had the great honor of meeting Ms. Alverda Orlando when she served on the County Historic Resources Commission.  She and I sat together at a County History Fair one time with a display of information about the Davenport Jail.  We both had great fun watching people smile when I placed the original iron bars from the Jail on my lap and begged people to help me escape.  Alverda edited the “Lime Kiln Chronicles” and recorded many interviews with Davenport’s historic characters:

Santa Cruz County Public Librabry search, Alberta Orlando

Santa Cruz Sentinel Obituary, Alverda Orlando
At her memorial last weekend, it was wonderful to see so many from the Community gather to honor her.  I am very glad to know that her daughter, Lucia, now serves on the County Historic Resources Commission.

Please join me in lighting a candle for Alverda, and her family.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ASK SANTA CRUZ COUNTY SUPERVISORS WHAT THEY WOULD DO IF A BATTERY ENERGY STORAGE SITE THEY HAVE APPROVED WERE TO CATCH FIRE, SUCH AS WHAT HAS JUST HAPPENED IN MOSS LANDING.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
First Bloom, Maritime Chaparral

The ridgeline expanse of chaparral lay dormant, wafting resinous scents, clicking and crackling as the morning sun’s first rays dried the maroon, shredding bark strands which hang peeling from the skin-smooth twisty manzanita trunks. Through the late summer and fall, each day brought the same routine, sometimes hotter days, sometimes nights bringing fog, dripping and awakening lichen which festoon branches and carpet the ground, nestled into lichens and patches of rabbit poop. Then, the rain came, soaking the rocky ground. Now, months later, maritime chaparral awakens with its first bloom.

Frost and Petal Snow
Today, on the early morning drive to the trailhead we encountered huge white, slippery frost patches along the spine of Ben Lomond Mountain where Empire Grade bisects high chaparral, towering oak forest, and miles of burned conifer trunks. We were off to Big Basin not for lingering in the recovering redwood forest as much as to spend time in the warmth of chaparral. Once on the trail, my cheeks and nose were numb with cold, as we descended from magnificent wet old growth forest onto drier rocky ocean view ridges with a different type of snow…petalfall.

The 3 types of manzanitas at Big Basin and Butano State Park have already been blooming for a month. The best show is from a shrub that only grows in the southern part of the Santa Cruz mountains, but there are two other species of manzanita also flowering. The woodland edge manzanita, a species that can get 20’ tall, is aptly called Santa Cruz manzanita; it gets large clusters of obviously pinkish flowers. Glossy leaf manzanita with its small dark green boxwood-like leaves form the neatest of dense bushes with tiny white flowers. Giant woody burls of brittle leaf manzanita send out much less organized clusters of trunks, intertwining with other shrubs to add to the branchy complexity of impenetrable scrubland. In the chill shade below manzanita bush canopies, a carpet of white…the snow of spent blossoms covers moss mats and gravelly barrens.

More Unfolding
The manzanitas are first, but other chaparral shrubs are also awakening. We saw the first dusty, dark blue flower clusters of the pine-scented, warty-leaved wild lilac. Milk maid’s simple four petaled flowers adorned the trailsides where we walked along with the very first boisterous redwood sorrel blossoms emerging from a lush carpet of shamrock leaves. I look forward to hiking in chaparral in a month or so, when there will be an even more impressive profusion of flowers.

Next: Flowering Hillsides
We will soon encounter the 5th spring after the 2020 CZU Lightning Complex Fire, and the burned hillsides promise a Big Show. First up in the pageant: blue blossom, or wild lilac. They have just begun, but in 6 weeks there will be thousands of acres of sky blue flowers covering 10’ tall glossy leaved shrub-trees. Fire-following bush poppies are next, in June: 2” wide, cheery yellow flowers smiling from the startling silvery blue-green canopies of six foot tall leggy shrubs. Magenta flowering and very poky chaparral pea, twisty white flowers of twining wild morning glory, and white spikes of chamise. For more than half the year, maritime chaparral is a colorful show with patches of yellows, splashes of blue, rafts of white and pink, and dots of red set in cushions of diverse blue-green mounds of shrubs, sometimes towered over by occasional pines or redwoods.

Misplaced Scorn, Not Enough Love
These shrubby ecosystems are being disrespected (again) right now, but we should show them more love. News and talk shows about the fires in southern California frequently include scorn of the shrubby landscape which carries fire so fiercely. ‘Control that vegetation!’ some say. ‘Cut down those shrubs!’ others exclaim. At the top of Loma Prieta, cell phone tower owners mow down many acres of the most beautiful chaparral. Even local parks have started destroying chaparral along trails and fire roads. Few note that no matter how much energy you put into messing up that habitat, what comes up will still be flammable, and probably badly so.

On the other hand, chaparral blankets and protects the poorest of soils allowing rain to replenish the groundwater. In places where humans have tried hard to convert chaparral to something else, they manage to create a terrible weedy patch – fine fuels that carry fire fast. And, in those places, the hillsides give way in heavy rains and fill streams with sediment, creating flooding and debris flow problems.  Where these amazingly drought tolerant chaparral shrubs are given a chance, they hold incredibly steep poor soils in place allowing rainfall to soak in without landslides.

Now, Go!
If you can find some time to spend with chaparral, try taking a few trips to the same place in the next few months to watch the flower display change and unfold. Those ridges in Butano and Big Basin State Parks are great chaparral displays. Summit Road near Loma Prieta is also quite nice. Despite fuels management and long intervals without fire, some patches of chaparral persist in Wilder Ranch and in/around Nisene Marks, both State Parks. Montara Mountain in San Mateo County is my favorite chaparral trekking location…amazing views, too.

When you go to these places, here are some questions for the trip:

  • How many Ceanothus, aka blue blossom or wild lilac, do you see? Is there variation in flower color? What’s your favorite?
  • What kind of rock is the chaparral anchored into? Do you see any soil? How do these shrubs get water?
  • How long has it been since there was a fire in that patch of chaparral? Is there a lot of dead fuel build up? Are there young or old pines, which might indicate how old the stand is?
  • Is the chaparral well managed by people? Are invasive plants under control or spreading? Are the roads and trails eroding or well maintained? Are the nearby houses, power lines, and roads sensitively integrated into the system?

After your return from your chaparral tour, please keep this conversation alive. Talk to your friends and family about chaparral. Read more about it. Vote as if chaparral mattered: political candidates should have opinions about how to protect rare habitats given the constant onslaught of poor human behavior.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, January 20, 2025

Today, as our presidency changes hands, I am reprinting, in full, an Opinion Editorial that ran in The San Jose Mercury News on November 10, 2024. The headline on that article read, in part, “Local Government Does Work.”

I was a local government official in Santa Cruz County for twenty years. I am, thus, speaking from personal experience when I tell you that Cindy Chavez (pictured above), who wrote that editorial statement, is absolutely right. Chavez served as an elected official on both the San Jose City Council and on the Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors.

After the election of Donald J. Trump to the presidency, last November, professors and pundits were putting out statements like the following: The End of US Democracy Was All Too Predictable. You can click that link if you’d like to see what I had to say about that statement.

Anyone worried about the future of our democracy (and we should all be worried, I believe) can do something about that worry – something meaningful – by immediately engaging themselves actively and aggressively with their local government. Take it over! Make it work for you!

This prescription is not an invitation to waste your time. Believe what Cindy Chavez has said. You can take it from me:

Local Government Does Work

Cindy Chavez: A message as I leave office — local government does work

Words from departing politician after 20 years on the San Jose City Council and Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors

Having spent two decades in elected office at the city and county level in Santa Clara County, I have learned something about the relationship between government and the people — something I feel a need and an obligation to share as I leave office.

Local government can work responsively and pragmatically. We can make a dent in local, national and global problems in our own way. We can tackle our troubles and concerns and tap into our community’s vitality.

Consider the COVID-19 pandemic, a catastrophe that left many feeling powerless and touched all corners of our planet. County residents wanted and needed medical care, vaccines, information, transportation and more. Those needs were manifested throughout our county of 2 million people. Our county administration and Public Health Department led on this issue and set the response standard for the rest of the nation.

Other examples came six years ago, when O’Conner and St. Louise hospitals had to be sold, and this year, when Regional Medical Center initiated cutbacks in stroke care and other critical services. These were private sector issues; we could have easily just thrown up our hands and let community assets go by the wayside.

Instead, community members organized and called for preserving these essential health services. The county responded by purchasing O’Connor and St. Louise. The purchase of Regional Medical Center is in the works, with services expected to be restored in the future. Plain and simple, these purchases saved lives and will save many more.

What is it about local government that allows it to uniquely produce such achievements? I believe it results from democracy at the local level.

Local government is accessible and has direct interactions. It isn’t hard for residents to speak at City Hall or the county Board of Supervisors’ chambers, in person or virtually.

Local government is open and governed by the Brown Act and the Public Records Act to make sure business is done where residents can see it happen.

Local public officials listen. Even if they are being told what they don’t want to hear, they try to respond. That’s because most local officials represent relatively small districts, cities or towns. Disgruntled residents can organize to replace them. Successful recalls do happen.

Local government is pragmatic. We focus on issues that may not rile up the left or right wings of politics or result in much castle intrigue. Building libraries, paving streets, operating 911 systems or responding to medical emergency calls induces officials to concentrate on reality, not rhetoric.

All these hallmarks of local government empower us to institute change and make an impact, whereas we might feel powerless at the state and national level. Change here can serve as a template and inspiration for greater change at higher levels of government.

Days after the national election, there’s plenty to be gloomy about. I understand. But after 20 years serving you in Santa Clara County, I’m convinced local government is a strong and vital pillar supporting American democracy.

It deserves your continuing energy and support, even if we are disappointed with it some of the time. It will never be easy. Democratic government challenges our wisdom, our patience and our sense of fairness.

That local relationship between elected officials and the governed, like all relationships, has times of stress and turmoil. And like the other great relationships of our lives, it’s worth it.

Cindy Chavez served on the San Jose City Council from 1998-2006 and has served on the Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors since 2013. She will step down on Tuesday and begin her new job as county manager of Bernalillo County, N.M., the following day.

Originally Published: November 9, 2024 at 5:15 AM PST

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
VENGEFUL CAESAR, ALTERNATIVE FACTS, SPICEY REDUX?

President Joe Biden was given a sendoff by Saturday Night Live’s Weekend Update with Colin Jost saying, “President Biden said that the Israel-Hamas ceasefire talks were one of the toughest negotiations he had ever experienced. The hardest part was convincing both sides that he was still president.” Jost’s co-host, Michael Che, reported that Biden, after delivering his farewell address from the Oval Office“triumphantly rode off into the pavement,” showing older footage of him crashing his bike. Che added, “Biden defended his administration’s accomplishments by ending every sentence with, ‘You ungrateful bastards.'” Taking a potshot at incoming Donald Trump, Jost’s reaction to the newly released official inaugural portrait, a scowling takeoff on his Georgia booking photo, offered, “Trump is trying to look so hardcore in this photo, I’m surprised he didn’t add a parental advisory sticker and a durag.”

The Biden administration recently announced that the president had commuted the sentences of about 1,500 people, with pardons of 39 individuals convicted of crimes such as drug offenses. These acts follow the earlier pardon of his son, Hunter, which stirred quite a controversy. On his show, Stephen Colbert commented, “Wow! I didn’t know he had 39 sons. That’s impressive. What Biden did today is the largest single-day act of clemency in modern history. I believe that is an emphatic and generous act of forgiveness and hope. That will be knocked out of the headlines as soon as Trump threatens to bomb Manila because he cut himself on one of their envelopes. You know that’s coming.”

James Carville in a video interview for Politicon says President Biden is the “most tragic” political figure of his lifetime, not because he pardoned Hunter, but because his dropping from his presidential candidacy came too late for Democrats to put together a competitive race against Trump. “I actually feel for Biden,” he said, knowing full well that he spoiled Harris‘ chances. “He wasn’t crooked, he didn’t pursue bad policies, he is the most tolerant, loving, caring, non-prejudiced person you can imagine, and this is what he’s faced with,” Carville remarked. Biden’s pledges to run for reelection and not to interfere in his son’s legal cases, both reversed, lead Carville to believe Biden’s wavering resulted in the Democratic loss despite a strong and admirable race. Unconcerned about Hunter being let off the hook, Carville rationalized the act by saying, “Ok, everybody’s going to do whatever they’re gonna do with their own children.” But he goes on to say that had Joe made his announcement to drop out several months earlier, the election result would have been different, arguing, “And it wouldn’t have been that close because we would’ve had so many talented frickin’ people running.” After which, he maintains, Biden could have left the White House “on a high note” as “the toast of Washington,” having landmarks named after him, with a future Democratic president pardoning Hunter.

“What’s so sad is it didn’t have to be this way. He brought it all on himself. All of this is self-inflicted. It’s tragic, it’s sad, and of course everything about him is…it’ll be six years before somebody comes back and talks about all of the stunning things Biden accomplished.” Carville’s deep respect for Biden made the election result even more devastating for him, and though he had predicted an unequivocal win for Harris/Walz, he admitted that the lack of primaries left many Democrats feeling they had been co-opted. MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell, last week on his The Last Word show, had an exclusive interview with the outgoing president, where he complemented Biden on his many accomplishments, many having received little fanfare during his tenure. To his regret, Biden admits he did “too little politicking” in communicating his achievements, while expressing his concerns about democracy as we move into the Trump regime.

Steve Schmidt writes on his The Warning blog, “The American people are fickle, and soon the majority will bear the economic, security and moral consequences of their vote.” He regrets that two long years await us before voters can cast ballots for or against the MAGA dominated governance. Schmidt sees Trump stepping into the Oval Office as a “political colossus, an angry, vengeful Caesar, who will tear down America’s institutions that have been in effect since FDR.” He points to MAGA as “a propaganda machine that depicted the most powerful nation in world history as a rotten hells cape, immoral, corrupt, failing and occupied by an ‘enemy within.'” This machine prevailed because it is stronger, more powerful and better funded than anything that exists in opposition, that has been building for 30 years to bring about a different America. Schmidt doesn’t hold back about Trump, pronouncing him as being a chilling choice of the voters, who is a man-child who has never worked an hour in his life, never succeeded at anything, whose life is a tabloid joke, and is as ignorant about the world as a person could conceivably be, a father who indulges his children in order of their nitwittery.

Schmidt decries the impending cruelty of MAGA in their handling of migrants, and Trump’s ‘zero tolerance’ family separation policy — the cruelty being a permanent feature of MAGA culture. He maintains that MAGA has not been shy regarding its declarations that ‘might makes right,’ ‘the strong inherit the Earth,’ and ‘the rich have a right to rule over their lessers’ — as long as they are obedient to Donald Trump. Schmidt adds, “Donald Trump is going to create the most extreme and servile administration in history. It will be utterly lawless. It is going to smash every institution, collective security agreement and scientific agency it can. The first year of the Trump presidency will seed the catastrophe to come. At first the people will cheer, but then it will start to slip away each day. Trump will be undone by his overreach, arrogance and insecurities. Musk and Vance will destabilize the administration, and bring it to its tip-over point at a rapid pace. Trump has the ball, and it’s of the wrecking variety. He intends to use it.” He concludes, “Donald Trump is writing our future. It’s what we chose as a country. What a shameful act. The price will be immense.”

Economist Paul Krugman predicted on ‘The Daily Blast’ podcast, “A lot of people” who voted for Trump “are going to get brutally scammed” upon Trump’s return to the Oval Office, when he enacts his “really radical” and “terrible” economic policies. Raising tariffs and cutting taxes on high income earners will batter the working class, and the deportation of millions of immigrants will have an even worse effect on the economy. There are no Wall Street “heavyweights” to “steer him away” from his destructive instincts to redistribute income, and small business owners who are “the most fervent MAGA types out there” will suffer, just as small local businesses have been targeted for scams throughout Trump’s business career by not getting paid for their work.

So why do Republicans fall so quickly for ‘information’ that simply isn’t true? A problem with reality is that it’s just a bridge too far? Henry Morgan posted on Quora that the 1976 presidential election loss to a peanut farmer rocked their very souls, which led them to use focus group studies to put them on a winning track. The result was a decision to divide the country along the lines of religion, switching from fiscal conservatives to religious conservatives, fundamentally changing the nature of the party from a pragmatic group of people searching for workable solutions to the country’s problems. This new faith community believed the most important issues to Republicans were group loyalty and shared belief. A group centered on its beliefs as opposed to its goals quickly finds it is difficult to change beliefs if the facts don’t line up, and in particular if the beliefs are wrapped in religion — handed down by God! Solution? ‘Alternative facts’ — beliefs are important, facts are less so. The party was more willing to create facts that align with their beliefs, and then believing those ‘facts.’ Morgan calls this ‘cowardice,’ predicting ever worse disasters for the country, because policy has to align with real facts. Beliefs are not terribly important in politics — facts and aligned policies need to be the focus. The religious right has changed the way people discuss positions, with the Trump cult being an extension of this — con men making a profession of manipulating voters through their feelings and beliefs, with half the country under the spell of an imbecile. In conclusion, Morgan tells Republicans to remember that ‘whataboutism‘ is simply an indication that you are wrong, without a leg to stand on!

A few weeks ago, Stephen Colbert brought attention to what he called Donald Trump’s “farm-team of far-right weirdos” who are vying for attention in hopes of gaining a spot in his administration. One wannabe is ultra-conservative Christian nationalist, Oklahoma Education Superintendent Ryan Walters who has made headlines for attempting to push Christianity into the state’s classrooms, mandating Bibles be placed into classrooms along with lessons. Colbert said, “Yes, because Bibles always make places more holy. That’s why only wholesome stuff happens in motels.” Responding to news that Superintendent Walters was also demanding that students watch a video of himself praying for Trump, Colbert said, “OK, that’s a weird thing to force public school kids to watch. But you know what? I pray. I’ll even pray for Donald Trump right now,” and clasping his hands together, bowing his head, he asked, “Dear Lord. Do you know Donald Trump? God, help us.” In his monologue, Colbert pointed out that a paperback Bible can be purchased for $1.99, and that Walters spent “a whopping $60 apiece” on Trump Bibles, using money from the state treasury.

It is rumored that Trump will take the oath of office on one of his Trump Bibles — never hurts to do a bit of free telemarketing when you have a captive audience of billions. Perhaps the Bible, the guitar, the tennis shoes, the watches, and NFTs are old hat by now with market saturation, but never fear! Last week he announced a new grift by releasing a new meme coin. He TRUMPeted on social media, “My NEW Official Trump Meme is HERE! It’s time to celebrate everything we stand for: WINNING! Join my very special Trump Community. GET YOUR $TRUMP NOW. Have fun!” Republicans Against Trump immediately posted: “You’re nothing but a shameless grifter. Truly pathetic.” The coin features an image drawn from the July assassination attempt, blurring the line between his government role and the continued effort of his family to profit from his power and global fame. Getting into the game, Melania announced her $Melania coin later. This is simply a sign that the Trump Crime Family will be less hesitant in his second term to bend or breach traditional ethical boundaries, in particular because this coin is issued as cryptocurrency, which is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Anybody willing to take them to court on this? Probably not, since it was disclosed that he intends to name cryptocurrency advocate, Paul Atkins, to the SEC chairmanship.

President-elect Trump was royally roasted across social media after announcing that his inauguration would be moved indoors due to “very cold weather,” expected to be the coldest inauguration day in 40 years according to ABC News. Trump was eager to show a photo of the weather forecast, minus any suspicious black Sharpie marks, and revealing that “various dignitaries and guests” will be “brought into the Capitol,” adding, “This will be a very beautiful experience for all, and especially for the large TV audience.” Social media commenters pointed out that previous inaugurations took place outside in equally frigid weather, and that Trump was more fearful of a low turnout as in 2017, when Sean ‘Spicey’ Spicer had to cover for low crowd size without benefit of a black Sharpie. Political strategist David Axelrod pointed at Trump’s age as being a factor, but another responder added, “For an administration all about tough guy culture, they certainly don’t seem that tough. Guess he fears his cult followers won’t be that dedicated and that his hair will get messed up with a hat.” Minnesota Governor Tim Walz trolled by posting a photo of himself covered in snow flurries, writing, “There’s no such thing as bad weather, just bad clothing.” It should be noted that Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman wore shorts, sneakers and a hooded sweatshirt, viewing Trump’s swearing-in ceremony from the front row of seats. Good clothing for the event! An out-of-country poster speculated that Trump didn’t wish to be cold, but with hotel bookings at a record low, the attendance was going to be pathetic. Trump also predicted a turnout of 200,000 to 600,000 to watch the inaugural parade, to be held indoors (in a venue that holds 20,000!), and it will be embarrassing to hear him make excuses for those unable to attend as he touts unprecedented ratings for online and TV viewers. This poster says other presidents have held ceremonies in the cold, but then other presidents have been mostly honorable men, with Trump being the most objectionable, unpresidential creature to squat in the Oval Office, and while the world laughs at Trump, there is grieving for the US.

Melania attracted much attention for her Inaugural Day outfit — a dark navy coat, matching navy hat with a white stripe, dark navy heels and black gloves. The hat drew the most attention, some calling it “stunning” and “classy.” Others were quick to point out that the first lady resembled the McDonald’s Hamburglar character, minus the mask. Another asked, “Why is she dressed like Michael Jackson? She looks Smooth Criminal era Michael Jackson at a funeral.” A VP Harris supporter added, “Melania is in mourning today. Four more years stuck next to this clown!”

Satirical writer Andy Borowitz in his The Borowitz Report says: “In an eleventh-hour decision on Sunday, the Inauguration of Donald J. Trump has been moved from the Capitol Rotunda to the interior of a Tesla Cybertruck. The change of venue, dictated by Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), means that only people with a net worth of over $100 billion will be able to attend. “There’s room for me, Zuckerberg, and Bezos, but, unfortunately, no JD Vance,” Musk said. “I usually don’t let employees work remotely, but JD will be allowed to call in.” The decision to hold the inauguration inside the electric vehicle pleased Trump, who estimated the number of people inside the truck at 4 million.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Resistance

“Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear, not absence of fear.”
~Mark Twain

“I shall earnestly and persistently continue to urge all women to the practical recognition of the old Revolutionary maxim. Resistance to tyranny is obedience to God.”
~Susan B. Anthony

“To fly we have to have resistance.”
~Maya Lin

“The intensity of the pain depends on the degree of resistance to the present moment.”
~Eckhart Tolle

“Whatever you resist you become. If you resist anger, you are always angry. If you resist sadness, you are always sad. If you resist suffering, you are always suffering. If you resist confusion, you are always confused. We think that we resist certain states because they are there, but actually they are there because we resist them.”
~Adyashanti

...

Peacful jellyfish… just set this to full screen and breathe for a bit…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.
Email: webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)
...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 15 – 21, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on Downtown Plan Extension DEIR… Steinbruner… off this week … Hayes… Cattle Grazing on Public Lands … Patton… Artificial Sweetener … Matlock… calling a bluff…51 and counting…neither more nor less… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… A glacier guide’s story Quotes on… “Inauguration”

...

FISHING ON THE SAN LORENZO. December 8, 1940. This was on the opening of Steelhead Season (remember steelhead?). It’s at Murray Street on East Cliff Drive

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: January 15, 2025

STILL BURNING. The unimaginable reality of 25 people killed, 82,000 still evacuated, 90,000 under threat of evacuation, and 45 acres burned is hard to wrap your head around. In the Palisades and Eaton fires alone, some 12,000 structures have been destroyed, and containment is at 22% and 55% respectively. Firefighters and first responders are working tirelessly, as are volunteers, community members, and total strangers. It will be a long time before there is such a thing as “life as usual” in Los Angeles. I was thinking just the other day about what the long-term and wide-spread effects of all this are going to be. It’s not just the people that owned and lived in those houses and ran those businesses, it’s the entire human ecology around them that is disrupted. Imagine being a real estate agent in LA now… or a landscaper, or a handyman, or a sanitation worker. I saw an article stating that close to 30,000 students were affected by these fires. It’s just incomprehensible.

HELPING LA. While they are in need of donations of all sorts (people have lost ev-e-ry-thing after all), following the impulse to load up the car and drive down there is not that great of an idea. In fact, when there are disasters, well meaning “civilians” are often a hindrance as opposed to the help they want to be. If you feel moved to give to SoCal (and you should, if you can), please coordinate with some form of already ongoing relief effort. Here’s an article on KQED on How to Help People Affected by the LA Fires, containing links and useful information. Here’s something I learned that I did not know – if you have a GoFundMe that specifies that the money will be used for relief (like house repairs, funeral expenses, etc) from a natural disaster, then you can not receive funds from FEMA for that same disaster. That’s a good thing to know! Also, be leery of fundraising scammers. Sadly, these “digital looters” pop up around natural disasters.

...

STAR WARS: SKELETON CREW. Disney+ series (7.2 IMDb) *** It’s refreshing when a big franchise realizes they’ve created a universe big enough to tell other stories (look at Star Trek Lower Decks – a successful animated comedy entrenched deeply in the Star Trek Universe), and that’s what Skeleton Crew does for Star Wars. A quartet of children, chafing at the bureaucratic cloister of their homeworld, stumble on a crashed spaceship and find themselves launched into the rough and tumble Star Wars Universe. Using a rough “Treasure Island” plotline, there’s space piracy aplenty: Jude Law’s character is referred to as Cap’n Silvo (nod to Long John Silver from Treasure Island) and the ship’s yarr-voiced droid is SM-33 (Smee was Captain Hook’s first mate in Peter Pan). Good for adults and children (though not TOO young – plenty of life-taking and intense scenes). ~Sarge

NIGHTBITCH. Hulu movie (5.6 IMDb) *** This film is ideal for husbands and fathers, capturing the mix of profound and bullshit (and profound again) moments in a woman’s journey from being a successful artist to new motherhood. What begins as a seemingly supernatural plot evolves into a raw, magical realist exploration of the chaos and sacrifice of motherhood and identity. It’s a subjective, visceral experience, navigating the emotional and (literal) physical mess of this transformative stage. ~Sarge

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

BABYGIRL. In theaters. (6.6 IMDb) ** “Babygirl” aka “Nicole’s mid-to-late life crisis” feels false in so many ways, including, if not especially, the sound of her orgasms. A lot of reviews have focused on the exchange of power, particularly female empowerment because the traditional male-female age gap is turned on its head. I found the deeper message to be that no matter how successful a woman becomes, what she truly craves is to be objectified and bossed around by a man. Have 50 years of feminism and a powerful #metoo movement taken us nowhere? Kink part aside, her young buck gets abusive in other ways and she’s just there ready to forgive and forget and go another round. In real life she would have ended up alone with nothing in a studio apartment going to Sex Addicts Anonymous meetings. Besides being distracted by facial tweaks and procedures, I couldn’t help wondering what compelled Nicole to do this movie in the first place other than to show off her toned 57 year-old body while she can. Which begs the old adage, just because you can, doesn’t mean you should. ~Hillary

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

...

January 13, 2025

Downtown Plan Extension Draft (and bogus) Environmental Impact Report

The long-awaited draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) for the proposed Downtown Plan Extension has been released. The deadline for you to submit comments is February 21.

This proposed extension of the downtown area is the most massive development ever in the city of Santa Cruz. It swallows up an existing small neighborhood, displacing its residents. It encompasses Front Street where the current Warriors Arena is located, Center and Cedar Sts. and extends to the first roundabout for a total of twenty-nine acres. The Plan includes the addition of 1,600 to 1,800 new housing units and 60,000 square feet of new commercial space. A new arena for the Santa Cruz Warriors is a key feature.

When this plan was first publicly floated by the city Planning Department it had new building heights as high as twenty stories. For comparison, the above photo of the new building currently under construction on Front St. is seven stories. While city council attempted to cap building heights in this Downtown Plan Extension at twelve stories, we now know that there can be no height limit imposed on new construction that takes advantage of the State Density Bonus. And what savvy investor in the lucrative Santa Cruz real-estate market wouldn’t take advantage of this state-imposed power grab of local control?

The Plan area sits smack dab in the middle of tourist traffic heading to and from the Boardwalk, Wharf, and beach area and the lower westside neighborhood traffic heading to and from downtown and the Eastside. Given that knowledge, a valid DEIR would carefully study the congestion impact on current traffic from the expected additional traffic of renters in the new 1,600 housing units, plus their guests plus their deliveries, plus the traffic to and from the 60,000 square feet of new commercial, plus the traffic to and from the new Warriors Arena/Entertainment Center. Such a study would predictably have concluded significant impacts and mitigations could have been proposed. I can think of a few.

However, there is no such study in this DEIR under Transportation Section 14. The DEIR concludes there is no significant impact from traffic and therefore no Mitigation Measures required.

How do the consultants manage to arrive at this absurd conclusion? Partly by deciding to study only VMT or Vehicle Miles Traveled and omit Congestion from the study. This limited focus is allowed under CEQA however additional study of congestion is allowed if a particular project warrants it. If ever there was a project that cried out for a study of congestion rather than VMT, this is it. The city should have required such a study. Input into the Scoping meeting for the project from members of the public specifically asked that such a study be done. Ignored. So, the fact that the three miles between Laurel St. and your home on the lower westside, or to the Wharf or to the beach which now takes fifteen minutes will take up to an hour or longer once this project is built is a non-issue for the city and its CEQA consultants.  Before the project and after the project are the same three miles, including for ambulances and other emergency vehicles. No significant issue found.

The other avenue the consultants use to arrive at a no significant issue conclusion is via misleading information. Under Analytical Method 14.4.2, page 14-7 they describe the “Construction of a new arena with a slightly higher capacity than currently exists” to assess its impacts. The existing arena is 35,000 square feet with a seating capacity of 2,500. The new arena is proposed to be 180,000 square feet with a seating capacity up to 4,000 with anticipated year-round events. That difference is not a “slightly higher capacity.” Describing it as such signals that this is a DEIR designed to achieve the result the city wants, not designed to objectively study the environmental impacts of this mammoth transformative project.

I have read only the Transportation section. Further reading may reveal other sections similarly manipulated. Our city government has a history of producing environmental documents that violate the law (Wharf Master Plan) or not preparing environmental documents when they are required (Save Our Big Trees.)

If this EIR process follows that pattern, if public comments are further invalidated and if not corrected by a city council vote, the only recourse the public has is to file a lawsuit. Then the city will blame you for holding up the Warriors games and delaying the provision of more housing.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

Becky’s taking this week off, but she’ll be back!

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS, HOLDING OFFICIALS ACCOUNTABLE.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY DOING JUST ONE THING.

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Cattle Grazing on Public Lands

Last week’s negotiated settlement at Point Reyes National Seashore is the latest example of how controversy over cattle grazing on public land gets resolved. The polarity is typical. On one ‘side’ are ranchers, their families and workers, and the broad community that supports family farms, local agriculture, and organic or nowadays regenerative agriculture. On the other ‘side’ are environmentalists, pro-species, pro-clean water, pro-wildlife, and anti-livestock where there’s profit on public lands. The battle at Point Reyes is just one in this war across the U.S. West, and it has been going on for decades. At least at Point Reyes, the two sides don’t neatly align in the expected ways between the two mainstream political parties. Why did it get so bad at Point Reyes that legal action and tens of millions of dollars were needed to settle the issues? Could this kind of thing occur on public lands closer to the Monterey Bay? Let’s look closer to see.

The Vast Gulf

Conflicts with recreation, water quality concerns, and impacts on native plant and wildlife species are the issues most commonly raised when there are concerns about cattle grazing on public land. And, there is good science to support the value of carefully planned cattle grazing to reduce wildfire impacts while promoting native plant and wildlife conservation. In addition to these types of issues, there are pro- and anti- cattle advocates out there, on one hand in support of agriculture or cute critters for children to adore; and, on the other hand, wanting only native animals on the land or against meat eating, methane producing, and otherwise cruel corporate cattle corporations.

Radical Center

There are many of us who are experiencing the beauty of collaboration between livestock managers and conservationists: we are achieving more emergent success than anyone thought possible 30 years ago. Chief among these collaborative networks’ concerns has been development and sprawl…greed that replaces private ranches with housing tracks and shopping malls. In California, we also have shared concerns about the vitality of ranching economics, water provision, wildlife conservation, and catastrophic wildfire. Each of these issues has seen progress because a respectful, trusting network keeps showing up and working together. It takes everyone who has an interest in land management to create innovative solutions: ranchers, conservationists, researchers, land managers, regulatory agencies, community members, resource advisors and consultants, and planners. But, each of these groups has unique interests, different languages, different cultures. We get past these differences by gathering together and learning from one another in well planned, moderated dialogues. The Quivira Coalition is the first group I know to start these discussions, and many followed. The Central Coast Rangeland Coalition (CCRC) is working on this stuff locally, and is celebrating its 20th Anniversary in 2025. I copy here the pledge from the Quivira Coalitions website (link above), a pledge that mirrors the work of other groups like the CCRC:

“We pledge our efforts to form the ‘Radical Center’ where:

  • The ranching community accepts and aspires to a progressively higher standard of environmental performance;
  • The environmental community resolves to work constructively with the people who occupy and use the lands it would protect;
  • The personnel of federal and state land management agencies focus not on the defense of procedure but on the production of tangible results;
  • The research community strives to make their work more relevant to broader constituencies;
  • The land grant colleges return to their original charters, conducting and disseminating information in ways that benefit local landscapes and the communities that depend on them;
  • The consumer buys food that strengthens the bond between their own health and the health of the land;
  • The public recognizes and rewards those who maintain and improve the health of all land; and
  • All participants learn better how to share both authority and responsibility.”

Who is Showing Up, Who is Not

Where do you see cows on public land; how is it working; how do you know? There are cattle grazing on Midpeninsula Open Space, Santa Clara Open Space, State Parks (Pacheco State Park), BLM (Ft. Ord, Cotoni Coast Dairies), POST, and on City of Santa Cruz (Moore Creek, Arana Gulch). Of these, MidPen, POST, and Santa Clara regularly show up to work with the CCRC. I believe that these are the organizations that are most apt to succeed and least likely to end up in the terrible situations that Point Reyes has been experiencing. Why do some show up and not others? I suggest that the third bullet is as important as the next-to-last. It takes the oversight agency’s interest in results as well as the public’s engagement to nudge public land managers to the table.

My Experience at Point Reyes

I am an unabashed native plant conservationist, have researched and visited coastal prairie habitat at Point Reyes for many years, and I have NOT been impressed. Two of the science papers that got me started on my doctoral research were from Point Reyes. One told the story of a rare wildflower that was protected to death when cattle grazing was removed from its wetland habitat. The other illustrated how another rare wildflower thrived because of an appropriate cattle grazing regime. I consequently surveyed across fencelines at Point Reyes and found native annual wildflowers to be more diverse and abundant on the cattle grazed side of the fence, as opposed to the side where grazing had been excluded. In fact, I found the very rare San Francisco Owl’s clover in abundance in the areas with, and not so much without, cattle grazing. I have subsequently made many returns to Point Reyes to learn about what is going on. During one field trip, I found out that the cattle ranchers and park managers had only the most rudimentary ability to discuss a topic that had long been a priority, common interest: the encroachment of brush onto coastal prairies. During another excursion to explore the health of the very endangered Point Reyes Horkelia, park employees indicated that not only did they not have any data to share about the health of this species, but also that I was not permitted to monitor the species without extensive paperwork, even in areas open and easily accessible to the public (see bullet point above, re: defense of procedure vs. production of results). Nevertheless, I found that the cattle grazing regime had hammered nearly to obliteration this rare species whereas adjoining cattle excluded areas still had a few individuals which were on the verge of being obliterated by weeds, especially iceplant, a species that is relatively easy to eradicate in such instances where it is a local threat to an endangered species. I’m sure that the cattle rancher had no idea about rare species and I’m sure that the Park employees had never considered talking to the rancher about its conservation. In my experience, such communication is essential to improved success.

Where From Here?

Reflecting on my experience at Point Reyes, I am unsurprised about the recent outcome, but I am undeterred to keep helping the Central Coast Rangeland Coalition avoid such unproductive mayhem wherever possible. I challenge the Bureau of Land Management, State Parks, the City of Santa Cruz, and all other land stewardship entities to take the above pledge, joining constructive dialogues that demonstrate success at taking care of our lands. And, I challenge everyone else who is reading this to take the portion of the pledge that applies to you. I especially challenge the “Conservation Architects” (you know who you are)…including those who think highly of the concept of a “Great Park” designed to encompass most of the Santa Cruz Mountains…to now doubly consider what kind of baby-sitting federal agencies need to achieve conservation success. Together, we can make a difference. But, we need the principles of Radical Center-based collaboration (as articulated above) to take root in all places before we will see the harvests we so desperately need.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, January 13, 2025

On November 9, 2024, The New York Times published a “Letter To The Editor” from Julia Lee. You can read her letter, below. Lee was reacting to an article that documented how one teenager’s involvement with an “artificial” companion took him to suicide.

“Artificial” relationships are, by definition, not “real.” Online “sweeties” are fake!

Can we find a way to renew our commitment to the “real world”?

We need to do that!

I keep putting it this way, “Find Some Friends“!

Real ones, that is. Artificial sweeteners are bad for our health!

oooOOOooo

To the Editor:

Kevin Roose highlights the danger of A.I. companions worsening isolation by replacing human relationships with artificial ones. I agree that while these apps may offer entertainment and support, they also risk deepening loneliness by diminishing one’s ability to engage in real social interactions.

As a high school student, I have friends who rely on Character.AI to help them cope with loneliness. The tragic case of Sewell Setzer III shows how these platforms can draw teens away from real-life connections and proper mental health resources.

To better understand the risks, I visited the website Sewell had been associated with, only to find that on the topic of mental health, I saw no warnings or links to professional assistance.

Alarmingly, the A.I. is presented as an expert and even claims to be human, deceiving users with humanlike traits such as sarcasm and humor. We need stricter safety measures to prevent harm, especially to younger users.

Julia Lee
Fairfax, Va.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
PANA-MAGA CANAL, HOUSE OF DELUSIONS, FUNNY/NOT FUNNY THREE RINGER

Nations ’round the globe are perking up their collective ears with Trump’s spouting off about his territorial expansion wishes, prompting Seth Meyers on his The Late Night show to throw in a few comments regarding Greenland, which Trump has been eyeing since his first term. Meyers goaded Trump with, “I’d like to say something to Donald Trump about his threat to take Greenland by military force that might take some of our viewers by surprise — DO IT!” Continuing his encouragement to Trump, he said, “Go get Greenland, you coward…don’t show me your face ever again…I’m calling your bluff. Stop making these crazy promises. Do it. I want it. Go get it.” In a taunting tone, Meyers added, “Why won’t you get it? You afraid of Denmark, bro? You starting to remember they got those big-ass dogs,” as he showed a picture of a tough-looking Great Dane. Meyers joked that Trump will “keep downgrading” his threats to “smaller and smaller countries,” predicting that “Russia’s going to do whatever it wants while he threatens Peru with, ‘We’re coming. We’re going to get Macchu Picchu back where it belongs.'” To Trump’s suggestion that NHL legend Wayne Gretzky should be Canada’s new Prime Minister, Meyers argued, “I think Trump picked Gretzky because that’s the only Canadian he knows,” suggesting that Trump probably wants the Prime Minister to Ireland be the Lucky Charms mascot. Many readers were delighted when The New York Post ran a front page cartoon of Trump using a pointer on a world map with a renamed Greenland as ‘Our Land,’ Canada as ’51st State,’ the Gulf of Mexico as ‘Gulf of America,’ and the Panama Canal as ‘Pana-MAGA Canal.’

What started as the MAGA-in-Chief’s calamitously ignorant, and incredibly exorbitant 25% tariff threats to our allies has degraded into his hazardous expansionist dreams. Canada was quick to defy his bullying over a new tax policy proposal. Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau immediately became a target for Trump who called him “Governor Trudeau” with a suggestion that Canada become the US’s 51st state. Trudeau had been under tremendous pressure to resign, and after deputy prime minister Freeland resigned under protest, and with concerns over Trump’s tariff increases threat, the calls for him to step down became too overwhelming for him to ignore, so he made his announcement to resign. Immediately, Trump launched into posts on Truth Social, proclaiming what a great nation could result from a US/Canada merger, with no tariffs, reduced taxes, and security from Russian and Chinese threats. Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene proclaimed Donald Trump as ‘Canada’s liberator,’ accusing Trudeau of “tyrannical COVID abuse, destroying free speech, and being Zelenskyii’s biggest cheerleader. Trudeau RESIGNS!”

Elizabeth May, a Green Party member of Canada’s Parliament, recently held a news conference where she voiced a hard “NO…thanks, but no thanks,” to Trump’s proposal for Canadian statehood, citing his “monumental ignorance” of Canadian politics and the five different parties in their “sovereign nation,” which, by the way, has no need for “braggarts, bullies, or dictators.” “No one runs for Prime Minister in Canada!” she emphasized, referring to Trump’s Wayne Gretzky plug, and suggesting he borrow one of his grandchildren’s school books to brush up on his history. She proposed that perhaps CaliforniaOregon and Washington might care to join their provinces where they have universal health care, safe streets, gun laws, and where women have health rights which are going by the wayside in the US…and that perhaps a Province of Vermont could be included? Also, no ‘Go Fund Me’ posts needed to rescue patients denied medical care by greedy insurance companies! May emphasized that the two countries, who have been good friends and allies, should continue to be trading partners, not combatants, since Canadian goods are a bargain for the US, based on the current exchange rates of their respective dollars, and that perhaps Trump might even prefer they join the EU! May goes on to say that if The Don’s 51st state proposal was a joke, it failed miserably, and that Trump is not acting as a president-elect should conduct himself with his disrespectful comments, and that she, for one, will not throw Mexico under his bus!

Trump has also used his threat to impose 25% tariffs on imports from Mexico unless that country stops migrants and drugs from crossing into the US, suggesting that they are not currently cooperating to do so…a total lie particularly aimed at US voters. Mexico’s President Sheinbaum responded sharply with her claim that American gun trafficking to her country is fueling crime and violence among gangs who smuggle drugs into US markets. She noted, “Tragically, it is in our country that lives are lost to the violence resulting from meeting the drug demands in yours.” Sheinbaum suggests that the two nations’ interrelated national challenges underscore the need for cross-border cooperation rather than Trump’s insults and confrontational attitude. She uses US statistics to make her point that border crossings are down, since Mexico is acting to prevent travel across their own southern border, thwarting migrants who want to head to the US…hardly an “invasion” as Trump is claiming. As reported in both The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal, the Mexican government security operations shuttle migrants back to the south and away from our border in what they call ‘El Carrousel.’ Experts see President Biden’s efforts at cracking down on illegal crossings as succeeding greater than any past efforts, all without tariffs.

However, Trump and his MAGA gang are ignoring the success, pretending nothing is being accomplished, while scamming behind the smokescreen of denial, a swindle that is focused on tariffs. Arianna Huffington wrote back in 2000 in her book ‘How to Overthrow the Government,’ “Our political landscape is so littered with duplicity and deceit, we’ve actually come to expect our leaders to lie. What once would have shocked us now barely registers. We’ve become inured to wrongdoing. So politicians mangle the truth — call it ‘spin’ — and the public lets it slide, too numb to care…it’s because, even though we don’t like it, we don’t consider it really damaging. Spinning sounds cute, almost constructive…something that should engender indulgent smiles rather than outrage.” Huffington said it should be termed ‘propaganda’ where the propagandist succeeds by claiming to be nothing more than the humble mouthpiece of ‘the people.’ The more the public is duped, the more its deceivers can claim to express the public’s will which only brings forth an orgy of euphemisms. “Humpty Dumpty would have been right a home,” Huffington declares, “when he told Alice, ‘When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.”

Greg Sargent writes in The New Republic“All this paves the way for larger deceptions later. Bank on it: The moment Trump takes office, the lower apprehension numbers will magically become real metrics. Fox News will start trumpeting them and he’ll start claiming the border has achieved pacification due to his strength. Indeed, Trump very well may credit his current threat of tariffs with ‘forcing’ Mexico to make the lower numbers of border crossings a reality.” During a recent conversation between Trump and Sheinbaum, she explained to him Mexico’s strategy to address the migration phenomenon, observing human rights, while not closing the border but instead building bridges between government and people. But we find Trump crowing that she agreed to close the border, taking credit for something in which he hasn’t even been a participant. No need to let a troublesome thing like ‘reality’ get in the way of building a house of delusions, eh?

Brad Reed writes in Raw Story that some MAGAs are eager to start launching military operations inside Mexico to take out drug cartel leaders, though experts believe it would do little to stop the supply of drugs coming into the US. Mexico has found this approach to be a failure, which only started an explosion of violence within the cartel, so killing off capos within the gangs is not new, only a failed strategy. One military veteran declared the strategy as being, “Iraq all over again. We’re not fighting an army. We’re fighting poverty. Let’s fight desperation. Let’s fight hopelessness. That sounds a whole lot like what we did in Afghanistan for 20 years unsuccessfully.”

During his 1976 campaign for US Senator from CaliforniaSamuel Hayakawa said of the proposed transfer of the Panama Canal from the US to Panama“We should keep the Panama Canal. After all, we stole it fair and square.” It should be noted that a few years later, Senator Hayakawa helped win approval for the transfer; but now we find that president-elect Trump is railing for a reversal of the ownership. Trump feels the Canal authority is charging “exorbitant prices and rates of passage” on US naval and merchant ships, demanding that fees either be lowered, or give it back to this country. The US is the canal’s biggest customer and Trump’s fear is that the passage is in danger of falling under China’s control as the second-biggest customer. Failing to get much attention is the outstanding tax evasion case against Trump, Trump Panama Hotel Management LLC, and Trump International Hotels who are accused of not paying the required 12.5% tax rate to the Panamanian government. The lawsuit alleges the companies kept the money, “intentionally evading taxes” and leaving the new owner liable for millions. According to Malcolm Ferguson in The New Republic, a tax audit of the hotels submitted as evidence found massive inconsistencies in the case still pending in New York District Court. In 2018, Panamanian officials stepped in, stripping the Trump name from the Trump Ocean Club International Hotel and Tower.

Co-president-elect Musk, donning his own global expansionist/interference cloak, is asking whether the US should “liberate the people of Britain from their tyrannical government” as he launched into a series of X posts to call for the release of a jailed right-wing activist, and the imprisonment of a junior minister of the Labour government. The Tesla head-honcho is calling for the jailing of Jess Phillips, a member of Prime Minister Starmer’s cabinet, calling her a “rape genocide apologist” over her handling of investigations into organized gangs accused of systematic rape of young women. The Labour government says it is focused on enacting recommendations of a 2022 study, which were not implemented by the previous Conservative government, as Starmer rebukes Musk for grandstanding, taking advantage of an “utterly sickening issue” for his own advantage: “Those who are spreading lies and misinformation as far and wide as possible are not interested in victims, they’re interested in themselves.” A propagandist — neither more nor less?

Musk has spoken out for Islamophobic fascist activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, who goes by his pseudonym, Tommy Robinson. Robinson, a member of the fascist British National Party was convicted of mortgage fraud and assault for stalking a female journalist at her residence, and is now serving 18 months in prison for repeating false allegations against a Syrian refugee. Musk disagrees with his incarceration, but MAGA-lover Nigel Farage of Britain’s right-wing Reform Party can’t abide Robinson. Farage’s outspokenness spurred Musk to call for his ouster as Reform Party leader. A few weeks ago, Musk meddled in German politics, endorsing the far-right Alternative für Deutschland party, to which Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre in an interview said he finds it “worrying that a man with enormous access to social media and large financial resources is so directly involved in the internal affairs of other countries.” So, it’s destined to be a complete Barnum & Bailey three-ringer — who’s next?

Dr. Jo posts on Quora that despite Trump’s appointment of a lot of real clowns to his cabinet, creating the most dangerous circus in the history of the world, it’s not a circus…not even close. To wit: appearance and apparent clumsiness hide the fact that real circus clowns are capable and competent; circus acts are carefully scripted; circuses have rules and mechanisms for safety. Trump has initiated a reality show, with supporters who have yet to cope with his narcissism, as he sees the whole of reality as reality TV, himself being the hero, consequently, many of his selections are sycophantic Fox News presenters. But, however self-indulgent, it’s not totally a reality show which can be arbitrary and bizarre, with many people behind the scenes to capture and edit any bad things before damage control is needed. In Trump 2.0, we find that the safety nets are absent, wild animals are free to roam, emergency exits are blocked, fire hazards are acute…equipment wasn’t checked because nobody cares, appointees/performers are hardly competent…existing just for show — the competent ones have left or are about to leave, or will be fired by Musk, and no script…which is done daily upon the whims of Trump.

Dr. Jo concludes, however, that the reality show is funny…or will be funny when the “legion of spiteful, vindictive” Trumpers in the crowd realize what is really happening. Sooner, rather than later, almost everyone who voted for Trumpy McTrumpface will be quite surprised. They are currently sharing in the reality-impaired delusion…until they get a drubbing. Repeatedly, the US will be managed into the ground, just like Twitter X, until there is nothing left of value, except that anything of value will be in the pockets of Trump and his gang. Time to grab your peanuts, popcorn and cotton candy and watch from afar, preferably from a parallel universe, because it ain’t gonna be pretty.

TV host Stephen Colbert on The Late Show last week, reported that President Biden was in California“doing what presidents should do: pledging federal disaster support to a stricken state.” At a press conference, Biden also announced that he was officially the first sitting president to become a great-grandfather, as is eldest granddaughter gave birth to a baby boy. “And with under two weeks left, there’s still time for Joe to set more old-man presidential records,” Colbert suggested, such as “most Malt-o-Meals consumed at 4 a.m., most rubber bands collected in an old cigar box, first president ever to fall asleep at a picnic and be carried away by ants.” As Nietzsche asked, “Is not life a hundred times too short for us to bore ourselves?”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Inauguration

“Nothing valuable can be lost by taking time. If there be an object to hurry any of you in hot haste to a step which you would never take deliberately, that object will be frustrated by taking time; but no good object can be frustrated by it.”
~Abraham Lincoln

“Much has been given us, and much will rightfully be expected from us. We have duties to others and duties to ourselves; and we can shirk neither.”
~Theodore Roosevelt

“Old truths have been relearned; untruths have been unlearned. We have always known that heedless self-interest was bad morals; we know now that it is bad economics.”
~Franklin Delano Roosevelt

“Only by helping the least fortunate of its members to help themselves can the human family achieve the decent, satisfying life that is the right of all people.”
~Harry S. Truman

“Ask not what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country.”
John F. Kennedy

...

The Moth has some fascinating stories…


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.
Email: webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)
...

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 8 – 14, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on the Wharf Reopening… Steinbruner… Sewage sludge, desal, or brackish water conversion… Hayes… What’s in the air… Patton… A Force For World Peace… Matlock… certification…banana republicanism…hilarity…gravitas… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… Pseudoscience Support… Quotes on… “Wildfires”

...

COOPER AND FRONT STREETS.This was taken after 1866 when the Hall of Records went down. It was also before 1882 when the Octagon was built and became our Hall of Records. Note the City Jail, now MAH, isn’t up yet and the Red Ball hasn’t arrived. Watch this space.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: January 8, 2025

SOCAL BURNING. Los Angeles is in flames, and there will not be any containment until the winds die down. There are five fires, and entire neighborhoods have been obliterated. “Only” five deaths have been reported so far, but obviously that number could go up. Evacuation orders are in place for thousands of people, and the chaos is just unimaginable. My heart goes out to all the people – and wildlife – affected by these fires. If you feel moved to help, the American Red Cross is the organization that Jamie Lee Curtis recommends. She was just on the Tonight Show where she mentioned this as she was talking about her neighborhood burning.

As for us here in Santa Cruz County… if you have a house, do you have a defensible perimeter around it? Have you cut back trees, trimmed bushes, made sure your house isn’t surrounded by piles of burnable materials? If the answer is no, then you might want to think about that. That, and packing a bug-out bag to have on hand. It can happen so quickly.

MOVIE REVIEWERS. Please join me in welcoming our intrepid trio of movie reviewers: Hillary Bratton, Jennifer Bratton, and Jeffery (Sarge) Sargent! It seems fitting to me that we need three people to attempt to fill Bruce’s shoes, and I absolutely love that both his daughters have graciously agreed to take part. The first reviews are coming right up!

...

SMALL THINGS LIKE THESE. PrimeTV. (6.9 IMDb) *** A quietly ponderous Christmas tale set in a small town in Ireland in 1985 (swear to god it feels more like the 1940s…). Cillian Murphy plays a loving father and quietly likable coal delivery man, who comes into conflict with the steely “kind” Mother Superior (Emily Watson) of the local school and “Magdelene Laundry” for fallen girls. A bit of a slow walk, and as heartening as it could be, given the Laundries wouldn’t be eliminated till the mid 1990s. Excellent performances all around, particularlly given how little dialogue there was. ~Sarge

EMILIA PÉREZ. Netflix. (6.8 IMDb) ***- A musical for those who don’t like musicals. Emilia Pérez is a spectacular film with a compelling story. A ruthless drug cartel leader, Juan “Manitas” Del Monte (played by Karla Sofía Gascón), seeks the help of attorney Rita Mora Castro (played by Zoe Saldaña, who just won a golden globe) to undergo gender affirmation surgery and begin a new life as Emilia Pérez. However, things go awry when she invites her unsuspecting former wife Jessi (played by Selena Gomez) and her children to live with her. The musical numbers are strong and short. ~Jennifer

A COMPLETE UNKNOWN. In theaters. (7.8 IMDb) ****I don’t know what I can say about this movie that you haven’t heard from your friends or read about in social media or reviews. It’s one of best movies I’ve seen in a long, long time – and I’m not a fan of biopics, especially musical biopics, but this one is so well done! Although the director, James Mangold, did ‘Walk the Line’, the Johnny Cash movie with Joaquin Phoenix, and that was great too. Timothée Chalamet captures our vision of a young Dylan to a T. He’s an incredibly soulful actor, and Ed Norton as Pete Seeger is uncanny. They edited the songs down from their original versions, but they did in such a way that they never feel like they’re being yanked out from under you; it just makes you want to go and listen to the originals. My 25 year old son loved it too. Run, don’t walk, and believe all the hype because it’s true. ~Hillary

BABYGIRL. In theaters. (6.6 IMDb) ** “Babygirl” aka “Nicole’s mid-to-late life crisis” feels false in so many ways, including, if not especially, the sound of her orgasms. A lot of reviews have focused on the exchange of power, particularly female empowerment because the traditional male-female age gap is turned on its head. I found the deeper message to be that no matter how successful a woman becomes, what she truly craves is to be objectified and bossed around by a man. Have 50 years of feminism and a powerful #metoo movement taken us nowhere? Kink part aside, her young buck gets abusive in other ways and she’s just there ready to forgive and forget and go another round. In real life she would have ended up alone with nothing in a studio apartment going to Sex Addicts Anonymous meetings. Besides being distracted by facial tweaks and procedures, I couldn’t help wondering what compelled Nicole to do this movie in the first place other than to show off her toned 57 year-old body while she can. Which begs the old adage, just because you can, doesn’t mean you should. ~Hillary

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

...

Monday January 6, 2025

Wharf Reopening

The reopening of the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf on Saturday January 4th was good news for all, especially the workers. The sea lions’ barking competed with the dignitaries’ speeches which were short and positive in tone. There was no finger-pointing or scapegoating from those who spoke. That would come later.

Santa Cruz City Council member Scott Newsome, whose district includes the Wharf, spoke of “the character of a community that is revealed in times of crisis.”

He was referring to the positives. I’m experiencing the negatives. Both are part of the character of the community. The negatives are whipped up by scapegoating and social media. I was disappointed to see the Sentinel give a mouthpiece following the ceremony to Council member Renee Golder to further the finger pointing. Her statement in Sunday’s Sentinel that “the unfortunate impact of the litigation we were in was that it stopped some of the funding and some of the construction from happening that absolutely needed to happen” is just plain false. The lawsuit did not stop any funding. Maybe the city decided to not apply for funding to replace the pilings at the Wharf end but that is a different matter. Nor did the lawsuit stop “construction that needed to happen.” The only construction at the end of the Wharf that needed to happen was the replacement of the damaged pilings identified in 2014.  For some members of the community, these false accusations are as a red flag to a bull. They get stirred up and aggressive.

Social media is a platform for anyone who has a strong opinion based on limited, skewed or no facts. Their postings come with sarcasm, nastiness and sometimes threats. Don’t Morph the Wharf! is getting many hurled our way.

Perhaps the lowest was from someone who is impersonating the group, and particularly me, on X. He’s posted some nasty stuff, looking like it is coming from me. People re-post it, and it takes on a life of its own, amplified. Social media make dead fish seem almost quaint.

On the topic of misinformation, many people saw the CBS News Bay Area interview with the retired Wharf Supervisor who opined that the collapse of the end of the Wharf would never have happened had they been able to proceed with a 2013 Plan to strengthen the shear of the Wharf with an eastern and western walkway. He said they had a Plan plus funding ready to go in 2013 but were stopped by a CEQA lawsuit. No mention of the damaged pilings at the end of the Wharf. Nor that those walkways are a long way from the Wharf end.

Where to begin? First, there was no Plan in 2013. The Wharf Master Plan wasn’t on paper until 2014. Then, even with no lawsuit, any large project must go through proper environmental review and public hearings which can take years. It was six years before the Plan finally made it to City Council in 2020 prior to any legal challenge. There was no funding associated with the Plan.

Besides hyperbole, there’s factual inaccuracies. I met with the retired Wharf Supervisor early on, probably around 2016, bringing to his attention the concerns of many community members about the changes and additions proposed for the Wharf in the Wharf Master Plan. We had a pleasant discussion in his office where he showed me many historical photos and shared his vast experience of the Wharf. Towards the end of our conversation, I brought up the subject of the western walkway. He shared that it was an idea from a staff member of the Coastal Commission, that its inclusion was about increased public access and it could probably be removed from the Plan. I left feeling somewhat hopeful. The labelling of the western walkway as “essential” for Wharf stability came much later, after members of the public found problems with its inclusion.

Finally, it bears repeating that the context for the end of the Wharf’s collapse includes the city’s failure to replace documented damaged pilings requiring replacement since 2014. As for the work being done during the collapse, a legitimate question is, what was the quality of pile replacement work being done by the consulting engineering firm? Not pointing fingers; just asking an appropriate question.

A noticeable absence on the dais at the Wharf Reopening ceremony was the current Wharf supervisor. If there is to be an investigation, as surely there must be, maybe the city will ask the Wharf crew for their observations and conclusions. That would be far more productive than scapegoating community groups and regurgitating false narratives.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS MANAGER RESIGNS
Some in the know feel that Santa Cruz County Fairgrounds CEO Zeke Fraser was likely instructed by the State to resign “for health reasons”.  Apparently, other problematic CEO’s in the California Fair industry have also left quickly “for health reasons”, having received advice letters from the State.  The problems that came about under CEO Fraser’s watch were largely, in my opinion, due to his willingness to let those in charge of the Fairgrounds Foundation (Jeannie Kegebein) and Ag History Project (Dave Kegebein, former CEO who was fired after a State Audit), and a debacle involving Granite Construction dumping a mountain of soil  next to a creek from Highway One expansion.  The idea was to expand the parking lot, but went awry when State officials became aware of the unpermitted and unauthorized project.  CEO Fraser presented three different versions of the contract he supposedly had with Granite, yet claimed publicly he was unaware of what Granite was doing.  Hmmm….
 
The Press Release states that last year’s Fair was the most profitable ever.  I wonder how that can be known when CEO Fraser never publicly presented any financial accounting of the Fair to the Board or the Public?
 
Pajaronian: The Fairgrounds CEO resigns

Stay tuned to see who comes in the revolving door at the fairgrounds.  Purportedly, legal teams from the California Dept. of Food & Ag (DCFA) hand the Fair Board of Directors a short list of who they feel can step in as Interim CEO.  Do you know someone who would do a good job managing this gem that is critical for emergency sheltering as well as a great venue for events, and a County Fair that brings everyone together?  If so, please contact Michael Flores <michael.flores@cdfa.ca.gov>
 
DEVELOPERS LOBBYING TO PREVENT STRICTER REGULATIONS ON AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEALS FUNDED BY MUNICIPAL BONDS
Last year’s Santa Cruz County Grand Jury Report “Housing for Whom?” brought forth some shocking investigative information about the lack of Santa Cruz City’s tracking around affordable housing occupancy that was largely ignored by the City Council:

The City Municipal Code requires that local residents and workers in the City of Santa
Cruz who meet income eligibility requirements are given preference (priority) for
Inclusionary Housing. But is this happening?

The Grand Jury investigation determined that the City keeps no records, does no
tracking, gathers no data, and has no evidence to determine if preference is being given
to local residents and local workers when renting Inclusionary Housing units.

The City has conflicting and contradictory policies on whether Inclusionary Housing
applies to low, very low and extremely low income earners only, or whether moderate
income earners are also eligible. The City cannot state what percentage of the City’s
affordable housing is occupied by income-verified UCSC students.

Grand Jury Housing Report

I wonder if the County has the  same problem with data tracking regarding whether developers and non-profits who build and manage affordable housing projects for the County, thereby reaping the benefit of ZERO property tax payments on government-owned developments, are charging tenants a reduced rent reflecting this savings?
 
Apparently, this is a big problem in California, according to an investigation.
The report was published December 31, 2024, and revealed large sums of money developers spent to lobby legislators to stop laws that would tighten regulations about what “affordable” rents really can mean, and require developers and non-profits managing the units to potentially pay property taxes if the rents did not reflect the financial benefit of no property taxes paid to the municipalities.
 
Take a look at this excerpt:

Developers making millions from ‘affordable housing’ program lobbied California lawmakers to shut down regulation

“But the rents the developers charge also don’t abide by the same strict regulations as federally subsidized affordable housing. About half of the units at the 13 Northern California essential housing properties charge higher rents than comparable nearby market-rate buildings, the Bay Area News Group previously reported.

Meanwhile, for the 3,401 units across those properties, developers have collected $25 million in upfront fees and stand to make millions more in interest payments over the 30- to 40-year lifetime of the bonds. Another $48 million in fees has gone to the bankers and law firms that issue the bonds. Meanwhile, cities forfeit an annual $21 million in property taxes to support the program, though each city is meant to recoup property taxes lost at the end of the bond’s term, as the agency gives them an option to purchase or sell the property.

In 2022, the legislature proposed regulating these deals to ensure the rent discounts would be commensurate with the tax benefits the program received. Working with the California Housing Partnership, Assemblyman Chris Ward, a San Diego Democrat, introduced a bill, AB 1850, to establish stricter affordability standards and cap developers’ fees on the essential housing deals — what he hoped would prevent “abuse” by some for-profit players that “snookered” cities into giving up property taxes without delivering on middle-income housing promised.

Waterford and Catalyst hired top lobbyists to fight the bill — Catalyst Housing spent $186,565 to hire lobbyists at Actum, and Waterford spent $135,000 to hire lobbyists at Axiom Advisors, including Jason Kinney, a friend of Gov. Gavin Newsom, who attended an infamous 2020 dinner party at the French Laundry with the governor despite pandemic-era restrictions.

As AB 1850 went to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee for a second hearing, two votes were in play: Majority Leader Bob Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, and Sen. Anna Caballero, D-Merced, the committee’s chair. With Hertzberg not voting, Caballero cast the deciding vote that killed the bill.
 
Four months later, Caballero’s reelection campaign received $4,000 from a group that had never donated to her before: Waterford. In March 2023, they donated another $4,000.

But there are limits to that influence. In 2023, for example, essential housing came under a new threat when a county tax assessor in Southern California argued that moderate-income housing didn’t qualify for a property tax exemption and used an obscure provision of tax law to start billing Waterford, as well as some tenants, for taxes. Waterford fought back, saying that neither the company nor its tenants should foot the bill. If Waterford is forced to pay taxes, the company said, it will eat at the company’s profits to the point where the projects would be unfeasible.
 

Assemblyman Josh Lowenthal, a Democrat from Waterford’s home district in Long Beach who has received $50,000 from Waterford’s founders and their partners in campaign donations, introduced AB 2506, a bill to stop county assessors from charging tenants these taxes. A spokesperson for Lowenthal said in a statement that Waterford “was one of many stakeholders involved in discussions on this program,” among housing advocacy groups, tenants and county assessors.

Lowenthal later pulled the bill after it stalled in a committee where staff were highly critical of the precedent it would set.”

Please ask your County Supervisor about how Santa Cruz County tracks the rents of affordable housing projects here, and what tax breaks the agencies managing them receive:
Affordable Housing Project Tracker — Housing Santa Cruz County
 
I wonder how much money each Supervisor received from developers and housing non-profits during the last election?

Contact your Supervisor
 
WHEN WILL COUNTY UPDATE SUPERVISOR WEBSITE?
I hope the Board of Supervisor website is updated soon.  As of this writing, the website still shows the former Board member’s smiling faces and contact information.  Board of Supervisors  However, according to a social media post below by the new 5th District Supervisor, Monica Martinez, she and 2nd District Supervisor Kim DeSerpa were sworn in December 23, 2024. If that is true, I wonder why Supervisor Zach Friend and Bruce McPherson presided over the SPECIAL BOARD MEETING on December 27 to declare a state of emergency regarding storm damage?

“Yesterday was an unforgettable day as I was sworn in by Assemblymember Gail Pellerin, alongside Supervisor Kim DeSerpa of District 2. Having my children by my side reminded me why this work matters so much—for their future and for every family in our community.

It’s an incredible honor to serve as your 5th District Supervisor, and I’m filled with gratitude for the trust you’ve placed in me. I’m ready to get to work, listen, and lead with compassion and determination. Together, we will make a difference.”  Monica Martinez  12/24/2024

AUDITOR URGES BETTER ACCOUNTABILITY
Two years ago, the State Auditor determined that the State’s Housing & Community Development (HCD) had used questionable data and methods to calculate the new round of the State’s housing mandates, known as Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA).

RHNA Audit Background Paper
 
Now, the State Auditor is finding other departments have serious weaknesses in their methods and financial reports as well.

[California State Auditor urges departments to tighten accounting controls]
 
Ask your elected representatives to follow up on this and require better financial accountability and transparency.

Contact:

 
WHY NOT USE BRACKISH DESAL INSTEAD OF SEWAGE WATER?
The City of Antioch will soon begin operations at a brackish desalination plant that will produce 5,500 AcreFeet of drinking water for the residents.   Couldn’t the same sort of project be used in areas of the County using brackish wells near the Bay, or even near the mouth of the San Lorenzo River where summer water tables rise so high that brackish water flows out of streetlight electrical boxes?  [Antioch brackish desalination plant set to begin operations]

Take a look at what Antioch is doing:
 
Antioch Brackish Water Desalination Project
Brackish Water Desalination Facility Project
 
Wouldn’t it make sense to use brackish water, rather than sewage water, as a supplemental water source?  I think so, in addition to increasing surface water runoff.  While both require energy-intensive reverse-osmosis, using treated sewage water adds a high-level dependency on hazardous chemicals and the unknown long-term health impacts on vulnerable segments of the population because not all contaminants can be removed completely. Who knows what the cumulative impacts of injecting nitrate, chloride, DEET, Ibuprofen, sucralose and a host of other chemicals that are known to persist in these treated waters. 
 
Soquel Creek Water District’s PureWater Soquel is set to start injecting treated sewage water into the MidCounty area aquifer in April.  Write the Board with your thoughts:
Soquel Creek Water District Board of Directors <bod@soquelcreekwater.org> and copy the Clerk of the Board, Emma Western <emmaw@soquelcreekwater.org>.
 
In Monterey County, two such similar projects have been proposed.   Deep Water Desal and CalAm’s Brackish Well Project in Marina.  Regulations and litigation have stalled both, Deep Water Desal has been stalled by changes in ocean water intake permitting, and may be either studying methods to eliminate harm, or examining subsurface intake, but the project still seems active:

[DeepWater Desal General Information]
[Deepwater Desal has long been out of the public eye, but expect that to change in 2018.]
  
CalAm Water wants to build a new brackish well desalination in Marina but has met with resistance from the City of Marina.
 
Purportedly, Sand City has had a brackish desal plant since 2010, the first of such in California:

Sand City Coastal desalination plant

Sand City Coastal Desalination Plant in Monterey County was the first full-scale brackish seawater desalination facility in the state of California.  It became operational in May 2010 and can produce 268,000 gallons/day (300 acre-feet/year)

Status of desalination plants in California
 
The plant supplies more than enough water for the needs of the City:
Sand City Desalination

Current General Manager of Soquel Creek Water District, Ms. Melanie Mow-Schumacher, actually worked at Deep Water Desal for a short time before returning to the golden halls of the District. I wonder why?
 
SEWAGE SLUDGE CONTAMINATES FARMLAND WITH CARCINOGENIC PFAS
Where does the City take it?  The Central Valley?  According to many reports now emerging, farmland where sewage sludge has been applied as a fertilizer are now contaminated with the “forever carcinogen” PFAS. and the farms must now idle, due to contamination.
 
Forever chemicals tainting food supply, destroying American farmers

New York Times article (paywall)

I forwarded this information to the County Water Advisory Commission.  One Commissioner who has shown great interest replied with a recommendation to watch the movie Dark Waters; a 2019 American legal thriller film, directed by Todd Haynes and written by Mario Correa and Matthew Michael Carnahan. The story dramatizes Robert Bilott’s case against the chemical manufacturing corporation DuPont after they contaminated a town with unregulated chemicals.”

2,700 ACRE RANCH GIFTED TO UC REGENTS FOR UCSC RESEARCH AND EDUCATION
Since 2013, the UC Regents have been considering a gift of the 2,700-acre Strathearn Ranch in San Benito County.  The transfer finally happened last November, complete with an endowment fund of $7-$10 million for operational costs and improvement. 

UC Santa Cruz announces a new 2,400-acre UC Reserve after Regents approval
 
“Consisting of 2,700 acres of real property located at Tres Pinos, San Benito County, California, Strathearn Ranch is a bequest under the Lee Von Hasseln Living Trust (the “Living Trust”) that requires the Regents to establish the Strathearn Ranch Reserve as a separate reserve under the UCNRS within 12 months after the donor’s death, which occurred in January 2024.”

DESIGNATION OF THE STRATHEARN RANCH RESERVE (SAN BENITO COUNTY) INTO THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA NATURAL RESERVE SYSTEM
 
The UC Regents  Study Committee had anticipated annual operational costs could be $550,000 annually. (see page 9)
 
I wonder what the UCSC researchers and students will study, and how the students in K-12 will be folded into the educational experience?

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND ASK QUESTIONS, HOLDING OFFICIALS ACCOUNTABLE.

MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY DOING JUST ONE THING.

Cheers,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
What’s In the Air?

Have you heard the question “What’s in the water?” I’ve encountered that question recently posed in the context of a situation when odd, inexplicable things had been happening at an organization. Then, new, seemingly fresh and rational personnel are hired, but those people quickly seem just as odd and inexplicable, less fresh and innovative and then things just stay the same kind of weird. How can that possibly happen?! And we exclaim, “What’s in the water?” It’s as if people are being medicated through their drinking water into a kind of sub-par state of being. “They drank the Kool-Aid” is another way of saying that same thing, I guess, except less innocuously referencing a terrible tragedy in South America some time ago. Judging by the amount of filtered water, bottled water, and such that people purchase, it does seem as if we are very, very concerned about what is in our water. What about the air? What’s in our air?

The Direction of the Wind
In my daily routine, each time I walk outside I try to pay attention to the wind. Which way is the wind headed? I feel the breeze on my skin or watch the swaying of the grass and trees. I tilt my body until I face straight into it, to know best the precise direction. Ialso ask how is the wind blowing right where I am versus farther away? Sometimes the wind is gentle close but raging nearby, on higher ground, where trees ‘talk’ and sway.

The directions of the wind can be predictable, but it is becoming less so. Winds around the Monterey Bay are often from the north or northwest, mainly cool breezes. Winter storms especially sweep in with gales from the northwest. Bomb cyclones come from that way. Atmospheric rivers tilt the direction more from the west. Especially cold storms come more from the north. Once the breeze starts coming from those other two ways, things get weird.

The downslope, Santa Ana winds of southern California (aka devil winds) make things really weird to our south. Those winds are from the east and can be very strong; fires rage, people freak out. Luckily, that phenomenon doesn’t happen here, but we do get occasional winds from the east. I swear I can smell the desert on those winds, the smell of creosote bush. Those breezes are warm and dry just like the winds from the south. I can very well recall the stormy winds from the south: those brought us the CZU Lightning Complex Fire as well as a couple other tattered hurricane remnants that created havoc across the state. When winds come from the south or east, beware of fire and keep your eye out for the odd human behavior associated with Santa Ana winds in southern California. We might also be concerned about the better-documented situation where those breezes carry the spores of fungi that cause Valley Fever, an air quality concern…borne on the wind as they say.

Air Quality
Once you recognize the direction from which the wind blows, the next question becomes what is that air carrying? When the wind blows ‘just right’ (from the northeast), we get a nasty soup of smog hanging out to sea, blown out of the Golden Gate and then generally downcoast where you get to appreciate that the Bay keeps us a bit sheltered and inland from those toxic breezes. Northeast winds are rare, but that smog carries lots of ugly chemistry. There’s stuff you don’t want to breathe for its toxicity, but there is also lots of fertilizer from car exhaust. Catalytic converters do a good job of turning exhaust into readily available nitrogen compounds that are fertilizing the landscape. Healthy? Nay. Fertilizer makes habitats more weedy, weeds grow bigger and make a bigger wildfire danger when they dry. The tall weeds outcompete native wildflowers. Fires carried by those weeds are devastating California’s deserts, endangering things like Joshua trees. The Golden Gate (NE wind) is one of our passages for nitrogen-laced air pollution, the other is the Pajaro Valley, belching out smog pushed by the more northerly breezes passing down through the southern end of the Silicon Valley.

Those ‘Fresh’ Westerlies
If you are like me, you feel lucky to have that great expanse of clean ocean air to keep us breathing well. Think again. We are seeing more and more pollution from China reaching our shores. Those giant cargo containers full of ‘stuff’ isn’t the only thing coming from the east. Coal fired power plants are making a yuckola mess of chemicals that are polluting California’s air. But, let’s not rest all of the blame on human’s insatiable appetite for stuff in the present. Some of the toxic air particles are from greed of the deep past: gold mining. Mercury was used in processing gold in California. That mercury flowed downstream and into the ocean; it is now being carried back to land in fog and rain, concentrating up the food chain and poisoning mountain lions in the Santa Cruz Mountains.

Famous Air Quote

“We have some incredibly talented people that know environment and what we’re doing probably better than any people on Earth.

From day one, my administration has made it a top priority to ensure that America has among the very cleanest air and cleanest water on the planet.  We want the cleanest air.  We want crystal-clean water, and that’s what we’re doing and that’s what we’re working on so hard.”

I’m guessing you know the source of this quote by now. If not, you can probably guess from the recognizable style. We hope that President Trump, like all politicians, recognizes how much the vast majority of citizens value clean air, so that there is ample motivation to do something about it. If politicians don’t act on these things, we all suffer. Unfortunately, few journalists hold any politician accountable to their clean air record: after all, it is anti-business to do so, and the news needs money.

Our Work
Vote. Get an air purifier for your house. Buy less. Go outside and think about the breeze…the direction of the wind…the strength of the wind…and what is carried on those breezes.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Saturday, January 4, 2025

Paul Krugman, pictured above, won the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2008. He writes for The New York Times, and and on October 19, 2024, Krugman’s “Opinion” column in The Times was titled, “Trump’s Radical Tariff Proposal Could Wreck Our Economy.”

Click right here for the column (understanding that you may be stymied by a paywall imposed by The Times). I, personally, think that this column is very much worth reading. It is a relatively short and pretty understandable explanation of tariffs, and explains how they work (or don’t work, I guess you’d have to say).

I want especially to highlight the following point, which isn’t really about the “economic” impact of tariffs, but speaks to another aspect of what lowering trade barriers can mean:

Some of Roosevelt’s officials, especially Cordell Hull, his long-serving secretary of state believed that closer trading ties between nations were a force for world peace.

We are “in this together” not only on a national basis, but on a global basis, as well. “Beating” other countries, economically – putting national economic self-interest as a top priority – is contraindicated.

“World Peace” ought to be on our New Year’s Resolutions List, so I am urging you to think about the point that Krugman is making!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
ACCOUNTABILITY, SECRET SATURDAY, A FRENCH AMBASSADOR

Well, it had to happen…Donald Trump’s election victory was certified by a joint meeting of Congress presided over by his opponent, Vice President Kamala Harris, a thirty minute tragedy that was only delayed for a couple of minutes by unhappy Blue Staters trying to crash the proceedings by breaking down the doors…naaahhh, that didn’t happen! But the peacefulness and decorum of the process was in stark contrast to that of the “normal day in DC” of 2020, as now described by MAGAs of course. Those charged with crimes during the storming of the Capitol are in Trump’s sights to avoid accountability with his pardons…as many as 1500 may avoid charges, slates wiped clean from the ugliness of that day. As Representative Jamie Raskin, a former member of the House Select Committee said, “This is an asymmetry we’ve been pointing out from the beginning that there has been relative accountability up until this point for the people who smashed the police officers over the head with Confederate battle flags or speared them with Trump flags or stormed the Capitol and so on — vis a vis the masterminds behind the whole process.”

Trump’s indictments for his role in seeking to block the peaceful transfer of power in Georgia have hit a snag, and Special Prosecutor Smith’s request to dismiss the J6 case without prejudice, leaves the door open for possible refilings in the future, but admittedly, the likelihood fades with the passage of time. Representative Zoe Lofgren, another House Select Committee member, adds, “Trump won the election…it is pretty pathetic that the officers who defended our lives are so disrespected and that the criminal who egged them on is now going back into the White House. You know, he has vowed to pardon the criminals who attacked the Capitol. People died. I always make a point of calling some of the officers who were injured on the sixth so they know it’s not the whole world that has forgotten their sacrifice.” Federal prosecutor Mary McCord, former acting head of the Justice Department’s National Security Division warns, “There’s no question that some of the defendants are currently still very empowered, and you have to imagine that they’re not going to be nearly as deterred from engaging in behavior that violates the law — particularly something that Trump may want them to do — in the future.” Former federal prosecutor in the US attorney’s office in DCRizwan Qureshi, declared, “I think the bedrock of a true democracy is a peaceful transition of power. That’s why those who engaged in actual violent conduct on that date need to be held accountable…because accountability and respect for rule of law are necessary to deterring violence and preserving our democracy that I think we take for granted every day.”

The rule of law was dealt a poke in the eye with a secretive Saturday night party at Mar-a-Lago, reportedly celebrating efforts to overturn the 2020 election…no publicity, no press invitations, just attended by the likes of John EastmanMichael FlynnJeffrey ClarkRudy Giuliani, and Peter Navarro as they watched a documentary film about Eastman. Attorney Eastman was delegated to pressure Vice President Pence not to certify the results of the presidential vote of 2020, to the praise of Trump’s introductory remarks on Saturday. “I’m a big fan of John Eastman. Y’know, he was right. He happened to be right. That’s why they changed the law and nobody wants to talk about that. They said he’s not allowed to do it, he’s not allowed to do it, and they convinced him he’s not allowed to do it, our vice president, then right after the election they changed the law so he can’t do it.” Hosts of MSNBC Weekend, in discussing it on Sunday, prompted Michael Steele to ask, “What was the sense in this room, what was the purpose of this gathering, is it just an in-your-face-moment or just a tale of things to come?” Vaughn Hilyard’s take is that it was clear from Trump’s guest list that it was no coincidence about the purpose. Symone Sanders Townsend tersely responded, “Let’s just put a finer point on it, this is sickening! This is sickening, I am sick. Navarro, Clark, the people that went to the Capitol to take up arms against the US government, because the president at the time lied to them, that’s what happened. Those are not patriots. What Donald Trump did last night is a disgrace to the country and Constitution, and the fact that they didn’t tell anybody about it lets you know that they knew what they were doing was untoward, and they wanted to do it anyway.”

Steve Schmidt writes on The Warning that many have called for President Biden to issue preemptive pardons for the likely targets included in Trump’s promised retributions in his abuse of presidential powers. Schmidt is against such action, calling the Constitution and our own dignity as our protectors. Accepting a pardon means admitting a crime, and the necessity of opposing Donald Trump is not a crime. It is necessary, and will continue to be necessary, he maintains. Opposition to Donald Trump doesn’t need explanation or justification, so fight against criminalization of matters of conscience under a regime that doesn’t tolerate criticism or dissent. The fear that Trumpers have instilled throughout America “isn’t just unseemly…it is disconcerting, pathetic at some level and cynical at another,” Schmidt says. The premise that Biden should issue preemptive pardons is “among the worst ideas ever floated. It is a gateway to banana republicanism through a side door.”

Andy Borowitz writes in The Borowitz Report“In a series of scathing Truth Social posts on Tuesday, Donald J Trump lambasted President Biden for issuing a pardon without being paid for it. ‘Pardoning someone for free was an incredibly selfish act,’ Trump wrote. ‘This will lower the market value of every future pardon I give. The framers of the Constitution gave the president pardon power for one reason: to make money,’ Trump continued. ‘I have too much respect for the Constitution to pardon people for free.’ In perhaps the strongest denunciation of Biden’s actions, he added, ‘Any decent father would have made Hunter ambassador to France.'”

In response to Trump’s promise of pardons, bootlicking Republicans are sucking up to him in a time-honored and traditional way: by being cowards. And, all those Senators and Representatives who hunkered down for safety on January 6, 2021, are all lined up to show him they can roll over for him. Senator Lindsey Graham said, “We’ll see what he does. I mean it’s been four or five years (since J6). The ones that hurt cops, they’d be in a different category for me, but we’ll leave that up to him.” Trump’s charge that the House Select Committee destroyed evidence that would have exonerated him, and fantasizing Liz Cheney before a firing squad, all seem to be fine with the GOP. The detailed events in the 850-page report from the committee were terrifying, illuminating and damning, and most voters oppose Trump’s plan to pardon insurrectionists, but what most voters want has never been the Republican Party’s bag, writes Walter Einenkel on Daily Kos.

Author Charles Pierce, in discussing presidents of his lifetime, says they were not perfect men, but for the most part, “they approached the job, and they took to the podium, with all the gravitas they could muster as appropriate for the job. They tried, at least, to reach for something in the presidency that was beyond their grasp as ordinary human beings. They were not all ennobled by the attempt, but they tried nonetheless.” Looking at our current prospect, he moans, “And comes now this hopeless, vicious buffoon, and the audience of equally hopeless and vicious buffoons who laughed and cheered when he made sport of a woman whose lasting memory of the trauma she suffered is the laughter of the perpetrators. Now he comes, a man swathed in scandal, with no interest beyond what he can put in his pocket and what he can put over on a universe of suckers, and he does something like this while occupying an office that we gave him, and while endowed with a public trust that he dishonors every day he wakes up in the White House. The scion of a multigenerational criminal enterprise, the parameters of which we are only now beginning to comprehend. A vessel for all the worst elements of the American condition. And a cheap, soulless bully besides…Watch how a republic dies in the empty eyes of an empty man who feels nothing but his own imaginary greatness, and who cannot find in himself the decency simply to shut up even when it is in his best interest to do so…Watch him behind the seal of the President of the United States. Isn’t he a funny man? Isn’t what happened to that lady hilarious? Watch the assembled morons cheer. This is the only story now.”

As if to echo Pierce’s words, the president-elect will be attending an interfaith prayer service in DC the day before he is inaugurated — his wealthiest supporters are invited if they write a big enough check. This news is reported by Religion News Service, which gathered the information from Trump’s inaugural committee which has a list of different tiers of ‘benefits‘ for the various donor contribution amounts. On January 18, donors can get tickets to a ‘Make America Great Again Rally,’ a cabinet reception and a dinner with VP-elect Vance, to be followed the next day with the “pay-to-pray” event, so dubbed by RNS reporter Jack Jenkins.

Humorist Dave Barry had the perfect summation of the 2024 election season in his 2024 yearly wrap:  But what made 2024 truly special, in terms of sustained idiocy, was that it was an election year. This meant that day after day, month after month, the average American voter was subjected to a relentless gushing spew of campaign messaging created by political professionals who—no matter what side they’re on—all share one unshakeable core belief, which is that the average American voter has the intellectual capacity of a potted fern. It was a brutal, depressing slog, and it felt as though it would never end. In fact it may still be going on in California, a state that apparently tabulates its ballots on a defective Etch-a-Sketch.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Wildfires

“I’d rather fight 100 structure fires than a wildfire. With a structure fire you know where your flames are, but in the woods it can move anywhere; it can come right up behind you.”
~Tom Watson

“My father was a wildfire. Really. Nobody could save him from anything. His family turned away from him, and he broke up with his first wife. It just happened to be that when he was going to get back up on his feet, my mother was there.”
~John Carter Cash

“No matter the natural disaster I’ve covered, whether it’s a wildfire or flood, I always come back with a much greater perspective.”
~Ginger Zee

“Due to climate change, wildfires are growing in size, frequency, and intensity, and wildfire seasons are becoming longer.”
~Mikie Sherrill

“It is known that wildfires behave unpredictably – this is fundamental – but it is my experience that humans in the presence of wildfire are also likely to behave in aberrant and unpredictable ways.”
~Michael Leunig

...

Wired does this whole series of different professions doing “tech support”, answering questions from people on the internet. This one is really good, it’s called Pseudoscience Support.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.
Email: webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)
...

Subconscious Comics
Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

January 1 – 7, 2025

Highlights this week:

Greensite… on the Wharf end collapse…. Steinbruner… Workbench, Capitola Mall… Hayes… Renewal… Patton… tik tok, tiktok… Matlock… kissing the ring…free to think…funniest idea… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… New Year’s…bingo? Quotes on… “New Year”

...

DOWNTOWN SOQUEL circa 1900. Carolyn Swift in her book “Soquel Landing to Capitola~ by~the~Sea” says that’s the Congregational Church in the foreground, and Daubenbiss house on the hill in distance, center of photograph.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.

Additional information always welcome: email photo@brattononline.com

Dateline: January 1, 2025

WE ARE STILL HERE. I told you we’d let you know what we came up with, but you’ve probably already figured it out. We are continuing much the same as before. The consensus is that Bruce would not have wanted us to shut down operations. I have archives of historic photos to pull from, we are figuring out some other details moving forward, and we are keeping the name, BrattonOnline. We will do our best to do good by him.

Thanks for sticking with us,

~Webmistress (Gunilla)

CELEBRATING BRUCE. As of yet, we don’t know any details about the who, what, where and when with regards to a memorial or celebration of life being held for Bruce. After all, it’s been Christmas and New Year’s, and people have understandably been busy and unavailable. Something will happen though, and as soon as we know, we will let you know all about it here. Promise.

...

NOTE: Since we used to keep Bruce’s reviews up for some time, I’m phasing these out slowly. I don’t believe movie reviews will go away though, so watch this space…

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

EMILIA PEREZ. Netflix movie. **** (7.3 IMDB). An amazing mix of musical and drama like I’ve never seen before. Zoe Saldana and Selena Gomez take leads in this Mexico City mystery that flips between sex changes and family values. We’ll see more of this film around Oscar time as Netflix continues to sell it. DO not miss it.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

BILLIONAIRE ISLAND. Netflix series. (6.3 IMDB). We learn from this drama that Norway is the world’s salmon producer. Because of this there’s a ruthless woman rival who works very hard and only partially honestly to take the Salmon farm and business from her. It also tells us the difference between farmed and wild salmon. There’s lots of rich people living their lives with golf and generally focusing on making more money. Interesting but not compelling.

NOBODY WANTS THIS. Netflix series (8.1 IMDB). Adding a so called “romantic comedy” is rare for BrattonOnline but this one has a 8.1 IMDB AND THAT’S RARE. It stars Kristin Bell as the shiksa (now 44 years old) and Adam Brody as the Rabbi. It’s all in L.A. and it’s fast paced and focuses on the relationship between LA Angelenos and the large and influential Jewish population. Plus the gay population gets their share of the comedy in their 25 minute programs.

...

December 30, 2024

A Community Loss

Sadly, everything in the photo at the end of the Wharf collapsed into the ocean on Monday, December 22. Now the blame game has begun. The city manager said at Friday’s press conference, with the mayor nodding in agreement, that “we have projects that could have prevented this most recent collapse.” He cited delays caused by lawsuits against the city, “that have left our Wharf more vulnerable.” In short order that story was picked up by major news outlets with the predictable onslaught of hate directed at the community group, Don’t Morph the Wharf! and me, as its most visible spokesperson.

Being on the receiving end of hate is no fun. You wonder how far people will take it. I thought of those poll workers whose lives were shattered by the hatred whipped up by the election lies of Giuliani and others. Many years ago, someone left a dead fish jammed in the window of my truck. Being rather naïve about such symbolism, I wondered if it was a gift. Ignorance can be bliss. I must have angered someone over attempts to save a heritage tree, back when there were big trees left to save.

If facts still matter, the reasons for the collapse of the Wharf’s last 150 feet are easy to explain. Neither a lawsuit nor protected birds played any part, but they are easy targets, especially for those who uncritically accept the headlines and never ask why. Why did a community group file a lawsuit against the city over the Wharf Master Plan? Why did the court rule against the city? Did the city do something illegal under CEQA? The answer of course is yes. It was captured in a quote by an environmental attorney, Stuart M. Flashman from Oakland who was not involved in the lawsuit. He saw the city as partly responsible for the litigation. This was his statement on the issue to reporter Malcolm Maclachlan in the Daily Journal, a statewide legal journal.

It (the city) failed to be entirely honest in the CEQA evaluation of the project. It claimed some of the impacts weren’t significant, when the evidence before it indicated they would be.

Judge Paul Burdick ruled that the city was required to revise sections of its EIR to be legal under environmental law. So, is the lawsuit to blame for this delay? What about a city trying to pass off an illegal EIR?

It’s worth remembering that at the beginning of the Wharf Master Plan process, the city tried to fulfill its legal requirements with a Mitigated Negative Declaration rather than a full Environmental Impact Report. That was the beginning of the many concerned individuals coalescing into the Don’t Morph the Wharf! community group. Our first action was to ask environmental attorney Susan Brandt-Hawley to write a letter to the city, pointing out that an EIR was necessary for a project of this scale on a historic structure. At the council meeting that addressed her letter, the city attorney advised council that, “out of an abundance of caution, the city should do an EIR.” So, who was responsible for this delay?

What about the comment to the press from the city manager that they had projects that could have prevented the collapse? Let’s review the facts and timeline.

In 2014, to accompany the Wharf Master Plan, an Engineering Report was completed. This Report involved divers inspecting each of the 4,445 pilings plus stringers that give the Wharf its strength to withstand the ocean’s pounding for over 100 years, or at least up until December 22. The engineers’ conclusion was that the Wharf was in good condition, due to careful maintenance by the various Wharf crews and I would add, the brilliant design in 1914 of Master Engineer Brunnier. The Report noted that 5% of the pilings needed replacement due to damage. You can see a map of this 5% on the city’s website (hard to find but it’s there.) Many of these damaged pilings were under the demolished Miramar and have been replaced. Many others were under the end of the Wharf. They have not been replaced in the ten years since the Engineering Report tagged them for replacement. Such lack of attention should raise eyebrows and redirect the pointed fingers away from a community group and back to the city. The excellent Wharf crew should not be scapegoated for the decision to neglect the end of the wharf: it is a top management decision.

The claim by the city that they could not get funding for such maintenance work until the Wharf Master Plan was approved is belied by the fact that the city secured funds to replace the pilings under the Miramar before the approval of the Wharf Master Plan and during the lawsuit.

As for those projects that it is claimed could have prevented the collapse. Well, none of them could have been built without first replacing the damaged pilings which puts us back to square one. Even without a lawsuit it is doubtful such projects at the end of the Wharf would have been underway before now. And, without the lawsuit, the end of the Wharf would have included that highly unpopular 40-foot-tall Landmark building with the loss of the sea lion viewing holes.

One last fact: At the specific request of Don’t Morph the Wharf, the court order after judgment directed that the replacement of the 5% pilings called out in the Engineering Report, which had never been contested, could proceed unaffected by the judgment, as could all other proposed Wharf maintenance projects.

This loss and the impact on the workers who are out of a job until the Wharf is re-opened could have been prevented. The community deserves a thorough investigation without finger-pointing and scapegoating.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...
WORKBENCH IMPOSES AGGRESSIVE DEVELOPMENT ON SCOTTS VALLEY

For first time in the State, AB 2011, which allows developers to convert commercial property to affordable housing is being instituted…right in Scotts Valley.  Known as the Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act of 2022, the developer (in this case, Workbench) has the benefit of a streamlined, ministerial approval process, not subject to a conditional use permit if the development satisfies specified objective planning standards in commercial areas, making development a use by right, requiring the Labor Commissioner to enforce the obligation to pay prevailing wages.

Because the bill would impose new duties on local governments, it would impose a state-mandated local program.

Local government must submit annual reports on the effectiveness of developments under AB 2011 until the program sunset on January 1, 2033.

The City of Scotts Valley is against this development, but has no say at all because of the aggressive path Workbench is taking.

AB-2011 Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act of 2022

AB 2011, by Wicks. Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act of 2022.
Here is what Workbench proposes: Scotts Valley

Here is a good report from LookOut Santa Cruz about the issue:
State-approved Workbench project will be Scotts Valley’s first affordable housing development in decades. City leaders don’t want it.

NEW COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIONERS TO REPLACE WORKBENCH PRINCIPAL TIM GORDIN AS COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSIONER
Tim Gordin resigned from his influential appointed spot on the County Planning Commission in November.  Hmmm….

That is likely a good move, considering the many large projects Workbench is pursuing, including the controversial one in Scotts Valley, and the Clocktower Project in the City of Santa Cruz.

It will be refreshing to see how the new appointments made by Supervisor Manu Koenig, for 1st District Planning Commissioner and Alternate play out.

Planning Commissioner Shane Pavonetti

Alternate Planning Commissioner Luke Rizzuto

From Supervisor Manu Koenig’s newsletter:
Last week we seated a new D1 Planning Commissioner and Alternate Planning Commissioner. 

Commissioner Shane Pavonetti (who was sworn in by Clerk Tricia Webber in the County’s wedding room) is an architect, who I first met near the recent Maciel subdivision. As an owner and builder of single-family homes he questioned why the 21-unit developer should have concessions that were unavailable to him on smaller projects.

Alternate Commissioner Luke Rizzuto has been a general contractor in Santa Cruz County for 45 years and a resident of the Santa Cruz Mountains for 75 years. He served as President of the Loma Prieta Joint Union School Board and knows how to run a meeting.

I’m confident that these two will serve the district well by standing up for everyday residents, good architecture and cutting red tape.

WILL THIS FIVE-YEAR PILOT LABOR AGREEMENT PROGRAM HELP LOCAL SANTA CRUZ CONTRACTORS AND WORKERS?
The County Board of Supervisors approved a five-year pilot program restricting  contractors bidding on any of the 10 County capital improvement projects, each $5 million  to $90 million in estimated cost, selected by the County Administrative Office (CAO) Carlos Palacios to abiding by a new Project Labor Agreement (PLA) terms requiring union labor from Santa Cruz County, Monterey County or San Benito County to be hired on the jobs, paying prevailing wages.  Many workers from K&D Landscaping, a family-owned Watsonville business with over 130 employees, spoke against the PLA because their company would be locked out of bidding on many projects to be considered in the future.

Public Comment on the item was significant. It was clear that staff from the CAO office had worked closely with the Union leaders to craft the language of the Pilot Program, leading outgoing Supervisor Zach Friend to strongly question why it would allow a bid exceeding up to 25% of the staff estimate to still be accepted.  He asked that it be lowered to 10%, but staff was not supportive because “we started with a much lower number, but this was what was negotiated.” with the Union leaders at the table.

Supervisor Friend worried that the PLA will drive project costs up to the point that the County will not be able to get them done.

Supervisor Friend also felt the narrow definition of what non-union local contractors would be allowed to bid on projects under $3 million would cause harm and exclusion of local small contractors already doing good work and providing jobs in the Community.  He asked for changes to the language of the Pilot Program

Outgoing Supervisor Bruce McPherson did not support the PLA Pilot Program as presented because he read the Survey of Local Contractor Responses and noted none of them felt the PLA Pilot Program would benefit their businesses or workers.  “The County already has provisions for preference to local workforce, and to me, this [PLA] seems like  a solution in search of a problem.”

In the end, the matter passed with modifications including reducing the bid excedance to 10%, changing the definition of local contractors to “any contractor with license in Santa Cruz County” (it had been more restrictive to more than 20 employees and gross annual revenue of $7 million) and data provided on project cost overruns and scheduling by November, 2025 to the Board. It passed 3:1. Supervisor McPherson voted NO.  Supervisor Cummings was absent.

Here are the 10 projects selected for the five-year PLA Pilot Program (page 34 of the document)

Project Labor Agreement Pilot Program for the County of Santa Cruz

Addendum B
COVERED PROJECTS LIST / PILOT PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION
B.1 Covered Projects. This Agreement applies only to Covered Work performed under the
Construction Contract for the following Covered Projects:
B.1.1 Buena Vista Road Full Depth Reclamation.
B.1.2 County Facility Energy Savings Project.
B.1.3 Buena Vista Transfer Station.
B.1.4 1400 Emeline HVAC Replacement Project.
B.1.5 Anna Jean Cummings Park Athletic Sports Field Improvements.
B.1.6 Rail Trail Segment 10/11.
B.1.7 Ben Lomond Transfer Station.
B.1.8 South County Behavioral Health Facility.
B.1.9 South County Health Campus / Clinic.

B.1.10 Wheelock Facility Improvements.
 
B.2 The County shall provide the Council with additional information as to the scope of the Construction Contract(s) for, and estimated dollar value of, each Covered Project prior to bid.
 
B.3 Compliance with CEQA. In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act
(“CEQA”), nothing in this Agreement commits the County to undertake any act or activity

requiring the subsequent independent exercise of discretion by the County. The Covered Projects shall only be performed if and after certification, adoption or approval of any analysis required under CEQA. The Parties acknowledge that compliance with CEQA will be required in connection with consideration of the Covered Projects, and the County shall retain the discretion in accordance with CEQA and other applicable law to 

  1. adopt or certify an environmental analysis of a Covered Project or any portion thereof, prepared in accordance with CEQA, 
  2. change the scope of Covered Projects, identify and impose mitigation measures to mitigate significant environmental
    impacts, and/or limit the anticipated scope of any required public improvements,

  3. select other feasible alternatives to avoid significant environmental impacts, including the “no project” alternative, or 
  4. adopt a statement of overriding considerations in accordance with Public
    Resources Code Section 21081(b) relative to any significant environmental impacts of a Covered Project or any portion thereof, or implementation of any required public improvements, prior to taking final action if such significant impacts cannot otherwise be avoided, or (5) determine not to proceed with the Covered Projects or any portion thereof. Any action taken by the County in the exercise of its discretion relating to any analysis required by CEQA, shall not constitute a default or a breach of the terms of this Agreement by the County.

The individual project cost estimates were shown in the CAO staff presentation, but are not in the document above.  Staff stated the total anticipated costs of the 10 Covered Projects is $200-$230 Million.  The cost of the Segment 10/11 Rail Trail was $90 Million while the Anna Jean Cummings athletic fields improvements was $5-$10 Million, and the County Facility Energy Savings Project (not sure which one that is on the list in the document) was $5-$7 Million.

Take some time to listen to the comments and discussion here:

(Click on Item #7)

It will be interesting to see what the CAO staff has to report next November.

PROBLEMS AT THE SANTA CRUZ WHARF
In light of the Santa Cruz Wharf’s catastrophic loss of 150′ into the ocean last week, I thought it would be meaningful to review
the improvement plan adopted by the City Council last February. What do you think will happen next?  Mayor Fred Keeley has already said restoring the 150′ segment is questionable.

WHAT DOES SANTA CRUZ CITY DO WITH THE PUBLIC SAFETY DEVELOPER FEES COLLECTED?
The City collects many fees whenever building permit project applications are approved.  What happens with all that money?
I happened to find some information about the “Public Safety Fees” assessed and found it of interest.

The Fire Dept. purchased new life-saving equipment with the money, but it appears the police are letting the money accrue.

Write your City Council member and ask about this and other fees the City is collecting…how is it justified?  Who decides how it gets spent…or not?

APPLY TO SERVE ON A CITY OF SANTA CRUZ ADVISORY COMMISSION
Here is a chance to be at the table when critical local issues are discussed before the Councilmembers weigh in with their votes.

Current Openings | City of Santa Cruz

WHAT IS THE LATEST NEWS ON REDEVELOPMENT AT THE CAPITOLA MALL?
Listen in this Friday at 3pm on “Community Matters” to hear Capitola City Mayor Yvette Brooks discuss the latest news of the City…what will happen at the Capitola Mall?  Will the Rispin Mansion continue to sit empty while the City pays to have it beautifully  landscaped?

Listen in on your computer or smart device to Santa Cruz Voice.com and call in to join the discussion: santacruzvoice.com/

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ASK QUESTIONS AND EXPECT ANSWERS.
DO ONE THING THIS WEEK AND MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers and Happy New Year,
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...
Renewal

Winter Solstice, for me, is the beginning of the new year and, in this Mediterranean Place, a time for Earth’s renewal. As the legend of Ebenezer Scrooge teaches us, every moment presents an opportunity to choose a new path. How do we, how does this place, take this opportunity?

The Rain Soaks In

The soils are wetted. Sporadic storms have spread enough precipitation through our bioregion to soak the soils, and the earth is awakening. Not long ago, the ground was rock hard and dusty. Picks and shovels bounced from the soil with pinging noises, puffs of dust erupting at every thrust. The dry soil seemed lifeless, but close examination revealed insects and worms curled up in tight spheres of summer-protective cases. Roots were shriveled.

Recently, the ground in those same places welcomes the shovel’s gentle push; earthworms and soil insects wriggle and squirm in upturned dirt. The newly moist soil is shot through with white fungal threads, some places dense mats, other places more diffuse. Sweet earth aromas emanate from the ground. The surface of the earth is quickly becoming matted with newly germinating seedlings. Freshly hydrated perennials unfurl new leaves and tendrils.

Early Breeding Birds and Their Favorite Flowers

Zeeee-eeeng, POP! Hummingbirds have begun their dive-bombing whistles, a sign that nesting time is at hand. Between dive bombing displays and sips of nectar, Anna’s hummingbirds are gathering spider webs, which they weave into nests, adorning the outsides with lichen. Winter flowering salvias are a favorite food source, but native flowering currant is the nectar-producing prize, the earliest native hummingbird plant.

Hummingbirds hold a special place for many of the local native people. I wonder if they once helped hummingbirds by cultivating native flowering currant, which is nowadays very uncommon. Gardeners and restorationists might consider stewarding this native shrub. If you decide to plant it, please consider choosing very local genetic stock, preserving the legacy of evolution or deep historical cultivars. Central Coast Wilds has collections from many local watersheds. Flower color varies between populations, which might also have adaptations to very local soils, climate, etc.

Walks and Reflections

The short days and rainy spells force us walkers to be more inventive if we are to get outside. For many people, this time of year is disruptive…hopefully for the better. People seem more prone towards social events, family and friend get-togethers proliferate. Diets change for holiday fare. Many people take time off from work, making time for socializing and reflection.

For every few hours spent relaxing in the cozy indoors, renewal and fresh perspective happens much faster with time out of doors, in the fresh air, however wet or cold. This might be time to be alone or could be time with others; either way, nature presents good chances for breaking mental or emotional patterns, showing us new paths. The way to take those chances is to be quiet, to give over to our senses….look carefully, listen, feel, and smell. When I have really opened up into nature, I sometimes feel I am being watched and, looking around, I see a fox or a bird gazing at me.

Longer strolls with time to rest along the trail are the best. What will you consider if you give yourself a half hour sit-time with a good view?

New Year’s Resolutions

We are emerging from the longest nights with any luck having slowed down…reflecting…with new perspectives on ourselves, our communities, and the world around us. With calmer minds and more open eyes we might see how lucky we are to be in such a profoundly beautiful, deeply biologically diverse place. How can we better integrate into the natural world around us? We shun narcissistic tendencies, tending towards generosity to others, including the non-humans that depend on our respect for their survival. We each have something to contribute to the future of badger, to the next generation of mountain lion, for the wellbeing of humpback whale.

So, while we rightly reconsider how we might take better care of ourselves in 2025, we increasingly recognize that caring for others is absolutely necessary for self-care. What are we without a vibrantly healthy environment? Will future generations enjoy more, or fewer wildlife species? How do you build these ideas into your new self, into your renewed actions in the coming year?

The newly moist soil is rich and receptive. The earth is providing a gentle and productive place to grow.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, December 30, 2024

An article in the December 9, 2024, edition of The New York Times alerted readers to a potential “ban” of Tik Tok in the United States. As Wikipedia tells us (any of us who may be otherwise unaware), Tik Tok is “a short-form video hosting service owned by a Chinese internet company, ByteDance. It hosts user-submitted videos, which can range in duration from three seconds to 60 minutes. Tik Tok can be accessed with a smart phone app or the web.”

The United States government believes that “national security” is imperiled by the use of Tik Tok by American citizens, given that Tik Tok is owned by a Chinese company, which presumably means that the Chinese government might have easy access to any information that appears on Tik Tok, and might also be able to use the application to undermine our democracy.

As The Times’ article tells us, it turns out that “a panel of three judges in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit” agree with the government ban. Unless ByteDance sells Tik Tok to some company of which the government approves, it will be banned in the United States by mid-January (apparently, at just about the time the nation welcomes its next president).

I am not a Tik Tok user. I have no real idea what its fate may be. However, I want to use the occasion of the discussion about Tik Tok to make a more “general” point.

More and more, our avenues of communication are all “online.” We talk to friends and others, debate the issues of the day, and become informed about what’s going on by way of various internet platforms. Tik Tok is one of them (and is owned by a Chinese company). Other platforms are owned by U.S. companies (Google, and Facebook, and “X,” for instance).

Here’s the issue I suggest we need to think about: If our ability to communicate and to participate in society, and in the “politics” that I think is so very important), depends on internet platforms (and especially ones that are under the control of giant corporations that operate in their own, private interest, not in the “public” interest) we are absolutely at risk of losing our ability to communicate among ourselves, and we might lose that ability at a moment’s notice.

Tik Tok, Tik Tok, Tik Tok…. the clock is ticking down towards a massive internet outage. Maybe that outage will be caused by some natural event, like a solar flare, or maybe it will be caused by some action by a government hostile to the United States, or maybe it will be caused by some action of our own government, or perhaps even by private corporate action. If, or maybe better said, “when” that occurs, we will not be in a position to “organize,” or to do much of anything else. Our ability to communicate with each other, and to find out what is going on in the world, is something that we take for granted. But… all that is now almost totally dependent on systems that live on the internet.

We have built our interconnected society, in other words, on a massively unreliable foundation. This is true because the “online world” is different from the “real world.” It is particularly noteworthy that our online world is “owned” by private corporations, controlled by billionaires whose interest is not “public service,” but private profit.

This is just something to think about, as you ponder my oft-repeated suggestion that you “Find Some Friends.”

I mean “real world” friends!

Tik Tok, Tik Tok, Tik Tok.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...
MANDATE FOR EFFICIENCY, BRAIN DEAD TECH BROS, LEAVING TWITTER

Well, the electorate has spoken — a mandate according to the MAGAts, putting the man from Mar-a-Lago back into the Oval Office! But wait! It turns out The Man at Mar-a-Lago is none other than Elon Musk hibernating in one of the cottages onsite! Is he president, co-president, vice president or VP-in-waiting? It’s all very suspicious in light of all the shenanigans being pulled by this “high status male” peering over Mr. Trump’s shoulder and whispering in his good ear. During the recent presidential campaign, Musk used his X social media platform to promote the theory that a free-thinking ‘Republic’ can only exist under the decision-making of “high status males,” excluding women or “low T men,” of course. The theory was derived from 4chan, first seen in 2021 on that social media site, posted by an anonymous user who suggested that the only people able to think freely are “high testosterone alpha males” who would be qualified to a run a “Republic” designated “only for those who are free to think.” “People who can’t defend themselves physically (women and low T men) parse information through a consensus filter as a safety mechanism,” says the anonymous poster. “Only high T alpha males and aneurotypical people are actually free to parse new information with an objecive ‘is this true?’ filter,” they add. “This is why a Republic of high status males is best for decision making. Democratic, but a democracy only for those who are free to think.” “Aneurotypical” is not a word but it is assumed the writer meant neurodivergent individuals.

This theory, and others similar, promote hegemonic masculinity, being criticized for being sexist, exclusionary, not realistic and “toxic,” all popular in alt-right communities. “Interesting observation,” said Musk of this post. Mr. Tesla views such controversial or offensive positions as ‘free speech’ and should be allowed on his own platform even if it holds false or misleading information. The 4chan site itself is a hub of internet subculture, influenced by hacktivist and political movements, such as Anonymous and the alt-right. Posting can be done anonymously, a mainstay of the site, which has resulted in harmful content from a toxic community, which is emboldened to post hateful and abusive messages without fear of reprisal, with burgeoning of cyberbullying, harassment, and illegal activities; indeed, incidents of violence and harm must be taken into account. But now, talk about “interesting observations,” president-elect Trump has chosen to put Musk in charge of a ‘government efficiency commission‘ to audit the entire federal government, implementing “drastic reforms,” bringing with him his track record of bristling against regulation and government intervention. His efficiency in running a business and his abysmal stewardship of X should raise a few red flags, as we examine his repeated employee pay cuts and mass layoffs which resulted in a sputtering and barely functional social media site. Millions of previous users have abandoned the platform which is now a cesspool of hate speech, disinformation, and propaganda…the main proponent being Musk himself. His confounding missteps and micromanagement style may eventually eat away at the successes of SpaceX and Tesla, which may suggest that his real motivation in accepting Trump’s invitation is to deconstruct government from the very center rather than saving it money to continue operating. But, what the heck…with a former reality TV star president with an erratic business record, what could go wrong?

Former MSNBC host Keith Olbermann, on his Countdown podcast, is afraid there’s nothing to stop Musk from buying his former, troubled cable news network, though it is not technically up for grabs. Olbermann asks, “Is there anybody to stop someone, Musk or not, from buying MSNBC and turning it into pro-Trump propaganda? Well, who stopped Musk from doing that to Twitter?” Musk suggested the idea after Donald Trump, Jr. joked that making that purchase would be “the funniest idea ever!!!” Olbermann’s comments about a degraded Twitter note that it is now basically a place for Musk to talk to bots and “fellow brain-dead tech bros.” Fidelity Investments estimates that X is now worth 80% less than when Elon got his mitts on it. Comcast has plans to spin off most of its struggling cable networks into standalone entities owned solely by existing shareholders, and may ultimately divest from cable completely. However, Musk is already spread incredibly thin with all his enterprises, so MSNBC is in no danger…yet…only our government should fear his clutches.

And the clutches of his designated partner, Vivek Ramaswamy, in the new non-agency called the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE)…not legally recognized as yet. The two co-leaders are making a list and checking it twice of government employees they intend to fire when Trump is sworn in to the presidency, actually two lists obtained from former administration workers. The first lists people who they served with who would make possible political appointees; the other list grades people they worked with, with an ‘A’ for those who should stay, and a ‘B’ for those who should be ‘blacklisted or fired.’ Typically, civil servants or career officials are protected from political raids at agencies, but Trump has claimed he can use Schedule F, an executive order that would make them fireable, and most certain to end up before the court. Many applicants are seeking work in the DOGE inquisition agency, but few who are willing to work for free, as are Musk and Ramaswamy. M & R are eager to start their new assignments as they goad their adherents to start cyberbullying government employees, calling their positions “fake.” Some may remember that in 2022, Yoel RothTwitter’s head of trust and safety, was targeted by Musk who charged Roth was endangering children, which led to a multitude of haters accusing him of being a pedophile and calling for his death. Roth was chased away from Twitter after the Musk takeover, and had to relocate for his safety after the billionaire’s cyber campaign, a sign of what may lie ahead with M & R’s ‘efficiency’ moves.

The two claim to have a mandate from the American people and the Supreme Court as they try to reshape the federal government. They are advancing legally questionable arguments on tactics, but as ‘outside volunteers,’ they have no authority to actually cut anything or fire anyone. Those powers lie with TrumpCongress, federal agency heads, or anyone with actual power to do so; yet, the two imply that they will take a much more direct roles to personally achieve their desired result. It is estimated that Musk spent in excess of $200M to buy Trump’s presidency, so in return Trump is giving Musk free rein to reshape federal agencies that regulate Musk’s companies by purging the civil service that awards him lucrative government contracts. According to odactionnewsDOGE is not aiming to eliminate a wasteful, lawless, and antidemocratic bureaucracy in Washington — it is hoping to become one. Conservative critic George Conway joked, “It’s weird to think that Elon Musk will end up having paid far less for the United States government than he did for Twitter.”

Musk has proven his power by killing a bipartisan government funding bill that was set to be voted on, avoiding a government shutdown. His over-the-top social media posting spree encouraging Republican members of Congress to vote against the proposed plan succeeded, and it took several days to get it back on track in the nick of time. Stephen Colbert wasn’t surprised by his action, saying that the billionaire has a history of blowing things up…“particularly on the launch pad,” he joked by showing a SpaceX rocket failure in Cape Canaveral. Colbert continued, “I’m sure the founders are spinning in their graves with joy at the way all of this is playing out. After all, the Constitution does start with ‘We the people do whatever rich boy tells us. Rich boy makes the big square truck! And we obey! We the people, obey rich boy.” He then pointed out that Trump weighed in on the bill’s failure, echoing Musk’s posts, which then spurred comments of “President Musk, and Vice President Trump.” “Woof, well, if he’s gonna be the guy running everything, I’m gonna have to work on my Elon Musk impression. Here goes,” as he jumped into the air in mockery of Musk’s jumping on stage during a Trump rally. Senator Bernie Sanders posted, “Democrats and Republicans spent months negotiating a bipartisan agreement to fund our government. President Elon Musk doesn’t like it. Will Republicans kiss the ring?”

Elon is facing accusations of political meddling not only in this country, but across Europe, including the German Alternative for Germany (AfD) and Britains’s Reform UK parties. “Only AfD can save Germany,” Musk has written on X, leading one senior German politician to remark, “Stay out, Elon.” It is reported that Musk is considering a donation of $100M to the anti-immigration Reform UK after meeting that party’s leader at his new digs in Mar-a-Lago. Wary politicians in ItalyIreland, and France have told him “hands off” our domestic politics. Back in the USA, many are saying it’s Musk’s House now, with many Republicans proposing a Speaker of the House Musk, though he is backpedaling with Trump to make his actions on the funding bill appear to be Democrats‘ fault. Tiny cracks are beginning to appear in the GOP, stimulating calls for a Civil War within the party, which will make Trump a lamer duck than he desired to be. Trump wanted the world’s richest man as his sidekick, for the glamor and the fat wallet, and now it’s about to blow up on the launch pad. With Musk’s perceived clout, who owns the MAGA brand? Former MSNBC anchor and political analyst Chris Matthews called out Musk for tanking the funding bill by saying, “You’ve heard of a bull in a china ship — this guy is an elephant in a china shop.” Steve Schmidt on The Warning blog, speculates that, “Maybe we should call Elon ‘Daddy.’ I bet that’s what Trump calls him in private. Barron too.”

Satirist Andy Borowitz writes, “Elon Musk’s strenuous efforts to obtain power have dismally failed to make him an interesting person, a leading expert revealed. Professor Davis Logsdon of the University of Minnesota, a scholar who has written the definitive study about tedious graspers, said that Musk has made ‘the classic misjudgment that many boring people make: believing that access to power would make them less boring. He is still the reason all his employees want to work remotely.’ In more upbeat news for the Tesla CEO, Donald J. Trump has tapped Musk to mastermind mass deportations, arguing, ‘Elon already got millions of people to leave Twitter.'”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

New Year

“This is a new year. A new beginning. And things will change.”
~Taylor Swift

“Every single year, we’re a different person. I don’t think we’re the same person all of our lives.”
~Steven Spielberg

“To improve is to change; to be perfect is to change often.”
~Winston Churchill

“The best way to predict the future is to create it.”
~Abraham Lincoln

“Many years ago I resolved never to bother with New Year’s resolutions, and I’ve stuck with it ever since.”
~Dave Beard

...

This is such a good idea… off to make a bingo card! Happy New Year everyone!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential.
Email: webmistress@BrattonOnline.com
(Gunilla Leavitt)
...

Subconscious Comics

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

December 11 – 31, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bruce has left the building … Greensite… on Paving Paradise… Steinbruner… Water News and Blues, Ode to Post Office Jumps… Hayes… A Place for the Environment… Patton… Bruce Bratton: ¡Presente!… Matlock… Antichrist in Paris…joint custody…remember Joe?… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… some stories from Bruce’s 90th… Quotes on… “Life well lived”

...

PACIFIC AVENUE & CHURCH STREETS (SANTA CRUZ 7:45 am. 1957). That’s the Cooper house on the far left. Today we have Urban Outfitters, Rip Curl etc. Look again and see our Town Clock high atop the Odd Fellows Hall and squint closer and see the marquees of both the Santa Cruz and the Del Mar movie palaces.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.
Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com

Dateline: December 11, 2024

BRUCE HAS LEFT THE COLUMN. He has left the building, he has left this plane, he has left us. He is sorely missed, something evidenced not in the least by various tributes people have posted online.

For myself, I have been a bit numb since I found out. This is legitimately the longest “job” I’ve ever had. I communicated with this man every week since 2003, and now I’m not going to anymore. That is a weird feeling. As far as what happens to the column, all the other contributors and myself will have a meeting this week and discuss, and we will let you know what we come up with. I believe we all want to continue in some way in his name and honor, though things may look a little different moving forward. Stay tuned to this space though! We are taking a holiday break, and then we’ll be back after the new year.

If you have any comments, questions, or suggestions for me, feel free to email me at godmoma@gmail.com.

Happy Holidays to you all, whatever holiday you celebrate! I’m running one of Bruce’s favorite photos for this time of year – snow in downtown.

See you in the next year,

~Webmistress (Gunilla)

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

EMILIA PEREZ. Netflix movie. **** (7.3 IMDB). An amazing mix of musical and drama like I’ve never seen before. Zoe Saldana and Selena Gomez take leads in this Mexico City mystery that flips between sex changes and family values. We’ll see more of this film around Oscar time as Netflix continues to sell it. DO not miss it.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

BILLIONAIRE ISLAND. Netflix series. (6.3 IMDB). We learn from this drama that Norway is the world’s salmon producer. Because of this there’s a ruthless woman rival who works very hard and only partially honestly to take the Salmon farm and business from her. It also tells us the difference between farmed and wild salmon. There’s lots of rich people living their lives with golf and generally focusing on making more money. Interesting but not compelling.

NOBODY WANTS THIS. Netflix series (8.1 IMDB). Adding a so called “romantic comedy” is rare for BrattonOnline but this one has a 8.1 IMDB AND THAT’S RARE. It stars Kristin Bell as the shiksa (now 44 years old) and Adam Brody as the Rabbi. It’s all in L.A. and it’s fast paced and focuses on the relationship between LA Angelenos and the large and influential Jewish population. Plus the gay population gets their share of the comedy in their 25 minute programs.

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB)*** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and the reviews are stupendously great and RARE. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

CIVIL WAR. Max movie (7.1 IMDB) *** Has some fine scenes, but falls apart en toto. Kirsten Dunst, Jessie Plemons and Wagner Moura lead the cast. It really is about a new civil war right here in the USA. Reporters, photographers and politicians all race around headed to Washington D.C. to talk to and change how the president is thinking. Texas and California withdraw from the union and more hell breaks out. Watch it only if this seems and looks like a nightmare to you.

...

They Paved Paradise…

I wrote this week’s piece the day before Bruce Bratton died. A day later, on hearing that very sad news, I scrapped the lead-in paragraph where I jokingly scolded Bruce for even thinking about retiring at 91. Nothing easy about losing a friend and a Santa Cruz icon.

There will no doubt in due time be an outpouring of praise, recognition and thanks to Bruce, so I won’t make those well-deserved accolades the subject of this week’s piece except to say I’ve been honored and grateful to write for his blog since mid-2015 and hope it can continue in some form.

Turning from the personal to the political, the first sight of the development on the East Meadow at UCSC hit hard. I let out a loud involuntary expletive and my jaw dropped. The fact that it was going to happen was no surprise; the legal ruling favored UCSC over the many who tried to save the East Meadow, but seeing the destruction for the first time is visceral.

Any defense such as “but it’s student housing! but it’s child-care! is disingenuous at best. There are fewer units of family student housing being built on the Meadow than exist in the current family student housing complex, slated to be torn down. Why fewer? Why not more? The childcare aspect is simply replacing the existing childcare complex, also slated to be torn down. Legitimate questions can be asked about the ongoing neglect of the current family student housing complex that earns it the label of “past its useful life.” Will the same fate await this new complex? Obsolescence via neglect? In a period of human history with climate change breathing down our necks, preservation and rehabilitation of existing buildings should be the norm. To add insult to injury, this site, considered by many to be iconic if not sacred, could have been avoided had UCSC exercised patience for six months to allow mitigations to be developed for environmental impacts on an alternative site. Add hubris to the mix.

Sadly, this may be just the beginning of the desecration of the campus natural lands. The recent appellate court decision in favor of UC cited that UCSC can build on the upper campus without approval of outside agencies for water provision. The recent statement from Chancellor Larive anticipating the possible establishment of a medical school on campus, a departure from the historic focus on undergraduate education, suggests we are in for a UCSC growth surge. This does not auger well for the campus lands nor for impact of such growth on the community.

Until recently, respecting the tension between development and nature, wise campus architects and administrators largely preserved the best of both, allowing for a campus unique in the UC system and perhaps in the world. As Kenneth Norris, professor of Natural History at UCSC, fearing the future without careful stewardship of the land, wrote in 1982, “few members of the Santa Cruz community will know what is being lost until it is gone.”

It’s true that many community members (and students) view the campus lands as just open buildable space, oblivious to the unique flora and fauna habitats on campus that offer valuable research and educational opportunities. “Why not build on campus? They have plenty of land.” Is a common refrain. A parallel comment is “why not build student housing on the far west side of town? Plenty of open land there.” Well, student housing is being built on the far west side of town and in many other parts of town. Most new housing projects, the tall ones either under construction, already constructed or heading for approval have student occupants in mind, given the size of the units. Most students are not low income in that their parents can afford the extravagant rents even if local workers cannot.

It is not just coincidental that the destruction of campus lands parallels the destruction of the small-scale fabric of downtown and the Santa Cruz neighborhoods. Investors, developers, and state legislators have formed a formidable alliance. Unless we get organized, we will be shoved aside, along with the historical, the natural, the human-scale and the non-commercial gems of town and gown.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

CHEMICALS, CHEMICALS AND MORE CHEMICALS
Soquel Creek Water District Board approved the expensive contract for bulk delivery of many hazardous chemicals to the “Pure” Water Soquel treatment facility at the intersection of Chanticleer and Soquel Avenue in Live Oak.   It was on their consent agenda, and they did not discuss it.

See page 22 for a list of the nine chemicals for which Soquel Creek Water District’s “Pure” Water Soquel Project will require regular bulk delivery.

Neither the 2018 EIR, 2020 Addendum or 2021 Addendum ever analyzed the potential impacts on local roadways for these large and potentially hazardous truckloads of chemicals traveling on our highway and in the Live Oak Community, which is considered a Disadvantaged Community.

According to page 9 of this Invitation for Bid, the treatment facility is anticipated to start up on March 15, 2025, not the December or January date recently reported in local media

How will these large trucks navigate the sharp turn entry into the treatment facility driveway?  Hmmmm……  Stay tuned for necessary new traffic lights at that intersection, and hopefully no accidents involving pedestrians and cyclists at the new “whale” overcrossing immediate.

NEW COUNTY WELL ORDINANCE…FUTURE WELL PERMITS BECOME MORE RESTRICTED
If you or someone you know has a private well in certain “Areas of Concern” in the County, you no longer will be able to get a new, supplemental or replacement well permit.  Where are those restricted areas?  Take a look here at the areas marked in pink

Fairly well-hidden is the area around Soquel Creek Water District’s three injection wells, where 1.67million gallons of treated sewage water will be pressure-injected into the groundwater.  This effectively forces consolidation of the Pine Tree Lane Mutual and Bluff Mutual Water entities and other private wells in the area with Soquel Creek Water District.

Worse yet, there is no appeal process for any of the new well requirements or restrictions, or mandated reporting now approved. Read through the strikeout underline versions of this new hammer to private water rights. Well Ordinance Update

I wrote the County Water Advisory Commission this week about my concerns when the proposed Well Ordinance came for their blessing.  One  particular response from staff amazed me:
“Public trust values have priority over established water rights.”  Hmmm……..

Also, there is no appeals process included in the new well permitting ordinance, but staff claims that will come along later as policy.  What does that mean?

The Board of Supervisors approved this unanimously anyway.

FOR THE SECOND CONSECUTIVE YEAR, COUNTY WATER USE IS LOWEST SINCE 1984
Good news!  According to the 2024 Water Resources Status Report, water use by residents in the County is the lowest since recorded in 1984, for the second consecutive year.
Page 2 of 58

• For the second year in a row, total municipal water use reached its lowest level since
1984.

The draft Report was reviewed by the County Water Advisory Commission last Wednesday, and will next go to the Board of Supervisors.  That is what caused many in the City’s Water Commission to wonder how water use in the City could have increased by 22%.  Hmmmm…….

SANTA CRUZ CITY WATER RATES WILL LIKELY GO UP AGAIN
On December 9, the City Water Commission heard a thorough financial report from staff regarding the many capital improvement projects on the table with the goal of bridging an anticipated water supply gap of 500 million gallons/year by 2027.  Staff claimed water use increased 22%, a figure that caused some Commissioners to ponder why.

Staff ended with the thought that even though water use is up, the City is still not bringing in enough money to pay for the costs involved in the capital improvement projects and system operations. Therefore, they suggested that a new rate study is needed, and that the fixed rate could mirror what some water agencies in the State have increased by 45% or more.

FUTURE WATER FOR THE CITY WILL INCLUDE WATER FROM SCOTTS VALLEY AND TREATED SEWAGE WATER
The City Water Commission also heard an explanation of why staff has chosen “Portfolio #1” of potential water supply scenarios, weighting risks vs. costs.  This will include storing potable surface water in the aquifer when it is available, termed “Aquifer Storage & Recovery” or ASR, as well as sharing water with Scotts Valley Water District and also receiving treated sewage water from Soquel Creek Water District’s “Pure” Water Soquel Project.  Staff pointed out that the water from Soquel Creek Water District source is VERY expensive.

Interestingly, the greatest risks identified in the City’s use of water shared with Soquel Creek Water District are lack of agency agreement and public resistance.

The City would still consider desalination but the risk is permitting, and again, public resistance…based on the past Desal Alternatives public campaign that blocked a desal plant in 2013 with a citizen’s initiative to put the energy-intensive and environmentally problematic desalination project on hold.

I pointed out in testimony to the Commission that the Desal Alternatives action was before the energy and chemical-intensive option of making people drink recycled water (Direct Potable Reuse) or injecting it into the drinking water supply (Indirect Potable Reuse) was on the table.  I pointed out that over 100 comments made on the PureWater Soquel Project Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) were from the Desal Alternatives group, voicing concern about energy and environmental problems associated.

Commissioner David Baskin, who served on the initial City Water Supply Advisory Committee (WSAC) that met subsequently and developed the guidelines for the City’s future water supply projects, reminded staff and other Commissioners that “we wanted to do desal last!” with priority given to conservation incentives.

I testified that if the Desal Alternatives folks were quizzed now about the dilemma of desal vs. drinking treated sewage water, the opinion could be that desal would be preferable.  As I was being told that my time was up, I urged the Commission and staff to consider brackish wells at the sea coast, which would avoid the negative impacts on marine life that an open marine water intake would pose, and therefore, permitting would likely be much easier.

[Brackish Desalination Projects] I am not sure the Commission heard me…the Chair continued to tell me my time was up.

By the way, this City Water Commission meeting was held in the Downtown Library upstairs meeting room an hour after the library had closed.  No staff was at the door to allow Commissioners or members of the public in.  By a strange coincidence, the General Manager of Soquel Creek Water District was waiting inside the library lobby for another District staff member to arrive, and kindly let me in.

COMMENT NOW ON THE COUNTY’S EMERGENCY EVACUATION PLAN
If you care about what this County’s plan for emergency evacuation could look like, take a moment to look through the Draft County Emergency Operations Plan and send in your comment by December 16.
 OA Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) Base Plan.

Note that the Watsonville Airport is crucial in disasters…shouldn’t the County help pay for maintaining it?  Currently, that falls on the wallet of the City of Watsonville.

2.3.4.4 Air
The Watsonville Municipal Airport serves the general aviation community and
supports limited freight operations. The airport is the only fixed runway facility in
the county capable of handling large aircraft and is designated as an essential
facility in disaster response.

(page 52)

Please write the County Board of Supervisors and ask that they consider countywide funding of the airport in Watsonville.
Board of Supervisors (boardofsupervisors@santacruzcountyca.gov)

The Santa Cruz County Office of Response, Recovery and Resilience (OR3) is pleased to announce the draft Santa Cruz County Operational Area (OA) Evacuation Planning Appendix is now available for public review and comment from December 6, 2024 to December 16, 2024. Thank you to everyone who has contributed information, insights, and interviews to inform this current draft. (See link below)

The Evacuation Planning Appendix provides a framework for preparedness, response, and recovery operations related to a planned or spontaneous evacuation due to a natural, human-caused, or industrial emergency. This Appendix is a supplement to information within the OA Emergency Operations Plan (EOP) Base Plan.

Engaging with the “whole community” is an important aspect of our planning efforts at the County. We look forward to your constructive feedback, suggested revisions, and insights to refine and enhance the Appendix. Please feel free to share the draft widely.

Click the link to download a copy of the plan and submit feedback: Evacuation Planning Appendix

Thank you for your unwavering commitment to the safety and resilience of our community. Should you have any questions or require additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you!

Respectfully,

Amanda Gullings | Emergency Services Analyst (she/her)

amanda.gullings@santacruzcountyca.gov

831.454.3579 (O)

WHAT IS GOING ON UP THERE?
The large white golf-ball-like device on top of the County Sheriff Dept. has become a landmark for many, shared by the new pedestrian overcrossing on Highway One.  Two years ago, the people were told this weather radar equipment was 100% grant-funded, and  would provide publicly-available information about local storm activity and help in disaster preparedness.

Is that happening?

Recent correspondence with County staff has revealed that Public Works officials do not know much about the equipment and do not rely on it for storm activity affecting local rivers and streams.  They also did not know how to access any data that it might provide, instead relying on USGS stream gauges to monitor water levels during intense storms.

Better information came from another staff member, Antonella Gentile, and former flood control engineer at Public Works, Dr. Mark Strudley.

While we do utilize the radar system during storm monitoring, we are in the process of identifying long-term maintenance options for the radar system and funding sources for that maintenance.  One of the maintenance options is currently being pursued as a partnership with Scripps Institution at UC San Diego.  While a contract has not been negotiated with them, they are currently displaying the data from the radar and have plans to continue improving the interface.  You can view the interface here.  There is an archive tool available on the interface, but I do not think it is working yet, as the interface is still in development.  Real-time data is available during active weather, so tune in during the next rain event.  Please also try the dual-screen mode (button on the top of the radar display) to compare the data from the NWS radar to the County’s radar. 

The radar sensor covers inland areas within Santa Cruz County as well as the Monterey Bay and the north coast.  It is limited by the Santa Cruz Mountains, so the inland extent is somewhat less than the area within the circle shown below (snapshot from the map at AQPI Radar Viewer).  Select “Santa Cruz Reflectivity” or “Santa Cruz Rain Rate” from the layers icon on the map to see the circle and to monitor the data from our radar during wet weather.

Take a look at the data in the next storm and see what you think.

WHAT WILL HAPPEN WITH CALIFORNIA’S BUDGET?
A recent Cal Matters Opinion Letter in the Sentinel really gave me pause.  I am worried about the mounting debt at all levels of government.  The article below should make us all pause and ask…who can we hold accountable?

“Gov. Gavin Newsom’s Department of Finance, based on one short-term spike in income taxes, projected that revenues from the state’s three largest sources would remain above $200 billion a year indefinitely.

Newsom then declared that the budget had a $97.5 billion surplus, although that number never appeared in any documents.

“No other state in American history has ever experienced a surplus as large as this,” Newsom bragged as he unveiled a 2022-23 fiscal year budget that topped $300 billion.

With that in mind, he and the Legislature adopted a budget with billions in new spending, most notably on health and welfare programs and cash payments to poor families.
Within a few weeks, Newsom and legislators learned that real revenues were falling well short of the rosy projections. But the damage, in terms of expanded spending, was done.

Two years later, buried in its fine print, the deficit-ridden 2024-25 budget acknowledged that sales taxes and personal and corporate income tax revenues would fall well short of the $200 billion a year projection, estimating a $165.1 billion shortfall over four years.

The Legislature’s budget analyst, Gabe Petek, unveiled his office’s annual overview of the state’s finances Wednesday and it wasn’t a pretty picture.

There’s been a recent uptick in personal income tax revenues thanks to wealthy investors’ stock market gains , some stemming from Donald Trump’s presidential victory. However, Petek said, government spending — much of it dating from 2022’s phony surplus — is continuing to outpace revenues from “a sluggish economy,” creating operating deficits.

Assembly Speaker Robert Rivas, reacting to the analysis in a statement, indicated that he’s gotten the message.

“We need to show restraint with this year’s budget, because California must be prepared for any challenges, including ones from Washington,” Rivas said. “It’s not a moment for expanding programs, but for protecting and preserving services that truly benefit all Californians.”

Newsom will propose a 2025-26 budget in January, but no matter what he and the Legislature decide, the structural budget deficit will still be there when he exits the governorship in 2027. It will be part of his legacy”

California State Budget Error

THERE ARE JUST TOO MANY REGULATIONS TO KEEP TRACK OF!
Take a look at what I came across while doing some research.  What do you think?

11340. Legislative findings and declarations

The Legislature finds and declares as follows:
(a) There has been an unprecedented growth in the number of administrative regulations in recent years.
(b) The language of many regulations is frequently unclear and unnecessarily complex, even when the complicated and technical nature of the subject matter is taken into account. The language is often confusing to the persons who must comply with the regulations.
(c) Substantial time and public funds have been spent in adopting regulations, the necessity for which has not been established.
(d) The imposition of prescriptive standards upon private persons and entities through regulations where the establishment of performance standards could reasonably be expected to produce the same result has placed an unnecessary burden on California citizens and discouraged innovation, research, and development of improved means of achieving desirable social goals.
(e) There exists no central office in state government with the power and duty to review regulations to ensure that they are written in a comprehensible manner, are authorized by statute, and are consistent with other law.
(f) Correcting the problems that have been caused by the unprecedented growth of regulations in California requires the direct involvement of the Legislature as well as that of the executive branch of state government.
(g) The complexity and lack of clarity in many regulations put small businesses, which do not have the resources to hire experts to assist them, at a distinct disadvantage.

AT&T PLANS TO ELIMINATE COPPER LANDLINES IN FIVE YEARS
Earlier this year, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors took AT&T leaders to task in a public meeting and defended the peoples’ need to have copper landline telephone service kept intact and operational.  AT&T had applied with their regulatory agency, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to drop all such landlines as a carrier of last resort.  Amazingly, the CPUC sided with the people and denied the AT&T request.

But now, AT&T has issued a five-year warning that they plan to drop these copper landlines. Stay tuned! MSN

A LAST LOOK AT THE APTOS VILLAGE PROJECT….REMEMBERING THE WORLD-FAMOUS POST OFFICE JUMPS
I have often wondered about how all the backroom deals behind the Aptos Village Project ever got pulled together, and what deals continue still.  The area used to be a haven for kids to ride their bikes in the world-famous Post Office Jumps.  But Swenson bulldozed it all away without permits and without a care for the youth.  Swenson also dug up a buried fuel tank and hauled it away in the middle of the night, telling County Environmental Health staff investigating the foul diesel air that the tank had been located in a different location than where it actually had been located.  But that soil was contaminated, too.  And the water going to the Soquel Creek Water District’ Granite Way Well adjacent and downstream gradient?   Well…..

Take a look below at recent photos.  There is nothing there for the kids anymore.

These homes are built on the area where the underground fuel tank was buried.

How can anyone ever imagine this fits the character of the neighborhood, namely, the Bayview Hotel?

The hillside seen to the right in the image is the “park” that Swenson will someday donate to the County, and for which the County granted free easement across the Aptos Village Park adjacent for the large drainage pipes to dump parking lot storm water into the Aptos Creek.

The road to Nisene Marks State Park from Granite Way is gone, removing a bike pump track for young kids, a parking area that made wonderful Community concert days in the Park disappear, and removing an emergency access for the neighorhood.

What a shame that the world-famous Post Office Bike Jumps are gone…

An Ode to the Aptos Post Office Jumps | A Half-Acre of Glory

LISTEN IN ON FRIDAYS
Every Friday, 2pm-4pm, I host an online radio program called “Community Matters”.  I hope you will listen in from your computer or smart device and call in to join discussions about local topics and interesting people who are actively working to improve our Community.  The Santa Cruz Voice platform was begun by a group who really felt it important to provide good local radio in a way that does not require alot of expense and regulation.

This Friday, Ms. Sarah Christensen, the new CEO of the Santa Cruz Regional Transportation Commission (RTC),  will be my Guest.   What is the latest news on the rail trail and passenger train?

Listen in! santacruzvoice.com

THE IMPORTANCE OF CERTIFIED FARMERS MARKETS
Santa Cruz County is a bountiful and wonderful place to be.  Visiting the local farmers markets is a good way to find your healthy, locally-grown food and meet the folks who grew it for you.  Here is a good interview about our local farmers market network.  I think you will enjoy it!

A FOOD CHAIN RELEASE FROM MICHAEL OLSON 
If we are what we eat, then we are what is in those colorful packages of food that fill the shelves of the nations’ grocers.  But that is only the beginning of the story, because we are also what our food eats.  And that leads us to ask:

What does our food eat?

The Food Chain Radio Show & Podcast with Michael Olson hosts Catherine Barr, Executive Director, Monterey Bay Area Certified Farmers Markets, for a conversation about guaranteeing the authenticity of food.

Topics include a look at why California established a state-sponsored Certified Farmers Market Program; how the foods sold through the certified program are guaranteed to be from the farmers who sell the foods; and how the markets enforce the guarantee.

Show:  “Real Food from Real Farmers: Guaranteed!” (#1377)
Host: Michael Olson,  www.metrofarm.com: 
Sponsor:  TimeShare Media:

A TRIBUTE TO BRUCE
Since writing this contribution, I received the news that Bruce passed away in his sleep.  Though sad, it is a blessing.  I have thought of him so much since, and have felt honored to have known and worked together with him here.  Bruce spent alot of time trying to help me learn better, writing technique,  always stressing succinctness.  Well, that lesson is still in progress….

It was an honor to  learn from someone like Bruce who truly cared about our Community.  He told me about his work with the group in Operation Wilder back in the 1970’s, to stop the backroom deals that were spinning a plan to build 10,000 homes, a high-rise hotel, shopping center, conference center and seven acres of parking lot in the place where Wilder Ranch State Park is now.  We have Bruce and his dedicated crew of activists to thank….otherwise, that Park we all love and enjoy would be long gone.

Please join me in lighting a candle in honor of Bruce Bratton.  May he rest in peace with a life well-lived and a feisty spirit that lives on in the Community he loved and mentored.

Happy Winter Solstice,

Remember…

MAKE ONE CALL.  WRITE ONE LETTER.  ASK ELECTED OFFICIALS AND STAFF QUESTIONS AND EXPECT ANSWERS.
DO JUST ONE THING EVERY WEEK….YOU CAN MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE.

Cheers!
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

[Note: Grey wrote this before it was determined whether or not we continue the column without Bruce.]

A Place for the Environment
As a last column in this place, I want to reflect on the rarity of this space and ask this community to reflect on the reasons for environmental journalism to be so increasingly rare.

Environmental Journalism
We never expected the outwardly business-interest oriented Santa Cruz Sentinel to support environmental journalism, and it never really did. This has always been even more so with the Scotts Valley Banner. The Pajaronian, Monterey Herald, and Carmel Pine Cone have been little, if any, different. The present and past weekly newspapers have been the same…the Good Times, Metro Santa Cruz…Monterey County Weekly…same story: no environmental journalism.

We have recently seen the rise of e-news, but here again there is nothing to discover concerning environmental issues. Santa Cruz Local and Lookout Santa Cruz aren’t the same, but neither feature anything like environmental journalism.

Why
Do you consider our region to be environmentally friendly? If so, why do you think we do not support environmental journalism? Many people believe that we are surrounded by liberally minded, pro-environment citizens around the Monterey Bay. Politicians like to say ‘we’ protected this or that part of the ocean or the land…so, many of us must be environmentalists. Businesses and politicians frequently point to the magnificent nature around the Monterey Bay as an attractive area for tourism. With all of this apparent excitement and support for the environment, why the dearth of environmental journalism? Might it be that the marketing division of news sources are worried about their advertisers’ negative reactions to environmental journalism? The Garden Section probably won’t trigger such backlash and certainly the Sports Page isn’t going to do that…and, certain types of ‘news’ about crime, politicians, etc., also probably won’t cause business interest consternation.

Threats and Murder
The crisis in environmental journalism is global and includes widespread violence and even murder. I’m sure some readers have heard about environmental journalists being murdered south of the border. Although perhaps less violent, threats to environmental journalists are real even here: I have first-hand experience of intimidation and threats due to my investigations and writing, and I know many others have as well. I have spoken with reporters from major news organizations that have told me that environmental journalism is not a welcome part of their routine…it does not represent ‘news’ to the editors to whom they report. Standing up to power is scary and many would-be environmental journalists turn aside for fear of their safety and livelihood; self-censorship is common.

Now What?
When Bruce Bratton’s weekly blog goes, we lose the last source of environmental journalism in our region. For years, we have been able to hear from many journalists who are very intelligent and quite informed about regional issues. I have been very grateful for the privilege of joining them. Thank you, Bruce!

Starting next week, where will you turn to learn about the threats to the local environment, or what to do about them? You can be very sure that, without this source, there will be heightened environmental destruction.

What if…
What if some of the many very wealthy people in our region were to make long-term, large investments in environmental journalism? Might a major, multi-year gift to a media source such as Santa Cruz Local be a way to foster environmental journalism and, hence, a more pro-environmental acting citizenry? I have tried, and it does not seem that individual small donations will influence media outlets to change their stance to support environmental journalism. It will take something more. I am suggesting that large and long-term support is absolutely necessary as environmental journalism is an anathema to businesses. Business interests, including people aligned with the political mainstream of Social Democrats in our region, will not support media outlets that play environmental journalism forward.

What if, continued
What if any one of our local media sources were to outwardly embrace environmental journalism? A news outlet’s editorial department might decide that environmental journalism is an unoccupied niche that would receive readers’ attention. That outlet’s donor relations department might create a campaign to fund such an initiative. Editors of that outlet might advertise that their news would be moving in the direction of increased coverage of the environment and help people understand why that is important. They might even find that contributors to this blog would be willing to produce stories…
[Note: Grey wrote this before it was determined whether or not we continue the column without Bruce.]

A Place for the Environment
As a last column in this place, I want to reflect on the rarity of this space and ask this community to reflect on the reasons for environmental journalism to be so increasingly rare.

Environmental Journalism
We never expected the outwardly business-interest oriented Santa Cruz Sentinel to support environmental journalism, and it never really did. This has always been even more so with the Scotts Valley Banner. The Pajaronian, Monterey Herald, and Carmel Pine Cone have been little, if any, different. The present and past weekly newspapers have been the same…the Good Times, Metro Santa Cruz…Monterey County Weekly…same story: no environmental journalism.

We have recently seen the rise of e-news, but here again there is nothing to discover concerning environmental issues. Santa Cruz Local and Lookout Santa Cruz aren’t the same, but neither feature anything like environmental journalism.

Why
Do you consider our region to be environmentally friendly? If so, why do you think we do not support environmental journalism? Many people believe that we are surrounded by liberally minded, pro-environment citizens around the Monterey Bay. Politicians like to say ‘we’ protected this or that part of the ocean or the land…so, many of us must be environmentalists. Businesses and politicians frequently point to the magnificent nature around the Monterey Bay as an attractive area for tourism. With all of this apparent excitement and support for the environment, why the dearth of environmental journalism? Might it be that the marketing division of news sources are worried about their advertisers’ negative reactions to environmental journalism? The Garden Section probably won’t trigger such backlash and certainly the Sports Page isn’t going to do that…and, certain types of ‘news’ about crime, politicians, etc., also probably won’t cause business interest consternation.

Threats and Murder
The crisis in environmental journalism is global and includes widespread violence and even murder. I’m sure some readers have heard about environmental journalists being murdered south of the border. Although perhaps less violent, threats to environmental journalists are real even here: I have first-hand experience of intimidation and threats due to my investigations and writing, and I know many others have as well. I have spoken with reporters from major news organizations that have told me that environmental journalism is not a welcome part of their routine…it does not represent ‘news’ to the editors to whom they report. Standing up to power is scary and many would-be environmental journalists turn aside for fear of their safety and livelihood; self-censorship is common.

Now What?
When Bruce Bratton’s weekly blog goes, we lose the last source of environmental journalism in our region. For years, we have been able to hear from many journalists who are very intelligent and quite informed about regional issues. I have been very grateful for the privilege of joining them. Thank you, Bruce!

Starting next week, where will you turn to learn about the threats to the local environment, or what to do about them? You can be very sure that, without this source, there will be heightened environmental destruction.

What if…
What if some of the many very wealthy people in our region were to make long-term, large investments in environmental journalism? Might a major, multi-year gift to a media source such as Santa Cruz Local be a way to foster environmental journalism and, hence, a more pro-environmental acting citizenry? I have tried, and it does not seem that individual small donations will influence media outlets to change their stance to support environmental journalism. It will take something more. I am suggesting that large and long-term support is absolutely necessary as environmental journalism is an anathema to businesses. Business interests, including people aligned with the political mainstream of Social Democrats in our region, will not support media outlets that play environmental journalism forward.

What if, continued
What if any one of our local media sources were to outwardly embrace environmental journalism? A news outlet’s editorial department might decide that environmental journalism is an unoccupied niche that would receive readers’ attention. That outlet’s donor relations department might create a campaign to fund such an initiative. Editors of that outlet might advertise that their news would be moving in the direction of increased coverage of the environment and help people understand why that is important. They might even find that contributors to this blog would be willing to produce stories…

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Thursday, December 12, 2024

#347 / Bruce Bratton: ¡Presente!

Bruce Bratton ¡Presente!

Bruce Bratton, who died yesterday, made an indelible impact on my hometown community of Santa Cruz,  California. I am proud to have known Bruce, and to have worked with him. I am proud to have been his friend. I am grateful for Bruce’s enormous contributions to the community.

I came to live in the City of Santa Cruz in 1971. Bruce had showed up here a few years earlier. By the time I arrived, Bruce had already played a major role in helping to stop the construction of a nuclear power plant in Davenport, California. Shortly after my arrival, Bruce and a few stalwart others formed “Operation Wilder,” to derail the development of a massive expansion of the City of Santa Cruz onto the Santa Cruz County North Coast.

On what is now Wilder Ranch State Park, a Southern California development company was proposing to build 10,000 new homes. Had it been approved, that proposed development would have essentially doubled the population of the City, all by itself. Bruce and the other leaders of Operation Wilder, fighting this proposal, were sued by the developer for $181,000,000, apiece. That didn’t stop Bruce (or Operation Wilder). That development proposal, which would have fundamentally altered the future of my local community, and which would have turned the Santa Cruz County North Coast into a massive example of Silicon Valley-like urban sprawl, paving over both wildlands and agricultural land, was defeated.

Bruce Bratton played a leading role.

At the very same time that the fight to stop the development on Wilder Ranch was taking place, I got involved in another fight to save our coast – the fight to “Save Lighthouse Field,” the last remaining undeveloped open space right on the coastline in the City. We did save Lighthouse Field, just as Bruce and Operation Wilder saved our county’s North Coast by defeating the Wilder Ranch and Beaches project.

Those two land use victories were the basis upon which a vital, local, community-based politics was founded. From the very beginning, Bruce was a leader in stimulating, goading, agitating, and organizing for that kind of community-based politics, right up until yesterday. Bruce Bratton’s spirit and influence isn’t going to disappear, either.

My thanks to Bruce Bratton for his incredible contributions to our community. Let our memory of Bruce be for a blessing for this community, which owes Bruce Bratton so much!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

TEMPORARY PARALYSIS, TRUMP’S WORLD, MUGWUMPS, ONE TRUCK

Last week from the Borowitz Report, dateline Paris“The much-anticipated reopening of Notre Dame Cathedral on Saturday was ruined by the appearance of the Antichrist, observers said. Beelzebub, who had traveled form Palm Beach, was heard loudly complaining that he had come ‘all the way to Notre Dame and there was no football game.’ He late disrupted the ceremony by loudly hawking a shipment of $60 Bibles he had just received from China. French President Emmanuel Macron apologized to the world for inviting the Archfiend, but added, ‘At least he didn’t bring Elon.'”

Following the election of the AntichristJon Stewart on the Daily Show, said of the upcoming Trump administration, “This isn’t the end. I promise you, this is not the end. And we have to regroup, and we have to continue to fight, and continue to work day in and day out to create a better society for our children, for this world,” telling the studio audience, “…you just have temporary anxiety and paralysis that comes with disappointment and just a soupçon of despair…like we just looked down and realized there’s nothing beneath our feet,” ala the Roadrunner and Coyote at cliffside. Describing his own feelings about the election, he said, “In the joint custody agreement we now have in America, the kids are going to have to live with Dad for the summer and you just have to…eat it.”

Fox News poll has reported that a majority of Americans are hopeful about the re-election of President-elect Donald Trump, they are divided when it comes to the top nominees he has named for his administration, with 47% approving and 50% disapproving. His handling of the transition period has a 55% approval rating, higher than was the case in his previous transition to the high office, but far behind the approvals experienced by other recent presidents according to CNN. A Marist Poll records 86% approval on the Republican side, a 72% Democrat disapproval, and among independents, 43% disapproval and 38% approval which indicates a wait-and-see attitude. Trump’s choices have been named at a faster pace than eight years ago, but setbacks are likely, with Matt Gaetz already being eliminated…rather quickly.

USA Today columnist Nicole Russell says, “Donald Trump is still only the president-elect, but global leaders already are treating the incoming 47th president as America’s top leader. That bodes well for the Trump administration for the next four years, but it also raises the questions about the capacity for leadership of the Oval Office’s current occupant. That’s Joe Biden, by the way. Remember him?” Russell says that Biden and VP Harris have all but disappeared since the November election, with a month to go before the regime changeover. Trump was in the spotlight in Paris at Notre Dame, with Jill Biden being practically ignored by world leaders who flocked to Trump. French president Macron and Ukraine’s President Zelenskyy held talks with him and the UK’s Prince William had a brief meeting, as Trump smilingly enjoyed the much-desired attention. His reception clearly shows that the sitting US president has been abandoned for his lack of leadership. Russell asks, “If Democrats are already so irrelevant despite holding the Oval Office, what happens to them after Biden has left the building? But within the Democratic Party, on Capitol Hill – and even within his own administration – it feels like he left the Oval Office weeks ago.”

“As we’ve seen with Trump’s rambling speeches and news conferences, more isn’t always better. But disappearing from the public eye and from accountability via media engagement also is a bad look,” Russell continued. She mentions Joe’s pardon of his son, Hunter, as a strike against his legacy and at a cost to the public’s trust. In her view, “Global leaders’ deference to Trump says everything we need to know about the perception the world holds about Biden’s strength versus Trump’s. That is a good sign for America’s future as we leave behind the failures of the recent past. Joe Biden is still president, but it’s already Donald Trump’s world.” Sad, but true?

Chris Lehmann of The Nation magazine writes, “The air is still thick with postmortems of the 2024 election, but there’s already another mystery of public opinion that deserves at least as much scrutiny as the dismal outcome of presidential balloting. Americans beholding the squalid, bottom-feeding composition of the Trump cabinet-in-waiting – a grim panoply of grifters, self-dealing hacks, and sexual assaulters – report that they like what they see. Fifty-three percent of respondents say they’re optimistic or excited about the prospects for a second term – a photographic negative of the initial dawn of the Trump era, where that same majority said that it scared or concerned them. These findings come in the wake of a series of objectively awful appointments and botched and corrupt follow-throughs…this is to say nothing, of course, of the woeful unpreparedness of cabinet nominees for the consequential posts they’re assuming.” Lehmann ponders the public embrace of government corruption in examining Trump’s “bad-boys-fixation,” as characterized by Axios’ Jim Van De Hei and Mike Allen, who theorize that the “cabinet picks are a hit with male supporters who rally to brash confrontation as a political virtue.” Still, The Don is quite popular with white women voters, even though “characters like Musk, Oz and Ramaswamy are hardly swaggering studies in traditional machismo.”

Lehmann feels that the appeal of Trump’s named team is the force that fuels Trump’s popularity: his frontal assault of the ideology of meritocracy, as he insists that the political and business establishments are rigged against the public interest. “If the foundations of public life were mobbed-up, Trump argues, the trick is to have a mobbed-up insider using his influence on behalf of forgotten ordinary Americans. The pitch was essentially a dumbed-down version of FDR’s pledge to govern as a traitor to his moneyed class, except that Trump has proceeded to cultivate cronyism, using the powers of the state to reward personal fealty and punish what he views as ungrateful betrayals of his beneficence,” Lehmann writes. He feels that the assault on meritocracy by Trump and his cronies is a vision of government by and for the mobbed-up, that John Ganz terms the gangster Gemeinshcaft – a rigged system devised to ensure that insiders clean up at the expense of everybody else. In a message to the Democrats, who still cling to the core precepts of meritocratic rule, Lehmann remarks that to pull voters back into their fold, “there is no mystic messaging strategy or savvy payback tactic that will get this done in a single campaign; instead, the party needs to take a long, hard look at its own massive and deliberate retreat from a vital working-class politics in its elite-driven repudiation of the Bernie Sanders movement. A party movement that lives by meritocracy can very easily die by it. Just ask the Mugwups.”

In the continuing adventures of 2020 Election Denier, cash-strapped Mike Lindell, of MyPillow fame: he has filed a lawsuit against a corporate payday lender who “deceived” his company into accepting a $1.6M loan with a 409% annual interest rate. Lindell claims not to have any money as he juggles three other loans through the courts. Eighteen corporate entitles, plus MyPillow, claim that Cobalt Funding Solutions, and Streamline Advance also being involved, engaged in racketeering by extending a high-interest merchant cash advance, taking advantage of cash-strapped businesses that needed funds quickly. In OctoberLifetime Funding accused Lindell of defaulting on a $600,000 advance, and Shine Capital Group filed suit on a default of $2M from July. MyPillow borrowed $10M in 2022, later being dumped by lawyers for non-payment of legal expenses. Seeking cash advances can only mean that his situation has worsened, and as Lindell told NBC News earlier this year he “has no money and is down to his house and his truck.” Guess it means that the man who won the ‘Prove Mike Wrong‘ contest by proving that Mike’s evidence for the stolen election was useless won’t be getting his $5M payoff?

The Wall Street Journal has reported that president-elect Trump has been lobbying Florida’s Governor Ron DeSantis to consider appointing his daughter-in-law, Lara Trump to finish the last two years of Senator Marco Rubio’s term should Rubio be approved for the secretary of state position on Trump’s cabinet. Lara resigned from her Republican National Committee position to be ready for any movement in that direction, saying the Senate seat is “something I would seriously consider.” Many Republicans have been pushing the idea – currying favor with The Don – because her main qualification is that she married into the Trump family. She is also noted for producing and hosting a pro-Trump video program for her father-in-law’s campaign, and as co-chair of the RNC, she directed donations for the Republican Party into Trump-oriented goals such as paying off his legal bills. Best forgotten is her attempt at a music career which was blown to smithereens by her cringey music video about firefighters. During the presidential campaign she claimed that Kamala Harris didn’t get her jobs based on merit, but only because she’s a woman, while saying, “Do me a favor. Don’t ever give me a position based on the fact that I’m a woman. Either I earned it, or I didn’t – and that’s it. That’s all I need.” Jimmy Kimmel joked on his show, “Well, may I introduce Senator Lara Trump, ladies and gentlemen: graduated with a BA in communications at NC State, studied at the French Culinary Institute. Get that lady in government right away. Maybe it’s Trump’s way of telling her to please stop singing. I don’t know.” On the bright side, Kimmel said that the Florida Senate seat won’t go to former congressman Matt Gaetz, since he starts hosting a show on One America News in January. He adds, “For those who aren’t familiar with OAN, it’s like Fox News but crazier and younger, which is just the way Matt Gaetz likes it.”

Our community is a sadder place this month…remember Bruce!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Life well lived

“The man is a success who has lived well, loved much, and laughed often.”
~Robert Louis Stevenson

“The highest tribute to the dead is not grief but gratitude.”
~Thornton Wilder

“As a day well spent brings happy sleep, so life well used brings happy death.”
~Leonardo da Vinci

“No one is actually dead until the ripples they cause in the world die away.”
~Terry Pratchett

“You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough.”
~Mae West

“Neither fire nor wind, birth nor death can erase our good deeds”
~Buddha

...

Courtesy of one of my partners, here are some stories from Bruce’s 90th birthday party this past summer. It was a fantastic shindig, and you can tell he enjoyed the hell out of it! 🙂


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
84 Blackburn Street, Apt 102
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Cell phone: (831) 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...

Subconscious Comics

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

December 4 – 10, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton… time flies … Greensite… on Misogyny… Steinbruner… out this week … Hayes… A place for the environment… Patton… That First “R” Comes First For A Reason… Matlock… inauguration grift…FAFO…seeking cellmates…stay tuned… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you Malls turned into housing? … Quotes on… “Holidays”

...

THE BEAUTIFUL SPIVEY’S RESTAURANT. This was taken November 13, 1964. This gorgeous structure was on the corner of Ocean and Water Streets where Chase Bank sits. (formerly Home Savings & Washington Mutual). Spivey’s was always open 24 hours and I have no idea who owned it, or if it was part of a chain…any info out there??

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.
Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com

Dateline: December 4, 2024

A HECTIC TIME. So much going on, and Christmas is getting closer and closer. It’s more surreal every year, it seems. How is it possible that we are almost all the way through 2024 already? What happened this year, what was good and what was bad? Besides the oh-so-obvious, of course… I’ll go look at some “best of” lists and see what resonates.

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

EMILIA PEREZ. Netflix movie. **** (7.3 IMDB). An amazing mix of musical and drama like I’ve never seen before. Zoe Saldana and Selena Gomez take leads in this Mexico City mystery that flips between sex changes and family values. We’ll see more of this film around Oscar time as Netflix continues to sell it. DO not miss it.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

BILLIONAIRE ISLAND. Netflix series. (6.3 IMDB). We learn from this drama that Norway is the world’s salmon producer. Because of this there’s a ruthless woman rival who works very hard and only partially honestly to take the Salmon farm and business from her. It also tells us the difference between farmed and wild salmon. There’s lots of rich people living their lives with golf and generally focusing on making more money. Interesting but not compelling.

NOBODY WANTS THIS. Netflix series (8.1 IMDB). Adding a so called “romantic comedy” is rare for BrattonOnline but this one has a 8.1 IMDB AND THAT’S RARE. It stars Kristin Bell as the shiksa (now 44 years old) and Adam Brody as the Rabbi. It’s all in L.A. and it’s fast paced and focuses on the relationship between LA Angelenos and the large and influential Jewish population. Plus the gay population gets their share of the comedy in their 25 minute programs.

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB)*** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and the reviews are stupendously great and RARE. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

CIVIL WAR. Max movie (7.1 IMDB) *** Has some fine scenes, but falls apart en toto. Kirsten Dunst, Jessie Plemons and Wagner Moura lead the cast. It really is about a new civil war right here in the USA. Reporters, photographers and politicians all race around headed to Washington D.C. to talk to and change how the president is thinking. Texas and California withdraw from the union and more hell breaks out. Watch it only if this seems and looks like a nightmare to you.

THE DELIVERANCE. Netflix movie. (5.1 IMDB) ** Glenn Close leads the first part of this haunted house re-hash and she does a fine job. Then all the other characters turn it into the old Hollywood scary movie vehicle and take the thrills and fun out of it. As apparently required nowadays the racial issues are thrown in to give us some thoughtful stuff to focus on.  Avoid this one.

THE PERFECT COUPLE. Netflix series. (6.6 IMDB)  *** It takes place on Nantucket Island in Massachusetts.  Nicole Kidman, Live Schreiber and Dakota Fanning are the lead stars. A big and important wedding is about to happen and there’s a murder of all things. So the movie is all focused on whodunit! Suspicious darts are thrown and there really isn’t much of a surprise left to care about. It’s about a blah movie and you’ve seen it many, many times before.

BREATHLESS.  Net series. (6.3 IMDB) ***This Spanish production centers and details the business side of running a hospital. It deals with, and carefully exploits the union angles of labor managing, it revolves around the constant conflict between medicine and money. There doesn’t seem to be much difference between Mexican and United States in hospital operations

KAOS. Netflix series. (7.5 IMDB). * Even after viewing this one I’m not sure if it’s supposed to be a comedy or a semi serious religious Greek drama. Jeff Goldblum and David Thewlis play their darndest at being Zeus and Hades stomping around Olympus trying to influence any survivors who’ll listen to them. Read a good book instead.

MONSIEUR SPADE. Netflix series. (6.9 IMDB) * Clive Owen is either paying off a bet or simply forgot how to act…he plays at being the Dashiell Hammett character Sam Spade in this political drama set in France in 1963. He lives in the south of France and is supposed to be 60. A priest, an investigator, a mess of a cast all looking for a young girl named Teresa, don’t even think about this one!

HORIZON: AN AMERICAN SAGA. HBO series (6.8 IMDB) ** Kevin Costner (who must have had some lifting of face) not only directed this saga but is one of many featured costars along with Sienna Miller, and Luke Wilson. There is a murder in Montana during our civil war and the movie features a large focus on “Native Americans” being careful to respect them as important humans in a rare drama.

...

December 2, 2024
Misogyny on the Rise

Having worked in the field of violence against women for many decades, I take notice when these issues emerge from their veil of privacy into the public eye. Hence, the photo taken while in Costa Rica in 2020. I wondered if the folks behind this poster campaign at the University of Costa Rica enjoy the full support of their institution or whether they must battle for support, resources, and visibility, ]s I did at UCSC for thirty years.

There is no question we have made progress in destigmatizing rape and domestic violence. But there are many signs of backsliding, including ones close to home.

A December 1 headline in the Santa Cruz Sentinel titled, Threats toward Women Increase, detailed the online increase in misogynistic entries since the election of Donald Trump. Given the nature of online postings, the spread is swift and broad. While the initiators of disturbing slogans such as Your Body, My Choice may be extremists, they apparently find a ready audience in the wider communities. Whether the rhetoric leads to more actual male violence against girls and women is an unknown for now, however it is causing fear and alarm which are sufficient to restrict women’s freedom of movement and peace of mind.

I was discouraged with the response from the two women interviewed by Associated Press for the article. Their fear is understandable: how they are dealing with it is what is of concern. One student says she is carrying pepper spray around campus and her mom has ordered her and her sister a self-defense kit that includes keychain spikes, a hidden knife key and a personal alarm. Well-intentioned and ineffective.

In the decades when Women’s Self-defense was ubiquitous on college campuses and in communities across the country, gadgets such as pepper spray were shown to be worse than useless. They gave a false sense of security and in one study, all the women who tried to use them against volunteer “attackers” failed in the attempt. By contrast, the skills learned in a Women’s Self-defense class include practice in verbal assertiveness and simple, effective physical techniques to disarm an attacker, not to be confused with martial arts. In Santa Cruz, we had a robust Women’s Self-defense program at UCSC and classes in the community sponsored by the city’s Commission for the Prevention of Violence Against Women. No longer.

First came the ideology. Sometime early in the new century, word spread in rape prevention circles that unless an activity could be defined as “primary prevention” it was not worth adopting. “Primary prevention” meant stopping men raping. According to those promoting this ideology, self-defense did not fall under “primary prevention,” so it was actively discouraged and eventually abandoned on college campuses. When I cited examples of students who shared with me how they effectively got rid of an attacker using skills they learned in a Women’s self-defense class, the retort was that those men would just rape other women, so it was not “primary prevention.”

The City of Santa Cruz held on for a while. This year, however, they supported the city schools’ district ending its decade long self-defense classes for middle and high school girls and boys and replaced them with an online self-esteem, healthy relationships video funded by the city. This shift caught the attention of the public and of the 2023-24 Grand Jury (full disclosure, I was a member). The Grand Jury recommended the city work with the school district to reintroduce the self-defense program. The response was a negative, which was the same for the other Grand Jury recommendations addressing community safety.

While the City of Santa Cruz is retreating from its past leadership role in addressing issues of violence against women, other communities are stepping up their efforts. San Mateo County has just launched a pilot program in response to domestic violence. Among several initiatives, an advocate will now accompany law enforcement in its response to a domestic violence call. The advocate can offer resources and support on the spot which often means the difference between life and death. This effort is in response to five homicides in the city of San Mateo in 2024, all domestic violence related. In addition, two suicides were domestic violence related.

October is Domestic Violence Awareness month. Each year for the month of October, the Santa Cruz Sentinel publishes the daily tally for domestic violence calls to Emergency Dispatch. The total calls for October 2024 were three hundred and eighty-nine. In 2021 a woman was killed in a domestic violence attack in the City of Santa Cruz.

Given the current climate of overt misogyny, both online and in the real world, it would be wise for any city to double-down on its efforts to prevent male violence against women. The Grand Jury gave the City of Santa Cruz ample evidence of the need, and thoughtful recommendations for a response. In rejecting the recommendations, the city has signaled where violence against women falls on its list of priorities.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

Nothing from Becky this week, but the work continues on behind the scenes!

WRITE ONE LETTER. MAKE ONE CALL. ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers!
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

A Place for the Environment
I want to reflect on the rarity of this space and ask this community to reflect on the reasons for environmental journalism to be so increasingly rare.

Environmental Journalism
We never expected the outwardly business-interest oriented Santa Cruz Sentinel to support environmental journalism, and it never really did. This has always been even more so with the Scotts Valley Banner. The Pajaronian, Monterey Herald, and Carmel Pine Cone have been little, if any, different. The present and past weekly newspapers have been the same…the Good Times, Metro Santa Cruz…Monterey County Weekly…same story: no environmental journalism.

We have recently seen the rise of e-news, but here again there is nothing to discover concerning environmental issues. Santa Cruz Local and Lookout Santa Cruz aren’t the same, but neither feature anything like environmental journalism.

Why
Do you consider our region to be environmentally friendly? If so, why do you think we do not support environmental journalism? Many people believe that we are surrounded by liberally minded, pro-environment citizens around the Monterey Bay. Politicians like to say ‘we’ protected this or that part of the ocean or the land…so, many of us must be environmentalists. Businesses and politicians frequently point to the magnificent nature around the Monterey Bay as an attractive area for tourism. With all of this apparent excitement and support for the environment, why the dearth of environmental journalism? Might it be that the marketing division of news sources are worried about their advertisers’ negative reactions to environmental journalism? The Garden Section probably won’t trigger such backlash and certainly the Sports Page isn’t going to do that…and, certain types of ‘news’ about crime, politicians, etc., also probably won’t cause business interest consternation.

Threats and Murder
The crisis in environmental journalism is global and includes widespread violence and even murder. I’m sure some readers have heard about environmental journalists being murdered south of the border. Although perhaps less violent, threats to environmental journalists are real even here: I have first-hand experience of intimidation and threats due to my investigations and writing, and I know many others have as well. I have spoken with reporters from major news organizations that have told me that environmental journalism is not a welcome part of their routine…it does not represent ‘news’ to the editors to whom they report. Standing up to power is scary and many would-be environmental journalists turn aside for fear of their safety and livelihood; self-censorship is common.

Now What?
Bruce Bratton is talking about retiring. When his weekly blog goes, we lose the last source of environmental journalism in our region. For years, we have been able to hear from many journalists who are very intelligent and quite informed about regional issues. I have been very grateful for the privilege of joining them. Thank you, Bruce!

Where will you turn to learn about the threats to the local environment, or what to do about them? You can be very sure that, without this source, there will be heightened environmental destruction.

What if…
What if some of the many very wealthy people in our region were to make long-term, large investments in environmental journalism? Might a major, multi-year gift to a media source such as Santa Cruz Local be a way to foster environmental journalism and, hence, a more pro-environmental acting citizenry? I have tried, and it does not seem that individual small donations will influence media outlets to change their stance to support environmental journalism. It will take something more. I am suggesting that large and long-term support is absolutely necessary as environmental journalism is an anathema to businesses. Business interests, including people aligned with the political mainstream of Social Democrats in our region, will not support media outlets that play environmental journalism forward.

What if, continued
What if any one of our local media sources were to outwardly embrace environmental journalism? A news outlet’s editorial department might decide that environmental journalism is an unoccupied niche that would receive readers’ attention. That outlet’s donor relations department might create a campaign to fund such an initiative. Editors of that outlet might advertise that their news would be moving in the direction of increased coverage of the environment and help people understand why that is important. They might even find that contributors to this blog would be willing to produce stories…

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Monday, December 2, 2024
#337 / That First “R” Comes First For A Reason

I was, at one time, on the Board of Directors of Californians Against Waste. I have also served on the Board of Directors of the Californians Against Waste Foundation. You can, by the way, click one of those links to make a donation (hint, hint)!

CAW and CAWF preach the “Three R’s.”

  • Reduce
  • Reuse
  • Recycle

I think it’s fair to say that concerned members of the public tend to focus on the value and importance of “that “Third R,” “Recycling.”

That’s OK, but it’s the “First R” that is most important. The picture above shows plastic materials I have kept around in my home, hoping to “reuse” them (haven’t done it, though, have I?). The photograph below, showing materials that we all assume will be recycled, is intended to help make clear the scope of the problem.

What we need most is not more “Recycling.” What we need most is “Less.”

Less production. Less consumption. Less waste. Less pollution. Less danger to the natural environment that sustains all of our human activities.

Christmas is coming.

How about “Less” for Christmas? That is what’s called for, and we are all being called!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

WE LET THIS HAPPEN, WE BROKE IT, WE FIX IT, STAY TUNED

Did you get yours? The Trump Inauguration invitation from the Trump National Committee 2024? The email is headlined “The Greatest Celebration in American History.” Imagine! The accompanying photo, beneath gold formal lettering reading “Join President Trump at his Second Inauguration,” shows a silhouette of Trump from the backside as he walks toward the podium on the viewing stand, with crowds of attendees stretching out across the Capitol Ellipse as far as the eye can see, and maybe farther than the eye can see! But wait! What’s this at the bottom of the photo…a link that says, “ENTER TO WIN.” You’ll have to scroll down, and squint, to read the tiny legalese in the paragraph at the bottom: “Contributions to Trump National Committee JFC are not deductible for federal income tax purposes, blah, blah, blah…It’s because of the commitment and support from real Patriots, like YOU, that we will SAVE AMERICA! Thank you again for your generous support.” And, the winner will get…it doesn’t say, no promises made, though the implication is that you will get to attend the the greatest inauguration…seated behind the podium?…or in the cow pasture beyond the Ellipse where even Sean Spicer will never see you? Just send money to find out!? Just remember that selecting that link puts you into the Grifting Arena!

Assuredly, it’s simply another grift! Remember all the previous ‘contests’ to win an onstage appearance with Trump at one of his rallies? Or dinner at Mar-a-Lago with the candidate? Or a flight to the RNC convention with the Trump Team? Just ask for a list of those winners (it’s already been done with zilch offered by The Team). It only took three weeks after Election Day (almost two months beyond the required October 1 signing)  for Trump to reach an agreement with the outgoing President Joe Biden’s administration to initiate the official transition of power, but he is NOT signing the agreement with the General Services Administration to unlock federal funding for the transition. In lieu of the government money, his changeover will be backed by private donors, operating as a “self-sufficient organization.” The so-called ‘memorandum of understanding’ between Trump and Biden will enable Trump and his team to access non-public government information, receive government briefings and deploy personnel inside the federal agencies and departments they will soon control. Trump has concern about the mandatory ethics pledge in the ‘memorandum,’ which was left unsigned, that included avoiding conflicts of interest in the White House; so instead, The Team announced it will use its “existing ethics plan for those involved,” which meets federal requirements and will be posted on the General Services Administration’s website. Questions still remain from the first Trump transition, with an accurate accounting of funds raised still hidden away from the feds…hard to believe, eh?

Trump’s vow to dispense with using taxpayer funding for the transition costs leaves his financial arrangements obscure, with donors being kept secret, despite a promise: “Donors to the transition will be disclosed to the public. Consistent with Transition policy already in place, the Transition will not accept foreign donations.” To date, Trump’s Cabinet nominees have not undergone FBI vetting, prompting Senator Elizabeth Warren’s response, “[the team’s announcement] fails to answer key questions about national security threats and FBI vetting of nominees, and increases concerns about corruption. There appear to be serious gaps between the Trump transition’s ethics agreement and the letter of the law. The reliance of private donors to fund the transition is nothing more than a ploy for well-connected Trump insiders to line their pockets while pretending to save taxpayer’s money.” In a November 13 meeting at the White House between Biden and Trump, Biden welcomed the president-elect and promised a smooth transition.

Trump’s refusal to accept GSA funds in the transition is a first, which means the GSA’s ability to ascertain transparency that individual donations don’t exceed $5000 or that foreign influences are kept at bay…a concern since there are no restrictions on international donations for transitions, as are in place for presidential campaigns. In shutting out FBI background checks, The Team is conducting private checking…call it ‘Trump gets a pass to pass?’ NBC News’s Chuck Todd has taken issue with Trump’s cabinet selections, questioning whether he has taken moral character into consideration…however a low-lifer might venture into that realm is yet another question…while suggesting that the picks are a “low-character crowd.” Todd says, “He knows he’s behaved badly over the years…he has civil judgements against him to prove it…in his drive to achieve fame and fortune. So, following that logic, nothing makes his success look more mainstream and acceptable than surrounding himself with people who have never let their moral compass get in the way of their own ambitions. No one is saying that someone who is accused of sexual misconduct but isn’t charged with a crime should be cancelled from society or be impacted in their ability to get a job.” He laments that ‘character’ shouldn’t be a partisan attribute, that there are many supporters in each party with good character, but that perhaps we have gone from being “a bit too puritan” to “a bit too permissive.” Continuing, he says, “The minute you start making an exception for character flaws on your side of the political fence, you’ll regret it, because one day it will be coming from a political opponent and not a political ally; and, wouldn’t it be a shame if the electorate decided that politics now belongs to the low-character crowd. This is the moment I fear we are now facing.” Jimmy Kimmel summed it up pretty well when he said on his show, “The President is a criminal. 34 times over, he’s a convicted criminal. Truth be told he’s not even looking for a cabinet…he’s looking for cellmates. Okay?”

“We’re a country of 330-plus million, with all that entails. But if we stop demanding or attempting to find high-quality character in our elected officials, then how are we going to become a ‘more perfect union’?” Todd asks. “And yet, does anyone believe the current political world is attracting the best and brightest into public service? We as a nation have taken this concept of ‘ends justifies the means’ and essentially turned the country’s North Star of ‘whatever it takes’ for our own success, not just ‘whatever it takes’ for our own survival,” he concludes. A questioner on the Quora website questions why the MAGA cult is still angry after success in the electoral process, even though they were warned what would happen as they feigned understanding.  Paraphrasing an answer by Tiffany Thomas, where she writes: “Because it has never been about actual policy or humanity for them. They’ve treated the fate of the country like it’s the Super Bowl…but they don’t even know who they’re cheering for. This is going to be a hard lesson for us all, but MAGA are going to be blindsided when they suddenly realize that the hate/vitriol/destruction they begged for is going to directly impact them too. No one gets a pass, no one has privilege in a fascist system…all will vanish right alongside the rest of us. Their guilt and accountability will be very difficult for them to embrace and accept. They’ve reached the ‘FIND OUT’ part of ‘FAFO’ and watching them search, ‘How can I reverse my vote?’ is a small consolation. There is nothing anyone can do now.”

So, they want to reverse their votes? Ellie Quinlan Houghtaling in the The New Republic wrote in mid-November that some Trump voters were having “a shocking bout of buyer’s remorse” with the reality of awarding him a second shot at the presidency. She writes that, “On Election Day and in the hours following, searches for ‘how to change my vote’ spiked in states that the president-elect won, according to Google analytics.The searches first surged the morning of Election Day before declining the day afterward. Interest in the phrase was not short-lived, though, with numbers climbing again on Monday…just shy of a week out from the election, and continuing to grow throughout the week. The apparent change of heart comes after Trump allies had admitted Project 2025 was the plan all along, and after women and girls became the target of an overtly misogynistic, far-right campaign claiming ownership of their bodies.” Google Trends registered the phrase at 100 on a scale of 0 to 100, which indicates the peak popularity for a search term. Trump’s significant win in Iowa also generated the highest number of state-by-state queries for the term, however, it is difficult to determine whether the searches were initiated by Trump or Harris voters. Once the voter drops the ballot into the box, a vote cannot be changed, a hard lesson to learn for those who sincerely had voting regrets.

Alton Frye writes in The Hill“A majority has spoken. A disappointed minority may not admire the judgement rendered, but it must respect the right of the majority to express it. The election was clearly one in which voters’ perceived interests outweighed their professed values. Surely, not all of those supporting Donald Trump were applauding his character and the amoral values he represents. Close analysis of the promised Trump program suggests his voters may soon have second thoughts. Any new administration’s plans are subject to change, but if the next president is supported by the Republican-controlled Congress in executing the proposals set forth in the campaign, the hoped-for escape will lead to greater distress on several fronts. The multiple pledges of tax relief carry predictable consequences for national debt. Massive slashes in the federal work force would entail curtailments in public services. Politics breeds countless temptations, not all of them prudent.” In his wrap-up of the 2024 election, Frye says, “The dynamics invite diverse interpretations. One notable irony concerns the measurable movement of Hispanic voters toward support for Trump, despite his sometimes harsh stance toward immigrants. Some Hispanic commentators have viewed that movement as an importation of the frequent Latino gravitation toward a leader in chief, a ‘caudillo’ on the model of Juan Peron or Fidel Castro or Anastasio Somoza. Never mind that such caudillos have brought great grief to their peoples. Donald Trump has come to embody what one may call American machismo. The durability of that quality’s appeal will now be tested.”

Satirist Andy Borowitz, in a recent Substack post, writes, “In an advisory issued on Wednesday, the American Medical Association urged US patients seeking medical attention to go to Canada. ‘Commencing January 20, 2025, Americans should schedule even the most routine medical appointments north of the border,’ Dr. Harland Dorrinson, the president of the AMA, said. Dorrinson observed that recently announced changes to the nation’s healthcare establishment had already impacted Wall Street, with a boom for companies selling coffee bean extract, raspberry ketones, horse dewormer, and leeches. In the AMA’s gravest warning, he noted, ‘Rand Paul is now the most legit doctor in the US government.'” In a later post, Borowitz wrote, “Donald J Trump raised eyebrows in diplomatic circles on Saturday by naming the former drug lord Joaquin ‘El Chapo’ Guzman US ambassador to Mexico. Trump told reporters that the appointment of El Chapo was consistent with his policy of surrounding himself with ‘only the best people.’ When asked about El Chapo’s ten felony convictions, Trump said, ‘I wish he had more, but I still think he’s qualified.’ Trump’s plan hit a snag, however, when El Chapo turned down the post, stating that it would be ’embarrassing to serve in the same administration as Dr. Oz.'” Or serving in the same administration as Robert F Kennedy, Jr. who recently confessed to having a heroin addiction in his checkered past.

We can all echo Michael Moore’s final thoughts on November 2024: “Thank God, this month is over! We let this happen! We broke it. We fix it. Stay tuned.”

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Holidays

“A summary of every Jewish holiday: They tried to kill us, we won, let’s eat!”
~Alan King

“During the holiday season, it’s easy to forget that sometimes the best gift of all is simply the gift of time. I can’t think of anything a writer would appreciate more than being given time and space to work.” ~Kate Klise

“I have had a holiday, and I’d like to take it up professionally.”
~Kylie Minogue

“I work everyday, but every day is a holiday for me because I enjoy my work.”
~Sudha Murty

“After Pride, Christmas is a drag queen’s next best holiday. It’s pretty gay, full of tinsel and glitter and finery and campness.”
~Courtney Act

...

Turning malls into housing… here’s one look at how that can work!


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
84 Blackburn Street, Apt 102
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Cell phone: (831) 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...

Subconscious Comics

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

November 27 – December 3, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton… days of the week… Greensite… out this week… Steinbruner… Chloramine in water, Midtown crisis, and passenger rail comments due soon…. Hayes… People for Fire… Patton… Caitlin Johnstone’s Discouraged Comments… Matlock… …dominance & inevitability…ethics pledges…locked & loaded……Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… MTV Nostalgia Quotes on… “Thanksgiving”

...

CHUCK AND ESTHER ABBOTT AT THE NEW LIGHTHOUSE. Taken on 10/27/1967. The Lighthouse was dedicated on November 22, 1967. The Abbotts moved here in 1960. The lighthouse was built as a monument to their son who died surfing.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.
Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com

Dateline: November 27, 2024

GIVING THANKS! Once again, we are at Thanksgiving, which these days is followed by Black Friday, Small Business Saturday, Cyber Monday. amd Giving Tuesday. What will be the next one, Woeful Wednesday? And whatever happened to Sunday? Do let us know if you have any ideas.

THE LAST NIGHT AT TREMORE BEACH. Netflix series. (7.0 IMDB). *** An extra dramatic and moody plus scary drama about a composer/ pianist. It centers on his composing plus memories of his deceased wife. It’s all in Ireland at a beach house/cabin. It deals with fate, his predictions coming true. You’ll be mesmerized, don’t miss it.

BLITZ. Apple movie. (6.4 IMDB). **** This is much more of a saga of a young half black boy and what he has to deal with after he and his mom are separated. Apple pushes the Blitzkrieg attack on London by Hitler at the start of World War II. The prejudice, bigotry, and inhumanity are much more the main thrusts of the plot.

EMILIA PEREZ. Netflix movie. **** (7.3 IMDB). An amazing mix of musical and drama like I’ve never seen before. Zoe Saldana and Selena Gomez take leads in this Mexico City mystery that flips between sex changes and family values. We’ll see more of this film around Oscar time as Netflix continues to sell it. DO not miss it.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

BILLIONAIRE ISLAND. Netflix series. (6.3 IMDB). We learn from this drama that Norway is the world’s salmon producer. Because of this there’s a ruthless woman rival who works very hard and only partially honestly to take the Salmon farm and business from her. It also tells us the difference between farmed and wild salmon. There’s lots of rich people living their lives with golf and generally focusing on making more money. Interesting but not compelling.

NOBODY WANTS THIS. Netflix series (8.1 IMDB). Adding a so called “romantic comedy” is rare for BrattonOnline but this one has a 8.1 IMDB AND THAT’S RARE. It stars Kristin Bell as the shiksa (now 44 years old) and Adam Brody as the Rabbi. It’s all in L.A. and it’s fast paced and focuses on the relationship between LA Angelenos and the large and influential Jewish population. Plus the gay population gets their share of the comedy in their 25 minute programs.

Just a reminder…

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB)*** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and the reviews are stupendously great and RARE. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

CIVIL WAR. Max movie (7.1 IMDB) *** Has some fine scenes, but falls apart en toto. Kirsten Dunst, Jessie Plemons and Wagner Moura lead the cast. It really is about a new civil war right here in the USA. Reporters, photographers and politicians all race around headed to Washington D.C. to talk to and change how the president is thinking. Texas and California withdraw from the union and more hell breaks out. Watch it only if this seems and looks like a nightmare to you.

THE DELIVERANCE. Netflix movie. (5.1 IMDB) ** Glenn Close leads the first part of this haunted house re-hash and she does a fine job. Then all the other characters turn it into the old Hollywood scary movie vehicle and take the thrills and fun out of it. As apparently required nowadays the racial issues are thrown in to give us some thoughtful stuff to focus on.  Avoid this one.

THE PERFECT COUPLE. Netflix series. (6.6 IMDB)  *** It takes place on Nantucket Island in Massachusetts.  Nicole Kidman, Live Schreiber and Dakota Fanning are the lead stars. A big and important wedding is about to happen and there’s a murder of all things. So the movie is all focused on whodunit! Suspicious darts are thrown and there really isn’t much of a surprise left to care about. It’s about a blah movie and you’ve seen it many, many times before.

BREATHLESS.  Net series. (6.3 IMDB) ***This Spanish production centers and details the business side of running a hospital. It deals with, and carefully exploits the union angles of labor managing, it revolves around the constant conflict between medicine and money. There doesn’t seem to be much difference between Mexican and United States in hospital operations

KAOS. Netflix series. (7.5 IMDB). * Even after viewing this one I’m not sure if it’s supposed to be a comedy or a semi serious religious Greek drama. Jeff Goldblum and David Thewlis play their darndest at being Zeus and Hades stomping around Olympus trying to influence any survivors who’ll listen to them. Read a good book instead.

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB) *** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and I never watched any of them. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

MONSIEUR SPADE. Netflix series. (6.9 IMDB) * Clive Owen is either paying off a bet or simply forgot how to act…he plays at being the Dashiell Hammett character Sam Spade in this political drama set in France in 1963. He lives in the south of France and is supposed to be 60. A priest, an investigator, a mess of a cast all looking for a young girl named Teresa, don’t even think about this one!

HORIZON: AN AMERICAN SAGA. HBO series (6.8 IMDB) ** Kevin Costner (who must have had some lifting of face) not only directed this saga but is one of many featured costars along with Sienna Miller, and Luke Wilson. There is a murder in Montana during our civil war and the movie features a large focus on “Native Americans” being careful to respect them as important humans in a rare drama.

...

Gillian will be back next week!

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

CHLORAMINE  BY-PRODUCT STUDY…WILL PUREWATER SOQUEL PROJECT INJECT IT IN THE GROUNDWATER?
Many thanks to reader Judi who sent information about newly-discovered potential health risk associated with chloramine disinfection in drinking water.
Newly identified chemical in drinking water is likely in many homes and could be toxic, study finds.

I could not help but wonder if Soquel Creek Water District’s “PureWater” Soquel Project injected treated sewage water will be injecting chloramine into the groundwater, affecting the drinking water supply of the MidCounty area?

The Regional Water Quality Control Board looked the other way last December and approved the two permits for the District to inject 1.67 Million gallons/day of this treated sewage water that will include 33mg/L chloride. The original permit application had stated the injected waters would have 3.1 mg/L per day, but staff “caught” the discrepancy, along with another one regarding nitrate levels.

The Board’s staff acknowledged that injecting this treated sewage water into the groundwater will degrade the high-quality clean water that exists, but that it was within the limits of 10% of the assimilative capacity of the aquifer, and was allowable under new State recycled water regulations.

What remains to be seen is the cumulative impacts of injecting this stuff into the drinking water supply, and what will the increased chloride (a number monitored by the MidCounty Groundwater Agency to track the amount of saltwater intrusion happening) do to the geochemistry of the area’s water?  Similar projects in Orange County experience increased arsenic in water as a result.

Here is what the Regional Water Board staff dealt out in meaningless information to the Board last December, accepting all evaluations and analysis supplied by Soquel Creek Water District’s paid consultants:

“Changes Related to Chloride Concentration
The title 22 engineering report and antidegradation reports inadvertently reported the chloride concentration of the reverse osmosis (RO) permeate prior to product water post-treatment, which add chemicals to the water that include chloride. The anticipated chloride concentration after product water post-treatment should be 33.0 mg/L, not the 3.1 and 10.1 mg/L described in the antidegradation and title 22 engineering reports, respectively. A technical memorandum describing the anticipated chloride concentration in the product water is included in Attachment 2.

Although the new chloride concentration is higher than previously reported, it is still lower than the ambient concentration of 46.0 mg/L in the target injection aquifer, Purisima Unit A. Because the product water will have a lower concentration than ambient groundwater, the project is still expected to improve water quality with respect to chloride, and assimilative capacity will be gained not consumed, as was the case at the previously reported lower concentration. As such, staff has not made any changes made to the findings in the proposed permit. An errata to the title 22 engineering report has been approved by the Division of Drinking Water, and a revised antidegradation report was submitted to the Central Coast Water Board reflecting the change in chloride concentration.”

[Notice of Public Hearing, Nov 6, 2023]

The question now to ask is will the chloride be in the form of chloramine?

The District has divulged that it would use chloramine injection in the treated sewage effluent supplying the Project treatment plant in Live Oak as it travels under pressure in large pipes from the Santa Cruz City Wastewater Treatment plant.  I worry about the potential leaks in this large pipe now attached to both sides of the Laurel Street bridge, crossing the San Lorenzo River.

This photo shows the District’s contractors installing bird netting over the large pipes attached to the Laurel Street bridge. The pipes will carry pressurized chloramine-laden secondary treated sewage flowing to the Live Oak treatment facility, and on the other side, the pressurized contaminant concentrate flowing back from the Live Oak treatment facility to get dumped along with the City’s wastewater into the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary.

Both will likely have high levels of chloramine, which is toxic to all aquatic life and, unlike regular chlorine, does not dissipate in water or in air.

Write the Central Coast Regional Water Board staff Harvey Packard <harvey.packard@waterboards.ca.gov> and ask.

You could also try asking the Soquel Creek Water District Associate Manager who handles “all things PureWater Soquel”,  Cameron Kostigen-Mumper [LinkedIn].

Here is the RFP for bulk chemical delivery contracts to the PureWater Soquel Project

CITY OF SANTA CRUZ PROPOSES BUSINESS REDEVELOPMENT ZONES FOR FEES
Last week, I happened to see a small group gathered in the Branciforte Library Community meeting room at closing time.  What caught my attention through the window was the slide projected for the group, showing a colored map of the local corridor, and then a table showing how much proposed commercial and residential fees would be.  The library was closing, and I was told it was a “private meeting”, so I did not enter the in-progress presentation.

Since then, my curiosity compelled some research, where I learned that the plans I saw projected are likely part of the City of Santa Cruz Economic Development Plan for Midtown.

This led to some interesting information on the website of developer WorkBench, whose principal, Tim Gordin, sits on the County Planning Commission at the appointment of Supervisor Manu Koenig, who  happens to be a licensed real estate broker. The “Midtown Plaza” that Workbench is planning is quite a divergence from the character of the area.

Midtown Plaza — Workbench

Here is a bit more: 6-story apartment proposal in Midtown Santa Cruz prompts Sept. 16 meeting – Santa Cruz Local

Hopefully, I will have more about the Midtown Economic Development Plan next week when City staff Katie Ferraro returns from the holiday break.  My late friend Ed Silviera would always loudly protest the use of “Midtown” as the City’s way of eliminating the cultural and historic names of the area…once known as Villa de Branciforte and Seabright.

VIRTUAL PUBLIC MEETING FOR 232 RIVER STREET SIGNIFICANT DEVELOPMENT
While searching the Santa Cruz City Planning Dept. website, I found the information below about a new large project that would demolish existing homes in the area near the San Lorenzo River, and where the historic-looking Santa Cruz Down Works building is located.
Here is what the project looks like: 232 River Street

Virtual Community Meeting (PL): 232 River Street, Project Number: CP24-0131
Meeting Date: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 at 6:00 p.m.

  • Date: 12/03/2024 6:00 PM – 7:30 PM
  • Location: Zoom Meeting
  • Introduction: You are invited to attend the virtual Public Community Meeting, to be held on Tuesday, December 3 from 6:00 PM to 7:30 PM, for the project application related to 232 River St, Project Number: CP24-0131.

Join the Virtual Public Community Meeting for 232 River Street on December 3, 2024 at 6:00 PM.

You are invited to attend a Public Community Meeting, to be held on Tuesday, December 3, from 6:00 PM to 7:30 PM, for the project application related to 232 River Street, Project Number: CP24-0131.

Community members can click the link below to join the community meeting:

  • When: December 3, 2024 06:00 PM Pacific Time (US and Canada)
  • Topic: Virtual Community Meeting for Project 232 River Street, Project Number: CP24-0131
  • Webinar Link: https://us06web.zoom.us/j/88687259149     (Updated: 11/14/2024 5:45 PM)
  • Webinar ID: 886 8725 9149
  • Call: +1 669 444 9171 US

ABOUT THE PROJECT:

  • Project Size: Significant Development Project
  • City of Santa Cruz Project Number: CP24-0131 (Preapplication)
  • Address: 232 River Street
  • APN: 008-311-30

FORCING 24 FAMILIES TO MOVE
Show up on December 5 at the Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) meeting at 9am in Scotts Valley City Council Chambers to advocate a compassionate solution to forcing 24 families and elderly mobile home residents be allowed to stay in their homes along the rail corridor between 38th and 41st Avenue.

Here is why:

Last January, the RTC sent notice  to residents in the Castle Estates and Blue and Gold Star Mobile Home Parks notifying them that their homes are encroaching into the railroad right-of-way and must be moved by June, 2025.  The residents own their homes but not the land on which they sit.  Both Parks were originally built in the 1960’s, with  full approvals of the County and City of Capitola.  At that time, multiple freight trains were running daily to serve Davenport Cement Plant and lumber industries.

So why do the people have to move their homes now, and who would pay for doing so?

According to RTC staff, the Santa Cruz Branch Rail Line purchase in 2012 was completed without a thorough right-of-way survey.  The RTC did not have or did not spend the money to do this critical work until about three years ago and determined there were many encroachments along the 32-mile rail corridor between Watsonville and Davenport.  The rail line was purchased primarily for potential passenger rail service, but later, in 2013,, Congressman Sam Farr encouraged the RTC to squeeze in the Monterery Bay Sanctuary Scenic Trail on the corridor, too.  The RTC adopted that Master Plan on November 7, 2013. MBSST Network Master Plan FEIR [pdf]

That is the problem.  The rail line right of way widths are inconsistent, and in many places  it is too narrow to accommodate both rail and trail.  This dilemma is propelling the RTC to add new staff to deal with easements and acquisitions in an effort to make it all fit.

But what will happen in the case of the mobile home residents along the tracks between 38th and 41st Avenue, many who have lived with a train running in their backyard, now being told to relocate their homes by six months from now?  The RTC hired a consultant, HMH Group, to evaluate alternatives.  That report was presented to the County Mobile and Manufactured Homes Commission in April, but has yet to go to the official Commission.  RTC staff has stated that doing so would be redundant.

The HMH Alternative Analysis merely provides estimates for the cost of moving the encroaching mobile home units, some by inches, others by feet. There is no alternative analysis of simply moving the trail,   Costs per unit range from hundreds to tens-of-thousands of dollars and do not include the costs of the affected families living elsewhere during the relocation work..
Take a look at the Report and put yourself in the shoes of these folks:
Mobile Home Encroachment Removal Options [pdf]

Regardless of the distance the unit must be moved (if that is possible) it means the residents and their pets must move out for an extended period of time while all infrastructure is torn out and replaced.  Many of the units are old, and may not withstand the move without being damaged.   Moving the units further into the Park’s thoroughfares could require a variance from Central Fire District.

Understandably, the residents, some who are elderly and have lived in the Park for decades, are extremely worried.  The RTC has not corresponded with the residents since serving notice last January.

The two landowners, Millenium Housing (Castle Estates) and a private individual owner (Blue and Gold Star) are ultimately the parties responsible for working with the RTC to address the problem.  While Millenium Housing has been actively corresponding with the RTC, the other Park owner has taken a hands-off approach.

The RTC’s Open House last week to gather input on the Zero Emissions Passenger Rail Transportation project did in fact present the alternative to move the trail to either Brommer Street or Nova Avenue (likely making Nova a one-way street). This would allow the possibility of the two mobile home park owners to either lease the land under the encroaching units for 99 years, or purchase the land outright. Alternatively, the encroaching units could be replaced over time as they are sold.

Doing so would allow the multiple families to stay in their homes until there is again a train running on the tracks.  The last freight train ran in 2017.  The RTC estimates that construction on the passenger rail project could begin in 2032.

What do you think?  Please send your thoughts to the RTC and show up on December 5 at 9am in Scotts Valley City Council Chambers to support the many families who are afraid they will become homeless. Agendas – SCCRTC

PUBLIC COMMENT DUE DECEMBER 6 FOR PASSENGER RAIL ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW IN SANTA CRUZ
Santa Cruz ZEPRT Online Meeting

RAIL AND TRAIL MAP SEGMENTS MADE UNDERSTANDABLE
Do you find all the talk of “Segments” of rail trail projects confusing?  Join the crowd.  For that reason, I was very grateful to my friend, Al, for sending a recent explanation posted by Santa Cruz Local.

LIVE OAK LIBRARY ANNEX FINALLY GOT SOME BOOKS
Last Saturday, the Live Oak Library Annex had a grand opening ceremony.  Library Director Mr. Christopher Platt opened the festivity with an announcement that “the books arrived at 7am this morning.”  Indeed, the empty shelves were populated with books for all ages.  He rightly called it a Community Center.  County District Supervisor Manu Koenig also spoke, and declared this to be a perfect use of Measure S library funds.

Protesters were there, too, reminding the officials and public that the County Civil Grand Jury investigation determined it was not a proper use of Measure S library revenues.  A few members of the public and library staff privately told us they agreed. The 2021-2022 Grand Jury Report recommended that the County and Joint Library Authority review the decision to use Millions of Measure S library funds to build the Community Center,  consider returning the money and restore trust of the voters. to the voters.

Grand Jury Measure S report

Neither he County nor the Joint Library Authority agreed to that, dismissing the significance of the Grand Jury investigation and findings that the Live Oak Library Annex is NOT a library.
Board of Supervisors’ response to 2021-2022 Grand Jury Report

Library JPA response to Grand Jury Report

A few days following the Grand Opening ceremony, I visited the Annex to see if the books were still there.  They were, however, I could not check out a “Lucky Day” novel that caught my interest because the self-checkout equipment was not operational.  The receptionist at the Swim Center desk (there is NO staff at the Annex) also tried the equipment but without success.

While I could have walked away with many free copies of valuable books, I did not.  Instead, I returned the volume for display on the shelves…and accepted the situation as my “Not-so-Lucky Day” at the Live Oak Annex.

Library Director Mr. Christopher Platt did not acknowledge protest behind him.

The only way to check out a book is this self-checkout station that does not work.

The “Lucky Day” books are those that are in high-demand with long wait lists, available for three weeks without renewal (if you are able to check them out!).

The shelves were magically filled with books at 7am on the day of the opening ceremony of the Live Oak Library Annex.

CORRECTION TO PREVIOUS POST RE: CITY OF SANTA CRUZ WORK AT LOCH LOMOND
Many thanks to reader Doug who advised me that the City of Santa Cruz Water Dept. has not increased the level of the Newell Creek Dam that creates Loch Lomond Reservoir, but rather did other capital improvements to allow better use of the water stored by replacing the inlets and outlets for water supply.

My apologies.  I regularly attend the City Water Commission meetings and enjoy learning about the many good projects the City is doing to improve the ability to collect rainwater when it is abundant, and to treat it and inject it as potable water into the aquifer for storage (Aquifer Storage & Recovery or ASR).

The City’s good work at Loch Lomond Reservoir is described here…quite an amazing feat of engineering and construction in the interest of providing a reliable source of potable water for customers:

[construction of the Newell Creek dam inlet outlet replacement project]

These forward-thinking projects will make a regional water sharing management scheme possible, and not contaminate the groundwater with chemicals, hormones, nitrate and chloride that Soquel Creek Water District’s “PureWater” Soquel Project will inflict despite energy-intensive treatment processing.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  ATTEND A PUBLIC MEETING AND SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers!
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

People for Fire
Nature around the Monterey Bay has been adjusting to changing wildfire regimes; we should expect that to continue, but how that happens is up to us in many different ways. Very recently, we are putting purposeful, good fire back onto the land. This may help restore the land while protecting human infrastructure from catastrophic damage, but there are too few projects to learn from…we must learn more!

Burning History
The Monterey Bay area has been getting hotter and drier for 20,000 years, which coincides with the era of fire-lighting humans. Laguna de las Trancas is an ancient pond that lies on a geological fault on the North Coast. Ancient ponds record the history of their place in strata. Scientists have taken sediment cores from that pond and recorded layers of pollen and volcanic ash, going back through time as the deeper sediment is older. Volcanic ash has properties that allow us to know from which volcano it originates and scientists have used various methods to chart the age of ancient volcanic eruptions. So, volcanic ash serves as milestones marking known years in the sediment’s past. This is how we know that this region changed to a much more fire-prone landscape around 12,000 years ago, consequent with the widespread archeological evidence of humans. Before that, the dominant forest trees were firs; after that, fire-adapted redwoods came to dominate. More recently, for the past 1200 years, fire scars on ancient redwoods illustrate a 4-6 year burn return interval. Indigenous people likely managed the fires sweeping frequently through redwood forests, but their fire tending of this landscape tragically ended during the genocidal colonist period. Purposeful fire has been almost entirely absent on most of this landscape for 230 years. In its place, long-interval catastrophic wildfires have caused all sorts of mayhem and loss of life.

Indigenous Pyro Management
Oral history, written accounts at the time of colonist contact, pollen records in ponds, burn scars on ancient trees, and vegetation patterns on this landscape are things that can teach us bits about thousands of years of intentional use of fire by humans. One early written account from early Old-World colonist explorers notes that many of the meadows around Monterey Bay were burned black. We know now that without burning and/or grazing all of this region’s prairies change quickly into forests, so fire must have been maintaining meadows for a very long time, in the absence of grazing and tree-pulling by the Pleistocene megafauna. The blackened meadows hampered the progress of invading Old-World explorers because they had trouble feeding their horses, which they relied on for transport. In this case, we might contemplate the use prairie fire as self-defense, but we also know that indigenous peoples used fire to cultivate native plants that served as medicine, salad greens, grain, basket materials and much more.

Good Fire Emerging Now
California’s governor has set a goal of using prescribed fire on a half million acres a year. It has been 1/10th of that for too long but indigenous folks probably burned more like 3 million acres (or more) a year previously.

Most people do not see the natural landscape as their pharmacy, grocery store, or fibershed, but many people look to the hills and know the danger of wildfire. Purposeful, good fire is starting to address this last concern and one day will help people reunite with the land in those other ways.

I was recently fortunate to interact with the Central Coast Prescribed Burn Association as they purposefully burned big patches of brush on Santa Cruz County’s North Coast. After much planning and preparation, forty volunteers gathered one Saturday to light big patches of hillside on fire. The goal was to restore coastal prairie and to train more wildland fire lighters in order to expand our region’s capacity to reintroduce fire on the landscape. These volunteer groups are growing around the world, including here in California. We have learned that their work is essential for everyone’s safety, and for the stewardship of the land, which provides us so much: water, timber, livestock, recreation, clean air, food, health, and solace.

Value-Added Fire
As we realize the importance of good fire in natural lands, entrepreneurs are envisioning profit. People are cashing in on the wildfire crisis by managing wildland fuels to power electrical generators. Some are seeing a potential to power electrical land stewardship equipment with generators fired by the fuel that equipment is removing. Others are already hauling wildland fuels to generation facilities supplying regions in Northern California with power. New technology allows burning wildland fuels to create charcoal, which is added to agricultural areas improving water holding capacity and maybe even soil fertility. That carbon is captured to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. The machines are called ‘carbonators’ and they use thousands of gallons of water a day to keep them cool, which is the trick to making charcoal.

There was a lull for a bit, fand now there’s a rejuvenation of wood fired heaters for rural homes. The new woodstoves are engineered to be very efficient with very low air particulate output. Greenhouse gas (carbon) output is from recently grown wood rather than ancient fossil fuels.

The Future?
I envision a time when robots harvest biomass for fuel, farming every square inch of Planet Earth for energy. Imagine micro technology…ant-sized robots that prune plants in cultivated landscapes and natural areas, hauling bits of biomass back to larger robots which haul it to biomass energy production facilities…one big conveyor belt of fuel stolen from natural food webs. I do not like that future, but it seems inevitable in our ‘civilized’ world. How far off is that future? Without another way of managing wildfire, the day of that scenario is coming closer, quickly. The alternative is for more people to be involved with community groups managing purposeful, good fire across large areas, like the Monterey Bay region.

Your Role
Each of us has a role in helping Good Fire gain traction. Start with getting an air filter for your house: you need one anyway for wildfire smoke. Air pollution is a great concern, even with purposeful fires. The recent burning exercise I was a part of was delayed a week because of air quality concerns, and that week delay caused a bunch of issues with people’s schedules, wasted catering food, etc. If we can all be better prepared for smoke, it will be easier to get Good Fire on the ground. If you are able, help to figure out a way to get air filters to folks who can’t afford them!

We can’t expand Good Fire unless everyone feels safe in their homes. So, helping people get safe in their homes is an important thing. And, even when those homes are well secured against wildfire, people still need to be talked to, shown Good Fire, and helped to shed their fears. We can try to experience purposeful fire and see how well it is managed and then tell those stories to more people: there is a lot of fear about even professionally managed, purposeful fire.

The last thing I think more people might do: volunteer to help! The Prescribed Burn Associations could use more volunteers. Learning to manage purposeful fire is hard work and many people are needed.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

Sunday, November 24, 2024

#329 / Caitlin Johnstone’s Discouraged Comments

Observer Media, based in New York, identifies Caitlin Johnstone as “a reader-supported independent journalist from Melbourne, Australia.” Johnstone publishes a Substack newsletter (“Caitlin’s Newsletter”) in which she regularly attacks the United States Government for all of its many failings, and for all of its affirmatively bad acts. On September 6, 2024, Johnstone titled her commentary as follows: “Revolution Is Now.”

Sometimes, Johnstone identifies the United States Government as “The Empire.” I may be engaging in a bit of oversimplification here, because “The Empire” named by Johnstone is probably more than just the United States government. However, our government is certainly right at the center of “The Empire,” in Johnstone’s analysis – and that is not a good thing!

An example of how Johnstone employs the term can be seen from the following excerpt from Johnstone’s September 6th edition:

People are always asking me what we can do to fight the tyranny and depravity of the empire and create a healthy world.

“But what can we do?” they ask. “You always talk about the problems, but we need solutions! How do we solve the problems you keep pointing to?”

It’s especially common during US election season, because I tend to spend a lot of time pointing to the fraudulent nature of western electoral politics and saying Americans will never be able to vote their way out of their problems.

Which is of course fair. If I’m saying “Not that way, it’s a dead end,” it’s only fair that I should be asked which way actually leads to the exit.

Trouble is I talk about solutions all the time here, and I’m always practicing what I preach and leading by example; some people just can’t seem to hear what I’m saying. It goes in one ear and out the other, because I don’t have any solutions that are as easy and immediate as “Cast your vote for Donald Trump, he’ll fight the Deep State” or “Cast your vote for Kamala Harris, she’ll stop fascism.”

The truth of the matter is that in the here and now there are no easy and immediate solutions to the problems we face in our world. The system is far too deeply entrenched, and people are far too deeply indoctrinated with propaganda to be persuaded to fight against it right now (emphasis added).

Not having a specific and positive program to recommend, Johnstone suggests that those concerned should be trying to spread discontent and dissatisfaction as the next best thing:

An effective solution that we can all begin applying in the here and now is working to foment a revolutionary zeitgeist by spreading awareness of the depravity and deceit of the empire. The primary obstacle to real change is the fact that far too many people are far too brainwashed by propaganda to rise up against our rulers, so our first task is to begin working to wake people up out of that propaganda-induced coma so they can see how desperately real change is needed … We cultivate a habit of small acts of sedition, trying to do something every day to de-normalize the abuses of the empire in the eyes of the public. Our historically unprecedented ability to share ideas and information around the world in real time makes circulating unauthorized materials much easier than it used to be, and much more democratic. This is something we can all dedicate ourselves to.

For what it’s worth, I don’t think this is the right approach. The approach Johnstone is recommending is similar, I think, to what “Adbusters” is recommending, cultivating widespread anger and outrage, with the idea that this can, and will, precipitate the kind of positive revolutionary changes we truly do need.

I, personally, think that we need to tell ourselves the absolute opposite of what Johnstone is saying. Instead of telling ourselves how powerless we are to make the changes we need to make – and truly “revolutionary” changes are definitely called for – it’s my suggestion that we take seriously the idea that our system of “self-government” will, in fact, allow us to govern ourselves. But let’s be candid. As we look around, we can’t really say, in fact, that we are directly engaged, most of us, in the governing process.

We are spectators and critics, and we don’t like what’s happening. If that’s where we leave it, then we have no one to blame but ourselves. Let’s take Patti Smith seriously when she says, in her wonderful song, “People Have The Power.”

We have the power, but we are not using it as we could, and “spreading awareness of the depravity and deceit of the empire” is not a way to motivate the kind of unified (revolutionary) actions that can change the world. Rather, it’s a way to convince ourselves that we aren’t, and can’t be, in charge, which leads to the opposite of the kind of empowerment we need to mobilize.

It’s a Sunday today, so let me quote Jesus: “whoever loses their life will find it.” We, in the end, are in charge of “The Empire.” But to exercise the power to which we have access, those who choose to undertake a “revolution” will need to “lose” our present lives, and to decide that the purpose of our lives is something else, entirely, from what we are doing today.

Don’t we have positive ideas about how our world should be constructed – how things could be made better? I think we do, and we need to get to work on that. It’s a whole new and different life we need, and while criticism can motivate, what we really need to do is not to criticize what exists, but to create what needs to be.

And don’t tell me that we can’t do that.

We can.

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

A LEOPARD MANDATE, TRANSITIONING, NO GUARDRAILS, HIDING SLAVERY

“I never thought leopards would eat MY face!” complains the voter who helped elect the leader of the Leopards Eating People’s Faces Party. This Twitter meme will simply be schadenfreude for the next four years for those who voted against Donald Trump’s third run at the presidency, enjoying every look of disbelief as the leopard takes a bite – you did this to yourself, America! Two bar patrons enjoying a beer are discussing politics when one says to the other, “Okay, you voted for Trump…convince me I’m wrong about my worst fears.” The MAGA-hatted companion replies, “Are you kidding?! I hope you’re right!!” Yeah, we’ll see about that when the leopards are loosed.

Trump and his MAGAts are crowing that the election victory is a mandate for his policies, but as it now stands, neither he nor Harris won even 50% of the popular vote; and while Trump narrowly won the popular vote contest, he had -2% winning margins in the key Blue Wall states…his victory being decided by a handful of people in a handful of states. Yet his reactionary followers still want him to blow up the government and impose the Project 2025 objectives on the whole country, while his other supporters outside the MAGA pale simply want lower prices and a secure border. If he is smart, Trump will be satisfied with inheriting the best economy in the world and a border that is reasonably secure, freeing him up to gloat on his victory and go play golf. He is not smart; he will be only be more resolute in his wish to impose tariffs, deport people, and exact revenge on his “enemies within” as he hacks away and runs roughshod over our civil liberties. As he moves quickly to appoint a regime of loyalty in his cabinet selections, which will allow him to operate autocratically, disillusioned supporters will find that expressing their displeasure only unlocks the leopard cage. Matt Kerbel writes on Wolves and Sheep on Substack, that Trump’s “driving rationale was dominance and inevitability” during his campaign, and that will permeate his second term. “Claiming a non-existent mandate for unpopular policies that harm his voters stands to weaken him politically, and can be used by the opposition to undermine the perception that he is strong. Trump’s MAGA base will never abandon him, and he owns the Republican party regardless of how much damage he does. They will always prop him up. But the way the rest of the country reacts to Trump will matter. We cannot end Trump’s presidency. But we can reduce Trump’s ability to use his presidency to end the republic,” Matt concludes.

Trump continues to flout ethics laws and norms ahead of his inauguration date, by accepting donations to fund the transition and refusing to sign ethics pledges or deliver an ethics plan mandated by the Presidential Transitions Act. The transition team also has not signed an agreement with the FBI allowing the agency to do background checks on Trump’s nominees. Deadlines were missed in September and October to sign memorandums of understanding with the Biden White House to facilitate the outgoing administration’s collaboration with Trump’s transition team, despite promises from Trump team leaders to do so. A New York Times story reports that the transition team has privately created an ethics code and conflict-of-interest guidance for transition staff, but those documents do not include the legal requirement of a statement regarding how Trump will handle conflicts of interest as an officeholder. Senator Elizabeth Warren wrote to Biden’s staff saying, “This failure undercuts the fundamental purpose of presidential transition laws. In effect, president-elect Trump is undermining his administration’s ability to manage urgent national security threats, health and safety threats, and serious conflicts of interest starting on day one of his presidency.”

In the past, even in Trump’s 2016 transition, incoming administrations have signed an agreement to receive financial assistance from the General Services Administration which monitors the transition process. Acceptance of the funds, signing the agreement requires the teams to abide by conditions that would limit individual donations to $5000 and mandate transparency about donors. One concern with nondisclosure, is that of foreign influence, there being no restrictions on international donations to transition teams. Public policy Professor Heath Brown of John Jay College, and a presidential transition expert told the The Times“When money isn’t disclosed, it’s not clear how much is donated, who is donating, and what they are getting in return for their donation. It’s an area where the vast majority of Americans would agree that they want to know who is paying that bill.”

The Trump transition team is conducting its own, private background checks with the excuse that the FBI is too slow and could disrupt Trump’s desire to get to work quickly. CNN has been told that Trump has privately questioned whether background checks are even necessary. Trump’s noncompliance with background checks, transparency rules, and ethics are simply groundwork for a corrupt administration worse than his first term, when he used his position to enrich himself and grant favors to his wealthy cronies. By not signing the transition agreement, Trump doesn’t have to work within the confines of the fundraising limits or disclose what interest groups are funding his transition to the Oval Office…the door is wide open. And we, the taxpayers, will pay for any favors that Trump bestows upon his generous benefactors.

The president-elect has made known his belief that at times laws can be ignored, even those in the US Constitution. And this dictum has now tainted the beliefs of his inner circle of aides, advisors, and the MAGA base. ABC News Chief Washington Correspondent Jonathan Karl reported that one Trump adviser told him, “If you are on the wrong side of the vote, you’re buying yourself a primary. That is all. The president gets to decide his Cabinet. No one else.” Here’s what The Appointments Clause in Article IISection 2Clause 2 of the US Constitution says: “…and [the President] shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the Supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law.” Not clear enough? The Senate advises and consents, not the MAGA mob! But can it hold up after a Trump takeover?

Following the defeat of the British, several attempts were made to arrive at a cohesive document to unite the new society to defeat the struggle for sectional supremacy. Benjamin Franklin’s 1775 draft presented to the Continental Congress to form a national government was ignored, as were attempts by several others. Three distinct societies had developed in the colonies, each one largely determined by the role of slavery in the labor force. Pennsylvania’s John Dickinson headed a committee that arrived at a plan in 1776 which was revised for seventeen months, becoming weaker with each revision before being presented in its final form in 1777. Because it was drafted during war, it had much to do with a mutual defense mechanism, but Southern states were put off because it made no distinction between slaves and white men in the apportionment of taxation. Slaves were property, not people, and Dickinson’s lack of awareness was offensive!

The inside cover blurb of Lawrence Goldstone’s 2005 book, ‘Dark Bargain: Slavery, Profits and the Struggle for the Constitution,’ reads, “On September 17, 1787, at the State House in Philadelphia, thirty-nine men from twelve states [Rhode Island refused to send delegates] signed America’s Constitution after months of often bitter debate. They created a magnificent, enduring document, even though most of the delegates were driven more by pragmatic, regional interests than by idealistic vision. Many were meeting for the first time, others after years of contention, and the inevitable clash of personalities would be as intense as the advocacy of ideas or ideals.” Over the next several months, that number of thirty-nine men would increase or decrease with the comings and goings of individuals, to a total of fifty-five participants debating the merits of their own wishes to rescue the states from the totally inadequate Articles of Confederation.

The text continues: “No issue was of greater concern to the delegates than that of slavery: it resounded through debates on the definition of treason, the disposition of the rich lands west of the Alleghenies, the admission of new states, representation and taxation, the need for a national consensus, and the very makeup of the legislative and executive branches of the new government. Goldstone provocatively makes clear, ‘to a significant and disquieting degree, America’s most sacred document was molded and shaped by the most notorious institution of slavery.'” Goldstone’s book chronicles the forging of the Constitution through the prism of the crucial compromises made by men both driven and repelled by slavery, and the needs of the slave economy. State House debates, backroom conferences in taverns and inns lasted until the wee hours, with the philosophical contributions of James Madison waning, gradually being usurped by South Carolinian John Rutledge, a lawyer and plantation owner. Madison was particularly perturbed at Maryland’s Luther Martin, a successful attorney and an antifederalist, who was seen by many as a drunken buffoon, especially after holding the floor with a two-day speech…though being praised by many, as well. Later in his career, Martin was retained by a Quaker in a land dispute, being asked “not to drink a drop” during the trial. The trial became stressful and Martin was afraid he would lose the case by remaining sober, so during a lunch break he purchased a bottle of brandy and a loaf of bread, pouring the brandy over the loaf as he ate it with a knife and fork. Promise kept! He then proceeded to win the case having fortified himself sufficiently.

After the participants had finally agreed on the final document and returned to their various regions, the next task was to convince their state governments to accept to the results of their work, convincing which included wining and dining, cajoling, arm-twisting, and even lying to get a consensus on an instrument which specified that growers’ importation of slaves would end in twenty years…we know how that turned out! Years later, Abraham Lincoln was quoted as saying, “Slavery was hid away in the Constitution, just as an afflicted man hides away a wen or cancer, which he does not dare cut out at once, lest he bleed to death.” Goldstone ends his volume in a chapter entitled ‘Supreme Law of the Land,’ in which he writes, “But, in the central role it played, the weight of evidence leads inescapably to the conclusion that the Constitution was drafted by highly pragmatic men who were pursuing limited and self interested goals. Philosophical concerns seemed to play only a minor role in the proceedings, and only then with but a few of the participants. Nonetheless, for all that, precisely because the delegates in Philadelphia were pragmatic, and were there to represent specific, parochial interests, they were able to draft a document that was workable, adaptable, and able to survive challenges that could never have been imagined in 1787. It is distinctly possible that had idealism dominated in Philadelphia, American democracy would have failed.”

Now, after standing fast, close to 240 years, we have a buffoon and his army who want to take an axe to the hard-won document, to make small changes like enshrining the right of billionaires and corporations to bribe judges and politicians, or insert the doctrine of corporate personhood, or simply throw the whole thing out and start over. At this point, 19 Republican-controlled states have signed on to a call for a convention under Article V, heavily funded by rightwing billionaires. In fact, we might consider that the Constitution is being rewritten already…consider the decisions of the six judges on the Supreme Court when they turned a law-breaking president into a king, ended rights of women to make decisions about their own bodies, gutted the power of federal agencies to protect consumers and the environment, and legalized bribery of politicians as long as the bribes are paid AFTER a vote…simply a ‘tip’ of appreciation, you see? The encore has in its sights gay marriage, contraception, pornography and banned books, union rights and religion in schools. The American public be damned in their overwhelming desire to see gun control, an end to gerrymandering, higher wages, money out of politics, climate action, fair taxation with enforcement for the morbidly rich and corporations, and SCOTUS term limits…and on and on.

Ruth Ben-Ghiat writes on her Lucid blog on Substack“Before Bill Barr became Donald Trump’s third attorney general, he circulated a memo that was more or less an audition tape for the job he ultimately got. In it, Barr argued in favor of what had previously been a fringe theory of a powerful ‘unitary executive,’ – a president able to consolidate power at the expense of the other two branches as a very powerful leader…even Bill Barr would have never dreamed of arguing the president could use SEAL Team Six to assassinate a political rival and walk away with no consequences…now, the Supreme Court says it’s so.” Ruth calls Trump’s naming of Russell Vought to lead the Office of Management and Budget as context for the turn to the monarchical, away from the democratic, since Vought was the godfather of Project 2025 which will restructure our institutions. Though Trump claimed no knowledge of P2025 during his campaign, it is clear that was a lie, since he spoke at a Heritage Foundation conference in April 2022, where he told the audience that the groundwork was being laid with detailed plans for exactly what the movement would do.

Ben-Ghiat continues, “Project 2025 is a wrap. It’s locked and loaded, and ready to go. If you believe it’s about to disappear or that Trump won’t use any of it, I have some swampland in Florida for you.” She says that as recently as AugustTrump had “blessed” the project and that it was ready to put into action, because British journalists secretly recorded him making such claims. “Now it’s clear that all of the horribles are on the table, everything from the end of the Department of Education to the discontinuation of the weather warnings NOAA provides,” she declares. As Kevin Roberts of the Heritage Foundation said in July‘We are in the process of the second American Revolution, which will remain bloodless if the left allows it to be.’ The leopards are hungry and ready to perform their facials. The guardrails are down. We can only wait and see, as we put our efforts behind the Planning for a Better Day Party

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Thanksgiving

“Be thankful for what you have; you’ll end up having more. If you concentrate on what you don’t have, you will never, ever have enough.”
~Oprah Winfrey

“I am grateful for what I am and have. My thanksgiving is perpetual.”
~Henry David Thoreau

“Thanksgiving dinners take eighteen hours to prepare. They are consumed in twelve minutes. Half-times take twelve minutes. This is not coincidence.”
~Erma Bombeck

“Even though we’re a week and a half away from Thanksgiving, it’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas.”
~Richard Roeper

“An optimist is a person who starts a new diet on Thanksgiving Day.”
~Irv Kupcinet

...

The first 12 minutes of MTV, back on Aug 1, 1981.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
84 Blackburn Street, Apt 102
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Cell phone: (831) 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...

Subconscious Comics

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment

November 20 – 26, 2024

Highlights this week:

Bratton… Webmistress says take a breath… Greensite… on 831 Almar St…. Steinbruner… about the non-library, water, water, and passenger rail?… Hayes… Power and Pitfalls of Experiential Learning … Patton… OMG. Really?… Matlock… Cheerios…friendship obligation…none of (y)our business… Eagan… Subconscious Comics and Deep Cover… Webmistress serves you… Princess Bride behind the scenes Quotes on… “Take a Break”

...

PACIFIC AVENUE AND CATHCART STREETS, JAN.29, 1963. You can barely make out the J.C. Penney Store on the close right was Taqueria Vallarta for a while and is now Five Guys. Johnny’s Bike and Sport Shop on the opposite corner is now Old School Shoes. That big Santa Cruz Bowling Pin advertises the bowling alley, which became the new Catalyst in April of 1975, if I remember correctly.

photo credit: Covello & Covello Historical photo collection.
Additional information always welcome: email bratton@cruzio.com

Dateline: November 20, 2024

JUMPING IN TO SAY… Webmistress here, just reminding everyone that it’s ok to take a break when it feels like whole world is going crazy. Stop and breathe. Go for a walk if you can! I have started doing this every morning, which is an entirely new way of life for me! I had no idea we had so many dogs in our neighborhood… One foot in front of the other, life goes on.

EMILIA PEREZ. Netflix movie. **** (7.3 IMDB). An amazing mix of musical and drama like I’ve never seen before. Zoe Saldana and Selena Gomez take leads in this Mexico City mystery that flips between sex changes and family values. We’ll see more of this film around Oscar time as Netflix continues to sell it. DO not miss it.

LA MAISON. Apple series. - (6.0IMDB). All about two of the top French fashion houses and their internal and external pressures to be number one in the world of fashion. It’s foolish, pointless, not funny, nor meaningful…do not watch, no matter what or who says so.

THE SECRET OF THE RIVER. Netflix series. *** (8.2 IMDB). Frida Cruz and Mario Guzman are two Oaxaca born boys who accidentally watch the accidental death by drowning of a neighbor.  As they become older they grow closer and try to determine whether or not they are gay. 20 years later they reunite and deal with the ongoing issues. Definitely worth watching.

MARTHA. Netflix movie (7.2 IMDB). This is an amazing, even shocking. interestingly created documentary centering on the world’s most successful businesswoman Martha Stewart. Marrying into wealth, she parlayed her love and her acumen into becoming one of the most influential world citizens. Open, honest, even charming, she made one or two stock investment mistakes. Her failure, plus prison time, involves Justin Bieber  and it’s hard to believe, but you will when you watch this portrait. Inspirational.

BILLIONAIRE ISLAND. Netflix series. (6.3 IMDB). We learn from this drama that Norway is the world’s salmon producer. Because of this there’s a ruthless woman rival who works very hard and only partially honestly to take the Salmon farm and business from her. It also tells us the difference between farmed and wild salmon. There’s lots of rich people living their lives with golf and generally focusing on making more money. Interesting but not compelling.

NOBODY WANTS THIS. Netflix series (8.1 IMDB). Adding a so called “romantic comedy” is rare for BrattonOnline but this one has a 8.1 IMDB AND THAT’S RARE. It stars Kristin Bell as the shiksa (now 44 years old) and Adam Brody as the Rabbi. It’s all in L.A. and it’s fast paced and focuses on the relationship between LA Angelenos and the large and influential Jewish population. Plus the gay population gets their share of the comedy in their 25 minute programs.

Just a reminder…

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB)*** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and the reviews are stupendously great and RARE. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

CIVIL WAR. Max movie (7.1 IMDB) *** Has some fine scenes, but falls apart en toto. Kirsten Dunst, Jessie Plemons and Wagner Moura lead the cast. It really is about a new civil war right here in the USA. Reporters, photographers and politicians all race around headed to Washington D.C. to talk to and change how the president is thinking. Texas and California withdraw from the union and more hell breaks out. Watch it only if this seems and looks like a nightmare to you.

THE DELIVERANCE. Netflix movie. (5.1 IMDB) ** Glenn Close leads the first part of this haunted house re-hash and she does a fine job. Then all the other characters turn it into the old Hollywood scary movie vehicle and take the thrills and fun out of it. As apparently required nowadays the racial issues are thrown in to give us some thoughtful stuff to focus on.  Avoid this one.

THE PERFECT COUPLE. Netflix series. (6.6 IMDB)  *** It takes place on Nantucket Island in Massachusetts.  Nicole Kidman, Live Schreiber and Dakota Fanning are the lead stars. A big and important wedding is about to happen and there’s a murder of all things. So the movie is all focused on whodunit! Suspicious darts are thrown and there really isn’t much of a surprise left to care about. It’s about a blah movie and you’ve seen it many, many times before.

BREATHLESS.  Net series. (6.3 IMDB) ***This Spanish production centers and details the business side of running a hospital. It deals with, and carefully exploits the union angles of labor managing, it revolves around the constant conflict between medicine and money. There doesn’t seem to be much difference between Mexican and United States in hospital operations

KAOS. Netflix series. (7.5 IMDB). * Even after viewing this one I’m not sure if it’s supposed to be a comedy or a semi serious religious Greek drama. Jeff Goldblum and David Thewlis play their darndest at being Zeus and Hades stomping around Olympus trying to influence any survivors who’ll listen to them. Read a good book instead.

SLOW HORSES. Apple series. (8.2 IMDB) *** There’s been five seasons or series of Slow Horses so far and I never watched any of them. Slow Horses is British slang for “slough house”. And Slough House is where the wild, clever talking M15 British agents who have made professional mistakes hang out between cases. Gary Oldman is the lead and he’s a perfect fit as are Kristin Scott Thomas and Jonathan Price. Set aside some down time and watch this one. It’s been nominated for 9 Emmy awards.

MONSIEUR SPADE. Netflix series. (6.9 IMDB) * Clive Owen is either paying off a bet or simply forgot how to act…he plays at being the Dashiell Hammett character Sam Spade in this political drama set in France in 1963. He lives in the south of France and is supposed to be 60. A priest, an investigator, a mess of a cast all looking for a young girl named Teresa, don’t even think about this one!

HORIZON: AN AMERICAN SAGA. HBO series (6.8 IMDB) ** Kevin Costner (who must have had some lifting of face) not only directed this saga but is one of many featured costars along with Sienna Miller, and Luke Wilson. There is a murder in Montana during our civil war and the movie features a large focus on “Native Americans” being careful to respect them as important humans in a rare drama.

THE WATCHERS. Max movie.(5.7 IMDB) *** An incredibly puzzling movie set in Ireland with Dakota Fanning delivering a parrot to a more than unbelievable and invisible bunch of humans hiding out in an impossible part of a forest. Full of legends, myths, and puzzles, it’s worth your time.

AMERICAN MURDER: Laci Peterson. Netflix series.  (7.0 IMDB) **** It’s a documentary about a murder that happened in 2002. Laci Peterson was murdered and her husband Scott was convicted, and more than 20 years later he and his family are still working to disprove his involvement. It takes place in Berkeley and Modesto and gives us some concept of how big a role the media plays. There’s more documentaries being produced on the Peterson case and we are advised to wait for a better version.

...

November 18, 2024

Burying the Heart of Santa Cruz

The pace of new high-rise projects in the city of Santa Cruz accelerates to a point where it is hard to keep track. My photo captures the massive equipment being used to move fill into the space between the outside levee and the Riverfront building under construction on Front Street. I recall the Planning Commission meetings when this project was touted and approved. The newly filled space will serve as a splendid linear public park we were told. Time will tell. Concepts and reality may or may not align.

Perhaps you have attended one of the recent zoom meetings offered by the city for the pre-planning stage of new high-rise projects. These are done in conjunction with Workbench, which appears to be developer du jour. I recently attended the zoom for 831 Almar St. I had to leave early so could not stay to ask a question or comment, but I did listen to the recording made available on the Planning Department project website. The zoom meeting was well-run by the city planner who recorded public comments and gave plenty of time for those members of the public out of the sixty-eight in attendance who chose to speak or write questions. Councilmember Renee Golder, whose district includes the project, submitted important questions of concern regarding the loss of industrial land and tailoring the housing for UCSC students.

The project architect, Mark Primack gave an overview on why this site, zoned for industrial, is perfect for a six-story mixed-use housing project. According to Primack, “zoning is always behind the times.” He omitted to mention that the return on investment for housing outstrips any other land use. The far west side includes some of the last remaining industrial zoned land in the city. There was a time when it was deemed critical to preserve industrial lands for major worksites; to avoid developing a city with all housing and little else.

In 2008, the live/work project on Delaware, on industrial land west of Swift St.  was approved by council. This was a zoning compromise. A few years later, the developer came back to council and begged to be let off the hook for the “work” part of the project. He got his way. More recently, that land has been approved for UCSC student and staff housing on a 5-2 council vote. So much for preserving scarce industrial lands. For 831 Almar, zoned industrial, Workbench tried to make  ceramics, breweries and chocolate factories that sell cakes pass as industrial enterprises.

There was a time when developers had to give lip service to supplying housing for essential workers to gain council approval for their projects. Never mind that such housing turned out to be mostly occupied by students, the illusion was necessary. No longer. The Food Bin is presented as future student housing, the Delaware project is approved for 600 students and now 831 Almar with a projected occupancy of 400 to 600 students markets itself as providing students flexibility in housing. With an expanding UCSC, developers can assure investors of top tier returns.

To promote this project, there’s some fiddling with the facts. According to architect Primack, “the city has an ongoing battle with the university for them to provide half the housing that students need on campus. That’s the limit that the city set.” Wait on, the city has set no such limit! The city, and particularly the community, would very much like UCSC to provide housing for most of its students on campus, not just fifty percent. That would sure lower rents in the city!

With respect to off-campus housing, the 2008 Comprehensive Settlement Agreement states that,” UCSC agrees not to construct high-density off-campus housing in the city unless consistent with city zoning.”

So that is what Primack meant by “zoning is always behind the times.” With developers eager to construct student housing once the land is re-zoned, we can forget about workforce housing. No wonder the city council avoided answering the Grand Jury when it required a response to whether inclusionary housing was occupied by residents and local workers as mandated by city code. It all makes sense in a sick sort of way.

Gillian Greensite is a long time local activist, a member of Save Our Big Trees and the Santa Cruz chapter of IDA, International Dark Sky Association  http://darksky.org    Plus she’s an avid ocean swimmer, hiker and lover of all things wild.

...

THIS IS NOT A LIBRARY AND SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN BUILT WITH MEASURE S LIBRARY BOND MONEY
The Live Oak “Library” Annex is having a grand opening this Saturday, 11am-1pm.  Maybe a guest will bring a book or two to donate to the site because the shelves are all empty.

Please join the protest at 11am to let the elected officials know that it was wrong to use Measure S money to build this Live Oak Library Annex that has NO books and NO librarian but instead relies on Parks Dept. staff at the Simpkins Swim Center desk to answer questions.

The 2021-2022 Santa Cruz County Civil Grand Jury investigated the County’s use of Measure S special tax money that was supposed to be restricted to use for improving libraries:

How a Community Center Became a “Library”, The Transformational Power of Measure S Funds

“The Grand Jury has concluded that the Annex is an expansion of the Live Oak
Community Center and not an expansion of the Live Oak Branch Library. Following the
State’s elimination of redevelopment agencies, County Parks was left without a ready
source of capital funds needed to complete the vision of the Community Center.
Measure S filled the void. The Grand Jury recommends that the County Board of
Supervisors reassess its decision to use Measure S funds to improve the Live Oak
Community Center and restore the voters’ trust.”

The required responses by the Board of Supervisors were dismissive and totally inadequate. The Board disagreed that Measure S monies were restricted to use for libraries and should not have been used to expand the Community Center, stating that the Live Oak Library needed space for programs and did not have it, so the Annex fills that need.

The Board disagreed that having the Annex would adversely affect the Library System’s Operating Budget.  We now know that was a lie because all but one branch, the Downtown Branch, is closed on Sundays because there is not enough money to staff another library, such as the Live Oak Branch, on Sundays for four hours of patron use.
The Board simply rejected the single good recommendation the Grand Jury made, stating it was “not appropriate.”

Recommendation:

“The Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors should
reassess its decision to use Measure S funds to improve the Live Oak
Community Center and either reimburse the Library Facilities Financing
Authority or commit additional funds to establish the Annex as a library
resource consistent with other SCPL branches.”

The Live Oak Annex is not staffed.  The folks who are stationed at the Swim Center desk adjacent are expected to make themselves available for any questions that arise, and are responsible for any problems that occur.

Please join us in reminding the elected officials that what they did still stinks and that they need to regain our trust.  Maybe the one who is responsible for this egregious travesty, former First District County Supervisor John Leopold, will dare to show his face.



SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT BOARD IS INSULTED BY QUESTIONING
On November 19, the Soquel Creek Water District Board of Directors waved through on their Consent Agenda Item 4.6, approving a two-year contract with the Eurofins and MBAS Labs to conduct sampling and analysis of the finished Project water that will be injected into the groundswater.  I timely requested the Board pull this item from their Consent Agenda for better public discussion and staff response to 13 questions I submitted.  The Board refused to pull the item, and Board President Bruce Jaffe scolded me harshly for personally insulting him by asking questions.  Director Tom LaHue chimed in that it is obvious that I just don’t understand the Project.  Director Carla Christensen simply told me not to worry because the lab would be able to do work that the District employees cannot.  Directors Rachel Lather and Jennifer Balboni sat smirking.

Such arrogance has consumed the District’s attitude in general.

No staff offered to meet with me to answer my questions that included how the public would be able to see the data generated by Eurofins and MBAS, and concerns that there is no mention in the contract to include sampling and reporting of biological contaminants responsible for fouling the reverse osmosis membranes, thereby rendering them less effective at removing contaminants while also increasing energy demand to operate the system.  [Reverse osmosis membrane biofouling: causes, consequences and countermeasures]

That worries me, and should worry the District Board but they didn’t seem to care. They approved this contract as a consent agenda item while dismissively rejecting all public questioning, deeming it an “insult”.

SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT HISTORY OF NO CONSIDERATION OF REALITY
Last month, the Soquel Creek Water District Board held a lively discussion about how to make their ugly PureWater Soquel Project more attractive, feeling “out-done” by the whale motif on the new Chantlcleer Pedestrian Overcrossing adjacent.

Supposedly, an ad hoc committee will bring recommendations to the Board sometime soon, so I thought I would help them by providing a compendium of documents showing that the District failed all along to recognize the Chanticleer Overcrossing impacts on the ugly PureWater Soquel sewage water treatment facility.  I submitted the correspondence in a timely fashion, so that it would be included in the November 19, 2024 Board Correspondence packet.

The Board said nothing, NOTHING AT ALL, about the documents.  I guess they had other things on their minds, such as whether to increase rates January 1, 2025 by 12%.

They did that.  Even though the rate increases are to pay for a service the ratepayers are NOT receiving…basin sustainability and the PureWater Soquel Project.  That is the basis for the legal challenge in Case 24CV00566.

Of interest was the fact that District Finance Director Leslie Strohm announced that “the District has not posted a net gain in position in four years, and have not increase unrestricted revenue (cash).  In effect, we are below where we need to be in reserves.”

The District is in financial trouble, but continues to hire consultant after consultant…and the Pure”Water Soquel Project operational costs, initially thought to be $2.5 million/ year, are now forecast at $6.2 Million annually.

Wow.

NO NEW PROJECTS … REDUCING THE COST OF NEW WATER SERVICE IN SOQUEL CREEK WATER DISTRICT
On November 19, the Board of Soquel Creek Water District decided that since there are no capital improvement projects on the drawing board, once PureWater Soquel Project treated sewage water injection comes online, they must re-evaluate the cost for new water service hookups for ADU’s..  Effective January 1, 2025, the cost for a new construction service line will cost about half of what the District has charged in the past.  Except for 4″ service lines…those will increase 9%.  Hmmmmmm…

Ms. Leslie Strohm, Director of District Finance, could not explain why the new 4″ connections would have a 9% increase when all other connections will decrease.  When questioned, she said “I will have to talk with our consultant about that.”  Isn’t it amazing that the Director of Finance, who is receiving a $1,000/month bonus until PureWater Soquel Project comes online, is clueless about a financial issue she presented to the Board?

Unfortunately, her slide presentation was not provided to the public in advance of the November 19 meeting, and at the time of this writing, still has not been posted to the website.. [Agenda – 11/19/2024]

I asked how the District will allay the upset of ADU applicants who paid $22,000 for a new hookup, but would have paid about $11,000 under the new adjustment had they waited?  Staff said they have been letting applicants know about possible water capacity fee changes since June.  That added six month to peoples’ projects…if they felt it worth the wait.

WATER STORAGE, NOT DRINKING TREATED SEWAGE WATER
A reader kindly sent me the link below to news that the State is investing heavily in raising the levels of dams in California, including San Luis Reservoir.  The reader implored that this is a superior idea and opposes Soquel Creek Water District forcing customers to drink treated sewage water from the PureWater Soquel Project.  I could not agree more.
Deal reached to expand massive reservoir near Bay Area to increase water supplies

The City of Santa Cruz has also increased the height of the Newell Creek Dam to allow for more storage at Loch Lomond Reservoir.  That is good news.  However, the City is still looking to PureWater Soquel, possibly doubling the treatment capacity, in order to meet the City’s anticipated future supply needs in a prolonged drought.  That would be in addition to the City injecting potable water into the aquifer, and pumping it back out in the summer.  That is known as aquifer storage and recovery (ASR).

The City is, in my observation, looking at ways to make use of water when it is plentiful, and to avoid the need to rely on Soquel Creek Water District.  The famed Water Optimization Analysis Report, outlining how the City’s ASR and PureWater Soquel Project would work in tandem has not yet been completed.  Earlier models the Montgomery & Associates consultants did showed that if the two projects occurred at the same time, water would spew out of the ground surface.  Heidi Luckenbach, Director of City Water, reminded the Soquel Creek Water District Board about that when she spoke to them on October 15.

Montgomery & Associates consultant is also doing the Water Optimization Analysis.  The date for completion of that report keeps getting pushed out.

What also is not being done is a follow up Airborne ElectroMagnetic (AEM) resistivity study by helicopter that would give a clear indication of where the saltwater/freshwater interface is in the areas of PureWater Soquel injection wells and the MidCounty Basin in general.  That was done in 2017 to provide a snapshot of the situation.  However, no current information exists, other than the monitoring wells showing groundwater levels increasing or stabilized.

I have asked the MidCounty Groundwater Agency (MGA)as well as Soquel Creek Water District to fund a new AEM study before the PureWater Soquel Project comes online to verify the conditions the Project is supposedly correcting.  While a few on the Board of the MGA nodded in agreement, no action was taken.  The Soquel Creek Water District Board scoffed, with President Bruce Jaffe attempting to take District credit for the 2017 study.  He was set straight by new General Manager Melanie Mow-Schumacher.  Good luck getting the District to do anything that could possibly show there is not a saltwater interface problem to the extent that they have screamed and used to justify their expensive Project that has thrown the District into deep debt.

The State did an AEM helicopter survey a couple of years ago, but chose to only make two very broad passes over the area that could have provided a comparison with the 2017 flight results, and chose to fly inland over areas that the initial study supposedly could not include due to flight over residential areas.

I have asked the MidCounty Groundwater Agency Board many times to have another AEM flight over the same areas as they paid to have done in 2017.  How else can they determine if the PureWater Soquel Project, the capstone of their Groundwater Sustainabilty Plan, is working or not?  How will Soquel Creek Water District otherwise know if the Project is actually supporting groundwater sustainability, for which they have already approved action as a basis for increasing their customer rates last February?

The Project start-up has been pushed back to March, 2025.

WILL THERE EVER BE PASSENGER RAIL HERE?
There have be a couple of recent gatherings to discuss passenger rail plans in Santa Cruz County and Monterey County, but both make me think it will not happen in my life time.  The RTC held a presentation at the Mello Center in Watsonville. I was glad there was an initial presentation.  That dissolved into an open house format where no one could hear questions of others or the answers provided.  People were supposed to festoon the maps with sticky notes and colored dots, thereby allowing the RTC to check off the box that there was “robust community involvement’.  Sigh.  What I found interesting is that the passenger rail is not being planned to continue beyond Santa Cruz, failing to link Davenport and the San Vicente Redwood area or Cotoni-Coast National Monument.

When I asked staff about that, they suggested I write it on a Comment Card.

The second passenger rail public event was across the Pajaro River to learn more about the Pajaro Rail Station, presented by TAMC, the Monterey County equivalent to the Santa Cruz County RTC.  This was a noisy open house format that was well-attended.

Transportation Agency for Monterey County seeking community input on proposed Pajaro-Watsonville Multimodal Station Project – SCCRTC

The large maps of the Salinas Road area at Railroad Avenue in Pajaro is the focal point to build a new passenger rail station that would allow CalTrain and Amtrak passenger rail service with links to the Bay Area and beyond.  i learned that TAMC is embarking on an environmental study of the potential train station area, and that Union Pacific Railroad has alot to say with how this all gets done.  They do not want a passenger rail loading platform on a curved track, ostensibly for visibility of other on-coming train operators.  How long would that straight section of track need to be?  Who knows, said the staff, but TAMC is planning for 800′.

Construction could begin in 2029…with more studies to yet be done.  Sigh.  I asked why links to Santa Cruz rail lines could not be suited to buses with rail conversion ability?  Staff said the State won’t fund something like that.  I got discouraged by learning that the State and Fed. government will not subsidize passenger rail operation and maintenance.  Why is it different than bus systems, which do seem to get grants for operations and capital improvement?

Weigh in with your comments and ideas before December 6.

WHAT WILL MOBILE HOME RESIDENTS DO?
Please listen in this Friday at 2pm to “Community Matters” online radio to hear Ms. Roxanne Stanley talk about what is happening along the RTC-owned Santa Cruz Branch Rail Line in the areas where mobile home parks have been deemed to be encroaching.   Roxanne is working to organize her neighbors in an effort to reason with the RTC, who has put all residents there on notice that encroaching units will be moved on or by June, 2025.  The second hour will be an interview with Mr. Tony Crane, to do a election follow up on Monica Martinez in the Fifth District Supervisor race, and a review of the local media’s affect on the election.  Listen in from your computer or smart device.and join the conversation.

WRITE ONE LETTER.  MAKE ONE CALL.  SEND IN COMMENT ON A LOCAL PROJECT.
MAKE A BIG DIFFERENCE THIS WEEK BY JUST DOING SOMETHING.

Cheers!
Becky

Becky Steinbruner is a 30+ year resident of Aptos. She has fought for water, fire, emergency preparedness, and for road repair. She ran for Second District County Supervisor in 2016 on a shoestring and got nearly 20% of the votes. She ran again in 2020 on a slightly bigger shoestring and got 1/3 of the votes.

Email Becky at KI6TKB@yahoo.com

...

Power and Pitfalls of Experiential Learning
Most people I know rejoice when they hear about students engaged with experiential learning, but what does that term mean and how far should it go? Ronald Reagan was largely responsible for making it less affordable to attend colleges and universities, and when he did many cynics muttered about industry and their political party lackies wanting cheaper, more subservient labor. This purposeful dumbing down of our society is having grave consequences, and not just in one spot on the political spectrum. Backlash is occurring, but not the kind of backlash you might hope for: increasingly close relationships between industry and university systems. Industry hungers for skilled workers. And so, we are witnessing the rise of the trade school. Well-run trade schools could nurture collaboration, fostering Democracy, but this runs counter to oligarchical aspersions of the 1%. How will we solve this tension?

California’s Public Institutions of Higher Learning
What is the difference between the 4 different public institutions of higher learning in California: the 116 “community colleges,” 3 “polytechnic state universities,” 20 other “state universities“, and 10 “UC’s?” Community colleges are sorting machines to bridge the ‘better’ students into higher division courses at the other institutions. Around 20% of lower division students in California’s universities drop out; to keep the machine running, there must be replacements in line –community colleges produce those replacements. The “mission of the California Community Colleges is to advance California’s economic growth and global competitiveness through education, training, and services that contribute to continuous work force improvement.” In other words, community colleges are the first step for students entering trade school in California’s higher education system. As such, community colleges are primarily designed to feed students into the polytechnic universities, the purest type of university trade school. The term ‘polytechnic’ refers to vocational training, aka “trade school.” For administrative efficiency as well as similarity of mission, California’s 3 polytechnic universities are administered by the California State University (CSU) system. The other 20 CSU’s are a bit more abashedly also trade schools. The UC’s are clearly distinct from trade schools by their promotion of teaching theory and nurturing critical thinking, conducting research that advances theories, not current practice – they eschew applied research.

The Danger of Trade Schools in California
Trade schools are often proud of experiential learning, a key component of skills-based training. Industry saves money if the State spends the money building skills in the soon-to-be workforce. The current overrated excitement about training grade school students in STEM is a symptom of this thinking. Skills based training, including STEM training, is a big problem when things change as rapidly as they are changing. Most skills we teach to make widgets today are not the skills that will be needed a short period of time. Despite this, trade school curricula leave little room for elective courses. By their sophomore year, students must define their major, and to succeed at that declared major a student has no room in their schedule to explore other subjects. On top of this, trade schools are teaching a narrow set of ‘soft skills,’ related to obedience to process: students who can navigate the bureaucracy are the ones that succeed. The result of this system is an emerging workforce trained narrowly in already irrelevant job skills excepting the skill to navigate protocol.

Faltering Trade Schools
Years ago, California’s trade schools hired professors with experience in private industry. After Reagan gutted public higher education funding, competition increased between colleges and universities for other revenue sources from skyrocketing student fees, public:private partnerships (industry funding), and alumni donations. This competition led trade schools to attempt to become more like UCs: “top-tier” universities. And so, trade schools turned changed the old model of hiring professors experienced in “real world” industries to hiring the same types of professors UC would hire. Lucky for them, there is a glut of academically aspiring PhDs. Trade school administrators increasingly apply the screws to faculty, who are caught in demoralizing  stress. Professors at trade schools must teach as many tuition-paying students as possible: low faculty:student ratios are more profitable. To be successful these faculty must help with fundraising, meeting with industry officials to keep up reputations of building a skilled workforce. On top of those obligations, trade school faculty play the game of courting ‘top tier’ status for their university by somehow, miraculously wedging in time for publication-quality research.

Long-Lasting, Relevant Workforce Skill: Collaboration
Instead of, or at least in addition to, training trade school students on ‘how good are you at navigating protocol,’ trade schools might also focus on collaborative skills. What if experiential learning at trade schools focused on student engagement to solve real-world problems, interacting with real world stakeholders? In this case, faculty and students would interact with the stakeholders involved in any given issue…perhaps industry representatives, regulators, policymakers, financiers, interested citizens, labor leaders, etc. Students would be reviewed by their ability to critically evaluate situations and for the feasibility of their creative solutions. Faculty would be reviewed by the quality of their student mentorship on collaboration skills. Collaborative skill training would focus on power analysis, defining success, facilitating dialogues for mutual understanding, identifying gaps in knowledge, and identifying solutions of greatest benefit.

Contextual Shift
Training a future workforce skilled in collaboration would increase productivity while creating a more peaceful citizenry, but would also likely threaten wealth inequality…and so is a major threat to industry leaders. If those entering the industrial workforce understood the regulatory context of their work, they might favor solutions that meet regulatory expectations, rather than attempting to challenge or circumvent the rules. On the other hand, if those entering regulatory workforce understood industrial context of their work, they might be less likely to apply rules inappropriately in favor or in contravention of industry. In either case, accusations of a ‘dark state’ would evaporate and the people’s will for regulations would likely be more fully realized. Core to collaboration training is the idea that we can achieve more through collaboration than trade-offs faced with compromise. Those in power like the frame where the only pathway to solution is compromise because they think they always win as much as could be won. That mistaken assumption is evident in the politics of the USA.

DEI is the Answer
Even trade schools are teaching Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI), which holds great promise as a back door to training in collaboration. The skills I outlined above are inherent to implementing a more DEI-oriented society. The question is…will DEI suffuse everything at trade schools (and beyond), or will it be siloed as yet another idea in the world of ideas? In some places, we are seeing an attack on DEI training…after reading this essay, I hope you can think more critically about why that might be.

I also hope you will consider the implications of higher education tilting towards trade schools, away from the humanities, history, critical thinking, and theory.

Grey Hayes is a fervent speaker for all things wild, and his occupations have included land stewardship with UC Natural Reserves, large-scale monitoring and strategic planning with The Nature Conservancy, professional education with the Elkhorn Slough National Estuarine Research Reserve, and teaching undergraduates at UC Santa Cruz. Visit his website at: www.greyhayes.net

Email Grey at coastalprairie@aol.com

...

#322 / OMG. Really?

Robert Reich is pictured above, but I’m betting that you didn’t need me to tell you that. I think it’s fair to say that Reich is one of our better known “public intellectuals.” Most of the people I hang out with, anyway, would immediately recognize Reich if they saw him on the street. Click this link if you would like to learn more about Reich. That link will also furnish you with a picture of a much younger Robert Reich.

My blog posting today comes as a reaction to one of Reich’s own blog postings, as published on Substack. Reich’s posting on November 14, 2024, had this title: “Trump wants Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to be Health Secretary. OMG. Really?

Reich doesn’t have much good to say about other recent nominations, either:

Friends,

Trump is giving his middle finger to America.

Nominating the alleged sexual trafficker Matt Gaetz to be Attorney General, Fox News host Pete Hegseth to be Secretary of Defense, and bizarro Tulsi Gabbard to be Director of National Intelligence are acts of nihilistic disruption.

Now, nominating conspiracist and fabulist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to the nation’s leading health job — overseeing the Food and Drug Administration, the Centers for Disease Control, and the National Institutes of Health, among other sensitive positions — is an act of utter hubris.

At a time when the truth is a precious common good, and the public’s health is already precarious, RFK Junior has made a name for himself spreading dangerous health lies…. I knew Robert F. Kennedy, and Robert F. Kennedy Junior is no Robert F. Kennedy. If not for his lustrous name, RFK Junior would be just another crackpot in the ever-growing pool of bottom-feeding fringe characters encircling Trump like ravenous slugs.

In my immediate reaction to the election of Donald J. Trump to the presidency, I said that “we are now likely going to be presented with an incredible opportunity to renew the vigor and effectiveness of democratic self-government in the United States.” This rather optimistic statement was based on my prediction that Trump, as president, would do things that would, ultimately, discredit him, and discredit his Administration, and would thus let concerned citizens make some very much-needed changes to our federal government.

So far, these early nominations (aptly characterized by Reich) provide some evidence that I may have been correct in my prediction. We may well find ourselves, sooner rather than later, with an opportunity to make real, substantive changes.

But to take advantage of the opportunities that will come, however and whenever they do, we will need to be actively engaged, ourselves.

“Self-government” does require that we be engaged, ourselves.

Let’s not forget that. Let’s not drop the ball!

Gary Patton is a former Santa Cruz County Supervisor (20 years) and an attorney for individuals and community groups on land use and environmental issues. The opinions expressed are Mr. Patton’s. You can read and subscribe to his daily blog at www.gapatton.net

Email Gary at gapatton@mac.com

...

JOKING DOGES, ADJOURNING POWER GRAB, RESIGNATION, A CIRCUS

Comedian Wanda Sykes said on Jimmy Kimmel Live last week that though she “got her hopes up,” about a potential Kamala Harris win, she wasn’t surprised that Trump won. “I mean it’s so many reasons why you can say it happened. But, I think, you know, a lot of us aren’t, like, totally shocked, because sometimes America is just gonna America.” Not comfortable with the outcome, she asserted, “I’m a Black woman and a lesbian…how do you think I’m doin’? It’s like ‘Okay,’ you get your hopes up, you think you’ll move forward.” She pinned the blame for Trump’s victory with, “I blame those damn Cheerio commercials, showing all those interracial couples. You scared the [crap] outta white people. What are y’all doin’? Just sell the damn cereal…why you gotta be bringing us into this?”

HuffPost reports that eight years after a win in 2016, a defeat in 2020, The Don is now the next president-elect of the country, regaining “the seat of immense power with fresh grievances, threats of being a dictator on ‘day one’ and calling for retribution against his ‘enemies within.'” Don’t look for any respect for the rule of law…only the rule of one, “the greatest challenge to our democratic experiment since the Civil War.” HP says, “This is not a drill…now is not the time to cower or capitulate,” pledging to cover actions of the Trump administration “with the same rigor and honesty that we always have.” JoJo from Jerz posted on X“How sad it must be believing that doctors, scientists, scholars, historians, economists and journalists are all lying to you, but a criminal conman, business cheat, reality TV game show host with a lifelong history of blatant, unapologetic, nonstop lying, is telling you the truth.”

In just the couple of weeks since the election, Trump’s old buddy Vlad Putin, is messing with his orange head. It took Putin two days to congratulate him, during a news conference, on his election success, which surely raised the former president’s uncertainty about the ‘friendship’ with his favorite strongman. Trump then claimed there had been a phone conversation with Putin, during which he warned the Russian leader not to escalate the war on the Ukrainians. Then came a poke in the eye from the Kremlin, denying that there was a phone call, which allows Putin to go ahead with plans to use North Korean troops to retake some occupied Russian territory, and move back into Donbas province. Will Trump learn a lesson about the limits of a misconstrued personal relationship as he is forced to consider our national interests early on? Naaahhh! Russia’s chief of intelligence, Nikolai Patrushev, made a comment in the Moscow newspaper, Kommersant“The election campaign is over. To achieve success in the election Donald Trump relied on certain forces to which he has corresponding obligations. As a responsible person, he will be obliged to fulfill them.” Obligations to certain forces? This psychological punch is telling Mr. Trump that Russians now deserve payback for contributing to his election victory with their phony videos against Harris, and phoning in bomb scares to polling stations! Some are speculating that this is a blackmail threat by communicating that they have compromising information pointing to Trump or his staffers about colluding in these Russian ‘contributions.’

Throughout the campaign Trump made his wishes known that he wants a realignment with Putin, but Patrushev’s response simply reveals that Russia’s main goal is to sow chaos, breed mistrust, and weaken the bonds of democracy in the West, no matter who is president of the USA. Trump’s MAGAts are willing to go along with their leader for better relations with Russia as they seek to weaken China’s influence in the world. We can only speculate how Trump will proceed, whether he will change, or whether he even has the capability to change his standpoint as it becomes more apparent that Putin wants us to fail. Trump has a history of keeping private his conversations with Putin, the Washington Post finding at least sixteen private conversations…that we know about…during Trump’s first three years in office. A 2018 closed-door meeting in Helsinki is still a mystery, with Trump confiscating notes from his interpreter, ordering him to not disclose any details of the conversation. It’s notable that he told reporters ahead of the 2019 G20 summit in Osaka, Japan that his meetings with Putin were “none of your business.” The ambiguousness is alive and well today!

Trump, being true to form, continues to poke fun at his lackeys. Elon Musk was a victim last week when Trump accused him of hanging around Mar-a-Lago for too long. “Elon won’t go home. I can’t get rid of him…until I don’t like him,” he mocked his  billionaire buddy, addressing Republican lawmakers on the Hill at their first meeting following his election victory. Musk has accompanied Trump on the golf course, in the dining room, and sharing conversations with world leaders whom Trump has called. MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell sees Trump’s comments about Musk before the assembled audience as an assertion of his dominance in front of a group that has to laugh along with him. O’Donnell says, “Everyone laughed. They laughed that uncomfortable laugh. But they laugh when Donald Trump makes a joke about someone on his team, a joke that everyone knows is true, a joke that paints that person as pathetic, as Donald Trump’s personal sense of superiority demands that he do.” O’Donnell believes that the new agency, the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), is a joke as well, a humiliating demotion, with co-leader Musk being responsible in a “fake job that holds little more power than that of a K Street lobbyist.” As an added insult, he was given a working partner in Vivek Ramaswamy…not even a billionaire! Lawrence pointed out that Trump’s other cabinet appointments have been for standing federal departments…DOGE is not. Tech journalist, Kara Swisher, predicts the relationship between the two egotistical, narcissistic and indomitable entities is destined to fail. Donald owes Elon, but if he garners too much attention…poof! It’s all over a la Steve Bannon. Swisher notes that “Trump goes through people like tissues, essentially…they’re going to clash at some point.”

The provocative Cabinet picks Trump has made are stirring up outrage and shock in DC, even among the GOP, triggering a melt-down just as the president-elect intends. Most outrageous has been naming Matt Gaetz as his attorney general. Tulsi Gabbard will be director of national intelligence if confirmed, and Fox News anchor Pete Hegseth is headed for the defense secretary position. Those three individuals pose questions about The Don’s motivations and the direction of his second term, not least because of their professional, ethical or experiential qualities, or lack of them, reports CNN. Their commonality is an unfailing loyalty to Trump, all avid proponents of the stunt politics he spearheaded on social media; and if his “retribution” is to be carried out they will obey his orders. Trump rocked the boat further with his naming of Robert F Kennedy, Jr. as secretary of Health and Human Services, who it seems will be given free rein to carry out whatever he wants, should he pass muster with the Senate…unless…

Trump has no intention of seeking Senate permission! Fearing that even a GOP-controlled Senate might be hesitant to confirm his choices, it’s speculated that he will adjourn both houses of Congress under the never-used Article II, section 3 of the Constitution, enabling him to recess-appoint his Cabinet nominees. Can you say, ‘Power Grab?’ This move allow him to impose on the government, everyone he wants, no matter how corrupt, extreme, inexperienced or controversial they might be. If Trump attempts this, and can get away with it, he will effectively remove the Senate’s confirmation powers forever, a norm-shattering disruption of politics, governance, and presidential power. With certainty, a high-stakes face-off followed by litigation would erupt, with no guarantee about the result. Conservative legal activist, Ed Whelan, hopes the rumor to take this path is wrong, being appalled at the idea. “It’s a fundamental general feature of our system of separated powers that the president shall submit his nominations for major offices to the Senate for approval. That feature plays a vital role in helping to ensure that the president makes quality picks,” he says. Whelan points out that it would take cooperation of Speaker Johnson and the House majority, being far from clear whether Republicans in either chamber have the spine to stand up to this unprecedented wrecking ball.

Black sheep, blackballed, ex-Vice President Pence jumped into the conversation, albeit uninvited, to plead with Republicans to reject RFK Jr. as our next Health & Human Services secretary. As odacationnews says, “before you go wondering if Pence has suddenly found something resembling a moral compass, his reasoning is entirely predictable: Kennedy is pro-choice. Pence is most certainly not. RFK Jr.’s certifiably nutty views on vaccines and other conspiratorial musings aren’t the problem, mind you. It’s Kennedy’s unforgivable opinion that a woman should have the right to make important medical decisions for herself. Noted, Mike. Don’t you have somewhere irrelevant to be?”

The Meidas Touch Network on You Tube has a presentation by Francis M. Maxwell, sharing videos of global impressions of Trump’s election, many of which have invoked fear and laughter around the world. The Scottish First Minister was ridiculed by a parliament member addressing his colleagues, for “offering his congratulations on behalf of the Scottish government to convicted felon Donald Trump…words fail me.” On Tik Tok, both the Finnish and Norwegian female parliament members proclaimed “our American sisters are not alone.” Referencing the Musk super pac’s $200M fund for Trump’s election, Australia has introduced a new bill that will ban billionaire Elon Musk and others from buying elections in that nation to insure that what happened in the US does not happen in their country. French President Macron called the Trump election “a moment of acceleration,” as he sees the possible trade war between China and the US as a time for adjustment of power, both economically and commercially, within the European community. He asked, “Do we want to read history as written by others, or do we want to write our own history? Now is the time to defend national and European interests.”

California Attorney GeneralRob Bonta, said his organization “will be there” if Trump attacks the rights of the state’s citizens, and will insure that California will remain “a steadfast beacon of hope and progress.” This tack is being taken up by attorneys general across the country to legally defend against Trump administration excesses. In Trump’s first term, states brought on a wave of lawsuits to block moves like his travel ban, and family separations, as we even now face threats of mass deportations and rolling back of environmental regulations. Democratic governors see the trifecta of the White House and Congress, and a more conservative judiciary shrinking the number of venues for advancing Democrat’s policies at the federal level. The actions of governors and state AGs can make a difference not only in their own states, but across the nation. Preparations for several months entailed monitoring comments from Trump and his colleagues, studying Project 2025, and scrutinizing the conservative Heritage Foundation’s framework for Trump II. Preparations include prewriting briefs needing only slight editing in preparation for filing as needed. Bonta says, “What we learned from the first Trump administration is that he can’t help but break the law. It’s part of his brand. It’s part of what he does.” Trump’s first go-around brought in a world of heightened AG activism, resulting in current legal officers “much more proactive in getting ready for challenges that don’t even exist.” As the Turkish proverb tells us: “When a clown moves into the palace, he does not become king. The palace becomes a circus.”

The New York Times reports that Special Counsel Jack Smith is said to be assessing how to wind down his two federal criminal investigations and prosecutions of Donald Trump, with plans to beat the president-elect’s threat to fire him “within two seconds” of taking office by resigning first. With the Justice Department’s long-standing policy of not prosecuting a sitting president, Smith has notified prosecutors and FBI agents on his team that they can begin planning their own departures.The Supreme Court’s ruling that presidential conduct can’t be prosecuted even after a president leaves office covers such a broad swath, that their decision that a “president is immune from being held liable for ‘official acts'” pretty much frees Trump from many of his actions, anyway. DOJ regulations require that Smith make a final report on his investigation, allowing him to lay out the case against Trump on charges related to his role in the J6 Capitol attack and the mishandling of classified documents. It’s a race against time to see if he can complete that report to be made public before Biden’s term ends, but his intention is to leave no “significant part of his work for others to complete.” Is that Bill Barr hiding in the wings? Both House Judiciary Chairman Jim Jordan and Representative Barry Loudermilk have requested that Smith’s office preserve all records in the Trump probes, signaling that a congressional inquiry is in the making, prompting Elon Musk to laud the move on X, posting, “Jack Smith’s abuse of the justice system cannot go unpunished.”

Late Show host, Stephen Colbert charged that Trump, since his election, has “already managed to be way worse” than he expected, by bringing up the Matt Gaetz nomination. “During the campaign, I thought if Trump won, he would do the worst things I could imagine. Turns out, I don’t have much of an imagination,” he said. Colbert then directed his anger to Attorney General Merrick Garland for failing to prosecute Trump earlier, saying, “Are you sorry you didn’t speed up those Trump trials, you schmuck?” Can’t say he wasn’t warned!

Dale Matlock, a Santa Cruz County resident since 1968, is the former owner of The Print Gallery, a screenprinting establishment. He is an adherent of The George Vermosky school of journalism, and a follower of too many news shows, newspapers, and political publications, and a some-time resident of Moloka’i, Hawaii, U.S.A., serving on the Board of Directors of Kepuhi Beach Resort. Email: cornerspot14@yahoo.com
 

...

EAGAN’S SUBCONSCIOUS COMICS. View classic inner-view ideas and thoughts with Subconscious Comics a few flips down.

EAGAN’S DEEP COVER. See Eagan’s “Deep Cover” down a few pages. As always, at TimEagan.com you will find his most recent  Deep Cover, the latest installment from the archives of Subconscious Comics, and the ever entertaining Eaganblog.

Take a Break

“Try to pause each day and take a walk to view nature.”
~Lailah Gifty Akita

“Almost everything will work if you unplug it for a few minutes…including you.”
~Anne Lamott

“Each person deserves a day away in which no problems are confronted, no solutions searched for. Each of us needs to withdraw from cares which will not withdraw from us.”
~Maya Angelou

“Wisdom is knowing when to have rest, when to have activity, and how much of each to have.”
~Sri Sri Ravi Shankar

“Sometimes you need to give yourself a break when you’ve had a lot of life change.”
~Barbara Freethy

...

One of my favorite movies of all time, here’s a deep dive on the Miracle Max scene.


COLUMN COMMUNICATIONS. Subscriptions: Subscribe to the Bulletin! You’ll get a weekly email notice the instant the column goes online. (Anywhere from Monday afternoon through Thursday or sometimes as late as Friday!), and the occasional scoop. Always free and confidential. Even I don’t know who subscribes!!
Snail Mail: Bratton Online
84 Blackburn Street, Apt 102
Santa Cruz, CA 95060
Email: Bratton@Cruzio.com
Cell phone: (831) 212-3273
All Technical & Web details: Gunilla Leavitt @ godmoma@gmail.com
...

Subconscious Comics

Deep Cover

Posted in Weekly Articles | Leave a comment